transition and threshold

100
1

Upload: rachael-jennings

Post on 30-Mar-2016

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Thesis exploring the nature of the interstitial Urban space

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Transition and Threshold

1

TRANSITION+THRESHOLD

Page 2: Transition and Threshold

2

CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION

SITE | EXPLORATIONS, ITERATIONS

REPOPULATING THE IN-BETWEEN

STREET EXTEND

CLOISTER | COURTYARD |CONSTELLATION

A HISTORY OF CONTAINMENT

THRESHOLD | FRAME

PEDAGOGY | PROGRAMME

CUTTING + REVEALING

DESIGN DEVELOPMENT

FINAL PRESENTATION

BIBLIOGRAPHY

APPENDIX

2

3

10

16

18

31

53

60

68

71

87

97

99

Page 3: Transition and Threshold

3

I N T R O D U C T I O N

This thesis is an investigation into the in-between space.

I am interested in the most apparent interpretation of the

interstitial realm; how the gaps in our built environment

define spatial layers, articulating thresholds between

public and private, inside and outside. Moments for

pause and reflection, dynamic perception.

In between spaces also have a social role, in their

greatest manifestations they can create gestures

of inclusion, shared spaces that foster community

integration and cohesion.

School has a unique position in a person’s life, it forms a

temporal threshold between infancy and adulthood and

thus provides an perfect medium for exploring this thesis.

The annual theme of the school of architecture, “Inherited

Landscape”, also has resonances with this exploration

as designing within existing fabric already implies an in-

between space; gaps between old and new, past and

present.

Page 4: Transition and Threshold

4

S I T E | E X P L O R A T I O N S , I T E R A T I O N S

Page 5: Transition and Threshold

5

S I T E 1 | N O R T H S T R A N D

The first site investigated is at the intersection of North

Strand road and East wall road adjacent to the Tolka

river and Fairview park. The context is that of an urban

village, close to the city but contained and self sufficient.

A strong sense of identity is created by the intersection of

routes; road, river and train.

Following a number of studies the site proved to be

too large and open to be an effective medium for an

exploration of the in-between space.

site sketch [Author]

Page 6: Transition and Threshold

6

site sections [Author]

site plan [Author]

Page 7: Transition and Threshold

7

The next site was the result of a search for interstitial

spaces in the dense fabric of Dublin’s inner city; finding

a function for the forgotten, space in the void. By linking

the currently dilapidated Aldborough House to the Fire

Station Art Studios via Hewardine terrece a route is

created, a campus that is greater than the sum of its

parts.

However the size and dispersion of these spaces

resulted in the site being unsuitable for a school brief

considering the need for open play space and ancillary

facilities.

S I T E 2 | B U C K I N G H A M S T R E E T

context drawing highlighting educational institutions [Author]

Page 8: Transition and Threshold

8site plan [Author]

route section [Author]

Page 9: Transition and Threshold

9

The site chosen for the school design is on Sean Mac

Dermott street again in Dublin’s north inner city. It was

occupied by the Magdalene Asylum run by the sisters of

Charity of Refuge since from approximately 1877 until it

was closed as the last Magdalene Laundry in Ireland in

1996.

The site has an interesting combination of building

remnants and open space. Its size and aspect is

appropriate for a school brief and it presents the complex

challenge of creating a new identity for a building with an

oppressive history.

S I T E 3 | S E A N M A C D E R M O T T S T R E E T

site photo [Author]

Page 10: Transition and Threshold

10context drawing [Author]

Page 11: Transition and Threshold

11

R E P O P U L A T I N G T H E I N - B E T W E E N

Page 12: Transition and Threshold

12

specific work spaces such as studios for art create stimulating environments and movement through the school

initial spatial study 1 [Author]

Page 13: Transition and Threshold

13

elements of transition such as stairs become spaces for interaction, performance and casual learning

initial spatial study 2 [Author]

Page 14: Transition and Threshold

14

an internal street allows students to showcase and display their work, strengthening school pride and identity

initial spatial study 3 [Author]

Page 15: Transition and Threshold

15

this “street” can also foster community inclusion by becoming a space for markets and social interaction

initial spatial study 4 [Author]

Page 16: Transition and Threshold

16

S T R E E T E X T E N D

Page 17: Transition and Threshold

17

[ R E F E R E N C E ] U N I V E R S I T A L U I G I B O C C O N I , M I L A NG R A F T O N A R C H I T E C T S

PRIVATE PUBLIC

By extending the street into the body of the school

education and community become interlinked; children

can actively and socially engage with other members of

society and outside school hours the space is inhabited

and used for community meetings, night classes, sports

and other activities

The ground floor of the Universita Luigi Bocconi in Milan

is public space which, “reaches out to the city and

beckons the visitor into the heart of the interior.”1

The ground floor mediates between the life of the city

and the life of the University through a series of spatial

movements from street (public) to the offices hovering

above (private).

This series of thresholds creates spatial richness and

diverse inhabitation, it becomes, “ a city in miniature”. 2

1. O’Regan, J and Dearey, N (Ed.) (2009) New Irish Architecture. 24, AAI Awards Kinsale : Gandon Editions2. Ibid.

[diagram: Author. project: Grafton Architects]

Page 18: Transition and Threshold

18

study model: public | private + routes.

[diagram: Author. project: Grafton Architects]

Page 19: Transition and Threshold

19

C L O I S T E R | C O U R T Y A R D | C O N S T E L L A T I O N

Page 20: Transition and Threshold

20

[ R E F E R E N C E ] L ’ A B B A Y E D U T H O R O N E T

The school design has been largely influenced by a study

of abbeys and monasteries. The cloister plan creates a

calm and clear route around a central garden, creating

a threshold between the interior and exterior worlds. In

le Thoronet there is a covered external walkway with

spaces within this thickened threshold to sit and pause

looking towards the garden. A secondary route on top of

the covered arcade allows for external circulation on the

upper level, open to the sky.

Ground floor plan. Fujimoto, Sou (2008)The Cistercian Abbey of Le Thoronet. A + U: Architecture and urbanism

Page 21: Transition and Threshold

21

Sections. Fujimoto, Sou (2008)The Cistercian Abbey of Le Thoronet. A + U: Architecture and urbanism

Page 22: Transition and Threshold

22

Image courtesy of Jonathan Janssens

Page 23: Transition and Threshold

23

Image courtesy of Jonathan Janssens

Page 24: Transition and Threshold

24study model: classroom section + garden. [Author]

fig. 19

Page 25: Transition and Threshold

25

[ R E F E R E N C E ] H A C K E S C H E H O E F E , B E R L I N

The Hackeshe Hoefe are a series of courtyards off

a busy street in the centre of Berlin. They provide a

pedestrian terrain away from the noise of traffic and

create a knitted pattern of shops, cafes and a cinema.

The route through is hinted at by glimpses into the next

court, they become sequentially more calm and serene

until you reach the trees and water of the graveyard at

the other end.

This underlines the motif of a hidden garden, an oasis of

green that is glimpsed but never fully revealed

solid | void | route study drawing [Author]

Page 26: Transition and Threshold

26

Hackeshe Hoefe [Author]

Page 27: Transition and Threshold

27

hidden garden concept drawing 1 [Author]

Page 28: Transition and Threshold

28

hidden garden concept drawing 2 [Author]

Page 29: Transition and Threshold

29

[ R E F E R E N C E ] R O M A C E N T R E F O R C O N T E M P O R A R Y A R T SC A R U S O S T J O H N

Also influenced by monastery plans, Caruso St. John

describe their centre for contemporary arts in terms of

constellations; emerging as a balance of forces rather

than through a finite set of forms.1 Existing structures

on site are preserved, augmented and demolished

where appropriate, the serial industrial aesthetic of the

barracks is engaged with but there is not a deliberate

distinction made between old and new construction.

The juxtaposition of the different elements creates an

exciting spatial diversity and expresses the history and

culture of the city in a way that would not be possible in a

completely new building.

This painterly method of overlaying new and old provided

hints to working within the existing context of the

Convent. The buildings should be thoroughly understood

and analysed; allowed to express their voice without

being overly precious about formal consistencies or

historical delineations.

Model: Caruso St. John

1. Caruso St. John. (2000) Roma Centre for Contemporary Arts. A + T

Page 30: Transition and Threshold

30

Ground floor plan: Caruso St. John

Section: Caruso St. John

Page 31: Transition and Threshold

31

[model: Author project: Caruso St. John]

structure + light study model

Page 32: Transition and Threshold

32

U N C A N N Y R E P R E S S I O N | A H I S T O R Y O F C O N T A I N M E N T

Page 33: Transition and Threshold

33

The Magdalene Asylum was an institution founded

as one of many in Britain and Ireland as part of the

Female Penitentiary Movement in the 19th Century.

The first Magdalene Asylum was established in Dublin

in 1767. The movement was founded in England, “for

the rescue reclamation and protection of betrayed and

fallen women”.1 It was to provide temporary shelter

for prostitutes, abused women and girls or unmarried

mothers mostly of the lower social classes, with the

objective to give them rest, hygiene, food, work and

enough education to take up work outside prostitution,

mostly as domestic servants. While the Magdalene

Asylums were founded and initially managed by lay

people most institutions in Ireland were taken over by

catholic orders during the middle of the 19th century.

The Order of Our Lady of Charity of Refuge was founded

in France in 1666 under the rule of the Augustinian

Order. “As well as poverty, chastity and obedience, the

nuns took a fourth vow, which obliged them to labour for

the conversion of penitent women.”2 They ran the biggest

Magdalene Institutions in Ireland and enforced strict rules

which were still enforced until well into the second half

of 19th Century. These rules included complete silence

during work, at mealtime and in the dormitories, cutting

or shaving of hair, none or only limited contacts with

families, assigning of new names to the inmates, long

hours of prayers and devotion, very limited education.

Under the management of the Sisters the Magdalene

Homes often developed into long term homes for the

penitents.

T H E M A G D A L E N E A S Y L U M

1. Finnegan, F (2001) Do penance or perish : a study of Magdalen asylums in Ireland. Piltown, Co. Kilkenny : Congrave Press

2. Ibid.

Page 34: Transition and Threshold

34

As in the Convent of the Sisters of Charity of Refuge on

Sean Mac Dermott Street Lower, the women worked

mostly in laundries. These commercial laundries were

often the main support of the Convents, the Sisters had

therefore an interest to keep the institutions well staffed.

The women were ‘brought‘ to the institutions primarily by

priests or relatives, mostly illegally. However the majority

of the women would have been either too young or

not well enough educated to be aware of their legal

status. Some women spent the majority of their adult

life in the homes. Estranged from their families, friends

and let down by society, they became increasingly

institutionalised and died eventually in the care of the

nuns. The laundries gradually became less viable due

to the introduction of domestic washing machines and

the changing of social values in Ireland. The Laundry on

Sean Mac Dermott street was closed in 1996 as the last

remaining Magdalene Laundry in Ireland.

Magdalene “penitents” participating in a Corpus

Christi Procession on Sean Mac Dermott street in

1950s. [J.M. Smith 2007]

Page 35: Transition and Threshold

35

[ R E F E R E N C E ] L E T T E R F R A C K F U R N I T U R E C O L L E G EO ’ D O N N E L L + T U O M E Y

A building with a similar history of institutional cruelty was

St. Joseph’s industrial school in Letterfrack Co. Galway,

opened in 1887 by the Christian Brothers for boys who

had committed minor criminal offences or who were

destitute or homeless. The boys provided free labour for

local businesses and suffered much violence and abuse

at the hands of the Brothers.

After the Brothers left the building in 1973 it was taken

over by a community group involved in education and

development and the building needed to be altered

to fit its new purpose. O’ Donnell + Tuomey’s design

incorporates the existing buildings and also creates new

purpose built structures. The institutional rigidity is relieved

by creating a new axis off centre and views out are

created by lowering the windows.1 The new structures

have a language of their own but work with the existing

volumes to create a new entrance forecourt.

The design is strongly informative for the school project

on Sean Mac Dermott Street. Without turning its back

on history or context, the furniture college creates a new

and positive image for the institutional building; through

a combination of minor interventions, new building and

the creation of rich urban spaces the building is reborn,

becoming a symbol of the positive forces of community

and education.

1. O’Donnell & Tuomey Architects (2004)Transformation of an institution : the Furniture College, Letterfrack, : Ireland’s Pavilion at the Venice Biennale. Oysterhaven, Kinsale : Gandon Editions

Page 36: Transition and Threshold

36

Model: O’ Donnell + Tuomey Architects

Page 37: Transition and Threshold

37

The Uncanny is a specific type of fear, a paradox that

combines the familiar with the fearful. Freud describes

it as the return of the repressed. 1 The culture of

containment associated with the Magdalene Laundry has

resonances with this particular type of horror; society was

aware of the atrocities being committed but deliberately

tried to repress this distasteful version of reality.

The laundry and dormitory buildings were destroyed in a

fire in 2006 but the remaining convent buildings still retain

the vestiges of its past, with its powerful presence on

the street and high walls to hide the world within it is like

a manifestation of the Uncanny space. This is a valuable

dialectical tool in trying to alleviate these inherent cultural

and physical fears. By revealing a new interior, a garden,

the sounds and songs of children playing and learning,

the Uncanny fears are pin-pricked, light is shed on the

dark and repressed void.

T H E U N C A N N Y

1. Freud, S. (1919) The Uncanny

Page 38: Transition and Threshold

38

nun’s cell. convent building.[Author]

Page 39: Transition and Threshold

39

corridor convent building. [Author]

Page 40: Transition and Threshold

40

gaps in wall sketch. railway street.[Author]

Page 41: Transition and Threshold

41

The Uncanny also has associations with doubling and

dual hidden worlds. 1 Stairs create this duality; always

simultaneously creating a positive and negative space.

IBy acknowledging this spatial reality and inhabiting this

void, spaces to hide, dark and exciting spaces can be

created in the poche or in-between spaces.

“In architecture the prototypical spandrel is the triangular

space “left over” on top when a rectangular wall is

pierced by a passageway capped with a rounded arch.

By extension a spandrel is any geometric configuration

of space inevitably left over as a consequence of other

architectural decisions. Thus the space between the floor

and the first step of a staircase or the horizontal course

between the lintels of a horizontal line of windows and the

bottom of the row of windows on the floor just above are

also called spandrels.” 2

The renewal or refurbishment of an existing structure

such as the convent building is full of opportunities

to investigate the potentials of these “spandrels”; the

gaps between new and old, adapted consequences

of previous design decisions, the space in the shutter

box of a sash window. The motif of spandrels informs

the detailed design of inhabited in-between spaces

throughout the school design.

P O C H E + S P A N D R E L | I N H A B I T E D V O I D

1. Freud, S. (1919) The Uncanny2. Gould, S (1997) The Exaptive Excellence of Spandrels as a Term and Prototype. Proceedings of the National

Academy of Sciences 94

Page 42: Transition and Threshold

42

attic of convent building.[Author]

Page 43: Transition and Threshold

43

stairs sketch [Author]

Page 44: Transition and Threshold

44

“secret” hidden spots for a quiet read[Author]

Page 45: Transition and Threshold

45

den with ball pool and periscope for covert spying[Author]

Page 46: Transition and Threshold

46

perspective: stairs + library[Author]

Page 47: Transition and Threshold

47

detail: storage boxes in steps[Author]

Page 48: Transition and Threshold

48

S I T E | M O R P H O L O G Y

Sean Mac Dermott Street formerly known as Gloucester Street (renamed in 1933), formed part of the Gardiner

Estate and was developed from 1760 by Luke Gardiner II as part of the expansion of North Dublin in the

18th Century which included Mountjoy Square, Upper and Lower Gardiner Street, Beresford Place, South of

Summerhill and Rutland Street. Luke Gardiner II contributed to the development until his death at the 1798

Battle of New Ross. Most of his estate was sold off by 1848 and a number of the buildings of the estate were

converted into tenements. What had been a fashionable living area around Gardiner Street gradually developed

into one of the worst slums of Dublin. By the end of the nineteenth century most of the terraced Georgian

houses were converted into tenements.

Roque’s map from 1756 shows Great Martin’s Lane which would later become Mecklenburgh Street and Railway Street. Further west on Marlborough Street the site for St. Thomas church is already visible which was planned as visual axis for Gloucester Street.

1756

1773

Shows the beginning extension of the Gardiner estate to the east.

Page 49: Transition and Threshold

49

1811

1847

1889

Shows the extent of the development of the Gardiner Estate to the east of the city.

Shows the first buildings of the Magdalene Asylum on Mecklenburgh Street Lower. Remnants of the external wall towards now Railway Street is still in place. The building was later used as part of the laundry complex. The original Dispensary building on Mecklenburgh Street Lower is also in place. The rear buildings at Palace Yard were only removed in 2006.

Shows the extension of the Magdalene Asylum towards Gloucester Street Lower. The first part of the Convent building is already in place together with the dormitory designed between 1868 and 1874. The laundry was positioned to the rear. The drying posts for the laundry are shown in the Convents Yard.

Page 50: Transition and Threshold

50

Shows the expansion of the Magdalene Asylum since 1888. The Convent building was extended along Gloucester Street Lower with a Convent Chapel to the rear for the Sisters of Our Lady of Charity who took over the Asylum in 1877. The former Palace Yard with the new ‘Dispensary’ building at Lower Tyrone Street (renamed from Mecklenburgh Street Lower, subsequently renamed Railway Street) was now part of the Asylum. The laundry buildings have also expanded towards the inner of the yard.

1909

1936

One of the last major developments to the Magdalene Asylum is the extension of the Convent building along now Sean Mac Dermott Street Lower (renamed from Gloucester Street Lower) sometime after 1909. The buildings on Railway Street opposite the laundry have been demolished probably to make way for the Liberty House complex built in 1938/39.

Page 51: Transition and Threshold

51

31868-1874

11909-1936

21888

b u i l t o r d e r

c o n s t r u c t i o n p e r i o d

g r o u n d f l o o r p l a n

r o o f p l a n

r e a r e l e v a t i o n

f r o n t e l e v a t i o n ( m i r r o r e d )

building phases diagram [Author]

Page 52: Transition and Threshold

52

folded elevations to courtyard. existing [Author]

Page 53: Transition and Threshold

53

chapel interior [Author]

Page 54: Transition and Threshold

54

T H R E S H O L D | F R A M E

Page 55: Transition and Threshold

55

The entrance to a school is a critical element in defining

its presence and ethos. It should create a civic gesture

of inclusion while at the same time defining the school’s

territory. It should describe the world within; encouraging

entry with light and view.

The entrance of Trinity College Dublin creates a

sequence of layered thresholds. It begins with a gap

between footpath and door, after entering through the

large wooden doors you are in an octagonal space that

is inside but feels external due to materiality and wind

flowing through, there is a clear view of trees, lawns

and the cloistered world outside. From here you decide

whether to continue into the courtyard or to move laterally

via the inside space either side. The richness comes

from a certain ambiguity between inside and outside,

public and private and a layering of framed views and

space.

This defining of frame is reminiscent of Edward Hopper

paintings where there is an implied gap between frame

and viewer. Looking through the doors of Trinity you are

initially unaware of the interstitial gap or frame between

the two external worlds. Similarly when we look at

Hopper’s characters through the frame of a window,

invisible space is created between the two frames.

The Whitney museum in New York creates spatial

stratification in the vertical plane. From the footpath and

the sheltered entrance bridge there are views to a terrace

below, belonging to the more private territory of the

museum; it can only be accessed from the world within.

The entrance of the school should create layers of

movement between the public life of the street and the

private inner world of the school. Subtle mediations

between inside and outside.

E N T R A N C E

Page 56: Transition and Threshold

56

[Author] trinity college. entrance study

Page 57: Transition and Threshold

57

fig. 47 Room in New York (1932) Edward Hopper

Page 58: Transition and Threshold

58

Whitney study [model: Author project: Marcel Breuer]

Image courtesy of the Whitney Musuem of Modern Art

Page 59: Transition and Threshold

59

[Author]entrance study. relief model.

Page 60: Transition and Threshold

60

[Author]

subtraction | addition. elevation studies.

Page 61: Transition and Threshold

61

P E D A G O G Y | P R O G R A M M E

Page 62: Transition and Threshold

62

The design is influenced by a number of studies on

pedagogy. Rudolf Steiner proposed a curriculum focused

on the individual child proposing that different types of

learning such as art or music require different spaces. He

also had specific instructions as to differing classroom

designs depending on different age groups.

Ken Robinson identifies a tendency in contemporary

education towards job readiness at the expense of

creativity.

The Reggio Emilia method stresses the importance of

the school as civic space and a central piazza forms the

social heart of the school, a non-hierarchical space for

meetings and group activities.

Maria Montessori created a way of learning that focused

on a more tactile approach, there is a strong focus on

learning through play and building.

The conclusion was for a school with flexible spaces for

different types of learning; workshops, art rooms and

gardens for growing and experiencing nature.

E D U C A T I O N A L T H E O R Y

Müller, T & Schneider, R (Eds.) (2002) Montessori : Lehrmaterialien 1913-1935, Möbel und Architektur = Teaching materials 1913-1935, furniture and architecture Munich ; London : Prestel

Page 63: Transition and Threshold

63

B R I E F A N A L Y S I S

To develop a programme our thesis group analysed the

schedule of accommodation of a number of schools.

I looked at the Department of Education repeat design

school and compared in to two very compact designs;

the Ranelagh Multidenominational School by O’ Donnell

+ Tuomey in Dublin and the Open Air School by Duiker

and Bijvoet in the Netherlands. The conclusion was that

despite the small footprint of the two school, provision

was made for external sheltered space, areas to learn

and play outside and that this is completely absent from

the Department of Education school.

Page 64: Transition and Threshold

64

Department of Education Standard SchoolSt. Benedict’s National School Ongar, Dublin 15

Total Floor Area: 2,214sqmNumber of Pupils: 304m2 per pupil: 7.3sqmSchool Type: PrimaryTypical Classroom size: 80sqm

Gen

eral

Cla

ssro

oms

(16X

80s

qm)

Anc

illar

y - L

ibra

ry

Circ

ulat

ion

- Hal

lway

s

Com

mun

al -

Din

ing

area

’s /

Pla

y ar

ea’s

Out

door

- B

alco

ny s

pace

s N

/A

Rec

reat

ion

- 2 X

Bal

l Cou

rts +

Yar

d

Adm

in -

Toile

ts, O

ffice

s, C

hang

ing

room

s

Brief study [diagram: Author project: Dept. of Education]

Page 65: Transition and Threshold

65

Open Air School, Amsterdam, the NetherlandsJohannes Duiker and Bernard Bijvoet

Total Floor Area: 1620sqmNumber of Pupils: 220m2 per pupil: 7.36sqmSchool Type: PrimaryTypical Classroom size: 76sqm

Gen

eral

Cla

ssro

oms

(16X

80s

qm)

Anc

illar

y - M

usic

, Sci

ence

, Lib

rary

, Lec

ture

Roo

ms

N/A

Circ

ulat

ion

- Hal

lway

s

Com

mun

al -

Ent

ranc

e H

all

Out

door

- B

alco

ny s

pace

s

Rec

reat

ion

- Cou

rtyar

d of

per

imet

er b

lock

Adm

in -

Offi

ces,

Sta

ff

Brief study [diagram: Author project: Duiker + Bijvoet]

Page 66: Transition and Threshold

66

Ranelagh Multidenominational School, Dublin 6O’ Donnell Tuomey Architects

Total Floor Area: 1142sqmNumber of Pupils: 250m2 per pupil: 4.6sqmSchool Type: PrimaryTypical Classroom size: 70sqm

Gen

eral

Cla

ssro

oms

(16X

80s

qm)

Anc

illar

y - L

ibra

ry

Circ

ulat

ion

- Hal

lway

s

Com

mun

al -

Din

ing

area

’s /

Pla

y ar

ea’s

Out

door

- B

alco

ny s

pace

s

Rec

reat

ion

- Yar

d

Adm

in -

Toile

ts, O

ffice

s, S

taff

Brief study [diagram: Author project: O’Donnell + Tuomey]

Page 67: Transition and Threshold

67

classroom studies; inbetween + sheltered external spaces [Author]

Page 68: Transition and Threshold

68

BR

IEF

. SCHOOL16 X Classrooms 8X80 Genera l Off ice Pr inc ip les Off ice Staff Room Staff W/C Home school l ia ison | breakfast c lub Hal l

PRACTICAL | SHAREDArt Room Meta l | Wood Workshop Music | Drama RoomKitchen and store [wi th access to growing plots] L ibrary [part of c i rcu lat ion]Changing rooms & WC Showers Sports Equipment Storage

+Circulat ion 20% 429

TOTAL INTERNAL

EXTERNAL SPACE5-aside footbal l p i tch 16X27 432sqmvert ica l gardens 8X40 400roof p layground 500[1332sqm]

TOTAL

sqm12801616501250200[1624]

1001208012070601250[612]

429

[2595]

432400500[1332]

3927

Page 69: Transition and Threshold

69

C U T T I N G + R E V E A L I N G

Page 70: Transition and Threshold

70

Conical Interesct. (1975) Gordon Matta-Clark.

Page 71: Transition and Threshold

71

In order to develop a visual link between street and

garden and to define a forecourt and entrance hall a

cut is made through the section of the building with the

greatest dilapidation and fire damage; in the centre. This

creates a space between new and old, revealing and

connecting. Matta Clark’s “Conical Intersect” project was

an interesting reference; by cutting through a building in

a working class area in Paris he reveals the nature of the

interior and also creates a view through to the Pompidou

Centre then under construction.

I N T E R S E C T

cut + reveal concept model [Author]

Page 72: Transition and Threshold

72

existing

demolition

ground floor plan existing. scale 1:500

Page 73: Transition and Threshold

73

existing

demolition

first floor plan existing. scale 1:500

Page 74: Transition and Threshold

74

second floor plan existing. scale 1:500

existing

demolition

Page 75: Transition and Threshold

75

D E S I G N D E V E L O P M E N T

Page 76: Transition and Threshold

76

concept model: juxtaposing and offsetting volumes creating routes, connections and external spatial variations [Author]

Page 77: Transition and Threshold

77

arranging volumes to define central court [Author]

Page 78: Transition and Threshold

78

massing sketch [Author]

Page 79: Transition and Threshold

79

massing model [Author]

Page 80: Transition and Threshold

80

plan strategy sketches [Author]

Page 81: Transition and Threshold

81

context model [Author]

Page 82: Transition and Threshold

82

G R O U N D F L O O R P L A N

1. school entrance2. ha l l entrance3. l ibrary zone4. workshop5. pr inc ip le’s off ice6. genera l off ice7. staff room8. home school l ia ison room9. hal l10. c lassroom11. sensory garden12. 5-as ide p i tch13. sport centre

1

2

3

4

56

7

8

9

10

10

10

1010

10

10

10

11

12

13

section strategy sketches [Author]

Page 83: Transition and Threshold

83

G R O U N D F L O O R P L A N

1. school entrance2. ha l l entrance3. l ibrary zone4. workshop5. pr inc ip le’s off ice6. genera l off ice7. staff room8. home school l ia ison room9. hal l10. c lassroom11. sensory garden12. 5-as ide p i tch13. sport centre

1

2

3

4

56

7

8

9

10

10

10

1010

10

10

10

11

12

13

ground floor plan development [Author]

Page 84: Transition and Threshold

84

14. sc ience lab15. language lab16. remedia l c lassroom

17. p lant nursery18. k i tchen and cookery c lassroom19. music room20. art room

9

10

10

10

1010

10

10

10

11

9

11

14

15

16

18

20

21

17

19

3

F I R S T F L O O R P L A N S E C O N D F L O O R P L A N

first floor plan development [Author]

Page 85: Transition and Threshold

85

14. sc ience lab15. language lab16. remedia l c lassroom

17. p lant nursery18. k i tchen and cookery c lassroom19. music room20. art room

9

10

10

10

1010

10

10

10

11

9

11

14

15

16

18

20

21

17

19

3

F I R S T F L O O R P L A N S E C O N D F L O O R P L A N

first floor plan development [Author]

Page 86: Transition and Threshold

86

section development. entrance hall [Author]

Page 87: Transition and Threshold

87

section development. classroom [Author]

Page 88: Transition and Threshold

88

F I N A L P R E S E N T A T I O N

Page 89: Transition and Threshold

89

ground floor plan. nts. [Author]

Page 90: Transition and Threshold

90

first floor plan. nts. [Author]

second floor plan. nts. [Author]

Page 91: Transition and Threshold

91

section thru courtyard. nts. [Author]

Page 92: Transition and Threshold

92

entrance hall [Author]

Page 93: Transition and Threshold

93

circulation/workspace [Author]

Page 94: Transition and Threshold

94

stairs/library[Author]

Page 95: Transition and Threshold

95

section thru courtyard - sports hall. nts. [Author]

Page 96: Transition and Threshold

96

section thru existing- courtyard - classrooms. nts. [Author]

Page 97: Transition and Threshold

97

classroom study. nts. [Author]

Page 98: Transition and Threshold

98

view from railway street. [Author]

Page 99: Transition and Threshold

99

Bachelard, G. (1969) The poetics of space. Boston : Beacon Press.

Caruso, A (2009) The feeling of things : escritos de arquitectura. Barcelona : Ediciones Poligrafa

Ceppi, G & Zini, M. (Eds.) Children, spaces, relations : metaproject for an environment for young children.

Reggio Emilia : Reggio Children

Christian, S (Ed.) (2003) Building in existing fabric : refurbishment, extensions, new design Basel :

Birkhäuser.

Chipperfield, D. (2004)1998 /2004 Madrid : El Croquis

Finnegan, F (2001) Do penance or perish : a study of Magdalen asylums in Ireland. Piltown, Co. Kilkenny :

Congrave Press

Freud, S. (1919) The Uncanny

Fujimoto, Sou (2008) The Cistercian Abbey of Le Thoronet. A + U: Architecture and urbanism

Giebeler, G (2009) Refurbishment manual. London : Springer.

Gould, S (1997) The Exaptive Excellence of Spandrels as a Term and Prototype. Proceedings of the

National Academy of Sciences 94

Müller, T & Schneider, R (Eds.) (2002) Montessori : Lehrmaterialien 1913-1935, Möbel und Architektur =

Teaching materials 1913-1935, furniture and architecture Munich ; London : Prestel

Lee, P (2000) Object to be destroyed : the work of Gordon Matta-Clark Cambridge, Mass. ; London : MIT

Press

O’Donnell & Tuomey Architects (2004) Transformation of an institution : the Furniture College, Letterfrack.

Ireland’s Pavilion at the Venice Biennale. Oysterhaven, Kinsale : Gandon Editions

B I B L I O G R A P H Y

Page 100: Transition and Threshold

100

O’Regan, J and Dearey, N (Ed.) (2009) New Irish Architecture. 24, AAI Awards Kinsale : Gandon Editions

Stoller, E (2000) The Whitney Museum of American Art / photographs by Ezra Stoller ; preface by Maxwell

Anderson ; introduction by K. Michael Hays New York : Princeton Architectural Press

Smith, J (2007) Ireland’s Magdalen Laundries and the nation’s architecture of containment Notre Dame,

Ind. : University of Notre Dame Press

Troyen, C (2007) Edward Hopper. London : Thames & Hudson

Venturi, R (1966) Complexity and contradiction in architecture. New York : Chicago : Museum of

ModernArt ; Graham Foundation for Advanced Studies in the Fine Arts

Žižek, S. (2010) Living in the end times. London : Verso

Zumthor, P. (2006) Atmospheres : architectural environments - surrounding objects. Basel : Birkhauser

Verlag