thesis final
TRANSCRIPT
INTRODUCTION Pages:1-8
1
INTRODUCTION
Blunt thoraco-abdominal injuries are one of the major causes of unnatural
deaths(1). These two body cavities contain most of the vital organs and
therefore, injury to these organs even by blunt trauma usually leads to a fatal
outcome. Blunt trauma to the chest and abdomen can be produced in various
situations such as road traffic accidents, railway accidents, fall from height and
blunt weapons.
Maximum numbers of victims are generally from road traffic accidents. A
significant number of these road traffic accident victims are likely to die of
thoracoabdominal trauma. Data available suggests that a significant mortality
due to road traffic accidents exists in north east Delhi.
In India 1, 00,300 males and 17,939 females totaling 1, 18,239 persons were
killed during the year 2008, while traveling by various modes of transport on
roads. 25,135 persons (21.2%) of these were occupants of ‘Truck/Lorry’, 23,552
(19.9%) were riding on ‘Two-wheelers’, 12,551 (10.6%) were killed while
traveling in buses and 10,324 (8.7%) were pedestrians.
While in Delhi 1884 males and 214 females totaling 2098 persons were killed
during the year 2008, while traveling by various modes of transport on roads.
173 persons of these were occupants of ‘Truck/Lorry’,69 were riding on ‘Two-
wheelers’,110 were tempo/van occupants,10 were jeep occupants,151 were car
2
occupants,554 were riding on three wheelers,589 were bicycle occupants ,133
were killed while traveling in buses,230 were others and 230 were pedestrians.
883 males and 96 females totaling 979 persons were killed during the year
2008 in rail accidents in Delhi (2).
North east Delhi has two national highways and railway lines in its vicinity. As a
result of this the pattern of road traffic in this region is quite distinct from that in
other parts of Delhi. In 2006 total number of Cars and Jeeps plying on the roads
of Delhi were 15,89,872, Motor cycles and Scooters were 32,99,838, Auto
Rickshaws were 74,189, Taxis were 24,958, Buses were 46,581,and Goods
Vehicles were 1,49,972.The total number of cases of road traffic accidents
were 9699 and in these accidents 2167 persons died and 8769 persons were
injured(3).
Railway accidents are also not uncommon in this region. Homicides using blunt
weapons are also quite common here.
Physiologically based trauma scores available are:
1. The Revised Trauma Score (RTS)
2. The Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE)
3. The sequential organ failure assessment (SOFA) score
4. The systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) score
5. Emergency trauma score (EMTRAS)
3
The Revised Trauma Score (RTS) is one of the more common physiologic
scores. It uses 3 specific physiologic parameters, as follows: (1) Glasgow Coma
Scale (GCS), (2) systolic blood pressure (SBP), and (3) respiratory rate (RR).
The Acute Physiology and Chronic Health Evaluation (APACHE) has 2
components, as follows: (1) the chronic health evaluation, which incorporates
the influence of comorbid conditions (eg, diabetes mellitus, cirrhosis, chronic
renal failure, heart disease malignancy), and (2) the Acute Physiology Score
(APS). The APS consists of weighted variables representing the major
physiologic systems, including neurologic, cardiovascular, respiratory, renal,
gastrointestinal, metabolic, and hematologic variables. In 1985, the APACHE
system was revised (ie, APACHE II) by reducing the number of APS variables
from 34 to 12, restricting the comorbid conditions, and deriving coefficients for
specific diseases.
The sequential organ failure assessment (SOFA) score is based on 6 different
parameters, as follows: respiratory system (PaO2/FiO2, mm Hg), cardiovascular
system (blood pressure/vasopressors), hepatic system (bilirubin,
mg/dL), coagulation system (plateletsX103/mm3), renal system (creatinine,
mg/dL), and neurological system (Glasgow Coma Scale).
The systemic inflammatory response syndrome (SIRS) score is a generalized
response to nonspecific insults, including infections, pancreatitis, trauma, and
burns.
4
Raum et al developed the emergency trauma score (EMTRAS) comprising of 4
parameters: patient age, Glasgow Coma Scale, base excess, and prothrombin
time (PT).
Physiologically based scores measure parameters such as blood pressure,
respiratory rate, and level of consciousness and are useful for early evaluation
of the injured person and not relevant in postmortem evaluation.
Combined Anatomical and physiologically based trauma scores available are:
1. Trauma and Injury Severity Score (TRISS)
2. Severity Characterization of Trauma (ASCOT)
Trauma and Injury Severity Score (TRISS) combines anatomic and physiologic
measures of injury severity (ISS and RTS, respectively) and patient age in order
to predict survival from trauma.
Champion et al introduced A Severity Characterization of Trauma (ASCOT) in
1990 as an improvement over TRISS. ASCOT uses the AP in place of the ISS.
(4)
5
Anatomical scores are based on the characterization of injuries anatomically, as
outlined below.
Abbreviated Injury Score (AIS)
Injury Severity Score (ISS)
New Injury Severity Score (NISS)
Penetrating Abdominal Trauma Index (PATI)
ICD-based Injury Severity Score (ICISS)
Anatomic scales score each organ injury separately. The abbreviated injury
scale (AIS) and the injury severity score (ISS), which is based on the AIS, are
the most frequently used anatomical scales. The American Medical Association,
for Automotive Medicine & the Society of Automotive Engineers established the
AIS in 1973.It has been revised several times, and latest revision was in 2005.
In its present form the AIS codes injuries based on their anatomic site, nature
and severity.
The ISS is also an anatomically based ordinal scale, with a range from 1 to 75.
To compute the ISS the nine AIS body regions are grouped into six: head or
neck, face, chest, abdominal or pelvic contents, extremities or pelvic girdle, and
external. The ISS is then calculated as the sum of the squares of the highest
AIS scores for the three most severely injured body regions. For example, if a
person sustained multiple injuries to the head, thorax and extremities, and if the
most severe injuries in each body region were a closed non-depressed vault
skull fracture (AIS =2), one rib fracture (AIS = 1), and an open tibial fracture
6
(AIS = 3), the ISS would be calculated as the sum of squares of each of these
values. An exception to this algorithm happens when any single body region
has AIS of 6, when an ISS of 75 is then assigned.
Recently, researchers have proposed a new injury severity score (NISS) which,
unlike the ISS, considers the three most severe injuries, regardless of body
region. The NISS is computed as the simple sum of squares of the three most
severe AIS (1990 revision and 2005) injuries (5).
The penetrating abdominal trauma index (PATI) score is used to calculate the
risk of complications in patients undergoing celiotomy for penetrating abdominal
trauma.
Another, more recent approach to anatomic injury scoring is based on the
International Classification of Disease, Ninth Edition (ICD-9) codes. This
method is termed ICD-9 Injury Severity Score (ICISS) and uses survival risk
ratios (SRRs) calculated for each ICD-9 discharge diagnosis. SRRs are derived
by dividing the number of survivors in each ICD-9 code by the total number of
patients with the same ICD-9 code. ICISS is calculated as the simple product of
the SRRs for each of the patient's injuries.
NISS being the latest and effective method for studying postmortem injuries,
was used in my study.
The regular use of trauma scores in Forensic Medicine may provide a
standardized database of autopsy findings which would make a tremendous
7
contribution to the quality of trauma treatment and assessment of preventable
death. This study will highlight the importance of ISS/NISS in trauma care and
in assessing the prognosis of thoraco-abdominal trauma cases. In the recent
past no study assessing the thoraco abdominal injuries using ISS/NISS has
been done in this region. Hence the present study was undertaken.
8
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Pages: 9-37
9
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Cox (6) studied Blunt abdominal trauma in a 5-year analysis of 870 patients
requiring celiotomy in the department of surgery, Maryland institute for
emergency medical systems, Baltimore, Maryland. 870 patients with blunt
abdominal trauma were reviewed, representing 12.89 % of the total admissions
over a five year period. Motor vehicles continued to be the major cause(89.5%)
of injury to these patients. Of the injuries incurred, spleen was involved in 42% of
cases, the liver in 35.6% of cases, the serosa, and blood vessels diaphragm and
bowel, were involved to a lesser extent (0.4%).
Bergqvist et al (7) studied patients with abdominal trauma and fatal outcome in an
analysis of a 30-year series in rural Swedish area. They found that Patients with
blunt abdominal trauma with fatal outcome comprised of 127 patients. Several
facts indicate that more severe trauma has been appearing more often during
this period The mortality rate has, however, been stable, but the patients have
become older. More patients died from pulmonary complications than from the
trauma itself. One very important development was the significant decrease in
mortality among children.
Brainard et al (8) studied Injury profiles in pedestrian motor vehicle trauma
in Tucson, USA. Hundred fifteen consecutive pedestrians who were struck by
motor vehicles were studied to determine the magnitude and patterns of the
injuries sustained. The mortality rate was 22%, and 17 of 25 patients who died
10
did so during the initial resuscitative efforts, primarily due to head, chest, and/or
abdominal injury. The average Injury Severity Score (ISS) among all patients was
20; however, it was significantly higher (46) in nonsurvivors. The majority of the
victims were men (72%), and the average age of all patients was 35 years. As
the patient's age increased, so did the likelihood of mortality, fractures, and
prolonged hospital stay. The most frequently injured organ system was
musculoskeletal (77%), followed by head (34%), abdomen (21%), and chest
(15%). The most common fractures seen were tibia-fibular (39), pelvis (35), and
femur (31). Hospital stay averaged 11 days.
Arajarvi et al (9) studied Chest injuries sustained in severe traffic accidents
by seatbelt wearers, in Finland during the period 1972-1985, there occurred
3,468 severe traffic accidents in which one or more of the drivers or passengers
sustained an injury leading to a fatal outcome within 30 days. Of the victims who
had been wearing seatbelts, 207 had fatal and 73 had severe chest injuries. The
four leading causes of fatalities resulting from chest injuries were ruptures of the
aorta (37%), ruptures of the heart (28.4%), and bilateral lung contusions (31.1%)
or lacerations (15.5%). In addition to chest injuries, 87% of the victims had other
concomitant injuries, the most common abdominal injuries being liver injuries
(40.2%) and spleen ruptures (26.5%).
Kumar et al (10) studied ISS as a yard stick in assessing the severity and
mortality of various abdominopelvict trauma hospitalized victims –a clinical vis a
11
vis autopsy study. They studied 51 cases of vehicular accident showing
abdominopelvic trauma, along with associated injuries. A detailed ISS score was
done in all the cases and it was seen that victims in their 30s and 40s died only if
their severity score was above 50.It was also observed that when the score was
less than 20, the mortality level was minimal, while above 20 there was linear
increase. In two of the cases studied, the score was 75.When comparing the ISS
obtained from postmortem examination with the score derived from the clinical
assessment, there was a difference of 9 to 16 in 64.86% of victims.
Guirguis et al (11) studied Trauma Outcome Analysis of Two Canadian
Centers Using the TRISS Method .A total of 274 adult patients with multiple-
system injuries were studied; their demographic data, Trauma Scores (TS) on
arrival to the Emergency Room, and Injury Severity Scores (ISS) were reviewed.
The TRISS scores and Z and M statistics were then calculated. In the Hamilton
group, 106 consecutive patients from April through July 1987 were studied. The
majority of patients (72%) were male, and the median age was 26 years. The
majority of patients (96.2%) sustained blunt trauma, with motor vehicle accidents
(MVA) being the most common (76.4%) mechanisms of injury. In the Ottawa
group, 168 consecutive patients from April 1987 through October 1988 were
studied. The majority of patients (73%) were male, and the median age was 39
years. Blunt trauma accounted for the majority (91.7%) of injuries, with MVAs
being responsible for 58% of injuries.
12
Poole et al (12) studied Pelvic fracture from major blunt trauma. Outcome is
determined by associated injuries. The medical records of all patients admitted to
the University of Mississippi Medical Center (UMC) from January 1986 through
December 1989 with a diagnosis of pelvic fracture were reviewed. Pelvic
hemorrhage has been implicated as the cause of death in 50% of patients who
die following pelvic fractures. To establish correlates of morbidity and mortality
from pelvic fractures due to blunt trauma, they reviewed 236 patients treated
during 4 years. The average age of the 144 men and 92 women was 31.5 years,
the average Injury Severity Score was 21.3, the average blood requirement was
5 units, and the average hospital stay was 16.8 days. One hundred fifty-two
patients (64.4%) were injured in motor vehicle accidents, 33 (14%) had motor
vehicle-pedestrian accidents, 16 (6.8%) had crush injuries, 12 (5.1%) each had
either motorcycle accidents or falls, and 11 (4.6%) had miscellaneous accidents.
Eighteen patients (7.6%) died, with seven (38.9%) deaths due to hemorrhage.
Only one death was caused by pelvic hemorrhage. Other deaths were due to
hemorrhage from other sites (6), head injury (5), sepsis or multiple-organ failure
(4), pulmonary injury (1), and pulmonary embolus (1). None of the septic deaths
was related to a pelvic hematoma. Multivariate multiple regression analysis
showed that the severity of injury was correlated with indices of severity of pelvic
fractures such as fracture site (p less than 0.0001), fracture displacement (p less
than 0.005), pelvic stability (p less than 0.0001), and vector of injury (p less than
0.01). However death could not be predicted on the basis of these indices of
severity (p greater than 0.28). Massive bleeding from pelvic fractures was
13
uncommon, and the major threat of hemorrhage was from nonpelvic sites.
Furthermore, although injury severity was correlated with the severity of the
pelvic fracture, hospital outcome was determined by associated injuries and not
by the pelvic fracture.
Bishop et al (13) studied evaluation of a comprehensive algorithm for blunt
and penetrating thoracic and abdominal trauma in the Department of Surgery,
King-Drew Medical Center, Los Angeles. During a 4-month period, the
management decisions and clinical course of 434 trauma patients were
prospectively observed. Thirty-four patients had no signs of life on arrival to the
emergency department (ED) and were excluded from the statistical evaluation;
the remaining 400 patients constituted the study group. The mean Injury Severity
Score (ISS), Penetrating Abdominal Trauma Index (PATI), and Trauma Score
(TS) scores in the series were 21 +/- 10, 34 +/- 12, and 13 +/- 3 respectively. The
overall patient mortality of the study group was 17 per cent; it was 61 per cent in
those patients with major deviations from the algorithm and 6 per cent in patients
who complied with the algorithm. There were 108 patients with ISS scores
between 20 and 50.
Roux and Fisher (14).Studied Chest injuries in children: an analysis of 100
cases of blunt chest trauma from motor vehicle accidents in Rondebosch, South
Africa. One hundred twenty-eight cases of chest injury were seen in a Paediatric
Trauma Unit over a 5 1/2-year period. One hundred patients sustained motor
14
vehicle accident (MVA)-related blunt chest injuries, 91 of them as pedestrians.
Nine children had blunt chest injuries from falls, 10 had stab wounds (3 assault, 7
accidental), and 9 had gunshot injuries (6 from birdshot used by police during
civil disturbance). MVA-related injuries were studied separately, as an
etiologically homogeneous group. Sixty-five of these patients were under the age
of 6. All but 3 also had serious extrathoracic injuries. The mean injury severity
score (ISS) in MVA-related injuries was 25. Eight patients died, all with an ISS of
34 or more, 7 of whom had fatal head injuries. In MVA-related injuries, pulmonary
contusion (n = 73) was the most frequent lesion seen, followed by rib fracture (n
= 62), posttraumatic effusion (n = 58), pneumothorax (n = 38), and pneumatocele
(n = 5). Analysis suggests that lung injury is a central event in MVA-related blunt
chest trauma.
Daly and Thomas (15) studied trauma deaths in the South West Thames
Region. All traumatic deaths occurring in the South West Thames Region during
1988 were studied. They analyzed 434 of these deaths (mean age 52 years) in
some detail. Of the deaths, 59 per cent occurred before arrival at hospital. Road
traffic accidents are the commonest cause of death from trauma, being most
prevalent in the areas containing major trunk roads. The majority of deaths due
to chest injury (79 per cent) and multiple injuries (70 per cent) occurred before
arrival at a hospital, whereas the majority of deaths due to head injury (63 per
cent) occurred after admission.
15
King et al(16) studied correlation of trauma scoring and outcome in a
Canadian trauma centre. Three hundred consecutive patients treated at a single
trauma unit were studied. Two patients were excluded because of lack of
physiologic data. Blunt injuries (94%) were most frequently from motor vehicle
accidents (46%). The mean Injury Severity Score was 21.16.
Poole and Ward (17) studied causes of mortality in patients with pelvic
fractures in the University of Mississippi Medical Center, Jackson. Three hundred
forty-eight patients were admitted directly to the hospital following blunt injuries;
these patients formed the basis of this review. There were 220 men and 128
women with an average age of 31 years, a mean Injury Severity Score of 21.8,
and an average hospital stay of 16.5 days. Almost two thirds of patients were
injured in motor vehicle accidents, and about one eighth were pedestrians struck
by a vehicle. Smaller numbers were injured in crushing accidents, motorcycle
accidents, falls, and miscellaneous injuries. Only 32 patients (9%) had an
isolated pelvic fracture. Associated injuries to the head, chest, abdomen, and
upper and lower extremities were frequent, and these injuries often had a greater
impact on outcome than the pelvic fracture. Twenty-eight patients died, an overall
mortality rate of 8%. Only four deaths (14.3%) were a direct result of the pelvic
fracture, and bleeding from a transected femoral artery contributed to one of
these deaths. Most deaths were caused by severe head injury, nonpelvic
hemorrhage, and multiple organ failure. Although the pelvic fracture may result in
16
prolonged hospitalization, and can be a cause of extended disability, it is an
infrequent cause of mortality.
Craig et al (18) studied pancreatic injuries from blunt trauma in Hungary and
found that during past 10 years they treated 13 patients with major pancreatic
injuries from blunt trauma. Twelve had been involved in motor vehicle collisions,
none of whom were wearing seat belts. One patient was injured in an assault.
Only five patients had physical findings suggesting intra-abdominal injury. The
five patients in whom peritoneal lavage was performed had free intraperitoneal
blood from injuries to other abdominal viscera. One injury was diagnosed by
ultrasound. Injuries were equally distributed throughout the pancreas, with two
injuries in the head, three in the body, five in the tail, and three with injuries in
both the head and the body. Five patients had ductal injuries. Injury Severity
Score averaged 28.5 +/- 2.6 (mean +/- standard error), and mean hospital stay
was 31 +/- 9.8 days.
Hill et al (19) studied the outcome after injury to car occupants and to
pedestrians in the Department of Surgery, Royal Prince Alfred Hospital, Sydney,
Australia. The study group consisted of all adult car occupants and pedestrians
sustaining major injury -- Injury Severity Score (ISS) of >15 -- in a defined area of
central Sydney from mid-1991 to mid-1994. The study included 65 car occupants
(median ISS, 32) and 101 pedestrians (median ISS,34). Major abdominal injury
(p = 0.003) and thoracic aortic disruption (p = 0.06) were more common in car
17
occupants. The overall car occupant mortality was 38% compared with 46% in
the pedestrians (p = 0.37). Seventy-two percent of car occupant fatalities
occurred in the field, most commonly from ruptured thoracic aorta, whereas 63%
of pedestrian deaths occurred in hospital (p = 0.005), most commonly from head
injury.
Friedman et al(20) studied the AIS. They assessed the applicability of the
AIS and the ISS systems for postmortem forensic documentation of trauma in the
department of Anesthesiology, Sheba Medical Center, Jerusalem, Israel. In a
prospective study, all trauma autopsies performed between January 1 and June
30, 1993, were coded according to the AIS and ISS method. All the cases were
reviewed by a consultant in forensic medicine and a traumatologist. Cases were
grouped in three categories according to ISS values: 0-14, 16-66, and 75. These
categories represent minor, major, and incompatible with life injuries,
respectively. All autopsy findings in which ISS was <14 were peer-reviewed to
establish mechanism and cause of death. In the six month period, 279 trauma
related autopsies were studied. Age at death averaged 37.1 .Eighty six percent
of the victims were male. Penetrating trauma was the mechanism of injury in
67%.ISS was 0-14 in 19 cases, 16-66 in 150 cases, and 75 in 110 cases. In
conclusion, AIS and ISS scoring systems are applicable to trauma forensic
documentation. Using these methods for coding postmortem findings may help in
establishing a database for trauma research, and this information could
constitute a major part of continuous quality improvement of trauma
18
management. Low ISS values may serve as a warning, sometimes indicating
preventable death.
Chong et al (21) studied Pelvic fractures and mortality in the College of
Medicine and Asian Medical Center, Seoul, South Korea. A retrospective study of
all patients (N = 343) with pelvic fractures admitted to the trauma service was
conducted to evaluate the impact of pelvic fractures on mortality. All patients
sustained additional injuries with an average Injury Severity Score (ISS) of
twenty. Thirty-six patients died. Six patients died as a direct result of pelvic
hemorrhage. In six other patients, pelvic fractures contributed to their demise.
The other twenty-four patients died from brain injury, thoracic hemorrhage, or
other non-pelvic causes. Overall mortality for patients with pelvic fractures was
10.5 percent. This was a 1.4 fold increase in mortality compared to other trauma
patients during the same time period without pelvic fractures. Mortality was
dramatically increased in patients over sixty years of age (37 percent mortality
compared to 8 percent). This greater than four-fold increase in deaths in the
elderly appears to be an age related effect because the elderly patients generally
had a lower ISS and less severe pelvic trauma than younger patients. They
conclude that sustaining a pelvic fracture places the patient at an increased risk
of death. Pelvic fractures contributed directly to death in one-third of the
mortalities, one-third died from complications associated with pelvic fractures,
and one-third died from other causes.
19
Velmahos et al (22) studied patterns of injury in victims of urban free falls in
Los Angeles, California and found that 187 consecutive presented to their trauma
centre during a 9 month period (September 1994 to June 1995) after a fall from a
height of 5 to 70 feet. Only three falls were from heights of more than 40 feet. Of
these patients, 116(65.1%) suffered significant trauma. Fractures were the most
common injuries, accounting for 76.2% of all injuries. Spinal fractures were
detected in 37 patients and were associated with neurologic deficit in
7.Intraabdominal injuries occurred in 11 patients, requiring operative intervention
in 9 of them. Solid organ lacerations prevailed, but small bowel perforation and
bladder rupture were present in one case each. Significant retroperitoneal
hematoma was detected in only one case and a thoracic aortic rupture in one
more. Intraabdominal organ injuries are much more common than retroperitoneal
ones.
Adesunkanmi et al (23) studied road traffic accidents to African children:
assessment of severity using the ISS and found that 324 Children were injured in
road traffic accidents in western Nigeria between January 1992 to December
1995. This represented 2% of all attendances at the emergency room.
Pedestrians represented the largest group of patients. Head injuries were the
most common injuries, followed closely by limb trauma. Chest and abdominal
trauma accounted for only 2.5 and 1.5 % of patients, respectively. IN 306
children the ISS was 1-25 with no mortality but significant morbidity. Eighteen
20
patients had an ISS of 26-54 with a 61% mortality rate (11 patients). The highest
ISS were found in the group of patients who were passengers in a motor vehicle.
Banerjee KK et al (24) studied thoracoabdominal injuries in fatal road traffic
accidents in northeast Delhi. Amongst all the victims of fatal road traffic accidents
47.4% of victims had thoracoabdominal injuries with an adult male
preponderance. Most of these cases (50.9%) died at the spot with very few
(1.8%) surviving more than 12 hours. Majority of the victims (29%) had a
combination of injuries to the chest, abdomen and fracture of pelvis. The lungs
(52.7%) in the chest and Liver (56.3%) in the abdomen were the commonest
solid organs involved besides perforation of intestines (10.9%) amongst hollow
viscera. Pedestrians (54.5%) were the most vulnerable amongst the victims.
Trucks (42.1%) and buses (34.2%) formed the majority of offending vehicle.
Allen et al (25) studied outcomes after severe trauma at a northern
Canadian regional trauma centre. All trauma patients admitted between 1991
and 1994 who had an Injury Severity Score (ISS) greater than 12 were studied.
Of 526 patients with an ISS greater than 12, 416 (79%) were suitable for TRISS
analysis. Of these 416 patients, 310 (74%) were men. The mean age was 39
years The leading causes of injury were motor vehicle-traffic accidents in 48%,
motor vehicle-nontraffic in 21% and falls in 8%. Overall, there were more
unexpected survivors than patients who died.
21
Pape et al (26) studied appraisal of early evaluation of blunt chest trauma:
development of a standardized scoring system for initial clinical decision making
in the department of trauma surgery at Hannover medical school, Germany. A
retrospective investigation was performed on the basis of 4,571 blunt polytrauma
(Injury Severity Score [ISS] > or = 18) patients admitted to their unit. Inclusion
criteria were treatment of thoracic injury that required intensive care therapy,
initial Glasgow Coma Scale score greater than 8 points, and no local or systemic
infection. Patients with thoracic trauma and multiple associated injuries (ISS > or
= 18) were included. In all patients, the association between various parameters
of the thoracic injuries and subsequent mortality and morbidity was investigated.
The association between rib fractures and chest-related death was low (> three
ribs unilateral, mortality 17.3%, odds ratio 1.01) unless bilateral involvement was
present (> three ribs bilateral, mortality 40.9%, odds ratio 3.43).
Gustavo et al (27) studied the role of associated injuries on outcome of blunt
trauma patients sustaining pelvic fractures in the emergency service, department
of surgery and orthopaedic surgery, Santa casa school of Medicine, Sao Paulo,
Brazil. Retrospective review of the medical records of patients admitted with a
pelvic fracture during a 42-month period was carried out. One hundred and three
patients were included in the study. Fifty-nine were male, and the mean age was
34. The mean Revised Trauma Score (RTS) and Injury Severity Score (ISS)
were 7.1 and 20, respectively. Pedestrian vs vehicle (59%), was the most
frequent mechanism of injury. Twenty patients died (19%) most frequently due to
22
"shock". Complications developed in 37 patients (36%), pneumonia being the
most frequent. Age greater than 40 years (p=0.02), "shock" upon admission
(p=0.002), a Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS)<9, Head AIS>2 (p<0. 001), Chest
AIS>2 (p=0.007), and abdominal AIS>2 (p=0.03) all correlated with increased
mortality. The outcome of patients with pelvic fractures due to blunt trauma
correlates with the severity of associated injuries and physiological derangement
on admission rather than with characteristics of or the type of fracture
Segers et al (28) conducted the retrospective analysis of 187 cases of
thoracic trauma seen between January 1, 1994 and June 30, 1999 in Belgique.
The majority of the patients were male (male-female ratio 2.9:1) and the average
age at admission was 41.1 years. Blunt trauma, especially motor vehicle
accidents (72.2%) and falls (17.1%), were the most frequent causes of chest
injury (95.8%). The average ISS for the total group was 27.8 (ranges: 4-75). In
only 17.6% of the patients an isolated thoracic trauma was present. Rib fractures
(n = 133), pulmonary contusion (n = 110), pneumothorax (n = 78) and
haemothorax (n = 65) were the most frequent lesions The overall mortality rate
was 16.6%. Main causes of death were intracranial hypertension, sepsis
combined with multiple organ failure, and hypovolaemic shock. For patients who
did not survive the average ISS was 40.3. Mortality after thoracic trauma remains
relatively high, especially in case of associated neurotrauma. The ISS is a
valuable score for assessing the severity of trauma and predicting outcome.
23
Nikolić et al (29) studied correlation between survival time and severity of
injuries in fatal injuries in traffic accidents in the Institute of Forensic Medicine,
University school of medicine, Belgrade. The sample included 272 persons: 193
males and 79 females. The proportion of men was more significant (chi 2 = 4.76;
0.01 < p < 0.05). Average age was 51.08 years (SD = 18.08): males 49.84 +/-
17.41 and females 54.09 +/- 19.38. The most frequently injured persons in their
sample were pedestrians (134). The sample distribution by ISS values showed
three peaks: for ISS--75, 41-50 and 26-35. Peaks indicated the number of the
injured body regions and trauma severity in these persons. In 87 persons who
did not survive, the ISS value was 75. There were 73 persons without outliving
period with ISS values less than 75: their mean ISS value was 31.87 (SD =
11.30). In 112 cases the mean outliving period was 4.79 days (SD = 3.77) and
their mean ISS value was 18.05 (SD = 15.33), which was a statistically significant
lower ISS value than in previous group (t = 7.015; p < 0.001). A weak negative
correlation between outliving period and ISS values in their sample was noted
(coefficient of linear correlation r = -0.452). Coefficient of a determination (r2 =
0.20), pointed to the fact that direct correlation outliving period-trauma severity
was only about 20% and the rest of correlation i.e. 80% depended on other
factors (e.g. effective emergency medical system and triage, prompt and correct
diagnosis, adequate medical treatment and care, etc.). The calculated linear
regression was as follows: outliving period approximately 52-3 ISS. This
regression pointed out that critical and potentially fatal injury, in their sample, was
injury with ISS of 17. There were 22 persons with ISS < or = 7. Six of them died
24
on the spot as car passengers; they died due to mechanical asphyxia
(thoracoabdominal pressure) or respiratory and/or circulation failure due to
critical chest injury (flail chest, contusions and rupture of the lungs with
consequent haemopneumothorax). The rest of 16 persons survived trauma in an
average of 8.56 days (SD = 3.88), and the causes of death were pneumonia,
thrombus and fat embolism, sepsis, etc.
Milić et al (30) studied causes of death in long-term survivors of injuries
sustained in traffic accidents at the Institute of Forensic Medicine, University
school of medicine, Belgrade. The sample included 31 persons injured in traffic
accidents with outliving period longer than 15 days: 21 males and 10 females (chi
2 = 0.047; p > 0.1). Average age was 49.90 years (SD = 18.28). All persons in
their sample were over the age of 19. The most commonly injured persons were
pedestrians (16). The mean outliving period was 41.19 days (SD = 12.60). There
was a weak positive correlation between outliving period and age in their sample
(coefficient of linear correlation r = 0.35). The authors combined the autopsy and
available clinical data in order to get the ISS value for each case. The mean ISS
value was 36.18 (SD = 8.70). There was no correlation between outliving period
and severity of trauma (coefficient of linear correlation r < 0.14). All deaths in the
sample were violent according to autopsy reports. In autopsy reports, dissectors
always noted only one injured body region: head and neck injuries in 21 cases,
chest injuries in 3, trauma of locomotor system in 5 and in 2 cases abdominal
injuries. However, by analyzing these reports, the authors emphasized that in 22
25
cases one body region was severely injured, in 7 cases two body regions and
three regions in 2 cases. According to the authors severe injury has score 3 or
more by 3. In four cases the dissectors pointed no complication of initial injuries
as a competitive cause of death. In 15 cases they mentioned it as general, and in
the rest of cases as decided (e.g. pneumonia, sepsis, thromboembolism, etc.). In
five cases, the complications of initial injury were the precipitated and immediate
cause of death (the initial injury in all these cases was less than 16 by ISS i.e.
severe but not critical). The seven cases were treated microscopically. These
microscopical findings only proved the already established autopsy findings and
were not crucial for case solution. It was alarming, that one third of cases in the
sample were completed without considering the clinical medical data. This is
forensic vitium artis. Nowadays, there are a few syndromes which could be the
cause of death i.e. fat embolism syndrome, multiple organ failure) and systemic
inflammatory response syndrome. The diagnosis of these syndromes is possible
only clinically: the autopsy and histological findings are not specific.
Hughes et al (31) studied intraabdominal gastrointestinal tract injuries
following blunt trauma in Australia and found that motor vehicle accidents were
responsible for 92% admissions. Injuries were gastric (1.1%), duodenal (8.4%),
small bowel (67.3%), and rectal (1.1%).Thirty day mortality was 23%.Patients
dying within 24 hour of injury were 9.5%, out of which 4.1% were directly related
to the GIT. 13.5% patients died within two weeks of admission, 4.1% of which
were attributable to the GIT.
26
Jha et al (32) studied epidemiological study of road traffic accident cases at
Jawaharlal Institute of Postgraduate medical education and research (JIPMER)
Hospital, Pondicherry and found that there were 83% male and 17% female
accident victims. Labourers were the highest (29.9%) among the victims. The
highest number of accidents took place in the month of January (12.9%) and on
Sundays (17.1%). The occupants of the various vehicles constituted the large
(45%) group of the victims. Among the motorized vehicles, two wheeler drivers
were more (31.1%) involved in accidents.
Goel et al (33) studied epidemiological and Trauma Injury and Severity
Score (TRISS) analysis of trauma patients at a tertiary care centre in Lucknow,
Uttar Pradesh, India. Of the 180 trauma patients studied, 123 were men (70.3%)
with a mean age of 24.7 years; 143 patients had blunt injuries while 32 patients
had penetrating injuries. A nearly equal percentage of men were injured on the
road (39.8%) as at home (39.0%), while most women (65.4%) were injured at
home. The mortality rate was 31.4%. TRISS methodology was applied to 88.6%
of patients. All the 113 survivors had a probability of survival > or = 0.5 and were
considered expected survivors. Among the 42 deaths, 32 had a probability of
survival > or = 0.5 and were considered unexpected deaths, while 10 of the
deaths had a probability of survival <0.5 and were expected deaths.
27
Singh and Dhattarwal (34) studied pattern and distribution of injuries in fatal
road traffic accidents in Rohtak and found that 450 fatal road accidents which
occurred during one year period, constituted 29.8% of total medicolegal deaths
autopsied (1510) during same period. Pedestrians were the commonest group of
victims involved, comprising 28.7% cases, followed by occupants of cabs and
jeeps (25.8%) and motorcyclists (23%). The commonest age group involved was
21-30 years (27.3%) followed by 31-40 years (20.6%) and 11-20 years (17.3%)
males’ out- numbered females in ratio 9: 1. Two third of cases were in age group
of 11-- 40 years. 31.6% cases occurred on National Highways and 27.1% cases
occurred on State Highways. Heavy vehicles were commonest offenders,
responsible for 38.9% fatalities followed by cars and jeeps (30.4%) cases.
Counted together extremity injuries outnumbered others (78.5%). Next were
head and face 77.6%, chest 44%, abdomen 31.8% and neck 12.9% of all cases.
Chest injuries were present in 44% cases and included fracture of ribs 36.9%
cases, rupture of diaphragm 2% cases only and contusions and laceration of
lungs in 29.8% cases. Abdominal injuries were seen in 31.8% cases and
included laceration of liver (26.9%), spleen 12.7%, gut 4.7%, kidneys 3.8%, and
bladder 2.9%.Fractures, dislocation and lacerations were commonest seen in
89.1 % and 88.8% cases followed by abrasions (84.4%). In 450 subjects, 664
injuries or group of injuries were believed to be fatal or contributing to death.
Fatal injury per case being 1.4. Head injury was dominant in all road users
(50.4%) followed by multiple injuries (15.8%) and thoraco-abdominal injuries
(7.6%). 4.2% cases reached hospital within first 15 minutes, 15.4% died on the
28
spot and were not brought to hospital 24% reached within half an hour and 57%
reached in next one hour and remaining 19% were rushed to hospital in more
than one and half hours. Altogether, 39.5% victims had succumbed within 1 hour,
2/3rd (67.8%) by 12 hours, 3/4th (77.1%) by 48 hours and 90% by one week and
97.7% within two weeks. The longest survival period was 30 days and 15 hours.
Cooper et al (35) studied the incidence of abdominal injury in patients with
thoracic and/or pelvic trauma. The Scottish Trauma Audit Group (STAG)
collected the data on trauma patients reaching to the hospital in Scotland who
were hospitalised for at least three days or who die as a result of their injuries
and found that 507/3644(14%) patients with significant chest trauma but no
pelvic trauma had concomitant abdominal injuries, compared to 111/1397(8%)
patients with pelvic Trauma but no chest trauma. The likelihood of concomitant
abdominal injury increased significantly if both chest and pelvis injuries were
present (239/507, 47%; p< 0.001).Amongst patients with combined chest and
pelvic trauma, the incidence of abdominal injury increased with severity of pelvic
and chest injury (pelvis and chest both AIS=2:5/45,11%;either pelvis or chest
AIS=3+:81/198,41%;both pelvis and chest AIS=3+:153/264,58%;p< 0.001).
Murlidhar and Roy (36) studied trauma outcomes in India: an analysis
based on TRISS methodology in a Mumbai university hospital. They studied
1074 severely injured patients. Survival analysis was completed for 98.3% of the
patients. The majority of the patients were men (84%) and the average age was
29
31 years. 90.4% were blunt injuries, with road traffic crashes (39.2%) being the
most common cause. The predicted mortality was 10.89% and the observed
mortality was 21.26%. The mean Revised Trauma Score (RTS) was 6.61 +/- 1.65
and the mean Injury Severity Score (ISS) was 16.7 +/- 10.67. The average
probability of survival (Ps) was 89.14. The M and Z statistics were 0.84 and -
14.1593, respectively.
Meera and Nabachandra (37) studied pattern and ISS in blunt thoraco-
abdominal trauma cases in Manipal and found that males out numbered females
in the ratio of 3.8: 1. The commonest age group of the victims was 21-30 years
(20.80%). Vehicular accident was the leading cause of blunt thoraco abdominal
trauma (86.40%) followed by assault by blunt weapon (8%). 12.80% of the
victims had no associated external injuries to the thoraco abdominal region. 59
victims (47.2%) died at the spot. 15 cases (12.0%) died within1hour and 13
victims (10.04%) survived less than 2 hours. Only 2 victims (1.60%) survived up
to more than 1 week. The commonest cause of death was haemorrhagic shock
(as a result of intra thoracic and abdominal bleeding) combined with head injury
in 61(48.80%) cases followed by haemorrhagic shock alone in (44%) of the
cases. Peritonitis was the cause of death in 2 (1.60%) cases. It was found that in
victims with low ISS (21-30 and 31-40 ISS score ranges) survival was more as
compared to the victims with high ISS (51-60, 61-70 and 71-75 ISS score
ranges). The spot-death victims had a mean ISS of 61.73 and cases who died
30
within 1 hour showed 48.33 as the mean ISS. Mean ISS was low in those victims
who survived more than 1 week i.e. 27.50.
Chaudhary et al (38) studied profile of Road Traffic Accident cases in
Kasturba Hospital of M.G.I.M.S., Sevagram, Wardha, Maharashtra and found
that a total 125 road traffic accident cases were admitted from July 1999 to June
2000. Out of them 32 cases died and were autopsied, 15 patients were brought
dead from the spot and directly sent for autopsy examination. Maximum cases of
road traffic accident were among males (83.20%), male to female ratio was
4.9%. Maximum incidence of RTA was in the age group of 20 to 39 years
comprising 51.20%. Most common victim was pedestrian 44% followed by
drivers 32.87%, and occupant 23.20%.Incidence was more common among the
two wheeler vehicle driver. Head was the commonest site to be injured in road
traffic accident. Liver and lung involvement was highest among internal organ
injuries. Overall fatality was 27.11% and it was more in female cases. Head injury
was commonest cause of death in road traffic accident.
Flagel BT et al (39) studied rib fractures. The National Trauma Data Bank
(NTDB, v. 3.0 American College of Surgeons, Chicago, IL) was queried for
patients sustaining 1 or more rib fracturesThe NTDB included 731,823 patients.
Of these, 64,750 (9%) had a diagnosis of 1 or more fractured ribs. Thirteen
percent (n = 8,473) of those with rib fractures developed 13,086 complications, of
which 6,292 (48%) were related to a chest-wall injury. The overall mortality rate
31
for patients with rib fractures was 10%. The mortality rate increased (P < .02) for
each additional rib fracture. Increasing the number of rib fractures correlated
directly with increasing pulmonary morbidity and mortality. Patients sustaining
fractures of 6 or more ribs are at significant risk for death from causes unrelated
to the rib fractures.
Sharma et al (40) studied trauma score as a valuable tool for documentation
of autopsy reports of trauma victims and found that out of a total 14390 victims of
Road Traffic Accidents reporting to the Emergency Wing at Government Medical
College Hospital,Chandigarh, 552 (4%) had a fatal outcome; whereas 304 (2%)
sustained permanent disability of variable extent. Over all, 282 (51%) victims
died within 6 hours of the accident, of which 149 (27%) died either on the spot or
were declared brought dead to the hospital. Among the offending vehicles,
motorcycles outnumbered all other categories of vehicles claiming 25% victims of
fatal accidents whereas pedestrians (41%) constituted the majority among the
victims.
Rautji et al (41) studied the AIS and its correlation with traumatic accidental
deaths in South Delhi in 400 autopsies of road traffic accident victims. They
classified these cases into different injury groups according to the ISS. Fifty eight
cases (14.5%) were assigned an ISS value of <25; 244(61%) cases were valued
between 25-49, 38 cases(9.5%) were valued between 50-74 and 60 cases (15%)
had a value of 75.The age group between 21-30 years was most vulnerable,
32
comprising 38% of the cases. Males comprised 90% of the total cases.
Pedestrians were involved in 44% of cases. Buses/minibuses were the most
common offending vehicles. Head and neck were the most vulnerable body
regions being involved in 75% cases. Sixty six percent of the patients suffered
multiple traumas. In cases with ISS less than 50; about 96% of the victims did not
receive optimal care quickly enough with lack of prehospital resuscitation
measures and lengthy transportation time to Hospital being of major importance.
Pathak et al (42) studied fatality due to chest injury in road traffic accident
victims of Varanasi and adjoining districts, U.P. and found that chest injuries in
combination with other regional injuries (61.76%) were the second commonest
cause of fatal road traffic accident cases, commonest being head injuries . The
greater frequency of fatality in the regional injury, i.e. chest injuries was due to
involvement of two vital organs, viz. heart and lungs. In chest injury, the
majorities of cases had lung injuries (81.30%) and were followed by injuries to
the heart (43.08%). Major great vessels were injured in (21.95%) of deceased.
The abdominal injuries were mostly found associated with chest injuries. Liver
was injured in 12.19% victims. Syncopal death (haemorrhagic shock) along with
asphyxia was the commonest mode of death (30.08%) followed by asphyxia
(27.64%) alone. More than two third (69.91%) victims died at the place. of
incidence.
33
Nikolić et al (43) studied forensic expertise of the injury severity in fatally
injured car-occupants. A total of 500 cases were analyzed: 282 car-drivers and
218 front car-passengers, average age of 41.48 +/- 15.31 and 39.78 +/- 16.93.
There were 401 males and 99 females. The most injured body region was head
with neck: AIS = 3.50 +/- 2.48, for car-drivers, and AIS = 3.54 +/- 2.50, for front
car-passengers, as well as thorax: AIS = 3.63 +/- 2.16 car-drivers, and AIS =
3.37 +/- 2.14, for front car-passengers. More severe injuries of head (AIS > or =4)
suggested that deceased was a front car-passenger (Wald = 13.27; p = 0.04).
More severe injuries of thorax and abdomen (AIS > or =5) indicated that
deceased was a car-driver (Wald = 5.72; p = 0.02, and Wald = 8.23; p = 0.01,
respectively). The injury severity of the face and limbs were useless in such
expertise (Wald = 1.72; p = 0.19, and Wald =0.89; p = 0.34, respectively). An
average ISS was 57.31 +/- 20.16 for car-drivers, and 54.54 +/- 21.01 for front
car-passengers.
Giannoudis et al (44) studied prevalence of pelvic fractures, associated
injuries, and mortality in the United Kingdom. Prospective data from 106 trauma
receiving hospitals forming the Trauma Audit and Research Network were
studied. Between January 1989 and December 2001 data of 159,746 trauma
patients were collected in the Trauma Audit and Research Network database.
Because of incomplete data, 1,610 pelvic fracture patients and 13,499 patients
without pelvic fracture were excluded from detailed analysis. In total, 11,149
patients in the pelvic ring fractures (PG) and the remaining 133,486 patients in
34
the NPG (control) group were included in the final analysis.There were
statistically significantly more patients with an Injury Severity Score >15 in the PG
group (n = 3,576; 32.1%) than in NPG group (n = 19,238; 14.4%) (p < 0.001),
indicating that pelvic injuries were more often associated with other injuries. The
majority of patients sustained Abbreviated Injury Score (AIS) 2 pelvic injuries
(65.0%), whereas AIS 4 and 5 injuries were found in less than 10% of patients.
Pelvic ring injuries were most commonly associated with chest trauma with >AIS
2 severity in 21.2% of the patients, head injuries (>AIS 2) in 16.9%, liver or
spleen injuries in 8.0%, and two or more long bone fractures in 7.8%. The 3-
month cumulative mortality rate of the patients with pelvic injuries was 14.2%
(1,586 patients) versus 5.6% (7,465 patients) of the NPG group.Age, early
physiologic derangement, and presences of other injuries (head or trunk) were
associated with reduced survival rates.
Zargar et al (45) studied a total of 276 consecutive trauma patients in 6
general hospitals for thoracic injury at Sina trauma and surgery research center,
Sina general hospital, medical sciences, University of Tehran. There were 246
males (89.1%) and 30 females (10.9%) ranging from 3 to 80 years with a mean
age of (34+/-17) years. Road traffic accident was the main cause of injury,
especially for pedestrians, followed by stab wound (89 cases, 32.1%) and falling
injuries (32 cases, 11.6%), respectively. Haemothorax or pneumothorax (50.4%)
and rib fracture (38.6%) were the most common types of chest injury. Extremity
fracture was the most common associated injury with the rate of 37% ( 85/230),
35
followed by head injury (25.2%) and abdominal trauma (19.6%). The presence of
blunt trauma, head injury and abdominal injury independently adversely affect
mortality after chest trauma.
Michiue et al (46) evaluated 5 cases of clinically unexpected delayed
collapse followed by death using the abbreviated injury scale (AIS), injury
severity score (ISS), and a clinical trauma care method (trauma and injury
severity score, TRISS). In these cases, major injury (AIS = 3-5) was found in the
head, chest and/or abdomen at autopsy, and ISS was estimated to be 11-45
(serious to critical but not incompatible with life). By the TRISS method, the
probability of survival (P (s)) was estimated to be >0.5 for all cases (0.60-0.99),
suggesting that these were preventable deaths.
Ndiaye et al (47) studied the fatal injuries of car drivers in France. Mean
annual mortality at the wheel of a car was computed by dividing the total number
of drivers killed (n=383) by the population of the Rhône Department (1.6 million)
during the period 1996-2004 it was 5.41 males per 100,000 and 1.41 females per
100,000, with 78% of the casualties residing in the Department. Three-quarters
of the casualties died at the scene of the crash. The injuries were analyzed for
the 287 killed drivers whose deaths could be explained by the described injuries
(at least one AIS 4+ injury). Of these, 41% had an ISS of 75 (at least one AIS 6
injury), 21% had an ISS of between 40 and 74, 33% an ISS of between 25 and
40, and 6% an ISS of between 16 and 24. In the case of all the AIS 4+ injuries,
36
the three most frequent locations for injuries were the thorax only (30% of
casualties), the head only (23%) and a combination of the two (18%). Abdominal
injuries occurred in only 10% of casualties and spinal injuries in 9% of casualties.
In the thorax, the most common injury was flail chest with haemothorax or
pneumothorax. In the case of the head, the most frequent injuries were to the
brain (haemorrhage, haematoma and axonal injuries). In spite of the use of
restraint devices, the thorax and head are still the priority vital areas for
protection in the case of car drivers. For one in four of the fatalities, death cannot
be explained by any of the injuries we know about.
Koo et al (48) studied mortality in patients with multiple injuries in a referral
hospital. They studied the cases of 198 patients with a mean (SD) age of 43.9
(19) years. Ninety-three percent had suffered blunt trauma. The mean ISS, the
prehospital RTS, and the TRISS were 16.9 (11.2), 10.8 (2.5), and 0.95 (0.2),
respectively. Twenty-five patients died. Fifteen deaths were classified as
preventable or potentially preventable.
Palmer (49) studied AIS 2005 versus AIS 1998—A double-coding exercise
to identify issues for trauma data .602 injuries sustained by 109 patients were
compared Discrepancies in data consistency were more common in head and
chest injuries. Data mapped to a different codeset performed better in
comparisons than raw AIS98 and AIS05 code sets.
37
OBJECTIVES OF RESEARCH
Pages: 38-39
38
OBJECTIVES OF RESEARCH
1. To study the pattern of fatal blunt thoraco-abdominal trauma.
2. To correlate the relationship between survival time and injury severity score.
39
MATERIAL AND
METHODS Pages:
40-43
40
MATERIAL AND METHODS
1. Material for the present study was collected from the cases of blunt
thoracoabdominal trauma brought for medico legal autopsy to the
Mortuary of the Department of Forensic Medicine, University College of
Medical Sciences and Guru Teg Bahadur Hospital, Delhi.
2. Cases brought during the period November 2008 to February 2010 were
taken up for the study. A total of 95 cases were studied irrespective of age
and sex of victims.
3. a. All the cases showing fatal blunt thoracic and/ or abdominal injuries
with or without external injuries were included in the study.
b. Dead bodies showing severe degree of decomposition particularly
of the internal organs were excluded from this study to avoid
false interpretation of findings.
4. The severity of the injuries was established using the NISS. NISS of each
injured body region was calculated using the Association for Advancement
of Automotive Medicine, 1990(50) (Appendix 1) and Association for
Advancement of Automotive Medicine, 2005(51) (Appendix 2) protocol.
41
5. In cases of road traffic accidents detailed information regarding type of
vehicle involved and category of victims was obtained from inquest
papers, police and relatives of the deceased. The types of vehicles were
categorized into bus/minibus, truck, car, two wheelers, others (three
wheelers etc.) and unknown. Victims were categorized into pedestrians,
two wheelers occupants, cyclist, car occupants, bus/truck passenger and
others.
6. The following instruments and documents were used for the study :
a. Autopsy table and instruments.
b. Inquest papers and other related documents.
c. Measuring tape / Scale
d. Gloves
e. Standard Autopsy suit
f. Computer
7. Universal precautions were taken while performing autopsies. They were
a. Appropriate proper clothing i.e. gloves, masks, eyewear, headwear,
shoe covers, an impervious or full-covered gown were worn while
conducting postmortem examination.
b. Hand washing was done after contamination with blood or other
body fluids and immediately after the gloves were removed.
42
c. After using scalpels, disposable syringes, needles and other sharps
they were placed in puncture resistant containers for disposal.
These containers were placed as close as practical to the area
where sharps were being used.(52)
8. A predesigned Case Record Form (Appendix 3) was used to enter the
various data for:
a. Parameters being studied.
b. New Injury Severity Score(NISS)
9. Relationship between NISS and survival time was established using
regression analysis and obtaining coefficient of correlation.
43
OBSERVATIONS
AND RESULTS
Pages
: 44-59
44
OBSERVATIONS AND RESULTS
Detailed observations for 93 autopsies with evidence of fatal thoracoabdominal
trauma during the period 1st November 2008 to 30 th March, 2010 were carried
out and various statistical results were drawn from them. These are described as
follows:
AGE INCIDENCE
The most common age group involved was between 21-30 years of age
comprising 29% of total 93 cases followed by the age group of 11-20 years
comprising 20.4% of total cases. Children below 10 years constituted only 7.5%
of total cases. Persons above 60 years constituted only five cases, i.e., 5.4% of
total cases. (Table 1)
The most vulnerable age group involved among males was between 21-30
years of age comprising 30.4% of total 79 cases followed by the age group of 11-
20 years comprising 22.8% of total cases. The most vulnerable age group
involved among females between 21-30 and 31-40 years of age each comprised
of 21.4% of the 14 cases. (Table2).
SEX INCIDENCE
Among those 93 cases studied, males comprised 79 cases, i.e., 84.9% of cases,
while females were only 14 in number, i.e., 15.1% of cases.
45
Table 1: Age wise distribution of males and females.
AGE GROUP IN YEARS
MALES FEMALESTotal
Percentage
0-10 5 2 7 7.5
11-20 18 1 19 20.4
21-30 24 3 27 29
31-40 13 3 16 17.2
41-50 12 1 13 14
51-60 4 2 6 6.5
>60 3 2 5 5.4
Total 79 14 93 100
Table 2: Age and sex wise distribution of cases.
Age Group in Years
Males Percentage Females Percentage
0-10 5 6.3 2 14.3
11-20 18 22.8 1 7.1
21-30 24 30.4 3 21.4
31-40 13 16.5 3 21.4
41-50 12 15.2 1 7.1
51-60 4 5.1 2 14.3
>60 3 3.8 2 14.3
Total 79 100 14 100
46
CAUSE OF TRAUMA
The most common cause of blunt fatal thoracoabdominal trauma was vehicular
accident seen in 79.57% of cases. (Table 3)
Table 3: Distribution of cases according to cause of trauma
Number of cases Percentage
Vehicular accident 74 79.57
Train accident 14 15.05
Fall from height 3 3.23
Others 2 2.15
Total 93 100
REGIONS OF BODY INVOLVED IN VICTIMS HAVING FATAL
THORACOABDOMINAL INJURIES
Pelvic injuries alone constituted the maximum number of cases (22.58%).
Whereas chest and pelvis combined were injured only in a solitary case (1.08%).
Abdomen alone or in combination with other regions were involved in the
maximum number of cases (63.44%) (Table 4).
47
Table 4: Distribution of cases according to regions of the body involved
Region of the body
involvedNo. of cases Percentage
Chest alone 12 12.90
Abdomen alone 19 20.43
Pelvis alone 21 22.58
Chest and abdomen 15 16.13
Chest and Pelvis 1 1.08
Abdomen and Pelvis 7 7.53
Abdomen, Chest and Pelvis 18 19.35
Total 93 100
PERIOD OF SURVIVAL
In 93 cases, it was found that 60cases (64.5%) (Were dead on arrival i.e., died at
the scene/spot or were brought dead to the casualty (Table 5).Those surviving
for more than a day constituted only 8.6% of the cases.
48
Table 5: Distribution of cases in relation to period of survival.
Period of survival Number of cases Percentage of cases
Dead on arrival 60 64.5
<2 HRS. 9 9.7
2-6 HRS 7 7.5
6-12 HRS 5 5.4
12-24 HRS 4 4.3
1-7 DAYS 7 7.5
1-4 Weeks 1 1.1
Total 93 100
VICTIMS
A total of 37 pedestrians (39.78%) were killed in 93 fatal blunt thoracoabdominal
trauma cases. The next common category was two wheeler occupants which
accounted for 24 cases (25.81%). Car occupants were not involved in any case.
(Table 6).
49
Table 6: Thoracoabdominal trauma victims
Type of Victim Number of victims Percentage
Pedestrian 37 39.78
Two wheelers occupants 24 25.81
Cyclist 7 7.53
Car occupants 0 0
Bus/Truck passenger 2 2.15
Fall from height 3 3.23
Train accidents 14 15.05
Others 6 6.45
Total 93 100
OFFENDING VEHICLES
In the pesent study Bus/Minibus and Unknown caused maximum, blunt fatal
thoracoabdominal trauma i.e., 15 cases which amount to 16.13% of the total
cases. (Table 7).Two wheelers like motorcycle/scooter caused the least number
of fatalities (5.38%).
50
Table 7: Victims in relation to offending vehicles
Offending vehicle Number of victims Percentage
Bus/Minibus 15 16.13
Truck 11 11.83
Car 13 13.98
Two wheelers (Motorcycle, scooter ) 5 5.38
Train 14 15.05
Three wheelers (Auto, rickshaw etc) 10 10.75
Others* 10 10.75
Unknown 15 16.13
Total 93 100
*Wall collapse, fall of copper bundle on body, fall from bullock cart etc.
ASSOCIATED EXTERNAL INJURIES
In the present study, 88.20% of the cases showed associated external injuries on
the thoracoabdominal region while the remaining 11.80% did not show any
external injuries.
ORGANS INJURED
Rib fracture is seen in majority of cases (55). Liver and lungs were the
commonest injured visceral organs. (Table 8).Pancreas was the least injured
organ. In the 0-20 years age group Liver was most commonly injured whereas
after 20 years of age the Lungs were the most commonly injured organ.
51
Table 8: Number of victims in relation to different organs injured
Agegroup
Liver Spleen Bowel Pancreas KidneyUrete
rBladd
er Rib #
Lung Heart Pelvis
0-10 5 2 2 0 2 0 1 0 2 0 3
11-20 10 5 7 1 7 0 4 6 9 3 9
21-30 14 11 3 1 9 0 2 19 16 5 14
31-40 7 4 2 1 5 1 3 11 9 4 6
41-50 8 6 2 1 2 0 2 9 6 3 7
51-60 3 0 0 0 1 0 1 5 5 0 3
>60 3 2 0 0 2 0 0 5 3 0 1
total 50 28 16 4 28 1 13 55 50 15 43
INJURY SEVERITY SCORE
NEW INJURY SEVERITY SCORE (1990)
Mean NISS was 42.89. Maximum cases belong to high (50-75) NISS group i.e.
43%. (Table 9)
52
Table 9: Distribution of cases according to new injury severity score (1990)
NISS Score (1990) Number of cases Percentage
0-25 21 22.6
25-50 32 34.4
50-75 40 43.0
Total 93 100
NEW INJURY SEVERITY SCORE (2005)
Mean ISS was 46.59.Maximum cases belong to high (50-75) ISS group i.e.
51.6% (Table 10)
Table 10: Distribution of cases according to new injury severity score
(2005)
NISS Score (2005) Number of cases Percentage
0-25 21 22.6
25-50 24 25.8
50-75 48 51.6
Total 93 100
53
AGE GROUPS IN RELATION TO NEW INJURY SEVERITY SCORE
(2005)
The maximum numbers of victims (48) were having NISS of 50-75 (Table 11).
Amongst these the largest number (16) belonged to the 21-30 year age group.
Table 11: Age groups in relation to new injury severity score (2005)
Age group NISS 0-25 NISS 25-50 NISS 50-75 Total
0-10 3 2 2 7
11-20 5 5 9 19
21-30 7 4 16 27
31-40 2 5 9 16
41-50 3 3 7 13
51-60 1 4 1 6
>60 0 1 4 5
TOTAL 21 24 48 93
Survival period in relation to new injury severity score
In the present study maximum, blunt fatal thoracoabdominal trauma i.e., 35
cases belong to NISS 50-75 among dead on arrival group, and as survival period
increases, NISS 0-25 and NISS 25-50 contain more number of cases (Table 12
and Table13).
54
Table 12: Survival period in relation to new injury severity score (1990)
NISS Score
(1990)
Dead on arrival
<2 HRS2-6 HRS
6-12 HRS
12-24 HRS
1-7
DAYS
1-4
Weeks
0-25 7 4 2 2 3 3 0
25-50 18 3 5 2 1 3 0
50-75 35 2 0 1 0 1 1
Total 60 9 7 5 4 7 1
Table 13: Survival period in relation to new injury severity score (2005)
NISS
Score
(2005)
Dead on
arrival
< 2
HRS
2-6
HRS
6-12
HRS
12-24
HRS
1-7
DAYS
1-4
Weeks
0-25 6 4 3 2 3 3 0
25-50 15 1 2 2 1 3 0
50-75 39 4 2 1 0 1 1
Total 60 9 7 5 4 7 1
55
MANNER OF DEATH
In all the cases studied manner of death was accidental.
CAUSE OF DEATH
Haemorrhagic shock accounted for the largest number of cases (70.97%).
followed by Asphyxia (20.43%) (Table 14).Asphyxia was as a result of bilateral
rib fractures (flail chest).
Table 14: Showing cause of death in relation to sex
Cause of death Number of cases Percentage
Asphyxia 19 20.43
Neurogenic shock 4 4.30
Haemorrhagic shock 66 70.97
Septicaemic shock 4 4.30
Total 93 100
CORRELATIONS
Correlation between NISS 1990 /NISS 2005 and period of survival (Ps)
Correlation or co-relation can refer to any departure of two or more random
variables from independence, but most commonly refers to a more specialized
56
type of relationship between mean values. There are several correlation
coefficients, often denoted ρ or r, measuring the degree of correlation. The most
common of these is the Pearson correlation coefficient, which is mainly sensitive
to a linear relationship between two variables.
The most familiar measure of dependence between two quantities is the Pearson
product-moment correlation coefficient, or "Pearson's correlation." It is obtained
by dividing the covariance of the two variables by the product of their standard
deviations. Karl Pearson developed the coefficient from a similar but slightly
different idea by Francis Galton.
The population correlation coefficient ρX, Y between two random variables X and Y
with expected values μX and μY and standard deviations σX and σY is defined as:
where E is the expected value operator, cov means covariance, and, corr a
widely used alternative notation for Pearson's correlation.
The Pearson correlation is defined only if both of the standard deviations are
finite and both of them are nonzero. It is a corollary of the Cauchy–Schwarz
inequality that the correlation cannot exceed 1 in absolute value. The correlation
coefficient is symmetric: corr(X,Y) = corr(Y,X).
57
The Pearson correlation is +1 in the case of a perfect positive (increasing) linear
relationship, −1 in the case of a perfect decreasing (negative) linear relationship
[5], and some value between −1 and 1 in all other cases, indicating the degree of
linear dependence between the variables. As it approaches zero there is less of
a relationship. The closer the coefficient is to either −1 or 1, the stronger the
correlation between the variables.
If the variables are independent, Pearson's correlation coefficient is 0, but the
converse is not true because the correlation coefficient detects only linear
dependencies between two variables. For example, suppose the random variable
X is symmetrically distributed about zero, and Y = X2. Then Y is completely
determined by X, so that X and Y are perfectly dependent, but their correlation is
zero; they are uncorrelated. However, in the special case when X and Y are
jointly normal, uncorrelatedness is equivalent to independence (55).
The results showed a negative correlation between NISS 1990 and Ps (period of
survival) with an r-value of −0.438 (p < 0.005). (Table15) and Coefficient of a
determination r2 = 0.19. The results also showed a negative correlation between
NISS 2005 and Ps (period of survival) with an r-value of −0.472 (p < 0.005)(Table
16) and Coefficient of a determination r2 = 0.19. This means that as NISS
increases period of survival decreases.NISS 1990 had a mean of 42.89 and the
NISS 2005 had a mean of 46.59 in our trauma patient population The strength of
58
the relationship between NISS 2005 and Ps was greater than that between NISS
1990 and Ps.
Table 15: Correlation between NISS 1990 and Period of survival.
Period of survival(Ps)
NISS 90
Ps
Pearson CorrelationSignificance (2-tailed)
N1.000
-0.4380.000
93
NISS 90Pearson Correlation
Significance (2-tailed)N
-0.4380.000
931.000
Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
Table 16: Correlation between NISS 2005 and period of survival
Period of survival(Ps)
NISS 90
Ps
Pearson CorrelationSignificance (2-tailed)
N1.000
-0.4720.000
93
NISS 90Pearson Correlation
Significance (2-tailed)N
-0.4720.000
931.000
Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).
59
DISCUSSION Pages: 60-75
60
DISCUSSION
Age and sex distribution of victims
In the present study it was observed that majority of cases were males in the age
group of 21-30 years. The large number of cases in this age group can be
attributed to the fact that this period of life is the most vulnerable to trauma
because of a very high level of outdoor activities. Male dominance in this type of
injury could likely be due to the fact the males are more exposed to trauma as
they constitute working and earning member in majority of families and so move
out of the house more often than females, Similar findings were also observed by
Jha et al (32), Meera and Nabachandra (37), Rautji et al (41), Sharma et al (40), and
Mansar et al (53)
Associated External injuries
In this study, 88.20% of the cases showed associated external injuries on the
thoracoabdominal region while the remaining 11.80% did not show any external
injuries. Similar findings were also observed by Meera and Nabachandra(37). In
their study, 87.20% of the cases showed associated external injuries on the
thoracoabdominal region while the remaining 12.80% did not show any external
Injuries.
The reason for absence of associated external injuries in 12.80% of cases may
be that most part of the thoracoabdominal region is covered with clothes and so
abrasions and bruises are less likely.
61
Cause of blunt thoracoabdominal trauma
In the present study, majority of blunt thoracoabdominal injuries were due to
vehicular accidents (79.57%), followed by train accident, fall from height, hit by
fall of heavy objects etc. There was no case of assault by blunt weapon. This
finding is also in agreement with the work of Meera and Nabachandra (37) who
also observed that the commonest cause of blunt thoracoabdominal trauma was
vehicular accidents (86.40%).(Table 17)
Table 17 comparison of causes of fatal blunt thoracoabdominal trauma with
the study done at Imphal.
Present study
(North east
Delhi)
Meera and Nabachandra (37)
(Imphal)
Vehicular Accident 79.57% 86.40%
Assault by blunt weapon 0% 8.00%
Hit by fall of heavy
objects 1.08% 2.40%
Fall from height 3.23% 2.40%
Kick by horse 0% 0.80%
Train accidents 15.05% 0%
Others 1.07% 0%
62
Regions of body involved in victims having fatal Thoracoabdominal injuries
Pelvis was injured in maximum number of cases. (22.58%).This may be due to
the fact that in maximum cases offending vehicle were bus/minibus and trucks
(heavy vehicles) and accident with these vehicles causes primary impact injuries
over the pelvic region. Another reason for the greater involvement of the pelvis
could be due to fall on the ground after impact with offending vehicle leading to
pelvic trauma. Abdomen alone was involved in 20.43% of cases.Abdomen alone
or in combination with other regions was involved in the maximum number of
cases (63.44%). This is because cases of fatal blunt thoracoabdominal trauma
were taken and so due to lack of any protective bony cage unlike the chest there
was a far greater fatality when the abdomen was involved in comparison to the
chest.
These findings are also in agreement with the findings of Bergqvist et al (7) who
studied patients with abdominal trauma and fatal outcome in an analysis of a 30-
year series in a rural Swedish area. They found that Patients with blunt
abdominal trauma with fatal outcome comprised of 127 patients and found that
one fourth of these patients died from an abdominal inury alone.
In the present study chest and abdomen involvement without pelvic trauma
comprised 16.13% of cases, abdomen and pelvis involvement without chest
63
trauma in 7.53% of cases. These findings are also in agreement with the findings
of Cooper et al (35). who studied the incidence of abdominal injury in patients with
thoracic and/or pelvic trauma. The Scottish Trauma Audit Group (STAG)
collected the data on trauma patients reaching to the hospital in Scotland who
were hospitalised for at least three days or who die as a result of their injuries
and found that 507/3644(14%) patients with significant chest trauma but no
pelvic trauma had concomitant abdominal injuries, compared to 111/1397(8%)
patients with pelvic Trauma but no chest trauma. The likelihood of concomitant
abdominal injury increased significantly if both chest and pelvis injuries were
present (239/507, 47%; p< 0.001).Amongst patients with combined chest and
pelvic trauma, the incidence of abdominal injury increased with severity of pelvic
and chest injury (pelvis and chest both AIS=2:5/45,11%;either pelvis or chest
AIS=3+:81/198,41%;both pelvis and chest AIS=3+:153/264,58%;p< 0.001).
Accident victims
A total of 37 (39.78%) pedestrians were killed in 93 fatal blunt thoracoabdominal
trauma cases. Similar increased numbers of thoracoabdominal trauma among
pedestrians have also been reported by Jha et al (32), Meera and Nabachandra
(37), and Sharma et al (40) (Table 18).The next common category was two wheeler
occupants which accounted for 24 (25.81%) cases. Two victims were Bus/Truck
passengers. Cyclists were killed in 7(7.5%) cases. Others (occupants of TSR,
tractors etc.) accounted for 6 (6.45%) cases. Car occupants were not involved in
any case. This may be because cars plying with high speed on the roads in this
64
region are less as compared with other parts of Delhi due to heavy traffic
congestion in this area of Delhi making speeding difficult. The pedestrians in
most of the instances were knocked down by heavy vehicles leading to fatal
thoracoabdominal injuries. Encroachment of pavements making people walk on
roads, little segregation between vehicular and pedestrian traffic, lack of
awareness among pedestrian of road rules and lack of pedestrian crossings are
some of the reasons for increased involvement of pedestrians. Poor maintenance
of roads and lack of observance of traffic rules by vehicular traffic are some other
reasons.
Table 18: Comparison of victims of blunt fatal thoracoabdominal trauma
with those at Jammu, Delhi and Chandigarh
Victim Present study Sharma et al (40)
North east Delhi Jammu DelhiChandigar
h
Pedestrian 39.78% 46.17% 47.03% 42.07%
Two wheelers
occupants25.81% 30.38% 22.17% 24.97%
Cyclist 7.53% 1.92% 10.85% 13.24%
Bus/Truck passenger 2.15% 12.6% 8.11% 8.28%
Car 0% 0% 0% 0%
Fall from height 3.23% N.I* N.I N.I
65
Train accident 15.05% N.I N.I N.I
Others 6.45% 8.94% 12.98% 11.45%
*N.I = Not included in the study
OFFENDING VEHICLE
Amongst the offending vehicles Bus/Minibus were responsible for blunt fatal
thoracoabdominal deaths in 15 cases which amount to 16.13% of the total cases.
The trucks and cars were also responsible for large number of deaths (11.83%
and 13.98% respectively). A large number of buses are plying on the roads in
this region as people of low socioeconomic group live here and so it is a common
mode of transport. Hence a large number of fatalities are caused by these
vehicles. Three wheelers (auto rickshaws) were responsible for 10.75% of fatal
blunt thoracoabdominal trauma cases. Low income/middle income group people
use more auto rickshaws and so there is increased use of auto rickshaws in this
part of Delhi leading to an increased percentage of auto rickshaws as offending
vehicle in our study. Another major killer was Trains which caused fatal
thoracoabdominal trauma in 15.05% of cases. These findings are also in
agreement with the findings of Sharma et al (40) who however had a large number
of Bus/Minibus being the offending vehicles as compared to the present study.
(Table19) Two wheelers caused only 5.38% of deaths whereas in study of
Sharma et al (40) it was the offending vehicle in 12.59% cases in Jammu, 10.53%
cases in Delhi and 12.41% cases in Chandigarh respectively. The reason for this
could be that two wheelers move with slow speed on the roads because of heavy
66
traffic congestion in this part of Delhi as compared to other parts of Delhi and
other cities like Jammu and Chandigarh.
Table 19: Comparison of Offending vehicle in blunt fatal thoracoabdominal
trauma with those at Jammu, Delhi and Chandigarh
Offending vehicle Present study Sharma et al (40)
North east Delhi Jammu DelhiChandigar
h
Bus/Minibus 16.13% 26.09% 29.68% 26.21%
Truck 11.83% 17.79% 14.5% 13.52%
Car 13.98% 15.32% 10.41% 18.06%
Two wheelers 5.38% 12.59% 10.53% 12.41%
Train 15.05% N.I* N.I N.I
Three wheelers 10.75% 0% 0% 0%
Unknown 16.13% 16.88% 18.92% 14.48%
Others 10.75% 10.49% 16.02% 15.31%
*N.I = Not included in the study
PERIOD OF SURVIVAL
In the present study majority of cases were dead on arrival. Similar findings have
also been reported by Meera and Nabachandra (37) and Sharma et al (40). This
67
emphasizes the fact that most of our vital organs are present in the chest and
abdominal cavity and further the abdominal cavity lacks any protective bony
cover. So trauma quickly leads to injuries to the vital organs and major blood
vessels present in the thoracic and abdominal cavities. Inadequate infrastructure
for early transport of victims and lack of proper management of trauma patients
on the way to hospital because of traffic congestion on the highway leads to early
deaths. These victims need on–spot emergency, medical care and rapid
transportation from the incident site to the hospital which is lacking in this part of
Delhi. Further there is involvement of heavy vehicles in 27.96% of cases and
trains in 15.05% of cases which leads to severe trauma to vital organs leading to
early deaths
INJURY SEVERITY SCORE
The strength of the relationship between NISS 2005 and Ps was greater than
that between NISS 1990 and Ps in the present study as the results showed a
negative correlation between NISS 1990 and Ps (period of survival) with an r-
value of −0.438 (p < 0.005) and Coefficient of a determination r2 = 0.19. The
results also showed a negative correlation between NISS 2005 and Ps (period of
survival) with an r-value of −0.472 (p < 0.005) and Coefficient of a determination
r2 = 0.19.
The reason could be that in AIS 2005 the pelvis is divided into the pelvic ring and
the acetabulum.The pelvic ring is a single anatomical structure for AIS coding no
68
matter the number of fractures to specific aspects. In AIS 2005 displaced as a
fracture descriptor has been deleted. In AIS 2005 coding for rib fractures has
been simplified with the most significant discrimination being between flail and no
flail. In AIS 2005 code is one level higher for the bilateral situation (56).
In the present study maximum cases belong to high (50-75) NISS group.
(Table 20)
Table 20: Comparison of NISS 1990 and NISS 2005
NISS 1990 NISS 2005
NISS 0-25 22.6% 22.6%
NISS 25-50 34.4% 25.8%
NISS 50-75 43.0% 51.6%
NISS of trauma victims had a mean of 42.89. The results showed a negative
correlation between NISS 90 and Ps (period of survival) with an r-value of −0.438
(p < 0.005). The results also showed a negative correlation between NISS 05
and Ps (period of survival) with an r-value of −0.472 p < 0.005). NISS 90 had a
mean of 42.89 and the NISS 05 had a mean of 46.59 in our trauma patient
population. This means that as NISS increases period of survival decreases.
69
A weak negative correlation between period of survival and NISS values
[coefficient of linear correlation r = -0.438 (1990) and -0.472 (2005) respectively]
and Coefficient of a determination [r2 = 0.19 (1990) and 0.22 (2005)
respectively], pointed to the fact that direct correlation between period of survival
and NISS was only about 19% and 22% respectively and the rest of correlation
i.e. 81% and 78% depended on other factors (e.g. effective emergency medical
system and triage, prompt and correct diagnosis, adequate medical treatment
and care, etc.).
The present study is in agreement with the study of Kumar et al (10) who studied
51 cases of vehicular accident showing abdominopelvic trauma, along with
associated injuries. A detailed ISS score was done in all the cases and it was
seen that victims in their 30s and 40s died only if their severity score was above
50.It was also observed that when the score was less than 20, the mortality level
was minimal, while above 20 there was linear increase. In two of the cases
studied, the score was 75.
The present study is also in agreement with the study of Nikolić et al (29) who
studied correlation between survival time and severity of injuries in fatal traffic
accidents in the Institute of Forensic Medicine, University school of medicine,
Belgrade. The sample included 272 persons: 193 males and 79 females. They
also found a weak negative correlation between outliving period and ISS values
70
in his sample (coefficient of linear correlation r = -0.452) and Coefficient of a
determination (r2 = 0.20).
The present study is also in agreement with the study of N. Yousaf et al (54) who
correlated different parameters and scoring systems with the probability of
survival in trauma patients in Pilgrim Hospital, UK and found that ISS of trauma
victims had a mean of 10.22. The results showed a strong negative correlation
between ISS and Ps with an r-value of −0.633 (p < 0.005). GCS correlated
strongly with Ps, with an r-value of 0.733 (p < 0.005). In the regression analysis;
ISS showed a strong correlation with Ps.
The present study is also in agreement with the study of Verma and Biswas (57)
who studied all cases of accidental deaths at Department of Forensic Medicine,
University College of Medical Sciences & GTB Hospital Delhi. One hundred and
ten victims of road traffic accidents were studied consecutively whose detailed
history and case records were available. The multiple regressions establish that
NISS correlate significantly with survival period (Sing F=0.0486) in their study.
The present study differs from the study done by Rautji et al (41) (Table 21).This is
because their study was on traumatic deaths involving any region of the body
where as the present study was confined to fatal thoracoabdominal injuries.
Head injury contributed to a large number of deaths in their study. Most of the
71
victims of head injury had only minor injuries present over other parts of the body
leading to a lower injury severity score. In the present study 2-3 major organs
had significant trauma leading to higher injury severity score.
Table 21: Comparison of NISS in blunt fatal thoracoabdominal trauma in
our study with those at south Delhi.
Present study (North East Delhi) Rautji et al (41)
NISS 1990 NISS2005 (South Delhi)
NISS 0-25 22.6% 22.6% 14.5%
NISS 25-50 34.4% 25.8% 61%
NISS 50-75 43.0% 51.6% 24.5%
The present study is also in agreement with the study of Friedman et al (20) who
studied all trauma autopsies performed between January 1 and June 30, 1993,
were coded according to the AIS and ISS method in Sheba Medical Center,
Jerusalem, Israel.. All cases were reviewed by a consultant in forensic medicine
and a traumatologist. Cases were grouped in three categories according to ISS
values: 0-14, 16-66, and 75. These categories represent minor, major, and
incompatible-with-life injuries, respectively. All autopsy findings in which ISS was
< or = 14 were peer-reviewed to establish mechanism and cause of death. In the
72
6-month period, 279 trauma-related autopsies were studied. Age at death
averaged 37.1 +/- 18.7 (mean +/- SD). Eighty-six percent of the victims were
male. ISS was 0-14 in 19 cases, 16-66 in 150 cases, and 75 in 110 cases. This
meant that ISS 0-14 comprised of 6.81% of cases and ISS 16-66 comprised of
53.76% of cases. As their ISS range is different from the present study an exact
comparison cannot be made. However their findings in general are in agreement
with the present study.
The present study also differ from the study done by Milić J et al (30) who studied
causes of death in long-term survivors of injuries sustained in traffic accidents at
the Institute of Forensic Medicine, University school of medicine, Belgrade. The
sample included 31 persons injured in traffic accidents with outliving period
longer than 15 days: 21 males and 10 females (chi 2 = 0.047; p > 0.1). There
was a weak positive correlation between outliving period and age in their sample
(coefficient of linear correlation r = 0.35). The authors combined the autopsy and
available clinical data in order to get the ISS value for each case. The mean ISS
value was 36.18 (SD = 8.70). There was no correlation between outliving period
and severity of trauma (coefficient of linear correlation r < 0.14).
It was observed that in our study victims with low NISS (0-25 and 25-50 NISS
score ranges) survival was more as compared to the victims with high NISS (50-
75 NISS score ranges). These findings are in agreement with the findings of
Meera and Nabachandra (37), who studied 125 cases of blunt thoracoabdominal
73
trauma which were brought for medicolegal autopsy at the mortuary of Forensic
Medicine Department of Regional Institute of Medical Sciences, Imphal during
the period from October 2001 to July 2003 and it was found that in victims with
low ISS (21-30 and 31- 40 ISS score ranges) survival was more as compared to
the victims with high ISS (51-60, 61-70 and 71-75 ISS score ranges). The spot-
death victims had a mean ISS score of 61.73 and cases who died within 1 hour
showed 48.33 as the mean ISS. Mean ISS was low in those victims who survived
more than 1 week i.e.27.50.
The present study findings are also in agreement with the findings of Sharma et
al (40) who found that out of a total 14390 victims of Road Traffic Accidents
reporting to the Emergency Wing at Government Medical College Hospital,
Chandigarh, 552 (4%) had a fatal outcome. Out of these 124 cases had an ISS
36-75 and they survived for 1-6 hours. Twenty eight cases had an ISS 16-65 with
the survival of 6-12 hours. Thirty nine cases had an ISS <16 with the survival of
12-24 hours and Fortythree cases an ISS <16 with the survival of 1-3 days.
The present study findings are also in agreement with the findings of Bergqvist et
al (7) who studied patients with abdominal trauma and fatal outcome in an analysis
of a 30-year series in rural Swedish area. They found that Patients with blunt
abdominal trauma with fatal outcome comprised of 127 patients and when ISS is
below 25 the mortality risk is minimal and above 25 it is an almost linear
74
increase. When ISS is 50 the mortality is 50% and when above 70 it is close to
100%.
These findings are also in agreement with the findings of Ndiaye et al (47) studied
the fatal injuries of car drivers in France. Three-quarters of the casualties died at
the scene of the crash. The injuries were analyzed for the 287 killed drivers
whose deaths could be explained by the described injuries (at least one AIS 4+
injury). Of these, 41% had an ISS of 75 (at least one AIS 6 injury), 21% had an
ISS of between 40 and 74, 33% an ISS of between 25 and 40, and 6% an ISS of
between 16 and 24.
75
CONCLUSION
AND
RECOMMENDATIONS
Pages
: 76-79
76
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
In the present study majority of the victims were male (84.9%).Youngsters in the
age group of 21-30 years (29%) were most commonly involved in trauma cases.
64.5% of cases of fatal thoracoabdominal trauma were dead on arrival.
Vehicular accident was the most common cause of fatal thoracoabdominal
trauma (79.57%). Buses were found to be the main offending vehicles.(16.13%
of the cases). Most common category of victims involved in vehicular accidents
was pedestrians (39.78%).
Among 0-10 and 11-20 years age groups most frequently injured organ was
Liver. Rib fracture is seen in majority of cases (55). Liver and lungs were the
commonest injured visceral organs. Maximum number of victims had pelvic
injuries alone. (22.58%) Maximum cases died of haemorrhagic shock. (70.97%).
Maximum cases are in NISS (50-75) group.i.e. in 43% of cases.NISS 1990 had a
mean of 42.89 and the NISS 2005 had a mean of 46.59.There is a negative
correlation between NISS 1990 and Ps with an r-value of −0.438 (p < 0.005) and
between NISS 2005 and Ps with an r-value of −0.472 (p < 0.005).NISS 2005 is
better than NISS 1990. There is a weak negative correlation between ISS and
period of survival.
Further studies are needed on this topic where physiological parameters should
also be included along with anatomical parameters for trauma scoring.
77
The following preventive measures are suggested
1. Encroachments on roads should be dealt with strictly.
2. There should not be any stray animals walking on the roads.
3. Trauma centers should be established in this part of Delhi.
4. Separate tracks should be made alongside the main roads for cyclists and
pedestrians.
5. Strategies that increase the use of seat belts or child restraints will result
in fewer injuries.
6. Stricter enforcement of speed limits will result in fewer injuries. The overall
contribution of speed to accidents is not known but is widely quoted to be
one third of all fatalities.
7. Safer design of roads and roadside environments will result in fewer
injuries as a result of trauma.
8. Roadside guardrails (crash barriers) and crash cushions will reduce injury
severity.
9. Area wise traffic management schemes should be targeted at areas with
high injury rates which will reduce pedestrian injury rates. The provision of
crossing patrollers, measures to redistribute traffic, and the design of
roads to reduce speeds are effective in reducing pedestrian injuries.
10. Permanently switched on lights on cars can reduce daytime road traffic
accidents.
11. Road safety education for children will reduce road traffic accidents .
78
12. People should be encouraged to use railway over bridge rather than
directly crossing the railway tracks.
The police, the fire brigade, individual initiatives, private ambulances and
non government organizations provide some prehospital care to the
injured in this part of Delhi and there is no central coordination for trauma
patients. Most of the ambulances operating in this part of Delhi are just
transport vehicles that only have an oxygen cylinder and the ambulance
staff is generally not trained in prehospital care. Patients are transported
to the hospital by personal or commercial vehicle in most of the cases.
These are some of the factors apart from injury severity scoring which
affect the period of survival.NISS will give knowledge about the prognosis
of trauma victim. It will guide on the urgency of treatment i.e. people with
greater injury severity score have to be given priority or energetic
treatment.
So therefore it is recommended that injury severity scoring be done
immediately as soon as the patient arrives to the casualty so that some of
the deaths can be prevented.
79
SUMMARY
Pages: 80-81
80
SUMMARY
The present study was undertaken to focus light upon the pattern and injury
severity score of fatal thoracoabdominal injuries in relation to various factors in
the Northeast Delhi. A total number of 93 cases were studied from 1st November
2008 to 30th March, 2010. The results of the present study are summarized as
follows:
1. 84.9% of the victims were male and 64.5% of cases of fatal
thoracoabdominal trauma were dead on arrival.
2. Vehicular accident was the most common cause of fatal thoracoabdominal
trauma (79.57%).
3. Buses were found to be the main offending vehicles and pedestrians were
the most common category of victims.
4. Ribs, lungs and Liver were the organs most commonly affected.
5. Maximum number of victims had pelvic injuries alone. (22.58%)
6. Maximum cases died of haemorrhagic shock. (70.97%)
7. Maximum cases are in ISS (50-75) group.i.e. in 43% of cases.
8. NISS 90 had a mean of 42.89 and the NISS 05 had a mean of 46.59.
9. There is a negative correlation between NISS 90 and Ps with an r-value of
−0.438 (p < 0.005) and between NISS 05 and Ps with an r-value of −0.472
(p < 0.005).
81
REFERENCES Pages: 82-90
82
REFERENCES
1. Burke MP. Forensic medical investigation of motor vehicle incidents. 1st
ed. New York: Taylor and Francis;2007:p 2.
2. Criminal Records Bureau [homepage on the internet]. Accidental Deaths
in India [cited 2010 April 2]. Available from:
http://ncrb.nic.in/ADSI2008
3. Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi [homepage on the
Internet]. Statistical Hand Book 2007 [cited 2008 Sept 15]. Available from:
http://www.des.delhigovt.nic.in
4. Trauma Scoring Systems [homepage on the internet]. Trauma articles
[cited 2010 April 2]. Available from:
http://emedicine.medscape.com/article/433404-overview
5. Stevenson M, Segui-Gomez M, Lescohier I, Di Scala C, McDonald-Smith
G. An overview of the injury severity score and the new injury severity
score. Injury Prevention. 2001;7:10–13.
6. Cox EF. Blunt abdominal trauma. A 5-year analysis of 870 patients
requiring celiotomy. Ann Surg.1984 ;199: 467–474.
7. Bergqvist D, Hedelin H, Karlsson G, Lindblad B, Matzsch T. Patients with
abdominal trauma and fatal outcome: analysis of a 30-year series. J
Trauma.1983 ;23:499-502.
83
8. Brainard BJ, Slauterbeck J, Benjamin JB, Hagaman RM, Higie S. Injury
profiles in pedestrian motor vehicle trauma. Ann Emerg
Med.1989 ;18 :881-883.
9. Arajärvi E, Santavirta S.Chest.injuries sustained in severe traffic accidents
by seatbelt wearers. J Trauma.1989 ;29:37-41.
10. Kumar B, Paul G, Sharma AK. Injury severity score as a yardstick in
assessing the severity and mortality of various abdomino-pelvic trauma
hospitalized victims – a clinical vis a vis autopsy study. Med Sci Law. 1989
;29:333-6.
11. Guirguis EM, Hong C, Liu D, Watters JM, Baillie F, McIntyre RW.Trauma
outcome analysis of two Canadian centres using the TRISS method. J
Trauma. 1990 ;30:426-9.
12. Poole GV, Ward EF, Muakkassa FF, Hsu HS, Griswold JA, Rhodes R
S.Pelvic fracture from major blunt trauma. Outcome is determined by
associated injuries. Ann Surg.1991;213: 532–539
13. Bishop M et al.Evaluation of a comprehensive algorithm for blunt and
penetrating thoracic and abdominal trauma.AmSurg.1991;57:737-46.
14. Roux P, Fisher RM.Chest injuries in children: an analysis of 100 cases of
blunt chest trauma from motor vehicle accidents. J Pediatr
Surg.1992 ;27 :551-5.
15. Daly KE, Thomas PRS.Trauma deaths in the South West Thames
Region.Injury.1992 ;23:393-396.
84
16 King PM, Tucker WS, Waddell JP, Brown T.Correlation of trauma scoring
and outcome in a Canadian trauma centre. Can J Surg.1994 ;37:185-8.
17 Poole GV, Ward EF.Causes of mortality in patients with pelvic fractures.
Poole GV, Ward EF. Orthopedics.1994 ;17:691-6.
18 Craig MH, Talton DS, Hauser CJ, Poole GV. A Pancreatic injury from blunt
trauma. Am Surg. 1995 ;61:125-8.
19 Hill DA, Delaney LM, Duflou J. Population-based study of outcome after
injury to car occupants and to pedestrians. J Trauma. 1996 ;40:351-5.
20 Friedman Z, Kugel C, Hiss J, Marganit B, Stein M, Shapira SC. The
Abbreviated Injury Scale-a valuable tool for forensic documentation of
trauma. Am J Forensic Med Pathol.1996 ;17:233-8.
21 Chong KH, DeCoster T, Osler T, Robinson B.Pelvic fractures and mortality.
Iowa Orthop J. 1997 ;17:110-4.
22 Velmahos GC et al. Patterns of injury in victims of urban free falls.World J
Surg. 1997 ;21:816-20.
23 Adesunkanmi AR, Oginni LM, Oyelami OA, Badru OS.Road traffic
accidents to African children: assessment of severity using the ISS. Injury.
2000 ;31:225-8.
24 Benerjee KK, Agrawal BBL, Kohli A. Study of thoracoabdominal injuries in
a fatal road traffic accident in north-east Delhi. J Forensic Med Toxicol.
1998 ;14: 56-62.
85
25 Allen DM, Hicks G, Bota GW.Outcomes after severe trauma at a northern
Canadian regional trauma centre Can J Surg.1998 ;41:53-8.
26 Pape HC, Remmers D, Rice J, Ebisch M, Krettek C, Tscherne H.
Appraisal of early evaluation of blunt chest trauma: development of a
standardized scoring system for initial clinical decision making.J Trauma.
2000 ;49:496-504.
27 Gustavo PJ, Coimbra R, Rasslan S, Oliveira A, Fregoneze M, Mercadante
M. The role of associated injuries on outcome of blunt trauma patients
sustaining pelvic fractures. Injury. 2000 ;31:677-82.
28 Segers P et al Thoracic trauma: an analysis of 187 patients.Acta Chir
Belg. 2001 ;101:277-82.
29 Nikolić S, Micić J, Mihailović Z. Correlation between survival time and
severity of injuries in fatal injuries in traffic accidents.Srp Arh Celok Lek.
2001 ;129:291-5.
30 Milić J, Nikolić S, Mihailović Z. Analysis of causes of death in long-term
survivors of injuries sustained in traffic accidents.Srp Arh Celok Lek.
2002 ;130:149-53.
31 Hughes TMD, Elaton C, Hitos K, Perez JV, Mcdougall PA. Intra-abdominal
gastrointestinal tract injuries following blunt trauma. Injury. 2002 ;33:617-
626.
32 Jha JN, Srinivasa DK, Roy G, Jagdish S.Epidemiological study of road
traffic accident cases. Ind J Community Med. 2004 ;29:1-8.
86
33 Goel A, Kumar S, Bagga MK.Epidemiological and Trauma Injury and
Severity Score (TRISS) analysis of trauma patients at a tertiary care
centre in India. Natl Med J India. 2004 ;17:186-9.
34 Singh H, Dhattarwal SK.Pattern and distribution of injuries in fatal road
traffic accidents in Rohtak (Haryana).JIndian Acad Forensic Med.
2004 ;26:22-23.
35 Cooper JG, Smith R, Cooper AJ.The incidence of abdominal injury in
patients with thoracic and/or pelvic trauma. Injury Extra. 2005 ;36:259—
263
36 Murlidhar V, Roy N.Measuring trauma outcomes in India: An analysis
based on TRISS methodology in a Mumbai university hospital. Injury. 2004
;35:386-390.
37 Meera TH, Nabachandra HA. Study of pattern and Injury Severity Score in
blunt thoraco-abdominal trauma cases in Manipal. Medicolegal Update.
2005 ;5:47.
38 Chaudhary BL, Singh D, Tirpude BH, Sharma RK, Meel V.Profile of Road
Traffic Accident Cases in Kasturba Hospital of M.G.I.M.S., Sevagram,
Wardha, Maharashtra. Medico-Legal Update.2005 ;5:10-12.
39 Flagel BT et al.Half-a-dozen ribs: the breakpoint for mortality. Surgery.
2005 ;138:717-23.
87
40 Sharma BR, Harish D, Bangar S, Singh VP.Trauma score: a valuable tool
for documentation of autopsy reports of trauma victims. JIndian Acad
Forensic Med. 2005 ; 27: 77-81.
41 Rautji R, Bhardwaj DN, Dogra TD. The Abbreviated Injury Scale and its
correlation with traumatic accidental deaths in South Delhi. Med Sci Law.
2006 ;46:157-65.
42 Pathak MK, Ahamad Z, Agrawal P, Yadav S, Chaturvedi R, Tripathi SK.
Fatality due to chest injury in road traffic accident victims of Varanasi and
adjoining districts, U.P. Medicolegal Update. 2006 ;4:65-71.
43 Nikolić S, Atanasijević T, Popović V, Babić D.Forensic expertise of the
injury severity in fatally injuried car-occupants.Srp Arh Celok Lek.
2007 ;135:74.
44 Giannoudis PV et al.Prevalence of pelvic fractures, associated injuries,
and mortality: the United Kingdom perspective.J Trauma. 2007 ;63:875-
83.
45 Zargar M, Khaji A, Karbakhsh DM.Thoracic injury: a review of 276
cases.Chin J Traumatol. 2007 ;10:259-62.
46 Michiue T, Ishikawa T, Quan L, Zhu BL, Maeda H.Forensic pathological
evaluation of injury severity and fatal outcome in traffic accidents: five
illustrative autopsy cases of clinically unexpected death.Forensic Sci Med
Pathol. 2008 ;4:153-8.
88
47 Ndiaye A, Chambost M, Chiron M.The fatal injuries of car driver.
Forensic Sci Int. 2009 ;184:21-7.
48 Koo M, Sabaté A, Bassas E, Lacambra M, López S. Mortality in patients
with multiple injuries: analysis using the trauma and injury severity score in
a referral hospital. Rev Esp Anestesiol Reanim. 2009 ;56:83-91.
49 Palmer C.AIS 2005 vs. AIS 1998—A double-coding Exercise to Identify
Issues for Trauma Data.Injury Extra.2009 ;40:145.
50 Surgicalcriticalcare.net [homepage on the internet]. Injury severity
score[cited 2008 Sept 2]. Available from:
http://www.surgicalcriticalcare.net/Resources/ injury severity scoring.pdf
51 Trauma Association of Canada [homepage on the internet]. Abbreviated
injury scaling news /update [cited 2010 April 2]. Available from:
http://www.traumacanada.org/TRISC/AIS%20News/AIS_News.htm
52 Vij K, Krishan K.Risk factors and prevention of infection in autopsy room -
a review. Indian J Forensic Med Toxicol. [serial online] 2003 [cited 2010
April12]. Available from:
http://www.icfmt.org/
53 Mansar AH, Aadeel TM, Osman K, Iskandar S.An Epidemiological Study
of Abdominal and Pelvic Injury Trauma in post-mortem Cases at Hospital
KualaLumpur Between The Year of 2002-2003.Jurnal Sains Kesihatan
Malaysia.2008 ;6: 65-73.
89
54 Yousaf N, Saleem MU, Sheraz B, Attar F, Deshmukh R.Correlating
different parameters and scoring systems with the probability of survival in
trauma patients. Injury.2006 ;12:109.
55 Wikipedia.[homepage on the internet]. Correlation and dependence. [Cited
2010 April 2]. Available from:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Correlation_and_dependence
56 Gennarelli TA, Elaine W. AIS 2005: a contemporary injury scale. Injury.
2006 ;37:1083-1091.
57 Verma SK, Biswas G. Comparing short term survival by ISS and NISS in
road traffic accidents. Indian J Forensic Med Toxicol.[serial online] 2003
[cited 2010 April12]. Available from:
http://www.icfmt.org/
90