the eleventh annual mcgill university/peopil conference on ...€¦ · montreal 2015 edinburgh 2016...
TRANSCRIPT
Page 1
31AUG18
The Eleventh Annual
McGill University/PEOPIL
Conference on
INTERNATIONAL AVIATION LAW:
LIABILITY, INSURANCE & FINANCE 19-20 October 2018
at
The National Gallery of Ireland
Merrion Square
Dublin 2
Ireland
Page 2
This event brings together World-Leading aviation liability, insurance & FINANCE
experts to address the following topics:
• Comparative Jurisprudence under the Warsaw System and the Montreal
Convention of 1999
• Liability of Airlines, Airports, Maintenance Providers & ANSPs
• Products Liability of Manufacturers Aircraft, Engines & Component Parts
• Governmental Liability
• Consumer Protection Regulation & Litigation
• Aircraft Leasing and Finance
• The Challenges of Settlement
• In addition, the conference will host a luncheon and reception/dinner to facilitate
networking between attorneys, insurers, air carriers, manufacturers and
governmental representatives.
This is the Eleventh Annual McGill/PEOPIL Conference
on International Aviation Liability, Insurance & Finance
Prior conferences were held in:
Toulouse 2008
Montreal 2009
Amsterdam 2010
Montreal 2011
London 2012
Montreal 2013
London 2014
Montreal 2015
Edinburgh 2016
Montreal 2017
Page 3
GOLD SPONSORS
SILVER SPONSORS
BRONZE SPONSORS
Page 4
PROGRAMME
FRIDAY 19 OCTOBER 2018
8:15 – 9:00
REGISTRATION
9:00 – 10:00
Recent Developments in Air Carrier Liability • Comparative Analysis of Recent Warsaw and Montreal Convention
Jurisprudence in Europe, the US, Latin America and Asia/Pacific
• Applicability of the 261/2004 EU regulation to non-EU carriers
• Update on the “extraordinary circumstances” defense: recent EU Jurisprudence
• Recent Aviation Disaster Litigation
• Conflicts Between U.S. and European Courts
• The Challenges of Achieving Global Uniformity
Chair: Paul Stephen Dempsey – McGill University, Montreal, Canada
Speakers:
Luiz Eduardo Arena Alvarez– Arena Alvarez Advogados – Sao Paulo
Jorge Góngora - Góngora Reina & Associates, Bogotá
Andrew Harrington – Norton White, Sydney
Jeanne O’Grady – Speiser Krause, New York
Rebecca Smith - Irwin Mitchell LLP, London
10:00 – 11:00
Liability of Manufacturers of Aircraft and Component
Parts
• Does governmental certification preempt tort claims?
• What are Recoverable Damages?
• The Conflict Between North American and European Courts
• TCAS, Autopilot and Automation
• Will we see more use of the Hague Convention on Products Liability?
• Is there Liability Exposure for Foul Cabin Air and Radiation?
• What is the liability for the use of counterfeit parts?
Chair: Heather Devine – Isaacs & Co., Toronto
Page 5
Speakers:
Stephen Coxhead - Fowler White Burnett, Miami
Vonnick Le Guillou – DLA Piper, Paris
Brandt Madsen – SmithAmundsen, Chicago
David Weiner – Arnold & Porter, Houston
Zhang Chaohan – Northwest University of Political Science & Law, Xi’an
11:00 – 11:20
Refreshment Break
11:20 – 12:20
Liability of Governments for Aviation Accidents and
Acts of Terrorism
• Sovereign Immunity
• The US Foreign Sovereign Immunity Act and the Federal Tort Claims Act
• The US Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act, or JASTA
• What will be the liability exposure of the United States should other nations
enact reciprocal legislation?
• Under what circumstances can a State force a foreign airline to waive sovereign
immunity as a condition of licensing?
• Libya’s Settlement with Families of Pan Am 103
• The Challenges of State Liability: A look at KAL 007, Lockerbie, the September
11, 2001, U.S. terror attacks, MH 17 and Cuban Brothers to the Rescue
Chair: Jim Morris – Ashfords, London
Speakers:
Alisa Brodkowitz – Friedman Rubin, Seattle
Jim Kreindler – Kreindler & Kreindler, New York
12:20 – 13:40
Lunch
Page 6
13:40 – 14:40
Liability of Airports, ANSPs and Maintenance Providers
• Liability of airports for passenger injury
• The contractual liability of the airport operator
• Cyber Security: Airport risk and liability
• Implementation of the data protection EU 2016/679 Regulation
• Airport operation risks, related liability and insurance program
• The lessor and manufacturer liability, latest developments
• Liability of lessors under the principle of negligent entrustment
• Liability of maintenance providers
Chair: Jean-Michel Fobe – Sybarius Advocates, Brussels
Speakers:
Valérie Augros - Avocat à la Cour, Paris
Adrian Cioranu – EUROCAE, Paris
Isabelle Lelieur, Chevrier Avocats, Paris
Ann-Frederique Pothier – Eurocontrol, Brussels
14:40 – 15:50
Court Is in Session: Analyzing the Importance of Trial in
Aviation Accident Cases
Choice of Jurisdiction: Trial Considerations
Comparative Fault and Joint Liability
Admissibility of Government Investigations and Criminal Proceedings
Time to Trial and Cost
Trial, Strategy, and Verdict – Judge vs. Jury
Using “The Threat” of Trial in Settlement Negotiation
Chair: Robert Hedrick - Aviation Law Group, Seattle
Panel Speakers:
Robert A. Clifford – Clifford Law Offices, Chicago
Sigrid Preissl – Bourayne & Preissl, Paris
Gerard Forlin QC – Cornerstone Barristers, London
Joe Fiorante – Camp, Fiorante, Matthews, Vancouver
Page 7
15:50 – 16:10
Refreshment Break
16:10 – 17:30
Aviation Litigation in Ireland: How It Works
• Irish Legal Issues relating to aviation liability and insurance
• PIAB (statutory scheme for personal injury),
• Coroners Inquests after the Norfolk Coroner Judicial Review case
• SAR operations
Chair: James Healy-Pratt – Stewarts Law LLP, London
Speakers:
Kieran Cowhey - Dillon Eustace, Dublin
Simon McAleese – McAleese & Co., Dublin
Patrick McGurgan – Coroner for Northern Ireland, Belfast
18:00 – 19:30
Gala Reception and Dinner
Keynote Speaker:
Stephen Kavanagh, CEO Aer Lingus
THE STEPHEN’S GREEN HIBERNIAN CLUB
9 S t Stephen's Green, Dublin 2
“An unparalleled degree of comfort, refinement and privacy at the heart of Dublin
since 1840”
Page 8
SATURDAY 20 OCTOBER 2018
9:30-10:30
Air Carrier Liability: What is an “Accident”, and What
Damages are Recoverable under the Warsaw/Montreal
Conventions
Review of recent court decisions on what constitutes accident and bodily injury.
To what extent are courts permitting recovery for emotional and mental injuries?
How courts treat medical emergencies in flight?
Review of recent court decisions on the scope of (dis)embarkation.
Should the carrier be liable for passenger-to-passenger assaults?
Should the carrier be liable for occurrences that are not related to the operation of
the aircraft?
What will be the liability exposure of crew and/or air marshals who subdue an
unruly passenger?
Chair: George Leloudas – Swansea University
Speakers:
Simon Balls - Kennedys, London
Michel F. Baumeister - Baumeister & Samuels, P.C., New York
Andrew Harakas – Clyde & Co., New York
Mark K. Schwartz - Driggers, Schultz & Herbst, PC, Troy, Michigan
Page 9
10:30-11:30
The Challenges of Aircraft Leasing and Finance
Smart choices in aircraft investment – asset types and jurisdictional risk
Monitoring the Cape Town Convention – scoring compliance by member States
The future of export credit and financing
Expunging clogs in the title and other interventions: how the Irish High Court
keeps watch on the Cape Town international registry
Subsidies and State aid: updates on the GATT, Airbus-Bombardier and other
recent flashpoints
Chair: Brian F. Havel – McGill University, Montreal
Speakers:
Catherine Duffy – A&L Goodbody, Dublin
Donald Gray- Blakes & Company, Toronto
Dr. Donal Patrick Hanley – ACG Aircraft Leasing Ireland Limited, Dublin
Richard Sharman – Clifford Chance, London
Serap Zuvin - Cakmak Law Offices, Istanbul
11:30-11:50
Refreshment Break
11:50 -13:00
Aviation Litigation in the United States: How it Works Conflict of Laws Venue Forum Non Conveniens Jury Trials Appeals
Chair: Patricia Barlow – Barlow Law, San Francisco
Speakers:
Stuart Fraenkel – Nelson & Fraenkel LLP, Los Angeles
Christopher Knight – Fowler White Burnett, Miami
Kevin Sutherland - Clyde & Co., San Francisco
13:00-14:00 Lunch
Page 10
14:00 - 15:30
The Challenges of Settlement Negotiation & Emerging
Insurance Issues
The Challenges of Multi-Jurisdictional Settlements in Complex International
Aviation Litigation Against Multiple Tortfeasors
Settlement Complications in Cases Involving Long-Missing Commercial Aircraft
Settlement/Payment Difficulties Due to Sanctions and International Trade Controls
Use of “Structured Settlements”
Emerging Insurance Issues (e.g., Acts of Terrorism, Conflict Zones, Cyber Security)
Chair: Alan Reitzfeld – Retired Senior Partner, Holland & Knight, New York
Panelists:
Anna Anatolitou – Ince & Co., London
Martin Blake – Juris Resolutions, Dublin
Steven C. Marks – Podhurst Orseck PA, Miami
Anna Masutti – LexJus Sinacta, Milan
Suzanne McCarthy– Global Aerospace, New Jersey
Page 11
2018 CONFERENCE INFORMATION
Venue: The National Gallery of Ireland
Merrion Square W, Dublin 2, Ireland
Nearby Hotels: See https://hotelmap.com/pro/MCP3Z#calendar
Passport/Visa Information: If you are visiting Ireland, a valid passport is generally required.
It is the responsibility of the visitor, before entering Ireland, to ensure that he or she has the
necessary documents, including those required to enter Ireland or re-entry into his/her own
country.
For latest programme information: Visit the McGill website at
https://www.mcgill.ca/iasl/events/iali/iali2018 and the PEOPIL website at https://peopil.com/
Sponsorship Liaison:
Dr. Wolfgang Resch
PEOPIL
Imperial House
31 Temple Street
Birmingham
B2 5DB
England, UK
www.peopil.com
Email: [email protected]
Tel +44 (0)121 643 4962
Fax +44 (0)121 643 9405
Questions: contact Maria D’Amico at 514-398-5095 or e-mail [email protected]
Page 12
Conference on
INTERNATIONAL AVIATION LAW:
LIABILITY, INSURANCE & FINANCE
REGISTRATION FORM Name _________________________________________________________
Firm: _________________________________________________________
Address: _________________________________________________________
Email: _________________________________________________________
REGISTRATION FEE
Registration fee includes admission to the 2-day program, refreshments,
luncheons, and reception and gala dinner.
Kindly check mark which of the following categories and registration fees apply
to you. All amounts below are stated in British Pounds Sterling
Total Number
EARLY BIRD RATE
After September
15
Total Amount
Delegate Rate* @ £440 @ £490
Speakers* @ £365 @ £400
Students, government, academics, and PEOPIL Young Lawyers Section members
@ £195 @ £225
* Members of PEOPIL, the European Aviation Club, and graduates of McGill University enjoy a
£40 discount off these rate categories. SPECIAL 1-DAY Rate 30% Discount off above rate.
□ I will attend the Friday lunch.
□ I will attend the Friday evening gala dinner.
□ I will attend the Saturday lunch.
Page 13
PAYMENT METHODS:
Payment by Credit/Debit Card
I wish to pay by MasterCard or Visa (WE DO NOT ACCEPT ANY OTHER CREDIT CARDS)
I wish to debit my account with the amount of £ ______
Card No: ______________________________________________
Expiry date:___________________
3 digit Security Code (on the back of the card) _______________
Name as on card:_________________________________________
Cardholder's address:______________________________________
Country _____________________________________________
Date & Signature:____________________________________________
By bank transfer:
I attach proof of payment by bank transfer to PEOPIL (at no charge to the organisers)
Account No 0101 5883
LLOYDS BANK, OLD MARKET SQUARE, NOTTINGHAM NG1 6FD, ENGLAND, UK
Account Beneficiary: PEOPIL
Sort Code 30-96-18
BIC LOYDGB21069
IBAN GB 09 LOYD 3096 1801 0158 83
Payment by Cheque I enclose a cheque for £ ___________
Terms and conditions: This booking form constitutes a legally binding document.
PEOPIL/McGill reserve the right to vary or cancel the conference where the occasion necessitates.
PEOPIL/McGill accept no liability if, for whatever reason, the conference does not take place.
Cancellations will be acceptable in writing and a charge to cover administration will be made as follows: -
prior to the event over 21 days 15%, 14-20 days 50%, 13 days or less 100%.
Transfers to another person will be acceptable in writing and a charge of 15% of the fee to cover
administration costs will be applied.
Date and Sign:
___________________________________________________________________ PLEASE RETURN FORM TO:
PEOPIL, Imperial House, 31 Temple Street,
Birmingham B2 5DB, England, UK
Fax: +44 (0)121 6439405
PLEASE NOTE: Accommodation is not included in this package and McGill/PEOPIL are not responsible for hotel
reservations. You may book a room directly with one of the Conference Hotels.
For available hotels see: https://hotelmap.com/pro/MCP3Z#calendar