transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

71
Transportation Myths and Sacred Cows The Restoration of Our Cities and Towns Norman W. Garrick University of Connecticut

Upload: thelastmile

Post on 23-Dec-2014

571 views

Category:

Design


1 download

DESCRIPTION

Discussion of transportation planning for more livable cities

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Transportation Myths and Sacred Cows The Restoration of Our Cities and Towns

Norman W. GarrickUniversity of Connecticut

Page 2: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 3: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 4: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 5: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 6: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 7: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 8: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 9: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 10: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 11: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Gilbert’s 1909 plan to connect the train stationand downtown

Page 12: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

myth   [mith]

any invented story, idea, or concept:

sacred cow 

an individual, organization, institution, etc., considered to be exempt from criticism or questioning.

Page 13: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Myth 1Traditional Cities are Obsolete

Page 14: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 15: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Le Corbusier’s Plan Voisin for Paris

c1925

“In the age of the automobile and the skyscraper, the corridor street had become a ‘dead organ’ incapable of fulfilling its

function.

In the Plan Voisin, Le Corbusier analyzed this function into two parts, transportation and sociability,

and created two new urban forms to deal with them: superhighways and pedestrian malls.”

From Urban Utopias by Robert Fishman

Page 16: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 17: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Source: Die Disziplinierung Der Stadt Moderner Stadtebau in Zurich 1900 bis 1940 by Daniel Kurz

Page 18: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 19: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 20: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

The Housing Act of 1949

Page 21: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 22: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 23: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 24: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

“Our success as a country and as a species utterly

depends on the health and wealth of the

cities.”

Page 25: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

“America’s poor treatment of its own cities over the past half century helps spawn many of out most dire problems,

from increased inequality to

environmental damage to the recent economic collapse.”

Page 26: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 27: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 28: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Myth 2Networks are no longer important

http://www.georgeglazer.com/maps/newengland/images/newhavenmap-det2.jpg

Page 29: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 30: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 31: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

How Did This Drastic Change Occur?

One important agency in getting rid of the grid

network was the Federal Housing Authority

FHA Technical Bulletin No. 7 (1938)Planning Profitable Neighborhoods

Page 32: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

According to the FHA the grid layout was

Monotonous Had Little Character Uneconomical Posed Safety Concerns

?

Page 33: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

California Cities Study of Street Networks

Twenty-four Cities

Page 34: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

versus

Risk of Severe Injury or Fatality*

Chance of being Severely Injured

30% Higher

Chance of being Killed

50% Higher *Given that an injury occurred

Page 35: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Net

herlan

ds

Switz

erla

nd

Nor

way

Swed

en UK

Ger

man

y

Den

mar

k

Fran

ce

Austria

Austral

ia

Canad

a

New

Zea

land

Belgi

um USA2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16In 2005 the USA had

the highest traffic fatality rate of any OECD Country

Page 36: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 20050

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

USA Traffic Fatality Rate1970 to 2005

Page 37: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 20050

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

Changes in Traffic Fatality Ratein 16 OECD Countries

Page 38: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

9%

2%

4%

1%

9%

2%

Percentage of People Walking, Biking or Taking Transit

Page 39: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Odds of Dying in a Road Accident based on Intersection Density*

1 in 200

1 in 500

*Given that an injury occurred

Page 40: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Percentage of People Walking, Biking or Taking TransitEffect of Intersection Density for Gridded Network

< 81 81-144 144-225 225+0%

5%

10%

Page 41: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Cities with a fine grained network of small streets were

much safer and also had more walking and biking

Page 42: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Street Networks are not the only important Networks in Cities

For example, Network of Neighborhoods

Page 43: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Myth 3Good Transportation is Fast Transportation

Page 44: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 45: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities
Page 46: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Sixty years ago, Lewis Mumford reminded us that the exact opposite of this myth was true when he said

“A good transportation system minimizes unnecessary

transportation”

Page 47: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

What is Transportation for?

The purpose of transportation is to provide access to goods and people

Page 48: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Access

Speed

=

Distance

Page 49: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Access

Distance

=

Speed

Page 50: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Access to Pharmacies in Hartford

½ Mile

Page 51: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Access to Pharmacies in Washington, DC

½ Mile

Page 52: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

In Cities, Speed Kills

Literally and figuratively!

Page 53: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

0 10 20 30 40 500

20

40

60

80

100

05

45

85

Impact Speed (mph)

% C

han

ce o

f F

atal

ity

Source: U.K. Department of Transportation, Killing Speed and Saving Lives, London, 1987.

Speed KillsChance of Pedestrian Fatality vs. Impact Speed

Page 54: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Speed Kills Urbanism

Page 55: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Streetcars: Great Access – Great Urban Compatibility

Page 56: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Speedier Travel, not Faster Vehicles

This does not mean that we should never try to speed up travel, but any increase in speed should

be done in a way that is compatible with the character of urban places

In Zurich, faster transit is achieved by giving the transit priority in many ways

Page 57: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Myth 4Traffic is always growing and we must accommodate it or the city will come to a halt

Page 58: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Predict and ProvideStreet and Highway Capacity

“With projections indicating fifty thousand cars by 1960, Moot (chair of the City Planning

Commission) projected a need for fourteen thousand new (parking) spaces.”

Page 59: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Minimum Parking Standards

Most cities require that a minimum amount of parking must be added for each 1000 sq. ft. of new development

or each new job or resident

Page 60: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Sufficient Parking a Must!

“The most critical improvement to [neighborhood shopping districts] which could be made at this time is the provision of off-street

parking facilities” (City of Harford, 1972).

‘With projection indicating fifty thousand cars by 1960, Moot (chair of the City Planning Commission)

projected a need for fourteen thousand new (parking) spaces.

Mayor Joseph Mruk agreed. Not only would the city build three parking ramps (garages), it would encourage the private development of parking

facilities downtown “by assisting in the condemnation and assembly of necessary

sites.” The campaign to build parking spaces for twenty-five thousand automobiles began in 1950.’

Page 61: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 201025000

50000

75000

100000

125000

150000

Growth of Parking in 4 New England Cities

Which city has prospered the most?

Page 62: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Daytime Population 4 New England Cities

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010125000

150000

175000

200000

225000

250000

275000

Page 63: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Persons per Parking Space 4 New England Cities

1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 20101.00

3.00

5.00

7.00

Cambridge

Lowell

Hartford

New Haven

Page 64: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

6.0 9.0 12.0 15.0 18.03500

6500

9500

12500

Parking versus People12 Cities Nationwide

Peop

le*

Den

sit

y

Parking* per person* Based on daytime population

Page 65: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

6.0 9.0 12.0 15.0 18.03500

6500

9500

12500

Parking versus People12 Cities Nationwide

* Based on daytime population

Peop

le*

Den

sit

y

Parking* per person

Page 66: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

The Benefit of Walking, Biking, Transit

12 Cities Nationwide

Walking, Biking, Transit, At Home* Based on daytime population

10% 30% 50% 70%3500

6500

9500

12500

Peop

le*

Den

sit

y

Page 67: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Transportation Matters!

The goal of the modernist was to create cities that worked for cars.

We embraced this philosophy in Connecticut, and it failed abysmally

Page 68: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Some Places Developed Transportation Systems that Serve the

City, Not the Other Way Around

http://www.cycling-embassy.dk/2010/08/16/1803/

Page 69: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

Planning in an Auto-Oriented World

Page 70: Transportation myths and sacred cows restoring our cities

1. What are the strategic long term goals of the city?

2. Does a particular project advance or hinder these goals?

3. How does the project strengthen vital networks in the city (street, transit, neighborhood, regional networks?

4. Does the project help reduce the city’s environmental footprint?

5. Does the project reduce the long term economic burden for travelers in the city?

6. Does the project make the city more attractive and vital over the long run?

Streetcars and Freeway Removal