Quanta Magazine

https://www.quantamagazine.org/mega-magnet-reveals-superconductor-secret-20160222/ February 22, 2016

The Quantum Secret to SuperconductivityIn a virtuoso experiment, physicists have revealed details of a “quantum critical point” that underlieshigh-temperature superconductivity.

By Natalie Wolchover

The 90-tesla magnet system at the National Laboratory for Intense Magnetic Fields in Toulouse,France.

The energy equivalent of several kilograms of TNT surged into the coil, bathing the 0.003-caratcrystal in its bore in one of the strongest magnetic fields ever generated.

From the magnet came a small boom like the sound of a foot stomping, said engineer Jérôme Béard— but thankfully, no explosion. His calculations held up.

With that magnetic blast and a subsequent series of identical ones executed last winter, researchersat the National Laboratory for Intense Magnetic Fields (LNCMI) in Toulouse, France, uncovered akey property of the crystal, a matte-black ceramic in a class of materials called cuprates that are themost potent superconductors known. The findings, reported today in the journal Nature, provide amajor clue about the inner workings of cuprates, and may help scientists understand how thesematerials allow electricity to flow freely at relatively high temperatures.

Quanta Magazine

https://www.quantamagazine.org/mega-magnet-reveals-superconductor-secret-20160222/ February 22, 2016

“Technically amazing,” said J.C. Séamus Davis, an experimental physicist with appointments atCornell University, St. Andrews University in Scotland, and Brookhaven National Laboratory whowas not involved in the experiment. “The paper is a masterpiece.”

Sample of yttrium bariumcopper oxide, one of a class of crystalline materials called cuprates which are the most potent knownsuperconductors.

The experimental team, led by LNCMI staff scientist Cyril Proust and Louis Taillefer of theUniversity of Sherbrooke in Canada, used their 90-tesla magnet — which creates a magnetic fieldnearly two million times as strong as the one enshrouding Earth — to momentarily strip awaysuperconductivity in their cuprate sample. This revealed details of the underlying phase from whichthe behavior seems to arise.

With the veil lifted, the scientists discovered a sharp change in behavior at what appears to be a“quantum critical point” in cuprates, reminiscent of the freezing point of water. Theorists have longspeculated that such a quantum critical point might exist, and that it could play a key role insuperconductivity, said Andrey Chubukov, a condensed-matter theorist at the University ofMinnesota. “One thing is to say this; another thing is to measure it,” Chubukov said.

Superconductivity is a phenomenon in which electricity flows without resistance from the material itmoves through, so that no energy is lost in the process. It occurs when electrons (the negativelycharged carriers of electricity) unite to form pairs, balancing each other’s properties in a way thatallows them all to move in unison. The phase in which this happens is delicate, typically occurringonly when a material is cooled to rock-bottom temperatures. But if wires could be engineered to actas superconductors at room temperature, experts say the lossless electrical transmission wouldgreatly reduce global energy usage and usher in a host of new technologies, such as magneticallylevitating vehicles and cheap water-purification systems.

The force driving superconductivity is strongest in cuprates. As IBM researchers Georg Bednorz andK. Alexander Müller discovered in 1986 (in work that earned them Nobel Prizes the following year),cuprates superconduct at much higher temperatures than other materials, suggesting that theirelectrons are paired by a different and stronger glue. But cuprates must still be cooled below minus100 degrees Celsius before they become superconductive. The glue must be further strengthened ifsuperconductors’ operating temperatures are to be dialed up. For 30 years scientists have asked:

Quanta Magazine

https://www.quantamagazine.org/mega-magnet-reveals-superconductor-secret-20160222/ February 22, 2016

What is the glue — or, more precisely, the quantum mechanical interaction between electrons —that causes superconductivity to arise in cuprates?

From left: Nicolas Doiron-Leyraud, Louis Taillefer and Sven Badoux, members of the experimentalteam at the University of Sherbrooke in Canada.

While the detection of a quantum critical point does not definitively answer that question, “this hasreally clarified the situation,” said Subir Sachdev, a leading condensed-matter theorist at HarvardUniversity. The finding knocks several proposals for the electron-pairing glue in cuprates out of therunning. “There are now two prominent candidates for what’s happening,” Sachdev said.

One of the candidates, if verified, would enter the textbooks as a completely novel quantumphenomenon, with an exoticism that appeals to many theorists. But if the other, more conventionalexplanation of high-temperature superconductivity proves true, then, according to Davis, scientistswill immediately know the key handle that needs to be turned to strengthen the effect. In that case,in the quest for room-temperature superconductivity, Davis said, “the route forward would be clear.”

Under the DomeProust, Taillefer and their collaborators set out eight years ago to blaze a trail to the center of thecuprate “phase diagram,” a map representing the hodgepodge of different phases exhibited by thematerials as their properties are varied.

The two extreme ends of the map are well-understood: Pure, unadulterated cuprate crystals —mapped on the left side of the diagram — act as insulators, while cuprates that have been dopedwith many extra electrons or “holes” (deficits of electrons that behave like positively chargedparticles), mapped on the right, behave like metals. “The big fundamental question is,” Taillefer said,“How does the system go from insulator to metal?” Scientists become lost in the jumble of phases

Quanta Magazine

https://www.quantamagazine.org/mega-magnet-reveals-superconductor-secret-20160222/ February 22, 2016

that occur at intermediate doping levels — including superconductivity, which rises like a dome inthe middle of the phase diagram.

Thephase diagram of hole-doped cuprates.

The map offers a clue: A line slopes up and to the left above the superconductivity dome, dividingtwo other, higher-temperature phases of the material. Extend this line downward to lowertemperatures, and it strikes the base of the superconductivity dome exactly at its center point.Theorists have long suspected that the nature of this point might be the key to understandingsuperconductivity, which seems to form a bubble around it. Fifteen years ago, Taillefer and Proust,who was then a postdoctoral researcher in Taillefer’s lab, started to think about how to investigatethis possible critical point. The problem was that the two phases they observed at highertemperatures, which seemed bound to meet at this point at a temperature of absolute zero,disappeared when superconductivity kicked in. In order to probe what happens during the transitionfrom one phase to the other, the team had to find a way to stop the electrons in cuprates fromforming superconducting pairs in the vicinity of the critical point.

To do this, the scientists needed a big magnet. Magnetic fields destroy superconductivity by exertingopposite forces on the electrons in each superconducting pair, breaking their connection. But thestronger the pairing glue in a superconductor, the harder it is to break. “With cuprates, themagnetic field you need to dissuade superconductivity is very high,” Proust said.

A Mighty MagnetMagnets can only be as strong as the materials they are made of, which must withstand theenormous mechanical forces generated by tsunamis of electricity.

The 90-tesla magnet at LNCMI in Toulouse works by charging a bank of 600 capacitors, thendischarging them all at once into a coil the size of a trash can. The coil is made of ultra-strong

Quanta Magazine

https://www.quantamagazine.org/mega-magnet-reveals-superconductor-secret-20160222/ February 22, 2016

copper alloy reinforced with Zylon, a fiber stronger than Kevlar. For about 10 milliseconds, the flashflood of current generates a powerful magnetic field running through the coil’s bore. Although theLNCMI magnet can’t match the power of the 100-tesla magnet at Los Alamos National Laboratory inNew Mexico, “we are able to make a very long pulse, two times longer than in Los Alamos,” enablingmore precise measurements, Béard said.

As the engineers built the magnet, collaborators at the University of British Columbia preparedsamples of a cuprate called yttrium barium copper oxide. They doped the samples with four differentconcentrations of holes, spanning from one side of the hypothesized critical point to the other. Uponcooling the samples to minus 223 degrees Celsius and blasting them with magnetic pulses,momentarily destroying superconductivity, they measured a property of the material that indicatesthe number of holes per atom that are involved in carrying electricity. Normally, this “carrierdensity” increases gradually as a function of doping. But at a critical point, it would be expected tochange suddenly, indicating a spontaneous reorganization of the electrons in the crystal. And that’swhat the scientists measured: a sharp, sixfold jump in the carrier density at 19 percent doping, theexpected location of the critical point.

From left: Jérôme Béard, David Vignolles, Cyril Proust and Wojciech Tabis, members of theexperimental team at the National Laboratory for Intense Magnetic Fields in Toulouse.

“There clearly is a hidden critical point right where Louis [Taillefer] says there is,” said Davis, whofound indirect evidence for the existence of this point in 2014. “It points strongly to the idea thatthere is a sudden change to the electronic structure at that critical point.”

Quantum Critical PointUnlike the freezing point of water, which is crossed by raising or lowering the water temperature,the critical point in cuprates is a “quantum critical point,” or a point of balance between two

Quanta Magazine

https://www.quantamagazine.org/mega-magnet-reveals-superconductor-secret-20160222/ February 22, 2016

competing quantum mechanical states, at zero temperature. The quantum state that prevails to theleft of the quantum critical point in the phase diagram causes the electrons to be “ordered,” orarranged into a pattern. The quantum effect that dominates on the right causes the electrons to befree-moving. But as the system approaches the critical point from either the left or the right, theamount of order in the system starts to fluctuate, due to competition between the two states. It isthese fluctuations of order that are hypothesized to give rise to superconductivity in the vicinity ofthe quantum critical point. The question is: What kind of order is it?

For the past five years, researchers have suspected a type of order known as charge density waves— essentially, ripples of overly dense and under-dense regions of electrons. But the new experiment,as well as recent findings by Davis’ group, indicate that the charge density wave order dies out at alower doping level, too far to the left of the quantum critical point. Now, two leading possibilitiesremain.

A bank of 600 capacitors powers the mega-magnet in Toulouse.

The more conventional option, proposed in the late 1980s by David Pines, Douglas Scalapino andother theorists, is antiferromagnetism, a type of order in which electrons alternate their spindirections in a checkerboard pattern — up, down, up, down, etc. Fluctuations in this checkerboardarrangement near the quantum critical point cause oppositely spinning electrons to becomeattracted to each other and pair up, giving rise to superconductivity. Several indirect observationssupport the antiferromagnetism hypothesis. According to Chubukov, because this order would beexpected to set in at a quantum critical point, the new discovery is “the necessary missing link” inthe antiferromagnetism explanation.

But if straightforward antiferromagnetism were the answer, physicists would have cracked the casedecades ago. Experimenters have long tried and failed to detect antiferromagnetic order in thephase at the top left of the superconductivity dome — the presumed ordered phase to the left of the

Quanta Magazine

https://www.quantamagazine.org/mega-magnet-reveals-superconductor-secret-20160222/ February 22, 2016

quantum critical point. “The trouble in the cuprates is, there is no long-range order that anyone canfind,” said Stephen Julian, an experimental condensed-matter physicist at the University of Toronto.When experimenters look for the checkerboard pattern, they don’t see it.

However, defenders of the antiferromagnetic explanation point to the crystalline structure ofcuprates, which are essentially stacked, two-dimensional sheets, and to a 1975 theorem known asthe Mermin-Wagner theorem, which says that true, long-range antiferromagnetic order cannotdevelop in two-dimensional materials at non-zero temperatures. Instead, perhaps only patches oforder develop, like sections of checkerboard, and these cannot be detected with existingexperimental techniques. Long-range antiferromagnetic order only sets in at low temperatures,proponents say. The problem is that antiferromagnetism gets overridden by the phase it incites —superconductivity — and so still cannot be observed.

Not everyone thinks the Mermin-Wagner theorem is relevant. Davis points out thatantiferromagnetic order has been detected in undoped cuprates, which have the same two-dimensional structure. The lack of antiferromagnetic order seen so far near the critical point has ledsome researchers to abandon this idea and support a more exotic theory put forward by Sachdev,which builds on concepts that Philip Anderson, a Nobel Prize winner and one of the founders ofcondensed-matter physics, advanced in the 1980s. Sachdev posits a kind of order in cuprates thatisn’t seen in other materials. In this order, electrons form composites possessing fractions of spinand charge. Sachdev maintains that remnants of this order, which he has dubbed the fractionalizedFermi liquid or FL* state, form the precursor to high-temperature superconductivity.

The scientists are continuing their experiments with an even more powerful magnet, hoping to learnmore about the underlying phase from which superconductivity emerges in cuprates.

Deciding whether the newfound quantum critical point is associated with antiferromagnetism orsomething more unusual like FL* will once again require powerful magnets. Experimenters arealready working on ways to search for the checkerboard pattern of antiferromagnetic order at lowtemperatures, while using magnetic pulses to wipe out the superconductivity that arises there. “Allthese things will happen now,” Taillefer said. “It looks so much like an [antiferro]magnetic transitionat that critical point, that that’s the question we need to answer.”

Quanta Magazine

https://www.quantamagazine.org/mega-magnet-reveals-superconductor-secret-20160222/ February 22, 2016

If antiferromagnetism turns out to be the electron-pairing glue in cuprates, then theorists willimmediately focus on determining why the glue is so much stronger in these materials than inothers, in hopes of further strengthening it. FL*, on the other hand, would provide theorists with anew set of dials altogether. Either way, many are optimistic that they are on track to raise theoperating temperatures of superconductors. “I don’t think anybody believes there’s a fundamentallimit” that prevents room-temperature superconductivity, Julian said. “The argument is how long it’sgoing to take us to get there. Some people think it’s just around the corner. Some people think it’sgoing to take a very long time.”

This article was reprinted on Wired.com.