the “do more engineering” process · 2018-09-07 · pugh matrix taguchi’s parameter design...
TRANSCRIPT
The “Do More Engineering” ProcessINTEGRATING DFMA INTO THE PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
Activity
Distribute 100% product development cycle time across the four phases
Typical Product Development Process
DesignValidation & Verification
“Go To Market”Concept
SA/GA
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
Source: Plastics Design Forum
The More Things Change …
3
20
27
13
55
22
15
5
0 20 40 60 80 100
ConventionalDesign Process
DFMA DesignProcess
Percentage of Design Time
Concept design Initial design
Design changes Data dissemination
40% Time Savings
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
The More Things Change …
Exhibit II Japanese automaker with QFD made fewer changes than U.S. company without QFD Source: Lawrence P. Sullivan, “Quality Function Deployment,” Quality Progress, June 1986, p. 39. © 1986 American Society for Quality Control. Reprinted by permission.
HBR Article by John Hauser and Don Clausing … May 1988
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
Source: Ford Motor Company
The More Things Change …
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
Fabrycky & Blanchard, 1993
The More Things Change …
66%
80%
100%
Conceptual/PreliminaryDesign
Detail Design/Development Production
ProductUse/Support/Phaseout/Disposal
Ease of Change
Cost Incurred
Knowledge
Life Cycle Costs Committed
(Architecture, Technology, Performance, etc..)
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
“Do More Engineering” Product Development Process
Tech Dev.
VOC
Portfolio
Business Decision Architecture
Pipeline Resource Management
Metrics
VOC/QFDDFMAVA/VERobust Design
PFMEADFREarly Supplier Inv.Target Costing
DOEPugh MatrixDFMEA
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
Definition Stage10 2
43
Design Implementation Stage
Manufacturing and Operations Implementation Stage
65
7 8
Production Stage
“Do More Engineering” Product Development Process
“Make It Work” “Make It Break”
Design
V & V “Go To Market”
Concept
SA/GA
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
“Do More Engineering” Best Practices
◦ Multifunctional PD Teams
◦ VOC & QFD
◦ VAVE & Functional Flow Diagrams
◦ DFMA®/ DF”x”
◦ Competitive Benchmarking
◦ Reusability Assessement
◦ Pugh Matrix
◦ Taguchi’s Parameter Design
◦ Robustness Development Fixtures
◦ Systems Engineering
Phase 1 Best Practices Plus:
◦ Early Customer Involvement
◦ Early Supplier Involvement
◦ Decision & Risk Analysis
◦ Fault Tree Analysis
◦ DFMEA/PFMEA
◦ Critical Parameter Layouts
◦ Manufacturing Process Capabilities Assessment
◦ Target Costing
◦ MRP II
Definition Stage10 2
“Make It Work” “Make It Break”O
bje
ctiv
es:
Sup
erio
r Sy
stem
Co
nce
pts
Ro
bu
st T
ech
no
logi
es
Ob
jectives:W
ell defin
ed featu
res, pe
rform
ance,
& fu
nctio
nal req
uirem
en
tsSu
bsystem
s defin
ed &
pro
ven ro
bu
stC
om
mitm
ent to
integrated
pro
j. plan
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
Great Process ≠ Great Outcome◦Lacked diligence in Portfolio Management
◦Too many projects/person
◦“Sunk money” syndrome … lacked diligence in canceling projects
◦“Ugly baby” syndrome … prima donna engineers not open to others’ ideas (especially from manufacturing)
◦Poor accountability
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
Ingredients for DFMA® Deployment Success◦Structured product development process … phased objectives, deliverables, & tools (Best Practices)
◦Stakeholders set clear expectations/goals and support “good decisions”
◦Consistent, data-driven decision making processes
◦Clear roles & responsibilities (i.e. RASI)
◦Effective competency development
◦Designated subject matter experts (SME’s) to serve as mentors & consultants
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
Ingredients for DFMA® Deployment Success
◦Project portfolio management … project identification, prioritization, funding, and staffing
◦Project staffing for success … 2-3 projects/person
◦Project metrics & tracking: status, no. parts, costs, NRE, capital … predicted vs. actual vs. target
◦Lessons learned collected & shared
◦ Integration with other business processes and practices (i.e. VAVE, FMEA, MRP/ERP, etc.)
Boothroyd Dewhurst, Inc. 2018
Facts … Discipline … Constancy of Purpose
“Without discipline, there is no Marine Corp.”
“In God we trust, all others bring data.”“Create constancy of purpose toward improvement …”
Thank You!!!