the role of arbitration clauses in risk minimisation when

79
© Copyright 2015 by K&L Gates LLP. All rights reserved. The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when Investing in Africa International Arbitration Webinar Series 23 September 2015 Ian Meredith, Partner, Coordinator International Arbitration Practice Group, K&L Gates LLP Babatunde Fagbohunlu SAN, Partner, Aluko & Oyebode, Lagos, Nigeria Prof. Dr. Mohamed Abdel Wahab, Partner and Head of the International Arbitration and Project Finance Groups, Zuificar & Partners, Cairo, Egypt Des Williams, Director, Werksmans Attorneys, Johannesburg, South Africa

Upload: others

Post on 01-May-2022

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

© Copyright 2015 by K&L Gates LLP. All rights reserved.

The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when Investing in Africa

International Arbitration Webinar Series 23 September 2015

Ian Meredith, Partner, Coordinator International Arbitration Practice Group, K&L Gates LLP

Babatunde Fagbohunlu SAN, Partner, Aluko & Oyebode, Lagos, Nigeria

Prof. Dr. Mohamed Abdel Wahab, Partner and Head of the International Arbitration and Project Finance Groups, Zuificar & Partners, Cairo, Egypt

Des Williams, Director, Werksmans Attorneys, Johannesburg, South Africa

Page 2: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

WELCOME Ian Meredith, Partner, Coordinator

International Arbitration Practice Group, K&L Gates LLP

Page 3: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

RISK MANAGEMENT IN WEST AFRICAN INVESTMENTS: THE ROLE OF ARBITRATION

AGREEMENTS Babatunde Fagbohunlu SAN, Partner, Aluko & Oyebode, Lagos, Nigeria

Page 4: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Countries:

o Nigeria o Ghana o Cote d’Ivoire

Economic Overview

Legal Landscape and Risk Management

Outline

3

Page 5: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Population: 173 million (47% of West Africa)

Africa’s biggest oil exporter

Power sector reforms

Divestments by IOCs from risky onshore assets

Significant project finance and M&A activity

Nigeria Economic Overview

4

Page 6: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Ghana Economic Overview

Population: 26.4 million

Significant industries: oil and gas, mining and agriculture

Net FDI inflow 2013 – US$3.2 billion

5

Page 7: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Cote d’Ivoire Economic Overview

Population: 23.2 million

Significant industries: oil and gas, agriculture and manufacturing

Net FDI inflow 2013 – US$371 million

6

Page 8: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Project Finance in Africa

NGA: USD 18 bn

GHA: USD 11 bn

ZAF: USD 10 bn

Sub-Saharan Africa Deal Volume 2003 to 2013, USD bn

USD 0 bn

USD 1- 9 bn

>USD 9 bn

• 21 SSA countries had one or more project finance deals in the last 10 years.

• Top countries were Nigeria (USD 17 billion), Ghana (USD South Africa (USD 10 Angola (USD 4 billion)

11 billion), billion) and

• These 4 countries top league tables thanks to

the regional a few jumbo

transactions (for example: Jubilee oil field in Ghana)

• These 4 countries accounted for 70% of Sub-Saharan Africa’s total.

Source: World Bank (http://www.imf.org/external/np/seminars/eng/2014/CMR/pdf/Dornel_ENG.pdf) 7

Page 9: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Project Finance in Africa – Top 10 Countries

Country No. of Projects Deal Size ($M)

South Africa 30 9,039

Nigeria 8 7,477

Kenya 8 1,157

Ivory Coast 3 996

Uganda 1 867

Mozambique 3 835

Ghana 2 498

Tanzania 1 340

Angola 1 250

Cameroon 2 203

Total 59 21,662

Country

No. of Projects

Deal Size ($M)

Nigeria 28 17,793 Ghana 14 10,925 South Africa 45 9,928 Angola 8 4,460 Madagascar 1 2,100 Zambia 7 2,047 Gabon 6 2,018 Ivory Coast 8 1,399 Kenya 9 1,357 Mozambique 4 1,327 Total 130 53,354

Source: World Bank (http://www.imf.org/external/np/seminars/eng/2014/CMR/pdf/Dornel_ENG.pdf) 8

Page 10: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

• Extractive industries (Oil & Gas, and mining) account for 64% (USD 37 billion) of Sub-Saharan Africa’s project finance volume.

• Worldwide, extractive industries account for 36% of the total project finance market, almost half the share of Africa.

• The extractive industries’ disproportionate share of Sub- Saharan Africa’s project finance market highlight the region’s infrastructure gap discussed earlier.

• On average over the 2003-2013 period, infrastructure finance represented only billion, versus potential of billion per year.

project USD 1 USD 12

Africa Project Finance Deal by Sector (2003-2013, USD $bn)

Industrials, $2, 4%

PPP, $1, 1%

Telecom, $9, 15% Mining, $10,

17%

Power, $10, 17%

Oil & Gas, $27, 46%

World Project Finance Deal by Sector (2003-2013, USD $bn)

Leisure & Property, $57,

3%

Industrials, $209, 10% Telecom, $74,

4% Oil & Gas, $399, 19%

Mining , $165, 8%

Roads & Transportation,

$450, 22%

Power, $565, 28%

PPP, $132, 6%

Project Finance Sectors

Source: World Bank (http://www.imf.org/external/np/seminars/eng/2014/CMR/pdf/Dornel_ENG.pdf) 9

Page 11: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Project Finance in WAEMU •

14 transactions closed over 2003-2013 totaling USD 2.7 billion: 4% of Africa project finance volume.

Extractive industries: USD 1.7 billion (63%) Infrastructure: USD 1.0 billion (37%)

Year Country Project Name Sector Project debt ($m) 2004 Mali Loulo gold mine Mining 82 2005 Burkina Faso Youga gold mine Mining 34 2005 Cote d'Ivoire Baobab CI-40 oil field Oil&Gas 80 2006 Cote d'Ivoire Mana gold mine Mining 20 2007 Senegal Blaise Diagne airport Transport 493 2008 Cote d'Ivoire Afren oil & gas acquisition Oil&Gas 205 2008 Senegal Sabodala gold mine Mining 130 2010 Cote d'Ivoire Baobab oli field Oil&Gas 207 2010 Senegal Dakar Diamniadio toll road Transport 132 2012 Cote d'Ivoire Azito IPP expansion Power 450 2012 Cote d'Ivoire IHS tower acquisition Telecom 100 2013 Cote d'Ivoire Ciprel IPP Power 331 2013 Cote d'Ivoire SECI CI-27 gas field expansion Oil&Gas 200 2013 Senegal Sendou IPP Power 206 Total 14 Projects 2,670

Source: World Bank (http://www.imf.org/external/np/seminars/eng/2014/CMR/pdf/Dornel_ENG.pdf) 10

Page 12: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Economic Outlook

FDI activity is in sectors where contracting parties typically choose arbitration:

o Extractive industries: contracts between Governments and IOCs (i.e. OPL, OML); State Enterprises and Contractors (i.e. JOA, PSC), Intra-IOC’s (i.e. Farm Out, Unitisation,); IOCs and service contractors; LNG Sales/Offtake contracts,

11

Page 13: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Economic Outlook

FDI Activity (cont’d):

o Infrastructure & Construction projects: FIDIC, JCT Contracts, etc.

o Transportation: Shipping, Railway and Aviation – Charter party/Bill of lading, Lease, (wet/dry),

o Finance and private equity: ISDA, Shareholders Agreement,

o Telecommunications and Information Technology

12

Page 14: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Legal Framework

Anglophone West-Africa (Nigeria, Ghana, Gambia, Sierra Leone, Liberia): • Common law heritage

• Arbitration legislation largely modelled on the UNCITRAL Model Law and New York Convention

• Permit Institutional or ad hoc Arbitration at parties’ choice

Francophone West –Africa • Dual system • OHADA System (the Common Court of Justice and Arbitration)

• Non-OHADA (ad hoc or institutional)

13

Page 15: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

A large number of international arbitrations will continue to be seated outside Africa

o Free choice of non-African venues o Recent controversies which impact free choice (Local Content and transfer of

technology legislation in Nigeria)

o Many investment arbitrations will be held under ICSID provisions

o BITs

o In absence of BITs, investment statutes provide for ICSID arbitration

• Nigerian Investment Promotion Commission Act • Ghana

Legal Framework: Choice of Seat

14

Page 16: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Legal Framework: Choice of Seat

Bargaining Power/Limitations on Contractual Freedom: o Nigeria - Practice in PSC contracting (Model Agreements)

o Increasing competitiveness of bidding rounds/entry of China/Korea into

African markets

15

Page 17: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

POSITIVE OUTLOOK

Legal Reform/Institution

Developments Pro – Arbitration

Judicial Decisions BITS/ICSID

Arbitration in Africa

16

Page 18: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Legal/Institutional Framework

Laws (UNCITRAL Model Law and New York Convention)

o Judicial support (enforcement of arbitration agreements; support for process; enforcement of awards)

o Limited judicial intervention

o Arbitrator’s jurisdiction to determine jurisdiction

o Finality – degree of review

Institutions

17

Page 19: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Africa - A Decade After New York Convention

18

Page 20: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Africa - New York Convention in 2013

19

Page 21: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

20

Page 23: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Judicial Support

Arbitration Agreements

Arbitral Process

Enforcement of Awards

22

Page 24: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Issues Arising: Courts and the Arbitral Process

Interference in arbitration proceedings

Nigeria – injunctions against arbitral proceedings, proceedings delayed by interim challenge in court

Ghana – “matters of national or public interest” or which “relate to the environment” may be inarbitrable

23

Page 25: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Issues Arising: Mandatory Law/Policy

Scope of what is arbitrable o Tax disputes

o Environmental issues

24

Page 26: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Issues Arising: Mandatory Law/Policy

Local content requirements

o Nigeria Oil and Gas Industry Content Development Act

Professional Regulation

o Legal Practitioners Act o Recent Tribunal Decision on Legal Representation o Impact on Legal representation

25

Page 27: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Improving the Outlook

Political, legal and institutional reform

Nigeria Ghana Cote d’Ivoire

Role of international arbitration institutions

LCIA, LCIA-MIAC, AALCO, ICC, UNCITRAL, OHADA

26

Page 28: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

FOREIGN DIRECT INVESTMENT AND INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION IN THE MENA REGION: PROSPECTS,

CHALLENGES AND RISKS Prof. Dr. Mohamed Abdel Wahab, Partner and Head of the International Arbitration and

Project Finance Groups, Zuificar & Partners, Cairo, Egypt

Page 29: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

K&L Gates Webinar - 23 September 2015

Foreign Direct Investment and International Arbitration in the MENA

Region: Prospects, Challenges and Risks

Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Founding Partner and Head of the International Arbitration, Zulficar & Partners (Cairo) Chair of Private International Law and Professor of Dispute Resolution, Cairo University

Vice-President, ICC International Court of Arbitration, Member of the Court of Arbitration, LCIA, Vice-President, LCIA – Arab Users Council,

Member of the Advisory Committee, CRCICA, Vice-President, Chartered Institute of Arbitrators (Egypt Branch).

28 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 30: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Outline I. Legal Culture, Investment Trends, and

Dispute Resolution Landscape.

II. Arbitral Institutions.

III.Sectors of Interest and FDI Trends.

IV.Concluding Remarks: Prospects,

challenges and Risks.

29 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 31: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Africa: A Snapshot.

The Legal Culture.

The Dispute Resolution Landscape.

Judicial Trends and Arbitration.

30

I. Culture, Investment, and Dispute Resolution

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 32: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

The recorded history of early civilization arose in Egypt, and Nubia, the Sahel (covers parts of (from west to east) the Gambia, Senegal, southern Mauritania, central Mali, Burkina Faso, southern Algeria and Niger, northern Nigeria and Cameroon, central Chad, southern Sudan, northern South Sudan and northern Eritrea), the Maghreb the Horn of Africa, and South Africa. The Homo Erectus is said to have originated in Africa.

Some anthropological studies consistently established that ancient Egyptians were originally Africans and overtime gained biological affinities towards Middle Eastern and southern European populations.

31

Africa - Continental Snapshot

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 33: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Africa is now composed of 55 Sovereign States (54 members of the African Union to the exclusion of Morocco), with more than 1 billion inhabitants. Legal systems in Africa are a diverse mix of common, civil, customary and religious law. There are over 700 (known) languages, and working languages include: English, French, Portuguese, and Arabic. Africa has experienced high and continuous economic growth in the past decade. The average annual real growth rate: 1980-1989 1.8% 1990-1999 2.6% 2000-2010 5.3%

(UNCTAD Report 2014 “Catalyzing investment for Transformative Growth in Africa)

32

Africa - Continental Snapshot

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 34: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Legal Culture

The dominance of civil law systems and far-

reaching influence of Egyptian law. The interplay between civil law background,

common law practice, and Islamic Shari’a principles.

33 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 35: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Throughout the MENA region, disputes are on the rise and there has been an increase of the number of arbitration and mediation proceedings. More dispute resolution institutions and

centers are being established. The number of BITs (IIAs) has also increased. Greater reluctance to resort to State courts for

cross border disputes.

34

The Dispute Resolution Landscape

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 36: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Two North African States have arbitration laws modelled on the UNCITRAL Model Law: Tunisia (1993) and Egypt (1994).

Five North African States have ratified the New York Convention (Egypt, Tunisia, Algeria, Morocco, and Mauritania) – Libya and North Sudan did not yet join.

Six North African States have ratified the Washington ICSID Convention (Egypt, North Sudan, Tunisia, Algeria, Morocco, and Mauritania) – Libya did not yet join.

35

The Dispute Resolution Landscape

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 37: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

The most active African States in arbitration (in terms of known number of cases) are: Egypt, Mauritius, Nigeria, South Africa, Tunisia. African States concluded 828 known BITs, with the following 6 countries having concluded the highest number of BITs: (ICSID & UNCTAD Statistics)

Egypt (around 102-109 BITs) Morocco (around 63-67 BITs) Tunisia (around 54-59 BITs) South Africa (around 50 BITs) Algeria (around 42-47 BITs) Mauritius (around 38-41 BITs)

36

The Dispute Resolution Landscape

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 38: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

The total number of known treaty-based cases (1987-2013) reached 568 cases. About three-quarters of which were brought against developing and transition economies. The top 10 Respondent States (1987-2013) included 1 North African State (Egypt). In total and until 31 December 2014, ICSID had registered 497 cases, with 10% State Parties involved from the MENA region. In terms of economic sectors: the Oil, Gas & Mining sector topped the chart by 26%, followed by the energy and power sector with 14% of all registered cases.

37 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

The Dispute Resolution Landscape

Page 39: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

• The Past Decade: Greater awareness of international

arbitration. Competition for arbitration-friendliness. Arbitration legislations and

enforcement/recognition challenges.

38

Judicial Trends and Arbitration

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 40: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

II. Arbitration Institutions • Institutional vs. Ad Hoc Arbitration. • Examples of institutions for MENA region

cases: ICC, LCIA, LCIA-DIFC & LCIA-MIAC,

CRCICA (UNCITRAL Rules Based), DIAC Other Centers (ADCAC, BCDR-AAA, Qatar

Arbitration Centre, Gulf Arbitration Centre, etc.) New Centers?

39 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 41: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Some ICC & LCIA Statistics

40

ICC

2013

Sub-Saharan Africa cases involved parties from 29 nationalities and seats in 8 countries in the region. African involvement increased by more than 85% in 14 years. In 2010, 70% of the seats of arbitration were in Europe, 14% in Asia/Pacific, 14.5% in the Americas, and 1.5% in Africa (compared to 0.5% ten years ago). In 2013, cases involving State and State owned entities (86 cases out of 767) 34% came from Africa (9% North Africa and 26% Sub-Saharan Africa).

LCIA

201

3 A total of 290 arbitrations were referred to the LCIA with around 12% involving African Parties (with Mauritius 1.8% and Nigeria 2% and South Africa 1.4%).

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 42: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Source: http://crcica.org.eg/newsletters/nl032014/nl032014a001t.html

41

Some CRCICA Statistics

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 43: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Source: http://crcica.org.eg/newsletters/nl032014/nl032014a001t.html

42

Some CRCICA Statistics

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 44: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

The number of cases registered with DIAC from 2007 to 2013

Source: http://www.diac.ae/idias/archiveevents/CASESTATIC/

© Zulficar&Partners 43

DIAC Statistics

Page 45: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

• What, how, and where to choose? Freedom of choice by the parties. Costs of arbitration and facilities offered by the

arbitral institution. Certainty and comprehensiveness of the arbitration

rules. The impact of arbitration legislation on the choice

of the seat of arbitration. The flexibility of the enforcement and recognition

of arbitral awards. 44

II. Arbitration Institutions

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 46: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

III. Sectors of Interest & FDI Trends

• Oil & Gas; • Telecommunications; • Infrastructure; • Power; and • Finance and Financial services.

45 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 48: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

The oil and gas, power and infrastructure sectors remain very attractive sectors for investments in the MENA region.

Since 2009, MENA economies have been exposed to repeated external and internal hits as a result of the global economic crisis and the so-called ‘Arab Spring’ (more likely ‘Arab Winter’). Indeed, in 2011, some MENA countries witnessed an average of 70% decrease in FDI inflows compared to 2010. Yemen, Egypt, Libya, and Tunisia, were significantly hit. Egypt experienced disinvestments exceeding USD 600 million between 2010 and 2011.

47 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

III. Sectors of Interest & FDI Trends

Page 49: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

In 2013, amongst North African and Arab States, Egypt became been the 3rd largest FDI recipient, benefitting from 12% of total FDI inflows in the MENA region. Similarly, Morocco, Iraq and Kuwait experienced

important increases in FDI inflows. Morocco, for example, signed a PPP agreement with Renault group to build a second production line investing USD 542 million.

48 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

III. Sectors of Interest & FDI Trends

Page 50: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

FDI inflows by MENA country destination (% of the total)

Source: UNCTAD FDI Database 49 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

III. Sectors of Interest & FDI Trends

Page 52: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

• Several Gulf Cooperation Council (‘GCC’) economies have injected substantial investments and project financing to several MENA region economies in transition, such as Egypt, Jordan, Morocco, Tunisia and Yemen.

• The UAE was the largest investor in the MENA region (surpassing the USA), with a total of USD 163 billion invested in 543 projects

Source: World Bank, 2013.

51 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

III. Sectors of Interest & FDI Trends

Page 53: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

• FDI to the MENA region remain concentrated in a limited number of sectors. In 2013, coal, oil and natural gas (also referred to as ‘natural resource’ or ‘mining sector’) were the leading industries benefitting from FDI inflows.

• Between 2003 and 2012, the natural resource and non-tradable sectors (mainly real estate and construction) received nearly 50% more greenfield FDI flows than tradable non-resource manufacturing and commercial services, especially for countries like Egypt, Jordan and Libya.

52 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

III. Sectors of Interest & FDI Trends

Page 54: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Greenfield FDI inflows into Arab Countries in Transition by sector and source (% of total), 2003-2011.

Source: World Bank, 2012 (based on FDI Markets). 53 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

III. Sectors of Interest & FDI Trends

Page 55: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

• In contrast, ‘high quality’ FDI (i.e. FDI that creates employment and promotes transfer of technologies and managerial know-how to host economies) in non-oil tradable manufacturing and services, has decreased substantially, making of the MENA region one of the least integrated developing regions in global value chains.

• FDI in manufacturing accounted for just one fifth of all FDI inflows to the region.

Source: OECD, 2014 and World Bank, 2013.

54 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

III. Sectors of Interest & FDI Trends

Page 56: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

In the MENA region the legal framework on Alternative Dispute Resolution (‘ADR’) is perceived as a moderate to minor obstacle to FDI. The Arbitrating and Mediating Disputes Perception Score (AMDPS) measures the average perception of contributors, based on a scale from 1 to 5, of the extent to which the legal framework on ADR is an obstacle to FDI. The highest scores indicate the regions where the obstacle is perceived as bigger. The score is 2.8 in MENA region. (FDI Regulations database, 2012)

There seems to be a direct relationship between FDI and AMDPS. Economies that score better on the AMDPS tend to facilitate the receipt of more FDI inflows.

55

Investment Trends & Dispute Resolution

© Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 57: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

IV. Prospects, Challenges and Risks

Prospects: It is clear that North Africa and the wider

MENA region are open for business with ample opportunities for ‘greenfield’, ‘brownfield’ and ‘high quality’ FDI in oil & gas, mining, infrastructure, telecommunications, power (including renewable energy) and financial services sectors.

56 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 58: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

IV. Prospects, Challenges and Risks

Challenges & Risks:

Regional volatility. Uncertain investment and regulatory climate. Policy and legal uncertainty. Transparency and rule of law. Absence of conducive dispute resolution

environment and infrastructure.

57 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 59: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

IV. Prospects, Challenges and Risks

Challenges & Risks:

Absence of affluent businesses’ and consumers’ markets, and sophisticated banking industry. Absence of world class physical infrastructure

and logistics facilities. Varied judicial approaches to ADR and

international arbitration. 58 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 60: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

We wouldn’t be investing as much in the rest of Africa if we didn’t believe. Africa

will be the success story in the next decades … Africa is on the move and it is

moving forward.

(Julian Roberts, Group Chief Executive, Old Mutual, January 2014)

59 © Prof. Dr. Mohamed S. Abdel Wahab

Page 61: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

ARBITRATION IN SOUTH AFRICA Des Williams, Director, Werksmans Attorneys, Johannesburg, South Africa

Page 62: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

SOUTH AFRICA – THE INVESTMENT LANDSCAPE

> Second largest economy in Africa (after Nigeria)

> Contributes about 25% of African GDP, 40% of its industrial output and 50% of its electricity supply.

> Ranked as an upper middle income economy by the World Bank.

> Population approximately 52million.

> 11 official languages.

> Broad Based Black Economic Empowerment (BBBEE) a key Government policy.

> Investment treaties are being replaced by controversial Promotion and Protection of Investment Bill.

61

Page 63: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

SOUTH AFRICA – LEADER IN FDI PROJECTS

> In 2012 and 2013 South Africa received at least double the number of FDI projects of the second largest recipient.

Source – E&Y Attractiveness Survey – Africa 2014

62

Page 64: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

SOUTH AFRICA AS AN INVESTOR IN AFRICA

> South Africa is the third largest investor in Africa (after the UK and US).

Source – E&Y Attractiveness Survey – Africa 2014

63

Page 65: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

SOUTH AFRICA – AN ATTRACTIVE INVESTMENT DESTINATION

Source – E&Y Attractiveness Survey – Africa 2014

64

Page 66: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

SOUTH AFRICA – INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITIES

Source – E&Y Attractiveness Survey – Africa 2014

65

Page 67: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

ARBITRATION

Arbitration in South Africa

> is a popular method of commercial dispute resolution;

> enjoys strong court support;

> will soon be supported by the introduction of major new arbitration legislation.

66

Page 68: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

KEY EVENTS FROM 1998 TO 2015

• Law Commission’s report in 1998 made three core proposals -

Introduction of the UNCITRAL Model Law .

Implementation of changes to legislation on the New York Convention.

Accession to the Washington Convention.

67

Page 69: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

1998 TO 2015 (cont)

Progress was slow. Political issue was perception that arbitration was inimical to judicial transformation in post-apartheid South Africa.

Perception has now changed for the following reasons –

Strong court support from both Supreme Court of Appeal and Constitutional Court

Realisation that South Africa was losing ground to Mauritius and other centres as a regional arbitration centre.

Arbitration no longer seen as inimical to judicial transformation.

68

Page 70: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

THE NEW INTERNATIONAL ARBITRATION ACT

Two of the Commission’s key proposals have been accepted, in

principle.

> Introduction of the UNCITRAL Model Law.

> Implementation of changes to legislation on New York

Convention.

Bilateral investment treaties have fallen out of favour. To be

replaced by new Promotion and Protection of Investment Act.

International Arbitration Act expected to be enacted in early

2016.

69

Page 71: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

MAJOR ARBITRATION ORGANISATIONS

> Arbitration Foundation of Southern Africa (“AFSA”)

> Africa ADR, which is a domestic and regional arbitration organisation affiliated to AFSA.

> The Court of Arbitration of the International Chamber of Commerce (“ICC”).

> London Court of International Arbitration

Also note establishment of China-Africa Joint Arbitration Centre (“CAJAC”).

70

Page 72: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

HOT SECTORS

> Mining

> IT/Telecoms

> Banking and finance

> General/commercial

71

Page 73: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

SOUTH AFRICA AS A REGIONAL ARBITRATION CENTRE

> Introduction of new International Arbitration Act will stimulate development as regional arbitration centre. Main competition will continue to be Mauritius. South Africa has significant geographic and infrastructural advantages.

> Signs of increasing activity as regional arbitration centre. Examples, in our arbitration practice, include the following

Acting for Kamoto Copper (a DRC company) against Zhongji (A Chinese company) in litigation and arbitration proceedings in South Africa arising from termination of a construction contract in the DRC.

Representing the Namibian subsidiary of a UK mining group against the Namibian subsidiary of an Indian mining group in arbitration proceedings concerning rights under a prospecting agreement.

72

Page 74: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

THE ARBITRATION CLAUSE

The most widely used standard arbitration clauses are –

AFSA

ICC

LCIA

Too early to say whether CAJAC arbitration clause will be widely used.

73

Page 75: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

Standard clauses are all acceptable, but note the following –

AFSA rules provide for an appeal, if agreed. No appeal unless provided for in arbitration clause or subsequently agreed.

Clause should provide for –

Seat of the arbitration.

The language to be used in the arbitration proceedings.

The governing law of the contract

Standard form multi-tiered dispute resolution clauses (eg, FIDIC) widely used, particularly in construction and engineering contracts.

74

Page 76: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

CONCLUSION

> South Africa very well placed to develop as the major Southern African regional arbitration centre.

> Climate has changed. Political hesitation has given way to strong support.

> China increasingly important. Strong Chinese support for resolution of commercial disputes through regional organisations. Most recent example is CAJAC.

75

Page 77: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

WEBINAR Q&A

Page 78: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when

THANK YOU Please join us for additional webinars in the K&L Gates International Arbitration Webinar Series.

29 October 2015 Can the Arbitration Process under Bermuda Form Policies Be Enhance for Policyholders?

2 December 2015 A Review of the International Arbitration Landscape Across Three of the Main Latin American Arbitral Centres

Learn more about these and other webinars at klgateshub.com

The K&L Gates International Webinar Series will continue in 2016.

Page 79: The Role of Arbitration Clauses in Risk Minimisation when