timetable version 8 (22 may 2018) - planning

Timetable – Version 8 (22 May 2018)

FISHERMANS BEND PLANNING REVIEW PANEL

STAGE 1 – HEARING ROOM 1

Day 1: Thursday 1 March 2018

Time Party Sub No Allocated

10.00am – 10.15am Preliminary matters 15 mins

10.15am – 1.00pm Fishermans Bend Ministerial Advisory Committee, represented by Meredith Sussex, Chair

3 hours

1.00pm – 2.00pm Lunch Break

2.00pm – 2.15pm St Kilda Cycling Club, represented by Melinda Jacobsen and Paul Jane

61 15 mins

2.30pm – 2.45pm Trevor White 194 15 mins

2.45pm – 3.45pm Metropolitan Waste and Resource Recovery Group, represented by Michelle Lee and Nick Harris

92 60 mins

Day 2: Friday 2 March 2018


9.30am – 10.00am Victorian Transport Association, represented by Peter Anderson

140 30 mins

10.00am – 11.30am Australian Institute of Architects, represented by Ruth White et al

176 1.5 hours

11.30am – 11.45am Tea break

11.45am – 12.30pm Affordable Housing Industry Group, represented by Nicola Foxworthy and Kate Breen

243 45 mins

12.30pm – 12.50pm Fishermans Bend Business Forum, represented by David Weston (Employment)

232 20 mins

12.50pm – 1.05pm Keith and Karen Sutherland (Lorimer) 30 15 mins


2.00pm – 3.00pm National Storage Property Trust, represented by Pat Rodgers (Wirraway)

121 60 mins

3.00pm – 3.15pm Tea break

3.15pm – 4.00pm CBQ Corp Pty Ltd, represented by Liam Riordan (Montague) 67 45 mins

4.00pm – 5.00pm Proactive Ageing Pty Ltd, represented by Steve Zanon (Employment)

197 60 mins

Day 3: Wednesday 14 March 2018



10.30am – 1.00pm Minister for Planning, represented by Susan Brennan SC, Marita Foley and Rupert Watters of Counsel, instructed by Harwood Andrews and calling the following expert witness:

Leanne Hodyl of Hodyl + Co on urban design

1/5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Minister for Planning, cont




10.15am – 1.00pm Minister for Planning, continued and calling the following expert witness:


2/5 days



Day 5: Friday 16 March 2018



10.15am – 1.00pm Minister for Planning, continued and calling the following expert witness:

John Glossop of Glossop Town Planning on planning

3/5 days



Fishermans Bend Planning Review Panel Hearing Timetable (Version 8)

Day 6: Monday 19 March 2018



10.15am – 1.00pm Minister for Planning, continued and calling the following expert witnesses:

Luke Mackintosh of Ernst & Young on development viability

Julian Szafreniec of SGS Economics & Planning on economic context

Joanna Thompson of Thompson Berrill Landscape Design on open space planning

4/5 days



Day 7: Tuesday 20 March 2018



10.15am – 1.00pm City of Port Phillip, represented by Terry Montebello and Briana Eastaugh of Maddocks Lawyers, with Aiden O’Neill of Council and calling the following expert witness:

Paul Shipp of Urban Enterprise on infrastructure (Evidence called by the City of Port Phillip and City of Melbourne)

153 1/1.5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm City of Port Phillip, continued, and calling the following expert witness:

Tom Patterson of Ramboll on flood mitigation

(Evidence called by the City of Port Phillip and City of Melbourne)

153




10.15am – 11.30am Minister for Planning, continued and calling the following expert witness:


11.30am – 11.45am Tea Break

11.45am – 1.00pm City of Port Phillip, continued and calling the following expert witness:

Marcus Spiller of SGS on affordable housing

153 .5/1.5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm City of Melbourne, represented by Juliet Forsyth and Eliza Bergin of Counsel, opening submission

188




10.15am – 1.00pm City of Melbourne, continued and calling the following expert witness:

Rob Milner of 10 Consulting Group on planning

188 1/1.5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm City of Melbourne, continued, including presentation from Rob Adams

188

Day 10: Monday 26 March 2018



10.15am – 10.30am 15 mins

10.30am – 12.00pm Ace Body Corporate Management, represented by Julie McLean and Ben Mahon of Bosco Johnson (Wirraway)

100 1.5 hours


2.00pm – 4.00pm City of Melbourne, cont,


Day 11: Tuesday 27 March 2018



10.15am – 11.15am Bellamia Nominees Pty Ltd and PCLC Investment Pty Ltd, represented by Andrea Pagliaro of Urbis (Wirraway)

136 1 hour

11.15am – 11.30am Tea break 15 mins


Joanna Thompson of Thompson Berrill Landscape Design on open space planning

Will Fooks of GTA Consultants on strategic transport planning (Integrated Transport Plan)

1.00pm – 2.00pm Lunch Break 5/5 days





10.15am – 11.00am City of Port Phillip cont


Professor Donald Bates of Lab Architect Studio on urban design

John Kiriakidis of GTA Consultants on strategic transport planning

2.75 hours


2.00pm – 4.30pm Minister for Planning, cont 2.5 hours




10.15am – 1.00pm Minister for Planning, cont 3 hours

STAGE 2: GENERAL – HEARING ROOM 1

Day 14: Monday 9 April 2018



10.30am – 1.00pm City of Port Phillip, represented by Terry Montebello and Briana Eastaugh of Maddocks Lawyers, with Aidan O’Neill of Council and calling the following expert witness:

Simon McPherson of Global South on urban design

153 1 day


2.00pm – 4.30pm City of Port Phillip, cont 153

Day 15: Tuesday 10 April 2018



10.15am – 1.00pm City of Melbourne, represented by Juliet Forsyth and Eliza Bergin of Counsel and calling the following expert witness:

Koos de Keijzer of DKO Architecture Pty Ltd on urban design

188 1/1.5 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm City of Melbourne, cont 188


Day 16: Wednesday 11 April 2018



10.15am – 1.00pm Norton Rose Fulbright, on behalf of numerous clients, represented by Chris Canavan QC, Nicholas Tweedie SC and Jane Sharp of Counsel, instructed by Norton Rose Fulbright providing general submissions and calling the following expert witnesses:

Charmaine Dunstan of Traffix Group on transport planning (Evidence called by Norton Rose Fulbright and Russell Kennedy for Sel Reklaw Pty Ltd)

Mark Sheppard of David Lock Associates on urban design

(Evidence called by Norton Rose Fulbright, Planning & Property Partners and Russell Kennedy)

various 1/3 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Norton Rose Fulbright, cont various

Day 17: Thursday 12 April 2018



10.15am – 1.00pm Norton Rose Fulbright, cont

Mark Sheppard of David Lock Associates on urban design (Evidence called by Norton Rose Fulbright, Planning & Property Partners and Russell Kennedy)

2/3days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Norton Rose Fulbright, cont

Day 18: Friday 13 April 2018



10.15am – 1.00pm Norton Rose Fulbright, cont

Andrew Biacsi of Contour on planning (Evidence called by Norton Rose Fulbright and Russell Kennedy for Sel Reklaw Pty Ltd)

Ian Shimmin of Urbis on economics

various 3/3 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Belsize Nominees, Costa Fox Developments and Springbank Properties Pty Ltd represented by Chris Canavan QC, Nicholas Tweedie SC and Jane Sharp of Counsel, instructed by Norton Rose Fulbright (Lorimer) and calling the following expert witness:

Mark Sheppard of DLA on urban design

129 2.5 hours




10.15am – 11.15am APA Group, represented by Natalie Bannister of Hall and Wilcox 189 60 mins

11.15am – 11.35am Meike Wagenhoff 168 20 mins


11.50am – 12.50pm Community Alliance of Port Phillip, represented by Rhonda Small et al

139 60 mins


2.00pm – 2.15pm Friends of Westgate Park, represented by Lyn Allison 10 15 mins

2.15pm – 3.15pm SouthPort Urban Responsible Renewal (SPURR), represented by Rowan Groves

190 60 mins





10.15am – 1.00pm Port of Melbourne Operations Pty Ltd, represented by David Vorchheimer of HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

134 3 hours


2.00pm – 3.00pm EPA Victoria, represented by Ruth Davies and Paul Torre 198 60 mins

3.00pm – 3.45pm Fishermans Bend Network, represented by Jennifer Stone 125 45 mins


4.00pm – 5.00pm The Father Bob Maguire Foundation, represented by Memuzin River

106 60 mins



MONTAGUE – HEARING ROOM 1 SANDRIDGE – HEARING ROOM 2

Day 21: Wednesday 18 April 2018



10.15am – 11.15am Minister for Planning, cont 60 mins

11.15am – 1.00pm City of Port Phillip, cont 153 1 day


2.00pm – 4.30pm City of Port Phillip, cont




10.15am – 11.45am Submission of Mr Tweedie for Norton Rose Fulbright for various clients (from Days 16,17,18)

1.5 hours

11.45 – 12.00noon Tea Break 15 mins

12.00noon – 1.00pm Lie Properties Pty, Perpetual Normandy Pty Ltd and Normanby Road Developments Pty Ltd represented by Chris Canavan QC, Nicholas Tweedie SC and Jane Sharp of Counsel, instructed by Norton Rose Fulbright and calling the following expert witnesses:


87, 120, 207

1/2 days


2.00pm – 5.00pm Lie Properties et al, cont




10.15am – 1.00pm Lie Properties et al, continued and calling the following expert witness:

Stuart McGurn of Urbis on town planning

87, 120, 207

2/2 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Lie Properties et al, cont



1.00pm – 1.15pm Preliminary matters 15 mins

1.15pm – 2.15pm Minister for Planning 60 mins


2.30pm – 4.30pm City of Port Phillip 153 2 hours


Page 2





10.15am – 1.00pm Gurner 2-28 Montague Street; E133 Property; Thousand Degree Pty Ltd; Lutkas Pty Ltd; Gladyslake Pty Ltd, Ausun Proprty CDB Pty Ltd and D W Keir Pty Ltd; EPC Pacific Pty Ltd, represented by Chris Wren QC, instructed by Planning and Property Partners, and calling the following expert witness:


90, 91, 94, 95, 96, 173

1/2 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Gurner et al, cont




10.15am – 1.00pm Gurner et al, cont 90, 91, 94, 95, 96, 173

2/2 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Gurner et al, cont




10.15am – 1.00pm Goodman Limited, represented by Nicholas Tweedie SC and Jane Sharp of Counsel, instructed by Norton Rose Fulbright (all precincts except Montague) and calling the following expert witness:

Catherine Heggen of Message Consultants on urban design and on town planning

149 1/2 days


2.00pm – 4.30pm Goodman Limited, cont 149


Page 3





10.15am – 1.00pm Lateral Estate Pty Ltd and Core Complex Pty Ltd, represented by Chris Wren QC, instructed by Planning and Property Partners and calling the following expert witness:

Mark Sheppard of DLA on urban design (Evidence also called by Jane Property Group in relation to sites within the Sandridge Precinct)

182, 242

1 day


2.00pm – 4.30pm Lateral Estate Pty Ltd and Core Complex Pty Ltd, cont 182, 242




10.15am – 10.45am Kembla No 16 Pty Ltd, represented by Craig Murphy 244 30 mins

10.45am – 11.15am Surveyors Place, represented by Craig Murphy 249 30 mins

11.15am – 1.15pm Carri Nominees Pty Ltd, represented by Urbis 123 2 hours


2.00pm – 3.00pm Little Lane Child Care, represented by Will Pearce of Human Habitats

63 60 mins


3.15pm – 3.45pm Salta Properties, represented by Will Pearce of Human Habitats (Employment precinct)

62 30 mins



12.00pm – 12.15pm Preliminary matters 15 mins

12.15pm – 3.15pm Salvo Property Group, represented by Chris Canavan QC, Nicholas Tweedie SC and Jane Sharp of Counsel, instructed by Norton Rose Fulbright and calling the following expert witness:


Stuart McGurn of Urbis on planning

250 3 hours

Day 29: Tuesday 1 May 2018



10.15am – 10.45am Marlton Investments Pty Ltd, represented by Chris De Silva of Mesh

164 30 mins

10.45am – 1.00pm Wadhawan Holdings Pty Ltd, represented by Nicola Collingwood of Counsel, instructed by Mills Oakley, and calling the following expert witnesses:

David Song of SongBowden on planning

Jason Walsh of Traffix Group on transport

143 5 hours


2.00pm – 4.45pm Wadhawan Holdings Pty Ltd, cont 143


Page 4


Day 30: Wednesday 2 May 2018



10.15am – 1.15pm The Jane Property Group, represented by Chris Wren QC, instructed by Planning and Property Partners, and calling the following expert witness:

Mark Sheppard of DLA on urban design (in relation to Montague Precinct properties)

131 3 hours




10.15am – 11.15am Teller Group, represented by Jamie Govenlock of Urbis 169 60 mins

11.15am - 11.30am Tea Break

11.30am – 1.00pm Citipower, represented by Nicholas Tweedie SC and Jane Sharp of Counsel, instructed by Norton Rose Fulbright and calling the following expert witness:

Catherine Heggen of Message Consultants on urban design and on town planning

175 1.5 hours

Day 31: Thursday 3 May 2018



10.15am – 1.00pm Barro Group Pty Ltd, represented by Jeremy Gobbo QC, instructed by Ponte Lawyers and calling the following expert witness:

Marco Negri of Contour on planning (Lorimer precinct)

89, 163, 165

3 hours


2.00pm – 4.30pm City of Melbourne, continued and calling the following expert witness:

Euon Williamson of Creative Enterprise Environment on ESD

(Evidence called by the City of Port Phillip and City of Melbourne)

188 2.5 hours




10.15am – 1.00pm Delta Group, represented by Stuart Morris and Nicola Collingwood of Counsel, instructed by Mills Oakley, and calling the following expert witnesses:



180 4 hours


2.00pm – 3.00pm Delta Group, cont

3.00pm – 3.45pm Aquaino Pty Ltd, represented by Chris Canavan QC, and instructed by HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

68 45 mins


Page 5


Day 32: Friday 4 May 2018



10.15am – 11.45am SM253 Pty Ltd, represented by Adrian Finanzio SC of Counsel, instructed by Herbert Smith Freehills

185 1.5 hours




9.45am– 1.00pm Toyota Motor Corporation Australia Ltd, represented by Paul Chiappi of Counsel, instructed by Clayton Utz and calling the following expert witnesses:

Brendan Rogers of Urbis on town planning

Charmaine Dunstan of Traffix on traffic

220 3.25 hours

Day 33: Monday 7 May 2018



10.15am – 12.15pm Elmarn Pty Ltd, represented by Tom Kalder 17 2 hours


1.30pm – 4.30pm Jopsal Pty Ltd, represented by Antonio Calabro of SAC Building Workshop

156 3 hours




10.15am – 12.30pm Closings from Minister for Planning and City of Port Phillip 2.5 hours




10.15am – 10.45am 202N Pty Ltd, represented by Alex Gelber of HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

135 30 mins

10.45am – 1.00pm Closing from Minister for Planning and City of Port Phillip

WIRRAWAY – HEARING ROOM 2




10.15am – 11.15am Minister for Planning 60 mins


11.30am – 1.30pm City of Port Phillip 153 2 hours


Page 6

LORIMER – HEARING ROOM 1 WIRRAWAY – HEARING ROOM 2




10.15am – 11.15am Minister for Planning 60 mins


11.30am – 1.00pm City of Melbourne, represented by Juliet Forsyth and Eliza Bergin of Counsel

188 1 day

1.00pm – 2.00pm Lunch

2.00pm – 4.30pm City of Melbourne, cont 188




10.15am – 10.45am Armsby Architects, represented by John Armsby 58 30 mins

10.25am – 1.00pm The Jane Property Group, represented by Chris Wren QC, instructed by Planning and Property Partners, and calling the following expert witness:


(Evidence also provided on behalf of Third Street Pty Ltd and Sel Recklaw Pty Ltd)

131 4 hours


2.00pm – 4.00pm The Jane Property Group, cont 131




10.15am – 1.00pm W W Sidwell Investments Pty Ltd; Lorimer Place Owners Corporation; VCHQ2 Pty Ltd, represented by Chris Wren SC, instructed by Planning and Property Partners and calling the following expert witness:

Mark Sheppard of DLA on urban design (Evidence also provided on behalf of CostaFox Development, Springbank Properties Pty Ltd and Belsize Nominees)

79, 162, 130

1 day


2.00pm – 4.40pm W W Sidwell Investments Pty Ltd, cont




10.15am – 1.00pm Third Street Pty Ltd, represented by Chris Canavan QC, Nicholas Tweedie SC and Jane Sharp of Counsel, instructed by Norton Rose Fulbright and calling the following expert witness:


217 4 hours


2.00pm – 3.00pm Third Street Pty Ltd, cont 217




10.15am – 12.15pm Claric Ninety Nine Pty Ltd, represented by Anthony Msonda-Johnson of Roberts Day

36 2 hours

12.15pm – 1.00pm Claric 178 Pty Ltd, represented by Anthony Msonda-Johnson of Roberts Day

37 45 mins


2.00pm – 3.00pm Urban Development Institute of Australia (Victoria), represented by Danni Addison

215 1 hour

3.00pm – 3.15pm Tea Break 15 mins

3.15pm – 4.45pm Minister for Planning, tabling of revised draft controls (Document 246)and response to Document 294

1.5 hours




10.15am – 1.00pm Diamond Salmon Pty Ltd and Prime Port Melbourne Pty Ltd; One Smart Pty Ltd; Mitmazal Pty Ltd; Moniton Pty Ltd; Thistlethwaite St Pty Ltd (Montague) represented by Nicola Collingwood of Counsel and instructed by Rigby Cooke Lawyers, and calling the following expert witness:

David Barnes of Hansen Partnership on planning

167, 172, 208, 222, 115,

3 hours


Page 7





10.15am – 10.45am Yarra’s Edge Class Action Committee (YCAC), represented by Catherine Dawson

228 30 mins

10.45am – 11.45am Dexus Property Group, represented by Andrea Pagliaro of Urbis

184 60 mins

11.45am – 12.00pm Tea break

12.00pm – 12.30pm Lorimer Properties Pty Ltd and Lorimer Properties Unit Trust, represented by Michael Dunn of Metropol Planning Solutions

253 30 mins


1.40pm – 1.55pm Sail and Adventure Ltd, represented by Peter van Duyn 114 15 mins

2.00pm – 2.30pm Peter Hirst 46 30 mins

2.30pm – 3.00pm Irene Hirst 47 30 mins




10.15am – 1.00pm Springbank Properties Pty Ltd, represented by Chris Canavan QC, Nicholas Tweedie SC and Jane Sharp of Counsel, instructed by Norton Rose Fulbright and calling the following expert witness:


104 3 hours


2.00pm – 5.00pm Costa Fox Developments, represented by Chris Canavan QC, Nicholas Tweedie SC and Jane Sharp of Counsel, instructed by Norton Rose Fulbright and calling the following expert witnesses:


Charmaine Dunstan of Traffix Group on traffic

71 3 hours




10.15am – 1.00pm Kador Group Holdings Pty Ltd, (Sandridge) represented by Nicola Collingwood, instructed by Mills Oakley and calling the following expert witnesses:



141 3 hours


2.00pm – 3.00pm J & D Bowen Pty Ltd and Bowen & Pomeroy Pty Ltd, represented by Carly Robertson of Counsel, instructed by Rigby Cooke Lawyers

181 1 hour


3.15pm – 4.15pm Soundfirm, represented by Carly Robertson of Counsel and instructed by Ryan Commercial Lawyers

178 1 hour


Page 8





10.15am – 1.00pm Hansen Construction Materials Pty Ltd, represented by Jason Kane of Counsel, instructed Cornwall Stodart and calling the following expert witnesses:

David Barnes of Hansen Partnership on strategic planning

Henry Turnbull of Traffix Group on traffic

147 3 hours


2.00pm – 4.30pm Belsize Nominees Pty Ltd, represented by Norton Rose Fulbright, and calling the following expert witness:


196 2.5 hours




10.15am – 1.00pm Sel Reklaw Pty Ltd, represented by Chris Canavan QC, Nicholas Tweedie SC and Jane Sharp of Counsel, instructed by Russell Kennedy Lawyers and calling the following expert witnesses:


Michael Eaddy of Mel Consultants on wind modelling

150 4 hours


2.00pm – 3.00pm Sel Reklaw Pty Ltd, cont 150


3.15pm – 4.15pm Closings from Minister for Planning and City of Port Phillip, if required

60 mins




10.15am – 11.15am ANZ, represented by Nicola Collingwood of Counsel, instructed by Rigby Cooke, and calling the following expert witness:

David Barnes of Hansen Partnership on planning

216 1 hour

11.15am – 11.30am Tea Break

11.30am – 1.00pm Samma Group Pty Ltd and Spec Property Development (Montague), represented by Stuart Morris QC, instructed by Minter Ellison and calling the following expert witnesses:

Craig Czarny of Hansen Partnership on urban design

Julia Bell of DLA on urban design

Charmaine Dunstan of Traffix Group on traffic

202 4 hours


2.00pm – 4.30pm Samma Group Pty Ltd and Spec Property Development, cont



FINALISATION – HEARING ROOM 1



10.00am – 10.15am Preliminary Matters 15 mins

10.15am – 11.15am Industry Business Hub (Montague), represented by Ian Pitt QC of Best Hooper Lawyers

255 1 hour

11.15am – 11.30am Tea break 15 mins

11.30am – 12.00pm Inchcape Australia Ltd (Lorimer), represented by Chris Canavan QC and Jane Sharp of Counsel, instructed Norton Rose Fulbright

254 30 mins

12.00pm - 1.00pm Lunch

1.00pm – 2.30pm Melbourne Water, represented by Robert Considine 1.5 hours


9.30am – 12.30pm Accompanied site inspection of the Port of Melbourne




10.15am – 1.00pm Round table discussion regarding drafting issues 3 hours


2.00pm – 3.00pm Transport for Victoria, represented by Garry Button and Dimitri Lolas

1 hour

3.00pm – 3.15pm Tea break 15 mins

3.15pm – 3.45pm Closing submissions, Port of Melbourne Operations 134 30 mins




10.15am – 11.45pm Closing submissions, City of Port Phillip 1.5 hours


12.00pm – 1.00pm Closing submissions, City of Melbourne 2 hours


2.00pm – 3.00pm Closing submissions, City of Melbourne

3.00pm – 6.30pm Closing submissions, Minister for Planning 3 hours

Day 46: Monday 18 June 2018


Reserve Day

Day 47: Tuesday 19 June 2018


Reserve Day

Day 48: Wednesday 20 June 2018


Reserve Day

Hearing Timetable Notes:

1. Stage 1 Hearings will include matters from all precincts. 2. Montague and Lorimer precinct hearings will run concurrently with Wirraway and Sandridge, except where noted. 3. This timetable may be amended without notice. 4. Please arrive at least 15 minutes before your scheduled time of commencement. If you are unable to be present at your

scheduled time, please contact Planning Panels Victoria as soon as practicable. 5. Any queries regarding this timetable should be made to Andrea Harwood of Planning Panels Victoria on 8392 5123. 6. Getting to Planning Panels Victoria:

Planning Panels is on the 75 and City Circle tram lines and a short walk from the Collins Street trams 109, 112 and 48. It is also a short walk from Parliament Train Station.

timetable version 8 (22 may 2018) - planning

Documents