the holy prophet (sallallaahu Álayhi wasallam) has an education like that of childrenlunatics and...

8/9/2019 'The Holy Prophet (Sallallaahu layhi Wasallam) has an education like that of childrenlunatics and animals of every

1/9

Ashraf Ali Thanvi, a founder member of Deoband says: 'The Holy Prophet (Sallallaahulayhi Wasallam) has an education like that of children, lunatics and animals of everycategory.' (Hifzul Imaan pg. 7)

The TruthThe view of Hadhrat Moulana Ashraf Ali Thanvi is that: Hadhrat Moulana was asked,'Did you in Hifzul Imaan or any other book write anything directly or indirectly comparingthe education of Rasulullah (Sallallaahu layhi Wasallam) to that of children, lunatics andanimals? If not then what is your ruling regarding a person who holds such a belief?' Inreply to that Moulana states, 'Let alone writing such falsehood and filth, my heart hadnever even perceived such falsehood and verily if anyone holds such a belief he is out of thefold of Islam.' (Faisal-e-Khusoomat pg. 21

SUNNI REPLY

Is this not a BIG lie? I have not seen any lie like this on any website. Shias are known forproviding false reference after their claim. But here Deobandis have surpassed shias!

I fall short of words to express my amazement on this lie. The very statement is present in

Hifzaul Iman (page 7) and our Deobandi friend says that Mawlana Asharf ali thanvee was askedthis question and he said this belief is kufr!!


2/9


3/9


4/9

Mawlana Asharf ali thanvee did compare the knowledge of prophet with lunatic , animals ,insane , satan , and any normal person . And this Deobandi writer turns the table and says that

this statement was made by some one else and Mawlana Asharf ali thanvee said that these typeof statement is kufr!

I now ask , are not these websites claiming to propagate the knowledge of Islam?

Isnt lying a big sin in Islam? Then why are they lying?

False Allegation

To think of Rasulullah (Sallallaahu layhi Wasallam) in Salaat is worse than thinking ofcows and donkeys. (Siraate Mustaqeem pg. 150)

ClarificationThe abovementioned statement is not found anywhere in 'Siraate Mustaqeem' that, 'Tothink of Rasulullah (Sallallaahu layhi Wasallam) in Salaat is worse than thinking of cowsand donkeys.'Moreover, it is stated in the Hadith that Salaat should be performed with full attention.Therefore, when the name of Rasulullah (Sallallaahu layhi Wasallam) is recited in'Tashahhud' the thought of the Rasul (Sallallaahu layhi Wasallam) will come and shouldcome. The Salaat will not be rendered incorrect and this is not unlawful at all. Therespected Moulana did not stop anyone from this.

SUNNI REPLY

If we have a number line on which lies can be graded then I will give this lie infinity grade!

Which ever Deobandi website has this article , what did they think? That no one will ever noticethese lies? Or that they will notice but will not reply?

The above statement is present in the book . Please see this scan.


5/9


6/9


7/9


8/9

Deobandis says that "cow, ox , horse" are animals and if some one gets thought of these animalsduring salah then one will automatically try to leave this thought , as they are 'dirty animals" and

one will once again concentrate towards Allah. However, if some one gets a thought of prophet ,

during salah, then due to love of prophet one will continue to indulge in that thought and will no

longer concentrate towards Allah,hence his salah will not be perfect.

Any one who makes this Tawil ( interpretation) of their 'shaheed" sahab's writing has definitely

not read the urdu wordings in the statement.

Islami Dehalvee sahab says the thought is 'worse than" ( zyada bura) than the thought of Ox and

cow.

So shaheed sahab is comparing the thought of prophet and animals together. Morever, whensome one recites durood in salah , one automatically gets a thought of prophet.

A person recites " la ilaha il allah ashraf ali thanvee rasul allah' in his dream and that is alright

for deobandis . The tawil being a hadith in which a man was so happy that he saidz' I am lordand He is my creation" and prophet smiled. Deobandis use this hadith to justify that 'dream', butthe justification won't work. That is for someother time Insha Allah.

So the truth is , Deobandis make tawil only to support their scholars statement. But all these

tawil has been refuted , because these comments were made in Urdu or Farsi language and Ahlus

sunnah scholars have shown with the use of language skills that no tawil can be made here as per

the rules of Urdu and Persian language.

And now be ready to read those lines which will make yourealize what is called the height of double standard

Mawlana Abdul Majid Daryabadi , the beloved disciple and Khalifah of Mawlana Ashraf Alithanvee wrote a book Hakimul Ummat, which is a biography of Mawlana Ashraf Ali thanvee.

Mawlana Abdul Majid wrote a letter to Mawlana Asharf ali about a problem. Both ,the, problem

and its reply by Mawlana Ashraf Ali Thanvee has been mentioned in this book. Read it andplease decide what justice can you do for Islam.

Mawlana Abdul Majid wrote

Lack of concentration in Salaat is an old problem. But it is my experience that whenever I

imagined you in Salaat the problem of concentration vanished only for a short while though.

Nevertheless, please advice me if this action is correct , if it is not, then I shall be careful in

future( Hakimul Ummat, page 54)


9/9

This was the personal question of Mawlana Abdul Majid, now listen to the answer of MawlanaThanvee

Answer

It is correct as long as you do not disclose this to other people

( Hakimul Ummat page 54)

I will leave the judgment on the respected reader. Fear Allah and keep in mind , on that day

when the Sun will be so down that everyone of us will be sweating, when every one of us will be

running from one prophet to another , that day , Sayyedul Anmbiya, will intercede for us.

May Allah give the love of His beloved prophet in the hearts of all the muslims and may we all

die in this state of love. Ameen.

the holy prophet (sallallaahu Álayhi wasallam) has an education like that of childrenlunatics and...

Documents