trachoma in south australia

1
422 seniority, can hardly have much appeal for men and women who have spent long years in postgraduate train- ing, and may indeed have been senior registrars. More- ever, the medical-assistant grade looks as though it were going to perpetuate the two characteristics that have made so many people sorry to be a S.H.M.o. First, it is not designed as the ordinary stepping-stone between the senior registrar and the consultant, but will instead bear the old welcoming inscription " Abandon hope, most of you who enter here ". And it also seems likely to preserve the enormous disadvantage, for a career grade, that its maximum salary will always be a little below the minimum salary of the consultant. Who, one may ask, is willingly going to become a medical assistant-except possibly a few general practitioners, or some married women, who might take such an appointment part-time ? Before any such terms of service are settled, we hope those concerned will at least reconsider the possibility of overlapping scales of salary-so that a senior doctor who has worked for, say, twenty-five years in the intermediate grade will earn more (not less) than a young doctor who has just won his consultant spurs.4 Essentially, what is in question is whether the new grade is to be senior or junior. We remain of the opinion that a career grade of this kind should be senior. To carry the appropriate prestige it would need a title less depress ing than either " senior hospital medical officer " or " medical assistant "; and we still favour the title of " specialist " which we have so often proposed.4 But whatever the grade is called for administrative purposes, the actual appointments in it should be those of assistant physician, assistant surgeon, assistant pathologist, assistant psychiatrist, and so on. The fact that some of these titles are at present attached to certain consultant appointments seems to us insufficient reason for preventing a change which would generally be consistent with the realities of hospital life. If it became usual for prospective consultants to move into this intermediate grade as soon as their training was finished, the grade would lose its dead-end character. And actually, of course, even doctors who had spent many years in it should still be able to qualify for a consultant appointment by showing their fitness for consultant work and their readiness to assume its responsibilities. TRACHOMA IN SOUTH AUSTRALIA THE discovery of active trachoma in quite a number of people in Adelaide, including doctors, has caused surprise; for in Australia this infection was thought to be virtually confined to the outback. Though the disease may seldom or never be serious unless hygienic conditions are bad, it is important enough to justify full investigation of any flare-up. Until about 1942 the general belief was that Australia had little or no active trachoma; but subsequent surveys showed that this was certainly not true of the aborigines.1-3 Thus in one investigation in the Northern Territory 3051 were affected out of 4876 examined, while in a smaller study, of about 500, 90% showed evidence of infection and 7 °% were blind in one or both eyes. In other surveys, an equally high proportion of the people showed signs of past or present infection, but eyesight was seldom seriously impaired. This raised the question whether Australia may have two strains of trachoma organism-a virulent one 1. Webb, R. C. Med. J. Aust. 1957, i, 460. 2. Flynn, F. ibid. 1957, ii, 269. 3. Yates, P. C. ibid. 1963, i, 828. possibly introduced with the Afghan camel-drivers who were brought to Australia about a century ago, and a milder one spread from South-east Asia by Chinese and Indonesians. Flynn 2 seems no need for such an explanation. He points out that both the benign and the destructive disease begin with a florid infection; but, whereas in favourable conditions this may subside with hardly any sequels, in unfavourable conditions-e.g., secondary infection, or exposure to hot dry wind and dust-the results may be disastrous. That trachoma may have suddenly become epidemic in Adelaide is suggested by the fact that one ophthalmologist (Mr. D. 0. Crompton) has seen 18 cases in his private practice in a single month. Believing that the incidence of clinical trachoma in South Australia is quite high and is rapidly increasing, he is very properly pressing for a survey in schools and other institutions, and is urging that all suspected cases shall be examined by a virologist, and kept under observation so that the effect of treatment can be judged. Fortunately the Institute of Medical and Veterinary Science at Adelaide is able to undertake the necessary cytological studies; and it had investigated some 600 patients up to last November. Unfortunately, on the other hand, it cannot go on with this work unless a small additional unit can be created for this special purpose. We hope this can be done, not only for reasons of public health but also because the Adelaide institute is capable of making a positive contribution to the virology of this disease. SPREAD OF VIRUS HEPATITIS THE two types of acute viral hepatitis differ in the way they spread: infective hepatitis is almost always an enteric infection, whereas serum hepatitis is conveyed only by the parenteral route. As might be expected of an infection conveyed from fasces to mouth, infective hepatitis is far commoner in children. The incubation period of infective hepatitis is 15-60 days and that of serum hepatitis is 50-160 days. But in other respects-clinical course, bio- chemical derangements in serum and fxces, and histo- logical changes in the liver-they are very similar. The majority of sufferers, especially children, have a mild form of the disease without jaundice, and this anicteric hepatitis may need sensitive liver-function tests for its recognition. The agents responsible have not been isolated with certainty; so there are no specific serological tests for antibodies. The evidence for infectivity of specimens and transmission of the disease are based on human transmission experiments-a very unsatisfactory state of affairs. Thus, any data collected from epidemics are of the greatest value in piecing together the true picture of spread. Foremost in these laborious epidemiological endeavours are Moseley and his co-workers who have recently studied two epidemics in Des Moines, Iowa. These epidemics came in cycles; they tended to reach a peak in the winter; there was a slow rise and fall in the epidemic curve; and the attack-rate was high in the 5-14 age- group-features attributable to person-to-person spread. An intestinal-oral route was suggested by the lower attack-rate that accompanied better sanitation, im- proved socioeconomic status, coupled with better sewage disposal and removal of privies, and the lessening of household congestion. Since hepatitis is primarily a disease of schoolchildren, particular attention was paid to 4. Moseley, W. H., Speers, J. F., Chin, T. D. Y. Amer. J. publ. Hlth, 1963, 53, 1603.

Upload: doankiet

Post on 05-Jan-2017

214 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: TRACHOMA IN SOUTH AUSTRALIA

422

seniority, can hardly have much appeal for men andwomen who have spent long years in postgraduate train-ing, and may indeed have been senior registrars. More-

ever, the medical-assistant grade looks as though it weregoing to perpetuate the two characteristics that have madeso many people sorry to be a S.H.M.o. First, it is not

designed as the ordinary stepping-stone between thesenior registrar and the consultant, but will instead bearthe old welcoming inscription " Abandon hope, most ofyou who enter here ". And it also seems likely to preservethe enormous disadvantage, for a career grade, that itsmaximum salary will always be a little below the minimumsalary of the consultant. Who, one may ask, is willinglygoing to become a medical assistant-except possibly afew general practitioners, or some married women, whomight take such an appointment part-time ? Before anysuch terms of service are settled, we hope those concernedwill at least reconsider the possibility of overlapping scalesof salary-so that a senior doctor who has worked for,say, twenty-five years in the intermediate grade will earnmore (not less) than a young doctor who has just won hisconsultant spurs.4

Essentially, what is in question is whether the new

grade is to be senior or junior. We remain of the opinionthat a career grade of this kind should be senior. To carrythe appropriate prestige it would need a title less depressing than either " senior hospital medical officer " or

" medical assistant "; and we still favour the title of" specialist " which we have so often proposed.4 Butwhatever the grade is called for administrative purposes,the actual appointments in it should be those of assistantphysician, assistant surgeon, assistant pathologist,assistant psychiatrist, and so on. The fact that some ofthese titles are at present attached to certain consultant

appointments seems to us insufficient reason for preventinga change which would generally be consistent with therealities of hospital life. If it became usual for prospectiveconsultants to move into this intermediate grade as soonas their training was finished, the grade would lose itsdead-end character. And actually, of course, even doctorswho had spent many years in it should still be able to

qualify for a consultant appointment by showing theirfitness for consultant work and their readiness to assumeits responsibilities.

TRACHOMA IN SOUTH AUSTRALIA

THE discovery of active trachoma in quite a number ofpeople in Adelaide, including doctors, has caused surprise;for in Australia this infection was thought to be virtuallyconfined to the outback. Though the disease may seldomor never be serious unless hygienic conditions are bad, itis important enough to justify full investigation of anyflare-up.

Until about 1942 the general belief was that Australiahad little or no active trachoma; but subsequent surveysshowed that this was certainly not true of the aborigines.1-3Thus in one investigation in the Northern Territory 3051were affected out of 4876 examined, while in a smallerstudy, of about 500, 90% showed evidence of infectionand 7 °% were blind in one or both eyes. In other surveys,an equally high proportion of the people showed signs ofpast or present infection, but eyesight was seldom seriouslyimpaired. This raised the question whether Australia mayhave two strains of trachoma organism-a virulent one

1. Webb, R. C. Med. J. Aust. 1957, i, 460.2. Flynn, F. ibid. 1957, ii, 269.3. Yates, P. C. ibid. 1963, i, 828.

possibly introduced with the Afghan camel-drivers whowere brought to Australia about a century ago, and amilder one spread from South-east Asia by Chinese andIndonesians. Flynn 2 seems no need for such an explanation.He points out that both the benign and the destructivedisease begin with a florid infection; but, whereas infavourable conditions this may subside with hardly anysequels, in unfavourable conditions-e.g., secondaryinfection, or exposure to hot dry wind and dust-theresults may be disastrous.That trachoma may have suddenly become epidemic in

Adelaide is suggested by the fact that one ophthalmologist(Mr. D. 0. Crompton) has seen 18 cases in his privatepractice in a single month. Believing that the incidenceof clinical trachoma in South Australia is quite high andis rapidly increasing, he is very properly pressing for asurvey in schools and other institutions, and is urging thatall suspected cases shall be examined by a virologist, andkept under observation so that the effect of treatment canbe judged. Fortunately the Institute of Medical andVeterinary Science at Adelaide is able to undertake the

necessary cytological studies; and it had investigated some600 patients up to last November. Unfortunately, on theother hand, it cannot go on with this work unless a smalladditional unit can be created for this special purpose.We hope this can be done, not only for reasons of publichealth but also because the Adelaide institute is capableof making a positive contribution to the virology of thisdisease.

SPREAD OF VIRUS HEPATITIS

THE two types of acute viral hepatitis differ in the way theyspread: infective hepatitis is almost always an entericinfection, whereas serum hepatitis is conveyed only bythe parenteral route. As might be expected of an infectionconveyed from fasces to mouth, infective hepatitis is farcommoner in children. The incubation period of infectivehepatitis is 15-60 days and that of serum hepatitis is50-160 days. But in other respects-clinical course, bio-chemical derangements in serum and fxces, and histo-logical changes in the liver-they are very similar. The

majority of sufferers, especially children, have a mildform of the disease without jaundice, and this anicterichepatitis may need sensitive liver-function tests for its

recognition. The agents responsible have not beenisolated with certainty; so there are no specific serologicaltests for antibodies. The evidence for infectivity of

specimens and transmission of the disease are based onhuman transmission experiments-a very unsatisfactorystate of affairs. Thus, any data collected from epidemicsare of the greatest value in piecing together the true

picture of spread.Foremost in these laborious epidemiological endeavours

are Moseley and his co-workers who have recentlystudied two epidemics in Des Moines, Iowa. These

epidemics came in cycles; they tended to reach a peak inthe winter; there was a slow rise and fall in the epidemiccurve; and the attack-rate was high in the 5-14 age-group-features attributable to person-to-person spread.An intestinal-oral route was suggested by the lowerattack-rate that accompanied better sanitation, im-

proved socioeconomic status, coupled with better sewagedisposal and removal of privies, and the lessening ofhousehold congestion. Since hepatitis is primarily a

disease of schoolchildren, particular attention was paid to4. Moseley, W. H., Speers, J. F., Chin, T. D. Y. Amer. J. publ. Hlth, 1963,

53, 1603.