thinking about advanced nanotechnologies€¦ · self-assembly using dna biosensors from...

55
Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies Dr K. Eric Drexler 26 February 2008

Upload: others

Post on 07-Sep-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Thinking About

Advanced Nanotechnologies 

Dr K. Eric Drexler

26 February 2008

Page 2: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

What is ‘nanotechnology’?

Nanotechnology today:Products that have a significant dimension less than 1/10micron (= 100 nanometers).

Future, revolutionary nanotechnology: nano-scale machines building products with atomic precision and digital control

Productive Nanosystems

Page 3: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Porphyrins

Metal complexesMetal-oxide clusters

Nanotube segments

electronic, chemical,biological, structural,

electronic, optical,optoelectronic,

electromechanical, electrochemical...

Quantum dots

Specialized functional structures:(atomically precise parts)

Page 4: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Modular Molecular Composite Nanosystems:

Page 5: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Kuhlman et al., Science 302:1364–68 (2003)

“Design of a Novel Globular Protein Foldwith Atomic-Level Accuracy”

Page 6: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Liu and Kuhlman, Nucleic Acids Res34:W235–W238 (2006)

“RosettaDesign server for protein design”

www.rosettadesign.med.unc.edu

Page 7: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Structural DNA nanotechnology:

Mark Sims, design using Nanoengineer-1 (2007)

Page 8: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Structural DNA nanotechnology: AFM image

Paul Rothemund, Nature 440:297 (2006)Million-atom, 100 nm diameter, atomically precise, 3D structures

Page 9: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

DNA/protein interface technology

Zinc finger protein (blue) binding DNA (orange)

Page 10: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Zinc-finger design software online

Zinc Finger Consortium, www.zincfingers.org

Page 11: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Modular Molecular Composite Nanosystems:

Integrate components to build systems:

‒ 3D atomically precise scaffold, easily re-configured ‒ 100s to 1000s of parts in addressable locations

Page 12: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

100 nm structure

Page 13: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

25 nm productive nanosystem

Page 14: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Physics limits performance

Page 15: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Technology pushes toward limits

Page 16: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Existing products show part of what is achievable

Page 17: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Some systems can be modeled

Page 18: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT
Page 19: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Molecular machinery

— These examples can be simulated, but not yet built —Molecular dynamics by NanoEngineer-1

Advanced-generation systems

Page 20: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Machine-phase chemistry

John

Bur

ch

Allis D.G., Drexler KE, “Design and Analysis of a Molecular Tool for CarbonTransfer in Mechanosynthesis.” J Comp Theo Nanosci, 2:45–55 (2005).

Advanced-generation systems

Page 21: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Doubling sizesby convergent assembly

Design and rendering by John Burch

Advanced-generation systems

Page 22: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Some systems can be modeled

Page 23: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Productive systems can link to form pathways

Page 24: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

High-payoff pathways can be found

Page 25: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

MAXIMALUTILITY

SIMPLESTINSTANCEScientific inquiry

Engineering design

Information flows, ideal objectives

SIMPLESTTHEORY

A

E

≤ ≤

= =

MAXIMALOPTIONS

physicalsystem

concretedescription

abstractmodel

abstractmodel

concretedescription

physicalsystem

constraint  measurement 

fabricationdesign 

Page 26: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Parallel issues, contrasting implications

Typical facts and views

Issues

Invites study

Informative

Defective

Initial conditions

Grows with time

Less tractable

Topic premature

Broad exploration

Discourages use

Problematic

Often adequate

Control inputs

Limited by control

More capable

Need more teams

Poor coordination

Unknown property

Unexpected outcome

Inaccurate models

Dynamical trajectory

Dynamical uncertainty

More complex

Multiple problems

Independent teams

In science: In engineering:

Page 27: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

Modular Molecular Composite Nanosystems:

Integrate components to build systems:

‒ 3D atomically precise scaffold, easily re-configured ‒ 100s to 1000s of parts in addressable locations

Page 28: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

100 nm structure

Page 29: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

25 nm productive nanosystem

Page 30: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

30

Single-Wall Carbon Nanotubesfor Nanoelectronics & Biosensors SWNT devices SWNT circuits Interactions with proteins and DNA Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT

(10,10) SWNT

Page 31: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

31

DNA on CNT (covalent)

Page 32: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

32

DNA on CNT (adsorb)

1545-1548

Page 33: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

33

DNA-CNT2

1545-1548

Page 34: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

34

DNA-CNT 3338-342

NA: poly-T, in vitro evolved ssDNA, dsDNA orRNA from bacteria or yeast.

NA+surfactant+sonication. Near-IR fluorescence indicates well dispersed

SWNT. Anion-exchange chromatography separates

DNA-CNT by size and electronic tube-type.

M

S

Page 35: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

35

Protein-CNT 1 Non-specific binding of protein to CNT. Inhibition by PEG coating. Specific protein binding enabled.

Avidin on bare CNT

No avidin on PEG/Triton CNT

Page 36: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

36

Protein-CNT 2

Anything curious about this data?

Avidin on biotin/ CNT

Blocked avidin with biotin/CNT

Page 37: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

37

Protein CNTbiosensor 1

Non-specific binding of proteins to CNT. Inhibition by PEO coating. Construction of specific biosensors by coating with PEO-

conjugates. Quartz crystal microbalance (QCM) and direct electrical

measurements.

(Non-ionic surfactants)

Page 38: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

38

Protein CNT biosensor 2

Page 39: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

39

Protein CNT biosensor 3

Page 40: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

40

Protein CNT biosensor 4

Page 41: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

41

Protein CNT biosensor 5

Page 42: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

42

Metallic nanowires templated on DNA

775-778

Page 43: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

43

Metal nanowire 2

775-778

Page 44: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

44

Molecular lithography 1

72-75

Page 45: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

45

Molecular lithography 2

72-75

Page 46: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

46

Molecular lithography 3

72-75

Page 47: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

47

DNA CNT FET 1

1380-1382

Page 48: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

48

DNA CNT FET 2

1380-1382

Page 49: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

49

DNA CNT FET 3

1380-1382

Self-assembled FET. Assembly errors... Contact resistance... Hysteresis...

Page 50: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

50

Bacteriophage-λ DNA has been used as a templatefor the deposition of various metals including:

Silver: E. Braun, Y. Eichen, U. Sivan, G. Ben-Yoseph, Nature 391,775 (1998).

Gold: K. Keren, et al., Science, 297, 72 (2002). Gold: F. Patolsky, Y. Weizmann, O. Lioubashevski, I. Willner,

Angew. Chem.-Int. Edit. 41, 2323 (2002). Copper: C.F. Monson, A.T. Woolley, Nano Lett. 3, 359 (2003). Platinum: W.E. Ford, O. Harnack, A. Yasuda, J.M. Wessels, Adv.

Mater. 13, 1793 (2001). Palladium: J. Richter, et al., Adv. Mater. 12, 507 (2000).

Page 51: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

51

Grainy wires

Pd

Cu

APL, 78, 536-538 (2001)

Pd

Page 52: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

52

SA 4x4 DNA templates1882-1885

Page 53: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

53

SA TAO DNA templates

Page 54: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

54

Crossed wire arrays 1

Page 55: Thinking About Advanced Nanotechnologies€¦ · Self-assembly using DNA Biosensors from protein/CNT (10,10) SWNT. 31 DNA on CNT (covalent) 32 DNA on CNT (adsorb) 1545-1548. 33 DNA-CNT

55

Crossed wire arrays 2