Teaching Controversial Issues

Area of focus Conflict Resolution

KS3 History Year 10 O Key Element Citizenship Pupils should have opportunities to: Investigate the long and short term causes and consequences of the partition of Ireland and how it has influenced Northern Ireland today including key events and turning points.

How the topic was chosen

O Year 10 mixed ability class in all girls secondary school O While studying events in Ireland 1900- 1921 some

pupils raised the question of why there were no pictures or information about women. What were women doing in 1916 they asked?

O While this was identified as an interesting enquiry for the class by themselves , there was a range of limited knowledge and understanding of the Northern Ireland Conflict for many of the pupils and little understanding of the significance of the past on their lives today.

O Teacher felt the class were open to discussion and willing to participate in both group and pared activities.

The PlanningO Preliminary Meeting for half an hour after

school to discuss the procedure where the best starting point would be for the class and what they might gain from the process.

O The class was chosen on the basis that they had already questioned why women had been air brushed out of their history text books and it was felt that the Easter Rising provided a rich context to develop and explore issues around gender, equality and diversity as well as examining the significance of a historical event.

Planning Day O The focus for the lessons was on

commemoration as it highlighted the issue not only of the role of women rebel or otherwise but also how history can be selectively interpreted to justify actions of people today. This would provide fertile ground for the girls to discuss issues around the stereo typing of women in history and indeed today which still causes conflict in many societies across the world.

Planning Day O It was decided to focus on three

lessons and that the class would have done a bit of work on the background and key events beforehand.

O Lesson 1 What do we remember and what do we forget about the Easter Rising ?

O Lesson 2 What role did women really play on the Easter Rising?

O Lesson 3 Why is the Easter Rising significant?

Strategies O Contracting to establish procedures for working

will be done beforehand O Effective questioning throughout and for the

launch of lessons What do you See strategy from Facing History

O Paired and small group work – how to work together?

O Popcorn method of taking turns at reading.O Carousel O Each One Teach One

O EvaluationO Through the debrief sessionsO Observation by Tony McCauley (3rd lesson)

Lesson 1Cultural Identity –

flags, symbols and conflict (Global)O ILOS

O To participate in discussion and respect other students’ views

O To gain a better understanding of the importance of appreciating different views

O LessonO 4 corners ice-breakerO Powerpoint on world flags with quizO Facilitator-led discussion on what the flags representO Flags in conflict situationsO Conclude with thoughts on…‘All flags should be banned in Northern Ireland.’Do you agree?

Alan

Lesson 2Cultural Identity –

flags, symbols and conflict (Local)

O ILOS:O To appreciate that historically Northern Ireland has been

perceived as a bi-cultural societyO To explore the causes and consequences of conflict

O LessonO 4 corners with flags (Union, Irish, 6 counties Ulster and

Province of Ulster) and teacher-led discussionO History of Northern Ireland conflict up to peace process

(youtube footage included)O BBC footage of conflict in Short Strand following flag protestO Back to statement at end of lesson 1‘All flags should be banned in Northern Ireland.’Do you agree?How do they feel now?

Alan and Tracey

Lesson 3Conflict Resolution

O ILOS: O To examine how conflict can be resolved on a global scale.O To use drama to illustrate the current difficulties

surrounding flags in Northern Ireland.O To provide ways of managing conflict at a community level.

  O Activities:

O Examples of Global Conflict Resolution powerpoint/youtubeO Teacher-led discussion leading to Northern Ireland peace

process O Scenario role play in groups. O Students in groups write down 3 things they think should

happen now in Northern Ireland to help resolve the issues surrounding the flag protests.

Tracey

Interesting Reactions…O To the age old question, ‘Does your

background effect your cultural identity?’…O Twins (male and female) gave different

responses to the flags 4 corners exercise!O Male twin felt more of an affiliation with the

Irish tricolourO Female twin stood between the Irish tricolour

and the Union Flag.

Evaluation from the students…… really good, made you understand more about the meaning behind the flags…

When you play games, it helps you learn more… in a practical way

The sweets encouraged us!

I liked the use of videos

Drama helps you be in the position of others.

I liked the interactive way using 4 corners.

It was good having the two teachers … different viewpoints

Activities like that help you when answering evaluation questions in GCSE modules

Where do we go from here?

O TimeO MoneyO OpportunityO Partner school?

O It’s worth it!