ucpb v. samuel
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
1/29
%#'$
&% &% !%#$
!0994307
;078:8
$!&$$ $& ,3/ %%
&$ #08543/0398
#4
!708039#$$%
,7507843&$%##%
#,3/
#$
!742:,90/
::89
$
#
%88,!09943147#0;04307947,7:3/07#:04190#:08414:79.
800894,33:904:79 41550,80.843(
/,90/,3:,7,3/ 98#084:943(
/,90/$05902-073#'4%0,88,0/4:7941550,80.843,3/
#084:943,11720/39:73900.843(
/,90/,7.,3/7/07(
/,90/,
41 90 #043, %7, 4:79 #% 7,3. 41 ,,9 9 3 ; ,80 4
/0.,73 ;4/ 90 3907089 7,90574;/0/ 3 9057428847 3490800.:90/- 90 708543/0398
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
2/29
$54:808 $,2:0 ,3//0990 0:84 854:808 0:84 3 1 ,;47 41 50994307&390/4.43:9
!,39078,3&!
%0574.0/:7,,3/1,.9:,,390.0/03984198.,80,70,81448
357&!7,390/90854:8080:84,!7428847490830:3/07,
70/97002039070- 90 ,9907.4:/,;,174290 147207 .70/941 :5 94, 2,2:2
,24:39 41 ! 43 50848 147 , 9072 03/3 43 57 %0 854:808 0:84
.43899:90/ 49079,3 90757428847 34908 , 70, 089,902479,0 4;07 5,7.0841 ,3/ 3
#4,89.4;070/-%7,381070791.,90841%904%,3/%,8,//943,
80.:79 147 90 4-,943 %070/9 7002039,8 8:-806:039 ,203/0/ 94 3.70,8090
,24:394190!742884749083094 ,2,2:241!4350848,3/940903/90
9072907041940-7:,7
%0854:8080:84,;,0/90280;084190.70/930:3/07901443!7428847
4908
! ,9041! ,9:79,90 24:39$0.:70/
57 ::89 ! , ::89 !
4;02-07 ,7. !
%09700574288473490807070300/80;07,9208357905,2039
4190573.5,,3/390708941 90 ,9907 9457428847 34908070/0-90/1742 90854:808
0:848,..4:399&!09,.4384/,90/4,3147!43,8,,3700,80/9490
854:8080:84:3/074305742884734909,/:0/,90410-7:,7
%4 .425090 ,;, 90280;08 41 90!43 .70/9 300903/0/ 94 902 -
&!90854:8080:8400.:90/9424705742884734908147,949,41!
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
3/29
! ,9041! ,9:79,90 24:39$0.:70/
0.02-07 0-7:,7 !
,3:,7 0-7:,7 !
40;07 90 854:808 0:84,00/ 9,9 90 ,24:398 .4;070/ - 9080 ,89 94 57428847
34908 070 30;07 700,80/ 47 .70/90/ 94 907 ,..4:39 ,3/ 9:8 .,20/ 9,9 90 573.5,
3/0-90/3088,843!43
3,3.,80&!,550/39070897,9084390/110703957428847349087,331742
94742940-7:,790854:8080:84070,-0945,90949,8:241
!
7420-7:,794:30&!.4393:0/94.,703907089,3/503,9
43904-,94384190854:8080:84,81448
! 24:39$0.:70/ 3907089 !03,9 %49,
! !
!
/,8
/,8
!
! /,8
/,8
!
! /,8
!
%0854:8080:8440;071,0/942,0,35,20394190147043,24:398
3$05902-07&!/02,3/0/9,990854:8080:845,907949,4-,943
41!5:8,99473081008-:990854:8080:841,0/94.42590709
3 0.02-07&! 1470.480/ 905745079082479,0/-90 854:8080:84 94
80.:70907.70/930.-9,9920,70,/-,4430/94!
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
4/29
30-7:,790854:8080:8410/,!0994314733:2039..4:393 ,3/
,2,08,,389&!990#%41,,99
3,7.90#%7:0/31,;474190854:8080:84/854834190.,80
,81448
!#$$ $# :/2039 8 070- 703/070/ /0.,73 90
39070897,90:80/-&!(;4/,3/901470.48:70,3/$071180791.,9041$,0 ;4/ &!( 8 070- 47/070/ 94 709:73 94 90 854:808 0:84( 90
5745079088:-0.941901470.48:70945,90854:8080:84(90,24:3941!-,41,99473081008 ,3/945,90.4898418:9%0854:808
0:84(,70070-47/070/945,&!(908:241!(
3, 90 #% /030/ &!84943 147 #0.438/07,943(
5742593
&!94,550,90#%0.8439904:7941550,8%04:7941550,8,11720/90
#%0.843949
##5702808.438/070/90/0.843/,90/,7.4190#043,%7,4:797,3.,,993;,8048
070-#8:-0.9949024/1.,9439,9/0103/,39,550,39&!8349,-0147,994730810084790.4898418:9
(
3$05902-07904:7941550,8/030/&!84943147#0.438/07,943
147,.412079&!9:810/9057080395099438:-299390144388:081474:7
7084:943
%# # % % # % !!$%%$#&$#'#$###%#
%$ % %#% #'%
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
5/29
!#'$%#$%#%#&!%!%%##$!%$
%# # % % # % !!$%%$#&$#'#$###%#
% !&%% % %# % #$!%$%$$ ## #$!%$ % ! !%%#
% &% ' $%%&$%#%!$$!
%# # % % # % !!$
%%$#&$#'#$###%#% $ % %# % & %
#$!%%#%$&%!#!#%$&% ##% !&%% #$!%$
%$$
'
%# # % % # % !!$%%$#&$#'#$###%#
% $ % %# % & !%%##'%%%#&%%
'
%# # % % # % !!$
%%$#&$#'#$###%%##%$$$ %$&$% #$!%$
#&%#&$!!(
',/941903907089#,908
%04:7941550,80/9,99025489434139070893901443574;84314:3/
39057428847349084190854:8080:848;4/,89039070897,908,3/90-,8089070147
070/0907230/840-50994307&!
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
6/29
# '& #' ,3/470 43 47 -01470 /:0 /,90 $!$
$& %% &$ ### 439 ,3/ 80;07,574280945,94&%&%!%#$#4747/07
,9 &! / ,,9 ;03:0 ,,9 9 !55308 90 8:2 41
**************!$$!*****!5530:7703.93907089907043,9907,903/.,9;041709,7,9047,8/0907230/-907,3.0,/
(
&!,8807989,9988,70;078-007747,3/.,289,909039070897,90,8349
3:207.,6:,3910/3901,.0419057428847349089,8343090088.,9047.,10/
,9909204100.:943907041,9907,903/.,9;04190709,7,90&!.43903/8
9,9 8,/574;8432:89-070,/9,34907895:,94339057428847349088:-0.9394
70;09039070897,90,810/
%0 3907089 7,90 8, -0 8:-0.9 94 70;0 ,3/ 2, -0 3.70,80/ 47/0.70,80/-90#.438/073,2434907890570;,313,3.,,3/
24309,7 .43/9438 47 90 7,90 41 3907089 ,3/ .,708 . 4907 -,38 4713,3.,3899:9438.,70474110794.,7014782,7,..4224/,9438,3/47
90708:9357419,-99490#,1907/:0.438/07,94341,/0,38990###(
39870,7/&!,;0789,99080,70;,/7010703.07,908,394,570;,37,90
4757207,90,40/-984:793!449,3;4:7941550,8(:79072470&!
,7:089,90;03190574;84,8/0907230/-90-7,3.0,/8.438/070/;4/8:.,
/0.,7,9434:/ 349 5841,.94 703/07 90 .4330.93 .,:80 3/.,9;041709, 7,90
;4/3;04190805,7,-9.,:80419070/97002039.70,/8
$0.943 $05,7,-9 ,:80 1 ,3 430 47 2470 41 90 574;8438
.439,30/398#%47/4.:2039800.:90/3.4330.94307098, -0 /0.,70/ 3;,/ 0, 47 :303147.0,-0 3 ,3 70850.9 90 ;,/9
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
7/29
0,9,3/03147.0,-94190702,33574;8438070418,3493,3,-0,110.90/4725,70/
(
..47/394&!90254894341906:089430/39070897,908//3493173043
90 573.50 412:9:,941 .4397,.98 -0.,:80 90 854:8080:84,/ 90 -079 94 .4480090747349947030907.70/930,9903039070897,908500/-50994307
(&!
,84.,289,9,88:239070,8,3/010.93902:9:,94190.4397,.9,9909204198
3.059438:./010.9,8.:70/-908:-806:039.43/:.94190854:8080:843,;,3
90280;084190.70/930174257940-7:,794:9,73,357490899
70850.9 94 90 3907089 7,908 25480/ - &! ..47/3 94&! 90701470 90 854:808
0:84,7030894550(
0,7009904:7941550,8,3/13/342079390.43903943841&!
79.04190;4/0574;/08
79%0.4397,.92:89-3/-49.4397,.935,790898;,/947
.425,3.0.,3349-001994904143041902
0,550/98574;843 3!5530,943,,3;4:7941550,8(070
00/
347/079,94-,9438,7831742.4397,.982,,;090147.041,
-09003 90 5,7908 90702:89 -02:9:,9 -09003 90 5,7908 -,80/43907088039,06:,9.4397,.9.439,33 ,.43/943. 2,08 98 1:12039
/0503/0390.:8;0:54390:3.439740/41430419 0.4397,.935,79088;4/,7.,;8#9,0,7/,3.$#03.00;03,88:239,9
90!2434,3,7002039-0900390!,3/9057;,90708543/039,;090!,.0380,94:31,.99070,83430943.70,809039070897,90,9
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
8/29
/:7390907241904,39,9.03804:/ ,;0-0033:,3/;4/147-03;4,9;04190573.50412:9:,9088039,3.4397,.9894:/,;0
3;0890/904,3,7002039990.,7,.90741,.4397,.941,/0843070905,7908 /4 349 -,7,3 43 06:, 14493 90 0,07 5,798 90 /0-947
5,79.5,943-0370/:.0/9490,9073,9;0949,09470,;09":,;8,
&343#4.38:7,3.04!$:.,.4397,.98,;079,-097,514790 0,07 5,79 42 90 .4:798 41 :89.0 2:89 57490.9 ,,389 ,-:80 ,3/2548943
%0574;84389,939,99039070898,-0,9907,903/.,9;041709,7,9047
,8/0907230/-907,3.0,/83/00//0503/03984043904150994307&!
&3/078:.574;84350994307&!,894.4.0843,9 9039070897,908,-0,
7,903/.,9;04190709,7,9047,7,90,8/0907230/-907,3.0,/8&!
8;0398.4.090 7,9084:/-0.,9047.,/090723,-03-49 .4.081090741
908094.4.0857080398 ,3455479:39147&!941 907,90,990-,3.,30,8
.44808:.,3459439:82,3900397039070897,90574;843;4,9;04190573.5041
2:9:,941.4397,.98
49:89430-:97,907-49419080.4.08,70/0503/039840439041&!
0,7,7,90,8/0907230/-907,3.0,/;0890,9907:31099070//8.7094343,9
90 7,902,-0%07,3.0,/2,.4480,37,9004780/08708870,7/890 7,90
3/.,9;04190709,7,90908,20.,3349-0.438/070/,8;,/147-03,394,
570;,37,904757207,90,40/-984:793!449,3%039070897,903!449,3
70,/8
%0,7/4/07 ,7008 945, 3907089507 ,33:2 ,95:89057207,9041
$0.:79,3,3/%7:89425,3(
398574;8433!449,390708,10/2,734;07907010703.07,90%:8905,7908
.,3 0,8 /0907230 90 3907089 7,90 - ,553 8250 ,79209.3 90 4907 ,3/ 90
574;843 3 90 .,80,9 -,7/408349850.1,32,73,-4;047-0490709,7,90
&!.,350903907089,9,3507.039,0,-4;047-0490709,7,90,,3;39
:31099070//8.709433/09072339039070897,90
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
9/29
%0 895:,943 3 9057428847 34908 8:-0.93 90 3907089 7,9094 70;0/408349
703/07902548943-&!4139070897,90843904-,94384190854:8080:84;,/
..47/3948,/895:,943
%0 3907089 7,90 8, -0 8:-0.9 94 70;0 ,3/ 2, -0 3.70,80/ 47
/0.70,80/-90#.438/073,2434907890570;,313,3.,,3/24309,7 .43/9438 47 90 7,90 41 3907089 ,3/ .,708 . 4907 -,38 47
13,3.,3899:9438.,70474110794.,7014782,7,..4224/,9438,3/4790708:9357419,-99490#,1907/:0.438/07,94341,/0,38
990###(
984:/-054390/4:99,9 90,:94799470;09039070897,90,8;03&!,430,8
90 03/074704;07&!2, ,55 90 .438/07,9438 03:207,90/ 3 98574;843 ,8 9
808847/0/390,-4;0574;843&!2,;0,82:.09,89/08708940,.
41901443.438/07,943890570;,313,3.,,3/24309,7.43/943907,90
413907089,3/.,708.4907-,384713,3.,3899:9438.,70474110794.,70147
82,7,..4224/,9438,3/4790708:9357419,-99490#&!,1907/:0
.438/07,94341,/0,38990###90854:8080:84,3,8390.,80
419039070897,90574;843907083410/2,73,-4;047-049080.438/07,9438
3;0419014704390$05,7,-9,:80.,33498,;0090741909445943841
&! ,89490 3907089 94 -0 25480/,8-49 459438 ;4,9090 573.50 41 2:9:,9 41
.4397,.98
&!0801,0/94.43;3.0:89,990854:8080:8407030894550
894550 .,3349 -0570/.,90/ 43 ,3 0, ,.9 8 -09003 90 5,7908 94 , .4397,.9
;,/9.,3349-0;03949-0894550198574-90/-,478,,3895:-.54.(
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
10/29
%0 3907089 7,90 574;8438 3 90 .,80 ,9 -,7 ,70 0, 349 43 -0.,:80 41 90
574;8438 41 90;4/0 43 2:9:,9 41 .4397,.98 -:9 ,84 ,8 8, -0 /8.:880/ ,907
-0.,:80 90 ;4,90 90 %7:9 3 03/3 .9 49 /8.483 90 97:0 13,3.0 .,708 3
.4330.9439 900903843841.70/9 8 1:79072470,147241/0.05943.0.,3349
.4:3903,3.098,,3899054.4190$9,90,889,90/390%7:9303/3.9
$0.0.,7,94341!4.98070-/0.,70/94-09054.4190
$9,909457490.998.90381742, ,.41,,703088419097:0.48941.70/99490:807- ,88:73,1:/8.48:70418:..4899,;041570;039390
:3314720/:8041.70/99490/097203941903,943,0.4342(
4704;07090854:8080:843/00/,700/94703090.70/9309041103/3
574;8438,70 14:3/ 3 90 5742884734908 90280;08 349 3 90 .70/9 30 3 13 90
39070897,908390574288473490894 .4;0790 70300/.70/9 30&!8970807;0/94
9801 90 8,20 94 459438 , 7,90 3/.,9;0 41 90 709, 7,90 47 , 7,90 ,8
/0907230/-907,3.0,/
77473425:9,943
&!,8807989,90-4990#%,3/904:7941550,8;4/0/9039070897,908
25480/-&!-49 1,0/943.:/03907.425:9,94341904:989,3/34-,94341
90854:8080:84900,7,9041390708941507 ,33:2:7907247090503,9.,708
070,84/0090/390/0.84384190#%,3/904:7941550,8$0.94379.0
433907089,3/4907,3,70841908:-0.970/97002039574;/08
$0.943 !03,9,708 3 ,//943 94 90 3907089574;/0/ 147 3$0.9434198#%,3573.5,4-,9434190%070:3/07
.83495,/03/:08, -0 8:-0.994 ,503,9.,7041430507.0394190,24:39418:.4-,9435072439.425:90/1742/:0/,90:39
90 4-,943 8 5,/ 3 1: 1 90 -,3 ,..007,908 90 8. 5,2039 41,;,20398070:3/075:78:,3994#%'0704190503,9.,708,
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
11/29
-0:80/4390949,573.5,,24:394:989,3/3,3/:35,/.425:90/174290/,9041,..007,943:39904-,94385,/31:
(
!,7,7,541905742884734908,8489,908
3.,80413435,20394198!7428847490490,92,9:790
439,3/80;07, ,700 94 5,,3 ,//943, 8:2 06:;,039 94 90391;0507.039 41 90 949, /:0 43 90 490 ,8 ,9947308 100 ,8/0 1742 90
0503808,3/.489841.40.9430907,.9:,3.:770/47349 ,3/,503,9.,7041430507.03950724394390949,,24:39/:0,3/:35,/1742
/,9041/01,:9:391:5,/(
!09943071:7907.,289,99808003990/94,994730810085:78:,3994$0.943
419070/970020399:8
1908,706:7090807;.0841.4:3801479003147.020394198
798 :3/07 98 #% 90 4908 90 .4,907,8 ,3/ 4907 70,90//4.:20398 90 8, -0 03990/ 94 70.4;07,9947308 1008 06:;,03994
3490889,390391;0507.0394190949,,24:398/:0,3/4:989,3/30.:8;041.4898,3/49070503808(
34907 ,00/ .425:9,943, 07747 54390/ 4:9 - &! 8 90 30,943 41 90
4254:3/33907089,700/:543-905,7908:3/07$0.943419070/97002039
$0.9434254:3/3390708939070893495,/03/:08,14725,794190573.5,,3/8,-08:-0.994908,2039070897,90,80703895:,90/
(
,3/5,7,7,541908:-0.95742884734908
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
12/29
39070893495,/03/:08,-0,//0/94,3/-0.4205,794190573.5,,3/8,080-0,73907089,9908,207,90
(
&!,89,;0789,990,55.,9434190854:8080:8485,20398390/85:90/
.425:9,943/4083497010.9905,7908,7002039%0#%/0/:.90/905,20392,/0-90
854:808 0:84 ,24:393 94 ! 1742 90 573.5, 41 ! %8 ,8
,00/3.4388903999070/97002039,80,8990,700203941905,7908,8
9490 1,.984190 .,8035,7,7,54190 854:8080:848,31089,943,3/494343
!745480/$95:,94341,.98,3/88:08;8;8&!8,31089,943905,7908,700/9,9
90,24:3941!,8,550/9490 3907089,3/3499490573.5,3,..47/9
$0.94379.0 419070/9 7002039437/07 41 9055.,943 41 !,20398
.574;/08
$0.943 55.,943 41 !,2039 !,20398 2,/0 - 90 %
8,-0,550/3,..47/,3.0990144347/074157010703.0
..4:39870.0;,-0,3/49074:94154.090503808 743903/0073,94300994730800,3/4907050380841
.40.943 !03,9.,708 !,89/:03907089 !73.5,,2479,943!,20393,770,78 /;,3.03907089 :989,3/3-,,3.0,3/ 49074-,943841%94901,3(
%:8,..47/394&!903907089.,708503,9.,708,3/,99473081008,/
-0030774304:80.:/0/-90#%,3/904:7941550,8174290.425:9,9434190
949,,24:39/:0,3//02,3/,-01742854:8080:84
%0854:8080:848/010380,894,908088:0889,990/02,3/2,/0-&!8
147,.438/07,--07,24:39,3/9070147090/02,3/84:/-0.438/070/;4/%070
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
13/29
-0334;,//02,3/,..47/39490854:8080:8490704:/-034/01,:9,3/90701470
9039070898,3/503,9084:/349.42203.0947:389,80802574507941470.480
90 2479,0/ 574507908 47 10 , .,80 ,,389 90 854:808 0:84,9947308 1008070 349
,77,390/
0,7009&!43988.47001,:9 .42203.08:543 :/.,47097,:/.,
/02,3/(%00.088,24:3938:.,/02,3//4083493:190/02,3/9801.8
;,/970850.99490574507,24:39.4397,77:34:/5:9.42207.,97,38,.94383
/8,77, ,8 ;,/9 41 /02,3/8 4:/ -0 /0503/039 43 90 0,.93088 41 90 .425:9,9438
907041.,7094441903.4390890/
%070-03,;,//02,3/43905,7941&!,-090.088;090854:8080:84
,70.438/070/3/01,:9970850.99490574507,24:39,3/907014709039070898,3/90
503,908-0,3947:3,99,95439
8 70,7/8 90 ,,7/ 41 0, 3907089 3 1,;47 41 50994307 90 #% ,.9:,
70.430/9,98,/0,390708984:/-025480/9:8%070-0334;,/895:,943,8
943907089900,7,904139070898,-0.,70/(
9800289,9 90#% 3,/;079039
4;07440/983433.:843398.425:9,943
%0854:8080:84,/0;03473,,80/14790#%9425480980,7,9041
39070893-4990-4/,3/9057,074198509943990#%
$3.090574;84343901341907,90413907089-908404190708543/039,383:,3/;4/43900,7,90413907089.8
507,33:2.,3-00,.,70/,3/25480/-90 -,3.4:/,24:399443,-4:9!83.0:594::89
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
14/29
##3;0419014704350994307857,147:/20394747/07
,410
,250147905:-.44/,,38990,389,3:31,7,/;,39,041900,075,7994907.4397,.9/0.,73900,7,9041507,33:2,8902548,-07,90413907089:5940-7:,743904,341
243(
9080849,990854:8080:84,/,.340/0/-0147090#%9074-,943945,
,0,3907089439074,380390#%1,0/943.:/0900,3907089398
.425:9,943 40;07 90 854:808 0:84 2070 /0103/0/ 3 90 ,550,90 .4:798 98 343
3.:843,8908,20,8-0301.,94902080040;078:11.039-,889425480,
0, 3907089 3 1,;47 4150994307 3 90 .,80,9 -,7 ,8,90 ,;0;4/0/ 8 2070 90
895:,90/7,90413907089,3/34990895:,9439,9904,38,0,733907089
02:89080:54/90.4397,.9895:,943574;/390.4254:3/3413907089
%0 574;8438 3 90 70/9 7002039 ,3/ 3 90 57428847 34908 574;/3 147 90
.4254:3/3413907089070309073:10/-90#%47904:7941550,8347,88,0/
- 90 854:808 0:84 3 907 509943 9 90 #% %0 .4254:3/3 41 39070898 ,8
1:79072470 -003 /0.,70/ - 98 4:79 94 -0 0, 0 ,;0 0/ 3 %,3 ; 4:79 41
550,8(9,9
94:9 570:/.0 94 90 574;8438 41 79.0 3907089 /:0 ,3/:35,/ 8, 349 0,73 3907089 40;07 90 .4397,.93 5,7908 2, -
895:,943.,59,0903907089/:0,3/:35,/.,8,//0/573.5,
8,0,73303907089
870,7/890254894341503,90840;07,94:0,70080:54/390
2548943 907041 3 90 .4397,.9 0 13/ 90 7,90 36:94:8 0 3 90 .,80 41 7488
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
15/29
0.088;03907089890503,9895:,90/390.4397,.92,,84-070/:.0/-90.4:798198
36:94:847:3.438.43,-0(
013/90503,925480/-&!7,3317429494-036:94:8
.438/073901,.99,998503,98,70,/4;07,3/,-4;090.4254:3/0/3907089080
25480/ 3 90 .4397,.91 , 3907089 3 9801,8 -003 /0.,70/ :3.438.43,-0 - 98
4:79(,92470,94503,94;07,3/,-4;0905,203941.4254:3/0/
3907089&!98012:89,;070,0/98,89,;0:8,8,250.425:9,9434190854:808
0:8484-,9431-49903907089,3/90503,9.,70,7070/:.0/94
870,7/890,9947308100890854:8080:84.,3,.9:,-0,-090701470;031
9070,/-00334/02,3/3, .,803 .4:79 8 90 :/.,/02,3/7010770/ 94 379.0
(
4190;4/0.4:/5:9904-473/0,
%0#%40;07,840/&!,-0147,99473081008398.,80,890854:808
0:84070 147.0/ 94 9,9090 88:0 43 90 0,9 41 90 3907089 7,90574;843 41 90
57428847 34908 %0 ,,7/ 41 ,9947308 1008 9 2:89 -0 70.,0/ 1,8 :3/07 90 84:3/
/8.709434190.4:79(
$3.0-495,7908070147.0/949,909457490.990770850.9;0
798 ,3/ -49 ,70 03990/ 94 90 ,,7/41 ,9947308 1008 1742 904907 57,.9., 70,8438
/.9,90 9,9 0 809 411 47 .425038,90 -49 5,7908 ,-908 147 ,9947308 1008 %0701470
3890,/41,,7/3,9947308100831,;47415099430708,2070,117290/0094341
90,,7/41,994730810089490854:8080:84
38:204/9,9854:8080:8484:/89-00/,-0147,.4254:3/0/0,
390708941507,33:2,3/,503,9.,7041507,33:20,844/9,93890,/41
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
16/29
,,7/3,9947308100831,;47415099430708,2070,117290/009434190,,7/
41,994730810089490854:8080:84
33:20394190470.48:70$,0
!74507908 41 854:808 0:84 ,/ -003 1470.480/ 9908 94 . ,/ ,70,/ -003
.4384/,90/43 0-7:,7 ,3/,7.390 3,2041&! ,8 90 854:808
0:841,0/94007.80907794170/025943.0570/43,7.%0#%
40;07,33:0/901470.48:70412479,0-,80/43,3,00/3.4770.9.425:9,9434190
854:8080:8483/0-90/3088
&!,0089,93430419074:3/814790,33:203941,1470.48:708,0,705708039
390.,80,9-,7:7907247090,33:203941901470.48:70574.00/38,3/90.0791.,908
418,007024490/-908:-806:03988:,3.04130.0791.,908419903903,20418,/
-,3&!.,289,9 90854:8080:848,.943147,33:2039411470.48:70.43899:908,
.4,907,,99,.4398.0791.,90841990,3,.95748.7-0/-$0.94341!708/039,0.700
4490780343,890!745079#0897,9430.700.574;/08
$0.9430791.,903498:-0.9 94.4,907,,99,..0791.,9041
990 8, 349 -0 8:-0.9 94 .4,907, ,99,. 9 .,3349 -0 ,9070/ 24/10/ 47.,3.00/0.0593,/70.9574.00/33,..47/,3.09,
%0854:8080:847094799,983.090,/907994701:805,203941,30.088;0
/02,3/43907 ,..4:39 90 .,3349 -0 8,/94 -0 3/01,:9 147 701:83 945, 90 8,20
43806:039 ,..47/3 94 90 854:808 0:84 90 03147.02039 41 8:. 0, ,3/
4;07.,70//02,3/974:1470.48:70412479,084:/-0;4/0/
0,7009&!,3/,117290 ;,/941901470.48:70574.00/38$3.00
,70,/14:3/9,9,;,//02,3/,82,/0-&!:54390854:8080:84/08590-03
0.088;090854:8080:84,70.438/070/3/01,:9970850.99490574507,24:3941907
4-,943 94 &! ,3/ 9:8 90 5745079 902479,0/ 94 80.:70 8:. ,24:398 2, -0
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
17/29
1470.480/43806:039574.00/841901470.48:708,084:/-0,550/9490090394190
,24:39894.&!8791:03990/
8 ,7:0/ - &! 3430 41 90 74:3/8 147 90 ,33:2039 41 , 1470.48:70 8,0 ,70
5708039 3 98 .,80 %0 74:3/8 147 90 574507 ,33:2039 41 90 1470.48:70 8,0 ,70 90
1443 9,9 9070 ,8 17 ,:/ .4:843 ,../039 2:9:, 289,0 -70,. 41 97:89 47
28.43/:.9-905:7.,8079,9908,0,/349-0031,7,3/70:,7.43/:.90/47
9,99057.0,83,/06:,90,3/903,/06:,.,88470,9,89484.90.438.03.04190
.4:79(
,-9147'4,94341%7:9303/3.9
%0#%,11720/-904:7941550,825480/,13041!147&!8
,00/;4,94341#05:-..94490780343,890%7:9303/3.9
&! .,0308 98 2548943 43 90 ,7:2039 9,9 $0.943 ,41 90 %7:9 3
03/3.9.2,3/,908901341,3,.9439470.4;078:.503,92:89-02,/0:3/07
901443.7.:289,3.08
$0.943,3.70/94743.4330.9439,3.70/997,38,.943
1,8 94 /8.480 94 ,3507843,3 31472,943 3 ;4,943 41 98 .9 47,370:,94388:0/9070:3/078,-0,-0948:.507843390,24:3941!
473 ,3,24:3906:,949.09013,3.0.,70706:70/-8:. .70/947 3.4330.94398:. 97,38,.943.0;07870,9070.0599,98:. ,-9
8, 349 0.00/ ! 43 ,3 .70/9 97,38,.943 .943 94 70.4;07 8:.503,92,-0-74:9-8:.507843934300,7174290/,904190
4..:7703.0 41 90 ;4,943 3 ,3 .4:79 41 .42509039 :78/.943 25,884:78
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
18/29
..47/3 94&!904:79 41 550,8 0;03 89,90/9,9 ,(/2990/ 90 473,
.425,39//34905.9,00,;4,9434190%7:9 3 03/3.9,3/ 34,.94394
1472,,/2990,203/0/509943.057088,008;4,9434190%7:9303/3
.9(,82,/00907-708543/0398(854:8080:84,3/90407.4:79(
&!1:7907.,289,990,.9439470.4;0790503,914790;4,9434190%7:9
3 03/3 .9 ,/-003 -,770/ - 90 4300,7 5708.759;0 5074/ 574;/0/ 147 3 90.9
&!,8807989,95079070.47/84190.,8090,908941908:-0.95742884734908,/-003
00.:90/43,3:,7-:990473,5099434190854:8080:84,810/-0147090
#%430-7:,7 .,8,1907 90 057,943 41 905074/ 94 10 90 8,2043
,3:,7
3902,990741,0,9434190;4,9434190%7:9 3 03/3.9904:7941
550,87:0/
/2990/ 90473,.425,39//34905.9,00,;4,9434190%7:9303/3.9,3/34,.943941472,,/2990,203/0/509943
,82,/00907-708543/0398(854:808 0:84,3/90 407 .4:79 3 8:.97,38,.9438 90 /0-947 ,3/ 90 03/3 3899:9438 /4 349 /0, 43 ,3 06:,
14493,3/98,,83903/0/9457490.9905:-.1742//0347:3/8.480/
.,708439074,34-,9438706:73,1:/8.48:70907041-9003/070 13/ 9,9 98 3173020392,-0 310770/47 250/ 1742,0,9438 9,903 708543/0398( 854:808 0:8400.:90/ 90 57428847 34908 90 3907089
7,90 .,70,-0 907043 070 019 -,3 %:8 50994307( &! 1 ,0/ 94/8.,7098/:994/8.48031:94708543/0398($54:8080:8490.,708
,55.,-0439074,38(
0,7009904:7941550,8%0,0,9438390.425,392:.24709,3
90990907041,70.4397439079,39,989,90/-904:7941550,8013/9,990
,0,94341;4,9434190%7:9303/3.9.,3,84-0310770/1742908,20,0,943
390.425,390/8.:880/0,707
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
19/29
- 3 :3,907, 25483 ,3 3.70,80/ 3907089 7,908 8. 708543/039
-,3 ,8 700/ 43 90 574;843 41 907 57428847 3490 7,393 708543/039-,390540794:3,907,19039070897,908.7,90,8349/0907230/
390574288473490-:9,8019840949041907,3.0,/4190
708543/039,3(
%0,0,9439,9 9057428847 349087,39&!90540794:3,907, 1 90
39070897,908.079,3,8420,389,9905742884734908/4349.439,3,.0,789,9020393
793 41 90 13,3.0 .,70 0570880/ 3 90728 41 50848 ,3/ .039,;48 ,3/ 90
507.039,09,9 90 13,3.0 .,70 -0,789490 ,24:39 94-0 13,3.0/0570880/ ,8 , 8250
,33:,7,9043904:989,3/3:35,/-,,3.041904-,943(
:7907247090854:808
0:84857,071478:.490770018:89,3/06:9,-0390570280884:/-0/0020/943.:/090.;503,9574;/0/1473$0.943,4190%7:9303/3.9
&!8.439039439,998,.9439470.4;0790503,914790;4,9434190%7:93
03/3.9,8,70,/5708.7-0/808094:92079%0503,914790;4,9434190
,.9 8 ! 47 ,3 ,24:39 06:, 94 9.0 90 13,3.0 .,70 706:70/ - 8:. .70/947 3
.4330.94398:.97,38,.943.0;07870,9070.0599,98:.,-98,3490.00/
!43,3.70/997,38,.943(898503,9/0503/8439013,3.0.,70706:70/
4190-477407 90-4774078.,:8041,.9434:/43,..7:0038:.13,3.0.,708
706:70/ 3 90 .,80 ,9 -,7 90 /,90 41 90 /02,3/ 147 5,2039 41 90 13,3.0 .,70 8
$05902-070901470.48:70,82,/0430.02-07%0134190.,80
430-7:,789070147093904300,75708.759;05074/
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
20/29
&! ,7:08 9,9 , ;4,943 41 90%7:9 3 03/3.9 -03 , .723, 4110380
.,3349 -0 310770/ 347 250/ 1742 90 ,0,9438 2,/0 3 90 .425,39(
!0793039
574;84384190.970,/
$0. , 3 .70/9474 3 .4330.9439 ,3 .70/9 97,38,.9431,8 94 /8.480 94 ,3507843,3 31472,943 3 ;4,943 41 98 .9 47,3
70:,94388:0/9070:3/078,-0,-0948:.507843390,24:3941!473 ,3,24:3906:,949.09013,3.0.,70706:70/-8:. .70/947 3
.4330.943 9 8:. 97,38,.943 .0;07 8 90 70,907 0.059 9,9 8:.,-98,3490.00/!43,3.70/997,38,.943.9439470.4;078:.
503,9 2, -0 -74:9 - 8:. 507843 93 430 0,7 1742 90 /,90 41 904..:7703.04190;4,9433,3.4:7941.42509039:78/.9433,3,.943
:3/07988:-80.9433.,3507843803990/94,70.4;0790.70/9478,-0,-014770,843,-0,99473081008,3/.4:79.4898,8/0907230/-90
.4:79
. 350784341:;4,908,3574;8434198.947,370:,94388:0/9070:3/078,-0130/-3490889,3!
4724709,3!4725784320391473490889,32439834724709,34300,747-49
8.,3-00,30/1742$0.943,,3/.4190%7:9303/3.990;4,94341908,/
.9;0878094-49.723,,3/.;,-908$0.943..438/078,.723,411038090
1:;4,9434190.92548390503,9907014741130257843203947-49 $0.943
,43904907,3/.0,7574;/08 147,.;.,:8041,.9431471,:70 94/8.480,3
31472,943 41 90 706:70/ 31472,943 94 ,3 507843 3 ;4,943 41 90 .9 %0 503,9
90701478,3,24:3941!473,3,24:3906:,949.09013,3.0.,70706:70/-90
.70/9473.4330.94398:.97,38,.943.0;07870,9070.0599,990,-98,
349 0.00/ ! 43 ,3 .70/9 97,38,.943 %0 ,.943 94 70.4;07 8:. 503,9 2, -0
3899:90/-90,70;0/57;,90507843805,7,90,3/3/0503/039 174290.723,.,80
147908,204110380
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
21/29
390.,80,9-,79070147090.;,.9439470.4;0790503,9:3/07$0.943,41
90%7:9303/3.9,/-0034393899:90/990,.94394/0.,7090390708983
90 57428847 34908 ;4/,3/ 90 ,.943 94 /0.,70 90 1470.48:70 ;4/ %8 43/07 8
,40/:3/07#:0$0.9434190#:08414:79.574;/08
$43/0741.,:80841,.9435,792,343050,/3,88079
390,9073,9;047490780,82,3.,:80841,.943,802,,;0,,389,34554835,798:-0.994901443.43/9438
, %05,7943390.,:80841,.9438,.4259 907:084343/07415,7908
- %0 43/07 8, 349 3.:/0 850., .; ,.9438 47 ,.94384;0730/-850.,7:08
. 07090.,:80841,.943,70-09003908,205,7908-:95079,394/1107039 ;03:0847 :78/.9438 90 43/072,-0,40/ 3 90#043,
%7,4:79574;/0/4304190 .,:80841,.943 1,89390 :78/.943418,/.4:79,3/90;03:00890703,3/
/ 070 90 .,28 3 , 90 .,:808 41 ,.943 ,70 573.5, 14770.4;0741243090,70,90,24:39.,20/8,-090908941:78/.943
3,99,.390#%8/85489434390;4,9434190%7:9303/3.983.090
8,20,8349,00/390.425,39&!8,.9:, ,880793,;4,94341/:0574.088
3/00//:0574.0882,3/,9089,9,/0103/,3984:/-08:11.039 ,55780/41902,990780
47804:/-0/0103/328014707801,,38940;07390:57097,-701
10/ -90854:8080:84-0147090#% 90.,2 147.;8,3.9438 147 ;4,9434190
%7:9303/3.9,8057088,00/9:8
4704;0783.017429089,79708543/039-,3;4,90/90%7:9303/3.9
334931472390-4774073793-014709000.:9434190!74288474908 41 90 3907089 7,90 0570880/ ,8 , 507.039,0 41 90 949, 4,3 90
708543/039-,33890,/8,-0945,509943078/4:-090,24:3990-,38.,73509943078-,418,3.94314798;4,943
(
3908,2057097,-70190854:8080:84,840570887,80/90144388:0
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
22/29
-40890057088433/.,9;07,9041709,8..425990
%7:9 3 03/3 .9 574;843 94057088 90 3907089 7,90 ,8 , 8250 ,33:,507.039,041904,3
(
%080 ,88079438 ,70 84 .0,7 ,3/ :306:;4., 9,9 ,3 ,990259 41 &! 94 103
347,3.04190,88079434198 88:0 3 98.,80,894570;039 9 17425:993:5,/010380
90709485,34,8
!09943071:7907548989,998900974549,3%7,4:79.,8:78/.94394
97,3/,/:/.,9090,00/;4,9434190%7:9303/3.9.438/0739,9905708039
,.943,00/3;4;0/,830.70/997,38,.943,89070,843430!742884749030
0/8,7000,;0,70,/7:0/9,990,.9439470.4;0790503,9:3/07$0.943
,4190%7:9 3 03/3.9,/-003 439 3899:90/9 90,.94394/0.,7090
390708983905742884734908;4/,3/90,.94394/0.,70901470.48:70;4/%070
,/-003346:089439,990,-4;0,.9438-0439490:78/.9434190#%$:-80.943.
4190,-4;06:490/$0.9434190#:08414:794343/0741,:80841.943574;/08
.07090.,:80841,.943,70-09003908,205,7908-:95079,394/1107039;03:0847:78/.94389043/072,-0,40/390#043,%7,4:79 574;/0/430 41 90 .,:808 41,.943 1,89390 :78/.943 418,/
.4:79,3/90;03:00890703
:7907247045033,.70/930/408349.70,90,.70/997,38,.943414,3472:9::2
83.09014720782070,5705,7,947.4397,.99490.4397,.9414,3472:9::2&3/078:.
.70/93090 -,3820704-0/14790.438/07,9438850.10/90701479403/9490
49075,79,24:3983490.00/390 29574;/0/%0.70/997,38,.9439:84..:770/349
0390.70/930,845030/-:97,9070390.70/930,8,;,0/41390.,80,9-,7
90;4,9434190%7:9303/3.9,00/4..:770/34903905,790800.:90/90
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
23/29
70/9 7002039070 34 3907089 7,90 ,82039430/ -:9 03 90 5,7908 00.:90/ 90
574288473490807090,00/41103/339070897,90,8895:,90/
&!1:7907,7:089,983.090854:8080:84070/:;03.4508419 08:-0.9
57428847 34908,1907 907 00.:943 903 90 070 /: 34910/ 41 90 90728 907041 3
8:-89,39,.425,3.0990%7:9303/3.9
3.024700/8,700$0.9434190%7:9303/3.9.0,7574;/089,990
/8.48:7089,9020392:89-01:7380/57479490.438:22,943419097,38,.943
$ 3 .70/947 8, 1:738 94 0,. 507843 94 42 .70/9 8
0
903/0/5747 9490.438:22,943419097,38,.943,.0,789,902039 3793 80993 14799490 09039,55.,-0 ,3/ 3 ,..47/,3.09 7:08,3/
70:,94385708.7-0/-904,7/90144331472,943
90 .,8 57.0 47 /0;070/ 57.0 41 90 5745079 47 807;.0 94 -0,.6:70/
90,24:3981,394-0.70/90/,8/435,2039,3/4797,/03
90/110703.0-0900390,24:3988091479:3/07.,:808,3/
90.,7083/;/:,9020/.,705,/4794-05,/-8:.
5078433.4330.94399097,38,.943-:9.,703493./0399490090384341.70/9
90949,,24:3994-013,3.0/
9013,3.0.,700570880/3907284150848,3/.039,;48,3/
90507.039,09,99013,3.0-0,789490949,,24:3994-013,3.0/
0570880/,8,8250,33:,7,9043904:989,3/3:35,/-,,3.041904-,943
%07,943,04198574;84389457490.9:807841.70/91742,,.41,,7030884190
97:0.489907041574.00/3174290050703.09,9-,38,70,-094.43.0,8:.97:0.489-
//03.,708:3.079,394139070897,908/0/:.94341390708981742904,30/,24:39,3/
900%0,9070-80089457490.9/0-9478-5072993902941:,5570.,909097:0
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
24/29
.489419074,39403,-090294;01:.4380399490.4397,.9,3/945745070;,:,90
907 459438 3 ,77;3 ,9 -:83088 /0.8438 &54/3 &!8 .,2 41 8:-89,39,
.425,3.04://010,990805:7548084190%7:9303/3.9%0-0,90//8.4;0741
90 97:0 .489 41 .70/9 944 41903 349 -0 ,-0 94 70;0780 90 0110.98 41 ,3 ,70,/
.438:22,90/-:83088/0.843
3 ,//943 90 57428847 34908 90 .4508 41 . 070 57080390/ 94 90 854:808
0:84 ,1907 00.:943 ,70 349 8:11.039 3491.,943 1742 &! 8 0,707 /8.:880/ 90
39070897,90574;84390703/4083498:11.0393/.,9095,79.:,799039070897,9094
-0,550/94904,3.4;070/-8,/5742884734908
47:2$4553
&!,/ 0,70724;0/94 /8288 90509943473,,804 3#%
,,99439074:3/9,9 90854:8080:843899:90/,34907.,80;,804'
-0147090#%41#4,893;4;3908,205,7908,3/88:08&!.,289,9
0 ;,80 4' 39, ,550,78 94 -0 , /1107039 ,.943 ,8 9 57,0/ 147 90
88:,3.0 41 , 902547,7 70897,33 47/07 ,3/47 3:3.943 94 8945 1470.48:70 41 854:808
0:84857450790895480888:08.,7082,794948041905708039.,80(
%4574;0
985439&!.90/90854:8080:848203/0/!099433;,804'.
.439,38 82,7 ,0,9438,8 9480 3 905708039 .,80%0#%41,,9 /030/&!8
4943 948288,804147,.412079!0994307&!7,80/90 8,2088:0
9904:7941550,8,3/87,83908,2088:09:834
%0854:8080:84.,29,9 90 88:0 3;,804'-0147090#%41
#4,89 , !09943 147 3:3.943 ,389 470.48:70 8 90 5745709 41 90 1470.48:70
-014709097:0,..4:3941854:8080:848/0907230/3904907,3/9088:03,804
-0147090#%41,,99890;,/9419039070897,90574;843%0854:808
0:84.,29,9;,804',8-0.4202449-0.,:80-0147090#%41#4,8
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
25/29
9.4:/,.9439070897,3347/07&!574.00/0/9 901470.48:70,3/,:.9438,0
890,.984:994-070897,30/-;,804',8,70,/-003,..42580/90
854:8080:84,/9410,/1107039,.9439,94133:20394190470.48:70$,0,80
4990#%,,99
;0310,88:20147908,041,7:203940;079,943430.,:8041,.9438
3;4;0/39094.;,.94383,2090;4,9434190794190854:8080:8434994
,;090757450791470.480/147,3,24:3990/43494090#:08414:7930;0790088
,48 90 13 41 90 80.43/,.943;,804',8/82880/ -90#%41
#4,89-01470901341,804990#%41,,9983.090;03:041
9,943,8574;/0/14739070/9700203983,,99
#:0 $0.943 -,78 90 7013 41 ,3 ,.943 570;4:8 /82880/ 43 3 90
1443389,3.08
$ 110.9 41 /8288,$:-0.9 94 90 79 41 ,550, ,3 47/077,393, 24943 94/8288 -,80/435,7,7,581 ,3/ 41 80.943
070418,-,790701341908,20,.94347.,23
2574507;03:0,8,74:3/14790/8288,41,3,.943814:3/35,7,7,5 .41
$0.94334935,7,7,581,3/
$%74:3/89390920147-:9-014701390,3807
9490.425,394750,/3,880793,.,2,2494394/82882,-02,/043,34190144374:3/8
, %,9 90 .4:79 ,8 34 :78/.9434;07 90507843 41 90 /0103/3
5,79
-%,990.4:79,834:78/.9434;07908:-0.92,99074190.,2
.%,9;03:082574507,/
/%,9905,3911,8340,.,5,.9948:0
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
26/29
0%,9 90708,34907,.943503/3-09003908,205,7908147908,20.,:80
1 %,9 90 .,:80 41 ,.943 8 -,770/ - , 5747 :/2039 47 - 90
89,9:904129,9438
%,99050,/3,88079390.,289,90834.,:8041,.943
%,9 90 .,2 47/02,3/ 809 1479 3 90 5,39118 50,/3 ,8
-0035,/,;0/,-,3/430/47490780093:80/
%,9 90 .,2 43 . 90 ,.943 8 14:3/0/ 8 :303147.0,-0
:3/0790574;8438419089,9:904117,:/8 ,3/
%,9,.43/943570.0/0391471390.,2,8349-003.4250/9
(25,8088:550/
03,3,.9438/82880/439024943419049075,799843039074:3/
14790/8288,41,3,.9438 14:3/ 35,7,7,581 ,3/ 9,9 90,.943.,3349-0
7010/8 70,7/8 , 90490774:3/8 90 .425,3,39 8 ,40/ 94 10 8,20 ,.943 -:9
84:/9,0.,709,9989209810/990574507.4:7947,190790,..425820394190
07890,-8039.43/943570.0/039,890.,802,-0
&!40;07-7389490,990394341984:79,4943147#0.438/07,94310/
-90854:8080:8443,3:,79 90#%41#4,89.4943,/349
09 -003 7:0/ :5430390 854:808 0:84 10/;,80 4 9 90#%41
,,903.09070070,00/94503/3 ,.9438-09003908,205,790843908,20
88:0 ,9 909204190 1341;,804430-7:,79 90#%41
,,9%889349.,304:713/38983/00/900307,7:09,93.,808070
9070,7094503/3,.9438-09003908,205,790843908,2088:0984:/-090,907
.,809,9 84:/ -0/82880/40;07 98 7:0 8 349,-84:90..47/394 984:79 3
0/,3347547,943;4:7941550,8(
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
27/29
39080.,808980;/0399,9901789,.943,810/3,39.5,9434190134190,907,.943,3/905:75480894570025990,9078:947574;/0
,-,88147800390/8288,419080.43/,.943
;031988349905:75480147901341901789,.94392,
30;0790088-0/82880/190 ,907,.9438 902470,557457,90;0.014790;039,943419088:08-09003905,7908%:83#,248;!07,9,9,80/
%(07:04398503/039,/408349706:709,9 90 ,907
.,8084:/0/94900,707.,80,98706:70/207089,99070 -0 ,34907 503/3 ,.943 349 , 5747 503/3 ,.943
438/073 90-74,/07 8.45041 36:7 3;4;0/ 3;,804,3/904.,943419057450793;4;0/3407747,8
.422990/ - 90 407 .4:79 3 /010773 94 90 ,9,,3 .4:798:78/.943
;03 90701470 90 503/03. 41 94 ,.9438 90 1443 ,70 90
700;,39.438/07,94383/0907233.,.94384:/-0/82880/90/,90 41 13 9 57010703.0 0307, ;03 94 90 1789 ,.943 10/ 94 -0
709,30/ 0907 90 ,.943 84:9 94 -0 /82880/ ,8 10/ 2070 945700259 90 ,907 ,.943 47 94 ,39.5,90 98 13 ,3/ , 90 -,88 147 98
/8288,,3/090790,.943890,557457,90;0.01479,939088:08-09003905,7908
390.,80,9-,7;,804'-0147090#%41#4,89,8,3,.943
1473:3.943,,389,1470.48:708,09,9,8,70,/-0030/0;,804
-01470 90#%41 ,,99 3.:/08,3 ,.943 147 90 ,33:2039 41 8,/ 1470.48:70 ,3
,.943.079,324705745073;04190 00.:9434190 1470.48:708,0%0147207.,80
,8257450710/3#4,89090,9907,810/3,,9990574507;03:041
90,.943,82,3/,90/-9070/97002039980;/039907014709,9;,804
8902470,557457,90;0.01479,939088:08-09003905,7908,8.425,70/94
;,804'%:80 7:0 9,9 90#%41 ,,99 ,8 349 3 07747 3 349
/82883;,804
## 900.84341904:7941550,88070-#9 90
1443%$
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
28/29
3 ,//943 94 90 8:2 41 ! ,8 /0907230/ - 90 .4:798 , 6:4708543/039854:808$,2:0 ,3//09900:84,70 ,84 ,-0 147 90 1443
,24:398
,!03,941507,33:24390,24:39/:0(
174290/,9041/02,3/
,3/
-4254:3/0/0,390708941507,33:24390,24:39/:0(
1742/,90
41/02,3/
%01443,24:3988,-0/0/:.90/174290,-94190854:808$,2:0,3//09900:84
, !,20398 2,/0 - 90 854:808 3 90 ,24:39 41 ! %0805,203988,-0,550/9490/,9041,.9:,5,2039419014433
9047/079,990,70890/949
503,9.,708/:0,3//02,3/,-0,84190920415,2039 3907089/:0,3//02,3/,-0,84190920415,2039 573.5,,2479,9435,20393,770,78,84190920415,2039; 4:989,3/3-,,3.0
- !03,9 :3/07 #05:-. .9 4 3 90 ,24:39 41 ! %8,24:398,-0/0/:.90/174290,-94190854:808$,2:0,3//0990
0:84430-7:,79490144339047/079,990,70890/
949
503,9.,708/:0,3//02,3/,-0,841920415,2039 3907089/:0,3//02,3/,-0,84190920415,2039 573.5,,2479,9435,20393,770,78,84190920415,2039; 4:989,3/3-,,3.0
%0 1470.48:70 41 2479,0 8 070- /0.,70/ ' 43806:039 90,24:398 . 90 #043, %7, 4:79 ,3/ 90 4:79 41 550,8 47/070/
708543/0398 94 5, ,8 24/10/ 3 98 0.843 8, -0 /0/:.90/ 1742 90
574.00/841901470.48:708,0
-
8/3/2019 UCPB v. Samuel
29/29