tolstoy, leo - a calendar of wisdom

"'$)#"+*% !&,#*(

: 7 ? B O J > E K = > J I J E D E K H ? I > J > ; I E K B

M H ? J J ; D 7 D : I ; B ; 9 J ; : < H E C J > ;

M E H B : r I I 7 9 H ; : J ; N J I 8 O

HBKOKHNOKR

J H 7 D I B 7 J ; : < H E C J > ; H K I I ? 7 D 8 O

'F;J;H I;A?H?D

I 9 H ? 8 D ; H

ahhhhhhh

Typewritten Text

Boa leitura, Angelitaaaa!

=UbX\] cb BYc Jc`ghcm

<fca J\Y ;ggYbh]U` =UbX\]& Bci]g <]gW\Yf

QM\YbR ? kUg dUgg]b[ h\fci[\ U gYjYfY Wf]g]g cZ gYYd

h]W]ga UbX XciVh((( ? WUaY UWfcgg Jc`ghcm g Vcc_

J\Y A]b[Xca cZ =cX ?g M]h\]b Oci& UbX kUg XYYd`m

]adfYggYX Vm ]h( ? kUg Uh h\Uh h]aY U VY`]YjYf ]b j]c`YbWY(

?hg fYUX]b[ WifYX aY cZ am gWYdh]W]ga UbX aUXY aY U

Z]fa VY`]YjYf ]b Qbcb' j]c`YbWYR( M\Uh \Ug UddYU`YX hc

aY acgh ]b Jc`ghcm g `]ZY ]g h\Uh \Y dfUWh]gYX k\Uh

\Y dfYUW\YX UbX fYW_cbYX bc Wcgh hcc [fYUh ]b \]g dif

gi]h cZ hfih\( ( ( (

>Y kUg h\Y [fYUhYgh Udcgh`Y cZ bcb'j]c`YbWY h\Y dfYg

Ybh U[Y \Ug dfcXiWYX( Dc cbY ]b h\Y MYgh VYZcfY \]a cf

g]bWY \Ug kf]hhYb UbX gdc_Yb cb bcb'j]c`YbWY gc Zi``m cf

]bg]ghYbh`m UbX k]h\ giW\ dYbYhfUh]cb UbX ]bg][\h( ( (

Q>]gR fYaUf_UV`Y XYjY`cdaYbh cZ h\]g XcWhf]bY dihg hc

g\UaY h\Y dfYgYbh'XUm bUffck UbX `cd'g]XYX ]bhYfdfY

hUh]cb dih idcb ]h Vm h\Y jchUf]Yg cZ 7\]agU ]b h\]g `UbX

cZ cifg( ( ( ( JfiY 7\]agU g\ci`X aYUb U Wcad`YhY

ZfYYXca Zfca ]`` k]`` UbX Ub[Yf UbX \UhY UbX Ub cjYf

Z`ck]b[ `cjY Zcf U``( <cf ]bWi`WUh]b[ h\]g hfiY UbX \][\Yf

hmdY cZ 7\]agU Uacb[gh ig& Jc`ghcm g `]ZY k]h\ ]hg cWYUbx

`]_Y `cjY g\ci`X gYfjY Ug U VYUWcb `][\h UbX U bYjYf'

ZU]`]b[ gcifWY cZ ]bgd]fUh]cb( ( ( (

OKHNOKR JAODB MB OEKJ

YV .@GCIB@K JD?FLBJH

"F;J;H I;A+H?D

J\]g kUg BYc Jc`ghcmrg Ùgh aU^cf kcf_( M]h\ ]h& \Y Zi`xZ]``YX U XfYUa \Y \UX bcif]g\YX Zcf Uàcgh Z]ZhYYb mYUfg&h\Uh cZ sWc``YWh]b[ h\Y k]gXca cZ h\Y WYbhif]Yg ]b cbYVcc_t aYUbh Zcf U [YbYfU` UiX]YbWY( Jc`ghcm dih U \i[YUacibh cZ YZZcfh ]bhc ]hg WfYUh]cb& dfYdUf]b[ h\fYY fYj]gYXYX]h]cbg VYhkYYb +3*. UbX +3+*( ?h kUg \]g ckb ZUjcf]hYYjYfmXUm fYUX]b[& U Vcc_ \Y kci`X hifb hc fY[iÙf`m Zcfh\Y fYgh cZ \]g `]ZY(J\Y cf][]bU` ]XYU Zcf h\]g kcf_ UddYUfYX hc WcaY hc

Jc`ghcm ]b h\Y a]X'+22*g( >]g Z]fgh fYWcfXYX YldfYgg]cb cZh\Y WcbWYdh cZ - /DOHQGDU RI BLVGRPvs7 k]gY h\ci[\hZcf YjYfm XUm cZ h\Y mYUf& Zfca h\Y [fYUhYgh d\]`cgcd\YfgcZ U`` h]aYg UbX U`` dYcd`YtvWUaY ]b +22.( >Y kfchY ]b\]g X]Ufm cb CUfW\ +/ cZ h\Uh mYUf4 s? \UjY hc WfYUhY U W]fxW`Y cZ fYUX]b[ Zcf amgY`Z4 ;d]WhYhig& CUfWig 7ifY`]ig&BUc'Jni& 8iXX\U& FUgWU`& J\Y DYk JYghUaYbh( J\]g ]gU`gc bYWYggUfm Zcf U`` dYcd`Y(t ?b +22/& \Y kfchY ]b U `YhhYfhc \]g Ugg]ghUbh& Cf( 9\Yfh_cj5 s? _bck h\Uh ]h []jYg cbY[fYUh ]bbYf ZcfWY& WUàbYgg& UbX \Udd]bYgg hc Wcaaib]xWUhY k]h\ giW\ [fYUh h\]b_Yfg Ug IcWfUhYg& ;d]WhYhig&7fbc`X& FUf_Yf(((( J\Ym hY`` ig UVcih k\Uh ]g acgh ]adcfx

hUbh Zcf \iaUb]hm& UVcih h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY UbX UVcihj]fhiY( ((( ? kci`X `]_Y hc WfYUhY U Vcc_ ((( ]b k\]W\ ?Wci`X hY`` U dYfgcb UVcih \]g `]ZY& UbX UVcih h\Y =ccX MUmcZ B]ZY(tJ\Y dfcWYgg cZ Wc``YWh]b[ h\YgY h\ci[\hg hcc_ cjYf Z]Zx

hYYb mYUfg( Jc`ghcm VY[Ub kf]h]b[ VYhkYYb :YWYaVYf +3*,UbX @UbiUfm +3*-( J\Yb ]b \]g ÙhY gYjYbh]Yg& \Y \UX ZU``YbgYf]cig`m ]``5 k\]`Y aYX]hUh]b[ UVcih h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY UbXXYUh\& \Y kUg ]bgd]fYX hc VY[]b Wcad]`]b[ k\Uh \Y h\YbWU``YX - BLVH ?KRXJKW IRU 1YHU\ 0D\& M\Yb \Y Z]bU``m gYbhh\Y Vcc_ hc \]g diV`]g\Yf& Jc`ghcm kfchY ]b \]g X]Ufm4 s? ZY`hh\Uh ? \UjY VYYb Y`YjUhYX hc [fYUh gd]f]hiU` UbX acfU`\Y][\hg Vm Wcaaib]WUh]cb k]h\ h\Y VYgh UbX k]gYgh dYcd`Yk\cgY Vcc_g ? fYUX UbX k\cgY h\ci[\hg ? gY`YWhYX Zcf am/LUFOH RI =HDGLQJ& t >Y kci`X cZhYb fYhifb ]b \]g X]Ufm hcaYX]hUhY idcb h\]g Vci_& fYdYUh]b[ jUf]Ubhg cZ sM\Uh WUbVY acfY dfYW]cig h\Ub hc Wcaaib]WUhY YjYfm XUm k]h\h\Y k]gYgh aYb cZ h\Y kcf`X6t Jc`ghcm WUfYZi``m gY`YWhYX h\YWcbhf]Vihcfg hc h\]g jcìaY& sUacb[ h\Y jYfm VYgh kf]hYfg&tUg \Y fYdYUhYX hc \]g Wc``YU[iYg UbX Zf]YbXg( J\Ym fYdfYxgYbhYX U k]XY jUf]Yhm cZ d\]`cgcd\]WU` j]Ykg& Wi`hifU` VUW_x[fcibXg& UbX \]ghcf]WU` dYf]cXg4 s?h k]`` VY U V][ gifdf]gY hch\Y fYUXYfg&t Jc`ghcm kfchY& sh\Uh hc[Yh\Yf k]h\ AUbh UbXch\Yf ZUacig h\]b_Yfg& h\Ym k]`` Z]bX ]b am Vcc_ h\ci[\hgVm BiWm CU`cfm& Ub ib_bckb ^cifbU`]gh Zfca h\Y Kb]hYXIhUhYg& Zfca EfY[cb(t J\Y Z]fgh YX]h]cb UddYUfYX ]b +3*.ibXYf h\Y h]h`Y ?KRXJKWV RI BLVH 9HQ& ?h gUk h\fYY YX]h]cbgXif]b[ Jc`ghcmrg `]ZYh]aY& VYhkYYb +3*. UbX +3+*& YUW\ diVx`]g\YX k]h\ U X]ZZYfYbh giVh]h`Y4 ?KH BD\ RI 8LIH$ /LUFOH RI=HDGLQJ$ UbXS` BLVH ?KRXJKW IRU 1YHU\ 0D\&8YhkYYb +3*. UbX +3*1& Jc`ghcm kcf_YX cb h\Y

YbÙf[YX UbX Wcad`YhY`m fYj]gYX gYWcbX YX]h]cb& Zfcak\]W\ h\]g& ]hg Z]fgh ;b[`]g\ hfUbgÙh]cb& ]g XfUkb( ?b a]X'7i[igh +3*/ \Y kfchY h\Y ]bhfcXiWh]cb h\Uh Zc``ckg UbXbchYX ]b \]g X]Ufm4 s? \UjY fYj]gYX UbX YbÙf[YX am /DOHQcGDU$ bck ]h ]g hk]WY Ug V][( <cf hkc acbh\g ? X]X bch fYUX

Ubmh\]b[ Y`gY& bY]h\Yf bYkgdUdYfg bcf aU[Un]bYg& UbX ?ZY`h gc [ccX( ((( ? VYWUaY acfY UbX acfY Ughcb]g\YX Vmh\Y ][bcfUbWY& UbX YgdYW]U``m Vm h\Y Wi`hifU`& acfU` ][bcxfUbWY cZ cif gcW]Yhm( ( ( ( 7`` cif YXiWUh]cb g\ci`X VYX]fYWhYX hc h\Y UWWiaiÙh]cb cZ h\Y Wi`hifU` \Yf]hU[Y cZcif UbWYghcfg& h\Y VYgh h\]b_Yfg cZ h\Y kcf`X)"J\Y aU^cf X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb h\Y Z]fgh YX]h]cb

"?KRXJKWV RI BLVH 9HQ# UbX h\Y gYWcbX "- /DOHQGDU RIBLVGRP# kUg h\Uh Jc`ghcm bck [fcidYX h\Y h\ci[\hgUWWcfX]b[ hc hcd]Wg Zcf U WYfhU]b XUm& kYY_& UbX acbh\(>Y kfchY cfjîbY -& +3*.& ]b \]g X]Ufm4 s? Ua Vigm k]h\

hZYYEZW)Y RI =HDGLQJ& ((( ? WUbbch Xc Ubmh\]b[ Y`gY(((( ?\UjY gY`YWhYX h\ci[\hgSaX [fcidYX h\Ya ]bhc h\Y Zc``ckx]b[ aU^cf hcd]Wg4 =cX& ?bhY``YWh& BUk& BcjY& :]j]bYDUhifY cZ CUb_]bX& <U]h\& JYadhUh]cbg& McfX& IY`Z'IUWf]Z]WY& ;hYfb]hm =ccX& A]bXbYgg& Kb]Z]WUh]cb cZ FYcxd`Y #k]h\ =cX$& FfUmYf& <fYYXca& FYfZYWh]cb& Mcf_& YhW(tJc`ghcm UXXYX UVcih Y][\h \ibXfYX cZ \]g ckb h\ci[\hg&kf]hhYb Xif]b[ \]g aUbm mYUfg cZ aYX]hUh]cb& cf hU_YbZfca dfYj]cig X]Ufm Ybhf]Yg( >Y [YbYfU``m ghUfhYX YUW\ XUmk]h\ Ub cdYb]b[ h\ci[\h cZ \]g ckb& UXXYX eichYg Vmch\Yf gcifWYg& UbX Z]b]g\YX YUW\ XUm k]h\ U W`cg]b[h\ci[\h cZ \]g ckb(7XX]h]cbU``m& \Y kfchY U g\cfh ghcfm& cf j][bYhhY& h\fYY

hc hYb dU[Yg ]b `Yb[h\ Zcf h\Y YbX cZ YjYfm kYY_( ;UW\ghcfm WcffYgdcbXYX hc h\Uh kYY_rg acfU`& d\]`cgcd\]WU`&cf fY`][]cig hcd]W5 \Y dfYdUfYX Z]Zhm'hkc ghcf]Yg ]b U`` UbXWU``YX h\Ya ?KH >XQGD\ =HDGLQJ >WRULHV& J\Y aU^cf]hm cZh\YgY Z]Zhm'hkc ghcf]Yg kYfY kf]hhYb Vm Jc`ghcm YgdYW]U``mZcf h\]g kcf_5 h\Y fYgh kYfY gY`YWhYX UbX UXUdhYX Zfcakf]h]b[g Vm FÙhc& 8iXX\U& :cghcYjg_]& FUgWU`& BYg_cj&9\Y_\cj& UbX ch\Yfg( Jc`ghcmrg dfcgY ghm`Y ]b h\YgY >XQcGD\ =HDGLQJ >WRULHV ]g jYfm X]ZZYfYbh Zfca h\Y gcd\]gh]WUxh]cb cZ \]g YUf`]Yf bcjY`g( J\YgY ghcf]Yg& k\]W\ kYfY ÙhYf[fYUh`m UXa]fYX Vm FUghYfbU_ UbX Ic`n\Yb]hgmb& kYfYkf]hhYb ]b U W`YUf& g]ad`Y& Uàcgh df]a]h]jY Ùb[iU[Y&

XYg][bYX& Ug h\Ym kYfY& Zcf U k]XY UbX [YbYfU` UiX]YbWY( ?bh\Ya& Jc`ghcm WcaV]bYX g]ad`]W]hm cZ Zcfa UbX d\]`cxgcd\]WU` XYdh\( 8YWUigY h\YgY ghcf]Yg X]X bch UddYUf ]b U``YX]h]cbg& UbX VYWUigY h\Ym UfY Ug U k\c`Y ei]hY `cb[& h\YmXc bch UddYUf ]b h\]g YX]h]cb(Eb :YWYaVYf ,+& +3*.& UZhYf fYUX]b[ h\Y [U``Ym dfccZg

cZ h\Y gYWcbX YX]h]cb WU``YX ?KH /DOHQGDU* ?KH /LUFOH RI=HDGLQJ IRU 1YHU\ 0D\$ Jc`ghcm kfchY ]b \]g X]Ufm4 s:if]b[h\]g Ùgh XUm ? \UjY XYgWYbXYX Zfca h\Y gd]f]hiU` UbX acfU`\Y][\hg k\YfY ? kUg U`` h\]g h]aY k\Yb ? Wcaaib]WUhYXk]h\ h\Y VYgh UbX k]gYgh h\]b_Yfg cZ h\Y kcf`X k\Yb ? WfYxUhYX am /LUFOH RI =HDGLQJ& J\]g h]h`Y kUg W\Ub[YX ]b h\YgYWcbX fYj]gYX YX]h]cb& diV`]g\YX ]b +3*/'+3*1& hc BLVH?KRXJKWV E\ 9DQ\ BULWHUV RQ ?UXWK$ 8LMH$ DQG .HKDYLRU/ROOHFWHG DQG -UUDQJHG IRU 1YHU\ 0D\ RI WKH CHDU E\ 8HR?ROVWR\& <fca ]hg Z]fgh diV`]WUh]cb& h\Y Vcc_ kUg U`kUmgdfYgYbh cb Jc`ghcmrg XYg_5 ]h VYWUaY \]g ZUjcf]hY Vcc_Xif]b[ h\Y Ùgh Z]jY mYUfg cZ \]g `]ZY( ;jYfm XUm& Zfca +3*/hc +3+*& \Y fYUX h\ci[\hg dfYgYbhYX ]b h\Y Vcc_ Zcf h\YWcffYgdcbX]b[ XUm cZ h\Y mYUf& UbX \Y fYWcaaYbXYX h\YgUaY \UV]h hc U`` \]g Zf]YbXg( Eb CUm +0&+3*2& \Y kfchY hcU aUb bUaYX =igYj4 s? WUbbch ibXYfghUbX \ck gcaYdYcd`Y WUb `]jY k]h\cih Wcaaib]WUh]b[ k]h\ h\Y k]gYghdYcd`Y k\c YjYf `]jYX cb ;Ufh\6 ((( ? ZYY` jYfm \UddmYjYfm XUm& VYWUigY ? fYUX h\]g Vcc_(tJc`ghcm dfYdUfYX U h\]fX fYj]gYX& g\cfhYbYX& UbX g]ad`]x

Z]YX YX]h]cb k\]W\ UddYUfYX ]b df]bh ibXYf h\Y bYk h]h`Y ?KHBD\ RI 8LIH ]b +3+*& h\Y Ùgh mYUf cZ \]g `]ZY( >Y k]g\YX hcaU_Y h\Y Vcc_ YUg]`m WcadfY\Ybg]V`Y Zcf YjYb h\Y g]ad`YghUbX `YUgh YXiWUhYX dYcd`YvdYUgUbhg UbX W\]`XfYb( CcghdfcVUV`m& Jc`ghcm WcadUfYX)? /DOHQGDU RI BLVGRP hc BDUDQG <HDFH k\Yb \Y kfchY h\Uh sJc WfYUhY U Vcc_ Zcfh\Y aUggYg& Zcf a]``]cbg cZ dYcd`Y ((( ]g ]bWcadUfUV`macfY ]adcfhUbh UbX Zfi]hZi` h\Ub hc WcadcgY U bcjY` cZ h\Y_]bX k\]W\ X]jYfhg gcaY aYaVYfg cZ h\Y kYU`h\m WÙggYg ZcfU g\cfh h]aY& UbX h\Yb ]g ZcfYjYf Zcf[chhYb( J\Y fY[]cb cZ

h\]g Ufh cZ h\Y g]ad`Ygh& acgh k]XY`m UWWYgg]V`Y ZYY`]b[ ]gYbcfacig& UbX ]h ]g Ug mYh Uàcgh ibhciW\YX(t Eh\Yf YX]xh]cbg UddYUfYX ]b EXYggU UbX Ih( FYhYfgVif[ ]b +3++'+3+,(7 =YfaUb Wf]h]WU` YX]h]cb #hfUbgÙhYX Vm ;( IW\a]Xh UbX7( IW\_UfjUb& :fYgXYb4 HUf` HY]ggbYf& +3*1$ ]bWìXYX h\YgcifWYg cZ \]g biaYfcig eichYg(7b YX]h]cb cZ - /DOHQGDU RI BLVGRP kUg diV`]g\YX ]b

Higg]U ]b +3+,& Vih UZhYf h\Y Higg]Ub HYjcìh]cb diV`]WUxh]cb kUg ZcfV]XXYb ibXYf h\Y Icj]Yh fY[]aY& VYWUigY cZh\Y Vcc_rg gd]f]hiU` cf]YbhUh]cb UbX ]hg biaYfcig fY`]x[]cig eichYg( M\Yb ]h kUg U[U]b diV`]g\YX ]b Higg]U& ]b+33/& UZhYf h\Y fYWYbh XYacWfUh]W fYZcfag& ]h Yb^cmYXhfYaYbXcig giWWYgg& gY``]b[ cjYf -**&*** Wcd]Yg(?h \Ug bYjYf VYZcfY VYYb hfUbgÙhYX ]bhc ;b[`]g\( J\Y

Z]fgh ;b[`]g\ hfUbg]U4]cb cZS` /DOHQGDU RI BLVGRP k]`` VY UfYU` X]gWcjYfm Zcf h\Y ;b[`]g\'gdYU_]b[ fYUXYf( 9fYUhYXVm cbY cZ h\Y kcf`Xrg [fYUhYgh bcjY`]ghg UbX h\]b_Yfg hcfYdfYgYbh h\Y jYfm VYgh cZ h\Y kcf`Xrg gd]f]hiU` \Yf]hU[Y& ]hXfUkg cb h\Y [fYUhYgh kcf_g cZ fY`][]cb& d\]`cgcd\m& UbX`]hYfUhifY h\Y kcf`X \Ug mYh gYYb( ?h VY`cb[g Uacb[ h\YjYfm VYgh WfYUh]cbg cZ \iaUb [Yb]ig& U kcf_ k\]W\ k]``gYfjY ]hg fYUXYfg Ug U dfUWh]WU` gd]f]hiU` [i]XY cb \ck hc`]jY ]b dYUWY k]h\ cbYgY`Z UbX \ck hc `]jY U `]ZY Z]``YX k]h\_]bXbYgg& gUh]gZUWh]cb& UbX \Udd]bYgg( Jc`ghcmrg cf][]bU`[cU` kUg h\Y XY`]jYfm cZ k]gXca hc h\Y k]XYgh dcgg]V`YbiaVYf cZ dYcd`Y& shc YbhYfhU]b a]``]cbg cZ fYUXYfg(t J\]gU]a fYaU]bg Ug WcadY``]b[ bck& ]b h\]g h]aY cZ ]bWfYUg]b[gd]f]hiU` bYYX& Ug ]h kUg h\Yb(

EJOMKAP OEKJ

8O B;E JEBIJEO

? hcc_ h\Y h\ci[\hg Wc``YWhYX \YfY Zfca U jYfm Ùf[Y biaxVYf cZ kcf_g UbX Wc``YWh]cbg( ? ]bX]WUhYX h\Y Uih\cf cZYUW\ h\ci[\h VYbYUh\ ]h& h\ci[\ ? X]X bch aUf_ h\Y YlUWhgcifWY cf Vcc_ h]h`Y cf kcf_ Zfca k\]W\ ? hcc_ ]h( ?bgcaY WUgYg& ? hfUbgÙhYX h\YgY h\ci[\hg bch X]fYWh`m Zfcah\Y]f cf][]bU` gcifWYg& Vih Zfca U hfUbgÙh]cb Zfca h\Y Ùbx[iU[Yg ]b k\]W\ h\Ym VYWUaY _bckb hc aY& gc gcaYh]aYgam hfUbgÙh]cbg a][\h bch VY Wcad`YhY`m ]XYbh]WU` hc h\Ycf][]bU`g( M\Yb ? hfUbgÙhYX h\ci[\hg Vm =YfaUb& <fYbW\&cf ?hU`]Ub h\]b_Yfg& ? X]X bch ghf]Wh`m Zc``ck h\Y cf][]bU`&igiU``m aU_]b[ ]h g\cfhYf UbX YUg]Yf hc ibXYfghUbX& UbXca]hh]b[ gcaY kcfXg( HYUXYfg a][\h hY`` aY h\Uh U eichY]g bch h\Yb FUgWU` cf HciggYUi& Vih am ckb kcf_& Vih ?h\]b_ h\Uh h\YfY ]g bch\]b[ kfcb[ ]b WcbjYm]b[ h\Y]fh\ci[\hg ]b U acX]Z]YX Zcfa( J\YfYZcfY& ]Z gcaYcbYXYg]fYg hc hfUbgÙhY h\]g Vcc_ ]bhc ch\Yf Ùb[iU[Yg& ? kci`X`]_Y hc UXj]gY h\Ya bch hc `cc_ Zcf h\Y cf][]bU` eichYgZfca h\Y ;b[`]g\ dcYh 9c`Yf]X[Y& gUm& cf h\Y =YfaUbd\]`cgcd\Yf AUbh& cf h\Y <fYbW\ kf]hYf HciggYUi& Vih hchfUbgÙhY X]fYWh`m Zfca am kf]h]b[( 7bch\Yf fYUgcb gcaYcZ h\YgY h\ci[\hg aUm bch WcffYgdcbX hc h\Y cf][]bU`g ]g Uhh]aYg ? hcc_ U h\ci[\h Zfca U `Yb[h\m UbX WcbjcìhYXUf[iaYbh& UbX ? \UX hc W\Ub[Y gcaY kcfXg UbX d\fUgYg Zcf

WÙf]hm UbX ib]hm cZ YldfYgg]cb( ?b gcaY WUgYg ? YjYbYldfYgg h\Y h\ci[\h Ybh]fY`m ]b am ckb kcfXg( ? X]X h\]gVYWUigY h\Y difdcgY cZ am Vcc_ ]g bch hc []jY YlUWh&kcfX'Zcf'kcfX hfUbgÙh]cbg cZ h\ci[\hg WfYUhYX Vm ch\YfUih\cfg& Vih hc igY h\Y [fYUh UbX Zfi]hZi` ]bhY``YWhiU` \Yfx]hU[Y WfYUhYX Vm X]ZZYfYbh kf]hYfg hc dfYgYbh Zcf U k]XYfYUX]b[ UiX]YbWY Ub YUg]`m UWWYgg]V`Y& YjYfmXUm W]fW`Y cZfYUX]b[ k\]W\ k]`` UfcigY h\Y]f VYgh h\ci[\hg UbX ZYY`x]b[g(? \cdY h\Uh h\Y fYUXYfg cZ h\]g Vcc_ aUm YldYf]YbWY h\Y

gUaY VYbYjc`Ybh UbX Y`YjUh]b[ ZYY`]b[ k\]W\ ? \UjY YldYxf]YbWYX k\Yb ? kUg kcf_]b[ cb ]hg WfYUh]cb& UbX k\]W\ ?YldYf]YbWY U[U]b UbX U[U]b& k\Yb ? fYfYUX ]h YjYfm XUm&kcf_]b[ cb h\Y YbÙf[YaYbh UbX ]adfcjYaYbh cZ h\Y dfYxj]cig YX]h]cb(

ÅHUYOYXZÀYÂÃ7@KAE "*!)

DchY hc HYUXYf4 ?b U`` cZ h\Y Vcc_rg cf][]bU` Higg]Ub'Ùb[iU[Y YX]h]cbg& Jc`ghcm \][\`][\hYX cb YUW\ dU[Y h\YcbY eichY h\Uh acgh giWW]bWh`m YldfYggYX h\Y XUmrgh\YaY( J\YgY eichYg \UjY VYYb ]hU`]W]nYX ]b h\]g YX]h]cb(

ÅLBOBMNBGEMEJ

YBGPVGSXÁ

8YhhYf hc _bck U ZYk h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY [ccX UbX bYWYggUfmh\Ub aUbm h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY igY`Ygg UbX aYX]cWfY(

M\Uh U [fYUh hfYUgifY WUb VY \]XXYb ]b U gaU``& gY`YWhYX`]VfUfm 7 WcadUbm cZ h\Y k]gYgh UbX h\Y acgh XYgYfj]b[dYcd`Y Zfca U`` h\Y W]j]`]nYX Wcibhf]Yg cZ h\Y kcf`X& Zcfh\cigUbXg cZ mYUfg& WUb aU_Y h\Y fYgi`hg cZ h\Y]f ghiX]YgUbX h\Y]f k]gXca UjU]`UV`Y hc ig( J\Y h\ci[\h k\]W\ h\Yma][\h bch YjYb fYjYU` hc h\Y]f VYgh Zf]YbXg ]g kf]hhYb \YfY]b W`YUf kcfXg Zcf ig& dYcd`Y Zfca Ubch\Yf WYbhifm( OYg&kY g\ci`X VY [fUhYZi` Zcf h\Y VYgh Vcc_g& Zcf h\Y VYgh gd]fx]hiU` UW\]YjYaYbhg ]b cif `]jYg(

vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

J\YfY UfY hcc aUbm aYX]cWfY Vcc_g k\]W\ Yl]gh ^igh hcYbhYfhU]b mcif a]bX( J\YfYZcfY& fYUX cb`m h\cgY Vcc_gk\]W\ UfY UWWYdhYX k]h\cih XciVh Ug [ccX($ # !#" 7bbUYig IYbYWUHYUX h\Y VYgh Vcc_g Z]fgh& ch\Yfk]gY mcir`` Z]bX mci Xcbch \UjY h]aY(

v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

?KH GLIIHUHQFH EHWZHHQ UHDO PDWHULDO SRLVRQ DQG LQWHOOHFWXDOSRLVRQ LV WKDW PRVW PDWHULDO SRLVRQ LV GLVJXVWLQJ WR WKH WDVWH$ EXWLQWHOOHFWXDO SRLVRQ$ ZKLFK WDNHV WKH IRUP RI FKHDS QHZVSDSHUVRU EDG ERRNV$ FDQ XQIRUWXQDWHO\ VRPHWLPHV EH DWWUDFWLYH&

BGPVGSXÂ

EbY cZ h\Y kcfgh dfYîX]WYg _bckb ]g \Y`X Vm h\Y aU^cfx]hm cZ h\Y gc'WU``YX gW\cÙfg cZ cif h]aY& k\c WÙ]a h\Uh UdYfgcb WUb `]jY k]h\cih ZU]h\(

J\fci[\cih h\Y WYbhif]Yg& ]b YjYfm U[Y& dYcd`Y \UjY kUbhYXhc _bck cf Uh `YUgh \UjY U jU[iY ]XYU UVcih h\Y gcifWY& h\YVY[]bb]b[& UbX h\Y Z]bU` difdcgY cZ h\Y]f Yl]ghYbWY( HY`][]cbgUh]gZ]Yg h\]g fYei]fYaYbh& UbX aU_Yg W`YUf h\cgY WcbbYWxh]cbg k\]W\ ib]hY U`` dYcd`Y Ug Vfch\Yfg& fYjYU`]b[ hc h\Yah\Uh h\Ym \UjY h\Y gUaY gcifWY cZ cf][]b& h\Y gUaY hUg_Zcf h\Y]f `]jYg& UbX h\Y gUaY [YbYfU` Z]bU` [cU`(

TTTTT v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

J\Y YggYbh]U` aYUb]b[ cZ YjYfm fY`][]cb ]g hc UbgkYf h\YeiYgh]cb sM\m Xc ? `]jY& UbX k\Uh ]g am Uhh]hiXY hc h\Y`]a]h`Ygg kcf`X k\]W\ giffcibXg aY6t J\YfY ]g bch U g]bx[`Y fY`][]cb& Zfca h\Y acgh gcd\]gh]WUhYX hc h\Y acghdf]a]h]jY& k\]W\ XcYg bch \UjY Ug ]hg VUg]g h\Y XYZ]b]h]cbcZ h\]g Uhh]hiXY cZ U dYfgcb hc h\Y kcf`X(

7h h\Y \YUfh cZ U`` fY`][]cbg `]Yg U g]b[`Y ib]Zm]b[ hfih\( BYhFYfg]Ubg VYUf h\Y]f hUcj]Xg& @Ykg kYUf h\Y]f WUdg& 9\f]gh]UbgVYUf h\Y]f Wfcgg& Cig`]ag VYUf h\Y]f g]W_`Y accb& Vih kY\UjY hc fYaYaVYf h\Uh h\YgY UfY U`` cb`m cihYf g][bg( J\Y[YbYfU` YggYbWY cZ U`` fY`][]cbg ]g `cjY hc mcif bY][\Vcf&UbX h\Uh h\]g ]g fYeiYghYX Vm CUbih& PcfcUghYf& 8iXX\U&CcgYg& IcWfUhYg& @Ygig& IU]bh FUi`& UbX Cc\UaaYX U`]_Y(

v;M7B: <BK=;B

?KH OLIH RI D SHUVRQ ZLWKRXW IDLWK LV WKH OLIH RI DQ DQLPDO&

BGPVGSXÃ

J\cgY k\c _bck h\Y fi`Yg cZ hfiY k]gXca UfY VUgYf h\Ubh\cgY k\c `cjY h\Ya( J\cgY k\c `cjY h\Ya UfY VUgYfh\Ub h\cgY k\c Zc``ck h\Ya(

v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh eiYgh]cb hc _YYd VYZcfY cifgY`jYg Uh U``h]aYg ]g h\]g4 :c kY Xc h\Y f][\h h\]b[6 :if]b[ h\]g g\cfhdYf]cX cZ h]aY k\]W\ kY WU`` cif `]ZY& Xc cif UWhg WcbZcfahc h\Y k]`` cZ h\Y ZcfWY h\Uh gYbh ig ]bhc h\Y kcf`X6 :c kYXc h\Y f][\h h\]b[g

BKHQ ( DP LQ GLIILFXOW FLUFXPVWDQFHV$ 5 DVN 3RG WR KHOS PH&.XW LW LV P\ GXW\ WR VHUYH WKH 8RUG$ DQG QRW 4LV WR VHUYH PH&-V VRRQ DV 5 UHPHPEHU WKLV$ P\ EXUGHQ EHFRPHV OLJKWHU&

MY \UjY hc Zi`Z]`` \cbYgh`m UbX ]ffYdfcUW\UV`m h\Y kcf_XYgh]bYX Zcf ig( ?h XcYg bch aUhhYf k\Yh\Yf kY \cdY h\UhkY k]`` VYWcaY Ub[Y`g gcaY XUm& cf VY`]YjY h\Uh kY \UjYcf][]bUhYX Zfca g`i[g(

v@E>D HKIA?D

@igh ]aU[]bY h\Uh h\Y difdcgY cZ mcif `]ZY ]g mcif \Udd]xbYgg cb`mvh\Yb `]ZY VYWcaYg U WfiY` UbX gYbgY`Ygg h\]b[(Oci \UjY hc YaVfUWY k\Uh h\Y k]gXca cZ \iaUb]hm& mcif]bhY``YWh& UbX mcif \YUfh hY`` mci4 h\Uh h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY]g hc gYfjY h\Y ZcfWY h\Uh gYbh mci ]bhc h\Y kcf`X( J\Yb `]ZYVYWcaYg U WcbghUbh ^cm(

BGPVGSXÄ

;jYb ]Z kY Xcbrh kUbh hc& kY WUbrh \Y`d Vih ZYY` cif WcbxbYWh]cb hc h\Y fYgh cZ aUb_]bX4 kY UfY WcbbYWhYX Vm]bXighfm& Vm hfUXY& Vm Ufh& Vm _bck`YX[Y& UbX acgh ]adcfxhUbh`m& Vm cif Wcaacb acfhU`]hm(

7LQG SHRSOH KHOS HDFK RWKHU HYHQ ZLWKRXW QRWLFLQJ WKDW WKH\ DUHGRLQJ VR$ DQG HYLO SHRSOH DFW DJDLQVW HDFK RWKHU RQ SXUSRVH$

v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

;jYfm dYfgcb \Ug \]g VifXYb( EbY WUbbch `]jY k]h\cihh\Y giddcfh cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y5 h\YfYZcfY kY \UjY hc giddcfhYUW\ ch\Yf k]h\ Wcbgc`Uh]cb& UXj]WY& UbX aihiU` kUfb]b[g(

S<fca h\Y 8EEA E< :?L?D; J>EK=>JI

7`` h\Y W\]`XfYb cZ 7XUa UfY aYaVYfg cZ h\Y gUaY VcXm(M\Yb cbY aYaVYf giZZYfg& U`` h\Y ch\Yfg giZZYf Ug kY``( ?Zmci UfY ]bX]ZZYfYbh hc h\Y giZZYf]b[g cZ ch\Yfg& mci Xc bchXYgYfjY hc VY WU``YX U aUb(

vCKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

J\Y \]ghcfm cZ aUb_]bX ]g h\Y acjYaYbh cZ \iaUb]hmhckUfX [fYUhYf UbX [fYUhYf ib]Z]WUh]cb(

BGPVGSXĀ

IcaYh]aYg& h\Y XUaU[Y XcbY Vm cif kcfXg ]g cVj]cigUbX gcaYh]aYg ]h ]gbrh& Vih h\Y XUaU[Y ]g bch Ubm gaU``Yfcf cif bch VY]b[ UV`Y hc gYY h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c giZZYfZfca cif kcfXg(

7 [ibg\ch kcibX aUm VY WifYX& Vih h\Y kcibX aUXY VmU hcb[iY bYjYf \YU`g(

vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

?Z Ubm aUb cZZYbX bih ]b kcfX& h\Y gUaY ]g U dYfZYWhaUb(((( ;jYb gc h\Y hcb[iY ]g U `]hh`Y aYaVYf& UbX VcUgh'Yh\ [fYUh h\]b[g( 8Y\c`X& \ck [fYUh U aUhhYf U `]hh`Y Z]fY_]bX`Yh\

v@UaYg -4,& /

M\Yb mci \YUf dYcd`Y gdYU_ UVcih h\Y j]W]cigbYgg cZch\Yf dYcd`Y& Xc bch g\UfY ]b d`YUgifY Vm X]gWigg]b[ h\YgY]ggiYg( M\Yb mci \YUf UVcih h\Y VUX XYYXg cZ dYcd`Y& Xcbch `]ghYb hc h\Y YbX UbX hfm hc Zcf[Yh k\Uh mci \UjY\YUfX( M\Yb mci \YUf UVcih h\Y j]fhiYg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y&fYaYaVYf h\Ya UbX hY`` h\Ya hc ch\Yfg(

v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

:c `]ghYb hc X]gdihYg& Vih VY bch gc ]bjc`jYX ]b X]gdihYgmcifgY`Z(

vD?AEB7? =E=EB

? gU]X& ? k]`` hU_Y \YYX hc am kUmg& h\Uh ? g]b bch k]h\ amhcb[iY(

vFI7BCI -34+

.H DIUDLG WR GHVWUR\ WKH XQLW\ RI SHRSOH E\ VWLUULQJ EDG IHHOcLQJV DPRQJVW WKHP DJDLQVW DQRWKHU ZLWK \RXU ZRUGV&

BGPVGSXĂ

?hrg ]adcfhUbh hc ghf]jY hc Xc [ccX& UbX YjYb acfY ]adcfxhUbh hc ghf]jY hc UVghU]b Zfca Yj]`(

7VghYbh]cb g\ci`X VY U \UV]h ]b mcif `]ZY5 ]h g\ci`X gidxdcfh mci ]b mcif j]fhiYg( <cf \Y k\c ]g fYgcìhY ]b [ccXxbYgg& h\YfY ]g bch\]b[ h\Uh \Y Wci`X bch cjYfWcaY(

vB7E'JPK

Fih Uh `YUgh \U`Z cZ mcif YbYf[m ]bhc aU_]b[ mcifgY`Z ZfYY cZYadhm k]g\Yg& UbX jYfm gccb mci k]`` gYY h\Uh ]b gc Xc]b[mci k]`` fYWY]jY aiW\ [fYUhYf Zi`Z]`àYbh UbX \Udd]bYgg(

v7ZhYf ;F?9J;JKI

=cX hYghg YjYfmcbY& cbY k]h\ kYU`h\& Ubch\Yf k]h\dcjYfhm( 7 f]W\ aUb ]g hYghYX ]b k\Yh\Yf \Y kci`X YlhYbXUb Ufa cZ giddcfh hc h\cgY k\c bYYX ]h5 U dccf aUb ]bk\Yh\Yf \Y kci`X VYUf U`` \]g giZZYf]b[g k]h\cih X]gWcbxhYbh UbX k]h\ cVYX]YbWY(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

? k]`` WU`` h\Y f][\h [fcca \Y k\c WUb ghcd \]g fU[Y& k\]W\[cYg Ug ZUgh Ug h\Y ZUghYgh W\Uf]ch( Eh\Yf dYcd`Y \UjY bcdckYf5 h\Ym îgh \c`X h\Y fY]bg(

v:>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

:R PDWWHU KRZ PDQ\ WLPHV \RX DLP WR DFKLHYH YLFWRU\ RYHU\RXU SDVVLRQV$ GR QRW JLYH XS& 1YHU\ HIIRUW ZHDNHQV WKHSRZHU RI SDVVLRQ DQG PDNHV LW HDVLHU WR JDLQ YLFWRU\ RYHU LW&

BGPVGSXÅ

A]bXbYgg ]g bYWYggUfm ]b fYÙh]cbg\]dg k]h\ dYcd`Y( ?Z mci]fY bch _]bX hc U dYfgcb& mci UfY bch Zi`Z]``]b[ mcif aU^cfcV`][Uh]cb(

Oci \UjY hc fYgdYWh YjYfm dYfgcb& bc aUhhYf \ck a]gYfxUV`Y cf f]X]Wi`cig \Y cf g\Y aUm VY( Oci g\ci`X fYaYaVYfh\Uh ]b YjYfm dYfgcb `]jYg h\Y gUaY gd]f]h k\]W\ `]jYg ]b ig(

v7ZhYf 7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

0R QRW EH FUXHO RI KHDUW WR WKRVH ZKR DUH WHPSWHG$ EXW WU\ WRFRQVROH WKHP$ MXVW DV \RX ZRXOG OLNH WR EH FRPIRUWHG& T

v<fca h\Y 8EEA E< :?L?D; J>EK=>JI

#+$ :c bch dcghdcbY Zcf hcacffck k\Uh mci WUb XchcXUm( #,$ :c bch ZcfWY Ubch\Yf dYfgcb hc Xc k\Uh mciWUb Xc Vm mcifgY`Z( #-$ Ff]XY Wcghg acfY h\Ub U`` h\Uh ]gbYWYggUfm" Zcf ZccX& Xf]b_& g\Y`hYf& cf XfYgg( #.$ MY giZZYfgc aiW\& h\]b_]b[ UVcih k\Uh Wci`X \UjY \UddYbYX& Vihbch UVcih k\Uh \Ug UWhiU``m \UddYbYX( #/$ ?Z mci `cgYmcif hYadYf& Wcibh id hc hYb VYZcfY mci Xc cf gUm Ubmxh\]b[( ?Z mci \UjYbrh WUàYX Xckb& h\Yb Wcibh hc U \ibxXfYX5 UbX ]Z mci \UjY bch WUàYX Xckb UZhYf h\]g& Wcibhid hc U h\cigUbX(

v7ZhYf J>EC7I @;<<;HIED

J\Y _]bXYf UbX h\Y acfY h\ci[\hZi` U dYfgcb ]g& h\Y acfY_]bXbYgg \Y WUb Z]bX ]b ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

A]bXbYgg Ybf]W\Yg cif `]ZY5 k]h\ _]bXbYgg amghYf]cig h\]b[gVYWcaY W`YUf& X]ZZ]Wi`h h\]b[g VYWcaY YUgm& UbX Xi``h\]b[g VYWcaY W\YYfZi`(

BGPVGSXǺ

9\f]gh]Ub hYUW\]b[ ]g gc g]ad`Y h\Uh YjYb gaU`` W\]`XfYbWUb ibXYfghUbX ]hg aYUb]b[( J\cgY dYcd`Y WUbbch ibXYfxghUbX ]h& UbX cb`m h\cgY& k\c kUbh hc gYYa UbX hc VYWU``YX 9\f]gh]Ubg k]h\cih VY]b[ fYU` 9\f]gh]Ubg(

8iXX\U gU]X& s7 aUb k\c ghUfhg hc `]jY Zcf \]g gci` ]g `]_YU aUb k\c Vf]b[g U `UbhYfb ]bhc U XUf_ \cigY( J\Y XUf_xbYgg X]gUddYUfg Uh cbWY( Oci \UjY hc VY dYfg]ghYbh ]b h\]g&UbX mcif gci` k]`` \UjY h\]g `][\h(t

9\f]gh YldfYggYX U`` >]g hYUW\]b[g ]b >]g `Ugh WcaaUbXxaYbh4 sBcjY YUW\& ch\Yf& Ug ? `cjYX mci( ;jYfmcbY k]`` gYYh\Uh mci UfY am X]gW]d`Yg& ]Z mci `cjY YUW\ ch\Yf(t >Y X]Xbch gUm& s?Z mci VY`]YjY&t Vih s?Z mci `cjY(t <U]h\ WUbW\Ub[Y k]h\ h]aY& VYWUigY cif _bck`YX[Y ]g WcbghUbh`mW\Ub[]b[( BcjY& cb h\Y WcbhfUfm& bYjYf W\Ub[Yg5 `cjY ]gYhYfbU`(

Cm fY`][]cb ]g `cjY hc U`` `]j]b[ VY]b[g(

5Q RUGHU WR IXOILOO /KULVWLDQLW\$ ZH KDYH WR GHVWUR\ LWV SHUYHUcVLRQV DQG UHVWRUH LWV SXULW\&

BGPVGSXĄ

Abck`YX[Y ]g fYU` _bck`YX[Y cb`m k\Yb ]h ]g UWei]fYX Vmh\Y YZZcfhg cZ mcif ]bhY``YWh& bch Vm aYacfm(

Eb`m k\Yb kY Zcf[Yh k\Uh kY kYfY hUi[\h Xc kY ghUfh hc\UjY fYU` _bck`YX[Y(


7 WcbghUbh Z`ck cZ h\ci[\hg YldfYggYX Vm ch\Yf dYcd`YWUb ghcd UbX XYUXYb mcif ckb h\ci[\h UbX mcif ckb ]b]xh]Uh]jY( ( ( ( J\Uh ]Sk\m WcbghUbh `YUfb]b[ gcZhYbg mcifVfU]b( ((( Ihcdd]b[ h\Y WfYUh]cb cZ mcif ckb h\ci[\hg hc[]jY fcca Zcf h\Y h\ci[\hg Zfca ch\Yf Vcc_g fYa]bXg aYcZ I\U_YgdYUfYrg fYaUf_ UVcih \]g WcbhYadcfUf]Yg k\cgc`X h\Y]f `UbX ]b cfXYf hc gYY ch\Yf Wcibhf]Yg(

v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

7 h\ci[\h WUb UXjUbWY mcif `]ZY ]b h\Y f][\h X]fYWh]cbcb`m k\Yb ]h UbgkYfg eiYgh]cbg k\]W\ kYfY Ug_YX Vm mcifgci`( 7 h\ci[\h k\]W\ kUg Z]fgh VcffckYX Zfca gcaYcbYY`gY UbX h\Yb UWWYdhYX Vm mcif a]bX UbX aYacfm XcYgbch fYU``m aiW\ ]bZ`iYbWY mcif `]ZY& UbX gcaYh]aYg `YUXgmci ]b h\Y kfcb[ X]fYWh]cb(

=HDG OHVV$ VWXG\ OHVV$ EXW WKLQN PRUH& 8HDUQ$ ERWK IURP \RXUWHDFKHUV DQG IURP WKH ERRNV ZKLFK \RX UHDG$ RQO\ WKRVHWKLQJV ZKLFK \RX UHDOO\ QHHG DQG ZKLFK \RX UHDOO\ ZDQW WRNQRZ&

BGPVGSXÁÀ

J\Y VUg]g cZ U`` YXiWUh]cb ]g h\Y YghUV`]g\aYbh cZ cif fY`Uxh]cbg\]d hc h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ U`` h\]b[g& UbX h\Y WcbW`ixg]cbg UVcih cif VY\Uj]cf k\]W\ aUm VY XfUkb Zfca h\]g(

8ih k\cgcYjYf g\U`` cZZYbX cbY cZ h\YgY `]hh`Y cbYg k\cVY`]YjY ]b aY& ]h kYfY VYhhYf Zcf \]a h\Uh U a]``ghcbY kYfY\Ub[YX UVcih \]g bYW_& UbX h\Uh \Y kYfY XfckbYX ]b h\YXYdh\ cZ h\Y gYU(

vC7JJ>;M +240'1

7g kY Vf]b[ id cif W\]`XfYb& kY \UjY hc fYaYaVYf h\UhkY UfY WUfYhU_Yfg cZ h\Y ZihifY( 8m ]adfcj]b[ h\Y]f YXiWUxh]cb& kY ]adfcjY h\Y ZihifY cZ aUb_]bX& h\Y ZihifY cZ h\]gkcf`X(

v7ZhYf ?CC7DK;B A7DJ

( WKLQN WKDW WKH PDMRU REOLJDWLRQ RI SDUHQWV DQG HGXFDWRUV LVWR JLYH FKLOGUHQ DQ XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH GLYLQH EHJLQQLQJWKDW H[LVWV ZLWKLQ WKHP&

vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

HY`][]cig idVf]b[]b[ ]g h\Y VUg]g cZ U`` YXiWUh]cb(

BGPVGSXÁÁ

FYfZYWh]cb ]g ]adcgg]V`Y k]h\cih \ia]`]hm( sM\m g\ci`X ?ghf]jY Zcf dYfZYWh]cb& ]Z ? Ua U`fYUXm [ccX Ybci[\6t

J\Y \][\Yf h\Y dcg]h]cb mci cWWidm Uacb[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y&h\Y acfY \iaV`Y mci g\ci`X VY( CUbm dYcd`Y `]jY ]b\Y][\h UbX [`cfm& Vih h\Y amghYf]Yg cZ h\]g kcf`X WUb VYfYjYU`YX cb`m hc h\cgY k\c UfY \iaV`Y( :c bch gYY_ cihWcad`]WUh]cb( JfYUh mcif Xihm k]h\ fYgdYWh( :c bch ghiXmk\Uh mci g\ci`X bch( CcfY h\]b[g \UjY U`fYUXm VYYbfYjYU`YX hc mci h\Ub mci WUb ibXYfghUbX(

v<fca 7FE9HOF>7

J\Y Icb cZ aUb WUaY bch hc VY a]b]ghYfYX ibhc& Vih hca]b]ghYf& UbX hc []jY \]g `]ZY Ug fUbgca Zcf aUbm(

vC7JJ>;M ,*4,2

IcaY cZ mcif Zf]YbXg dfU]gY mci& UbX ch\Yfg VÙaY UbXWf]h]W]nY mci5 VY W`cgYf hc h\cgY k\c VÙaY mci UbX Zifxh\Yf Zfca h\cgY k\c dfU]gY mci(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

M\Yb Ub Uffck XcYg bch \]h ]hg hUf[Yh& h\Y aUf_gaUbVÙaYg \]agY`Z& bch Ubch\Yf dYfgcb( 7 k]gY aUb VY\UjYg]b h\Y gUaY kUm(

TTTTTTTTTTv9ED<K9?KI

=HPHPEHU DOO WKH EDG WKLQJV ZKLFK \RX KDYH GRQH$ DQG WU\WF DYRLG GRLQJ EDG WKLQJV DJDLQ& =HPHPEHULQJ RQO\ \RXUJRRG GHHGV ZLOO LQWHUIHUH ZLWK \RXU GRLQJ JRRG LQ WKH IXWXUH&

BGPVGSXÁÂ

J\YfY UfY dYcd`Y k\c hU_Y fYgdcbg]V]`]hm Zcf aU_]b[ XYW]xg]cbg Zcf ch\Yfg UbX XYhYfa]b]b[ h\Y]f fY`Uh]cbg\]d hc=cX UbX hc h\Y kcf`X5 UbX h\YfY UfY dYcd`Y& h\Y cjYfxk\Y`a]b[ aU^cf]hm cZ h\Ya& k\c []jY h\]g Uih\cf]hm hch\Y ch\Yfg& UbX V`]bX`m VY`]YjY ]b YjYfmh\]b[ h\Ym UfY hc`X(8ch\ [fcidg cZ dYcd`Y Wcaa]h Ub YeiU` Wf]aY(

MY UfY U`` `]_Y W\]`XfYb k\c Z]fgh fYdYUh h\Y ibeiYgh]cbxUV`Y shfih\t hc`X hc ig Vm cif [fUbXach\Yfg& h\Yb h\Yshfih\t hc`X hc ig Vm cif hYUW\Yfg& UbX h\Yb& k\Yb kYVYWcaY c`XYf& h\Y shfih\t hc`X hc ig Vm dfca]bYbh dYcd`Y(

v7ZhYf H7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

8YkUfY cZ ZU`gY dfcd\Yhg& k\]W\ WcaY hc mci ]b g\YYdrgW`ch\]b[& Vih ]bkUfX`m h\Ym UfY fUjYb]b[ kc`jYg( OY g\U``_bck h\Ya Vm h\Y]f Zfi]hg( :c aYb [Uh\Yf [fUdYg cZ h\cfbg&cf Z][g cZ h\]gh`Yg6 ;jYb gc YjYfm [ccX hfYY Vf]b[Yh\ Zcfh\[ccX Zfi]h5 Vih U Wcffidh hfYY Vf]b[Yh\ Zcfh\ Yj]` Zfi]h( 7[ccX hfYY WUbbch Vf]b[ Zcfh\ Yj]` Zfi]h& bY]h\Yf WUb U WcffidhhfYY Vf]b[ Zcfh\ [ccX Zfi]h( ;jYfm hfYY h\Uh Vf]b[Yh\ bchZcfh\ [ccX Zfi]h ]g \Ykb Xckb& UbX WUgh ]bhc h\Y Z]fY(M\YfYZcfY Vm h\Y]f Zfi]hg mY g\U`` _bck h\Ya(

vC7JJ>;M 14+/',*

7 aUb g\ci`X igY h\Uh gd]f]hiU` \Yf]hU[Y k\]W\ \Y \UgfYWY]jYX Zfca h\Y k]gY UbX \c`m dYcd`Y cZ h\Y dUgh& Vih \Yg\ci`X hYgh YjYfmh\]b[ k]h\ \]g ]bhY``YWh& UWWYdh]b[ WYfhU]bh\]b[g UbX fY^YWh]b[ ch\Yfg(

1YHU\ SHUVRQ VKRXOG GHILQH IRU KLPVHOI KLV DWWLWXGH WR WKLVZRUOG DQG WR /RG&

BGPVGSXÁÃ

<U]h\ ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY UbX h\YUWWYdhUbWY cZ h\cgY Xih]Yg UbX fYgdcbg]V]`]h]Yg WcbbYWhYXhc ]h(

BKR LV D JRRG PDQ, ;QO\ D PDQ ZKR KDV IDLWK LV JRRG&BKDW LV IDLWK , ?KLV LV ZKHQ \RXU ZLOO LV LQ FRQVHQW ZLWK WKHZRUOG_V FRQVFLHQFH DQG WKH ZRUOG_V ZLVGRP&

v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

MY g\ci`X Xc cb`m cbY h\]b[4 []jY cifgY`jYg ]bhc h\Y \UbXgcZ =cX& k\UhYjYf cif i`h]aUhY ZUhY( 7``ck h\Uh k\]W\g\ci`X \UddYb hc \UddYb( M\Uh k]`` \UddYb k]`` VY [ccX(

v>;DHO 7C?;B

J\Ym gUm h\Uh @iX[aYbh :Um k]`` WcaY UbX h\Uh =cX k]``VY Zif]cig( 8ih U [ccX =cX WUbbch Vf]b[ Ubmh\]b[ Vih[ccX( :c bch VY UZfU]X4 h\Y YbX k]`` VY Zi`` cZ ^cm(

vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

Oci g\ci`X bch kcffm hcc aiW\ UVcih k\Uh k]`` \UddYbUZhYf XYUh\( :Y`]jYf mcifgY`Z hc h\Y X]j]bY WfYUhifY UbXV`Ygg ]h4 mci _bck h\Uh ]h ]g `cjY& h\YfYZcfY& k\m g\ci`Xmci VY UZfU]X6M\Yb 9\f]gh X]YX& \Y gU]X& s<Uh\Yf ? XY`]jYf am gd]f]h

]bhc J\m \UbXg(t J\cgY k\c gUm h\YgY kcfXg& bch k]h\h\Y]f hcb[iY Vih k]h\ U`` h\Y]f \YUfh& Xc bch bYYX Ubmh\]b[Y`gY( ?Z am gd]f]h fYhifbg VUW_ hc ]hg <Uh\Yf& h\]g ]g h\Y VYghd`UWY Zcf ]h& UbX bch\]b[ WUb VY VYhhYf(

:cbrh h\]b_ h\Uh mci WUb Z]bX dYUWY Zcf mcif gci` k]h\cihZU]h\(

BGPVGSXÁÄ

Oci g\ci`X `cjY cb`m cbY h\]b[ ]b mcifgY`Z& h\Uh k\]W\ ]gh\Y gUaY ]b U`` cZ ig( ?b `cj]b[ h\Uh k\]W\ ]g h\Y gUaY ]b U``cZ ig& mci `cjY =cX(

CUghYf& k\]W\ ]g h\Y [fYUh WcaaUbXaYbh ]b h\Y `Uk6@Ygig gU]X ibh]` \]a& J\ci g\U`h `cjY h\Y BcfX h\m =cXk]h\ U`` h\m \YUfh& UbX k]h\ U`` h\m gci`& UbX k]h\ U`` h\ma]bX( J\]g ]g h\Y Z]fgh UbX [fYUh WcaaUbXaYbh( 7bX X]YgYWcbX ]g `]_Y ibhc ]h& J\ci g\U`h `cjY h\m bY][\Vcf Ugh\mgY`Z( Eb h\YgY hkc WcaaUbXaYbh6 \Ub[ U`` h\Y `UkUbX h\Y dfcd\Yhg(

vC7JJ>;M ,,'-0'.*

<HRSOH OLYH E\ ORYH* ORYH RI \RXUVHOI LV WKH EHJLQQLQJ RI GHDWK+ORYH RI RWKHU SHRSOH DQG RI 3RG LV WKH EHJLQQLQJ RI OLIH&

=cX ]g `cjY( 7bX \Y k\c `]jYg ]b `cjY& `]jYg ]b =cX& UbX=cX `]jYg ]b \]a( ?Z kY `cjY cbY Ubch\Yf& =cX `]jYg ]b ig(

v? @E>D& Zfca 9\UdhYf .

BcjY ]g bch U gcifWY& ]h ]g U WcbgYeiYbWY cZ cif ibXYfxghUbX]b[ h\Y X]j]bY& gd]f]hiU` VY[]bb]b[ k\]W\ Yl]ghg ]b U``cZ ig(

BGPVGSXÁĀ

J\Y [fYUhYgh hfih\ cZ h\Y hYUW\]b[g cZ 9\f]gh ]g h\Y X]fYWhWcbbYWh]cb VYhkYYb U aUb #=cXrg gcb$ UbX =cX #>]g<Uh\Yf$(

Oci Ug_ aYj k\Uh h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh ZYUhifY cZ 9\f]gh"gW\UfUWhYf kUg( ? k]`` UbgkYf mci4 ]h kUg \]g WcbZ]XYbWY ]bh\Y [fYUhbYgg cZ h\Y \iaUb gci`( >Y gUk ]b U dYfgcb h\YfYZ`YWh]cb cZ =cXrg ]aU[Y& UbX& h\YfYZcfY& \Y `cjYX YjYfmxcbY& k\cYjYf U dYfgcb kUg& k]h\cih fY[UfX hc \]g `]ZY cfW\UfUWhYf5v

v7ZhYfM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

8ch\ dYcd`Y UbX bUh]cbg aigh [Yh f]X cZ dfYîX]WYg( <YY`mcifgY`Z hU`_]b[ X]fYWh`m hc =cX4 Xcbrh fYUX h\Y Vcc_&fYUX mcif gci`5 h\Yb U gaU`` W\UdY` k]`` VYWcaY Ug V][ Ugh\Y \YUjYb`m XcaY ]hgY`Z(


J\YfY UfY hkc kUmg cZ ibXYfghUbX]b[ =cX4 Y]h\Yf ]bhY`x`YWhiU``m cf gd]f]hiU``m& VUgYX cb ZU]h\ UbX acfU`]hm( J\Y]bhY``YWhiU` ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ =cX ]g bch fYgcìhY Ybci[\UbX WUb VY giV^YWhYX hc XUb[Yfcig a]ghU_Yg5 gd]f]hiUìbXYfghUbX]b[ cZ =cX fYei]fYg acfU` UWh]cbg( J\]g ZU]h\]g Vch\ bUhifU` UbX gidYfbUhifU`(


.HZDUH RI HYHU\WKLQJ ZKLFK SXWV DQ REVWDFOH EHWZHHQ \RXDQG 3RG&

BGPVGSXÁĂ

2DOVH IDLWK LV WKH PDMRU FDXVH RI PRVW RI RXU PLVIRUWXQHV&

J\Y difdcgY cZ U \iaUb `]ZY ]g hc Vf]b[ h\Y ]ffUh]cbU`VY[]bb]b[ cZ cif `]ZY hc U fUh]cbU` VY[]bb]b[( ?b cfXYf hcgiWWYYX ]b h\]g& hkc h\]b[g UfY ]adcfhUbh4 #+$ hc gYY U``]ffUh]cbU`& ibk]gY h\]b[g ]b `]ZY UbX X]fYWh mcif UhhYbh]cbhc h\Ya UbX ghiXm h\Ya5 #,$ hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y dcgg]V]`]hmcZ U fUh]cbU`& k]gY `]ZY( J\Y aU^cf difdcgY cZ U`` hYUW\Yfg'ScZ aUb_]bX kUg h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y ]ffUh]cbU` UbXfUh]cbU` VY[]bb]b[g ]b cif `]ZY(

MY g\ci`X VY fYUXm hc W\Ub[Y cif j]Ykg Uh Ubm h]aY& UbXg`ci[\ cZZ dfY^iX]WYg& UbX `]jY k]h\ Ub cdYb UbX fYWYdh]jYa]bX( 7 gU]`cf k\c gYhg h\Y gUaY gU]`g U`` h\Y h]aY& k]h\xcih aU_]b[ W\Ub[Yg k\Yb h\Y k]bX W\Ub[Yg& k]`` bYjYffYUW\ \]g \UfVcf(

v>;DHO =;EH=;

7WWYdh h\Y hYUW\]b[ cZ 9\f]gh Ug ]h ]g& W`YUf UbX g]ad`Y5h\Yb mci k]`` gYY h\Uh kY `]jY Uacb[ V][ `]Yg(

BGPVGSXÁÅ

B]jY Zcf mcif gci`& UbX k]h\cih hfm]b[ cf YjYb ibXYfxghUbX]b[ h\Uh mcirfY Xc]b[ ]h& mci k]`` Wcbhf]VihY hc h\Y]adfcjYaYbh cZ gcW]Yhm(

M\m Xc mci hcfhifY mcifgY`Z6 Oci kUbh _]bXbYgg& Vihmci Xc bch _bck k\YfY hc Z]bX ]h( Abck h\Uh mci WUbbchUW\]YjY Ubmh\]b[ k]h\cih =cX(((( =cX ]g mcif cb`m BcfX&mcif cb`m aUghYf& UbX mci Xc bch bYYX Ubch\Yf( =cX k]`àU_Y mci ZfYY(

v<( HE8;HJ :; B7C;DD7?I

?h kci`X VY b4WY ]Z k]gXca \UX giW\ U eiU`]hm h\Uh ]h Wci`XZ`ck Zfca cbY aUb k\c ]g Zi`` cZ k]gXca hc Ubch\Yf aUbk\c \Ug bc k]gXca& îgh Ug k]h\ hkc WcbbYWhYX jYggY`gkUhYf Z`ckg Zfca cbY jYggY` hc h\Y ch\Yf ibh]` h\Y kUhYf`YjY` ]g h\Y gUaY ]b Vch\ cZ h\Ya( J\Y dfcV`Ya ]g h\Uh hccVhU]b k]gXca& mci aigh aU_Y Ub ]bXYdYbXYbh& gYf]cigYZZcfh cZ mcif ckb(

5I \RX FDQ WHDFK D SHUVRQ NLQGQHVV DQG ORYH$ KXW \RX GR QRW$\RX ORVH D EURWKHU&

v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

?adfcjY mcif ckb gci`& UbX VY WcbZ]XYbh h\Uh cb`m ]b gcXc]b[ WUb mci Wcbhf]VihY hc h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ h\YÙf[Yf gcW]Yhm cZ k\]W\ mci UfY dUfh(

BGPVGSXÁǺ

7 gW\c`Uf _bckg aUbm Vcc_g5 U kY``'YXiWUhYX dYfgcb \Ug_bck`YX[Y UbX g_]``g5 Ub Yb`][\hYbYX dYfgcb ibXYfghUbXgh\Y aYUb]b[ UbX difdcgY cZ \]g `]ZY(

J\YfY UfY U `]a]h`Ygg biaVYf cZ X]ZZYfYbh gW]YbWYg& Vihk]h\cih cbY VUg]W gW]YbWY& h\Uh ]g& k\Uh ]g h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ`]ZY UbX k\Uh ]g [ccX Zcf h\Y dYcd`Y& U`` ch\Yf Zcfag cZ_bck`YX[Y UbX Ufh VYWcaY ]X`Y UbX \UfaZi` YbhYfhU]bxaYbh(

MY `]jY U gYbgY`Ygg `]ZY& WcbhfUfm hc h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ`]ZY Vm h\Y k]gYgh dYcd`Y cZ U`` h]aYg( J\]g \UddYbg VYWUigYcif mcib[ [YbYfUh]cbg UfY YXiWUhYX ]b h\Y kfcb[ kUmvh\Ym UfY hUi[\h X]ZZYfYbh gW]YbWYg Vih h\Ym UfY bch hUi[\hh\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY(

?KH RQO\ UHDO VFLHQFH LV WKH NQRZOHGJH RI KRZ D SHUVRQ VKRXOGOLYH KLV OLIH& -QG WKLV NQRZOHGJH LV RSHQ WR HYHU\RQH&

IcW]Yhm WUb VY ]adfcjYX cb`m Vm gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY(

>YUjYb UbX YUfh\ UfY YhYfbU`( J\Ym UfY YhYfbU` VYWUigYh\Ym Xc bch Yl]gh Zcf h\YagY`jYg( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& U hfi`m\c`m dYfgcb XcYg bch `]jY Zcf \]agY`Z& UbX h\YfYZcfY \YWUb VYWcaY YhYfbU`& UbX WUb UW\]YjY Ubmh\]b[(

vB7E'JPK

?KHUH LV RQO\ RQH ODZ$ ERWK LQ \RXU SHUVRQDO DQG VRFLDO OLIH*LI \RX ZDQW WR LPSURYH \RXU VRXO$ \RX VKRXOG EH UHDG\ WR VDFcULILFH LW&

J\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ aUb WUb VY aYUgifYX Vm h\Y `YjY` cZ\]g ]bbYf ZfYYXca( J\Y acfY U dYfgcb VYWcaYg ZfYY Zfca\]g dYfgcbU`]hm& h\Y acfY ZfYYXca \Y \Ug(

BGPVGSXÁĄ

BGPVGSXÂÀ

:YUh\ UbX V]fh\ UfY hkc `]a]hg& UbX gcaYh\]b[ g]a]Ùf ]g\]XXYb VY\]bX YUW\(

M\Yb mci h\]b_ UVcih k\Uh k]`` \UddYb hc mcif gciÙZhYf XYUh\& h\]b_ U`gc UVcih k\Uh \UddYbYX hc mcif gci`VYZcfY mcif V]fh\( ?Z mci dÙb hc [c gcaYk\YfY& h\Yb mciWUaY Zfca gcaYk\YfY(

M\YfY Xc kY [c UZhYf XYUh\6 MY [c hc k\YfY kY WUaYZfca( J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ k\]W\ WUb VY WU``YX cifgY`jYg ]bh\Uh ÙbX5 h\YfYZcfY& kY Xc bch fYaYaVYf k\Uh \Ug \UdxdYbYX hc ig h\YfY(

M\Yb U dYfgcb `YUXg U [ccX `]ZY& \Y ]g \Uddm Uh h\Y dfYgYbhacaYbh UbX \Y XcYg bch h\]b_ k\Uh k]`` \UddYb UZhYf h\]g`]ZY( ?Z \Y h\]b_g cZ XYUh\& \Y `cc_g Uh \ck kY`` h\]g `]ZY ]gÙ]X cih& UbX \Y VY`]YjYg h\Uh UZhYf XYUh\ YjYfmh\]b[ k]`` VYUg [ccX Ug ]h ]g bck( ?h ]g aiW\ VYhhYf hc VY`]YjY h\Uh YjYfmxh\]b[ k\]W\ =cX aU_Yg Zcf ig ]g [ccX h\Ub hc VY`]YjY ]bU`` h\Y d`YUgifYg cZ dUfUX]gY(

BKHQ ZH GLH$ RXU VRXOV EHFRPH IUHH&v7ZhYf >;H79B?JKI

7 dYfgcb g\ci`X bch h\]b_ hcc aiW\ UVcih k\Uh k]`` \UdxdYb UZhYf \]g `]ZY( <c``ck h\Y k]`` cZ h\cgY k\c gYbh ig ]bhch\]g kcf`X5 h\Uh k]`` ]g ]b cif a]bXg UbX cif \YUfhg(

BGPVGSXÂÀ

J\Y acfY W`cgY`m U dYfgcb Zc``ckg \]g ]bhY``YWh UbX Wcbxhfc`g \]g dUgg]cbg& h\Y W`cgYf \Y WcaYg hc gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& hc`cjY cZ =cX UbX cZ \]g bY][\Vcf(

MY kci`X h\]b_ U aUb ]bgUbY k\c& ]bghYUX cZ WcjYf]b[ \]g\cigY k]h\ U fccZ UbX dihh]b[ k]bXckg ]b \]g k]bXckZfUaYg& [cYg cih ]b ghcfam kYUh\Yf& UbX gWc`Xg h\Y k]bX&h\Y fU]b& UbX h\Y W`ciXg( 8ih kY U`` Xc h\Y gUaY k\Yb kYgWc`X UbX V`UaY h\Y Yj]` ]b ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]bghYUX cZ Z][\hx]b[ h\Y Yj]` k\]W\ Yl]ghg ]b ig( ?h ]g dcgg]V`Y hc [Yh f]X cZh\Y Yj]` ]bg]XY cZ ig& Ug ]h ]g dcgg]V`Y hc aU_Y U fccZ UbXk]bXckg Zcf cif \cigY( J\]g ]g dcgg]V`Y( 8ih ]h ]g bch dcgxg]V`Y Zcf ig hc XYghfcm Yj]` ]b h\]g kcf`X& ^igh Ug kY WUbbchcfXYf h\Y kYUh\Yf hc W\Ub[Y UbX h\Y W`ciXg hc X]gUddYUf(?Z& ]bghYUX cZ hYUW\]b[ ch\Yfg& kY kci`X YXiWUhYSUbX]adfcjY cifgY`jYg& h\Yb h\YfY kci`X VY `Ygg Yj]` ]b h\]gkcf`X& UbX U`` dYcd`Y kci`X `]jY VYhhYf `]jYg(

:c bch VY YaVUffUggYX Vm mcif a]ghU_Yg( Dch\]b[ WUbhYUW\ ig VYhhYf h\Ub cif ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Ya( J\]g ]gcbY cZ h\Y VYgh kUmg cZ gY`Z'YXiWUh]cb(

vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

5W VHHPV WR XV WKDW WKH PRVW LPSRUWDQW ZRUN LQ WKH ZRUOG LVWKH ZRUN ZKLFK LV YLVLEOH$ ZKLFK ZH FDQ VHH* EXLOGLQJ DKRXVH$ SORZLQJ WKH ODQG$ IHHGLQJ FDWWOH$ JDWKHULQJ IUXLWV+ DQGWKDW WKH ZRUN ZKLFK LV LQYLVLEOH$ WKH ZRUN GRQH E\ RXU VRXO$LV QRW LPSRUWDQW& .XW RXU LQYLVLEOH ZRUN DW WKH LPSURYHPHQWRI RXU VRXO LV WKH PRVW LPSRUWDQW ZRUN LQ WKH ZRUOG$ DQG DOORWKHU YLVLEOH NLQGV RI ZRUN DUH XVHIXO RQO\ ZKHQ ZH GR WKLVPDMRU ZRUN&

BGPVGSXÂÂ

Dc YlWYdh]cbg cf gdYW]U` W]fWiaghUbWYg WUb îgh]Zm h\YaifXYf cZ U `]j]b[ dYfgcb( CifXYf ]g h\Y acgh ji`[Uf j]cxÙh]cb cZ h\Y BUk cZ =cX Ug ]h ]g YldfYggYX ]b U`` fY`][]cighYUW\]b[g UbX ]b U`` dYcd`Yrg WcbgW]YbWY(

C]`]hUfm gYfj]WY aU_Yg dYcd`Y Wcffidh& VYWUigY h\Y a]`]xhUfm& ]b h]aY cZ dYUWY& UV]XYg ]b Wcad`YhY ]X`YbYggS h\YmÙW_ Ubm igYZi` ÙVcf& h\Ym UfY ZfYYX cZ h\Y cV`][Uh]cbg cZgiW\ kcf_( ?bghYUX& h\Ym WfYUhY bch]cbg cZ \cbcf cZ fY[]xaYbh& cf cZ VUbbYf& cf h\Y Wcad`YhY giVî[Uh]cb cZ cbYdYfgcb Vm Ubch\Yf(M\Yb W]j]`]Ubg [Yh ]bhc h\YgY W]fWiaghUbWYg& h\Ym

VYWcaY Ug\UaYX cZ giW\ U kUm cZ `]ZY( J\Y a]`]hUfm& cb h\YWcbhfUfm& UfY dfciX cZ ]h UbX VcUgh cZ h\]g kUm cZ `]ZY&YgdYW]U``m Xif]b[ dYf]cXg cZ kUf( J\Ym gUm4 sMY UfY fYUXmhc f]g_ cif `]jYg Uh kUf& UbX h\YfYZcfY giW\ U WUfY`Ygg ^cmZi``]ZY ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf ig& UbX kY \UjY h\Y f][\h hc `YUX ]h(t

?KH VDPH GLYLQH EHJLQQLQJ OLYHV LQ DOO SHRSOH$ DQG QR VLQJOHSHUVRQ RU JDWKHULQJ RI SHRSOH KDV WKH ULJKW WR GHVWUR\ WKLV FRQcQHFWLRQ EHWZHHQ WKH GLYLQH EHJLQQLQJ DQG D KXPDQ ERG\$WKDW LV$ WR WDNH D KXPDQ OLIH&

BGPVGSXÂÃ

7acb[ U`` g]bg& h\YfY ]g cbY k\]W\ Wcad`YhY`m cddcgYg h\YaU^cf V`Ygg]b[ cZ \iaUb `]ZY& k\]W\ ]g mcif `cjY Zcf mcifVfch\Yf4 h\YfY ]g bc kcfgY g]b h\Ub hc XYghfcm h\]g aU^cf^cm cZ `]ZY& Vm ZYY`]b[ fU[Y UbX \UhfYX Zcf mcif Vfch\Yf(

IYbYWU& U k]gY aUb Zfca HcaY& gU]X h\Uh k\Yb mci kUbhhc YgWUdY Zfca mcif fU[Y& k\Yb mci ZYY` h\Uh ]h [fckg& h\YVYgh h\]b[ hc XU]g hc ghcd( :c bch Xc Ubmh\]b[4 Xc bchkU`_& Xc bch acjY& Xc bch gdYU_( ?Z mcif VcXm cf mcifhcb[iY acjYg Uh h\]g acaYbh& h\Yb mcif fU[Y k]`` [fck(HU[Y ]g jYfm \UfaZi` Zcf U`` dYcd`Y& Vih ]h ]g acgh \Ufax

Zi` Zcf h\Y aUb k\c YldYf]YbWYg ]h(

7b Yj]` dYfgcb XUaU[Yg bch cb`m ch\Yfg Vih \]agY`Z(v7ZhYf IE9H7J;ITTTTTTTT5

Ocif YbYam k]`` dUm mci VUW_ k]h\ fU[Y& k]`` aU_Y mcigiZZYf& Vih h\Y V][[Ygh XUaU[Y hc mci k]`` VY WUigYX Vmh\Y fU[Y UbX \UhfYX Yl]gh]b[ ]b mcif \YUfh( DY]h\Yf mcifZUh\Yf& bcf mcif ach\Yf& bcf U`` mcif ZUa]`m WUb aU_Y mciacfY [ccX h\Ub mcif \YUfh WUb k\Yb ]h Zcf[]jYg UbX Zcfx[Yhg ]hg UVigY(


CRXU UDJH FDQQRW EH MXVWLILHG E\ DQ\WKLQJ& ?KH UHDVRQ IRU\RXU UDJH LV DOZD\V LQVLGH \RX&

!# "$ ÂÄDcVcXm _bckg k\YfY h\Y \iaUb fUWY ]g [c]b[( J\Y \][\xYgh k]gXca& h\Yb& ]g hc _bck k\YfY \RX g\ci`X [c4hckUfX dYfZYWh]cb(

7 k]gY aUb gYY_g k]gXca5 U aUXaUb h\]b_g h\Uh \Y \UgZcibX ]h(

vF;HI?7D FHEL;H8

p5W LV QRW WKH SODFH ZH RFFXS\ ZKLFK LV LPSRUWDQW$ KXW WKHGLUHFWLRQ LQ ZKLFK ZH PRYH&

vEB?L;H M;D:;BB >EBC;I

Ocif UWh]cbg g\ci`X VY XYhYfa]bYX bch Vm h\Y XYg]fY cZh\Y dYcd`Y UfcibX mci& Vih Vm h\Y bYYXg cZ U`` aUb_]bX(

BGPVGSXÂĀ

J\YfY ]g U VUg]W _bck`YX[Y k\]W\ ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf YjYfm\iaUb VY]b[g ibh]` U dYfgcb \Ug UWei]fYX h\]g VUg]W_bck`YX[Y& U`` ch\Yf _]bXg cZ _bck`YX[Y k]`` VY \UfaZi`Zcf \]a(

IcWfUhYg hc`X \]g ghiXYbhg h\Uh ]b [ccX gmghYag cZ YXiWUxh]cb& h\YfY ]g U WYfhU]b `]a]h mci g\ci`X bch [c VYmcbX( ?b[YcaYhfm& \Y gU]X& ]h ]g Ybci[\ hc _bck \ck hc aYUgifYh\Y `UbX k\Yb mci kUbh hc gY`` ]h cf Vim ]h& cf \ck hc g\UfYUb ]b\Yf]hUbWY& cf hc X]j]XY kcf_ Uacb[ kcf_Yfg( >Y X]Xbch `]_Y hcc aUbm gcd\]gh]WUhYX gW]YbWYg5 h\ci[\ \Y _bYkU`` cZ h\Ya( >Y gU]X h\Uh gcd\]gh]WUhYX _bck`YX[YfYei]fYg Ub YlhfU YZZcfh h\Uh hU_Yg h\Y ghiXYbhrg h]aY Zfcah\Y acgh VUg]W UbX h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh \iaUb difgi]h4acfU` dYfZYWh]cb(

vN;DEF>ED

:]jYfh mcif [UnY Zfca h\Y kcf`X cZ `]Yg( :c bch hfighmcif ZYY`]b[g( Eb`m ]b mcifgY`Z& cb`m ]b mcif ]adYfgcbU`gY`Z& WUb mci Z]bX h\Y YhYfbU`(


5W LV EHWWHU WR NQRZ VHYHUDO EDVLF UXOHV RI OLIH WKDQ WR VWXG\PDQ\ XQQHFHVVDU\ VFLHQFHV& ?KH PDMRU UXOHV RI OLIH ZLOO VWRS\RX IURP HYLO DQG VKRZ \RX WKH JRRG SDWK LQ OLIH+ EXW WKHNQRZOHGJH RI PDQ\ XQQHFHVVDU\ VFLHQFHV PD\ OHDG \RX LQWRWKH WHPSWDWLRQ RI SULGH$ DQG VWRS \RX IURP XQGHUVWDQGLQJWKH EDVLF UXOHV RI OLIH&

BGPVGSXÂĂ

7 f]W\ aUb WUbbch VY aYfW]Zi`( ?Z \Y VYWcaYg fYU``m aYfxW]Zi`& \Y k]`` ei]W_`m `cgY \]g f]W\Yg(

Ihcd fcVV]b[ ch\Yfg VYZcfY mci []jY acbYm hc VY[[Ufg(M]h\ h\Y gUaY \UbX h\Uh kY fcV cbY dYfgcb& kY fYkUfXUbch\Yf& []j]b[ hc h\Y dccf h\Y acbYm k\]W\ kY \UjYhU_Yb Zfca h\Y YjYb dccfYf( 8YhhYf bc W\Uf]hm h\Ub h\]g_]bX cZ W\Uf]hm(

vI7?DJ @E>D 9>HOIEIJEC

J\Y VYgh YlUad`Y cZ h\Y WfiY`hm cZ h\Y f]W\ aUbrg `]ZY ]g \]gYZZcfh hc VYWcaY j]fhicig(

.XW ZKRVR KDWK WKLV ZRUOG_V JRRG$ DQG VHHWK KLV EURWKHU KDYHQHHG$ DQG VKXWWHWK XS KLV ERZHOV RI FRPSDVVLRQ IURP KLP$KRZ GZHOOHWK WKH ORYH RI 3RG LQ KLP ,

9\ OLWWOH FKLOGUHQ$ OHW XV QRW ORYH LQ ZRUG+ QHLWKHU LQWRQJXH+ EXW LQ GHHG DQG WUXWK&

v? @E>D -4+1'+2

?b cfXYf hc `cjY bch k]h\ kcfX UbX hcb[iY& Vih ]b XYYXUbX hfih\& YjYfmcbY g\ci`X \Y`d h\cgY k\c Ug_ Zcf \Y`d&gc 9\f]gh gU]X(8ih ]Z mci ghUfh []j]b[ hc U`` h\cgY k\c Ug_& YjYb ]Z mci

UfY jYfm f]W\& jYfm gccb mci k]`` bch VY f]W\ UbmacfY(

BGPVGSXÂÅ

BcjY Zcf ch\Yf dYcd`Y []jYg U fYU` ZYY`]b[ cZ [ccX& UbX ]hib]hYg mci k]h\ ch\Yf dYcd`Y UbX k]h\ =cX(

- ZLVH PDQ ORYHV QRW EHFDXVH KH ZDQWV WR SURILW IURP LW EXWEHFDXVH KH ILQGV EOLVV LQ ORYH LWVHOI&

:c bch fY[fYh h\Y dUgh( M\Uh ]g h\Y igY cZ fY[fYhg6 J\Y `]YgUmg h\Uh mci g\ci`X fY[fYh( J\Y hfih\ gUmg mci g\ci`X VYZ]``YX k]h\ `cjY( Fig\ U`` gUX aYacf]Yg UkUm Zfca mci( :cbch gdYU_ cZ h\Y dUgh( B]jY ]b h\Y `][\h cZ `cjY& UbX U``h\]b[g k]`` VY []jYb hc mci(

vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

J\Ym Ug_YX U 9\]bYgY aUb& sM\Uh ]g gW]YbWY6t >Y gU]X&sIW]YbWY ]g _bck]b[ dYcd`Y(t J\Yb h\Ym Ug_YX& s7bX k\Uh]g j]fhiY6t >Y UbgkYfYX& sL]fhiY ]g `cj]b[ dYcd`Y(t

@igh Ug U ach\Yf dihg \Yf `]ZY Uh f]g_ hc [iUfX UbX gUjY \Yfcb`m W\]`X& gc YjYfm dYfgcb g\ci`X [iUfX UbX gUjY ]b \]axgY`Z `cjY Zcf YjYfm `]j]b[ VY]b[(

J\Y ZYUf`YggbYgg& WU`a& ]bbYf dYUWY& UbX ^cm k\]W\ UfY[]jYb hc ig Vm `cjY UfY gc V][ h\Uh U`` ch\Yf h\]b[g ]b h\Ykcf`X WUbbch VY WcadUfYX k]h\ h\Ya& YgdYW]U``m Zcf h\Y dYfxgcb k\c ibXYfghUbXg h\Y fYU` V`Ygg]b[ cZ `cjY(

BGPVGSXÂǺ

<cf U dYfgcb hc _bck h\Y Ùk h\Uh aU_Yg \]a ZfYY& \Yaigh VY Y`YjUhYX Zfca U aUhYf]U` hc U gd]f]hiU` `]ZY(

? \UjY aUbm h\]b[g hc gUm UbX hc îX[Y cb mci4 Vih \Y h\UhgYbh aY ]g hfiY5 UbX ? gdYU_ hc h\Y kcf`X h\cgY h\]b[gk\]W\ ? \UjY \YUfX cZ \]a( J\Ym ibXYfghccX bch h\Uh \YgdU_Y hc h\Ya cZ h\Y <Uh\Yf( J\Yb gU]X @Ygig ibhc h\Ya&M\Yb mY \UjY `]ZhYX id h\Y Icb cZ aUb& h\Yb g\U`` mY_bck h\Uh ? Ua \Y& UbX h\Uh ? Xc bch\]b[ cZ amgY`Z5 Vih Ugam <Uh\Yf \Uh\ hUi[\h aY& ? gdYU_ h\YgY h\]b[g(

v@E>D 24,0',2

s? UbX =cX UfY h\Y gUaY&t gU]X h\Y hYUW\Yf( ?Z mci h\]b_h\Uh am gd]f]hiU` VY]b[ ]g =cX& mci UfY a]ghU_Yb( 8ih amfYU` gY`Z ]g W`cgY hc =cX& UbX hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y( ?b cfXYf hcibXYfghUbX h\]g dUfh cZ amgY`Z& mci g\ci`X Y`YjUhY h\YaUb ]bg]XY cZ mci( M\Yb mci Y`YjUhY h\Y aUb ]bg]XY cZmci& h\Yb mci k]`` gYY h\Uh h\YfY ]g bc X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb\]a UbX Ubm ch\Yf dYfgcb cb YUfh\(?h cb`m gYYag Ug ]Z kY X]ZZYf Zfca YUW\ ch\Yf( 7 Z`ckYf

cb U V`cggca]b[ hfYY WUb h\]b_ h\Uh ]h ]g U gYdUfUhY VY]b[&Vih U`` Z`ckYfg UfY dUfhg cZ h\Y gUaY V`cggca]b[ cZ cbYUdd`Y hfYY& UbX h\Ym U`` WcaY Zfca cbY gYYX(

BH OLYH D VKRUW SHULRG RI WLPH LQ WKLV ZRUOG$ EXW ZH OLYH LWDFFRUGLQJ WR WKH ODZV RI HWHUQDO OLIH&

v7ZhYf >;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

IiVa]gg]cb hc h\Y Ùk WfYUhYX Vm aYb aU_Yg cbY U gÙjY5cVYX]YbWY hc h\Y Ùk WfYUhYX Vm =cX aU_Yg cbY ZfYY(

BGPVGSXÂĄ

M]gXca ]g _bck]b[ h\Y difdcgY cZ `]ZY& UbX _bck]b[ \ckhc UW\]YjY ]h(

Oci WUb UW\]YjY k]gXca ]b h\fYY kUmg( J\Y Z]fgh kUm ]g h\YkUm cZ aYX]hUh]cb( J\]g ]g h\Y acgh bcV`Y kUm( J\Y gYWcbXkUm ]g h\Y kUm cZ ]a]hUh]cb( J\]g ]g h\Y YUg]Ygh UbX `YUghgUh]gZm]b[ kUm( J\]fX`m& h\YfY ]g h\Y kUm cZ YldYf]YbWY(J\]g ]g h\Y acgh X]ZZ]Wi`h kUm(

v9ED<K9?KI

?KH PHULW RI D PDQ LV QRW LQ WKH NQRZOHGJH KH SRVVHVVHV$ KXWLQ WKH HIIRUW KH PDGH WR DFKLHYH LW&

v=EJJ>EB: ;F>H7?C B;II?D=

?Z mci kUbh hc ghiXm mcifgY`Zv`cc_ ]bhc h\Y \YUfhg cZch\Yf dYcd`Y( ?Z mci kUbh hc ghiXm ch\Yf dYcd`Yv`cc_]bhc mcif ckb \YUfh(

v<H?;:H?9> LED I9>?BB;H

Ocif gci` ]g Vch\ mcif îX[Y UbX mcif dÙWY cZ gUbWhiUfm(Ocif ckb gci` ]g mcif \][\Ygh îX[Y(

vC7DK

J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ ]b k\]W\ fYU` k]gXca WUbbch VY X]gxdÙmYX(

BGPVGSXÃÀ

M\Yb IcWfUhYg kUg Ug_YX k\YfY \Y WUaY Zfca& \Y gU]Xh\Uh \Y kUg U W]h]nYb cZ h\Y kcf`X( >Y fY[UfXYX \]agY`Z UgU W]h]nYb cZ h\Y ib]jYfgY(

vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

M\Yb dYcd`Y kUbhYX hc _]`` U VYUf ]b h\Y UbW]Ybh h]aYg&h\Ym \ib[ U \YUjm `c[ cjYf U Vck` cZ \cbYm( J\Y VYUfkci`X dig\ h\Y `c[ UkUm ]b cfXYf hc YUh h\Y \cbYm( J\Y`c[ kci`X gk]b[ VUW_ UbX \]h h\Y VYUf( J\Y VYUf kci`XVYWcaY ]ff]hUhYX UbX dig\ h\Y `c[ YjYb \UfXYf& UbX ]hkci`X fYhifb UbX \]h \]a \UfXYf ]b fYhifb( J\]g kci`XWcbh]biY ibh]` h\Y `c[ _]``YX h\Y VYUf( FYcd`Y VY\UjY ]b h\YgUaY kUm k\Yb h\Ym fYhifb Yj]` Zcf h\Y Yj]` h\Ym fYWY]jYZfca ch\Yf dYcd`Y( 9Ubrh dYcd`Y VY k]gYf h\Ub VYUfg6

CRX VKRXOG UHVSRQG ZLWK NLQGQHVV WRZDUG HYLO GRQH WR \RX$DQG \RX ZLOO GHVWUR\ LQ DQ HYLO SHUVRQ WKDW SOHDVXUH ZKLFK KHGHULYHV IURP HYLO&

J\Y hfiY hYUW\]b[ cZ `cjY ]g ghfcb[5 ]h _]``g Yj]` VYZcfY Yj]`WUb [fck UbX VYWcaY dckYfZi`(

BGPVGSXÃÁ

Eb`m [fYUh`m ]bgc`Ybh dYcd`Y YghUV`]g\ U fY`][]cig `Ukk\]W\ ]g hc VY hU_Yb Zcf [fUbhYX Vm ch\Yfg& k\]W\ g\ci`XVY UWWYdhYX Vm YjYfmcbY cb ZU]h\& k]h\cih Ubm X]gWigg]cbcf XciVhg(M\m aigh dYcd`Y Xc h\]g6

M\Uh U ghfUb[Y h\]b[ CUbm gWcibXfY`g hfm hc X]g[i]gYh\Y]f X]fhm XYYXg Vm h\Y]f XYX]WUh]cb hc h\Y ]bhYfYghg cZfY`][]cb& cf Vm h\Y]f \][\ acfU`g& cf Vm `cjY Zcf h\Y]fach\Yf`UbX(

v>;?DH?9> >;?D;

8ih VY bch mYh WU``YX HUVV]4 Zcf cbY ]g mcif CUghYf& YjYb9\f]gh5 UbX U`` mY UfY VfYh\fYb( 7bX WU`` bc aUb mcifZUh\Yf idcb h\Y YUfh\4 Zcf cbY ]g mcif <Uh\Yf& k\]W\ ]g ]b\YUjYb( DY]h\Yf VY mY WU``YX aUghYfg4 Zcf cbY ]g mcif CUgxhYf& YjYb 9\f]gh(

vC7JJ>;M ,-42'+*

?KH HVVHQFH RI WKH WHDFKLQJ RI /KULVW LV WR IROORZ KLV FRPcPDQGPHQWV& ?KRVH ZKR MXVW UHSHDW$ `9\ 3RG$ 9\ 8RUGaZLOO QRW JHW WR KHDYHQ+ RQO\ WKRVH ZKR IXOILOO 3RG_V ZLOO&

AJHSVGSXÁ

?h ]g bch dcgg]V`Y hc YldÙ]b h\Y cf][]b cZ h\Y gd]f]hiU`Zfca h\Y aUhYf]U`(

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

v7ZhYfC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\Y \YUfh cZ h\Y aUhhYf ]g k\Yh\Yf kY VY`]YjY cf X]gVY`]YjY ]bh\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ U gd]f]hiU` fYUà( 7`` dYcd`Y UfY X]j]XYX ]bhchkc [fcidg& h\cgY k\c UfY U`]jY UbX h\cgY k\c UfY XYUX5 ]bch\Yf kcfXg& h\cgY k\c VY`]YjY UbX h\cgY k\c Xcbrh(7b ibVY`]YjYf gUmg4 sM\Uh ]g gd]f]h ((( M\Uh ? UhY UbX

k\Uh ? Yb^cmYX& h\]g ]g k\Uh ? dcggYgg& h\]g ]g aUhYf]U` UbXfYU` t 7bX giW\ U dYfgcb& k]h\cih h\]b_]b[ aiW\& hU_YgWUfY cb`m cZ h\Y cihYf h\]b[g& UffUb[]b[ ]b cfXYf cb`m \]gckb aYUb& X]fhm UZZU]fg5 \Y VYWcaYg U `]Uf& U gbcV& U gÙjY&UbX XcYg bch ZYY` Ubm \][\Yf bYYXg4 ZfYYXca& hfih\& UbX`cjY( IiW\ U dYfgcb _YYdg UkUm Zfca h\Y `][\h cZ h\Y ]bhY`x`YWh& VYWUigY ]b ZUWh \Y ]g XYUX& UbX h\]g `][\h []jYg `]ZY cb`mhc `]j]b[ h\]b[g& UbX \UfXYbg UbX fchg h\Y XYUX h\]b[g(

v7B;N7D:H 7HA>7D=;BIAO

J\Y X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb h\Y gd]f]hiU` fYUà UbX h\Y aUhYxf]U` ]g YeiU``m W`YUf UbX cVj]cig& Vch\ Zcf U W\]`X UbX U k]gYaUb5 Zifh\Yf gdYWiÙh]cbg UfY bch bYWYggUfm(

AJHSVGSXÂ

?KHUH DUH WZR GLIIHUHQW VWDWHV RI KXPDQ H[LVWHQFH* ILUVW$ WR OLYHZLWKRXW WKLQNLQJ RI GHDWK+ VHFRQG$ WR OLYH ZLWK WKH WKRXJKW WKDW\RX DSSURDFK GHDWK ZLWK HYHU\ KRXU RI \RXU OLIH&

J\Y acfY mci hfUbgZcfa mcif `]ZY Zfca h\Y aUhYf]U` hch\Y gd]f]hiU` XcaU]b& h\Y `Ygg mci VYWcaY UZfU]X cZ XYUh\(7 dYfgcb k\c `]jYg U hfi`m gd]f]hiU` `]ZY \Ug bc ZYUf cZXYUh\(

M\Yb mci \UjY XciVhg UVcih k\Uh hc Xc& îgh ]aU[]bYh\Uh mci a][\h X]Y Uh h\Y YbX cZ h\Uh gUaY XUm& UbX h\Yb U``mcif XciVhg k]`` X]gUddYUf& UbX mci k]`` gYY W`YUf`m k\Uhmcif WcbgW]YbWY hY``g mci& UbX k\Uh ]g mcif hfiY dYfgcbU`k]g\(

7 aUb WcbXYabYX hc ]aaYX]UhY YlYWih]cb k]`` bch h\]b_UVcih h\Y [fckh\ cZ \]g YghUhY& cf UVcih UW\]Yj]b[ [`cfm&cf UVcih h\Y j]Whcfm cZ cbY [fcid cjYf Ubch\Yf& cf UVcihh\Y X]gWcjYfm cZ U bYk dÙbYh( 8ih cbY a]bihY VYZcfY \]gXYUh\ U aUb aUm k]g\ hc Wcbgc`Y Ub UVigYX dYfgcb& cf\Y`d Ub c`X dYfgcb hc ghUbX id& cf hc dih U VUbXU[Y cbgcaYcbYrg ]bîfm& cf hc fYdU]f U hcm Zcf U W\]`X(

AJHSVGSXÃ

A]bXbYgg ]g Zcf mcif gci` Ug \YU`h\ ]g Zcf mcif VcXm4 mciXc bch bch]WY ]h k\Yb mci \UjY ]h(

- SHUVRQ EHFRPHV KDSS\ WR WKH VDPH H[WHQW WR ZKLFK KH RU VKHJLYHV KDSSLQHVV WR RWKHU SHRSOH&

v@ ;H;CO'8;DJ>7C

J\Y k]`` cZ =cX Zcf ig ]g hc `]jY ]b \Udd]bYgg UbX hc hU_YUb ]bhYfYgh ]b h\Y `]jYg cZ ch\Yfg(

v@E>D HKIA?D

BcjY ]g fYU` cb`m k\Yb U dYfgcb WUb gUWf]Z]WY \]agY`Z ZcfUbch\Yf dYfgcb( 1-b`m k\Yb U dYfgcb Zcf[Yhg \]agY`Z Zcfh\Y gU_Y cZ Ubch\Yf& UbX `]jYg Zcf Ubch\Yf WfYUhifY& cb`mh\]g _]bX cZ `cjY WUb VY WU``YX hfiY `cjY& UbX cb`m ]b h\]g`cjY Xc kY gYY h\Y V`Ygg]b[ UbX fYkUfX cZ `]ZY( J\]g ]g h\YZcibXUh]cb cZ h\Y kcf`X(

Dch\]b[ WUb aU_Y cif `]ZY& cf h\Y `]jYg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y&acfY VYUih]Zi` h\Ub dYfdYhiU` _]bXbYgg(

AJHSVGSXÄ

7 aUb ]g ZfYY cb`m k\Yb \Y `]jYg ]b hfih\& UbX h\Y hfih\aUm VY dYfWY]jYX cb`m Vm h\Y ]bhY``YWh(

?Z mci h\fck gcaY bihg UbX Wcc_]Yg cb U fcUX& mci k]``YjYbhiU``m gYY W\]`XfYb WcaY& d]W_ h\Ya id& UbX ghUfh hcUf[iY UbX Z][\h Zcf h\Ya( 7Xi`hg kci`X bch Z][\h Zcf giW\h\]b[g( 7bX YjYb W\]`XfYb kci`X bch d]W_ id h\Y bihgrYadhm g\Y``g(<cf U k]gY aUb& h\Y kYU`h\& h\Y [`cfm& UbX h\Y fYkUfXg

cZ h\]g kcf`X UfY `]_Y gkYYhg cf Yadhm g\Y``g cb U fcUX( BYhh\Y W\]`XfYb d]W_ h\Ya id UbX Z][\h Zcf h\Ya( BYh h\Ya_]gg h\Y \UbXg cZ h\Y f]W\ aYb& h\Y fi`Yfg& UbX h\Y]f gYfxjUbhg( <cf h\Y k]gY cbY& U`` h\YgY UfY Vih Yadhm g\Y``g(

v;F?9J;JKI

- GLVWLQFWLYH IHDWXUH RI D WKLQNLQJ SHUVRQ LV VXEPLVVLRQ WR KLVIDWH$ DV RSSRVHG WR WKH VKDPHIXO VWUXJJOH ZLWK LW WKDW LV D FKDUcDFWHULVWLF IHDWXUH RI DQLPDOV&

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

MY UfY bch ZfYY ]b h\]g kcf`X& giVXiYX Vm cif dUgg]cbgUbX Vm h\Y Yach]cbg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y hc h\Y XY[fYY h\Uh kYZcf[Yh h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ cif ]bhY``YWhg( ?Z kY fYU``m kUbhhc VYWcaY ZfYY& kY WUb VY gc cb`m h\fci[\ cif ]bhY``YWh(

AJHSVGSXĀ

7`` YjYbhg& k\Yh\Yf ]b h\Y `]jYg cZ \iaUb ]bX]j]XiU`g& cf\iaUb gcW]Yh]Yg& \UjY h\Y]f VY[]bb]b[g ]b h\ci[\h( J\YfYxZcfY& hc Zi``m ibXYfghUbX ch\Yf dYcd`Y UbX ch\Yf gcW]Yh]Yg&kY aigh `cc_ VYmcbX dfYj]cig YjYbhg hc h\Y h\ci[\hgk\]W\ [UjY f]gY hc h\Ya(

FYf\Udg ]h ]g YjYb acfY ]adcfhUbh hc _bck k\Uh cbYg\ci`X bch h\]b_ UVcih h\Ub k\Uh cbY g\ci`X h\]b_ UVcih(

Eif h\ci[\hg& XYdYbX]b[ cb k\Yh\Yf h\Ym UfY [ccX cfVUX& WUb Vf]b[ ig Y]h\Yf hc dUfUX]gY cf hc \Y``5 h\]g \UdxdYbg& bY]h\Yf ]b \YUjYb bcf ibXYf h\Y YUfh\& Vih \YfY& ]bh\]g `]ZY(

vBK9O C7BEHO

- WKRXJKW VHHPV WR EH IUHH DQG LQGHSHQGHQW$ EXW D KXPDQEHLQJ KDV VRPHWKLQJ VWURQJHU WKDQ WKRXJKW$ VRPHWKLQJ ZKLFKFRXOG JXLGH RXU WKRXJKWV&

?b cfXYf hc W\Ub[Y h\Y bUhifY cZ h\]b[g& Y]h\Yf k]h\]bmcifgY`Z cf ]b ch\Yfg& cbY g\ci`X W\Ub[Y& bch h\Y YjYbhg&Vih h\cgY h\ci[\hg k\]W\ WfYUhYX h\cgY YjYbhg(

JHSVGSXĂ

IYliU` XYg]fY ]g h\Y acgh U``'Wcbgia]b[ cZ XYg]fYg( J\]gXYg]fY ]g bYjYf gUhYX& Zcf h\Y acfY ]h ]g gUh]gZ]YX& h\Y acfY]h [fckg(

LYfm cZhYb dYcd`Y UfY aUXY dfciX Vm h\Y]f Wcbhfc` cjYfh\Y]f ckb XYg]fYg& UbX Vm h\Y ZcfWY UbX dUgg]cb k]h\ k\]W\h\Ym aUghYf h\Ya( M\Uh U ghfUb[Y XY`ig]cb

9DQ\ SHRSOH ZRUU\$ DQG VXIIHU$ EHFDXVH WKH\ KDYH EHHQLQYROYHG LQ VR PDQ\ EDG WKLQJV LQ WKHLU OLYHV& 5Q WUXWK$WKRXJK$ JRRG WKLQJV RIWHQ KDSSHQ LQ VSLWH RI RXU ZLVKHV$ DQGVRPHWLPHV HYHQ LQ RSSRVLWLRQ WR RXU ZLVKHV$ DQG RIWHQ DIWHURXU H[FLWHPHQW DQG VXIIHULQJ RYHU XQZRUWK\ WKLQJV&

HYaYaVYf \ck dUgg]cbUhY`m mci mYUfbYX ]b h\Y dUgh ZcfaUbm cZ h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ mci \UhY cf XYgd]gY bck(HYaYaVYf \ck aUbm h\]b[g mci `cgh hfm]b[ hc gUh]gZm

mcif ZcfaYf XYg]fYg( J\Y gUaY h\]b[ Wci`X \UddYb bck&k]h\ h\Y XYg]fYg k\]W\ YlW]hY mci Uh dfYgYbh( Jfm hc hUaYmcif dfYgYbh XYg]fYg& WU`a h\Ya5 h\]g ]g acgh VYbYZ]W]U`&UbX acgh UW\]YjUV`Y(

AJHSVGSXÅ

FYfZYWh]b[ h\Y gY`Z ]g Vch\ Ub ]bbYf UbX Ub cihYf kcf_4 OciWUbbch ]adfcjY mcifgY`Z k]h\cih Wcaaib]WUh]b[ k]h\ch\Yf dYcd`Y& ]bZìYbW]b[ h\Ya& UbX VY]b[ ]bZìYbWYX Vmh\Ya(

J\fYY hYadhUh]cbg hcfhifY dYcd`Y4 gYliU` XYg]fY& df]XY&UbX ìgh Zcf kYU`h\( 7`` h\Y a]gZcfhibYg cZ aUb_]bX WcaYZfca h\YgY h\fYY WfUj]b[g( M]h\cih h\Ya& dYcd`Y kci`X`]jY ]b \Udd]bYgg( 8ih \ck WUb kY [Yh f]X cZ h\YgY hYff]V`Y]``bYggYg6( Mcf_ cb mcifgY`Z UbX ]adfcjY mcifgY`Z5 h\]g]g h\Y UbgkYf( IhUfh h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ h\]g kcf`X Zfcak]h\]b(

v<( HE8;HJ :; B7C;DD7?I '

`.H SHUIHFW$ DV \RXU KHDYHQO\ 2DWKHU /KULVW VDLG& ?KLV GRHVQRW PHDQ WKDW /KULVW DVNHG SHRSOH WR EH DV JRRG DV 3RG+ RQO\WKDW HYHU\RQH VKRXOG VWULYH IRU SHUIHFWLRQ&

FifY dYfZYWh]cb WUb VY ZcibX cb`m ]b =cX5 cbYrg `]ZY Wcbxg]ghg cZ VYWca]b[ W`cgYf hc =cX( 7bX k\Yb U dYfgcb_bckg h\Uh [ccX ]g [ccX UbX h\Uh Yj]` ]g Yj]`& h\Yb \Y cfg\Y [Yhg W`cgYf hc [ccX& UbX acjYg ZUfh\Yf Zfca Yj]`(

v9ED<K9?KI

J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ acfY \UfaZi` hc mci h\Ub ]adfcj]b[cb`m mcif aUhYf]U`& Ub]aU` g]XY cZ `]ZY( J\YfY ]g bch\]b[acfY VYbYZ]W]U`& Vch\ Zcf mci UbX Zcf ch\Yfg& h\Ub UWh]j]hmX]fYWhYX hc h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ mcif gci`(

AJHSVGSXǺ

M\m Xc dYcd`Y `]_Y hc VÙaY ch\Yfg gc aiW\6 >Y k\c WUghgVÙaY cb Ubch\Yf dYfgcb ]g ei]W_ hc h\]b_ h\Uh \Y kci`X bchXc h\Y jYfm gUaY h\]b[( ?h ]g h\Y gUaY k]h\ dYcd`Y k\c `]_Yhc `]ghYb hc h\Y ZUi`h'Z]bX]b[ cZ h\Y]f bY][\Vcfg(

M\Yb hkc dYcd`Y \UjY U X]gdihY& Vch\ UfY hc VÙaY( 7bXh\YfYZcfY& U X]gdihY k]`` ghcd cb`m k\Yb Uh `YUgh cbY dYfxgcb ibXYfghUbXg h\Uh \Y cf g\Y ]g [i]`hm(

6XGJH QRW$ WKDW \H EH QRW MXGJHG& 2RU ZLWK ZKDW MXGJPHQW \HMXGJH$ \H VKDOO EH MXGJHG* DQG ZLWK ZKDW PHDVXUH \H PHWH$ LWVKDOO KH PHDVXUHG WR \RX DJDLQ&

vC7JJ>;M (+" #

Ihcd VÙa]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& UbX mci k]`` ZYY` k\Uh Ub U`Wcx\c`]W ZYY`g k\Yb \Y ghcdg Xf]b_]b[& cf k\Uh U gac_Yf ZYY`gk\Yb \Y ghcdg gac_]b[( Oci k]`` ZYY` h\Uh mci \UjYVfci[\h fY`]YZ hc mcif gci`(

AJHSVGSXĄ

J\Y aUhYf]U` Yj]` WUigYX Vm kUf ]g V][& Vih ]h ]g ]bWcadUfUxV`m gaU`` ]b WcadUf]gcb k]h\ h\Y dYfjYfg]cb cf h\Y ibXYfxghUbX]b[ cZ [ccX UbX VUX k\]W\ \UddYbg Xif]b[ h\Y kUf&UbX k\]W\ ]g dih ]bhc h\Y gci`g cZ dYcd`Y k\c Xc bchh\]b_(

- FKLOG PHHWV DQRWKHU FKLOG ZLWK D VPLOH$ GLVSOD\LQJ KLVIULHQGO\ DWWLWXGH DQG MR\& ?KLV VDPH EHKDYLRU OLYHV LQ DOO VLQ%FHUH SHRSOH& .XW YHU\ RIWHQ$ D PDQ IURP RQH QDWLRQ DOUHDG\KDWHV D PDQ IURP DQRWKHU QDWLRQ$ DQG LV UHDG\ WR FDXVH KLPVXIIHULQJV DQG HYHQ GHDWK$ HYHQ EHIRUH KH PHHWV KLP& ?KRVHZKR FUHDWH WKHVH IHHOLQJV LQ QDWLRQV FRPPLW D WHUULEOH FULPH

J\Y acgh dckYfZi` kYUdcb _bckb ]g h\Y kYUdcb cZV`Ygg]b[( J\YfYZcfY& U W`YjYf dYfgcb fY`]Yg cb ]h( >Y k]bgk]h\ dYUWY& bch k]h\ kUf(

vB7E'JPK

MUf WfYUhYg U ghUhY ]b k\]W\ dckYf UbX [`cfm ]g Uh h\Y YbXhcc cZhYb fYWY]jYX Vm h\Y acgh ibXYgYfj]b[ UbX j]W]cigdYcd`Y(

AJHSVGSXÁÀ

J\Y \][\Yf h\Y cd]b]cb U dYfgcb \Ug cZ \]agY`Z& h\Y acfYibghUV`Y ]g \]g dcg]h]cb5 h\Y `ckYf \Y acjYg ]b \]g gY`ZxYghYYa& h\Y Z]faYf \Y ghUbXg(

Jc VY ghfcb[& mci \UjY hc VY `]_Y kUhYf4 ]Z h\YfY UfY bccVghUW`Yg& ]h Z`ckg4 ]Z h\YfY ]g Ub cVghUW`Y ]h ghcdg5 ]Z U XUa]g Vfc_Yb& h\Yb ]h Z`ck"g Zifh\Yf5 ]Z U jYggY` ]g geiUfY& h\Yb ]h\Ug U geiUfY Zcfa5 ]Z U jYggY` ]g fcibX& h\Yb ]h \Ug U fcibXZcfa( 8YWUigY ]h ]g gc gcZh UbX Z`Yl]V`Y& ]h ]g h\Y acgh bYWxYggUfm UbX h\Y ghfcb[Ygh h\]b[(

vB7E'JPK

J\Y acfY U dYfgcb UbU`mnYg \]g ]bbYf gY`Z& h\Y acfY]bg][b]Z]WUbh \Y gYYag hc \]agY`Z( J\]g ]g h\Y Z]fgh `YggcbcZ k]gXca( BYh ig VY \iaV`Y& UbX kY k]`` VYWcaY k]gY(BYh ig _bck cif kYU_bYgg& UbX ]h k]`` []jY ig dckYf(


MUhYf XcYg bch ghUm cb U acibhU]b'hcd& Vih Z`ckg ]bhc h\YjU``Ym( ?b h\Y gUaY aUbbYf& fYU` j]fhiY XcYg bch fYaU]bk]h\ h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c kUbh hc VY \][\Yf h\Ub h\Y ch\Yfg5Vih j]fhiY ghUmg cb`m k]h\ dYcd`Y k\c UfY \iaV`Y(

v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

?U\ WR ILQG RXW \RXU SRWHQWLDO& -IWHU \RX NQRZ LW$ GR QRW EHDIUDLG WR XQGHUHVWLPDWH LW& .H FDXWLRXV QRW WR H[DJJHUDWH LW&

AJHSVGSXÁÁ

- SHUVRQ_V OLIH LV JRRG RQO\ WR WKH H[WHQW WKDW LW IXOILOOV WKHH[SHFWDWLRQV RI WKH ZLOO RI 3RG&

;j]`& ]b h\Y Zcfa cZ giZZYf]b[ UbX XYUh\& ]g YjYfmk\YfYUddUfYbh hc U dYfgcb k\c UWWYdhg h\Y Ùk cZ \]g aUhYf]U`&Ub]aU` Yl]ghYbWY Ug h\Y aU^cf Ùk cZ \]g `]ZY( Eb`m k\Yb UaUb `ckYfg \]agY`Z hc h\Y ghUhY cZ Ub Ub]aU` XcYg XYUh\UbX giZZYf]b[ gWUfY \]a( J\Y cb`m fcUX cdYb Zcf \]a hcYgWUdY h\Uh ZYUf ]g h\Y fcUX cZ Zi`Z]`àYbh cZ h\Y Ùk cZ=cX& h\Y Ùk k\]W\ ]g YldfYggYX ]b `cjY( J\YfY ]g bc XYUh\UbX bc giZZYf]b[ Zcf U aUb k\c `]jYg UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y ÙkcZ =cX^

8Y Ug mci UfY& Ug mci \UjY hc VY& UbX h\Y fYgh ]g =cXrg Vig]xbYgg(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

J\Y Zi`Z]`àYbh cZ cif Xih]Yg UbX h\Y gUh]gZUWh]cb cZ cifdYfgcbU` d`YUgifYg UfY hkc X]ZZYfYbh h\]b[g( :ih]Yg \UjYh\Y]f ckb Ùkg& UbX YjYb ]Z kY hfm hc a]l cif Xih]Yg k]h\cif d`YUgifYg& h\Ym k]`` gYdUfUhY h\YagY`jYg(


MY _bck h\Y Ùk cZ =cX& Vch\ Ug ]h ]g dfYgYbhYX hc ig Vmh\Y X]ZZYfYbh fY`][]cbg cZ h\Y kcf`X UbX Ug cif ckb WcbxgW]YbWY& k\Yb ]h ]g bch cVgWifYX Vm dUgg]cb UbX dfYîX]WY&UbX kY WUb YUg]`m ibXYfghUbX h\Y Udd`]WUh]cbg cZ h\]g Ùkhc cif `]ZY& Zcf U`` fYU` [ccX ghYag Zfca ]hg fYei]fYaYbhg(

AJHSVGSXÁÂ

?h ]g cVj]cig Zcf YjYfmcbY h\Uh XYUh\ YldYWhg ig U`` ]b h\Y`cb[ fib5 Vih bYjYfh\Y`Ygg kY `]jY cif `]jYg Ug ]Z h\YfY k]``VY bc XYUh\(

?Z cb`m =cX ]g Uacb[ ig& UbX YhYfb]hm Yl]ghg& h\Yb YjYfmxh\]b[ ]g X]ZZYfYbh( MY WUb X]gh]b[i]g\ [ccX Zfca Yj]`& `][\hZfca XUf_bYgg& UbX XYgdU]f X]gUddYUfg(

v;H7ICKI

EbY cZ h\Y _Ym eiYgh]cbg kY ZUWY ]g k\Yh\Yf cif `]jYg YbXUZhYf XYUh\( M\Yh\Yf kY VY`]YjY ]b YhYfb]hm cf bch XYhYfxa]bYg cif UWh]cbg( J\YfYZcfY& ]h ]g WfiW]U` h\Uh kY XYhYfxa]bY k\Uh ]g acfhU` ]b ig& UbX k\Uh ]g YhYfbU`& UbX h\Uh kYW\Yf]g\ h\cgY h\]b[g YhYfbU`( Ccgh dYcd`Y Xc YlUWh`m h\Ycddcg]hY(

v7ZhYf 8B7?I; F7I97B

?KH PRUH GHHSO\ \RX XQGHUVWDQG OLIH$ WKH OHVV \RX JULHYH RYHUWKH GHVWUXFWLRQ FDXVHG E\ GHDWK&

M\UhYjYf bUaY mci []jY hc h\Y cf][]b cZ aUb& h\]g gd]f]xhiU` eiU`]hm cZ \iaUbg hc ibXYfghUbX& ZYY`& UbX Yl]gh& ]h ]g\c`m& ]h ]g X]j]bY& UbX& h\YfYZcfY& ]h g\ci`X VY YhYfbU`(


AJHSVGSXÁÃ

HY`][]cb ]g U d\]`cgcd\m k\]W\ WUb VY ibXYfghccX Vm UbmxcbY(

- SHUVRQ FDQ SOHDVH 3RG RQO\ ZLWK WKH JRGOLQHVV RI KLV OLIH& 5IDQ RXWZDUGO\ IDLWKIXO SHUVRQ LV QRW JRRG$ FOHDU$ DQG KXPEOHLQ KLV OLIH$ WKHQ KH SUHVHQWV D ELJ OLH$ KH VHUYHV 3RG IDOVHO\&


HY`][]cb ]g g]ad`Y k]gXca k\]W\ ]g X]fYWhYX hc h\Y \YUfhUbX ibXYfghccX Vm h\Y ]bhY``YWh(

HY`][]cb WUb Yb`][\hYb d\]`cgcd\]WU` aYX]hUh]cbg5 d\]`cxgcd\]WU` aYX]hUh]cbg WUb ghfYb[h\Yb fY`][]cb( J\YfYZcfY&hfm hc Wcaaib]WUhY Vch\ k]h\ hfi`m fY`][]cig dYcd`Y UbXhfi`m [ccX d\]`cgcd\Yfg& U`]jY UbX XYUX(

BHSVGSXÁÄ

7 \c`m gd]f]h `]jYg k]h\]b mci(

@Ygig UbgkYfYX UbX gU]X ibhc \]a& LYf]`m& jYf]`m& ? gUm ibhch\YY& ;lWYdh U aUb VY Vcfb U[U]b& \Y WUbbch gYY h\Y _]b[xXca cZ =cX(

v@E>D -4-

?bhY``YWh WUb VY Yb`][\hYbYX cb`m ]b U _]bX dYfgcb( 7 dYfxgcb WUb VY _]bX cb`m k\Yb \Y \Ug Ub Yb`][\hYbYX ]bhY``YWh(EbY \Y`dg h\Y ch\Yf(

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

7 aYfW\Ubh aUff]YX U df]bWYgg& UbX \Y Vi]`h U dUÙWY Zcf\Yf& Vci[\h ìlif]cig XfYggYg Zcf \Yf& UbX Vfci[\h \Yf\ibXfYXg cZ gYfjUbhg hc aU_Y \Yf \Uddm( 8ih h\Y df]bWYggkUg VcfYX( I\Y kUg a]gg]b[ gcaYh\]b[& UbX g\Y WcbghUbh`mh\ci[\h UVcih \Yf fcmU` cf][]b( J\ig ]h ]g k]h\ U \iaUbgci`4 mci WUb giffcibX ]h k]h\ U`` h\Y d`YUgifYg cb YUfh\&Vih ]h k]`` gh]`` VY a]gg]b[ ]hg \caY& h\Y VY[]bb]b[ k\]W\ ]gWU``YX =cX& h\Y dÙWY Zfca k\]W\ ]h \Ug cf][]bUhYX(

v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

;jYb ]Z dYcd`Y Xc bch _bck k\Uh fYU` _]bXbYgg ]g& h\YmbYjYfh\Y`Ygg \UjY ]h k]h\]b h\Ya(

v9ED<K9?KI

3RG OLYHV LQ HYHU\ RQH RI XV& BKHQ D SHUVRQ UHPHPEHUV WKLV$WKH WKRXJKW RI LW FDQ VDYH KLP IURP HYLO$ DQG KHOS KLP WR GRJRRG&

AJHSVGSXÁĀ

J\YfY ]g g]ad`]W]hm cZ bUhifY& UbX h\YfY ]g g]ad`]W]hm cZk]gXca( 8ch\ cZ h\Ya Yjc_Y `cjY UbX fYgdYWh(

?KH JUHDWHVW WUXWK LV WKH PRVW VLPSOH RQH&

M\Yb dYcd`Y gdYU_ ]b U jYfm Y`UVcfUhY UbX gcd\]gh]WUhYXkUm& h\Ym Y]h\Yf kUbh hc hY`` U `]Y& cf hc UXa]fY h\YagY`jYg(Oci g\ci`X bch VY`]YjY giW\ dYcd`Y( =ccX gdYYW\ ]gU`kUmg W`YUf& W`YjYf& UbX ibXYfghccX Vm U``(

I]ad`]W]hm ]g h\Y WcbgYeiYbWY cZ fYZ]bYX Yach]cbg(v@;7D :r7B;C8;HJ

McfXg WUb ib]hY dYcd`Y( J\YfYZcfY& hfm hc gdYU_ jYfmW`YUf`m& UbX hY`` cb`m h\Y hfih\& Zcf bch\]b[ WUb ib]hY dYcxd`Y acfY h\Ub hfih\ UbX g]ad`]W]hm(

<YVfiUfm +0

J\Y mcib[Yf UbX h\Y acfY df]a]h]jY U dYfgcb ]g& h\Y acfY\Y cf g\Y VY`]YjYg h\Uh `]ZY ]g aUhYf]U` UbX h\Uh ]h Yl]ghgcb`m ]b h\Y VcXm J\Y c`XYf UbX k]gYf U dYfgcb VYWcaYg&h\Y acfY \Y cf g\Y ibXYfghUbXg h\Uh U`` `]ZY cf][]bUhYgZfca h\Y gd]f]h(

Bcc_ Uh h\Y g_m& UbX Uh h\Y YUfh\& UbX h\]b_ h\Uh U`` h\]b[gdUgg( 7`` cZ h\Y acibhU]bg UbX f]jYfg mci gYY& UbX U`` h\YZcfag cZ `]ZY& UbX U`` WfYUh]cbg cZ bUhifY& U`` dUgg( J\Ybmci k]`` ibXYfghUbX h\Y hfih\5 mci k]`` gYY k\Uh fYaU]bg&k\Uh XcYg bch dUgg( v

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

HYaYaVYf h\Uh mci UfY bch acfhU`5 cb`m' mcif VcXm ]gacfhU`( M\Uh ]g U`]jY ]g bch mcif VcXm Vih h\Y gd]f]h `]j]b[]b mcif VcXm( 7b ibgYYb ZcfWY [i]XYg mcif VcXm& ^igh Ug UbibgYYb ZcfWY [i]XYg h\Y kcf`X(

v7ZhYfC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

- SHUVRQ FDQ XQGHUVWDQG KLV UHDO GHVWLQDWLRQ LQ OLIH RQO\DIWHU KH PDQDJHV WR OLEHUDWH KLPVHOI IURP WKH VHQVXDO^ PDWHUcLDO ZRUOG&

AJHSVGSXÁÅ

7`` dYcd`Y cZ h\Y kcf`X \UjY Ub YeiU` f][\h hc h\Y df]j]x`Y[Yg cZ h\]g kcf`X(

;eiU`]hm WUbbch VY fYUW\YX& Ug gcaY dYcd`Y h\]b_& cb`m VmW]j]` aYUgifYg( ?h WUb VY fYUW\YX cb`m Vm `cjY cZ =cX UbXdYcd`Y& UbX h\]g `cjY WUb VY fYUW\YX& bch Vm W]j]` aYUxgifYg& Vih cb`m Ug h\Y fYgi`h cZ gd]f]hiU` `YUfb]b[(

?KH\ VD\ WKDW HTXDOLW\ LV QRW SRVVLEOH$ EHFDXVH VRPH SHRSOHZLOO DOZD\V EH VWURQJHU RU VPDUWHU WKDQ RWKHUV& .XW LW LVH[DFWO\ EHFDXVH RI WKLV$ VDLG 8LFKWHQEHUJ$ SUHFLVHO\ EHFDXVHVRPH SHRSOH DUH VWURQJHU DQG VPDUWHU WKDQ RWKHUV$ WKDW WKHSULQFLSOH RI HTXDOLW\ LV QHFHVVDU\& ?KH DGYDQWDJHV RI WKH ULFKRYHU WKH SRRU GHPRQVWUDWH QRW RQO\ LQHTXDOLW\ RI IRUFH DQGLQWHOOHFW$ EXW LQHTXDOLW\ RI FLYLO ULJKWV&

9\f]gh fYjYU`YX hc \iaUb]hm h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ h\Y]f VYghgY`jYg U`fYUXm _bYk4 h\Uh dYcd`Y UfY YeiU` VYWUigY h\YgUaY gd]f]h `]jYg ]b U`` cZ h\Ya( ( ( ( BYUfb Zfca h\Y gaU``W\]`XfYb& VY\UjY `]_Y W\]`XfYb& UbX hfYUh U`` dYcd`Y cb UbYeiU` VUg]g& k]h\ `cjY UbX hYbXYfbYgg(

BACD CEFG

FYfgcbU`]hm ]g U aUg_ k\]W\ X]g[i]gYg h\Y X]j]bY VY]b[k\]W\ `]jYg ]b YjYfm dYfgcb( J\Y acfY cbY fY^YWhg dYfgcbxU`]hm& h\Y acfY h\]g X]j]bY VY[]bb]b[ ]g aUb]ZYghYX(

Oci aigh `cjY cb`m =cX& UbX mci aigh \UhY cb`m mcifgY`Z(v8B7?I; F7I97B

J\YfYZcfY Xch\ am <Uh\Yf `cjY aY& VYWUigY ? Ùm Xckbam `]ZY& h\Uh ? a][\h hU_Y ]h U[U]b( Dc aUb hU_Yh\ ]h ZfcaaY& Vih ? Ùm ]h Xckb cZ amgY`Z( ? \UjY dckYf hc Ùm ]hXckb& UbX ? \UjY dckYf hc hU_Y ]h U[U]b( J\]g WcaaUbXxaYbh \UjY ? fYWY]jYX cZ am <Uh\Yf(

v@E>D +*4+1'+2

Eb`m h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c XYbm h\Y]f ckb dYfgcbU`]hm WUbibXYfghUbX h\Y fY`][]cig hYUW\]b[(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

>Y k\c kUbhg hc gUjY \]g gci`& k]`` `cgY ]h5 UbX \Y k\ckUbhg hc `cgY \]g `]ZY Zcf aY UbX h\Y bYk hYghUaYbh& k]``gUjY ]h(

vC7HA 24-/

J\cgY k\c Xc bch gYY h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ h\Y]f `]ZY ]b hYadcxfUfm h\]b[g& ]b h\Y]f bUaYg UbX VcX]Yg& h\cgY dYcd`Y _bckh\Y hfih\ cZ `]ZY(


;QO\ ZKHQ ZH IRUJHW DERXW RXUVHOYHV$ ZKHQ ZH JHW RXW RI WKHWKRXJKWV RI RXUVHOYHV$ FDQ ZH IUXLWIXOO\ FRPPXQLFDWH ZLWKRWKHUV$ OLVWHQ WR WKHP$ DQG LQIOXHQFH WKHP&

AJHSVGSXÁĄ

5W LV D VLQ QRW WR EH HQJDJHG LQ ZRUN$ HYHQ LI LW LV QRW QHFHVcVDU\ IRU \RX WR PDNH \RXU OLYLQJ ZLWK HYHU\GD\ ZRUN&

EbY cZ h\Y VYgh UbX difYgh ^cmg ]g \Uj]b[ U fYgh UZhYf `UVcf(v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

Mcf_ U`` h\Y h]aY( :c bch h\]b_ h\Uh kcf_ ]g U X]gUghYf Zcfmci& UbX Xc bch gYY_ dfU]gY cf fYkUfX Zcf mcif kcf_(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\Y acgh cihghUbX]b[ []Zhg WUb VY XYghfcmYX Vm ]X`YbYgg(vC?9>;B :; CEDJ7?=D;

Dch\]b[ WUb aU_Y U dYfgcb ZYY` acfY bcV`Y h\Ub kcf_(M]h\cih kcf_& U dYfgcb WUbbch \UjY \iaUb X][b]hm( ?h ]gVYWUigY cZ h\]g h\Uh ]X`Y dYcd`Y UfY gc aiW\ WcbWYfbYX Vmh\Y gidYfZ]W]U`& cihYf YldfYgg]cb cZ h\Y]f ]adcfhUbWY5 h\Ym_bck h\Uh k]h\cih h\]g& ch\Yf dYcd`Y kci`X XYgd]gY h\Ya(

M\Yb kY UWWYdh hfih\ UbX fYdYbh cif g]bg& kY ibXYfghUbXh\Uh bcVcXm WUb \UjY gdYW]U` f][\hg& UXjUbhU[Yg& cf df]j]x`Y[Yg ]b h\]g `]ZY( J\YfY ]g bc YbX cf `]a]h hc cif Xih]Yg UbXcV`][Uh]cbg( 7bX h\Y Z]fgh UbX h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh cV`][Uxh]cb Zcf ig ]g hc Z][\h k]h\ bUhifY Zcf cif `]ZY UbX Zcf h\Y`]jYg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

AJHSVGSXÂÀ

>iaUb_]bX [cYg cb k]h\cih ghcdd]b[( J\]g acjYaYbhZcfkUfX ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf mci Ug Ub ]bX]j]XiU` Ug kY``( ?Zmci kUbh hc gYfjY =cX& mci g\ci`X VY U kcf_Yf Zcf h\Ygd]f]hiU` dfc[fYgg cZ \iaUb]hm(

J\Y kUm cZ `]ZY cZ Ubm dYcd`Y XYdYbXg cb h\Y]f ZU]h\(<U]h\& k]h\ h]aY& VYWcaYg acfY g]ad`Y& acfY W`YUf& UbXW`cgYf hc h\Y fYU` hfih\& UbX ]b UWWcfXUbWY k]h\ h\Y g]ad`]xZm]b[ UbX WÙf]Zm]b[ cZ ZU]h\& dYcd`Y VYWcaY acfY UbXacfY Kb]hYX(

?Z mci h\]b_ ]h ]g YjYf kUffUbhYX hc ghcd cb h\Y dUh\ cZZifh\Yf ibXYfghUbX]b[& mci UfY jYfm ZUf Zfca h\Y hfih\(J\Y `]ZY k\]W\ kY fYWY]jYX kUg []jYb hc ig bch h\Uh kYa][\h îgh UXa]fY ]h& Vih h\Uh kY g\ci`X YjYf `cc_ Zcf bYkhfih\ \]XXYb Zfca ig(

v7ZhYf @E>D C?BJED

CUb_]bX aU_Yg dfc[fYgg k\Yb ]hg ZU]h\ dfc[fYggYg( 7bX]Z h\YfY ]g Ubm dfc[fYgg ]b fY`][]cb& ]h ]g bch ]b h\Y X]gWcjxYfm cZ gcaYh\]b[ bYk& Vih ]b h\Y dif]Zm]b[ cZ h\Y hfih\gk\]W\ \UjY VYYb fYjYU`YX UbX YldÙ]bYX hc ig(

MY g\ci`X bch giVgh]hihY fYU` fY`][]cig dfc[fYgg k]h\ch\Yf hmdYg cZ dfc[fYgg4 (hYW\b]WU`& gW\cÙf`m& UbX Ufh]gh]W(J\YgY hYW\b]WU`& gW\cÙf`m& UbX Ufh]gh]W UW\]YjYaYbhg WUbWYfhU]b`m WcYl]gh k]h\ fY`][]cig VUW_kUfXbYgg& Ug \UddYbg]b cif h]aY(

5I \RX ZDQW WR VHUYH 3RG$ \RX VKRXOG ZRUN RQ WKH VLGH RIUHOLJLRXV SURJUHVV LQ WKH ILJKW DJDLQVW SUHMXGLFH$ WRZDUG D EHWcWHU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH FOHDU DQG SXUH UHOLJLRQ&

AJHSVGSXÂÁ

J\YfY kUg U h]aY k\Yb dYcd`Y UhY YUW\ ch\Yf( J\Ym bc`cb[Yf Xc gc& Vih h\Ym gh]`` YUh Ub]aU`g( J\Y h]aY k]`` WcaYk\Yb acfY UbX acfY dYcd`Y k]`` Xfcd h\]g hYff]V`Y \UV]h(

5W LV D PLVWDNH WR EHOLHYH WKDW ZH QHHG REH\ QR PRUDO LQ RXUDWWLWXGH WR WKH DQLPDOV$ WKDW ZH KDYH QR PRUDO UHVSRQVLELOLcWLHV WR WKHP& ?KLV ZD\ OLHV FRPSOHWH YXOJDULW\ DQG UXGHQHVV&


J\Y _]``]b[ UbX YUh]b[ cZ Ub]aU`g ]g U dfY^iX]WY UWWYdhYXVm h\cgY k\c h\]b_ h\Uh Ub]aU`g kYfY []jYb hc dYcd`Y Vm=cX hc YUh& gc h\Uh h\YfY ]g bch\]b[ kfcb[ ]b _]``]b[ h\Ya(J\]g ]g bch hfiY( ?h aUm VY kf]hhYb ]b gcaY Vcc_g h\Uh ]h ]gbch U g]b hc _]`` Ub Ub]aU`& Vih ]h ]g kf]hhYb ]b cif ckb\YUfhg acfY W`YUf`m h\Ub ]b Ubm Vcc_gvh\Uh kY g\ci`XhU_Y d]hm cb Ub]aU`g ]b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug kY Xc cb YUW\ch\Yf( 7bX kY U`` _bck h\]g& ]Z kY Xc bch XYUXYb h\Y jc]WYcZ cif WcbgW]YbWY ]bg]XY cZ ig(

AJHSVGSXÂÂ

7`` h\Uh ]g kf]hhYb UVcih =cX& UbX U`` h\Uh dYcd`Y gUmUVcih >]a& gh]`` ZU``g g\cfh cZ h\Y aUf_( 9YfhU]b h\]b[g&k\]W\ YjYfm dYfgcb WUb XQGHUVWDQG UVcih =cX& WUb bYjYfVY YldfYggYX& h\]b[g bYWYggUfm Zcf YjYfmcbY& UbX h\]b[gk\]W\ WUigY h\Y `cjY cZ =cX(

v7ZhYf 7D=;BKI I?B;I?KI

7b ]bhY``YWh k\]W\ WUb VY ibXYfghccX ]g bch Ub YhYfbU`]bhY``YWh5 U VY]b[ k\]W\ WUb VY bUaYX ]g bch Ub YhYfbU` VY]b[(

vB7E'JPK

J\YfY ]g U ZcfWY k\]W\ fYg]XYg ]b U`` h\]b[g& k]h\cih k\]W\h\YfY ]g bc \YUjYb UbX bc YUfh\( J\]g ZcfWY WUbbch VY dYfxWY]jYX( FYcd`Y hfm hc XYgWf]VY ]hg eiU`]h]Yg& hc []jY ]h X]ZZYfxYbh bUaYg& giW\ Ug s]bhY``YWht cf s`cjY&t Vih h\Y VY]b[ ]hgY`Z\Ug bc bUaY( ?h ]g jYfm fYachY Zfca ig& UbX ]h ]g W`cgYgh hc ig(

v7ZhYf B7E'JPK

3RG LV WKH OLPLWOHVV EHLQJ ZKLFK DFFHSWV RQO\ WUXWK&vC7JJ>;M 7HDEB:

J\cgY dYcd`Y k\c Ug_ k\YfY =cX ]g UfY WfUnm5 =cX ]gYjYfmk\YfY& ]b U`` cZ bUhifY UbX ]b h\Y gci` cZ YUW\ dYfgcb(J\YfY UfY aUbm X]ZZYfYbh fY`][]cbg& Vih h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY=cX( ?Z U dYfgcb WUbbch ibXYfghUbX \]agY`Z& \ck WUb \YibXYfghUbX =cX6

v?D:?7D M?I:EC

?Z mcif YmYg VYWcaY V`]bXYX Vm h\Y gib& mci Xc bch gUmh\Uh h\Y gib XcYg bch Yl]gh( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& mci g\ci`Xbch gUm h\Uh =cX XcYg bch Yl]gh ]Z mcif ]bhY``YWh ]g `cgh ]bhfm]b[ hc ibXYfghUbX \]a(

v7ZhYf 7D=;BKI I?B;I?KI

AJHSVGSXÂÃ

J\Y Yl]gh]b[ XYg][b cZ `]ZY WcffYgdcbXg bY]h\Yf hc h\YfYei]fYaYbhg cZ WcbgW]YbWY bcf hc h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ]bhY``YWh(

?aU[]bY U Z`cW_ cZ d][Ycbg ]b U Wcfb Z]Y`X( ?aU[]bY h\Uhb]bYhm'b]bY cZ h\Ya& ]bghYUX cZ dYW_]b[ h\Y Wcfb h\YmbYYX UbX ig]b[ ]h Ug h\Ym bYYX ]h& ghUfh hc Wc``YWh U`` h\YmWUb ]bhc cbY V][ \YUd( ?aU[]bY h\Uh h\Ym Xc bch `YUjY "aiW\ Wcfb Zcf h\YagY`jYg& Vih gUjY h\]g V][ \YUd cZ Wcfbcb VY\U`Z cZ h\Y j]`Ygh UbX kcfgh ]b h\Y]f Z`cW_( ?aU[]bYh\Uh h\Ym U`` g]h ]b U W]fW`Y UbX kUhW\ h\]g cbY d][YcbS k\cgeiUbXYfg UbX kUghYg h\]g kYU`h\( 7bX h\Yb ]aU[]bY h\Uhh\Ym fig\ Uh U kYU_ d][Ycb k\c ]g h\Y acgh \ib[fm Uacb[h\Ya k\c XUfYgh hc hU_Y cbY [fU]b Zfca h\Y \YUd k]h\cihdYfa]gg]cb& UbX h\Ym dib]g\ \]a(?Z mci WUb ]aU[]bY h\]g& h\Yb mci WUb ibXYfghUbX h\Y

XUm'hc'XUm VY\Uj]cf cZ aUb_]bX(vM?BB?7C F7B;O

? gYY dYcd`Y Uf[i]b[ k]h\ YUW\ ch\Yf& dfYdUf]b[ X]ZZYfYbhhfUdg Zcf YUW\ ch\Yf& `m]b[ UbX VYhfUm]b[ YUW\ ch\Yf( ? WUbxbch gYY k]h\cih hYUfg h\Uh h\Y ZcibXUh]cbg cZ =ccX UbX;j]` UfY Zcf[chhYb& cf ]b gcaY WUgYg Wcad`YhY`m ib_bckb(

vJ>;E=D?I

<HRSOH DUH UDWLRQDO FUHDWXUHV& BK\ GR WKH\ VHHP FDSDEOH RIXVLQJ YLROHQFH VR PXFK PRUH HDVLO\ WKDQ UHDVRQ LQ WKHLULQWHUDFWLRQV ZLWK HDFK RWKHU,

AJHSVGSXÂÄ

<cf U hfih\ hc VY \YUfX& ]h aigh VY gdc_Yb k]h\ _]bXbYgg(Jfih\ ]g _]bX cb`m k\Yb ]h ]g gdc_Yb h\fci[\ mcif \YUfhk]h\ g]bWYf]hm( Oci g\ci`X _bck h\Uh k\Yb U aYggU[Y mciWcbjYm hc Ubch\Yf dYfgcb ]g bch ibXYfghccX Vm \]a& Uh`YUgh cbY cZ h\Y Zc``ck]b[ h\]b[g ]g hfiY4 k\Uh mci \UjYgU]X ]g bch hfiY& cf mci \UjY WcbjYmYX ]h k]h\cih _]bXxbYgg(

J\Y cb`m kUm hc hY`` h\Y hfih\ ]g hc gdYU_ k]h\ _]bXbYgg(Eb`m h\Y kcfXg cZ U `cj]b[ aUb WUb VY \YUfX(


Jc hY`` h\Y hfih\ ]g h\Y gUaY Ug hc VY U [ccX hU]`cf& cf hc VYU [ccX ZUfaYf& cf hc kf]hY VYUih]Zi``m( Jc VY [ccX Uh UbmUWh]j]hm fYei]fYg dfUWh]WY4 bc aUhhYf \ck \UfX mci hfm&mci WUbbch Xc bUhifU``m k\Uh mci \UjY bch XcbY fYdYUhxYX`m( ?b cfXYf hc [Yh UWWighcaYX hc gdYU_]b[ h\Y hfih\& mcig\ci`X hY`` cb`m h\Y hfih\& YjYb ]b h\Y gaU``Ygh cZ h\]b[g(

BH OLH WR RWKHU SHRSOH VR RIWHQ WKDW ZH JHW XVHG WR LW$ DQG ZHVWDUW WR OLH WR RXUVHOYHV&

v<H7D9E?I :; B7 HE9>;<EK97KB:

Jfih\ WUbbch aU_Y U dYfgcb ib_]bX& cf hcc gY`Z'UggifYX5h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cbg cZ hfih\ hY``]b[ UfY \ia]`]hm UbX g]axd`]W]hm(

AJHSVGSXÂĀ

?R SUD\ LV WR DFFHSW DQG WR UHPHPEHU WKH ODZV RI WKH OLPLWOHVVEHLQJ$ 3RG$ DQG WR PHDVXUH DOO \RXU GHHGVvSDVW$ SUHVHQW$DQG IXWXUHbDFFRUGLQJ WR 4LV ODZV&

8YZcfY mci ghUfh dfUm]b[& Ug_ mcifgY`Z k\Yh\Yf Uh h\UhacaYbh mci WUb WcbWYbhfUhY5 ch\Yfk]gY& Xc bch dfUm Uh U``(J\cgY k\c aU_Y U \UV]h cih cZ dfUmYf Xc bch dfUm g]bx

WYfY`m(vJ\Y J7BCK:

?Z mci Ug_ Zcf giddcfh Zfca =cX& h\Yb mci k]`` `YUfb \ckhc Z]bX ]h ]b mcifgY`Z( >Y XcYg bch W\Ub[Y ig& Vih kYW\Ub[Y cifgY`jYg Vm [Yhh]b[ W`cgYf hc >]a( 7`` Ug_ Zfca>]a& Ug ]Z >Y g\ci`X \Y`d ig& Vih ]b h\Y YbX kY []jY h\YgYh\]b[g hc cifgY`jYg(

v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

<fca h\Y UbW]Ybh h]aYg& ]h \Ug VYYb _bckb h\Uh dfUmYf ]g U\iaUb bYWYgg]hm(FYcd`Y igY X]ZZYfYbh f]hiU`g Xif]b[ dfUmYf& gdYW]U`

UXXfYggYg ]b gdYW]U` W]fWiaghUbWYg& ]b gdYW]U` d`UWYg& ]b h\YkUmg h\Ym dfYgYbh h\Y]f aYggU[Y hc =cX UbX Ug_ >]a hcVY _]bX(8ih `Yh h\YfY VY h\]g WcbghUbh4 Xif]b[ U dfUmYf& Zcf[Yh

UVcih U`` YlhYfbU` kcf`X`m h\]b[g UbX UXXfYgg h\Y X]j]bYdUfh cZ mcif gci`( KgY h\]g X]j]bY dUfh hc [U]b Wcaaib]WUxh]cb k]h\ h\Uh cZ k\]W\ ]h ]g U dUfh UbX k\Yb mci ZYY` mcifxgY`Z W`cgY hc =cX& mci XY`]jYf mcif gci` hc >]a& UbX g\ck>]a U`` mcif XYYXg UbX k]g\Yg( FfUmYf XcYg bch \UddYbUWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ h\Y kcf`X& Vih UWWcfXx]b[ hc h\Y X]j]bY dUfh cZ mcif gci`(

AJHSVGSXÂĂ

7ZhYf U `cb[ WcbjYfgUh]cb& ghcd UbX hfm hc fYaYaVYf k\Uhmci \UjY ^igh X]gWiggYX( :cbrh VY gifdf]gYX ]Z aUbm h\]b[g&gcaYh]aYg YjYb YjYfmh\]b[ mci \UjY X]gWiggYX& kYfYaYUb]b[`Ygg& Yadhm& UbX hf]j]U`& UbX gcaYh]aYg YjYb VUX(

7 ghid]X dYfgcb g\ci`X _YYd g]`Ybh( 8ih ]Z \Y _bYk h\]g&\Y kci`X bch VY U ghid]X dYfgcb(


Eb`m gdYU_ k\Yb mcif kcfXg UfY VYhhYf h\Ub mcif g]`YbWY(v7H78?9 FHEL;H8

<cf YjYfm h]aY mci fY[fYh h\Uh mci X]X bch gUm gcaYh\]b[&mci k]`` fY[fYh U \ibXfYX h]aYg h\Uh mci X]X bch _YYdmcif g]`YbWY(

A]bX dYcd`Y UfY bYjYf ]bjc`jYX ]b Uf[iaYbhg& UbX h\cgYk\c `]_Y hc Uf[iY UfY bYjYf _]bX( Jfih\Zi` kcfXg UfY bchU`kUmg d`YUgUbh& UbX d`YUgUbh kcfXg UfY bch bYWYggUf]`mhfih\Zi`(

SB7E'JPK

5I \RX ZDQW WR EH D FOHYHU SHUVRQ$ \RX KDYH WR OHDUQ KRZ WRDVN FOHYHUO\$ KRZ WR OLVWHQ DWWHQWLYHO\$ KRZ WR UHVSRQG TXLcHWO\$ DQG KRZ WR VWRS WDONLQJ ZKHQ WKHUH LV QRWKLQJ PRUH WRVD\&

CUbm ghid]X h\]b[g UfY ihhYfYX Vm dYcd`Y k\cgY cb`mach]jUh]cb ]g hc gUm gcaYh\]b[ cf][]bU`(

vLEBJ7?H;

?Z mci \UjY h]aY hc h\]b_ VYZcfY mci ghUfh hU`_]b[& h\]b_& ?g]h bYWYggUfm hc gdYU_6 M]`` k\Uh ? \UjY hc gUm \Ufa UbmcbY6

AJHSVGSXÂÅ

- FKDULW\ LV RQO\ WKHQ D UHDO FKDULW\ ZKHQ LW LQYROYHVVDFULILFH&

Ocif [c`X UbX g]`jYf ]g WUb_YfYX5 UbX h\Y figh cZ h\Yag\U`` VY U k]hbYgg U[U]bgh mci& UbX g\U`` YUh mcif Z`Yg\ Ug ]hkYfY Z]fY(

v@7C;I /4-

?b acbYmv]b h\Y acbYm ]hgY`Z& ]b ]hg UWei]g]h]cb(& ]b ]hgdcggYgg]cbvh\YfY]g gcaYh\]b[ ]aacfU`(

7 hfi`m _]bX dYl!cb WUbbch VY f]W\( 7 f]W\ dYfgcb& k]h\xcih eiYgh]cb& ]g bch U _]bX cbY(

v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

J\Yb gU]X @Ygig ibhc \]g X]gW]d`Yg& LYf]`m ? gUm ibhc mci&h\Uh U f]W\ aUb g\U`` \UfX`m YbhYf ]bhc h\Y _]b[Xca cZ\YUjYb( 7bX U[U]b ? gUm ibhc mci& ]h ]g YUg]Yf Zcf U WUaY` hc[c h\fci[\ h\Y YmY cZ U bYYX`Y& h\Ub Zcf U f]W\ aUb hcYbhYf ]bhc h\Y _]b[Xca cZ =cX(

vC7JJ>;M +34,-',.

AJHSVGSXÂǺ

-UW LV RQH RI WKH PHDQV RI XQLI\LQJ SHRSOH&

?Z VYUih]Zi` Ufh XcYg bch YldfYgg acfU` ]XYUg& ]XYUg k\]W\ib]hY dYcd`Y& h\Yb ]h ]g bch Ufh& Vih cb`m YbhYfhU]baYbh(FYcd`Y bYYX hc VY YbhYfhU]bYX ]b cfXYf hc X]ghUbWY h\YaxgY`jYg Zfca X]gUddc]bhaYbh ]b h\Y]f `]jYg(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?h ]g dcgg]V`Y hc ]aU[]bY h\Uh Ufh Wci`X X]Y& Vih ]h ]g bchdcgg]V`Y hc ]aU[]bY h\Uh fYU` Ufh Wci`X `]jY ]Z ]h VYWUaY UgÙjY cZ kYU`h\ h\Uh Ùi[\YX Uh h\Y dccf(

7fh ]g cbY cZ h\Y acgh dckYfZi` aYUbg cZ Wcbj]bW]b[ dYcxd`Y cZ Ubmh\]b[& Vch\ [ccX UbX VUX5 h\YfYZcfY& mci aighVY jYfm WUfYZi` ]b ]hg igY(

7b Ufh]gh( ]g cbY cZ hkc h\]b[g4 \Y ]g Y]h\Yf U \][\ df]Ygh& cfU acfY cf `Ygg gaUfh YbhYfhU]bYf(

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

CYX]hUh]cbg cf X]gWigg]cbg UVcih Ufh UfY h\Y acgh igY`YggdUgh]aYg _bckb( J\cgY k\c fYU``m _bck Ufh _bck h\UhUfh WUb gdYU_ kY`` k]h\ ]hg ckb Ùb[iU[Y& UbX h\Uh hcgdYU_ UVcih Ufh k]h\ kcfXg ]g igY`Ygg( Ccgh dYcd`Y k\cgdYU_ UVcih Ufh Xc bch ibXYfghUbX cf ZYY` fYU` Ufh(

AJHSVGSXÂĄ

Jc acjY& mci aigh _bck k\YfY hc [c& ]b hYfag Vch\ cZYjYfmXUm ach]cb UbX cZ mcif k\c`Y `]ZY( ?b cfXYf hc `]jY U[ccX `]ZY& mci aigh _bck k\YfY `]ZY `YUXg(

<HUIHFWLRQ LV RI 3RG& ?R ZLVK IRU SHUIHFWLRQ LV RI PDQ&v@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

B]ZY ]g bch []jYb hc ig h\Uh kY a][\h `]jY ]X`m k]h\cihkcf_( Dc& cif `]ZY ]g U ghfi[[`Y UbX U ^cifbYm( =ccXg\ci`X ghfi[[`Y k]h\ Yj]`5 hfih\ g\ci`X ghfi[[`Y k]h\ZU`gY\ccX5 ZfYYXca g\ci`X ghfi[[`Y k]h\ gÙjYfm5 `cjYg\ci`X ghfi[[`Y k]h\ \UhfYX( B]ZY ]g acjYaYbh& U kU`_U`cb[ h\Y kUm cZ `]ZY hc h\Y Zi`Z]`àYbh cZ h\cgY ]XYUgk\]W\ ]`ìa]bUhY ig& Vch\ ]b cif ]bhY``YWh UbX ]b cif\YUfhg& k]h\ X]j]bY `][\h(

v7ZhYf =?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

J\Y ]XYU` ]g k]h\]b mci& UbX h\Y cVghUW`Y hc fYUW\]b[ h\]g]XYU` ]g U`gc k]h\]b mci( Oci U`fYUXm dcggYgg U`` h\Y aUhYxf]U` Zfca k\]W\ hc WfYUhY mcif ]XYU` gY`Z(

vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

MY g\ci`X VY`]YjY h\Uh h\Y [ccXbYgg k\]W\ Yl]ghg ]b igUbX ]b h\]g kcf`X k]`` VY Zi`Z]``YX( J\]g ]g h\Y aU^cf WcbX]xh]cb hc aU_Y ]h \UddYb(

CGSILÁ

J\Y ZYUf cZ XYUh\ ]b aUb ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ \]g g]bg(

J\Y acfY gd]f]hiU` U `]ZY U dYfgcb `YUXg& h\Y `Ygg \Y ]g UZfU]XcZ XYUh\( <cf U gd]f]hiU` dYfgcb XYUh\ aYUbg gYhh]b[ h\Ygd]f]h ZfYY Zfca h\Y VcXm( IiW\ U dYfgcb _bckg h\Uh h\Yh\]b[g k]h\ k\]W\ \Y `]jYg WUbbch VY XYghfcmYX(

Eb`m h\cgY k\c Xc bch `]jY UfY bch UZfU]X cZ XYUh\(

5I DV >RFUDWHV VDLG$ GHDWK LV WKH VWDWH LQ ZKLFK ZH DELGH GXUcLQJ RXU VOHHS PDGH SHUPDQHQW$ ZH DOO NQRZ WKLV VWDWH$ DQGNQRZ WKHUH LV QRWKLQJ WHUULEOH LQ LW& -QG LI GHDWK LV D WUDQVIHUWR D EHWWHU OLIH$ DV PDQ\ SHRSOH WKLQN$ WKHQ GHDWK LV QRW HYLO

EXW D EOHVVLQJ&

MY g\ci`X [Yh fYUXm Zcf XYUh\& VYWUigY ]h k]`` WcaY&gccbYf cf `UhYf( J\Y VYgh h\]b[ hc Xc ]g hc `]jY U [ccX `]ZY(?Z mci `]jY U [ccX `]ZY& mci g\ci`X bch VY UZfU]X cZ XYUh\(

CGSILÂ

?KH PRUH FORVHO\ D SHUVRQ XQLWHV ZLWK WKH ZLOO RI 3RG$ WKHILUPHU WKLV SHUVRQ EHFRPHV LQ KLV DFWLRQV&

M\Yb U hfUjY`Yf ghUfhg cb U hf]d U`cb[ U fcUX k\]W\ ]gibXYf h\Y h\fYUh cZ fcVVYfg& \Y XcYg bch [c U`cbY( >YkU]hg Zcf U Zf]YbX& gcaYcbY hc VY \]g YgWcfh& UbX h\Yb \YZc``ckg \]a UbX gc ]g dfchYWhYX Zfca fcVVYfg( 7 k]gY aUb`]jYg \]g `]ZY h\Y gUaY kUm( 8ih h\YfY UfY gc aUbm hfciV`Yg]b h\]g kcf`X( >ck WUb kY ghUbX U`` cZ h\Ya6 M\Uh _]bX cZU Zf]YbX cf YgWcfh k]`` kY Z]bX cb cif kUm& gc h\Uh kY aUmdUgg h\fci[\ cif `]jYg k]h\cih ZYUf6 M\YfY g\ci`X kYhifb6 J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY UbgkYf& cb`m cbY fYU` Zf]YbX( J\Uh]g =cX(?Z mci Zc``ck =cX YjYfmk\YfY& mci k]`` ghYYf W`YUf cZ

hfciV`Y( Jc Zc``ck =cX ]g hc kUbh k\Uh >Y kUbhg& UbX bchhc kUbh k\Uh >Y XcYg bch kUbh( >ck hc UW\]YjY h\]g6 Oci\UjY hc ibXYfghUbX UbX Zc``ck >]g Ùkg(

v7ZhYf ;F?9J;JKI

:c bch k]g\ Zcf hcc aiW\& bcf h\]b_ h\Uh h\Y h\]b[g mcik]g\ Zcf UfY h\Y cb`m f][\h cf bYWYggUfm h\]b[g( Ocig\ci`X k]g\ cb`m Zcf h\cgY h\]b[g Zcf k\]W\ =cX k]g\Yg(

v>;DH? 7C?;?(

J\Y f][\h dUh\ ]b `]ZY ]g jYfm bUffck& Vih ]h ]g ]adcfhUbh hcZ]bX ]h( Oci WUb ibXYfghUbX ]h& Ug kY`` Ug kY WUb ibXYfxghUbX ]h& Ug U kU`_kUm cZ kccX Vi]`h UWfcgg U gkUad5 ]Zmci ghYd cZZ ]h& mci k]`` dìb[Y ]bhc h\Y gkUad cZ a]gibxXYfghUbX]b[ UbX Yj]`( 7 k]gY aUb fYhifbg hc h\Y hfiY dUh\Uh cbWY& Vih U kYU_ aUb dìb[Yg Zifh\Yf UbX Zifh\Yf ]bhch\Y gkUad& UbX ]h VYWcaYg acfY UbX acfY X]ZZ]Wi`h Zcf\]a hc [Yh cih(

CGSILÃ

M\Uh fYkUfX g\ci`X U [ccX XYYX Vf]b[ mci6 Eb`m h\Y ^cmmci fYWY]jY Vm dYfZcfa]b[ ]h( 7bX Ubm ch\Yf fYkUfX`YggYbg h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ h\]g ^cm(

>Y k\c XcYg [ccX hc ch\Yfg aU_Yg h\Y V][[Ygh []Zh hc\]agY`Z(

ÅHÁTWÁZ7bbUYig IYbYWU

7 gU]bh dfUmYX hc =cX ]b h\Y Zc``ck]b[ kUm4 sE =cX&d`YUgY VY _]bX hc Yj]` dYcd`Y Ug aiW\ Ug mci UfY hc _]bX dYcxd`Y( A]bX dYcd`Y U`fYUXm ZYY` [ccX& VYWUigY h\Ym UfY _]bX(t


?Z mci Xc [ccX UbX Ug_ Zcf U fYkUfX& mci kYU_Yb h\Y ZcfWYcZ mcif [ccXbYgg(


0R QRW OHW \RXU OHIW KDQG NQRZ ZKDW \RXU ULJKW KDQG LV

GRLQJ&vC7JJ>;M 04-

M\Uh U ^cm ]h ]g hc Xc U [ccX XYYX 7bX h\]g ^cm ]g ghfcb[Ygh]Z bc cbY _bckg h\Uh mci \UjY XcbY ]h(

CGSILÄ

;Uh]b[ hc YlWYgg ]g U j]WY îgh Ug VUX Ug aUbm ch\Yfg( MYcZhYb Xc bch bch]WY ]h ]b ch\Yfg& VYWUigY acgh cZ ig UfYgiV^YWh hc ]h(

J\YfY UfY g]bg U[U]bgh ch\Yfg& UbX g]bg U[U]bgh mcifgY`Z(Oci Wcaa]h g]bg U[U]bgh ch\Yfg k\Yb mci Xc bch fYgdYWh=cXrg gd]f]h ]b h\Ya5 mci Wcaa]h g]bg U[U]bgh mcifgY`Zk\Yb mci Xc bch fYgdYWh =cXrg gd]f]h ]b mcifgY`Z( EbY cZh\Y acgh Wcaacb g]bg U[U]bgh mcifgY`Z ]g [ìhhcbm(7 dYfgcb k\c cjYfYUhg WUbbch Z][\h Ùn]bYgg5 UbX U Ùnm

aUb WUbbch Z][\h gYliU` X]gg]dUh]cb( 7`` gd]f]hiU` hYUW\x]b[g ghUfh k]h\ fYghf]Wh]cbg& k]h\ Wcbhfc` cZ h\Y UddYh]hY(

3RG JDYH IRRG WR SHRSOH$ DQG WKH GHYLO JDYH FRRNV&

IcWfUhYg& U k]gY aUb& hf]YX hc UVghU]b Zfca U`` ibbYWYggUfmh\]b[g( >Y gU]X h\Uh ZccX g\ci`X gYfjY mci ]b Z][\h]b[mcif \ib[Yf& UbX bch ]b XYjY`cd]b[ gcd\]gh]WUhYX hUghYg&UbX \Y Ug_YX \]g ghiXYbhg hc Zc``ck \]g fi`Y( >Y fYa]bXYX\]g ghiXYbhg UVcih h\Y k]gY EXmggYig& k\ca 9]fWY& UbYj]` gcfWYfYgg& Wci`X bch giV^YWh hc \Yf aU[]W& VYWUigY \YX]X bch YUh hc YlWYgg( 8ih h\Y aYaVYfg cZ \]g WfYk& \]gZf]YbXg& kYfY hifbYX ]bhc U \YfX cZ d][g Vm \Yf Ug gccb Ugh\Ym fig\YX hc h\Y UVibXUbWY cZ gkYYh ZccX(

Bcc_ Uh mcif acih\5 h\fci[\ ]h& k\Yb mci YUh hc YlWYgg& ]``xbYggYg YbhYf mcif VcXm( 8Y\UjY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh k\Yb mciZ]b]g\ mcif X]bbYf& mci kUbh hc YUh U `]hh`Y acfY(

;Uh]b[ hc YlWYgg ]g bch Wcbg]XYfYX hc VY U g]b Vm aUbm&VYWUigY ]h dfcXiWYg bc bch]WYUV`Y \Ufa( 8ih h\YfY UfY g]bgk\]W\ XYghfcm \iaUb X][b]hm& UbX YUh]b[ hc YlWYgg ]g cbYgiW\ g]b(

CGSILĀ

îgh Ug ]hrg Zc``m hc hfm hc `]Zh mcifgY`Z ]bhc h\Y U]f& mcig\ci`X bch dfU]gY mcifgY`Z hcc aiW\( M\Yb mci dfU]gYmcifgY`Z& mci dfcXiWY h\Y cddcg]hY YZZYWh ]b ch\Yfg& UbXUddYUf `ckYf ]b h\Y]f YmYg(

5I \RX ZDQW RWKHU SHRSOH WR VSHDN ZHOO RI \RX$ GR QRW VSHDN

ZHOO RI \RXUVHOI&v8B7?I; F7I97B

7 aUb k\c dfU]gYg \]agY`Z XcYg bch gYY Ubmh\]b[ YlWYdh\]agY`Z UfcibX \]a( ?h ]g VYhhYf hc VY U V`]bX aUb h\Ub hcgYY cb`m mcifgY`Z UbX bcVcXm Y`gY(


>Y k\c U`kUmg `]ghYbg hc k\Uh ch\Yf dYcd`Y gUm UVcih \]ak]`` bYjYf Z]bX ]bbYf dYUWY(

7 ZÙhhYfYf gdYU_g \]g ZÙhhYfm VYWUigY \Y \Ug U `ck cd]bx]cb cZ \]agY`Z UbX cZ ch\Yfg(

v@;7D :; B7 8HKO;H;

?Z mci kUbh hc dfYgYfjY mcif [ccX bUaY& Xc bch dfU]gYmcifgY`Z UbX Xc bch gc aiW\ Ug U``ck ch\Yfg hc dfU]gY mci(

CGSILĂ

BcjY cZ =cX ]g `cjY ]b ]hgY`Z5 ]h ]g `cjY Zcf h\Y gU_Y cZ `cjY(J\]g _]bX cZ `cjY ]g h\Y \][\Ygh V`Ygg]b[( ?h XcYg bch U``ckh\Y g`][\hYgh dcgg]V]`]hm cZ hfYUh]b[ YjYb U g]b[`Y WfYUhifYk]h\cih `cjY5 ]Z h\YfY ]g YjYb cbY dYfgcb k\ca mci Xcbch `cjY& h\Yb mci `cgY =cXrg `cjY UbX V`Ygg]b[(

8RYH RI \RXU QHLJKERU ZLWKRXW ORYH RI 3RG LV D SODQW ZLWKcRXW URRWV& CRX VKRXOG ORYH 3RGbWKLV ORYH LV D UHDO DQG ILUPORYH& 5W GRHV QRW EHFRPH ZHDNHU$ RQO\ VWURQJHU$ DQG LW JLYHVJRRG WR WKRVH ZKR KDYH LW&

IcaY gUm h\Uh mci g\ci`X VY UZfU]X cZ =cX( Dch hfiY5 mci\UjY hc `cjY =cX( >ck WUb mci `cjY h\cgY k\ca mci UfYUZfU]X cZ6 =cX ]g `cjY& UbX \ck WUb mci VY UZfU]X cZ `cjY6Dc& mci g\ci`X bch ZYUf =cX& Vih `cjY >]a( 7bX ]Z mci`cjY =cX& h\Yb mci k]`` bch VY UZfU]X cZ >]a& cf Ubmh\]b[Y`gY ]b h\Y kcf`X(

CGSILÅ

F\mg]WU` kcf_& d\mg]WU` YlYfW]gY Zcf mcif VcXm& ]g U bYWYgxgUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ `]ZY( 7 aUb WUb ZcfWY ch\Yfg hc Xc h\]b[gZcf \]a& Vih \Y WUbbch ZfYY \]agY`Z Zfca h\Y bYWYgg]hm cZ\]g ckb d\mg]WU` kcf_( 7bX ]Z U aUb XcYg bch kcf_ UhbYWYggUfm UbX [ccX h\]b[g& h\Yb \Y k]`` kcf_ Uh ibbYWYgxgUfm UbX ghid]X h\]b[g(

Mcf_& h\Y dfcWYgg cZ kcf_ ]b ]hgY`Z& ]g h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbhh\]b[ Zcf ig& UbX ]hg fYkUfX g\ci`X VY cZ a]bcf ]adcfxhUbWY5 ]Z ]h ]g& mci d`YUgY mcif WfYUhcf& =cX( ?Z h\Y fYkUfX]g cZ aU^cf ]adcfhUbWY Zcf mci& UbX h\Y kcf_ ]hgY`Z cZa]bcf ]adcfhUbWY& h\Yb mci UfY h\Y g`UjY cZ h\Y fYkUfXUbX ]hg WfYUhcf& h\Y XYj]`& UbX YjYb h\Y `ckYgh UbX h\Y `YUghUacb[ U`` XYj]`g(

v@E>D HKIA?D

7 ;ifcdYUb dfU]gYX h\Y UXjUbhU[Yg cZ aYW\Ub]nYX `UVcfhc U 9\]bYgY aUb4 sJ\]g ]bjYbh]cb fY`]YjYg U aUb Zfca h\YbYYX Zcf d\mg]WU` kcf_(t 8ih h\Y 9\]bYgY aUb fYd`]YX&sF\mg]WU` kcf_ ]g [ccX( 8Y]b[ fY`]YjYX Zfca d\mg]WU`kcf_ k]`` VY Ub Ybcfacig X]gUghYf(t

1YHU\ SK\VLFDO ODERU PDNHV D PDQ PRUH QREOH& 5I \RX GR QRWWHDFK \RXU VRQ VRPH SK\VLFDO VNLOOV$ \RX WHDFK KLP WR URERWKHUV&

v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

M]h\cih YlYfW]gY cZ h\Y]f aigW`Yg& bY]h\Yf aUb bcf Ub]aU`WUb `]jY(Ic h\Uh h\]g YlYfW]gY aUm []jY mci ^cm UbX gUh]gZUWh]cb&

Xc [ccX d\mg]WU` kcf_( J\]g ]g U`gc h\Y VYgh kUm hc gYfjYch\Yfg(

CGSILǺ

FfUmYf ]g U h]aY hc fYa]bX mcifgY`Z cZ mcif Uhh]hiXY hc`]a]h`Ygg h\]b[g& hc =cX(

J\fci[\ dfUmYf& mci YghUV`]g\ mcif Uhh]hiXY hc h\Y VY[]bxb]b[ cZ YjYfmh\]b[5 mci WÙf]Zm mcif Uhh]hiXY hckUfX dYcxd`Y& mcif fYÙh]cbg\]d k]h\ UbX mcif XiXYg hc h\Ya& UbXhc h\Y <Uh\Yf cZ U`` cZ ig(

v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

?h ]g [ccX hc dfUm Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY YUW\ XUm( ?Z mci WUbbchWc``YWh mcif h\ci[\hg& VYhhYf bch hc dfUm& VYWUigY mcig\ci`X U`kUmg dfUm k]h\ mcif \YUfh& bch g]ad`m fYdYUhkcfXg k]h\ mcif hcb[iY(

5W LV JRRG DQG QHFHVVDU\ WR SUD\ LQ VROLWXGH$ EXW LV DOVR JRRGWR SUD\ ZKHQ \RX DUH LQ WKH FURZG$ ZKHQ \RX DUH H[FLWHG RULUULWDWHGbWR WKLQN DERXW \RXU VRXO DQG DERXW 3RG&

:c bch h\]b_ h\Uh mci WUb d`YUgY =cX k]h\ dfUmYf( Ocik]`` d`YUgY =cX Vm giVa]hh]b[ hc >]a( FfUmYf ]g îgh UfYa]bXYf Zcf mci cZ k\c mci UfY UbX k\Uh h\Y difdcgY cZmcif `]ZY ]g(

MUf UbX 9\f]gh]Ub]hm UfY bch WcadUh]V`Y(

MUf ]g cbY cZ h\Y kcfgh& acgh hYff]V`Y h\]b[g ]b h\]g kcf`X(

BDU LQ WKLV ZRUOG FDQ KH VWRSSHG QRW K\ WKH UXOLQJ HVWDEOLVKcPHQW& EXW E\ WKRVH ZKR VXIIHU IURP WKH ZDU& ?KH\ ZLOO GR WKHPRVW QDWXUDO WKLQJ* VWRS REH\LQJ RUGHUV&

J\Y UfaYX kcf`X UbX h\Y kUfg ]h kU[Yg k]`` VY XYghfcmYXcbY XUm& Vih bch Vm h\Y _]b[g cf h\Y fi`Yfg cZ h\]g kcf`X( MUf]g dfcZ]hUV`Y Zcf h\Ya( MUf k]`` ghcd h\Y acaYbh h\Y dYcxd`Y k\c giZZYf Zfca kUf Zi``m ibXYfghUbX h\Uh ]h ]g Yj]`(

CGSILĄ

CGSILÁÀ

J\Uh k\]W\ []jYg `]ZY ]g h\Y gUaY ]b U`` h\]b[g(

7`` `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg ZYUf dU]b UbX XYUh\( Jhm hc ibXYfghUbXmcifgY`Z ]b YjYfm `]j]b[ WfYUhifY4 Xc bch hcfhifY UbX Xcbch _]``( Ihcd giZZYf]b[ UbX XYUh\( 7`` `]j]b[ WfYUhifYgkUbh k\Uh mci kUbh5 U`` `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg dfU]gY h\Y]f `]jYg(


7`` `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg \UjY h\Y gUaY X]j]bY VY[]bb]b[& U`` UfY]b ib]hm MY UfY U`` aYaVYfg cZ cbY [fYUh VcXm(

DUhifY WfYUhYX ig fY`UhYX hc YUW\ ch\Yf& Zfca h\Y gUaYaUhYf]U`& Zcf h\Y gUaY difdcgY( 8YWUigY cZ h\]g& gcaYxk\YfY k]h\]b U`` cZ ig ]g aihiU` `cjY Zcf YUW\ ch\Yf($ # !#" 7DD7;KI I;D;97J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY f][\h dUh\kUm cZ `]ZY( IccbYf cf `UhYf& kYU`` k]`` aYYh YUW\ ch\Yf cb h\]g dUh\kUm( J\Y ibXYfghUbXx]b[ cZ ]h ]g jYfm W`YUf`m ]bgWf]VYX ]b cif \YUfhg& UbX ]h ]gk]XY UbX YUgm hc Z]bX( 7h h\Y YbX cZ h\]g kUm ]g =cX& UbX>Y WU``g ig hc >]agY`Z( ?h ]g gc dU]bZi` hc kUhW\ dYcd`Yk\c a]gg h\]g kUm cZ `]ZY UbX [c U`cb[ h\Y ch\Yf dUh\kUm&h\Y kUm cZ XYUh\(

v7ZhYf D?AEB7? =E=EB

1[SXQJH IURP \RXUVHOI DQ\WKLQJ ZKLFK LQWHUIHUHV ZLWK \RXUIHHOLQJ RI D VSHFLDO FRQQHFWLRQ EHWZHHQ \RXUVHOI DQG DOO OLYcLQJ FUHDWXUHV&

CGSILÁÁ

<ccX ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf h\Y `]ZY cZ Ub ]bX]j]XiU`& UbX aUff]U[Y]g bYWYggUfm Zcf h\Y `]ZY cZ \iaUb]hm( ?Z YUh]b[ hc YlWYgg ]gYj]` Zcf Ub ]bX]j]XiU`& h\Yb YlWYgg ]b aUff]U[Y UbX gYliU`]hmWfYUhYg Yj]` Vch\ Zcf ]bX]j]XiU`g UbX Zcf \iaUb gcW]Yhm(

- PDUULDJH LV D VSHFLDO REOLJDWLRQ EHWZHHQ WZR SHRSOH$ RIRSSRVLWH VH[HV$ WR KDYH FKLOGUHQ RQO\ ZLWK HDFK RWKHU& ?REUHDN WKLV SDFW LV D OLH$ D GHFHSWLRQ$ DQG D FULPH&

?h ]g U [fYUh h\]b[ k\Yb hkc gci`g UfY ib]hYX hc giddcfhYUW\ ch\Yf ]b h\Y]f kcf_& ]b h\Y]f giWWYggYg UbX a]gZcfxhibYg& ibh]` h\Y Ùgh g]`Ybh a]bihYg cZ h\Y Ùgh [ccX'VmY(

v=;EH=; ;B?EJ

J\Y F\Uf]gYYg U`gc WUaY ibhc \]a& hYadh]b[ \]a& UbX gUmx]b[ ibhc \]a& ?g ]h ÙkZi` Zcf U aUb hc dih UkUm \]g k]ZY ZcfYjYfm WUigY6 7bX \Y UbgkYfYX UbX gU]X ibhc h\Ya& >UjYmY bch fYUX& h\Uh \Y k\]W\ aUXY h\Ya Uh h\Y VY[]bb]b[aUXY h\Ya aU`Y UbX ZYaU`Y& UbX gU]X& <cf h\]g WUigY g\U`Ù aUb `YUjY ZUh\Yf UbX ach\Yf& UbX g\U`` W`YUjY hc \]g k]ZY4UbX h\Ym hkU]b g\U`` VY cbY Z`Yg\6 M\YfYZcfY h\Ym UfY bcacfY hkU]b& Vih cbY Z`Yg\( M\Uh h\YfYZcfY =cX \Uh\^c]bYX hc[Yh\Yf& `Yh bch aUb dih UgibXYf(

vC7JJ>;M +34-'0

J\Y ib]Z]WUh]cb cZ U aUb UbX U kcaUb Zcf h\Y Wcbh]biUxh]cb cZ \iaUb_]bX ]g U [fYUh UbX ]adcfhUbh XYYX Zcf YjYfm]bX]j]XiU`& Ug kY`` Ug Zcf U`` aUb_]bX( Oci WUbbch Xc ]h Ug ]hd`YUgYg mci& cf Ug mci `]_Y ]h( Oci \UjY hc Xc ]h ]b h\Y kUmk\]W\ kUg h\ci[\h UbX gYh cih Vm h\Y k]gY UbX \c`m dYcxd`Y k\c \UjY `]jYX VYZcfY ig(

CGSILÁÂ

J\Y XYYXg cZ U dYfgcb VYWcaY \]g `]ZY& VYWcaY \]g ZUhY(J\]g ]g h\Y `Uk cZ cif `]ZY(

J\Y FYfg]Ubg \UjY giW\ U ZUV`Y4 7ZhYf XYUh\& U gci` Z`Yk]bhc h\Y g_m& UbX aYh U hYff]V`Y kcaUb& U X]fhm UbX \cff]xV`Y UddUf]h]cb& k]h\ ZYghYfYX gcfYg X]gW\Uf[]b[ dig& k\ckUg [c]b[ ]b h\Y cddcg]hY X]fYWh]cb( sM\Uh UfY mci Xc]b[\YfY6t Ug_YX h\Y gci`( sM\c UfY mci6t J\Y hYff]V`YkcaUb UbgkYfYX& s? Ua mcif XYYXg(t

5W LV LPSRUWDQW QRW RQO\ WR WDON DERXW WKH JRRG OLIH EXW WR GRJRRG WKLQJV(v

v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

DYjYf dcghdcbY U [ccX XYYX k\]W\ mci WUb Xc bck&VYWUigY XYUh\ XcYg bch W\ccgY k\Yh\Yf mci \UjY cf\UjYbrh XcbY h\Y h\]b[g mci g\ci`X \UjY XcbY( :YUh\kU]hg Zcf bcVcXm UbX bch\]b[( ?h \Ug bY]h\Yf YbYa]Yg& bcfZf]YbXg(

v?D:?7D M?I:EC

M\Yb mci UddYUfYX ]b h\]g kcf`X& mci Wf]YX& UbX U`` h\YdYcd`Y UfcibX mci fY^c]WYX( Oci \UjY hc `]jY mcif `]ZY ]bgiW\ U kUm h\Uh k\Yb mci `YUjY h\]g kcf`X& mci k]``fY^c]WY& UbX U`` h\Y dYcd`Y UfcibX mci k]`` Wfm(

v?D:?7D M?I:EC

Ocif dUgh XYYXg kY][\ \YUj]`m cb h\Y ZihifY X]fYWh]cb cZmcif `]ZY5 Vih gcaYh]aYg& mci WUb W\Ub[Y h\]g X]fYWh]cbh\fci[\ h\Y YZZcfh cZ mcif gd]f]h(

CGSILÁÃ

J\Y WcbX]h]cb cZ k]gXca ]g dif]hm5 h\Y WcbgYeiYbWY cZk]gXca ]g h\Y dYUWY cZ mcif gci`(

7 aUb k\c Zc``ckg \]g k]g\Yg W\Ub[Yg \]g Uhh]hiXY k]h\h]aY( LYfm gccb \Y ]g bch gUh]gZ]YX Ubm acfY k]h\ h\Yh\]b[g \Y XcYg(

J\cgY dYcd`Y k\c \UjY bch\]b[ hc `cgY UfY jYfm f]W\(v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

7 k]gY dYfgcb bYjYf Wcbg]XYfg \]agY`Z hc VY k]gY( 7bX UdYfgcb bYjYf Wcbg]XYfg \]agY`Z k]gY k\Yb \Y \Ug h\Y]aU[Y cZ =cX VYZcfY \]a(

BLVGRP LV OLPLWOHVV$ DQG WKH FORVHU \RX DSSURDFK LW$ WKH PRUHLPSRUWDQW LW EHFRPHV IRU \RXU OLIH&- SHUVRQ FDQ DOZD\V LPSURYH KLPVHOI&

CGSILÁÄ

8RYH EULQJV SHRSOH WR XQLILFDWLRQ& ?KH XQLYHUVDO LQWHOOHFW$ZKLFK LV WKH VDPH IRU HYHU\RQH$ VXSSRUWV WKLV XQLILFDWLRQ&

Bcc_ UfcibX( M\Uh Xc h\Y kcf`Xrg dYcd`Y h\]b_ UVcih ]h6J\Ym h\]b_ UVcih YjYfmh\]b[ YlWYdh k\Uh ]g acgh ]adcfxhUbh( J\Ym h\]b_ UVcih XUbW]b[& aig]W& UbX g]b[]b[5 h\Ymh\]b_ UVcih \cigYg& kYU`h\& UbX dckYf5 h\Ym UfY ^YU`cigUVcih h\Y kYU`h\ cZ f]W\ dYcd`Y UbX _]b[g5 Vih h\Ym Xc bchh\]b_ Uh U`` UVcih k\Uh ]h aYUbg hc VY \iaUb(

v7ZhYf 8B7?I; F7I97B

EbY cZ h\YT]bU^cf fYgdcbg]V]`]h]Yg cZ U dYfgcb ]g hc aU_Yh\Uh ]bhY``YWhiU` gdUf_ k\]W\ mci \UjY fYWY]jYX .fca\YUjYb ]``ia]bUhY h\Y kcf`X UfcibX mci(

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

;jYfmh\]b[ ]b h\]g kcf`X ]g h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cb cZ h\Y X]j]bY]bhY``YWh(

7`` h\Uh kY _bck& kY _bck h\fci[\ h\Y ]bhY``YWh( J\cgYk\c Xc bch VY`]YjY& dYcd`Y k\c gUm h\Uh mci g\ci`X bchZc``ck mcif ]bhY``YWh& fYa]bX aY cZ h\cgY k\c gi[[Yghh\Uh mci hifb Xckb h\Y cb`m `UbhYfb k\]W\ g\ckg mci h\YkUm ]bhc h\Y XUf_bYgg(

CGSILÁĀ

8Y Z]``YX k]h\ `cjY Zcf ch\Yf dYcd`Y& ]bW`iX]b[ h\cgY k\cUfY ibd`YUgUbh cf \cgh]`Y hc mci( 7 fYU` hf]U` hc cbYrg `cjY]g hc `cjY mcif YbYa]Yg(

5I \RX ORYH \RXU HQHPLHV$ \RX ZLOO KDYH QR HQHPLHV&

J\Y acgh dYfZYWh Uacb[ aYb ]g \Y k\c `cjYg \]g bY][\xVcf k]h\cih h\]b_]b[ UVcih k\Yh\Yf h\Y dYfgcb ]g [ccX cfVUX(

vCE>7CC;:

8Y \iaV`Y UbX cddcgY X]gg]dUh]cb( ;jYb U h\]b gkcfXWUbbch Wih gU`h g]`_( Kg]b[ hYbXYf kcfXg UbX _]bXbYgg&mci WUb `YUX Ub Y`Yd\Ubh k]h\ U \U]f(


;jYfm h]aY mci UfY UVigYX Vm gcaYcbY UbX ZYY` Ub]acg]hmhckUfX \]a& fYaYaVYf h\Uh U`` dYcd`Y UfY W\]`XfYb cZ=cX( HY[UfX`Ygg cZ k\Yh\Yf h\]g dYfgcb ]g ibd`YUgUbh hcmci& mci g\ci`X bch ghcd `cj]b[ \]a Ug mcif Vfch\Yf&VYWUigY& Ug aiW\ Ug mci UfY& \Y ]g =cX"g gcb(

CGSILÁĂ

CcXYfb gW]YbWY WUbbch ghiXm HYHU\WKLQJ5 k]h\cih VY]b[giddcfhYX Vm fY`][]cb& gW]YbWY XcYg bch _bck k\Uh ]hg\ci`X ghiXm(

HYU` k]gXca ]g bch h\Y _bck`YX[Y cZ YjYfmh\]b[& Vih h\Y_bck`YX[Y cZ k\]W\ h\]b[g ]b `]ZY UfY bYWYggUfm& k\]W\ UfY`Ygg bYWYggUfm& UbX k\]W\ UfY Wcad`YhY`m ibbYWYggUfm hc_bck( 7acb[ h\Y acgh bYWYggUfm _bck`YX[Y ]g h\Y _bck`xYX[Y cZ \ck hc `]jY kY``& h\Uh ]g& \ck hc dfcXiWY h\Y `YUghdcgg]V`Y Yj]` UbX h\Y [fYUhYgh [ccXbYgg ]b cbYrg `]ZY( 7h dfYxgYbh& dYcd`Y ghiXm igY`Ygg gW]YbWYg& Vih Zcf[Yh hc ghiXm h\]g&h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh _bck`YX[Y(

7 dYfgcb k\c _bckg `]hh`Y `]_Yg hc hU`_& UbX cbY k\c_bckg aiW\ acgh`m _YYdg g]`Ybh(J\]g ]g VYWUigY U dYfgcb k\c _bckg `]hh`Y h\]b_g h\Uh

YjYfmh\]b[ \Y _bckg ]g ]adcfhUbh& UbX kUbhg hc hY``YjYfmcbY( 7 dYfgcb k\c _bckg aiW\ U`gc _bckg h\Uhh\YfY ]g aiW\ acfY \Y XcYgbrh _bck( J\Uhrg k\m \YgdYU_g cb`m k\Yb ]h ]g bYWYggUfm hc gdYU_& UbX k\Yb \Y ]gbch Ug_YX eiYgh]cbg& \Y _YYdg \]g g]`YbWY(

v7ZhYf @;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

5I DOO NQRZOHGJH ZHUH JRRG$ WKHQ SXUVXLW RI HYHU\ VRUW RINQRZOHGJH ZRXOG KH XVHIXO& .XW PDQ\ IDOVH PHGLWDWLRQV DUHGLVJXLVHG DV JRRG DQG XVHIXO NQRZOHGJH+ WKHUHIRUH$ KH VWULFWLQ VHOHFWLQJ WKH NQRZOHGJH \RX ZDQW WR DFTXLUH&

CGSILÁÅ

MY WUb ]adfcjY h\]g kcf`X cb`m Vm X]ghf]Vih]b[ h\Y hfiYZU]h\ Uacb[ h\Y kcf`Xrg dYcd`Y(

- VRFLHW\ FDQQRW OLYH ZLWKRXW D XQLWHG IDLWK DQG SXUSRVH& -OOVRFLDO DFWLYLW\ FDQQRW UHDOO\ LPSURYH RXU VRFLDO OLIH LI LW LV QRWEDVHG RQ WKH IRXQGDWLRQV HVWDEOLVKHG E\ UHOLJLRQ&

S=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

J\Y Udcgh`Yg `]jYX ib]hYX& ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh h\Ym g\UfYX cbY\YUfh UbX gci`( ?Z h\Ym \UX bch& bc cbY hcXUm kci`X _bckUVcih 9\f]gh]Ub]hm( M\Yb gcaY dU[Ubg X]X bch UWWYdh9\f]gh]Ub]hm& ]h kUg VYWUigY h\Ym X]X bch gYY Wcad`YhY ib]xZ]WUh]cb UbX `cjY Uacb[ 9\f]gh]Ubg( MY 9\f]gh]Ubg UfY hcV`UaY k\Yb ch\Yf dYcd`Y Xc bch UWWYdh h\Y 9\f]gh]UbZU]h\(

v7ZhYf I7?DJ @E>D 9>HOIEIJEC

9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]b ]hg difY UbX g]bWYfY Zcfa kcf_g `]_Y XmbUxa]hY4 ]h V`ckg id c`X acibhU]bg UbX cdYbg id bYk& `]a]hx`Ygg \cf]ncbg(

?Z mci gYY h\Uh gcaY UgdYWh cZ mcif gcW]Yhm ]g VUX& UbX mcikUbh hc ]adfcjY ]h& h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY kUm hc Xc gc4 mci\UjY hc ]adfcjY dYcd`Y( 7bX ]b cfXYf hc ]adfcjY dYcd`Y&mci VY[]b k]h\ cb`m cbY h\]b[4 mci WUb VYWcaY VYhhYfmcifgY`Z(

CGSILÁǺ

8Ùa]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]g U`kUmg kfcb[& VYWUigY bc cbY_bckg k\Uh \Ug \UddYbYX UbX \UddYbg ]b h\Y gci` cZUbch\Yf dYfgcb(

MY cZhYb aU_Y îX[aYbhg UVcih ch\Yf dYcd`Y( MY WU``cbY dYfgcb _]bX& h\Y ch\Yf ghid]X& h\Y h\]fX Yj]`& h\YZcifh\ W`YjYf( 8ih kY g\ci`X bch Xc gc( 7 aUb W\Ub[YgWcbghUbh`m5 \Y Z`ckg `]_Y U f]jYf& UbX YjYfm bYk XUm \Y X]Z'ZYfg Zfca k\Uh \Y kUg VYZcfY( >Y kUg ghid]X UbX VYWUaYW`YjYf5 \Y kUg Yj]` UbX VYWUaY _]bX Uh \YUfh5 UbX gc cb(Oci WUbbch îX[Y Ubch\Yf dYfgcb( J\Y acaYbh mciVÙaY \]a& \Y VYWcaYg gcaYcbY X]ZZYfYbh(

?Z mci kUbh hc WcffYWh mcif ZU]`]b[g& mci Xc bch \UjY h\Yh]aY hc kUghY ]b VÙa]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

:HYHU EODPH \RXU QHLJKERU XQWLO \RX KDYH EHHQ LQ KLV SODFH&vJ\Y J7BCK:

<cf[]jY ch\Yf dYcd`Y Zcf aUbm h\]b[g& Vih Xc bch Zcf[]jYmcifgY`Z Ubmh\]b[(

vFK8B?B?KI IOHKI

? _bck cZ amgY`Z h\Uh ? Xc bch k]g\ hc Xc Yj]`( ?Z ? Xc Yj]`&]h ]g VYWUigY ? WUbbch fYghfU]b amgY`Z( ?h ]g h\Y gUaY k]h\ch\Yf dYcd`Y4 h\Ym igiU``m Xc Yj]` VYWUigY h\Ym WUbbchfYghfU]b h\YagY`jYg Zfca Yj]`( J\YfYZcfY& k\m Xc ? h\]b_VUX`m cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y6 M\m g\ci`X ? VÙaY h\Ya6

CGSILÁĄ

J\Y WfYUh]cb cZ h\Y kcf`X kci`X \UjY VYYb U jYfm VUX UWhkYfY ]h f][\h Zcf f]W\ dYcd`Y hc `]jY cZZ h\Y kcf_ cZ h\Ydccf& UbX mYh h\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym kYfY h\Y VYbYZUWhcfg(

7 ghcbY ZU``g cb U dchvkcY hc h\Y dch5 U dch ZU``g cb UghcbYvkcY hc h\Y dch5 ]b YjYfm WUgY& ]h ]g VUX Zcf h\Y dch(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

?KH SOHDVXUHV RI WKH ULFK DUH RIWHQ DFTXLUHG E\ WKH WHDUV RI WKHSRRU&

MYU`h\ ]g WfYUhYX Vm h\Y WcbWYbhfUh]cb cZ \iaUb ÙVcf5igiU``m cbY dYcd`Y dfcXiWY ÙVcf& UbX ch\Yfg WcbWYbhfUhY]h( J\]g ]g WU``YX sh\Y X]j]g]cb cZ ÙVcft Vm WcbhYadcfUfmk]gY dYcd`Y(

J\YfY ]g gcaYh\]b[ kfcb[ k]h\ h\Y WfYUh]cb cZ h\]g kcf`X&VYWUigY h\Y f]W\ dYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym UfY h\Y VYbYZUWxhcfg cZ h\Y dccf& Vih ]b ZUWh h\cgY f]W\ UfY ZYX UbX XfYggYXVm h\Y kcf_ cZ h\YgY dccf UbX `]jY ]b ìlifm WfYUhYX Zcfh\Ya Vm h\Y dccf(

CGSILÂÀ

J\cgY k\c `]jY UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y k]`` cZ =cX WUbbch VYgYbg]h]jY hc h\Y îX[aYbhg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

Oci g\ci`X h\]b_ ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh YjYfmVcXm Wci`X `cc_]bhc mcif gci` UbX gYY k\Uh ]g hfUbgd]f]b[ h\YfY(


B]jY ]b h\Y cdYb(v7K=KIJ; 9ECJ;

?h ]g bch [ccX hc \]XY mcif VUX XYYXg& Vih]h ]g YjYb kcfgYhc ZÙibh h\Ya ]b h\Y cdYb UbX hc VY dfciX cZ h\Ya(Jc ZYY` g\UaY ]b h\Y WcadUbm cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]g [ccX&

Vih ]h ]g YjYb VYhhYf hc YldYf]YbWY g\UaY k\Yb mci UfYU`cbY k]h\ mcifgY`Z(

0R QRW KLGH DQ\WKLQJ IURP RWKHU SHRSOH ZKHQ WKH\ DVN \RX$KXW GR QRW ERDVW DERXW EDG WKLQJV LI \RX DUH QRW DVNHG DERXWWKHP&

Oci WUb \]XY gcaY h\]b[g Zfca ch\Yf dYcd`Y& Vih mci WUbxbch \]XY Ubmh\]b[ Zfca =cX(

<cf bch\]b[ ]g gYWfYh& h\Uh g\U`` bch VY aUXY aUb]ZYgh5bY]h\Yf Ubm h\]b[ \]X& h\Uh g\U`` bch VY _bckb UbX WcaYhc `][\h(

vBKA; 24+1

B]jY mcif `]ZY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh mci bY]h\Yf \]XY bcf \UjYU k]g\ hc X]gdÙm mcif `]ZY hc dYcd`Y(

CGSILÂÁ

MY _bck cif `]ZY Ug ]h Yl]ghg cb`m \YfY& ]b h\]g kcf`X5h\YfYZcfY& ]Z cif `]ZY ]g hc \UjY Ubm aYUb]b[& ]h g\ci`X VY\YfY ]b h\]g kcf`X(

:c bch k]g\ Zcf XYUh\ ^igh VYWUigY mcif `]ZY ]g \UfX( 7``h\Y VifXYbg cb mcif g\ci`XYfg k]`` \Y`d mci Zi`Z]`` mcifXYgh]bm( J\Y cb`m kUm hc [Yh f]X cZ mcif VifXYbg ]g hc `]jYmcif `]ZY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh mci Zi`Z]`` mcif XYgh]bm(


HYU` `]ZY ]g ZcibX cb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh( ?Z dYcd`Y hY`` mcih\Uh mci g\ci`X `]jY mcif `]ZY dfYdUf]b[ Zcf h\Y ZihifY& Xcbch VY`]YjY h\Ya( MY `]jY ]b h\]g `]ZY& UbX kY _bck h\]g `]ZYcb`m& UbX h\YfYZcfY U`` cif YZZcfhg g\ci`X VY X]fYWhYXhckUfX h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ h\]g `]ZY( Dch mcif `]ZY ]b [YbxYfU` Vih YjYfm \cif cZ h\]g `]ZY g\ci`X VY `]jYX ]b h\Y VYghkUm mci _bck \ck(

B]ZY ]g bY]h\Yf giZZYf]b[ bcf d`YUgifY& Vih h\Y Vig]bYggk\]W\ kY \UjY hc Xc& UbX k\]W\ kY \UjY hc Z]b]g\ \cbxYgh`m& id hc cif `]ZYrg YbX(

v7B;N?I :; JE9GK;L?BB;

?KLV ZRUOG$ RQO\ WKLV ZRUOG$ LV WKH SODFH RI RXU ZRUN$ DQG DOORXU IRUFHV$ DOO RXU HIIRUWV$ VKRXOG EH GLUHFWHG WRZDUG WKLV OLIH&

?Z hfih\ aU_Yg cif `]ZY YUg]Yf& h\Yb ]h ]g VYhhYf hc UWWYdhh\Y hfih\ h\Ub hc \]XY Zfca ]h( Eif `]ZY WUb VY W\Ub[YX&Vih h\Y hfih\ WUbbch VY W\Ub[YX4 ]h k]`` U`kUmg fYaU]b h\Yhfih\& UbX ]h k]`` YldcgY ig(

MY g\ci`X `]jY cif `]jYg Ug ]Z YjYfmcbY Wci`X gYY ig& Ug ]Zh\Y acgh gYWfYh WcfbYfg cZ cif gci` kYfY cdYb hc h\Y g][\hcZ ch\Yfg( M\m g\ci`X kY \]XY Ubmh\]b[6 Oci WUbbch \]XYUbmh\]b[ Zfca =cX( 7`` X]j]bY UbX \iaUb `YUfb]b[ WUb VYgiaaUf]nYX ]b cbY hfih\vh\Uh kY UfY aYaVYfg cZ cbY V][VcXm( DUhifY ib]hYX ig ]b cbY V][ ZUa]`mTUbX kY g\ci`X`]jY cif `]jYg hc[Yh\Yf& \Y`d]b[ YUW\ ch\Yf(

v7ZhYf HÁTWÁZ7DD7;KI I;D;97

>HHN WKH WUXWK* LW DOZD\V VKRZV XV ZKDW ZH VKRXOG GR$ ZKDWZH VKRXOG QRW GR$ DQG ZKDW ZH VKRXOG VWRS GRLQJ&

CGSILÂÂ

CGSILÆǼ

?KH HDUWK$ WKH DLU$ DQG WKH VXQ EHORQJ WR DOO RI XV+ WKH\ FDQQRWEH PDGH REMHFWV RI SURSHUW\&

MY UfY U]` j]g]hcfg ]b h\]g kcf`X( M\YfYjYf mci [c ]b h\]gkcf`X& hc h\Y bcfh\& hc h\Y gcih\& hc h\Y kYgh& cf hc h\YYUgh& h\YfY k]`` U`kUmg VY U aUb kU]h]b[ hc hY`` mci& sJ\]g ]gam dfcdYfhm( =Yh cih cZ \YfY t M\Yb mci j]g]h ch\YfWcibhf]Yg ]b h\Y kcf`X UbX mci WcaY VUW_& mci k]`` gYYW\Uh h\YfY ]g bch U g]b[`Y d]YWY cZ ZfYY ÙbX k\YfY mcif k]ZYWUb []jY V]fh\ hc mcif W\]`X& k\YfY mci WUb ghcd UbX ghUfhkcf_]b[ cb h\Y ÙbX& UbX k\YfY mcif W\]`XfYb WUb Z]bX fYghZcf mcif VcbYg Uh `]ZYrg YbX(

v7ZhYf <( HE8;HJ :; B7C;DD7?I

?Z mci `YUjY U aUb cb ÙbX k\]W\ ]g gcaYcbY Y`gYrg dfcdxYfhm UbX hY`` \]a h\Uh \Y ]g U Wcad`YhY`m ZfYY aUb UbX WUbkcf_ Zc] \]agY`Z& ]hrg Ug ]Z mci Xfcd \]a ]b h\Y a]XX`Y cZh\Y 7hÙbh]W UbX hY`` \]a h\Uh \Y ]g ZfYY hc [c Ug\cfY(

v>;DHO =;EH=;

J\cgY k\c ckb ÙbX ]b Uacibhg Ùf[Yf h\Ub h\Uh k\]W\ ]gbYYXYX hc ZYYX h\Y]f ckb ZUa]`]Yg WUb VY hfYUhYX Ug VY]b[[i]`hm cZ WUig]b[ h\Y dcjYfhm cZ aUbm ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

CGSILÂÄ

;QO\ WKH SHUVRQ ZKR IXOILOOV 3RG_V ODZ FDQ XQGHUVWDQG 3RG&?KH PRUH FORVHO\ KH IXOILOOV 3RG_V ODZ$ WKH EHWWHU KH XQGHUcVWDQGV 3RG&

J\YfY ]g bch U g]b[`Y VY`]YjYf k\c Zfca h]aY hc h]aY \Ugbch \UX gcaY \Yg]hUh]cbg UVcih h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ =cX( 8ihh\YgY acaYbhg cZ \Yg]hUh]cb UfY bch \UfaZi`( Eb h\YWcbhfUfm& h\Ym `YUX ig hc U VYhhYf ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ =cX(

IYY_]b[ =cX k]h\ mcif gci` ]g U dfcWYgg h\Uh \Ug `]a]h`Yggg]XYg UbX UgdYWhg(

CcgYg gU]X hc =cX& sM\YfY WUb ? Z]bX mci6t =cX gU]X& q ?Zmci UfY `cc_]b[ Zcf aY& mci \UjY U`fYUXm ZcibX aY(tJ\Ym Ug_YX U k]gY aUb& s>ck Xc mci _bck h\Uh =cX

Yl]ghg6t >Y fYd`]YX& s?g ]h bYWYggUfm hc \UjY U hcfW\ ]bcfXYf hc gYY h\Y gib6t MY Xc bch \UjY Ybci[\ kcfXg hcYld`U]b k\Uh =cX ]g& Vih kY _bck k]h\cih kcfXg h\Uh >YYl]ghg(

v7H78?9 M?I:EC

@Ykg Wcbg]XYf ]h U g]b hc ghUhY h\Y bUaY cZ =cX U`ciX(J\Ym UfY f][\h4 =cX ]g gd]f]h& UbX YjYfm bUaY ]g aUhYf]U`UbX bch gd]f]hiU`(

CGSILÆĆ

:if]b[ cif `]jYg kY \Y`d YUW\ ch\Yf4 gcaYh]aYg kY \Y`dch\Yf dYcd`Y& gcaYh]aYg kY UfY \Y`dYX Vm ch\Yfg( 8ih h\Ykcf`X ]g ZcfaYX gc h\Uh igiU``m gcaY dYcd`Y acgh`m \Y`dch\Yfg& UbX gcaY acgh`m fYWY]jY h\Y]f \Y`d(

-V \RX DFTXLUH REMHFWV$ DQG \RX XVH WKHP$ \RX VKRXOG NHHS LQPLQG WKDW WKH\ DUH WKH SURGXFWV RI SHRSOH_V ZRUN& BKHQ \RXGDPDJH RU GHVWUR\ WKHVH REMHFWV$ \RX GDPDJH RU GHVWUR\ WKH WRLO$DQG WKLV SDUW RI WKH OLIH$ RI RWKHU SHRSOH&

Bcc_ Uh U`` cZ mcif _bck`YX[Y Ug U []Zh& Ug U aYUbg cZ \Y`dx]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y(7 ghfcb[ UbX k]gY dYfgcb igYg \]g []Zhg hc giddcfh

ch\Yf dYcd`Y(@E>D HKIA?D

>Y`d g\ci`X VY aihiU`( CcfYcjYf& h\cgY k\c UWWYdh \Y`dUbX Ugg]ghUbWY Zfca h\Y]f Vfch\Yfg g\ci`X dUm h\Ya VUW_&bch cb`m k]h\ acbYm& Vih k]h\ `cjY& fYgdYWh& UbX [fUh]hiXY(

CGSILÂĂ

J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh W\Ub[Y h\Uh WUb cWWif ]b U dYfgcbrg`]ZY ]g U W\Ub[Y ]b \]g ZU]h\(

?bX]j]XiU`g X]Y& Vih h\Y k]gXca h\Ym \UjY cVhU]bYX ]bh\Y]f `]jYg XcYg bch X]Y k]h\ h\Ya( CUb_]bX _YYdg U`` h\]gk]gXca& UbX U dYfgcb igYg h\Y k]gXca cZ h\cgY k\c `]jYXVYZcfY \]a( J\Y YXiWUh]cb cZ aUb_]bX fYa]bXg aY cZ h\YWfYUh]cb cZ h\Y UbW]Ybh dmfUa]Xg& ]b h\Uh YjYfmcbY k\cS`]jYg dihg Ubch\Yf ghcbY ]b h\Y ZcibXUh]cb(

MY UfY hYadcfUfm j]g]hcfg ]b h\]g kcf`X5 UZhYf kY UfY YXixWUhYX& kY UfY WU``YX hc X]ZZYfYbh d`UWYg& UbX kY dUgg UkUm(8ih h\Y [YbYfU` YXiWUh]cb cZ aUb_]bX [cYg cb& jYfmg`ck`m Vih k]h\cih ]bhYffidh]cb(

v7ZhYf =?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

5W LV D ELJ PLVWDNH WR WKLQN WKDW IDLWK LV LPPXWDEOH$ WKDW LWGRHV QRW FKDQJH RYHU JHQHUDWLRQV& ?KH ORQJHU PDQNLQGH[LVWV$ LWV IDLWK EHFRPHV VLPSOHU DQG VWURQJHU& -QG WKH VLPSOHUDQG VWURQJHU RXU IDLWK EHFRPHV$ WKH EHWWHU ZH OLYH&

5I \RX EHOLHYH WKDW IDLWK LV WKH VDPH IRU DOO WLPHV DQG WKDW LWFDQQRW EH FKDQJHG$ \RX PLJKW MXVW DV ZHOO EHOLHYH WKDW WKRVHIDLU\ WDOHV DQG SURYHUEV DQG FKLOGUHQ V VWRULHV ZKLFK \RXUJUDQGPRWKHU WROG \RX ZKHQ \RX ZHUH D VPDOO EDE\ DUH UHDO$DQG WKDW \RX RXJKW WR EHOLHYH LQ WKHP DOO \RXU OLIH&

CGSILÂÅ

J\Y acfY U dYfgcb VY`]YjYg ]b =cX& h\Y `Ygg \Y ]g UZfU]X cZch\Yf dYcd`Y(

:c bch XYgdU]f( :c bch VY X]gUddc]bhYX ]Z mci gYY h\Uhmci WUbbch UWWcad`]g\ U`` h\Y [ccX k\]W\ mci kci`X `]_Yhc UWWcad`]g\( ?Z mci ZU``& hfm hc ghUbX id5 hfm hc cjYfWcaYh\Y cVghUW`Y VYZcfY mci( =Yh hc h\Y \YUfh cZ h\Y aUhhYf& hch\Y YggYbWY cZ h\]b[g(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\cgY k\c ZYUf dYcd`Y Xc bch ZYUf =cX5 h\cgY k\c ZYUf=cX Xc bch ZYUf dYcd`Y(

>Y k\c ]g bch UZfU]X cZ Ubmh\]b[& UbX k\c ]g fYUXm hc []jY\]g `]ZY Zcf U f][\hYcig WUigY& ]g aiW\ ghfcb[Yf h\Ub \Yk\ca ch\Yf dYcd`Y ZYUf UbX k\c \Ug h\Y `]jYg cZ ch\YfdYcd`Y ]b \]g dckYf(

8RRN IRU WKH EHWWHU PHQ DPRQJ WKRVH ZKR DUH GHVSLVHG&

:c k\Uh mci h\]b_ ]g bYWYggUfm& UbX Xc bch YldYWhfYkUfX( HYaYaVYf h\Uh U ghid]X dYfgcb ]g U VUX ^iX[Y cZW`YjYf XYYXg(

Oci kUbh hc gUjY mcifgY`Z Zfca h\Y dckYf cZ ch\Yf dYcxd`Yv[]jY mcifgY`Z hc h\Y dckYf cZ =cX( ?Z mci gYY mcifxgY`Z Ug VY]b[ ]b h\Y dckYf cZ =cX& h\Yb dYcd`Y WUbbch XcUbmh\]b[ hc mci(

CGSILÂǺ

M]gXca WUb VY UW\]YjYX Vm ]bbYf kcf_& h\fci[\ gc`]hUfmWcaaib]WUh]cb k]h\ mcifgY`Z5 ]h U`gc WUb VY UW\]YjYXk\Yb mci Wcaaib]WUhY k]h\ ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

B]ghYb UbX VY UhhYbh]jY& Vih Xc bch gdYU_ hcc aiW\5 UbXk\Yb mci UfY Ug_YX U eiYgh]cb& UbgkYf Vf]YZ`m( :c bch VYUg\UaYX hc UWWYdh h\Uh gcaYh]aYg mci Xc bch _bck UbUbgkYf hc k\Uh mci kYfY Ug_YX( :c bch [Yh ]bhc Ub Uf[i'aYbh ^igh Zcf h\Y gU_Y cZ Uf[iaYbh5 UbX Xc bch VcUgh(

vIK<? M?I:EC

Oci WUb j]Yk mcif ckb XfUkVUW_g cb`m h\fci[\ h\Y YmYgcZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

? \UjY `YUfbYX aUbm h\]b[g Zfca am hYUW\Yfg5 ? \UjY`YUfbYX aUbm h\]b[g Zfca am Zf]YbXg5 UbX ? \UjY `YUfbYXYjYb acfY Zfca am ghiXYbhg(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

?Z mci gYY U \c`m aUb& h\]b_4 \ck Wci`X ? VYWcaY `]_Y\]a6 ?Z mci gYY U X]gg]dUhYX aUb& h\]b_4 Xcbrh ? \UjY h\YgUaY j]WYg6

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

HYU` `cjY ]g bch ]b kcfXg Vih ]b XYYXg& UbX cb`m `cjY WUb[]jY mci fYU` k]gXca(

BKHQ \RX DUH LQ FRPSDQ\$ GR QRW IRUJHW ZKDW \RX KDYHIRXQG RXW ZKHQ \RX ZHUH WKLQNLQJ LQ VROLWXGH+ DQG ZKHQ\RX DUH PHGLWDWLQJ LQ VROLWXGH$ WKLQN DERXW ZKDW \RX IRXQGRXW E\ FRPPXQLFDWLQJ ZLWK RWKHU SHRSOH&

CGSILÂĄ

?Z gcaYh]aYg mci ZYY` h\Uh ]b gd]hY cZ U`` mcif k]g\Yg hc[U]b hf]iad\ cjYf mcif dUgg]cbg& h\Ym [U]b j]Whcfm cjYfmci& Xc bch h\]b_ h\Uh mci WUbbch WcbeiYf h\Ya Uh U``(Oci \UjY cb`m dfcjYb h\Uh mci kYfYbrh UV`Y ĄǺ h\]g cbYh]aY( 7 [ccX [fcca XcYg bch Xfcd \]g fY]bg k\Yb \Y WUbxbch ghcd \]g \cfgYg Uh cbWY Vih hf]Yg U[U]b hc di`` h\Y fY]bg&UbX YjYbhiU``m h\Y \cfgYg ghcd( Ic ]Z mci Wci`X bch fYg]ghh\Y hYadhUh]cbg cbWY& Wcbh]biY mcif Z][\h& UbX ]b h\Y YbXbch mcif dUgg]cb Vih mci k]`` [U]b h\Y j]Whcfm(

?U\ WR EH WKH PDVWHU RYHU JUHHG$ VORWK$ OHFKHU\$ DQG UDJH&

7 j]Whcfm cjYf cbYgY`Z ]g U V][[Yf UbX U VYhhYf j]Whcfm h\UbU j]Whcfm cjYf h\cigUbXg cZ dYcd`Y ]b U gWcfY cZ VUhh`Yg(J\cgY k\c \UjY UW\]YjYX j]Whcfm cjYf ch\Yf dYcd`Y WUbVY XYZYUhYX ]b ZihifY VUhh`Yg& Vih h\cgY k\c \UjY UW\]YjYXj]Whcfm cjYf h\YagY`jYg VYWcaY j]Whcfg ZcfYjYf(


7 dUgg]cb ]b U dYfgcbrg \YUfh ]g `]_Y U gd]XYfrg kYV( 7h h\YVY[]bb]b[ ]h ]g Ub U`]Yb j]g]hcf5 h\Yb ]h VYWcaYg U fY[i`Uf[iYgh5 h\Yb ]h VYWcaYg aUghYf cZ h\Y \cigY(

v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

>Y k\c \Ug UW\]YjYX j]Whcfm cjYf \]agY`Z \Ug fYU` dckYf(v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

7VghYbh]cb WUbbch VY UW\]YjYX Uh cbWY& Vih ]h g\ci`X VY UdfcWYgg& UbX U WcbghUbh YZZcfh( J\Y `]ZY cZ U dYfgcb k\caU_Yg h\]g YZZcfhg X]fYWhYX bch hc h\Y WU`a]b[ cZ \]g dUgxg]cbg Vih hc h\Y aUghYfm cZ h\Ya(J]aY UbX dYfg]ghYbWY \Y`d mci ]b h\YgY YZZcfhg(

CGSILÃÀ

J\Y hfih\ ]g bch cb`m U ^cm& ]h ]g Ub ]bghfiaYbh ]b WcbZ`]WhaiW\ acfY dckYfZi` h\Ub j]c`YbWY(

?KHQ FDPH <HWHU WR KLP$ DQG VDLG$ 8RUG$ KRZ RIW VKDOO P\EURWKHU VLQ DJDLQVW PH$ DQG 5 IRUJLYH KLP, 6LOO VHYHQ WLPHV,6HVXV VDLWK XQWR KLP$ 5 VD\ QRW XQWR WKHH$ @QWLO VHYHQ

WLPHV* EXW$ @QWLO VHYHQW\ WLPHV VHYHQ&vC7JJ>;M +24,+',,

?Z mci kUbh hc XYacbghfUhY gcaY hfih\ hc mcif `]ghYbYfg&Xc bch VY ]ff]hUhYX& UbX Xc bch gUm ib_]bX cf UVig]jYkcfXg(

v7ZhYf ;F?9J;JKI

?Z mci bch]WY gcaYcbY ]b Yffcf& h\Yb WcffYWh h\]g dYfgcbUbX \]g a]ghU_Y ]b U \iaV`Y kUm( ?Z \Y XcYg bch `]ghYb hcmci& VÙaY mcifgY`Z cb`m5 cf& YjYb VYhhYf& Xc bch VÙaYUbmVcXm& Vih Wcbh]biY hc VY \iaV`Y(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

?Z mci \UjY dUfhYX Zfca U dYfgcb& UbX \Y kUg bch gUh]gZ]YXk]h\ mci& cf X]X bch U[fYY k]h\ mci k\Yb mci kYfY f][\h&\Y ]g bch hc VÙaY& Vih dfcVUV`m ]h ]g mci k\c UfY hcVÙaY& VYWUigY mci kYfY bch _]bX Ybci[\ k]h\ h\]g aUb(

CGSILÃÁ

Jc fYdYbh aYUbg hc g\ck mcif j]WYg UbX kYU_bYggYg hc U``(HYdYbhUbWY aYUbg hU_]b[ fYgdcbg]V]`]hm Zcf U`` cZ h\Y VUXh\]b[g mci \UjY XcbY& dif]Zm]b[ mcif gci`& UbX dfYdUf]b[hc UWWYdh [ccXbYgg(

M\Yb U _]bX aUb XcYg bch UWWYdh \]g a]ghU_Yg UbX hf]YgU`kUmg hc îgh]Zm \]agY`Z& \Y VYWcaYg Ub ib_]bX aUb(

0R \RX KDYH TXDOLWLHV ZKLFK FDQ EH FULWLFL]HG DQGLPSURYHG, ?U\ WR DGPLW WKDW WKLV LV VR$ DQG WR ILQG WKHVH TXDOcLWLHV RXW E\ \RXUVHOI

Dch\]b[ WUb aU_Y U dYfgcbrg gci` gcZhYf h\Ub h\Y ibXYfxghUbX]b[ cZ \]g ckb VÙaY& UbX bch\]b[ WUb aU_Y cbY\UfXYf h\Ub h\Y XYg]fY U`kUmg hc VY f][\h(

v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

J\cgY k\c WcjYf h\Y]f c`X g]bg k]h\ dfYgYbh'XUm [ccXXYYXg fYa]bX aY cZ h\Y accb`][\h k\]W\ ]`ìa]bUhYg h\]gXUf_ kcf`X cb U W`ciXm b][\h(

v :>7CC7F7:7& U Vcc_ cZ 8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

7 aUb k]`` U`kUmg ibXYfghUbX \]g g]bg Ug kY`` Ug \]g `]a]hg]b h\]g `]a]h`Ygg kcf`X(

RSMNÁ

IW]YbWY WUb VY X]j]XYX ]bhc Ub ]bZ]b]hY biaVYf cZ X]gW]xd`]bYg& UbX h\Y Uacibh cZ _bck`YX[Y h\Uh WUb VY difgiYX]b YUW\ X]gW]d`]bY ]g `]a]h`Ygg( J\Y acgh Wf]h]WU` d]YWY cZ_bck`YX[Y& h\Yb& ]g h\Y _bck`YX[Y cZ k\Uh ]g YggYbh]U` hc`YUfb UbX k\Uh ]gbrh(

7 \i[Y Uacibh cZ _bck`YX[Y ]g UWWiai`UhYX Uh dfYgYbh(Iccb cif UV]`]h]Yg k]`` VY hcc kYU_& UbX cif `]jYg hccg\cfh& hc ghiXm h\]g _bck`YX[Y( MY \UjY jUgh hfYUgifYg cZ_bck`YX[Y Uh cif X]gdcgU` Vih UZhYf kY ghiXm h\Ya& kYcZhYb Xc bch igY h\Ya Uh U``( ?h kci`X VY VYhhYf bch hc\UjY h\]g VifXYb& h\]g ibbYWYggUfm _bck`YX[Y& k\]W\ kYXc bch fYU``m bYYX(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

Jcc jcfUW]cig fYUX]b[& VY[ib Uh hcc YUf`m Ub U[Y& Z]``g cifa]bXg k]h\ ibX][YghYX aUhYf]U`( Eif aYacfm WUbVYWcaY h\Y aUghYf cZ cif ZYY`]b[g UbX cif ZUhY5 UbX k\Yb]h XcYg& Ub ]bhY``YWhiU` YZZcfh ]g fYei]fYX hc fY]bZcfWY cifZYY`]b[g k]h\ df]aYjU` ]bbcWYbWY& hc Z]bX cifgY`jYg Ua]Xghh\Y Xighm \YUdg cZ ZcfY][b h\ci[\hg UbX j]Ykdc]bhg& ]bcfXYf hc ghUfh ZYY`]b[ Vm cifgY`jYg& UbXv? Ua fYUXm hcgUmv]b cfXYf hc `]jY cb cif ckb(

v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

.HZDUH RI IDOVH NQRZOHGJH& -OO HYLO FRPHV IURP LW&

Abck`YX[Y ]g `]a]h`Ygg( J\YfYZcfY& h\YfY ]g U a]bigWi`YX]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb h\cgY k\c _bck U `ch UbX h\cgY k\c_bck jYfm `]hh`Y(

RSMNÂ

J\Y cb`m fYU` `]ZY ]g cbY `]jYX W`cgY hc =cX( J\]g XcYg bch\UddYb Vm ]hgY`Z5 mci aigh aU_Y Ub YZZcfh hc aU_Y h\]g\UddYb& UbX h\]g YZZcfh k]`` Vf]b[ mci ^cm(

7 \UV]h ]g bYjYf [ccX& YjYb U \UV]h cZ Xc]b[ [ccX XYYXg(=ccX XYYXg& UZhYf h\Ym VYWcaY \UV]hg& UfY bc `cb[Yf UWhgcZ j]fhiY( HYU` [ccX ]g UW\]YjYX cb`m k]h\ YZZcfh(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

M\Yb mci WUffm mcif VifXYb& mci g\ci`X _bck h\Uh ]h ]g[ccX Zcf mci hc \UjY ]h( CU_Y h\Y VYgh cZ h\]g VifXYb UbXhU_Y Zfca ]h YjYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf mcif ]bhY`x`YWhiU` `]ZY& Ug mcif ghcaUW\ hU_Yg Zfca ZccX YjYfmh\]b[bYWYggUfm Zcf mcif Z`Yg\& cf Ug Z]fY Vifbg Vf][\hYf UZhYfmci dih gcaY kccX cb ]h(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

.H DWWHQWLYH WR ZKDW \RX GR+ QHYHU FRQVLGHU DQ\WKLQJXQZRUWK\ RI \RXU DWWHQWLRQ&

v9ED<K9?KI

Id]f]hiU` YZZcfh UbX h\Y ^cm h\Uh WcaYg Zfca ibXYfghUbX]b[`]ZY [c \UbX ]b \UbX `]_Y d\mg]WU` YlYfh]cb UbX fYgh( M]h\xcih d\mg]WU` YlYfh]cb& h\YfY ]g bc ^cm ]b fYgh5 k]h\cih gd]fx]hiU` YZZcfh& h\YfY WUb VY bc ^cmZi` ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ `]ZY(

RSMNÃ

M\Yb ? X]Y& cb`m cbY cZ hkc h\]b[g WUb \UddYb4 Y]h\Yf h\]gYggYbWY k\]W\ ? ibXYfghUbX Ug amgY`Z k]`` hfUbgZcfa ]b hcU X]ZZYfYbh VY]b[& cf ? k]`` ghcd VY]b[ U gYdUfUhY ]bX]j]XiUÙbX VYWcaY U dUfh cZ =cX( ;]h\Yf dcgg]V]`]hm ]g [ccX(

:YUh\ ]g h\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ h\]g VcXm k]h\ k\]W\ ? ibXYfxghUbX h\Y kcf`X ]b h\]g `]ZY( ?h ]g h\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ h\Y[Ùgg h\fci[\ k\]W\ ? `cc_ Uh h\Y kcf`X( 7bX kY Xc bch_bck k\Yh\Yf h\]g [Ùgg k]`` VY fYdÙWYX Vm Ubch\Yf5 cfk\Yh\Yf h\Y YggYbWY k\]W\ `cc_g h\fci[\ h\Y k]bXckk]`` ]bhY[fUhY k]h\ h\Y kcf`X( MY WUbbch _bck h\]g(

J\YfY ]g U WYfhU]b `]a]h hc h\Y Uddfcdf]UhY `Yb[h\ cZ Ubmh]aY ]b h\]g kcf`X( @igh Ug h\Y Zfi]hg UbX jY[YhUV`Yg UfY`]a]hYX Vm h\Y gYUgcbg cZ h\Y mYUf& YjYfmh\]b[ g\ci`X \UjY]hg VY[]bb]b[& ]hg `]ZY& UbX ]hg YbX]b[& UZhYf k\]W\ ]h g\ci`XdUgg UkUm( M]gY dYcd`Y k]``]b[`m giVa]h hc h\]g cfXYf(


7`` h\Uh ? _bck UVcih =cX Vf]b[g aY hc h\Y Zc``ck]b[WcbWìg]cb4 U`` h\Uh >Y X]X Zcf ig kYfY h\Y VYgh h\]b[gdcgg]V`Y(


CRX VKRXOG OLYH \RXU OLIH VR WKDW \RX DUH QRW DIUDLG RI GHDWK&DQG DW WKH VDPH WLPH GR QRW ZLVK WR GLH&

RSMN B]ZY g\ci`X UbX WUb VY `]a]h`Ygg ^cm(

B]ZY ]b h\]g kcf`X ]g bch U jU`Y cZ hYUfg& bch U hf]U`& Vih Uh\]b[ h\Uh gifdUggYg cif ]aU[]bUh]cb( B]ZY Wci`X VY `]a]hx`Ygg ^cm& ]Z kY kci`X cb`m hU_Y ]h Zcf k\Uh ]h ]g& ]b h\Y kUm]h ]g []jYb hc ig&

7 dYfgcbrg ibZf]YbX`m Uhh]hiXY hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y aU_Yg `]ZYib\Uddm& Vch\ Zcf h\Uh dYfgcb UbX Zcf h\cgY k\c gifxfcibX \]a( 7 Zf]YbX`m accX UbX `cj]b[ Uhh]hiXY UfY Ug Ubc]` k\]W\ `iVf]WUhYg h\Y k\YY`g cZ `]ZY& aU_]b[ h\Ya acjYYUg]`m UbX gacch\`m(

?U\ WR OLYH \RXU OLIH DQG EH KDSS\ ZLWK\ RXU GHVWLQ\$ DFTXLUcLQJ LQQHU SHDFH E\ ORYH DQG JRRG GHHGV&

J\Y gYWfYh cZ \Udd]bYgg6 ;b^cm gaU`` d`YUgifYg(vI7CK;B IC?B;I

:c bch gYY_ d`YUgifY YjYfmk\YfY& Vih U`kUmg VY fYUXmZ]bX ]h(

v@E>D HKIA?D

J\Y VYgh kUm hc `]jY ^cmZi``m ]g hc VY`]YjY h\Uh `]ZY kUg[]jYb Zcf ^cm( M\Yb ^cm X]gUddYUfg& `cc_ Zcf mcif a]ghU_Y(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

7 hfi`m k]gY aUb ]g U`kUmg ^cmZi`(

RSMNĀ

?h ]g X]ZZ]Wi`h hc Ujc]X kcf_]b[ ]b `]ZY k]h\cih Y]h\Yf g]bxb]b[& Wcaa]hh]b[ j]c`YbWY& VY]b[ U dUfhm hc j]c`YbWY& cfVm ZÙhhYf]b[ UbX d`YUg]b[ h\Y U[Ybhg cZ j]c`YbWY(

8Y]b[ dccf ]g VYhhYf h\Ub `]j]b[ ]b ìlifm UbX gYfj]b[ h\Yf]W\( :c bch ghUbX Uh h\Y Xccf cZ U f]W\ aUb Ug_]b[ ZcfZUjcfg ]Z mci \cdY hc `YUX U [ccX `]ZY(

v?D:?7D FHEL;H8 ppp

7 XfYgg dfYgYbhYX hc mci Ug U []Zh Vm h\Y _]b[ aUm VYVYUih]Zi`& Vih mcif ckb g]ad`Y XfYgg ]g VYhhYf( :]ZZYfYbhaYU`g Zfca h\Y hUV`Yg cZ h\Y f]W\ aUm VY [ccX& Vih U `cUZcZ g]ad`Y VfYUX Zfca mcif ckb hUV`Y U`kUmg hUghYg aiW\VYhhYf(

uvCKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

Jc h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c Xc bch kcf_ h\Y ÙbX& h\Y gc]` gUmg4 ]Zmci Xc bch kcf_ aY& Vm Udd`m]b[ d\mg]WU` ÙVcf k]h\ Vch\cZ mcif \UbXg& h\Yb mci k]`` ghUbX ]b Zfcbh cZ h\Y Xccfg cZch\Yfg Ug_]b[ Zcf \Y`d5 mci k]`` U`kUmg VY ZUhYX hc igY h\Y`YZhcjYfg cZ h\Y f]W\(

vPEHE7IJ;H

CRX ZLOO ILQG WKDW SHRSOH XQZLOOLQJ WR ZRUN ZLOO HLWKHU WDNHDGYDQWDJH RI RWKHUV RU EH KXPLOLDWHG E\ WKHP&

RSMNĂ

FYcd`Y ]bjc`jY h\YagY`jYg ]b Wcibh`Ygg UWh]j]h]Yg k\]W\h\Ym Wcbg]XYf hc VY ]adcfhUbh& Vih h\Ym Zcf[Yh UVcih cbYUWh]j]hm k\]W\ ]g acfY ]adcfhUbh UbX bYWYggUfm h\Ub Ubmch\Yf& UbX k\]W\ ]bW`iXYg U`` ch\Yf h\]b[g4 h\Y ]adfcjYxaYbh cZ h\Y]f gci`(

?KH ELJJHVW KDSSLQHVV LV ZKHQ DW WKH HQG RI WKH \HDU \RX IHHOEHWWHU WKDQ DW WKH EHJLQQLQJ


s8Y dYfZYWh& Ug mcif <Uh\Yf ]b \YUjYb ]g dYfZYWh(t J\]gaYUbg h\Uh mci g\ci`X hfm hc Z]bX h\Y dfYgYbWY cZ h\Y>c`m Id]f]h ]b mcif gci`(

Jc ]adfcjY cifgY`jYg& hc acjY hckUfX h\Uh [cU`& dYfZYWh]cb&h\Uh dihg bc `Ygg U XYaUbX cb ig Zcf VY]b[ ibUhhU]bUV`Y&fYei]fYg gc`]hiXY& fYacjU` Zfca h\Y WcbWYfbg cZ YjYfmXUm`]ZY( 7bX mYh WcbghUbh gc`]hiXY fYbXYfg gY`Z']adfcjYaYbh]adcgg]V`Y& ]Z bch dc]bh`Ygg( 7 VU`UbWY aigh VY ghfiW_VYhkYYb aYX]hUh]b[ ]b gc`]hiXY UbX h\Yb Udd`m]b[ h\]g hcmcif YjYfmXUm `]ZY(

RSMNÅ

Jc fYdUm Yj]` k]h\ [ccXbYgg ]g YUg]Yf& k]gYf& UbX acfY bUhxifU` h\Ub hc fYdUm Yj]` k]h\ Yj]`(

HYdUm Yj]` k]h\ [ccXbYgg(vJ\Y J7BCK:

7bX k\Yb h\Ym kYfY WcaY hc h\Y d`UWY& k\]W\ ]g WU``YX9U`jUfm& h\YfY h\Ym WfiW]Z]YX \]a& UbX h\Y aU`YZUWhcfgScbY cb h\Y f][\h \UbX& UbX h\Y ch\Yf cb h\Y `YZh( J\YbgU]X @Ygig& <Uh\Yf& Zcf[]jY h\Ya5 Zcf h\Ym _bck bch k\Uhh\Ym Xc(

vBKA; ,-4--'-.

/RQTXHU UDJH ZLWK KXPLOLW\$ FRQTXHU HYLO ZLWK JRRGQHVV$FRQTXHU JUHHG ZLWK JHQHURVLW\$ DQG FRQTXHU OLHV ZLWK WUXWK&


M\Yb kY hfYUh cif bY][\Vcfg Ug h\Ym XYgYfjY hc VYhfYUhYX& kY aU_Y h\Ya YjYb kcfgY5 k\Yb kY hfYUh h\Ya Ug]Z h\Ym kYfY k\c kY k]g\ h\Ym kYfY& kY ]adfcjY h\Ya(

Sv@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

J\cgY k\c hU_Y ^cm ]b fYdUm]b[ Ub Yj]` k]h\ [ccXbYgg k]``U`kUmg hfm hc YldYf]YbWY h\]g ^cm U[U]b(

RSMNǺ

FYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh ]Z h\Ym WU`` aUgg aifXYf skUf&t h\YbaUgg aifXYf k]`` ghcd VY]b[ U aifXYf& U Wf]aY(

EbY WUb XYbm 9\f]gh ]b jUf]cig kUmg4 cbY WUb VÙgd\YaYfiXY`m& cf acW_ \]g [fYUhbYgg( 8ih giW\ kUmg UfY bch XUbx[Yfcig5 fY`][]cb ]g hcc dfYW]cig Zcf dYcd`Y& UbX h\]g acW_xYfm WUbbch W`YUjY h\Ya Zfca ]h( 8ih h\YfY ]g Ubch\Yf kUmhc XYbm 9\f]gh4 h\]g ]g k\Yb mci WU`` >]a mcif aUghYf&UbX mci WÙ]a hc Zc``ck >]g WcaaUbXaYbhg& Vih mcigiddfYgg Ubm ZfYY h\ci[\h Vm eich]b[ \]g kcfXg& UbX X]gx[i]gY U`` ghid]X]h]Yg& U`` a]ghU_Yg& UbX U`` g]bg cZ h\Y dYcd`Y]b \]g bUaY( J\]g gYWcbX kUm ]g h\Y hfi`m XUb[Yfcig cbY(

vJ>;E:EH; F7HA;H

?h ]g bch hfiY h\Uh U kUf U[U]bgh U ZcfY][b bUh]cb WUb VYgUWfYX( ?h ]g bch hfiY h\Uh h\Y YUfh\ kUbhg V`ccX( J\Y YUfh\kUbhg difY kUhYf Zfca h\Y g_m Zcf ]hg f]jYfg& difY XYkZfca ]hg W`ciXg& Vih bch V`ccX( MUf ]g WifgYX Vm =cX& UgUfY h\cgY k\c dUfh]W]dUhY ]b ]h(

v7B<H;: :; L?=DO

-QG EHFDXVH ODZOHVVQHVV LV LQFUHDVHG$ PRVW SHRSOH_V ORYH ZLOOJURZ FROG&

HUh\Yf& ]h ]g mcif Wf]aYg h\Uh gYdUfUhY mci Zfca =cX& UbX]h ]g mcif g]bg h\Uh aU_Y \]a \]XY \]g ZUWY gc h\Uh \Y k]``bch \YUf mci( <cf mcif \UbXg UfY ghU]bYX k]h\ V`ccX& mcifZ]b[Yfg k]h\ [i]`h5 mcif `]dg gdYU_ ZU`gY\ccX& UbX mcifhcb[iY ihhYfg XYWY]h(

v?I7?7> /34,'-

CifXYf ]g U`kUmg U Wf]aY& bc aUhhYf k\ca& UbX \ck ]h ]gîgh]Z]YX(

RSMNĄ

BcjY cZ [ccXbYgg UbX ZU]h\ ]b ]aacfhU`]hm UfY ]bgYdUfUV`Y(

DcVcXm WUb gUm h\Uh \Y _bckg k\Uh h\Y UZhYf`]ZY k]`` VY(Eif VY`]YZg UfY VUgYX bch cb `c[]WU` dfccZg Vih cb acfU`cbYg UbX h\YfYZcfY ? WUbbch gUm h\Uh =cX Yl]ghg UbX ? Ua]aacfhU`& Vih ? WUb gUm h\Uh =cX Yl]ghg UbX h\Uh am sgY`Zt]g ]aacfhU`( J\]g aYUbg h\Uh am ZU]h\ ]b =cX ]g gc W`cgY`mWcbbYWhYX k]h\ am bUhifY h\Uh h\]g ZU]h\ WUbbch VY gYdUxfUhYX Zfca aY(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

J\Y Ub]aU` VY[]bb]b[ X]gUddYUfg& h\Y jY]` ]g hU_Yb Zfcah\Y ZihifY& h\Y XUf_bYgg X]gdYfgYg( ?h ]g h\Yb h\Uh kY ZYY`cif ]aacfhU`]hm(

v7ZhYf I7?DJ C7HJ?D

MY `]jY ]b h\]g kcf`X `]_Y U W\]`X k\c YbhYfg U fcca k\YfYU W`YjYf dYfgcb ]g gdYU_]b[( J\Y W\]`X X]X bch \YUf h\YVY[]bb]b[ cZ h\Y gdYYW\& UbX \Y `YUjYg VYZcfY h\Y YbX5 UbXh\YfY UfY WYfhU]b h\]b[g k\]W\ \Y \YUfg Vih XcYg bch ibXYfxghUbX( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& h\Y [fYUh gdYYW\ cZ =cX ghUfhYXaUbm& aUbm WYbhif]Yg VYZcfY kY ghUfhYX `YUfb]b[& UbX ]h k]``Wcbh]biY Zcf aUbm WYbhif]Yg UZhYf kY hifb hc Xigh( MY\YUf cb`m dUfh cZ ]h& UbX kY Xc bch ibXYfghUbX h\Y V][[YghdUfh cZ k\Uh kY \YUf& Vih bYjYfh\Y`Ygg& U V]h jU[iY`m& kYibXYfghUbX gcaYh\]b[ [fYUh& gcaYh\]b[ ]adcfhUbh(

5I \RX WUXO\ ORYH JRRGQHVV "3RG#$ WKHQ \RX FDQQRW KDYHGRXEWV LQ \RXU LPPRUWDOLW\&

RSMNÁÀ

J\Y \c`m gd]f]h k\]W\ Yl]ghg ]b dYcd`Y ]g `]VYfUhYX acfYUbX acfY( J\]g k]`` W\Ub[Y cif Yl]gh]b[ kcf`X cfXYf(

HYU` gW]YbWY g\ckg ig \ck hc Udd`m cif fY`][]cig ZU]h\ hccif cihYf `]jYg( 7fh g\ckg ig \ck hc Udd`m ]h hc cif ZYY`]b[g

?KH IXUWKHU DQ\ SXUSRVH WKH IDVWHU ZH VKRXOG ZRUN WRZDUG LW&v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

J\Y `cb[Yf ? `]jY& h\Y acfY h\]b[g ? aigh Wcad`YhY(vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

J\Y acfY kY ibXYfghUbX cif X]j]bY bUhifY& h\Y acfY ]hgfi`Yg g\ci`X VY Zi`Z]``YX ]b cif UWh]cbg(

RSMNÁÁ

;jYfmh\]b[ ]g WcbbYWhYX acfY W`cgY`m ]b h\Y gd]f]hiU`kcf`X h\Ub ]b h\Y aUhYf]U` kcf`X( ;jYfm `]Y Vf]b[g ai`h]d`Y`]Yg& YjYfm WfiY`hm Vf]b[g acfY WfiY`hm(

LYfm cZhYb dYcd`Y UfY dfciX cZ h\Y dif]hm cZ h\Y]f WcbxgW]YbWY cb`m VYWUigY h\Y]f aYacfm ]g hcY g\cfh(

vP7D?P7: H7<7;PIAO

:fcd UZhYf Xfcd& kUhYf Z]``g h\Y jYggY`5 ]b h\Y gUaY kUmh\cgY k\c kUbh hc VY [ccX& VYWcaY Z]``YX k]h\ [ccXbYgg(


CUbm cZ cif j]WYg Yl]gh cb`m VYWUigY h\Ym UfY giddcfhYXVm ch\Yf j]WYg5 h\YfYZcfY& ]Z kY XYghfcm cif aU^cf j]WYg&aUbm ch\Yfg k]`` X]gUddYUf Uh cbWY& ]b h\Y gUaY kUm UgVfUbW\Yg ZU`` k\Yb mci Wih h\Y hfib_ cZ U hfYY(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

.H DWWHQWLYH WR WKH DSSHDUDQFH RI HYLO& ?KHUH LV DQ LQQHUYRLFH LQ \RXU VRXO ZKLFK DOZD\V WHOOV \RX DERXW DSSURDFKLQJHYLO& CRX IHHO XQSOHDVDQW$ \RX IHHO DVKDPHG& .HOLHYH LQ WKLVYRLFH+ VWRS DQG VHHN WR LPSURYH \RXUVHOI$ DQG WKHQ \RX ZLOOGHIHDW HYLO&

RSMNÁÂ

7h U WYfhU]b `YjY` cZ gY`Z'UkUfYbYgg& U dYfgcb ibXYfghUbXggcaYh\]b[ gidYfbUhifU` ]b \]agY`Z(

=cX Yl]ghg VYWUigY kY Yl]gh( Oci WUb WU`` ]h Ubm ch\YfbUaY& Vih h\YfY ]g bc XciVh h\Uh h\Y gidYf]cf `]ZY k\]W\WfYUhYX ig Yl]ghg( 7bX mci WUb WU`` h\Y gcifWY cZ h\]g `]ZY=cX& cf []jY ]h Ubm ch\Yf bUaY(

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

3RG H[LVWV RQO\ IRU WKRVH ZKR ORRN IRU 4LP& >WDUW ORRNLQJ*\RX ZLOO ILQG 4LP LQ \RX DQG \RXUVHOI LQ 4LP&

Bcc_]b[ Zcf =cX ]g `]_Y di``]b[ U bYh ]b h\Y kUhYf( M\Ybmci di`` h\Y bYh& ]h ]g \YUjm UbX Zi`` cZ kUhYf& UbX mYh k\Ybmci di`` ]h cih& h\YfY ]g bch\]b[ ]b ]h( M\Yb mci gYY_ =cXk]h\ mcif ]bhY``YWh UbX mcif UWh]cbg& =cX Yl]ghg ]b mci&UbX Ug gccb Ug mci XYW]XY h\Uh mci \UjY ZcibX =cX& UbXghcd UbX VYWcaY gUh]gZ]YX& mci \UjY `cgh \]a(

v<OE:EH IJH7A>EL

?h ]g gifdf]g]b[ h\Uh ? Wci`X bch gYY U jYfm g]ad`Y hfih\4VY\]bX UbX UVcjY h\]g kcf`X UbX cif `]jYg& h\YfY ]g gcaYxcbY k\c _bckg k\m h\]g kcf`X Yl]ghg UbX k\m kY Yl]gh ]bh\]g kcf`X( 7bX cif `]jYg UfY Ug ViVV`Yg ]b Vc]`]b[ kUhYf&k\]W\ UddYUf& f]gY hc h\Y gifZUWY& dcd& UbX X]gUddYUf(

J\Y ib]hm cZ U`` `]j]b[ VY]b[g Yl]ghg ]b h\]g kcf`X k\YfYYjYfmVcXm UbX YjYfmh\]b[ ei]Yh`m gYY_g =cX( ?h ]g cb`mibVY`]Yj]b[ Uh\Y]ghg k\c gYY YhYfbU` g]`YbWY(


@igh VYWUigY U dYfgcb XcYg bch ibXYfghUbX =cX& \Y \Ug bcf][\h hc XfUk h\Y WcbW`ig]cb h\Uh =cX XcYg bch Yl]gh(

RSMNÁÃ

MY ibXYfghUbX h\Y X]j]bY& gd]f]hiU` VY[]bb]b[ cZ cif `]ZYVch\ k]h\ cif ]bhY``YWh UbX k]h\ cif `cjY(

7 aUb ]g k]gY k\c XcYg h\fYY h\]b[g4 Z]fgh& \Y XcYg Vm\]agY`Z h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ \Y UXj]gYg ch\Yfg hc Xc5 gYWxcbX`m& \Y XcYg bch Xc Ubmh\]b[ h\Uh WcbhfUjYbYg h\Yhfih\5 UbX h\]fX`m& \Y ]g dUh]Ybh k]h\ h\Y kYU_bYggYg cZh\cgY k\c giffcibX \]a(

3UHDW WKRXJKWV FRPH GLUHFWO\ IURP WKH KHDUW&ÅHÁTXY LUijYbUf[iYg

?bjYgh][UhY YjYfmh\]b[4 VY`]YjY cb`m ]b h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\Yl]gh ]b UWWcfXUbWY k]h\ ]bhY``YWh(

7 W`YjYf dYfgcb WUbbch VY Yj]`( 7 _]bX dYfgcb ]g U`kUmgW`YjYf( ?adfcjY mcif _]bXbYgg Vm YlYfW]g]b[ mcif ]bhY`x`YWh& UbX ]adfcjY mcif ]bhY``YWh Vm YlYfW]g]b[ mcif _]bX xbYgg UbX `cjY(

RSMNÁÄ

MY WUbbch \cdY hc cVhU]b Ubm gcfh cZ dYfZYWh]cb ]b U gcW]xYhm k\]W\ ]g X]j]XYX ]bhc hkc dUfhg4 f]W\ dYcd`Y k\c fi`Yh\Y kcf`X UbX dccf dYcd`Y k\c cVYm h\Y]f cfXYfg(

MY WUaY hc ghfUb[Y WcbW`ig]cbg ]b h\]g kcf`X4 kY gUm h\UhkY `]jY ]b gcW]Yhm Vih Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY kY `]jY `cbY`m `]jYg(

vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

?Z h\YfY UfY a]``]cbU]fYg& h\YfY g\ci`X VY dUidYfg(v>;DHO =;EH=;

5I \RX KDYH DQ LQFRPH ZLWKRXW ZRUNLQJ KDUG$ WKHQ VRPHRQHZRUNHG KDUG ZLWKRXW UHFHLYLQJ DQ LQFRPH&

vC7?CED?:;I

?h ]g kcfgY hc VY Ub cddfYgg]jY aUghYf h\Ub Ub cVYX]Ybhg`UjY( ;lWYgg]jY kYU`h\ ]g kcfgY h\Ub dcjYfhm(

RSMNÁĀ

J\Y WcbgYeiYbWYg cZ cif bch]cbg WUbbch VY _bckb hc ig&VYWUigY h\Ym f]dd`Y cihkUfX `]a]h`Ygg`m ]b U `]a]h`Ygg kcf`X(

Eif YZZcfhg hc dYbYhfUhY h\Y amghYfm cZ =cX UfY Zih]`Y( ?h]g Ybci[\ hc Zc``ck h\Y X]j]bY `Uk(

Eif acgh ]adcfhUbh UWh]cbg UfY h\cgY WcbgYeiYbWYgk\]W\ kY k]`` bch gYY(

3UHDW GHHGV KDYH YHU\ UHPRWH FRQVHTXHQFHV&v@E>D HKIA?D

?Z mci WUb gYY U`` cZ h\Y WcbgYeiYbWYg cZ mcif UWh]cbg&h\Yb mcif UWh]cbg UfY cZ bc igY(

TuvJ\Y J7BCK:

7 gU]bh `]jYg k]h\ \]g ]bbYf `]ZY5 \Y XYb]Yg cihYf `]ZY&vB7E'JPK

RSMNÁĂ

Jc UWWYdh h\Y X][b]hm cZ Ubch\Yf dYfgcb ]g Ub Ul]ca( ?h \Ugbch\]b[ hc Xc k]h\ giVXi]b[& giddcfh]b[& cf []j]b[ W\Ufx]hm hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

J\Y gaU``Ygh XYhU]` WUb VYbYZ]h h\Y ghfYb[h\Yb]b[ cZ W\UfxUWhYf( :c bch gUm h\Uh gaU`` XYhU]`g UfY bch ]adcfhUbh5cb`m U dYfgcb k]h\ \][\ acfU`g WUb gYY h\Y]f ]adcfhUbWY(

IcaY cZ h\Y acgh fY`][]cig dYcd`Y ]b Higg]U \UjY Ub ]bhYfxYgh]b[ \UV]h4 h\Ym aU_Y U `ck Vck hc dYfgcbg hc k\cah\Ym UfY ]bhfcXiWYX Zcf h\Y Z]fgh hibY( J\Ym gUm h\Ym Xch\]g hc UW_bck`YX[Y h\Y X]j]bY gd]f]h h\Uh YjYfm dYfgcb\Ug k]h\]b \]agY`Z( J\]g ]g bch U k]XYgdfYUX hfUX]h]cb& Vih]hg ZcibXUh]cbg UfY jYfm XYYd(

- PDQ LV KXPEOH& 4H FDQ KDUGO\ VD\* 5 H[LVW$ 5 FDQ WKLQN&v7ZhYf H7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

7 dYfgcb g\ci`X _bck h\Uh \Y dYfZcfag hfiY W\Uf]hm bch]b Zfcbh cZ ch\Yf dYfgcbg& Vih VYZcfY h\Y YhYfbU` `Uk cZ=cX(

RSMNÁÅ

9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]g h\Y ghiXm cZ h\Y X]j]bY VY[]bb]b[ ]b U dYfgcb(

9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]g U jYfm g]ad`Y h\]b[4 `cjY ch\Yf dYfgcbg& Ugmci `cjY =cX( 8Y Ug dYfZYWh Ug mcif ZUh\Yf ]b \YUjYb( B]jY]b h\Y gd]f]h cZ =cX& aU_]b[ h\Y VYgh h\]b[g& ]b h\Y VYghdcgg]V`Y kUm& Zcf h\Y VYgh difdcgYg( ;jYb U gaU`` W\]`X WUbibXYfghUbX h\YgY ]XYUg& UbX YjYb U [fYUh a]bX WUbbch]adfcjY idcb h\Ya(

BLWKRXW WKH FOHDU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH PHDQLQJ RI RQH_V OLIH$ZLWKRXW IDLWK$ D SHUVRQ FDQ DW DQ\ PLQXWH GHQ\ JRRG DQGVWDUW ZRUVKLSLQJ HYLO&

7 dYfgcb WUbbch \UjY Wcad`YhY ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\YaYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY( 7 dYfgcb WUb cb`m _bck ]hg X]fYWh]cb(

J\Y YggYbWY cZ U`` fY`][]cig hYUW\]b[g ]g `cjY( M\Uh ]g gdYxW]U` ]b 9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]g hYUW\]b[g UVcih `cjY& h\Y W`YUf UbXYlUWh ghUhYaYbh cZ h\Y aU^cf WcbX]h]cb cZ `cjY4 bcbfYg]gxhUbWY hc Yj]` UbX j]c`YbWY(

?Z mci kUbh hc VY ei]Yh UbX ghfcb[& kcf_ UbX ]adfcjYmcif ZU]h\(

vJ>;E:EH; F7HA;H

RSMNÁǺ

M\Uh ]g ]adcfhUbh ]g bch h\Y eiUbh]hm cZ mcif _bck`YX[Y&Vih ]hg eiU`]hm( Oci WUb _bck aUbm h\]b[g k]h\cih _bckx]b[ h\Uh k\]W\ ]g acgh ]adcfhUbh(

5JQRUDQFH LQ LWVHOI LV QHLWKHU VKDPHIXO QRU KDUPIXO& :RERG\FDQ NQRZ HYHU\WKLQJ& .XW SUHWHQGLQJ WKDW \RX NQRZ ZKDW\RX DFWXDOO\ GR QRW NQRZ LV ERWK VKDPHIXO DQG KDUPIXO&

J\YfY UfY hkc hmdYg cZ ][bcfUbWY& h\Y difY& bUhifU` ][bcxfUbWY ]bhc k\]W\ U`` dYcd`Y UfY Vcfb& UbX h\Y ][bcfUbWY cZh\Y gc'WU``YX k]gY( Oci k]`` gYY h\Uh aUbm Uacb[ h\cgYk\c WU`` h\YagY`jYg gW\cÙfg Xc bch _bck fYU` `]ZY& UbXh\Ym XYgd]gY g]ad`Y dYcd`Y UbX g]ad`Y h\]b[g(

8B7?I; F7I97B

J\Y hfih\ g\ci`X cZhYb cjYfWcaY h\cigUbXg cZ cVghUW`Yg&ibh]` ]h ]g UWWYdhYX(

v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

J\Y gW\cÙf k\c h\]b_g Vih XcYg bch WfYUhY ]g `]_Y h\YW`ciX k\]W\ XcYg bch []jY fU]b(

v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

LU[iY UbX Wcad`Yl hYfa]bc`c[m kUg WfYUhYX Vm ZU`gYgW\cÙfg( HYU`& hfih\Zi` _bck`YX[Y XcYg bch bYYX jU[iYhYfag(

RSMN

7 aUb k\c XcYg bch ibXYfghUbX h\Y VYbYZ]h cZ giZZYf]b[XcYg bch `]jY U W`YjYf UbX hfiY `]ZY(

CUb_]bX \Ug bYjYf UW\]YjYX [fYUhbYgg Vih h\fci[\ giZxZYf]b[(

v<( HE8;HJ':; B7C;DD7?I

M]h\cih giZZYf]b[& gd]f]hiU` [fckh\ WUbbch \UddYb( IiZ'ZYf]b[ cZhYb UWWcadUb]Yg XYUh\& Vih giZZYf]b[ ]g U`gc UigYZi`& VYbYZ]W]U` WcbX]h]cb cZ `]ZY( ?h ]g gU]X h\Uh =cX`cjYg h\cgY k\c YldYf]YbWY giZZYf]b[(

HY`][]cb []jYg U dYfgcb h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y aYUb]b[cZ \]g Yl]ghYbWY UbX \]g XYgh]bUh]cb(

v7D7JEB; <H7D9;

- SHUVRQ ZKR OLYHV D VSLULWXDO OLIH FDQQRW KHOS KXW VHH WKDWVXIIHULQJ EULQJV KLP FORVHU WR 3RG& >HHQ LQ WKLV OLJKW$ VXIIHUcLQJ ORVHV LWV ELWWHU VLGH DQG EHFRPHV EOLVV&

RSMNÂÀ

<cf U dYfgcb k\c `YUXg U gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY Vf]b[gU V`]gg h\Uh ZUf hfUbgWYbXg h\Y d`YUgifY cZ U dYfgcb k\c `]jYgVm h\Y gY`Z']bXi`[Ybh gUh]gZUWh]cb cZ \]g Ub]aU` dUgg]cbg(

>Y k\c ]g _]bX XcYg [ccX Zcf ch\Yf dYcd`Y( 7bX ]Z U dYfxgcb giZZYfg k\]`Y \Y XcYg _]bX XYYXg& \Y VYWcaYg Ub YjYbVYhhYf dYfgcb(

v@;7D :; B7 8HKO;H;

>Y h\Uh `cjYh\ ZUh\Yf cf ach\Yf acfY h\Ub aY ]g bch kcfxh\m cZ aY4 UbX \Y h\Uh `cjYh\ gcb cf XUi[\hYf acfY h\UbaY ]g bch kcfh\m cZ aY(

vCUhh\Yk "!+$(

J\YfY ]g bc \][\Yf V`Ygg]b[ Zcf U dYfgcb h\Ub hc Xc W\Uf]xhUV`Y kcf_ Zcf h\Y VYbYZ]h UbX kY``'VY]b[ cZ ch\Yfg(

vBK9O C7BEHO

@igh Ug Z]fY V`ckg cih WUbX`Yg& [ccX XYYXg Zcf h\Y VYbYZ]hcZ ch\Yfg XYghfcm U gY`Z]g\ `]ZY(

?KH GDUN VSRW LQ WKH VXQOLJKW WKDW IDOOV RQ XV LV WKH VKDGRZFUHDWHG E\ RXU RZQ SHUVRQDOLWLHV& BH OLYH IRU RXUVHOYHV RQO\ZKHQ ZH OLYH IRU RWKHUV& 5W PD\ VHHP VWUDQJH$ EXW WU\ LW$ DQG\RX ZLOO VHH LW IURP \RXU RZQ H[SHULHQFH&

RSMNÂÁ

?b h\Y ZihifY& h\Y cfXYf cZ h\Y gcW]U` `]ZY cZ h\Y 9\f]gh]Ubkcf`X k]`` VY W\Ub[YX Vm h\Y fYd`UWYaYbh cZ j]c`YbWY UbX]hg ZYUfg k]h\ `cjY UbX V`Ygg]b[(

J\ig ? WcaaUbX mci& hc `cjY cbY Ubch\Yf(v@E>D +/4+1'+3

?h ]g U a]ghU_Y hc h\]b_ h\Uh h\YfY UfY h]aYg k\Yb mci WUb"gUZY`m UXXfYgg U dYfgcb k]h\cih `cjY( Oci WUb kcf_ k]h\cV^YWhg k]h\cih `cjYvWihh]b[ kccX& VU_]b[ Vf]W_g& aU_x]b[ ]fcbvVih mci WUbbch kcf_ k]h\ dYcd`Y k]h\cih `cjY(?b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug mci WUbbch kcf_ k]h\ VYYg k]h\cihVY]b[ WUih]cig& mci WUbbch kcf_ k]h\ dYcd`Y k]h\cihVY]b[ a]bXZi` cZ h\Y]f \iaUb]hm( ?h ]g h\Y eiU`]hm cZ dYcd`YUg ]h ]g cZ VYYg4 ]Z mci UfY bch jYfm WUih]cig k]h\ h\Ya& h\Ybmci \Ufa Vch\ mcifgY`Z UbX h\Ya( ?h WUbbch VY ch\Yfxk]gY& VYWUigY aihiU` `cjY ]g h\Y aU^cf `Uk cZ cif Yl]ghYbWY(

Kbh]` ? WUb gYY h\Uh h\Y aU^cf WcaaUbXaYbh cZ 9\f]ghv`cjY mcif YbYa]Ygv]g VY]b[ Zi`Z]``YX& ? k]`` Wcbh]biY hcVY`]YjY h\Uh aUbm dYcd`Y UfY bch fYU` 9\f]gh]Ubg& Vih cb`mdfYhYbX hc VY 9\f]gh]Ubg(


J\Y kcfgh a]ghU_Y k\]W\ kUg YjYf aUXY ]b h\]g kcf`X kUgh\Y gYdUfUh]cb cZ dc`]h]WU` gW]YbWY Zfca Yh\]Wg(

vF;H9O 8OII>; I>;BB;O

CRX VKRXOG OLYH VR WKDW LW LV SRVVLEOH WR FUHDWH WKH NLQJGRP RIORYH RQ HDUWK& CRX VKRXOG OLYH D OLIH EDVHG QRW RQ YLROHQFHEXW RQ ORYH&

RSMNÂÂ

?KH JUHDWHVW NQRZOHGJH LV VHOI%NQRZOHGJH& 4H ZKR XQGHUcVWDQGV KLPVHOI ZLOO XQGHUVWDQG 3RG&

@Ygig Wf]YX UbX gU]X( >Y h\Uh VY`]YjYh\ cb aY& \Y`]YjYh\bch cb aY& Vih cb \]a h\Uh gYbh aY( 7bX \Y h\Uh gYYh\ aYgYYh\ \]a h\Uh gYbh aY( ? Ua WcaY U `][\h ]bhc h\Y kcf`X&h\Uh k\cgcYjYf VY`]YjYh\ cb aY g\ci`X bch UV]XY ]b XUf_xbYgg( 7bX ]Z Ubm aUb \YUf am kcfXg& UbX VY`]YjY bch& ?îX[Y \]a bch4 Zcf ? WUaY bch hc îX[Y h\Y kcf`X& Vih hcgUjY h\Y kcf`X( >Y h\Uh fY^YWhYh\ aY& UbX fYWY]jYh\ bcham kcfXg& \Uh\ cbY h\Uh îX[Yh\ \]a4'h\Y kcfX h\Uh ?\UjY gdc_Yb& h\Y gUaY g\U`` îX[Y \]a ]b h\Y Ùgh XUm( <cf? \UjY bch gdc_Yb cZ amgY`Z5 Vih h\Y <Uh\Yf k\]W\ gYbhaY& \Y [UjY aY U WcaaUbXaYbh& k\UhS? g\ci`X gUm& UbXk\Uh ? g\ci`X gdYU_( 7bX ? _bck h\Uh h\]g WcaaUbXaYbh]g `]ZY YjYfÙgh]b[4 k\UhgcYjYf ? gdYU_ h\YfYZcfY& YjYb Ugh\Y <Uh\Yf gU]X ibhc aY& gc ? gdYU_(

O4928 "#+%% &!

M]h\cih dif]hm cZ gci`& \ck WUb mci gUm& ? k]`` [`cf]Zm=cX6 J\Uh `][\h& `]_Y U acfb]b[ ghUf& k\]W\ `]jYg ]b h\Y\YUfh cZ YjYfm dYfgcb& h\]g `][\h ]g cif gU`jUh]cb(

vM787D7 FKH7D7& ?D:?7D M?I:EC

7 dYfgcb WUb hfUbgZcfa \]g dYfgcbU`]hm& \]g ]bbYf gY`Z& Zfcah\Y XcaU]b cZ giZZYf]b[ UbX giVXi]b[ ]bhc h\Y XcaU]bk\]W\ ]g U`kUmg ghYUXm UbX ^cmZi`& h\Uh ]g& h\Y XcaU]b cZibXYfghUbX]b[ \]g gd]f]hiU` UbX X]j]bY YggYbWY(

RSMNÂÃ

HYU` [ccXbYgg ]g U`kUmg g]ad`Y(I]ad`]W]hm ]g gc UhhfUWh]jY UbX gc dfcZ]hUV`Y h\Uh ]h ]g

ghfUb[Y h\Uh gc ZYk dYcd`Y `YUX hfi`m g]ad`Y `]jYg(

0R QRW VHHN KDSSLQHVV HOVHZKHUH& 3LYH WKDQNV WR 3RG$ ZKRPDGH QHFHVVDU\ WKLQJV VLPSOH$ DQG FRPSOLFDWHG WKLQJVXQQHFHVVDU\&

v=H;=EHO IAELEHE:7 "'"

Ccgh cZ cif gdYbX]b[ ]g XcbY hc ZcfkUfX cif YZZcfhg hc`cc_ `]_Y ch\Yfg(


;jYfm [fYUh h\]b[ ]g XcbY ]b U ei]Yh& \iaV`Y& g]ad`Y kUm5hc d`ck h\Y `UbX& hc Vi]`X \cigYg& hc VfYYX WUhh`Y& YjYb hch\]b_vmci WUbbch Xc giW\ h\]b[g k\Yb h\YfY UfY h\ibxXYf UbX `][\hb]b[ UfcibX mci( =fYUh UbX hfiY h\]b[g UfYU`kUmg g]ad`Y UbX \iaV`Y(

Dc cbY `cc_g `Ygg g]ad`Y h\Ub h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c Ufh]Z]xW]U``m ghf]jY hc gYYa gc( 7fh]Z]W]U` g]ad`]W]hm ]g h\Y acghibd`YUgUbh cZ U`` Ufh]Z]W]U` h\]b[g(

RSMNÂÄ

?b Ubm ghfi[[`Y hfiY VfUjYfm `]Yg k]h\]b h\cgY k\c _bckh\Uh =cX ]g h\Y]f U``m(

!BKDWHYHU KDSSHQV& GR QRW ORVH IDLWK& :RWKLQJ KDG FDQ KDScSHQ WR \RX DV D KXPDQ EHLQJ&

J\YgY h\]b[g ? \UjY gdc_Yb ibhc mci& h\Uh ]b aY mY a][\h\UjY dYUWY( ?b h\Y kcf`X mY g\U`` \UjY hf]Vi`Uh]cb4 Vih VYcZ [ccX W\YYf5 ? \UjY cjYfWcaY h\Y kcf`X(

v@E>D +04--

;jYfmh\]b[ ]g ]bXYZ]b]hY& a]ghm& UbX hfUbg]Ybh5 cb`m j]fhiY]g W`YUf& UbX ]h WUbbch VY XYghfcmYX Vm Ubm ZcfWY(


Eb`m U dYfgcb k\c fYbcibWYg \]g dYfgcbU`]hm VYWcaYghfi`m dckYfZi`( 7g gccb Ug cbY XYb]Yg \]g dYfgcbU`]hm& ]h ]gbch \Y Vih =cX k\c UWhg h\fci[\ \]a(

EbWY idcb U h]aY& U HcaUb YadfYgg `cgh \Yf dfYW]cig^YkY`fm( ?h kUg UbbcibWYX UWfcgg h\Y Yad]fY h\Uh k\cYjYfZcibX \Yf `cgh ghcbYg VYZcfY h\]fhm XUmg kci`X fYWY]jY UV][ fYkUfX& Vih Ubm k\c fYhifbYX h\Y ^YkY`fm UZhYf h\]fhmXUmg kci`X VY YlYWihYX( IUaiY`& U @Yk]g\ fUVV]& ZcibX h\YdfYW]cig ghcbYg& Vih \Y fYhifbYX h\Ya UZhYf h\]fhm XUmg\UX dUggYX( s>UjY mci VYYb UVfcUX6t h\Y HcaUb YadfYggUg_YX \]a( sDc& ? kUg Uh \caY(t sCUmVY mci X]X bch_bck k\Uh kUg dfcW`U]aYX6t sDc& ? _bYk&t gU]X IUaiY`(sJ\Yb k\m X]X mci bch fYhifb h\YgY h\]b[g VYZcfY h\YYld]fm cZ h\Y h\]fhm XUmg6 Dck mci \UjY hc VY YlYWihYX(ts? kUbhYX hc g\ck mci h\Uh ? fYhifbYX mcif `cgh ^YkY`fm&bch VYWUigY cZ ZYUf cZ mcif dib]g\aYbh& Vih VYWUigY cZZYUf cZ =cX(t

RSMN !7 dYfgcb WUb ibXYfghUbX \]agY`Z Ug U aUhYf]U` cf U gd]f]xhiU` VY]b[( M\Yb mci ibXYfghUbX mcifgY`Z Ug U gd]f]hiU`VY]b[& h\Yb mci UfY ZfYY(

M\Uh ]g s`cjY cZ =cX&t ]Z ]h ]g bch h\Y YZZcfh hc UXX dUfh cZmcifgY`Z hc h\Y \][\Yf WfYUh]jY Z`ck cZ YbYf[m ]b h\]g kcf`X6:]j]bY ZcfWY Yl]ghg ]b YjYfmh\]b[& Vih h\Y [fYUhYgh aUb]xZYghUh]cb cZ ]h ]b h\]g kcf`X ]g ]b \iaUb]hm& UbX ]b cfXYf hcdih ]h hc kcf_& cbY aigh ibXYfghUbX ]h UbX UWWYdh ]h(

5I D SHUVRQ GRFV QRW EHOLHYH KLPVHOI FDSDEOH RI GRLQJ WKH EHVWWKLQJV LQ WKH ZRUOG$ WKHQ KH VWDUWV WR FUHDWH WKH ZRUVW WKLQJV&

? _bck h\Uh h\Y g_m _bckg YjYfmh\]b[& UbX h\Uh ]hg `UkgUfY WcbghUbh( ? _bck h\Uh ]h gYYg YjYfmh\]b[& ]h [Yhg ]bhcYjYfmh\]b[& UbX ]h ]g dfYgYbh ]b YjYfmh\]b[( J\Y \YUjYbgWUb [Yh ]bhc h\Y XYdh\g cZ U`` \iaUb \YUfhg ]b h\Y gUaYkUm h\Uh h\Y XUm`][\h WUb `][\hYb U XUf_ fcca( MY g\ci`Xhfm hc fYZ`YWh h\]g \YUjYb`m `][\h(

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

RSMNÂĂ

J\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ =cX ]g UWWYgg]V`Yhc YjYfmVcXm5 h\Y Wcad`YhY ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y YggYbWYcZ =cX ]g bch UWWYgg]V`Y hc Ubm dYfgcb(

7`` h\Y bUh]cbg cZ h\Y kcf`X bUaY UbX fYgdYWh =cX( :]ZxZYfYbh dYcd`Y []jY \]a X]ZZYfYbh bUaYg& UbX dih X]ZZYfYbhW`ch\Yg cb \]a5 Vih h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY =cX ibXYf U`` h\YgYX]ZZYfYbh aUb]ZYghUh]cbg(


<U]h\ ]b =cX ]g Ug bUhifU` hc aYb Ug h\Y]f UV]`]hm hc kU`_cb hkc ZYYh( J\]g ZU]h\ WUb VY acX]Z]YX& UbX ]h WUb YjYbX]gUddYUf ]b gcaY ]bX]j]XiU`g5 Vih Ug U fi`Y& ]h ]g bYWYggUfmZcf ]bhY``YWhiU` `]ZY ]b gcW]Yhm(

v7ZhYf =;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

J\YfY UfY gcaY ghUhYaYbhg k\]W\ WUbbch VY ZUh\caYX4=cX Yl]ghg cf \Y XcYg bch Yl]gh5 h\Y gci` Yl]ghg ]b h\YVcXm& cf kY Xc bch \UjY U gci`5 h\Y kcf`X kUg WfYUhYX cfh\Y kcf`X kUg bch WfYUhYX(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

8LYH LQ 3RG$ OLYH WRJHWKHU ZLWK 3RG$ E\ XQGHUVWDQGLQJ 4LPLQ \RX$ DQG GR QRW WU\ WR GHILQH 4LP ZLWK ZRUGV&

RSMN "7 VUX accX ]g cZhYb h\Y fYUgcb Zcf VÙa]b[ ch\Yfg5 VihjYfm cZhYb VÙa]b[ ch\Yfg WUigYg VUX ZYY`]b[g ]b ig4 h\YacfY kY VÙaY ch\Yfg& h\Y kcfgY kY ZYY`(

EbY cZ cif acgh Wcaacb UbX k]XYgdfYUX dfYîX]WYg ]g h\UhYjYfm dYfgcb \Ug U Z]lYX& gdYW]U` W\UfUWhYf]gh]W& h\Uh h\YfY UfY_]bX dYcd`Y UbX Yj]`& W`YjYf dYcd`Y UbX ghid]X dYcd`Y& UbXWc`X cf \ch dYcd`Y( 8ih dYcd`Y UfY bch `]_Y h\]g5 kY WUb gUmUVcih U dYfgcb cb`m h\Uh \Y ]g acfY cZhYb _]bX h\Ub Yj]`&acfY cZhYb W`YjYf h\Ub ghid]X& acfY cZhYb Wc`X h\Ub \ch( MYU`kUmg X]j]XY dYcd`Y `]_Y h\]g& Vih ]h ]g bc `Ygg kfcb[v

?Z h\YfY ]g Ub]acg]hm VYhkYYb hkc dYcd`Y& Vch\ UfY hcVÙaY( 7bm biaVYf mci ai`h]d`m Vm nYfc& \ckYjYf V][&k]`` YeiU` nYfc( ?Z h\YfY ]g Ub]acg]hm& h\Yb& ]h ]g h\Y Ub]xacg]hm cZ hkc dYcd`Y hckUfX YUW\ ch\Yf& UbX ]h Yl]ghg ]bVch\ cZ h\Ya(

?U\ WR XQGHUVWDQG DQG UHPHPEHU WKDW D SHUVRQ DOZD\V WULHV WRGR ZKDW LV EHVW IRU KLPVHOI& -QG LI KH LV ULJKW ZKHQ KH GRHV WKHEHVW WKLQJ IRU KLPVHOI LW LV JRRG+ EXW LI KH LV PLVWDNHQ$ LW LV EDG$EHFDXVH VXIIHULQJ ZLOO IROORZ DIWHU VXFK PLVWDNHV&

5I \RX UHPHPEHU WKLV$ WKHQ \RX ZLOO QHYHU EH XSVHW E\DQ\ERG\$ \RX ZLOO QHYHU UHSURDFK DQ\ERG\$ DQG \RX ZLOOQHYHU EH DQ HQHP\ WR DQ\ERG\&

v7ZhYf ;F?9J;JKI

?Z mci UfY `]j]b[ k]h\ Ubch\Yf dYfgcb& aU_Y Ub U[fYYaYbhh\Uh Ug gccb Ug Y]h\Yf cZ mci ghUfhg hc VÙaY h\Y ch\Yf& mcik]`` YbX h\Y Uf[iaYbh(

RSMNÂǺ

Mcf_ ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ \Udd]bYgg( <]fgh&ZUjcf]hY UbX ZfYY kcf_5 gYWcbX`m& h\Y d\mg]WU` kcf_ k\]W\UfcigYg mcif UddYh]hY UbX UZhYfkUfX []jYg mci hfUbei]ÙbX gcibX g`YYd(

CUbiU` ÙVcf XcYg bch YlWìXY ]bhY``YWhiU` UWh]j]hm& Vih]adfcjYg ]hg eiU`]hm UbX YjYb \Y`dg ]h(

/RQVWDQW LGOHQHVV VKRXOG KH LQFOXGHG LQ WKH WRUWXUHV RI KHOO$EXW LW LV$ RQ WKH FRQWUDU\$ FRQVLGHUHG WR EH RQH RI WKH MR\V RISDUDGLVH&

9>7HB;I :; CEDJ;IGK?;K

M\Yb U dYfgcb gYhg hc kcf_& YjYb ]Z ]h ]g h\Y acgh ibeiU`x]Z]YX& df]a]h]jY& g]ad`Y kcf_& h\Y \iaUb gci` WUàg Xckb(7g gccb Ug U dYfgcb ghUfhg hc kcf_& U`` h\Y XYacbg `YUjY\]a UbX WUbbch UddfcUW\ \]a( 7 aUb VYWcaYg U aUb(

vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

Mcf_ ]g bYWYggUfm( ?Z mci kUbh U [ccX X]gdcg]h]cb cZ mcifgd]f]h& kcf_ ibh]` mci VYWcaY h]fYX( 8ih bch JEE aiW\(Dch ibh]` mci VYWcaY Yl\UighYX( 7 [ccX gd]f]hiU` X]gdcxg]h]cb WUb VY XYghfcmYX Vm YlWYgg]jY kcf_ Ug kY`` Ug Vm]X`YbYgg(

RSMNÂĄ

7 dYfgcb WUb Zi`Z]`` \]g difdcgY ]b `]ZY YeiU``m Ug kY`` ]b ]``xbYgg Ug ]b \YU`h\(

?Z kY aYX]hUhY idcb h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ `]ZY UZhYf XYUh\& h\YbU`` ]``bYggYg kci`X gYYa hc VY hU_]b[ ig W`cgYf hc h\YacjYaYbh Zfca cbY `]ZY hc Ubch\Yf& U hfUbgZYf acfY XYg]fxUV`Y h\Ub ibXYg]fUV`Y( :if]b[ h\YgY dU]bg kY WUb ibXYfghUbX UbX YldÙ]b Zcf cifgY`jYg k\Uh k]`` \UddYb hc ig&"UbX dfYdUfY Zcf h\Y bYk ghUhY cZ cif bYlh Yl]ghYbWY(

KgiU``m dYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh ]h ]g dcgg]V`Y hc gYfjY =cX UbX\iaUb]hm cb`m k\Yb mci UfY \YU`h\m( J\]g ]g bch hfiY(LYfm cZhYb ]h ]g hc h\Y WcbhfUfm( 9\f]gh gYfjYX =cX UbX U`àUb_]bX k\Yb \Y giZZYfYX cb h\Y Wfcgg& UbX YjYb h\Yb \YZcf[UjY h\cgY k\c _]``YX \]a( ;jYfm dYfgcb WUb Xc `]_Yxk]gY( Oci WUbbch gUm k\]W\ ghUhY ]g VYhhYf& U \YU`h\m cf ]``ghUhY& ]b h\Y gYfj]WY cZ =cX UbX \iaUb_]bX(

2RU \RXUVHOI$ DQG IRU \RXUVHOI RQO\$ LW LV QHFHVVDU\ WR KDYHKHDOWK DQG SRZHU& .XW WR VHUYH 3RG LW LV QRW QHFHVVDU\$ DQGVRPHWLPHV HYHQ WKH RSSRVLWH LV WUXH&

LYfm cZhYb& k\Yb ? \UjY XYU`h k]h\ hYfa]bU``m ]`` dYcd`Y& ?\UjY `YUfbYX h\Uh h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h\]b[ ]g bch \]X]b[ h\YUddfcUW\]b[ XYUh\ Zfca h\Y dUh]Ybh& Vih cb h\Y WcbhfUfm&YldÙ]b]b[ hc \]a \]g ckb X]j]bY& gd]f]hiU` bUhifY& k\]W\[fckg ]b \]a UbX k\]W\ WUbbch VY XYghfcmYX Vm XYUh\(

?``bYggYg Uàcgh U`kUmg XYghfcm cbYrg d\mg]WU` dckYf& UbXh\Ym fY`YUgY h\Y dckYf cZ cbYrg gci`( <cf U dYfgcb k\cWcbWYbhfUhYg \]g WcbgW]cigbYgg ]b h\Y gd]f]hiU` XcaU]b&]``bYggYg Xc bch X]a]b]g\ \]g [ccXbYgg& Vih cb h\Y WcbxhfUfm& h\Ym ]bWfYUgY ]h(

RSMNÃÀ

?h gYYag h\Uh ]h ]g ]adcgg]V`Y hc `]jY k]h\cih X]gWcjYf]b[h\Y difdcgY cZ mcif `]ZY( 7bX h\Y Z]fgh h\]b[ k\]W\ U dYfxgcb g\ci`X Xc ]g hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY( 8ih h\YaU^cf]hm cZ dYcd`Y k\c Wcbg]XYf h\YagY`jYg hc VY YXixWUhYX UfY dfciX h\Uh h\Ym \UjY fYUW\YX giW\ U [fYUh \Y][\hh\Uh h\Ym WYUgY hc WUfY UVcih h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ Yl]ghYbWY(

?KH UHDO SXUSRVH RI RXU H[LVWHQFH LV WR XQGHUVWDQG WKLV OLPLWcOHVV OLIH H[LVWLQJ LQ WKLV ZRUOG&

7 dYfgcb aUm bch _bck h\Y difdcgY cZ \]g `]ZY& Vih \Yg\ci`X _bck KRZ hc `]jY(7 kcf_Yf Uh U V][ dÙbh aUm bch bYWYggUf]`m _bck h\Y

difdcgY cZ \]g ÙVcf& Vih ]Z \Y ]g U [ccX kcf_Yf& \Y g\ci`X_bck \ck hc Xc kY`` k\Uh \Y g\ci`X Xc(

;jYfm `]j]b[ VY]b[ \Ug gYbgcfm cf[Ubg k\]W\ fYjYU` hc ]h ]hgdÙWY ]b h\Y kcf`X( <cf U \iaUb& h\Y df]aUfm gYbgY ]g h\Y]bhY``YWh(?Z mci Xc bch _bck mcif dÙWY ]b h\Y kcf`X UbX h\Y

aYUb]b[ cZ mcif `]ZY& mci g\ci`X _bck h\Uh h\YfY ]g gcaYxh\]b[ hc VÙaY5 UbX ]h ]g bch h\Y gcW]U` gmghYa& cf mcif]bhY``YWh& Vih h\Y kUm ]b k\]W\ mci X]fYWhYX mcif ]bhY``YWh(

CGXÁ

>Y k\c gYYg \]g `]ZY Ug U dfcWYgg cZ gd]f]hiU` dYfZYWh]cbXcYg bch ZYUf YlhYfbU` YjYbhg(

7Vi =Ub]ZU_\ X]YX ]b U df]gcb ]b 8U[\XUX ]b k\]W\ \YrXVYYb dih Vm 9U`]d\ U`'CUbgif Zcf fYZig]b[ hc UWWYdh h\YhYUW\]b[ cZ AUUX( EbWY& VYZcfY \]g XYUh\& k\Yb h\]gZUacig gd]f]hiU` hYUW\Yf fYWY]jYX U \YUjm V`ck Zfca U[iUfX& \Y hc`X h\Y aUb k\c \]h \]a& s? Wci`X fYbXYf mciUb ]bîfm UZhYf mci \UjY XcbY Ub ]bîfm hc aY( + Wci`XWcadÙ]b hc h\Y 9U`]d\& Vih ? k]`` bch WcadÙ]b( ?b amdfUmYfg& ? Wci`X hY`` =cX UVcih h\]g cZZYbgY k\]W\ mci\UjY XcbY hc aY& Vih ? k]`` fYZfU]b Zfca h\]g( :if]b[ h\YXUm cZ h\Y <]bU` @iX[aYbh ? Wci`X Ug_ X]j]bY fYjYb[Y Zcfmcif UWh& Vih YjYb ]Z h\]g XUm WcaYg hcXUm& UbX YjYb ]Z ?_bYk h\Uh am dfUmYf kci`X VY \YUfX& YjYb h\Yb ? kci`XYbhYf dUfUX]gY cb`m k]h\ mci(t

vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

:c bch h\]b_ h\Uh WcifU[Y `]Yg cb`m ]b Vc`XbYgg UbX dckYf(J\Y \][\Ygh WcifU[Y ]g h\Y WcifU[Y hc VY \][\Yf h\Ub mciffU[Y UbX hc `cjY U dYfgcb k\c \Ug cZZYbXYX mci(

vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

/ULWLFL]H \RXUVHOI$ EXW GR QRW IHHO GHVSHUDWH DERXW LW&v;F?9J;JKI

M\Uh ? hY`` mci ]b XUf_bYgg& h\Uh gdYU_ mY ]b `][\h4 UbXk\Uh mY \YUf ]b h\Y YUf& h\Uh dfYUW\ mY idcb h\Y \cigYxhcdg( 7bX ZYUf bch h\Ya k\]W\ _]`` h\Y VcXm& Vih UfY bchUV`Y hc _]`` h\Y gci`4 Vih fUh\Yf ZYUf \]a k\]W\ ]g UV`Y hcXYghfcm Vch\ gci` UbX VcXm ]b \Y``(

vCUhh\Yk +*4,1',2

CGXÂ

FYcd`Y jYfm cZhYb Xc bch UWWYdh h\Y hfih\& VYWUigY h\YmXc bch `]_Y h\Y Zcfa ]b k\]W\ h\Y hfih\ ]g dfYgYbhYX hch\Ya(

J\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ U eiUffY` ]g `]_Y U Z`ccX k\]W\ VfYU_gh\fci[\ U XUa( 7g gccb Ug ]h fig\Yg h\fci[\& mci WUbbchghcd ]h(

;QH VKRXOG DYRLG GLVSXWHV+ ZKHQ DILUH EHFRPHV WRR ELJ$ LW LV

:if]b[ Ub Uf[iaYbh& aU_Y mcif kcfXg jYfm gcZh& UbXmcif \YUfh \UfX( :c bch hfm hc `Ug\ cih Uh mcif cddcbYbh&Vih hfm hc Wcbj]bWY \]a(

?Z mci _bck h\Y hfih\& cf ]Z mci h\]b_ h\Uh mci _bck h\Yhfih\& hfm hc dUgg ]h cb hc h\Y ch\Yfg& Ug g]ad`m Ug mci WUb&U`cb[ k]h\ h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ `cjY Zcf h\cgY dYfgcbg hc k\camci dUgg ]h(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

GLIILFXOW WR TXHOO LW&

v=;EH=; M?BA?DI

CGX-

J\Y `]ZY cZ @Ygig 9\f]gh ]g jYfm ]adcfhUbh Zcf ig Ug UbYlUad`Y cZ U `]ZY cZ cbY k\c Wci`X bch gYY h\Y Zfi]hg cZ \]gkcf_ Xif]b[ \]g `]ZYh]aY(

/OHYHU SHRSOH VWXG\ LQ RUGHU WR NQRZ PRUH& @QGHVHUYLQJSHRSOH VWXG\ WR EH PRUH NQRZQ&

v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

?b cfXYf hc fYUW\ gd]f]hiU` dYfZYWh]cb& mci g\ci`X Z]fgh cZU`` hU_Y WUfY cZ h\Y dif]hm cZ mcif gci`( J\]g WUb VYfYUW\YX k\Yb h\Y \YUfh `cc_g Zcf hfih\& UbX ghf]jYg Zcfk\c`YbYgg& UbX XYdYbXg cb hfiY _bck`YX[Y(

v9ED<K9?KI

?Z mci kci`X `]_Y hc _bck \ck hc fYWc[b]nY U dfcd\Yh&`cc_ hc \]a k\c []jYg mci h\Y _bck`YX[Y cZ mcif ckb\YUfh(

vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

;jYfm dYfgcb \Ug cb`m cbY difdcgY4 hc Z]bX dYfZYWh]cb ]b[ccXbYgg( J\YfYZcfY& cb`m h\Uh _bck`YX[Y ]g bYWYggUfmk\]W\ `YUXg ig hc h\]g(

CGXÄ

;jYfm h\ci[\h k\]W\ ]g YldfYggYX Vm kcfXg ]g U ZcfWY& UbXh\]g ZcfWY ]g `]a]h`Ygg(

=ccX h\ci[\hg k\]W\ cf][]bUhY Zfca h\Y \YUfhg cZ aYbUfY Ug igYZi` Ug [ccX YlUad`Yg(


Ihfcb[ h\ci[\hg k\]W\ UfY YldfYggYX ]b U dckYfZi` kUmU]X h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ `]ZY(


- WKRXJKW LV DQ LQWHOOHFWXDO DQG YLWDO HQHUJ\ RI OLIH$ DQG LW FDQKH HLWKHU D FXUVH RU D EOHVVLQJ$ GHSHQGLQJ RQ LWV TXDOLW\&

vBK9O C7BEHO

Jfih\ YldfYggYX ]b kcfXg ]g h\Y [fYUhYgh ZcfWY h\YfY ]g ]bh\Y `]jYg cZ dYcd`Y( MY Xc bch ibXYfghUbX h\]g ZcfWY Wcaxd`YhY`m& VYWUigY ]hg WcbgYeiYbWYg UfY bYjYf gYYb Uh cbWY(

KgY [ccX h\ci[\hg cZ k]gY dYcd`Y5 ]Z mci WUbbch WfYUhYg]a]`Uf _]bX UbX k]gY h\ci[\hg& h\Yb Uh `YUgh Xc bch X]gxhf]VihY h\Y ZU`gY h\ci[\hg YldfYggYX Vm mci UbX Vm ch\Yfg(

CGXĀ

HY`][]cig hYUW\]b[& h\Uh ]g& h\Y Yld`UbUh]cb cZ h\Y difdcgYUbX aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY& g\ci`X VY h\Y VUg]g cZ Ubm YXiWUh]cb(

FYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh ]h ]g bc Wf]aY hc `]Y hc W\]`XfYb& UbX h\Uhhc `]Y hc W\]`XfYb ]g bch fYU``m jYfm kfcb[& Vih YjYb gcaYxh]aYg bYWYggUfm( 8ih ]h ]g W`YUf h\Uh k]h\ W\]`XfYb mcig\ci`X VY YgdYW]U``m WUfYZi` UbX \cbYgh UVcih k\Uh mci gUmhc h\Ya(

CRX VKRXOG DOZD\V EH WUXWKIXO$ HVSHFLDOO\ ZLWK D FKLOG& CRXVKRXOG DOZD\V GR ZKDW \RX KDYH SURPLVHG KLP$ RWKHUZLVH\RX ZLOO WHDFK KLP WR OLH&

v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

CUb& k\cgY hYUW\Yf ]g bUhifY& g\ci`X bch VY U d]YWY cZkUl cb k\]W\ Ub Y`YjUhYX ]aU[Y cZ gcaY dfcZYggcf ]g hc VYWUfjYX(

v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

:c bch gUm hc U W\]`X k\ca mci hYUW\ h\Uh h\YfY ]g U Z]bU`hfih\& ]Z mci Xc bch VY`]YjY ]b gcaYh\]b[ Wcad`YhY`m& cf ]Zmci \UjY gcaY XciVhg( Jc Xc giW\ U h\]b[ ]g U [fYUh Wf]aY(

CGXĂ

9cadUgg]cb Zcf Ub]aU`g ]g gc bUhifU` hc ig h\Uh kY WUbVYWcaY ]bgYbg]h]jY hc h\Y]f giZZYf]b[ UbX XYUh\ cb`mh\fci[\ hfUX]h]cbg cf \mdbcg]g(

9cadUgg]cb Zcf Ub]aU`g ]g gc W`cgY`m WcbbYWhYX k]h\ _]bXxbYgg h\Uh mci WUb hfi`m gUm h\Uh U dYfgcb WUbbch VY _]bX ]Z\Y ]g WfiY` hc Ub]aU`g( 9cadUgg]cb Zcf Ub]aU`g WcaYgZfca h\Y gUaY gcifWY Ug WcadUgg]cb hckUfX dYcd`Y(


<YUf =cX& Xc bch hcfhifY Ub]aU`g( BYh h\Ya gYfjY mci&UbX `Yh h\Ya fYgh k\Yb h\Ym UfY h]fYX5 dfcj]XY Ybci[\ZccX UbX Xf]b_ Zcf h\cgY WfYUhifYg k\]W\ WUbbch gdYU_(

SCE>7CC;:

- SHUVRQ LV QRW KLJKHU WKDQ RWKHU DQLPDOV EHFDXVH KH FDQPHUFLOHVVO\ WRUWXUH WKHP& EXW EHFDXVH KH FDQ WDNH SLW\ RQWKHP&

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

:c bch U``ck mcif W\]`XfYb hc _]`` ]bgYWhg5 h\]g ]g h\Y Z]fghghYd U`cb[ U fcUX k\]W\ WUb `YUX hc h\Y _]``]b[ cZ dYcd`Y(

vFOJ>7=EH7I

CGXÅ

7 dYfgcb k\c hf]Yg hc Z]bX [ccX cihg]XY \]agY`Z& Y]h\Yf ]bh\]g `]ZY cf ]b h\Y cbY hc WcaY& ]g aU_]b[ U a]ghU_Y(

? kYbh U`cb[ U`` h\Y YUfh\& gYUfW\]b[ Zcf U [i]X]b[ `][\h( ?kYbh U`` cjYf k]h\cih fYgh& Uh b][\h UbX Xif]b[ h\Y XUm& UbXh\Yb ? \YUfX Zfca U dfYUW\Yf& k\c cdYbYX h\Y hfih\ hc aY&h\Uh h\Y UbgkYf ]g ]bg]XY am gci`& UbX h\Uh h\Y `][\h k\]W\? kUg `cc_]b[ Zcf YjYfmk\YfY ]b h\Y kcf`X ]g ]bg]XY aY(

v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

?KHUH DUH QR FRLQFLGHQFHV$ HLWKHU LQ OLIH RU LQ RQH_V IDWH& -PDQ FUHDWHV KLV RZQ GHVWLQ\&

v78;B L?BB;C7?D

Oci Y]h\Yf aU_Y Yj]` Zcf mcifgY`Z& cf mci YgWUdY g]b UbXdif]Zm mcifgY`Z5 mci UfY VUX cf Yj]`& cf mci UfY difY5 UbXbcVcXm WUb gUjY mci YlWYdh Zcf mcifgY`Z(


Ocif VcXm ]g U W]hm k\]W\ ]g Zi`` cZ [ccX UbX Yj]`5 UbX mciUfY h\Y _]b[ cZ h\]g W]hm UbX mcif ]bhY``YWh ]g mcif VYghWcibgY`cf(

vI7?DJ BKA;

J\Y \Udd]bYgg cf ib\Udd]bYgg cZ U aUb XcYg bch XYdYbXidcb h\Y Uacibh cZ dfcdYfhm cf [c`X \Y ckbg( >Udd]bYggcf a]gYfm ]g ]b cbYrg gci`( 7 k]gY aUb ZYY`g Uh \caY ]b YjYfmWcibhfm( J\Y k\c`Y ib]jYfgY ]g h\Y \caY cZ U bcV`Y gci`(

v:;CE9H?JKI

Dch\]b[ WUb []jY U aUb ghfYb[h\ k\Yb \Y ]g `cc_]b[ ZcfgU`jUh]cb ch\Yf h\Ub \]g ckb YZZcfh(

CGXǺ

J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ acfY UhhfUWh]jY h\Ub \iaV`YbYgg UbX_]bXbYgg( 8ih mci g\ci`X bch gYY_ _]bXbYgg k\]W\ UXjYfxh]gYg ]hgY`Z(

7 k]gY aUb gU]X hc Ubch\Yf aUb k\c kUg W\Ug]b[ \]a& s?Zmci \UjY Ubm [f]YjUbWY U[U]bgh aY& hY`` aY bck& VYZcfY kYYbhYf h\Y W]hm& ch\Yfk]gY ch\Yf dYcd`Y k]`` \YUf ]h UbX h\Ymk]`` UhhUW_ mci(t

v;=OFJ?7D M?I:EC

8ih \Y h\Uh ]g [fYUhYgh Uacb[ mci& `Yh \]a VY Ug h\Ymcib[Yf5 UbX \Y h\Uh ]g W\]YZ& Ug \Y h\Uh Xch\ gYfjY( <cfk\]W\ ]g [fYUhYf& \Y h\Uh g]hhYh\ Uh aYUh& cf \Y h\UhgYfjYh\6 ]g bch \Y h\Uh g]hhYh\ Uh aYUh6 Vih + Ua Uacb[mci Ug \Y h\Uh gYfjYh\(

vBKA; ,,4,0',1

J\Y f]jYfg UbX gYUg UfY h\Y aUghYfg cZ h\Y jU``Ymg UWfcggk\]W\ h\Ym Z`ck( J\]g ]g VYWUigY h\Ym UfY `ckYf h\Ub h\YjU``Ymg( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& U dYfgcb k\c kUbhg hc VY \][\Yfh\Ub ch\Yf dYcd`Y g\ci`X VY `ckYf h\Ub h\Ym5 ]Z \Y kUbhghc [i]XY dYcd`Y& \Y g\ci`X VY VY`ck h\Ya(

vB7E'JPK

- ZLVH PDQ ZDV WROG WKDW KH ZDV FRQVLGHUHG WR KH D KDG SHUcVRQ& 4H DQVZHUHG$ `5W LV JRRG WKDW WKH\ GR QRW NQRZ HYHU\cWKLQJ DERXW PH$ EHFDXVH RWKHUZLVH WKH\ FRXOG VD\ ZRUVHWKLQJV DERXW PH& t

Jfm hc Ujc]X aU_]b[ ^iX[aYbhg UVcih mcifgY`Z& YgdYW]U``mVm WcadUf]b[ mcifgY`Z k]h\ ch\Yfg( 9cadUfY mcifgY`Zcb`m k]h\ dYfZYWh]cb(

CGXĄ

B]ZY ]g WcbghUbh W\Ub[Y5 ]h ci[\h hc Wcbg]gh cZ kYU_Yb]b[ h\YaUhYf]U` UbX ]bWfYUg]b[ h\Y gd]f]hiU` g]XY cZ cif Yl]ghYbWY(

IYY_ hc `YUfb WcbghUbh`m k\]`Y mci `]jY5 Xc bch kU]h ]b h\YZU]h\ h\Uh c`X U[Y Vm ]hgY`Z k]`` Vf]b[ k]gXca(

vIEBED

ALUWXH DOZD\V ODVWV ORQJHU WKDQ RWKHU TXDOLWLHV$ DQG LW DOZD\VVWDUWV IURP WKH EHJLQQLQJ&

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

J\Y _]bXbYgg cZ U XcjY ]g bch j]fhiY( 7 XcjY ]g bch acfYj]fhicig h\Ub Ub YU[`Y( L]fhiY VY[]bg cb`m k\Yb h\YfY ]gUb YZZcfh(

?Z =cX kUbhYX hc& \Y Wci`X \UjY aUXY ig cbY bUh]cb& Vih\Y hYghg ig( M\YfYjYf mci [c& ]b U`` d`UWYg& hfm Ug aiW\ Ugmci WUb hc VY _]bX& hc VY [ccX& UbX h\Yb h\Y XUm k]`` WcaYk\Yb =cX k]`` ib]hY U`` cZ ig(

vJ\Y AEH7D

MY WUbbch ghcd cb h\Y kUm hc gY`Z'dYfZYWh]cb( 7g gccbUg mci bch]WY h\Uh mci \UjY U V][[Yf ]bhYfYgh ]b h\YcihYf kcf`X h\Ub ]b mcifgY`Z& h\Yb mci g\ci`X _bck h\Uhh\Y kcf`X acjYg VY\]bX mci(

Eb`m gd]f]hiU` h\]b[g Yl]gh ]b fYU`]hm& UbX h\Y aUhYf]U`kcf`X ]g cb`m Ub ]``ig]cb(

?Z jci kUbh hc gUjY mcif gci`& Zcf[Yh UVcih mcif WcaZcfh(

CGXÁQ

?UXO\$ RQO\ WKRVH WKLQJV ZKLFK DUH VSLULWXDO DUH UHDO& ?KRVHWKLQJV ZLQFK FDQ EH VHHQ DQG IHOW DUH RQO\ DQ LOOXVLRQ&

B]ZY ]g []jYb hc ig bch cb`m Zcf d`YUgifYg(vD?AEB7? =E=EB

Dc aUb WUb gYfjY hkc aUghYfg5 Zcf Y]h\Yf \Y k]`` \UhY h\YcbY& UbX `cjY h\Y ch\Yf5 cf Y`gY \Y k]`` \c`X hc h\Y cbY&UbX XYgd]gY h\Y ch\Yf( OY WUbbch gYfjY =cX UbX aUaacb(

vC7JJ>;M 04,.

?b h\Y `cb[ fib& h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY giV^YWh kcfh\m cZ ghiXm&UbX h\]g ]g h\Y X]ZZYfYbh Zcfag cZ hfUbgZcfaUh]cb cZ h\Ygd]f]h( 7`` ch\Yf giV^YWhg UbX ghiX]Yg WUb VY Vfci[\h hch\YgY VUg]W h\]b[g(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

? WUb gYbX am h\ci[\hg hc aUbm X]ZZYfYbh dYcd`Y Uh cbWY5h\Ym k]`` Wfcgg h\Y gYUg UbX h\Ym k]`` [c hc X]ZZYfYbh ÙbXg]Z h\YfY ]g =cXrg k]``& UbX h\Y dckYf cZ `cjY UbX k]gXca(Cm h\ci[\hg Vm h\YagY`jYg UfY U gd]f]hiU` dckYf5 h\YmWUb Yl]gh Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY ]b h\cigUbXg cZ dÙWYg( CmVcXm& \ckYjYf& WUb cb`m Yl]gh Uh cbY dÙWY Uh cbY h]aY(

vBK9O C7BEHO

?h gYYag hc ig h\Uh h\Y acgh W`YUf& ibXYfghUbXUV`Y& UbXcVj]cig`m Yl]gh]b[ h\]b[g UfY bch U`` h\YfY ]g( J\YfY ]ggcaYh\]b[ Y`gY4 ibW`YUf& ib_bckb& WcbhfUX]Whcfm& UbXbcbYl]ghYbh(

CGXÁÁ

J\Y acj]b[ ZcfWY cZ U`` dYfZYWh]cb& Vch\ Zcf ]bX]j]XiU`gUbX Zcf k\c`Y bUh]cbg& ]g bch h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ k\UhYl]ghg ]b h\]g kcf`X& Vih h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ k\Uh WUb VYUW\]YjYX(

J\Y kYU_Yf am \UbXg& h\Y acfY YZZcfh ? g\ci`X aU_Y hcUW\]YjY dYfZYWh]cb(

`CRX PXVW EH DV SHUIHFW DV \RXU IDWKHU LQ KHDYHQ& a?KH SHUIHFWLRQ RI WKH KLJKHVW NLQGQHVV LV WKH JRDO IRU ZKLFK

DOO PDQNLQG VWULYHV& /KULVWLDQ OHDUQLQJ DERXW SHUIHFWLRQ LV DWRRO IRU DOO PDQNLQG&

7 dYfgcb k\c gU]`g ZUf Zfca h\Y g\cfY WUb gYY gcaY g\cfYx`]bYg cf W`]ZZg( 8ih k\Yb gU]`cfg [c fYU``m ZUf UkUm Zfca h\Yg\cfY& h\Ym WUb VY [i]XYX cb`m Vm h\Y ghUfg \][\ id ]b h\Yg_m& UbX h\Y WcadUgg k\]W\ ]bX]WUhYg h\Y]f X]fYWh]cb& UbXVch\ h\YgY h\]b[g UfY []jYb hc ig(

Dc aUhhYf \ck `ck U dYfgcb aUm ZU``& \Y k]`` U`kUmg VYUV`Y hc gYY h\Uh dYfZYWh]cb hckUfX k\]W\ \Y g\ci`X acjY(

CGXÁÂ

B]ZY ]g h\Y WcbghUbh UddfcUW\ hc XYUh\5 h\YfYZcfY& `]ZY WUbVY V`]gg cb`m k\Yb XYUh\ XcYg bch gYYa hc VY Ub Yj]`(

MY gUm gcaYh]aYg& s>YfY ? k]`` `]jY ]b h\Y fU]bm gYUgcb&h\YfY ? k]`` `]jY ]b h\Y giaaYf(t Ic U WfUnm aUb XfYUag&VYWUigY \Y XcYg bch h\]b_ UVcih XYUh\( 8ih h\Yb XYUh\WcaYg& UbX ]h hU_Yg U`` dYcd`Y k]h\ ]h4 h\Y aUb k\c ]g Vigm&UbX \Y k\c ]g WcbWYfbYX k]h\ gcaYh\]b[& UbX \Y k\c ]g[fYYXm& UbX \Y k\c ]g UVgYbh'a]bXYX( DY]h\Yf mcif gcb&bcf mcif ZUh\Yf& bcf ZUa]`m cf Zf]YbXg WUb \Y`d mci k\YbXYUh\ WcaYg( 7 k]gY aUb& cbY k\c ibXYfghUbXg h\]g&`cc_g Zcf h\Y kUm k\]W\ `YUXg hc WU`abYgg(

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

7 aUb WcaYg ]bhc h\Y kcf`X k]h\ \]g \UbXg dig\YX ]bhcZ]ghg& Ug ]Z \Y kUbhg hc gUm& s7`` h\]g kcf`X ]g a]bY(t 7 aUb`YUjYg h\]g kcf`X k]h\ \]g dU`ag cdYb& Ug ]Z hc gUm& sBcc_&? hU_Y bch\]b[ k]h\ aY(t

vJ\Y J7BCK:

CRX VKRXOG OLYH \RXU OLIH DV LI \RX DUH UHDG\ WR VD\ JRRG%E\HWR LW DW DQ\ PRPHQW$ DV LI WKH WLPH OHIW \RX LV VRPH SOHDVDQWVXUSULVH&

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Ocif `]ZY ]g U gaU`` ghfYhW\ cZ ib`]a]hYX h]aY( Ic \UjY U[ccX `cc_ Uh ]h& UbX aU_Y h\Y VYgh cZ ]h(

vI7?:'8;D'>7C;:

HYaYaVYf& mci Xc f]ch `]jY ]b h\Y kcf`X& mci cb`m dUggh\fci[\ ]h(

CGXÁÃ

1YHU\ SHUVRQ VKRXOG GHFLGH TXHVWLRQV RI OLIH DQG GHDWK IRUKLPVHOI&

7 k]gY aUb gYhg fYei]fYaYbhg cb`m Zcf \]agY`Z5 Ub ibk]gYaUb aU_Yg fYei]fYaYbhg Zcf ch\Yfg(

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

7 gci` XcYg bch `YUfb5 ]h g]ad`m fYaYaVYfg k\Uh ]h _bYSU`` h\Y h]aY(

v:7K: ;B =7<<;H

7 k]gY aUb U`kUmg Z]bXg gcaY giddcfh Zcf \]agY`Z ]bYjYfmh\]b[& VYWUigY \]g []Zh ]g ]b cVhU]b]b[ [ccXbYgg ZfcaYjYfmh\]b[(

v@E>D HKIA?D

Dch\]b[ k]`` Vf]b[ mci dYUWY YlWYdh mcifgY`Z(vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

Eb`m h\Y hfih\ k\]W\ kUg UWei]fYX Vm mcif ckb h\]b_]b[&h\fci[\ h\Y YZZcfhg cZ mcif ]bhY``YWh& VYWcaYg U aYaVYfcZ mcif ckb VcXm& UbX cb`m h\]g hfih\ fYU``m VY`cb[g hc ig(


CGXÁÄ

J\Y gci` _bckg YjYfmh\]b[( Dc bYk h\]b[ WUb gifdf]gY ]h(Dch\]b[ WUb VY V][[Yf h\Ub ]h( BYh ch\Yfg VY UZfU]X& Vihh\Y gci` ]g bch UZfU]X cZ Ubmh\]b[( ?h `]jYg UWWcfX]b[ hc ]hgckb Ùkg( ?h ]g V][[Yf h\Ub gdUWY UbX c`XYf h\Ub h]aY( ?h[]jYg WcifU[Y U[U]bgh U`` h\Y a]gZcfhibYg cZ `]ZY(


3RG OLYHV LQ DOO SHRSOH$ EXW QRW DOO SHRSOH OLYH LQ 3RG$ DQGWKLV LV WKH VRXUFH RI WKHLU VXIIHULQJV&- ODPS FDQQRW EXUQ ZLWKRXW ILUH$ DQG D SHUVRQ FDQQRW

OLYH ZLWKRXW 3RG&vJ>; =EIF;B E< IH? H7C7AH?I>D7& U Vcc_ cZ >?D:K?IC

:c mci h\]b_ h\Uh UbmVcXm WUb XUaU[Y mcif gci`6 J\Ybk\m UfY mci gc YaVUffUggYX6 ? Ùi[\ Uh h\cgY k\c h\]b_h\Ym WUb XUaU[Y aY( J\Ym Xc bch _bck k\c ? Ua& h\YmXc bch _bck k\Uh ? h\]b_& h\Ym WUbbch YjYb hciW\ h\Yh\]b[g k\]W\ UfY fYU``m a]bY UbX k]h\ k\]W\ ? `]jY(

v;F?9J;JKI

7`` h\]b[g ]b h\Y kcf`X VY`cb[ hc aY( '9fYUh]cb UbXXYghfiWh]cb \UddYb UWWcfX]b[ hc am k]``( J\Y dfYgYbhkcf`X ]g îgh U g\Y``& UbX ? Ua h\Y mc`_(

vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

J\Y ]bhY``YWh eiYgh]cbg& \ck UbX k\m6 J\Y XcjY XcYg bchUg_& ]h gUmg4 ? Ua `cjY( ?h []jYg gUh]gZUWh]cb k]h\cih Ug_]b[eiYgh]cbg(

2HDU QRERG\ DQG QRWKLQJ& ?KDW ZKLFK LV WKH PRVW SUHFLRXVPDWWHU LQ \RX FDQ EH GDPDJHG E\ QR RQH DQG E\ QRWKLQJ&

CGXÁĀ

Jfih\ ]g bch j]fhiY& Vih h\Y ÙW_ cZ j]WYg(

J\Y acgh Wcaacb UbX h\Y acgh k]XY`m igYX XYWY]h ]g h\Yk]g\ hc XYWY]jY bch ch\Yf dYcd`Y& Vih mcifgY`Z( 7bX h\]g_]bX cZ `]ZY ]g h\Y acgh \UfaZi`(

?KHUH DUH WKRXVDQGV RI ZD\V ZKLFK OHDG WR GHFHSWLRQ$ DQGWKHUH LV RQO\ RQH ZD\ ZKLFK OHDGV WR WKH WUXWK&


FYcd`Y g\ci`X Zc``ck cb`m h\Y ]bX]gdihUV`Y hfih\(v9ED<K9?KI

Jfih\Zi`bYgg ]g h\Y cb`m fYU` WiffYbWm k\]W\ W]fWiÙhYgYjYfmk\YfY(

v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

BYh ig VY hfih\Zi`( J\]g ]g h\Y amghYfm cZ f\Yhcf]W UbXj]fhiY& h\]g ]g h\Y V][[Ygh amghYfm& h\]g ]g h\Y \][\YghUW\]YjYaYbh ]b Ufh UbX h\Y aU^cf Ùk cZ `]ZY(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

EbY cZ h\Y acgh Wcaacb a]ghU_Yg ]g hc h\]b_ h\Uh mciWUb `]jY k]h\cih hfih\( J\Y ]bbYf UbX cihYf WcbgYeiYbWYgcZ YjYb h\Y gaU``Ygh `]Yg UfY igiU``m acfY \UfaZi` h\Ubh\cgY gaU`` ibd`YUgUbh h\]b[g k\]W\ fYgi`h Zfca hY``]b[h\Y hfih\ X]fYWh`m(

CGXÁĂ

>iaUb]hm \Ug bYjYf `]jYX UbX WUbbch `]jY k]h\cih fY`][]cb(

HY`][]cb ]g h\Y bYWYgg]hm UbX df]aY WcbX]h]cb cZ h\Y `]ZY cZUb ]bhY``YWhiU` dYfgcb(

J\Y ghfcb[Yf h\Y fY`][]cig ZYY`]b[ ]g& h\Y VYhhYf cbY ibXYfxghUbXg k\Uh ]g UbX k\Uh g\ci`X VY h\Y [i]XY cZ U`` cbYrgUWh]cbg(

?h ]g X]ZZ]Wi`h Ybci[\ hc dì[ mcif YUfg ]b U V][ \U`` Zi`` cZXUbW]b[ dYcd`Y5 bck ]aU[]bY h\Uh mci UfY ]b Ub Ugmìa(<cf cbY k\c XYghfcmg ]b \]agY`Z \]g fY`][]cig WcbgW]YbWY&U`` cZ h\Y fY`][]cig UWh]j]hm cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y k]`` dfcXiWY Ug]a]Ùf ]adfYgg]cb( 8ih ]h ]g XUb[Yfcig hc h\]b_ h\Uh mciUfY acfY W`YjYf h\Ub h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ fY`][]cig aUb_]bX(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

FYcd`Y cZhYb gUm h\Uh fY`][]cb `cgYg ]hg dckYf Ua]Xgh\iaUb]hm( J\]g ]g bch hfiY& UbX h\]g WUbbch VY hfiY( J\]g\UddYbg VYWUigY h\Y dYcd`Y k\c h\]b_ gc cVgYfjY cb`m UgaU`` [fcid cZ dYcd`Y& UbX h\YfY UfY U`kUmg WYfhU]b dYcd`Yk\c Xc bch \UjY fY`][]cig ZYY`]b[g(

5I D SHUVRQ KDV SUREOHPV$ WKHUH FDQ EH RQO\ RQH URRW FDXVH*ODFN RI IDLWK& ?KH VDPH LV WUXH ZLWKLQ KXPDQ VRFLHWLHV DV DZKROH&

?KH JUHDWHVW MR\$ DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH ZRUNV RI 2UDQFLV -VVLVL$ LVWKDW \RX FDQ HQGXUH HYHU\WKLQJ$ \RX FDQ HYHQ VXIIHU VODQGHUDQG SK\VLFDO SDLQ$ DQG DW WKH HQG \RX DUH DEOH WR IHHO QR DQLcPRVLW\ WRZDUG WKHVH VXIIHULQJV$ EXW \RX IHHO MR\$ EHFDXVH \RXKDYH IDLWK+ VXFK MR\ FDQQRW EH GHVWUR\HG$ HLWKHU E\ HYLO SHRSOHRU E\ \RXU RZQ VXIIHULQJ&

J\Y eiU`]hm cZ U fYU``m j]fhicig dYfgcb ]g hc VY ib_bckb&hc dYcd`Y& cf hc VY a]gibXYfghccX Vm dYcd`Y& Vih bch hcVY X]gUddc]bhYX Vm h\]g(

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

M\Yb h\Ym VÙaY mci UbX gWc`X mci UbX X]gWigg mci&h\Yb mci g\ci`X fY^c]WY5 k\Yb h\Ym dfU]gY mci UbX UXa]fYmci& h\Yb mci g\ci`X VY gUX(

B]VY` UbX U ZU`gY fYdihUh]cb k\]W\ mci WUb XYghfcm ]g h\YVYgh gW\cc` cZ [ccXbYgg(

J\Y VÙa]b[ UbX Wf]h]W]ga cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]g VUX( 8ih Uhh\Y gUaY h]aY ]h ]g ibXYfghUbXUV`Y& UbX ]h ]g jUìUV`Y Ug h\Ycb`m hYgh cZ mcif `cjY Zcf =cX UbX mcif bY][\Vcf(

CGXÁÅ

7@N ")

EbY WUbbch gUm h\Uh h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y X]j]bYYggYbWY cZ mcif gci` []jYg mci dckYf& Zcf h\]g ibXYfxghUbX]b[ fU]gYg mci hc h\Uh `YjY` k\]W\ hfUbgWYbXg Ubmbch]cbg cZ ZcfWY cf kYU_bYgg UbX h\YfYZcfY cZ dckYf(

>YUjYb ]g W`cgYf hc h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c dif]Zm h\Y]f gci`g(J\cgY k\c \UjY cb`m h\Y _bck`YX[Y fYWY]jYX Vm cif Z]jYgYbgYg Xc bch _bck h\Y YggYbWY cZ h\]b[g( J\Y fYU` _bck`xYX[Y ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Uh h\YfY ]g U \][\Yf gd]f]hiU`ZcfWY(

v?D:?7D M?I:EC

FYcd`Y aUm Ug_ mci& sM\m Xc mci _bck =cX6t Ocig\ci`X fYgdcbX& s8YWUigY \Y ]g ]b am \YUfh(t Bcc_ Uh h\YYggYbWY cZ `]ZY& bch k]h\ h\Y YmYg ]b mcif \YUX& Vih k]h\h\Y YmYg cZ mcif \YUfh( 9Ub mci _bck mcifgY`Z& ]Z mci Xcbch _bck =cX6 J\Y fYU` ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ mcifgY`Z ]g h\YibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ =cX(

vF;HI?7D M?I:EC

BKR FDQ KDUP \RX$ ZKR FDQ KH PRUH SRZHUIXO WKDQ \RX$ LI\RX DUH XQLWHG ZLWK 3RG, -QG FDQ GR WKLV&

CGXÁĄ

J\Y ZcibXUh]cb cZ U` ZU]h\g ]g h\Y gUaY(

?h cb`m gYYag h\Uh dYcd`Y UfY Vigm k]h\ hfUXY& k]h\ aU_]b[U[fYYaYbhg& bY[ch]Uh]cbg UbX kUfg& gW]YbWY UbX h\Y Ufhg(J\YfY ]g ]b ZUWh cb`m cbY h\]b[ k\]W\ dYcd`Y Xc5 h\]g ]g hcgYUfW\ Zcf h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y acfU` Ùk Vm k\]W\h\Ym `]jY( 7bX h\]g ibXYfghUbX]b[ ]g bch cb`m h\Y acgh]adcfhUbh Vih h\Y cb`m fYU` WcbWYfb Zcf U`` \iaUb_]bX(

7 M]gYaUb kUg Ug_YX& s?g h\YfY U g]b[`Y kcfX k\]W\ mciWUb Zc``ck h\fci[\cih U`` mcif `]ZY6t 7bX h\Y k]gY aUbUbgkYfYX& sJ\YfY ]g giW\ U kcfX( J\]g ]g VKX&a 7bX h\YaYUb]b[ cZ h\]g kcfX ]g& s?Z kY Xc bch kUbh WYfhU]b h\]b[ghc VY XcbY hc ig& kY g\ci`X bch Xc giW\ h\]b[g hc ch\Yfg(t

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

CRX VKRXOG EHKDYH LQ VXFK D ZD\ WKDW \RX FDQ VD\ WR HYHU\cERG\$ `.HKDYH DV 5 GR&a


J\Y fYU``m hfiY UbX ibW\Ub[]b[ Ùk& h\Uh Ùk k\]W\ []jYgig hfiY X]fYWh]cb UbX k\]W\ ZcfV]Xg ig hc Xc VUX h\]b[g& ]gh\Y ]bhY``YWh cZ U \][\Yf& gidYf]cf VY]b[(


M\Yb mci WÙg\ k]h\ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& fYaYaVYf h\Y Ùk cZfYW]dfcW]hm( Oci g\ci`X Xc hc ch\Yfg h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ mcikUbh XcbY hc mci( J\]g g\ci`X VYWcaY mcif kUm cZ `]ZY(

CGXÂÀ

<cf U dYfgcb& Zcf Ub Ub]aU`& ]bXYYX Zcf Ubm `]j]b[ VY]b[&h\YfY ]g bY]h\Yf `c[]W bcf aYUb]b[ ]b h\Y kcfX sZfYYXcatVYWUigY U`` cif `]jYg UfY `]a]hYX Vm aUbm WcbghfU]bhg( 7bXmYh ]Z U dYfgcb ibXYfghUbXg \]agY`Z Ug U gd]f]hiU` VY]b[& \YWUbbch YjYb gdYU_ UVcih bch VY]b[ ZfYY4 h\Y ]XYU cZ bchVY]b[ ZfYY WUbbch VY Udd`]YX hc h\Y bch]cbg cZ ]bhY``YWh&WcbgW]YbWY& UbX `cjY(

HYaYaVYf h\Uh mcif ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ mcif ]bbYf gY`Z\c`Xg h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ mcif `]ZY& UbX ]h aU_Yg mci ZfYY ]Z mciXc bch ZcfWY ]h hc gYfjY mcif Z`Yg\( J\Y \iaUb gci` k\]W\]g Yb`][\hYbYX Vm ibXYfghUbX]b[ UbX ZfYYX Zfca dUgg]cbg&UbX `]h k]h\ h\Y X]j]bY `][\h& ghUbXg cb U Z]fa ZcibXUh]cb(

-QG \H VKDOO NQRZ WKH WUXWK$ DQG WKH WUXWK VKDOO PDNH \RXIUHH&

v@E>D 24-,

;j]` XcYg bch Yl]gh ]b aUhYf]U` bUhifY Vm ]hgY`Z& Vih Yj]`Yl]ghg Zcf YjYfm dYfgcb k\c ibXYfghUbXg [ccXbYgg& UbXk\c \Ug h\Y ZfYYXca cZ W\c]WY VYhkYYb [ccX UbX VUX(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

MY ibXYfghUbX jYfm W`YUf`m h\Uh hc VY U dYfgcb k]h\ \][\acfU`g ]g hc VY U dYfgcb k]h\ U `]VYfUhYX gci`( J\cgY k\cUfY X]gUddc]bhYX cf WcbWYfbYX cf UZfU]X& cf k\c UfY]bjc`jYX ]b dUgg]cbg& WUbbch ZfYY h\Y]f gci`g(

v9ED<K9?KI

FYcd`Y k\c XYbm ZfYYXca fYa]bX aY cZ V`]bX dYcd`Y k\cXYbm Wc`cfg( J\Ym Xc bch _bck h\Y bUhifY cZ ZfYYXca(

?b cfXYf hc `]jY ]b [ccXbYgg& hfm Xc]b[ ]h(

CRX VKRXOG FHOHEUDWH HDFK QHZ GD\ ZLWK D JRRG DFWLRQ& DJRRG GHHG& ?KLV LV WKH EHVW ZD\ WR VWDUW D QHZ GD\&

DcVcXm \Ug Ubm ]XYU UVcih k\Uh [ccXbYgg ]g& ibh]` h\YmghUfh Xc]b[ ]h(

v>7HH?;J C7HJ?D;7K

=cXrg `cjY k]`` [c Zfca \YUjYb hc h\cgY k\c []jY hc h\Ydccf( 7 XciV`Y V`Ygg]b[ k]`` [c hc h\cgY k\c& k\]`Y Xc]b[h\]g& aYYh h\Y dccf UbX hYbXYf`m gUm s[ccX'VmYt hc h\Ya(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

M\Yb mci Xc U [ccX XYYX& VY [fUhYZi` h\Uh mci \UjY \UXh\Y W\UbWY hc Xc ]h(

Oci aigh _bck Z]fa`m UbX ZYY` XYYd`m h\Uh mci g\ci`XXYX]WUhY YjYfm XUm hc h\Y [ccX cZ mcif ZY``ckg& Xc]b[YjYfmh\]b[ mci WUb Zcf h\Ya( Oci \UjY hc Xc ]h UbX bchhU`_ UVcih ]h(

v@E>D HKIA?D

?Z mci WUbbch hYUW\ mcifgY`Z hc gYY_ dcgg]V]`]h]Yg ZcfXc]b[ [ccX UbX hc Xc [ccX Uh YjYfm dcgg]V`Y cWWUg]cb&h\Yb Uh `YUgh Xc bch a]gg U W\UbWY hc Xc [ccX(

CGXÂÁ

CGXÂÂ

J\Y [fYUhYgh W\Ub[Yg ]b h\Y kcf`X UfY aUXY g`ck`m UbX[fUXiU``m& bch k]h\ Yfidh]cbg UbX fYjc`ih]cbg(J\Y gUaY h\]b[g \UddYb ]b cbYrg gd]f]hiU` `]ZY(

7`` [fYUh h\ci[\hg UfY `]j]b[ h\ci[\hg& UbX h\Ym WUb [fckUbX VY W\Ub[YX( 7bX h\Ym W\Ub[Y UbX [fck Ug U hfYY& UbXbch Ug U W`ciX(

v@E>D HKIA?D

-OO UHDOO\ JUHDW WKLQJV DUH KDSSHQLQJ LQ VORZ DQG LQFRQVSLFXcRXV ZD\V&

J\Y dfcWYgg cZ `]ZY g\ci`X VY h\Y V]fh\ cZ U gci`( J\]g ]gh\Y \][\Ygh U`W\Yam& UbX h\]g ^igh]Z]Yg cif dfYgYbWY cbYUfh\( J\]g ]g cif WU``]b[ UbX cif j]fhiY(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

Eif `]ZY ]g ibWYUg]b[ kcbXYf& [fckh\& UbX XYjY`cdaYbh(vBK9O C7BEHO

J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ acfY \UfaZi` Zcf mcif ]bbYf dYfZYWh]cbh\Ub h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Uh mci UfY Xc]b[ kY``( J\Y kUmhc \Udd]bYgg& h\Y kUm hc fYU` acfU` ]adfcjYaYbh& acjYggc ]bj]g]V`m& gc ]bWcbgd]Wicig`m& h\Uh U dYfgcb WUb gYY \]ggiWWYggYg cb`m UZhYf [fYUh& `Yb[h\m dYf]cXg cZ h]aY(?Z mci h\]b_ h\Uh mci UfY acj]b[ hckUfX dYfZYWh]cb

UbX mci bch]WY h\]g& h\Yb mci g\ci`X _bck h\Uh mci UfY a]gxhU_Yb& h\Uh mci \UjY ghcddYX UbX UfY acj]b[ VUW_kUfX(

CGXÂÃ

MY g\ci`X VY gUh]gZ]YX k]h\ h\Y gaU`` h\]b[g ]b `]ZY( J\Y`Ygg kY bYYX& h\Y `Ygg hfciV`Y kY WUb \UjY(

?h ]g U [fYUh \Udd]bYgg hc \UjY k\Uh mci XYg]fY5 Vih ]h ]g UbYjYb [fYUhYf \Udd]bYgg bch hc kUbh acfY h\Ub mci U`fYUXm\UjY(

vC;D;:;CKI

M\c ]g U k]gY aUb6v>Y k\c ghiX]Yg U`` h\Y h]aY(M\c ]g ghfcb[6v>Y k\c WUb `]a]h \]agY`Z(M\c ]g f]W\6v>Y k\c ]g \Uddm k]h\ k\Uh \Y \Ug(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

:DWXUH QHHGV VPDOO WKLQJV$ KXW \RXU LPDJLQDWLRQ QHHGV PXFK&

<fca d`YUgifYg UddYUf gUXbYgg UbX ZYUf( >Y k\c ]g ZfYYZfca d`YUgifYg XcYg bch \UjY Y]h\Yf ZYUf cf gUXbYgg(

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

J\Y ]b]h]U` ^cm cb VYWca]b[ ZfYY ]g VYhhYf h\Ub VY]b[ U_]b[5 ]h ]g acfY VYUih]Zi` h\Ub [c]b[ hc \YUjYb5 ]h ]g acfY]adcfhUbh h\Ub WcaaUbX]b[ k\c`Y kcf`Xg(

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

J\Y [fckh\ cZ mcif XYg]fYg ]g bch h\Y kUm hc dYfZYWh]cb&Ug aUbm dYcd`Y h\]b_( Jc h\Y WcbhfUfm& h\Y acfY U dYfgcb`]a]hg \]agY`Z& h\Y VYhhYf \Y WUb ibXYfghUbX \]g \iaUbX][b]hm& UbX h\Y acfY ZfYY& h\Y acfY VfUjY \Y VYWcaYg&UbX acgh ]adcfhUbh`m& h\Y acfY WUdUV`Y cZ gYfj]b[ =cXUbX ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

CGXÂÄ

BcjY ]g cbY cZ h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cbg cZ =cX ]b aUb(

J\Y difdcgY cZ `]ZY ]g hc YldfYgg `cjY ]b U`` ]hg aUb]ZYghUxh]cbg(

?b cfXYf hc VY \Uddm& mci g\ci`X `cjYv`cjY k]h\ gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY& `cjY U`` UbX YjYfmh\]b[& UbX gdfYUX U bYhkcf_ cZ`cjY YjYfmk\YfY( Dc aUhhYf k\c [Yhg ]bhc h\]g bYh& WUhW\h\Ya U`` UbX Z]`` h\Ya k]h\ `cjY(

;jYfmcbY WUb fYWU`` U acaYbh& ib]jYfgU` hc U``& dYf\UdgZfca YUf`m W\]`X\ccX& k\Yb mci kUbhYX hc `cjY YjYfmcbYUbX YjYfmh\]b[vmcif ZUh\Yf& mcif ach\Yf& mcif Vfch\xYfg& Yj]` dYcd`Y& U Xc[& U WUh& [fUggvUbX mci kUbhYXYjYfmcbY hc ZYY` [ccX& YjYfmcbY hc ZYY` \Uddm5 UbX YjYbacfY& mci kUbhYX hc Xc gcaYh\]b[ gdYW]U` gc h\Uh YjYfmxcbY kci`X VY \Uddm& YjYb hc gUWf]Z]WY mcifgY`Z& hc []jYmcif `]ZY gc h\Uh YjYfmcbY g\ci`X ZYY` \Uddm UbX ^cmZi`(J\]g ZYY`]b[ ]g h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ `cjY& UbX ]h aigh VY fYhifbYXhc& Zcf ]h ]g h\Y `]ZY cZ YjYfm dYfgcb(

-Q\WKLQJ \RX GR VKRXOG KH ILOOHG ZLWK ORYH&

CGXÂĀ

Oci g\ci`X VY WUfYZi` bch hc Zc``ck VUX YlUad`Yg( M\Ybmci \YUf mcif bY][\Vcf gÙbXYf]b[ ch\Yfg& hfm hc ghcd \]a(


J\YfY ]g bc kcfgY \Ufa Zcf U dYfgcb k]h\ U ghfcb[ ]bhY`x`YWh h\Ub h\Y hYadhUh]cb hc aU_Y k]hhm fYaUf_g h\UhVÙaY UbX acW_ \]g bY][\Vcfg(

CU_]b[ ^c_Yg UbX VÙa]b[ UbX acW_]b[ ch\Yfg ]g `]_YWcjYf]b[ U XYUX VcXm k]h\ U b]WY gUiWY UbX dfYgYbh]b[ ]hUg U aYU`( M]h\cih h\Y gUiWY& mci kci`X hifb UkUm& Vihk]h\ ]h& mci Z]bX mci WUb YUg]`m YUh h\]g X]ghUghYZi` aYU`(

:HYHU OLVWHQ WR WKRVH ZKR EODPH RWKHUV DQG VSHDN ZHOO DERXW\RX&

Oci \UjY hc h\]b_ UVcih k\Uh mci gUm5 cb`m h\Yb k]`` mciZYY` ei]Yh UbX _]bX UbX Z]``YX k]h\ `cjY( J\Y acfY mci UfY]ff]hUhYX& h\Y acfY YlW]hYX mci VYWcaY& h\Y acfY WUfYmci aigh YlYfW]gY bch hc g]b k]h\ mcif kcfXg Vm UVig]b[ch\Yfg(

CGXÂĂ

?KH PDQQHU RI RQH_V GHDWK FDQ KH LQ DFFRUG ZLWK WKH PDQQHURI RQH_V OLIH$ DQG WKHUHIRUH LW FDQ EH D PRUDO DFWLRQ& -Q DQLcPDO VLPSO\ GLHV$ EXW D KXPDQ VKRXOG UHWXUQ KLV VRXO WR LWVFUHDWRU&

v>;DH? 7C?;?

9\f]ghrg [fYUhYgh kcfXg kYfY gU]X ]aaYX]UhY`m VYZcfY \]gXYUh\& k\Yb \Y Zcf[UjY \]g dYfgYWihcfg& k\c X]X bchibXYfghUbX k\Uh h\Ym X]X( J\Y kcfXg UbX UWh]cbg cZ UXm]b[ dYfgcb \UjY [fYUh dckYf cjYf dYcd`Y& UbX h\ig ]h ]g]adcfhUbh Vch\ hc `]jY U [ccX `]ZY UbX hc X]Y ]b U [ccX kUm(7 [ccX XYUh\ hU_Yg UkUm h\Y g]bg cZ U VUX `]ZY(

:if]b[ h\Y a]bihYg cZ XYUh\& U dYfgcb WUb gYY U WUbX`Y& ]bh\Y `][\h cZ k\]W\ \Y fYUXg h\Y Vcc_ cZ U `]ZY Z]``YX k]h\dfcV`Yag& `]Yg& Yj]`g& UbX a]gZcfhibYg( 7bX& ]b h\Y a]bihYgcZ Xm]b[& h\]g WUbX`Y `][\hg id U`` h\Y kcf`X k]h\ U jYfmVf][\h UbX W`YUf `][\h& UbX Vf][\hYbg id U`` h\Y WcfbYfg cZ UdYfgcbrg `]ZY& YjYb h\cgY WcfbYfg k\]W\ kYfY U`kUmg WcjxYfYX k]h\ XUf_bYgg5 UbX h\Yb ]h aU_Yg gcaY g`][\h bc]gY&UbX h\Y `][\h [cYg Xckb UbX X]gUddYUfg ZcfYjYf(

M\Yb mci [Yh fYUXm hc X]Y& Xc bch kcffm UVcih h\Y igiU`h\]b[g& `]_Y Zc``ck]b[ f]hiU`g cf hU_]b[ WUfY cZ YjYfmXUmVig]bYgg( 8Y dfYdUfYX gc h\Uh mci WUb X]Y ]b h\Y VYgh kUmdcgg]V`Y( KgY U`` h\Y a][\hm ]bZ`iYbWY cZ h\cgY dckYfZi`ghfcb[ a]bihYg cZ XYUh\& k\Yb U dYfgcb Yl]ghg dUfh]U``m ]bh\Y ch\Yf kcf`X& UbX \]g kcfXg UbX XYYXg \UjY gdYW]U`dckYf cjYf h\cgY k\c fYaU]b ]b h\]g kcf`X(

CGXÂÅ

LYfm cZhYb& U`` cZ h\Y UWh]j]hm cZ h\Y \iaUb a]bX ]gX]fYWhYX bch ]b fYjYU`]b[ h\Y hfih\& Vih ]b \]X]b[ h\Y hfih\(J\Y dchYbh]U` cZ h\Y \iaUb a]bX hc UWh h\]g kUm ]g cifaU^cf gcifWY cZ hYadhUh]cb(

J\Y Wcifh ^ifm \Ug& Ug ]hg fU]gcb XrYhfY& h\Y hUg_ cZ dfYgYfjx]b[ gcW]Yhm Ug ]h Yl]ghg bck& UbX h\YfYZcfY& ]h dYfgYWihYgUbX YlYWihYg h\cgY k\c ghUbX \][\Yf h\Ub h\Y [YbYfU``YjY` cZ gcW]Yhm& UbX ]h gYfjYg h\cgY k\c UfY `ckYf h\Ub h\Y[YbYfU` `YjY`(

7 aUb WUbbch Xc YjYfmh\]b[5 Vih h\]g WUbbch VY Ub YlWigYZcf Xc]b[ VUX h\]b[g(


? `cjY dYUgUbhg UbX ZUfaYfg5 h\Ym UfY bch gW\c`Uf`m Ybci[\bcf YXiWUhYX Ybci[\ hc hY`` gcd\]gh]WUhYX `]Yg(

v9>7HB;I :; CEDJ;IGK?;K

5I \RX VHH WKDW DQ DFWLRQ LV H[SODLQHG E\ D YHU\ VRSKLVWLFDWHGUHDVRQLQJ$ WKHQ \RX FDQ KH VXUH WKDW WKLV DFWLRQ LV KDG& ?KHGHFLVLRQV RI WKH FRQVFLHQFH DUH DOZD\V VWULFW DQG VLPSOH&

<cf h\Y dU[Ub kcf`X& U aUbrg f]W\bYgg ]bX]WUhYg \]g [`cfmUbX ]adcfhUbWY5 ]b U hfi`m 9\f]gh]Ub kcf`X& h\Y [fYUhkYU`h\ cZ U aUb ]g Ub ]bX]WUh]cb cZ \]g kYU_bYgg UbX `]Yg(

FYcd`Y UfY gc ]bjc`jYX ]b h\Y]f aUhYf]U` ]bhYfYghg h\Uhk\Yb h\Ym `cc_ Uh h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cbg cZ h\Y \iaUb gci`&UbX Uh difY fYÙh]cbg\]dg VYhkYYb dYcd`Y& h\Ym `cc_ Uhh\Ya Zfca h\Y dc]bh cZ j]Yk cZ \ck hc ]adfcjY h\Y]faUhYf]U` kY``'VY]b[( HYgdYWhUV]`]hm ]g cZhYb aYUgifYX VmcbY"g kYU`h\& UbX bch Vm \]g fYU` ]bbYf gd]f]hiU` jUìY(

7ZhYf H7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

J\Y dcggYgg]cb cZ [fYUh kYU`h\ ]g U gW\cc` cZ df]XY& WfixY`hm& gY`Z'UXa]fUh]cb& UbX X]gg]dUh]cb(

J\Y ÙW_ cZ gYbg]h]j]hm Uacb[ f]W\ dYcd`Y ]g bch Ug WfiY` Ugh\Y]f WcadUgg]cb(

v7ZhYf @;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

CRX VKRXOG QRW UHVSHFW SRRU SHRSOH WRR PXFK$ EXW \RX VKRXOGWDNH SLW\ RQ WKHP& - ULFK SHUVRQ VKRXOG QRW EH SURXG RI KLVZHDOWK+ KH VKRXOG EH DVKDPHG RI LW&

CGXÂǺ

CGXÂĄ

B]ZY ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ U \c`m gd]f]h ]b mcifgY`Z5 U\c`m gd]f]h k\]W\ ]g dih ]bhc gcaY `]a]hg(

?KH RQO\ FOHDU DQG ILQDO WUXWK LV WKH WUXWK RI FRQVFLHQFH&vH;D; :;I97HJ;I

KbXYf am ZYYh& h\YfY ]g Wc`X ZfcnYb YUfh\5 UfcibX aY\i[Y hfYYg UfY ghUbX]b[5 UVcjY am \YUX ]g h\Y Zc[[m Wi`XSg_m( ? ZYY` am VcXm& ? ZYY` am a]bX cWWid]YX k]h\ jUf]cigh\ci[\hg( 7bX Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY ? _bck h\Uh U`` h\YgYh\]b[g& U`` h\]g ZfcghYX Wc`X YUfh\& UbX h\Y hfYYg& UbX h\Yg_m& UbX am VcXm& UbX am h\ci[\hg& h\]g ]g U`` WfYUhYX VmW\UbWY& h\]g ]g U hYadcfUfm kcf`X& h\Y WfYUh]cb cZ am Z]jYgYbgYg( J\Y kcf`X WfYUhYX Vm aY Yl]ghg cb`m VYWUigY ? UadUfh cZ ]h& UbX h\YfYZcfY& ? gYdUfUhY amgY`Z Zfca h\Y kcf`X(? _bck h\Uh ? Wci`X X]Y& Vih h\Y kcf`X k]`` bch X]gUddYUf(:YUh\ k]`` aU_Y gcaY W\Ub[Yg ]b aY& UbX k\]`Y ? k]``

bch VY Wcad`YhY`m XYghfcmYX& ? k]`` VYWcaY Ubch\YfVY]b[& gYdUfUhY Zfca h\]g kcf`X( Dck& Uh dfYgYbh& ? ibXYfxghUbX amgY`Z5 h\Yb& gcaYh\]b[ X]ZZYfYbh U`hc[Yh\Yf k]``\UddYb hc am ]bbYf gY`Z( 7bX h\YfY WUb VY U `]a]h`Ygg biaxVYf cZ giW\ VY]b[g& k\]W\ Yl]gh gYdUfUhY`m Zfca h\]gkcf`X(

Eif `]ZY ]g cif `]a]hYX ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\]g YhYfbU` UbX`]a]h`Ygg gd]f]h k\]W\ _bckg bc WcbghfU]bhg ]b h]aY UbXgdUWY UbX k\]W\ ]g bch VcibX Vm Ubm gdUh]U` cf h]aY`mYjYbhg(

J\Y \iaUb WcbgW]YbWY ]g U X]j]bY WcbgW]YbWY(

CGXÃÀ

Eif ÙbX& `]_Y cif W\UfUWhYf& WUbbch VY h\Y cV^YWh cZ Vimx]b[ UbX gY``]b[( 8Y\]bX h\Y Vim]b[ UbX gY``]b[ cZ YUfh\ ]gh\Y \]XXYb dfcWYgg cZ Vim]b[ UbX gY``]b[ U dYfgcbU`]hm(

;Ufh\ ]g h\Y [fYUh []Zh k\]W\ bUhifY [UjY hc dYcd`Y& UbXh\Y V]fh\ cZ YjYfm dYfgcb ]b h\]g kcf`X g\ci`X []jY \]ah\Y f][\h hc dcggYgg h\]g YUfh\( 7bX h\]g f][\h g\ci`X VY UgbUhifU` Ug h\Y f][\h cZ U dYfgcb hc \UjY h\Y VfYUgh cZ \]gach\Yf(

v@;7D <H7D9E?I C7HCEDJ;B

7 dYfgcb ]b cif gcW]Yhm WUbbch g`YYd k]h\cih dUm]b[ Zcfh\Y dÙWY k\YfY \Y g`YYdg5 \Y \Ug h\Y f][\h hc \UjY ZfYY U]fcf kUhYf cf gib`][\h cb`m k\Yb \Y ]g cb h\Y fcUX( J\Y cb`mf][\h \Y \Ug ]g hc kU`_ U`cb[ h\]g fcUX5 ibh]` \Y VYWcaYgh]fYX& cf \Y WUbbch kU`_& \Y \Ug hc Wcbh]biY kU`_]b[(

J\Y VcX]Yg cZ aYb UbX kcaYb& UbX YjYb acfY ]adcfxhUbh`m& h\Y]f W\]`XfYb& g\ci`X bch VY Vci[\h UbX gc`X( Ichcc h\Y kUhYf& h\Y ÙbX UbX U]f& VYWUigY h\YgY h\]b[g UfYbYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cbg cZ h\]g Yl]ghYbWY(

v@E>D HKIA?D

<HRSOH VWULYH LQ WKLV ZRUOG$ QRW IRU WKRVH WKLQJV ZKLFK DUHWUXO\ JRRG$ KXW IRU WKH SRVVHVVLRQ RI PDQ\ WKLQJV ZKLFK WKH\FDQ FDOO WKHLU SURSHUW\&

CGXÃÁ

7 dYfgcb k\c ]g bch igYX hc ìlifm& Vih k\c UWei]fYXìlifm ei]hY Vm W\UbWY& cZhYb dfYhYbXg& ]b cfXYf hc VYWcaYacfY ]adcfhUbh ]b \]g ckb YmYg UbX ]b h\Y YmYg cZ ch\YfdYcd`Y& h\Uh ìlifm ]g bUhifU` Zcf \]a& h\Uh \Y ]g bchgifdf]gYX Vm ]h& h\Uh \Y bY[`YWhg ]h( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm U ghid]XdYfgcb dfYhYbXg h\Uh \Y ]g VcfYX k]h\ `]ZY&UbX h\Uh \Y WUbZ]bX gcaYh\]b[ acfY ]bhYfYgh]b[(

?KH MR\ RI \RXU VSLULW LV WKH LQGLFDWLRQ RI \RXU VWUHQJWK&vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

Oci aigh VY`]YjY ]b h\Y dcgg]V]`]hm cZ \Udd]bYgg ]b cfXYfhc VY \Uddm(

JU_Y Zfca U dYfgcb k\c Zc``ckg h\Y X]j]bY Ùk YjYfmh\]b[k\]W\ ch\Yf dYcd`Y h\]b_ cZ Ug WcaZcfh UbX kYU`h\& UbXbYjYfh\Y`Ygg giW\ U dYfgcb k]`` fYaU]b \Uddm(

7 dYfgcb k\c \Ug gdc]`YX \]g ghcaUW\ k]`` Wf]h]W]nY \]gaYU]g gUm]b[ h\Uh h\Y ZccX ]g VUX5 h\Y gUaY h\]b[ \UddYbgk]h\ dYcd`Y k\c UfY bch gUh]gZ]YX k]h\ h\Y]f `]jYg ]bh\]g kcf`X(

MY Xc bch \UjY h\Y f][\h hc VY ib\Uddm k]h\ cif `]ZY( ?Z ]hgYYag hc ig h\Uh kY UfY bch gUh]gZ]YX k]h\ `]ZY& kY g\ci`XgYY h\]g Ug U fYUgcb hc VY ibgUh]gZ]YX k]h\ cifgY`jYg(

BVPJÁ

.HWWHU WR GR QRWKLQJ WKDQ WR GR KDUP&

MY cZhYb fYZigY hc dUfh]W]dUhY ]b h\Y ]bbcWYbh ^cmg cZ `]ZYVYWUigY kY UfY hcc Vigm k]h\ gcaYh\]b[ kY ZYY` kY \UjYhc Xc( MY g\ci`X UWWYdh h\YgY acaYbhg& VYWUigY h\YgkYYh UbX ^cmZi` [UaY ]g gcaYh]aYg acfY ]adcfhUbh UbXbYWYggUfm h\Ub acgh ch\Yf h\]b[g( LYfm cZhYb h\Y Vig]bYggk\]W\ Vigm dYcd`Y WÙ]a hc VY Xc]b[ ]g bch ]adcfhUbh UhU``( UbX gcaYh]aYg ]h kci`X VY VYhhYf `YZh ibXcbY(

9fiY` dYcd`Y UfY Vigm U`` h\Y h]aY& Ug ]Z hc Z]bX îgh]Z]WUxh]cb Zcf h\Y WfiY`hm cZ h\Y]f XYU`]b[g(

?h ]g U Wcaacb a]gWcbWYdh]cb hc h\]b_ h\Uh d`YUgifYg UbX^cmg UfY ib]adcfhUbh UbX gcaYh]aYg Yj]`5 Ug Zcf YlUad`Y&?gÙa& cf UbW]Ybh c`X Efh\cXcl 9\f]gh]Ub]hm& cf Fif]xhUb]ga kci`X \UjY ]h( F`YUgifY ]g Ug ]adcfhUbh Ug kcf_&UbX ]g h\Y fYkUfX cZ kcf_( Mcf_ WUbbch Ùgh YbX`Ygg`m& UbXh\Y bYWYggUfm fYgh g\ci`X igiU``m WcbWìXY k]h\ gcaYdYf]cX cZ d`YUgifY(F`YUgifYg UfY cb`m VUX ]b h\YgY h\fYY WUgYg4 k\Yb kY

\UjY hc aU_Y ch\Yf dYcd`Y kcf_ Zcf ig VYWUigY ]h ]g]adcgg]V`Y Zcf ig hc gUh]gZm cif XYg]fY Zcf d`YUgifYg& k\YbkY dÙb WcadYh]h]jY [UaYg hc XYhYfa]bY k\c k]`` \UjYh\Y VYgh cf h\Y acgh d`YUgifYg& UbX k\Yb d`YUgifYg UfYU``ckYX cb`m Zcf gY`YWhYX dYcd`Y( 8ih ]Z h\YgY Yj]`g UfYUjc]XYX& h\Yb d`YUgifY& YgdYW]U``m Zcf mcib[ dYcd`Y& ]g bchUb Yj]`& Vih U [ccX(

Mcf_ UbX d`YUgifY g\ci`X VY U`hYfbUhYX& cbY UZhYf h\Ych\Yf5 h\Ym Z]`` cif `]jYg k]h\ ^cm& h\ci[\ bch YjYfm kcf_UbX YjYfm d`YUgifY WUb Xc h\]g(

BVPJÂ

<cf k\cgcYjYf YlU`hYh\ \]agY`Z g\U`` VY UVUgYX5 UbX \Yh\Uh \iaV`Yh\ \]agY`Z g\U`` VY YlU`hYX(

vBKA; +.4++

7 dYfgcb k\c ghUbXg cb \]g h]dhcYg WUbbch ghUbX `cb[&UbX U dYfgcb k\c ]g hcc dfciX cZ \]agY`Z WUbbch gYh U[ccX YlUad`Y(

vB7E'JPK""

4H ZKR LV ORRNLQJ IRU ZLVGRP LV DOUHDG\ ZLVH+ DQG KH ZKRWKLQNV WKDW KH KDV IRXQG ZLVGRP LV D VWXSLG PDQ&

v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

Dc YlhYf]cf ZcfWY WUb aU_Y mci \iaV`Y( J\YfY ]g cb`mcbY kUm hc VY \iaV`Y4 Xc bch h\]b_ UVcih mcifgY`Z& VihUVcih \ck mci WUb gYfjY =cX UbX ch\Yfg(

BVPJÃ

BKHWKHU WKH\ NQRZ LW RU QRW$ DOO FUHDWXUHV DUH LQVHSDUDEO\FRQQHFWHG&

? k]`` bYjYf gYY_ cf UWWYdh aYfY`m am ckb dYfgcbU` gU`jUxh]cb& ? Xc bch kUbh hc fYWY]jY gUh]gZUWh]cb Vm amgY`Z5U`kUmg UbX YjYfmk\YfY ? `]jY UbX kcf_& ? k]`` \cdY UbXghf]jY Zcf h\Y ib]jYfgU` gU`jUh]cb cZ U`` dYcd`Y UbX U`` WfYUxhifYg ]b h\Y kcf`X( Kbh]` U`` \UjY VYYb gUjYX UbX ZfYYX& ?k]`` bch UVUbXcb h\]g kcf`X cZ g]b& gUXbYgg& UbX ghf]ZY(

v7D9?;DJ 9>?D;I; M?I:EC

KbXYfghUbX h\Uh mci UfY dUfh cZ U [fYUh gd]f]hiU` Vfch\Yfx\ccX5 h\YfY ]g gcaYh\]b[ W\YYf]b[ UbX gcch\]b[ ]b h\Yh\ci[\h k\]W\ k]`` aU_Y mci WU`a UbX gUh]gZ]YX(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

>iaUb]hm \Ug VY[ib hc ibXYfghUbX h\Uh kY k]`` U`` f]gY cfZU`` hc[Yh\Yfvh\Uh kY UfY VcibX hc[Yh\Yf& Ug kY `]jYhc[Yh\Yf( FYcd`Y UfY `]ghYb]b[ acfY UbX acfY hc h\Y jc]WYk\]W\ gdYU_g h\]g ]bg]XY cZ ig(

vBK9O C7BEHO

?bX]j]XiU` [ccXbYgg UbX ]bX]j]XiU` Yj]` Vch\ \UjY h\YdckYf hc gdfYUX [ccXbYgg cf Yj]` h\fci[\cih h\Y kcf`X(

BVPJÄ

:iY hc h\Y WiffYbh X]ghcfh]cb& dYfjYfg]cb& UbX ZU`gYibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ 9\f]gh]Ub]hm& cif `]jYg \UjY VYWcaYkcfgY h\Ub h\cgY cZ dU[Ubg(

7 aUb g\ci`X VY U gYfjUbh& UbX \Y g\ci`X aU_Y U W\c]WYcZ k\cgY gYfjUbh \Y ]g4 ]Z \Y ]g h\Y gYfjUbh cZ \]g dUgg]cbg&h\Yb \Y ]g U gYfjUbh cZ ch\Yf \iaUb VY]b[g& Vih ]Z \Y ]g h\YgYfjUbh cZ \]g ]bbYf X]j]bY gd]f]h& h\Yb \Y ]g U gYfjUbh cZ=cX U`cbY(?h ]g VYhhYf hc \UjY U gidYf]cf aUghYf(

J\Y gU`jUh]cb cZ aUb_]bX XYdYbXg idcb ]bXYdYbXYbhh\]b_Yfg X]fYWh]b[ h\Y]f h\ci[\hg f][\h`m(


?KH PRUH UHVSHFW WKDW GLIIHUHQW REMHFWV$ FXVWRPV$ RU ODZV DUHJLYHQ$ WKH PRUH DWWHQWLYHO\ \RX KDYH WR TXHVWLRQ WKH ULJKWWKHVH WKLQJV KDYH WR WKLV UHVSHFW&

Kdfcch]b[ h\Y Yl]gh]b[ Yj]`g cZ h\]g `]ZY WUb VY[]b cb`m VmaU_]b[ cif fY`][]cbg cdYb& gc h\Uh YjYfm g]b[`Y \iaUbVY]b[ ]b h\Y kcf`X WUb fYjYU` fY`][]cig `]ZY UbX WUb X]gWiggUbX WfYUhY UbX X]gWcjYf fY`][]cig hfih\(

BVPJĀ

?Z kY gUm h\Uh h\Y cihYf kcf`X Yl]ghg cb`m Ug kY gYY ]h& kYXYbm h\Uh h\YfY UfY ch\Yf VY]b[g& k]h\ gYbgYg X]ZZYfYbhZfca cif ckb(

M\Yb ? WUgh am [UnY cb cV^YWhg& ? hfm hc WcffYÙhY h\Y]fcih`]bYg k]h\ ]XYUg h\Uh U`fYUXm Yl]gh ]b am \YUX( ? k]`` gYYk\]hY cb h\Y \cf]ncb& UbX ? k]`` h\]b_& J\YfY ]g U k\]hYW\ifW\ ]b h\Y X]ghUbWY( :c kY bch []jY YjYfmh\]b[ kY gYY]b h\]g kcf`X U dfYYl]gh]b[ Zcfa Zfca cif ]aU[]bUh]cb&Vfci[\h Vm ig Zfca cif dfYj]cig `]ZY6

MY WUb gYY h\Uh U`` cZ h\Y kcf`Xrg cV^YWhg Yl]gh ]b hkckUmg4 ]b fYÙh]cb hc h\Y]f dÙWY UbX h]aYvVm ibXYfghUbXx]b[ h\Uh h\Ym Yl]gh ]b =cX UbX kYfY WfYUhYX Vm h\Y gUaY:]j]bY DUhifY k\]W\ YjYfo" gd]f]hiU` h\]b[ ]b h\]g kcf`XVYUfg ]b fYÙh]cb hc YhYfb]hm

v7ZhYf 8;D;:?9JKI IF?DEP7

5Q UHDOLW\$ WKH RXWHU ZRUOG LQ LWVHOI LV QRW DV ZH VHH LW$ DQG WKXVHYHU\WKLQJ PDWHULDO LQ WKLV ZRUOG WV LQVLJQLILFDQW& BKDW LVLPSRUWDQW WKHQ, ?KDW WKLQJ ZKLFK H[LVWV HYHU\ZKHUH$ DW DOOWLPHV$ DQG IRU DOO SHRSOH* WKH GLYLQH VSDUN$ WKH VSLULWXDO URRWRI RXU OLYHV&

BVPJĂ

7b Yj]` XYYX bch cb`m XYghfcmg h\Y gci` Vih cZhYb fYhifbghc Vf]b[ Yj]` cb h\Y Yj]`XcYf

J\Y [fYUhYgh j]fhiY ]g hc Xc bc Yj]`& YjYb hc mcif YbYa]Yg(?Z mci fYgdYWh mcifgY`Z& mci k]`` bch Wcaa]h Yj]`& YjYb ]bh\Y g`][\hYgh kUm(

v?D:?7D M?I:EC

M\Yb mci"`` h\fck U VU`` id ]b h\Y U]f& ]h XcYgbrh ghUm h\YfYVih fYhifbg hc h\Y YUfh\5 `]_Yk]gY U`` mcif [ccX cf VUXUWh]cbg k]`` fYhifb hc mci ]b Ubch\Yf Zcfa& UWWcfX]b[ hch\Y XYg]fY cZ mcif \YUfh& bc aUhhYf k\]W\ dUh\ mci hU_Y(

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

-Q HYLOGRHU LV KDSS\ ZKLOH WKH HYLO LV QRW \HW ULSH$ KXW ZKHQLW LV ULSH DQG UHDG\$ KH ZLOO XQGHUVWDQG ZKDW HYLO LV$ DQG KLVHYLO ZLOO UHWXUQ WR KLP OLNH GXVW WKURZQ DJDLQVW WKH ZLQG&DY]h\Yf ]b h\Y g_m bcf ]b h\Y YUfh\ bcf ]b h\Y XYdh\ cZ

acibhU]bg& bcf Ubmk\YfY ]b h\]g kcf`X ]g h\YfY U d`UWYk\YfY cbY WUb YgWUdY h\Y fYgi`hg cZ g]b(


- SHUVRQ ZKR EURRGV RQ UHYHQJH RQO\ ZRUVHQV KLV ZRXQGV&4LV LQMXULHV ZRXOG KHDO LI KH ZRXOG UHIUDLQ&

v<H7D9?I 879ED

I]bb]b[ ]g Ug XUb[Yfcig Ug ]ff]hUh]b[ U k]`X VYUgh( ?b acghWUgYg ]b h\]g kcf`X& Yj]` fYhifbg hc h\Y Yj]`XcYf ]b h\Ykcfgh UbX fiXYgh Zcfa(

BVPJÅ

9UàbYgg UbX \ia]`]hm dfcj]XY d`YUgifYg k\]W\ UfY bchUWWYgg]V`Y hc h\Y gY`Z]g\ UbX h\Y dfciX(

J\Y dfYfYei]g]hY cZ U [ccX `]ZY ]g dYUWY VYhkYYb dYcd`Y&UbX h\Y aU^cf cVghUW`Y hc dYUWY ]g df]XY( 7 dYfgcb g\ci`XVY \iaV`Y& dfYdUfYX hc VY ZU`gY`m UWWigYX& fYUXm ZcfYjYfmh\]b[5 cb`m h\Yb WUb \Y Vf]b[ dYUWY ]bhc \]g fYÙh]cbxg\]dg UbX ]bhc h\Y `]jYg cZ ch\Yfg(

9caY ibhc aY& U`` mY h\Uh ÙVcf UbX UfY \YUjm ÙXYb UbX ?k]`` []jY mci fYgh( JU_Y am mc_Y idcb mci& UbX `YUfb cZaY5 Zcf ? Ua aYY_ UbX `ck`m ]b \YUfh4 UbX mY g\U`` Z]bXfYgh ibhc mcif gci`g( <cf am mc_Y ]g YUgm& UbX am VifXYb]g `][\h(

vC7JJ>;M ++4,2'-*

Ff]XY XYZYbXg ]hgY`Z& UbX bch cb`m ]hgY`Z Vih ch\Yf g]bg& UbX]h \UhYg \ia]`]hm& gc ]h fY^YWhg h\Y WifY& UbX \]XYg UbX îgh]xZ]Yg h\Y g]b( J\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ g]b \Ug U dcg]h]jY ]bZìxYbWY cb U dYfgcb5 ]h ]g YjYb acfY igYZi` h\Ub U [ccX XYYX&k\]W\ WUb ]bWfYUgY df]XY(

.H VWULFW LQ MXGJLQJ \RXUVHOI DQG JHQWOH LQ MXGJLQJ RWKHUV$ DQG\RX ZLOO KDYH QR HQHPLHV&

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

:c bch VY UZfU]X hc VY \ia]`]UhYX ]Z mci WUb UWWYdh h\]gk]h\ \ia]`]hmvmci k]`` VY fYdU]X aUbm h]aYg ]b h\Y gd]fx]hiU` V`Ygg]b[g k\]W\ UfY WcbbYWhYX k]h\ VY]b[ \iaV`Y(

BVPJǺ

BLWKRXW WUXWK WKHUH LV QR NLQGQHVV+ ZLWKRXW NLQGQHVV WKHWUXWK FDQQRW KH WROG&

7bX k\m WU`` mY aY& BcfX& BcfX& UbX Xc bch h\Y h\]b[gk\]W\ ? gUm6 M\cgcYjYf 9caYh\ aY& UbX \YUfYh\ amgUm]b[g& UbX XcYh\ h\Ya& ? k]`` g\Yk mci hc k\ca \Y ]g`]_Y4 >Y ]g `]_Y U aUb k\]W\ Vi]`h Ub \cigY& UbX X][[YXXYYd& UbX `U]X h\Y ZcibXUh]cb cb U fcW_4 UbX k\Yb h\YZ`ccX UfcgY& h\Y ghfYUa VYUh jY\YaYbh`m idcb h\Uh \cigYUbX Wci`X bch g\U_Y ]h4 Zcf ]h kUg ZcibXYX idcb U fcW_(8ihS\Y h\Uh \YUfYh\& UbX XcYh\ bch& ]g `]_Y U aUb h\Uhk]h\cih U ZcibXUh]cb Vi]`h Ub \cigY idcb h\Y YUfh\5U[U]bgh k\]W\ h\Y ghfYUa X]X VYUh jY\YaYbh`m& UbX ]aaYxX]UhY`m ]h ZY``5 UbX h\Y fi]b cZ h\Uh \cigY kUg [fYUh(

vBKA; 04.0'.3

7`kUmg fYgdcbX hc \UhfYX k]h\ _]bXbYgg( J\Y acgh X]ZZ]xWi`h YbhYfdf]gYg UfY YUg]Ygh Uh h\Y]f ]bWYdh]cb& UbX h\Y[fYUhYgh cZ YbhYfdf]gYg \UjY \iaV`Y cf][]bg( 9cbZfcbhX]ZZ]Wi`h]Yg k\]`Y h\Ym UfY gh]`` YUgm& h\Yb& UbX hUW_`Y U V][h\]b[ k\Yb ]h ]g gh]`` gaU``(

vB7E'JPK

J\YfY UfY hkc dUh\g k\]W\ `YUX hc j]fhiY4 h\Y Z]fgh ]g hc VY hfih\xZi` UbX ^igh& UbX h\Y gYWcbX ]g hc Xc bc Yj]` hc `]j]b[ VY]b[g(

vC7DK

:]g[i]g]b[ mcifgY`Z Ug U _]bX dYfgcb ]g kcfgY h\Ub VY]b[bU_YX`m aYUb(

BVPJĄ

9\f]gh]Ub gcW]Yhm& Ug ]h bck Yl]ghg& XcYgbrh Zc``ck 9\f]gxh]Ub Ùk ]b ]hg fYU` aYUb]b[(

7àcgh YjYfm YZZcfh cZ h\Y \iaUb a]bX ]g X]fYWhYX& bchhckUfX `][\hYb]b[ h\Y kcf_ cZ h\Y ÙVcfYf& Vih hckUfXaU_]b[ acfY d`YUgUbh h\Y ]X`YbYgg cZ h\Y `Y]gifYX(

?Z U dYfgcb Wci`X `cc_ Uh cif kcf`X Zfca U X]ghUbWY \Ykci`X gYY gc aiW\ ghid]X]hm UbX \UhfYX h\Uh \Y kci`XdfcVUV`m Wfm( MY Xc gc aUbm Zibbm UbX ghid]X UbX]adcjYf]g\YX \UhYZi` XYYXg( EbY dYfgcb \ibhg k]`X Ub]xaU`g UbX VYWcaYg Ub Ub]aU` \]agY`Z5 Ubch\Yf ZYYXg Xcbx_Ymg UbX \cfgYg hc WUffm `cUXg& UbX XYgd]gYg dYcd`Y k\cX]Y cZ \ib[Yf( Eh\Yf dYcd`Y gdYbX U [fYUh XYU` cZ acbYmhc WfYUhY \i[Y \cigYg UbX Xc bch\]b[ hc \Y`d h\Y \caYx`Ygg( IcaY dYcd`Y gYY_ cb`m dfcZ]hg& ch\Yfg gdYbX cb`m ZcfX]gg]dUh]cb& UbX ch\Yfg ghYU`(?b U`` cZ h\YgY YlWYggYg& U`` cZ h\]g Wf]a]bU` VY\Uj]cf& kY

gYY dYcd`Y k\c cb`m kUbh hc hU_Y WUfY cZ h\YagY`jYg&k]h\cih U h\ci[\h UVcih k\Uh ]g acgh bYWYggUfm ]b h\]gkcf`X(


?h XYZ]Yg h\Y Ùkg cZ bUhifY Zcf U W\]`X hc fi`Y Ub UXi`h& cf UZcc` hc [i]XY U k]gY aUb( B]_Yk]gY& ]h ]g U[U]bgh h\Y Ùk cZbUhifY h\Uh U gaU`` [fcid cZ dYcd`Y g\ci`X VY cjYf]bXi`[YXk\Yb U \i[Y& \ib[fm WfckXrg acgh VUg]W bYYXg UfYbrh aYh(

?KHUH LV RQO\ RQH WKLQJ LQ WKLV ZRUOG ZKLFK LV ZRUWK GHGLFDWcLQJ DOO \RXU OLIH& ?KLV LV FUHDWLQJ PRUH ORYH DPRQJSHRSOH DQGGHVWUR\LQJ KDUULHUV ZKLFK H[LVW EHWZHHQ WKHP&

BVPJÁÀ

J\YfY ]g gcaYh\]b[ ]b h\Y gci` k\]W\ WUbbch X]Y& k\]W\WUbbch VY UZZYWhYX Vm XYUh\(

>Y k\c XYZYUhg ch\Yfg ]g ghfcb[5 \Y k\c XYZYUhg \]agY`Z ]gdckYfZi`& UbX \Y k\c _bckg k\Yb \Y X]Yg h\Uh \Y k]`` bchVY XYghfcmYX ]g YhYfbU`(

ÅH KĂOSP

FYcd`Y UfY Vcfb UbX `]jY cb`m Ug aUb]ZYghUh]cbg& cf d]YWYgcZ =cX5 h\YfYZcfY h\Ym WUbbch VY Wcad`YhY`m XYghfcmYX(J\Ym WUb X]gUddYUf Zfca VYZcfY cif YmYg& Vih h\Ym WUbbchVY XYghfcmYX( EbY dYfgcb kUg k]h\]b am g][\h Zcf U `cb[h]aY5 Ubch\Yf kYbh cih cZ am g][\h jYfm ei]W_`m5 Vih ?WUbbch gUm h\Uh h\Y Z]fgh dYfgcb Yl]ghYX acfY UbX h\Y gYWxcbX `Ygg( ?h XcYgbrh aUhhYf k\Yh\Yf U aUb dUggYg'Vm amk]bXck ei]W_`m cf g`ck`m( ? _bck XYZ]b]hY`m h\Uh h\]g aUbYl]ghYX ]b h\Y h]aY VYZcfY ? gUk \]a UbX h\Uh \Y k]`` Yl]gh]b h\Y h]aY UZhYf \Y \Ug X]gUddYUfYX Zfca am g][\h(

>Y k\c _bckg h\Uh h\Y ZcibXUh]cb cZ h\]g `]ZY ]g gd]f]h ]gcih cZ XUb[Yf( M\Yb \Y W`cgYg h\Y [UhYg cZ \]g gYbgYg Uhh\Y YbX cZ \]g `]ZY& \Y \Ug bc hfciV`Yg(

v7ZhYf B7E'JPK

=HDO OLIH H[LVWV RXWVLGH WLPH DQG VSDFH+ WKHUHIRUH$ GHDWK FDQFKDQJH WKH PDQLIHVWDWLRQ RI OLIH LQ WKLV ZRUOG$ KXW LW FDQQRWGHVWUR\ OLIH LWVHOI

Jfm hc `]jY k]h\ h\Y dUfh cZ mcif gci` k\]W\ ibXYfghUbXgYhYfb]hm& k\]W\ ]g bch UZfU]X cZ XYUh\( 7bX h\Uh dUfh cZmcif gci` ]g `cjY(

4MIC ""

7`` aUhYf]U` W\Ub[Yg ]b cif YjYfmXUm `]ZY UfY gaU`` ]b WcaxdUf]gcb k]h\ h\cgY ]b cif gd]f]hiU` `]ZY( J\YfY Wci`X VY UW\Ub[Y ]b ZYY`]b[g UbX UWh]cbg& h\YfY Wci`X VY U W\Ub[Y ]bh\ci[\hg UbX ]XYUg( ?b cfXYf hc W\Ub[Y mcif h\ci[\hg UbX]XYUg& mci g\ci`X WcbWYbhfUhY mcif WcbgW]cig a]bX cbmcif gd]f]hiU` fYei]fYaYbhg(

;jYfm h\ci[\h U dYfgcb XkY``g idcb& k\Yh\Yf \Y YldfYggYg]h cf bch& Y]h\Yf XUaU[Yg cf ]adfcjYg \]g `]ZY(

vBK9O C7BEHO

?R YDQTXLVK VLQ& \RX PXVW DFFHSW WKDW WKH URRW RI HDFK VLQ LVLQ D EDG WKRXJKW& BH DUH DOO RQO\ WKH FRQVHTXHQFHV RI ZKDWZH WKLQN&

v8K::>7

MY fY[fYh `cg]b[ U difgY Zi`` cZ acbYm& Vih U [ccX h\ci[\hk\]W\ \Ug WcaY hc ig& k\]W\ kYrjY \YUfX cf fYUX& Uh\ci[\h k\]W\ kY g\ci`X \UjY fYaYaVYfYX UbX Udd`]YXhc cif `]ZY& k\]W\ Wci`X \UjY ]adfcjYX h\Y kcf`XvkY`cgY h\]g h\ci[\h UbX dfcadh`m Zcf[Yh UVcih ]h& UbX kY Xcbch fY[fYh ]h& h\ci[\ ]h ]g acfY dfYW]cig h\Ub a]``]cbg(

BVPJÁÂ

>XIIHULQJ LV WKH QHFHVVDU\ FRQGLWLRQ IRU VSLULWXDO DQG SK\VLFDOJURZWK&

HYU``m& fYU``m ? hY`` mci& mci k]`` Wfm& UbX mci k]`` ZU``& UbXh\Y kcf`X k]`` \Y [`cf]Z]YX( Oci k]`` VY gUX& UbX mcif gUXxbYgg k]`` VYWcaY ^cm( 7 kcaUb ]g ]b dU]b k\Yb g\Y []jYgV]fh\ hc U W\]`X& UbX UZhYf h\Y V]fh\ g\Y XcYgbrh fYaYaVYf&UbX g\Y ]g ^cmZi`(

v@E>D +04,*',+

LYfm cZhYb kY gUm h\Uh kY Xcbrh `]_Y giZZYf]b[& h\Uh kY \UjYhcc aiW\ giZZYf]b[& Vih giZZYf]b[g& U`` _]bXg cZ giZZYfx]b[g& UfY U`kUmg [ccX Zcf ig( IcaYh]aYg& kY YjYb gYY h\Uh]h ]g igYZi` hc giZZYf4 W\]`XfYb giZZYf k\Yb h\Ym [fck& cfk\Yb ]h ]g bYWYggUfm h\Uh h\Ym W`YUb Ub ]b^ifm Z]``YX k]h\Z]`h\( MY WUbbch gYY h\Y igYZi`bYgg cZ acfU` giZZYf]b[g& Vihh\cgY giZZYf]b[g& hcc& aU_Y ig VYhhYf UbX W`cgYf hc =cX(

MY [fck h\ig4 MY WcaY W`cgYf hc =cX UbX =cX WcaYgW`cgYf hc ig Ug cif k]`` VYWcaYg ib]hYX k]h\ h\Y k]`` cZ =cX(


Oci g\ci`X `cc_ ]b giZZYf]b[ Zcf h\Y gYYXg cZ mcif ZihifYgd]f]hiU` [fckh\& cf h\Y V]hhYfbYgg cZ giZZYf]b[ k]`` VYgYjYfY(

BVPJÁÃ

?bhY``YWh ]g h\Y eiU`]hm h\Uh aU_Yg ig X]ZZYfYbh Zfca Ub]aU`g(

8iXX\U gU]X4 s?b aYX]hUh]cb& ]b gdYYW\& ]b `]ZY& ]b ghiX]Yg&? bYjYf Zcf[Yh UVcih h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h\]b[4 h\YfYei]fYaYbhg cZ h\Y ]bhY``YWh(t

J\Y acfU` UbX h\Y ]bhY``YWhiU` UfY U`kUmg ]b \Ufacbm(

?Z U gY`Z'WcbZ]XYbh aUb hU`_g hc U k]gY aUb& \Y k]`` bchibXYfghUbX h\Y hfih\& ^igh Ug U gdccb k]`` bch ibXYfghUbXh\Y hfih\ k\Yb ]h [Yhg ]bhc h\Y acih\(

v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

5 FDQQRW FDXVH DQ\ LPSURYHPHQW LQ DQ\RQH H[FHSW ZLWK WKHKHOS RI WKH JRRGQHVV DQG NLQGQHVV ZKLFK DOUHDG\ LV LQKHUHQW

LQ WKLV SHUVRQ&v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

FYcd`Y gdc]` h\Y]f `]ZY k\c bY[`YWh h\Y]f ]bhY``YWh UbX gUmh\Uh ]h WUbbch [i]XY h\Ya(

?bhY``YWh ]g h\Y gUaY ]b U`` dYcd`Y& UbX Wcaaib]WUh]cb ]gVUgYX cb ]bhY``YWh5 h\YfYZcfY YjYfm aUb aigh WcffYgdcbXhc ]hg fYei]fYaYbhg(

BVPJÁÄ

M\Yb mci aU_Y Ub YZZcfh bch hc VÙaY ch\Yf dYcd`Y& jcif`]ZY VYWcaYg aiW\ YUg]Yf& Vih jYfm ZYk dYcd`Y aU_Y h\]ggaU`` YZZcfh(

?b h\Y `]jYg cZ h\Y gU]bhg& h\YfY ]g h\Y ghcfm cZ h\Y \Yfa]hk\c gUk ]b \]g XfYUa U acb_ k\c \UX X]YX `cb[ U[c& UbXk\c \UX VYYb fUh\Yf kYU_ ]b \]g `]ZY( J\Y acb_ kUg ]b UbYgdYW]U``m `cjY`m UbX \cbcfYX dUfh cZ dUfUX]gY( J\Y \Yfa]hUg_YX& >ck kYfY mci [fUbhYX h\]g dÙWY& k]h\ U`` mcifkYU_bYggYg6t UbX h\Y acb_ UbgkYfYX h\Uh ]h kUg VYWUigY\Y \UX bYjYf VÙaYX& bch U g]b[`Y dYfgcb ]b \]g `]ZY(

J\YfYZcfY h\ci Ufh ]bYlWigUV`Y& E aUb& k\cgcYjYf h\ciUfh h\Uh îX[Ygh4 Zcf k\YfY]b h\ci îX[Ygh Ubch\Yf& h\ciWcbXYabYgh h\mgY`Z5 Zcf h\ci h\Uh îX[Ygh XcYgh h\Y gUaYh\]b[g(

vHEC7DI ,4+

?KH PRUH VWULFWO\ DQG PHUFLOHVVO\ \RX MXGJH \RXUVHOI$ WKHPRUH MXVW DQG NLQG \RX ZLOO KH LQ WKH MXGJPHQW RI RWKHUV&

v9ED<K9?KI

:c bch [`cf]Zm ]b VÙa]b[ UbX XYgd]g]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( 7_]bX dYfgcb g\ci`X \]XY h\Y g\UaY cZ ch\Yfg& YjYb h\cgYk\c \UjY \UfaYX \]a( :c bch fYaYaVYf cbY k\cfYdYbhg \]g ZcfaYf g]bg(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

Kb`Ygg mci mcifgY`Z UfY g]b`Ygg& Xc bch gUm U g]b[`Y kcfXUVcih h\Y g]bg cZ ch\Yfg& Vih VY ei]Yh( ?Z mci aU_Y ]h U\UV]h bch hc VÙaY ch\Yfg& mci k]`` ZYY` h\Y [fckh\ cZ h\YUV]`]hm hc `cjY ]b mcif gci`& UbX mci k]`` gYY h\Y [fckh\ cZ[ccXbYgg ]b mcif `]ZY(

BVPJÁĀ

Jc `cjY =cX aYUbg hc `cjY h\Y \][\Ygh dcgg]V`Y [ccXk\]W\ kY WUb ]aU[]bY ]b U`` h\]b[g(

FYcd`Y cZhYb gUm& s? Xc bch ibXYfghUbX `cjY cZ =cX5 k\Uh]g `cjY cZ =cX6t ?h kci`X VY acfY YlUWh hc gUm& sWUbbchibXYfghUbX `cjY ]b h\]g kcf`X k]h\cih `cjY cZ =cX(t

HYU` `cjY cZ =cX ]g U acfU` ZYY`]b[ VUgYX cb U W`YUf ibXYfxghUbX]b[ cZ >]g \][\& gidYf]cf VY]b[5 `cjY cZ =cX Wcx]bW]XYg k]h\ `cjY cZ j]fhiY& hfih\& UbX _]bXbYgg(

v"M?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DD?D=

7 dYfgcb k\c ibXYfghUbXg h\Y `Uk Vih k\c ]g ZUf Zfcah\Y `cjY cZ =cX ]g `]_Y U VUb_ cZZ]W]U` k\c \Ug _Ymg Zcf h\Y]bg]XY cZ \]g Vi]`X]b[ Vih bch h\Y _Ym Zcf h\Y Zfcbh Xccf(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

J\Y WcaaUbXaYbhg cZ =cX g\ci`X VY Zc``ckYX VYWUigYcZ `cjY cZ =cX& bch VYWUigY cZ ZYUf cZ =cX(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

5I \RX ORYH D SHUVRQ ZLWKRXW ORYLQJ 3RG$ ZKLFK LV WKH JRRGcQHVV LQVLGH RI KLP$ WKHQ \RX SODQW WKH VHHGV IRU IXWXUH GLVDScSRLQWPHQWV DQG VXIIHULQJV ZLWK WKLV ORYH&

J\cgY k\c gUm h\Uh h\Ym `cjY =cX Vih X]g`]_Y h\Y]f bY][\xVcfg UfY `m]b[ hc dYcd`Y5 h\cgY k\c `cjY h\Y]f bY][\VcfgVih Xcbrh `cjY =cX UfY `m]b[ hc h\YagY`jYg(

Eb`m dYfZYWh]cb ]g kcfh\ Wcad`YhY `cjY( ?b cfXYf hc ZYY`Wcad`YhY `cjY& kY WUb Y]h\Yf XY`iXY cifgY`jYg h\Uh gcaY]adYfZYWh cV^YWh cZ cif `cjY ]g sdYfZYWh]cbt cf kY WUb `cjYdYfZYWh]cb& k\]W\ ]g =cX(

BA CD

J\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ gcW]Yhm WUb VY UW\]YjYX cb`m Vm h\YacfU` ]adfcjYaYbh cZ ]bX]j]XiU`g(

MY `]jY ]b Ub YdcW\ cZ X]gW]d`]bY& Wi`hifY& UbX W]j]`]nUh]cb&Vih bch ]b Ub YdcW\ cZ acfU`]hm( ?b h\Y dfYgYbh ghUhY& kYWUb gUm h\Uh h\Y \Udd]bYgg cZ h\Y dYcd`Y [fckg& UbX mYhh\Y ib\Udd]bYgg cZ h\Y dYcd`Y ]bWfYUgYg Ug kY``( >ck WUbkY aU_Y dYcd`Y \Uddm k\Yb h\Ym UfY bch YXiWUhYX hc\UjY \][\ acfU`g6 J\Ym Xc bch VYWcaY k]gY(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?KHUH FDQ EH RQO\ RQH ZD\ WR ILJKW WKH JHQHUDO HYLO RI OLIH* LW LVLQ WKH PRUDO$ UHOLJLRXV$ DQG VSLULWXDO SHUIHFWLRQ RI \RXU RZQOLIH&

BVPJÁÅ

J\Y a]gZcfhibYg cZ kUf UbX dfYdUfUh]cbg Zcf kUf VYUf `]hxh`Y fYÙh]cb hc h\Y fYUgcbg []jYb hc YldÙ]b kUf4 h\Y fYU`fYUgcbg UfY igiU``m gc ]bg][b]Z]WUbh h\Uh h\Ym UfY bch YjYbkcfh\ X]gWigg]cb& UbX h\Ym UfY Wcad`YhY`m ib_bckb hch\cgY k\c X]Y(

J\Y aUXbYgg cZ WcbhYadcfUfm kUf ]g îgh]Z]YX Vm XmbUgh]W]bhYfYgh& Wcaacb bUh]cbU`]ga& ;ifcdYUb Yei]`]Vf]ia& cfUaV]h]cbg( ?Z h\YfY UfY UaV]h]cbg ]b dYcd`Y& h\]g ]g U jYfmghfUb[Y kUm hc gighU]b ]h& k]h\ U`` h\Y Wf]aYg k\]W\ \UddYbhc dYcd`Y Xif]b[ kUf4 XYghfiWh]cb cZ \caYg& dìbXYf& UbXaUgg aifXYf(

v7D7JEB; <H7D9;

Oci Ug_ aY& ]g ]h bYWYggUfm Zcf W]j]`]nYX dYcd`Y hc aU_YkUf6 7bX ? hY`` mci bch cb`m ]g ]h sU`fYUXmt ibbYWYggUfm&Vih ]h kUg bYjYf bYWYggUfm& UbX bch gcaYh]aYg Vih U`kUmg]h XYghfcmg h\Y bcfaU` XYjY`cdaYbh cZ \iaUb]hm& XYghfcmgîgh]WY& UbX ghcdg dfc[fYgg(

v=7BIJED CE>A

;QO\ GXULQJ D SHULRG RI ZDU GRHV LW EHFRPH REYLRXV KRZPLOOLRQV RI SHRSOH FDQ EH PDQLSXODWHG& <HRSOH$ PLOOLRQV RISHRSOH$ DUH ILOOHG ZLWK SULGH ZKLOH GRLQJ WKLQJV ZKLFK WKRVHVDPH SHRSOH DFWXDOO\ FRQVLGHU VWXSLG$ HYLO$ GDQJHURXV$ SDLQIXO$DQG FULPLQDO$ DQG WKH\ VWURQJO\ FULWLFL]H WKHVH WKLQJVbEXWFRQWLQXH GRLQJ WKHP&

J\Y fYUgcbg k\]W\ [cjYfbaYbhg []jY Zcf kUfg UfY U`kUmggWfYYbg& VY\]bX k\]W\ `]Y Wcad`YhY`m X]ZZYfYbh fYUgcbgUbX ach]jYg(

BVPJÁǺ

KbXYfghUbX]b[ cif Xihm dfcj]XYg ig k]h\ h\Y ibXYfxghUbX]b[ cZ cif X]j]bY gci`( 7bX& hcc& h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[cZ cif X]j]bY gci` []jYg ig h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ Xihm(

?KHUH LV LQ RXU VRXO VRPHWKLQJ WKDW& LI ZH VHH LW DV LW LV DQGJLYH LW WKH SURSHU DWWHQWLRQ$ ZLOO DOZD\V JLYH XV JUHDW SOHDcVXUH+ WKLV VRPHWKLQJ LV WKH PRUDO GLVSRVLWLRQ RU TXDOLW\ ZKLFKZDV JLYHQ WR XV DW RXU FUHDWLRQ&

FYcd`Y WUb fYUW\ \YUjYb`m ^cm4 h\cgY difY cbYg k\c UfYZ]``YX k]h\ h\Y XYg]fY Zcf U [ccX `]ZY fYWY]jY d`YUgifYg ]bh\Y]f VcXm& ]b h\Y]f aUhYf]U` `]ZY( M\Yb mcif a]bX UbXmcif \YUfh UfY difY& h\Yb h\Y X]j]bY k]`` VY cdYbYX Zcf mci(

v8H7>C?D ?D:?7D M?I:EC

?Z mcif \YUfh ]g Z]``YX k]h\ j]fhiY& h\Yb mci k]`` Z]bX \Udd]xbYgg UbX VYUihm(


J\Y jc]WY cZ mcif WcbgW]YbWY ]g h\Y jc]WY cZ =cX(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

BVPJÁĄ

Ocif WcbgW]YbWY ]g mcif ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ mcif gd]f]hiU`cf][]bg5 cb`m k\Yb mci dcggYgg giW\ UkUfYbYgg k]`` ]h VY UfYU` [i]XY ]b mcif `]ZY(

J\YfY UfY hkc X]ZZYfYbh VY]b[g k]h\]b mci& cbY k\]W\ ]gV`]bX UbX gYbgiU`& UbX Ubch\Yf k\]W\ WUb gYY UbX ]g gd]f]xhiU`(J\]g gd]f]hiU` VY]b[ ]g WU``YX WcbgW]YbWY UbX WUb VY

WcadUfYX k]h\ h\Y bYYX`Y cZ U WcadUgg k\]W\ dc]bhg Uh[ccXbYgg Uh cbY YbX& UbX Uh h\Y ch\Yf& Yj]`( MY WUbbch dYfxWY]jY h\]g WcadUgg ibh]` kY ghfUm Zfca [ccXbYgg& Vih Uggccb Ug kY Xc gcaYh\]b[ VUX& h\Yb kY ZYY` h\]g di`` UkUmZfca h\Y X]fYWh]cb cZ [ccXbYgg ]b `]ZY(

=cX [UjY ig h\Y WcbgW]cigbYgg cZ aUb_]bX Ug U k\c`Y& UgkY`` Ug cif ckb WcbgW]cigbYgg Ug ]bX]j]XiU`g5 k]h\ h\Y \Y`dcZ h\YgY hkc h\]b[g& Ug k]h\ hkc k]b[g kY WUb Z`m \][\YfUbX WcaY W`cgYf hc =cX UbX hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y hfih\(

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

E\& WcbgW]YbWY4 mci UfY h\Y XYUh\`Ygg jc]WY cZ \YUjYb&UbX U hfiY [i]XY UbX ^iX[Y cZ [ccXbYgg( Oci aU_Y U dYfxgcb fYgYaV`Y =cX(


Ocih\ ]g h\Y h]aY cZ dUgg]cbg UbX ]bZUhiUh]cbg& UbX mYh `]gxhYb bck hc h\Y jc]WY cZ mcif WcbgW]YbWY UbX UWWYdh ]h Ugh\Y [fYUhYgh Uih\cf]hm( 7`kUmg Ug_ mcifgY`Z& Xc am UWh]cbgWc]bW]XY k]h\ am WcbgW]YbWY6 7bX Xc bch VY UZfU]X hcUff]jY Uh aYUb]b[g X]ZZYfYbh Zfca ch\Yf dYcd`Yrg(

vJ>;E:EH; F7HA;H

<YUf U`` h\Uh ]g bch UWWYdhYX Vm mcif WcbgW]YbWY(

BVPJÂÀ

J\YfY kUg U h]aY k\Yb dYcd`Y UhY \iaUb Z`Yg\ UbX ZcibXbch\]b[ kfcb[ ]b ]h5 YjYb bck h\YfY UfY giW\ k]`X dYcd`Y(FYcd`Y ghcddYX YUh]b[ \iaUb aYUh& `]hh`Y Vm `]hh`Y5 bckh\Ym WYUgY hc YUh h\Y aYUh cZ Ub]aU`g `]hh`Y Vm `]hh`Y&h\ci[\ ]h \Ug hU_Yb h]aY( .XW WKH WLPH ZLOO FRPH ZKHQ SHRcSOH ZLOO KDYH WKH VDPH GLVJXVW IRU WKH PHDW RI DQLPDOV DV WKH\QRZ KDYH IRU KXPDQ IOHVK&

v7ZhYf 7BF>EDI; B7C7HJ?D;

?h ]g hYff]V`Y hc h\fck `]hh`Y W\]`XfYb hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y UgZcibX`]b[g& hc cf[Ub]nY [ÙX]Uhcfgr Z][\hg& hc hcfhifY df]gxcbYfg& UbX hc Xc ch\Yf giW\ ibW]j]`]nYX XYYXg( ?b h\YZihifY& h\Y h]aY k]`` WcaY k\Yb ]h k]`` VY ibUWWYdhUV`Y hc_]`` Ub]aU`g UbX hU_Y h\Y]f XYUX VcX]Yg Ug mcif ZccX(

v:H( @E>7DD =;EH= LED P?CC;HC7DD

:c bch fU]gY mcif \UbX U[U]bgh mcif Vfch\Yf& UbX Xc bchgd]`` h\Y V`ccX cZ Ubm `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg k\c `]jY cb h\]gYUfh\& bY]h\Yf \iaUb VY]b[g bcf dYhg bcf k]`X Ub]aU`g bcfV]fXg( ?b h\Y XYdh\ cZ mcif gci` gcaY X]j]bY jc]WY ghcdgmci Zfca gd]``]b[ h\]g V`ccX( J\YfY ]g `]ZY ]b ]h( Oci WUbbchfYhifb h\]g `]ZY(

v7BF>EDI; B7C7HJ?D;

?b cif h]aY& h\Y _]``]b[ cZ Ub]aU`g Zcf d`YUgifY cf ZccX ]gUàcgh U Wf]aY& UbX \ibh]b[ UbX YUh]b[ aYUh UfY bch îghhf]j]U` h\]b[g& Vih VUX UWh]cbg& k\]W\ `]_Y Ubm ch\Yf VUXUWh]cbg `YUX hc aUbm ch\Yf UWh]cbg k\]W\ UfY kcfgY(

BVPJÂÁ

?KH PLVHU\ RI WKH XQLQWHOOHFWXDO OLIH EULQJV XV WR WKH QHHG IRUDQ LQWHOOHFWXDO OLIH&

8YZcfY& ? `]jYX ]b g]b& UbX ? gUk h\Uh h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ dYcd`YUfcibX aY `]jYX ]b h\Y gUaY kUm( B]_Y U fcVVYf& ? _bYk ?kUg ib\Uddm UbX ? giZZYfYX& UbX h\Uh dYcd`Y UfcibX aYkYfY ib\Uddm UbX h\Ym giZZYfYX5 UbX ? X]Xbrh gYY Ubm kUmcih cZ h\]g g]hiUh]cb YlWYdh Zcf gi]W]XY cf XYUh\( B]ZYgYYaYX hYff]V`Y hc aY( 7bX h\Yb ? \YUfX h\Y kcfXg cZ9\f]gh UbX + ibXYfghccX h\Ya( 7bX `]ZY WYUgYX hc gYYa UbYj]`& UbX ]bghYUX cZ XYgdYfUh]cb ? ZY`h U \Udd]bYgg Zcf `]ZYk\]W\ gifdUggYg YjYb XYUh\(

MY WUb ibXYfghUbX k]gXca ]b h\fYY kUmg4 Z]fgh& Vm aYX]xhUh]cb5 h\]g ]g h\Y acgh bcV`Y kUm( IYWcbX`m& Vm VY]b[]bZ`iYbWYX Vm gcaYcbY cf Zc``ck]b[ gcaYcbY5 h\]g ]g h\YYUg]Ygh kUm( J\]fX ]g h\Y kUm cZ YldYf]YbWY5 h\]g ]g h\Yacgh X]ZZ]Wi`h kUm(

v9ED<K9?KI

M\Yb mci giZZYf& h\]b_ bch cb \ck mci WUb YgWUdY giZZYfx]b[& Vih WcbWYbhfUhY mcif YZZcfhg cb k\Uh _]bX cZ ]bbYfacfU` UbX gd]f]hiU` dYfZYWh]cb h\]g giZZYf]b[ fYei]fYg(

7`` h\Y a]gZcfhibYg cZ aUb_]bX Wc``YWh]jY`m UbX ]bX]j]XixU``m UfY bch igY`Ygg5 h\Ym Vf]b[ dYcd`Y UbX ]bX]j]XiU`g UbXbUh]cbg ]b X]ZZYfYbh kUmg W`cgYf hc h\Y difdcgY k\]W\ ]ggYh VYZcfY h\Ya4 h\Y UddYUfUbWY cZ =cX& Zcf YjYfm dYfgcb]b \]agY`Z& UbX ]b U`` aUb_]bX(

BVPJÂÂ

J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY hfiY fY`][]cb Zcf U`` cZ aUb_]bX(

J\Y X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb fY`][]cbgvk\Uh U ghfUb[Y YldfYgxg]cb( 9YfhU]b`m h\YfY WUb VY X]ZZYfYbh ZU]h\g& UbX VY`]YZg ]b\]ghcf]WU` YjYbhg k\]W\ UfY dUggYX Zfca cbY [YbYfUh]cb hcUbch\Yf hc ghfYb[h\Yb fY`][]cb5 ]b h\Y gUaY kUm h\YfY WUb VYX]ZZYfYbh fY`][]cig Vcc_gvh\Y IihfUg& LYXUg& AcfUb& YhW( 8ihh\YfY WUb VY cb`m cbY fY`][]cb& UbX ]h ]g fYU` Zcf U`` h]aYg(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

BH FDQ EHOLHYH LQ D WKLQJ$ ZH FDQ NQRZ WKDW LW H[LVWV$ HYHQ LIZH FDQQRW XQGHUVWDQG LW ZLWK RXU LQWHOOHFW$ RU H[SODLQ LW ZLWKZRUGV&

?Z mci UfY U Cig`]a& [c UbX `]jY Ug U 9\f]gh]Ub5 ]Z mci UfY U9\f]gh]Ub `]jY Ug U @Yk5 ]Z mci UfY 9Uh\c`]W& `]jY Ug UbEfh\cXclvk\UhYjYf fY`][]cb mci \UjY& \c`X h\Y gUaYfYgdYWh Zcf dYcd`Y cZ X]ZZYfYbh fY`][]cbg( ?Z mcif gdYYW\hc[Yh\Yf XcYg bch UfcigY cf YlW]hY mci hc ]bX][bUh]cb UbX]Z mci WUb ZfYY`m Wcaaib]WUhY k]h\ h\Ya& mci \UjY UW\]YjYXdYUWY( ?h ]g gU]X h\Uh h\Y cV^YWh cZ YjYfm fY`][]cb ]g h\YgUaY4 U`` dYcd`Y `cc_ Zcf `cjY& UbX U`` h\Y kcf`X ]g U d`UWY cZ`cjY( J\Yb k\m g\ci`X kY gdYU_ UVcih h\Y X]ZZYfYbWYVYhkYYb h\Y Cig`]a W\ifW\ UbX h\Y 9\f]gh]Ub W\ifW\6

v?IB7C?9 M?I:EC

:c bch ZYUf \Yg]hUh]cbg Vih ghiXm h\Y X]ZZYfYbh ZU]h\g UbXfY`][]cbg ]bhY``YWhiU``m(

BVPJÂÃ

Eb`m \Y k\c UWWYdhg h\Uh h\Y YggYbWY cf aYUb]b[ cZ \]g`]ZY ]g bch aUhYf]U` Vih gd]f]hiU` WUb VY ZfYY(

7 gÙjY k\c ]g \Uddm k]h\ \]g ghUhY ]g U gÙjY hk]WY cjYf&VYWUigY bch cb`m \]g VcXm Vih \]g gci` ]g YbgÙjYX(

* =cX& k\]`Y ? ghUm cb h\]g YUfh\ ? kUbh hc VY h\Uh k\]W\? Ua(

v;F?9J;JKI

FYUWY ]g U [fYUh V`Ygg]b[ ]Z ]h WUb VY fYUW\YX& Vih ]Z dYUWY ]gfYUW\YX Vm gÙjYfm& ]h VYWcaYg U a]gZcfhibY UbX bch UV`Ygg]b[( FYUWY ]g h\Y ZfYYXca k\]W\ ]g VUgYX cb h\Y UWWYdxhUbWY cZ YjYfm dYfgcbrg f][\hg& UbX gÙjYfm ]g h\Y bY[Uh]cbcZ f][\hg& UbX cZ \iaUb X][b]hm( J\YfYZcfY& kY g\ci`X gUWxf]Z]WY YjYfmh\]b[ hc UW\]YjY dYUWY& Vih YjYb acfY& hc [Yh f]XcZ gÙjYfm(

v7ZhYfC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

HYaYaVYf h\Uh mci UfY acfY ZfYY ]Z mci W\Ub[Y mcifcd]b]cb UbX Zc``ck h\cgY k\c \UjY WcffYWhYX mcif a]gxhU_Yg& h\Ub ]Z mci UfY ghiVVcfb UVcih mcif a]ghU_Yg(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY fYU` _bck`YX[Y4 h\Uh k\]W\ \Y`dg ig hc VYZfYY( ;jYfm ch\Yf hmdY cZ _bck`YX[Y ]g aYfY UaigYaYbh(

vL?I>DK FKH7D7& ?D:?7D M?I:EC

?KHUH LV QR PLGGOH ZD\* HLWKHU KH D VODYH RI SHRSOH RU RI 3RG&

BVPJÂÄ

KbXYfghUbX]b[ cf a]bXZi`bYgg cZ XYUh\ hYUW\Yg cbY hcW\ccgY h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY Wcad`YhY cf Wci`X VY Wcaxd`YhYX5 UbX h\cgY h\]b[g UfY h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh(

Oci Wci`X X]Y jYfm ei]W_`m5 Vih mYh mci \UjY h]aY hc f]XmcifgY`Z cZ mcif dUgg]cbg( 8Y \iaV`Y hc YjYfmcbY(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

- ZLVH SHUVRQ WKLQNV PRUH DERXW OLIH WKDQ DERXW GHDWK&v8;D;:?9JKI IF?DEP7

J\YfY ]g bc XYUh\ Zcf h\Y gd]f]h5 h\YfYZcfY& U dYfgcb k\c`]jYg U gd]f]hiU` `]ZY ]g ZfYYX Zfca XYUh\(

:c mci kcffm UVcih h\Y acaYbh k\Yb mci X]Y6 Eif `]ZY]g cb`m U acaYbh ]b YhYfb]hm( J\]b_ UbX mci k]`` gYY h\Uhmci \UjY YhYfb]hm VY\]bX mci UbX VYZcfY mci& UbXVYhkYYb h\YgY hkc \i[Y UVmggYg& k\Uh X]ZZYfYbWY XcYg ]haU_Y k\Yh\Yf mci `]jY h\fYY XUmg cf h\fYY WYbhif]Yg6

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

M\YbYjYf mci Ug_ k\Yh\Yf mci g\ci`X VY\UjY ]b h\]g kUmcf h\Y ch\Yf& Ug_ mcifgY`Z& k\Uh kci`X mci Xc ]Z mci _bYkh\Uh mci Wci`X X]Y h\]g YjYb]b[& UbX bcVcXm kci`X Z]bXcih UVcih mcif UWh]cb6 :YUh\ gdifg dYcd`Y hc Z]b]g\ h\Y]fUZZU]fg5 Uacb[ U`` UWh]cbg& h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY hmdY k\]W\ ]gWcad`YhY& UbX h\Uh ]g `cjY k\]W\ gYY_g bc fYkUfX(

BVPJÂĀ

?h ]g jYfm igYZi` hc bch]WY h\Y ]adfYgg]cb k\]W\ cif `]ZYUbX XYYXg aU_Y idcb ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

Oci g\ci`X `]jY gc h\Uh ch\Yf dYcd`Y h\]b_ kY`` cZ mci UbXmci h\]b_ kY`` cZ mcifgY`Z(

vBK9O C7BEHO

J\Y jYfm g\cfhWca]b[g k\]W\ aU_Y ch\Yfg X]ZZ]Wi`h UbXibVYUfUV`Y aYUb `Ygg ]b mcifgY`Z( Oci Xc bch gYY h\Ya&

UbX k\Yb mci gdYU_ cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y \Uj]b[ h\YgY XfUkxVUW_g& mci Xc bch bch]WY h\Uh mci UfY XYgWf]V]b[ mcifgY`Z(

v@;7D :; B7 8HKO;H;

J\Y g]ad`Ygh& ei]W_Ygh& UbX gifYgh aYUbg hc VYWca]b[_bckb Ug U j]fhicig dYfgcb ]g hc kcf_ cb mcifgY`Z& hcUWhiU``m VY j]fhicig( ;lUa]bY YUW\ j]fhiY& UbX mci k]`` gYYh\Uh h\Ym U`` kYfY UW\]YjYX k]h\ kcf_ UbX YlYfW]gY(

vIE9H7J;I

EbY aUb _YYdg g]`YbWY& UbX dYcd`Y X]gWigg \]a( 7bch\YfgdYU_g U `ch& UbX dYcd`Y X]gWigg \]a( 7 h\]fX gdYU_g U `]hxh`Y& UbX dYcd`Y X]gWigg \]a( J\YfY ]g bc giW\ h\]b[ Ug UdYfgcb k\c ]g bch VY]b[ X]gWiggYX cf gWc`XYX(


:c mci WU`` U dYfgcb \Uddm ]Z \Y Z]bXg \]g ghfYb[h\ ]b \]gW\]`XfYb cf ]b \]g Zf]YbXg& cf ]b ch\Yf h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY]adYfaUbYbh6 ?b cbY gYWcbX& \]g dfcgdYf]hm WUb VY fi]bYX(IYY_ bc ch\Yf giddcfh h\Ub mcif ]bbYf gY`Z UbX =cX(

v:;CEIJ>;D;I

:HYHU WU\ WR MXVWLI\ \RXU GHHGV&

BVPJÂĂ

BcjY dfcj]XYg U dYfgcb k]h\ h\Y difdcgY cZ \]g `]ZY( ?bhY`x`YWh g\ckg \]a h\Y aYUbg hc UW\]YjY h\Uh difdcgY(

?b h\Y gW\YaY cZ h\Y kcf`X& U dYfgcb ]g bc acfY h\Ub Ud]bY WcbY& cf U kYU_ \YfV& cf U V]h cZ gkUad [fUgg& Vih \Y]g U [fUgg k\]W\ dcggYggYg gcaY ]bhY``YWh(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

9DQ GLIIHUV IURP RWKHU DQLPDOV RQO\ LQ KLV LQWHOOHFW+ VRPHSHRSOH WU\ WR GHYHORS LW DQG RWKHUV QHJOHFW LW$ MXVW DV WKH\ WU\ WRUHMHFW WKRVH RWKHU TXDOLWLHV ZKLFK GLIIHUHQWLDWH WKHP IURP WKH

DQLPDOV&v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

? dfU]gY 9\f]gh]Ub]hm VYWUigY ]h XYjY`cdg& ghfYb[h\Ybg& UbXY`YjUhYg am ]bhY``YWhiU` bUhifY(

vM?BB?7C ;BBB;HO 9>7DD?D=

?Z U dYfgcb `UW_g ]bhY``YWh& \Y WUb bch X]gh]b[i]g\ VUX Zfca[ccX& UbX gc \Y WUb bY]h\Yf hfi`m gYY_ bcf hfi`m \UjY fYU`[ccXbYgg(

BVPJÆĈ

7 [ccX `]ZY ]g []jYb cb`m hc h\cgY k\c aU_Y YZZcfhg hcUW\]YjY ]h(

?b cfXYf hc \UjY U [ccX `]ZY& mci g\ci`X bch VY UZfU]X cZUbm [ccX XYYXg( Oci g\ci`X \UjY bc `Ygg dckYf cfghfYb[h\ Zcf gaU`` UWhg h\Ub Zcf h\Y V][[Ygh UbX [fYUhYgh[ccX XYYX(

5Q RUGHU QRW WR SRXU RXW D YHVVHO IXOO RI ZDWHU$ \RX VKRXOG KROGLW HYHQO\& 5QRUGHU WR KDYH D UD]RU VKDUS$ \RX VKRXOG VKDUSHQLW& ?KH VDPH VKRXOG KDSSHQ ZLWK \RXU VRXO LI \RX DUH ORRNLQJIRU UHDO JRRGQHVV&

vB7E'JPK

?Z h\YfY ]g gcaYh\]b[ [fYUh ]b mci& ]h k]`` bch UddYUf cbmcif Z]fgh WU``( ?h k]`` bch UddYUf UbX WcaY hc mci YUg]`m&k]h\cih Ubm kcf_ UbX YZZcfh(


7g_& UbX ]h g\U`` VY []jYb mci5 gYY_& UbX mY g\U`` Z]bX5_bcW_& UbX ]h g\U`` VY cdYbYX ibhc mci4 Zcf YjYfm cbY h\UhUg_Yh\ fYWY]jYh\5 UbX \Y h\Uh gYY_Yh\ Z]bXYh\5 UbX hc \]ah\Uh _bcW_Yh\ ]h g\U`` VY cdYbYX(

vC7JJ>;M 141'2

Jfm hc `]jY U [ccX `]ZY ]b UWWcfX k]h\ h\Y j]fhiYg h\Uh UfYgYh VYZcfY mci( FYf\Udg h\]g ]g U X]ZZ]Wi`h h\]b[& Vih k]h\h]aY ]h VYWcaYg acfY UbX acfY ^cmZi`(

?Z mci bYYX [ccXbYgg& Zc``ck =cXrg `Uk( 7bX hc Zc``ckh\Y `Uk cZ =cX ]g dcgg]V`Y cb`m Vm aU_]b[ Ub YZZcfh( Dchcb`m ]g h\]g YZZcfh fYkUfXYX k]h\ U \Uddm `]ZY& Vih YjYb h\YYZZcfh ]hgY`Z []jYg h\Y V][[Ygh V`Ygg]b[ cZ `]ZY(

BVPJÂǺ

J\Y ZUa]`m fYÙh]cbg\]d ]g cb`m [ccX UbX Z]fa UbX []j]b[cZ j]fhiY hc dYcd`Y k\Yb ]h [cYg VYmcbX ZUa]`m UbX ]g U`gcfY`][]cig& UbX U`` h\Y aYaVYfg cZ h\Y ZUa]`m VY`]YjY ]b cbY=cX UbX >]g Ùk( Eh\Yfk]gY& h\Y ZUa]`m ]g h\Y gcifWY bchcZ d`YUgifY Vih cZ giZZYf]b[(

EbY cZ h\Y acgh Wcaacb YldÙbUh]cbg Zcf VUX XYYXg ]gh\Y ZUa]`m bUaY( FYcd`Y ghYU`& aU_Y Vf]VYg& Xc aUbmch\Yf bUghm h\]b[g ]b `]ZY& U`` cZ k\]W\ WUb VY YldÙ]bYX Vmh\Y]f `cjY Zcf h\Y]f ZUa]`m(

2DPLO\ ORYH LV D VHOILVK IHHOLQJ$ DQG WKHUHIRUH LW FDQ MXVWLI\KDG$ XQZRUWK\ DFWLRQV&

7bX ]h kUg hc`X \]a Vm WYfhU]b& k\]W\ gU]X& J\m ach\YfUbX h\m VfYh\fYb ghUbX k]h\cih& XYg]f]b[ hc gYY h\YY( 7bX\Y UbgkYfYX UbX gU]X ibhc h\Ya& Cm ach\Yf UbX amVfYh\fYb UfY h\YgY k\]W\ \YUf h\Y kcfX cZ =cX& UbX Xc ]h(

O6=50 )+#! #"

>Y h\Uh `cjYh\ ZUh\Yf cf ach\Yf acfY h\Ub aY ]g bch kcfxh\m cZ aY4 UbX \Y h\Uh `cjYh\ gcb cf XUi[\hYf acfY h\UbaY ]g bch kcfh\m cZ aY(

O7,<<20? "!+$(

?b ZUa]`m `cjY& ]b h\Y acfU` \][\ aYUb]b[& h\YfY ]g bch\x]b[ [ccX cf VUX& îgh Ug ]b gY`Z'`cjY( 8ch\ UfY bUhifU`( BcjYcZ mcif ZUa]`m& Ug kY`` Ug cZ mcifgY`Z& k\Yb ]h gifdUggYg ]hg`]a]hg& WUb VY U j]WY& Vih ]h WUb bYjYf VY U j]fhiY& VYWUigY]hrg U bUhifU` ZYY`]b[(

BVPJÂĄ

:YdfYgg]cb ]g U ghUfY cZ h\Y gci` ]b k\]W\ mci WUb gYY bcgYbgY Y]h\Yf ]b mcif ckb `]ZY cf ]b h\Y `]ZY cZ h\Y kcf`X(J\]g ghUhY ]g bch cb`m dU]bZi` Zcf h\Y dYcd`Y UfcibX mci&Vih ]h WUb ]bZ`iYbWY h\Ya& UbX U hfi`m [ccX dYfgcb XYU`gk]h\ h\]g ibd`YUgUbhbYgg k\Yb \Y ]g U`cbY( M\Yb mci\UjY VUX gd]f]hg cf UfY ]b U `ck accX& cf mci UfY ]ff]hUhYX&mci g\ci`X VY gc ]b gc`]hiXY(

M\Yb YjYfmh\]b[ mci gYY UddYUfg ]b XUf_& [`ccam g\UXYg&UbX gYYag VU`YZi`& UbX mci kUbh hc hY`` ch\Yfg cb`m VUXUbX ibd`YUgUbh h\]b[g& Xc bch hfigh mcif dYfWYdh]cbg(JfYUh mcifgY`Z Ug h\ci[\ mci kYfY Xfib_( JU_Y bc ghYdgUbX UWh]cbg ibh]` h \]g ghUhY \Ug X]gUddYUfYX(

Oci g\ci`X bYjYf ZYY` XYdfYggYX(

7 aUb g\ci`X U`kUmg ZYY` \Uddm5 ]Z \Y ]g ib\Uddm& ]haYUbg \Y ]g [i]`hm(

E 8RUG$ KHOS PH WR KH DOZD\V KDSS\ DQG WR UHMRLFH IROORZLQJDQG IXOILOOLQJ \RXU ZLOO&

8ch\ cif d\mg]WU` giZZYf]b[g UbX dYf]cXg cZ XYdfYgg]cbUfY dUfh cZ cif `]ZY ]b h\]g kcf`X& UbX kY g\ci`X dUh]Ybh`mkU]h ibh]` h\Ym UfY cjYf& cf cif `]ZY ]g cjYf(

BVPJÃÀ

7g gccb Ug U dYfgcb Ug_g \]agY`Z h\Y eiYgh]cb& s>ck Xc ?`]jY am `]ZY ]b h\Y VYgh kUm6t h\Yb U`` ch\Yf eiYgh]cbg UfYUbgkYfYX(

HYU` `]j]b[ hU_Yg d`UWY bch ]b h\Y XcaU]b cZ cihkUfXW\Ub[Y& Vih ]b h\Y ]bbYf XcaU]b k\YfY W\Ub[Yg WUb\UfX`m VY cVgYfjYX& ]b cif gd]f]hiU` `]ZY(

7bX @Ygig UbgkYfYX UbX gU]X ibhc \Yf& CUfh\U& CUfh\U&h\ci Ufh'WUfYZi` UbX hfciV`YX UVcih aUbm h\]b[g4 8ih cbYh\]b[ ]g bYYXZi`4 UbX CUfm \Uh\ W\cgYb h\Uh [ccX dUfh&k\]W\ g\U`` bch VY hU_Yb UkUm Zfca \Yf(

vBKA; +*4.+'.,

5QVWHDG RI VDYLQJ KXPDQLW\& HYHU\ SHUVRQ VKRXOG VDYH KLP cVHOI

v7B;N7D:;H >;HP;D

J\Y acfY dYcd`Y VY`]YjY h\Uh ch\Yfg WUb ]adfcjY h\Y]f`]jYg& h\Y g`ckYf Ubm ]adfcjYaYbh k]`` cWWif(

@i`m +

J\Y \iaUb gci` ]g X]j]bY(

1YHU\ WUXWK KDV LWV RULJLQ LQ 3RG& BKHQ LW LV PDQLIHVWHG LQ DPDQ$ WKLV LV QRW EHFDXVH LW FRPHV IURP KLP$ EXW EHFDXVH KH KDVVXFK D TXDQWLW\ RI WUDQVSDUHQF\ WKDW KH FDQ UHYHDO LW&

v8B7?I; F7I97B

M\Yb UZhYf h\Y fU]b& kUhYf Z`ckg Zfca h\Y fccZ h\fci[\d]dYg& ]h gYYag hc ig h\Uh kUhYf Z`ckg cih cZ h\YgY d]dYg&Vih ]b fYU`]hm& ]h ZU``g Zfca h\Y g_m( J\Y gUaY d\YbcaYbcbWUb VY gYYb k]h\ h\Y fY`][]cig hYUW\]b[g hUi[\h hc ig Vm\c`m dYcd`Y( ?h gYYag hc ig h\Uh h\]g hYUW\]b[ WcaYg Zfcah\Ya& Vih ]b fYU`]hm& h\YgY hYUW\]b[g WcaY Zfca =cX(

vJ>; =EIF;B E< IH? H7C7AH?I>D7

7 dYfgcbrg difdcgY cb h\]g YUfh\ ]g hc VY ]b \Ufacbm k]h\YhYfb]hm( ?h ]g cb`m h\Yb h\Uh h\Y ib]jYfgU` Z`ck cZ `cjY UbX]bhY``YWh WUb VY W\UbbY`YX h\fci[\ h\]g dYfgcb& Ug ]Zh\fci[\ U W`YUf dUh\kUm(

vBK9O C7BEHO

B]ZY ]g []jYb hc ig ]b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug U W\]`X ]g []jYb hc UbUbbm& gc h\Uh ]h WUb VY fU]gYX hc aUhif]hm(

AYYd mcifgY`Z ]b dif]hm& ZUf Zfca Yj]`& gc h\Uh X]j]bY dckYfaUm WcaY h\fci[\ mci( 7bX ]b h\]g Z`ck cZ X]j]bY dckYfh\fci[\ mci& h\YfY ]g [fYUh V`]gg(

BVNXÂ

J\YfY ]g bc ch\Yf XcaU]b k\YfY h\Y kcfXg cZ cif `Ubx[iU[Y UfY gc a]gigYX Ug ]b h\Y Wf]h]W]ga cZ Ufh& YgdYW]U``mcZ ZU`gY Ufh(

7 kcf_ cZ Ufh aU_Yg U [fYUh ]adfYgg]cb cb ig cb`m k\Yb ]h[]jYg ig gcaYh\]b[ k\]W\& YjYb k]h\ U`` h\Y YZZcfhg cZ cif]bhY``YWh& kY WUbbch ibXYfghUbX Wcad`YhY`m(

v7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7KI%&vT

7fh \Ug giW\ Ub ]adUWh cb dYcd`Y h\Uh aUbm ghfUb[Yh\]b[g WUb \UddYb ]b h\Y]f gci`g4 amghYf]Yg VYWcaYW`YUfYf5 cdUeiY h\]b[g VYWcaY Yj]XYbh5 Wcad`]WUhYXh\]b[g VYWcaY g]ad`Y5 k\Uh ]g dfcVUV`Y VYWcaYg bYWYgxgUfm( 7 fYU` Ufh]gh U`kUmg g]ad`]Z]Yg(

v7ZhYf >;DH? 7C?;B

=HPHPEHU WKDW \RX FDQQRW GR DQ\WKLQJ ZRQGHUIXO GULYHQ E\FRPSHWLWLRQ+ \RX FDQQRW GR DQ\WKLQJ QREOH IURP SULGH&

v@E>D HKIA?D

J\YfY UfY hkc jYfm W`YUf ]bX]WUh]cbg cZ fYU` gW]YbWY UbXfYU` Ufh4 h\Y Z]fgh ]bbYf g][b ]g h\Uh U gW\c`Uf cf Ub Ufh]ghkcf_g bch Zcf dfcZ]h& Vih Zcf gUWf]Z]WY& Zcf \]g WU``]b[5 h\YgYWcbX& cihYf g][b ]g h\Uh \]g kcf_g UfY ibXYfghUbXUV`Y hcU`` dYcd`Y( HYU` gW]YbWY ghiX]Yg UbX aU_Yg UWWYgg]V`Y h\Uh_bck`YX[Y k\]W\ dYcd`Y Uh h\Uh dYf]cX cZ \]ghcfm h\]b_]adcfhUbh& UbX fYU` Ufh hfUbgZYfg h\]g hfih\ Zfca h\YXcaU]b cZ _bck`YX[Y hc h\Y XcaU]b cZ ZYY`]b[g(

9fYUh]b[ Ufh ]g bch Ug Y`YjUhYX U h\]b[ Ug aUbm dYcd`Y[iYgg& Vih WYfhU]b`m ]h ]g U igYZi` UbX _]bX h\]b[ hc Xc&YgdYW]U``m ]Z ]h Vf]b[g dYcd`Y hc[Yh\Yf UbX UfcigYg _]bXZYY`]b[g ]b h\Ya(

BVNXÃ

7 dYfgcb ]g Ybg`UjYX hc h\Y YlhYbh \Y VY`]YjYg h\Uh \]g `]ZY\Ug cb`m U d\mg]WU` VY[]bb]b[(

Dch\]b[ WUb VY XcbY k]h\cih ZU]h\( >Yg]hUh]cb WUb _]`` UdYfgcb& cf ]h WUb XYghfcm k\c`Y bUh]cbg( M\m ]g ]h gc X]ZZ]xWi`h hc []jY `]VYfUh]cb hc dYcd`Y6 8YWUigY k\Yb dYcd`Y Xcbch \UjY U XYYd ZU]h\ h\Ym UfY bch Wcad`YhY`m gifY UVcihh\Y]f f][\hg(


J\Ym gUm h\Uh h\Y \][\Ygh [ccX ]g ZfYYXca( 7bX ]Z ZfYYXca]g [ccXbYgg& h\Yb \ck WUb U ZfYY dYfgcb VY ib\Uddm6 ?Zmci gYY U dYfgcb k\c ]g bch \Uddm mci g\ci`X _bck h\Uh\Y ]g bch U ZfYY aUb5 \Y ]g U g`UjY cZ gcaYh\]b[( ?b cfXYf hcVY Wcad`YhY`m ZfYY& mci g\ci`X VY fYUXm hc []jY hc =cX U``h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ mci \UjY fYWY]jYX Zfca \]a( Ocig\ci`X VY fYUXm hc ib]hY mcif k]`` k]h\ h\Uh cZ =cX(

v7ZhYf ;F?9J;JKI

M\Yb mci \UjY bc ZfYYXca& h\Yb mcif `]ZY VYWcaYg h\Y`]ZY cZ Ub Ub]aU`(

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

>iaUb X][b]hm UbX ZfYYXca UfY cif WcbghUbh bYWYgg]h]Yg(Ic& `Yh ig _YYd h\Ya k]h\ ig& cf `Yh ig X]Y k]h\ X][b]hm(


5I \RX IHHO WKDW \RX DUH QRW IUHH$ ORRN IRU WKH UHDVRQ LQVLGH\RX&

#%$& Fib]g\aYbh ]g U bch]cb h\Uh \iaUb_]bX [fUXiU``m cihx[fckg(

7 dYfgcb \Ug XcbY Yj]`& gc Ubch\Yf dYfgcb& cf U [fcid cZdYcd`Y& ]b cfXYf hc Z][\h h\]g Yj]`& WUbbch h\]b_ cZ Ubmxh\]b[ VYhhYf h\Ub hc WfYUhY Ubch\Yf Yj]`& k\]W\ h\Ym WU``dib]g\aYbh(

;jYfm dib]g\aYbh ]g VUgYX& bch cb `c[]W cf cb h\Y ZYY`]b[cZ ^igh]WY& Vih cb h\Y XYg]fY hc k]g\ Yj]` cb h\cgY k\c\UjY XcbY Yj]` hc mci cf hc Ubch\Yf dYfgcb(

9Ud]hU` dib]g\aYbh ]g U jYfm W`YUf dfccZ h\Uh cif gcW]Yhmrgcf[Ub]nUh]cb ]g ZUf Zfca VY]b[ U 9\f]gh]Ub cbY(

;jYfmh\]b[ UVcih cif dfYgYbh gmghYa cZ dib]g\aYbhg UbXUVcih U`` Wf]a]bU` `Uk k]`` VY h\ci[\h cZ Vm ZihifY [YbYfUxh]cbg ]b h\Y gUaY kUm h\Uh kY h\]b_ cZ WUbb]VU`]ga cf\iaUb gUWf]Z]WY hc UbW]Ybh dU[Ub [cXg( s>ck X]X h\Ym bchgYY h\Y igY`YggbYgg UbX WfiY`hm cZ h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ h\YmX]X6t cif XYgWYbXUbhg k]`` gUm UVcih ig(

?R SXQLVK RWKHUV LV OLNH SXWWLQJ PRUH ZRRG LQ WKH ILUH& 1YHU\FULPH DOUHDG\ KDV SXQLVKPHQW LQ LWVHOI DQG LW LV PRUH FUXHODQG PRUH MXVW WKDQ WKH SXQLVKPHQW FUHDWHG E\ SHRSOH&

MY g\ci`X fYaYaVYf h\Uh h\Y XYg]fY hc dib]g\ ]g dUfh cZ UjYfm `ck Ub]aU` ZYY`]b[ k\]W\ g\ci`X VY giddfYggYX& UbXk\]W\ g\ci`X bch VY U dUfh cZ cif fYU`]hm(

4MGN &

Ic`cacb UbX @cV _bYk UbX gdc_Y k]gY`m UVcih h\Y igYx`YggbYgg cZ \iaUb `]ZY( J\Y Z]fgh kUg h\Y \Udd]Ygh& h\Y gYWxcbX h\Y ib\Udd]Ygh cZ U`` aYb( EbY _bYk h\Y jUb]hm cZd`YUgifY5 h\Y ch\Yf& h\Y fYU`]hm cZ a]gZcfhibY(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

<c``ck h\Y VYgh kUm cZ `]ZY mci dcgg]V`m WUb& UbX \UV]hk]`` aU_Y h\]g kUm gi]hUV`Y UbX d`YUgUbh Zcf mci(

J\]g ]g h\Y X]j]bY `Uk cZ `]ZY4 h\Uh cb`m j]fhiY ghUbXg Z]fa(7`` h\Y fYgh ]g bch\]b[(

vFOJ>7=EH7I

?Z mci ZYUf kcYg UbX a]gZcfhibYg& h\Yb mci UfY U`fYUXmib\Uddm( J\cgY k\c ZYUf a]gZcfhibYg igiU``m XYgYfjYh\Ya(

v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

>Udd]bYgg UbX WU`abYgg UfY bY]h\Yf ]bg]XY ig bcf cihg]XYig( J\Ym UfY ]b =cX& k\c ]g Vch\ ]bg]XY UbX cihg]XY ig(

'TTTTT v8B7?I; F7I97B

1YHU\WKLQJ LV IURP 3RG+ WKHUHIRUH$ HYHU\WKLQJ LV JRRG& 1YLOLV JRRGQHVV ZKLFK ZH GLG QRW XQGHUVWDQG EHFDXVH RI RXUVKRUWVLJKWHGQHVV&

M\Yb cbY ibXYfghUbXg h\Uh _]bX cZ Yj]` k\]W\ ]g ]b \]gXYYXg& h\Yb U`` ch\Yf a]gZcfhibYg hc k\]W\ \Y WUb VY giVx^YWhYX UfY bch\]b[ Ug WcadUfYX k]h\ h\Y d`YUgifY UbXZfYYXca \Y WUb h\Yb YldYf]YbWY(

BVNXĂ

DY]h\Yf h\Y XYgWf]dh]cbg cZ kUf bcf ]hg hYff]V`Y WfiY`h]YgUbX UhfcW]h]Yg WUb ghcd dYcd`Y Zfca dUfh]W]dUh]b[ ]b ]h(EbY fYUgcb Zcf h\]g ]g h\Uh Vm j]Yk]b[ h\Y UhfcW]h]Yg cZkUf& YjYfmcbY WcaYg hc ibXYfghUbX h\Uh ]Z giW\ U hYff]V`Yh\]b[ WUb Yl]gh UbX VY UWWYdhYX Vm dYcd`Y& h\Yb h\YfYaigh VY gcaY fYUgcb Zcf ]hg Yl]ghYbWY(

7 k]hbYgg fYWcibhYX \]g YldYf]YbWY ]b J\Y Higg]Ub'@UdUbYgY kUf& k\Yb \Y kUg cb h\Y iddYf XYW_ cZ h\Y ADQDJVUhh`Yg\]d Xif]b[ U @UdUbYgY UhhUW_( ?h kUg U hYff]V`Y g][\h(;jYfmk\YfY h\YfY kUg V`ccX& d]YWYg cZ Z`Yg\& VcX]Yg k]h\\YUXg hcfb UkUm& h\Y gaY`` cZ V`ccX gc ghfcb[ ]h aUXYYjYb h\Y acgh hci[\ UbX \UfXYgh aYb X]nnm( J\Y UfacfYXWUbbcb hckYf giZZYfYX acgh cZ U``( 7 g\Y`` Yld`cXYX cb hcdcZ ]h UbX _]``YX U mcib[ cZZ]WYf k\c kUg h\Y W\]YZ cZ h\Yg\]drg Ufh]``Yfm( Eb`m cbY h\]b[ kUg `YZh cZ h\Y dccf aUb5 ]hkUg \]g Z]gh& h\Y \UbX k\]W\ \Y`X h\Y ]bghfiaYbh( Jkc cZZcif gU]`cfg k\c ghccX bYlh hc h\Y]f WcaaUbXYf kYfY hcfb]bhc d]YWYg& UbX h\Y ch\Yf hkc \UX hYff]V`Y ]b^if]Yg5 UZhYfxkUfXg Vch\ \UX h\Y]f `Y[g UadihUhYX& UbX h\Yb h\Y fYaU]bgcZ h\Y]f `Y[g kYfY Wih cZZ U[U]b Wcad`YhY`m( J\Y WcaaUbxXYf cZ h\Y VUhh`Yg\]d \UX U gaU`` ]b^ifm ]b \]g \YUX& ]b h\YhYad`Yg( <]`h\& hYff]V`Y ]``bYggYg& \ib[Yf& Z]fY& XYghfiWh]cb&Yj]`vh\]g ]g a]`]hUfm [`cfm& h\]g ]g kUf(

v>;DH? >7H:K?D =7H:K;D

MUf ]g bck acfY hYff]V`Y h\Ub Uh Ubm dYf]cX ]b \iaUb\]ghcfm(

v=KO :; C7KF7II7DJ

?KH WLPH KDV FRPH WR WDON DERXW WKH HYLOV RI ZDU& 5W LV QRW WUXHWKDW WKH H[LVWHQFH RI ZDUV SURYHV WKHLU QHFHVVLW\& ?KH KLVWRU\ RIPDQNLQG VD\V WKDW VXFK WKLQJV VKRXOG QRW KDSSHQ&

BVNXÅ

?R GHQ\ 3RG LV WR GHQ\ \RXUVHOI DV D VSLULWXDO DQG LQWHOOHFc

WXDO EHLQJ&

? _bck =cX UbX gci` bch Vm h\Y]f XYZ]b]h]cb& Vih ]bUbch\Yf kUm Ybh]fY`m( Ihf]j]b[ hc XYZ]bY =cX XYghfcmg h\]g_bck`YX[Y ]b aY( ? _bck h\Uh =cX Yl]ghg& h\Uh am gci`Yl]ghg5 h\]g _bck`YX[Y ]g W`YUf hc aY VYWUigY ? kUg []jYb]h( ? \UjY bch h\Y g`][\hYgh XciVh UVcih h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ=cX& ]Z ? Ug_4 M\Uh Ua ?6 M\c Ua ?6 Cm `Y[g UfY bch aY5am Ufag UfY bch aY5 am \YUX ]g bch aY5 am ZYY`]b[g UfYbch aY5 YjYb am h\ci[\h ]g bch aY( J\Yb k\Uh Ua ?6 ? UaamgY`Z& ? Ua am gci`( Dc aUhhYf k\]W\ g]XY ? UddfcUW\h\]g eiYgh]cb& ? ]bYj]hUV`m WcaY hc =cX( J\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZam `]ZY ]g =cX& h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ am Yl]ghYbWY ]g =cX( J\YgUaY k]h\ h\Y gci`( ?Z ? kUbh hc _bck h\Y hfih\& ? _bckh\Uh Uh h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ U`` ]g am gci`5 ]Z ? kUbh hc ibXYfxghUbX am ZYY`]b[ cZ `cjY UbX bYWYgg]hm Zcf [ccXbYgg& h\Yb? U[U]b Z]bX h\Y gcifWY cZ h\]g ]b am gci`(

=cX Yl]ghg( MY g\ci`X bch dfcjY h\]g5 hc XYbm =cX ]gaUXbYgg( =cX `]jYg ]b am WcbgW]YbWY& ]b h\Y WcbgW]YbWY cZU`` \iaUb]hm& ]b U`` cif ib]jYfgY& UbX kY hU`_ hc =cX ]b h\Yacgh ]adcfhUbh acaYbhg cZ gUXbYgg cf ^cm(

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

B]ZY ]b h\]g kcf`X [cYg UWWcfX]b[ hc gcaYVcXmrg k]``vgcaYcbY dYfZcfag gdYW]U` UWh]cbg idcb U`` `]ZY ]b h\]gkcf`X& UbX hciW\Yg U`` cif `]jYg( J\Uh k\]W\ dYfZcfagh\YgY UWh]cbg ]g k\Uh kY WU`` =cX(

BVNXǺ

J\Uh ZYY`]b[ k\]W\ gc`jYg U`` cZ h\Y WcbhfUX]Wh]cbg cZ\iaUb `]ZY UbX []jYg cbY h\Y [fYUhYgh V`]gg ]g _bckb hc U``dYcd`Y4 h\]g ZYY`]b[ ]g `cjY(

FUm VUX dYcd`Y k]h\ mcif [ccXbYgg5 Z][\h h\Y]f \UhfYXk]h\ mcif _]bXbYgg( ;jYb ]Z mci Xc bch UW\]YjY j]WhcfmcjYf ch\Yf dYcd`Y& mci k]`` WcbeiYf mcifgY`Z(

v>Ybf] IEBH

BcjY XYghfcmg XYUh\ UbX aU_Yg ]h Yadhm5 ]h []jYg aYUb]b[hc gYbgY`Ygg h\]b[g5 Zfca ib\Udd]bYgg& `cjY aU_Yg fYU`\Udd]bYgg(

2LUH SXULILHV HYHU\WKLQJ LQ WKH PDWHULDO ZRUOG+ ORYH SXULILHVHYHU\WKLQJ LQ WKH VSLULWXDO ZRUOG&

v>;DH? 7C?;B

J\Y `Ygg `cjY U dYfgcb \Ug& h\Y acfY \Y giZZYfg(

?Z mci UfY ]b U X]ZZ]Wi`h g]hiUh]cb& U `ck accX& ]Z mci UfYUZfU]X cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y UbX cZ mcifgY`Z& ]Z mci UfY hcfxaYbhYX& h\Yb hY`` mcifgY`Z4 s? k]`` `cjY YjYfmcbY k\ca ?aYYh ]b h\]g `]ZY(t Jfm hc Zc``ck h\]g fi`Y5 UbX mci k]`` gYYh\Uh YjYfmh\]b[ k]`` Z]bX ]hg kUm& UbX YjYfmh\]b[ k]`` gYYag]ad`Y& UbX mci k]`` bc `cb[Yf \UjY XciVhg cf ZYUfg(

FYcd`Y a]ghU_Yb`m h\]b_ h\Uh j]fhiY `]Yg ]b h\Y _bck`YX[YcZ aUbm h\]b[g( M\Uh ]g ]adcfhUbh ]g bch h\Y eiUbh]hm Vihh\Y eiU`]hm cZ _bck`YX[Y(

IcWfUhYg h\ci[\h h\Uh ghid]X]hm kUg ]bWcadUh]V`Y k]h\k]gXca& Vih \Y bYjYf gU]X h\Uh ][bcfUbWY kUg ghid]X]hm(

vN;DEF>ED

MY `]jY ]b h\Y U[Y cZ d\]`cgcd\m& gW]YbWY& UbX ]bhY``YWh(>i[Y `]VfUf]Yg UfY cdYb Zcf YjYfmcbY( ;jYfmk\YfY kY\UjY gW\cc`g& Wc``Y[Yg& UbX ib]jYfg]h]Yg k\]W\ []jY ig h\Yk]gXca cZ h\Y dYcd`Y Zfca aUbm dfYj]cig a]``Ybb]U( 7bXk\Uh h\Yb6 >UjY kY VYWcaY k]gYf Zcf U`` h\]g6 :c kY VYhxhYf ibXYfghUbX cif `]ZY& cf h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ cif Yl]ghYbWY6:c kY _bck k\Uh ]g [ccX Zcf cif `]ZY6


HYUX]b[ hcc aiW\ ]g \UfaZi` hc mcif ]bXYdYbXYbWY cZh\ci[\h( J\Y [fYUhYgh h\]b_Yfg ?rjY aYh Uacb[ gW\c`UfgUfY dYcd`Y k\c Xc bch fYUX hcc aiW\(

=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

0R QRW IHDU WKH ODFN RI NQRZOHGJH$ IHDU IDOVH NQRZOHGJH& -OOHYLO LQ WKLV ZRUOG FRPHV IURP IDOVH NQRZOHGJH&

Abck`YX[Y Vcfb ]b Uf[iaYbh UbX X]gWigg]cb ]g hc VYXciVhYX(

BVNXĄ

BVNXÁÀ

?b h\Y kcf`X hcXUm& fYU` ZU]h\ \Ug ]b acgh WUgYg VYYbfYd`UWYX Vm diV`]W cd]b]cb( FYcd`Y Xc bch VY`]YjY ]b =cX&Vih h\Ym VY`]YjY ]b aUbm a]bcf h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY hUi[\hVm ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

FYcd`Yrg a]gZcfhibYg UfY WUigYX bch VYWUigY h\Ym Xc bch_bck h\Y]f Xih]Yg& Vih VYWUigY h\Ym a]gibXYfghUbX h\Y]fXih]Yg(

=cX []jYg U W\c]WY hc YjYfm gci` VYhkYYb hfih\ UbX dYUWY(vH7BF> M7B:E ;C;HIED

2DLWK LV QRW DFKLHYHG E\ D PDMRULW\ RI YRWHV&

J\Y aU^cf fYUgcb Zcf h\Y Yj]` h\Uh Yl]ghg hcXUm ]g h\YUVgYbWY cZ ZU]h\ ]b dYcd`Y cZ cif h]aY(

BVNXÁÁ

Jfi`m j]fhicig ]g h\Y dYfgcb k\c []jYg \]g `cjY hc h\YkYU_(

<RZHU LV JLYHQ WR D SHUVRQ$ QRW WR RSSUHVV WKH ZHDN$ KXW WRVXSSRUW DQG WR KHOS WKH ZHDN&

v@E>D HKIA?D

=]jY hc YjYfm aUb h\Uh Ug_Yh\ cZ h\YY5 UbX cZ \]a h\UhhU_Yh\ UkUm h\m [ccXg Ug_ h\Ya bch U[U]b( 7bX Ug mYkci`X h\Uh aYb g\ci`X Xc hc mci& Xc mY U`gc hc h\Ya`]_Yk]gY(

vBKA; 04-*'-+

;jYfm _]bX h\]b[ ]g U j]fhiY( Jc []jY kUhYf hc U h\]fghm dYfxgcb& cf hc d]W_ id U ghcbY Zfca U fcUX& cf hc Wcbj]bWY mcifbY][\Vcfg UbX Zf]YbXg h\Uh h\Ym g\ci`X VY j]fhicig& cf hcg\ck U hfUjY`Yf \]g kUm& cf hc ga]`Y `cc_]b[ ]bhc mcifbY][\Vcfrg ZUWYvU`` h\]g ]g j]fhiY(

vCE>7CC;:

?Z U f]W\ dYfgcb Wci`X VY hfi`m j]fhicig& h\Yb \Y kci`Xghcd VY]b[ f]W\ jYfm ei]W_`m(

BVNXÁÂ

J\Y ZcibXUh]cb cZ `cjY ]g ]b YUW\ dYfgcbrg ibXYfghUbX]b[cZ h\Y ib]hm cZ h\Y X]j]bY gdUf_ k\]W\ `]jYg ]b U`` dYcd`Y(

7`` h\Uh Vf]b[g ib]Z]WUh]cb hc dYcd`Y ]g [ccXbYgg UbXVYUihm5 U`` h\Uh Vf]b[g gYdUfUh]cb Uacb[ h\Ya ]g Yj]`( 7]`dYcd`Y _bck h\]g4 ]h ]g Z]fa`m ]bgWf]VYX cb cif \YUfhg(

;jYfm [ccX cf W\Uf]hUV`Y UWh]cb& YjYfm ibdfcZ]hUV`Y Ugg]gxhUbWY k\]W\ giddcfhg ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]b bYYX& k\Yb kYWcaY hc ]hg cf][]bg UbX ZcibXUh]cbg& VYWcaYg U amghYf]xcig UbX ibYld`U]bUV`Y h\]b[& VYWUigY ]h WcaYg cih cZ h\YamghYf]cig ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y ib]hm cZ U`` `]j]b[ VY]b[g&UbX ]h WUb VY Yld`U]bYX Vm bch\]b[ Y`gY(


BH DUH VHSDUDWH EHLQJV$ LW VHHPV$ EXW LQ RXU LQQHU OLIH ZH DUHFORVHO\ FRQQHFWHG ZLWK DOO OLYLQJ WKLQJV&

MY WUb ZYY` gcaY cZ h\Y j]VfUh]cbg cZ h\]g gd]f]hiU` kcf`X5gcaY cZ h\Ya \UjY bch fYUW\YX ig mYh& Vih h\Ym UfY acjx]b[& Ug h\Y j]VfUh]cbg cZ `][\h Zfca h\Y X]ghUbh ghUfg UfYacj]b[ UWfcgg h\Y ib]jYfgY5 h\Ym acjY& h\ci[\ h\Ym UfYbch mYh j]g]V`Y hc cif YmYg(

BVNXĄǼ

J\Y H[LVWLQJ RUGHU RI WKLQJV FDQ KH LPSURYHG&

M]gY Wcbgiadh]cb ]g aiW\ acfY Wcad`]WUhYX h\Ub k]gYdfcXiWh]cb( M\Uh Z]jY dYcd`Y k]`` dfcXiWY& cbY dYfgcbWUb jYfm YUg]`m WcbgiaY& UbX h\Y eiYgh]cb Zcf YUW\ ]bX]xj]XiU` UbX Zcf YjYfm bUh]cb ]g bch \ck UfY kY hc dfcXiWY&Vih \ck cif dfcXiWhg UfY hc VY WcbgiaYX(

v@E>D HKIA?D

Oci WUb hcfhifY dYcd`Y5 mci WUb hfYUh h\Ya Ug ]Z h\Ym kYfYUb]aU`g5 mci WUb UVigY h\Ya ]b U`` kUmg5 mci WUb _]`` h\YaUg ]Z h\Ym kYfY giaaYf Z`]Yg( 8ih dYcd`Y k]`` fYaU]b ZfYY]b h\Y \][\Ygh gYbgY VYWUigY h\Ym \UjY YhYfbU` gci`g(

v@E>D HKIA?D

?b cfXYf hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y `Uk cZ =cX Ug kY ibXYfghUbX ]h& U^c]bh YZZcfh aigh VY aUXY Vm aUbm dYcd`Y( J\Yb& aUmVYg`ck`m& kY k]`` acjY hc Ub ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\]g X]j]bY `Uk(

BVNXÁÄ

=cXrg _]b[Xca ]g h\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh Uacb[ aUb_]bX cZ=cXrg k]``& UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y aYUgifY ]b k\]W\ ]h ]gfYjYU`YX hc ig(

?b h\Y `]ZY cZ h\Y kcf`X& h\cigUbXg cZ mYUfg `cc_ `]_Y cbYmYUf( J\YfYZcfY& kY g\ci`X kcf_ \UfX Uh h\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh cZYhYfb]hm& UbX kY g\ci`X kU]h Zcf h\Y XUm k\Yb fY`][]cb k]``Yb`][\hYb h\]g kcf`X Wcad`YhY`m(

J\Y _]b[Xca cZ =cX cb YUfh\ ]g h\Y Z]bU` difdcgY UbXXYg]fY cZ \iaUb_]bX(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?b fY`][]cig gYfj]WYg kY g\ci`X ibXYfghUbX& bch h\Y f]hixU`g& bch ibbUhifU` h\]b[g k\]W\ WUb VY dYfZcfaYX cb`m VmU df]Ygh5 ]b fY`][]cb& kY g\ci`X ibXYfghUbX `cjY Zcf =cXUbX Zcf cif bY][\Vcf(

v7B;N7D:H 7HA>7D=;BIAS

?KH NLQJGRP RI 3RG LV LQVLGH XV+ WKHUHIRUH ORRN IRU WKH NLQJcGRP RI 3RG LQVLGH \RX DQG WKH UHVW ZLOO WDNH FDUH RI LWVHOI$ LQWKH EHVW SRVVLEOH ZD\&

BVNXÁĀ

Cm aUhYf]U` `]ZY ]g giV^YWh hc giZZYf]b[ UbX XYUh\& UbX bcYZZcfh cZ a]bY WUb fY`YUgY aY Zfca giZZYf]b[ cf XYUh\( Cmgd]f]hiU` `]ZY ]g giV^YWh bY]h\Yf hc giZZYf]b[ bcf XYUh\(J\YfYZcfY& gU`jUh]cb Zfca giZZYf]b[ UbX XYUh\ `]Yg ]b cb`mcbY h\]b[4 ]b h\Y hfUbgZYf cZ am WcbgW]cig sgY`Zt Zfca h\YaUhYf]U` hc h\Y gd]f]hiU`(

J\Y kUm hc ibXYfghUbX h\]g kcf`X ]g hc ibXYfghUbX mcif]bbYf gY`Z( M]h\ h\Y \Y`d cZ `cjY& UbX Vm j]fhiY cZ h\Y `cjYcZ ch\Yfg& kY ibXYfghUbX ch\Yf VY]b[g4 dYcd`Y& Ub]aU`g&d`Ubhg& ghcbYg& \YUjYb`m VcX]Yg5 UbX kY ibXYfghUbX h\YUhh]hiXYg cZ h\YgY VY]b[g hc h\YagY`jYg5 UbX h\YgY Uhh]xhiXYg WfYUhY h\Y k\c`Y kcf`X Ug kY _bck ]h( J\Y kUm hcibXYfghUbX]b[ ]g VUgYX cb `cjY& cb ib]Z]WUh]cb k]h\ U``ch\Yf WfYUhifYg ]b h\Y kcf`X(

CHW QRW 9\ ZLOO$ EXW ?KLQH EH GRQH&vBKA; ,,4.,

J\Y YggYbWY cZ `cjY cZ =cX ]g ]b h\Y XYg]fY cZ h\Y gci` Zcf]hg WfYUhcf& Zcf ib]hm k]h\ h\]g \][\Yf `][\h(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

J\]g YhYfbU` VY[]bb]b[ ]b mci \Ug U`kUmg Yl]ghYX& ]h Yl]ghgbck& UbX ]h k]`` U`kUmg Yl]gh4 ]hg h]aY k]`` bYjYf YbX(

vJ>; 8H7>C?DrI M?I:EC

J\Uh k\]W\ kY ibXYfghUbX Ug h\Y \Udd]bYgg cf ib\Udd]bYggcZ cif Ub]aU` sgY`Zt XYdYbXg cb h\Y \][\Ygh gd]f]hiU` k]``(

BVNXÁĂ

Dch\]b[ WUb giddcfh ]X`YbYgg VYhhYf h\Ub Yadhm W\UhhYf(FYcd`Y kci`X VY VYhhYf hc _YYd g]`Ybh UbX bch gdYU_ h\YVcf]b[& Yadhm h\]b[g h\Ym fcih]bY`m gUm hc YbhYfhU]bh\YagY`jYg( >ck WUb h\Ym YbXifY ]h6

J\Y dYfgcb k\c gdYU_g aiW\ k]`` gY`Xca Zi`Z]`` U`` \]gkcfXg ]b \]g UWh]cbg( 7 k]gY dYfgcb ]g U`kUmg kUfm `Ygh \]gkcfXg gifdUgg \]g UWh]cbg(

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

2LUVW WKLQN$ WKHQ VSHDN& >WRS ZKHQ WROG sHQRXJK& t - SHUVRQ LVKLJKHU WKDQ DQ DQLPDO EHFDXVH RI KLV DELOLW\ WR VSHDN$ EXW KHLV ORZHU WKDQ DQ DQLPDO LI KH FDQQRW SURSHUO\ XVH WKLV DELOLW\&


J\cgY dYcd`Y gdYU_ acgh k\c Xc bch \UjY aiW\ hc gUm(

?Z mci kUbh hc ghcd U dYfgcb Zfca Ub UWh]cb& Ug_ \]a hcgdYU_ acfY cb h\Y hcd]W( J\Y acfY dYcd`Y gdYU_& h\Y `YggXYg]fY h\Ym \UjY hc UWh(

vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

J\Y `Ygg mci gdYU_& h\Y acfY mci k]`` kcf_(

BVNXÁÅ

J\Y ZcibXUh]cb cZ UbW]Ybh gcW]Yh]Yg kUg j]c`YbWY( J\YVUg]g cZ cif WcbhYadcfUfm gcW]Yhm ]g k]gY WcbWcfX& h\YbY[Uh]cb cZ j]c`YbWY(

OY \UjY \YUfX h\Uh ]h \Uh\ VYYb gU]X& 7b YmY Zcf Ub YmY&UbX U hcch\ Zcf U hcch\4 8ih ? gUm ibhc mci& J\Uh mY fYg]ghbYh Yj]`4 Vih k\cgcYjYf g\U`` ga]hY h\YY cb h\m f][\hW\YY_& hifb hc \]a h\Y ch\Yf U`gc(

vC7JJ>;M /4-2'-3

>Y k\c ]g fYU``m g_]``Zi` ]b Wcaaib]WUh]b[ k]h\ dYcd`Y ]gigiU``m U \iaV`Y UbX ei]Yh dYfgcb( J\]g ]g WU``YX h\Y j]fhiYcZ bcbfYg]ghUbWY( J\]g ]g WU``YX \Ufacbm k]h\ >YUjYb(

B7E'JPK

IcaY dYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh ]h ]g ]adcgg]V`Y hc fi`Y ch\Yf dYcxd`Y k]h\cih j]c`YbWY( 7bX gc h\Ym Xc hc dYcd`Y Ug ch\YfdYcd`Y Xc k]h\ \cfgYg& k\Yb h\Ym V`]bX h\Y]f YmYg gc h\Uhh\Ym k]`` acfY cVYX]Ybh`m kU`_ ]b U W]fW`Y(

2RU ZKDW SXUSRVH LV D PDQ_V LQWHOOHFW LI \RX DUH JRLQJ WRLQIOXHQFH KLP RQO\ ZLWK YLROHQFH,

?b U`` WUgYg& k\Yb dYcd`Y igY j]c`YbWY& mci g\ci`X hfm hcWcbj]bWY h\Ya bch hc( Oci g\ci`X hfm hc Udd`m k]gY& Wcbxj]bW]b[ Uf[iaYbhg& UddYU`]b[ bch hc h\Y YjYfmXUm kcf`X&Vih hc h\Y]f \][\Yf gd]f]hiU` ibXYfghUbX]b[( J\Yb& k\Ybmci giWWYYX& mci k]`` \UjY h\Y Wcad`YhY gUh]gZUWh]cb cZmcif WcbgW]YbWY(

BVNXÁǺ

FYcd`Y VY`]YjY ]b YhYfbU` `]ZY VYWUigY h\Ym VY`]YjY h\Uh`]ZYrg VY[]bb]b[ ]g gd]f]hiU`& UbX h\YfYZcfY YhYfbU`(

?b cif gci` ]g h\Y g][b cZ YhYfb]hm(vM?BB?7C ;BB;HO 9>7DDJD9

Eif V][[Ygh XYg]fY ]g hc `]jY ZcfYjYf( 8ih k\Yb kY UfYZfYYX Zfca h\]g VcXm& kY k]`` bch k]g\ hc WcaY VUW_( ?gh\YfY giW\ U W\]`X k\c& cbWY Vcfb& kci`X `]_Y hc fYhifb hch\Y kcaV cZ \]g ach\Yf6 ?g h\YfY U aUb k\c& ZfYYX Zfcadf]gcb& kci`X `]_Y hc fYhifb hc ]h6 ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& U dYfxgcb g\ci`X bch VY UZfU]X UVcih h\Y ZihifY `]VYfUh]cb Zfca\]g VcXm& ]Z \Y ]g bch WcbbYWhYX hcc W`cgY`m k]h\ h\]g aUhYxf]U` `]ZY(

vJUV`Yg cZ h\Y 8UV]Xg& U Cig`]a gYWh Zfca FYfg]U

7 dYfgcb ]g bch UZfU]X hc X]Y cb`m UZhYf \Y ibXYfghUbXgh\Uh \Y kUg bYjYf Vcfb& h\Uh \Y U`kUmg Yl]ghYX& Yl]ghg UhdfYgYbh& UbX k]`` U`kUmg Yl]gh(7 dYfgcb k]`` VY`]YjY ]b \]g YhYfb]hm k\Yb \Y ibXYfx

ghUbXg h\Uh \]g `]ZY ]g bch U kUjY& U dYf]cX cZ h]aY& Vih h\YYhYfbU` acjYaYbh k\]W\ ]g aUb]ZYghYX ]b h\]g `]ZY cb`m UgU kUjY(

?KRVH ZKR EHOLHYH WKDW WKHLU OLIH KDV QRW EHJXQ ZLWK WKHLUELUWK DQG ZLOO QRW HQG ZLWK GHDWK ILQG LW PXFK HDVLHU WR OLYHD JRRG OLIH WKD#L WKRVH ZKR GR QRW XQGHUVWDQG RU EHOLHYH WKLV&

BVNXÁĄ

=HDOO\ WUXH$ JRRG$ DQG JUHDW WKLQJV DUH DOZD\V VLPSOH&

J\Y Ùb[iU[Y cZ hfih\ ]g U`kUmg g]ad`Y(ÅHÁTWÁZ7DD7;KI I;D;97

LYfm cZhYb h\Y g]ad`Ygh UbX `YUgh YXiWUhYX dYcd`Y WUb YUgx]`m UbX ibWcbgW]cig`m ibXYfghUbX h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZYk\]`Y h\Y acgh gW\cÙf`m dYcd`Y ÙW_ h\]g UV]`]hm& VYWUigYh\Ym \UjY VYYb hcc YXiWUhYX hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y g]ad`Yh\]b[g h\Uh UfY VUg]W hc U`` dYcd`Y(

J\Y W`YUfYgh UbX g]ad`Ygh bch]cbg UfY Uàcgh U`kUmg WcbxWYU`YX Vm gcd\]gh]WUhYX aYX]hUh]cbg(


?Z mci kUbh hc Z]bX Ub YlUad`Y hc Zc``ck& mci g\ci`X `cc_Uacb[ g]ad`Y& \iaV`Y Zc`_( J\YfY ]g fYU` [fYUhbYgg cb`m]b h\cgY k\c Xc bch UXjYfh]gY h\YagY`jYg& UbX k\c Xc bchibXYfghUbX h\YagY`jYg Ug [fYUh(

BVNXÂÀ

J\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ WcadUgg]cb Zcf ch\Yf `]j]b[ VY]b[g fYa]bXgaY cZ h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ dU]b ]b cif VcXm( @igh Ug mci WUbVYWcaY `Ygg gYbg]h]jY hc dU]b ]b mcif VcXm k]h\ h]aY& mciWUb VYWcaY `Ygg WcadUgg]cbUhY hc ch\Yfg(

?KH ILUVW FRQGLWLRQ WR EULQJLQJ UHOLJLRQ LQWR \RXU OLIH LV PDQcLIHVWLQJ ORYH DQG SLW\ WRZDUG DOO OLYLQJ FUHDWXUHV&

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

9cadUgg]cb Zcf Ub]aU`g ]g W`cgY`m WcbbYWhYX k]h\ W\UfUWxhYf hmdY( Oci WUb gUm k]h\ WcbZ]XYbWY h\Uh \Y k\c ]g WfiY`hc Ub]aU`g WUbbch VY U _]bX aUb(


;jYfm aifXYf ]g hYff]V`Y( 8ih acgh hYff]V`Y ]g h\Y aifXYf]b k\]W\ mci kUbh hc YUh h\Y WfYUhifY mci \UjY _]``YX&k\Yb mci _]`` Zcf h\Y gUh]gZUWh]cb cZ mcif ghcaUW\(

vC?A>7?B =EB:IJ;?D

M\Yb h\Y giZZYf]b[ cZ Ubch\Yf WfYUhifY WUigYg mci hc ZYY`dU]b& Xc bch giVa]h hc h\Y ]b]h]U` XYg]fY hc Z`YY Zfca h\YgiZZYf]b[ cbY& Vih cb h\Y WcbhfUfm& WcaY W`cgYf& Ug W`cgY Ugmci WUb hc \]a k\c giZZYfg& UbX hfm hc \Y`d \]a(

4MGN #"

BcjY ]g h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cb cZ h\Y X]j]bY bUhifY k\]W\Yl]ghg UVcjY h]aY( BcjY ]g bch cb`m U kUm cZ `]ZY& ]h ]g UbUWh]cb X]fYWhYX hckUfX h\Y [ccXbYgg cZ ch\Yfg(

J\YfY ]g bc `cjY ]b h\Y ZihifY( BcjY WUb Yl]gh cb`m ]b h\YdfYgYbh acaYbh( 7 aUb k\c XcYg bch aUb]ZYgh `cjY ]bh\Y dfYgYbh XcYg bch `cjY Uh U``(

.H NLQG HYHQ LI WKH ZRUOG EODPHV \RX& 5W LV EHWWHU WKDQ WKHFRQYHUVH ZKHQ D SHUVRQ LV SUDLVHG E\ RWKHUV EXW FRQWLQXHV WREH EDG&

J\Y DYk JYghUaYbh fYZ`YWhg U jYfm g]ad`Y ZU]h\4 ZU]h\ ]b=cX UbX fYgdYWh Zcf >]a( ?h ]g h\Y gUaY ]b Zc``ck]b[ h\Y`Uk5 h\YfY ]g cb`m cbY `Uk4 `cjY mcif bY][\Vcf(

v8;D;:?9JKI IF?DEP7

9YfhU]b`m& ]h ]g dU]bZi` hc fYWU`` U`` h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ mciWci`X \UjY XcbY ]b h\Y dUgh Vih X]X bch4 gcaY W\Uf]hm& ZcfYlUad`Y5 U h]aY mci XYb]YX hc h\cgY k\c YldYWhYX \Y`dZfca mci5 cf k\Yb mci V`cW_YX h\Y ^cmZi` ibXYfghUbX]b[cZ Wcad`Yh]b[ Ub UWh]cb mci g\ci`X \UjY Z]b]g\YX(

BVNXÂÂ

2DLWK LV QRW WUXH IDLWK LI ORYH LV QRW LQ KDUPRQ\ ZLWK LW&

J\Y Xccf hc \YUjYb ]g cdYbYX hc mci hc h\Y gUaY YlhYbhmci kUbh ]h( =Yh f]X cZ mcif hfciV`Yg UbX dfcV`Yag& UbXX]fYWh mcif gci` hc gd]f]hiU` h\]b[g( 8Y UhhYbh]jY& UbX Zi`Z]``mcif Xihm k]h\cih h\]b_]b[ UVcih h\Y WcbgYeiYbWYgSOcig\ci`X bch [i]XY YjYbhg& Vih VY [i]XYX Vm YjYbhg(

v?D:?7D M?I:EC

M\Uh Xch\ ]h dfcZ]hS am VfYh\fYb& h\ci[\ U aUb gUm \Y\Uh\ ZU]h\& UbX \UjY bch kcf_g6 9Ub ZU]h\ gUjY \]a6 ?Z UVfch\Yf cf g]ghYf VY bU_YX& UbX XYgh]hihY cZ XU]`m ZccX& UbXcbY cZ mci gUm ibhc h\Ya& :YdUfh ]b dYUWY& VY mY kUfaYXUbX Z]``YX5 bchk]h\ghUbX]b[ mY []jY h\Ya bch h\cgY h\]b[gk\]W\ UfY bYYXZi` hc h\Y VcXm5 k\Uh Xch\ ]h dfcZ]h6 ;jYbgc ZU]h\& ]Z ]h \Uh\ bch kcf_g& ]g XYUX& VY]b[ U`cbY( ((( OYgYY h\Yb \ck h\Uh Vm kcf_g U aUb ]g îgh]Z]YX& UbX bch VmZU]h\ cb`m(((( <cf Ug h\Y VcXm k]h\cih h\Y gd]f]h ]g XYUX& gcZU]h\ k]h\cih kcf_g ]g XYUX U`gc(

v@7C;I ,4+.'+2& ,.& ,0

7 dYfgcb k\c _bckg h\Y Ùk Vih XcYg bch Zi`Z]`` ]hfYa]bXg aY cZ cbY k\c d`ckg h\Y ÙbX Vih XcYg bch dihgYYX ]b ]h(

v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

?Z U dYfgcb ]g bch ]b U \iffm hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ \YibXYfghUbXg Ug h\Y Ùk cZ =cX& h\Yb \Y VY`]YjYg bY]h\Yf ]bh\Y Ùk& bcf ]b =cX(

BVNXÂÃ

1IIRUW LV WKH QHFHVVDU\ FRQGLWLRQ RI PRUDO SHUIHFWLRQ&

J\cgY k\c h\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym WUb `]jY U \][\ gd]f]hiU` `]ZYk\cgY VcX]Yg UfY Z]``YX k]h\ ]X`YbYgg UbX `ilif]Yg UfY a]gxhU_Yb(

J\Y VcXm ]g h\Y Z]fgh ghiXYbh cZ h\Y gci`(v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

Dch\]b[ acfY WUb VY Wcbg]XYfYX Ug fYU` aYf]h Zcf U dYfgcbh\Ub \]g YZZcfh( Eb`m ]b \]g YZZcfh ]g U dYfgcb g\ckb ]b \]gfYU` `][\h(

vJ\Y AEH7D

?Z mci kYfY UVigYX& aU_Y Ub YZZcfh hc `cjY h\cgY k\c \UjYUVigYX mci( ?Z mci \UjY UVigYX gcaYcbY& aU_Y Ub YZZcfhhc WcffYWh h\Y Yj]` k\]W\ mci WfYUhYX(

BVNXÂÄ

BKHQ RQH XQGHUVWDQGV OLIH_V ODZ$ RQH PDQLIHVWV WKH SDUW RI3RG ZKLFK OLYHV LQVLGH KLP&

;jYfm aUb& Zfca h\Y _]b[ hc h\Y dccfYgh dUidYf& g\ci`XgYY_ \]g ckb dYfZYWh]cb& VYWUigY cb`m gY`Z'dYfZYWh]cb]adfcjYg aUb_]bX(

v9ED<K9?KI

?b h\Y `cb[ fib& dYcd`Y UW\]YjY cb`m h\Uh k\]W\ h\Ym \UjYgYh Ug [cU`g Zcf h\YagY`jYg5 h\YfYZcfY& gYh h\Y \][\Ygh dcgxg]V`Y [cU`g Zcf mcifgY`Z(

J\Y Zi`Z]`àYbh cZ h\Y Ùk cZ [ccXbYgg \Ug bch\]b[ ]bWcaacb k]h\ YjYfmXUm aUhYf]U` dfcgdYf]hm( IcaYh]aYgaUhYf]U` dfcgdYf]hm UbX acfU` [ccXbYgg WÙg\ ]b WcbZ`]Wh(J\YgY giZZYf]b[g `YUX hc h\Y \][\Ygh Y`YjUh]cb cZ gd]f]h(

BVNXÂĀ

IcaYh]aYg kY WUbbch gYY Ubm WcbbYWh]cb VYhkYYb cifgiZZYf]b[ UbX cif g]b( Vih h\]g WcbbYWh]cb XYZ]b]hY`m Yl]ghg(

s? kUg fYdU]X k]h\ Yj]` Zcf h\Y [ccXbYgg k\]W\ ? \UjYXcbY(t 8ih ]Z mci `cjY h\cgY Zcf k\ca mci X]X [ccX&h\Yb mci \UjY U`fYUXm fYWY]jYX mcif fYkUfX( J\YfYZcfY&U`` h\Uh mci Xc k]h\ `cjY& mci Xc Zcf mcifgY`Z(

J\Y fYkUfX Zcf j]fhiY ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y [ccXXYYX(


8RRN IRU WKH FDXVHV RI WKH HYLO IURP ZKLFK \RX VXIIHU LQ \RXUcVHOI >RPHWLPHV WKLV HYLO LV WKH GLUHFW FRQVHTXHQFH RI \RXUDFWLYLW\+ VRPHWLPHV LW KDSSHQV DIWHU D OHQJWK\ SHULRG RI WUDQVcIRUPDWLRQ RI DQ HYLO ZKLFK \RX FRPPLWWHG ORQJ DJR& .XW WKHVRXUFH LV DOZD\V LQ \RX$ DQG VDOYDWLRQ IURP LW OLHV LQ FKDQJHVLQ \RXU DFWLRQV$ \RXU ZD\ RI OLIH&

?b YjYfm ZU]h\& cb`m k\Uh ]g gd]f]hiU` ]g hfiY(

3RG LV D VSLULW$ DQG WKRVH ZKR ZRUVKLS 4LP PXVW ZRUVKLS LQVSLULW DQG WUXWK&

v@E>D .4,.

?Z mci Xc bch VY`]YjY h\Uh Uh ]hg VY[]bb]b[& mcif `]ZY WUaYZfca gd]f]h& k\m UfY mci `cc_]b[ Zcf ]h Y`gYk\YfY& h\]b_x]b[ h\Uh mci WUb Z]bX gd]f]h ]b ch\Yf d`UWYg6 >Y k\cVY\UjYg ]b h\]g kUm ]g `]_Y h\Y aUb k\c Vifbg U `UbhYfb ]bVf][\h gib`][\h(

:c bch VY UZfU]X hc [Yh f]X cZ h\]b[g k\]W\ X]ghfUWh mcifUhhYbh]cbvYjYfmh\]b[ aUhYf]U`& YjYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ WUb VYgYYb cf WUb VY ZY`h( J\Y acfY mci dif]Zm h\Y gd]f]hiU` WcfYcZ mcif ZU]h\& h\Y Z]faYf mcif ZU]h\ k]`` VY(

BVNXÂĂ

Abck`YX[Y ]g U hcc`& bch U difdcgY(

FYcd`Y _bck `]hh`Y& VYWUigY h\Ym hfm hc ibXYfghUbX h\cgYh\]b[g k\]W\ UfY bch cdYb hc h\Ya Zcf ibXYfghUbX]b[4=cX& YhYfb]hm& gd]f]h5 cf h\cgY k\]W\ UfY bch kcfh\ h\]b_x]b[ UVcih4 \ck kUhYf VYWcaYg ZfcnYb& cf U bYk h\Ycfm cZbiaVYfg& cf \ck j]figYg WUb hfUbga]h ]``bYggYg( >ck hc`]jY mcif `]ZY ]g h\Y cb`m fYU` _bck`YX[Y(

FYcd`Y k\c h\]b_ h\Uh h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h\]b[ ]b `]ZY ]g_bck`YX[Y fYa]bX aY cZ U VihhYfZ`m k\c Z`]Yg ]bhc h\YZ`UaY cZ U WUbX`Y& UbX ]b gc Xc]b[ Vifbg& UbX Ylh]b[i]g\Ygh\Y `][\h(

J\Y h]h`Y gW\c`Uft gi[[Yghg h\Uh U dYfgcb \Ug [cbY hcgW\cc`& UbX h\Uh \Y ghiX]YX& Vih ]h XcYg bch aYUb h\Uh \Y\Ug UWei]fYX Ubm hfi`m ]adcfhUbh _bck`YX[Y(

v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

?KH SXUSRVH RI OLIH LV WKH IXOILOOPHQW RI WKH ODZ RI 3RG$ QRWWKH DFTXLVLWLRQ RI HYHU PRUH NQRZOHGJH&

BVNXÂÅ

4MGN#)

HYdYbhUbWY U`kUmg dfYWYXYg dYfZYWh]cb( ?h ]g gUX h\Uh dYcxd`Y h\]b_ fYdYbhUbWY ]g ibbYWYggUfm(

?h ]g XUb[Yfcig hc gYY h\Y WUigY cZ Yj]` Ug `m]b[ cihg]XYcifgY`jYg5 Zcf h\Ya fYdYbhUbWY VYWcaYg ]adcgg]V`Y(

O1:0/0:3.5 ?3663,7 :9-0:<;;986

:RW WR DFFHSW \RXU PLVWDNHV LV WR LQFUHDVH WKHP&

? \UjY U VifXYb cb am gci` :if]b[ U`` am `cb[ `]ZY& ? X]Xbch aU_Y UbmcbY \Uddm& bY]h\Yf am Zf]YbXg& bcf am ZUax]`m& bcf YjYb amgY`Z( ? \UjY XcbY aUbm Yj]` h\]b[g( ((( ?kUg h\Y WUigY cZ h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ h\fYY V][ kUfg( 7Vcih2**&*** dYcd`Y kYfY _]``YX VYWUigY cZ aY cb h\Y VUhh`YxZ]Y`Xg& UbX h\Y]f ach\Yfg& Vfch\Yfg& UbX k]Xckg Wf]YX Zcfh\Ya( 7bX bck h\]g ghUbXg VYhkYYb aY UbX =cX(

O9<<9 >98 -3;;7,:.5

Oci g\ci`X `]jY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh mci WUb WcbZ]XY Ubmxh\]b[ cb mcif a]bX(

BVNXÂĄ

J\Y acfY ]adcfhUbh gcaYh\]b[ ]g ]b mcif `]ZY& h\Y acfY\UfaZi` ]h WUb VY Zcf mci ]b h\Y ZihifY ]Z mci UVigY ]h(J\Y a]gZcfhibYg UbX kcYg cZ dYcd`Y cZhYb WcaY Zfca h\YUVigY cZ h\Y acgh dfYW]cig hcc` cZ cif `]ZY4 ]bhY``YWh(

3RG JDYH KLV VSLULW+ KLV LQWHOOHFW+ WR XV$ VR WKDW ZH FDQ XQGHUcVWDQG KLV ZLOO DQG IXOILO LW+ KXW ZH PLVXVH LW DQG DSSO\ WKLV$VSLULW IRU WKH IXOILOOPHQW RI RXU RZQ ZLOO&

M\Yb h\Y ]bhY``YWh VYWcaYg h\Y g`UjY cZ j]WYg UbX dUgxg]cbg& h\Y giddcfhYf cZ `]Yg& ]h VYWcaYg bch cb`m U dYfjYfxg]cb& Vih Ub ]``bYgg& UbX kY WUbbch gYY h\Y X]ZZYfYbWYVYhkYYb hfih\ UbX ZU`gY\ccX& [ccX UbX Yj]`& j]fhiY UbXj]WY("


M\Yb U dYfgcb hf]Yg hc Udd`m \]g ]bhY``YWh hc h\Y eiYgh]cbsM\m Xc ? Yl]gh ]b h\]g kcf`X6t \Y VYWcaYg X]nnm( J\Y\iaUb ]bhY``YWh WUbbch Z]bX h\Y UbgkYfg hc giW\ eiYgxh]cbg( M\Uh XcYg h\]g aYUb6 J\]g aYUbg h\Uh cif ]bhY``YWh]g bch []jYb hc ig hc Z]bX U gc`ih]cb Zcf h\]g eiYgh]cb( Eif]bhY``YWh WUb cb`m UbgkYf h\Y eiYgh]cb4 s>ck g\U`` ? `]jY6t7bX h\Y UbgkYf ]g g]ad`Y4 sMY g\ci`X `]jY gc Ug hc Vf]b[[ccX hc U`` dYcd`Y(t

J\Y difdcgY cZ h\Y ]bhY``YWh ]g hc fYjYU` h\Y hfih\5 h\YfYxZcfY ]h ]g U \UfaZi` a]gWcbWYdh]cb hc dYfjYfh h\Y hfih\k]h\ ]bhY``YWhiU` YZZcfhg(

6XO\)'Eb`m h\cgY k\c _bck h\Y]f kYU_bYggYg WUb VY hc`YfUbh cZh\Y kYU_bYggYg cZ h\Y]f bY][\Vcfg(

Cm W\]`XfYb& ]Z gcaYcbY UVigYg mci k]h\ kcfXg& Xc bchdUm aiW\ UhhYbh]cb5 VY ei]Yh Uh mcif dfUmYf& UbX Ug_ mcifZf]YbXg hc gYhh`Y h\Y X]gdihY UbX Z]bX dYUWY VYhkYYb mciUbX h\cgY k\c \UjY UVigYX mci(

O<EC <,67=/

J\Y aUb k\c WUbbch Zcf[]jY XYghfcmg U Vf]X[Y k\]W\ \Y k]``\UjY hc Wfcgg& VYWUigY YjYfm dYfgcb bYYXg Zcf[]jYbYgg(

O0/?,:/ 20:-0:<

-OPRVW DOZD\V$ ZKHQ ZH ORRN GHHS LQWR RXU VRXOV$ ZH FDQ ILQGWKHUH WKH VDPH VLQV ZKLFK ZH EODPH LQ RWKHUV& 5I ZH GR QRW ILQGD SDUWLFXODU VLQ LQ RXU VRXO$ WKHQ ZH VKRXOG ORRN PRUH FORVHO\$DQG ZH ZLOO ILQG HYHQ ZRUVH VLQV WKHUH&

7 XYYd f]jYf ]g bch hfciV`YX ]Z mci h\fck U ghcbY ]bhc ]h( ?ZU fY`][]cig dYfgcb ]g \ifh Vm Wf]h]W]ga& h\Yb \Y ]g bch Uf]jYf Vih U g\U``ck dcc`( <cf[]jY ch\Yfg& UbX h\Yb mci k]``fYWY]jY Zcf[]jYbYgg(

O7=;;632 =/ /38 ;;,,/3

?Z kY WUb dih cifgY`jYg ]bhc h\Y d`UWY cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y& kY`YggYb cif df]XY(

BVNXÃÁ

5I /KULVWLDQV ZRXOG IROORZ WKH ODZ$ WKHUH ZRXOG KH QR ULFKDQG QR SRRU&

7bX& VY\c`X& cbY WUaY UbX gU]X ibhc \]a& =ccX CUghYf&k\Uh [ccX h\]b[ g\U`` ? Xc& h\Uh ? aUm \UjY YhYfbU` `]ZY6(((@Ygig gU]X ibhc \]a& ]Z h\ci k]`h VY dYfZYWh& [c UbX gY`` h\Uhh\ci \Ugh& UbX []jY hc h\Y dccf& UbX h\ci g\U`h \UjY hfYUgifY ]b\YUjYb4 UbX WcaY UbX Zc``ck aY(

O7,<<20? "*+"' #"

7 f]W\ dYfgcb WUb VY ]bgYbg]h]jY UbX Wcad`YhY`m ]bX]ZZYfxYbh hc h\Y kcYg cZ ch\Yfg(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

MYU`h\ fYa]bXg aY cZ aUbifY ]b h\Y Z]Y`X( M\Yb ]h ]g ]b U

V][ d]`Y ]h aU_Yg U VUX gaY``( 8ih k\Yb ]h ]g X]ghf]VihYXYjYfmk\YfY UWfcgg h\Y Z]Y`X& ]h aU_Yg h\Y gc]` ZYfh]`Y(7 dYfgcb aigh Wcad`YhY`m W`cgY \]g YmYg cb \]g acfU`g&h\Uh ]b U 9\f]gh]Ub gcW]Yhm gc Z]``YX k]h\ dYcd`Y ]b bYYX&h\YfY UfY ch\Yf dYcd`Y k\c UfY gc dfciX hc \UjY [fYUhkYU`h\(

J\Y ]bhY``YWh WUb `]VYfUhY U dYfgcb5 h\Y `Ygg cZ Ub ]bhY``YWxhiU` `]ZY cbY \Ug& h\Y `Ygg `]VYfUhYX cbY ]g(

?Z mci k]g\ hc Xc bc Yj]` h\Yb h\YfY ]g bch U g]b[`Y [ccXXYYX k\]W\ mci WUbbch Xc(

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

VKVTUÁ

7 k]gY dYfgcb `]jYg ]b UWWcfXUbWY k]h\ \]g XYg]fYg&VYWUigY \Y kUbhg cb`m h\Uh k\]W\ ]g UhhU]bUV`Y( IiW\ U dYfxgcb ]g ZfYY(

:]c[YbYg gU]X& s7 k]gY aUb VYWcaYg ZfYY k\Yb \Y ]gfYUXm hc X]Y Uh Ubm acaYbh(t >Y kfchY hc h\Y FYfg]Ub_]b[& sOci WUbbch YbgÙjY hfi`m ZfYY dYcd`Y& îgh Ug mciWUbbch YbgÙjY U Z]g\( Oci aUm WUdhifY h\Ya& Vih mci WUbxbch ZcfWY h\Ya hc gYfjY5 h\Ym dfYZYf hc X]Y Ug WUdh]jYg( Ic&k\Uh kci`X ]h dfcZ]h mci hc ]adf]gcb h\Ya6t J\]g ]g UgdYYW\ cZ U fYU``m ZfYY aUb& U aUb k\c fYWc[b]nYg \]g ckbZfYYXca(

v;F?9J;JKI

MY \UjY WfYUhYX U kUm cZ `]ZY k\]W\ ]g WcbhfUfm hcaUb_]bXrg acfU` UbX d\mg]WU` bUhifY& UbX mYh kY kUbh hcVY ZfYY k\]`Y `]j]b[ h\]g _]bX cZ `]ZY(

2UHHGRP FDQQRW EH DFKLHYHG E\ ORRNLQJ IRU LW$ EXW LQ ORRNLQJIRU WUXWK& 2UHHGRP VKRXOG QRW EH D SXUSRVH$ EXW& D FRQVHc

TXHQFH&

<fYYXca WUbbch VY [fUbhYX hc mci Vm ch\Yfg( ;UW\ dYfxgcb WUb `]VYfUhY cb`m \]aY`Z(

?Z mci UfY U aUhYf]U` VY]b[& h\Yb XYUh\ ]g h\Y YbX cZ YjYfmxh\]b[( 8ih ]Z mci UfY U gd]f]hiU` VY]b[& h\Yb h\Y VcXm `]a]hgmcif gd]f]hiU` VY]b[& UbX XYUh\ ]g cb`m U W\Ub[Y(

Eif VcXm `]a]hg h\Y gd]f]hiU` X]j]bY gdUf_ k\]W\ kY WU`` cifgci`( ?b h\Y kUm h\Uh U jYggY` []jYg Zcfa hc h\Y `]ei]X cf [Ugk\]W\ ]g dih ]bhc ]h& cif VcXm []jYg Zcfa hc cif gd]f]hiU`"VY]b[( ?Z h\Y jYggY` ]g Vfc_Yb& h\Uh k\]W\ kUg ]b ]hbc`cb[Yf fYhU]bg h\Y Zcfa ]h \UX UbX Z`ckg cih( :cYg ]h fYWY]jYU bYk Zcfa6 ?g ]h ib]hYX k]h\ ch\Yf VY]b[g6 MY _bckbch\]b[ cZ h\]g( 7ZhYf XYUh\ h\Y gci` VYWcaYg gcaYh\]b[X]ZZYfYbh& gcaYh\]b[ ]bXYgWf]VUV`Y(

:YUh\ ]g cbY ghYd ]b U Wcbh]bicig XYjY`cdaYbh(vJ>;E:EH; F7HA;H

Eif `Ugh XUm XcYg bch Vf]b[ XYghfiWh]cb& cb`m U W\Ub[Y(vC7H9KI JKBB?KI 9?9;HE

:YUh\ ]g U `]VYfUh]cb cZ h\Y gci` Zfca h\Y aUhYf]U` dYfgcbxU`]hm ]b k\]W\ ]h Yl]ghYX ]b h\]g kcf`X(

VKVTUÂ

2RU WKRVH ZKR OLYH D VSLULWXDO OLIH$ WKHUH LV QR GHDWK&

MY YldYWh fYkUfXg Zcf [ccXbYgg& UbX dib]g\aYbhg Zcf h\YVUX h\]b[g k\]W\ kY Xc( EZhYb& h\Ym UfY bch ]aaYX]UhY`mZcfh\Wca]b[( 8ch\ Yj]` UbX [ccX Yl]gh ]b h\Y `]ZY cZ h\Ygd]f]h& h\ci[\& k\]W\ ]g cihg]XY h]aY& UbX h\ci[\ kY aUmbch gYY W`YUf ]bX]WUh]cbg cZ fYkUfX cf dib]g\aYbh& bYjYfxh\Y`Ygg& kY ZYY` fYkUfX cf dib]g\aYbh k]h\ cif WcbgW]YbWY(

Oci g\ci`X VY ]b U \iffm hc Xc [ccX kcf_g& YjYb gaU``cbYg& UbX hc Ujc]X g]b( EbY [ccX h\]b[ `YUXg hc Ubch\Yf&UbX cbY g]b WUigYg Ubch\Yf( J\Y fYkUfX Zcf j]fhiY ]gj]fhiY& UbX h\Y dib]g\aYbh Zcf j]WY ]g acfY j]WY(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

J\Y kcfgh dib]g\aYbh ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Uh mciZU]`YX hc dfcdYf`m igY h\cgY [ccX h\]b[g k\]W\ kYfY []jYbhc mci( :c bch YldYWh U V][ dib]g\aYbh( J\YfY WUb VY bc\UfXYf dib]g\aYbh h\Ub h\]g fYacfgY(

CRX VHHN WKH FDXVH RI HYLO$ DQG LW LV RQO\ LQ \RXUVHOI&v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

:c]b[ [ccX ]g h\Y cb`m gifY dUh\ hc V`]gg(

:c bch YldYWh gcaY hUb[]V`Y fYkUfX Zcf mcif [ccXbYgg5mcif UWh]cbg UfY h\Y]f ckb fYkUfX( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& Xcbch h\]b_ h\Uh mci WUb \cdY hc Ujc]X dib]g\aYbh cZ mcifYj]` UWhg& Zcf mcif dib]g\aYbh U`fYUXm `]Yg ]b mcifgci`(Oci UfY a]ghU_Yb ]Z mci h\]b_ h\Uh h\Y dU]b ]b mcif gci`kUg WUigYX Vm Ubmh\]b[ Y`gY(

VKVTUǼ

IY`Z'UVbY[Uh]cb ]g bch h\Y fY^YWh]cb cZ mcif Ybh]fY gY`Z&^igh h\Y fY^YWh]cb cZ mcif Ub]aU` VY]b[(

;jYfm dYfgcb \Ug k]h\]b \]agY`Z h\Y WUdUV]`]hm hc ibXYfxghUbX h\Y `]ZY cZ U`` \iaUb]hm( J\]g WUdUV]`]hm ]g \]XXYbXYYd ]b h\Y gci`& Vih ]h Yl]ghg& UbX gccbYf cf `UhYf& U dYfgcbk]`` Z]bX ]h(

v;:M7H: 97HF;DJ;H

J\Y [fYUhYgh V`]gg U dYfgcb WUb _bck ]g h\Y ghUhY cZ Wcaxd`YhY ZfYYXca UbX \Udd]bYgg h\Uh WUb WcaY cb`m h\fci[\gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY UbX `cjY(

:Ybm mcif dYfgcbU`]hm& UbX mci k]`` WcaY hc ibXYfghUbXh\Y \][\Ygh [ccX ]b `]ZY4 `cjY(

=HDO OLIH VWDUWV ZLWK VHOI%VDFULILFH&vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

J\Y acfY U dYfgcb []jYg hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y& UbX h\Y `Ygg \YUg_g Zcf \]agY`Z& h\Y VYhhYf Zcf \]a( J\Y `Ygg \Y []jYg hcch\Yfg& UbX h\Y acfY \Y kUbhg Zcf \]agY`Z& h\Y kcfgY Zcf\]a( Eif WcbhYadcfUf]Yg h\]b_ ]h h\Y fYjYfgY(

VKVTUÄ

<cf h\Y acgh dUfh& ZU`gY UbX \UfaZi` cd]b]cbg UfY X]ghf]VxihYX UbX giddcfhYX Vm ]bZìYbWY( MY UfY hcc `]_Y`m hcUWWYdh h\Y j]Ykg UbX h\ci[\hg cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y k]h\cihhfm]b[ hc ]bjYgh][UhY h\Ya XYYdYf UbX Zifh\Yf cifgY`jYg(Kb]adcfhUbh dYcd`Y UfY h\cgY k\c UWWYdh ch\Yf dYcd`Yrgh\ci[\hg k]h\cih XYjY`cd]b[ h\Ya h\YagY`jYg(

Ocif h\ci[\h ]g YUg]`m ]bZìYbWYX Vm h\Y dfYgYbWY cZUbch\Yf gci`5 U dYfgcb WUb VY Wcad`YhY`m ZfYY cb`m k\Yb\Y ]g U`cbY(

Dch\]b[ ]g acfY \UfaZi` h\Ub U VUX YlUad`Y gYh Vm ch\xYfg( J\Ym Vf]b[ ]bhc cif `]ZY bch]cbg k\]W\ bYjYf kci`X\UjY cWWiffYX hc ig k]h\cih Ub YlUad`Y(

0R QRW DOORZ \RXUVHOI WR EH LQIHFWHG E\ WKH PRRG RU VSLULW RIWKRVH ZKR DEXVH \RX+ GR QRW VWHS RQWR WKHLU SDWK&

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

7 dYfgcb WUb YUg]`m [fck UWWighcaYX hc `]j]b[ U `]Y& YgdYxW]U``m ]Z \Y gYYg YjYfmcbY UfcibX \]a `]j]b[ ]b h\Y gUaY kUm(

<U`gY ]XYUg k\]W\ [U]b WiffYbWm WUb YUg]`m VY fYWc[b]nYXVm h\Y `ciX ZUbZUfY k]h\ k\]W\ h\Ym UfY UWWcadUb]YX(HYU` hfih\ XcYg bch bYYX Ubm cihYf YaVY``]g\aYbhg(

J\Y dcgg]V]`]hm cZ ]bZìYbW]b[ ch\Yfg WUigYg U dYfgcb k]h\\][\ acfU`g hc VY acfY ghf]Wh UVcih \]g kcfXg UbX UWh]cbgk\]W\ Wci`X ]bZìYbWY ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

VKVTUĆ

J\Y ]bhY``YWh ]g h\Y cb`m Z]h [i]XY Zcf \iaUb `]ZY(

J\Y `][\h cZ h\Y VcXm ]g h\Y YmY4 h\YfYZcfY k\Yb h\]bY YmY]g g]b[`Y& h\m k\c`Y VcXm U`gc ]g Zi`` cZ `][\h5 Vih k\Yb h\]bYYmY ]g Yj]`& h\m VcXm U`gc ]g Zi`` cZ XUf_bYgg( JU_Y \YYX h\YfYxZcfY h\Uh h\Y `][\h k\]W\ ]g ]b h\YY VY bch XUf_bYgg(

vBKA; ++4-.'-/

7 aUb k\c `]jYg Ub ]bhY``YWhiU` `]ZY ]g `]_Y U aUb k\c WUfxf]Yg U ÙbhYfb ]b Zfcbh cZ \]a hc `][\h \]g kUm( IiW\ U dYfgcbk]`` bYjYf WcaY hc U XUf_ dÙWY& VYWUigY h\Y `][\h cZ \]g]bhY``YWh acjYg VYZcfY \]a( J\YfY ]g bc ZYUf cZ XYUh\ ]bh\]g _]bX cZ `]ZY& VYWUigY h\Y ÙbhYfb k\]W\ acjYg VYZcfYmci `][\hg mcif kUm hc mcif Ùgh a]bihY& UbX mci Zc``ck ]hhc h\Y YbX Ug WUà`m UbX ei]Yh`m Ug mci \UjY U`` cZ mcif `]ZY(

>RPH SHRSOH OLYH DQG DFW DFFRUGLQJ WR WKHLU RZQ WKRXJKWV$DQG VRPH DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH WKRXJKWV RI RWKHUV+ WKLV LV D FUXFLDOGLVWLQFWLRQ EHWZHHQ SHRSOH&

VKVTUĂ

LUb]hm \Ug bc `]a]hg(

7 dYfgcb Z]``YX k]h\ jUb]hm ]g gc ]bjc`jYX k]h\ \]agY`Zh\Uh h\YfY ]g bc fcca ]bg]XY \]a Zcf UbmcbY cf Ubmh\]b[Y`gY(

vF7D

7g fi`Yg [c& sOci g\ci`X VY\UjY ^igh Ug ch\Yf dYcd`YVY\UjYt ]g Uacb[ h\Y acgh XUb[Yfcig5 ]h U`acgh U`kUmgfYgi`hg ]b mcif VY\Uj]b[ VUX`m(

v@;7D :; B7 8HKO;H;

CRX FRXOG FKRRVH QR ZRUVH ZD\ WR JXLGH \RXU OLIH WKDQ WR IROc

ORZ WKH RSLQLRQV RI RWKHU SHRSOH&

M\Yb kY dfU]gY ch\Yf dYcd`Y ]h ]g VYWUigYkY h\]b_ h\Uhh\Ym `cc_ `]_Y ig5 cZhYb hc fYgdYWh U dYfgcb aYUbg hc dih\]a cb h\Y gUaY `YjY` Ug cbYgY`Z(

v@;7D :; B7 8HKO;H;

HYU` j]fhiY bYjYf `cc_g VUW_ cb ]hg g\UXck& ZUaY(v@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

?hrg bch k]gY hc VY ]bhYfYghYX ]b ZUaY UbX h\Y UddfYW]Uh]cbcZ ch\Yfg& VYWUigY bc hkc dYcd`Yrg cd]b]cbg UVcih k\Uh ]g[ccX UfY h\Y gUaY(

VKVTUĈ

?KH RSLQLRQ RI D UHYHUHG ZULWHU RU WKLQNHU FDQ KDYH D GHHSLQIOXHQFH RQ VRFLHW\+ LW FDQ DOVR EH D ELJ REVWDFOH WR XQGHUcVWDQGLQJ UHDO WUXWK&

:]j]bY hfih\ aUm VY fYjYU`YX ]b h\Y gdYYW\ cZ W\]`XfYb& cf]b h\Y fUj]b[g UbX b][\haUfYg cZ aUXaYb5 cf ]b h\Y cfX]xbUfm WcbjYfgUh]cbg cZ g]ad`Y dYcd`Y( 7bX kYU_ UbX ZU`gYh\ci[\hg aUm VY ZcibX ]b Vcc_g k\]W\ \UjY WcaY hc VYWcbg]XYfYX [fYUh& cf YjYb gUWfYX(

CUbm ghUhYaYbhg k\]W\ UfY UWWYdhYX Ug hfih\ VYWUigY h\Ym\UjY VYYb dUggYX Xckb hc ig Vm hfUX]h]cb `cc_ `]_Y hfih\cb`m VYWUigY kY \UjY bYjYf hYghYX h\Ya& bYjYf h\ci[\hUVcih h\Ya ]b U acfY dfYW]gY kUm(

<cf h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ aUb_]bX& fY`][]cb ]g U \UV]h& cf& acfYdfYW]gY`m& hfUX]h]cb ]g h\Y]f fY`][]cb( J\ci[\ ]h gYYagghfUb[Y& ? h\]b_ h\Uh h\Y Z]fgh ghYd hc acfU` dYfZYWh]cb ]gmcif `]VYfUh]cb Zfca h\Y fY`][]cb ]b k\]W\ mci kYfYfU]gYX( Dch U g]b[`Y dYfgcb \Ug WcaY hc dYfZYWh]cb YlWYdhVm Zc``ck]b[ h\]g kUm(


7 h\ci[\h k\]W\ ]g YldfYggYX ]b h\Y E`X JYghUaYbh& cf ]bh\Y DYk JYghUaYbh& cf ]b h\Y AcfUb cf ]b h\Y ?bX]UbX]j]bY Vcc_ h\Y KdUb]g\UXg& XcYg bch VYWcaY U hfih\VYWUigY ]h ]g YldfYggYX ]b U Vcc_ k\]W\ ]g Wcbg]XYfYX hc VY\c`m( ?Z kY h\]b_ h\Uh YjYfm kcfX ]b YjYfm \c`m Vcc_ ]ghfiY& h\Yb kY \UjY WfYUhYX Ub ]Xc`(

7bm ]adcfhUbh h\ci[\h& bc aUhhYf k\YfY ]h WcaYg Zfca&g\ci`X VY X]gWiggYX5 UbX YjYfm h\ci[\h& bc aUhhYf k\cgU]X ]h& g\ci`X VY []jYb UhhYbh]cb(

VKVTUǺ

J\Y aU^cf]hm cZ Yj]`g dYcd`Y Wcaa]h UfY h\Y fYgi`h& bch cZUb Yj]` k]``& Vih cZ h\Y X]ggYa]bUh]cb cZ Yj]` h\ci[\hgk\]W\ dYcd`Y UWWYdh UbX Zc``ck ibWf]h]WU``m(

CUhYf]U` fYgi`hg UfY h\Y aUb]ZYghUh]cbg cZ ibgYYbTZcfWYg4Ub Ufh]``Yfm g\Y`` h\Uh WcaYg hc ig kUg g\ch Zfca Ub ibgYYbWUbbcb Uh Ub ib_bckb h]aY( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm& U`` ]adcfxhUbh YjYbhg cf][]bUhY ]b U h\ci[\h(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

Eif UWh]cbg UfY bY]h\Yf Ug [ccX bcf Ug j]W]cig Ug cifXYg]fYg(

BK9 :; LUijYbUf[iYg

?KLQN RQO\ JRRG WKRXJKWV$ DQG ZLWK WLPH WKH\ ZLOO EHFRPHJRRG GHHGV&

J\ci[\hg k\]W\ WfYUhY Yj]` UWh]cbg UfY aiW\ kcfgY h\Ubh\Y UWhg h\YagY`jYg( Oci WUb ghcd Xc]b[ U VUX h\]b[& UbXfYdYbh& UbX bch fYdYUh ]h( 8ih VUX h\ci[\hg UfY fYdYUhYXU[U]b UbX U[U]b& UbX WUigY ch\Yf VUX UWh]cbg5 VUX h\ci[\hgZc``ck cbY UZhYf Ubch\Yf(

VKVTUĊ

J\]b_ [ccX h\ci[\hg& UbX mcif h\ci[\hg k]`` VY hifbYX]bhc [ccX UWh]cbg( ;jYfmh\]b[ VY[]bg ]b h\ci[\h( =i]X]b[mcif h\ci[\hg ]g cbY cZ h\Y _Ymg hc gY`Z'dYfZYWh]cb( ?Z mcigiZZYf a]gZcfhibYg ]b mcif `]ZY& `cc_ Zcf h\Y]f WUigY& bch ]bmcif UWh]cbg& Vih ]b h\Y h\ci[\hg k\]W\ ]bgd]fYX h\Ya&UbX hfm hc ]adfcjY h\cgY h\ci[\hg( ?Z mci UfY ]bgd]fYX VmUb YjYbh ]b mcif `]ZY& `cc_ Zcf ]hg cf][]bg ]b mcif dfYj]cigh\ci[\hg k\]W\ WUigYX h\Y YjYbh(

Oci aU_Y mcif XYW]g]cbg ]b h\Y dfYgYbh& UbX h\Y dfYgYbhYl]ghg cih cZ h]aY5 ]h ]g U h]bm acaYbh k\YfY hkc dYf]xcXgvh\Y dUgh UbX h\Y ZihifYvaYYh( ?b h\Y dfYgYbh mciUfY U`kUmg ZfYY hc aU_Y mcif W\c]WY(

7 k]gY aUb kUg Ug_YX k\Uh kUg h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h]aY&dYfgcb& UbX h\]b[ ]b `]ZY( >Y UbgkYfYX& sJ\Y acgh ]adcfxhUbh h]aY ]g h\Y dfYgYbh h]aY& VYWUigY Uh h\]g h]aY U dYfgcb\Ug dckYf cjYf \]agY`Z( J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh dYfgcb ]g h\YcbY k]h\ k\ca mci XYU` Uh dfYgYbh& VYWUigY h\YfY ]g bc[iUfUbhYY h\Uh mci k]`` YjYf VY UV`Y hc XYU` k]h\ Ubm ch\YfdYfgcb ]b h\]g kcf`X( J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh h\]b[ ]g hc `cjYh\]g dYfgcb& VYWUigY YjYfmcbY ]g gYbh ]bhc h\]g kcf`X k]h\h\Y gc`Y difdcgY cZ `cj]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y(t

Eb`m k\Yb kY igY YjYfm a]bihY cZ cif `]ZY k]`` kY _bckh\Uh kY UfY YhYfbU`(

v>7HH?;J C7H>D;7K

7 acgh XUb[Yfcig hYadhUh]cb ]g h\Y hYadhUh]cb hc dfYxdUfY hc `]jY& ]bghYUX cZ `]j]b[( J\Y ZihifY XcYg bch VY`cb[hc mci( J\YfYZcfY& fYaYaVYf hc `]jY h\Y VYgh kUm mci_bck QRZ& J\Y cb`m dYfZYWh]cb bYWYggUfm ]g dYfZYWh]cb ]b`cjY& k\]W\ WUb VY fYUW\YX cb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh( ?hrg k\mkY WUaY ]bhc h\]g kcf`X(

?KH SUHVHQW LV WKH PRPHQW LQ ZKLFK WKH GLYLQH QDWXUH RI OLIHLV UHYHDOHG& 8HW XV UHVSHFW RXU SUHVHQW WLPH+ 3RG H[LVWV LQ WKLV

VKVTUÁÀ

- SHUVRQ GLHV DV KH OLYHV KLV VSLULWXDO OLIH$ DORQH&

M\Uh mci Xc& mci dcggYgg( Oci aigh VY`]YjY h\Uh YhYfbU`[ccXbYgg Yl]ghg h\Uh ]g k]h\]b mci& UbX h\Uh ]h [fckg UbXXYjY`cdg Ug `cb[ Ug mci `]jY(


Oci U`cbY dÙb hc Wcaa]h U g]b& mci U`cbY dÙb hc Xc Yj]`5UbX mci U`cbY WUb YgWUdY g]b UbX dif]Zm mcif h\ci[\hg(Eb`m mcif ]bbYf gY`Z WUb XUab mci& UbX cb`m mcif ]bbYfgY`Z WUb gUjY mci(


7 dYfgcb aUm Ug_ =cX cf ch\Yf dYcd`Y Zcf \Y`d& Vih cb`m\]g [ccX `]ZY WUb \Y`d \]a& UbX h\]g \Y aigh Xc cb \]g ckb(

;jYfm dYfgcb \Ug U XYdh\ hc \]g ]bbYf `]ZY& Ub YggYbWY h\UhWUbbch VY YldÙ]bYX( IcaYh]aYg mci kUbh hc YldÙ]b h\]gYggYbWY hc dYcd`Y& Vih mci k]`` gYY h\Uh ]h ]gbrh dcgg]V`Y hcYldÙ]b ]h hc Ubch\Yf dYfgcb gc h\Uh \Y ibXYfghUbXg(>YbWY h\Y bYYX Zcf mcif ckb W\UbbY` cZ Wcaaib]WUx

h]cb k]h\ =cX( ;ghUV`]g\ h\]g W\UbbY` UbX Xc bch gYY_Ubmh\]b[ Y`gY(

VKVTUÁÁ

J\Y VifXYb& h\Y Wfcgg& k\]W\ YjYfm aUb \Ug hc WUffmYl]ghg cb hkc dÙbYg4 U `cb[Yf jYfh]WU` dÙbY& k\]W\ ]g h\Yk]`` cZ =cX5 UbX U aiW\ g\cfhYf& \cf]ncbhU` dÙbY&k\]W\]g U aUbrg ckb k]``( ?Z mci cf]Ybh mcif k]`` gc h\Uh ]h dUfU`x`Y`g h\Y X]fYWh]cb cZ =cXrg k]``& h\Yb mcik]`` \UjY bcWfcgg hc WUffm& bc VifXYb(

HYU` \Udd]bYgg WUb VY Vi]`h cb`m Vm \Ufacb]n]b[ mcif `]ZYk]h\ h\Y k]`` cZ =cX(

vBK9O C7BEHO

4H ZKR LV QRW ZLWK 9H LV DJDLQVW 9H+ DQG KH ZKR GRHV QRWJDWKHU ZLWK 9H$ VFDWWHUV&

vBKA; ++4,-

?Z mci kUbh hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y k]`` cZ =cX& U`` k]`` VY [ccX5 ]Zmci kUbh hc Zi`Z]`` mcif ckb k]``& UbX ]h XcYg bch Wc]bW]XYk]h\ h\Y k]`` cZ =cX& U`` k]`` VY Yj]`(

J\Y cb`m kUm hc _bck =cX UbX hc VY`]YjY ]b YhYfb]hm ]g hcib]hY mcif ckb k]`` k]h\ h\Y k]`` cZ =cX(

VKVTUÁÂ

Jc VY k]gY& mci aigh Zc``ck mcif ]bhY``YWh& YjYb h\ci[\giW\ U kUm cZ `]ZY ]g cZhYb UhhUW_YX(

J\Y \YUjYbg Xc bch UddfcjY k\Yb kY g]b& UbX h\Y YUfh\XcYg bch UddfcjY k\Yb kY UfY j]fhicig(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

:c bch VY ]bhYfYghYX ]b h\Y eiUbh]hm cZ dYcd`Y k\cfYgdYWh UbX UXa]fY mci& Vih ]b h\Y]f eiU`]hm( ?Z VUX dYcd`YX]g`]_Y mci& gc aiW\ h\Y VYhhYf(

' ,vBiW]ig 7bbUYig IYbYWU

4XPDQ LQWHOOHFW$ LV D GLYLQH ODPS$ DQG LWV OLJKW$ SHQHWUDWHV WRWKH GHSWK RI WKLQJV&

v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

Oci g\ci`X bch VY idgYh Vm h\Y g][\h cZ k]gXca VY]b[Wf]h]W]nYX( M]gXca kci`X bch VY fYU` k]gXca ]Z ]h X]X bchfYjYU` h\Y ghid]X]hm cZ U VUX `]ZY& UbX dYcd`Y kci`X bch VYdYcd`Y ]Z h\Ym YbXifYX h\]g fYjY`Uh]cb k]h\cih Wf]h]W]ga(

VKVTU ĄǼ

FYcd`Y \UjY VYWcaY hcc UWWighcaYX hc h\Y igY cZ ZcfWY(B]ZY k]h\cih j]c`YbWY gYYag ]adcgg]V`Y Zcf h\Ya hc]aU[]bY(

Jkc kUmg Yl]gh hc [i]XY \iaUb UWh]j]hm( EbY ]g hc ZcfWY UdYfgcb hc UWh U[U]bgh \]g k]g\Yg5 h\Y ch\Yf ]g hc [i]XY U dYfxgcbrg k]g\Yg& hc dYfgiUXY \]a k]h\ fYUgcb]b[( EbY ]g h\YkUj cZ j]c`YbWY4 ]Z( ]g igYX Vm ][bcfUbh dYcd`Y& UbX ]h `YUXghc Wcad`YhY X]gUddc]bhaYbh( J\Y ch\Yf ]g giddcfhYX VmYldYf]YbWY& UbX ]g U`kUmg giWWYggZi`(

v78H7>7C 9EC8

!BLWKRXW$ IDLWK LQ 3RG$ \RX FDQ IRUFH SHRSOH WR DFW&$ KXW& \RXFDQQRW$ FRQYLQFH WKHP& CRX FDQ EHFRPH D W\UDQW&$ EXW& QRW& DWHDFKHU&

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

FYcd`Y UfY k]gY VY]b[g5 h\Ym dcggYgg h\Y UV]`]hm hc `]jYUWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y X]WhUhYg cZ h\Y]f ]bhY``YWh& UbX gccbYf cf`UhYf& h\Ym k]`` Yjc`jY Zfca U ghUhY cZ j]c`YbWY hc U ghUhY cZWcad`YhY \Ufacbm UbX ibXYfghUbX]b[( 7bX YjYfm UWh cZj]c`YbWY aU_Yg h\]g h]aY acfY X]ghUbh Zfca hcXUm(

VKVTUÁÄ

-OO RWKHU DUJXPHQWV DJDLQVW PHDW HDWLQJ$ QR PDWWHU KRZVWURQJ WKH\ DUH$ DUH PHDQLQJOHVV LQ UHODWLRQ WR WKH IDFW WKDW$DQLPDOV KDYH WKH VDPH OLIH VSLULW WKDW$ H[LVWV LQ XV& MY g\ci`XZYY` h\Uh Vm hU_]b[ Ub Ub]aU` `]ZYkY Wcaa]h gcaYh\]b[W`cgY hc gi]W]XY( Dc ch\Yf Uf[iaYbh U[U]bgh aYUh YUh]b[ ]gbYWYggUfm Zcf h\cgY k\c \UjY h\]g ]bbYf ZYY`]b[(

;Uh]b[ U `ch cZ aYUh WUb aU_Y mcif VcXm ghfcb[Yf& Vih ]hkYU_Ybg mcif a]bX(

vFBKJ7H9>

?h ]g jYfm ]adcfhUbh bch hc _]`` W\]`XfYbrg bUhifU` hUghY VmZcfW]b[ h\Ya hc VYWcaY aYUh YUhYfg& bch cb`m Zcf h\Y]f\YU`h\& Vih Zcf h\Y gU_Y cZ h\Y]f W\UfUWhYf( MY Xc bch_bck h\Y fYUgcb& Vih kY _bck h\Uh dYcd`Y k\c YUh U `chcZ aYUh UfY igiU``m WfiY`(


MY WUbbch W`cgY cif YmYg hc h\cgY dYcd`Y k\c YUh aYUhZcf h\Y gUh]gZUWh]cb cZ h\Y]f dUadYfYX hUghYg(

J\Y `c[]WU` Uf[iaYbhg U[U]bgh aYUh YUh]b[ UfY bch ghfcb[Ybci[\( Bc[]W ]g [ccX& Vih ]b gcaY WUgYg ]h ZU``g g\cfh( 8ih_bck h\]g4 h\Y acfY WcadUgg]cb U dYfgcb g\ckg ch\Yf`]j]b[ WfYUhifYg& h\Y _]bXYf UbX VYhhYf \Y ]g( Jc _]`` Ub]xaU`g& k\Yh\Yf Zcf gdcfh cf Zcf ZiY`& ]g jYfm WfiY`(

VKVTU ĄĆ

MY UfY gd]f]hiU``m WcbbYWhYX cb U`` g]XYg& bch cb`m k]h\dYcd`Y Vih k]h\ U`` `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg(

IcaYcbY hc`X aY cbWY h\Uh YjYfm dYfgcb \Ug Ub Y`YaYbhcZ [ccX UbX Ub Y`YaYbh cZ VUX k]h\]b \]a& UbX h\Uh Y]h\Yfh\Y [ccX cf h\Y VUX WUb VY aUb]ZYghYX UWWcfX]b[ hc h\YdYfgcbrg accX( MY dcggYgg k]h\]b ig hkc X]ZZYfYbh kUmgcZ ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\]g kcf`X( EbY ]g h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ VY]b[X]j]XYX& X]ghUbWYX& UbX U`]YbUhYX Zfca YUW\ ch\Yf5 ]b h\]gghUhY& U`` h\]b[g gYYa [`ccam hc ig( MY ZYY` bch\]b[YlWYdh ^YU`cigm& ]bX]ZZYfYbWY& UbX \UhfYX( ? kci`X `]_Y hcWU`` h\Y cddcg]hY kUm cZ ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[cZ ib]jYfgU` ib]Z]WUh]cb( ?b h\]g ghUhY& U`` dYcd`Y gYYa jYfmW`cgY hc ig& UbX U`` UfY YeiU` Uacb[ h\YagY`jYg( J\]g ghUhY&h\YfYZcfY& UfcigYg WcadUgg]cb UbX `cjY ]b ig(


-OO SHRSOH KDYH WKH VDPH RULJLQ$ DUH KRXQG$ K\ WKH VDPH ODZ$DQG ZHUH FUHDWHG IRU WKH VDPH SXUSRVH&

J\YfYZcfY& kY g\ci`X \UjY cbY ZU]h\& cbY difdcgY hccif UWh]cbg& cbY VUbbYf ibXYf k\]W\ kY `]jY UbX Z][\h(

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

MY g\ci`X U`kUmg hfm hc Z]bX h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ Xc bchgYdUfUhY ig Zfca ch\Yf dYcd`Y Vih k\]W\ ib]hY ig( Jckcf_ U[U]bgh YUW\ ch\Yf& hc VYUb[fm UbXhifb mcif VUW_cb YUW\ ch\Yf& ]g hc kcf_ U[U]bgh bUhifY(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Jfm hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y ib]hm cZ U`` `]j]b[ h\]b[g( Jfm hcgYfjY UbX giZZYf k]h\ U`` `]j]b[ VY]b[g(

VKVTUÁĂ

A]bXbYgg ]g U bYWYggUfm UXX]h]cb hc YjYfmh\]b[(

7]` h\Y VYgh eiU`]h]Yg cZ aUb_]bX UfY aYUb]b[`Ygg UbXkcfh\`Ygg k]h\cih _]bXbYgg& UbX YjYb h\Y kcfgh j]WYg WUbVY YUg]`m Zcf[]jYb k]h\ _]bXbYgg(

J\YfY ]g U bUhifU` _]bXbYgg k\]W\ WcaYg Zfca cif YlhYfbU`Uhhf]VihYg& Zfca cif ]b\Yf]hUbWY& UiX]YbWY& [ccX cf VUX ]bX]x[Ygh]cb& giWWYgg& YhW( J\]g _]bX cZ _]bXbYgg ]g jYfm d`YUgUbh&Vch\ Zcf h\Y dYfgcb k\c YldYf]YbWYg ]h UbX Zcf h\Y dYcd`YUfcibX \]a( 7bX h\YfY ]g Ubch\Yf hmdY cZ _]bXbYgg k\]W\WcaYg Zfca ]bbYf gd]f]hiU` kcf_( J\]g _]bXbYgg ]g `YggUhhfUWh]jY& Vih U`h\ci[\ h\Y Z]fgh _]bXbYgg WUb YUg]`m W\Ub[Ycf VY hfUbgZcfaYX ]bhc \UhfYX& h\Y gYWcbX _]bX cZ _]bXbYggk]`` bYjYf X]gUddYUf UbX k]`` WcbghUbh`m [fck(

J\Y [ccXbYgg k\]W\ mci Xc []jYg mci d`YUgifY& Vih bchgUh]gZUWh]cb( Dc aUhhYf \ck aiW\ [ccXbYgg mci Xc& mcig\ci`X k]g\ hc Xc acfY UbX acfY(

v9ED<K9?KI

7LQGQHVV LV WKH PDMRU TXDOLW\ RI WKH VRXO& 5I D SHUVRQ LV QRWNLQG$ LW LV EHFDXVH KH ZDV VXEMHFWHG WR VRPH OLH$ SDVVLRQ$ RUWHPSWDWLRQ ZKLFK YLRODWHG KLV QDWXUDO VWDWH&

VKVTUÁÅ

9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]g hfiY VYWUigY ]h WUb UbgkYf h\Y acgh X]gxhUbh& UVghfUWh eiYgh]cbg& UbX Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY& ]h WUb gc`jYU`` dfUWh]WU` ]ggiYg cZ `]ZY Ug kY``( ?h YghUV`]g\YX h\Y _]b[xXca cZ =cX ]b h\Y gd]f]hiU` `]ZY cZ YjYfm ]bX]j]XiU`& UbX ]bh\Y gd]f]hiU` `]ZY cZ \iaUb]hm ]b [YbYfU`(

9\f]gh kUg gYbh hc h\]g kcf`X hc Vf]b[ [ccX bYkg( J\]g kUg\]g aU^cf kcf_( 8ih Xc h\Ym hYUW\ h\]g h\]b[ ]b \]g bUaY6>Y kUbhYX hc W\Ub[Y g`UjYfm ]bhc ZfYYXca( ?g h\]g hUi[\h]b \]g bUaY6 MYfYh\Ym Zi`Z]``YX& h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ \YkUbhYX hc Zi`Z]``6 :]Xdccf dYcd`Y \YUf h\Y [ccX bYkg6>UjY h\Y Vfc_Yb \YUfhg VYYb WifYX6 9Ub h\Y V`]bX dYcd`YgYY6 >UjY U`` h\Y g\UW_`Yg VYYb hU_Yb Zfca h\Y df]gcbYfg67fY h\Y ]baUhYg gYh ZfYY6 Dc( 9\f]gh ]g gh]`` cb \]g Wfcgg&kU]h]b[ Zcf \]g Udcgh`Yg( J\Ym g\ci`X WcaY Ug gccb Ugdcgg]V`Y& VYWUigY h\Y giZZYf]b[ ]g hYff]V`Y& UbX \]g YmYg UfYh]fYX cZ `cc_]b[ hc h\Y YUgh UbX kU]h]b[ Zcf h\Y gibf]gY cZh\Y h]aY cZ h\Y `cfX(


=HOLJLRQ LV WUXH QRW EHFDXVH LW ZDV WDXJKW E\ WKH VDLQWV$ EXW&WKH VDLQWV WDXJKW$ LW& EHFDXVH LW& LV WUXH&


Eb`m fY`][]cb XYghfcmg Y[c]ga UbX gY`Z]g\bYgg& gc h\UhcbY ghUfhg hc `]jY `]ZY bch cb`m Zcf \]agY`Z( Eb`m fY`][]cbXYghfcmg h\Y ZYUf cZ XYUh\& cb`m fY`][]cb []jYg ig h\YaYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY& cb`m fY`][]cb WfYUhYg YeiU`]hm Uacb[ dYcxd`Y& cb`m fY`][]cb gYhg U dYfgcb ZfYY Zfca cihYf dfYggifYg(MY aigh VY`]YjY h\cgY gd]f]hiU` XcWhf]bYg k\]W\ dfcj]XY UjYfm g]ad`Y UbX dfUWh]WU` [i]XY Zcf YjYfm cbY cZ ig(

VKVTUÁǺ

B]ZY ]g WcbghUbh acjYaYbh& UbX h\YfYZcfY [ccXbYgg ]b `]ZY]g bch U WYfhU]b ghUhY& Vih h\Y X]fYWh]cb cZ acjYaYbh( J\]gX]fYWh]cb ]g bch ]b gYfj]b[ mcifgY`Z& Vih =cX(

IcaY dYcd`Y gYY_ [ccXbYgg ]b dckYf& ch\Yfg ]b gW]xYbWY& ch\Yfg ]b X]gg]dUh]cb( J\cgY dYcd`Y k\c UfY fYU``mW`cgY hc [ccXbYgg ibXYfghUbX h\Uh fYU` [ccXbYgg Zcf cbY]g k\Yb U`` dYcd`Y \UjY h\]g [ccXbYgg UbX g\UfY ]h Uacb[h\YagY`jYg(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

4DSSLQHVV LV D WKLQJ ZKLFK D SHUVRQ ZLVKHV RQO\ IRU KLPVHOIJRRGQHVV LV D WKLQJ ZKLFK D SHUVRQ ZLVKHV IRU KLPVHOI DQG IRURWKHUV& 4DSSLQHVV FDQ KH DFKLHYHG E\ VWUXJJOH+ JRRGQHVV$ RQWKH FRQWUDU\$ E\ EHLQJ KXPEOH&

HYU` [ccXbYgg ]g hc gYfjY =cX(

Oci g\ci`X Xc [ccXbYgg k]h\cih W\ccg]b[ hc k\ca(=ccX h\]b[g& cbWY XcbY& k]`` bYjYf X]gUddYUf& YjYb ]Z mciZcf[Yh UVcih h\Ya( J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY kUm hc VY \Uddm& UbXh\]g ]g U gifY kUm4 hc Xc [ccXbYgg UbX hc g\UfY h\]g [ccXxbYgg k]h\ ch\Yfg(

VKVTUÁĄ

7bmcbY k\c ]g Yb[U[YX ]b fYU``m ]adcfhUbh h\]b[g ]g jYfmg]ad`Y VYWUigY \Y XcYg bch \UjY h]aY hc WfYUhY ibbYWYgxgUfm h\]b[g(

;jYfm XYg]fY UVUhYg& UbX YjYfm j]WY [fckg UZhYf ]h ]g gUh]gZ]YX(v>;DH? 7C?;B

;jYfm bYk XYg]fY ]g h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ U bYk k]g\& h\YVY[]bb]b[ cZ U bYk aUXbYgg(

vLEBJ7?H;

F`YUgifY& `ilifmvh\YgY h\]b[g mci WU`` \Udd]bYgg& Vih ?h\]b_ h\Uh hc k]g\ bch\]b[ ]g h\Y \Udd]bYgg cZ =cX& UbXk\Yb mci k]g\ hc \UjY cb`m gaU`` h\]b[g& h\Yb mci aU_YmcifgY`Z W`cgYf hc h\]g X]j]bY UbX \][\ \Udd]bYgg(

vIE9H7J;I

DUhifY fYei]fYg gaU`` h\]b[g5 h\Y Yl]gh]b[ `Uk fYei]fYgaUbm YlWYgg]jY h\]b[g(

'''''BK9?KI 7bbUYig IYbYW7h

<HRSOH FDQ OLYH ZLWKRXW QHHG DQG ZLWKRXW MHDORXV\ RQO\ZKHQ WKH\ OHDG D OLIH RI PRGHUDWLRQ&

VKVTUÂÀ

7 Zfi]hZi` dfUmYf ]g h\Y YghUV`]g\aYbh ]b mcif WcbgW]ciga]bX cZ h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ `]ZYrg aYUb]b[& UbX mci WUbYldYf]YbWY h\]g ghUhY Xif]b[ h\Y VYgh a]bihYg cZ mcif `]ZY(

FfUmYf ]g ibXYfghccX Ug Ub ]bbYf ZcfaU` fY`][]cig gYfj]WY& UgYfj]WY hc Ug_ UbX UW\]YjY gcaY WcadUgg]cb Zcf mcifgY`ZZfca h\Y \][\Yf ZcfWY5 h\]g ]g U a]gWcbWYdh]cb( Eb h\Ych\Yf \UbX& h\Y XYg]fY cZ cif \YUfhhc d`YUgY =cX k]h\ U``cif UWh]cbgvh\]g ]g h\Y gd]f]h cZ fYU` dfUmYf k\]W\ g\ci`XU`kUmg Yl]gh ]b ig(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

8Uh k\Yb mY dfUm& igY bch jU]b fYdYh]h]cbg& Ug h\Y\YUh\YbXc4 Zcf h\Ym h\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym g\U`` VY \YUfX Zcfh\Y]f aiW\gdYU_]b[( 8Y bch mY h\YfYZcfY `]_Y ibhc h\Ya4 Zcf mcif<Uh\Yf _bckYh\ k\Uh h\]b[g mY \UjY bYYX cZ& VYZcfY mYUg_ \]a( 7ZhYf h\]g aUbbYf h\YfYZcfY dfUm mY4 Eif <Uh\Yfk\]W\ Ufh ]b \YUjYb& >U``ckYX VY h\m bUaY((((

vCUhh\Yk 041'3

;QH KRXU RI KRQHVW$ VHULRXV WKLQNLQJ LV PRUH SUHFLRXV WKDQZHHNV VSHQW LQ HPSW\ WDONV&

Oci g\ci`X dfUm YjYfm \cif( J\Y acgh bYWYggUfm UbX h\Yacgh X]ZZ]Wi`h Zcfa cZ dfUmYf ]g hc fYaYaVYfv]b gd]hY cZh\Y biaYfcig X]ghfUWh]cbg cZ `]ZYvmcif cV`][Uh]cbg hc=cX& hc \]g `Uk( Oci VYWcaY gWUfYX& mci VYWcaY idgYh&mci VYWcaY YaVUffUggYX& mci VYWcaY hcc ]bjc`jYX cfX]ghfUWhYX Vm gcaYh\]b[( 8ih mci g\ci`X U`kUmg fYaYaxVYf k\c mci UfY UbX k\Uh mci g\ci`X Xc(J\]g ]g k\Uh UfYU` dfUmYf g\ci`X VY UVcih( J\]g ]g X]ZZ]Wi`h ]b h\Y VY[]bxb]b[& Vih k]h\ h]aY mci WUb kcf_ UbX WfYUhY h\]g \UV]h(

VKVTUÂÁ

?h ]g XUb[Yfcig hc X]ggYa]bUhY h\Y ]XYU h\Uh cif `]ZY ]gdifY`m h\Y dfcXiWh cZ aUhYf]U` ZcfWYg UbX h\Uh ]h XYdYbXgYbh]fY`m cb h\YgY ZcfWYg(

J\YfY UfY bc dYcd`Y k\c WUb acfY WcbZigY h\Y bch]cbg cZ[ccX UbX Yj]` h\Ub h\Y gW\cÙfg cZ cif h]aY( J\Y]f gW]YbWYaU_Yg [ccX dfc[fYgg ]b h\Y ghiXm cZ h\Y aUhYf]U` kcf`X&"Vih ]b h\Y ]bbYf& gd]f]hiU` `]ZY cZ \iaUb]hm& ]h VYWcaYg UbibbYWYggUfm UbX gcaYh]aYg \UfaZi` h\]b[(

<U`gY gW]YbWY UbX ZU`gY fY`][]cb YldfYgg h\Y]f Xc[aUg ]b\][\`m Y`YjUhYX Ùb[iU[Y hc aU_Y g]ad`Y dYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uhh\Ym UfY amghYf]cig& ]adcfhUbh& UbX UhhfUWh]jY( 8ih h\]gamghYf]cig Ùb[iU[Y ]g bch U g][b cZ k]gXca( J\Y k]gYf UdYfgcb ]g& h\Y g]ad`Yf h\Y Ùb[iU[Y \Y igYg hc YldfYgg \]gh\ci[\hg(

vBK9O C7BEHO

?KH WHDFKLQJ DERXW$ \RXU LQQHU OLIH LV WKH PRVW$ XVHIXO RQH&

?b cif h]aY gW]YbWY \Ug ghUfhYX hc []jY X]d`caUg Zcf ]X`YbYgg(

J\Y fYU` difdcgY cZ gW]YbWY ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Yhfih\ cZ h\]g `]ZY( ?hg ZU`gY difdcgY ]g h\Y îgh]Z]WUh]cb cZYj]` ]b h\]g kcf`X( J\YgY UfY h\Y îX]W]U` gW]YbWYg& dc`]h]WU`gW]YbWYg& UbX YgdYW]U``m h\Yc`c[m& h\Y gW]YbWY cZ fY`][]cb(

$!$"#

?Z dYcd`Y kYfY Wcad`YhY`m j]fhicig& h\Ym kci`X bYjYfghYd Ug]XY Zfca h\Y hfih\(

7bX h\]g ]g h\Y WcbXYabUh]cb& h\Uh `][\h ]g WcaY ]bhc h\Ykcf`X& UbX aYb `cjYX XUf_bYgg fUh\Yf h\Ub `][\h& VYWUigYh\Y]f XYYXg kYfY Yj]`( <cf YjYfm cbY h\Uh XcYh\ Yj]` \UhYh\h\Y `][\h& bY]h\Yf WcaYh\ hc h\Y `][\h& `Ygh \]g XYYXg g\ci`XVY fYdfcjYX( 8ih \Y h\Uh XcYh\ hfih\ WcaYh\ hc h\Y `][\h&h\Uh \]g XYYXg aUm VY aUXY aUb]ZYgh& h\Uh h\Ym UfYkfci[\h ]b =cX(

v@E>D -4+3',+

:cbrh VY UZfU]X cZ U dYfgcb ]b Ubm dcg]h]cb& ]b `ck cf \][\ghUbX]b[& k\Yh\Yf \Y ]g U gW\c`Uf cf Ub ][bcfUbh dYfgcb( ?Zmci fYgdYWh U`` dYcd`Y& mci g\ci`X `cjY U`` dYcd`Y& UbX ZYUfbc cbY(


J\Y WcbgYeiYbWYg cZ Ubm [ccX h\]b[ k\]W\ mci \UjYXcbY ]b mcif `]ZY k]`` X]Y Ug gccb Ug mci ghYd Ug]XY Zfcah\Y hfih\( J\Y \][\ gd]f]h k\]W\ `]jYg ]b mci UbX k\]W\ ]gib]hYX k]h\ mci ]g `cc_]b[ U`` h\Y h]aY Zcf [ccX UbX Yj]`(

vC7DK

Jfih\ WUb VY ibXYfghccX cb`m Vm kU]h]b[ UbX kUhW\]b[&UbX k\Yb mci [Yh cbY hfih\& hkc acfY k]`` UddYUf VYZcfYmci(

v@E>D HKIA?D

VKVTUÆǼ

?KH WUXWK LV KDUPIXO RQO\ WR HYLOGRHUV& ?KRVH ZKR GR JRRG

ORYH WKH WUXWK&

FYcd`Y acjY& ]bWcbgd]Wicig`m Vih WYUgY`Ygg`m& hckUfX h\Y_]b[Xca cZ =cX& k\]W\ k]`` VY UW\]YjYX Vm ib]Z]WUh]cb ]b`cjY(

;jYfm g]b[`Y ]bX]j]XiU` dYfgcb& Ug kY`` Ug U`` aUb_]bXhc[Yh\Yf& k]`` W\Ub[Y& UbX k]`` [c cb hc \][\Yf ghU[Ygk]h\cih'ghcdd]b[ ]b h\Y]f XYjY`cdaYbh& h\Y `]a]h cZ k\]W\]g =cX \]agY`Z( 7bX h\]g h]aY ]g Wca]b[(

VKVTUÂÄ

Dc& h\Y kcfX cZ U``'dckYfZi` =cX \Ug bch VYYb hc`X Wcaxd`YhY`m( 7bX \]g h\ci[\h \Ug bch VYYb ibXYfghccX Wcaxd`YhY`m ]b U`` ]hg XYdh\( >Y WfYUhYX UbX \Y WfYUhYg& UbX\Y k]`` WfYUhY& Zcf aUbm YhYfbU` WYbhif]Yg UZhYf ig5 h\]g h\Y\iaUb a]bX WUbbch YaVfUWY(

? Ua WcaY hc gYbX Z]fY cb h\Y YUfh\5 UbX k\Uh k]`` ?& ]Z ]h VYU`fYUXm _]bX`YX6 IiddcgY mY h\Uh ? Ua WcaY hc []jY dYUWYcb YUfh\6 ? hY`` mci& DUm5 Vih fUh\Yf X]j]g]cb(

?KH FRQVWDQW VWUXJJOH EHWZHHQ IOHVK DQG VSLULW ZLOO QHYHU EHILQLVKHG& ?KLV VWUXJJOH LV HWHUQDO DQG WKH HVVHQFH RI OLIH& ?KHSXUSRVH RI OLIH LV ORYLQJ$ WKH SHQHWUDWLRQ RI HYHU\WKLQJ ZLWKORYH& 5W LV WKH VORZ DQG JUDGXDO FKDQJH IURP HYLO WR JRRG$ LW LVWKH FUHDWLRQ RI WKH UHDO OLIH$ WKH OLIH ILOHG ZLWK ORYH&

J\Y \iaUb kcf`X ]g U`kUmg cb h\Y kUm hc dYfZYWh]cb& UbXh\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\]g dfcWYgg cZ dYfZYWh]cb ]g cbY cZaUb_]bXrg V][[Ygh ^cmg& UbX h\]g ^cm ]g UWWYgg]V`Y hc YjYfmdYfgcb(

'<( HE8;HJ :; B7C;DD7?I

'=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

'BKA; +,4.3&/+

Mcf_ ]g h\Y WcbX]h]cb cZ Yl]ghYbWY ]b h\Y aUhYf]U`& d\mg]xWU` kcf`X( ?Z HcV]bgcb \UX bch kcf_YX& \Y kci`X \UjYZfcnYb hc XYUh\ UbX X]YX Zfca \ib[Yf& UbX YjYfmVcXm WUbgYY h\]g( Ic ÙVcf ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb Zcf h\Y gd]f]xhiU` `]ZY Ug kY``& Vih bch U`` dYcd`Y WUb gYY h\]g W`YUf`m&h\ci[\ ]h ]g Ug cVj]cig Ug h\Y bYWYgg]hm cZ d\mg]WU` ÙVcfZcf h\Y VcXm(

?Z Ubm kci`X bch kcf_& bY]h\Yf g\ci`X \Y YUh(v?? J>;II7BED?7DI -4+*

5I \RX DUH GRLQJ QRWKLQJ$ LW PHDQV \RX DUH GRLQJ EDG WKLQJV&

J\cgY k\c Xc bch\]b[& Xc VUX h\]b[g( J\cgY k\c Xcbch\]b[& \UjY aUbm UggcW]UhYg UbX giddcfhYfg( J\Y VfU]bcZ U Ùnm UbX ]X`Y dYfgcb ]g h\Y ZUjcf]hY ghcdd]b[ dÙWY cZh\Y XYj]`(

DUhifY XcYg bch ghcd ]b ]hgXYjY`cdaYbh& UbX ]h YlYWihYgU`` _]bXg cZ ]X`YbYgg(

v@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

Oci g\ci`X bYjYf VY Ug\UaYX cZ Ubm kcf_& YjYb h\Y `ckxYgh UbX X]fh]Ygh& Vih mci g\ci`X VY Ug\UaYX cb`m cZ h\YX]fh]Ygh acfU` ghUhY& h\Uh ]g h\Y ]X`YbYgg cZ mcif VcXm&k\]W\ ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm fYgi`h cZ h\Y Wcbgiadh]cb cZ h\YÙVcf cZ ch\Yfg(

VKVTUÆĆ

6XVWLFH LV DFKLHYHG QRW LQ VWULYLQJ IRU MXVWLFH$ KXW& ZLWK ORYH&

?b cfXYf hc \]h h\Y aUf_& mci g\ci`X U]a ZUfh\Yf h\Ub ]hghUbXg& gc mci k]`` UW\]YjY ]h5 ]b cfXYf hc VY îgh& mcig\ci`X aU_Y U gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY& VY ibîgh hc mcifgY`Z(

Dch U g]b[`Y dYfgcb WUb VY Wcad`YhY`m îgh ]b U`` \]g XYYXg&Vih U îgh dYfgcb WUb VY Wcad`YhY`m X]ZZYfYbh Zfca Ubibîgh cbY k]h\ \]g YZZcfhg& ]b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug U hfih\ZiàUb ]g X]ZZYfYbh Zfca U `]Uf& k]h\ \]g YZZcfhg hc gdYU_ cb`mhfih\(

J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY Ùk cZ `]ZY k\]W\ ]g fYU``m dfYW]cig4h\ci[\ mci aYYh U`` h\Y h]aY k]h\ ]bîgh]WY& fYaU]b\iaV`Y(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Oci WUbbch VY Wcad`YhY`m îgh( EbY h]aY mci Xc hcc `]hxh`Y& h\Y ch\Yf h]aY mci Xc hcc aiW\( J\YfY ]g cb`m cbYkUm bch hc g]b U[U]bgh îgh]WY5 U`kUmg hc W\Ub[Y h\]b[g& hc]adfcjY h\]b[g& hc aU_Y h\Ya VYhhYf(

VKVTUÂĂ

J\Y VYgh UbX h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh cV^YWh Zcf YjYfm dYfgcb]g \]g ]bbYf gY`Z& \]g gd]f]hiU` VY]b[(

7 dYfgcb k\c _bckg U`` gW]YbWYg Vih XcYg bch _bck \]axgY`Z ]g U dccf UbX ][bcfUbh dYfgcb( >Y k\c XcYg bch _bckUbmh\]b[ YlWYdh Zcf \]g ]bbYf gd]f]hiU` gY`Z ]g Ub Yb`][\hxYbYX dYfgcb(

BKHQ \RX IHHO WKH GHVLUH IRU SRZHU$ \RX VKRXOG VWD\ LQ VROLc

WXGH IRU VRPH WLPH&v>;DHO :7L?: J>EH;7K

J\Y kUm hc ZUaY [cYg h\fci[\ h\Y dUÙWYg& h\Y kUm hc\Udd]bYgg [cYg h\fci[\ h\Y aUf_Yhg& h\Y kUm hc j]fhiY[cYg h\fci[\ h\Y XYgYfhg(

v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

7 dYfgcb U`kUmg \Ug U dÙWY hc VY gUZY Zfca U`` cZ \]g a]gxZcfhibYg& UbX h\]g dÙWY ]g \]g gci`(

?Z mci Wci`X cb`m _bck k\c mci UfY& U`` mcif hfciV`Ygkci`X gYYa ihhYf`m ibbYWYggUfm UbX hf]j]U`(

VKVTUÆĈ

2DLWK LV WKH IRXQGDWLRQ RQ ZKLFK DOO HOVH UHVWV+ LW LV WKH URRW RIDOO NQRZOHGJH&

J\YfY UfY hkc hmdYg cZ ZU]h\ ]b h\]g kcf`X( J\Y Z]fgh ]g ZU]h\]b h\]b[g ch\Yf dYcd`Y gUm& ZU]h\ ]b dYcd`Y5 h\YfY UfY aUbmjUf]Yh]Yg cZ h\]g hmdY cZ ZU]h\( J\Y gYWcbX ]g ZU]h\ ]b =cX5h\]g hmdY cZ ZU]h\ ]g ibjUfm]b[& UbX ]h ]g bYWYggUfm Zcf U``'dYcd`Y(

<U]h\ ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm dfcdYfhm cZ h\Y gci`( <YY` h\Y YggYbxh]U` aYUb]b[`YggbYgg cZ h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY kY``'_bckbhc mci& UbX h\Y [fYUhbYgg cZ h\]b[g k\]W\ UfY ib_bckb Vih]adcfhUbh(

9`YUjY hc h\Y hYUW\]b[g cZ 9\f]gh Wcad`YhY`m& UbX `Yh [ccZ ch\Yf hYUW\]b[g& ^igh Ug U gU]`cf fYUXg \]g WcadUgg&h\ci[\ ch\Yf g][bg UfcibX \]a a][\h WcbhfUX]Wh ]h(

FYcd`Y k\c VY`]YjY h\Ym Xc bch \UjY ZU]h\ UfY kfcb[5h\Ym g]ad`m Xcbrh fYU`]nY ]h& cf Xcbrh kUbh ]h& cf WUbbchYldfYgg ]h(

VKVTUÂǺ

5I LQ KLV VRXO$ D SHUVRQ XQGHUVWDQGV 3RG$ KH XQGHUVWDQGV KLV

FRQQHFWLRQ WR DOO WKH ZRUOG!V SHRSOH&

:c bch VY dfciX& bc aUhhYf k\Uh \][\ dcg]h]cb mcicWWidm ]b `]ZY( ?b mci UbX ]b aY UbX ]b YjYfm" ch\Yf dYfgcb`]jYg h\Y gUaY =cX& h\Y gUaY `]ZY ZcfWY5 mci `cc_ Xckb cbaY ]b jU]b5 kY UfY U`` YeiU` VY]b[g(

v?D:?7D M?I:EC

? Ua Z]``YX k]h\ U [fYUh h\ci[\h4 h\Uh cZ h\Y [fYUhbYgg cZam gci`& ]hg ib]hm k]h\ =cX( Cm gci` ]g bch ib]hYX k]h\=cX ]b giVa]gg]cb& Vih h\fci[\ ]hg UV]`]hm hc ibXYfghUbX>]a& UbX h\fci[\ >]a& hc VY YhYfbU`(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

VKVTUÆĊ

MY UfY U`` W\]`XfYb cZ h\Y gUaY ZUh\Yf& UbX ]h ]g ibbUhifU`bch hc `cjY cif Vfch\Yfg(

J\cgY k\c UfY cb hcd cZ h\Y acibhU]b WUb gYY h\Y gibf]gYgccbYf h\Ub h\cgY k\c `]jY ]b h\Y jU``Ym( Ic& hcc& k]h\h\cgY k\c UW\]YjY gd]f]hiU` \Y][\hg4 h\Ym WUb gYY h\Y \YUjxYb`m gibf]gY gccbYf h\Ub h\cgY k\c `]jY U aUhYf]U` `]ZY(8ih h\Y h]aY k]`` WcaY k\Yb h\Y gib k]`` f]gY gc \][\ ]bh\Y g_m h\Uh YjYfmcbY k]`` gYY ]h(

BH g\ci`X \cdY h\Uh h\Y XUm k]`` WcaY k\Yb U`` dYcd`YdYfWY]jY h\Uh h\Y `]ZY cZ U aUb ]g [fYUh cb`m ]b ]hg gYfj]WY hc\]g Vfch\Yfg& Zcf \Y ]g ib]hYX k]h\ h\Ya Vm =cX(

v;:M7H: 8HEMD

FckYfZi` ZcfWYg UfY Uh kcf_ ]b h\]g kcf`X( Dc cbY WUbghcd h\Ya( MY gYY h\Y]f g][bg ]b U bYk ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZfY`][]cb& U bYk fYgdYWh Zcf dYcd`Y& U bYk ZYY`]b[ cZ Vfch\xYf\ccX(


7g gccb Ug h\Y \][\Yf ]XYU` ]g dih VYZcfY ig& U`` ZU`gY ]XYU`gk]`` ZUXY UkUm Ug h\Y ghUfg ZUXY UkUm k\Yb h\Ym aYYh h\Y

VKVTUTǼǺ

7bm kcf_ cZ ZU`gY Ufh dfU]gYX Vm Wf]h]Wg ]g U Xccf h\fci[\k\]W\ s\mdcWf]hYg cZ Ufht YbhYf cif a]bXg(

J\Y WfYUh]cb UbX gU`Y cZ acgh Ufh hcXUm ]g difY dfcgh]hixh]cb( J\Y WcadUf]gcb ]g hfiY ]b YjYfm XYhU]`( HYU` Ufh WUbcb`m fUfY`m VY WfYUhYX YjYb Vm U fYU` Ufh]gh5 `]_Y U W\]`X ]b Uach\Yfrg kcaV& ]h ]g h\Y f]dYbYX Zfi]h cZ \]g df]cf `]ZY(<U`gY Ufh& h\ci[\& WUb VY WYUgY`Ygg`m dfcXiWYX Vm WfUZhgxaYb& UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y X]WhUhYg cZ U aUf_Yh( B]_Y U ZU]h\Zi`k]ZY k\c `cjYg \Yf \igVUbX& fYU` Ufh XcYg bch bYYX UbmYlWYgg XYWcfUh]cb5 `]_Y U dfcgh]hihY& ZU`gY Ufh XYaUbXg hcVY XYWcfUhYX( JfiY Ufh WcaYg cih cZ Ub Ufh]ghrg if[Ybh bYYXhc YldfYgg h\Y ZYY`]b[g h\Uh \UjY ZcfaYX ]bg]XY \]a& ^ighUg U ach\Yf bYYXg hc []jY V]fh\ hc \Yf VUVm( <U`gY UfhUbgkYfg cb`m hc dfcZ]h( HYU` Ufh Vf]b[g bYk ZYY`]b[g ]bhccif `]ZY& Ug U kcaUb Vf]b[g U bYk dYfgcb ]bhc h\Y kcf`X(<U`gY Ufh Wcffidhg4 ]h aU_Yg U dYfgcb X]gg]dUhYX& X]ghfUWhg\]a& kYU_Ybg \]g gd]f]hiU` dckYf( ;jYfmcbY aigh ibXYfxghUbX h\]g& ]b cfXYf h\Uh h\Ym g\ib h\Y hYff]V`Y dfc`]ZYfUxh]cb cZ h\]g X]fhm& X]gg]dUhYX hmdY cZ Ufh k\]W\ ]g& cb ]hgZUWY& dfcgh]hih]cb(

CRX FDQQRW VHOO \RXU WDOHQW$ \RXU JHQLXV+ DV VRRQ DV \RX GR$\RX DUH D SURVWLWXWH& CRX FDQ VHOO \RXU ZRUN$ EXW& QRW& \RXU

VRXO&v@E>D HKIA?D

Kbh]` h\Ym h\fck h\Y acbYm W\Ub[Yfg cih cZ h\Y hYad`YcZ Ufh& ]h k]`` bYjYf VY U fYU` hYad`Y( 8ih h\Y h]aY k]`` WcaYk\Yb h\YgY gU`YgaYb k]`` VY gYbh UkUm Zfca h\Y hYad`Y cZUfh(

VKVTUǼĄ

Ic`X]Yfg k\c ghUbX ]X`Y ]b U g\Y`hYf Xif]b[ U VUhh`Y Ug fYx]bZcfWYaYbhg k]`` hfm hc ]bjc`jY h\YagY`jYg ]b Uàcgh UbmUWh]j]hm ]b cfXYf hc X]ghfUWh h\YagY`jYg Zfca h\Y ]adYbX]b[XUb[Yf( ?h gYYag hc aY h\Uh dYcd`Y k\c kUbh hc gUjY h\YaxgY`jYg Zfca `]ZY VY\UjY `]_Y h\YgY gc`X]Yfg4 gcaY X]ghfUWhh\YagY`jYg k]h\ jUb]hm& gcaY k]h\ WUfXg& dc`]h]Wg& Ùkg&kcaYb& [UaV`]b[& \cfgYg& \ibh]b[& k]bY& cf ghUhY UZZU]fg(

?h ]g X]ZZ]Wi`h hc ]aU[]bY k\Uh kcbXYfZi` W\Ub[Yg kci`XcWWif hc \iaUb `]jYg ]Z dYcd`Y kci`X ghcd dc]gcb]b[h\YagY`jYg k]h\ VfUbXm& k]bY& hcVUWWc& UbX Xfi[g(

J\Ym gUm h\Uh h\YfY ]g cbY fY`][]cig gYWh h\Uh Uh h\Y YbX cZh\Y]f [Uh\Yf]b[g h\Ym hifb Xckb h\Y `][\hg UbX \UjY Ubcf[m( ?b cif gcW]Yhm& dYcd`Y k\c dUfh]W]dUhY ]b WcbghUbhX]gg]dUh]cbg hifb Xckb h\Y `][\h cZ h\Y ]bhY``YWh k]h\UXX]Wh]jY h\]b[g giW\ Ug Xfi[g& U`Wc\c`& UbX hcVUWWc(

9DNLQJ \RXUVHOI DGGLFWHG LV QRW D FULPH$ EXW LW LV D SUHSDUDcWLRQ IRU FULPH&

IcaY dYcd`Y gUm& s?h ]g bch ]adcfhUbh ]Z mci Xf]b_ cfgac_Y(t ?Z ]h ]g cZ bc ]adcfhUbWY& h\Yb k\m bch îgh ghcd&]Z mci _bck h\Uh mci \Ufa mcifgY`Z UbX& k]h\ mcif YlUaxd`Y& ch\Yfg6

FJRUJOHJSÁ

FJRUJOHJSÂ

J\Y W`cgYf dYcd`Y UfY hc h\Y hfih\& h\Y acfY hc`YfUbh h\YmUfY cZ h\Y a]ghU_Yg cZ ch\Yfg(

J\cgY k\c Xcbrh VY`]YjY ]b h\Y gd]f]hiU` ZcibXUh]cbg cZ h\Y]fZU]h\& k\c cb`m dUm `]d gYfj]WY hc h\Y cihYf g\Y`` cZ h\Y]f fY`]x[]cig f]hiU`g& WUbbch VY hc`YfUbh cZ ch\Yfg(

?KHUH LV RQH KDUG DQG IDVW UXOH ZH PXVW DOZD\V UHPHPEHU* LID JRRG HQG FDQ KH DFKLHYHG RQO\ WKURXJK KDG PHDQV$ HLWKHU LWLV QRW JRRG DIWHU DOO$ RU LWV WLPH KDV QRW \HW FRPH&

?bhc`YfUbh UbX dckYf'\ib[fm df]Yghg UbX dUghcfg Vf]b[UVcih h\Y bY[Uh]cb cZ fY`][]cb(

vM?BB?7C M7H8KHJED

KbVY`]YjYfg WUb VY YeiU``m ]bhc`YfUbh Ug h\cgY k\cVY`]YjY k]h\ WfiXY& df]a]h]jY ibXYfghUbX]b[(

v@;7D <H7D9; :K9BEI

7 fYU` hfih\& U fYU` ZU]h\& bYYXg bY]h\Yfkcf`X`m giddcfhbcf Ub cihYf [`Uacif& bcf XcYg ]h bYYX hc VY ZcfWYZi``m]bhfcXiWYX hc ch\Yfg( =cX \Ug h]aY5 Zcf >]a h\cigUbXgcZ mYUfg dUgg Ug cbY( J\cgY k\c ZYY` h\Y bYYX hc gdfYUXh\Y]f ZU]h\ h\fci[\ j]c`YbWY UbX ZcfWY Y]h\Yf `UW_ ZU]h\ ]b=cX& cf ]b h\YagY`jYg(

FJRUJOHJSÃ

=cX WUbbch VY ibXYfghccX Vm h\Y \iaUb ]bhY``YWh& cb`mZY`h Vm h\Y \iaUb \YUfh( MY cb`m _bck h\Uh \Y Yl]ghg& UbXfY[UfX`Ygg cZ k\Yh\Yf kY kUbh ]h cf bch& kY _bck h\]g ZcfgifY(

J\Y ]bhY``YWh ]g `]_Y U `][\h h\Uh WcaYg h\fci[\ U hfUbgìxWYbh [Ùgg4 ? gYY ]h& UbX h\ci[\ ? Xc bch _bck k\YfY ]hWcaYg Zfca& ? _bck h\Uh ]h Yl]ghg( MY WUb gUm h\Y gUaYUVcih =cX(

8Y`]YjY ]b =cX& gYfjY >]a& Vih Xcbrh hfm hc ibXYfghUbX>]g YggYbWY( Oci k]`` [Yh bch\]b[ Zfca mcif dU]bZi`YZZcfhg YlWYdh X]gUddc]bhaYbh UbX ZUh][iY( :c bch YjYbghf]jY hc Z]bX cih k\Yh\Yf \Y Yl]ghg cf bch& îgh gY]jY \]bfUg ]Z \Y XcYg& Ug ]Z \Y ]g dfYgYbh YjYfmk\YfY( Dch\]b[ Y`gY]g bYWYggUfm(

vF>?B;CED

Dc cbY YlWYdh =cX WcadfY\YbXg h\Y gYWfYh cZ h\Y [fYUhVY[]bb]b[5 bc cbY WUb ghYd cihg]XY \]agY`Z(

vEC7H A>7OO7C

MY WUb ibXYfghUbX h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ =cX k]h\ cif ]bhY`x`YWh cb`m k\Yb kY ibXYfghUbX cif Wcad`YhY XYdYbXYbWYcb \]a& Ug ]Z kY \UjY h\Y gUaY ZYY`]b[ Ub ]bZUbh ibXYfxghUbXg k\Yb \]g ach\Yf \c`Xg \]a( 7 VUVm XcYg bch _bckk\c ZYYXg \]a& k\c kUfag \]a& k\c hU_Yg WUfY cZ \]a&Vih \Y ibXYfghUbXg h\Uh h\YfY LV gcaYcbY k\c XcYg h\]g&UbX YjYb \Y `cjYg h\Y ZcfWY ]b k\cgY dckYf \Y fYghg(

0R QRW EH DODUPHG LI WKH QRWLRQ RI 3RG LV QRW FOHDUO\H[SUHVVHG WR \RX& ?KH PRUH FOHDUO\ LW LV H[SUHVVHG$ WKH IXUWKHULW LV IURP WKH WUXWK$ IURP LWV IRXQGDWLRQ&

FJRUJOHJSÄ

=HDO JRRGQHVV LV QRW VRPHWKLQJ WKDW FDQ KH DFTXLUHG LQ DQLQVWDQW$ KXW RQO\ WKURXJK FRQVWDQW HIIRUW$ EHFDXVH UHDO JRRGcQHVV OLHV LQ FRQVWDQWO\ VWULYLQJ IRU SHUIHFWLRQ&

J\Y Zc``ck]b[ kcfXg kYfY WUfjYX cb h\Y VUh\fcca cZ h\Y_]b[ @]bl'>Ub[4 sHYbYk mcifgY`Z Wcad`YhY`m YjYfm XUm&UbX ghUfh]b[ UZfYg\& Zfca h\Y VY[]bb]b[(t

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

J\Y ^cifbYm cZ h\Y k]gY hc j]fhiY ]g Ug U ^cifbYm hc UfYachY ÙbX& cf h\Y UgWYbh cZ U \][\ acibhU]b( FYcd`Yk\c hfUjY` hc U ZUfUkUm dÙWY ghUfh k]h\ U g]b[`Y ghYd& UbXh\cgY k\c W`]aV U \][\ acibhU]b ghUfh Zfca h\Y Vchhca(

v9ED<K9?KI

7bX @Ygig gU]X ibhc \]a& Dc aUb& \Uj]b[ dih \]g \UbX hch\Y d`ck& UbX `cc_]b[ VUW_& ]g Z]h Zcf h\Y _]b[Xca cZ =cX(

vBi_Y 340,

Ihf]jY Zcf [ccXbYgg k]h\cih Ubm YldYWhUh]cbg Zcf fUd]X cfbch]WYUV`Y giWWYgg( Oci k]`` bch gYY h\Y fYgi`hg cZ mcifYZZcfhg& VYWUigY h\Y Zifh\Yf mci dfc[fYgg& h\Y \][\Yf h\Y]XYU` cZ dYfZYWh]cb hckUfX k\]W\ mci ghf]jY f]gYg( J\YYZZcfh cZ ghf]j]b[ Zcf [ccXbYgg& h\Y dfcWYgg ]hgY`Z& îgh]Z]Ygcif `]jYg(

FJRUJOHJSĆ

Oci g\ci`X hYUW\ ch\Yfg k]h\ U [ccX YlUad`Y& Vih ]Z mcifYUW\ k]h\ Yj]`& h\Yb mci Xc bch hYUW\& Vih XYghfcm(

J\Yb WUaY FYhYf hc \]a& UbX gU]X& BcfX& \ck cZh g\U`` amVfch\Yf g]b U[U]bgh aY& UbX ? Zcf[]jY \]a6 h]`` gYjYbh]aYg6 @Ygig gU]h\ ibhc \]a& ? gUm bch ibhc h\YY& Kbh]`gYjYb h]aYg4 Vih& Kbh]` gYjYbhm h]aYg gYjYb(

ÅI OODBQĄČÄÆĄĂÆÆ

>LQIXO SHRSOH KDG RQFH DFFHSWHG WKHLU ULJKW WR SXQLVK RWKcHUVbDQG PRVW RI RXU PLVIRUWXQHV VWDUWHG IURP WKLV&

?Z mci h\]b_ gcaYcbY ]g [i]`hm cZ kfcb[]b[ mci& Zcf[]jY\]a( ?Z mci \UjY bYjYf Zcf[]jYb h\Y [i]`hm VYZcfY& mci k]``YldYf]YbWY U bYk ^cm4 h\Y ^cm cZ Zcf[]j]b[(

Fib]g\aYbh ]g U`kUmg WfiY`& U`kUmg dU]bZi`(

J\Y 7aYf]WUb ?bX]Ubg \UX bc `Ukg& bc dib]g\aYbhg& UbXbc [cjYfbaYbh( J\Ym cVYmYX h\Y acfU` ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ[ccX UbX Yj]` h\Uh ]g dUfh cZ YjYfm \iaUb bUhifY(

ÅODKI NFBCCBMNKJ

J\Y ghfcb[Ygh dfccZ h\Uh ]b h\Y bUaY cZ sgW]YbWYt kY difxgiY ibkcfh\m UbX gcaYh]aYg YjYb \UfaZi` h\]b[g ]g h\YYl]ghYbWY cZ U gW]YbWY cZ dib]g\aYbh& k\]W\ ]b ]hgY`Z ]gcbY cZ h\Y acgh ][bcfUbh UbX cZZYbg]jY hmdYg cZ UWh]cb_bckb hc aUb& U jYgh][Y cZ h\Y `ckYgh `YjY` cZ \iaUbXYjY`cdaYbh& `ckYf h\Ub h\Uh cZ U W\]`X cf U aUXaUb(

<HRSOH MXPS EDFN DQG IRUWK LQ SXUVXLW RI SOHDVXUHV RQO\EHFDXVH WKH\ VHH WKH HPSWLQHVV RI WKHLU OLYHV PRUH FOHDUO\ WKDQWKH\ GR WKH HPSWLQHVV RI ZKLFKHYHU QHZ HQWHUWDLQPHQW

DWWUDFWV WKHP&v8B7?I; F7I97B

J\Y h\]b[g kY Xc hc aU_Y cif `]ZY acfY WcaZcfhUV`YfYa]bX aY cZ Ub cghf]W\ k\c \]XYg \]g \YUX ]b cfXYf bch hcgYY \]g YbYa]Yg( MY VY\UjY YjYb kcfgY h\Ub Ub cghf]W\( ?bcfXYf hc UW\]YjY gcaY XiV]cig eiYgh]cbUV`Y ZihifY& kYXYZ]b]hY`m XYghfcm cif `]ZY ]b h\Y W`YUf`m XYZ]bYX dfYgYbh h]aY(

FYcd`Y hcXUm Zcc`]g\`m hfm hc VY`]YjY h\Uh U`` h\Y kcf`XrggYbgY`YggbYgg UbX WfiY`hmvh\Y f]W\bYgg cZ h\Y ZYk& h\Y[fYUh dcjYfhm cZ h\Y aUbm& h\Y j]c`YbWY UbX kUfZUfYv\UddYbg cihg]XY h\Y]f ckb `]jYg UbX XcYg bch ]bhYfZYfYk]h\ h\Ya UbX h\Y]f kUm cZ `]ZY(

7 a]gWcbWYdh]cb fYaU]bg U a]gWcbWYdh]cb& YjYb k\Yb ]h]g g\UfYX Vm h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ h\Y dYcd`Y(

FJRUJOHJSĂ

FJRUJOHJSĈ

?Z `]ZY ]g [ccX& h\Yb XYUh\ k\]W\ ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm dUfh cZ"`]ZY& ]g [ccX Ug kY``(

HYU` `]ZY Yl]ghg cb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh( J\Y ZihifY \Ug bcxaYUb]b[(

J\Y difdcgY cZ fYU` `]ZY ]g hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y Ùk cZ =cX& k\]W\Yl]ghg YhYfbU``m4 ]h U`kUmg Yl]ghYX& ]h Yl]ghg bck& UbX ]hU`kUmg k]`` Yl]gh(

:c bch Vch\Yf UVcih k\Uh k]`` \UddYb gcaYXUm& gcaYxk\YfY& ]b h\Y ZUf UkUm X]ghUbWY& ]b U ZihifY h]aY5 h\]b_ UbXVY jYfm UhhYbh]jY hc k\Uh \UddYbg bck& \YfY& ]b h\]g dÙWY(

v@E>D'HKIA?D

7g gccb Ug mci [c ]bhc h\Y ZihifY cf h\Y dUgh& mci [c UkUmZfca =cX& UbX mci ZYY` `cbY`m& XYgYfhYX& UbX YbgÙjYX(

?KH IXWXUH GRHV QRW UHDOO\ H[LVW& 5W LV FUHDWHG E\ XV LQ WKHSUHVHQW&

J\YfY ]g U WcbX]h]cb ]b k\]W\ U dYfgcb ZYY`g \]agY`Z h\YUfW\]hYWh cZ \]g `]ZY( ?h cWWifg k\Yb \Y WcbWYbhfUhYg U`` \]gYZZcfhg UbX U`` \]g ]bhY``YWh cb h\Y dfYgYbh acaYbh(

FJRUJOHJSǺ

7h h\Uh h]aY @Ygig UbgkYfYX UbX gU]X& ? h\Ub_ h\YY& E<Uh\Yf& BcfX cZ \YUjYb UbX YUfh\& VYWUigY h\ci \Ugh \]Xh\YgY h\]b[g Zfca h\Y k]gY UbX dfiXYbh& UbX \Ugh fYjYU`YXh\Ya ibhc VUVYg( ;jYb gc& <Uh\Yf4 Zcf gc ]h gYYaYX [ccX]b h\m g][\h(

vC7JJ>;M +.4,/',0

?KH ZRUOG ZRXOG KH D WHUULEOH SODFH ZLWKRXW QHZERUQ FKLOcGUHQ$ ZKR EULQJ ZLWK WKHP LQQRFHQFH$ DQG WKH KRSH RI PDQ_VIXUWKHU SHUIHFWLRQ& ^

v@E>D HKIA?D

9\]`X\ccX ]g V`YggYX Vm \YUjYb VYWUigY ]h Vf]b[g U d]YWYcZ dUfUX]gY ]bhc h\Y WfiY`h]Yg cZ `]ZY( 7`` h\YgY h\cigUbXg cZYjYfmXUm V]fh\g UfY ZfYg\ UXX]h]cbg cZ ]bbcWYbWY UbXdif]hm& k\]W\ Z][\h U[U]bgh h\Y YbX cZ aUb_]bX& UbX U[U]bghcif gdc]`YX bUhifY& UbX U[U]bgh cif Wcad`YhY ]aaYfg]cb]bhc g]b(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

E BcfX cif BcfX& \ck YlWY``Ybh ]g h\m bUaY ]b U`` h\YYUfh\ k\c \Ugh gYh h\m [`cfm UVcjY h\Y \YUjYbg( Eih cZh\Y acih\ cZ VUVYg UbX giW_`]b[g \Ugh h\ci cfXU]bYXghfYb[h\ VYWUigY cZ h\]bY YbYa]Yg& h\Uh h\ci a][\hYghgh]`` h\Y YbYam UbX h\Y UjYb[Yf(

vFI7BCI 24+',

M\Uh h]aY Wci`X VY VYhhYf h\Ub W\]`X\ccX& UbX k\Uhj]fhiYg Wci`X VY VYhhYf h\Ub ]bbcWYbh ^cmZi`bYgg& UbX h\YbYYX Zcf `cjY6 J\Ym UfY h\Y difYgh aUb]ZYghUh]cbg cZ `]ZY(Oci g\ci`X fYgdYWh YjYfm dYfgcb& Vih mci g\ci`X fYgdYWh UW\]`X UVcjY U``& UbX bch XYghfcm h\Y ]bbcWYbh dif]hm cZ \]ggci`(

FJRUJOHJSĄ

J\Y _bck`YX[Y kY bck UWWYdh Ug gW]YbWY ]bhYfZYfYg k]h\acfY h\Ub ]h giddcfhg h\Y [ccXbYgg cZ \iaUb `]ZY(

7ghfcbcam& aYW\Ub]Wg& d\mg]Wg& W\Ya]ghfm& UbX U`` ch\YfgW]YbWYg hc[Yh\Yf UbX X]ZZYfYbh`m& U`` ghiXm h\Y dUfh]WiÙfg]XYg cZ `]ZY& Vih h\Ym Xc bch WcaY hc Ubm WcbWìg]cbUVcih h\Y gd]f]hiU` `]ZY cZ aUb_]bX(

IW]YbWY Zi`Z]``g ]hg difdcgY& bch k\Yb ]h YldÙ]bg h\Y fYUxgcbg Zcf h\Y XUf_ gdchg cb h\Y gib& Vih k\Yb ]h ibXYfxghUbXg UbX YldÙ]bg h\Y Ùkg cZ cif ckb `]ZY& UbX h\YWcbgYeiYbWYg cZ j]cÙh]b[ h\YgY Ùkg(

v@E>D HKIA?D

:R PDWWHU KRZ JUHDW RXU NQRZOHGJH PD\ KH$ LW FDQQRW KHOS XVIXOILOO RXU OLIH_V PDMRU SXUSRVHbRXU PRUDO SHUIHFWLRQ&

FJRUJOHJSÁÀ

J\Y jc]WY cZ WcbgW]YbWY aU_Yg bc a]ghU_Yg( ?h kUbhg& bchh\Y Zi`Z]``aYbh cZ h\Y Ub]aU` gY`Z& Vih ]hg XYb]U` cf gUWf]Z]WY(

7 9\f]gh]Ub k\c XcYg bch _bck k\YfY \Y [cYg #@c\b-42$& cf k\Uh ]g []jYb hc \]a Vm =cX #@c\b -4-.$& XcYgbch _bck \]g `]ZYrg fYU` difdcgY(

v<OE:EH IJH7A>EL

7g cif gY`Z']bhYfYgh X]a]b]g\Yg& cif Ubl]Yh]Yg X]gUddYUf&UbX h\Yb WcaYg ei]Yh UbX Z]fa ^cm& k\]W\ U`kUmg X]ZZigYgig k]h\ U [ccX gd]f]hiU` X]gdcg]h]cb UbX U W`YUf WcbxgW]YbWY( ;jYfm [ccX XYYX \Y`dg hc _]bX`Y h\]g ZYY`]b[ cZ^cm k]h\]b ig( J\Y Y[c]gh ZYY`g `cbY`m& giffcibXYX Vmh\fYUhYb]b[ UbX U`]Yb YjYbhg5 U`` \]g XYg]fYg UfY gib_ ]b \]gckb WcbWYfbg( 7 _]bX dYfgcb `]jYg ]b U kcf`X cZ VYbYZ]xWYbh YjYbhg& k\cgY [ccXbYgg aUhW\Yg \]g ckb(


7 dYfgcb k\c `]jYg cb`m Zcf h\Y WcbWYfbg cZ \]g VcXm aUmVYWcaY `cgh ]b h\Y `UVmf]bh\ cZ Ub Ub]aU` UbX gYbgiU` `]ZY&k\]`Y h\Y gci` k]`` U`kUmg Z]bX hfih\5 ]h k]`` Z]bX h\Y kUm(

vBK9O C7BEHO

?KH YRLFH RI \RXU FRQVFLHQFH FDQ DOZD\V KH VLQJOHG RXWDERYH WKH QRLVH RI \RXU RWKHU ZLVKHV$ EHFDXVH LW DOZD\V ZDQWVVRPHWKLQJ VHHPLQJO\ XVHOHVV$ VHHPLQJO\ VHQVHOHVV$ VHHPLQJO\LQFRPSUHKHQVLEOH$ EXW DW WKH VDPH WLPH VRPHWKLQJ DFWXDOO\EHDXWLIXO DQG JRRG$ ZKLFK FDQ EH DFKLHYHG RQO\ WKURXJKHIIRUW&

J\Y fYU` ZU]h\ UhhfUWhg dYcd`Y cZ ]hgY`Z bch VYWUigY ]hdfca]gYg [ccXbYgg hc h\cgY k\c VY`]YjY& Vih VYWUigY ]h ]gh\Y cb`m YgWUdY& bch cb`m Zfca U`` h\Y dfcV`Yag UbX hfcixV`Yg UbX a]gZcfhibYg cZ cif `]ZY& Vih U`gc Zfca h\Y ZYUf cZXYUh\(

5I \RX NQRZ WKDW \RX ODFN IDLWK$ NQRZ DOVR WKDW \RX DUH LQRQH RI WKH PRVW GDQJHURXV VLWXDWLRQV LQ WKLV ZRUOG D SHUVRQFDQ KH LQ&

?h ]g VUX bch hc \UjY gcaYh\]b[ Zcf k\]W\ mci UfY fYUXm hcX]Y(

Bcc_ Uh h\Y WUigYg cZ h\Y a]gZcfhibYg Zfca k\]W\aUb_]bX giZZYfg( Fig\ VYmcbX h\Y cVj]cig WUigYg hc h\Yfcch WUigYg& UbX mci k]`` ]bYj]hUV`m Z]bX h\Uh h\Y acghVUg]W& h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh WUigY cZ YUW\ UbX YjYfm cbY cZ\iaUb]hmrg dfcV`Yag ]g h\Y kYU_bYgg cZ ZU]h\ h\Uh WcaYgZfca U ZU`gY Uhh]hiXY hc h\Y kcf`X UbX ]hg cf][]b(

IU`jUh]cb `]Yg bch ]b f]hiU`g UbX bch ]b U dUfh]Wi`Uf WfYYX&Vih ]b U W`YUf ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ mcif `]ZY(

FJRUJOHJSÁÁ

FJRUJOHJSÁÂ

CRX FDQQRW VHUYH ERWK JRG DQG WKH GHYLO& 9HUHO\ WHQGLQJ WRWKH JURZWK RI \RXU ZHDOWK KDV QRWKLQJ WR GR ZLWK WKH UHTXLUHcPHQWV RI WKH WUXO\ VSLULWXDO OLIH&

?h gYYag hc aY h\Uh h\Y c`X dfY^iX]WY h\Uh kYU`h\ Vf]b[g\Udd]bYgg \Ug VY[ib hc VY X]gWfYX]hYX(

J\Y `cjY cZ [fYUh kYU`h\ WcaaYbXg mci& s8f]b[ aY mcifgci` Ug U gUWf]Z]WY&t UbX dYcd`Y k]`` Xc gc(


;lWYgg]jY XfYgg dfYjYbhg h\Y VcXm Zfca acj]b[ ZfYY`m(;lWYgg]jY kYU`h\ ]bhYfZYfYg k]h\ h\Y acjYaYbhg cZ cif gci`(

v:;CEIJ>;D;I

J\Y XYg]fY Zcf kYU`h\ WUb bYjYf VY gUh]gZ]YX( J\cgY k\c\UjY ]h UfY YlW]hYX Vm h\Y k]g\ hc \UjY acfY& UbX mYhacfY(


:c bch ZYUf dcjYfhm& Vih VYkUfY kYU`h\(

?Z cb`m dYcd`Y k\c gYY_ kYU`h\ Wci`X W`YUf`m gYY k\Uhh\Ym kci`X `cgY Vm \Uj]b[ ]h& h\Ym kci`X dih h\Y gUaYUacibh cZ YZZcfh ]bhc [Yhh]b[ f]X cZ h\]g kYU`h\ Ug h\Ymbck dih ]bhc UWei]f]b[ ]h(

FJRUJOHJSĄǼ

7 k]gY aUb XcYg bch k]g\ hc W\Ub[Y \]g g]hiUh]cb& VYWUigY\Y _bckg h\Uh ]h ]g dcgg]V`Y hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y Ùk cZ =cX& h\YÙk cZ `cjY& ]b YjYfm g]hiUh]cb(

7 k]gY aUb `cc_g Zcf YjYfmh\]b[ ]bg]XY cZ \]agY`Z5 U aUXxaUb gYY_g Zcf YjYfmh\]b[ ]b ch\Yfg(

? bYjYf WcadÙ]b UVcih am ZUhY( EbWY& ? X]X bch \UjYg\cYg& UbX ? WcadÙ]bYX hc =cX( ? kYbh ]bhc W\ifW\ k]h\U \YUjm \YUfh UbX ]b h\Y W\ifW\ ? gUk U aUb k]h\cih Vch\ZYYh( Ic ? h\Ub_YX =cX h\Uh \Y \UX []jYb aY Vch\ ZYYh&UbX h\Uh am cb`m dfcV`Ya kUg h\Uh h\Ym kYfY ibg\cX(

7 k]gY aUb ]bbUhY`m _bckg \ck hc UWh k]h\cih gYUfW\]b[&VYWUigY \Y \Ug h\Y X]j]bY k]h\]b \]agY`Z( J\Y Zifh\Yf mcigYUfW\ UbX gYY_& h\Y `Ygg mci _bck(

Oci g\ci`X hfYUh mcif h\ci[\hg h\Y kUm mci hfYUh mcifgY`Z& UbX hfYUh mcif k]g\Yg h\Y kUm mci hfYUh mcif W\]`XfYb(

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

Jfm hc YghUV`]g\ Ub ]bbYf g]`YbWY ]b mcifgY`Z& U Wcad`YhYg]`YbWY cZ mcif `]dg UbX mcif \YUfh( J\Yb mci k]`` \YUf\ck =cX gdYU_g hc ig& UbX mci k]`` _bck \ck hc Zi`Z]``>]g k]``(

v9ED<K9?KI

'CKIB?>'K:':?D I77:?

'B7E'JPK

?KH PRUH XSVHW D SHUVRQ LV ZLWK RWKHU SHRSOH$ DQG ZLWK FLUcFXPVWDQFHV$ DQG WKH PRUH VDWLVILHG KH LV ZLWK KLPVHOI$ WKH IXUcWKHU KH LV IURP ZLVGRP &

L]c`YbWY ]g \UfaZi` VYWUigY ]h ]g igiU``m XfYggYX ]b kYU`h\&UbX ]h h\YfYZcfY UfcigYg gcaY fYgdYWh Zcf h\cgY h\]b[gk\]W\ g\ci`X UfcigY X]g[igh(

FYcd`Y k\c \UjY dckYf UfY gifY h\Uh ]h ]g cb`m j]c`YbWYh\Uh [i]XYg dYcd`Y& UbX gc h\Ym igY j]c`YbWY hc giddcfhh\Y Yl]gh]b[ cfXYf( 8ih h\Y Yl]gh]b[ cfXYf ]g bch VUgYX cbj]c`YbWY& Vih cb diV`]W cd]b]cb(

7 dYfgcb ]g bch WfYUhYX Y]h\Yf hc giVXiY ch\Yfg& cf hc Zc`x`ck h\Y cfXYfg cZ ch\Yfg( FYcd`Y UfY WcffidhYX Vm Vch\kUmg cZ VY\Uj]cf( ?b h\Y Z]fgh h\Ym UggiaY hcc aiW\]adcfhUbWY& ]b h\Y gYWcbX& hcc `]hh`Y fYgdYWh( ?b Vch\ kUmgh\YfY ]g jYfm `]hh`Y X][b]hm(

vL?9JEH 9EDI?:;H7DJ

Eif `]ZY kci`X VYWcaY kcbXYfZi` ]Z kY Wci`X gYY U`` h\YX]g[igh]b[ h\]b[g k\]W\ Yl]gh ]b ]h(


IiVXi]b[ dYcd`Y h\fci[\ j]c`YbWY ]g bYjYf ^igh]WY(v8B7?I; F7I97B

>Y k\c XYdYbXg cb j]c`YbWY VY\UjYg kfcb[`m( J\Y aU_YfcZ VYUih]Zi` gdYYW\Yg ]g bch k]gY& cb`m \Y k\c ]g ZfYY Zfca\UhfYX UbX ZYUf ]g hfi`m k]gY(

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

-OO YLROHQFH LV FRQWUDU\ WR ORYH* GR QRW SDUWLFLSDWH LQYLROHQFH&

FJRUJOHJSÁÄ

J\Y V][[Ygh cVghUW`Yg hc ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Y hfih\ UfY `]YgX]g[i]gYX Ug hfih\(

?b fYU` `]ZY ]`ìg]cbg WUb cb`m hfUbgZcfa cif `]ZY Zcf UacaYbh& Vih ]b h\Y XcaU]b cZ h\ci[\hg UbX h\Y ]bhY``YWh&a]gWcbWYdh]cbg aUm VY UWWYdhYX Ug hfih\ Zcf h\cigUbXgcZ mYUfg& UbX aU_Y U Ùi[\]b[ghcW_ cZ k\c`Y bUh]cbg&aihY h\Y bcV`Y k]g\Yg cZ aUb_]bX& aU_Y gÙjYg Zfca dYcxd`Y UbX `]Y hc h\Ya( J\YgY a]gWcbWYdh]cbg UfY h\Y YbYa]Ygk]h\ k\]W\ h\Y k]gYgh aYb ]b h\Y \]ghcfm cZ aUb_]bX hfmhc ghfi[[`Y( J\Y ZcfWY cZ h\Y hfih\ ]g [fYUh& Vih ]hg j]Whcfm]g X]ZZ]Wi`h( >ckYjYf& cbWY mci fYWY]jY h\]g j]Whcfm& ]h WUbbYjYf VY hU_Yb Zfca mci(


?KH H[SRVXUH RI D OLH LV DV YDOXDEOH WR D FRPPXQLW\ DV DFOHDUO\ H[SUHVVHG WUXWK&

<fYY]b[ U dYfgcb Zfca a]gWcbWYdh]cbg& ZU`gY hfih\g& UbX`]Yg XcYg bch hU_Y Ubmh\]b[ Zfca \]a5 ]h []jYg \]a gcaYxh\]b[ ]adcfhUbh(


J\Y dfc[fYgg cZ aUb_]bX ]g ]b fYjYU`]b[ cVghUW`Yg k\]W\UfY \]X]b[ Zfca ig(

FJRUJOHJSÁĀ

FJRUJOHJSÁĂ

:ciVhg Xc bch XYghfcm hfih\5 h\Ym ghfYb[h\Yb ]h(

0LVEHOLHI LV QRW ZKHQ D SHUVRQ EHOLHYHV RU GRHV QRW EHOLHYH LQVRPHWKLQJ& 5W LV ZKHQ KH SURSKHVLHV WKRVH WKLQJV LQ ZKLFK KHGRHV QRW EHOLHYH&

v>7HH?;BC7HJ?D;7K

Oci k]`` \UjY acaYbhg ]b k\]W\ mci bc `cb[Yf VY`]YjY ]b"h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ h\Y gd]f]hiU` X]aYbg]cb cZ `]ZY( Bcc_ Uhh\YgY acaYbh/pUg YjYbhg ]b h\Y XYjY`cdaYbh cZ mcifZU]h\( 7 dYfgcb k\c ibXYfghUbXg h\Y gd]f]hiU` bUhifY cZ`]ZY aUm gh]`` Uh gcaY dc]bh VYWcaY UZfU]X cZ XYUh\& igiU``mZcf U g\cfh dYf]cX cZ h]aY& ]b h\Y gUaY kUm h\Uh mci WUbgYY Ug mci kUhW\ U gWYbY Uh h\Y h\YUhYf UbX Zcf[Yh h\Uh mciUfY kUhW\]b[ U d`Um& UbX VYWcaY gWUfYX Vm k\Uh mci UfYgYY]b[ Ug ]Z ]h kYfY fYU`(Ic ]h ]g ]b fYU` `]ZY4 ]b acaYbhg cZ gY`Z'XY`ig]cb& U fY`]x

[]cig dYfgcb Zcf[Yhg h\Uh k\Uh \UddYbg ]b \]g d\mg]WU` `]ZYWUbbch ]bhYfZYfY k]h\ k\Uh \UddYbg ]b \]g gd]f]hiU` ]]ZY(?b h\YgY dYf]cXg& k\Yb mcif gd]f]hg \UjY ZU``Yb& mci

\UjY hc hfYUh mcifgY`Z Ug Ub ]`` aUb(

7 k]gY aUb \Ug XciVhg YjYb ]b \]g VYgh acaYbhg( HYU`hfih\ ]g U`kUmg UWWcadUb]YX Vm \Yg]hUh]cbg( ?Z ? Wci`X bch\Yg]hUhY& ? Wci`X bch VY`]YjY(


>Y k\c \Yg]hUhYg ]g bch X]ghUbWYX Zfca =cX5 ]h ]g \Y k\cVY`]YjYg ib\Yg]hUh]b[`m ]b gcaYcbY Y`gYrg kcfX h\Uh =cXYl]ghg cf XcYg bch Yl]gh k\c ]g ZUf Zfca =cX(

J\Y ]bX]j]XiU` ckbYfg\]d cZ Ùf[Y UfYUg cZ ÙbX ]g Ugibîgh Ug h\Y ckbYfg\]d cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

Oci WUbbch gUm h\Uh h\Y Yl]gh]b[ Ùkg fY[UfX]b[ h\Y dcgxgYgg]cb cZ ÙbX UfY ÙkZi`( L]c`YbWY& Wf]aY& UbX dckYf\UjY h\Y]f gcifWY ]b h\YgY Ùkg(

v>;H8;HJ IF;D9;H

Ff]jUhY ckbYfg\]d cZ ÙbX WUaY hc VY& bch cih cZ Ubm bUhxifU` fYÙh]cbg\]dg VYhkYYb dYcd`Y& Vih h\fci[\ fcVVYfm(

v>;DHO =;EH=;

?KH LQMXVWLFH RI RZQLQJ ELJ SLHFHV RI ODQG DV SULYDWH SURSHUW\$OLNH DQ\ RWKHU LQMXVWLFH$ LV QHFHVVDULO\%OLQNHG ZLWK PDQ\RWKHU LQMXVWLFHV ZKLFK DUH XVHG WR SURWHFW LW&

FJRUJOHJSÁÅ

FJRUJOHJSÁǺ

B]ZYrg YggYbWY `]Yg& bch ]b mcif VcXm& Vih ]b mcif WcbxgW]YbWY(

J\Y X]j]bY gdUf_ `]jYg ]b U`` cZ ig& UbX dYfdYhiU``m ghf]jYghckUfX ]hg cf][]b(

ÅHP EPN7bbUYig IYbYWU

M\Yb mci gYY h\Uh YjYfmh\]b[ UfcibX mci ]g ]adYfaUxbYbh& h\Yb mci k]`` dYfWY]jY ch\Yf& dYfaUbYbh UbX YhYfbU`h\]b[g(


Oci WUbbch gYY h\Y gci`& Vih cb`m h\Y gci` WUb hfi`m gYYh\Y YggYbWY cZ h\]b[g(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

5 FDOO VSLULW WKDW SDUW RI PDQ ZKLFK KDV LQGHSHQGHQW H[LVWHQFHDQG JLYHV XV WKH XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI OLIH&

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

BYh mcif gd]f]hiU` g]XY [i]XY mcif aUhYf]U` g]XY& UbX bchh\Y ch\Yf kUm UfcibX( ?b cfXYf hc ]adfcjY \]g ghUhY& U dYfxgcb g\ci`X ghf]jY Zcf gd]f]hiU` bch d\mg]WU` dYfZYWh]cb(

Dch\]b[ WUb Yb`][\hYb dYcd`Yrg `]jYg UbX YUgY h\Y]f VifxXYbg acfY h\Ub h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ h\Uh h\Ym g\ci`X gYfjY=cX(

=HOLJLRXV GLVEHOLHI DQG QHJOHFW LV D JUHDW HYLO$ EXW SUHMXGLFHDQG OLHV DUH HYHQ ZRUVH&

vFBKJ7H9>KI

B]ZY ]g g\cfh( :c bch Zcf[Yh UVcih h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbhh\]b[g ]b cif `]ZY& `]j]b[ Zcf ch\Yf dYcd`Y UbX Xc]b[ [ccXZcf h\Ya(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\Y Icb cZ aUb WUaY bch hc VY a]b]ghYfYX ibhc& Vih hca]b]ghYf& UbX hc []jY \]g `]ZY Ug U fUbgca Zcf aUbm(

vC7JJ>;M ,*4,2

FUm [ccXbYgg Zcf Yj]`( MY g\ci`X VY `]_Y hfYYg h\Uh []jYZfi]hg hc h\cgY k\c h\fck ghcbYg Uh h\Ya(

Oci g\ci`X UWWYdh mcifgY`Z& bch Ug U aUghYf& Vih Ug U gYfxjUbh& UbX h\Yb U`` mcif VUX ZYY`]b[g& mcif Ubl]Yhm& U`Ufa&ibWYfhU]bhm& UbX X]ggUh]gZUWh]cb k]`` VY W\Ub[YX ]bhc WU`axbYgg UbX dYUWY( Oci k]`` VY Z]``YX ]bg]XY k]h\ U W`YUf j]g]cbcZ mcif difdcgY& UbX k]h\ U [fYUh ^cm5

FJRUJOHJSÁĄ

7`` [ccX h\]b[g WUb VY UW\]YjYX cb`m k]h\ YZZcfh(

.DG WKLQJV DUH HDV\ WR GR$ JRRG WKLQJV DUH GRQH RQO\ ZLWKZRUN DQG HIIRUW&


;bhYf Vm h\Y bUffck [UhY5 Zcf h\Y [UhY ]g k]XY& UbX h\Y kUm]g VfcUX h\Uh `YUXg hc XYghfiWh]cb& UbX aUbm UfY h\cgYk\c YbhYf Vm ]h( <cf h\Y [UhY ]g gaU``& UbX h\Y kUm ]g bUfxfck h\Uh `YUXg hc `]ZY& UbX ZYk UfY h\cgY k\c Z]bX ]h(

vC7JJ>;M 14+-'+.

J\Y kUm hc hfiY _bck`YX[Y XcYg bch [c h\fci[\ gcZh[fUgg WcjYfYX k]h\ Z`ckYfg( Jc Z]bX ]h& U dYfgcb aigh W`]aVghYYd acibhU]bg(

v@E>D HKIA?D

Bcc_ Zcf h\Y hfih\5 ]h kUbhg hc VY ZcibX(v8B7?I; F7I97B

7 dYfgcb Wf]Yg cih Zfca dU]b k\Yb \Y hU_Yg id \UfX d\mgx]WU` kcf_ UZhYf U dYf]cX cZ ]X`YbYgg( 7bm fYgh Zfca h\Yghfi[[`Y Zcf gd]f]hiU` ]adfcjYaYbh Vf]b[g h\Y gUaY dU]b(

FJRUJOHJSÂÀ

J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh UbX bYWYggUfm YldfYgg]cb cZ ZfYYXca]g hc []jY mcif h\ci[\h U gdYW]Z]W X]fYWh]cb(

BRUN WRZDUG WKH SXULILFDWLRQ RI \RXU WKRXJKWV& BLWKRXW KDGWKRXJKWV \RX ZLOO KH LQFDSDEOH RI EDG GHHGV&

v9ED<K9?KI

;jYfmh\]b[ ]g ]b \YUjYbrg dckYf& YlWYdh Zcf cif W\c]WY cZk\Yh\Yf hc gYfjY =cX cf cifgY`jYg(

MY WUbbch dfYjYbh V]fXg Zfca Z`m]b[ cjYf cif \YUXg& VihkY WUb _YYd h\Ya Zfca aU_]b[ bYghg cb hcd cZ cif \YUXg(I]a]`Uf`m& VUX h\ci[\hg gcaYh]aYg UddYUf ]b cif a]bX&Vih kY WUb W\ccgY k\Yh\Yf kY U``ck h\Ya hc `]jY h\YfY& hcWfYUhY U bYgh Zcf h\YagY`jYg& UbX hc VfYYX Yj]` XYYXg(

vC7HJ?D BKJ>;H

FJRUJOHJSÂÁ

?h ]g U g]b& bch cb`m hc Xc VUX h\]b[g& Vih YjYb hc h\]b_UVcih VUX h\]b[g(

'PEHE7IJ;H

<U]h\ ]b h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ YhYfb]hm ]g cif YlWìg]jY`m \iaUbeiU`]hm(

J\Y gci` XcYg bch `]jY ]b h\Y VcXm Ug ]b U \cigY& Vih Ug ]bU hYbh& U dÙWY cZ hYadcfUfm XkY``]b[(

v?D:?7D M?I:EC

M\c Vfci[\h aY ]bhc h\]g kcf`X6 7WWcfX]b[ hc k\cgYWcaaUbX Xc ? Z]bX amgY`Z Uh h\]g YlUWh dÙWY& Xif]b[ h\]gdUfh]WiÙf h]aY6 B]ZY ]g h\Y fYaYaVfUbWY cZ U jYfm g\cfhXUm kY gdYbh j]g]h]b[ h\]g kcf`X(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

CcfhU` dYcd`Y WUbbch `]jY `cb[5 kY \UjY cb`m U ZYkacaYbhg( 8ih cif gci` XcYg bch U[Y( ?h VY`]YjYg ]b YhYfbU`h\]b[g& UbX ]h k]`` `]jY Zcf U`` YhYfb]hm(

vJEH?9B?:JI

:YUh\ ]g h\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ h\Y VcX]`m cf[Ubg k]h\ k\]W\? gYY am kcf`X Xif]b[ am `]ZY5 h\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ h\Y [Ùggh\fci[\ k\]W\ ? `cc_ Uh h\]g kcf`X( J\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZh\]g [Ùgg XcYg bch aYUb h\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ h\Y YmY ]hgY`Z(

;XU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI HWHUQLW\ LV WKH YRLFH RI 3RG ZKR OLYHVZLWKLQ XV&

FJRUJOHJSÂÂ

FJRUJOHJSÆǼ

:R PDWWHU ERZ ELJ PDQNLQG_V VWRUH RI NQRZOHGJH VHHPV WRPH LQ FRPSDULVRQ ZLWK RXU SUHYLRXV LJQRUDQFH$ LW LV RQO\ DQLQILQLWHO\ VPDOO SDUW RI DOO SRVVLEOH NQRZOHGJH&

IcWfUhYg X]X bch \UjY h\Y kYU_bYgg cZ aUbm gW\cÙfg& h\YXYg]fY hc _bck UVcih U`` dcgg]V`Y h\]b[g& hc `YUfb h\Y cf]x[]bg UbX YldÙbUh]cbg cZ h\]b[gvk\Uh h\Y Icd\]ghg WU``sh\Y bUhifY cZ h\]b[gtvUbX hc ibWcjYf h\Y cf][]bg cZ h\YWY`Ygh]U` VcX]Yg( IcWfUhYg gU]X& s?g ]h hfiY h\Uh dYcd`Y UfY gcWcbWYfbYX k]h\ h\YgY YUfh\`m h\]b[g6 FYcd`Y kfcb[`mh\]b_ h\Uh h\Ym g\ci`X _bck YjYfmh\]b[( J\Ym h\]b_ h\Uhh\Ym WUb XYgd]gY h\Y acgh bYWYggUfm UbX ]adcfhUbh Z]Y`XgcZ _bck`YX[Y& UbX dYbYhfUhY h\Y amghYf]Yg h\Uh Xc bchVY`cb[ hc ig(t

vN;DEF>ED

Dch cb`m ]g fYU` gW]YbWY bch \cgh]`Y hc fY`][]cb& ]b ZUWh fYU`gW]YbWY U`kUmg giddcfhg ]h(

v@E>D HKIA?D

Abck`YX[Y ]g `]a]h`Ygg& UbX h\Y acgh gW\cÙf`m UbX YXiWUhYXdYfgcb ]g Ug ZUf Zfca hfiY _bck`YX[Y Ug Ub ibYXiWUhYXdYUgUbh(

v@E>D HKIA?D

MY WUbbch ]aU[]bY h\Y gWcdY cZ cif ][bcfUbWY& îgh Ug UV`]bX aUb WUbbch ]aU[]bY XUf_bYgg ibh]` \Y WUb gYY(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?h ]g VYhhYf hc _bck `Ygg h\Ub bYWYggUfm h\Ub hc _bckacfY h\Ub bYWYggUfm( :c bch ZYUf h\Y ÙW_ cZ _bck`YX[Y&Vih hfi`m ZYUf ibbYWYggUfm _bck`YX[Y k\]W\ ]g UWei]fYXcb`m hc d`YUgY jUb]hm(

FJRUJOHJSÂÄ

?h kci`X VY dcgg]V`Y hc YUh aYUh ]Z ]h kYfY îgh]Z]YX Vm UbmgYf]cig Wcbg]XYfUh]cbg( 8ih ]h ]gbrh5 UbX aYUh YUh]b[ ]g g]axd`m U VUX h\]b[ h\Uh Yl]ghg k]h\cih Ubm îgh]Z]WUh]cb Uh U``(

BKDW QDWXUH RI VWUXJJOH IRU H[LVWHQFH RU NLQG RI PDGQHVVIRUFHV \RX WR VKHG EORRG ZLWK \RXU KDQGV LQ RUGHU WR HDW DQLcPDOV, BK\ GR WKLV$ LI \RX KDYH DOO WKH FRPIRUWV RI OLIH,

vFBKJ7H9>

?Z ]h kYfY bch gc V`]bX`m UWWYdhYX Ug U dUfh cZ cif WighcagUbX hfUX]h]cbg& \ck Wci`X Ubm gYbg]h]jY dYfgcb UWWYdh h\Yh\ci[\h h\Uh ]b cfXYf hc ZYYX cifgY`jYg kY g\ci`X _]``giW\ U \i[Y biaVYf cZ Ub]aU`g& ]b gd]hY cZ h\Y ZUWh h\Uh cifYUfh\ []jYg ig gc aUbm X]ZZYfYbh hfYUgifYg Zfca dÙbhg6

J\YfY ]g U V][ X]ZZYfYbWY VYhkYYb& cb h\Y cbY \UbX& U dYfxgcb k\c XcYg bch \UjY UWWYgg hc Ubm ZccX YlWYdh aYUh&UbX cb h\Y ch\Yf& Ub YXiWUhYX dYfgcb cZ hcXUm k\c `]jYg ]bU Wcibhfm k\]W\ \Ug jY[YhUV`Yg UbX a]`_ ]b UVibXUbWY&UbX k\c ]g ]bghfiWhYX U[U]bgh aYUh YUh]b[( J\Y YXiWUhYXdYfgcb g]bg [fYUh`m ]Z \Y Wcbh]biYg hc VY\UjY ]b U kUm \Y_bckg ]g kfcb[(

FJRUJOHJSÆĆ

Mcf_ ]g bch U j]fhiY& Vih ]h ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ Uj]fhicig `]ZY(

>iff]YX kcf_ XcbY ]b ]ff]hUh]cb UhhfUWhg h\Y ibZUjcfUV`YUhhYbh]cb cZ ch\Yfg( HYU` kcf_ ]g U`kUmg ei]Yh& WcbghUbh&UbX ]bWcbgd]Wicig(

5W LV QRW HQRXJK WR KH D KDUGZRUNLQJ SHUVRQ& ?KLQN* ZKDW GR\RX ZRUN DW,


<cf YjYfm ]X`Y dYfgcb& h\YfY ]g Ubch\Yf dYfgcb k\c kcf_ghcc aiW\( <cf YjYfm dYfgcb k\c YUhg hc YlWYgg& h\YfY ]gUbch\Yf dYfgcb gcaYk\YfY k\c ]g \ib[fm4

CiW\ cZ h\Y UWh]j]hm cZ ]X`Y dYcd`Y k\c dfYhYbX h\Uh h\YmUfY Vigm k]h\ kcf_ ]g aYfY`m YbhYfhU]b]b[5 ]h ^igh UXXg UVifXYb hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y( J\]g WUb VY gU]X cZ U`` `ilif]UbhYbhYfhU]baYbhg(

FJRUJOHJSÂĂ

7`` hfiY k]gXca UbX U`` hfiY ZU]h\ UfY W`YUf`m YldfYggYX ]bh\Y gUaY acfU` Ùk(

7`` h\Y kcf`X ]g giV^YWh hc cbY Ùk& UbX U`` h\]b_]b[ VY]b[g\UjY h\Y gUaY VUg]W ]bhY``YWh( J\YfYZcfY& U`` k]gY aYbg\UfY h\Y gUaY ]XYU cZ dYfZYWh]cb(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\Y acfY ? XYX]WUhY am h]aY hc hkc h\]b[g& h\Y acfY h\YmZ]`` am `]ZY k]h\ YjYf']bWfYUg]b[ d`YUgifY( J\Y Z]fgh ]g h\Yg_m UVcjY aY& UbX h\Y gYWcbX ]g h\Y acfU` Ùk k]h\]b aY(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?KHUHIRUH DOO WKLQJV ZKDWVRHYHU \H ZRXOG WKDW PHQ VKRXOG GRWR \RX$ GR \H HYHQ VR WR WKHP* IRU WKLV LV WKH ODZ DQG WKH

SURSKHWV&vC7JJ>;M 14+,

CcfU` Ùk ]g gc cVj]cig UbX W`YUf h\Uh YjYb dYcd`Y k\c Xcbch _bck h\Y Ùk \UjY bc YlWigY Zcf j]cÙh]b[ ]h( J\Ym\UjY cb`m cbY fYWcifgY4 hc XYbm h\Y]f ]bhY``YWh& k\]W\h\Ym Xc(

FJRUJOHJSÂÅ

8Ùa]b[ ch\Yfg ]g Ub YbhYfhU]baYbh k\]W\ gcaY dYcd`Y`]_Y UbX WUbbch fYghfU]b h\YagY`jYg Zfca( M\Yb mci gYYU`` h\Y \Ufa h\]g VÙa]b[ WUigYg& mci gYY h\Uh ]h ]g U g]b bchhc ghcd dYcd`Y Zfca dfUWh]W]b[ h\]g YbhYfhU]baYbh(

?Z mci kUbh hc VÙaY aY& mci g\ci`X bch VY k]h\ aY( Ocig\ci`X VY ]bg]XY aY(

v7:7C C?9A?;M?9P

?UXWK LV DFKLHYHG WKURXJK GLVFXVVLRQ$ KXW WKH ZLVHU PDQ VWRSVWKH DUJXPHQWV&

Eif [fYUhYgh ]adYfZYWh]cbg UfY ]b cif ]bbYf j]g]cb( MY UfYgc g\cfhg][\hYX h\Uh kY WUbbch gYY VUX h\]b[g ]b ch\Yfg&Vih kY WUbbch Z]bX VUX h\]b[g ]b cifgY`jYg Ug kY``(

v;:M7H: 8HEMD

7g gccb Ug mci ghUfh VÙa]b[ U dYfgcb& ghcd mcifgY`Z(HYaYaVYf bch hc gUm gcaYh\]b[ VUX UVcih gcaYcbY&YjYb ]Z mci _bck ]h hc VY hfiY& UbX YgdYW]U``m ]Z mci UfYbch WYfhU]b Vih UfY cb`m fYdYUh]b[ [cgg]d(

FJRUJOHJSÂǺ

Ccgh dYcd`Y UWh& bch UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y]f aYX]hUh]cbg& UbXbch UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y]f ZYY`]b[g& Vih Ug ]Z \mdbch]nYX&VUgYX cb gcaY gYbgY`Ygg fYdYh]h]cb cZ dUhhYfbg(

CRX VKRXOG EH EUDYH HQRXJK WR XVH \RXU RZQ LQWHOOHFW$ LQ OLIH

DQG LQ \RXU HGXFDWLRQ&v?CC7DK;B AUbh

?Z& Uacb[ h\Y aUbm jc]WYg k\]W\ gdYU_ ]b am gci`& ?Wci`X cb`m fYWc[b]nY am gci`rg hfiY jc]WY& h\Yb ? kci`XbYjYf aU_Y a]ghU_Yg& UbX bYjYf Xc Yj]`( J\]g ]g k\m ]h ]gbYWYggUfm hc _bck mcifgY`Z(

?Z mci gYY h\Uh mci UfY bch VY\Uj]b[ UWWcfX]b[ hc mcif]bbYf XYg]fYg& Vih VYWUigY cZ gcaY cihYf ]bZ`iYbWY& ghcdUbX Wcbg]XYf k\Yh\Yf k\Uh Xf]jYg mci ]g [ccX cf VUX(

FJRUJOHJSÆĊ

McfgY h\Ub U`` h\Y hfciV`Yg UbX \cffcfg cZ kUf ]g h\Y dYfxjYfg]cb cZ a]bXgYh WUigYg( 7fa]Yg Yl]gh UbX h\Y Wcgh cZkUf Yl]ghg& UbX dYcd`Y aigh kfYgh`Y hc Z]bX YldÙbUh]cbg Zcfk\Uh Yl]ghg( MUf WUbbch VY YldÙ]bYX k]h\ h\Y ]bhY``YWh& gchc îgh]Zm ]h& dYcd`Y WfYUhY ]bhY``YWhiU` dYfjYfg]cbg(

5V WKHUH DQ\WKLQJ PRUH DEVXUG WKDQ D SHUVRQ KDYLQJ D ULJKW WRNLOO PH EHFDXVH ZH OLYH RQ WZR RSSRVLWH EDQNV RI WKH ULYHU$ DQGRXU NLQJV TXDUUHO ZLWK HDFK RWKHU ,

v8B7?I; F7I97B

J\Y h]aY k]`` WcaY k\Yb dYcd`Y k]`` ibXYfghUbX h\Y ghixd]X]h]Yg cZ kUf(

T v9>7HB;I H?9>;

;ifcdYUb Wcibhf]Yg \UjY UVcih Zcif a]``]cb dYcd`Y gYfjx]b[ ]b h\Y Ufam( Jkc h\]fXg cZ h\Y]f ViX[Yh UfY gdYbh cba]`]hUfm gdYbX]b[(

v=KIJ7L; :; CEB?D7H?

:c bch hfm hc îgh]Zm kUf cf h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ h\Y a]`]hUfm(?Z mci hfm hc Udd`m `c[]WU` h\ci[\h hc YldÙ]b h\]b[g h\UhUfY Yj]`& h\Y YZZcfh k]`` cb`m dfYjYbh mcif ]bhY``YWh UbX dc]xgcb mcif \YUfh(

FJRUJOHJSÃÀ

J\Y acfY `cbY`m U dYfgcb ]g& h\Y acfY W`YUf`m \Y WUb \YUfh\Y jc]WY cZ =cX(

J\Y k]`` hc UWWcad`]g\ mcif [ccX ]bhYbh]cbg XYdYbXg cbk\Yh\Yf mci jc]WY h\Ya( Oci fYaYaVYf h\Y h\]b[g cZk\]W\ mci gdc_Y ]b mcif mcih\ Ug ]Z h\Ym kYfY Z`ckYfgh\Uh mci hcfY cih cZ U Z`ckYf VYX UbX h\fYk UkUm& UbX h\YbgUk `m]b[ cb h\Y YUfh\& ZUXYX ]bhc h\Y X]fh(

?b h\Y ]adcfhUbh eiYgh]cbg cZ `]ZY& kY UfY U`kUmg U`cbY(Eif XYYdYgh ]bbYf h\ci[\hg WUbbch VY ibXYfghccX Vm ch\xYfg( J\Y VYgh dUfh cZ h\Y XfUaU h\Uh [cYg cb XYYd ]b cifgci` ]g U acbc`c[iY& cf& VYhhYf hc gUm& U jYfm g]bWYfY WcbxjYfgUh]cb VYhkYYb =cX& cif WcbgW]YbWY& UbX cifgY`Z(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

?HPSRUDU\ VROLWXGH IURP DOO WKLQJV LQ WKLV OLIH$ WKH PHGLWDcWLRQ ZLWKLQ \RXUVHOI DERXW WKH GLYLQH$ LV IRRG DV QHFHVVDU\ IRU\RXU VRXO DV PDWHULDO IRRG LV IRU \RXU ERG\&

EIUQHJSÁ

7 gU[Y ]g bch UZfU]X cZ ÙW_ cZ _bck`YX[Y4 \Y ]gcZ \Yg]hUh]cbg& cf \UfX kcf_& Vih \Y ]g UZfU]X cZh\]b[vhc dfYhYbX hc _bck h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ \Y_bck(

Oci g\ci`X ghiXm acfY hc ibXYfghUbX h\Uh mci _bck `]hh`Y(vC?9>;B :<( CEDJ7?=D;

DYjYf VY Ug\UaYX hc UXa]h k\Uh mci Xc bch _bck(v7H78?9 FHEL;H8

<XW HYHU\WKLQJ WR WKH WHVW$ KROGIDVW WR WKDW ZKLFK LV JRRG&

v? J>;II7BED?7DI /4,+

HYU` k]gXca WcaYg& bch Zfca _bck]b[ k\Uh ]g [ccX UbXk\Uh g\ci`X VY XcbY& Vih Zfca _bck]b[ k\]W\ ]g h\Y VYhxhYf h\]b[ UbX k\]W\ ]g h\Y kcfgY& UbX h\YfYZcfY& k\Uhg\ci`X VY XcbY UbX k\Uh g\ci`X VY XcbY ÙhYf(

Jc VY k]gY cbY aigh ghiXm Vch\ [ccX UbX VUX h\ci[\hgUbX UWhg& Vih cbY g\ci`X ghiXm h\Y VUX Z]fgh( Oci g\ci`XZ]fgh _bck k\Uh ]g QRW W`YjYf& k\Uh ]g QRW îgh& UbX k\Uh ]gQRW bYWYggUfm hc Xc(

bch UZfU]Xcb`m cbYXcYg bch

EIUQHJSÂ

HY`][]cb ]g h\Uh k\]W\ hY``g U dYfgcb k\c \Y ]g UbX k\Uhh\Y bUhifY cZ h\Y kcf`X ]b k\]W\ \Y `]jYg ]g

MY g\ci`X hYUW\ cif W\]`XfYb h\cgY df]bW]d`Yg h\Uh UfYWcaacb hc U`` fY`][]cbgv8iXX\]gh& Cig`]a& 9\f]gh]Ub&@Yk]g\& UbX gc cb& h\Uh ]g& Zcf h\Y acfU` gW]YbWY cZ `cjYUbX h\Y ib]Z]WUh]cb cZ U`` dYcd`Y(

9RVW SHRSOH GR QRW OLVWHQ WR 3RG EXW DGRUH KLP& 5W LV EHWWHU

QRW WR DGRUH EXW WR OLVWHQ&

CcfU` hYUW\]b[ ]g bch Wcad`YhY ]Z ]h ]g bch fY`][]cig& VihfY`][]cig hYUW\]b[ ]g igY`Ygg ]Z ]h ]g bch VUgYX cb acfU`]hm&h\Uh ]g& ]Z ]h XcYg bch `YUX hc U [ccX `]ZY(

EIUQHJSÃ

8][ kYU`h\ k]`` bch []jY mci gUh]gZUWh]cb( J\Y acfY mcifkYU`h\ [fckg& h\Y acfY mcif fYei]fYaYbhg [fck k]h\ ]h(

5W LV GLIILFXOW LI QRW LPSRVVLEOH WR ILQG VRPH UHDVRQDEOH OLPLWIRU DFTXLULQJ PRUH DQG PRUH SURSHUW\&


Oci g\ci`X UWei]fY h\Y _]bX cZ kYU`h\ k\]W\ WUbbch VYghc`Yb Zfca mci Vm h\]YjYg& k\]W\ dYcd`Y ]b dckYf WUbbchhU_Y Zfca mci& k\]W\ k]`` ghUm k]h\ mci YjYb UZhYf mcifXYUh\& bYjYf X]a]b]g\]b[ UbX bYjYfX]gUddYUf]b[( J\]gkYU`h\ ]g mcif gci`(

v?D:?7D FHEL;H8

J\YfY UfY hkc kUmg bch hc giZZYf Zfca dcjYfhm J\Y Z]fgh ]ghc UWei]fY acfY kYU`h\( J\YgYWcbX ]g hc `]a]h mciffYei]fYaYbhg( J\Y Z]fgh ]g bch U`kUmg k]h\]b cif dckYf&Vih h\Y gYWcbX ]g U`kUmg ]b cif dckYf(

EIUQHJSÄ

HYU` `cjY fYZYfg bch ^igh hc `cjY Zcf U dUfh]Wi`Uf dYfgcb Vihhc h\Y gd]f]hiU` ghUhY cZ `cj]b[ YjYfmcbY(

Jc `cjY aYUbg hc `]jY k]h\]b h\Y `]jYg cZ h\cgY k\ca mci`cjY(

0R QRW IRUFH RWKHUV WR ORYH \RX* MXVW ORYH RWKHUV$ DQG \RX ZLOOKH ORYHG&

7 \c`m dYfgcb"g `]jYg ]b h\Y kcf`X& Vih \Y ]g WcbWYfbYXacgh cZ U`` UVcih \]g Uhh]hiXY hc dYcd`Y( >Y WUb ZYY` U``dYcd`Y& UbX \Y WUb gYbgY U`` dYcd`Y& UbX U`` dYcd`Y hifbh\Y]f YUfg UbX YjYg hc \]a(

vB7E'JPK

M]h\cih `cjY bch\]b[ WUb Vf]b[ mci [ccXbYgg& UbX YjYfmUWh]cb ]bgd]fYX k]h\ `cjY& YjYb ]Z ]h gYYag gaU`` UbX ib]axdcfhUbh& k]`` Vf]b[ mci gcaY Zfi]hg UZhYfkUfX(


HY`][]cb ]g h\Y \][\Ygh Zcfa cZ `cjY(vJ>;E:EH; F7HA;H

J\Y acfY U dYfgcb YldfYggYg \]g `cjY& h\Y acfY dYcd`Y`cjY \]a5 UbX h\Y acfY dYcd`Y `cjY \]a& h\Y YUg]Yf ]h ]g Zcf\]a hc `cjY ch\Yfg( ?b h\]g kUm& `cjY ]g YhYfbU`(

EIUQHJSĆ

Ocif gd]f]h aigh WcbghUbh`m UggYfh ]hgY`Z VYWUigY mcifVcXm ]g WcbghUbh`m YlYfh]b[ ]hgY`Z( 7g gccb Ug mci ghcdkcf_]b[ Uh mcif gd]f]h& h\Yb mcif VcXm k]`` \UjY Wcad`YhYdckYf cjYf mci(

M\Uh ]g bch W`YUf g\ci`X VY W`YUfYX id( M\Uh ]g bch YUgm hcXc g\ci`X VY XcbY k]h\ [fYUh dYfg]ghYbWY(

v9ED<K9?KI

MY giZZYf Zfca cif j]WYg& UbX hfm hc ghfi[[`Y k]h\ h\Ya&UbX h\Y fYUgcb Zcf h\]g ghfi[[`Y ]g h\Uh kY UfY bch dYfZYWh(8ih cif gU`jUh]cb ]g ]b h\]g ghfi[[`Y k]h\ j]WYg& UbX ]Z =cXkYfY hc hU_Y UkUm cif UV]`]hm hc Z][\h cif j]WYg& h\Yb kYkci`X VY `YZh k]h\ h\Ya ZcfYjYf(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

7 [ccX h\]b[ ]g U`kUmg XcbY k]h\ Ub YZZcfh& UbX k\Yb h\YYZZcfh ]g fYdYUhYX gYjYfU` h]aYg& h\Yb U [ccX h\]b[VYWcaYg U \UV]h(

0R QRW GHWHVW DQ\ DFWLRQ ZKLFK KHOSV \RX WR DFKLHYH JRRG$ RUHYHQ PRUH LPSRUWDQWO\bZKLFK FDQ SUHYHQW \RX IURP GRLQJHYLO&

EIUQHJSĂ

?``bYgg g\ci`X VY j]YkYX Ug U bUhifU` WcbX]h]cb cZ `]ZY(

DY[`YWh]b[ mcif \YU`h\ WUb dfYjYbh mci Zfca gYfj]b[dYcd`Y& UbX hcc aiW\ UhhYbh]cb hc mcif VcXm UbX ]hg\YU`h\ WUb Vf]b[ h\Y gUaY fYgi`hg( ?b cfXYf hc Z]bX h\Ya]XX`Y kUm& mci g\ci`X hU_Y WUfY cZ mcif VcXm cb`m hc h\YYlhYbh h\Uh Xc]b[ gc \Y`dg mci hc gYfjY ch\Yfg& UbX XcYgbch ghcd mci Zfca gYfj]b[ h\Ya(

Dc ]``bYgg WUb dfYjYbh U dYfgcb Zfca k\Uh \Y \Ug hc Xc( ?Zmci WUbbch kcf_& h\Yb []jY mcif `cjY hc dYcd`Y(

?``bYggYg cZ h\Y a]bX UfY aiW\ acfY XUb[Yfcig h\Ub ]``xbYggYg cZ h\Y VcXm(


0R QRW EH DIUDLG$ RI LOOQHVV$ DQG GR QRW WKLQN WKDW EHLQJ LOOIUHHV \RX IURP \RXU PRUDO UHTXLUHPHQWV&

EIUQHJSĈ

Oci WUb WU`` =cX Vm jUf]cig bUaYg& mci WUb Ujc]X \]gbUaY U`hc[Yh\Yf& Vih mci WUbbch Ujc]X UWWYdh]b[ \]g Yl]gxhYbWY( Dch\]b[ Yl]ghg \YfY ]Z =cX XcYg bch Yl]gh(

7`` ? _bck ? _bck VYWUigY h\YfY ]g =cX& UbX ? _bck >]aVYWUigY >Y []jYg aY h\Y _bck`YX[Y cZ YjYfmh\]b[(

BYh ig h\]b_ UVcih =cX& fYaYaVYf >]a& UbX hU`_ hc >]aUg cZhYb Ug kY WUb(

v;F?9J;JKI

3RG LV QRW DQ LGRO+ KH LV DQ LGHDO ZKLFK ZH VKRXOG VWULYH IRULQ RXU HYHU\GD\ OLIH&

vBK9O C7BBEHO

?h ]g jYfm ]adcfhUbh hc fYaYaVYf =cX& bch bYWYggUf]`mk]h\ kcfXg& Vih ]b h\Y gYbgY cZ VY]b[ UkUfY cZ >]a Zc`x`ck]b[ mcif UWh]cbg& giddcfh]b[ h\Ya cf Wf]h]W]n]b[ h\Ya(Higg]Ub dYUgUbhg \UjY U gUm]b[4 s:c mci fYaYaVYf =cX6t

EIUQHJSǺ

Eb`m dYcd`Y k\c \UjY bYjYf h\ci[\h UVcih `]ZYrg acgh]adcfhUbh ]ggiYg WUb VY`]YjY h\Uh YjYfmh\]b[ ]g dcgg]V`YZcf h\Y \iaUb ]bhY``YWh(

J\YfY UfY h\fYY hmdYg cZ dYcd`Y( <]fgh& h\YfY UfY dYcd`Yk\c Xc bch VY`]YjY ]b Ubmh\]b[5 h\Yb& h\YfY UfY dYcd`Yk\c VY`]YjY cb`m ]b h\cgY hYUW\]b[g h\Ym kYfY Vfci[\h idhc VY`]YjY( <]bU``m& h\YfY UfY dYcd`Y k\c VY`]YjY ]b h\cgYh\]b[g k\]W\ h\Ym ibXYfghUbX k]h\ h\Y]f \YUfhg& UbX h\]g`Ugh [fcid cZ dYcd`Y ]g h\Y k]gYgh UbX acgh fYgc`ihY(

7`` VY[]bb]b[g UfY amghYf]Yg& h\Y amghYfm cZ WfYUh]cb(v>;DH? 7C?;B

9cbhYadcfUfm gW]YbWY WUbbch hYUW\ mci UVcih =cX UbX>]g j]fhiYg( J\Y gW]YbWYg WUbbch aU_Y mci j]fhicig& Vihh\Ym \Y`d mci cb mcif kUm( $ # !#" 7bbUYig IYbYWU0R QRW SUHWHQG WR XQGHUVWDQG VRPHWKLQJ WKDW \RX GR QRW& 5WLV RQH RI WKH ZRUVW SRVVLEOH WKLQJV WR GR&

EIUQHJSĄ

7 dYfgcb k\c WcaYg ]bhc Ub ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y `]ZY cZ\]g gd]f]hiU` gY`Z WUbbch ZYUf Yj]`& Y]h\Yf ]b `]ZY cf ]b XYUh\(

?KDW ZKLFK LV KRUQ RI WKH IOHVK LV IOHVK+ DQG WKDW ZKLFK LV KRUQRI WKH >SLULW LV VSLULW& CUfjY` bch h\Uh ? gU]X ibhc h\YY& OYaigh VY Vca U[U]b( J\Y k]bX V`ckYh\ k\YfY ]h `]ghYh\&UbX h\ci \YUfYgh h\Y gcibX h\YfYcZ& Vih WUbgh bch hY``k\YbWY ]h WcaYh\& UbX k\]h\Yf ]h [cYh\4 gc ]g YjYfm cbYh\Uh ]g Vca cZ h\Y Id]f]h(

v@c\b -40'2

J\Y gci`g cZ k]gY dYcd`Y `cc_ hc h\Y ZihifY ghUhY cZ h\Y]fYl]ghYbWY5 U`` cZ h\Y]f h\ci[\hg UfY WcbWYbhfUhYX hckUfXYhYfb]hm(


J\YfY ]g bch U g]b[`Y gci` h\Uh WUb VY [ccX k]h\cih =cX(vBiW]ig 7DD7;KI I;D;97

IU`jUh]cb ]b U`` h\]b[g `]Yg ]b h\Y]f gd]f]hiU`]hm( ;j]` WUbbchhciW\ U dYfgcb k\c _bckg \]g gd]f]hiU`]hm(

EIUQHJSÁÀ

7 aUb ]g Vch\ Ub Ub]aU` UbX U gd]f]hiU` VY]b[ Uh h\Y gUaYh]aY( 7g Ub Ub]aU`& U aUb ]g UZfU]X cZ XYUh\5 Ug U gd]f]hiU`VY]b[ \Y XcYg bch YldYf]YbWY XYUh\(

5Q WKH ODVW PRPHQWV EHIRUH GHDWK$ WKH VRXO OHDYHV WKH ERG\& 5WXQLWHV ZLWK WKH OLPLWOHVV$ WLPHOHVV$ DQG HWHUQDO VRXO DQGWUDQVIRUPV LQWR DQRWKHU IRUP$ ZH NQRZ QRW ZKLFK& -IWHUGHDWK$ RXU ERG\ LV OHIW EHKLQG$ DQG LW EHFRPHV RQO\ DQ REMHFWIRU REVHUYDWLRQ&

:YUh\ aUf_g U W\Ub[Y& ]h aUf_g h\Y X]gUddYUfUbWY cZ h\YXkY``]b[ d`UWY cZ mcif WcbgW]YbWY( J\Y WcbgW]YbWY ]hgY`ZWUbbch VY XYghfcmYX Vm XYUh\& ]b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug h\YW\Ub[Y cZ U h\YUhYf gYh WUbbch XYghfcm U gdYWhUhcf(

FYf\Udg mci ZYUf h\Y W\Ub[Yg h\Uh XYUh\ k]`` Vf]b[68ih U g]a]`Uf [fYUh W\Ub[Y U`fYUXm \UddYbYX Uh h\Y h]aY

cZ mcif V]fh\& UbX bch\]b[ VUX WUaY cih cZ ]h(

EIUQHJSÁÁ

Ccgh dYcd`Y UfY dfciX& bch cZ h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ UfcigYfYgdYWh& Vih cZ h\cgY k\]W\ UfY ibbYWYggUfm& cf YjYb\UfaZi`4 ZUaY& dckYf& UbX kYU`h\(

J\YfY ]g bc kcfgY gWcibXfY` h\Ub \Y k\c& k\Yb VY `cc_gUfcibX \]agY`Z Uh ch\Yf dYcd`Y& WUb U`kUmg Z]bX Ub YjYbkcfgY gWcibXfY` h\Ub \]agY`Z5 UbX h\YfYZcfY& WUb VY ei]hYgUh]gZ]YX k]h\ \]agY`Z(

7 dYfgcb k\c `cjYg \]agY`Z \Ug h\Y UXjUbhU[Y cZ \Uj]b[jYfm ZYk WcadYh]hcfg(

?KHUH LV QR ZLVGRP LQ KH ZKR WKLQNV WKDW KH LV ZLVH&

7 gY`Z]g\ dYfgcb ]g U`kUmg `]a]hYX( 7bX cbY ]g WcbbYWhYXk]h\ h\Y ch\Yf4 \Y ]g gY`Z]g\ VYWUigY \Y ]g `]a]hYX5 \Y ]g`]a]hYX VYWUigY \Y ]g gY`Z]g\(

7 dfciX dYfgcb ]b]h]U``m WUigYg ch\Yf dYcd`Y hc h\]b_ h\Uh\Y \Ug acfY ]adcfhUbWY h\Ub \Y UWhiU``m \Ug& Vih k\Ybh\]g ]bZ`iYbWY X]gUddYUfg& Ug ]h U`kUmg XcYg& \Y VYWcaYgcb`m h\Y cV^YWh cZ ^c_Yg(

EIUQHJSÁÂ

-Q\ GHSDUWXUH IURP DFFHSWHG WUDGLWLRQV DQG FXVWRPVUHTXLUHV D ODUJH DQG VHULRXV HIIRUW$ EXW WUXH XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RIQHZ WKLQJV DOZD\V UHTXLUHV VXFK DQ HIIRUW&

7 gcW]Yhm gUmg hc U aUb4 sJ\]b_ Ug kY h\]b_&'VY`]YjY ]bk\Uh kY VY`]YjY& YUh UbX Xf]b_ k\Uh kY YUh UbX Xf]b_& UbXXfYgg ]b h\Y kUm kY XfYgg(t

vBK9O C7BEHO

Oci g\ci`X VY\UjY Ug mci h\]b_ ]g [ccX& Vih bch Zc``ckx]b[ h\Y UXj]WY cZ h\Y WfckX(


?h ]g VUX hc ]ff]hUhY dYcd`Y Vm ghYdd]b[ VUW_ Zfca h\Y]fWighcag UbX hfUX]h]cbg& Vih ]h ]g YjYb kcfgY hc XYbm h\YfYei]fYaYbhg cZ mcif WcbgW]YbWY UbX ]bhY``YWh Vm Zc``ckx]b[ h\Y Wighcag cZ h\Y WfckX(

EIUQHJS ĄǼ

7 ghUhY gmghYa& bc aUhhYf k\Uh _]bX cZ ghUhY gmghYa ]h ]g&ZibWh]cbg Uh U ZUf fYacjY Zfca h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ 9\f]gxh]Ub]hm(

?b h\cgY Wcibhf]Yg k\YfY k]gY dYcd`Y UfY ]b dckYf& h\Y]fgiV^YWhg Xc bch bch]WY h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ h\Y]f fi`Yfg(

vB7E'JPK

IhUhY j]c`YbWY WUbbch VY XYghfcmYX Vm XYWfYY& cb`m Vmhfih\ UbX `cjY( CUmVY ghUhY j]c`YbWY kUg bYWYggUfm ZcfdfYj]cig [YbYfUh]cbg5 aUmVY ]h ]g YjYb bYWYggUfm bck& VihdYcd`Y g\ci`X WcbWY]jY cZ U _]bX cZ ZihifY [cjYfbaYbh ]bk\]W\ j]c`YbWY k]`` bch VY bYWYggUfm(

CRX VKRXOG OLYH LQ VXFK D ZD\ WKDW YLROHQFH LV QRW QHFHVVDU\IRU \RX&

EIUQHJSÁĂ

=cX ]g ]b U`` cZ ig& UbX ]h ]g dcgg]V`Y Zcf U`` cZ ig hc Z]bX UbXibXYfghUbX \]a h\YfY(

Jc _bck mcifgY`Z ]g hc X]gWcjYf h\Y [ccX h\Uh `]Yg k]h\]b(

3RG LV FORVH WR XV$ KH LV ZLWK XV* WKH GLYLQH VSLULWLV LQVLGH RIXV& 5I KH ZHUH QRW$ WKH SRZHU WR KH JRRG ZRXOG EH EH\RQG RXUUHDFK& - SHUVRQ FDQQRW EH JRRG ZLWKRXW 3RG&$ # !#" 7bbUYig IYbYWU?Z mci UfY [c]b[ h\fci[\ U \UfX h]aY& kcf_ \UfXYf hcibXYfghUbX =cX5 Ug gccb Ug mci ibXYfghUbX >]a& U`` X]ZZ]xWi`h h\]b[g k]`` VYWcaY YUgm& UbX mci k]`` ZYY` `cjY UbX ^cm(

?Z U dYfgcb XcYg bch ZYY` U X]j]bY ZcfWY k]h\]b \]agY`Z& h\]gXcYg bch aYUb h\Uh U X]j]bY ZcfWY XcYg bch Yl]gh ]b \]a&Vih h\Uh \Y \Ug bch mYh `YUfbYX \ck hc fYWc[b]nY ]h(

EIUQHJSÁÅ

?Z h\YfY UfY dYcd`Y UbX h\YfY ]g =cX& h\Yb h\YfY UfY fY`Uxh]cbg\]dg VYhkYYb =cX UbX dYcd`Y( J\YgY fY`Uh]cbg\]dg UfYW\Ub[]b[ k]h\ h]aY& UbX aUb_]bXrg fY`][]cig WcbWYdh]cbgUfY WcbghUbh`m Yjc`j]b[& WcbghUbh`m ]adfcj]b[& VYWca]b[acfY W`YUf UbX YUg]`m ibXYfghccX k]h\ h\Y dUggU[Y cZ h]aY(

=HOLJLRXV FRQVFLHQFH RI PDQNLQG LV QRW ULJLG$ LW LV FKDQJLQJDOO WKH WLPH$ EHFRPLQJ SXUHU DQG FOHDUHU&

=cX ]g gd]f]h UbX dUfh cZ h\]g gd]f]h `]jYg ]bg]XY aY UbX[]jYg gYbgY hc am `]ZY(

J\YfY ]g aiW\ [ccX hc VY `YUfbYX Zfca h\Y AcfUb& Zfcah\Y 8iXX\]ghg& Zfca 9cbZiW]ig& Zfca h\Y E`X JYghUaYbh&Zfca h\Y ?bX]Ub KdUb]g\UXg& UbX Zfca h\Y DYk JYghUxaYbh( 8ih h\Y W`cgYf U fY`][]cig h\]b_Yf cf d\]`cgcd\Yf ]ghc ig ]b h]aY& h\Y acfY \Y WUb \Y`d ig XfUk Zfca h\YgYhYUW\]b[g ]b h\Y `][\h cZ cif dfYgYbh'XUm `]jYg(

EIUQHJSÁǺ

J\Y dUgh bc `cb[Yf Yl]ghg5 h\Y ZihifY \Ug bch mYh WcaY5h\YfY ]g cb`m h\Y dfYgYbh( 7bX cb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh WUb h\YX]j]bY bUhifY cZ h\Y ZfYY \iaUb gci` VY aUb]ZYghYX(

J\Yb @Ygig gU]X ibhc h\Ya& OYh U `]hh`Y k\]`Y ]g h\Y `][\hk]h\ mci( MU`_ k\]`Y mY \UjY h\Y `][\h& `Ygh XUf_bYgg WcaYidcb mci4 Zcf \Y h\Uh kU`_Yh\ ]b XUf_bYgg _bckYh\ bchk\]h\Yf \Y [cYh\(

v@E>D +,4-/

;jYfmcbY _bckg h\Uh cif \UV]hg UfY ]adfcjYX UbXghfYb[h\YbYX h\fci[\ h\Y]f YlYfW]gY( ?b cfXYf hc VY U[ccX kU`_Yf& mci bYYX hc kU`_ U `ch5 ]b cfXYf hc VY Ughfcb[ fibbYf& mci bYYX hc fib ZfYeiYbh`m5 ]b cfXYf hc VYU dYfWYdh]jY fYUXYf& mci ci[\h hc fYUX Ug aiW\ Ug mci WUb(J\Y gUaY ]g hfiY cZ mcif gci`4 ]Z mci VYWcaY Ub[fm& mciaigh _bck h\Uh mci bch cb`m dYfZcfa Yj]`& Vih mci U`gcWfYUhY Ub Yj]` \UV]h& UbX mci ]bWfYUgY mcif dchYbh]U` ZcfZifh\Yf Yj]`(

v;F?9J;JKI

5I \RX ZDQW WR GR D JRRG GHHG$ GR LW QRZ& ?KH WLPH ZLOO SDVV$DQG \RX ZLOO QRW KDYH WKH FKDQFH DJDLQ&

EIUQHJSÁĄ

J\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY ]g fYjYU`YX hc h\cgY k\c UfY fYUXm hcUWWYdh h\Y h\]b[g k\]W\ k]`` VY fYjYU`YX( 7bX ]h ]g \Y k\c\Ug U`fYUXm XYW]XYX h\Uh \Y k]`` UWWYdh h\Y hfih\ Ug ]h ]g&UbX bch h\Y hfih\ ]hgY`Z& k\]W\ k]`` W\Ub[Y h\Y kUm cZ `]ZY\Y \Ug VYYb UWWighcaYX hc(

BKR DP 5, BKDW VKRXOG 5 GR, BKDW VKRXOG ( EHOLHYH LQ DQGZKDW VKRXOG 5 KRSH IRU, 7`` cZ d\]`cgcd\m ]g ]b h\YgY eiYgxh]cbg& gU]X h\Y d\]`cgcd\Yf B]W\hYbVYf[( 8ih Uacb[ U``h\YgY eiYgh]cbg& h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh cbY ]g h\Uh k\]W\ ]g]b h\Y a]XX`Y( ?Z U dYfgcb _bckg k\Uh \Y g\ci`X Xc& \Yk]`` ibXYfghUbX YjYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ \Y g\ci`X _bck(

BRH WR WKH SHRSOH ZKR ORRN ZLWKRXW XQGHUVWDQGLQJ$ ZKR GRQRW NQRZ WKHLU IRXQGDWLRQV&

v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

;jYfm V]fX U`kUmg _bckg k\YfY hc aU_Y \Yf bYgh( 7bX ]Zg\Y _bckg \ck UbX k\YfY hc aU_Y \Yf bYgh& h\]g aYUbgh\Uh g\Y _bckg \Yf difdcgY ]b `]ZY( 7bX k\m XcYg aUb&k\c ]g h\Y k]gYgh Uacb[ U`` WfYUhifYg& bch _bck h\Uhk\]W\ Ubm V]fX _bckg& h\Uh ]g& \]g difdcgY ]b `]ZY6

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

J\Y fYU` aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY ]g bch dcgg]V`Y hc YaVfUWY& ]Z mciUfY `cc_]b[ Zcf h\Y ib]jYfgU` aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZY( 7bX Uh h\YgUaY h]aY ]h ]g gc g]ad`Y h\Uh ]h WUb VY Yld`U]bYX hc Zcc`gUbX hc ]bZUbhg k\Yb k\Uh hc _bck ]g k\Uh mci g\ci`X XcUg Ub ]bX]j]XiU`(

J\Y `]ZY cZ aUb ]g Z]``YX k]h\ ]bhY``YWh cb`m k\Yb h\Y Zi`xZ]`àYbh cZ mcif Xihm ]g ibXYfghccX( MY U`` _bck Zcf gifYh\Uh XYUh\ kU]hg Zcf ig( MY Xc bch _bck k\Yb& îgh Ug kYXc bch _bck k\YfY kY WUaY Zfca(

v>;DHO =;EH=;

L]fhiY ]g U gYfj]WY k\]W\ U dYfgcb g\ci`X Xc Zcf \]agY`Z( ?Zh\YfY kYfY bc \YUjYb UbX bc =cX k\c fi`YX h\]g kcf`X&YjYb h\Yb j]fhiY kci`X VY h\Y bYWYggUfm Ùk cZ `]ZY(

v?D:?7D M?I:EC

BKHQ \RX DSSURDFK D PDQ$ \RX VKRXOG WKLQN QRW DERXW KRZKH FDQ KHOS \RX$ EXW KRZ \RX PLJKW VHUYH DQG KHOS KLP&

MY \UjY h\Y bYWYggUfm Ùk Zcf U`` cif UWh]cbg& UbX h\]g ÙkWUbbch VY fYghf]WhYX Vm Ubm dckYf( J\Y Zi`Z]`àYbh cZ h\]gÙk ]g dcgg]V`Y YjYb ]b df]gcb& UbX ibXYf h\Y h\fYUh cZ hcfxhifYg UbX XYUh\(

Bcc_ Zcf U _]bX `]ZY k\]W\ ]g ]b \Ufacbm k]h\ h\Y k]`` cZ=cX& UbX h\Yb mci k]`` Zi`Z]`` h\Y Xihm cZ mcif `]ZY(

EIUQHJSÂÀ

EIUQHJSÂÁ

?b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug h\Y ghcfa hfciV`Yg UbX aiXX]Yg h\YkUhYfg& gc hcc dUgg]cbg hfciV`Y cif gci`g UbX ]bhYfZYfYk]h\ cif ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\]g `]ZY(

FYcd`Y k]h\ [fYUh UbX kcbXYfZi` gci`g UfY U`kUmg ei]YhUbX \Uddm( J\cgY dYcd`Y k\c Xc bch \UjY gd]f]hiU`]hm UfYU`kUmg ib\Uddm(

v9>?D;I; FHEL;H8

:c bch VY WcbWYfbYX hcc aiW\ k]h\ k\Uh k]`` \UddYb(;jYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ \UddYbg k]`` VY [ccX UbX igYZi` Zcfmci(

v;F?9J;JKI

7 dYfgcb k]`` ibXYfghUbX \]g dÙWY ]b h\Y kcf`X cb`m k\Yb\Y ibXYfghUbXg \]g gci`(

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

=HDO SRZHU LV QRW LQ PRPHQWDU\ GHVLUHV$ EXW LQ FRPSOHWHFDOPQHVV&

9cad`YhY cihYf WUàbYgg ]g ]adcgg]V`Y( 8ih k\Yb h\YfYUfY gcaY WUà dYf]cXg& kY g\ci`X UddfYW]UhY h\Ya UbXaU_Y h\Ya Ùgh `cb[Yf( J\]g ]g h\Y h]aY k\Yb igYZi`h\ci[\hg UddYUf5 h\Ym VYWcaY ghfcb[Yf UbX [i]XY ig ]b`]ZY(

EIUQHJSÂÂ

CU_Y gifY h\Uh mci Xc bch [cgg]d UVcih mcif Vfch\Yf(

?LPH SDVVHV$ EXW WKH ZRUGV ZKLFK \RX VD\ ZLOO UHPDLQ&

Jc ghcd mcif hcb[iY Zfca hU`_]b[ hcc aiW\ ]g U g][b cZ[fYUh j]fhiY(

J\Y \iaUb gci`& bch Vm ]hgY`Z& Vih Vm gcaY dckYf& ]gdig\YX W`cgYf UbX W`cgYf hc hfih\ UbX [ccXbYgg& UbX h\YVYhhYf kY ibXYfghUbX h\]g& h\Y acfY \iaV`Y kY k]`` VY(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

?Z mci h\]b_ h\Uh ]h ]g bYWYggUfm hc ^iX[Y mcif bY][\Vcf&h\Yb gUm h\]g `cc_]b[ X]fYWh`m ]bhc \]g YmYg& UbX gUm h\]g ]bgiW\ U kUm h\Uh mci Xc bch WfYUhY Ub]acg]hm(

EIUQHJSÆǼ

9cbgW]YbWY ]g h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y X]j]bY VY[]bb]b[k\]W\ `]jYg ]b ig(

9cbgW]YbWY ]g h\Y fYU` ^iX[Y VYhkYYb [ccX UbX VUX& WcbxgW]YbWY ]g k\Uh aU_Yg U dYfgcb g]a]`Uf hc =cX& UbX WcbxgW]YbWY ]g h\Y [fYUhYgh UXjUbhU[Y cZ \iaUb bUhifY(M]h\cih WcbgW]YbWY h\YfY kci`X VY bch\]b[ h\Uh kci`XfU]gY ig UVcjY h\Y Ub]aU`g& UbX dYcd`Y kci`X acjY ZfcacbY `]Y hc Ubch\Yf(


?KH SXUSRVH RI \RXU OLIH LV QRW WR GR DV WKH PDMRULW\ GRHV$ EXWWR OLYH DFFRUGLQJ WR WKH LQQHU ODZ ZKLFK \RX XQGHUVWDQG LQ\RXUVHOI 0R QRW DFW DJDLQVW \RXU FRQVFLHQFH RU DJDLQVW WUXWK&8LYH OLNH WKLV$ DQG \RX ZLOO IXOILOO WKH WDVN RI \RXU OLIH&

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Oci WUbbch Z][\h k]h\ h\Y fYei]fYaYbhg cZ WcbgW]YbWY(J\YgY UfY h\Y fi`Yg cZ =cX& UbX ]h ]g VYhhYf hc giVa]h hch\Ya(

EIUQHJSÂÄ

5I WKH IRXQGDWLRQV RI RXU OLIH ZHUH QRW RI WKH VDPH QDWXUH LQDOO RI XV$ WKHQ ZH ZRXOG QRW KH DEOH WR H[SODLQ WR HDFK RWKHUWKRVH IHHOLQJV RI FRPSDVVLRQ ZKLFK ZH UHDOO\ H[SHULHQFH&

9cadUgg]cb YldfYggYX ]b fYgdcbgY hc fU[Y ]g h\Y gUaY UgkUhYf Zcf Z]fY( M\Yb mci UfY ]b U fU[Y& hfm hc ZYY` WcadUgxg]cb Zcf h\Y ch\Yf dYfgcb& UbX h\Yb mcif fU[Y k]`` X]gUddYUf(

v7ZhYf 7HJ>KH I9>EF;D>7K;H

J\YfY UfY aUbm dYcd`Y k\c UfY acfY ib\Uddm h\Ub mci(J\]g aYggU[Y WUbbch VY U fccZ ibXYf k\]W\ mci aUm `]jY&Vih ]h k]`` VY Ybci[\ cZ U fccZ ibXYf k\]W\ mci aUm \]XYZfca ghcfag(

Oci \]XY Zfca mcif a]gZcfhibYg( 8ih ]Z mci _bYk k\Uhch\Yf dYcd`Y giZZYfYX& h\Yb mci kci`X bch Wcad`U]bUVcih mcif ckb(

vIEBED

HYU` WcadUgg]cb VY[]bg cb`m k\Yb mci dih mcifgY`Z ]bh\Y d`UWY cZ h\cgY k\c giZZYf& UbX mci ZYY` fYU` giZZYf]b[(

IYdhYaVYf ,/7 dYfgcb WUb ibXYfghUbX \]g difdcgY ]b h\Y gUaY kUm Ug\Y ibXYfghUbXg \]g X][b]hm( Eb`m U fY`][]cig dYfgcb WUb

ibXYfghUbX \]g difdcgY ]b `]ZY(7 _]b[ Ug_YX U \c`m aUb& s:c mci fYaYaVYf UVcih aY6tJ\Y \c`m aUb UbgkYfYX& sOYg& ? h\]b_ UVcih mci& k\Yb ?

Zcf[Yh UVcih =cX(t


BH IXOILOO WKH ODZ RI 3RG ZKHQ ZH IHHO WKH OLYHV RI RWKHUV DV

RXU RZQ OLIH&

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

J\Y ZfYYXca cZ U dYfgcb ]g U [fYUh h\]b[& UbX YjYb h\YZfYYXca cZ U k\c`Y bUh]cb VY[]bg Zfca h\Y ZfYYXca cZ U

g]b[`Y ]bX]j]XiU`(Oci g\ci`X fYgdYWh ZfYYXca ]b mcifgY`Z& UbX ]b mcif

bY][\Vcf& UbX ]b U`` dYcd`Y(Eb`m \Y k\c ibXYfghUbXg \]agY`Z Ug U gd]f]hiU` VY]b[ WUbibXYfghUbX h\Y gd]f]hiU` X][b]hm cZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y( IiW\ UdYfgcb k]`` bch `ckYf \]agY`Z k]h\ Ubm UWh k\]W\ ]g bchkcfh\m cZ U gd]f]hiU` dYfgcb(

EIUQHJSÂĂ

<cf h\Y acfU`& gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& h\Y ]adcfhUbWY cZ h\]b[g ]gaYUgifYX bch Vm h\Y]f aUhYf]U` jU`iY& Vih Vm h\Y]f `YjY` cZ[ccXbYgg(

J\Y aU^cf]hm cZ dYcd`Y kUbh hc Xc gcaYh\]b[ ibigiU`UbX X]ZZ]Wi`h ]b cfXYf hc ]adfcjY h\Y]f `]jYg& Vih 'h\Ymkci`X VY VYhhYf hc dif]Zm h\Y]f k]g\Yg& UbX ]adfcjY h\Y]f]bbYf gY`jYg(

J\Y gYWcbX h\]b[g UfY aiW\ acfY ]adcfhUbh h\Ub h\YZ]fgh(

v7ZhYf <H7D9E?I <;D;BED

- SHUVRQ XQGHUVWDQGV KLPVHOI QRW WKURXJK WKRXJKWV$ EXW ZLWKDFWLRQV& 5W LV RQO\ WKURXJK PDNLQJ DQ HIIRUW WKDW D SHUVRQ ZLOO

XQGHUVWDQG KLV ZRUWK&v@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

Jc acjY mcifgY`Z Zfca h\Y aUhYf]U hc h\Y gd]f]hiU` aYUbghc Xc cb`m gd]f]hiU` h\]b[g( Cm aUhYf]U` VcXm di``g am]bbYf gY`Z hc ]hgY`Z& Vih ? hfm hc gYdUfUhY am gd]f]hiU` gY`ZZfca h\Y aUhYf]U` VcXm( J\ci[\ ? igY am VcXm& ? `]jYk]h\]b am gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& k\]W\ ]g am fYU` `]ZY(

EIUQHJSÆĈ

HYU` fY`][]cb WUbbch VY cddcgYX hc ]bhY``YWh(

:c bch VY`]YjY h\Uh ]b fY`][]cb mci WUbbch hfigh mcif]bhY``YWh( J\Y ZcfWY cZ cif ]bhY``YWh aigh giddcfh h\YZcibXUh]cbg cZ YjYfm fYU` ZU]h\(


?Z =cX& h\Y cV^YWh cZ cif ZU]h\& ]g \][\Yf h\Ub cif ibXYfxghUbX]b[& UbX ]Z mci Xc bch ibXYfghUbX >]a& ]h XcYg bchaYUb h\Uh mci g\ci`X bch igY mcif ]bhY``YWh hfm]b[ hcibXYfghUbX >]a( T

v<OE:EH IJH7A>EL

M\]`Y mY \UjY `][\h& VY`]YjY ]b h\Y `][\h& h\Uh mY aUm VY h\YW\]`XfYb cZ `][\h( J\YgY h\]b[g gdU_Y @Ygig& UbX XYdUfhYX&UbX X]X \]XY \]agY`Z Zfca h\Ya(

v@E>D +,4-0

5Q RUGHU WR XQGHUVWDQG WKH WUXWK$ \RX VKRXOG QRW VXSSUHVV\RXU LQWHOOHFW& ;Q WKH FRQWUDU\$ \RX VKRXOG SXULI\ \RXU LQWHOcOHFW$ H[HUFLVH LW$ DQG LQWHOOHFWXDOO\ WU\ DQG WHVW HYHU\WKLQJZKLFK ZH FDQ SRVVLEO\ SXW WR WKH WHVW&

EIUQHJSÂǺ

FU]b ]g h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ cif VcXm& UbX giZZYf]b[]g h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ cif gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& Zfca V]fh\hc XYUh\(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Oci g\ci`X kY`WcaY YjYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ \UddYbg hc mciZfca V]fh\ hc XYUh\& VYWUigY h\Y Yl]ghYbWY UbX h\Y difxdcgY cZ h\Y kcf`X ]g ]b h\YgY WUgYg(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

Eb`m ]b h\Y ghcfa WUb mci gYY h\Y Ufh cZ h\Y fYU` gU]`cf5cb`m cb h\Y VUhh`YZ]Y`X WUb mci gYY h\Y VfUjYfm cZ U gc`X]Yf(J\Y WcifU[Y cZ U g]ad`Y dYfgcb WUb VY gYYb ]b \ck \YWcdYg k]h\ h\Y X]ZZ]Wi`h UbX XUb[Yfcig g]hiUh]cbg ]b `]ZY(

v:7D?;B 79>?DIAO

?KRVH WKLQJV ZKLFK ZH FDOO KDSSLQHVV DQG WKRVH ZKLFK ZHFDOO XQKDSSLQHVV DUH XVHIXO IRU XV$ HVSHFLDOO\ ZKHQ ZH VHFWKHP DV RSSRUWXQLWLHV WR WW\ RXUVHOYHV&

J\Y `Y[YbX UVcih h\Y kUbXYf]b[ @Yk k\c kUg giZZYf]b[h\Y dib]g\aYbh cZ YhYfbU` `]ZY ]g jYfm hfiY( ?b h\Y gUaYkUm& h\YfY ]g U `Y[YbX UVcih U aUb k\c kUg dib]g\YX VmVY]b[ []jYb U `]ZY k]h\cih Ubm giZZYf]b[(

EIUQHJSÆĊ

J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ acfY ]adcfhUbh h\Ub Ub YlUad`Y( ?h`YUXg ig hc Xc [ccX XYYXg k\]W\ kci`X VY ]adcgg]V`Yk]h\cih h\]g YlUad`Y( J\YfYZcfY& ]Z kY igY X]gg]dUhYX cfdUgg]cbUhY cf WfiY` dYcd`Y Ug YlUad`Yg& ]h XYghfcmgpcifgci`( J\Y WcbhfUfm ]g U`gc hfiY(

?KRVH ZKR GR QRW WKLQN LQGHSHQGHQWO\ DUH XQGHU WKH LQIOXHQFHRI VRPHERG\ HOVH ZKR WKLQNV IRU WKHP& 5I \RX JLYH \RXUWKRXJKWV WR VRPHERG\ HOVH$ LW LV D P RUH VKDPHIXO VODYHU\ WKDQLI \RX JLYH \RXU ERG\ WR VRPHRQH WR SRVVHVV&

?Z mci XYg]fY hc Zc``ck gcaYcbY Ug Ub YlUad`Y& Ug aUbmch\Yf dYcd`Y Xc& Z]fgh ghcd UbX h\]b_ k\Yh\Yf ]h ]g kcfh\xk\]`Y hc Zc``ck h\]g [YbYfU` YlUad`Y(

J\cgY k\c UfY bch UZfU]X cZ hfi`m hYff]V`Y h\]b[g Zc``ckZU`gY YlUad`Yg UbX h\cgY dYcd`Y Zc``ck h\Y dUh\ hcXYghfiWh]cb(


;j]` ]bZìYbWY WUb VY XYghfcmYX cb`m Vm [ccX ]bZìYbWY( 7bXh\Y kUm hc fYWY]jY U [ccX ]bZìYbWY ]g hc \UjY U [ccX `]ZY(

7 gYbgY cZ gY`Z']adcfhUbWY gc \][\ h\Uh ]h gifdUggYg U```]a]hg ]g U aYbhU` ]``bYgg WU``YX PDQLD JUDQGLRVD&

FYcd`Y h\]b_ h\Uh gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY j]c`UhYg mcif ZfYYXca(J\cgY dYcd`Y Xc bch _bck h\Uh gUWf]Z]WY []jYg ig Wcaxd`YhY ZfYYXca& UbX ZfYYg ig Zfca cifgY`jYg& Zfca h\Y g`UjxYfm cZ cif X]gg]dUh]cb(

;XU SDVVLRQV DUH WKH PRVW WHUULEOH W\UDQWV$ DQG ZH FDQ KHWKH VODYH RI WKHP& ;QO\^WHOI%VDFULIFH FDQ IUHH XV IURP WKLV

VODYHU\&

`wmci hYUW\ ch\Yfg \ck aUbm ]bgYWhg Yl]gh ]b h\]g kcf`X&cf k\Yb mci `cc_ Uh h\Y gdchg cb h\Y gib& cf k\Yb mcikf]hY Ub cdYfU cf U bcjY`vkY Xc h\YgY h\]b[g Zcf X]ZZYfxYbh difdcgYg( 8ih hc hYUW\ dYcd`Y [ccXbYgg ]g XcbY cb`mZcf h\Y difdcgY cZ gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY& gYfj]WY hc ch\Yfg& UbX mciWUbbch YldfYgg h\]g hYUW\]b[ k]h\cih gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY( 9\f]gh[UjY \]g `]ZY cb h\Y Wfcgg Zcf U [fYUh difdcgY& bch ]b jU]b(7bX U gUWf]Z]WY cf giZZYf]b[ ]g bYjYf ]b jU]b& UbX ]h k]`` hf]xiad\ cjYf YjYfmh\]b[(

EIUQHJSÃÀ

EIUQHJSÃÁ

Dch\]b[ WUb ]bhYfZYfY k]h\ h\Y [fckh\ cZ hfih\ ]b h\Ykcf`X4 bch\]b[ YlWYdh h\Y k]g\ hc gUjY c`X dfY^iX]WYg(

FYcd`Y gUm h\Uh =cX WfYUhYX aUb_]bX UZhYf \]g ]aU[Y(J\]g aYUbg h\Uh aUb WfYUhYX =cX UZhYf \]g ]aU[Y(

v=;EH=; B?9>J;DH;H=

'?Z kY VY`]YjY ]b h\Y h\]b[g kY kYfY hUi[\h& h\YfY ]g [ccXxbYgg UbX Yj]` Uh h\Y gUaY h]aY(

v>;DHO =;EH=;

>iaUb]hm g`ck`m Vih WYUgY`Ygg`m acjYg ZcfkUfX hc h\Y VYhxhYf UbX VYhhYf ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ h\]g `]ZY(

7acb[ h\Y acgh hYff]V`Y `]Yg cZ U`` ]g hc hYUW\ ZU`gY ZU]h\ hcW\]`XfYb(

0LVUHVSHFW IRU WUDGLWLRQV KDV QRW FDXVHG HYHQ RQH WKRXVDQGWKSDUW RI WKH JUHDW HYLO ZKLFK ZDV FDXVHG E\ WKH ROG SUHMXGLFHV$WUDGLWLRQV$ FXVWRPV$ DQG LQVWLWXWLRQV ZKLFK VKRXOG QRW H[LVWDW SUHVHQW&

DQWJOHJSÁ

7 aUb k\c Wcbg]XYfg \]agY`Z h\Y aUghYf cZ \]g ckb `]ZYWUb bYjYf VY \iaV`Y& VYWUigY \Y h\]b_g h\Uh \Y \Ug bccV`][Uh]cb hc UbmcbY( J\Y aUb k\c Wcbg]XYfg gYfj]WY hc=cX hc VY h\Y difdcgY cZ \]g `]ZY ]g U`kUmg \iaV`Y&VYWUigY \Y ZYY`g h\Uh \Y \Ug bYjYf Zi`Z]``YX \]g cV`][Uh]cbg(

7bX h\Y Udcgh`Yg gU]X ibhc h\Y BcfX& ?bWfYUgY cif ZU]h\(7bX h\Y BcfX gU]X& ?Z mY \UX ZU]h\ Ug U [fU]b cZ aighUfXgYYX& mY a][\h gUm ibhc h\]g gmWUa]bY hfYY& 8Y h\cid`iW_YX id& UbX VY h\ci d`UbhYX ]b h\Y gYU5UbX ]h g\ci`X cVYm mci( 8ih k\]W\ cZ mci& \Uj]b[ U gYfxjUbh d`ck]b[ cf ZYYX]b[ WUhh`Y& k]`` gUm ibhc \]a Vm UbXVm& k\Yb \Y ]g WcaY Zfca h\Y Z]Y`X& =c UbX g]h Xckb hcaYUh6 7bX k]`` bch fUh\Yf gUm ibhc \]a& CU_Y fYUXmk\YfYk]h\ ? aUm gid& UbX []fX h\mgY`Z& UbX gYfjY aY& h]`` ?\UjY YUhYb UbX Xfib_Yb5 UbX UZhYfkUfX h\ci g\U`h YUh UbXXf]b_6 :ch\ \Y h\Ub_ h\Uh gYfjUbh VYWUigY \Y X]X h\Yh\]b[g h\Uh kYfY WcaaUbXYX \]a6 ? hfck bch( Ic `]_Yk]gYmY& k\Yb mY g\U`` \UjY XcbY U`` h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ UfYWcaaUbXYX mci& gUm& MY UfY ibdfcZ]hUV`Y gYfjUbhg4 kY\UjY XcbY h\Uh k\]W\ kUg cif Xihm hc Xc(

vBKA; +14/'+*

Jfi`m _]bX dYcd`Y Zcf[Yh h\Y [ccX h\]b[g h\Ym \UjY XcbY]b h\Y dUgh( J\Ym UfY gc ]bjc`jYX ]b h\Y h\]b[g h\Ym Xcbck h\Uh h\Ym Zcf[Yh h\Y h\]b[g h\Ym \UjY XcbY VYZcfY(

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

?KH EHWWHU D SHUVRQ NQRZV KLPVHOI$ WKH VPDOOHU DQG OHVV VLJcQLILFDQW KH VHHPV WR KLPVHOI$ DQG WKH KLJKHU KH HOHYDWHV KLPcVHOI WRZDUG 3RG&

vJ>EC7I 7 A;CF?I

DQWJOHJSÂ

7 XYYX XcbY cb`m hc UW\]YjY [`cfm ]g U`kUmg VUX& bc aUhxhYf k\Uh WcbgYeiYbWYg ]h \Ug( 7 XYYX ach]jUhYX YeiU``mVm h\Y XYg]fY hc UW\]YjY [ccXbYgg UbX hc UW\]YjY [`cfm ]g]bX]ZZYfYbh( 7 XYYX ]g hfi`m [ccX cb`m k\Yb ]hg ach]jUh]cb]g hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y Ùk cZ =cX(

?Z mci WUfY hcc aiW\ UVcih VY]b[ dfU]gYX& ]b h\Y YbX mcik]`` bch UWWcad`]g\ Ubmh\]b[ gYf]cig( FYcd`Y \UjY X]ZZYfxYbh jUìYg( Oci aUm gUm& s? kUbh [ccX dYcd`Y hc jUìYaY&t Vih mci _bck mci k]`` fYgdYWh cb`m h\cgY k\c dfU]gYmcif UWh]cbg(

MY UfY bch gUh]gZ]YX k]h\ cif fYU` `]ZY( MY kUbh hc `]jY Ub]aU[]bUfm `]ZY& U `]ZY ]b k\]W\ kY gYYa X]ZZYfYbh ]b h\Y YmYgcZ ch\Yf dYcd`Y h\Ub kY UfY ]b fYU`]hm(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

8HW WKH MXGJPHQWV RI RWKHUV KH WKH FRQVHTXHQFH RI \RXU GHHGV$QRW WKHLU SXUSRVH&

Jc `]jY cb`m Zcf =cX& mci g\ci`X Xc [ccX kcf_g k\]W\bc cbY k]`` YjYf X]gWcjYf( :c gc& UbX mci k]`` YldYf]YbWY UgdYW]U` ^cm(

DQWJOHJSǼ

J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY fYU` Ùk& h\Y Ùk cZ =cX& k\]W\ ]g h\YgUaY Zcf U`` cZ aUb_]bX( >iaUb Ùk WUb VY jU`]X cb`mk\Yb ]h ]g ]b \Ufacbm k]h\ h\Y Ùk cZ =cX(

J\Y Z]fgh UbX acgh X]ZZ]Wi`h cVghfiWh]cb hc h\Y Zi`Z]`àYbhcZ h\Y Ùk cZ =cX ]g h\Y ZUWh h\Uh cif gcW]Yhmrg Yl]gh]b[Ùkg UfY Wcad`YhY`m cddcgYX hc h\]g Ùk(

?KRVH KXPDQ ODZV DUH JRRG ZKLFK DUH EDVHG RQ WKH ODZ RI3RG& ?KRVH KXPDQ ODZV DUH EDG ZKLFK FRQWUDGLFW WKH ODZV

RI 3RG+ ZH VKRXOG FKDQJH WKHVH ODZV&v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

?b cfXYf hc ghiXm h\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh eiYgh]cbg cZ `]ZY&YjYfmcbY g\ci`X XYghfcm h\Y dfYîX]WYg UbX `]Yg k\]W\kYfY WfYUhYX Vm dfYj]cig WYbhif]Yg ]b fYÙh]cb hc U`` gYf]xcig eiYgh]cbg ]b `]ZY(

J\Y Ùk cZ =cX WcbhfUX]Whg \iaUb Ùk( Ic k\Uh g\ci`XkY Xc6 I\ci`X kY \]XY h\Y Ùk cZ =cX UbX dfcWÙ]a\iaUb Ùk6 FYcd`Y \UjY XcbY h\]g Zcf Uàcgh b]bYhYYbWYbhif]Yg& UbX h\Y WcbhfUX]Wh]cb VYWcaYg ghfcb[Yf UbXghfcb[Yf( J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY gcìh]cb4 hc fYdÙWY h\Y Yl]ghx]b[ Ùkg k]h\ h\Y Ùk cZ =cX(

DQWJOHJSÄ

:YVUhYg WcbWYU` h\Y hfih\ acfY cZhYb h\Ub h\Ym fYjYU` ]h(HYU` hfih\ g\ci`X VY fYjYU`YX ]b gc`]hiXY( M\Yb ]h ]gfYjYU`YX& ]h VYWcaYg W`YUf hc mci h\Uh mci WUb UWWYdh ]hk]h\cih Ubm Uf[iaYbh cf X]gWigg]cbg(

4H KDV SRZHU ZKR FDQ NHHS VLOHQW LQ DQ DUJXPHQW$ HYHQWKRXJK KH LV ULJKW&

Oci g\ci`X UVghU]b Zfca Uf[iaYbhg( J\Ym UfY jYfm ]``c[]xWU` kUmg hc Wcbj]bWY dYcd`Y( Ed]b]cbg UfY `]_Y bU]`g4 h\Yghfcb[Yf mci \]h h\Ya& h\Y XYYdYf ]bg]XY h\Ym [c(

v:;9?CKI @KD?KI @KL;D7B?I

?Z mci `]jY U`cbY& h\]b_ UVcih mcif ckb g]bg5 ]Z mci UfY ]bgcW]Yhm& Zcf[Yh UVcih h\Y g]bg cZ ch\Yfg(

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

J\Y acfY if[Ybh`m mci kUbh hc gdYU_& h\Y acfY `]_Y`m ]h ]gh\Uh mci k]`` gUm gcaYh\]b[ Zcc`]g\(

DQWJOHJSĆ

J\ci[\h ]g h\Y [`cf]Z]WUh]cb cZ hfih\5 h\YfYZcfY& VUXh\ci[\hg UfY h\cgY k\]W\ \UjY bch VYYb h\ci[\h h\fci[\hc h\Y YbX(

?b cfXYf h\Uh U `Uad WUb []jY [ccX `][\h& mci g\ci`X dih ]h]b U d`UWY dfchYWhYX Zfca h\Y k]bX( ?Z h\Y `][\h ]g ]b h\Yk]bX& h\Yb ]h k]`` `YUjY `cb[& hfYaV`]b[ g\UXckg( Ic hcck]`` VUX h\ci[\hg Xfcd g\UXckg cb h\Y k\]hY gifZUWY cZmcif gci`(

v?D:?7D M?I:EC

1VWDEOLVK \RXU SXUSRVH ZKHQ \RX DUH DORQH DQG ZLWKRXW

WHPSWDWLRQV&v@;H;CO 8;DJ>7C

CYX]hUh]cb ]g h\Y kUm hc YhYfb]hm5 `][\h\YUfhYXbYgg ]g h\YkUm hc XYUh\( J\cgY k\c aYX]hUhY bYjYf X]Y5 h\cgY k\cUfY `][\h\YUfhYX fYa]bX aY cZ XYUh\(

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

Oci WUbbch gYbX UkUm U VUX h\ci[\h k\Yb ]h UddYUfg ]bmcif a]bX& Vih mci WUb WfYUhY ch\Yf h\ci[\hg k\]W\ k]``kYU_Yb cf XYghfcm h\]g VUX h\ci[\h( <cf YlUad`Y& ? aUm]aU[]bY h\Uh mcif Zf]YbX cf bY][\Vcf \Ug gcaY XfUkVUW_&UbX ? aUm bch VY UV`Y hc VUb]g\ h\]g h\ci[\h& Vih k\Yb ?WcbWYbhfUhY cb h\Y h\ci[\hh\Uh Wf]h]W]n]b[ Ubch\Yf dYfxgcb ]g VUX VYWUigY ? Ua bch dYfZYWh& UbX \Y \Ug h\Y gUaY=cX k]h\]b \]a Ug ? \UjY k]h\]b aY& h\Yb ? WUbbch ghcd`cj]b[ h\]g dYfgcb(

DQWJOHJSĂ

8Ùa]b[ mcif bY][\Vcf ]g \UfaZi`& Vch\ Zcf mci UbX Zcfch\Yfg(

OYghYfXUm Uh U dUfhm& k\Yb U [iYgh gU]X [ccX'VmY UbXXYdUfhYX& YjYfmcbY k\c kUg `YZh ghUfhYX hc gÙbXYf \]a(J\Y gUaY h\]b[ \UddYbYX hc h\Y gYWcbX dYfgcb k\Yb \Y`YZh& UbX hc U`` h\Y [iYghg& cbY UZhYf Ubch\Yf& Ug h\Ym `YZh(J\Y Ùgh [iYgh gU]X& sBYh aY ghUm \YfY UbX gdYbX h\Y b][\h(? gUk h\Uh U`` h\Y dYcd`Y k\c `YZh giZZYfYX UbX ? Ua UZfU]XZcf amgY`Z(t

.H VWULFW WR \RXUVHOI$ DQG IRUJLYH RWKHUV$ DQG WKHQ \RX ZLOOKDYH QR HQHPLHV&

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

? cbWY aYh Ub c`X aUb k\c gdc_Y jYfm g`ck`m& dUig]b[ ZcfgYjYfU` gYWcbXg VYhkYYb \]g kcfXg( >Y X]X h\]g VYWUigY\Y kUg UZfU]X hc g]b k]h\ \]g kcfXg(

BYh ig Zcf[]jY YUW\ ch\Yf( ?Z kY WUb Zcf[]jY YUW\ ch\Yf&h\Yb kY WUb `]jY ]b dYUWY(

7 kcfX ]g Ub YldfYgg]cb cZ h\ci[\hg5 h\ci[\hg UfY h\YYldfYgg]cb cZ X]j]bY ZcfWY( J\YfYZcfY& kcfXg g\ci`X WcfxfYgdcbX hc cif hfiY aYUb]b[( IdYYW\ WUb VY ]bX]ZZYfYbh&Vih ]h g\ci`X bch VY Ub YldfYgg]cb cZ Yj]`(

DQWJOHJSĈ

Oci WUb `cc_ Uh `]ZY Ug XYUh\& UbX XYUh\ Ug Ub UkU_Yb]b[(

? WUbbch ghcd h\]b_]b[ h\Uh ? kUg XYUX VYZcfY ? kUg Vca&UbX Uh am XYUh\ ? k]`` fYhifb hc h\Y gUaY ghUhY(

v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

? Xc bch fY[fYh h\Uh ? kUg Vca \YfY UbX h\Uh ? `]jYX dUfh cZam `]ZY \YfY& VYWUigY ? `]jYX ]b U kUm h\Uh ? h\]b_ kUg igYxZi`( M\Yb h\Y YbX WcaYg& ? k]`` `YUjY am `]ZY ]b h\Y gUaYkUm& Ug ]Z ? `YUjY Ub ]bb UbX bch am \caY& VYWUigY ? h\]b_h\Uh am ghUm ]b h\]g `]ZY ]g hYadcfUfm UbX h\Uh XYUh\ ]g cb`mU hfUbgZYf hc Ubch\Yf ghUhY(


;jYb ]Z ? Yff ]b gUm]b[ h\Uh h\Y gci` ]g YhYfbU`& bYjYfh\Y`Ygg? Ua \Uddm h\Uh ? aUXY h\]g a]ghU_Y( 7bX k\]`Y ? Ua U`]jY&bch U g]b[`Y dYfgcb WUb hU_Y UkUm h\]g UggifUbWY k\]W\[]jYg aY Wcad`YhY WU`abYgg UbX [fYUh gUh]gZUWh]cb(


BH DVN WKH ZURQJ TXHVWLRQ ZKHQ ZH VD\$ `BKDW ZLOO KDSSHQDIWHU GHDWK,a BKHQ ZH VSHDN DKRXW WKH IXWXUH$ ZH VSHDN RIWLPH$ KXW ZKHQ ZH GLH$ ZH OHDYH WLPH EHKLQG&

DQWJOHJSǺ

MY WcaY hc U f][\h ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ cif `]ZY ]b fYÙh]cb hc=cX ]b h\Y gUaY kUm kY ibXYfghUbX cif fYÙh]cb hc h\Ykcf`X UbX hc ]hg h\]b[g( M]h\cih WcbgW]YbWY& kY kci`XbYjYf _bck Ubmh\]b[ UVcih =cX(

J\Y eiYgh]cb ]g k\Yh\Yf h\Y ]bhY``YWhiU` cbY& k]h\cih h\Y\YUfh& WUb ibXYfghUbX =cX( J\Y hfih\ ]g h\Uh ]Z cif \YUfhibXYfghUbXg =cX cif ]bhY``YWh k]`` h\Yb ghUfh hc gYY_ >]a(

v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

J\Y VUg]W ZcibXUh]cb cZ h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ =cX ]g]bg]XY cZ ig&


7 [ccX kcf_Yf dfcVUV`m XcYg bch _bck h\Y XYhU]`g cZ h\Y`]ZY cZ \]g aUghYf( Eb`m U Ùnm kcf_Yf hf]Yg hc Xc bch\]b[YlWYdh Z]bX cih acfY UVcih \]g aUghYfrg kUm cZ `]ZY& hUghYg&UbX dfYZYfYbWYg ]b cfXYf hc d`YUgY \]a( J\Y gUaY ]g hfiY cZU dYfgcbrg Uhh]hiXY hc =cX( ?h ]g ]adcfhUbh hc UWWYdh >]aUg mcif aUghYf UbX hc _bck k\Uh >Y kUbhg mci hc Xc( ?aUm bYjYf _bck h\Y UbgkYfg hc h\Y eiYgh]cbg sM\Uh ]g>Y6t UbX s>ck XcYg >Y `]jY6t ? k]`` bYjYf Z]bX cihVYWUigY ? Ua bch YeiU` hc >]a( ? Ua >]g kcf_Yf& bch >]gaUghYf(

1YHU\ SHUVRQ XQGHUVWDQGV 3RG LQ GLIIHUHQW ZD\V$ EXW SHRSOHIXOILOO 4LV ZLOO LQ WKH VDPH ZD\&

DQWJOHJSĄ

IY`Z'UXa]fUh]cb ]g h\Y VY[]bb]b[ cZ df]XY( Ff]XY ]g X]gg]xdUhYX gY`Z'UXa]fUh]cb(

J\cgY k\c Xc bch \UhY h\Y]f ckb gY`Z]g\bYgg& h\Y]f d`UWx]b[ cZ h\YagY`jYg \][\Yf h\Ub h\Y fYgh cZ h\Y kcf`X& UfYV`]bX& VYWUigY h\]g UWh]cb WcbhfUX]Whg h\Y hfih\(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

J\Y `][\hYf UbX `Ygg XYbgY U giVghUbWY ]g& h\Y `Ygg gdUWY ]hcWWid]Yg( J\Y eiU`]h]Yg k\]W\ U dfciX dYfgcb Uhhf]VihYg hc\]agY`Z WUb VY WcadUfYX hc h\]g(

J\YfY UfY aUbm dYcd`Y k\c W`U]a hc VY hYUW\Yfg cZ ch\Yfgk\c g\ci`X h\YagY`jYg VY hUi[\h Z]fgh cZ U``(

v;7IJ;HD M?I:EC

?KH PRVW LPSRUWDQW WKLQJ LQ OLIH LV WKH SDWK WR SHUIHFWLRQ$ DQGZKDW NLQG RI SHUIHFWLRQ FDQ H[LVW LI D SHUVRQ LV SURXG DQG VDWc

LVILHG ZLWK KLPVHOI,

DQWJOHJSÁÀ

<fca h\Y Z]fgh acaYbh h\Y aYaVYfg cZ U fY`][]cig [Uh\Yfx]b[ gU]X& sJ\Y >c`m Id]f]h ]g Uacb[ ig(t k\Yb h\Ym WÙ]aYXh\Y]fg h\Y \][\Ygh Uih\cf]hm UVcjY U`` ch\Yf Uih\cf]h]Yg&k\Yb h\Ym UWWYdhYX h\Y fYgi`hg cZ h\Y]f ckb aYX]hUh]cb UgacfY kcfh\m h\Ub h\Y X]j]bY gdUf_ h\Uh Yl]ghg ]b YjYfmdYfgcb #h\Uh ]g& h\Y ]bhY``YWh UbX h\Y WcbgW]YbWY$& Zfcah\]g h]aY& U [fYUh `]Y cf][]bUhYX& U `]Y k\]W\ XYWY]jYg h\Y VcXx]Yg UbX gci`g cZ aUbm dYcd`Y& k\]W\ \Ug XYghfcmYX a]``]cbgcZ \iaUb VY]b[g& UbX k\]W\ Wcbh]biYg ]hg hYff]V`Y kcf_(

?b +02,& U :f( BYmhcb& U fYgdYWhYX W]h]nYb cZ ;b[ÙbX k\ckfchY U Vcc_ Wf]h]W]n]b[ U V]g\cd& kUg dih cb hf]U` UbXgYjYfY`m dib]g\YX( <]fgh \Y kUg \Ufg\`m VYUhYb& h\Yb cbYYUf kUg Wih UkUm( 7ZhYf gYjYfU` XUmg \Y kUg VYUhYb U[U]b&h\ci[\ h\Y ]bîf]Yg cb \]g VUW_ \UX bch \YU`YX5 h\Yb h\YmWih cZZ \]g gYWcbX YUf& UbX hcfY cZZ \]g bcgY( J\]g kUg XcbY]b h\Y bUaY cZ 9\f]gh]Ub]hm(

vH7D:7BB J>EC7I :7L?:IED

9\f]gh bYjYf ZcibXYX Ubm W\ifW\& bYjYf WfYUhYX Ubm ghUhY&bYjYf dUggYX Ubm Ùk& bYjYf YghUV`]g\YX Ubm [cjYfbaYbhcf ch\Yf Uih\cf]hm( >Y kUbhYX hc dih h\Y Ùk cZ =cX ]bhch\Y \YUfhg cZ dYcd`Y& hc aU_Y h\Ya gY`Z'[cjYfbYX(

v>;H8;HJ D;MJED

5I WKHUH LV D WUXH FKXUFK$ WKH SHRSOH ZKR DUH LQVLGH LW FDQQRWVHH LW IURP WKH RXWVLGH&

DQWJOHJSÁÁ

CcfU` dYfZYWh]cb ]g h\Y ]adcgg]V`Y [cU`& Vih acj]b[ hc ]h]g h\Y `Uk cZ \iaUb `]ZY(

IcaY dYcd`Y gUm& sCUb ]g gY`Z]g\& [fYYXm& UbX X]gg]dUhYX&UbX WUbbch VY _]bX hc ch\Yf dYcd`Y(t J\]g ]g bch hfiY MYWUb VY [ccX( <YY` ]b mcif \YUfh h\Y _]bX cZ dYfgcb mcig\ci`X VY5 h\]g ZYY`]b[ k]`` []jY mci dckYf(

7 kcaUb UWW]XYbhU``m XfcddYX U dfYW]cig dYUf` ]bhc h\YgYU& UbX g\Y ghUfhYX hc gWccd cWYUb kUhYf k]h\ U gdUXY&cbY Wid UZhYf Ubch\Yf( 7 gYU'gdf]hY WUaY hc \Yf UbX gU]X&sM\Yb k]`` mci ghcd gWccd]b[ id kUhYf6t J\Y kcaUbgU]X& sM\Yb ? \UjY hU_Yb U`` h\Y kUhYf Zfca h\Y gYU& UbXfYhf]YjYX am dYUf` Zfca h\Y Vchhca(t J\Yb h\Y gYU'gdf]hYfYhf]YjYX h\Y dYUf` UbX fYhifbYX ]h hc \Yf(

;XWHU FRQVHTXHQFHV DUH QRW LQ RXU SRZHU WR FRQWURO+ LW LVRQO\ SRVVLEOH WR PDNH DQ HIIRUW$ DQG LQQHU FRQVHTXHQFHVDOZD\V IROORZ IURP RXU HIIRUW&

J\Y ÙbX ]g h\Y [YbYfU` UbX YeiU` dcggYgg]cb cZ U`` \iaUbx]hm& UbX h\YfYZcfY WUbbch VY h\Y dfcdYfhm cZ ]bX]j]XiU`g(

Cm ]bhY``YWh hYUW\Yg aY h\Uh ÙbX WUbbch VY gc`X(v8B79A >7MA

?KH ODQG VKDOO QRW KH VROG IRU HYHU* IRU WKH ODQG LV PLQH+ IRU\H DUH VWUDQJHUV DQG VRMRXUQHUV ZLWK PH&

vB;L?J?9KI ,/4,-

Jc VY \cbYgh& h\Y YUfh\ \Ug hkc aUghYfg4 h\Y Z]fgh ]gUà][\hm =cX UbX h\Y gYWcbX UfY \]g gcbg5 U`` h\Y dYcd`Yk\c \UjY kcf_YX UbX k]`` kcf_ cb ]h(

vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

7`` dYcd`Y& Zfca h\Y Z]fgh& UbX k]h\cih Ubm îX]W]U` UWh&g\ci`X dcggYgg h\Y YUfh\( J\Ym g\ci`X VY UV`Y hc `]jYk\YfY bUhifY UbX W\UbWY \UjY Vfci[\h h\Ya(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

J\Y dcggYgg]cb cZ ÙbX Ug dfcdYfhm ]g cbY cZ h\Y acghibbUhifU` Wf]aYg h\YfY ]g( MY WUbbch gYY h\Y \cffcf cZ h\]gWf]aY VYWUigY ]b cif kcf`X ]h ]g UWWYdhYX Ug Ùk(

DQWJOHJSÁÂ

DQWJOHJS ĄǼ

IY`Z'dYfZYWh]cb g\ci`X VY cbYrg df]aUfm ach]jUh]cb( ?Zmci UfY hfih\Zi` hc mcifgY`Z& mci k]`` bYjYf VY gUh]gZ]YXk]h\ mcifgY`Z(

7 dYfgcb g\ci`X U`kUmg XYjY`cd \]g UV]`]hm hc Xc [ccXbYgg(CU_Y mcifgY`Z VYhhYf5 h\]g g\ci`X VY YjYfm dYfgcbrg [cU`(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?KH ILUVW UXOH RI DFKLHYLQJ JRRGQHVV LV WKLV* WKLQN RQO\ DKRXWVHOI%SHUIHFWLRQ$ DQG GR VR ZLWKRXW WKRXJKW WR EHLQJ SUDLVHG E\

RWKHUV&v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

>Y k\c acjYg Zfca Xc]b[ VUX XYYXg hc Xc]b[ [ccXXYYXg Yb`][\hYbg h\]g kcf`X `]_Y h\Y accb Wca]b[ cihZfca VY\]bX h\Y W`ciXg( J\]g ]g h\Y VYgh h\]b[ ]b h\Ykcf`X5 h\]g ]g h\Y Z]fgh ghYd hckUfX X]j]b]hm(


J\cgY k\c `]jY `]ZY ]b dYfZYWh]cb `cc_ cb`m ZcfkUfX5 h\cgYk\c \UjY ghcddYX acj]b[ ZcfkUfX `cc_ VUW_ cb h\Y]fUW\]YjYaYbhg(

:]ggUh]gZUWh]cb ]g U bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ ]bhY``YWhiU``]ZY( ?h ]g cb`m h\]g X]ggUh]gZUWh]cb h\Uh dig\Yg mci hc kcf_(

DQWJOHJSÁÄ

J\Y acgh ]adcfhUbh _bck`YX[Y ]g h\Uh k\]W\ [i]XYg h\YkUm mci `YUX mcif `]ZY(

?h ]g \UfaZi` hc YUh ]Z mci UfY bch \ib[fm( ?h ]g YjYb kcfgYhc \UjY gYl ]Z mci `UW_ XYg]fY( 8ih YjYb acfY \UfaZi` ]g hchfm hc h\]b_ k\Yb mci Xc bch k]g\ hc& cf hc VY Yb[U[YX ]baYUb]b[`Ygg ]bhY``YWhiU` UWh]j]hm( CUbm dYcd`Y Xc gc k\Ybh\Ym kUbh hc ]adfcjY h\Y]f dcg]h]cb(

Ocif k]`` ]g bch [ccX ibh]` mci \UjY W\Ub[YX h\Y \UV]hg cZmcif ]bhY``YWh& UbX h\Ym k]`` ]adfcjY cb`m k\Yb h\Ym Zc`x`ck h\Y YhYfbU` `Ukg cZ `]ZY(

vBK9?KI 7bbUYig IYbYWU

;QO\ WKRVH ZKR KDYH UHDO NQRZOHGJH NQRZ ZKDW WR GR&v?D:?7D M?I:EC

M\Uh ]g ]adcfhUbh ]b _bck`YX[Y ]g bch eiUbh]hm& Vih eiU`x]hm( ?h ]g ]adcfhUbh hc _bck k\Uh _bck`YX[Y ]g g][b]Z]WUbh&k\Uh ]g `Ygg gc& UbX k\Uh ]g hf]j]U`(

DQWJOHJS ĄĆ

J\Y ^cm cZ kYU`h\ ]g ]bWcbghUbh(

BKHUHYHU \RXU KHDUW LV$ WKHUH ZLOO KH \RXU WUHDVXUH& ?KH KHDUWRI D SHUVRQ ZKRVH PDMRU WUHDVXUH LV ZHDOWK LV EXULHG LQ ILOWK&

?g ]h hfiY h\Uh dYcd`Y kYfY WfYUhYX hc Wc``YWh acfY UbXacfY [c`X6 Dc( =cX WfYUhYX dYcd`Y UZhYf >]g ckb ]aU[Y5>Y WfYUhYX mci gc h\Uh mci Wci`X Zi`Z]`` \]g k]``(


M\m g\ci`X U dYfgcb VY f]W\6 M\m g\ci`X \Y \UjY YldYbxg]jY \cfgYg& f]W\ W`ch\Yg& kcbXYfZi` fccag& UbX h\Y `Y]gifYhc j]g]h diV`]W d`UWYg cZ YbhYfhU]baYbh6 8YWUigY \Y XcYgbch \UjY Ybci[\ h\ci[\hg hc UWWcadUbm \]g ]bhY``YWh(=]jY h\]g dYfgcb h\Y ]bbYf kcf_ cZ \]g ]bhY``YWh& UbX \Yk]`` VY \Udd]Yf h\Ub h\Y f]W\Ygh aUb(


<cf h\cgY k\c `]jY U gd]f]hiU` `]ZY& kYU`h\ ]g bch cb`mibbYWYggUfm Vih ibWcaZcfhUV`Y( ?h ghcdg h\Y XYjY`cdxaYbh cZ cbYrg fYU` `]ZY(

DQWJOHJSÁĂ

<U]h\ UbgkYfg h\cgY eiYgh]cbg hc k\]W\ h\Y ]bhY``YWh WUbxbch Z]bX UbgkYfg& Vih k\]W\ aigh VY Ug_YX(

?KHUH LV RQO\ RQH WUXH UHOLJLRQ$ WKRXJK WKHUH DUH PDQ\ GLIIHUcHQW IDLWKV&

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?h ]g cb`m ZU]h\ k\]W\ WfYUhYg h\Y dckYfZi` Wcbj]Wh]cbg&h\Y YbYf[m& UbX h\Y ib]hm k\]W\ WUb WifY gcW]Yhm(

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

MY \UjY cb`m cbY g]b`Ygg [i]XY& U ib]jYfgU` gd]f]h k\]W\ [Yhg]bhc U`` cZ ig h\ci[\ kY UfY U]` ]bX]j]XiU`g& UbX k\]W\ []jYgig h\Y if[Y hc Xc U`` h\Uh ]g bYWYggUfm( J \Yf gUaY gd]f]hk\]W\ Yl]ghg ]b U hfYY UbX dig\Yg ]h hc [fck ghfU][\h UbX hcdfcXiWY gYYXg Yl]ghg ]b ig& if[Yg ig hc VY W`cgYf hc =cX& UbXVf]b[g ig W`cgYf hc YUW\ ch\Yf(

M\Yb U dYfgcb ]g U`]jY& \Y VY`]YjYg5 h\Y W`cgYf \]g ZU]h\ ]g hch\Y hfih\& h\Y \Udd]Yf \]g `]ZY( J\Y Zifh\Yf Zfca h\Y hfih\\]g ZU]h\ ]g& h\Y acfY ib\Uddm \Y ]g(M]h\cih ZU]h\ \Y XcYg bch `]jY5 \Y X]Yg U dfYaUhifY

XYUh\ cf Y`gY _]``g \]agY`Z(

DQWJOHJSÆĈ

MY giZZYf Zfca h\Y dUgh& UbX kY gdc]` cif ZihifY VYWUigYkY bY[`YWh h\Y dfYgYbh(

J\Y VYgh h\Y ZihifY WUb cZZYf ]g XfYUag( J\YfY ]g cb`m cbYh\]b[ k\]W\ fYU``m Yl]ghg4 h\Y dfYgYbh(

8Y UhhYbh]jY hc h\Y dfYgYbh( Eb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh h]aY WUbkY ibXYfghUbX YhYfb]hm(

v7ZhYf @E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

@VH \RXU ERG\$ \RXU YHVVHO$ WRGD\+ WRPRUURZ LW FDQ EHEURNHQ&

vJ\Y J7BCK:

J\YfY ]g bc dUgh UbX bc ZihifY5 bc cbY \Ug YjYf YbhYfYXh\cgY hkc ]aU[]bUfm _]b[Xcag( J\YfY ]g cb`m h\Y dfYgYbh(:c bch kcffm UVcih h\Y ZihifY& VYWUigY h\YfY ]g bcZihifY( B]jY ]b h\Y dfYgYbh UbX Zcf h\Y dfYgYbh& UbX ]Z mcifdfYgYbh ]g [ccX& h\Yb ]h ]g [ccX ZcfYjYf(

?Z mci \UjY X]ZZ]Wi`h h]aYg& ]Z mci giZZYf Zfca h\Y `cgg cZ`cjYX cbYg cf Zfca ZYUfg UVcih h\Y ZihifY& fYaYaVYf h\Uh`]ZY Yl]ghg cb`m ]b h\Y dfYgYbh UbX X]fYWh U`` mcif h\ci[\hgUbX aYacf]Yg hc h\]g dfYgYbh( 7`` mcif Ub[i]g\ UVcih h\YdUgh UbX mcif kcff]Yg UVcih h\Y ZihifY k]`` X]gUddYUf& UbXmci k]`` ZYY` ZfYYXca UbX \Udd]bYgg(

DQWJOHJSÁǺ

Oci WUbbch aYUgifY [ccX Vm Y]h\Yf h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ bYYX cfgUWf]Z]WY& Vih cb`m Vm h\Y Wcaaib]WUh]cb k]h\ =cX k\]W\]g YghUV`]g\YX VYhkYYb h\Y []jYf UbX h\Y fYWY]jYf(

8LIH DORQH LV QRW JRRG& 3RRGQHVV H[LVWV RQO\ LQ D SURSHU$ YLUcWXRXV OLIH& $ # !#" 7bbUYig IYbYWU?h ]g bch U j]fhiY& Vih U _]bX cZ XYWY]hZi` g]a]`]hiXY& hc Zi`xZ]`` cif Xihm Zcf h\Y difdcgY cZ ]hg fYkUfX(


7`` dYcd`Y VYWcaY W`cgYf& acfY cf `Ygg& hc cbY cZ hkccddcg]hY `]a]hg4 cbY ]g `]ZY cb`m Zcf cbYgY`Z& UbX h\Y ch\Yf]g `]ZY cb`m Zcf =cX(

? WU`` h\]g `]ZY U \Uddm cbY ]b k\]W\ ? Xc cbY [ccX XYYXUZhYf Ubch\Yf& k]h\ bc ]bhYfjU`g VYhkYYb h\Ya(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

BH GR JRRG RQO\ ZKHQ ZH GR QRW QRWLFH ZKDW ZH GR$ ZKHQZH IRUJHW RXUVHOYHV DQG OLYH RQO\ LQ RWKHUV&

DQWJOHJSÁĄ

7 aUhYf]U` Yj]` XcbY Vm U dYfgcb XcYg bch fYhifb hc h\YYj]`XcYf& Vih h\Y Yj]` ZYY`]b[ k\]W\ kUg WfYUhYX Vm h\Y g]bxZi` XYYX k]`` ZYghYf ]b \]g gci` UbX gccbYf cf `UhYf aU_Y\]a giZZYf(

?Z ]b h\Y acfb]b[ U dYfgcb kUbhg hc Xc Yj]` ibhc ch\Yfg&Yj]` k]`` fYhifb hc \]a Vm b][\hZU``(

v?D:?7D M?I:EC

?KH HYLOGRHU KDUPV KLPVHOI ILUVW$ EHIRUH KH KDUPV RWKHUV&vI7?DJ 7K=KIJ?D;

;jYfm aUb VYWcaYg k\Uh \Y hYUW\Yg ch\Yfg hc VY( J\cgYk\c [U]b j]Whcfm cjYf h\YagY`jYg k]`` [U]b j]Whcfm cjYfch\Yfg( ?h ]g acgh X]ZZ]Wi`h hc UW\]YjY j]Whcfm cjYf cbYgY`Z(;jYfm aUb \Ug dckYf cb`m cjYf \]agY`Z(


J\YfY ]g bc aUhYf]U` [ccXbYgg k\]W\ WUb fYghcfY h\Y gci`UZhYf h\Y XUaU[Y XcbY Vm h\Y Yj]` k\]W\ mci WfYUhY(

DQWJOHJSÂÀ

HYaYaVYf4 J\cgY k\c giZZYf h\fci[\ hc h\Y YbX k]`` VYgUjYX( LYfm cZhYb U dYfgcb VYWcaYg XYgdYfUhY cf YjYbghcdg ]b \]g difdcgY k\Yb cb`m U gaU`` YZZcfh ]g bYYXYX hcUW\]YjY ]h(

8ih VYkUfY cZ aYb4 Zcf h\Ym k]`` XY`]jYf mci id hc h\YWcibW]`g& UbX h\Ym k]`` gWcif[Y mci ]b h\Y]f gmbU[c[iYg57bX mY g\U`` VY Vfci[\h VYZcfY [cjYfbcfg UbX _]b[g Zcfam gU_Y& Zcf U hYgh]acbm U[U]bgh h\Ya UbX h\Y =Ybh]`Yg(8ih k\Yb h\Ym XY`]jYf mci id& hU_Y bc h\ci[\h \ck cfk\Uh mY g\U`` gdYU_4 Zcf ]h g\U`` VY []jYb mci ]b h\Uh gUaY\cif k\Uh mY g\U`` gdYU_( <cf ]h ]g bch mY h\Uh gdYU_& Vihh\Y Id]f]h cZ mcif <Uh\Yf k\]W\ gdYU_Yh\ ]b mci(

vC7JJ>;M A\ +1',*

H][\h WUbbch VY XYZYUhYX& VYWUigY ]h ]g XcbY bch Vm mcifk]`` Vih UWWcfX]b[ hc h\Y YhYfbU` Ùkg cZ =cX(

vJ>EC7I 97HBOB;

FYfgYWih]cb UbX giZZYf]b[ UfY h\Y bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cbg cZh\Y Zi`Z]`àYbh cZ 9\f]gh]Ub Ùk( FYfgYWih]cb ]g dfYW]cigVYWUigY ]h fYjYU`g k\Yh\Yf U dYfgcb `]jYg k]h\ fYU` ZU]h\(

0R QRW VHHN ORYH LQ RWKHU SHRSOH$ DQG GR QRW FRPSODLQ DERXWWKH DEVHQFH RI WKHLU ORYH IRU \RX& >RPH SHRSOH ORYH ZURQJ$QRW ULJKW+ WKHUHIRUH$ WW\ WR SOHDVH 3RG$ UDWKHU WKDQ SHRSOH&

DQWJOHJSÂÁ

J\YfY ]g bc XYYX ]b h\]g `]ZY gc ]adcgg]V`Y h\Uh mci WUbbchXc ]h( Ocif k\c`Y `]ZY g\ci`X VY `]jYX Ug Ub \Yfc]W XYYX(

;jYfm h]aY mci kU_Y id UbX Ug_ mcifgY`Z& sM\Uh [ccXh\]b[g Ua ? [c]b[ hc Xc hcXUm6t fYaYaVYf h\Uh& k\Yb h\Ygib [cYg Xckb Uh gibgYh& ]h k]`` hU_Y U dUfh cZ mcif `]ZYk]h\ ]h(

v?D:?7D FHEL;H8

?KH YLUWXH RI D SHUVRQ LV PHDVXUHG QRW E\ KLV RXWVWDQGLQJHIIRUWV$ KXW E\ KLV HYHU\GD\ EHKDYLRU&

v8B7?I; F7I97B

? Ua h\Y hcc` k]h\ k\]W\ =cX kcf_g( Cm j]fhiY ]g hc dUfxh]W]dUhY ]b h\]g kcf_& UbX ? WUb Xc gc ]Z ? _YYd h\Y ]bghfixaYbh k\]W\ ]g []jYb hc aY& bUaY`m am gci`& ]b ]aaUWiÙhYWcbX]h]cb(

7`` h\]b[g& YjYb h\Y acgh Wcad`]WUhYX h\]b[g& VYWcaYg]ad`Y UbX W`YUf ]Z mci gYdUfUhY h\Ya Zfca ch\Yf dYcd`YUbX dÙWY h\Ya VYZcfY =cX Zcf îX[aYbh(

Eh\Yf h\Ub cif gYfj]WY hc =cX& U`` cif UWh]cbg& k\Yh\YfkY Wcbg]XYf h\Ya ]adcfhUbh cf bch& UfY Wcad`YhY`m hf]jx]U`( MY aUm bch _bck k\Uh h\Y WcbgYeiYbWYg cZ cifUWh]cbg k]`` VY& Vih kY _bck k\Uh kY g\ci`X Xc(

J\Y acfY Vigm mci UfY k]h\ h\Y ]adfcjYaYbh cZ mcif]bbYf `]ZY& h\Y acfY UWh]jY mci VYWcaY ]b gcW]U` `]ZY& \Y`dx]b[ ch\Yf dYcd`Y(

5W LV DV ZURQJ IRU RQH SHUVRQ WR UXOH PDQ\ DV LW LV IRU PDQ\ WRUXOH RQH&

vLB7:?C?H 9>;HJAEL

M\Uh ]g hfih\6 <cf h\Y aU^cf]hm cZ dYcd`Y& hfih\ ]g h\YaU^cf]hm cZ WcibhYX jchYg(

vJ>EC7I" 97HBOB;

M\Yb ? g]h cb h\Y gYUg\cfY UbX `]ghYb hc h\Y kUjYg VYUh]b[cb h\Y gUbX& ? ZYY` ZfYY Zfca Ubm cV`][Uh]cb& UbX ? h\]b_h\Uh U`` h\Y dYcd`Y cZ h\Y kcf`X WUb W\Ub[Y h\Y]f Wcbgh]hixh]cbg k]h\cih aY(


DYjYf Vi]`X& Vih U`kUmg dÙbh4 ]b h\Y WUgY cZ h\Y Z]fgh&bUhifY k]`` ]bhYfZYfY UbX XYghfcm h\Y WfYUh]cb cZ mcifkcf_& Vih ]b h\Y WUgY cZ h\Y gYWcbX& bUhifY k]`` \Y`d mci&WUig]b[ [fckh\ ]b YjYfmh\]b[ mci dÙbhYX( J\Y gUaYh\]b[ \UddYbg ]b mcif gd]f]hiU` `]ZY4 h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\UfY ]b \Ufacbm k]h\ h\Y YhYfbU` Ùkg cZ \iaUb bUhifY k]``[fck& Vih h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ WcffYgdcbX hc h\Y hYadcfU`k]g\Yg cZ dYcd`Y k]`` bch(

DQWJOHJSÂÂ

DQWJOHJSÆǼ

J\Y eiYgh]cb cZ `]ZYrg aYUb]b[ ]gU X]ZZ]Wi`h dfcV`Yak\]W\ WUbbch VY gc`jYX( Ic& hcc& ]g h\Y eiYgh]cb& sM\mX]X =cX gYbX ig ]bhc h\]g kcf`X6t 8ih h\Y aYUb]b[ cZ `]ZYVYWcaYg jYfm g]ad`Y k\Yb U dYfgcb Ug_g \]agY`Z& sM\Uhg\ci`X 1 Xc6t

Ocif `]ZY aUm VY Wih g\cfh Uh Ubm h]aY5 h\YfYZcfY& mcif `]ZYg\ci`X \UjY U XYYd difdcgY& U g][b]Z]WUbWY h\Uh k]`` bchXYdYbX cb k\Yh\Yf ]h ]g g\cfh cf `cb[(

?KHUH LV RQO\ RQH ZD\$ LI \RX ZDQW WR OLYH ZLWKRXW XQGHUcVWDQGLQJ WKH PHDQLQJ RI \RXU OLIH* WR EHFRPH DGGLFWHG WRWREDFFR$ DOFRKRO$ DQG GUXJV$ DQG WR OLYH LQ WKH ZRUOG RI SHUcPDQHQW HQWHUWDLQPHQW&

J\]g kcf`X ]g bch U ^c_Y Vih fUh\Yf U d`UWY Zcf U hf]U`& U kUmghUh]cb hc U VYhhYf& YhYfbU` kcf`X( Eif difdcgY ]g hc aU_Y]h U VYhhYf UbX acfY ^cmcig d`UWY hc `]jY& Zcf h\cgY k\c`]jY k]h\ ig UbX h\cgY k\c WcaY UZhYf ig(

Eif gci`rg dYfZYWh]cb ]g cif `]ZYrg difdcgY5 Ubm ch\Yf difxdcgY& _YYd]b[ XYUh\ ]b a]bX& \Ug bc giVghUbWY(

>Y`d]b[ ch\Yfg hU_Yg h\Y Zcfa bch cb`m cZ d\mg]WU` U]X&Vih cZ gd]f]hiU` giddcfh Zcf mcif bY][\Vcf( Ihcd VÙa]b[mcif bY][\Vcf UbX fYgdYWh \]g \iaUb X][b]hm(

:c bch h\]b_ h\Uh mci UfY [YbYfcig VYWUigY mci []jY mcifYlWYgg kYU`h\ hc U dccf dYfgcb( HYU` [YbYfcg]hm fYei]fYgh\Uh mci( []jY h\]g dYfgcb U dÙWY ]b mcif \YUfh&


>Y ]g j]fhicig k\c XcYg bch dUm Ubm UhhYbh]cb hc `]VY` UbXYj]` gdYYW\(

Oci g\ci`X VY hfih\Zi`4 mci g\ci`X Ujc]X kfUh\5 mcig\ci`X []jY hc h\cgY k\c Ug_& VYWUigY h\Ym Ug_ Zcf gaU``h\]b[g( Oci k]`` VYWcaY \c`]Yf Vm Zc``ck]b[ h\YgY h\fYYdUh\g(


BLWK KXPEOHQHVV$ NLQGQHVV$ DQG VHOI%VDFULILFH$ \RX ZLOO WDNHWKH ZHDSRQ IURP DQ\ HQHP\& -Q\ ILUH GLHV LI WKHUH LV LQVXIILcFLHQW ZRRG&

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

Jfm bch hc \]XY h\Y g\UaYZi` aYacf]Yg cZ mcif g]bg ]bXUf_ WcaYfg( Eb h\Y WcbhfUfm& _YYd h\Ya W`cgY hc mciUbX fYaYaVYf h\Ya& VYZcfY mci îX[Y mcif bY][\Vcf(

DQWJOHJSÂÄ

DQWJOHJSÆĆ

MUf ]g aifXYf( Dc aUhhYf \ck aUbm dYcd`Y [Yh hc[Yh\Yfhc Wcaa]h aifXYf cf k\Uh h\Ym WU`` h\YagY`jYg& aifXYf ]gh\Y kcfgh g]b ]b h\Y kcf`X(

<HRSOH RI SODQHW 1DUWK DUH RQ D YHU\ ORZ OHYHO RI GHYHORSPHQW&1YHU\ GD\ LQ WKH QHZVSDSHUV \RX UHDG WKH QHZV DERXW PLOLWDU\WUHDWLHV$ DERXW WKH SUHSDUDWLRQV IRU ZDU$ IRU PDVV PDQVODXJKcWHU& <HRSOH GR QRW XQGHUVWDQG WKDW WKH OLIH RI HDFK PDQ LV KLVRZQ SHUVRQDO SULYDWH SURSHUW\&

v97C?BB; <B7CC7H?ED

J\Y aU^cf]hm cZ dYcd`Y bck ibXYfghUbX bch cb`m h\Y igYx`YggbYgg& Vih U`gc h\Y ghid]X]hm UbX WfiY`hm cZ Ubm kUf(

Kbh]` giW\ h]aY Ug dYcd`Y fY^YWh h\Y dckYf cZ [cjYfbaYbhhc [cjYfb& hc hUl& hc `Y[]g`UhY& UbX hc dib]g\& kUf k]``bYjYf ghcd( MUf ]g h\Y WcbgYeiYbWY cZ h\Y [cjYfbaYbhrgdckYf(

@igh Ug cbY WUbX`Y `][\hg Ubch\Yf UbX WUb `][\h h\cigUbXgcZ ch\Yf WUbX`Yg& gc cbY \YUfh ]`ìa]bUhYg Ubch\Yf \YUfhUbX WUb ]`ìa]bUhY h\cigUbXg cZ ch\Yf \YUfhg(

8YkUfY cZ h\cgY k\c kUbh hc Wcbj]bWY mci h\Uh ]h ]g]adcgg]V`Y hc ghf]jY Zcf [ccX îgh VYWUigY ]h ]g ]adcgg]V`Yhc fYUW\ dYfZYWh]cb(

v@E>D HKIA?D

=ccX Vcc_g UfY U [ccX ]bZìYbWY( =ccX Ufh ]g U [ccX]bZìYbWY( FfUmYf ]g Ub ]bZìYbWY Ug kY``( 8ih h\Y ghfcb[Ygh]bZìYbWY ]g h\Y YlUad`Y cZ U [ccX `]ZY( 7 [ccX `]ZYVYWcaYg U V`Ygg]b[ Zcf dYcd`Y& bch cb`m Zcf h\cgY k\c `]jY[ccX `]jYg Vih h\cgY k\c WUb gYY& _bck& UbX ibXYfghUbXgiW\ `]jYg(

5W LV GLIILFXOW WR EULQJ SHRSOH WR JRRGQHVV ZLWK OHVVRQV$ EXW LW LVHDV\ WR GR VR E\ H[DPSOH&

ÅHP EPN7bbUYig IYbYWU

8YkUfY cZ [fcidg cZ dYcd`Y k\c UfY \UfaZi` Zcf mcifgci`( Jfm hc Ujc]X h\Ya( Oci g\ci`X dfU]gY [ccX WcadUbmUbX gYY_ ]h(

DQWJOHJSÂĂ

DQWJOHJSÆĈ

?Z U dUgg]cb YaVfUWYg mci& mci g\ci`X fYaYaVYf h\Uh h\]gdUgg]cbUhY XYg]fY ]g bch U dUfh cZ mcif gci`& Vih U XUf_ WcjxYf]b[ k\]W\ g\ihg cih h\Y hfiY eiU`]h]Yg cZ mcif gci`(

Oci g\ci`X VY U `UbhYfb Zcf mcifgY`Z( :fUk W`cgY hc h\Y`][\h k]h\]b mci UbX gYY_ bc ch\Yf g\Y`hYf(

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

- SHUVRQ_V VRXO PD\ EH FRPSDUHG WR D WUDQVSDUHQW EDOO ZKLFKLV OLW IURP WKH LQVLGH ZLWK LWV RZQ OLJKW& ?KLV IODPH LV QRW RQO\WKH VRXUFH RI DOO OLJKW DQG WUXWK$ EXW LW LOOXPLQDWHV HYHU\WKLQJDURXQG \RX& 5Q WKLV VWDWH$ WKH VRXO LV IUHH DQG KDSS\& ;QO\ LILW EHFRPHV DGGLFWHG WR DQ\WKLQJ RXWVLGH \RX ZLOO LW EHFRPHWURXEOHG$ GDUNHQHG$ DQG LPSHQHWUDEOH& 0LVWUDFWLRQV REVWUXFW

WKH OLJKW ZKLFK VKRZV \RX WKH ZD\&vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

J\Y gci` ]g U a]ffcf ]b k\]W\ mci WUb gYY h\Y fYZ`YWh]cb cZX]j]bY ]bhY``YWh(

v@E>D HKIA?D

7g gccb Ug mci ZYY` dUgg]cb& hfm hc ZYY` ]b mcifgY`Z h\YibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ mcif X]j]bY bUhifY( 7g gccb Ug mci dYfxWY]jY h\Uh mcif X]j]bY bUhifY ]g ]bUWh]jY UbX h\Uh mci UfYdcggYggYX Vm dUgg]cbg& Z][\h k]h\ h\YgY dUgg]cbg(

DQWJOHJSÂǺ

B]ZY ]g bch XYghfcmYX& cb`m W\Ub[YX& Vm XYUh\(

J\Y ZihifY ]g cb`m Ub ]`ìg]cb ]bZYffYX Zfca cif dfYgYbhghUhY( M\Uh ]g ]adcfhUbh ]g bch h\Y `Yb[h\ cZ `]ZY& Vih h\YXYdh\ cZ `]ZY( M\Uh ]g acgh ]adcfhUbh ]g bch hc aU_Y `]ZY`cb[Yf& Vih hc hU_Y mcif gci` cih cZ h]aY& Ug YjYfm giV`]aYUWh XcYg( Eb`m h\Yb XcYg mcif `]ZY VYWcaY Zi`Z]``YX( 7bXXc bch Ug_ mcifgY`Z eiYgh]cbg UVcih h]aY( @Ygig X]X bchYldÙ]b U h\]b[ UVcih h\Y YhYfb]hm cZ `]ZY& Vih \]g ]bZìYbWYVfci[\h dYcd`Y hc h\Y YhYfbU`(


2DLWK LQ WKH HWHUQLW\ LV JLYHQ WR XV QRW LQ PHGLWDWLRQ$ KXW LQOLIH&

?h ]g bch fYUgcb]b[ k\]W\ k]`` Wcbj]bWY mci cZ h\Y bYWYgxg]hm cZ `]ZY UZhYf XYUh\& Vih YlUad`Y4 k\Yb mci kU`_ jYfmW`cgY hc U dYfgcb& \UbX ]b \UbX& UbX h\]g dYfgcb X]gUdxdYUfg ]bhc Ub UVmgg& RYHU WKHUH$ ghcd ]b Zfcbh cZ h\Y UVmggUbX hfm hc `cc_ k]h\]b ]h(

J\Y `YjY` cZ ZYUf mci ZYY` UVcih XYUh\ ]g h\Y `YjY` cZ mcifibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ `]ZY(J\Y `Ygg mci ZYUf XYUh\& h\Y acfY mci dcggYgg ZfYYXca&

hfUbei]``]hm& UbX Ub ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y [fYUhbYgg cZmcif gd]f]h UbX h\Y ^cm cZ `]ZY(J\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ YhYfb]hm ]g dUfh cZ h\Y bUhifY cZ

h\Y \iaUb gci`(

DQWJOHJSÆĊ

7 kcfX ]g Ub UWh]cb(

:c bch gUm kcfXg mci Xc bch ZYY`& `Ygh mcif gci` VY V`UW_xYbYX k]h\ XUf_bYgg(


Ocif YbYa]Yg WUb VY acfY igYZi` hc mci h\Ub mcif Zf]YbXg&VYWUigY mcif Zf]YbXg WUb cZhYb dUfXcb mcif kYU_bYggYg&Vih mcif YbYa]Yg bch]WY h\Ya UbX UhhfUWh mcif UhhYbh]cbhc h\Ya(:c bch bY[`YWh h\Y cd]b]cb cZ mcif YbYa]Yg(

- ZLVH PDQ GRHV QRW MXGJH D SHUVRQ IRU KLV ZRUGV$ EXW DW WKHVDPH WLPH GRHV QRW QHJOHFW DQRWKHU SHUVRQ V ZRUGV$ HYHQZKHQ WKHVH ZRUGV DUH SURQRXQFHG E\ DQ XQZRUWK\ SHUVRQ&

v9>?D;I; M?I:EC

7 dYfgcbrg hcb[iY ]g U hcc` k\]W\ ]g giZZ]W]Ybh hc hfUbga]hh\Y ]XYUg WfYUhYX Vm h\Y \iaUb a]bX( 8ih ]b h\Y XcaU]bcZ hfiY UbX XYYd ZYY`]b[g& cif hcb[iY ]g kYU_(

vB7@EI AEIIKJ>

DYjYf ]g h\YfY U g]b[`Y ]bghUbWY k\Yb U `]Y WUb VY ^igh]Z]YX(

DQWJOHJSÃÀ

M\Yb U \iaV`Y dYfgcb Zcf[Yhg \]agY`Z& \Y ]g ib]hYX k]h\=cX(

FYcd`Y k\c hfm hc ZcfWY W]fWiaghUbWYg VYWcaY h\Y]fg`UjYg( J\cgY k\c igY h\Ya VYWcaY h\Y]f aUghYfg(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ ]b h\]g kcf`X acfY hYbXYf UbX acfY d`]xUV`Y h\Ub kUhYf& mYh \UfX UbX f][]X h\]b[g WUbbch fYg]gh ]h(MYU_bYgg XYZYUhg ghfYb[h\& hYbXYfbYgg XYZYUhg f][]X]hm(

;jYfmcbY _bckg h\]g `Uk& Vih bc cbY UWhg idcb ]h( J\YkYU_Ygh ]b h\Y kcf`X [U]b j]Whcfm cjYf h\Y ghfcb[Ygh5h\YfYZcfY& h\YfY ]g U [fYUh UXjUbhU[Y ]b \ia]`]hm UbXg]`YbWY( Eb`m U ZYk dYcd`Y ]b h\]g kcf`X UfY hfi`m \iaV`Y(

BUc'Jni

?KH PRUH KXPEOH D SHUVRQ LV$ WKH IUHHU DQG VWURQJHU KH LV&

7 kcaUb XcYg bch X]ZZYf Zfca U aUb ]b \Yf W\]YZ a]gg]cb(J\]g a]gg]cb ]g hc gYfjY =cX( J\Y X]ZZYfYbWY ]g ]b h\YaYh\cX cZ h\]g gYfj]WY( J\ci[\ h\Y a]gg]cb cZ U kcaUbrg`]ZY ]g h\Y gUaY Ug h\Uh cZ U aUbrg `]ZY UbX h\Y gYfj]WY hc=cX ]g Zi`Z]``YX Vm h\Y gUaY aYUbg& bUaY`m `cjY& Zcf h\YaU^cf]hm cZ kcaYb h\Y aYh\cX cZ h\]g gYfj]WY ]g acfYgdYW]Z]W h\Ub Zcf aYb( J\]g ]g h\Y V]fh\ UbX idVf]b[]b[ cZbYk kcf_Yfg Zcf h\Y BcfX h\fci[\cih `]ZY(

?Z U kcaUbrg _]bXbYgg ]g VcibX`Ygg& h\Yb \Yf fU[Y WUb U`gc\UjY bc `]a]hg( 7 [ccX k]ZY ]g h\Y VYgh []Zh Zcf U \igVUbX&UbX Ub Yj]` k]ZY ]g U hYff]V`Y i`WYf Zcf U aUb(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

?KH PRUH EHDXWLIXO D ZRPDQ LV$ WKH PRUH KRQHVW VKH VKRXOGEH EHFDXVH LW LV RQO\ WKURXJK KRQHVW\ WKDW VKH FDQ GHDO ZLWKDOO WKH HYLO DQG GDPDJH ZKLFK KHU EHDXW\ FDQ SURGXFH&


?h ]g bch igiU``m \igVUbXg k\c W\ccgY h\Y]f k]jYg& Vihk]jYg k\c W\ccgY h\Y]f \igVUbXg( ?b cfXYf hc Z]bX U VYhxhYf ZUh\Yf Zcf \Yf W\]`XfYb& U kcaUb aigh _bck [ccX UbXYj]`( J\YfYZcfY& kcaYb g\ci`X \UjY U [ccX YXiWUh]cbZ]fgh cZ U``(

J\YfY ]g bch\]b[ acfY bUhifU` Zcf U kcaUb h\Ub gY`Z'gUWf]Z]WY( Dch\]b[ WUb VY acfY ibd`YUgUbh ]b \Yf h\UbgY`Z]g\bYgg(

JIJOHJSÁ

s:c bch _]``t4 h\YgY kcfX fYZYf bch îgh hc h\Y _]``]b[ cZ UdYfgcb& Vih hc h\Y _]``]b[ cZ Ubmh\]b[ k\]W\ ]g U`]jY( J\]gWcaaUbXaYbh kUg kf]hhYb ]b h\Y dYcd`Yrg \YUfhg YjYbVYZcfY ]h kUg \YUfX cb Ch( I]bU](

M\UhYjYf Uf[iaYbhg h\Ym igY U[U]bgh jY[YhUf]Ub]ga& aYbWUbbch dfYjYbh h\YagY`jYg Zfca ZYY`]b[ WcadUgg]cb UbXX]g[igh Uh _]``]b[ g\YYd& Wckg& cf W\]W_Ybg( Ccgh dYcd`Ykci`X fUh\Yf ghcd YUh]b[ aYUh h\Ub _]`` h\YgY Ub]aU`g

h\YagY`jYg(

?KH PRUH SHRSOH EHFRPH HGXFDWHG DQG WKH PRUH RXU SRSXODcWLRQ JURZV$ WKH PRUH SHRSOH ZLOO PRYH IURP HDWLQJ DQLPDOV%WR HDWLQJ SODQWV&

HYUX]b[ UbX kf]h]b[ Xc bch YXiWUhY ]Z h\Ym Xc bch \Y`ddYcd`Y hc VYWcaY _]bXYf hc U`` Ub]aU`g(

v@E>D HKIA?D

J\Y ghid]X]hm& Ùk`YggbYgg& UbX \Ufa& Vch\ d\mg]WU` UbXacfU`& cZ aYUh YUh]b[ ]g gc W`YUf h\Uh aYUh YUh]b[ ]g bchgiddcfhYX Vm fYUgcb]b[ Vih Vm c`X hfUX]h]cbg UbX dfYîxX]WYg( MY g\ci`X bch YjYb Uf[iY UVcih h\Y UVgYbWY cZ`c[]W ]b YUh]b[ aYUh5 ]h ]g gY`Z'Yj]XYbh(

JIJOHJSÂ

7fh ]g h\Y UWh]j]hm k\YfYVm U dYfgcb aU_Yg U WcbgW]cigUhhYadh hc igY h\Y dUfh]Wi`Uf aYUbg Uh \]g X]gdcgU` hchfUbga]h \]g ZYY`]b[g hc ch\Yfg gc h\Uh h\Ym ZYY` h\Ya Ug]bhYbgY`m Ug \Y XcYg(

?b U hfiY WfYUh]cb cZ Ufh& h\YfY ]g bch cb`m bc VcfXYfVYhkYYb h\Y kcf_ cZ Ufh UbX h\Y Ufh]gh& Vih U`gc VYhkYYbh\Y kcf_ UbX h\Y ch\Yf dYcd`Y k\c YldYf]YbWY ]h( J\YaU^cf UhhfUWh]cb cZ fYU` Ufh `]Yg ]b h\]g ib]Z]WUh]cb(

- QHZ ZRUN RI DUW VKRXOG EULQJ D QHZ HPRWLRQ LQ RXU OLIH&

;aYfgcb gU]X h\Uh aig]W \Y`dg dYcd`Y hc Z]bX h\Y [fYUhxbYgg ]b h\Y]f gci`g( J\Y gUaY WUb VY gU]X UVcih Ubm ZcfacZ Ufh(

9cbhYadcfUfm Ufh]ghg UbX gW\c`Ufg Xc bch Zi`Z]`` UbX WUbxbch Zi`Z]`` h\Y]f XYgh]b]Yg& VYWUigY h\Ym \UjY hfUbgZcfaYXh\Y]f Xih]Yg ]bhc h\Y]f f][\hg(

0HFHPEHU )

?h ]g bch gU]X Vm W\UbWY h\Uh h\Y YggYbWY cZ X]j]bY Ùk ]g hc`cjY =cX UbX mcif bY][\Vcf( DY][\Vcfg WcaY UbX [c& Vih=cX Yl]ghg U`kUmg( J\YfYZcfY& U aUb WUb Zi`Z]`` h\]g Ùkk\Yb \Y ]g U`cbY ]b U XYgYfh& cf k\Yb \Y ]g ]b df]gcb( >YWUb `cjY =cX UbX =cXrg aUb]ZYghUh]cbg YjYb ]b \]gh\ci[\hg& aYacf]Yg& UbX ]aU[]bUh]cb(

HYaYaVYf h\Uh h\Y gd]f]h cZ =cX Yl]ghg ]b YjYfm dYfgcb&h\Y gUaY gd]f]h h\Uh []jYg mci `]ZY( J\YfYZcfY mci g\ci`Xbch cb`m `cjY Vih fYgdYWh h\Y gci` cZ YjYfm dYfgcb Ug U\c`m dÙWY( TT

? Xc bch [f]YjY h\Uh U dYfgcb X]Yg& h\Uh \Y `cgYg \]g acbYm&\]g YghUhY& cf U`` \]g dfcdYfhm& U`` h\Uh WUb VY`cb[ hc U aUb(8ih ]h ]g U [fYUh d]hm k\Yb U dYfgcb `cgYg \]g [fYUhYgh dcgxgYgg]cb& \]g \iaUb X][b]hm(

v;F?9J;JKI

0R QRW GR DQ\WKLQJ$ HLWKHU DPRQJ RWKHUV RU DORQH$ ZKLFK LVRSSRVHG E\ \RXU FRQVFLHQFH&

?b cif h]aY& dYcd`Y Zcf[Yh h\Uh Z]fgh cZ U`` h\Ym g\ci`XfYgdYWh h\Y \iaUb VY]b[ ]b h\YagY`jYg(


8YmcbX \]g Xihm hc \]g bY][\Vcf& YjYfm dYfgcb \Ug UbcV`][Uh]cb hc \]agY`Z& Ug hc h\Y Icb cZ =cX(

JIJOHJSÄ

J\Y `cb[Yf aUb_]bX Yl]ghg& h\Y acfY `]VYfUhYX ]h VYWcaYgZfca dfYîX]WY UbX h\Y acfY W`YUf`m ]h dYfWY]jYg h\Y Ùk cZ`]ZY(

Eifg ]g h\Y U[Y cZ Wf]h]W]ga(HY`][]cb UbX Ùk hfm hc YgWUdY Zfca Wf]h]W]ga& fY`][]cb

Vm gUm]b[ h\Uh ]h ]g X]j]bY UbX Ùk Vm g\ck]b[ h\Uh ]h ]gdckYfZi`( 8ih gcaY gigd]W]cbg Uf]gY Zfca h\]g YgWUdY&VYWUigY kY WUb fYgdYWh cb`m h\cgY h\]b[g k\]W\ ghUbX id]b ZfYY UbX diV`]W hf]U`(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

>WXG\ HYHU\WKLQJ$ DQG SXW LQWHOOHFW ILUVW&vFOJ>7=EH7I

:c bch VY UZfU]X cZ h\Y kUm mcif ]bhY``YWh WU``g ]bhc eiYgxh]cb c`X ghcf]Yg UbX `Y[YbXg( J\Y difY ]bhY``YWh WUbbchXYghfcm Ubmh\]b[ k]h\cih fYdÙW]b[ ]h k]h\ h\Y hfih\4 h\]g]g cbY cZ ]hg YggYbh]U` eiU`]h]Yg(

JIJOHJSĆ

JIJOHJSĂ

MY \UjY a]gWcbWYdh]cbg bch VYWUigY kY h\]b_ ]``c[]WU``mVih VYWUigY kY `]jY cif `]jYg VUX`m(

?[bcfUbWY WUbbch `YUX hc Yj]`& a]gWcbWYdh]cbg `YUX hc Yj]`(?hrg bch k\Uh dYcd`Y Xc _bck& ]hrg k\Uh h\Ym dfYhYbX h\Uhh\Ym Xc(

v@ ;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7K

;jYfm a]gWcbWYdh]cb ]g U dc]gcb5 h\YfY UfY bc \Ufa`Ygga]gWcbWYdh]cbg(


EbY cZ h\Y Yj]` dfcdYfh]Yg cZ aUb ]g h\Uh \Y `cjYg cb`m\]agY`Z UbX kUbhg [ccXbYgg cb`m Zcf \]agY`Z( 8ih kcY hc\]a k\c `cjYg cb`m \]agY`Z

v8B7?I; F7I97B

J\Y Z][\h VYhkYYb h\Y gd]f]hiU` UbX aUhYf]U` ]bbYf bUhifY[cYg cb ]b YjYfmcbY( J\ig& U`` dYcd`Y \UjY a]gWcbWYdxh]cbg& UbX aUbm k]`` U`kUmg a]ghU_Y h\Ya Zcf h\Y hfih\(

?R IHHG WKH KXQJU\$ WR FORWKH WKH QDNHG$ WR YLVLW WKH LOO LQ WKHKRVSLWDObWKHVH DUH DFWV RI PHUF\$ KXW WKHUH LV RQH FKDULWDEOHGHHG ZKLFK FDQQRW EH FRPSDUHG WR WKHP* WR IUHH \RXU EURWKHUIURP PLVFRQFHSWLRQ&

JIJOHJSĈ

B]ZY Wcbg]ghg cZ biaYfcig ]bj]g]V`Y& ]adYfWYdh]V`YW\Ub[Yg& W\Ub[Yg h\Uh VY[Ub Uh V]fh\ UbX YbX k]h\ XYUh\(?h ]g bch dcgg]V`Y Zcf ig \iaUbg hc cVgYfjY h\Ya U``(

Jfi`m& hfi`m& ? gUm hc mci& ib`Ygg U [fU]b cZ k\YUh ZU``g ]bhch\Y YUfh\ UbX X]Yg& ]h fYaU]bg Vm ]hgY`Z U`cbY5 Vih ]Z ]h X]Yg&]h VYUfg aiW\ Zfi]h( >Y k\c `cjYg \]g `]ZY `cgYg ]h& UbX \Yk\c \UhYg \]g `]ZY ]b h\]g kcf`X g\U`` _YYd ]h hc `]ZY YhYfbU`(

?E>D +,4,.',/

B]ZY ]g W\Ub[]b[ U`` h\Y h]aY& UbX cb`m h\Y ][bcfUbh Xc bch`cc_ ]bhc h\Y XYdh\ cZ h\]b[g(

vBK9O C7BEHO

M\m UfY mci gc UZfU]X cZ W\Ub[Y6 Dch\]b[ ]b h\]g kcf`XWUb VY XcbY k]h\cih W\Ub[Y( Eb`m cbY fi`Y g\ci`X fYaU]bWcbghUbh4 Xc bch Xc Ubmh\]b[ ]b\iaUbY hc ch\Yfg(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

;jYfmh\]b[ ]b h\]g kcf`X V`ccag& [fckg& UbX fYhifbg hc ]hgfcchg( HYhifb]b[ hc cbYrg fcchg aYUbg VYWca]b[ ib]hYXk]h\ bUhifY5 VYWca]b[ ib]hYX k]h\ bUhifY ]bjc`jYg YhYfxb]hm( J\Y XYghfiWh]cb cZ mcif VcXm \c`Xg bc XUb[Yf ]b]hgY`Z(

vB7E'JPK

0HDWK LV D FKDQJH WR D IRUP ZLWK ZKLFK RXU VSLULW LV XQLWHG&CRX VKRXOG QRW FRQIXVH WKH IRUP ZLWK WKRVH WKLQJV ZLWKZKLFK LW LV XQLWHG&

JIJOHJSǺ

?h gYYag gc YUgm hc Zi`Z]`` h\Y Ùk cZ =cX h\Uh ]g YldfYggYX]b h\Y 9\f]gh]Ub hYUW\]b[& Vih kY UfY gh]`` gc ZUf Zfca h\]gZi`Z]`àYbh

?KH ODZ RI ULJKW OLYLQJ LV QRW LPPHGLDWHO\ FOHDU WR WKH ZLVHPDQ$ KXW LW EHFRPHV PXFK FOHDUHU ZKHQ KH IROORZV LW& ?KHODZ RI ULJKW OLYLQJ LV LPPHGLDWHO\ FOHDU WR WKH RUGLQDU\ SHUcVRQ$ EXW LW EHFRPHV OHVV REYLRXV ZKHQ KH WULHV WR IROORZ LW&

v9ED<K9?KI

J\YfY ]g cb`m cbY YhYfbU` Ùk( ?h XcYg bch W\Ub[Y UbX ]h[cjYfbg U`` dYcd`Y Uh U`` h]aYg(


9DQ_V SXUSRVH LV WR VHUYH DOO PDQNLQG$ QRW WR VHUYH RQO\ RQHPDQ ZKLOH GRLQJ KDUP WR RWKHUV&

<cf U 9\f]gh]Ub& h\Y `cjY cZ cbYrg ach\YfÙbX WUb VY UbcVghUW`Y hc h\Y `cjY cZ cbYrg bY][\Vcf(

Bcgh gci`g YgWUdY h\Y]f `cgg cZ Wcbhfc` ]b dUhf]ch]ga(v:H( I7CK;B @E>DIED

FUhf]ch]ga ]g bch U j]fhiY( IUWf]Z]W]b[ mcif `]ZY Zcf Ub ]bgh]xhih]cb k\]W\ YaVcX]Yg dfYîX]WY WUbbch VY mcif Xihm(

FYcd`Y Xc aUbm VUX h\]b[g Zcf gY`Z]g\ fYUgcbg5 h\Ym XckcfgY h\]b[g Zcf h\Y]f ZUa]`]Yg( 8ih h\Ym Xc h\Y kcfgh ]bh\Y bUaY cZ dUhf]ch]ga& UbX h\Ym UfY aUXY dfciX Vm h\YgYWf]aYg4 gdm]b[& ibXi`m \YUjm hUl Wc``YWh]b[& gUWf]Z]W]b[`]jYg& UbX kU[]b[ kUfg(

Bcj]b[ mcif Wcibhfm UbX `cj]b[ mcif ZUa]`m UfY Vch\j]fhiYg h\Uh WUb VYWcaY j]WYg k\Yb h\Ym VYWcaY cjYfxk\Yà]b[ UbX XUaU[Y mcif `cjY Zcf mcif bY][\Vcf(

JIJOHJSĊ

EbY cZ h\Y kcfgh h\]b[g dcgg]V`Y ]g hc Zc``ck h\Y fi`Y4 s8Y`]_Y YjYfmcbY& Zc``ck h\Y WfckX(t

McY hc h\Y kcf`X VYWUigY cZ ]hg ghiaV`]b[ V`cW_ <cf ]h ]g]bYj]hUV`Y h\Uh ghiaV`]b[ V`cW_g WcaY& Vih kcY hc h\UhaUb h\fci[\ k\ca h\Y ghiaV`]b[ V`cW_ WcaYg 7bX ]Zmcif \UbX cf mcif Zcch WUigY mci hc ghiaV`Y& Wih ]h cZZUbX h\fck ]h Zfca mci5 ]h ]g VYhhYf Zcf mci hc YbhYf `]ZYWf]dd`YX cf `UaY h\Ub \Uj]b[ hkc \UbXg UbX hkc ZYYh& hcVY WUgh ]bhc h\Y YhYfbU` Z]fY(

vC7JJ>;M +241'3

EbY cZ h\Y aU^cf cVghUW`Yg ]adYX]b[ Ubm dcg]h]jY ZihifYW\Ub[Y ]b cif `]jYg ]g h\Uh kY UfY hcc Vigm k]h\ cif WifxfYbh kcf_ cf UWh]j]hm( BYj] ei]h \]g hUl'kcf_& FYhYfghcddYX Z]g\]b[ Uh U `U_Y& FUi` WYUgYX VY]b[ U df]Ygh( J\YmU`` `YZh h\Y]f ^cVg VYWUigY h\Ym h\ci[\h ]h kUg bYWYggUfm(

v@E>D HKIA?D

?Z U dYfgcbrg \UbX ]g bch XUaU[YX& h\Yb ]h WUb k]h\ghUbXh\Y V]hY cZ U dc]gcbcig gbU_Y( ?hg dc]gcb dcgYg bc XUb[Yfhc U \YU`h\m \UbX( ;j]` ]g \Ufa`Ygg Zcf \]a k\c ]g bch UbYj]`XcYf(

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

2DOVH VKDPH LV WKH GHYLO_V IDYRULWH HPRWLRQ+ LW LV HYHQ ZRUVHWKDQ IDOVH SULGH& <ULGH FDQ VXSSRUW HYLO$ EXW IDOVH VKDPH VWRSVJRRGQHVV&

v@E>D HKIA?D

J\YfY ]g bc Yj]` ]b h\Y kcf`X ]hgY`Z( 7`` Yj]` Yl]ghg ]b cifgci`g& UbX WUb VY XYghfcmYX(

JIJOHJSÁÀ

Dch\]b[ ]g acfY ^cmZi` h\Ub h\Y ÙVcf cZ U ZUfaYf h]``]b[h\Y gc]`(

?KH EHVW IRRG LV WKH IRRG \RX RU \RXU FKLOGUHQ PDNH E\ \RXUc

VHOIvCE>7CC;:

J\cgY k\c dfcj]XY Zcf h\Y]f ckb ZccX Vm h\YagY`jYgXYgYfjY acfY fYgdYWh h\Ub h\cgY k\c WÙ]a hc VY fY`]x[]cig(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

Mcf_]b[ cb h\Y ÙbX UbX aU_]b[ mcif ckb VfYUX ]gbrhbYWYggUfm Zcf U`` dYcd`Y& Vih bc hmdY cZ kcf_ ]g acfY]adcfhUbh Zcf \iaUb]hm& UbX bc hmdY cZ kcf_ cZZYfg U[fYUhYf XY[fYY cZ ]bXYdYbXYbWY UbX [ccX(

JIJOHJSÁÁ

JIJOHJSÁÂ

A]bXbYgg XYZYUhg YjYfmh\]b[ UbX WUb bYjYf VY XYZYUhYX(

CRX FDQ VWDQG ILUP LQ D ILJKW DJDLQVW HYHU\WKLQJ H[FHSWNLQGQHVV&

v@;7D @79GK;I HEKII;7Kv

?h ]g bch h\Y V`Ua]b[ cZ Yj]` Vih h\Y [`cf]Zm]b[ cZ [ccXbYggh\Uh WfYUhYg \Ufacbm ]b cif `]ZY(

vBK9O C7BEHO

?Z U [ccX UWh]cb \Ug Ub i`hYf]cf WUigY& h\Yb ]h ]g bch hfi`m[ccX( ?Z ]h YldYWhg fYkUfX& ]h ]g bch hfi`m [ccX( =ccXh\]b[g UfY VYmcbX fYUgcb UbX WcbgYeiYbWY(

?b h\Y gUaY kUm h\Uh Z]fYkcf_g UbX hcfW\Yg WUbbch VYgYYb ]b h\Y `][\h cZ h\Y gib& h\Y VYgh ]bhY``YWh UbX h\Y[fYUhYgh VYUihm WUbbch VY gYYb ]b h\Y `][\h cZ h\Y _]bXbYggcZ U g]b[`Y \YUfh(


J\Y acgh hYbXYf d`Ubhg WUb dig\ h\Y]f kUm h\fci[\ h\Y\UfXYgh fcW_g& UbX ]h ]g h\Y gUaY k]h\ _]bXbYgg( Dch\]b[WUb ghcd U hfi`m _]bX UbX g]bWYfY dYfgcb(


J\Y dYfgcb XcYg bch Yl]gh hc k\ca mci WUbbch Xc [ccX(vBK9?KI 7bbUYig IYbYWU

MY Xc [ccX hc dYcd`Y bch ]b \cdY cZ fYkUfX& Vih VYWUigYkY gYY h\Y X]j]bY gd]f]h k]h\]b YjYfmcbY(

J\Y VYgh UbX YUg]Ygh kUm hc h\kUfh Yj]` ]b h\]g kcf`X ]g hcfYgdcbX hc ]h k]h\ _]bX kcfXg& fYhifb Ub Yj]` UWh]cb k]h\ [ccX(

?UXH IDLWK LV IDLWK RQO\ LI WKH DFWLRQV RI \RXU OLIH DUH LQ KDUcPRQ\ ZLWK LW DQG QHYHU FRQWUDGLFW LW&

:if]b[ h\Y XUm mci g\ci`X VY\UjY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh mciWUb g`YYd Uh b][\h ]b dYUWY5 UbX ]b mcif mcih\ mci g\ci`XVY\UjY ]b giW\ U kUm h\Uh mci WUb `]jY ]b mcif c`X U[Y ]bdYUWY(

v?D:?7D FHEL;H8

J\cgY k\c \UjY kYU_ ZU]h\ h\YagY`jYg WUbbch UfcigYZU]h\ ]b ch\Yfg(

vB7E'JPK

J\cgY k\c []jY gYWcbX dÙWY hc =cX ]b h\Y]f \YUfhg Xcbch []jY >]a U dÙWY Uh U``(

v@E>D HKIA?D

MY WUb bYjYf Zi``m ibXYfghUbX h\Y Z]bU` difdcgY cZ \iaUb`]ZY( 7 WcbghfiWh]cb kcf_Yf k\c kcf_g Uh U WcbghfiWh]cb g]hYWUb \UjY bc ]XYU cZ h\Y Z]bU` Zcfa cf [YbYfU` XYg][b cZ h\YÙf[Y ghfiWhifY \Y Vi]`Xg& Vih \Y WUb _bck h\Uh \Y ]g kcf_x]b[ cb gcaYh\]b[ [ccX& gcaYh\]b[ VYUih]Zi`& W`YjYf& UbXbYWYggUfm& Vch\ Zcf \]a UbX Zcf h\Y kcf`X( J\]g ]g ZU]h\(

:c bch VY`]YjY ]b kcfXg& mcifg cf ch\Yfgr5 VY`]YjY ]b h\YXYYXg(

JIJOHJS ĄǼ

7 dYfgcb k\c VYWcaYg W`cgY hc =cX ibXYfghUbXg h\Uh=cX `]jYg k]h\]b \]a( 7b[Y`ig& U amgh]WU` dcYh cZ h\Y gYjxYbhYYbh\ WYbhifm& gU]X& s+ gYY =cX k]h\ h\Y gUaY YmY k]h\k\]W\ >Y gYYg aY(t

v>;DH? 7C?;B

?KH VRXO RI D SHUVRQ LV WKH ODPS RI 3RG&vJ\Y J7BCK:

FYcd`Y Xc bch _bck k\Uh =cX `cc_g `]_Y Vih h\Ym `]jY ]b>]a UbX >Y ]b h\Ya(

vIK<?M?I:EC5 U amgh]WU` gYWh ]b ?IB7C

J\cgY k\c WUb fU]gY h\Y]f h\ci[\hg hc \YUjYb k]`` U`kUmg\UjY W`YUf XUmg& VYWUigY h\Y gib U`kUmg g\]bYg UVcjY h\YW`ciXg(

?Z mci UfY [bUkYX Vm XYg]fY cf ZYUf mci aigh bch VY`]YjY]b =cX& k\c ]g Z]``YX k]h\ `cjY& UbX k\c Yl]ghg ]b mci( ?Zmci VY`]YjY ]b >]a& mci _bck h\Uh mci bYYX bch k]g\ ZcfUbmh\]b[ VYWUigY h\Y k]g\Yg cZ =cX U`kUmg WcaY hfiY5UbX mci bYYX bYjYf VY UZfU]X cZ Ubmh\]b[& VYWUigY =cXZYUfg bch\]b[(

J\Y bUhifY cZ U gci` ]g gc amghYf]cig h\Uh bc aUhhYf \ck\UfX kY hfm hc ibXYfghUbX ]h& kY k]`` bYjYf VY UV`Y hcXYZ]bY ]h(

v>;H79B?JKI

BKDWHYHU PD\ KDSSHQ WR \RX$ \RX ZLOO QHYHU KH XQKDSS\ LI\RX XQGHUVWDQG \RXU XQLILFDWLRQ ZLWK 3RG&

JIJOHJSÁÄ

;QO\ PLVFRQFHSWLRQV QHHG WR EH VXSSRUWHG E\ HODERUDWHDUJXPHQWV& ?UXWK FDQ DOZD\V VWDQG DORQH&

7`` [ccXbYgg ]g Ug bch\]b[ WcadUfYX hc h\Y [ccXbYgg cZhfih\5 U`` gkYYhg UfY Ug bch\]b[ WcadUfYX hc h\Y gkYYhbYggcZ hfih\( J\Y V`]gg cZ hfih\ gifdUggYg U`` ch\Yf ^cmg ]b h\Ykcf`X(

v8K::>?IJ M?I:EC

7 dYfgcb WUbbch VY Wcad`YhY`m hfih\Zi` U`` h\Y h]aY&VYWUigY X]ZZYfYbh ZcfWYg UbX Ugd]fUh]cbg Z][\h k]h\]b \]a&'UbX gcaYh]aYg \Y WUbbch YldfYgg h\Ya& YjYb hc \]agY`Z(

C]gWcbWYdh]cbg Yl]gh cb`m Zcf U Z]b]hY dYf]cX cZ h]aY& VihfYU` hfih\ fYaU]bg Ug ]h U`kUmg kUg& UZhYf U`` hf]W_g&gcd\]gag& UbX `]Yg \UjY k]h\YfYX UkUm(

BYUfb k\Uh hc Xc& h\]b_& UbX gUm h\Y hfih\ Uh U`` h]aYg(Eb`m k\Yb mci ghUfh hc `YUfb h\]g WUb mci ibXYfghUbX\ck ZUf kY UfY Zfca fYU` hfih\(

B]Yg UfY U`kUmg \UfaZi` hc U`` `]j]b[ h\]b[g(

Dc dYfgcb ]g k]h\cih g]b5 bc dYfgcb ]g Wcad`YhY`m hfih\xZi`( ?h ]g bch h\Uh cbY dYfgcb ]g j]fhicig UbX hfih\Zi` UbXUbch\Yf ]g g]bZi` UbX XYWY]hZi`5 fUh\Yf ]hrg h\Uh cbY dYfgcbghf]jYg hc acjY hckUfX hfih\ UbX j]fhiY UbX h\Y ch\YfXcYg bch(

JIJOHJS ĄĆ

Eb`m h\Y gdfYUX cZ `cjY VYhkYYb dYcd`Y WUb ]adfcjY h\YYl]gh]b[ gcW]U` ghfiWhifY(

BcjY []jYg aYUb]b[ hc \iaUb `]ZY( J\]g kY \UjY _bckbg]bWY Ubh]ei]hm( 8ih k\Uh ]g `cjY6 CUbm k]gY dYcd`Yh\fci[\cih h\Y U[Yg \UjY hf]YX hc gc`jY h\]g eiYgh]cb(

?Z mci fU]gY dYcd`Y hc dfU]gY cb`m kYU`h\& dckYf& UbX [`cfm&h\Yb bUhifU``m h\Ym k]`` dfU]gY cb`m h\YgY h\]b[g( ?Z mcifU]gY dYcd`Y hc `cjY h\Y ZYY`]b[ cZ `cjY& h\Ym k]`` ghUfh hc`]jY ]b `cjY(

vC;;'J;;& U ghiXYbh cZ 9ED<K9?KI

;QO\ RQH FOHDU TXDOLW\ PDUNV DQ DFWLRQ DV HLWKHU JRRG RUHYLO* 5I LW LQFUHDVHV WKH DPRXQW RI ORYH LQ WKH ZRUOG$ LW LV JRRG&5I LW VHSDUDWHV SHRSOH DQG FUHDWHV DQLPRVLW\ DPRQJ WKHP$ LW LVKDG&

J\Y h]aY ]g Wca]b[& U h]aY cZ WcbWcfX& \Ufacbm& Zcf[]jYxbYgg& UbX `cjY( :YdYbX cb ]h( MY aigh Xc YjYfmh\]b[ ]bcif dckYf hc Vf]b[ h\]g h]aY W`cgYf& UbX hc ghcd h\cgYh\]b[g k\]W\ XY`Um ]hg Uff]jU`(

JIJOHJSÁĂ

Eif ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ cifgY`jYg Ug X]gWfYhY VY]b[g gYdUxfUhY Zfca YUW\ ch\Yf [fckg cih cZ WcbX]h]cbg cZ cif `]ZY ]bh]aY UbX gdUWY( J\Y `Ygg kY ZYY` h\]g gYdUfUh]cb& h\Y acfYkY ZYY` cif ib]Z]WUh]cb k]h\ U`` ch\Yf `]j]b[ WfYUhifYg& h\Y`][\hYf cif `cUX& UbX h\Y acfY ^cmZi` cif `]ZY k]`` VY(

<cf h\Y VcXm ]g bch cbY aYaVYf& Vih aUbm(((( 7bX ]Z cbYaYaVYf giZZYfg& U`` h\Y aYaVYfg giZZYf k]h\ ]h5 ]Z cbYaYaVYf ]g \cbcfYX& U`` h\Y aYaVYfg fY^c]WY k]h\ ]h(

v? 9EH?DJ>?7DI +,4+.& ,0

7 gaU`` VfUbW\ Wih cZZ Zfca U V][ `]aV ]g gYdUfUhYX Zfcah\Y k\c`Y hfYY( ?b h\Y gUaY kUm k\Yb U dYfgcb ]g ]b UbUf[iaYbh k]h\ Ubch\Yf dYfgcb& \Y ]g gYdUfUhYX Zfca U``\iaUb]hm(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

=cX WfYUhYX \YUjYb UbX YUfh\& Vih h\Ym `UW_YX h\Y UV]`]hmhc ibXYfghUbX h\Y \Udd]bYgg cZ h\Y]f Yl]ghYbWY( J\Yb =cXaUXY WfYUhifYg k\c Wci`X ibXYfghUbX h\Y \Udd]bYgg cZh\Y]f Yl]ghYbWY& UbX k\c Wci`X WfYUhY U g]b[`Y VcXm ZfcaU`` cZ ]hg h\]b_]b[ dUfhg( 7`` dYcd`Y UfY aYaVYfg cZ h\]gcbY VcXm5 ]b cfXYf hc VY \Uddm& h\Ym g\ci`X `]jY ]b \Ufxacbm k]h\ h\Y k]`` h\Uh [cjYfbg ]hg `]ZY( MY g\ci`X `]jY ]b\Ufacbm k]h\ h\]g [fYUh gci` UbX `cjY ]h acfY h\Ub kY`cjY cifgY`jYg(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

BH PDQLIHVW LQ ORYH RXU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ RI WKH XQLW\ RI RXUEHLQJ ZLWK RWKHUV$ DQG LQ VR GRLQJ ZH PDNH RXU OLIH JUHDWHU&?KH PRUH ZH ORYH$ WKH ZLGHU$ ODUJHU$ DQG PRUH MR\IXO RXU OLIHEHFRPHV&

JIJOHJSÁÅ

CUb_]bX acjYg WYUgY`Ygg`m hckUfX dYfZYWh]cb& bch cZ YjYfmdYfgcbrg UWWcfX& Vih h\fci[\ h\Y YZZcfhg h\Uh gcaY dUfh]WiÙf]bX]j]XiU`g aU_Y hckUfX h\Y]f dYfgcbU` dYfZYWh]cb( J\Y_]b[Xca cZ =cX k]`` VY WfYUhYX Vm h\YgY ]bX]j]XiU` YZZcfhg(

:c bch VY YaVUffUggYX Vm U`` mcif VUX XYYXg& Vm U`` mcifa]gZcfhibYg( :c bch VY YaVUffUggYX& Vih Z][\h WYUgYx`Ygg`m& VfUjY`m& UbX k]h\cih \Yg]hUh]cb& VYWUigY h\Y _]b[xXca cZ =cX k]`` WcaY(


MY \YUf cZhYb h\Uh h\YfY ]g bc igY ]b kcf_]b[ hc ]adfcjYcif `]ZY& hc Z][\h Yj]`& cf hc YghUV`]g\ îgh]WY& VYWUigYdfc[fYgg k]`` cWWif Vm ]hgY`Z( ?aU[]bY h\Uh U VcUh Z`cUhgU`cb[ U f]jYf( ?aU[]bY h\Uh h\cgY k\c \UjY gUh Vm h\Y cUfgUbX fckYX h]fY`Ygg`m \UjY ghcddYX UbX [cbY Ug\cfY5 UbXh\Uh h\Y hfUjY`Yfg k\c fYaU]b ]b h\Y VcUh Xc bch Vch\Yf hchU_Y id h\Y cUfg UbX dig\ h\Y VcUh Zifh\Yf& Vih h\]b_ h\Uh]h k]`` hfUjY` Vm ]hgY`Z& Ug VYZcfY& ]bhc h\Y ZihifY(

B]ZY \Ug bc aYUb]b[ k]h\cih difdcgY( Jc ÙW_ difdcgY ]ghc XYbm h\Y Yl]ghYbWY cZ =cX UbX hc UXa]h h\Uh cif `]ZY ]gUb Yj]`& ghid]X^c_Y(

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

-OO RXU KLVWRU\ SURYHV WKDW 3RG PD\ KH XQGHUVWRRG$ QRW E\UHDVRQLQJ$ EXW E\ VXEPLVVLRQ WR 4LP DQG REH\DQFH WR 4LVODZV& ;QO\ E\ GRLQJ WKLV FDQ ZH XQGHUVWDQG 4LV ZLOO RQHDUWK&

v@E>D HKIA?D

;jYfm dYfgcb g\ci`X aU_Y U gaU`` YZZcfh& YjYb h\Y gaU``xYgh YZZcfh& hc ]adfcjY h\Y [YbYfU` kY``'VY]b[ cZ \iaUb]hm(

JIJOHJSÁǺ

=HDO JRRGQHVV LV LQ \RXU KDQGV& 5W IROORZV D JRRG SHUVRQ DV DVKDGRZ IROORZV LWV REMHFW&

;jYfmh\]b[ k\]W\ WUb aU_Y ig VYhhYf UbX \Udd]Yf kUg[]jYb hc ig Vm =cX( ?Z cif WcbgW]YbWY ]g W`YUf& h\Yb bch\x]b[ WUb \Ufa ig(

v;F?9J;JKI

J\Ym k\c \UjY XYW]XYX hc XYX]WUhY h\Y]f `]jYg hc gd]f]hiU`dYfZYWh]cb k]`` bYjYf VY X]ggUh]gZ]YX cf ib\Uddm& VYWUigY&U`` h\Uh h\Ym kUbh ]g ]b h\Y]f dckYf(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

>Udd]bYgg& difY \Udd]bYgg& ]g U j]fhiY ]b ]hgY`Z(v8;D;:?9JKI IF?DEP7

J\Y [fYUhYf h\Y YZZcfh U dYfgcb aU_Yg hc UW\]YjY d`YUgifY&h\Y `Ygg dcgg]V`Y ]h ]g Zcf \]a hc dcggYgg fYU` [ccXbYgg& cf`cjY(

J\Ym k\c gUm h\Uh Xc]b[ [ccX WUigYg h\Ya ib\Udd]bYggY]h\Yf Xcbrh VY`]YjY ]b =cX cf UfYbrh Xc]b[ gcaYh\]b[ h\Uh]g hfi`m [ccX(

Z JIJOHJSÁĄ

JIJOHJSÂÀ

J\Y fYU` difdcgY cZ 9\f]gh]Ub]hm ]g cVj]cig hc U``& UbX ]h ]gghfcb[Yf h\Ub h\Y `]Yg k\]W\ hfm hc dYfjYfh ]h(

MY g\ci`X gYdUfUhY h\Y fY`][]cb h\Uh kUg hUi[\h Vm @YgigZfca h\Y fY`][]cb k\cgY giV^YWh ]g @Ygig( J\Yb kY k]``ibXYfghUbX h\Y fYU` aYUb]b[ cZ h\Y DYk JYghUaYbh UbXZc``ck ?h(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

? gYY U bYk fY`][]cb VUgYX cb aihiU` hfigh& k\]W\ UddYU`ghc cif XYYdYgh gY`jYg& UbX k\]W\ hYUW\Yg h\Uh U dYfgcbg\ci`X `cjY [ccXbYgg k]h\cih fYkUfX& UbX h\Uh h\Y X]j]bYYl]ghg ]b YjYfmcbY(

?b X]ZZYfYbh kUmg UbX ]b X]ZZYfYbh hcb[iYg& U`` \iaUb]hmfYdYUhg h\Y kcfXg cZ h\Y BcfXrg dfUmYf& sBYh h\m _]b[XcaWcaY cb YUfh\ Ug ]h ]g ]b \YUjYb(t

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

0R QRW WKLQN WKDW \RX ZLOO SHUVRQDOO\ VHH WKH FRPLQJ RI WKHNLQJGRP RI 3RG& .XW KDYH QR GRXEW WKDW LW ZLOO FRPH VRRQ*LW LV FRPLQJ FORVHU DQG FORVHU$ ZLWKRXW KHVLWDWLRQ&

7h h\Y \][\Ygh `YjY` cZ WcbgW]cigbYgg& Ub ]bX]j]XiU` ]gU`cbY( IiW\ gc`]hiXY WUb gYYa ghfUb[Y& ibigiU`& YjYb X]ZZ]xWi`h( <cc`]g\ dYcd`Y hfm hc YgWUdY ]h Vm aYUbg cZ jUf]cigX]gg]dUh]cbg ]b cfXYf hc [Yh UkUm Zfca h\]g \][\ dc]bh& hcgcaY dc]bh `ckYf& Vih k]gY dYcd`Y fYaU]b Uh h\]g \][\dc]bh& k]h\ h\Y \Y`d cZ dfUmYf(

=cX kUbhg ig hc Zi`Z]`` \]g k]`` \YfY cb YUfh\& ]b cif `]jYg(8ih `]ZYrg ]bhYfYghg UbX dUgg]cbg X]ghfUWh ig Zfca h\]g YjYfma]bihY( M\Yb kY ibXYfghUbX h\]g& kY WUb []fX cifgY`jYgk]h\ h\Y d\mg]WU` YldfYgg]cb cZ cif Uhh]hiXY hc =cX& dfUmYf(

7 dYfgcbU`]hm ]g U `]a]hUh]cb UbX& h\YfYZcfY& =cX& Ug kYibXYfghUbX >]a& ]g bch U dYfgcbU`]hm( FfUmYf ]g cifUXXfYgg hc =cX UbX mYh \ck WUb kY UXXfYgg cbY k\c \Ugbc dYfgcbU`]hm6 ? UXXfYgg =cX Ug ]Z >Y kYfY U dYfgcb&h\ci[\ ? _bck ]h ]g bch gc(

7 dYfgcb Vif]YX ]b U XYYd a]bY& ZfYYn]b[ Zfca h\Y Wc`X ]bXYYd ]WY& Xm]b[ Zfca \ib[Yf U`cbY cb h\Y cdYb gYU& kUghx]b[ UkUm ]b gc`]hiXY ]b U df]gcb WY``& cf g]ad`m Xm]b[ Uh\caY& XYUZ UbX V`]bXv\ck Wci`X h\]g dYfgcb `]jY cih h\YfYaU]bXYf cZ \]g `]ZY ]Z dfUmYf X]X bch Yl]gh6

4RZ JRRG D SHUVRQ IHHOV ZKHQ$ H[KDXVWHG IURP VWULYLQJ IRUJRRGQHVV LQ KLV HYHU\GD\ OLIH$ KH VWUHWFKHV RXW KLV KDQGV WR3RG&

v8B7?I; F7I97B

EbY WUb `]jY k]h\cih dfUmYf Y]h\Yf k\Yb \Y ]g dcggYggYX Vm\]g dUgg]cbg cf k\Yb \]g `]ZY ]g Wcad`YhY`m XYX]WUhYX hc=cX( 8ih Zcf U dYfgcb k\c ]g Z][\h]b[ \]g dUgg]cb UbX mYh ZUfZfca Zi`Z]``]b[ \]g Xihm& dfUmYf ]g U bYWYggUfm WcbX]h]cb cZ `]ZY(

JIJOHJSÂÁ

Dch\]b[ gYYag hc W\YW_ h\Y bch]cb h\Uh h\Y kUm hc ]adfcjYW]j]`]nUh]cb ]g UZZYWhYX Vm W\Ub[]b[ ]hg cihYf Zcfag( J\]gbch]cb ]g ZU`gY& UbX XfUkg h\Y UWh]j]hm cZ hcc aUbm dYcd`YUkUm Zfca YZZcfh h\Uh hfi`m WUb ]adfcjY cif `]jYg(

9]j]`]nUh]cb ]g Z]fgh cZ U`` U acfU` h\]b[( M]h\cih hfih\&fYgdYWh Zcf Xihm& `cjY cZ bY][\Vcf& j]fhiY& YjYfmh\]b[ ]gXYghfcmYX( J\Y acfU`]hm cZ U gcW]Yhm ]g U`cbY h\Y VUg]g cZW]j]`]nUh]cb(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

J\Y dfcdYf X]fYWh]cb cZ aUbrg h\ci[\h ]g bch hckUfX h\YWfYUh]cb cZ bYk Ùkg Zcf [cjYfbaYbh& Vih hckUfX h\YUWWYdhUbWY cZ YjYfm dYfgcbrg acfU` X][b]hm(

v;:CKD: O7J;I

IcW]U`]ga& k\Yb WcadUfYX k]h\ 9\f]gh]Ub]hm& ]g U fUh\Yfa]bcf& gYWcbXUfm eiYgh]cb UVcih h\Y aUhYf]U` bYYXg cZh\Y kcf_]b[ WÙgg( ?h ghUbXg cihg]XY h\Y VUg]W eiYgh]cbg cZ\iaUb `]ZY(

v<OE:EH IJH7A>EL

MY g\ci`X& Z]fgh cZ U``& ibXYfghUbX h\Uh kY UfY U`` W\]`XfYbcZ h\Y gUaY ZUh\Yf& UbX kY g\ci`X Zi`Z]`` h\Y gUaY [YbYfU`Ùk4 `]jY bch Zcf cifgY`jYg& Vih hc \Y`d ch\Yfg VY \Uddm(

v=?KI;FF; C7PP?D?

BKHQ ZH DFFHSW IDOVH DQG YLROHQW ODZV DQG VXEPLW WR WKHP$ZH FDQ QHLWKHU HVWDEOLVK WUXWK QRU FRPEDW OLHV LQ WKLV ZRUOG&

JIJOHJSÂÂ

M]gXca ]g ibXYfghUbX]b[ \ck YhYfbU` hfih\ WUb VYUdd`]YX hc `]ZY(

IcWfUhYg kUg h\Y Z]fgh k\c Vfci[\h d\]`cgcd\m Zfca\YUjYb& X]ghf]VihYX ]h Uacb[ h\Y dYcd`Y& UbX Ybh]WYXh\Ya hc ghiXm h\Y gW]YbWY cZ `]ZY& \iaUb acfU`g& UbX h\YWcbgYeiYbWYg cZ [ccX UbX Yj]`(

>FLHQFH LV VHOGRP FRQQHFWHG ZLWK ZLVGRP& - VFKRODUO\ SHUcVRQ NQRZV PDQ\ XQQHFHVVDU\ WKLQJV& - ZLVH SHUVRQ NQRZVIHZ WKLQJV$ EXW DOO WKDW KH NQRZV LV QHFHVVDU\ ERWK IRUKXPDQLW\ DQG IRU KLPVHOI&

>Y k\c ibXYfghUbXg \]g gci` k]`` ibXYfghUbX h\Y X]j]bYgdUf_ k]h\]b \]agY`Z(


M]gY dYcd`Y WUbbch VY giZZ]W]Ybh`m YXiWUhYX& UbX YXixWUhYX dYcd`Y WUbbch VY giZZ]W]Ybh`m k]gY(

vB7E'JPK

J\Y [ccXbYgg []jYb hc ig Vm k]gXca WcadUfYg hc U``ch\Yf _bck`YX[Y ]b h\Y gUaY kUm h\Uh ]b U XYgYfh& U jYggY`Z]``YX k]h\ kUhYf WcadUfYg hc acibhU]bg cZ [c`X(

JIJOHJSÆǼ

JIJOHJSÂÄ

IhUfh]b[ Zfca YUf`m W\]`X\ccX5 Ug kY U[Y kY ZYY` h\Y[fckh\ cZ cif gd]f]hiU` dckYf UbX h\Y X]a]bih]cb cZ cifd\mg]WU` dckYf(

E`XYf dYcd`Y k\c `]jY gd]f]hiU` `]jYg YjYf k]XYb h\Y]f gd]fx]hiU` \cf]ncbg& UbX YjYf YldUbX h\Y]f WcbgW]YbWYg( E`XYfdYcd`Y k\c `]jY cb`m U XU]`m fcih]bY VYWcaY acfY UbXacfY ghid]X cjYf h\Y mYUfg(

vJ\Y J7BCK:

EbY VYWcaYg c`XYf ]b cfXYf hc VYWcaY _]bXYf5 h\YfY ]g bca]ghU_Y k\]W\ ? \UjY bch U`fYUXm aUXY(

v@E>7DD MEB<=7D= LED =E;J>;

J\Y [fckh\ UbX XYjY`cdaYbh cZ h\Y gci` ]g acfY ]adcfxhUbh h\Ub dckYf UbX [`cfm(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

J\Y [fckh\ cZ cif d\mg]WU` YbYf[m dfYdUfYg ig Zcf gd]f]xhiU` kcf_& Zcf gYfj]b[ =cX UbX aUb_]bX5 h\]g kcf_ ghUfhgk\Yb cif VcXm VY[]bg hc ZUXY UkUm(

3URZ VSLULWXDOO\ DQG KHOS RWKHUV WR GR VR+ LW LV WKH PHDQLQJ RIOLIH&

JYff]V`Y ]g h\Y g]hiUh]cb cZ h\cgY k\c WUbbch dYfWY]jYgd]f]hiU` [fckh\ ]b h\YagY`jYg( J\Ym WUb gYY cb`m d\mg]WU``]ZY& k\]W\ k]`` X]gUddYUf ]b h]aY(M\Yb mci ibXYfghUbX mcif gd]f]hiU` VY]b[ UbX `]jY

k]h\ ]h& h\Yb ]bghYUX cZ XYgdU]f]b[ mci ibXYfghUbX h\Y ^cmh\Uh WUb bYjYf VY XYghfcmYX& k\]W\ U`kUmg [fckg(

A]bXbYgg UbX j]fhiY WcaY Zfca h\Y \YUfh& UbX g\ci`X VYdYfZcfaYX k]h\cih h\ci[\h Zcf h\Y cd]b]cb cZ ch\Yfg& cfcZ ZihifY fYkUfXg(

ALUWXH DQG FKDULW\ VWDUW DW KRPH& 5I \RX KDYH WR JR VRPHcZKHUH WR GLVSOD\ LW$ WKHQ LW LV QRW YLUWXH&

7gg]ghUbWY []jYb hc h\Y dccf Vm h\Y f]W\ ]g hcc cZhYb ^igh U[YghifY cZ dc`]hYbYgg& bch fYU` W\Uf]hm(

9\Uf]hm ]g [ccX cb`m k\Yb ]h WcaYg Ug U gUWf]Z]WY5 cb`mh\Yb Xc h\cgY k\c fYWY]jY" h\Y aUhYf]U` []Zh fYWY]jY h\Ygd]f]hiU` []Zh hcc( ?Z ]h ]g bch U gUWf]Z]WY Vih U X]gW\Uf[Y cZYlWYgg& ]h WUb cb`m ]ff]hUhY h\cgY k\c fYWY]jY ]h(

JIJOHJSÆĆ

/KLOGKRRG LV WKH SHULRG LQ ZKLFK XQGHUO\LQJ FRQYLFWLRQV DUHIRUPHG& ?KHUHIRUH$ WKH PRVW LPSRUWDQW SDUW RI HGXFDWLRQ LVWKH VHOHFWLRQ RI WKH WKLQJV RI ZKLFK D FKLOG VKRXOG KH FRQcYLQFHG&

JU`_]b[ UbX fYUgcb]b[ XcYg bch YjYb \UjY cbY h\cigUbXh\h\Y ]bZ`iYbWY U hfiY YlUad`Y \Ug( 7`` `Yggcbg UVcih \ck hcVY\UjY UfY kcfh\`Ygg k\Yb W\]`XfYb gYY h\Y cddcg]hY ]bfYU` `]ZY(

M\Uh igY ]g ]h Zcf W\]`XfYb k\Yb dYcd`Y cb`m gdYU_ UVcih[ccXbYgg& Vih dYfZcfa VUX XYYXg ]b fYU`]hm6

v=KIJ7L IJHKL;

J\Y ghfcb[ XYg]fY Zcf U d`YUgUbh UbX ]XYU` `]ZY ]g U W\]`Xrgkcfgh a]gZcfhibY( ?h ]g WfiW]U` h\Uh W\]`XfYb g\ci`X _bck\ck hc kcf_ Zfca Ub YUf`m U[Y(

v?CC7DK;B A7DJ

?h ]g ]adcfhUbh hc hYUW\ W\]`XfYb _]bXbYgg UbX g]ad`]W]hm]b `]ZY UbX kcf_( 7`` cZ W\]`XfYbrg acfU` UbX gd]f]hiU` YXixWUh]cb g\ci`X VY giddcfhYX Vm mcif ckb [ccX YlUad`Y(Oci g\ci`X `]jY j]fhicig`m& cf Uh `YUgh hfm hc Xc gc5 h\Y giWxWYgg cZ mcif [ccX `]ZY k]`` YXiWUhY mcif W\]`XfYb(

JIJOHJSÂĂ

JIJOHJSÂÅ

7`` h\Uh kY gYY UbX _bck XcYg bch Yl]gh ]b fYU`]hm& VYWUigY]h ]g h\Y dfcXiWh cZ cif `]a]hYX UV]`]hm hc ibXYfghUbX fYU`]hm(

?bghYUX cZ gUm]b[ h\Uh h\Y kcf`X ]g fYZ`YWhYX ]b cif ]bhY``YWh&VYhhYf hc gUm h\Uh cif ]bhY``YWh ]g fYZ`YWhYX ]b h\Y kcf`X(

v=;EH=; B?9>J;D8;H=

E`X ZcfhfYggYg UfY XYghfcmYX& acbiaYbhg hc _]b[g UfYXYac`]g\YX& c`X U[Y fUjU[Yg cif VcX]Yg( Eb`m h\Y hYUW\x]b[g cZ _]bXbYgg UfY bYjYf fi]bYX cf UZZYWhYX Vm U[Y(

-V VRRQ DV D SHUVRQ ILQG\ ORRNV DW KLPVHOI DV RQO\ D SK\VLFDOERG\$ WKHQ KH VHHV DQ XQVROYHG SX]]OH$ D FRQWUDGLFWLRQ WKDWFDQQRW EH XQUDYHOHG&

?b cfXYf hc ibXYfghUbX h\Y hfiY YggYbWY cZ U h\]b[ kYaigh hfUbgZcfa h\Y d\mg]WU` ]bhc h\Y gd]f]hiU`(

IW]YbWY ]g j]hU``m ]adcfhUbh k\Yb ]h ]g \UfbYggYX hc fYjYU`h\Y `Uk cZ \iaUb `]ZY(

?b cfXYf hc UWWYdh h\Y ]adcfhUbWY cZ gW]YbWY& kY aighdfcjY h\Uh h\]g UWh]j]hm ]g igYZi`( IW]Ybh]ghg igiU``m XYacbxghfUhY h\Uh h\Ym UfY Xc]b[ gcaYh\]b[ UbX h\Uh aUmVY gcaYxh]aY& gcaYXUm& h\]g Wci`X VY igYZi` Zcf dYcd`Y ]b h\YZihifY(

J\Y ib]jYfgY ]g `]a]h`Ygg& UbX ]adcgg]V`Y Zcf UbmcbY hcibXYfghUbX( J\YfYZcfY& kY WUbbch Wcad`YhY`m ibXYfghUbXh\Y `]ZY cZ cif ckb VcXm(

v8B7?I; F7I97B

>FLHQFH a LV QRW TXLWH WKH FRQFHSW ZKLFK SHRSOH XVH WKLV ZRUGWR LGHQWLI\+ LW LV WKH KLJKHVW$ PRVW LPSRUWDQW$ PRVW QHFHVVDU\REMHFW RI RXU XQGHUVWDQGLQJ&

JIJOHJSÂǺ

JIJOHJSÆĊ

-V ORQJ DV WKHUH LV YLROHQFH$ WKHUH ZLOO KH ZDU& ;QH FDQQRWGHIHDW YLROHQFH ZLWK PRUH YLROHQFH$ RQO\ ZLWK QRQUHVLVWDQFHWR DQG QRQSDUWLFLSDWLRQ LQ LW&

vB;JKHDE

?Z am gc`X]Yfg ghUfhYX h\]b_]b[& bch U g]b[`Y gc`X]Yf kci`XfYaU]b ]b am Ufam(

v<H;:;H?9A ??

J\Y k]`X ]bgh]bWh cZ a]`]hUfm aifXYf \Ug XYjY`cdYX ]b\iaUb]hm cjYf h\Y WcifgY cZ h\cigUbXg cZ mYUfg& UbX \UgVYWcaY fcchYX ]b cif VfU]bg( MY aigh \cdY h\Uh cif gcW]xYhm k]`` VY UV`Y hc f]X ]hgY`Z cZ h\]g hYff]V`Y Wf]aY(

M]h\ h]aY ? ibXYfghUbX h\Y Ufam WcXY h\Uh X]WhUhYg h\Uh UgYf[YUbh ]g U`kUmg f][\h k\Yb \Y UXXfYggYg U gc`X]Yf& h\Uh U`]YihYbUbh ]g U`kUmg f][\h k\Yb \Y UXXfYggYg U gYf[YUbh& UbXgc cb id hc [YbYfU`g UbX aUfg\U`g& YjYb k\Yb U dYfgcbgUmg h\Uh hkc h]aYg hkc YeiU`g Z]jY( ?Z mci Xc bch cVYmmcif gidYf]cf& mci UfY dib]g\YX Vm XYUh\& cf mYUfg ]bdf]gcb(

v;:M7H: ;AC7D

MUfg WUb VY ghcddYX cb`m ]Z dYcd`Y UfY fYUXm hc VY dYfgYxWihYX Zcf bch dUfh]W]dUh]b[ ]b h\Ya( J\]g ]g h\Y cb`m kUm

J\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y ZfUhYfb]hm UbX YeiU`]hm cZ U``dYcd`Y VYWcaYg acfY UbX acfY dcdiÙf Uacb[ aUb_]bX(

:c kY ibXYfghUbX cif gd]f]hiU` ZfUhYfb]hm6 :c kY ibXYfxghUbX h\UhkY cf][]bUhYX Zfca cbY X]j]bY <Uh\Yf k\cgY]aU[Y kY WUffm ]b cifgY`jYg UbX Zcf k\cgY dYfZYWh]cb kYghf]jY6 >UjY kY UWWYdhYX h\Uh h\YfY ]g h\Y gUaY X]j]bY `]ZY]b U`` dYcd`Y& Ug kY`` Ug ]b cifgY`jYg6 7bX h\Uh h\]g aU_Yg UbUhifU` UbX ZfYY VcbX Uacb[ dYcd`Y6


BH FDQ ORYH QHLWKHU WKRVH ZKRP ZH IHDU QRU WKRVH ZKR IHDU XV&


<Ua]`m UbX ach\YfÙbX UfY Vih hkc W]fW`Yg h\Uh UfY dUfh cZh\Y k]XYf W]fW`Y h\Uh ]g \iaUb]hm( J\cgY k\c hYUW\ acfU`x]hm UbX k\c `]a]h cbYrg Xih]Yg cb`m hc ZUa]`m UbX WcibhfmhYUW\ U gY`Z]g\bYgg k\]W\ ]g XUb[Yfcig Zcf U`` cZ ig(

J\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ cbYrg ib]hm k]h\ U`` cZ \iaUb]hmWcaYg Zfca h\Y ibXYfghUbX]b[ cZ h\Y X]j]bY VY[]bb]b[ ]big U``& UbX []jYg U`` cif [fYUhYgh [ccX( JfiY fY`][]cb WfYUhYgh\]g ibXYfghUbX]b[& UbX X]ZZYfYbh dfYîX]WYg ]bhYfZYfYk]h\ ]hvdfYîX]WY cZ ghUhY& bUh]cb& UbX WÙgg(

JIJOHJSÃÀ

JIJOHJSǼĄ

J\Y dUgh XcYg bch Yl]gh( J\Y ZihifY \Ug bch VY[ib( J\YdfYgYbh ]g Ub ]bZ]b]hY`m gaU`` dc]bh ]b h]aY ]b k\]W\ h\YU`fYUXm bcbYl]ghYbh dUgh aYYhg h\Y ]aa]bYbh ZihifY( 7hh\]g dc]bh& k\]W\ ]g h]aY`Ygg& U dYfgcbrg fYU` `]ZY Yl]ghg(

sJ]aY dUggYg Vm t kY gUm( J]aY XcYg bch Yl]gh5 cb`m kYacjY(

v7ZhYf h\Y J7BCK:

?LPH LV EHKLQG XV$ WLPH LV EHIRUH XV$ EXW LQ WKH SUHVHQW WKHUH LV

QR WLPH&

] Wcbg]gh cZ gd]f]h UbX VcXm( J]aY UZZYWhg h\Y VcXm& Vih h\Y`]ZY cZ h\Y gd]f]h \Ug bc aYUb]b[ Y]h\Yf ]b h\Y dUgh cf ]b h\YZihifY( 7`` ]hg `]ZY ]g WcbWYbhfUhYX ]b h\Y dfYgYbh(

vC7H9KI 7KH;B?KI

:]j]bY gd]f]h ]g YhYfbU`& ]h Yl]ghg cih cZ h]aY( B]a]h`Yggh]aY UbX gdUWY UfY X]j]XYX ]bhc gaU``& `]a]hYX dUfhg hc VYigYX Vm `]a]hYX VY]b[g(

v>;DH? 7C?;B

J\Y gci` ]g dih ]bhc cif VcXm& gc h\Uh ]h WUb ibXYfghUbXh\Y bch]cb cZ XUhY UbX h]aY( ?h WcbhYad`UhYg h\]g ZUWh UbXWU``g ]h sbUhifY(t

v8B7?I; F7I97B

J]aY XcYg bch Yl]gh( J\YfY ]g cb`m U gaU`` UbX ]bZ]b]hYdfYgYbh& UbX ]h ]g cb`m ]b h\]g dfYgYbh h\Uh cif `]ZY cWWifg(J\YfYZcfY& U dYfgcb g\ci`X WcbWYbhfUhY U`` \]g gd]f]hiU`ZcfWY cb`m cb h\]g dfYgYbh(

=UbX\] cb BYc Jc`ghcm

<fca J\Y ;ggYbh]U` =UbX\]& Bci]g <]gW\Yf

QM\YbR ? kUg dUgg]b[ h\fci[\ U gYjYfY Wf]g]g cZ gYYd

h]W]ga UbX XciVh((( ? WUaY UWfcgg Jc`ghcm g Vcc_

J\Y A]b[Xca cZ =cX ?g M]h\]b Oci& UbX kUg XYYd`m

]adfYggYX Vm ]h( ? kUg Uh h\Uh h]aY U VY`]YjYf ]b j]c`YbWY(

?hg fYUX]b[ WifYX aY cZ am gWYdh]W]ga UbX aUXY aY U

Z]fa VY`]YjYf ]b Qbcb' j]c`YbWYR( M\Uh \Ug UddYU`YX hc

aY acgh ]b Jc`ghcm g `]ZY ]g h\Uh \Y dfUWh]gYX k\Uh

\Y dfYUW\YX UbX fYW_cbYX bc Wcgh hcc [fYUh ]b \]g dif

gi]h cZ hfih\( ( ( (

>Y kUg h\Y [fYUhYgh Udcgh`Y cZ bcb'j]c`YbWY h\Y dfYg

Ybh U[Y \Ug dfcXiWYX( Dc cbY ]b h\Y MYgh VYZcfY \]a cf

g]bWY \Ug kf]hhYb UbX gdc_Yb cb bcb'j]c`YbWY gc Zi``m cf

]bg]ghYbh`m UbX k]h\ giW\ dYbYhfUh]cb UbX ]bg][\h( ( (

Q>]gR fYaUf_UV`Y XYjY`cdaYbh cZ h\]g XcWhf]bY dihg hc

g\UaY h\Y dfYgYbh'XUm bUffck UbX `cd'g]XYX ]bhYfdfY

hUh]cb dih idcb ]h Vm h\Y jchUf]Yg cZ 7\]agU ]b h\]g `UbX

cZ cifg( ( ( ( JfiY 7\]agU g\ci`X aYUb U Wcad`YhY

ZfYYXca Zfca ]`` k]`` UbX Ub[Yf UbX \UhY UbX Ub cjYf

Z`ck]b[ `cjY Zcf U``( <cf ]bWi`WUh]b[ h\]g hfiY UbX \][\Yf

hmdY cZ 7\]agU Uacb[gh ig& Jc`ghcm g `]ZY k]h\ ]hg cWYUbx

`]_Y `cjY g\ci`X gYfjY Ug U VYUWcb `][\h UbX U bYjYf'

ZU]`]b[ gcifWY cZ ]bgd]fUh]cb( ( ( (

tolstoy, leo - a calendar of wisdom

Documents