the decision of the case "lenta of st. petersburg, russia", babson, bab123, march 1, 2006
TRANSCRIPT
Lenta of St.Petersburg, Russia
Presented by
Ludmila Sedina,
Nastya Mityurina,
Izabella Hrytsayenko,
Anastasia Shemshur,
Nikita Detochenko
Russian Business Environment
Political and Macroeconomic Issues
1990 – 2000: Russia struggled for survival
2400% inflation
Ruble loose 50% of its value
2000 – 2010: Putin’s Goal – 7% annual growth in GDP
Growth largely driven by high oil prices
2004: SMEs contributed to 13% of GDP
Economic success contributed to larger cities
Average monthly per capita income 350% & 40% above national average in Moscow & St. Petersburg
St. Petersburg – 2nd largest city, 4.5m population
Russian Retail Environment
Russia – Dynamic underdeveloped business environment
Rising consumption levels
Fastest growing food market in Eastern Europe
Difficult labour laws – Soviet influences
Lack of work ethics
Lack of loyalty to the employer
Unwillingness to work hard
Government, the greatest barrier
Russian customers are not demanding
The company - Lenta
1992 - Oleg Zherebtsov founded Lenta as a wholesale candy business
1993 – 1st small cash & carry retail store
1997 – 3 smalll retail stores
1998 – ruble collapsed, layoff 75% of workforce, warehouse cash & carry chain selling both grocery and selected non food items
2005 – 9 stores in St. Petersburg
Competitive Advantage
Low prices
Smaller margin than competitors
Convenience of being 24 * 7 open
Competition
Suppliers
Direct relationships with multiple suppliers to keep the prices low
No wholesaler in between
High purchasing power
No distribution warehouse, direct to store deliveries
100-120 deliveries / day
10% imported products – problems with customs
Inventory Systems
POS systems reading barcodes
Monitored using SAP computer system
Track fast & slow selling products
Monitor inventory levels to avoid stock outs & excess inventory levels
Analyze POS data for better decision making
Expansion becomes manageabl
Government Relations
Uninvolvement of Govt. in day to day operations to monitor safety
No government Quality check authority
Random inspection by government agencies – closed down alchoholaisles
Tax rate in St. Petersburg – 24%
Lenta established a tax reserve – "Yukos effect"
Financials
Transaction in Rubles
Financial statements in USD
Lenta had 4 Americans on its Board of directors
Lenta was looking for loans from western financial institutions
Intense Financial Growth
Internal cash flows
Debt Financing
Lenta’s HR Challenges
Hire 500 people, 20 for managerial roles
HR department – new in Russian market
Clash in Lenta's values and Russian market – customer service
Lack of managerial talent in Russia
High attrition rate Profit sharing plan – to retain & motivate its managers
Expansion of HR department – include T & D
Marketing & AdvertisingMarketing & Advertising - .35 to .38% of sales
First mega supermarket in St. Petersburg
Loyalty card program – discount to cardholders Personalised their communications with the customers
Advertising promoted 3 key customer benefits Low prices
Easy & fast shopping
Convenience of being 24 hours open
Billboards, Radio & monthly shopping circulars
Metro Radio – 3m people daily
Advertising for new store opening Inform the public of the opening (2-3 weeks)
Promote the opening day celebration
Building a new store
Land - Lease of 49 years from local government
Approval of plan from local government – fire marshals, environmental agencies, construction agencies, sanitation department
Conflicts between agencies
Corruption – approval on time
High cost to build - $ 20m
Buy extra land to sublet for complimentary businesses
Lenta’s Strategy
Open more stores in St. Petersburg
+ Huge untapped potential
+ No foreign players
+ Existing Relationships with suppliers
+ Established Brand name
+ Relationships with government
Open up stores in Moscow and then other high per capita cities
+ Huge market potential
+ Experience in similar markets
+ Easy availability of infrastructure
– High investment in reals estate
– Different form of government
2 options:
Recommendations
The foundation with their help private financial institute
Searching for lobbyists and business partners in the sphere of political elite and security forces
Intensive expansion in the region due to all of the following
Close cooperation with business schools and government programmes ahead of the elections
Thank you for your attention!