temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · joe wheaton, utah state...

25
Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based stream restoration: hypotheses, models and data. AFS/TWS 9/30/2019 Chris Jordan, NOAA-Fisheries Carol Volk, South Fork Research Inc. Joe Wheaton, Utah State University Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc.

Upload: others

Post on 08-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based stream restoration:

hypotheses, models and data.

AFS/TWS 9/30/2019

Chris Jordan, NOAA-FisheriesCarol Volk, South Fork Research Inc.Joe Wheaton, Utah State University

Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc.

Page 2: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Bridge Creek WatershedOregon, USA • 710 km2

John Day Basin

John Day Basin

Bridge Creek

BRIDGE CREEK INTENSIVELYMONITORED WATERSHED

Mitchell, OR

Mid-Columbia Steelhead

Slide from Nick Weber

Page 3: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Beaver inspired stream restoration: Bridge Ck.

Slide from Nick Weber

Page 4: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

103

Phase 4

Dynamic EquilibriumPhase 3

Aggrading

Phase 1

IncisingPhase 2

Widening

100

101

102

Figure Adapted fromCluer and Thorne,2014 by Weber

Page 5: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

DAM PERSISTENCE1988 - 2005

Demmer and Beschta, 2008

Page 6: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Mean Annual Flood Height 30 - 50

cm

BDAs - Beaver Dam Analogs

DisconnectedTerrace

Incision Trench

Slide from Nick Weber

Page 7: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Oregon, USA

John Day Basin

Bridge Creek

MurderersCreek

John Day Basin

Bridge Creek Watershed

Murderers Creek - Watershed Control

Spatial DesignTreatment Reaches - 4Control Reaches - 8Tributary Control - 2Watershed Control - 3

Mitchell, OR

Temporal Design2005

Pre-RestorationMonitoring

2009

RestorationImplementation

Adapted from Figure 2 of Bouwes et al. (2016)DOI: 10.1038/srep28581

Post-RestorationMonitoring

14 201506 07 08 10 11 12 13

Page 8: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Structure ID:

MC-08.2

Page 9: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

WATER TABLE ELEVATION CHANGE

1’-3’ increase in the height of the water table

2006 2013

Slide from Nick Weber

Page 10: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

FLOODPLAIN FREQUENTLY INUNDATED

Page 11: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Summer 2005

Summer 2014

Weber et al. (2017) DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0176313

Page 12: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

cou oe W

of:

(Before) (After)

Figure from Carol Volk (South Fork Research)

EXPANSION OF RIPARIAN ZONE

• Repeat high resolution (10 cm) imagery before& after 2009 treatment

Page 13: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

BRIDGE CREEK NDVI ANALYSIS

~20% increase productivity

natural storage resiliency

Silverman et al. 2018 map.sagegrouseinitiative.com

Page 14: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Water Surface Extent

Volk et al. in review

Page 15: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Ground Water Monitoring

Volk et al. in review

Untreated site

Treated site

Page 16: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Groundwater Elevation

Volk et al. in review

Page 17: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Volk et al. in review

Groundwater Elevation

Page 18: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Groundwater and Surface water Temperature

Volk et al. in review

Untreated site Treated site

Page 19: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

CHANNEL TEMPERATURE HETEROGENEITY

Page 20: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Stream Temperature Monitoring

Page 21: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Surface Water Temperature

Weber et al., 2017 Before After

Page 22: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

Take Home Message

• Beaver dams (natural, BDA) result in floodplain connectivity

• Floodplain connectivity results in riparian vegetation changes

• Floodplain connectivity results in groundwater – surface water interaction

• Groundwater – surface water interaction results in changes in water temperature in both surface and subsurface realm

Page 23: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,
Page 24: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,
Page 25: Temperature and hydrological impacts of beaver-based ...€¦ · Joe Wheaton, Utah State University. Nick Bouwes, Nick Weber, Eco Logical Research Inc. Bridge Creek Watershed. Oregon,

LONG TEMPERATURE PROFILE

August 2014