The 6th Meeting of the INTOSAI Working Group on Key National Indicators

REPORT ON THE REPORT ON THE WORKING GROUP WORKING GROUP ACTIVITYACTIVITY

((AprilApril 2012 - 2012 - AprilApril 2013) 2013)

Krakow, April 22-24, 2013

White Paper on KNIWhite Paper on KNI

2

• Principles for the Development and Use of Key National Indicators ;• Analysis of opportunities on the use of KNI for international comparisons and preparation of appropriate recommendations;• SAI's role in development and use of key indicators for R&D evaluation.

2

White White PaperPaper

International organizations

experience in progress measurement

Problem overview Conclusions

New subprojectsNew subprojects

Countries experience

in development and use of KNI

Role of KNI in sustainable development

monitoring

Recommendations for the development and

use of KNI in developing economies

Key national indicators: Guide to

terms and concepts

Principles for SAIs application of KNI

Recommendation for knowledge-based

economies

Main results of the Working Group Main results of the Working Group activity in 2011 -2013activity in 2011 -2013

• The actual version of the White Paper on KNI is prepared;

• The actual version of the Principles of development and use of KNI is prepared;

• The results of the sub-projects are received :• Analysis of opportunities on the use of KNI for

international comparisons in the context of sustainable development and recommendations;

• SAI's role in development and use of key indicators for R&D development.

3

4

The Group of Twenty

• Public debt• Budget deficit• Level of private savings• Private sector debt level• External imbalance indicator,

including trade balance, flow of net investment income and transfers

Systemic network crisis

Population growth not provided by resources

Risks

• Security• Society• Ecology• Job• Health• Public governance• Housing• Satisfaction with life• Balance between labour

and leisure• Education• Incomes

Global interaction failure

Main systemic financial crisis

Increase of greenhouse gas emissions

Imbalance between social and economic Imbalance between social and economic objectives and indicatorsobjectives and indicators

OECD Better Life Index

5

Visualization of comparison of Visualization of comparison of the countries’ the countries’ positions and development objectivespositions and development objectives

European meadow of life qualityEuropean meadow of life quality((according to the Better Life Index data (OECDaccording to the Better Life Index data (OECD))

6

Development of cooperation in the Development of cooperation in the sphere of progress measurement with sphere of progress measurement with

relevant international organizationsrelevant international organizations

7

WEFWEF

OECDOECD

IIASAIIASA

INTOSAIINTOSAI

Other organizations

UNUN

WBWB

Database on KNIsDatabase on KNIs

8

KNIs Subprojects in the CIS FrameworksKNIs Subprojects in the CIS Frameworks

9

• Assessment of the possibilities for methodological comparability of the

key national indicators of the CIS Member States;

• Summary table of the passports of the indicators of the CIS Economic

Development Strategy for the period up to 2020.

Priority areas of activity Priority areas of activity for 2013-2016for 2013-2016

• Pilot audits aimed at evaluating strategies for the national (regional) development with application of key sustainability indicators – as a second phase of the subproject "Analysis of opportunities on the use of KNI for

international comparisons in the context of sustainable development and recommendations“;

• Development of cooperation in the sphere of progress measurement with relevant international organizations. Widening the scope of cooperation with the OECD, WB, WEF, and other institutions, – including exchange of information and possible WG members’ participation in the

preparation of reports on national welfare and development prospects;

• Development of approaches and methods for the organization of trainings for SAIs’ staff on the use of KNIs in audit activities.

10

Priority areas of activity Priority areas of activity for 2013-2016for 2013-2016

• Methodological and information support of the KNIs identification for the evaluation of the imbalances of the global economy;

• The research on the use of KNIs in the evaluation of the effectiveness of national public procurement systems as a tool for implementation of strategic objectives of the socio-economic development;

• Development of technology based information tools for selection and assessment of KNI, including the visualization of research results.

11

Members and Observers of the Working Members and Observers of the Working GroupGroup

SAI of AustriaSAI of ArmeniaSAI of Bulgaria SAI of Hungary SAI of IndonesiaSAI of ItalySAI of Kazakhstan SAI of ChinaSAI of LatviaSAI of LithuaniaSAI of Morocco

12

SAI of MexicoSAI of Moldova SAI of PakistanSAI of PolandSAI of RussiaSAI of SlovakiaSAI of the USASAI of the UkraineSAI of FinlandSAI of SwitzerlandSAI of the Republic of South Africa

Working Group Members(22)

Observers (4)

SAI of Canada SAI of Kirgizia

SAI of ArgentineSAI of Belarus

new

new

new

Web-site of the INTOSAI Working Web-site of the INTOSAI Working Group on KNIGroup on KNI

13

www.ach.gov.ru/en/intosaikni

Thank you!Thank you!