the eu insolvency regulation and eu winding up directives and other collateral issues 26 september...
TRANSCRIPT
The EU Insolvency
Regulation and EU
Winding Up Directives
and other Collateral
Issues 26 September 2002
Ian Annetts
Allen & Overy
26 September 2002
Ian Annetts
Allen & Overy
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Introduction
EU Insolvency Regulation EU Winding Up Directives for Credit
Institutions and Insurance Undertakings
EU Settlement Finality Directive Proposed Hague Convention Unidroit: Collateral with Intermediaries
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Introduction to Insolvency Regulation
Council Regulation (EC) No 1346/2000 of 29 May 2000 on insolvency proceedings (the “Regulation”)
Became effective on 31 May 2002 Directly applicable throughout the EU
(with the exception of Denmark)
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Purpose of Regulation
Recognition provisions for both the office-holder and the effects of main proceedings
Clear choice of law rules regarding the effects of insolvency proceedings, co-ordination and other related issues, subject to exceptions
But NOT an attempt to introduce a single European insolvency law
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
When will the Regulation apply?
The “centre of main interests” of the debtor must be in the EU
Must be “collective insolvency proceedings” as listed in Annexes A and B of the Regulation
Debtor may be natural or legal person, a trader or an individual
Does not apply to insurance undertakings or credit institutions - Winding Up Directives
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Choice of jurisdiction provisions
Jurisdiction to open three types of insolvency proceedings: main proceedings where debtor has its
centre of main interests: recognised across EU
secondary proceedings where debtor has an establishment: territorial scope
territorial proceedings where debtor has an establishment and before main proceedings are opened
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Definitions (1)
“Centre of main interests”: not defined but rebuttable presumption that
place of registered office - article 3(1) should correspond to the place where the
debtor conducts the administration of his interests on a regular basis and is therefore ascertainable by third parties (but can therefore change) - recital (13)
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Definitions (2)
“Establishment”: defined as “any place of operations where the
debtor carries out a non-transitory economic activity with human means or goods - article 2(h)
equivalent to a branch office or agency? mere presence of assets unlikely to be sufficient
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Definitions (3)
“Main proceedings”: can be opened in the Member State where
the debtor has its centre of main interests - article 3(1)
universal scope and aim to encompass all the debtor’s assets on an EU-wide basis
any of the proceedings listed in Annex A (winding up or reorganisation proceedings)
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Definitions (4)
“Secondary proceedings”: can be opened subsequently in any Member
State where the debtor has an establishment - article 3(3)
opened by either the office-holder in the main proceedings or any other person authorised to open secondary proceedings under local insolvency law
limited in scope to assets located in that Member State
only winding up proceedings listed in Annex B
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Definitions (5)
“Territorial proceedings”: can be opened before the commencement of
main proceedings in any Member State where the debtor has an establishment - article 3(2)
can only be opened: where main proceedings cannot be opened;
or where requested by creditor with domicile,
residence or registered office in Member State - article 3(4)
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Definitions (6)
“Territorial proceedings” (cont):
not limited to winding up proceedings but can be converted into winding up proceedings if requested by office-holder in main proceedings - article 37
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Choice of law provisions article 4(2)
Law of Member State where proceedings opened generally to determine effect of those proceedings, for example: what assets form part of estate powers of office-holder conditions for set-off effects of proceedings on current
contracts lodging and ranking of claims effects of closure of proceedings avoidance of transactions
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Recognition provisions
Main proceedings to be recognised, and have same effects, in other Member States so long as no secondary proceedings - articles 16 and 17
Foreign officeholder to be recognised in other Member States - article 18
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Co-ordination provisions
Creditors may lodge claims in either or both of main and secondary proceedings - sharing rules if lodge claims in both
Office-holders in main and secondary proceedings duty bound to communicate and co-operate
Each office-holder to lodge claims in his proceedings in any other proceedings
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Impact of the Regulation on Security
The “rights in rem”exception in Article 5 to the primary choice of law rule in Article 4
Opening of insolvency proceedings shall not affect rights in rem of creditors in respect of debtor’s assets situated within another Member State
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Impact of the Regulationon Security (continued)
A “right in rem” includes: right to dispose and to be repaid
from the proceeds of the assets right to the beneficial use of assets
This does not preclude actions for voidness, voidability or unenforceability - Article 5(4)
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Impact of the Regulationon Security (continued)
Determining location of right in rem under Article 2(g): tangible property, the Member State
where the asset is situated registered property, the Member State
where the asset register is kept claims, where the obligor of the claim
has its centre of main interests
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Impact of the Regulationon Security (continued)
Thus, a deposit at the London branch of a German bank would be situated in Germany for the purposes of Article 5 (and otherwise?)
Practical impact on financial markets documentation (structure and drafting)
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Impact of the Regulation on Set-off
The “set-off”exception in Article 6 to the primary choice of law rule in Article 4
Opening of insolvency proceedings shall not affect the right of creditors to demand set-off of claims where set-off is permitted by the law applicable to the insolvent debtor’s claims
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Impact of the Regulationon Set-off (continued)
Thus, an insolvent French company’s deposit made with an English bank’s London branch under English law may be set off as a matter of English law, even if set-off is prohibited under French insolvency law
This does not preclude actions for voidness, voidability or unenforceability - Article 6(2)
Likely impact on financial markets practice and documentation (structure and drafting)
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Impact of the Regulationon Reservation of Title
The “reservation of title”exception in Article 7 to the primary choice of law rule in Article 4
Opening of insolvency proceedings shall not affect the right of a seller to an asset based on reservation of title, and shall not rescind the sale, where the asset is situated in another Member State
This does not preclude actions for voidness, voidability or unenforceability - Article 7(3)
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Avoidance Rules
Consider avoidance rules and effects of Article 13: general rule is that law of Member State where
insolvency proceedings opened will determine the insolvency avoidance rules - Article 4(2)(m)
BUT may be defence under Article 13 if the governing law of the transaction does not allow any means of challenging the detrimental act in the relevant case
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Avoidance rules (continued)
Consider an Italian company which may be subject to main insolvency proceedings in Italy
Under Italian insolvency law, it may be possible to challenge a transaction document under the Italian avoidance laws
If the transaction document is governed by English law, and there is no means of challenging the transaction as a matter of English law, the counterparty will have a defence under Article 13
Care needed over choice of governing law
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Winding Up Directives
Directive 2001/24/EC of 4 April 2001 on the reorganisation and winding up of credit institutions. Implementation by 5 May 2004
Directive 2001/17/EC of 19 March 2001 on the reorganisation and winding up of insurance undertakings. Implementation by 20 April 2003
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Credit Institutions WUD
Home Member State (which authorises a bank) has sole right to implement reorganisation measures or winding up proceedings under the laws of that Member State, subject to exceptions
Those laws will be automatically and immediately effective throughout the Community
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Credit Institutions WUD (continued)
Obligations to inform host Member States with branches and to publicise to third parties
Rules corresponding to Articles 5, 6, 7 and 13 of the Insolvency Regulation
Enforcement of proprietary rights re registered instruments governed by the law where the register is located
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Credit Institutions WUD (continued)
Netting and repurchase agreements are governed by the chosen law of the relevant agreement
Transactions on a regulated market are governed by the law of that market
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Insurance Undertakings WUD
Home Member State (which authorises an insurance undertaking) has sole right to implement reorganisation measures or winding up proceedings under the laws of that Member State, subject to exceptions
Those laws will be automatically and immediately effective throughout the Community
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Insurance Undertakings WUD (continued)
Insurance claims must take precedence in any distribution on winding up
Obligations to inform host Member States with branches and publicise to third parties
Rules corresponding to Articles 5, 6, 7 and 13 of the Insolvency Regulation
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Insurance Undertakings WUD (continued)
Transactions on a regulated market are governed by the law of that market
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Settlement Finality Directive
Directive 98/26/EC of 19 May 1998 on settlement finality in payment and securities settlement systems
Implemented by 11 December 1999
Purpose: to achieve finality of settlement within designated systems, even on insolvency of a participant
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Settlement Finality Directive (continued)
Applies to participants (eg credit institutions, investment firms, public authorities) in systems designated by a Member State’s designating authority
Rules of the system must be governed by the laws of a Member State
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Settlement Finality Directive (continued)
Disapplies insolvency laws which would avoid, revoke or disrupt netting and settlement of a “transfer order” made through a system or collateral provided in connection with transfer orders
Rules of system will be recognised throughout the Community
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Settlement Finality Directive (continued)
Article 9(2): rights in respect of securities recorded in a register, account or centralised deposit system located in a Member State shall be governed by law of that Member State
Place of the Relevant Intermediary Approach (PRIMA)
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Hague Convention
Convention on the Law Applicable to Certain Rights in respect of Securities held with an Intermediary
Concerned only with conflicts of laws
Currently draft of June 2002, to be signed, after diplomatic session, on 14 December 2002
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Hague Convention (continued)
Requires adoption by at least three States and implementation as necessary
Convention will conform private international law treatment of indirectly held securities in line with PRIMA
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Hague Convention (continued)
Article 4 determines where PRIMA is located; likely to be law agreed between parties, either generally or for the purposes of Article 2(1)
If no law is agreed, fallback is law where the intermediary is organised
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Unidroit
International Institute for the Unification of Private Law (Unidroit)
Project on “Harmonised Substantive Rules for the Use of Securities Held with Intermediaries as Collateral”
Scope of project still being determined - end 2004?
BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1BK:969523v1 ALLEN & ALLEN & OVERYOVERY
Unidroit (continued)
Likely to attempt to conform substantive law on creation, perfection and disposition of interests in securities held by intermediaries, including right of intermediary and collateral taker to use securities
The EU Insolvency Regulation and EU
Winding Up Directives and other Collateral
Issues26 September 2002
Ian Annetts
Allen & Overy
26 September 2002
Ian Annetts
Allen & Overy