the use of copyright to quell online expression: - no judge, no jury, but there is an executioner...

5
The use of copyright to quell online expression: - no judge, no jury, but there is an executioner Prepared for Government and the Internet: Participation, Expression and Control European University Institute, March 9 th 2011 Benjamin Farrand

Upload: cori-fields

Post on 17-Dec-2015

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The use of copyright to quell online expression: - no judge, no jury, but there is an executioner Prepared for Government and the Internet: Participation,

The use of copyright to quell online expression: - no judge, no jury, but there is an executioner

Prepared for Government and the Internet: Participation, Expression and ControlEuropean University Institute, March 9th 2011

Benjamin Farrand

Page 2: The use of copyright to quell online expression: - no judge, no jury, but there is an executioner Prepared for Government and the Internet: Participation,

The use of copyright to quell online expression

A basic introduction to copyright: - concept, justifications and legislative acts

Internationally: - the TRIPS agreement, WIPO treaties

European Union: - InfoSoc Directive (2001/29/EC) and the Enforcement Directive (2004/48/EC)

US: - Digital Millennium Copyright Act 1998

The intent of copyright legislation being supplanted by complete control of all use of works – including restricting criticism or debate through a form of ‘censorship by the back door’

Church of Scientology v Karen Spaink (Netherlands 2005)

Page 3: The use of copyright to quell online expression: - no judge, no jury, but there is an executioner Prepared for Government and the Internet: Participation,

By state actors?

Page 4: The use of copyright to quell online expression: - no judge, no jury, but there is an executioner Prepared for Government and the Internet: Participation,

By private/non-state actors?

Page 5: The use of copyright to quell online expression: - no judge, no jury, but there is an executioner Prepared for Government and the Internet: Participation,

Methods & Conclusions

DMCA/Enforcement Directive takedowns

ISP filtering?

‘Indirect copyright issues’?

Accountability?

Access to information and accountability?