thesun 2008-11-06 page08 ex-deputy ministers son freed of murder charge

2
news  without   borders 8 theSun | THURSDA Y NOVEMBER 6 2008 Ex-deputy minister’s son  freed of murder charge KUALA LUMPUR: A former deputy minister’s son and two others were acquitted and discharged by the High Court here yesterday of a charge of murdering a doctor ve years ago. Justice Datuk Mohamed Apandi Ali, in acquitting college student Nor Adzlan Idris, 25, and Lee Jun Jo, 27, and Choy Chin Chuan, 25, both unemployed, without calling for their defence, ruled that the prosecution had failed to make out a prima facie case against them. They were charged with murdering Dr T. Ariaratnam, 66, at Arinaga Medical Centre in Bangsar Park here between 3.30am and 4am on April 21, 2003. Nor Adzlan is a son of Tan Sri Idris Abdul Rauf, a former deputy federal territories minister and former MP for TWO OTHERS ALSO ACQUITTED OVER MURDER OF BANGSAR PARK DOCTOR Up to 75% Industrial Court cases settled KUALA LUMPUR: The Human Re- sources Ministry has settled 60% to 75% of the industrial cases this year through the newly-introduced arbitra- tion process. The minister, Datuk Dr S. Subrama- niam, said yesterday only 512 cases were referred to the Industrial Court this year compared with 3,200 last  year. “We have saved time and cost. But, more importantly, we have ensured speedier justice for all parties in a dispute,” he said when opening the Malaysian Employers Federation (MEF) 2008 Conference here. Subramaniam said that in the last six months, he had personally handled many of the cases and managed to reduce the number of cases referred to the Industrial Court. He said the ministry wanted to ensure there was no backlog of cases as this had caused hardship to the parties involved. The delays in many cases were because of technical reasons and not caused by the courts. “We hope the amendments to the Employment Act and the Labour Act will further assist in the speedy disposal of cases,” he said. On foreign workers, Subramaniam said the government was on track with plans to reduce the number by about 500,000 within the next two  years despite the Home Ministry still approving new permits for foreign workers. “We can’t help it because the plantation and construction sectors still need foreign workers as locals do not want to take up the job offers,” he said. The government’s target was to bring down the number of legal foreign workers from 2.2 million to 1.7 or 1.8 million in two years. He also warned companies to en- gage local workers and refrain, as far as possible, from hiring foreign workers in view of the global economic meltdown which could see many workers out of  jobs as companies and factories shut down operations. On the minimum wage, Subra- maniam said many could lose their  jobs if the government implemented the RM900 a month minimum wage as proposed by the Malaysian Trades Union Congress, as employers might want to trim their operations because of rising operational costs. – Bernama Parit Buntar. Mohamed Apandi said the prosecution, which had called 21 witnesses, including Kuala Lumpur Hospital forensic consultant Dr Mohamed Shah Mahmud, had relied heavily on circumstantial evidence to prove its case. “The burden is on the prosecution to assist the court in making irresistible conclusion that all of these youths had common intention in murdering Dr Ariaratnam,” he said. He said he was not calling for their defence mainly because of several “gaping holes” in the prosecution’s case, especially the failure to call two Indian nationals who should have been critical witnesses. The failure of the prosecution and the investigating ofcer in taking diligent steps to ensure the presence of the two clinic assistants, Vellaichamy Sockalinggam and Vasudevan Perumal, had weakened their case. Mohamed Apandi said the prosecution had also failed to prove the common intention and pre-planning on the part of the accused to rob and kill the doctor. Although there was evidence by two prosecution witnesses the trio had discussed the robbery, it was not clear and there was an absence of proof of who among the three had caused the fatal slash wound on the doctor’s head. He said the court decided not to call the trio to enter their defence mainly to stop the defence from exposing further holes in the prosecution’s case. Deputy public prosecutor Afzainizam Abdul Aziz told reporters he will refer the matter to the attorney- general’s ofce for further instruction. Counsel Gooi Soon Seng appeared for Lee, K.Y. Leong for Choy, and Naran Singh for Nor Adzlan. Lee had to be sent back to the Sungai Buloh prison pending the outcome of another case in which he is charged with ve others with causing the death of an inmate during a riot in 2006. Marine police seize RM3.2m handphones KLANG: Marine police detained an Indonesian vessel on its way home and seized 13 suitcases lled with 12,838 handphones worth an esti- mated RM3.2 million. Federal marine police commander SAC II Isa Munir said the captain, two crew members from Indonesia and a Malays ian, aged between 37 and 48, were also detained at about 12.30pm while marine police were patrolling the South Port area of Port Klang yesterday. Police found 14 boxes lled with telephone accessories inside the vessel that had been declared and cleared by the customs. Isa said the Malaysian was arrested when he tried to bribe the police, offering RM30,000 for the release of the goods.

Upload: impulsive-collector

Post on 30-May-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: TheSun 2008-11-06 Page08 Ex-Deputy Ministers Son Freed of Murder Charge

 

news without  borders

8 theSun | THURSDAY NOVEMBER 6 2008

Ex-deputy minister’s son freed of murder charge

KUALA LUMPUR: A formerdeputy minister’s son and twoothers were acquitted anddischarged by the High Court here yesterday of a charge of murdering a doctor five yearsago.

Justice Datuk MohamedApandi Ali, in acquittingcollege student Nor AdzlanIdris, 25, and Lee Jun Jo, 27,and Choy Chin Chuan, 25,both unemployed, without calling for their defence, ruledthat the prosecution had failedto make out a prima facie caseagainst them.

They were charged withmurdering Dr T. Ariaratnam,66, at Arinaga Medical Centrein Bangsar Park here between3.30am and 4am on April 21,2003.

Nor Adzlan is a son of TanSri Idris Abdul Rauf, a formerdeputy federal territoriesminister and former MP for

TWO OTHERS ALSO ACQUITTED OVER MURDER OF BANGSAR PARK DOCTOR

Up to 75% Industrial Court cases settledKUALA LUMPUR: The Human Re-sources Ministry has settled 60% to75% of the industrial cases this yearthrough the newly-introduced arbitra-tion process.

The minister, Datuk Dr S. Subrama-niam, said yesterday only 512 caseswere referred to the Industrial Courtthis year compared with 3,200 last

 year.“We have saved time and cost. But,

more importantly, we have ensuredspeedier justice for all parties in adispute,” he said when opening theMalaysian Employers Federation (MEF)2008 Conference here.

Subramaniam said that in the lastsix months, he had personally handledmany of the cases and managed toreduce the number of cases referredto the Industrial Court.

He said the ministry wanted toensure there was no backlog of casesas this had caused hardship to theparties involved.

The delays in many cases werebecause of technical reasons and notcaused by the courts.

“We hope the amendments tothe Employment Act and the LabourAct will further assist in the speedydisposal of cases,” he said.

On foreign workers, Subramaniamsaid the government was on trackwith plans to reduce the number byabout 500,000 within the next two

 years despite the Home Ministry stillapproving new permits for foreignworkers.

“We can’t help it because theplantation and construction sectorsstill need foreign workers as locals donot want to take up the job offers,” hesaid.

The government’s target was tobring down the number of legal foreignworkers from 2.2 million to 1.7 or 1.8million in two years.

He also warned companies to en-gage local workers and refrain, as far aspossible, from hiring foreign workers inview of the global economic meltdownwhich could see many workers out of

 jobs as companies and factories shutdown operations.

On the minimum wage, Subra-maniam said many could lose their jobs if the government implementedthe RM900 a month minimum wageas proposed by the Malaysian TradesUnion Congress, as employersmight want to trim their operationsbecause of rising operational costs.– Bernama

Parit Buntar.Mohamed Apandi said the

prosecution, which had called21 witnesses, including KualaLumpur Hospital forensicconsultant Dr Mohamed ShahMahmud, had relied heavilyon circumstantial evidence toprove its case.

“The burden is on theprosecution to assist the

court in making irresistibleconclusion that all of theseyouths had common intentionin murdering Dr Ariaratnam,”he said.

He said he was not callingfor their defence mainlybecause of several “gapingholes” in the prosecution’scase, especially the failureto call two Indian nationals

who should have been criticalwitnesses.

The failure of theprosecution and theinvestigating officer in takingdiligent steps to ensure thepresence of the two clinicassistants, VellaichamySockalinggam and VasudevanPerumal, had weakened theircase.

Mohamed Apandi said theprosecution had also failed toprove the common intentionand pre-planning on the part of the accused to rob and killthe doctor.

Although there wasevidence by two prosecutionwitnesses the trio haddiscussed the robbery, it was not clear and there was

an absence of proof of whoamong the three had causedthe fatal slash wound on thedoctor’s head.

He said the court decidednot to call the trio to entertheir defence mainly tostop the defence fromexposing further holes in theprosecution’s case.

Deputy public prosecutorAfzainizam Abdul Aziztold reporters he will referthe matter to the attorney-general’s office for furtherinstruction.

Counsel Gooi Soon Sengappeared for Lee, K.Y. Leongfor Choy, and Naran Singh forNor Adzlan.

Lee had to be sent backto the Sungai Buloh prisonpending the outcome of another case in which heis charged with five otherswith causing the death of aninmate during a riot in 2006.

Marine police seizeRM3.2m handphonesKLANG: Marine police detained an Indonesianvessel on its way home and seized 13 suitcasesfilled with 12,838 handphones worth an esti-mated RM3.2 million.

Federal marine police commander SAC IIIsa Munir said the captain, two crew membersfrom Indonesia and a Malays ian, aged between37 and 48, were also detained at about 12.30pmwhile marine police were patrolling the SouthPort area of Port Klang yesterday.

Police found 14 boxes filled with telephoneaccessories inside the vessel that had beendeclared and cleared by the customs.

Isa said the Malaysian was arrested whenhe tried to bribe the police, offering RM30,000for the release of the goods.

Page 2: TheSun 2008-11-06 Page08 Ex-Deputy Ministers Son Freed of Murder Charge