tamil nadu newsprint and papers limited kagithapuram ... · tamil nadu newsprint and papers limited...
TRANSCRIPT
TAMIL NADU NEWSPRINT AND PAPERS LIMITED Kagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu
DEINKING PLANT & UPGRADATION OFCAPTIVE COGENERATION PLANT
EXECUTIVE SUMMARYOF
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT (EIA) REPORT
March 2012
Prepared by
VIMTA LABS LTD SPB PROJECTS AND CONSULTANCY LTDHYDERABAD CHENNAI
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER # TITLE PAGE#
1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................ 3 1.1 Project Profile ................................................................................... 3 1.2 Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and Environmental Management Plan (EMP)..................................................................... 4 1.3 Environmental Setting of the Site ........................................................ 5 1.4 Project Cost...................................................................................... 8
2.0 DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT........................................................... 9 2.1 Soil Environment............................................................................... 9 2.2 Meteorology ..................................................................................... 9 2.3 Water Environment.......................................................................... 10 2.4 Noise Level Survey .......................................................................... 11 2.5 Flora and Fauna Studies ................................................................... 11 2.6 Socio-Economic Environment ............................................................ 11
3.0 ANTICIPATED ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES ......... 12 3.1 Impact during Construction Phase ................................................ 12 3.2 Impact during Operation Phase ................................................... 14
4.0 POST PROJECT ENVIRONMENT MONITORING PROGRAMME .......................... 16
5.0 ADDITIONAL STUDIES...................................................................... 17 5.1 Risk Assessment & Disaster Management Plan ................................. 17
6.0 PROJECT BENEFITS .................................................................................. 17
7.0 ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT PLAN............................................................ 18 7.1 Environment Management Plan during Construction Phase .................. 18 7.2 Environment Management Plan during Operation Phase ...................... 20
8.0 CONCLUSIONS ........................................................................................ 21
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-3
1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1.1 Project Profile
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited (TNPL) was promoted by
the Government of Tamil Nadu for the manufacture of newsprint and
printing and writing (P&W) papers, using bagasse as the principal
fibre source. The mill, located at Kagithapuram in Karur District
(≈400 km south west of Chennai), was commissioned in October
1985 with an installed capacity of 90,000 tpa of newsprint and P&W
papers (PM #1). The capacity has been increased by adding two
more paper machines and introducing Elemental Chlorine Free pulp
mills and now produces 400,000 tpa of paper.
The mill has always strived to attain best possible standards of
quality, by practising ISO 9001:2000 standards in the
manufacturing operations. The mill has established an Environment
Management System (EMS) complying with ISO 14001 standards
and has been acknowledged by the Centre for Science and
Environment (CSE) by awarding the “THREE GREEN LEAVES” under
“GREEN RATING PROJECT”.
Considering the installed production capabilities of Chemical Bagasse
Pulp (CBP) and Hard Wood Pulp (HWP) streets, about 60,000 tonnes
of pulp needs to be purchased
TNPL proposes to install a 300 BD tpd capacity of Deinking Plant
(DIP) to replace the imported pulp and make the mill self sufficient
in fibre demand and upgradation of Captive Cogeneration Plant
(CCP) to meet the power requirement for existing and proposed
facilities by installation of one (1) 125 tph new high pressure
Circulating Fluidised Bed Combustion boilers and one (1) new 41
MW TG of double extraction condensing turbo generator (here after
refered as “Project”).
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-4
Plant Capacities – Existing, Post Project and Proposed project are
given in the following table:
SlNo
Section Unit Existing PostProject
Project Proposal
1 Paper production tpa 400,000 400,000 - -2 Hard wood pulp BD tpd 330 330 - -3 Chemical
Bagasse PulpBD tpd 550 550 - -
4 DIP Pulp BD tpd - 300 300New DIP Plant5 Recovery Boiler BL
solids/day1740 1740 - -
6 Recausticisingplant
tpd 400 400 - -
7 Lime kiln tpd 340 340 - -8 Coal fired boiler tph 455 400 125New boiler of 125
tph replacing 3 nos.old boilers of 180tph
9 TurboAlternators
MW 81.12 103.62 41New turbine of 41MW replacing 2nos. old TG's of18.5 MW
10 Water treatment m3/day 1,20,000 1,20,000 - -
11 Wastewatertreatment
m3/day 85,000 85,000 - -
The total cost for the proposed plan is Rs 310 Crores. Out of this,
about Rs 39 Crores is earmarked for Environmental control and
management including water conservation measures.
1.2 Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and Environmental Management Plan (EMP)
1.2.1 Objective of the Study
As per environmental impact assessment notification dated on 14th
September 2006, any new industrial establishment or expansion of
production, capacities or change of product requires environmental
clearance (EC) to be obtained from Ministry of Environment and
Forest (MoEF), New Delhi. Considering the above points,
environmental impact assessment (EIA) report along with
environment management (EMP) has been prepared for various
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-5
environmental components, which may be affected due to the
proposed deinking plant and upgradation of captive cogeneration
plant of TNPL mill, Kagithapuram, Tamil Nadu.
The risk assessment and disaster management plan have also been
prepared to meet the eventualities during operation of the proposed
project of TNPL mill, Kagithapuram, Tamil Nadu.
The findings of the studies conducted during three (3) months
starting from December 2011 are discussed in the following
paragraphs.
1.3 Environmental Setting of the Site
Adequate land is available within the existing plant for
implementation of the proposed project. The proposed project area
is located within the existing plant premises at Pugalur-
Kagithapuram in the district of Karur, Tamil Nadu State. The site is
located at the intersection of longitude 77o49’25’’E and latitude
11o3’10’’ N and falls under Survey of India Topo sheet No 58 E/16,
F13, I/4 and J/1.
The site is about 400 km (aerial) from Chennai, the State capital
and it is about 18 km from Karur, the District Headquarters. The
National Highway NH-7, which connects Salem with Karur, is at 3
km in northeast direction from the plant site.
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-6
The details of environmental setting around the mill site are given inthe following table.
ENVIRONMENTAL SETTING OF THE SITE
Sl. No. Particulars Details1 Location
Town/Village PugalurDistrict KarurState Tamil Nadu
2 Latitude 11o 3’ 10’’ N3 Longitude 77o 49’ 25” E4 Elevation above mean sea level (MSL) 150 m5 Climatic conditions as per IMD Salem Predominant Annual Wind Direction: East,
Southwest, and WestAnnual mean Max Temp: 33.5ocAnnual mean Min Temp : 22.6 oC
6 Present land use at the proposed site Industrial7 Nearest Highway/Road NH-7 connecting Salem to Karur (3 km NE)8 Defence Installations None within 10 km radius9 Nearest railway station Pugalur R.S, 0.8 km WNW
10 Nearest airport/air strip Thiruchirapalli, 80 km ESE11 Nearest village Nalliyampalayam, 0.3 km ENE12 Nearest town Karur, 18 km SE13 Nearest river Cauvery River, about 5.0 km NW14 Hills/valleys Some hillocks are present nearby
15 Archaeologically important places Nil in 10 km radius16 Nearest place of tourist/ Religious
importance Kalyana Venkataramana Temple,Thanthonimalai. Pasupatheswarar TempleKarur
17 Ecologically sensitive areas (NationalParks/Wildlife sanctuaries/bio-spherereserves)
No sensitive areas within 10 km radius
18 Reserved/Protected forests within10 km radius
None within 10 km radius
19 List of Industries EID Parry (India) Private Limited, BharatPetroleum Terminal
20 Topography of the plant site Plain21 Nature of soil Silty22 Major crops in the study area Sugarcane, Paddy
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-7
FIGURE 1
STUDY AREA MAP – 10 KM RADIUS
Tiru
man
imut
tar N
NH 7
NH 7
To Karur
Kuppachchipm
Olaippalayam
Palappatti
Kuduturai
Nanjai Idaiyar
Olurpatti
Padamudipm
Chellappampm
Minikavundampm
Viranampm
Nalliyampalayam
VellurPottanur Periya Karichchipm
Kumarapm
Kadambakkurichi
Mettuppm
Varappm
Palarpatti
Arumarkaranpudur
Manmangalam
Kudukuduttanur
VadugappalliMangachalipm
PerichchipmAtturNattamedu
Veppampalayam
Sadciyampm
Pavitram
Andippatti
Salipalayam
Talaiyuttuppatti
Pudurppatti
Kuppam
Kunadaipm
Naduppm
Velliyampm
Periyavattam
Neikuppam
Kulattuppm
Nanjal Kandalam
Bommalappm
Kandampm
Minachipm
Kolakkuttupudur
Chellappampm
Pandamangalam
Kuchchippm
Pugalur
Tottakkurichi
Velayudampm
Tirukkattutturai
Nadayanur
SemangiKavundan Pudur
Nallikkovil
Masakavundanpudur
Olaippalayam
Vettamangalam
Kurumbappatti
Ayyanur
AlampmSellarapmNaduppalayam
Punnamchattram
Kariyamputti
Nanapparappu
KurukkampmRS
Nalliyampalayam
Ayyampm
Ganapatipm
Periya Orattai
Ammapatti
Vallipm
Govindampm
Pulampm
Kallippm
Murtipalayam
Polamapuram
Kaddampm
Uppupm
Vadugapatti
Kalipm
Andisangi Ipalaiyam
Ayyapm
Vengara
C A U V E R Y R I V
E R
Valayakkaranpudur
Punniyakavundanpudur
Mulimangalam
Nagamanayakkanpm
Maravapm
Totampm
Muttanur
To Karur
11°
0'
Topo Sheet No, 58 E/16, F/13, I/4, J/1
11°
5'
77° 55' 78° 0' 78° 5'
77° 55' 78° 0' 78° 5'
11°
11°
5'
0'
Pugalur
SCALE
1 0 1 2 KM
N
10 KM
Proposed SiteRailway Line
River / StreamVillage
TNPL Boundary
LEGEND
Road
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-8
ENVIRONMENTAL ATTRIBUTES & FREQUENCY OF
MONITORING ADOPTED
Sl. No. Attribute Parameters Frequency of monitoring1 Ambient Air Quality PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NOx and CO The monitoring carried out at 10
locations at a frequency of 24hourly samples twice a week forone season (Monsoon season isexcluded). CO samples collectedon 8-hour basis.
2 Meteorology Surface
Wind Speed and Direction,Temperature, RelativeHumidity, Rainfall and othernon-instrumental observationslike visibility, hail,thunderstorms, dust storms,fog and smog.
Surface
a] Continuous with hourlyrecording through setting up of on-site meteorological station;
b] Data collected from secondarysources like nearest IMD station.
3 Water Quality Physical, Chemical andBacteriological Parameters.
16 (8 ground + 8 surface) watersamples once in during the studyperiod.
4 Ecology Existing terrestrial and aquaticflora and fauna.
Through field visits.
5 Noise Levels Noise levels in dB(A). Once during study period at 10locations.
6 Soil Characteristics Soil profile, characteristics, soiltype and texture, heavy metal,NPK value etc.
Once during study period at 10locations.
7 Land use Land use for differentcategories.
Land use as per the district censushandbook as well as with the helpof satellite imagery
8 Socio-Economicaspects
Socio-economiccharacteristics, labour forcecharacteristics.
Based on data from latestpublished district censushandbooks. There will not be anyR&R issues involved.
9 Geology Geological history Based on data collected fromsecondary sources.
10 Hydrology (Surfaceand Ground)
Drainage area and pattern,nature of streams, aquifercharacteristics, recharge anddischarge areas.
Based on data collected fromsecondary sources.
11 Traffic study Traffic density 2 locations
12 SODAR study Atmospheric inversion At the project site for one month
1.4 Project Cost
The cost of the total project is Rs 310 Crores which includes Rs 39
Crores for environmental protection measures.
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-9
2.0 DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT
Primary baseline environmental monitoring studies were conducted
during three (3) months from December 2011 representing winter
season and details are as follows:
2.1 Soil Environment
A total of ten (10) samples within the study area were collected and
analyzed. It has been observed that the texture of soil is sandy clay
in the study area. The pH of the soil extract varied from 7.9 to 8.4.
The electrical conductance varied from 267 to 415 µmhos/cm
indicating its favourable for agricultural soils.
Nitrogen values ranged between 32.4 to 148.7 kg/ha. The nitrogen
content in the study area falls in less to good category.
2.2 Meteorology & Ambient Air Quality
• Meteorology
On-site monitoring was undertaken for various meteorological
variables in order to generate the site-specific data. Data was
collected every hour continuously from December 2011 to March
2012 representing Winter season. The maximum and minimum
temperatures recorded during the study period are 36oC and 16oC.
The relative humidity found varying from 17.5 to 25.9. The
predominant winds are mostly from ENE (26.3%) and E (17.9%)
directions. A total of 27.9 mm rainfall was recorded during study
period. The skies for the most part of the study period were
observed to be cloudy and clear.
• Ambient Air Quality
To establish the baseline status of the ambient air quality in the
study area, the air quality was monitored at ten (10) locations. The
monitoring was carried out during winter season. The summary of
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-10
the average values of Ambient Air Quality monitored is given in
following table
SUMMARY OF AMBIENT AIR QUALITY IN THE STUDY AREA
Season PM10 PM2.5 SO2 NOx COWinter 2011-12 40.6-72.5 14.7-23.5 10.7-22.4 15.2-28.8 85-295
Concentrations are expressed in μg/m3
The results of the monitored data indicate that the ambient air
quality of the region in general is in conformity with respect to
rural/residential norms of National Ambient Air Quality standards of
CPCB, with present level of activities.
2.3 Water Environment
Eight (8) groundwater samples and eight (8) surface water samples
within the study area were considered for assessment. The water
samples were collected and analysed during winter season.
Surface Water Quality
The pH and conductivity of surface water varies from 7.7 to 8.0.
The TDS ranges from 422 to 768 mg/l. The chlorides and sulphates
were found to be in the ranges of 53-128 mg/l and 25.9 to 43.0
mg/l respectively. It is observed that chlorides and sulphates ranges
are well within the permissible limits. The physico-chemical and
biological analysis revealed that all the parameters were well within
the prescribed limits of IS: 2296 Class ‘C’ limits.
Ground Water Quality
The pH and conductivity vary from 7.6 to 8.3 and from 1330 to
9700 µS/cm respectively. Total dissolved solids ranged between
490mg/l and 6790 mg/l respectively.
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-11
Sodium and potassium contents are found to be in the range of 120-
1034 and 1-180 mg/l respectively. Chlorides and sulphates content
vary between 120 to 2730 mg/l and 72.6 to 785 mg/l respectively.
The heavy metal contents were found to be well within the limit.
Total coli forms and Insecticides and pesticides were found to be
absent. The physico-chemical and biological analysis revealed that
most of the parameters are well within the prescribed limits of IS:
10500.
2.4 Noise Level Survey
The noise monitoring has been conducted at ten (10) locations in
the study area. Day time and night time noise levels at residential
areas found to be varying from 45.1 dB(A) to 53.6 dB(A) and 41.5
dB(A) to 44.3 dB(A) respectively. In general, the noise levels are
found to be within the acceptable levels in residential areas.
2.5 Flora and Fauna Studies
Flora and fauna studies have been carried out in and around 10 km
from proposed project to assess the composition status of floral and
faunal components. During field survey, a total of 362 species of
plants of which 39.5% were phanerophytes, 37.5% were
therophytes,16.57 were hemicryptophytes,4.14% were hydrophytes
and others were 1.94%.
2.6 Socio-Economic Environment
As per 2001 census the study area consists of 179,487 persons
inhabited in the study area of 10 km radial distance from the
periphery of the proposed plant. The males and females constitute
49.87% and 50.1% of the study area population respectively. The
average household size of the study area is 3 to 4 persons. The
density of population reveals that the study area has an overall
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-12
density of about 440 persons per km2. In the study area, 15% of the
population belongs to Scheduled Castes (SC) and 0.01% of the
population belongs to Scheduled Tribes (ST). The study area
experiences total literacy rate of 62%. As per 2001 census records,
altogether the main workers works out to be 52.5% of the total
population. The marginal workers and non-workers constitute to
3.8% and 43.6% of the total population respectively.
3.0 ANTICIPATED ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES
3.1 Impact during Construction Phase
The environmental impacts during the construction stage will be
short term, temporary in nature and will be confined very close to
project sites. The manpower required for these activities should
preferably be employed from nearby villages.
3.1.1 Land Environment
No additional land is required for project, since the available space
of around 6 acres in the mill will be used for proposed project. The
proposed area for the project is already a developed area and is flat.
Hence, no major impact is envisaged on land use pattern of the
proposed project site.
3.1.2 Impact on Soil
The construction activities will result in loss of vegetation cover,
topsoil and earthen material to some extent in the plant area.
However, it is proposed to use the soil and earthen material for green
cover development and levelling of project site. Green cover will be
developed in the proposed project site in phased manner from
construction stage onwards.
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-13
Apart from localized construction impacts at the plant site, no adverse
impacts on soil in the surrounding area are anticipated.
3.1.3 Impact on Air Quality
The main sources of emission during the construction period are the
movement of equipment at site and dust emitted during the
levelling, grading, earthwork, foundation works and exhaust
emissions from vehicles and equipment deployed during the
construction phase is also likely to result in marginal increase in the
levels of SO2, NOx, PM and CO. The impact will be for short duration
and confined within the project boundary and is expected to be
negligible outside the plant boundaries. The impact will, however, be
reversible, marginal and temporary in nature. Proper maintenance
of vehicles and construction equipment will help in controlling the
gaseous emissions. Water sprinkling on roads and construction site
will prevent fugitive dust.
3.1.4 Impact on Terrestrial Ecology
The initial construction works at the project site involves land
clearance. During construction vegetation may be disturbed. Green
cover will be developed phase wise during construction to improve
the aesthetic value in the area and to screen out the fugitive dust
generated during construction.
The removal of vegetation from the soil and loosening of the topsoil
generally causes soil erosion. However, such impacts will be
confined to the project site and will be minimized through paving
and water sprinkling.
There are not many existing matured trees in the site. However,
green cover will be developed surrounding the plant facilities. The
existing trees will be preserved to the extent possible. Thus, no
major adverse impacts are envisaged on terrestrial ecology.
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-14
3.1.5 Socio-Economic Impacts
The proposed project will provide either direct or indirect job
opportunities to the local population as far as possible.
3.2 Impact during Operation Phase
3.2.1 Impact on Soil
Most of the impacts of proposed project on soils are restricted to the
construction phase, which will get stabilized during operational
phase. The impact on the topsoil will be confined to the proposed
project area.
3.2.2 Impact on Water Environment
In the plant, water is used mainly for Deinking plant, apart from
cooling water requirement and domestic purposes. The mill has
water drawl permission for 72,000 m3/day. The project will not
require additional water and likely to come down about 1000
m³/day due to installation of air cooled condenser in the place of
water cooled condenser. The total water requirement at present of
the mill and colony met from river Cauvery.
The existing wastewater treatment plant is adequate for the
proposed operation. Wastewater is/will be treated to conform to the
statutory standards of state pollution control board and MoEF before
discharging for irrigation.
The run-off water from the roof of the new structures and paved
areas shall be collected through storm water drainage system and
led to rain water harvesting structure.
The quality of water resources in the study area will not be
adversely affected.
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-15
3.2.3 Impact of Solid Waste Generation
The solid waste from the DIP-CCP is mainly fly ash and sludge. Fibre
sludge generated from wastewater treatment plant are the other
solid wastes.
The total ash expected from the plant will be about 150 (140+10)
tonnes per day. This will be used for making cement at TNPL’s mini
cement mill. The WWTP sludge (waste pulp) and SFT sludge will be
given to small paper mills to make low grade paperboards. The
sludge generated from the DIP plant of 90 tpd (dry basis) will be
used as a feed stock in the cement mill.
The sludge from sewage treatment plant will be dried and used as
manure for green cover maintenance. Canteen/sanitary waste will
be composted and used as manure for green cover development.
3.2.4 Noise Environment
The main noise generating sources from the proposed project will be
DIP machine, pumps, compressors along with cooling tower and
boilers. The noise levels at the source for these units will be in the
range of 80-90 dB (A).
3.2.5 Impact on Aquatic Ecology
The wastewater is given sufficient treatment to statutory levels of
Tamil Nadu State Pollution Control Board. The treated waste water
will be fully utilised for irrigation. Hence no impact of wastewater
disposal is envisaged on the aquatic bodies.
3.2.6 Impact on Reserve/Protected Forest
In 10 km study area there is no forest area was observed.
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-16
3.2.7 Impact on Human Health
The impact from the air emissions is not expected to be significant
since the stacks design and the atmospheric conditions are such that
the ambient air quality at present as well as in future after the
proposed facility comes up well within the prescribed ambient air
quality limits set forth by CPCB.
3.2.8 Impact on Public Health and Safety
The discharge of waste materials (stack emission, wastewater and
solid wastes), from process operations can have potential impact on
public safety and health. The impact from the discharge of waste
products is not expected to be significant since, the adverse impacts
on ambient air, water and soil quality are predicted to be low.
It is predicted that the impacts on public safety will be very low, due
to the effective safety system and safety management available in
the plant.
Overall, the impact on public safety and health from the proposed
project activities will be insignificant.
4.0 POST PROJECT ENVIRONMENT MONITORING PROGRAMME
Post project environmental monitoring is important in terms of
evaluating the performance of pollution control equipments installed
in the project. The sampling and analysis of the environmental
attributes will be as per the guidelines of Central Pollution Control
Board/Tamil Nadu Pollution control board (TNPCB). The frequency of
sampling and location of sampling will be as per the directives of
TNPCB.
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-17
5.0 ADDITIONAL STUDIES
5.1 Risk Assessment & Disaster Management Plan
The preliminary risk assessment of the plant has identified no
hazardous events, which would project damaging energies outside
of the plant boundary. Events identified for offsite facilities are
estimated to occur at extremely low incident frequencies and/or not
to significant levels of consequence. Management of hazardous
event scenarios and risks in general can be adequately managed to
acceptable levels.
An effective Disaster Management Plan (DMP) to mitigate the risks
involved has been prepared. This plan defines the responsibilities
and resources available to respond to the different types of
emergencies envisaged. Training exercises will be held to ensure
that all personnel are familiar with their responsibilities and that
communication links are functioning effectively.
6.0 PROJECT BENEFITS
It would be some what difficult to quantify all the benefits of a
project of this type and nature of state and national economy
because there are too many “spin-off” indirect benefits in addition to
direct benefits.
Some of the specific benefits are presented below:
The project will create direct employment to about 40 persons.
In addition to the direct employment at the mill, the project
would generate indirect employment to about 200 persons in
the industries and service organizations which will be supported
by the operations of the mill. In addition about 500 people may
get benefited in ancillary business such waste paper collection
and additional transport due to increased material movement.
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-18
In construction phase, approximately 400 people will be
employed in a day.
At optimum production level, prior to this project, mill requires
approximately 60,000 tpa of wood pulp to be imported which
will be replaced in the import of waste paper to the tune of
about 100,000 tpa for DIP and about 24,000 tpa of imported
coal for CCP. Considering the above there will a net recurring
savings of valuable foreign exchange to the tune of about Rs 50
Crores per annum.
The overall power generation per tonne of coal will be increased
from 1.58 to 1.78 MW per ton of coal by replacing the
inefficient low pressure boilers with efficient high pressure
boilers and efficient turbine.
By way of cost reduction being effected by substituting DIP in place
of imported pulp and replacing the inefficient boilers, the cost of
production will come down, resulting in higher profit margin. Being a
Tamil Nadu Government unit, the Tamil Nadu Government will be
benefited by higher contribution to its exchequer.
7.0 ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT PLAN
7.1 Environment Management Plan during Construction Phase
7.1.1 Air Quality Management
The activities like site development, grading and vehicular traffic
contribute to increase in PM and NOx concentrations. The mitigation
measures recommended to minimize the impacts are:
Water sprinkling in construction area;
Proper maintenance of vehicles and construction equipment;
and
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-19
Tree plantation in the area earmarked for green cover
development.
7.1.2 Water Quality Management
The mitigation measures recommended to minimize the impacts are
sedimentation tank to retain the solids from run-off water; oil and
grease trap at equipment maintenance centre; septic tanks to treat
sanitary waste at labour colony; and utilizing the wastewater in
green cover development.
7.1.3 Noise Level Management
Operation of construction equipment and vehicular traffic contribute
to the increased noise level. Recommended mitigation measures
include good maintenance of vehicles and construction equipment
and restriction of construction activities to day time only. Plantation
of trees around the project facilities will be done to attenuate the
noise. Provision of earplugs and earmuffs to workers will be made.
7.1.4 Ecological Management
During construction, vegetation in the plant premises is required to
be cleared. The felling of trees will be kept at minimum.
Transplantation of existing matured trees will be undertaken and
transplanted in the area earmarked for green cover development.
Extensive plantation has been done under green cover development
for the existing plant. Green cover has been developed and well
maintained along the internal roads and mill area. The mill has
made elaborate arrangement in developing green cover inside the
mill.
As part of the proposed project, this will be further improved.
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-20
7.2 Environment Management Plan during Operation Phase
7.2.1 Air Pollution Management
Fugitive and stack emissions from the proposed project will
contribute to increase in concentrations of PM, SO2, and NOx
pollutants. The mitigative measures recommended in the plant are:
Installation of ESP of efficiency more than 99.9% to limit the
PM concentrations below 100 mg/Nm3;
Provision of adequate stack height for wider dispersion of
gaseous emissions;
Provision of water sprinkling system at storage yard, etc.
7.2.2 Water Pollution Management
No fresh wastewater will be generated from deinked pulp line as
paper machine back water will be used, and marginal quantity of
fresh water used in DIP will be recycled elsewhere in the mill. The
recommended measures to minimise the impacts and conservation
of fresh water are:
Water conservation and recycling;
Air cooled condenser for conservation of water;
Provision of drain for existing storm water system to collect
and store run-off water during rainy season and utilization of
the same in the process to reduce the fresh water requirement;
and
Suitable rainwater harvesting structures will be constructed.
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-21
7.2.3 Noise Pollution Management
Equipments will be designed to conform to noise levels prescribed by
regulatory authorities. Provision of thick green cover to attenuate
the noise levels will be made.
7.2.4 Solid Waste Management
The solid waste from the CFBC Boiler (CFBC #7) will be mainly ash.
Additional ash expected from the proposed project will be about 10
tonnes per day. This will be used as feed stock in cement mill. The
expected waste sludge from deinking plant will be about 90 tpd
which will also be used as feed stock in TNPL’s mini cement mill.
7.2.5 Green cover Development
Green cover has been developed and well maintained along the
internal roads and mill area. The mill has made elaborate
arrangement in developing green cover inside the mill. Till date,
about 2,63,133 plants have been planted in and around the plant,
residential colony and other areas. As part of the proposed project,
this will be further improved.
7.2.6 Cost Provision for Environmental Measures
It is proposed to invest about Rs 39 Crores on pollution control,
monitoring systems for proposed equipment implementation of
environmental pollution control measures.
8.0 CONCLUSIONS
Growth and development, in harmony with the environment, has
always been the approach of TNPL, Kagithapuram.
The conclusions of EIA are:
Tamil Nadu Newsprint and Papers Limited EIA ReportKagithapuram, Karur District, Tamil Nadu DIP & Upgradation of CCP
Executive Summary
Prepared by SPB-PC & Vimta Labs Ltd ES-22
1. The DIP and upgradation of CCP is structured to be inline with
the requirements of MoEF/CPCB/TNPCB;
2. Community impacts will be beneficial, as the project will
generate significant economic benefits for the locality; and
3. Continued improvement in wastewater treatment facilities
coupled with high energy electro static precipitator will result in
minimising the impacts on the environment.
Hence, with the effective installation of Deinking Plant (DIP) and
upgradation of Captive Cogeneration Plant during the planning,
design, construction and operation phases, the proposed project can
proceed without any negative impact.