the pharmaceutical industry and the industrial pharmacist: a partnership for the 21st century
TRANSCRIPT
These are troubled times.....
€90bn Irish bailout ends in tunnoil.Now Europe fears crisis will spread
~. theguardian
Warning that VI< 'may neverrecover' ifGreece exits euro -.:
•
•••
•,
..(l. ,;
I .•:lA I
~ /1. "'t. :;o.a,,' - l
Greek austerity plans not ready, sayeurozone ministers Recession causes
doubts over Italy'sdeficit cut plans
1
....,
-EurOlone mlnls1.rs tUlve ~st doubt onGr••ce'. lIbility to push throughausterity menu re. n••ded to relene a130bn .uro (S170bn: [110bn) bailout.
AI it mtebng 01 finance 11\lOlS1ers In BrusselSGermany's WOlfoang SCnaeuDle saI<I a planagree<! Dy Gret<e'S fragile (oa~uonanerdays Of lalkS was -not at a Sl39t wMre It canDe slgned orrThe EU and IMF demaOde<l stoogent cuts In Gemlan FllIance Mlnls'« WoIfgq SChHII~
return IQ( the baIloUt mooey Ntgoc.IIII.ontlllYefll tome'lf tnOUgtI'
These are troubled times.....
•
.----- MOOCO
u.<--•
GERMAJff
FIWKE~" :tITAlY ~
CH'".-.--w'"
,-__ SOOTH
""'"
• SnlllN RECESSION(two or men quarten of negative~ lnck.u:fng the most rt<leflt quarter)
EMERGEO fROM RECESSION(two lJIIrteI'S (:If negative wowthbut most recent quarter was pos/tllOe)
• OCDGEO RECESSION (..., "'" ....Of morequarttrSof negative~
B1lA2ll
,-J---ARGENTlNA
'Ill- SOUTMAFRlCA
•
·....and pharma ;s not ';mmune~Fewer New Drugs Gain ApprovalPharmaceutteal companies have spent more on research anadevelopment over time. but have discovered fewer novel drugs goodenough to gain EO.A. approval.
PHARMAC£unCAL R&OEXPENOIT\JRES
$ 70 "'Iben
NEW DRUGSAPPROVED·
60
'95 '00 '10'OS'00
20
o'95
10
40
30
50
'09'OSI i ,
PhrMa...........iiie'fiitJe;fS· .
1""",1
10
o
60
50
40
30
20
• Does not Include biologies, "'Pharrnaceu!tcal Research and Manufacturersof Amcnca. or PhRMa, Includes most or the maJOr U.$. pharmaccutlcalresearch and biotechnology companies.
Souroes: Food .-ld Drug Admlnl51ratlon;Phal'fNCeUtal R~rch aM t·l.Nlut'ectorp.1"l cA Amenca
.....and pharma is not 'immune~
$40
$50
$43.0
$311.11 $39.4
New DrugApprov.1s (NHE.)
PhRHA Hom....rRaD Spe.nding-
53
60
50
-~ 39 -z: 40 ,"9.8c.2z 3 30 -- -$26.0 .-.. so- 26 ~8 30,.
30 $2.2.7 ....> -0 25 $19.0 $21.0
~- 24.. 22 $16.9.. 21 $20 etc $15.2 18 .." 20 $12.7 $"1:3.4 17 ~, E~ $11.5 ~~ ..0 ~
~..,.
10$JO
z
o $0
1992 1993 1994 1995 J996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
SOUl( : B.,,,II 8[ Con'POny: US ~ood and 0'''9 A""'-lIaUon
Drug Development is a Costly Business
The cost of producing a successful marketable productwas approximately €980 million in 2006
• Figure includes both the cost of the successful candidateand those of the failures.
• Failures represented over 70% of the total cost in 1995.
• Only 34% of new drugs introduced between 1990 and1994 registered revenues that exceeded the averageresearch and development cost (blockbusters).
• In 2003 it was estimated that in order to maintain ahealthy revenue growth rate of 10%, the ten largestpharmaceutical companies would need to launch aboutthree new compounds per year. Less than two launchesper company were actually achieved in 2000.
Drug Development is a Costly Business
Number of Compounds to Produce a New Drug
FDA Review
Phase 1111,000-5,000 Volunteers
PhUt 11100-500 Volunteers
5-10 Compounds
Phase I20-100 Vo:unteers
Clinical Trials
250 Compounds
Preclinical
• 3-6 Years • • 6-7Years • +- 0.5 - 2 Years --+
Source: PhRMA and FN estimates
Drug Development is a Costly Business
Number of Compounds to Produce a New Drug
Phase laPhase Ib Phase Ha
40-60 healthy 30-50 healthy 50 - 200
subjects patientssubjects
$300,000$300,000 $750 ,000
6 months6 months-l 9 months -2
year years
•6·1 Years
•
;p.==~~----- ,I' ' l...
•
Clinical Trials
•
Preclinical
3·6Vears•
Source: PhRMA and FN estimates
Drug Development is Time-Consuming
Number of Compounds to Produce a New Drug
FDA Review
Phase 1111,000-5,000 Volunteers
Phase 11
100-500 Volunteers
5-10 Compounds
Phase I20-100 Vo:unteers
Clinical Trials
250 Compounds
Preclinical
• 3-6 Years • • 6-7 Years • +- O.5-2Yean --+
Source: PhRMA and FN estimates
10-'5 years from start to launch
Growing Regulatory Conservatism
- - •
"The Committee's decided to ban further researchuntil it can be proven your 'wheel' poses no
threat to the environment, societ or public health"
Technology Stagnation
• 2004: Waters introduces the first of its ultra-high performanceliquid chromatography instruments (Acquity UPLC®), capable ofwithstanding the high pressures associated sub-2 flm particlecolumn technology.
• 2006: Waters launches Acquity UPLC® H-Class for researchers"who have been attracted by the promise of UPLC but remainreluctant to change largely because of their comfort levels withexisting HPLC systems and techniques" (Rohit Kanna, WatersVP ofworldwide marketing).
• 2012: Legacy methods are still running under HPLC quaternarymethodology. Companies try to obtain advantages of sub-2 flmparticle columns on regular HPLC instruments, or change tocore-shell columns, but few, if any, migrate to ultra-highperformance liquid chromatography.
Just to put things in perspective...
-_.. _...--- -- ----_.. -...-_.. - ---_... ------
------ ----
•
- -------- -----~-- _-..-- --
----_._-
Consequences of Technology Stagnation
• Production and quality control are not state-of-theart compared to other industries.
• Products are of good quality, but this comes atgreat effort and cost compared to other industries.
• High manufacturing costs are compounded by theuse of technologies that are inefficient by modernstandards.
• Technology stagnation in manufacturing andanalysis acts as a bottleneck in the development ofinvestigational medicinal products, particularlybiotechnological products.
Drug Development is Time-Consuming
Number of Compounds to Produce a New Drug
FDA Review
Phase 1111,000-5,000 Volunteers
Phase 11
100-500 Volunteers
5-10 Compounds
Phase I20-100 Vo:unteers
Clinical Trials
250 Compounds
Preclinical
• 3-6 Years • • 6-7 Years • +- O.5-2Yean --+
Source: PhRMA and FN estimates
10-'5 years from start to launch
Drug Development: A Race Against Time
20Blockbuster US Patent Expiries
18
20s(,1I16
BlaxinPrlnlv1l~ Intron Zlthromax<Il 14c: Imigran0 Novolin- Augmentin.- 12 Noupog(lnto
'" Rocephln Oxycontin~ Glucophagc 2010ft<Il 10.. Levaquln
'" M.lavotinCl) 8 Coton- Claritln Ditlucan
Provacld0 Advair Pravachol0
6NFla....nt
Lovenox
PaxllElfexor
4 Plavtx Epogon
Louc ZocorFosamaxNeurontln
2Procrlt Norvasc
Clpro Rlsperdal0
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
o~
'D[]J@
Drug Development: A Race Against Time
Annual Sales Volume in the EUbecoming available for competition
2,2682,115
1,024 1,018
2,059
°
2,000 1,1'74
1,000
€ million 2,On
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Drug Development: A Race Against Time
Developed Markets Generic Share
11.9% .
~Canada
olulV
24.2%
15.3%
16.2%
5.0% : 8-9%
13-14%
21-22%
21-22%
27-28%
.2010 Generic Share
.2015 Share Increase
'.'~5 Kore.
.
31.7% I 34-35%
12.8% 15-16%
.:l::.W
u,
- .'
21.3% : •. 27-28%
13.4% 21-22%
SourcE': IMS Market Prognoiis. Apr 2011
Drug Development: A Race Against Time"
.2010 Gel'!.'rk Sl'are
2015 Sh~re I"crea~e
27-28
8-9%
""=;-J 13-14%
,~.
........
lo...
P"",." SOLUTION.~-
::CoUlpanie's offer a mixed portfolio ofnt;~.- .".",," '::),ne:dici'hes"and generio m=-=ec1icines; 22
PI.... E_ p~ Ell '''' 21-22%
.........cRIop«d.1
HOWEVER2,268 34-35%
€. The' gene'rics market is a differenlngl1 game.2,000 1,774 ..~
•
•,
....
-~ .
~ l~
ID 12~
i 10
•~ .-
MiWY originatotOcompanies do not possess the e~perience
and/or know-how to play in the generic space, and musta,cquire or form joint ventures with existing players.
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Is Europe prepared to pay?In Europe, generics make up almost one halfofvolume
sales, but merely a fraction ofvalue sales100%
90%79%
70% 70%g Volume - generic market shareIIValue - generic market share
57% 60%50% 52% 53% 53%
48%
37% 38% 42% 4
13% 4
13% 43% 4~% 4~
32% 33% 34% iiI f"7% 28% i IiI I 28% I 28% 28% 30%
11 I!§ 18% 18% 17%16% 13% 13% 13% 13% 16%20%
0%
30%
60%
70%
40%
50%
80%
10%
Is Europe prepared to pay?
The European Union constantly considers costcontainment policies in public pharmaceuticalspending.
• External reference pricing as a tool to controlprices and set a parameter of expenditures.
• Rebates, clawback and payback policies.• Internal reference pricing.
The inclusion of the most recent medicinalproducts in reimbursement lists or governmentformularies is sometimes inexplicably delayed.
Is Europe prepared to pay?
"Europe has unfortunately slipped in termsofits willingness to pay for innovation. ...We're now at a point where we have to takethe view and I thinkface the reality thatreally it's about the us. and, excitinglyanew, it's about Japan in terms ofwhereinnovation should be driven."
(Sir Andrew Witty, CEO GlaxoSmithKline)
Where have we heard this before?R&D INVESTMENT
Pharmaceutical R&D ExpenditureNME LAUNCHES
New Molecular Entities (NMEs)by Region of First Launch
0+--.-.--,...,--,-.---.---.-.-..,9293949596979899000102
- -----
- ••/
-
Europe
U.5.
$30
IIIZ 20o-......-III'"
us
CAGR92-02
11%
8%
100%
80
60
40
20
o
203
1993-1997
170
1998-2002
It's not quite deja vu.Enter the Pharmaemerging Markets
Spending by Geography
$l,175-1,20SBn
2006
Soulte: IMS Hafht Progrosis., H,y 2012
2011
• United States
• EU5• Japan• Pharmerglng
• Canada• Rest of Europe• South Korea• Rest of Wond
It's not quite deja vu.Enter the Pharmaemerging Markets
RANk 2006 INDEX RANK 2011 INDEX RANk 2016 INDEX
1 United States 100 1 United States 100 1 United States 100
2 Japan 35 2 Japan 36 2 A China 3'3 A France 13 3 A China 21 3 V Japan 364 V Gennany 13 4 Germany 14 4 A Brazil 15
5 .6. China , 5 V France 12 5 V Germany 13
6 V Italy 8 6 .6. Brazil , 6 V France 11
7 A Spain 6 7 V Italy , 7 Italy 8
8 V UK 6 8 V Spain 7 8 A India 7, V Canada 6 , Canada 7 , A Russia 7
10 Brazil 5 10 V UK 7 10 V Canada 6
11 Australia 3 11 A Russia 5 11 V UK 6
12 Mexico 3 12 V Australia 4 12 V Spain 5
13 South Korea 3 13 A India 4 13 V Australia 4
14 Russia 3 14 V South Korea 4 14 A Argentina 4
15 V India 2 15 V Mexico 3 15 V South Korea 416 A Turkey 2 16 Turkey 3 16 V Mexico 3
17 V Netherlands 2 17 A Poland 2 17 A Venezuela 318 V Belgium 2 18 A Venezuela 2 18 V Turkey 319 A Greece 2 19 V Netherlands 2 19 A Indonesia 220 V Poland 2 20 V Belgium 2 20 V Poland 2
...... Change in ranking over prior 5 yearsAppendix notuR~nking in all years based on spending in constant US! at 04 2011 ellthange riltes.
Source: IMS Market Prognosis. May 2012 Index in each ~ar based on rat;o of country spending to U.S. spending (in constant USl) in the y~ar.
Outsourc;ng ;5 not new
CHIHIIs bKOmllIll • key ptodllCHt'ttlopIlItIlI (till"!of Gtntrll £ltclrk, Inttt.Pllifips,. Nicrosoft. _ ot/wf tlldruniuqIInts. Strfftqths; .ft IIIrdWIlt dI1lQn,nd tllIbtddfd soft'Hre. CII ctetersfOf ...__South r.orN lA!~
in CNStJI Cities..
PlIUP~K£S
Mort thM a.ooo for..C 'p'M15sourtt -"11_etfflnt n PlrUWIUI fibt~lic Unb. StttnqUIs ..dadt Iluqt SlIPPY of Enohh-spH~col.tducltfd KtoIIIIIMtS, soft·••t wriltrs,lrtllltKtS. 1,ltmllttl'm,,1Id QI'.phic artists..
MUICO8e<om!IlQ. f.YOI'it. rT IIld t.ttflnqoutsourtift9 hmnlor Us. compilitstf'IIt ...1to keep-' dM' to Ilomt.As CM Ind tlKtronlts COlDpiMs 110ftlIIiICM:twiIQ 0'l'H tbt botdfi. tMy It.baostln9 dtGlincl for~
OtAP trIKMI «ISts .1Id tcb:.It"wortfOfCt IUkt s'n JoH .ltril'IllQspot tor ell cHtrn fM1ttillQ SpillisItsptlklaq consumtrs In lilt U.S.•1lII[lI'opt.
AWORLD~r OF
OUTSOURCING
SOUTH AfRICAWtll-.duc.led spNktn of french, [n
41bll••nd Gfl'1M1l lrom,lI Mr ,lfrluisuff QrOWia9 ell cIDllfl c:.ltrinq mainly 10 EurOJlHI COt'I'lfIInln. OHf9U!.tlon
.,...", oIltlKom cOlld spHd 6t'tt1oplnHt.r- otlltf c.aII cfllttrS.rt 091.19"'.
Mawitius.
USTlRH [UROP!IIdII.nd AIlltIUI rT senb ptoftdtn.re oprflIn9 otnm Illllunq¥y. PoIud,IIId t!lf ClKil RfIIlIbIic. to 11Jl.~1tGtnMn lid~....... wortfOftt!or Eil"op4!llI cltllts.1OlUllIi W a..~riI.rtQl'owiJl9 IS IT .or~s lotGtnMl'I multiNtiorwlls.
RUSSIISome 100 local software servlce u'pon.rs tflIP»v \Ill to 10,000 ttlQiHfl'SsptCilIlizinq In complex projKts.llotlnqMOft.1. Motoroli. Illd lnttlllm slIIIIIItU (utrn. Stil Ms ID tllOflllOU5 ...I~d pool of -.,sttl"'s IIId dortoRttsin K»rx:ts. IT. Md UIl.
, INOIIJT stmces. dlIp~ uII ctnItrs,IlllIIlI&sint'U ,*,-otfiu W'lIflIlrNdy9fftfl'1tt $10bib Iaflpom Md cNdIlit S57 ... by 2008.1rd1n prtMOtnlu 1Itl, Iltosys,1Ad 'I'trv -Hlt11119IobiI1t1llltrs.1lld us. IT StRict f.1IlS1ft piI:IllQ 1ft.
Outsourcing is not newSOIII. mICA
IHIII
S-1OO 1Dc.II.of~Sf,... et , •.portm tIIlploy up to 1O,ooo"'Hfflsllfdllll ~ In COI!1plt. projII(t1. '"1Il9Jiklrtr Iilolllftlla. Ud ItItrlllnt 1IUtIRHI cmln. StllllM .. fllOl'bIUS_1'llPtd IlDOt of ..sttl"s II'ld doctorltft,n KItN:M. IT. MId IUtII.
EJS1lIII EIIIIIl
'IIfI f'ducItlld~ 01 FflllCll. Ea,au. lad GfnIoIII". III OWl' AImsutl''' ....1lIlI c.- cllltftJ utrr 119"I, to £JIfllOHll to"'P"n. ......l1onof ttIKClI'll cOllId '"" elf t'tlollmtnl0tW UQtm II'f O\A : , Ill_...........w~nwr "prof."art OClItlb19 ol'!ns IlllbJl9lry. PolIad..nd tilt Cltdl..,..SO tilt et.e1Mt~ _ £tl9lilH(>NklllllJ foruIof £sroptM citm. ........ "" ,_"IS""kS_rot
,....-. Gtmin IIIIlItIMtlcNlt.
t!..1Jut this is differe
AWORLDOF
OUTSOURCING
!«o1Dlllq' f.yo!1tt IT Ind .ftQiattflllllouIiOU1"Ol1CJ 1IIwa!of us.~tIlIt ....1to kHf -.on ellst to /lolllf.As CIf IIld tlf(ll'OQks cocrp.u 110....NIlU1tclllFWl O'l'tf lhI botdtr. tlWy ...boost 119 6tNnd tor "9'IlHrs..
COSIIIKICht.p trltcOlll costs.nd tdutllfllwortfotu IIlIU Sfn)oll • t/lrMItjspot for ull crntM Itrqdl/lq S~sll
SpUI'II9 alIlSumtrs In tIW U,$. aMEwopt.
IT ~ICM, cbill dt5iq11, ull Ctlll,rs.IIld tMlM$S blck-otric. wrd alrN:IyOtllll'litf $10 bIlbIlI ,.ports IfIdau:Iflit $51 biIlDJI by 2008. WdIn (ll'CIYiCItB'r TN,lnfosys. iftCIWiPfO ....." art
910llaJ lears. and US. IT MMC,!irmsIr, PIIInq ilL
Outsourcing is not newSOUIH IflICA
S-1OO lDc.II.ofhroan sttYIct , •.portfn tmploy up to 10,000fG9I~sllfdlllllllJ In QNll9lrx ...ojKl:s. blllq)lGrtf Motllftlla, lid IIlt,1 Un SUIRiD (film. Stilll.llM 'llOflDClUS"tCllltd PIli of ..sttl"s II'ld doctorllft'n KItf'C:n. IT. MId IUtII.
lUll
USlllll [1JIIIl
.....W A.'lItI1c:iD rT wr .,prof.n
..OIlItlb19 ol'!ns Illlblolry. PoIIad."Id tilt Cltdla.p.tllitlo tilt et.e1Mt~_~k ..fortt
for lsroptM tints. ............0Il'\I "" , ...1.., itS " WOfblilOO:1 forGtmin IIIIlItIMtlcNls.
Wlhducltlld~ of fflllCll, [aflU, lad GfnIoIII". III OWl' A'/bsutl'''....1lIlI aI ctIItftJ Yl:.II119"., 10 brooNn~Dtfll~.lJDft
of ftlKCItI COlIllI sptH cif tllop'1'ofnt.Otatr aGlm ft O\ii : , lIP •.-
t!..1Jut this is differe
AWORLDOF
OUTSOURCING
CHIM
Men tu. "000 forfl9ll toMNMS~-* lIl_lMfIftll n PI'"IriUI fibtNlpllC 1. SlmllItfI$"cllldr .... JIIIIlCIIy If~ fit.ul .. tdCittd _Cl I_I, 10ft..", 'lIIfflm. .I'tbitKll.l ht·'rl, ... qr.p/lIC Irtists.
S«0IllIq' f.-..o!1tt nMd ,tQiattfUlllOllIsourtlllCJ ",,"!'of us. (:OlII£IIIIH
UIIt ....1to ""' 1IPOrt dDS' 10 1lorM.As tit IIld tlf(troQks collp.n 110....NIlUIICIIIFlIl9 CMf lM bOtdtr. tlWy ...boost IllJ 6tNnd for tnqIllHrs..
IS bKomrtICI. Uy (IJtldIct*__IIlU! tM:tl' tor GtwII OKltIt, IIItrl.PIlitips.. McrosafL _lIttIIf NI;1...cs.lIb. SU'tftlIIM Il'. ""dwlft .....aIId ICllIlirddtd 1On..",_ e- cnltrsfer ....1Id 50uUI~ .rt .,.130III cNStJII atJft.::m
COSIIIKICht.p trltcOll toSb.nd tdutllHwortfotet IIlIU Sill Josf • tllrMIItjspot for nil c,nl«1 IIfqfl'Aq S~sll
spu~ 119 COIlSUlMl1ln tilt U,$.....Ewopt.
Made inAsia'1 ~ICM, cbill~ ull Ctlll,rs.IIld tMlM$S b1ck-offic. wrd alrN:IyOf._ $10 lIIlkrIlI ,.ports IfIdau:Illit $51 biIlDJI b~ 2008.lrdIn prtIYidtrs•• t.tI,lnfosys,IlldWVO .....,.rt
910ClaJ "ldtrs. and US. IT MMt", firmsIr, plIInQ In..
Outsourcing is not newSOUIH IflICA
S-1OO lDc.II.ofhoarl sttYIct , •.portfn tmploy up to 10,000fG9I~sllfdlllllllJ In CM9ltJ ...ojKl:s. blllqIklrt' Motllftlla,lIld Iatel Un SUIRiD cflltn. S MiM 'llOfblUS"l'llPtd IlDOt of ..sttl"s II'Id doctorllft'n KltN:n. IT. MId /UtI\.
Inll
USlllll [1JIIIl
..... .and A.'lItI1c:iD rT wr .,prof.n
..OIlItlb19 ol'!ns Illlblolry. PoIIad."Id tilt Cltdla.p.tllitlo tilt et.e1MtGHNI_~k ·lforttfor lsroptM tints. .............0Il'\I "" , ...1" itS " WOfblilOO:1 forGtmin IIIIlItIMtlcNls.
Wlhducltlld~ of fflllCll, [aflU, lad GfnIoIII". III OWl' A'/bsutl'''....1lIlI aI ctIItftJ Yl:rllll9"., to brooNn~Dtfll~.lJDft
of ftlKCIl'I COlIllI sptH cif tllop'1'ofnt.Otatr aGlm ft O\ii : , lIP •.-
t!.1Jut this is differe
AWORLDOF
OUTSOURCING
CHIM
Men tu. "000 tortllJlll toMNMS~-*111_ *ffIft1l n PI'"IriUI fibtNlpllC 1. SlmllItfI$"cllldr .... JIIIIlCIIy If~ fit,.ul .. tdCittd _Cl I_I, 10ft.••, writ'1'\, .I'tbitKll.l itt·ttl, 'lidor" Irtists.
1«OIIllI4. f.-..o!1tt nMd ,tQiatttlllllowIiOU1'til1C1 ",,"!'of us. (:OlII£IIIIH
UlIt ""'I to kHf 1IPOrt dDS' to IlomtAs tit IIld tlf(troQks collp.n 110....NIlUIICIIIFlIl9 CMf lM bOtdtr. tlWy Inboost IllJ 6tNnd for tnqIllHrs..
IS bKomrtICI. Uy (IJtldIct*__...1cMfl' I. GtwII OKltIt, IIItrl.PIlllips. M;uosafL _lIttIIf NI;1...cs
0II/IlJ. SU'IftlIIM Il'. ""dwlft .....and rlIlDtdr:lrd 1On..",_ e- cnltrsfer ....1Id 50uUI~ .rt .,.1301IIc~ crtlft,::m
COSIIIKICht.p trltcOll toSb.Ad tdutllHwortfotet IIlIU Sill Josf • tllrMIItjspot for nil c,nt«'J IIfqfl'Aq S~sll
spu~ 119 COIlSUlMl1ln tilt U,$. aMEwopt.
Invented in AsiaIT ~1Cn, cblll lift, ~ uil (MI',I'$,.lld tMlM$S b«k-offiClI'ITd alrNdyOtIlll'Itf $10 bilbIWl ,.ports Ifld aM:!flit $51 bt"1OI'I b~ 2008.lrdIn proyidtBhkt lftI,lnfosys. MCIW~ ...MIr.rt910ClaJ 1I1dtrs. and US. IT MfV'C' firmIr, plIlnq In..
Are emerging markets the solution?
( Global New Molecular EntitiesCountry Availability
Global Launches of New Molecular Entities
..... -- -.tlWlovatar• Orphan• fellowet'
o+-L-LJ--L.....LJL.....JL.I......--,O....................'"
... ,
3S ,~ "',wis 2S ~z
~ ,.,w,z
IS
~9 10 <~
5 1
w,ao"z
~ "'''~
5 ..""> SO"<> ...""B "'''" ,."~
~
""0w• '"<,~
#
• Add1tIon~1 2006·2010 NME available In 2016
• 2006-2010 NME available In 2011
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 IAverage1Per Ye"r12012 •l~l~ _
Are emerging markets the solution?
rE t e
",oltor
to 2011 IAver.I Per Yeilr12012 •
12016
Pharmerglng
• Additional 2006·2010 NME available In 2016
.2006-2010 NME available In 2011
Developed
Global New Molecular EntitiesCountry AvailabilityG b.
ew>: SO%~ z< "'..z "'"-"" ~ 70%
~ "'.. ..5 "'.. :5 60%-" '"~ """ :c SO%~ """ >- 40%~ ::l"'..0 UI 30%~ 20..~ 0• 10.. ~ 20%0 Cl~ ...« ... 10%<
~C. ~~~0
< w~ .. ! ~ ::l :! l;
I E~ - . '" O'lb8
,'"rVI
"#AdehU
• 2006-
SoY'''': IMS IMtltuto for KNItha,. In
Sourm: IMS Instituto for HNlthcalll Inbtn/ltic\ May 2012
Are emerging markets the solution?
GLobaL Launches of New MoLecuLar Entities
no 2011! AverageI Per Yeilr12012 •
12016
rE t e
OVdtor.- - --looovator• Orphan• Follower
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 1AverageI Per Year 112012 - 1l2016 _I
15
10
40,
5
35
o
VI 30w
o 2Sz
~ 20w>:z
~9"
""'..G b,
20..
10.....
"'..
Sou'''': IMS IMtltuto for KNltha..
Source: INS Instituto for HoaLthcart lnblNtics. May 2012
So let~s access emerging markets
This is not as straightforward as it seems.
• Diverse healthcare systems
• Fragmented markets
• Complex regulatory systems
• Cultural and language barriers
• Increased competition (local and global)
• Varied infrastructure
• Highly dynamic situation
India: A case study
In 2005:
• Sector ranked 4th worldwide in volumeterms, 13th in value.
• Market worth €3.6 billion (1% of worldmarket in value, 8% in volume).
• Growth rate of 5.1%, projected to reach€18.8 billion by 2010.
• Total exports around €2.25 billion, to over65 countries.
India: A case study
Why this success?
Jugaad: Literally, anarrangement or aworkaround, which has tobe used because of lack ofresources. Practically, acreative idea, a quick,alternate way of solving orfixing problems.
India: A case study
Today:
• Plans to widen scope of price controls to348 medicines from the current 74. "Mostcountries follow some form ofprice control.We need to ensure that expensive drugs areavailable at affordable rates to the poor."
(D.S. Kalba, Secretary, Pharmaceutical Department)
India: A case study
Figure 2: The Wealth Pyramid across the emerging markets (adapted from Prahalad andL1eberthal, 1998').
Purchasing power parity
In U.S. dollars
Population in millionsChina India 8razil
hi\ Greater than $20,000 2 7 9
a lot
Have \ $10,000 to $20,000 60 63 15
Have less \ $5,000 to $1 0,000 330 125 27
Have not \ Less than $5,000 800 700 105
India: A case study
Today:
• Plans to widen scope of price controls to348 medicines from the current 74. "Mostcountries follow some form ofprice control.We need to ensure that expensive drugs areavailable at affordable rates to the poor."
(D.S. Kalba, Secretary, Pharmaceutical Department)
• Big Pharma is having a hard timeprotecting the intellectual property of itsanticancer drugs.
India: A case study
"The danger ofpushing the pricesofprescription drugs down, down,down is that at some point thebusiness model of developingthese drugs will lose itsattractiveness. India isbecoming very reluctant torespect IP for Western companiesand that is becoming a challenge
fi "or us.
(Marijn Dekkers, CEO Bayer)
Is the writing on the wall?
Romania
100%
Brazil16Mn
PolandMexkoe·
Turke
South Africa •
Russia
Argentina. •
20% 40% 60% 80%% OF POPULATION WITH 2016 INCOME >55,000
•k1stan
• Indonesia
lodaIOOMn
Vietnam
Volume Growth and PopulationsWith >$5,000/year Income by Country in 2016
80%
~ 70%~,N '0%~
~, SO%
~ 40%05 30%w,0 20%"0> 10%#
0%
-10%
0%27.$
$9580
Tier 3Ph"rmel'1ll l "O
~... 1,
4.'
$2780•
• Brand spending
3.3 7.1
$2980
S150 - 16SBn
519480
1.9 2.6
$4780
• Total spending
11.2 7.9
Pharmerging Spending and Growth
516180
2011
SpendingIn 2016
Growth to2016
SoUJal: IMS InstitutQ for HoNlthcare Inknnaticl" IMS M«1'lIIt Proonosi$, IUV 2012 Sourct: lnstitutll fof HoNlthcn lofol1lllltics. I"S ~(bt Prognosis,. May 2<112; ((onollist IrttlliQtOtll Urnt, Jan 2012
Is the writing on the wall?
Pharmerging Spending and Growth
SpendingIn 2016 S161.n
r
SpendingIn 2016 51618" $478" $29B" •$278n
Tier 3Phannerglng
$9S8n
ton y n 0 6
Jtn AtnGll •
•Roman..
JSSIol •
PolandMexICO••
_-,"'!!!r~
SO,*, 100%
>$5,000
nO
'Mo
$150 - 1658"
Growth to2016
10.4
Growttl to2016
10.4 1.. 2." 4." 7.7
$194Bn2011
11.2 2011
eT""Sourw: LIIS 11lSt1t\I'- fof IiNlthCl'" In"" 11.2 7•• J.J 7.1 27.5
• Total spending • ","od spending
Source: JMS InstitutQ for ttwLthcarv lnformatics,. INS Hafkot Prognosis,. Hay 10lZ
Is the writing on the wall?
....,16'"
South AfnGll •
•
RUSSia •
a. Romanta
ulot ononyn06
Ol~ fcotlOPlSllnt....9"'IO' lImL Jln 2012
PolandMexICO••
,----""''''''''--BO,*, 100%
)ME :>$5,000
•Romania
100%
BraZil16Mn
South Africa •
Russia •Argentina.
• Thailand
IndialooMn
• Indonesia
20% 40% 60% 80%
% OF POPULATION WITH 2016 INCOME >55/000
Vietnam
•akist:an
Volume Growth and PopulationsWith >$5,OOO!year Income by Country in 2016
PolandMexico••
-10% +- "!.!u!!:.!!rk
0%
80%
'" 70%-•N 60%-:<l:I: 50%
~ 40%0
"Cl 30%w:E=> 20%....0> 10%I-
0%
SpendingIn 2016 $161.n
11.2
2011
10.4
Growth to2016
•~"~ "" ,_••, ... 'oh•• , I
Source: Institute for tWalthc:.w Infonnatics. IHS Milrblt Proonosis, May 2012; ECOllOlllst Intilij~ Unit,..lan 2012
Challenges in Emerging Markets• Many companies struggle with regulatory standards in
different global regions; companies from certain regionsmay work to higher standards than FDA or EU GMP.
• Pricing products is problematic. Different systems existand reference pricing lists change regularly. The wrongdecision in one market can backfire in an another region.NICE-like systems are being established in emergingmarkets.
• Products from certain countries are not easily registered inother countries due to historical and cultural issues.
• Wealth Pyramid is unlikely to change and generatesdifferent attitudes towards intellectual property protection:counterfeiting activities follow pharma in emergingmarkets.
Challenges in Emerging Markets
2016 Pharmaceutical Spend Per Capita2005$ and Population
900..III 800::>0z 700~III
" 600
ii!0 500
~~ 400u
'" 300~
;;J. 200::>zz" 100
0
Developed Ph.-merglng
US. $892 Pop. 326Mn
Japan $644 Pop. 124Mn
Canada $420 Pop. 36Mn
EUS $375 Pop. 320Mni -
South Korea $323 Pop. SOHn
Rest of Europe $321 Pop. lOSMn
Brazil $180 Pop. 201Hn
Russia $179 Pop. 14QMn
China $121 Pop. l,349Mn::---7-=:-::'--.,....,..,-:::-:-"'
Pharmerylng l1er 3 $96 Pop. i,OUMn
India $33 Pop. l,292Mn
POPULATION
50011:.: IKS Mol/ut Progf1OSl\, ~...Jy 2012: EconolA;st ht.llig,nc. Unit. Join 2012
Falsified Medicinal Products
2008 2009 2010 2011
Number of cases 3,207 3>368 1,812 2,494
Number of articles 8,891,056 11,462,533 3,200,492 27,460,538
India UAE India China(51.6%) (73-7%) (93.2%) (68.2%)
Provenance Top 3Syria India China India
(36.4%) (22.6%) (4·7%) (28.2%)
UAE China Hong Kong Hong Kong(8.7%) (l.4%) (04/0) (1.5%)
European Commission Taxation and Customs Union
Quality and safety are non-negotiable
• Manufacturer will remain responsible for ensuringEU GMP compliance of the API manufacturers heuses. Applicant for MA must confirm in writingthat manufacturer of finished product has verifiedcompliance with EU GMP of API manufacturerthrough audits.
• Finished product manufacturer must ensure thatAPIs it uses have been manufactured in line withEU GMP & distributed in line with EU GDP byconducting audits.
• Onus is on Qualified Persons.
Quality and safety are non-negotiable
• Medicinal products to bear safety features enablingwhole distributors and persons authorised orentitled to supply medicinal products to the publicto verify the authenticity of the medicinal productand identify individual packs, as well as a deviceallowing verification of whether the outerpackaging has been tampered with.
• Qualified Person has to ensure that the safetyfeatures have been affixed on the packaging.
Changes in the industry: globalisation
• Local knowledge is thekey to working locally, buthow is this knowledgeintegrated with the rest ofthe corporation?
• Change agents whosefocus is emerging marketsare needed throughoutthe organisation toprovide the missing link.
SCOTTISII IIIGIII~NI)S--
NOHTIII;HN V'.;1"N"M--Never underestimate Ihe importance of local knowledge.---_..__....._-_._.....-
"'...:.......-. .._-_....._-_.-............._.",_..--_..._.._...-....--_.._-__ 4. -- ... _
-..._-_ _.._-- "' ..--_...__ .,..: ......01==-01"-'-_"'_ HSBC ID_...,...;.. ..... _ '"'" workI'Iloc&1 blnIc
Changes in the industry: biologicals
60 -,----------------------------
"'0~ 50Qi...'"....~40
""'"~ 30::l<.IQi-0 2 0
El~ 10
Z
• Small molecules
• Biopharmaceuticals
1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003
Year
Changes in the industry: biologicalsBiosimilar penetration in Europe embryonic;potential in USA post 2014For R&D based companies is going to be an established market play
0/0 share of global biosimilars
lSO,GOO
300,000
~ 250,000..'"W lOO,OOO~
'"'" 1SO,000
100,000
so,ooo
o
Medica...Stada
5%
2001 '008 '00' 2010
The industrial pharmacist of the future
Seven Skill Sets Necessary to Operate in the PharmaceuticalIndustry of the Future
1) Ability to Manage Decentralized Intellectual Capital Resources
2) Ability to Work in Joint Ventures and Across Divisions. Cultures and Countries
3) Ability to Integrate an Understanding of Intellectual Property Laws,Scientific Expertise and Business Strategy
4) Ability to Spur Creativity While Managing Commercially
5) Knowledge and Insight on the Decision-Making Dynamics of Payers
6) Expertise in the Functioning and Decision-Making of Regulatory Agencies
7) Human Resource Skills to Help Transform Pharmaceutical Companies
The industrial pharmacist of the future• A changing workplace:
• drug discovery in Europe with drug developmentconducted in India and registration executed in Europeor North America
• drug discovery occurring in China, developed in China,commercialised in China and then registered andcommercialised in Europe
• drug discovery conducted in China, developmentconducted in India and commercialised in Europe
• Basic Formulation Development for smallmolecules will be outsourced to low cost countrieswhereas large molecules will be developed in theEU and USA.
«:European Industrial Pharmacists Group
• The main objective of El PG is to promote and upholdthe importance and role of the industrial pharmacistwithin the pharmaceutical industry.
• Promote the modern pharmaceutical industry toobservers and more importantly to young pharmacists
• Ensure that educational standards meet the needs of theindustrial pharmacist in the industry of 2020
• Provide mentoring and coaching to young pharmacistswho need career advice