(ultra)compact binaries from the palomar transient factory · detached white dwarf binary...

1
Targets of Interest: AM CVn Systems AM CVn systems are rare, ultra compact binaries. Their extremely short orbital periods are possible due to their Herich, Hdeficient composition. They are particularly interesting from an evolutionary point of view, and most are believed to be the end product of detached white dwarf binary evolution[10]. Their population density has proven difficult to measure, as population synthesis estimates have poorly matched observational evidence [11]. Verifying the models used for these estimates is one of the key goals of the PTF AM CVn System search. Simulation rendering of an AM CVn system PTF Photomeric Pipeline Variable source work with the PTF requires wellcalibrated data. We have developed a relative photometric calibration pipeline that provides 0.5% photometric accuracy over multiyear light curves in a fully automatic fashion. Moreover, it is able to handle bad weather and nonphotometric nights without generating erroneous values. With 300 million light curves over > 16,000 deg 2 to R~20.6, the PTF photometric "database" is one of the widest, deepest, and best calibrated synoptic surveys available. Photometric accuracy of a typical PTF field Palomar Transient Factory The Palomar Transient Factory[7,8] is a widefield synoptic survey that uses the Palomar 48" Oschin Schmidt Telescope to image up to 2,000 sq. deg. of the sky per night to a 5σ depth of R~20.6. Already amazingly successful in the discovery of supernovae, the completion of the PTF photometric pipeline provides an unprecedented look at the variability of sources over >16,000 sq. deg. of the sky. (Ultra)Compact Binaries from the Palomar Transient Factory Thomas A. Prince 1,2,3 , Eric Bellm 1 , Shrinivas Kulkarni 1 , David Levitan 1 , Bruce Margon 4 , and Paul Groot 5 , on behalf of the PTF Collaboration 6 1. Division of Physics, Mathematics, and Astronomy, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125. 2. Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125. 3. Email: [email protected] 4. Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of California, 1156 High Street, Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA. 5. Department of Astrophysics, IMAPP, Radboud University Nijmegen, P.O. Box 9010, 6500 GL Nijmegen, The Netherlands. 6. http://www.astro.caltech.edu/ptf/ 7. Law, N. M., Kulkarni, S. R., Dekany, R. G. et al., 2009, PASP, 121, 1395. 8. Rau, A., Kulkarni, S. R., Law, N. M. et al, 2009, PASP, 121, 1334. 9. Gänsicke, B. T., Dillon, M., Southworth, J. et al, 2009, MNRAS, 397, 2170. 10. Nelemans, G., Portegies Zwart, S. F., Verbunt, F., and Yungelson, L. R., 2001, A&A, 368, 939. 11. Carter, P. J., Marsh, T. R., Steeghs, D. et al, 2012, MNRAS, in press. 12. Levitan, D., Fulton, B. J., Groot, P. J. et al, 2011, ApJ, 739, 68. 13. Levitan, D., Kupfer, T., Groot, P. J. et al, 2013, MNRAS, in press. (Ultra)Compact Binaries Some of the most interesting astrophysical sources are compact binaries. Formed from complex evolutionary methods, these sources are unique probes of extreme astrophysics. Although rare and difficult to identify, many of these systems do show photometric variability that can be detected in synoptic surveys. Here, we present work by the Palomar Transient Factory (PTF) collaboration to identify and better understand dwarf novae, AM CVn systems, and redback/black widow pulsars. Outbursting System Search One particular aproach to the identification of (ultra) compact binaries is our search for outbursting systems. Specfically, we denote any source with photometric variability of >1.5 mag that is sustained over >1 day to be outbursting. This project has already identified several hundred new dwarf novae, six new IP candidates (see poster by Margon et al.; 148.10), and seven new AM CVn systems (see below and talk by Levitan on Thursday 401.01D). All outbursting system candidates are selected from the database of light curves, and spectroscopically confirmed using lowresolution spectra at collaboration telescopes. Example outbursting light curve from the PTF Targets of Interest: Dwarf Novae Hrich dwarf novae (DN) are relatively numerous, wellunderstood systems, yet still many questions remain about this class of systems. In particular, their evolution is not fully understood, including the 2–3 h "period gap" and the "period minimum". The most homogeneously selected sample of dwarf novae is currently from the SDSS spectroscopic survey[9], and is limited by the selection criteria that the SDSS uses to identify spectroscopic targets. The PTF allows us to search for these systems from their outbursts, thus providing a separate sample from those previously known. Thus far, we have spectroscopically confirmed >200 new DN and have additionally identified outbursts in ~100 more previously known DN. The PTF sample appears to have a similar period distribution to the SDSS sample. The newly identified DNs, all with spectra, have also allowed us to identify candidates with possible pulsating accretors. Such systems typically have accretion wings from the white dwarf accretor around the typical H emission lines. We are now conducting followup high speed observations of these systems. New AM CVn Systems Discovered The PTF has discovered seven new AM CVn systems: this represents 20% of the known population[12,13]. Of even more interest is that these systems were identified systematically from their outbursts. Previous population studies of AM CVn systems were based primarily on systems selected from the SDSS, either from spectra or colors. Our survey provides an independently obtained sample of the AM CVn system population that was selected not by the complex color cuts of the SDSS survey, but based on a colorindependent outburst selection. By combining this sample with an understanding of the outburst duty cycle of AM CVn systems (using combined light curves from multiple synoptic surveys), we will be able to verify the latest observational predictions of the AM CVn system population density. PTFS1119aq: an Eclipsing AM CVn System Of great interest is the AM CVn system PTFS1119aq, which was found to be eclipsing with an orbital period of ~22.5 min. PTFS1119aq is the shortest orbitalperiod AM CVn system known to outburst and is also the second known eclipsing AM CVn system, although the eclipses in PTFS1119aq are only grazing. Additional such eclipsing systems will help us better understand these unique systems by better constraining the masses and orbits of the system components. Targets of Interest: Pulsars A significant fraction of Fermi pulsars have proven to be eclipsing black widow or redback systems, where a spunup millisecond pulsar ablates its lowmass companion. These systems provide an evolutionary link between NS Xray binaries and isolated MSPs, and they permit measurement of NS masses. PTF photometry is enabling modelling of radio identified Fermi black widows such as PSR J212904 (Bellm et al, poster 154.10), and we continue to search for new Fermi counterparts via their optical variability. Folded Rband magnitudes for PSF J212904 showing ellipsoidal variability Six of the newly discovered AM CVn Systems from the PTF Phasebinned light curve of PTFS1119aq folded at 22.5 min. Comparison of the period distribution of known dwarf novae detected in both the PTF and in the SDSS Absorption wing spectra of a DN with a possible pulsating accretor

Upload: others

Post on 16-Sep-2019

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: (Ultra)Compact Binaries from the Palomar Transient Factory · detached white dwarf binary evolution[10]. Their population density has proven difficult to measure, as population synthesis

Targets of Interest: AM CVn SystemsAM CVn systems are rare, ultra­compact binaries. Their extremely shortorbital periods are possible due to theirHe­rich, H­deficient composition. Theyare particularly interesting from anevolutionary point of view, and most arebelieved to be the end product ofdetached white dwarf binaryevolution[10]. Their population densityhas proven difficult to measure, aspopulation synthesis estimates havepoorly matched observational evidence[11]. Verifying the models used for theseestimates is one of the key goals of thePTF AM CVn System search. Simulation rendering of an AM CVn system

WD AccretorM = 0.5 - 1 .0Mʘ

• Porb = 5 – 65 minutes• Population density poorly understood

He-rich donorM < 0.1Mʘ

Helium accretion diskwith hot spot

PTF Photomeric PipelineVariable source work with the PTFrequires well­calibrated data. We havedeveloped a relative photometriccalibration pipeline that provides 0.5%photometric accuracy over multi­yearlight curves in a fully automaticfashion. Moreover, it is able to handlebad weather and non­photometricnights without generating erroneousvalues. With 300 million light curvesover > 16,000 deg2 to R~20.6, the PTF photometric "database" is oneof the widest, deepest, and best calibrated synoptic surveys available.

Photometric accuracy ofa typical PTF field

Palomar Transient FactoryThe Palomar Transient Factory[7,8] is a wide­field synoptic survey thatuses the Palomar 48" Oschin Schmidt Telescope to image up to 2,000sq. deg. of the sky per night to a 5σ depth of R~20.6.Already amazingly successful in the discovery of supernovae, thecompletion of the PTF photometric pipeline provides an unprecedentedlook at the variability of sources over >16,000 sq. deg. of the sky.

(Ultra­)Compact Binaries fromthe Palomar Transient FactoryThomas A. Prince1,2,3, Eric Bellm1, Shrinivas Kulkarni1, David Levitan1, Bruce Margon4, and Paul Groot5, on behalf of the PTF Collaboration6

1. Division of Physics, Mathematics, and Astronomy, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125.2. Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125.3. E­mail: [email protected]. Department of Astronomy and Astrophysics, University of California, 1156 High Street, Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA.5. Department of Astrophysics, IMAPP, Radboud University Nijmegen, P.O. Box 9010, 6500 GL Nijmegen, The Netherlands.6. http://www.astro.caltech.edu/ptf/7. Law, N. M., Kulkarni, S. R., Dekany, R. G. et al., 2009, PASP, 121, 1395.8. Rau, A., Kulkarni, S. R., Law, N. M. et al, 2009, PASP, 121, 1334.9. Gänsicke, B. T., Dillon, M., Southworth, J. et al, 2009, MNRAS, 397, 2170.

10. Nelemans, G., Portegies Zwart, S. F., Verbunt, F., and Yungelson, L. R., 2001, A&A, 368, 939.11. Carter, P. J., Marsh, T. R., Steeghs, D. et al, 2012, MNRAS, in press.12. Levitan, D., Fulton, B. J., Groot, P. J. et al, 2011, ApJ, 739, 68.13. Levitan, D., Kupfer, T., Groot, P. J. et al, 2013, MNRAS, in press.

(Ultra­)Compact BinariesSome of the most interesting astrophysical sources are compact binaries. Formed fromcomplex evolutionary methods, these sources are unique probes of extremeastrophysics. Although rare and difficult to identify, many of these systems do showphotometric variability that can be detected in synoptic surveys. Here, we present workby the Palomar Transient Factory (PTF) collaboration to identify and better understanddwarf novae, AM CVn systems, and redback/black widow pulsars.

Outbursting System SearchOne particular aproach to the identification of (ultra­)compact binaries is our search for outburstingsystems. Specfically, we denote any source withphotometric variability of >1.5 mag that is sustainedover >1 day to be outbursting.This project has already identified several hundrednew dwarf novae, six new IP candidates (see poster byMargon et al.; 148.10), and seven new AM CVnsystems (see below and talk by Levitan on Thursday ­401.01D). All outbursting system candidates areselected from the database of light curves, andspectroscopically confirmed using low­resolution spectra at collaboration telescopes.

Example outbursting light curve from the PTF

Targets of Interest: Dwarf NovaeH­rich dwarf novae (DN) are relativelynumerous, well­understood systems, yetstill many questions remain about thisclass of systems. In particular, theirevolution is not fully understood, includingthe 2–3h "period gap" and the "periodminimum". The most homogeneouslyselected sample of dwarf novae is currentlyfrom the SDSS spectroscopic survey[9],and is limited by the selection criteria thatthe SDSS uses to identify spectroscopictargets. The PTF allows us to search forthese systems from their outbursts, thusproviding a separate sample from those previously known. Thus far, wehave spectroscopically confirmed >200 new DN and have additionallyidentified outbursts in ~100 more previously known DN. The PTF sampleappears to have a similar period distribution to the SDSS sample.

The newly identified DNs, all with spectra, havealso allowed us to identify candidates withpossible pulsating accretors. Such systemstypically have accretion wings from the whitedwarf accretor around the typical H emissionlines. We are now conducting follow­up high­speed observations of these systems.

New AM CVn Systems DiscoveredThe PTF has discovered seven new AM CVnsystems: this represents 20% of the knownpopulation[12,13]. Of even more interest is thatthese systems were identified systematicallyfrom their outbursts. Previous populationstudies of AM CVn systems were basedprimarily on systems selected from the SDSS,either from spectra or colors. Our surveyprovides an independently obtained sample ofthe AM CVn system population that wasselected not by the complex color cuts of theSDSS survey, but based on a color­independentoutburst selection. By combining this samplewith an understanding of the outburst dutycycle of AM CVn systems (using combined lightcurves from multiple synoptic surveys), we will be able to verify the latestobservational predictions of the AM CVn system population density.

PTFS1119aq: an Eclipsing AM CVn SystemOf great interest is the AM CVn system PTFS1119aq,which was found to be eclipsing with an orbital period of~22.5 min. PTFS1119aq is the shortest orbital­period AMCVn system known to outburst and is also the secondknown eclipsing AM CVn system, although the eclipses inPTFS1119aq are only grazing. Additional such eclipsingsystems will help us better understand these uniquesystems by better constraining the masses and orbits ofthe system components.

Targets of Interest: PulsarsA significant fraction of Fermi pulsars haveproven to be eclipsing black widow orredback systems, where a spun­upmillisecond pulsar ablates its low­masscompanion. These systems provide anevolutionary link between NS X­raybinaries and isolated MSPs, and theypermit measurement of NS masses. PTFphotometry is enabling modelling of radio­identified Fermi black widows such as PSRJ2129­04 (Bellm et al, poster 154.10), andwe continue to search for new Fermicounterparts via their optical variability. Folded R­band magnitudes for PSFJ2129­04 showing ellipsoidal variability

Six of the newly discovered AM CVn Systemsfrom the PTF

Phase­binned light curve ofPTFS1119aq folded at 22.5 min.

Comparison of the period distribution ofknown dwarf novae detected in both thePTF and in the SDSS

Absorption wing spectra of a DNwith a possible pulsating accretor