the rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

30
THE RATE OF ALCOHOLYSIS 0F o -N ITROACETAN ILIDE by HARRY MARTIN NELSON A THE3IS submitted to OREGON STATE COLLEGE in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the dereo of Í4ASTER OF SCIENCE June 1952

Upload: others

Post on 28-Oct-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

THE RATE OF ALCOHOLYSIS 0F o -N ITROACETAN ILIDE

by

HARRY MARTIN NELSON

A THE3IS

submitted to

OREGON STATE COLLEGE

in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the

dereo of

Í4ASTER OF SCIENCE

June 1952

Page 2: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

APPROVED:

Professor of Chemistry

In CharEe of I4ajor

Head of epartment of Chemistry

Chairman or School Graduate Committee

Dean of Graduate School

Date thesis is presented ' / Typed by Evelyn Kanzeltneyer

Page 3: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

The author wishes to express his sincere appre-

dation for the advice and encouragement extended him

throughout the course of this study by Elliot N. Marvell.

Page 4: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Pa.e

I NTB.ODUCT ION . . . . I

HISTORICAL . . . . 3

.)I3CUS3IOi . . a . * a 6

i PROCEDURE a * a a s s e a e a e e 6

2 RESULTS . s s a . a a a e s e a e e e 10

Â. iETHANOL SOLUTIONS ..... 10

B. ETHANOL SOLUTIONS s s s e e a a e e 17

C. CONCLUSIONS . . . . * 19

EAPERI1.cNTAL . . . . . . . e .......... 21

1. iiATbRIAIß . . . . . . e e 21

2. ALCOHOLAT SOLUTIONS . a * 22

3. ALCOhOLIC WIDROGEN CHLORIDE 23

4. EhPiRINTAL PROCEDURE e e e e s a a a s 23

bIbLIOGRAPHY s e . . . . . . . . 25

TABLES

I FIRST ORD RATE CONSTANTS FOR ALCOHOLYSIS OF o-NITROACETANILIDE IN kETHANOL . . . . e . 12

II COMPARISON OF RATE CONSTANTS FOR ALCOHOLYSIS OF o-NITROACETANILIDE IN 1ETHANOL. . . . . 14

III HALF ORDER RATE CONSTANTS FOR ALCOHOLYSIS OF o-NITROACETANILIDE IN ETHANOL . a . . 18

1V COi'PARISON OF RATE CONSTANTS FOR ALCOHOLYSIS OF o-NITROACETANILIDE IN ETHANOL e e 20

Page 5: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

TABLE CF CONTENT3 (CONT'D.)

FIGURES

i ALBORPTION SPECTRA OF o-NITROANILINE ANT) o-NITROACETANILIDE IN ALCOHOL SOLUTIONS . . 7

2 VARIATION OF LOG % TRANS1'iISSION WITH CON- CENTRÂT ION OF o-NITROANILINE IN METHANOL AT 500 rau . . . . . . * , 8

3 VARIATION OF LOG % TRANSMISSION WITH CON- CENTRÂT ION O F o-N ITROANILINE IN ETHANOL

rp rrr L. * S S S S S S S

4 VARIATION OF FIRST ORDER CONSTANT WITH k'LTHYLATE IONCONOENTRATION. .. .. .. .... .15

Page 6: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

TH RATE OF ALCOHOLYSIS OF 0.-N ITROACETAN ILIDE

INTRODUCT ION

In E.efleral the reaction between eaters and anonia

or amines provides a uefu1 method for the preparation of

ami.dea. Since this reaction Is essentially irreverib1e the alcoholysiB of amides Is not ordinarily attainable.

Verkade (6) has shown, however, that in the case of aniline

or naphthylamine derivativer which have a nitro croup

ortho or para to the amide 11nkae a new method is appli-

cable. The alcoholysis of such an ide is readily

accomplished by boiling in alcohol usine the correspondinE

sodium alcoholate as a catalyst. Thi8 method is remark-

ably successful (lO, 7, 1) giving nearly quantitative

yields of extremely pure amines. The occurrence of the

reaction is attributed to the powerful electron-attracting

effect of the nitro croup, which, accordinE to those

investiFatore, permits an ionization of the acetyl Eroup. In order to investlEate the mechanism of this

interest in', reaction a study of

nitroacetanilide was undertaken

the reaction is clean-cut it is

kinetic investigation. An addi

possibility of illuminating the

reaction and its formal analog,

esters under basic conditions.

the alcoholysia of p-

in this laboratory. 3ince

admirably suited to a

.ional incentive was the

relationship between this

the alcohol exchange of

Page 7: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

An extension of that study to o-nitroacetanillde forms the subject of the present discussion,

Page 8: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

3

HISTORICAL

In the course of their work on alkoxy-amino-

nitro compounds Verkade and Witjens desired to deacylate

2,3-dinitro-4-ethoxyacetanhlide. Attempts to carry out

this reaction by conventional methods employing. concen-

trated sulfuric acid, hydrochloric acid, and alcoholic

potassium hydroxide failed. The desired amine was

finally obtained (6) from the acetyl compound by a novel

method; deacetylation in boumE ethyl alcohol with sodium

ethoxide as a catalyst.

Further investiEation showed that for the success

of this new method of deacylation the presence of a nitro

group in the position ortho or para to the acetylamino

croup is necessary. The method was found to be applicable

to a variety of compounds of this type. A 0.02 N solu-

tion of sodium alcoholate in the corresponding alcohol

was used, usually in a quantity such that 0.03-0.05 moles

of alcoholate was present per mole of the substance to be

deacetylated. Water was found to interfere with the

reaction. These workers postulated the folloiinE mechanism

for the reaction.

Page 9: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

NHCOi1e

Q NO2

+

j,

h0

eCO21

In a subsequent paper (10) 1tjen, epster, and

Verkade discusBed the effects of bulky substituents ortho

to the nitro group. Such substituentr were found to lead

to a large decrease In the rate of deacylation in most

cases, This was considered to be a result of the storie hindrance of resonance (9), the ortho substituents pro-

vent int the nitro group from assuming a planar conf igura-

tion.thus preventing it from exerting its electromeric

effect. Ari investigation of the rate of the reaction was

initiated by Iarve1l, Geiszler, and Joncich. iien this investigation had been in progress for sorno months a

further article by Verkade concerning a siniila r study was

published (8). However, Vorkade's investigations were

more concerned with steric effects on mesomerism and the

analytical methods employed were somewhat loss precise

Page 10: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

5

than those used by Marvoll, Geiszier, and Joncich.

AccordinEly the rate of base catalyzed alcoholysis of

p-nitroacetanilido was measured not only in methanol but

in ethanol. It was found to have a first order depend-

ence on the anilide concentration and to vary linearly

with the alcoholato ion concentration.

The latter authors proposed the following mechanism

for the reaction.

o e

NHCONe NHG-OR

Q + ____ NO2

Q RO9 OH

Q +

NO2

Although the evidence obtained in the kinetic study of the

alcoholysis of p-nitroacetanilide was not sufficient to

prove that the reaction course outlined above is to be

preferred to any other possible mechanism, the postulated

course did permit correlation of all the data obtained.

It is of interest to note that this mechanism is similar

to the one presently accepted for base catalyzed ester

hydrolysis (2).

Page 11: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

DISCUSiION

1. PROCDUR

9inco the work on p-nitroacetanilide utilized a

spectrophotornetric method, that means of ana1yss waa

suested for this problem. The absorptions of solu-

t ions of o-nitroanilinc and o-nitroacetanilide in both

methanol and ethanol were measured in the res-ion of 500

¡nu. The results of these measurements are plotted in

FlEure 1.

It is seen that in both solvents the amine absorbs

appreciably at SOC mu while the amide is vlrtu:rily trans-

parent at this 'avelenth. Thus it should be possible

to analyze for the amine in the presence of the amide.

easurement of the absorptIon of amine solutions of imown

concentration avo the results plotted in FiEures 2 and

3. The linearity or these plots indicates that Beer's

law is followed in both solvents. The averaEe extinction

coefficients for the o-nitroaniline were, in methanol

solution 29.8, in ethanol solution 22.0.

A sample calculation of the amine concentration

follows.

Page 12: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

I."

80

z o

60 (I)

z 4

40

20

- 3 4 5

FIGURE I.

1/ / / ABSORPTION SPECTRA 0F o-NITROANILINE / / / AND o-NITROACETANILIDE N ALCOHOL / / / SOLUTIONS

/ / / I. o-NITROACETANILIDE 0.05 M IN EtOH

- I I / 2. o-NITROACETANILIDE 0.05M IN MeOH

/ I / 3. O-NITROANILINE 0.002M IN MeOH

/ / J 4. o-NITROANILINE 0.02 M IN EtOH

5. o-NITROANILINE 0.02 M IN MeOH

I I I I

460 470 480 490 500 510 520 0 40

WAVELENGTH (mu)

Page 13: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

2

'J

L

z. o U)

1 U) z 4 I-

#1 o o -I

I' I.1

r i i r i i i i i T I

O DILUTIONS MADE WITH METHANOL. -

Q DILUTIONS MADE WITH 005M AMIDE -

IN METHANOL.

3- -

-

o

-

5_ -

-

3_ o

FIGURE 2. VARIATION OF LOG % TRANSMISSION WITH I CONCENTRATION OF 0-NITROANILINE IN METHANOL

AT 500 MU.

0_ I I I I I I I I I I I

0 0.010 0.020 0.030 CONCENTRATION (MOLES/ LITER)

Page 14: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

I o w 1.9

z

w z'.8 -j

z 4 o i.7 I- z

¿ 1.6

U. o z'.5 o U) U) jI.4 U) z 4

l.3 I-

2 C, o -J

FIGURE 3. VARIATION OF LOG % TRANSMISSION

WITH CONCENTRATION OF 0-NITROANILINE IN

ETOH AT 500Mu.

0 0.010 0.020 CONCENTRATION (MOLES/LITER)

Page 15: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

lo

transrnisBlon 37.2 - lo (% trans./l0O) 0.429

lop (tran5./1Q0) - 29.8 0.0144

0.0144 x 1.1 (the dilution factor)

0.0158 (N, the cone. of amine)

The appearance of the dilution factor is due to the fact

that the reaction takes place in a basic medium. In arder

to ieasure the absorption and thus determine the caneen-

tration of the amine it is necessary to stop the reaction

by adding. alcoholic hydrogen chloride. Then the concen-

tration of the amine in the neutralized solution must be

multiplied by a factor which depends on the volume of

added acid in order to obtain the concentration of the

amine in the original basic solution.

2. RFULTS

A. M1VTHANOL $OLUTIONS

The rate of base catalyzed alcoholysis of o-nitro- acetanilide was measured in methanol at 30.000, The

reaction was followed spectrophotometriceiiy, the con-

centration of the product, o-nitroani1ire, being determined.

The reaction is as follows:

NHCOkie

+

NH2

C NO2

+ heCO2R

Page 16: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

:1].

The method of integration was used to determine

the order of the react ion. This method involves taking

tile rate equation in its integrated, form and finding

whether lt gives a specific rate constant which does not

drift as the reaction proresses. 'ith A0 the initial concentration

of amide

A the eonceútrat ion of amide at time t

N the concentration of amine at time t

andassuming A0-NA the rate equations and their integrated forms are:

for half order

-

for f irot order

- * .li dt cit

ror second order

l/2 [A01/2 - (A0 -

i A0 K, * log

-KA2 K ______ dt dt '-

2 A0(A0 - N)

The results for the runs in methanol are tabulated here together iith the values of the first order constant, WhiCh had the smallest drift.

Page 17: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

12

TABLE I

FIKT ORDER RATE OONBTANT3 FOR ALCOHOLYSIS OF o-NITROAOETANILIDE IN METHANOL

Number Total of

k1(mean) 3tandard Time ieasure- Run A0 13o x 103 Deviation (hrs.) znents

1 0.0200 0.0193 5.60 0.47 2.0 6

2 0.0200 0.0201 6.27 0.50 2.5 5

3 0.0150 0.00517 1.50 0.035 9.0 9

4 0.0300 0.00479 1.39 0.046 9.0 9

5 0.0150 0.00977 2.95 0.093 3.7 11

6 0.0300 0.00977 2.85 0.107 4.0 12

7 0.0150 0.0303 7.89 0.14 1.3 8

8 0.0300 0.0303 7.54 0.07 1.3 8

A0 initial concentration of amide

concentration of methylate ion

k1 fir3t order constant in min-

Page 18: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

13

rhe values of the half order, first order, and second

order constants calculated for the various times are

Elven in Table II for runs 3 and 6.

The expressions for the rate constants given here

were obtained on the assumption that the rate of reaction

depends only on the amide concentration. This can be

true only if the rate detenLininr step does not involve

the methylate ion, or if the methylate acts as a catalyst. In the latter case the base will be reEenerated and its

concentration will remain constant durinE a given run.

Then to obtain the order of the reaction with respect to

the base the rate of the reaction must be detornilned at

various base concentrations. A plot of the rate constant

against the base concentration should indicate the manner

of this dependence. The first order constants k1 are

plotted against the base concentration, in Fleure 4.

The linearity of this plot iiicates that the dependence

of the rate on the base concentration is first order.

Page 19: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

14

TABLE II

COMPARISON OF RATE CON3TANT3 FOR ALCOHOLYSIS OF o-NITROACETANILII)E IN METHANOL

Run6

k1! x 103

k1 io k2 Time (min.)

(mo1eeY21iter_h/2

m1n1) x

(min,1) (liters mo1e1min-)

21 11.4 2.71 0,223 40 10.6 2.75 0.240 60 10.0 2.72 0.254 81 9.8 2.79 0.282

100 9.6 2.81 0.304 120 9.4 2.86 0,335 140 9.0 2.82 0.352 160 8.8 2.88 0.393 180 8.6 2.90 0.433 200 8.6 2.98 0.492 220 8.4 2.99 0,538 240 8,2 3.03 0.605

Run3

60 2.00 1.50 0.255 120 1.83 1.50 0.286 180 1.72 1.46 0.308 240 1.71 1.48 0.354 300 1.66 1.53 0.419 360 1.61 1.56 0.493 420 1.52 1.54 0.542 480 1.40 1.46 0.556 540 1.37 1.51 0.682

Page 20: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

a

X

4

2

15

FIGURE 4. VARIATION OF FIRST ORDER

CONSTANT WITH METHYLATE ION

CONCENTRATION.

0.005 0.010 0.015 0.020 0.025 0.030 r.-

Page 21: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

16

By analoEy wi.th the case of the p-nitroacetanilide

the followinE mechanism may be written. O

NIIC 1ie

Q

NHCOI'ie

Q NO2

NH2

Q NO2

+ ieOe

+

III £eOH

e

e

+ ieOONe

Step I is a reversible reaction which occurs because the

carbonyl carbon is acidic due to the carbon-oxyen dipole.

The presence of the nitro croup is necessary to prevent

the unshared pair of electrons on the untho nitrogen from

mirat1ng towards the acidic carbon and partially neutral-.

izin the positive charEe. Because of the powerful sloe- tron attractinj property of the nitro Eroup when it is appropriately coupled to the aminoid nitroen this shift is hindered. Therefore the carbonium ion can react with

the alcoholato ion. lt may be assumed by ana1oy with

base catalyzed ester exchanEe that either I and II occur

simultaneously or a slower reaction I is followed by a

much more rapid reaction II. Reaction III which Is the

reaction of a very stronE base with a reasonably acidic

solvent may be expected to be rapid. On the basis of

Page 22: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

J-7

these assumptions step I should be rate determining.

If step I is assumed to be the rate determining

step the rate becomes

- K H

(A)(13)

It is seen, however, that since the base is regenerated

its concentration remains constant and may be included in

the second order constant to give a pseudo first order

constant. Then we have

i1 (A)

where

K1 K1 (B)

Qn the basis of this mechanism, then, the reaction should

be first order in the amide, the rate varying linearly with the alcoholate ion concentration. This is just the

behaviour observed in methanol.

B. ETHANOL SOLUTIONS

The same experimental methods were applied to the measurement of the rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanil-

ide in ethanol. The runs were all conducted at a tempera-

ture of 30.0°C. The values of the half order constant

k1/2, which gives the best fit in this ease, are given in

Table III.

Page 23: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

TAELE III HALF ORDER RATE CONSTANT3 FOh LLCOHOLISIS

OF o-NITROACETANILIDE IN ETHANOL

Number Total of'

k1/2 3tandard Time 1easure- Run A0 (mean) Deviation (hrB.) ments

X

9 0.0250 0.00505 13.4 0.44 3.0 9

10 0.0300 0.00469 12.6 0.34 3,0 9

11 0.0400 0.00469 12.6 0.40 3.0 12

Page 24: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

19

The data obtained in run 10 are given in Table IV

in more detail together with the values of the half,

first, and second order constants.

It is apparent that the reaction in ethanol is

initeiy half order with respect to the amide. The

half order constant, ki/2, exhibits no drift in an inter-

val of two to three half lives. The available data are

insufficient to permit any statement regarding the

deendence of the rate on the concentration of etbylate

ion.

C. CONCLU3IONS

The rate of the base-catalyzed alcoholysis of

o-nitroacetanilide in methanol has a first order depend- ence on the anilide concentration and varies linearly with the methylate ion concentration. These facts are con-

sistent with a mechanism similar to that preßently

accepted for base catalyzed ester hydrolysis. The rate of the alcoholysis in ethanol is half

order with respect to the anilide while the data now

available are Insufficient to indicate its dependence on

the base concentration. At present no reasonable mechanism

is available which would lead one to expect this behaviour,

To clarify the problem of the alcoholysis in

ethanol it is sugEested that in further studies the con-

centrat ion of the base be varied while the concentrations

of both the anilide and the amine be measured.

Page 25: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

20

TABLE 1V

COMPARISON OF RATE CONSTANTS FOR ALCOHOLYSIS OF o-NITROACE1INILIDE IN ETHANOL

Run9

Time (min.) k1/2 X io3 k1 x io3 k2

15 12,0 3.13 0.256

30 12.6 3.26 0.284

45 12.4 3.44 0.318

60 13.4 3.62 0.361

75 12.8 3.75 0.406

90 12.4 3.94 0.466

105 12.8 4.07 0,534

120 12.8 4.27 0.628

135 12.6 4.33 0.704

150 12.6 4.55 0,854

165 12,4 4.77 1.035

180 12.8 5.25 1.439

Page 26: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

21

EXPER INENTAL

1. IATERIAL3

o-Nitroanilirie

The o-njtroaniline used was Eastman Kodak Co. h1te Label

Erade. It was recrystallized three times from 50%

ethanol-water. This product had r. meltin- point of

72.5-73.5°C. (block, uncorr.). A further recrystr1iiza-

tion fro:. benzene did not chane the meltinE point,

o-Nttroacetanilide

The o-nitroacetanilide used was prepared from the amine

by acylation with acetic anhydride. After two recrystal-

lizationa from iacial acetic acid and one from acetone

the product had a IneitinE point of 93.0-94.0°C. (block,

uncorr.). Methanol

Commercial methanol was treated with furfural and patas-

iurn hydroxide according to the procedure of ortan and

Mark (5). Methanol, b.p. 64.500., was recovered from

the reaction mixture by distillation through a one meter

helices-packed column. This product was dried by the

method of Lund and Ejerrum (4) and diti1led, b.p. 64.5°C.,

directly into the storage vessel. The solvent storage

apparatus consisted of a 500 ml. Erlenmeyer flask

( 24/40) fitted with an all glass siphon and connected

Page 27: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

22

to a dryin, tower filled with a layer of indicating

Drierite ;md a lajer of soda-i1e in such a way that al].

the air entering the storage vessel passed through the

tower.

thano i

Commercial absolute ethanol was dried according to the

procedure of Lund and Bjerrum (4) and distilled through a

short helices-packed column directly into the storage

vessel described above.

2. ALCOHOLTE SOLUTIONS

The purified alcohol was placed in a 3-necked

flask fitted with a reflux condenser and a gas inlet tube.

The apparatus was protected by drying tubes containing

calcium chloride. The alcohol was brought to a boil and

then as the apparatus was being swept with nitrog en which

had been purified by passage throigh Fieser's solution and

dried with sulfuric acid, a small piece o sodium cut

under kerosene and rinsed in ether was dropped into the

solvent. when the sodium had dissolved the solution was

cooled in an ice-bath, the sweeping with nitrogen being

continued until the solution had reached room temperature.

The 3olUtOfl was thon transferred to a glass-stoppered

flask and protected from light. After a rough titration to obtain the approximate concentration dilutions were

Page 28: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

23

made to the desired concentration. Careful duplicate

titrations then eave the concentration of the dilute

salut ion.

The dilute alcoholate solutions were stored in

glass-atoppered bottles and protected from lieht. They

were used within a few days of their preparation0

The titration of all the base solutions waa

carried out by direct reaction with aqueous solutions of

hydrochloric acid using phenolphthalein as the indicator.

3. ALCOHOLIC HYDROGEN CHIRIDE

Solutions of alcoholic hydroer1 chloride were pre-

pared by dissolvinE. in the purified alcohol, dry hydrogen

chloride generated by adding, hydrochloric acid to sulfur

acid. The hydrogen chloride was dried by passage through

sulfuric acid. The solution obtained was titrated once

with aqueous sodium hydroxide using phonolphthalein and

diluted to the desired concentration. Careful duplicate titrations then gave the concentration of the dilute so lut ion.

4. EXPERIMENTAL METHOi)

Solutions of o-nitroacetaiilide in the anhydrous

alcohol were prepared by transferring an accurately

weighed sample to a volumetric flask and filling to the

mark with puro solvent. In most casos these solutions

Page 29: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

24

were Ifl?3dc? up freBh f() each run. In a typical run the

o]utj.on oÍ the amido and an a1coho1at solution of

appropriat.e concentration were thermostatted for one-

half' to three-quarters of an hour, Then, shortly before

the run was to begin, the ide solution was removed from

the bath and 10 ml. samples transferred to c.est tubes

fitted with 24/40 around lasa etoppers. The samples

of rnide solution were then replaced in the bath. To

initiate the run the sarples of amide were removed from

the bath at one minute intervals, 5 ml. of the alcoholate

solution added, and the reaction mixtures replaced in the

bath. The time ol' addinE the alcoholate solution was

taken as zero time. As the reaction proresßed samples

were removed from the bath and 2 ml. of alcoholic hydro-

gen chloride added. The concentration of the hydrogen

chloride was adjusted so that the acid added was five per

cent In excess of that necessary to neutralize all of the

base present. A part of the neutralized semple was then

transferred to an absorption cell and its transmission at

500 mu measured with the Beckman 4odel DU spectro-

photometer.

Page 30: The rate of alcoholysis of o-nitroacetanilide

25

BIBLIOGRAPHY

1. Fuson, t. C.; 1. N. karvell and. E. Howard, J0 OrE. Chem., 12, 799 (1947)

2. Hammett, L. P., Physicai OrEanic Chemistry', McGraw-Hill Book Co., Inc., New York, N.Y., 1940, p.354

3. Harnmett, L. P., ibid., p.50

k. Lund, H. and J. Ejerrum, Ler., 64, 210 (1931)

5. orton, A. A. and J. G. Mark, md. Ene. Chem., Anal. F4., , 151 (1934)

6. Verkade, P. E. and P. H. Wttjene, Rec. tray, chim., 62, 201 (1943)

7. Verkade P. E. and P. H. Witjens, ibid., , 631 (1946 S

8. Wepster B. M. and. P. E. Verkade, ibid.,, , 425 (1948

9. Whelarid, G. E., "The Theory of Rosonance, John Wiley and Sons, New York, N.Y., 1944, p.88

10. Witjens, P. H.; B. M. Wepater and P. E. Verkade, Ree. tray. chim., 62, 523 (1943)