t:p~:a~ ~~s~~~~!r~r~:e e~~s~:~:y ~f ~~~l:r 2 , fileorbiters. the data were selected so as to obtain...

1
orbiters. The data were se l ected so as to obtain a uniform di stribution of per iapsis longitudes over the surface of Mars, and both S- and X-band data were used where possible to elimi nate charged part icle effects. I nc lu sio n of-the Vik in g data arcs altered the Mart i an geoid features, as de fin ed by previo us sho rt-ar c analysis techniques of Mar iner 9 data, by about 80 meters in the Southern Hemisphere 1 and about 140 meters i n the Northern Hemisphere. J. Geophys. Res ., Red, Paper 750487 6530 Gross properties of the planet s LANDER LOCATIONS , MARS PHYSICAL EPHEMERIS, AND SOLAR SYSTEM PARAMETERS; DETERMINATION FROM VIKING LANDER TRACKING DATA A. P. Mayo (NASA Langley Research Center, Mail Stop 40lB, Hampton, VA 23665) w. T. Blackshear, R. H. Tolson, W. H. Michael, Jr ., G. M. Kelly, J. P. Brenkle, and T. A. Komarek Radio Tracking data from the Viking l a nders have been analyzed to determine the parameters of the Mars physical ephemeris, the radii of Mars at the landing sites, and the l ander locations . The orientati on of the Mars rot a tion axis, re - ferred to the 1950. 0 Earth mean equat or, equinox, and epoch, was determined as 317.340 ± 0.003° right ascensi on and 52.710 ± 0. 002° declination . The planet's rotation period was determined as 24 hr., 37 min . 22 . 663 ± 0.002 sec. Analyses indicate the determination of the motions of the Mars rotation axis wil l require additional tracking data. The Mars radii at the sites of landers 1 and 2 are 3389 .38 ± 0.06 km and 3381.91 ± 0 . 08 km, respectively . The areocentric location of lander 1 is 22.272 ± 0.002° N, 47.94 ± 0.2° W. The lander 2 location is 47.670 ± 0.00N, 225. 71 ± 0. W. The areocentric ri ght ascensions of the landers are determined as 227.314 ± 0. 002° for lander 1 and 99.546 ± 0. 00for lander 2 at Jan. 1 1 0 hr., 1977 (Julian Date 2443144 . 5) . Possible determinations of relativity parameters , solar oblateness, asteroid mass , and variations of the universal gravitational constant, from their effects on the planetary motions 1 will require the additional t rac king data of the Viking ex- rotation) 6545 Interiors of planets SEISMOLOGY ON MARS D. L. Anderson (Seismological Laborat ory, Calif. Inst. of Tech., Pasadena, Ca. 91125), W. F. Miller, G. V. Latham, Y. Nakamura, M. N. Toksoz, A. M. Dainty, F. K. Duennebier , A. R. Lazarewicz, R. L. Kovach, and T. C. D. Knight. A three-axis short period seismometer has been operating on the s urface of Mars in the Utopia Planitia region since September 4, 1976. During the first five months of operation approx. 640 hours of high qua lit y data, uncontaminated by Lander or wind noise, have been obtained . The detection threshold is estimated to be magnitude 3 to about 200 km and about 6.5 for the plane t as a whole. No large events have been seen during this period indicating that Mars is less seis - mically active than Earth. Wind is the major source of noise during the day although the noise level was at or below the sensitivity threshold of the seismometer for most of the night during the early part of the mission. Winds, and there- fore the seismic background, started to intrude into the night-time hours starting on Sol 119 (a Sol is a Martian day). The seismic background correlates well with wind velocity and is pro- portional to (wind velocity) 2, as appropriate for turbulent flow. The seismic envelope power spectral density is proportional to frequency to the minus 0. 66 to 0. 90 power during windy periods. A possible local seismic event was detected on Sol 80 . No wind data was obtained at the time so a wind disturbance cannot be ruled out. However • this event has some unusual characteristics and is similar to local events recorded on Earth through a Viking seismometer system. If interpreted as a natural se i smic even t it has a magnitude of 3 and a distance of llO km. Preliminary interpretati on of later a rrival s in the signal suggest a crustal thick- ness of 15 km at the Utopia Planitia Site which is within the range of crustal models derived from the gravity field. More events must be recorded before a firm interpretation can be .nade of seismicity of crustal structure. One firm conclusion is that the natural background noise on Mars is low and that the wind is the prime noise source. It will be possible to reduce this noise by a factor of 103 on futu re missions by removing the seismometer from the Lander thus making it possible to operate an extremely sensitive seismometer on the surface. (Mars seismicity • Mars crust, Mars wi:nds, Viking Seismology) J. GeQphys. , Red, Paper 750408 828 6560 Meteoritics CORRELATED 0 AND Mg ISOTOPIC ANOMALIES IN ALLENDE INCLUSIONS: II. MAGNETISM G. J. Wasserburg (The Lunatic Asylum, Div. of Geological and Planetary Science s, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California 91125) T. Lee and D. A. Papanastassiou Mg in two Allende Ca- Al rich inclusions s hows large isotopic, mass-dependent fractionation which enriched the heavier isotopes. After normaliza- tion, Mg in these inclusions shows negative mass frac tionation is correlated with distinct but smaller fractionation effec ts for 0 reported by Clayton and Mayeda for the same inclusions (see companion paper). The observation of distinctive but uniform Mg isotopic compos ition in different phases within single Allende inclu sions indicates that nuclear effects i n 0 and Mg are not due to the entrapment of interstellar carrier grains as discrete entities, which are preserved as rem- nants, but ar e instead due to a homogenized mix- ture of components of extraordi nar y isotopic com- position mixed with a component of ordinary solar sys tem material and subjected to isotopic frac- tionation. The distinct 0 isotopic composition of different phases within a single inclusion is believed to be due to incomp l ete back-reaction of the higher temperature condensates with a cooler solar nebula of "normal" composition. The pro- cesses responsible for the 0 and Mg nuclear ef - fects and the astrophysical site of their occur - rence remain undefined. Geophys . Res . Lett., Paper 710406 6560 Heteoritics CORRELATED OXYGEN AND MAGNES IUM ISOTOPE ANOMALIES IN ALLENDE INCLUSIONS, I: OXYGEN Robe rt N. Clayton and Toshiko K. Mayeda ( Enrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 60637 ) Two Ca-Al-rich inclusions from the Allende meteorite have been found to have undergone large mass -fractionati on of oxygen isotopes subsequent to incorpo ration of the nucleosynthetic 16 0- anomaly found in other Allende inclusions. The magnitude of the oxygen isotope fractionations is in constant ratio to the magnesium isotope fractiona ti ons found in the same inclusions by Wasserburg, Lee and Papanastassiou . The obser- vations support earlier theories of the addition of supernova ejecta into the solar nebula just prior to collapse and condensation . (Meteorites, oxygen isotopes, solar nebula, supernova ) . Geophys. Res. Lett ., Paper 710407 6575 Surface of planets IPL PROCESSING OF THE VIKING ORBITER IMAGES OF MARS See 6590 Instruments and techniq u es 6575 Surfaces of planets VIKING RADIO OCCULTATION MEASUREMENTS OF THE MARTIAN ATMOSPHERE AND TOPOGRAPHY; PRIMARY MISSION COVERAGE See 6510 Atmosphere of plane ts 6575 Surface of planets PROCESSING THE VIKING LANDER CAMERA DATA See 6590 Instruments and tec hniques 6575 Surface s of Planet s MARS: WATER VAPOR OBSERVATIONS FROM THE VIKING ORBITERS See 6510 Atmos phe res of Planets GENERAL ASPECTS H.P. Klein (NASA Ames Researc h Center, Moffett Field, California 94035, U.S .A. The Viking biologi ca l investigation has tested four different hypotheses regarding the possible n ature of Martian organisms . Whil e significant results were obtained for each of t hese, test s of three of the hypotheses appear to indicate the absence of biology in the s ample s used, while the fourth is consistent with a biological interpretati on. The origina l assumptions for each experiment and the experimental procedur es that wer e u til ized to t est these assumptions are reviewed . J. Geophys. Res. , Red, Paper 7S0439 SS 75 Surface of pl anets PECULIARITIES OF THE GEOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF THE MARS' SECTOR PHOTOGRAPHED BY AUTOMATIC STATIONS "MARS" (9 pp.) A. L. Sukhanov Geotect., No. 1, 1977 6575 Surface of planets GEOCHEMICAL AND MINERALOGICAL INTERPRETATION OF .THE VIKING INORGANIC CHEMICAL RESULTS P. Toulmin, III (U.S. Geological Survey, 959 National Center, Reston , VA 22092) A. K. Baird, B. C. Clark, K. Keil, H.J. Rose, J r. , R.P. Christian, P. H. Evans and W.C. Kellihe r The elemental analyses whose basis is des cr ibed in the preceding two papers represent the c ompo- sition of samp les of Martian fines ; the onl y un- determined major constituents thought to be pre- sent are H2 0, C0 2, Na 2 0, and possibly NOx. The samples are principally silicate particle s, with some admixture of oxide and probably carbona te minerals; the fines appear to hax_e been ind ur a- ted to a variable degree by a sulfate-rich in te r- granular cement. The overa ll elemental composi - tion is dissimilar to any single known miner al or rock type, and apparently represents a mixt ur e of materials. Close chemical similarity amon g samples at each site, and between the two s i t es , indicates effective homogenization of the fi nes , presumably by planetary windstorms, and fur t her suggests that the samples analyzed represent the fine, mobilizable materials over a large par t of the planet 's surface. Low trace-element, al ka- li, and alumina contents suggest that the gr eat preponderance of the materials in the mixtu r e i s of mafic derivation; highly differentiated, sa li c igneous rocks or their weathering products ar e insignifican t components of the samples . Nor ma- tive calculations, comparisons with refer ence libraries of analytical data, and mathemati c al mixture modeling have led to a qualitative m in- eralogical model in which the fines consist largely of iron- rich smectites (or their deg ra - dation products), carbonates , iron oxides, pr o- bably in part maghemite, and sulfate minera ls concentrated in a surface duricrust. The ori gi - nal smecti tes may have formed by interacti on of mafic magma and subsurface ice, and the su lf ates (and carbonates?) may have been concentrat ed in the c rust by subsurface l eaching, up- and competing models will accompany continu i ng acquisition of samples and data, and r efin emen t of the analy ses, particularly with respect t o t he critical light elements Mg , A, and Si. (Ma r s, t her in g) 6575 Surface of Planets MARTIAN IMPACT CRATERS AND EMPLACEMENT OF EJECTA BY SURFACE FLOS . M.H. Carr ( U.s . Ge ologiceJ. Survey, M enl o Park, California 94025 ) L . A. Crumpler, J.A. CUtts, R. Greeley, J . E. Guest and H. Ma sursky Several types of ma rti an impact craters have been recognized. The most c ommon type, t he rampart crater, is distinctively different fr om lunar and mercurian craters. It is typically surrounded by several layers of ejecta, each with a low ridge or escarpment at its outer edge. Outward flow of' ejecta eJ.ong the gr ound af't er ballistic depositi on is s uggested by fl ow li nes around obstacles, the a bsence of ejecta on top and on the lee side of obstacles, and t h e l arge radial distance to which continuous eje ct a i s found. The peculiar flow characteristics CJf the ejecta around these craters are tentativel y attributed to entrained gases or to contained water, either liquid or vapor, in the eject a as a \ result of impact melting of ground ice . Ej ecta of other craters lack fl ow features but h ave Ia marked radial pattern; still others have ejecta tpatterns that resemble those around lunar and 'mercurian craters . The internal features of martian craters, in genereJ., resemble thei r lunar and mercurian counterparts except that the transition from bowl-shaped to flat-floore d takes , place at about 5 krn diameter, a smaller si ze than for Mercury of the Moon. J. Geophys. Res., Red, Paper 7S0488 6575 Surface of planets COMMENTS ON: " CHARACTERISTICS OF FRESH MARTIAN CRATERS AS A FUNCTION OF DIAMETER: COMPARISON WITH THE MOON AND MERCURY" BY M. J. CINTALA ET AL. C. F."" Florensky 1 A. T. Basilevsky , and V. P. Polosukhin (Vernadsky Institute of Geochemi s try and Analytical Chemistry, USSR Academy of Sci- ences, Moscow, USSR) Cintala et al. attempt to determine: (1) at what diamete"rSfresh martian cr aters be gin to ldevelop features such as central peaks, flat bottoms, terraces, etc. and (2) what determi nes the threshold diameters for various feature s. 1 we argue that the r esults of Cintala !l· are biased by the way in which they collect and organize data. Geophys. Res. Lett., 7L0122 ',

Upload: nguyentuyen

Post on 22-Jun-2019

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

orbiters. The data were sel ected so as to obtain a uniform di stribution of peri aps i s longitudes over the surface of Mars, and both S- and X- band data were used where possible to elimi nate charged part i c l e effects. I nc lu sion of-the Vik ing data arcs altered the Mart i an geoid features, as defined by previous short-arc analysis techniques of Mariner 9 data, by about 80 meters in the Southern Hemisphere 1 and about 140 meters i n the Northern Hemisphere. J. Geophys. Res . , Red, Paper 750487

6530 Gross properties of the planet s LANDER LOCATIONS , MARS PHYSICAL EPHEMERIS, AND SOLAR SYSTEM PARAMETERS; DETERMINATION FROM VIKING LANDER TRACKING DATA A. P . Mayo (NASA Langley Research Center, Mail Stop 40lB, Hampton, VA 23665) w. T . Blackshear, R. H . Tolson, W. H. Michael, Jr . , G. M. Kelly, J. P. Brenkle, and T. A. Komarek

Radio Tracking data from the Viking l anders have been analyzed to determine the parameters of the Mars physical ephemeris, the radii of Mars at the landing sites, and the l ander locations . The orientation of the Mars rotation axis, re­ferred to the 1950. 0 Earth mean equator, equinox, and epoch, was determined as 317.340 ± 0.003° right ascension and 52.710 ± 0. 002° declination . The planet's r otation period was determined as 24 hr., 37 min . 22 . 663 ± 0.002 sec. Analyses indicate the determination of the motions of the Mars rotation axis will require additional tracking data. The Mars radii at the sites of landers 1 and 2 are 3389 .38 ± 0.06 km and 3381.91 ± 0 . 08 km, respectively . The areocentric location of lander 1 is 22.272 ± 0.002° N, 47.94 ± 0.2° W. The lander 2 location is 47.670 ± 0.002° N, 225 . 71 ± 0 . 2° W. The areocentric right ascensions of the landers are determined as 227.314 ± 0 . 002° for lander 1 and 99.546 ± 0 . 002° for lander 2 at Jan. 1 1

0 hr., 1977 (Julian Date 2443144 . 5) . Possible determinations of relativity parameters , solar oblateness, asteroid mass , and variations of the universal gravitational constant, from their effects on the planetary motions 1 will require the additional t rac king data of the Viking ex-

~~n<h~~p~~~~ioR~S .(,V~~~~g Pa~~~d7Sb4't'~{s, rotation)

6545 Interiors of planets SEISMOLOGY ON MARS D. L. Anderson (Seismological Laborator y , Calif. Inst. of Tech., Pasadena, Ca. 91125), W. F. Miller, G. V. Latham, Y. Nakamura, M. N. Toksoz, A. M. Dainty, F. K . Duennebier , A. R. Lazarewicz, R. L. Kovach, and T. C. D. Knight.

A three-axis short period seismometer has been operating on the s urface of Mars in the Utopia Planitia region since September 4, 1976. During the first five months of operation approx. 640 hours of high quality data, uncontaminated by Lander or wind noise, have been obtained . The detection threshold is estimated to be magnitude 3 to about 200 km and about 6 . 5 for the planet as a whole. No large events have been seen during this period indicating that Mars is less seis­mically active than Earth. Wind is the major source of noise during the day although the noise level was at or below the sensitivity threshold of the seismometer for most of the night during the early part of the mission. Winds, and there­fore the seismic background, started to intrude into the night-time hour s starting on Sol 119 (a Sol is a Martian day). The seismic background correlates well with wind velocity and is pro­portional to (wind velocity) 2, as appropriate for turbulent flow. The seismic envelope power spectral density is proportional to frequency to the minus 0. 66 to 0. 90 power during windy periods. A possible local seismic event was detected on Sol 80 . No wind data was obtained at the time so a wind disturbance cannot be ruled out. However • this event has some unusual characteristics and is similar to local events recorded on Earth through a Viking seismometer system . If interpreted as a natural sei smic even t it has a magnitude of 3 and a distance of llO km. Preliminary interpretation of later a rrivals in the signal suggest a crustal thick­ness of 15 km at the Utopia Planitia Site which is within the range of crustal models derived from the gravity field. More events must be recorded before a firm interpretation can be .nade of seismicity of crustal structure. One firm conclusion is that the natural background noise on Mars is low and that the wind is the prime noise source. It will be possible to reduce this noise by a factor of 103 on futur e missions by removing the seismometer from the Lander • thus making it possible to operate an extremely sensitive seismometer on the surface. (Mars seismicity • Mars crust, Mars wi:nds, Viking Seismology)

J. GeQphys. R~s. , Red, Paper 750408

828

6560 Meteoritics CORRELATED 0 AND Mg ISOTOPIC ANOMALIES IN ALLENDE INCLUSIONS: II. MAGNETISM G. J. Wasserburg (The Lunatic Asylum, Div. of Geological and Planetary Sciences, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California 91125) T. Lee and D. A. Papanastassiou

Mg in two Allende Ca- Al rich inclusions s hows large isotopic, mass-dependent fractionation which enriched the heavier isotopes. After normaliza­tion, Mg in these inclusions shows negative o2~g

:~!~:t:p~:a~ ~~s~~~~!r~r~:e 2E~~s~:~:y ~f ~~~l:r mass frac tionation is correlated with distinct but smaller fractionation effects for 0 reported by Clayton and Mayeda for the same inclusions (see companion paper). The observation of distinctive but uniform Mg isotopic compos ition in different phases within single Allende inclusions indicates that nuclear effects i n 0 and Mg are not due to the entrapment of interstellar carrier grains as discrete entities, which are preserved as rem­nants, but are instead due to a homogenized mix­ture of components of extraordinary isotopic com­position mixed with a component of ordinary solar sys tem material and subjected to isotopic frac­tionation. The distinct 0 isotopic composition of different phases within a single inclusion is believed to be due to incomp l ete back-reaction of the higher temperature condensates with a cooler solar nebul a of "normal" composition. The pro­cesses responsible for t he 0 and Mg nuclear ef­fects and the astrophysical site of their occur­rence remain undefined. Geophys . Res . Lett., Paper 710406

6560 Heteoritics CORRELATED OXYGEN AND MAGNES IUM ISOTOPE ANOMALIES IN ALLENDE INCLUSIONS, I: OXYGEN Robert N. Clayton and Toshiko K. Mayeda ( Enrico Fermi Institute, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 60637 )

Two Ca-Al-rich inclusions from the Allende meteorite have been found to have undergone large mass-fractionation of oxygen isotopes subsequent to incorporation of the nucleosynthetic 160-anomaly found in other Allende inclusions. The magnitude of the oxygen isotope fractionations is in constant ratio to the magnesium isotope fractiona tions found in the same inclusions by Wasserburg, Lee and Papanastassiou . The obser­vations support earlier theories of the addition of supernova ejecta into the solar nebula just prior to collapse and condensation . (Meteorites, oxygen isotopes, solar nebula, supernova ) . Geophys. Res. Lett . , Paper 710407

6575 Surface of planets IPL PROCESSING OF THE VIKING ORBITER IMAGES OF MARS See 6590 Instruments and techniques

6575 Surfaces of planets VIKING RADIO OCCULTATION MEASUREMENTS OF THE MARTIAN ATMOSPHERE AND TOPOGRAPHY; PRIMARY MISSION COVERAGE See 6510 Atmosphere of planet s

6575 Surface of planets PROCESSING THE VIKING LANDER CAMERA DATA See 6590 Instruments and techniques

6575 Surfaces of Planets MARS: WATER VAPOR OBSERVATIONS FROM THE VIKING ORBITERS See 6510 Atmos pheres of Planets

-M~5 vr~J~Gc~r8io8fC~Lt~NVESTIGATION: GENERAL ASPECTS H.P. Klein (NASA Ames Research Center, Moffett Field, California 94035, U.S .A.

The Viking biological investigation has tested four different hypotheses regarding the possible nature of Martian organisms . While significant results were obtained for each of t hese, tests of three of the hypotheses appear to indicate the absence of biology in the s amples used, while the fourth is consistent with a biological interpretation. The original assumptions for each experiment and the experimental procedur es that wer e utilized to t est these assumptions are reviewed . J. Geophys. Res. , Red, Paper 7S0439

SS 75 Surface of p l anets PECULIARITIES OF THE GEOLOGICAL STRUCTURE OF THE MARS' SECTOR PHOTOGRAPHED BY AUTOMATIC STATIONS "MARS" (9 pp.) A. L. Sukhanov Geotect., No. 1, 1977

6575 Surface of planets GEOCHEMICAL AND MINERALOGICAL INTERPRETATION OF

.THE VIKING INORGANIC CHEMICAL RESULTS P. Toulmin, III (U.S. Geological Survey, 959 National Center, Reston , VA 22092) A. K. Baird, B. C. Clark, K. Keil, H.J. Rose, J r. , R.P. Christian, P . H. Evans and W.C. Kellihe r

The elemental analyses whose basis is described in the preceding two papers represent the compo­sition of samples of Martian fines ; the only un­determined major constituents thought to be pre­sent are H2 0, C0 2 , Na 2 0, and possibly NOx. The samples are principally silicate particles , with some admixture of oxide and probably carbona te minerals; the fines appear to hax_e been indura­ted to a variable degree by a sulfate-rich inter ­granular cement. The overall elemental composi­tion is dissimilar to any single known mineral or rock type, and apparently represents a mixture of materials. Close chemical similarity among samples at each site, and between the two s i t es , indicates effective homogenization of the f i nes , presumably by planetary windstorms, and fur t her suggests that the samples analyzed represent the fine, mobilizable materials over a large par t o f the planet ' s surface. Low trace-element, alka­li, and alumina contents suggest that the great preponderance of the materials in the mixtu r e i s of mafic derivation; highly differentiated, sa lic igneous rocks or their weathering products are insignificant components of the samples . Norma­tive calculations, comparisons with refere nce libraries of analytical data, and mathematical mixture modeling have led to a qualitative min­eralogical model in which the fines consist largely of iron- rich smectites (or their degra ­dation products), carbonates , iron oxides, pro­bably in part maghemite, and sulfate minera l s concentrated in a surface duricrust. The origi­nal smectites may have formed by interaction of mafic magma and subsurface ice, and the sulfates (and carbonates?) may have been concentrated in the surf&~ c rust by subsurface l eaching, up-

=~~:t~~=n~?~~~: a~=s ~~:~o~:~i~:f~!e!:~~r~~a~~~= r and competing models will accompany continui ng acquisition of samples and data, and r efinemen t of the analyses, particularly with respect t o t he critical light elements Mg , A, and Si. (Ma r s,

J~eG;~~~Y~~mk~~ ~~ i~~d 'm~~~~~l7~b464ea t her in g)

6575 Surface of Planets MARTIAN IMPACT CRATERS AND EMPLACEMENT OF EJECTA BY SURFACE FLOS . M.H. Carr (U.s . Ge ologiceJ. Survey, Menlo Park, California 94025 ) L. A. Crumpler, J.A. CUtts, R. Greeley, J . E. Guest and H. Ma sursky

Several types of martia n impact craters have been recognized. The most c ommon type, t he rampart crater, is distinctively different from lunar and mercurian craters. It is typicall y surrounded by several layers of ejecta, each with a low ridge or escarpment at its outer edge . Outward flow of' ejecta eJ.ong the ground af'ter ballistic depositi on is suggested by flow lines around obstacles, the absence of ejecta on top and on the lee side of obstacles, and t h e l arge radial distance to which c ontinuous eject a i s found. The peculiar flow characteristics CJf the ejecta around these craters are tentatively attributed to entrained gases or to contained water, either liquid or vapor, in the ejecta as a

\result of impact melting of ground ice . Ej ecta of other craters lack flow features but have Ia marked radial pattern; still others have eject a tpatterns that resemble those around lunar and 'mercurian craters . The internal features of martian craters, in genereJ., resemble thei r lunar and mercurian counterparts except that the transition from bowl-shaped to flat-floore d takes ,place at about 5 krn diameter, a smaller size than for Mercury of the Moon. J. Geophys. Res., Red, Paper 7S0488

6575 Surface of planets COMMENTS ON: " CHARACTERISTICS OF FRESH MARTIAN CRATERS AS A FUNCTION OF DIAMETER: COMPARISON WITH THE MOON AND MERCURY" BY M. J. CINTALA ET AL. C. F."" Florensky 1 A. T. Basilevsky , and V. P. Polosukhin (Vernadsky Institute of Geochemis try and Analytical Chemistry, USSR Academy of Sci­ences, Moscow, USSR)

Cintala et al. attempt to determine: (1) at what diamete"rSfresh martian c r aters begin t o ldevelop features such as central peaks, flat bottoms, terraces, etc. and (2) what determines the threshold diameters for various features.

1we argue that the r esults of Cintala ~ !l· are biased by the way in which they collect and organize data. Geophys. Res. Lett., P~per 7L0 122

',