UTP

Pc

I TMt(loto TdTcw Tla

USER GTool foProcedu

Preparecentralc

ntent:

The State WaMS4s in ordehe General PPermit) requow impact deheir local planof the post-co

The Permit prdetailing landsThis initial emcode to correwithin the first

This documenandscaping re

GUIDE &or Planures

d for: Ccoastlidi

ater Resourcr to efficiently

Permit for Waires permittee

evelopment (Lnning and penstruction req

rioritizes the ascaping requ

mphasis is estect gaps andt year of the e

nt is intendedequirements

& TEMPLnning &

Central Ci.org

es Control By regulate stoaste Discharges to adminisLID) runoff starmitting procequirements.

analysis of theirements andablished thro

d impedimenteffective date

d to assist pand consider

LATE: M& Deve

Coast L

Board (State Worm water disge Requiremester a post-coandards for reess to assess

e landscape cd revisions whough the requts impacting of the Permit

ermittees witations which

Municiplopmen

Low Imp

Water Board)scharges (Geents (WDRs)onstruction segulated projes any gaps or

code, which ishich should birement that peffective imp

t (Section E.1

th the reviewshould be im

pal Landnt Revie

pact Dev

W(206

) adopted a eneral Permit ) for Storm Wtorm water mects. Sectionimpediments

s described abe implementepermittees coplementation 2.J(ii)(a)).

w of those poplemented to

dscape Gew Sta

velopme

Wayne E. Car6) 658-2674, w

statewide geNo. CAS000

Water Discharmanagement n E.12.J direcs impacting ef

as that portioned to protect onduct an ana

of post-cons

ortions of muo protect envir

Gap Anaandards

ent Initia

Prep

rlson, AICP, wecarlson@

eneral permit 0004). Sectiorges from Smprogram tha

cts permitteesffective imple

n of the municenvironment

alysis of the lstruction req

nicipal codesronmental qua

alysis and

ative

pared by:

LEED AP ahbl.com

for Small on E.12 of mall MS4s t includes

s to review mentation

cipal code tal quality. andscape uirements

s detailing ality.

2

U WmveLIMrcTMo

T(mcsfoa U Tbrteee

2 | P a g e

Using Lands

Water resourcmanagement.vegetated areengineered laLID Gap Anampact DevelMRUAP proviresources crecomprehensivThe landscapMunicipal Lanordinances) re

1. Veget2. Open3. Rooft4. Open5. Street

The organizate.g., landsca

management chapter. Eacstandards. Weformal municiadvise conduc

Using the Mu

The Municipabelow. The firreference exishird column pexisting code existing codesexample resp

cape Areas f

ces engineer The conceas and nat

andscapes sualysis Tool waopment Initiaded assistan

eated for the ve approach pe portion of tndscape Gapelated to cons

tation Conser Space Manaop Runoff Space/Clustt and Parking

tion of the temape strips) an

rather than ach subsectioe have denotipal “landscapcting review o

unicipal Land

al Landscape rst column liststing code anprovides spac

language tos and standaonse:

for Stormwat

rs have comecepts and prtive soils to ch as bioreteas created fo

ative as part ce to municipMRUAP wasin reviewing the gap analyp Analysis Toserved and cr

rvation agement

er Design Reg Lot Standard

mplate is on and can be ua more narro

on includes qted with doubpe code.” Tof all the lands

dscape Gap A

Gap Analysists an LID bennd summarizece for permitteo better addrerds to improv

ter Managem

e to understarinciples of lo

mimic a sitention also suor the Centraof the Munic

palities relateds a municipamunicipal regysis templateool allows rereated landsc

equirements ds

a continuum fsed to evalu

ow evaluationquestions for ble asterisks (To most cost-scape-related

Analysis Too

s Tool is in thnchmark or obe existing stanees to identifyess the objecve implement

ment

nd the valueow impact dte’s pre-deve

upport LID anal Coast Regcipal Regulatod to code updl code gap agulations for e was updatedeview of the capes in the fo

from conserveuate the comn of a locally-

the permitte(**) specific g-effectively sud elements to

ol

he form of a bjective. The ndards withiny if an impedictive. This coation of the p

e that landscadevelopment elopment hy

nd water qualigional Water ory Update Adates to suppanalysis tempLID barriers d to support municipal re

ollowing five a

ed (e.g. openmprehensive u-adopted landee to considap analysis eupport a stor identify LID i

table. The tasecond colum

n adopted codment exists o

olumn would post-construc

ape areas ca(LID) emph

ydrology. Adity objectivesBoard and t

Assistance Pport LID impleplate that alloand opportunstatewide Pe

egulatory struareas:

n space) to creuse of landsdscape or wader when revelements thatrmwater manimplementatio

able has threemn provides sde that pertaior there is an include sugg

ction standard

an have for stasize conserdditionally, c. In 2011, a he Central Croject (MRUA

ementation. Oowed a systemnities for imprermit compliacture (e.g. c

eated landscacaping for st

ater-tolerant lviewing its ct most likely ragement proon impedimen

e columns asspace for pern to the objeopportunity t

gested amendds. The follow

tormwater rvation of reated or Municipal

Coast Low AP). The One of the matic and rovement. nce. The

codes and

ape areas tormwater andscape odes and

reside in a ogram, we nts.

s depicted rmittees to ctive. The o improve dments to wing is an

3

E

MTsc (

3 | P a g e

Example

PARKING LOT

(a) Is the usstormwalandscap

Municipal LaThe following standards wheconsider to im

1) Vegetatio (a) Do re

Code Reguthe zorequirand c Oppo Incorpnaturanativevegetplan s

(b) If fore Code Tree cfound

Benchmark

T RUNOFF se of bioretentater practices ped areas and

ndscape Gasection prov

ere applicablemprove codes

on Conserva

gulations req

Reference Lo

lations that aoning code, prements may clearing and g

rtunity to Imp

porate naturaal (or native) e or near natation retentiospecifications

ests or specim

Reference Lo

conservation in landscap

/ Objective

tion islands aallowed withid/or setbacks

p Analysis Tvides additione standards mand standard

tion

quire or encou

ocation

address vegetparticularly inbe specified rading regula

prove

al vegetation pvegetation anative specieson requireme, and mainten

men trees are

ocation

regulations me chapters o

nd other n

s?

Tool Subsectal context to

may reside. Pds.

urage the pres

tation retention the landsca

in planned uations.

preservation nd soils and is. Considerents, replantinance require

present at de

may reside in or standards

Code RSumma

Sta

21.05.050.ELandscapingprotected wplanting surfwalks, or custrips shall bbetween turareas. 21.10.230.BParking lotsdivided into connected sutilizing raisstrips and ra

tions the question

Potential oppo

servation of n

on at developape chapter onit developme

standards intinclude a planminimum treng requireme

ements.

evelopment si

the zoning cexclusively d

Reference andary of Existingandards

E.2.e g shall be

with raised rfaces, depresurbs. Mowing be provided rf and shrub

B.2.b.iv s should be

a series of smaller lots sed landscapeaised walkwa

ns and the arortunities are

natural vegeta

pment or redeor site designent standards

to code basent list which dee density, ments, soil am

ites, must som

ode. These sdedicated to

d g

Imped

ssed

e ys.

The exspecifimpedlandscstormw Need of parbe desstormw Need specifstormwlandsccurb clists, setc.).

reas within a also presente

ation at develo

evelopment sn requirements, subarea pla

d on land usdefines whichminimum can

mendment sta

me of the sta

standards, whtrees. Tree p

diment / OppoImprove

xisting standafy designs thadiments to usecape areas fowater manag

to allow the eking lot landssigned to accwater flows.

technical detfications to suwater managcape strip arecuts, bioretentsoil specificati

permittee’s ced that permi

opment sites?

sites are oftents. Additionalans, design s

e and intensih plants are cnopy cover, andards, man

nd be preserv

here they exispreservation

ortunity to

ards at are e the or ement.

elevations scaping to cept

ails and upport ement in

eas (e.g., tion plant ions,

codes and ttees may

?

n found in l retention standards,

ity. Define onsidered minimum

nagement

ved?

st, may be standards

4

(

4 | P a g e

may aregula Oppo Consiinfeastable credit

(c) If therstream Code Streaecolo Oppo Consishoul

2) Open Spa (a) Are m

Code Toolsthat dcovenpropedetail Oppo Wherrelevadescrpracticonsisreserv

(b) Are op Code Desigstand Oppo Consicluste

also be addreations.

rtunity to Imp

ider languagesible. Include in the code.

t systems and

re is a streamm buffer be m

Reference Lo

m buffer ordgical and biol

rtunity to Imp

ider stream bd be of suffici

ace Managem

mechanisms in

Reference Lo

to ensure thado not reside nant languageerty. Sometims.

rtunity to Imp

e standard laant developmribe the partyces (if any), stent with theving a public

pen space ar

Reference Lo

gn preferenceards and plan

rtunity to Imp

ider standardering and imp

essed in desig

prove

e emphasizintree retentioTree conserv

d canopy cove

m buffer ordinamaintained wit

ocation

inances are ogical resour

prove

buffer standaient width to p

ment

n place to ma

ocation

at open spacin the local

e that is routinmes this lang

prove

anguage doesment permits y responsiblethe frequenc

e conditions. easement tha

reas required

ocation

es and standnned unit dev

prove

s that requireervious surfac

gn standards

ng the benefn and replanvation standaerage, which

ance in the mth native vege

often found rces performa

rds that requprotect the ha

anage open sp

ce areas are mmunicipal conely attachedguage can b

s not exist, cwhere open

e for managicy of required

If managemeat will allow th

to be consoli

ards for openvelopment or o

e the consolidce minimizati

and perform

fits of retainiting standard

ards can be bmay be adjus

municipality, doetation?

in local sensance standard

uire the conseabitat and wat

pace in perpe

managed in pde. These m

d to developmbe found in a

consider collespace is inteng the open d actions, anent of the opehe permittee t

idated into lar

n space areaother perform

dation of openon.

mance criteria

ng trees or ds in the codebased on a vsted based on

oes the ordin

sitive areas sds.

ervation of nter quality val

etuity?

perpetuity mamechanisms ment permits aappendices t

ecting templatended to be space, the

nd the remeden space is tto remedy def

rger units?

as may be fomance design

n spaces into

found in plan

replacing tree language. Pvariety of criten developmen

ance specify

standards, flo

native vegetatlues of the str

y be found inmay include and recordedto drainage m

te language conserved. nature of apies if manag

to occur by prficiencies.

ound in localstandards.

larger units a

nned unit dev

ees where reProvide a treeria includingnt type.

that at least p

oodplain stan

tion. The buream.

n policies andstandard eas

d against the tmanuals and

that can be aThe languag

pplicable manement does rivate parties

ly-adopted si

as a way to e

velopment

etention is ee species g tree unit

part of the

ndards, or

uffer width

practices sement or title of the standard

applied to ge should nagement not occur , consider

ite design

encourage

5

(

5 | P a g e

(c) Does

Code Discremanaperforas oppurpo Oppo Consicondit

(d) Are al Code Allowzonesin opedefinit Oppo Consispace

(e) Can o Code The aas pacriteri Oppo Consiway omay i

3) Rooftop R (a) Can r

Code The omanustorm

a minimum p

Reference Lo

etionary landaged in a narmance subdpen space. oses, buffering

rtunity to Imp

ider provisiontion.

llowed uses in

Reference Lo

ed uses ands, the alloweden space aretions, and the

rtunity to Imp

ider adding le areas as lon

open space b

Reference Lo

ability for opeart of developa.

rtunity to Imp

ider options tof ensuring prnclude assem

Runoff

rooftop runoff

Reference Lo

opportunity toals, locally-a

mwater manag

percentage of

ocation

d use approvatural conditioivision standaSometimes, g between us

prove

ns in the code

n open space

ocation

activities wid uses would eas that may e review and a

prove

language thang as the prim

e managed b

ocation

n space to beper agreemen

prove

hat would allorotection of o

mbling templa

f be discharge

ocation

o discharge dopted regio

gement.

f open space

vals often reon. Site desards often stipthis open sp

ses, or conser

e to encourag

e in areas def

thin open spbe found in aoccur on a d

approval crite

at would allowmary use for th

by a third party

e managed bnts, or as par

ow the use ofopen space aates and draft

ed into yard ar

stormwater nal stormwat

have to be m

equire a minisign requirempulate that a pace is furtherved in a natu

ge and/or req

fined?

pace areas ara permitted ordevelopment eria for variou

w stormwatehe open spac

y using land t

by a third parrt of planned

f land trusts areas in a maagreements

reas?

into yard areter design ma

managed in a n

imum percenments and ppercentage oer defined asural condition.

uire the cons

re found in ar conditionally

site may alss discretiona

er managemece is not comp

trusts or cons

rty may be founit develop

and conservatanner that min

to support thi

eas may be anuals, and

natural condit

ntage of the planned unit of a developms to be main.

servation of o

a variety of ay permitted usso be found iry permits.

ent practices promised.

servation ease

und in local epment or othe

tion easemennimizes burdeis approach.

found in locmunicipal co

tion?

developmendevelopment

ment site be mtained for re

open space in

areas. In opse table. Allon landscape

to occur wi

ements?

environmentaer performan

nts by third paens on local

cal stormwatde chapters

nt site be t or other

maintained ecreational

n a natural

pen space owed uses

chapters,

thin open

al policies, ce design

arties as a staff. This

er design related to

6

(

6 | P a g e

Oppo Consiinto y

(b) Do curoofto Code This rthis isfront ypondi Oppo Consistorm

(c) Are vstorm Code VegetGreennonrepitche Oppo Consirooftoamennot al

4) Open Spa (a) Does

Code Opencontroperforcluste Oppo If youthat ebe tie

rtunity to Imp

ider code lanard areas.

urrent gradingops?

Reference Lo

regulation is vs the case, aryards or roofng of stormw

rtunity to Imp

ider amendinmwater in front

vegetated roomwater, etc. fo

Reference Lo

tated roofs an Building Coesidential meaes may preclu

rtunity to Imp

ider amendmop space to sndments to loclow vegetated

ace/Cluster D

your municip

Reference Lo

space and cols. Regulatiormance desiger design regu

rtunity to Imp

ur municipalityencourage clud to a variety

prove

guage that a

g or drainage

ocation

very specific are there reguftops? If so, ater.

prove

ng existing cot yards.

ofs allowed? or the use of v

ocation

are generally ode (Appendasures that mude vegetated

prove

ments to local satisfy passivcal design stad roof designs

Design Requ

pality have op

ocation

luster design ons are likelygn criteria, siulations within

prove

y does not hustered devel of land use a

llows stormw

requirements

and may not ulations within

that would b

odes to remo

Do criteria vegetated roo

described inices A4 and

municipalities d roof designs

building codve open spaandards that s.

uirements

en space/clus

regulations cy found in zoite design gun smaller defi

have open splopment patteapplication typ

water from non

s allow for tem

be addressedn the code the an impedim

ove barriers

exist to allofs?

n building codA5) identifiemay adopt.

s.

des to encource requiremerequire steep

ster design re

can reside in oning chapteuidelines, andned areas of

pace/cluster derns and conpes.

n-pollution ge

mporary pond

d directly in eat preclude t

ment to the u

that would p

ow designers

des or local es vegetated Local design

rage the use ents providedp roof pitches

egulations?

various locatrs covering pd subarea pla municipality

design regulaservation of o

enerating surf

ding of storm

existing code emporary pose of lawn a

preclude the

to receive c

design standroofs as vol

n standards t

of vegetatedd the space or specify ro

ions within a planned unit ans that addy.

ations, considopen space.

faces to be d

water on fron

or stormwatending of storreas for the t

temporary p

credit for lan

dards. The luntary residethat require s

d roofs by allaccessible.

oofing materia

municipality’sdevelopmen

dress open s

der adopting These stand

ischarged

nt yards or

er plans. If mwater in temporary

ponding of

ndscaping,

California ential and steep roof

owing the Consider

als that do

s land use t or other

space and

standards dards can

7

(

7 | P a g e

(b) Is landesig Code Goalsunit d Oppo Considesigessen

(c) Are thdesig Code The eplann Oppo Consiproce

(d) Are fl(setba Code Flexibthe zdimen Oppo Allow for clu

5) Street Sta (a) Do ad

strips Code The dpublic Oppo Consistripsapprostreet

nd conservation regulations

Reference Lo

s and objectivevelopment r

rtunity to Imp

ider elevatingn by encourantial design ob

he entitlemenn?

Reference Lo

entitlement pred unit develo

rtunity to Imp

ider adoptingedurally stringlexible site dacks, road wid

Reference Lo

ble site criteriaoning code. nsional standa

rtunity to Imp

for design fleuster designs

andards

dopted street?

Reference Lo

design of the c works engin

rtunity to Imp

ider adopting . Remove bar

oval of variant tree rhythm w

on or impervi?

ocation

ves of open sregulations, d

prove

g stormwater aging the consbjectives.

nt criteria for

ocation

rocess for opopment sectio

prove

g an entitlement or challen

design criteriadths, lot sized

ocation

a may be loca Flexible sit

ards.

prove

exibility withinthat conserve

t sections all

ocation

landscape steering standa

prove

street standarriers that woces or desigwhile managi

vious cover re

pace/cluster design guidelin

managemenservation of o

open space/

pen space/cluons of the mu

ment processnging than a na available fod)?

ated in a plante design crit

n the code. Ee open space

low for open

trips and medards and deta

ards to allow fuld require thn deviations.ng stormwate

eduction a ma

design regulanes, and/or su

t among the open space a

/cluster desig

uster developunicipal code.

s for open non-cluster deor developers

nned unit deveteria may als

xamples inclue.

treatment an

dians within sails or local la

for treatment he use of biore Consider aer.

ajor goal or o

ations may beubarea plans

site design gand reduction

gn more strin

pments is typ.

space/clusteevelopment.s that utilize

elopment or oso reside in

ude reduced

nd conveyan

street rights-oandscape cod

and conveyaetention withi

adopting desig

objective of t

e found in the discussed ab

goals for an o of imperviou

ngent than fo

pically found

er developme

open space/

other performdesign guid

setbacks, roa

nce of stormw

of-way is typices.

ance of stormwin public-rightgn templates

the open spa

e zoning codebove.

open space/cus surface cov

or standard su

in the zoning

ents that is

/cluster desig

mance design delines or in

ad widths, and

water within l

cally describe

water within lts-of-way to res that allow fo

ace/cluster

e, planned

cluster site verage as

ubdivision

g code or

no more

gn options

section of bulk and

d lot sizes

landscape

ed in local

andscape equire the or desired

8

(

8 | P a g e

(b) Can a

Code Street Oppo Consiterminof culstorm

6) Parking L (a) Is a m

Code The pwithin Oppo Wherspecifparkin

(b) Is thesetba Code The umunicmanaTheredo no Oppo Wherlandslands

(c) Does lands Code The daddrelocallyin loc

a landscape is

Reference Lo

t design requ

rtunity to Imp

ider adoptingnus of the cull-de-sacs will

mwater manag

Lot Runoff

minimum perc

Reference Lo

percentage ofn the landscap

rtunity to Imp

e missing, cofied the form ng area or bas

e use of biorecks?

Reference Lo

uses and actcipal code. Tagement featue may also beot include the

rtunity to Imp

e landscapingcape areas cape and/or s

your designcaped areas

Reference Lo

design of laness landscapiy-adopted pu

cally-adopted

sland be crea

ocation

irements are

prove

g street stanl-de-sac. In a result in red

gement functio

centage of a p

ocation

f a parking lope or parking

prove

onsider requirof islands ansed on the nu

tention island

ocation

tivities allowehe stormwate

ures and may e instances wuse of landsc

prove

g within parkfor stormwa

stormwater m

manual spefor bioretentio

ocation

dscape islanng or parkingblic works enpublic works

ated within a c

typically foun

ndards that paddition to theduced impervons.

parking lot req

ot that is reqand loading c

ing a percentd perimeter laumber of stall

ds and other s

ed within laner managemebe silent to th

where the storcape areas.

ing areas is aater managemmanagement c

ecify requiredon?

ds and perimg and loading

ngineering stas engineering

cul-de-sac?

nd in local pub

provide desige aesthetic quvious surface

quired to be la

quired to be lchapters of a

tage of parkinandscape. It s.

stormwater p

dscape areaent chapter mhe use of landrmwater mana

already requirment practicechapters withi

d designs tha

meter buffer ag. Design d

andards. Desg standards.

blic works eng

gns which inualities, integrcoverage an

andscaped?

landscaped ismunicipal co

ng lots to be lacan be desc

practices allow

as may residemay also spec

dscape areasagement stan

red, consideres. This min the municip

at would prec

areas is typicdetails for lansign details fo

These stand

gineering stan

ntegrate landrating landscand may have

s often foundode.

andscaped. ribed as a pe

wed within lan

e in the landify the natures for stormwandards specif

r language thmay involve pal code.

clude the abi

cally found inndscape islanor landscape dards may id

ndards.

dscape areasaping into thethe potentia

d in the desig

Landscaping ercentage of t

ndscaped are

dscape chapte of allowed stter managemfy design solu

at will allow tamendments

ility to use p

n zoning chands may also

areas may adentify barrier

s into the e terminus al to serve

gn criteria

can be in the overall

eas and/or

ter of the tormwater

ment. utions that

the use of s to local

parking lot

apters that reside in

also reside r curbs or

99 | P a g e

berm/functi Oppo Wherallow barrieoften

/mounding pron.

rtunity to Imp

e landscapinthe landscap

er curbs arounspecified for

references tha

prove

g within parkpe areas to nd parking lotparking lot isl

at would prec

king areas is receive stormt landscapinglands.

clude the abil

already requmwater. Thisg as well as th

ity of the land

uired, consids may requirhe mounding

dscape area

er adopting de modificatioor berming o

to serve a bio

design detailson to details of the landsca

oretention

s that will related to

ape that is

(1) VEG

(a)

(b)

(c)

(2) OPE

(a)

GETATION CONSER

Do regulations rnatural vegetatio

If forests or specsites, must some

If there is a streadoes the ordinanstream buffer be

EN SPACE MANAG

Are mechanismsperpetuity?

Objective

RVATION require or encouraon at developmen

cimen trees are pe of the stand be

am buffer ordinannce specify that ae maintained with

EMENT s in place to man

age the preservatnt sites?

present at developpreserved? **

nce in the municipat least part of the native vegetatio

age open space

Code

tion of

pment

pality, e n?

in

Per

e Reference and SStand

rmittee Name

Summary of Exisards

sting Impe

ediment / Opporttunity to Improve

(b)

(c)

(d)

(e)

(3) ROO

(a)

(b)

(c)

Are open space larger units?

Does a minimummanaged in a na

Are allowed use

Can open spacetrusts or conserv

OFTOP RUNOFF Can rooftop runo

Do current graditemporary pondirooftops?

Are vegetated rodesigners to recetc. for the use o

Objective

areas required to

m percentage of oatural condition?

es in open space

e be managed byvation easements

off be discharged

ng or drainage reing of stormwater

oofs allowed? Doeive credit for lanof vegetated roofs

o be consolidated

open space have

in areas defined?

a third party usins?

to yard areas?

equirements allowr on front yards o

o criteria exist to andscaping, stormws? **

Code

d into

to be

? **

ng land

w for r

allow water,

e Reference and SStand

Summary of Exisards

sting Impe

ediment / Opporttunity to Improve

(4) OPE

(a)

(b)

(c)

(d)

EN SPACE / CLUST

Does your muniregulations?

Is land conservamajor goal or obregulations?

Are the entitlemmore stringent th

Are flexible site that utilize open road widths, lot s

Objective

TER DESIGN REQU

cipality have ope

ation or impervioubjective of the ope

ent criteria for ophan for standard

design criteria avspace/cluster de

sized)?

IREMENTS n space/cluster d

us cover reductionen space/cluster d

pen space/cluster subdivision desig

vailable for develoesign options (set

Code

design

n a design

design gn?

opers backs,

e Reference and SStand

Summary of Exisards

sting Impe

ediment / Opporttunity to Improve

(5) STR

(a)

(b)

REET STANDARDS Do adopted streconveyance of s

Can a landscapesac?

Objective

eet sections allow stormwater within

e island be create

for open treatme landscape strips

ed within the cul-d

Code

ent and s?

de-

e Reference and SStand

Summary of Exisards

sting Impe

ediment / Opporttunity to Improve

(6) PAR

(a)

(b)

(c)

RKING LOT RUNOF

Is a minimum pelandscaped? **

Is the use of biopractices allowesetbacks? **

Does your designwould preclude tareas for bioreten

Objective

F ercentage of a pa

retention islands ed within landscap

n manual specify rthe ability to use pntion? **

arking lot required

and other stormwped areas and/or

required designs tarking lot landsca

Code

d to be

water

hat ped

e Reference and SStand

Summary of Exisards

sting Impe

ediment / Opporttunity to Improve