the university of iowa department of orthodontics “advancing ... · 1998 – 2003 the tamil nadu...

3
Q The University of Iowa Department of Orthodontics “Advancing Orthodontics, One Smile at a Time” Dear Alumni and Friends, Airway is the new TMD! Has anyone noticed the similarity between orthodontics and airway that we went through with orthodontics and TMD? What I see is that a few charismatic, but ill-informed, dentists make unsubstantiated treatment claims. They convert ingenuous listeners who drink the Kool Aide and become disciples. A movement follows. Referral patterns alter. Years later, the quacks are exposed, cry persecution, and move on to new crusades. How do we deal with these patterns of misinformation? By conducting excellent scientific research to seek the truth and then apply this research in caring for our patients. In this issue, Dr. Marshall answers two questions addressing orthodontics and airway based upon current best scientific evidence. . . . Tom Q: Does orthodontic treatment with premolar extractions cause or predispose an individual to sleep-related breathing disorders? A: e best scientific evidence suggests that orth- odontic treatment with premolar extractions, by and large, does not affect airway dimension and does not cause, nor predispose, an individual to obstructive sleep apnea. In cases where maximum retraction of anterior teeth is planned (similar to when planning mandibular setback surgery), airway function should be considered. Currently there are 6 studies in the orthodontic lit- erature that address the effect of extraction on airway size. 1-6 Four of the studies 1-4 find extraction of pre- molar teeth does not result in airway changes when evaluating airway volume using CBCT (3 studies) or airway linear dimensions on lateral cephalograms (1 study). Two studies 5,6 evaluating the airway lin- ear dimensions on lateral cephalograms found that premolar extraction with maximum retraction of anterior teeth results in reduced airway linear dimen- sions in the oropharynx. With respect to retraction of maxillary anterior teeth, two recent studies sug- gest use of cervical headgear in non-extraction treatment does not affect airway dimensions 8 , and total distalization of the maxillary arch using a TAD-supported distalization appliance does not affect airway dimensions. 9 One study 7 , which addresses the relationship of pre- molar extraction and obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), found no difference in the incidence of OSA in 2792 adults with previous extraction of 4 premolars, compared to 2792 adults matched for age, gender and BMI. is is the best evidence currently available that premolar extractions do not cause or predispose and individual to OSA. It is important to note that no single cause of OSA has been identified. Airway dimension is one of multiple structural and physiologic factors considered risks for OSA. ese include: Structural: Retrognathic mandible Enlarged adenoids and tonsils Enlarged tongue “Dr. Steve Marshall discussed the relationship between orthodontic treatment and airways at our Iowa Society of Orthodontists annual meeting this past September. I asked Steve to summarize two important points from his talk as follows:” continued next page

Upload: others

Post on 17-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The University of Iowa Department of Orthodontics “Advancing ... · 1998 – 2003 The Tamil Nadu Dr.MGR Medical University, Chennai, India Bachelor of Dental Surgery (B.D.S) Post–Doctoral

Q

The University of Iowa Department of Orthodontics “Advancing Orthodontics, One Smile at a Time”

Dear Alumni and Friends,Airway is the new TMD! Has anyone noticed the similarity between orthodontics and airway that we went through with orthodontics and TMD? What I see is that a few charismatic, but ill-informed, dentists make unsubstantiated treatment claims. They convert ingenuous listeners who drink the Kool Aide and become disciples. A movement follows. Referral patterns alter. Years later, the quacks are exposed, cry persecution, and move on to new crusades. How do we deal with these patterns of misinformation? By conducting excellent scientific research to seek the truth and then apply this research in caring for our patients. In this issue, Dr. Marshall answers two questions addressing orthodontics and airway based upon current best scientific evidence. . . . Tom

Q: Does orthodontic treatment with premolar extractions cause or predispose an individual to sleep-related breathing disorders?

A: The best scientific evidence suggests that orth-odontic treatment with premolar extractions, by and large, does not affect airway dimension and does not cause, nor predispose, an individual to obstructive sleep apnea. In cases where maximum retraction of anterior teeth is planned (similar to when planning mandibular setback surgery), airway function should be considered. Currently there are 6 studies in the orthodontic lit-erature that address the effect of extraction on airway size.1-6 Four of the studies1-4 find extraction of pre-molar teeth does not result in airway changes when evaluating airway volume using CBCT (3 studies) or airway linear dimensions on lateral cephalograms (1 study). Two studies5,6 evaluating the airway lin-ear dimensions on lateral cephalograms found that premolar extraction with maximum retraction of anterior teeth results in reduced airway linear dimen-sions in the oropharynx. With respect to retraction of maxillary anterior teeth, two recent studies sug-

gest use of cervical headgear in non-extraction treatment does not affect airway dimensions8, and total distalization of the maxillary arch using a TAD-supported distalization appliance does not affect airway dimensions.9

One study7, which addresses the relationship of pre-molar extraction and obstructive sleep apnea (OSA), found no difference in the incidence of OSA in 2792 adults with previous extraction of 4 premolars, compared to 2792 adults matched for age, gender and BMI. This is the best evidence currently available that premolar extractions do not cause or predispose and individual to OSA.It is important to note that no single cause of OSA has been identified. Airway dimension is one of multiple structural and physiologic factors considered risks for OSA. These include:Structural: Retrognathic mandible Enlarged adenoids and tonsils Enlarged tongue

“Dr. Steve Marshall discussed the relationship between orthodontic treatment and airways at our Iowa Society of Orthodontists annual meeting this past September. I asked Steve to summarize two important points from his talk as follows:”

continued next page

Page 2: The University of Iowa Department of Orthodontics “Advancing ... · 1998 – 2003 The Tamil Nadu Dr.MGR Medical University, Chennai, India Bachelor of Dental Surgery (B.D.S) Post–Doctoral

Q

Monica Ginart

Monica Obniski

Andrew Richter

Sydney Sherman

Cody West

WELCOME THE FIRST YEAR RESIDENTS

- 2 -

Enlarged lateral pharyngeal walls Obesity (enlarges lateral pharyngeal walls and pos-

terior surface of the tongue) Physiologic: Collapsibility of the passive upper airway (low

muscle tone) Stability/instability of the overall ventilator control

system The arousal threshold to hypoxia and hypercapnia

(excess blood CO2) Reflex response to negative intraluminal pressure

in the upper airwayThe interplay of these factors in the pathogenesis of OSA is unknown.

Q: What is the orthodontist’s role in detecting and managing sleep-related breathing disorders?

A: The most important role of the orthodontist is recognizing airway problems and providing the ap-propriate physician referral. A medical history questionnaire should include ques-tions pertaining to potential risk factors. For example: Do you (or your child) have a history of: Mouth breathing? Snoring? Tonsil or adenoid condi-tions? Sinus problems? Nasal congestion? Asthma? Being easily tired? Daytime fatigue? Difficulty sleep-ing? Diabetes? High blood pressure? Cardiovascular (heart) problems?

Is there a family history of: Sleep apnea? Appliances to improve snoring? Palate surgery? Jaw surgery?The clinical exam should include an evaluation of risk factors: Craniofacial form Tonsils Space between soft palate and tongue Tongue size/form

If referral to a physician is warranted, include your list of patient risk factors in your communication to the physician.

References:1. Valiathan M. et al. Angle Orthod 2010; 80:1068– 1074.2. Stefanovic N. et al. Orthod Craniofac Res 2013; 16: 87–96.3. Maaitah A. et al. Angle Orthod 2012;82:853–859.4. Pliska BT, et al. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop 2016;150:937-445. Derya Germec-Cakan, et al. Eur J Orthod 2011;33(5):515-20.6. Wang Q, et al. Angle Orthod 2012;82:115–21.7. Larsen AJ, et al. J Clin Sleep Med 2015;11(12):1443 –1448 .8. Julku J, et al. Eur J Orthod 2017;40(3):285-95.9. Park JH, et al. Angle Orthod 2018;88(2):187-94.

Page 3: The University of Iowa Department of Orthodontics “Advancing ... · 1998 – 2003 The Tamil Nadu Dr.MGR Medical University, Chennai, India Bachelor of Dental Surgery (B.D.S) Post–Doctoral

Welcome

- 3 -

Chris Carlson (Class of 2003) and family in Scandinavia for two weeks.

AlumniNews

If you have news you would

like to share, then please

contact Tom;

[email protected],

Dr. Venugopalan’s Degrees:2016 – 2017 UMKC School of Dentistry, Kansas City, MO Doctor of Dental Surgery (D.D.S) 2010 – 2014 Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, MA Certificate in Orthodontics and Dentofacial Orthopedics2010 – 2014 Harvard University, Boston, MA Doctor of Medical Science (D.M.Sc) in Oral Biology 2005 – 2010 Texas A&M University Health Science Center Baylor College of Dentistry, Dallas, TX Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.) in Biomedical Sciences1998 – 2003 The Tamil Nadu Dr.MGR Medical University, Chennai, India Bachelor of Dental Surgery (B.D.S)Post–Doctoral Training:2011 – 2014 Forsyth Institute, Cambridge, MA Research Scholar in Dr. Henry Margolis Laboratory2010 – 2014 Harvard School of Dental Medicine, Boston, MA Residency in Orthodontics

We eagerly await the arrival of our newest full-time faculty member, Dr. Shankar Rengasamy Venugopalan, in January 2019. Shankar will be joining us from UMKC where he serves as staff orthodontist and researcher. His research interests include craniofacial development, genetics/genomes, and mineralized tissue biology. In addition, he has worked to identify factors affecting clinical outcomes in patients hospitalized for cleft lip/palate repair and orthognathic surgeries. We look forward to the knowledge and experience Dr. Venugopalan brings to the University of Iowa Orthodontic program.

FACULTYSPOTLIGHT