the purox system - columbia university...synthesis gas and can be processed for chemical use. figure...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: The Purox System - Columbia University...synthesis gas and can be processed for chemical use. Figure 9 gives an average analysis of the slag. The slag is primarily a product of the](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042018/5e76610e844c337e9329cd3e/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
THE PUROX SYSTEM
T. F. FISHER M. L. KASBOHM
J. R. RIVERO
Union Carbide Corporation
Tonawanda, New York
Union Carbide's PUROX System employs a partial oxidation process using oxygen for converting solid waste to fuel gas and inert slag. This system has been developed over the last several years. After initial studies, a S-ton/day pilot plant was built and operated under a variety of conditions to develop the basic process. The process has now been successfully demonstrated on a commercial scale in a 200 ton/day facility at Union Carbide's plant at South Charleston, West Virginia. The operation at South Charleston is continuing with the objective of obtaining additional design information.
Figure I gives a brief overview of the input and output from the process. One ton of refuse requires about 0.2 ton of oxygen and produces 0.7 ton of medium B.t.u. fuel gas, 0.22 ton· of sterile residue and 0.28 ton of wastewater. Within the process 0.03 ton of oil is separated in the gas cleaning train and recycled to the furnace for cracking into additional gas. All of these numbers are approximate and are given in an effort to give you a simplified view of the overall process.
Figure 2 shows a schematic of the reactor with an indication of the types of functions that are required for a successful plant operation. The key element of the system is a vertical shaft furnace. Refuse, which has been preprocessed for recovery of materials such as iron, is fed to the top of the furnace through a gas seal to prevent escape of fuel gas. Oxygen is injected into the bottom hearth section to provide the partial oxidation that drives the reactor. The furnace is maintained essentially
125
full of refuse which continually descends by gravity through the shaft. The oxygen in the hearth reacts with char formed from the particles of the refuse. This reaction generates the high temperature in the hearth needed to melt the glass, metal and other materials to give a molten residue. The molten material drains continuously into a water quench tank where it forms a hard granular aggregate.
The hot gases from the hearth section rise through descending refuse, cooling the gas and pyrolyzing the refuse to yield a fuel gas. In the upper portion of the furnace the gas is further cooled as it dries the fresh incoming refuse. This countercurrent heat exchange efficiently utilizes the energy of the gas and provides a top gas that is cleaned by the incoming refuse. The gases leaving the converter are further cleaned of their oil mist and excess water vapor by passing through a recirculating water scrubber system and an electrostatic precipitator. The liquid hydrocarbons and any entrained solids are separated from the scrubber water and recycled to the furnace for disposal. The condensate, which is the net water product discharge from the scrubber system, is cleaned of organics and sent to the sewer.
The initial pilot plant was operated at the Tarrytown Technical Center on simulated and real refuse. The unit was relatively smaIl, processing about 5 tons per day. The pilot plant is shown in Figure 3. The unit was operated to confirm the fundamental process design and to obtain data for designing the demonstration plant. This work was
![Page 2: The Purox System - Columbia University...synthesis gas and can be processed for chemical use. Figure 9 gives an average analysis of the slag. The slag is primarily a product of the](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042018/5e76610e844c337e9329cd3e/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
PUROX SYSTEM
TYPICAL INPUTS/OUTPUTS
0.2 TONS OXYGEN
1.0 TONS REFUSE
GAS CLE ANING
TRAIN
07 TONS FUEL GAS
0.28 TONS
WASTE;WATER
FURNACE 1.01 TONS
GAS
003 TONS OIL 0.22 TONS
STERILE RESIDUE
REFUSE
FEED HOPPER �"'�iK'j�
SEAL-==�O!!!
FIG.1
FUEL GAS PRODUCT
! SEAL-==� =���==::;l
OXYGEN
GAS CLEANING
TRAIN
RECYCLE
WATER QUENCH WASTE WATER
W�Ji;2..�==-GRANULAR
presented by Dr. Anderson at the 1974 National ASME Conference, Incinerator Division, in Miami, Florida and was published as part of the proceedings of the conference (p.337). The process is described in U.S. Patent 3,729,298.
The demonstration plant was completed in 1974 and has now been operated successfully on municipal refuse from Charleston and adjoining cities in West Virginia. Operation of the plant has successfully solved the problems associated with the 40-fold scale-up and has also demonstrated the cost and performance of a commercial scale system.
Figure 4 shows a sketch of the initial demonstration plant. The unit has now been expanded to
RESIDUE
FIG.2
126
include front end processing for ferrous metal recovery and liquid separation equipment for recycling the condensed oil to the reactor. The demonstration plant receives the municipal refuse by truck in the storage building. The refuse is moved and stacked with a front end loader. This same front end loader picks up the stored refuse; weighs it and dumps it onto the conveyor to the shredder. One operator handles the front end loader; a sec-ond operator handles the feedtrain, which consists of shredding, magnetic separation, and converter feeding. The operator on the shredder removes material such as logs, carpets or tires that may stall the shredder. Any material that can pass the shredder has no difficulty with the
![Page 3: The Purox System - Columbia University...synthesis gas and can be processed for chemical use. Figure 9 gives an average analysis of the slag. The slag is primarily a product of the](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042018/5e76610e844c337e9329cd3e/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
I \
•
I
e • •• -. - .
--, 1
t-
•
- '�. -
-
...
�,
\J I • • I
•
FIG. 3 5 TON/DAY "PUROX" SYSTEM PI LOT PLANT AT TARRYTOWN, NEW YOR K
127
,
,
•
,.
Ill • •
![Page 4: The Purox System - Columbia University...synthesis gas and can be processed for chemical use. Figure 9 gives an average analysis of the slag. The slag is primarily a product of the](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042018/5e76610e844c337e9329cd3e/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
128
![Page 5: The Purox System - Columbia University...synthesis gas and can be processed for chemical use. Figure 9 gives an average analysis of the slag. The slag is primarily a product of the](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042018/5e76610e844c337e9329cd3e/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
remainder of the process system. The discharge from the shredder passes under a magnetic separator where better than 90 percent ot the ferrous material (160 lbs./ton refuse) is removed. The shredder is operated to give a relatively coarse shred since this is quite satisfactory for feed to the converter. The material that passes the magnetic separator dumps onto the main conveyor and is �arried to the feed system near the top of the converter. The shredded refuse feed to the converter is controlled to maintain the bed in the converter between predetermined levels. The rate of the process is controlled by the rate of oxygen injection into the hearth. The reactor operates at a positive pressure of about 20 inches of water.
The moite,n slag discharges continuously from the hearth and is quenched in a water bath below the reactor. A slag conveyor with water seal brings the granular material from the pit up into a dumpster unit. The slag is weighed to give operating data before it is dumped on the adjoining ground for land fill. A fourth operator monitors the operation around the hearth and cOf)trols· the oxygen addition rate and the slag disposal. The reactor and hearth are refractory lined and the hearth is water cooled. The gas exiting from the top of the reactor is scrubbed with water sprays
as it passes down the line. Next, the scrubbed gas passes through the electrostatic precipitator where it is further cleaned and then to the burner for disposal. The flame is very clean and is relatively nonluminous. The scrubbing water passes to a decan t tank where both the light and heavy hydrocarbon layers are removed and returned to the reactor. The scrubbing water is filtered, cooled and recycled. The excess water from the condensate will be processed to remove organics and sent to the sewer. Figure 4 does not show the shredding equipment and the decant system; these units were added after the initial installation.
Figures 5, 6 and 7 show photographs of the demonstration plant as it was initially installed. They do nor include som of the more recent additions of front endequipment and gas cleanup.
The plant was operated in 1974 with as-received refuse. This refuse was fed directly from the front end loader onto the main conveyor going to the reactor feed system. There was no sorting of this refuse. A number of runs were made in this mode of operation and the equipment was modified where necessary to give a continuous operation.
, Early in 1975, the shredder and magnetic separator were installed for ferrous material recovery. The facility was then operated with this
FIG. 5 200 TON/DAY "PUR OX" SYSTEM FACILITY AT SOUTH CHARLESTON, WEST VIRGINIA
129
![Page 6: The Purox System - Columbia University...synthesis gas and can be processed for chemical use. Figure 9 gives an average analysis of the slag. The slag is primarily a product of the](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042018/5e76610e844c337e9329cd3e/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
,
I \
•
,
•
,
• ,
•
• d
.1
. - i
-
LL
,
"
•
130
![Page 7: The Purox System - Columbia University...synthesis gas and can be processed for chemical use. Figure 9 gives an average analysis of the slag. The slag is primarily a product of the](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042018/5e76610e844c337e9329cd3e/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
•
.�.
+ .", I IIi __
FIG. 7
front end processing in a steady state fashion. The data taken were quite accurate, giving excellent heat and material balances around the total system. We have now operated the facility to obtain performance data under conditions of extended periods of operation. During the extended run, we processed over 7,000 tons of refuse, with an on-stream factor of approximately 93 percent.
Figure 8 gives a typical analysis of the fuel gas from the unit. The fuel gas is primarily H2, CO, CO2 and light hydrocarbons. While we obtained a
TYPICAL GAS ANALYSIS
H2 CO C02 CH4 C2+ N2& A
Gas· Higher Heating Value
FIG.8
Vol.7r 26 40 23
5 5 1
370 Btu/Sef
300 Btu fuel gas from the pilot plant, we found that the demonstration plant gave a higher concen-
131
tration of hydrocarbons and a gas with about 370 Btu per cubic foot. Clean fuel gases with heating values above 300 Btu per cubic foot are interchangeable with natural gas for combustion. The fuel gas as shown on the chart is also a good synthesis gas and can be processed for chemical use.
Figure 9 gives an average analysis of the slag. The slag is primarily a product of the glass in the refuse with minor additions from the contained metals and the ash from the wood products. The material has gone through the melt condition at about 2S00°F and is inert from the standpoint of any environmental considerations.
Figure 10 gives a breakdown of the available energy from a PUROX facility. Taking a value of 9.5 million Btu per ton as the energy available in the refuse, about 20 percent of the energy is lost in the conversion, giving.a fuel production from the unit of 7.5 million Btu per ton. To operate the air separation plant and miscellaneous equipment requires about 100 kilowatt-hours of electric power per ton of refuse processed. This power would normally be purchased; however, for a total energy balance one million Btu of fuel gas from the system
![Page 8: The Purox System - Columbia University...synthesis gas and can be processed for chemical use. Figure 9 gives an average analysis of the slag. The slag is primarily a product of the](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022042018/5e76610e844c337e9329cd3e/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
A VERAGE SLAG ANALYSIS
MnO -- 0.3
Si02 -- 59.7
CaO -- 10.3 AI203 -- 10.5 Ti02 -- 0.6 BaO -- 0.2 P205 -- 0.1 FeO -- 6.2
MgO -- 2.2 Na20 -- 8.0
K20 -- 1.0 CuO -- 0.2
Misc. -- 0.7
100.0
Slag Production - 340 Ibs/ton Refuse
FIG.9
could be converted to the 100 kilowatt-hours of power. This would show a net production of 6.5
.
million Btu per ton of refuse. Special features of the PUROX System are: 1) The fuel gas is valua'ble either for combus
tion in power plants or as a synthesis gas for making chemical such as methanol and ammonia.
2) The quantity of fuel gas is significant for any given community. Taking a standard municipal refuse figure of 5 pounds per person, this gives a production of 16,000 Btu's of fuel gas produced per individual per day.
3) The separated ferrous is salable as scrap and
is worth about $2 per ton of refuse. 4) The solid rl;:sidue produced is less than
3 percent of the feed by volume and is an inert aggregate (glassy material) that can be used for such things as road fill.
5) There is no effluent to the atmosphere and the fuel gas produced, if burned, will have excellent characteristics since it is very low in both
•
sulfur and ash. 6) The condensed water vapor contains soluble
organics; however, this material will be' processed within the system to make the effluent acceptable to municipal sewers.
The PUROX System is receiving wide interest from municipalities across the country. While the initial development was focused on disposal of solid waste in an economic and environmentally acceptable fashion, the current energy crisis has placed increased emphasis on the resource recovery aspects of the fuel gas and ferrous material. Installations being considered range from 400 tons to 2,000 tons/day. To ensure reliable operation the facilities will incorporate multiple modular units for the refuse conversion step. Modular units will be sized to process from 200 to 350 tons/day. Each installation will have a customer for the fuel gas. One city finds that it can make 30 million gallons a year of methanol from a 1,500 tons/day PUROX plant; however, most municipalities expect to sell the fuel gas to utilities for use in power plants or for sale to gas customers.
AVAILABLE ENERGY FROM A "PUROX .. FACILITY
(Million B.t.u./Ton)
Energy Available in Refuse Energy Loss in Conversion
Energy Available in Fuel Gas
Energy for In-plant Electric Generation
Net Energy Produced
132
9.5
2.0
7.5
1.0
6.5