the civil side of things: orders of protection ms. lisabeth marquardt director, strategic...

24
THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MA RQ UARD T DIREC TOR, STRAT EG IC IN ITIATIVE S

Upload: dylan-jordan

Post on 20-Jan-2016

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

THE CIV

IL SID

E OF T

HINGS:

ORDERS OF P

ROTECTION

MS

. L I S

AB

ET H

MA

RQ

UA

RD

T

DI R

EC

T OR

, S

T RAT E

GI C

IN

I TI A

T I VE

S

Page 2: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

VALUE OF ROS

• Voluntary Compliance

• Mandatory Arrest

• Removal

Page 3: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

MORE VALUE OF ROS

• Documentation

• Limiting access

Page 4: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

POTENTIAL RISKS OF ROS

• Abuse worsens

• Collusion

• Exposure

Page 5: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

TYPES OF RESTRAINING ORDERS

Domestic Abuse ( 813.12)

Child Abuse (813.122)

Harassment (813.125)

Individuals at Risk (813.123)

Foreign Orders

Page 6: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

THE PROCESS

Two hearings

Personal Service

Constructive knowledge

Page 7: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

POTENTIAL REMEDIES

Review Injunction Form

http://www.wicourts.gov/forms1/circuit/index.htm

Page 8: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

RELATED SOPS

• Property

• Service

• Order retention

• Department employees

• Firearm provision enforcement

Page 9: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

WHAT CAN THEY TELL US ABOUT THE PETITIONER?

“In action”

Criminal case overlap

Credibility and follow-through

Page 10: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

WHAT CAN THEY TELL US ABOUT THE RESPONDENT?

• Patterns

• Guns

• Other evidence

Page 11: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

CONTACT BY PETITIONER

• Order not voided

• Safety strategy

• No mutual orders

Page 12: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

WHEN BOTH PARTIES FILE

• First to file

• Race for removal

• Can both have grounds

Page 13: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

A COURT ORDER IS A COURT ORDER

• Facebook, text, phone

• Not reporting as strategy

• Serious risk

Page 14: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

INVESTIGATING VIOLATIONS

• Abuser manipulation

• Other witnesses

• Victim experience

• Skilled abusers

Page 15: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

DOCUMENTING VIOLATIONS

• Service (Witness)

• Evidence of knowledge

• Terms of Order

Page 16: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

• Expect ambivalence

• Information about process

• Information about service

Page 17: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

Avoid

• prescribing

• oversimplifying

• appearing judgmental

Page 18: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

ABOVE AND BEYOND

• Assist connection to resources

• Request follow up

• Serve orders

• Standby for property pickup

Page 19: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

OTHER ORDERS

• 72 hour NCO

• Bail condition

• Sentencing

• Divorce

Page 20: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

BEHAVIOR THAT COURT CONSIDERS

Domestic Abuse — violence, threats of violence (that are specific), sexual abuse and property damage (in some cases)

Harassment — violence, threats of violence (that are specific), repeated behavior that serves “no legitimate purpose”, stalking, sexual assault

Page 21: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

Child Abuse — physical injury to a child by other than accidental means, various sexual abuse/exploitation (including exposing a child to pornography, causing a child to expose genitals, exposing genitals to a child, prostitution, etc.), emotional damage (from a parent) and manufacturing meth.

Page 22: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

Individual at Risk Interference of an investigationPhysical, Emotional and/or Sexual AbuseTreatment without consentUnreasonable confinement/restraintFinancial Exploitation NeglectHarassment StalkingMistreatment of an animal

Page 23: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

WHY IT MIGHT BE HARD TO GET THE STORY

Embarrassment

Feeling Responsible

Protecting the Abuser

Fear- of abuser, of losing kids, etc.

Denial

Special Circumstances

(disabilities, immigration status, same- sex relationship, financial dependence…)

Page 24: THE CIVIL SIDE OF THINGS: ORDERS OF PROTECTION MS. LISABETH MARQUARDT DIRECTOR, STRATEGIC INITIATIVES

Liz Marquardt, 414-276-1911

[email protected]

RO Clinic, 414-278-5079

Wisconsin Coalition Against DV

(608) 255-0539, www.wcadv.org