third space in the - nottingham.edu.cn

1
[SBE] [Yanning Xiang] [20219268] As response to socialist modernisation construction and Open-up policy, Tianjin, the former hyper-colonialcity and the most politically complex treaty port in China, has been undergoing a series of urban transformation since its liberation in 1949 to cover the former branding with new layers of identities. The thesis will examine the transformation of Minyuan Stadium in Five Avenues area in the former British Concession of Tianjin, with a particular interest on the in-between third spacewhere the top-down forming and bottom-up using of space can meet and negotiate by spatial production or appropriation respectively. The time focus is from 2004 to 2020, when the transformation process was accelerated by the typical government-led redevelopment with the rebranding of this area as cultural tourism district, leading to the trend of total westernisation in architectural representation, spectacular nature in built environment and gentrification in lifestyle. Through the Minyuan Stadium renovation project, the thesis intends to understand the regeneration model of Five Avenues and its postrun outcomes, and link them to the fabrication of post-concession identities of the city. Introduction Third Space in the Post-concession Era Minyuan Stadium in The Five Avenues in Tianjin s Former British Concession Methods Data collection Literature collection Field trip and observation In-depth interview Data analysis Synchronic analysis Diachronic analysis Content analysis Comparative analysis Urban Context Thesis Structure Formal Languages and Functions Research Questions How to reexamine the current urban redevelopment and architectural transformation in ex-British Concession of Tianjin, and enrich the understanding of them from post-concession perspective? How has the Third Space, the space in-between formally-planned space and informally-appropriated space, been produced in redevelopment and what are the values and implication? Spatial Agents of Renovation 2014 Key Theories Built heritages of colonialism in China Hybridity & Third Space Theory Context Informal Urbanism extend Minyuan Stadium Renovation 2014 in Five Avenues Case Analysis context analysis building analysis Formal languages and functions Informal use of spaces Transformation of Minyuan in history Typical regeneration model of Five Avenues for cultural tourism Field Post-colonial Urbanism Post-concession Nature Redevelopment of Five Avenues in Tianjin case selection tested by Informal Spaces 天津市和平区人民政府 国有资产监督管理委员会 [State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission of Heping District People's Government of Tianjin] 天津和平投资发展集团有限公司 [Tianjin Heping District Investment Development Group Co. Ltd] 天津五大道文化旅游发展 有限责任公司 [Tianjin Five Avenues Cultural Tourism Development Co. LTD] 天津市和平区民园地区提升改造工程指挥部 [Upgrading and Renovation Project Headquarters of Minyuan Area, Heping District, Tianjin] 天津市和平区人民政府 [People's Government of Heping District, Tianjin] 博风建筑工程设计有限公司 [Bo Feng Architectural Design and Engineering Co., Ltd.] 天津建工集团建筑设计有限公司 [Tianjin Construction Engineering Group Architectural Design Co., LTD] 天津住宅集团_建设工程总承包有限公司 [Tianjin Housing Group Construction Engineering General Contraction Co.LTD] Pre-operation Long-term private business operators Temporary private business operators Local residents Tourists developer supervise Post-operation design scheme construction unit construction drawing invest invest user Development Core Location Regeneration Model

Upload: others

Post on 19-Oct-2021

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

[SBE] [Yanning Xiang] [20219268]

As response to socialist modernisation construction and Open-up policy, Tianjin, the former ‘hyper-colonial’city and the most politically complex treaty port in China, has been undergoing a series of urbantransformation since its liberation in 1949 to cover the former branding with new layers of identities. Thethesis will examine the transformation of Minyuan Stadium in Five Avenues area in the former BritishConcession of Tianjin, with a particular interest on the in-between ‘third space’ where the top-down formingand bottom-up using of space can meet and negotiate by spatial production or appropriation respectively.The time focus is from 2004 to 2020, when the transformation process was accelerated by the typicalgovernment-led redevelopment with the rebranding of this area as cultural tourism district, leading to thetrend of total westernisation in architectural representation, spectacular nature in built environment andgentrification in lifestyle. Through the Minyuan Stadium renovation project, the thesis intends tounderstand the regeneration model of Five Avenues and its postrun outcomes, and link them to thefabrication of post-concession identities of the city.

Introduction

Third Space in thePost-concession Era

Minyuan Stadium in TheFive Avenues in Tianjin’sFormer British Concession

Methods

Data collection• Literature collection• Field trip and observation• In-depth interview

Data analysis• Synchronic analysis• Diachronic analysis• Content analysis• Comparative analysis

Urban ContextThesis Structure

Formal Languages and Functions

Research Questions

• How to reexamine the current urban redevelopmentand architectural transformation in ex-BritishConcession of Tianjin, and enrich the understandingof them from post-concession perspective?

• How has the Third Space, the space in-betweenformally-planned space and informally-appropriatedspace, been produced in redevelopment and whatare the values and implication?

Spatial Agents of Renovation 2014

Key Theories

Built heritages of colonialism in China

Hybridity &Third Space Theory

Context

Informal Urbanism

extend

Minyuan Stadium Renovation 2014 in Five Avenues

Case Analysis

context analysis

building analysis

Formal languages and functions

Informal use of spaces

Transformation of Minyuan in history

Typical regeneration model of Five Avenues for cultural tourism

Field

Post-colonial Urbanism

Post-concession Nature

Redevelopment of Five Avenues in Tianjin

case selection

tested by

Informal Spaces

天津市和平区人民政府国有资产监督管理委员会

[State-owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission of Heping

District People's Government of Tianjin]

天津和平投资发展集团有限公司[Tianjin Heping District Investment

Development Group Co. Ltd]

天津五大道文化旅游发展有限责任公司

[Tianjin Five Avenues Cultural Tourism Development Co. LTD]

天津市和平区民园地区提升改造工程指挥部[Upgrading and Renovation Project Headquarters of Minyuan Area,

Heping District, Tianjin]

天津市和平区人民政府[People's Government of Heping District,

Tianjin]

博风建筑工程设计有限公司[Bo Feng Architectural Design and Engineering Co., Ltd.]

天津建工集团建筑设计有限公司[Tianjin Construction Engineering Group

Architectural Design Co., LTD]

天津住宅集团_建设工程总承包有限公司[Tianjin Housing Group

Construction Engineering General Contraction Co.LTD]

Pre-operation

Long-term private business operators

Temporary private business operators

Local residents

Tourists

developer

supervise

Post-operation

design scheme

construction unit

constructiondrawing

invest

invest

user

Development Core

Location Regeneration Model