two spheres of activity in human life. public sphere

27
Two spheres of activity in human life

Upload: mitchell-howard

Post on 21-Jan-2016

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Page 2: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Page 3: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Page 4: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Page 5: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness

Page 6: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness, equality

Page 7: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness, equality

Work

Page 8: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness, equality

Work Commerce

Page 9: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness, equality

Work Commerce Government

Page 10: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness, equality

Work Commerce Government

Domestic sphere

Page 11: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness, equality

Work Commerce Government

Domestic sphere

Family, friends

Page 12: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness, equality

Work Commerce Government

Domestic sphere

Family, friends

Treatment depends on particular relationships

Page 13: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness, equality

Work Commerce Government

Domestic sphere

Family, friends

Treatment depends on particular relationships

Emotional ties

Page 14: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness, equality

Work Commerce Government

Domestic sphere

Family, friends

Treatment depends on particular relationships

Emotional ties

Historical fact:

Page 15: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness, equality

Work Commerce Government

Domestic sphere

Family, friends

Treatment depends on particular relationships

Emotional ties

Historical fact: In most of the world, for most of history, responsibility for activity in the two spheres has been segregated by sex.

Page 16: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Two spheres of activity in human life

Public sphere

Interaction with strangers

Governed by rules/laws

Fairness, equality

Work Commerce Government

Domestic sphere

Family, friends

Treatment depends on particular relationships

Emotional ties

Historical fact: In most of the world, for most of history, responsibility for activity in the two spheres has been segregated by sex.

People are socialized from birth to operate in the sphere of their sex.

Page 17: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Femininist Ethics

Page 18: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Femininist Ethics

What can moral theory tell us about the problems for women resulting from this historical segregation?

Page 19: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Femininist Ethics

What can moral theory tell us about the problems for women resulting from this historical segregation?

Unequal pay

Page 20: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Femininist Ethics

What can moral theory tell us about the problems for women resulting from this historical segregation?

Unequal pay

Unequal access to power

Page 21: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Femininist Ethics

What can moral theory tell us about the problems for women resulting from this historical segregation?

Unequal pay

Unequal access to power

Injustice in gendered family roles

Page 22: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Femininist Ethics

What can moral theory tell us about the problems for women resulting from this historical segregation?

Unequal pay

Unequal access to power

Injustice in gendered family roles

Feminine Ethics

Page 23: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Femininist Ethics

What can moral theory tell us about the problems for women resulting from this historical segregation?

Unequal pay

Unequal access to power

Injustice in gendered family roles

Feminine Ethics

What can the traditional experience of women tell us about the problems for moral theory resulting from this historical segregation?

Page 24: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Femininist Ethics

What can moral theory tell us about the problems for women resulting from this historical segregation?

Unequal pay

Unequal access to power

Injustice in gendered family roles

Feminine Ethics

What can the traditional experience of women tell us about the problems for moral theory resulting from this historical segregation?

Abstract universal principle vs. particular context

Page 25: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Femininist Ethics

What can moral theory tell us about the problems for women resulting from this historical segregation?

Unequal pay

Unequal access to power

Injustice in gendered family roles

Feminine Ethics

What can the traditional experience of women tell us about the problems for moral theory resulting from this historical segregation?

Abstract universal principle vs. particular context

Voluntary basis for obligations (contract) vs. finding ourselves involuntarily obligated (future generations)

Page 26: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

Femininist Ethics

What can moral theory tell us about the problems for women resulting from this historical segregation?

Unequal pay

Unequal access to power

Injustice in gendered family roles

Feminine Ethics

What can the traditional experience of women tell us about the problems for moral theory resulting from this historical segregation?

Abstract universal principle vs. particular context

Voluntary basis for obligations (contract) vs. finding ourselves involuntarily obligated (future generations)

Reason vs. emotion

Page 27: Two spheres of activity in human life. Public sphere

"Resolving conflicting responsibilities to dependent particular others" should be as important to moral theory as "rules for adjudicating competing rights and duties between generalized autonomous individuals".