united states district court eastern district of … · 12-cv-00740 learn, michael 17-cv-03322 lee,...

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

EASTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA

In re: Oil Spill by the Oil Rig * MDL No. 2179

“Deepwater Horizon” in the Gulf *

Of Mexico, on April 20, 2010 * SECTION: J

*

Applies to: * JUDGE BARBIER

*

Remaining Cases in the B3 * MAG. JUDGE WILKINSON

Pleading Bundle *

ORDER

[PTO 66 Compliance Order]

On February 22, 2017, the Court issued Pretrial Order No. 63 (“PTO 63”, Rec.

Doc. 22295), which ordered all plaintiffs who had timely filed a claim in the B3

pleading bundle and had not released their claims to submit a sworn statement

regarding the status of their claim. PTO 63 also required certain B3 plaintiffs to file

an individual lawsuit. The B3 claims of those who failed to comply with PTO 63 were

dismissed with prejudice. (Rec. Docs. 23047, 23735). Plaintiffs who were deemed

compliant with PTO 63 were subject to further proceedings of this Court.

On April 9, 2018, the Court issued Pretrial Order No. 66 (“PTO 66,” Rec. Doc.

24282), which required all Remaining B3 Plaintiffs (as identified in Rec. Doc. 24268)

to complete, sign, and serve a Particularized Statement of Claim (Exhibit A to PTO

66) on counsel for BP and the Plaintiffs’ Steering Committee (“PSC”) by July 9, 2018.

Many Remaining B3 Plaintiffs sought and received an extension up to and including

August 8, 2018 to comply with PTO 66. (Rec. Doc. 24671). PTO 66 warned that “[a]ny

Remaining B3 Plaintiff who fails to comply with his or her obligations under this

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 25356 Filed 01/31/19 of 22

2

Order may be required to show cause to this Court why his, her, or its claims should

not be dismissed with prejudice.” (PTO 66 at 2 (emphasis omitted)).

On September 20, 2018, the Court issued an Order to Show Cause Re:

Compliance with PTO 66 (“PTO 66 Show Cause Order,” Rec. Doc. 248875), attached

to which were four exhibits. Exhibit 1 identified 825 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs that

appeared to be compliant with PTO 66. Exhibit 2 identified 48 Remaining B3

Plaintiffs who failed to respond to PTO 66. Exhibit 3 identified 4 plaintiffs who did

not respond to PTO 63 but who did submit a response to PTO 66. Exhibit 4 identified

107 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs who submitted a response to PTO 66 that appeared to

be materially deficient for one or more identified reasons. The PTO 66 Show Cause

Order required the plaintiffs appearing on Exhibits 2, 3, and 4 to show cause in

writing by October 11, 2018 why their claim B3 claims should not be dismissed with

prejudice.

The Court received numerous responses to the PTO 66 Show Cause Order. BP

filed a reply brief on October 25, 2018. (Rec. Doc. 25110). The show cause responses

and non-responses are addressed below.

A. BP Does Not Object to Certain Plaintiffs Being Deemed

Compliant with PTO 66.

BP concedes in its brief that the plaintiffs identified below should be added to

the list of PTO 66-compliant plaintiffs. Accordingly, the following plaintiffs are

deemed compliant with PTO 66. Their B3 claims are not dismissed by this Order and

are subject to further proceedings of this Court.


3

Plaintiff Case No.

Assi, Mohammed 17-cv-03027

Baldo, Lisa Marie 17-cv-03368

Bank, Ryan Clayton 17-cv-03372

Benoit, Bernice Ann 17-cv-03323

Benoit, Roy Paul 17-cv-03328

Bonilla, Sara 17-cv-04133

Booker, Dondy 17-cv-03051

Brown, Michael Todd 17-cv-03366

Bruce, Shane Maddox 18-cv-02626

Burkett, Craig Michael 17-cv-03681

Caldwell, Stephon 13-cv-01007

Coco, III, Malcolm Alphonse 17-cv-03393

Couture, Jr., Raymond 17-cv-03373

Danos, Janice Marie 17-cv-03240

Davis, Frederick 17-cv-03140

Dwyer, Derek Thomas 13-cv-01010

Elliott, Cynthia Anne 13-cv-01011

Elrod, Aiden Connor 17-cv-03334

Elrod, Jarod Shane 17-cv-03331

Fetterhoff, Carol Lynn 17-cv-03350

Fetterhoff, Chayton Lee 17-cv-03350

Fetterhoff, Chelsea Lynn 17-cv-03350

Flair, Kimberly 17-cv-03161

Frazier, Debra 17-cv-03219

Gonzalez, Hector 17-cv-03257

Gooding, John 17-cv-03238

Green, Christopher Alan 17-cv-03191

Griffin, Kacey W. 17-cv-03258

Hall, Lorinzo 17-cv-03261

Hawthorne, Ayana 17-cv-03270

Henson, Jr James 17-cv-03276

Hill, Sherry 17-cv-03278

Hinton, Arlene 17-cv-04357

Hohnadell, Gale 17-cv-03999

Hohnadell, Kimberly 17-cv-03999

Hooker, Jarvis 17-cv-04065

Howard, John L 17-cv-03347

Howze, Alfonso Cardell 17-cv-03288

Jaouhari, Hilal 17-cv-03302

Jones, Sammie 17-cv-04383

Keller, Brian Edward 17-cv-01018

Kendrick, Jared Lee 13-cv-03928

Kiff, Hank J. 12-cv-03179


4

Kirkland, Christopher 17-cv-04391

Landrieu, David Joseph 17-cv-03161

Lawson Environmental

Services, LLC

12-cv-00740

Learn, Michael 17-cv-03322

Lee, Tiffany Monique 16-cv-13874

Louisiana Workers'

Compensation

Corporation

10-cv-02771

Martin, Jennifer Ann 17-cv-03228

McIntosh, William Dante 13-cv-01020

Murphy, Lorinzo 13-cv-01031

Naples, John 12-cv-02564

Nehlig, Chris Emile 17-cv-03376

Odoms Jr., Alonzo 16-cv-13201

Peschlow, Mark 17-cv-03598

Pettaway, John 17-cv-03599

Pinell, Richard J DBA Billy

Sue, Inc

17-cv-03349

Pritchett Jr., Wilbert Devon 17-cv-03231

Robin, III, Charles Raymond 17-cv-03381

Robin, Jr., Ricky R 17-cv-03383

Robin, Ricky Raymond 17-cv-03389

Robinson, Crystal 15-cv-06131

Robinson, Patrick 17-cv-04574

Scott, Katrina 17-cv-04579

Steiner, Machelle F 17-cv-03387

Summers, Andrea 17-cv-04262

Sunseri, Anthony 17-cv-04263

Tebbs, Michael 17-cv-04605

Terrebonne, Betty Ann 17-cv-04549

Treme, Josh 17-cv-04269

Triplett, Danny 17-cv-04270

Turner, Judy A. 17-cv-04614

Turner, Michael 17-cv-04210

Turner, Michael Anthony 17-cv-01035

Vaughan, Rochelle Avila 17-cv-03250

Walker, Cynthia 17-cv-04645

Walker, Glynn 17-cv-04645

Walker, Roxanne 17-cv-03012

Weathersby, Terry 17-cv-04275

Webb, John 17-cv-04276

Wensel, April 17-cv-04225

Williams, Armis 17-cv-03414

Williams, Viola 17-cv-04237


5

B. Plaintiffs that the Court Deems Compliant with PTO 66 Over

BP’s Objection

After considering their show cause responses and BP’s objections, the Court

deems the following plaintiffs to be compliant with PTO 66. Their B3 claims are not

dismissed.

Plaintiff Case No. Show Cause

Response Doc.

Norwood, Margaret 17-cv-03203 24966, 25130

Woodland, Antonio 17-cv-04240 25017

C. Plaintiffs for Whom PTO 66 Is Moot

Elizabeth Renee Moreau (16-cv-05754), Chelsea Co., LLC (12-cv-2650), and

Terry Louise Odom (16-cv-15974) were among the plaintiffs required to respond to

the PTO 66 Show Cause Order. Although they did not file a response, closer

inspection reveals that their cases had already been closed. Moreau and Chelsea Co.,

LLC voluntarily dismissed their claims. (Rec. Docs. 20305, 24692). Odom’s case was

transferred to another district court. (Rec. Doc. 19 in No. 16-cv-15974). Accordingly,

the issue of whether these plaintiffs complied with PTO 66 is moot.

D. Plaintiffs Who Did Not File a Response to the PTO 66 Show

Cause Order

The following plaintiffs failed to respond as required by the PTO 66 Show

Cause Order. Their B3 claims will be dismissed with prejudice.

Plaintiff Case No.

Abdelfattah, Yahya Omar 17-cv-03446 Aguinaga, Stephane 17-cv-03173

Baird, Bryan Joshua 17-cv-03178


6

Baker, Edward Joseph 17-cv-03685

Boose, Lawyer Jr. 17-cv-04135

Claery, Robert 17-cv-02855 Duong, Thanh Chan 16-cv-03953

Ferrell, Donald Lane 17-cv-02850

Fonseca, Kim Joseph 17-cv-03343

Hackney, David 17-cv-03175

Helmholtz, Michael 17-cv-02932

Howard, Alfred 17-cv-03286

Iames, Sandra Ann 17-cv-03217

Johnny Tran, LLC 17-cv-03351

Johnson, Patricia 17-cv-03309

Kinler, Charles Bernard 13-cv-02387

Lim, Seng 17-cv-03095

Luckes, Bernard 17-cv-02933

Ly, Anh 16-cv-03957

McKinley, David 17-cv-04562 Mielke, Blair Christopher 17-cv-03205

Miles, Debra L. 13-cv-02715

Nguyen, Dai V. 16-cv-03952 Nguyen, Loc 16-cv-03955

Nguyen, Nghia Ngoc 16-cv-03954

Padgett, Linda 13-cv-02357

Phan, Hanh Van 16-cv-03956

Reece, Kevin 17-cv-03172

Reed, Germaine 17-cv-03165

RMC General Contractors, LLC

11-cv-02527

Rodriguez, Ramon Luis 17-cv-04567

Salter, Christopher F. 17-cv-04289

Sample, James A. 17-cv-04290

Santiny, Laila 17-cv-04555

Santiny, Nicole 17-cv-04555 Santiny, Zana 17-cv-04555

Scott, Donald Joseph II 17-cv-04554

Simmons, Candice 17-cv-04247

Veillon, John R. 17-cv-04619

Waddle, Jan Michael 16-cv-04083

Wesley, Charles 17-cv-03326

Whitted, Roderick Deon 17-cv-04631


7

E. Plaintiffs Who Are Members of the Medical Benefits Settlement

Class

On January 11, 2013, the Court certified the Medical Benefits Settlement

Class and approved the Medical Benefits Class Action Settlement Agreement

(“Medical Settlement”). (Rec. Docs. 8218; 8217). Subject to certain exclusions, the

Medical Benefits Settlement Class is defined as all natural persons who:

1) Worked as CLEAN-UP WORKERS at any time between April 20, 2010 and

April 16, 2012; or

2) Resided in ZONE A for some time on each of at least sixty days between

April 20, 2010, and September 30, 2010 . . . , and developed one or more

SPECIFIED PHYSICAL CONDITIONS between April 20, 2010, and

September 30, 2010; or

3) Resided in ZONE B for some time on each of at least sixty days between

April 20, 2010, and December 31, 2010 . . . .

(Medical Settlement § I, Rec. Doc. 6427-1) (words in all capitals are further defined

in the Medical Settlement).

Class members are barred from commencing, asserting, and/or prosecuting

any and all “Release Claims” against any “Released Party,” as those terms are defined

under the Medical Settlement. (See Order and Judgment, Rec. Doc. 8218; Medical

Settlement § XVI, Rec. Doc. 6427-1). PTO 66 similarly explained that to the extent

plaintiffs “are indeed settlement class members and are seeking to pursue claims in

this litigation that are Released Claims under the [Medical Settlement], their claims

are subject to this Court’s Order and Judgment enjoining such claims.” (Rec. Doc.

24282 at 3). Consequently, PTO 66 required BP to provide the Claims Administrator

of Medical Settlement with a list of Remaining B3 Plaintiffs who identified

themselves as class members on their PTO 63 sworn statement or who did not appear


8

to submit a timely and valid opt out (or who revoked an opt out request). (Id.) The

Claims Administrator, in turn, provided the Court, BP, and the PSC with a list

stating whether any of the plaintiffs on BP’s list submitted claims under the Medical

Settlement and, if so, whether the Claims Administrator determined them to be class

members. A redacted version of the Claims Administrator’s chart is attached to this

Order as Exhibit 1.1

The PTO 66 Show Cause Order required 18 plaintiffs to show cause why their

B3 claims should not be dismissed for the reason that they appeared to be members

of the Medical Benefits Settlement Class. One of these plaintiffs, Joseph Edward

Baker, failed to respond to the PTO 66 Show Cause Order. (See Part D, supra). Of

the 17 who did respond to the PTO 66 Show Cause Order, BP subsequently conceded

that 4 should be added to the compliant list (John Howard, Richard Pinell d/b/a Billy

Sue, Inc., Machelle Steiner, and Hank Kiff). (See Part A, supra). This leaves 13

plaintiffs who appear to be members of the Medical Benefits Settlement Class and

who appear to pursue Released Claims: Sergio Alvarado, Charles Bradley, Patrick

Cage, James Collier, Ronald Hicks, Anthony Kizzee, Quient Liddell, Joe Locke,

Richard McBride, Rico McBride, Demetria Morris, Eric Taylor, and Alvin Thompson.

Each is discussed below. The Court will also address The Queen Esther Commercial

Fishing and Mary Taylor.

1 The Claims Administrator’s chart uses the following abbreviations: CUW (Clean-Up Worker),

POCF (Proof of Claim Form), DDF (Data Disclosure Form), SPC (Specified Physical Conditions),

PMCP (Periodic Medical Consultation Program).


9

Charles Bradley, Patrick Cage, Ronald Hicks, Anthony Kizzee, and Alvin

Thompson: None of these plaintiffs dispute in their show cause response that they

are members of the Medical Benefits Settlement Class or that they are pursuing

“Released Claims.” (Rec. Doc. 24967). Their B3 claims will be dismissed.

Rico McBride/Queen Esther Commercial Fishing: Rico McBride indicates in

his Particularized Statement of Claim that he brings claims for personal injury from

chemical exposure, personal injury other than from chemical exposure, breach of

contract, and possibly vessel damage. (Rec. Doc. 25059, Questions 17, 47, 48). As to

the claim for personal injury due to chemical exposure, that claim is barred by the

Medical Settlement’s class-wide release if Rico McBride is a member of the Medical

Benefits Settlement Class. (See Medical Settlement § XVI(A)(1), (B), Rec. Doc. 6427-

1). McBride asserts in a conclusory manner that he has not released his claims, but

fails to articulate why he is not a member of the Medical Benefits Settlement Class.

(Rec. Docs. 25059 at 2, 25145 at 2). On the other hand, the Claims Administrator

reports that Rico McBride is a class member who has received a payment at the A3

level (see Exhibit 1), which is corroborated by McBride’s PTO 63 sworn statement

where he identified himself as a class member and stated that he accepted a medical

settlement in the amount of $12,350.00—the amount paid at the A3 level. (16-15255,

Rec. Doc. 5). Therefore, McBride’s chemical exposure claim was released by the

Medical Settlement. McBride’s other claims are outside the scope of the Medical

Settlement’s release. However, the claim for personal injury other than from chemical

exposure will be dismissed because McBride fails to adequately describe in his


10

Particularized Statement of Claim any bodily injury (other than from chemical

exposure) or his damages due to that injury. (See Rec. Doc. 25059, Questions 29 and

39). The breach of contract and vessel damage claims will be dismissed because those

claims are barred by the individual releases reached through the Court-Appointed

Neutrals’ process (see Rec. Doc. 20620), and/or the class-wide release in the Economic

and Property Damages Settlement (Rec. Doc. 6430-1 § 10), and/or the class-wide

releases in the Halliburton and Transocean Punitive Damages and Assigned Claims

Settlement Agreements (Rec. Doc. 14644-1 § 10; Rec. Doc. 15322-1 § 10).2

Additionally, to the extent McBride’s vessel damage claim is in the B1 bundle, as

opposed to the B3 bundle, that claim was dismissed in 2016 by the PTO 60

Compliance Order. (Rec. Doc. 20996 at 5; see also PTO 64 Compliance Order, Ex. 3,

Rec. Doc. 23051-3 at 4 (listing Rico McBride among plaintiffs whose B1 claims were

previously dismissed for non-compliance with PTO 60); Rec. Doc. 23735 at 3-4,

denying McBride’s motion for reconsideration of PTO 64 Compliance Order).

Rico McBride and The Queen Esther Commercial Fishing (“Queen Esther”)

submitted a single Particularized Statement of Claim. (Rec. Doc. 25059 at 5). It is not

clear whether Queen Esther is a separate juridical entity, as opposed to merely a

trade name or “d/b/a” of Rico McBride. Assuming Queen Esther is a juridical entity,

2 The Claims Administrator for the Halliburton and Transocean Punitive Damages and Assigned

Claims Settlements has provided the Court with documentation confirming Rico McBride’s

membership in the Economic and Property Damages Settlement Class (often referred to as the the

“old class”). (See Exhibit 2 to this Order). Assuming Rico McBride’s vessel was in fact physically

damaged by the oil spill, then he is a member of the Punitive Damages Settlement Class (often referred

to as the “new class”) under the Halliburton and Transocean Settlements. (See Rec. Doc. 14644-1 §§ 3

& 4; Rec. Doc. 15322-1 §§ 3 & 4). The Court further notes that McBride himself claims to be a member

of the “old class” and the “new class.” (Rec. Doc. 25059 at 1-2).


11

the only B3 claims described in the Particularized Statement of Claim that it could

possibly assert are for breach of contract or vessel damage. However, the same

reasons that preclude Rico McBride from asserting these claims also apply to Queen

Esther. Queen Ester’s B3 claims will also be dismissed.

Richard McBride: Richard McBride’s B3 claims will be dismissed for

essentially the same reasons as Rico McBride’s.

Sergio Alvarado: Sergio Alvarado argues that BP’s assertion that he is a class

member is not supported by any evidence. (Rec. Doc. 24987). However, the Claims

Administrator confirmed Alvarado’s status as a Clean-Up Worker (see Exhibit 1),

which is corroborated by Alvarado’s own statement in his Particularized Statement

of Claim that he performed cleanup work during the oil spill. (Rec. Doc. 24987-1 at

4). Alvarado also argues that he was deemed compliant with PTO 63 in 2017, and “[i]f

BP believed Plaintiff was a member of the class, it had the opportunity to raise this

issue when reviewing the PTO-63 submission.” (Rec. Doc. 24987 at 2). However, the

fact that Alvarado was deemed compliant with PTO 63 does not mean that he is not

a class member, and the Court does not find that BP waived its right to raise the class

membership issue. Indeed, the reason that PTO 66 required the Claims

Administrator to prepare the report attached as Exhibit 1 was so the Court could cull

from the population of viable B3 claims those which are barred by the Medical

Settlement’s class-wide release.3 Finally, while Alvarado briefly refers to himself as

3 Several other plaintiffs also argued that BP waived the class membership argument. The Court

rejects those arguments as well. On a related note, the fact that a plaintiff is not a confirmed class

member in the Claims Administrator’s report does not establish that the plaintiff is not in fact a class


12

a “valid opt out,” (Rec. Doc. 24987 at 2), his name does not appear among the list of

timely and valid opt outs filed on November 21, 2012 (Rec. Doc. 7989), nor does he

produce any evidence to support his claimed opt-out status. Sergio Alvarado’s B3

claims will be dismissed.

Quient Liddell, Joe Locke, Eric Taylor, and Demetria Morris: These four

plaintiffs argue that they opted out of the Medical Settlement. (Rec. Docs. 24955

(Liddell), 24957 (Locke), 24969 (Taylor), 24956 (Morris). The Claims Administrator’s

report states that they each revoked their opt outs. (Exhibit 1). At the Court’s request,

the Claims Administrator provided the opt-out revocations, which are attached to this

Order as Exhibits 3 (Liddell), 4 (Locke), 5 (Taylor), and 6 (Morris). Their B3 claims

will be dismissed.

James Collier: In his Particularized Statement of Claim, James Collier

answered “yes” to the question, “Did BP, a government entity, or another company or

entity hire you to perform cleanup work in response to the oil spill?” (Rec. Doc. 24970-

1 at 4). Collier contends that this was “an unfortunate and inadvertent error.” He

further asserts that he did not engage in “Response Activities” and was not a “Clean-

Up Worker” under the Medical Settlement, therefore he is not a member of the

Medical Benefits Settlement Class. (Rec. Docs. 24970, 25117). According to the

Claims Administrator’s report, however, Collier submitted a claim under the Medical

Settlement for a Specified Physical Condition, the settlement program determined

Collier was a class member, and Collier received partial payment on his claim.

member, and nothing in this Order shall prevent a defendant from raising class membership and the

class-wide release as a defense to a plaintiff’s claim in the future.


13

(Exhibit 1). The report is supported by the “Explanation of Payment,” attached as

Exhibit 7 to this Order, which the Claims Administrator provided at the Court’s

request. James Collier’s B3 claims will be dismissed.

Mary Taylor: At the time the Show Cause Order issued, Mary Taylor had not

yet submitted a PTO 66 Particularized Statement of Claim. Consequently, she was

listed among the plaintiffs who submitted nothing in response to PTO 66. (Rec. Doc.

24875-2). Taylor submitted her Particularized Statement of Claim on October 5, 2018,

along with her response to the Show Cause Order. (Rec. Doc. 24965). BP argues that

Taylor’s claims should be dismissed because her Particularized Statement of Claim

was untimely and because she is a member of the Medical Benefits Settlement Class.

(Rec. Doc. 25110-7 at 4 n.2). Taylor replied to BP’s untimeliness argument, but not

the class membership issue. (Rec. Doc. 25132). The Claims Administrator’s report

states that Mary Taylor is a class member and that she received a payment on her

claim. (Exhibit 1). Taylor’s claim is for loss of consortium related to her husband’s

injuries from exposure to oil and/or dispersant. Such a claim is a Released Claim

under the Medical Settlement. (Medical Settlement § XVI(A)(2), Rec. Doc. 6427-1).

Consequently, even if the Court were to excuse the untimeliness of Taylor’s

Particularized Statement of Claim, it would still dismiss her B3 claims as released

by the Medical Settlement.

Accordingly, the B3 claims of the following plaintiffs will be dismissed with

prejudice:

Plaintiff Case No.

Alvarado, Sergio A 13-cv-01778


14

Bradley, Charles 17-cv-03164

Cage, Patrick 17-cv-03174

Collier, James 17-cv-03415

Hicks, Ronald 17-cv-03176

Kizzee, Anthony 17-cv-03158

Liddell, Quient 17-cv-04411

Locke, Joe 17-cv-04413

McBride, Richard 16-cv-06635

McBride, Rico / The Queen

Esther Commercial Fishing

16-cv-15255

Morris, Demetria 17-cv-04459

Taylor, Eric 17-cv-04600

Taylor, Mary 17-cv-03201

Thompson, Alvin 17-cv-03156

F. Plaintiffs Whose Particularized Statements of Claim Were

Untimely or Not Submitted

PTO 66 gave plaintiffs until July 9, 2018 (90 days) to file their Particularized

Statement of Claim. For those plaintiffs represented by Nexsen Pruet, LLC and

Douglas Schmidt, the Court granted an extension for filing until August 8, 2018. (Rec.

Doc. 24671). The following plaintiffs’ B3 claims will be dismissed because their

Particularized Statements of Claim were significantly late or not submitted at all.


Response

Doc.

PTO 66

Response

Date

Conerly, Jeffery 17-cv-03170 24967 9/18/18

Dorgan, Sheri

Allen

17-cv-03367 * 9/8/18

Evans, Glyn 17-cv-03167 24967 9/18/18

Gortney, Brian W.

II

15-cv-01047 * 9/8/18

Harris, Tishia

Maria

17-cv-04650 25019 9/25/18

Kelly, Billy Ray Jr. 17-cv-04388 25018 Did not

submit

Masters, James 12-cv-02332 25018 Did not

submit


15

Valdivieso, Sergio 12-cv-02004 * Did not

submit

The asterisk (*) denotes plaintiffs that appear to have served a show cause

response on BP, but did not file a show cause response with the Court. Information

in the “PTO 66 Response Date” column for these plaintiffs is based on information

provided in BP’s brief.

G. Plaintiffs Whose Particularized Statements of Claim Remain

Materially Non-Compliant

PTO 66 required plaintiffs to provide responses in their Particularized

statements of Claim that “are as specific and accurate as practicable” so that “the

Court and the parties [could] better under the nature and scope of the injuries,

damages, and causation alleged.” (Rec. Doc., 24282 at 1-2). The Particularized

Statement of Claim similarly required plaintiffs to answer every question “to the best

of your knowledge” and provide “as much information as you can.” (Rec. Doc. 24282-

1 at 1). As further explained in BP’s brief (Rec. Doc. 25110 at 7-8), the following

plaintiffs submitted Particularized Statements of Claim that failed to provide

sufficient responses to key questions about the injury allegedly suffered or damages

claimed. Their B3 claims will be dismissed.


Response Do.

Estate of Lula

Richardson

17-cv-04285 25014

McBride, Rico4 16-cv-15255 25059, 25145

Phillips, Shunna 17-cv-04395 25020

Thompson, Joe L.5 17-cv-02854 25061, 25143

4 Rico McBride’s claims are also dismissed for the reasons discussed in Part E, above. 5 Furthermore, Joe Thompson asserts in the Particularized Statement of Claim that he was a Clean-

Up Worker (Rec. Doc. 25110-8, Questions 9-11), and he did not opt-out of the Medical Benefits


16

H. Plaintiffs Who Did Not Comply With PTO 63

Ashley Thompson: Ashley Thompson (17-cv-02854) filed a complaint on April

3, 2017, but failed to include a PTO 63 sworn statement. Accordingly, on July 18,

2017, this Court dismissed her B3 claim with prejudice. (Rec. Doc. 23047).

Nevertheless, Ashley Thompson submitted a PTO 66 Particularized Statement of

Claim. Her B3 claims had already been dismissed, however, and shall remain so.

John Earl Miller, Jr.: John Earl Miller, Jr. submitted a PTO 66 Particularized

Statement of Claim, but it appears that he is not a party to a lawsuit filed in this

Court. Because Miller has no case or claim before this Court, whether he complied

with PTO 66 is of no moment. The Court will simply leave Miller off the list of PTO

66-compliant plaintiffs.

Michael Dean: Michael Dean6 (17-cv-06800) filed suit asserting B3-type claims

in Florida state court on May 15, 2017. Dean’s case was removed and then transferred

to this Court on July 26, 2017. As far as the Court is aware, Dean did not assert a B3

claim in this Court until after the PTO 63 Compliance Order issued on July 18, 2017.7

Dean appears to have complied with PTO 66, but has not complied with PTO 63. The

Court will deem Dean conditionally compliant with PTO 66. Within 21 days of the

issuance of this Order, Dean shall complete, sign, and file the PTO 63 Sworn

Settlement Class (see Rec. Doc. 7989). If this is true, then his claims would also be dismissed for the

reason that they are barred by the Medical Settlement’s class-wide release. 6 BP’s brief stated that Dean failed to file a response to the PTO 66 Show Cause Order. (Rec. Doc.

25110-2). As requested in Dean’s reply (Rec. Doc. 25112), the Court will treat Dean’s Motion to Correct

Clerical Error (Rec. Doc. 24952), filed on October 4, 2018, as his PTO 66 Show Cause response. 7 Dean did file a short form joinder in 2011, but it only asserted B1 claims, not B3 claims. (See 10-

8888, Rec. Doc. 22421).


17

Statement (Rec. Doc. 22295-1) in the individual docket for his case and simultaneously

file a notice of compliance in the master docket. If Dean complies, the Court will grant

his Motion to Correct Clerical Error (Rec. Doc. 24952) and re-open his case (which was

closed by the Order of September 6, 2018, Rec. Doc. 24814). If Dean fails to comply,

BP shall file a notice of non-compliance in the master docket and the Court will take

appropriate action.

I. Conclusion

In accordance with the above,

IT IS ORDERED that the following plaintiffs are deemed COMPLIANT with

PTO 66 and their B3 claims are not dismissed by this Order. These plaintiffs will be

added to the list of PTO 66-compliant plaintiffs, a revised version of which is attached

as Exhibit 8 to this Order:

Plaintiff Case No.

Assi, Mohammed 17-cv-03027

Baldo, Lisa Marie 17-cv-03368

Bank, Ryan Clayton 17-cv-03372

Benoit, Bernice Ann 17-cv-03323

Benoit, Roy Paul 17-cv-03328

Bonilla, Sara 17-cv-04133

Booker, Dondy 17-cv-03051

Brown, Michael Todd 17-cv-03366



Caldwell, Stephon 13-cv-01007

Coco, III, Malcolm Alphonse 17-cv-03393

Couture, Jr., Raymond 17-cv-03373

Danos, Janice Marie 17-cv-03240

Davis, Frederick 17-cv-03140

Dean, Michael8 17-cv-06800

Dwyer, Derek Thomas 13-cv-01010

8 Michael Dean is conditionally compliant as explained in part H, above.


18

Elliott, Cynthia Anne 13-cv-01011

Elrod, Aiden Connor 17-cv-03334

Elrod, Jarod Shane 17-cv-03331

Fetterhoff, Carol Lynn 17-cv-03350


Fetterhoff, Chelsea Lynn 17-cv-03350

Flair, Kimberly 17-cv-03161

Frazier, Debra 17-cv-03219

Gonzalez, Hector 17-cv-03257

Gooding, John 17-cv-03238

Green, Christopher Alan 17-cv-03191

Griffin, Kacey W. 17-cv-03258

Hall, Lorinzo 17-cv-03261

Hawthorne, Ayana 17-cv-03270

Henson, Jr James 17-cv-03276

Hill, Sherry 17-cv-03278

Hinton, Arlene 17-cv-04357

Hohnadell, Gale 17-cv-03999

Hohnadell, Kimberly 17-cv-03999

Hooker, Jarvis 17-cv-04065

Howard, John L 17-cv-03347

Howze, Alfonso Cardell 17-cv-03288

Jaouhari, Hilal 17-cv-03302

Jones, Sammie 17-cv-04383

Keller, Brian Edward 17-cv-01018

Kendrick, Jared Lee 13-cv-03928

Kiff, Hank J. 12-cv-03179

Kirkland, Christopher 17-cv-04391

Landrieu, David Joseph 17-cv-03161

Lawson Environmental Services,

LLC

12-cv-00740

Learn, Michael 17-cv-03322

Lee, Tiffany Monique 16-cv-13874

Louisiana Workers'

Compensation Corporation

10-cv-02771

Martin, Jennifer Ann 17-cv-03228

McIntosh, William Dante 13-cv-01020

Murphy, Lorinzo 13-cv-01031

Naples, John 12-cv-02564

Nehlig, Chris Emile 17-cv-03376

Norwood, Margaret 17-cv-03203

Odoms Jr., Alonzo 16-cv-13201

Peschlow, Mark 17-cv-03598

Pettaway, John 17-cv-03599

Pinell, Richard J DBA Billy Sue, 17-cv-03349


19

Inc

Pritchett Jr., Wilbert Devon 17-cv-03231

Robin, III, Charles Raymond 17-cv-03381

Robin, Jr., Ricky R 17-cv-03383

Robin, Ricky Raymond 17-cv-03389

Robinson, Crystal 15-cv-06131

Robinson, Patrick 17-cv-04574

Scott, Katrina 17-cv-04579

Steiner, Machelle F 17-cv-03387

Summers, Andrea 17-cv-04262

Sunseri, Anthony 17-cv-04263

Tebbs, Michael 17-cv-04605

Terrebonne, Betty Ann 17-cv-04549

Treme, Josh 17-cv-04269

Triplett, Danny 17-cv-04270

Turner, Judy A. 17-cv-04614

Turner, Michael 17-cv-04210

Turner, Michael Anthony 17-cv-01035

Vaughan, Rochelle Avila 17-cv-03250

Walker, Cynthia 17-cv-04645

Walker, Glynn 17-cv-04645

Walker, Roxanne 17-cv-03012

Weathersby, Terry 17-cv-04275

Webb, John 17-cv-04276

Wensel, April 17-cv-04225

Williams, Armis 17-cv-03414

Williams, Viola 17-cv-04237

Woodland, Antonio 17-cv-04240

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the B3 claims of the plaintiffs identified

below are DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE because they are non-compliant with PTO

66 and/or their claims were released.

With the exception of those cases marked “DO NOT CLOSE,” none of the cases

identified below have any claims remaining. Consequently, the Clerk of Court is

instructed to CLOSE each of the cases listed below EXCEPT those marked “DO NOT

CLOSE.”


20

Plaintiff Case No. Note

Abdelfattah, Yahya Omar 17-cv-03446 Aguinaga, Stephane 17-cv-03173 DO NOT CLOSE

Alvarado, Sergio A 13-cv-01778

Baird, Bryan Joshua 17-cv-03178


Boose, Lawyer Jr. 17-cv-04135

Bradley, Charles 17-cv-03164 Cage, Patrick 17-cv-03174

Claery, Robert 17-cv-02855 Collier, James 17-cv-03415 Conerly, Jeffery 17-cv-03170

Dorgan, Sheri Allen 17-cv-03367 Duong, Thanh Chan 16-cv-03953

Estate of Lula Richardson 17-cv-04285

Evans, Glyn 17-cv-03167 Ferrell, Donald Lane 17-cv-02850

Fonseca, Kim Joseph 17-cv-03343

Gortney, Brian W. II 15-cv-01047 Hackney, David 17-cv-03175

Harris, Tishia Maria 17-cv-04650 Helmholtz, Michael 17-cv-02932

Hicks, Ronald 17-cv-03176

Howard, Alfred 17-cv-03286 Iames, Sandra Ann 17-cv-03217 Johnny Tran, LLC 17-cv-03351

Johnson, Patricia 17-cv-03309

Kelly, Billy Ray Jr. 17-cv-04388

Kinler, Charles Bernard 13-cv-02387

Kizzee, Anthony 17-cv-03158 Liddell, Quient 17-cv-04411

Lim, Seng 17-cv-03095

Locke, Joe 17-cv-04413 Luckes, Bernard 17-cv-02933

Ly, Anh 16-cv-03957 Masters, James 12-cv-02332 McBride, Richard 16-cv-06635

McBride, Rico / The Queen Esther Commercial Fishing

16-cv-15255

McKinley, David 17-cv-04562 DO NOT CLOSE

Mielke, Blair Christopher 17-cv-03205

Miles, Debra L. 13-cv-02715

Morris, Demetria 17-cv-04459


21

Nguyen, Dai V. 16-cv-03952

Nguyen, Loc 16-cv-03955

Nguyen, Nghia Ngoc 16-cv-03954

Padgett, Linda 13-cv-02357

Phan, Hanh Van 16-cv-03956 Phillips, Shunna 17-cv-04395 DO NOT CLOSE Reece, Kevin 17-cv-03172

Reed, Germaine 17-cv-03165

RMC General Contractors, LLC 11-cv-02527

Rodriguez, Ramon Luis 17-cv-04567

Salter, Christopher F. 17-cv-04289

Sample, James A. 17-cv-04290

Santiny, Laila 17-cv-04555

Santiny, Nicole 17-cv-04555 Santiny, Zana 17-cv-04555

Scott, Donald Joseph II 17-cv-04554 DO NOT CLOSE

Simmons, Candice 17-cv-04247

Taylor, Eric 17-cv-04600 Taylor, Mary 17-cv-03201 DO NOT CLOSE

Thompson, Alvin 17-cv-03156 Thompson, Joe L. 17-cv-02854

Valdivieso, Sergio 12-cv-02004 Veillon, John R. 17-cv-04619

Waddle, Jan Michael 16-cv-04083

Wesley, Charles 17-cv-03326 Whitted, Roderick Deon 17-cv-04631

New Orleans, Louisiana, this 31st day of January, 2019.

_______________________________

United States District Judge

NOTE TO CLERK: Mail copies of this Order with the attached Exhibits to

the following plaintiffs, who appear to be pro se:




Claery, Robert 17-cv-02855

DeBose, Chrishawn Derrick 17-cv-03680


22

DeBose, Jimmy Raymond 17-cv-03675

DeBose, Karen Ann 17-cv-03670

Evans, Robert (Engineers &

Filmmakers Computer Users Group)

16-cv-03966

Ferrell, Donald Lane 17-cv-02850

Fetterhoff, Carol L. 17-cv-03350


Fetterhoff, Chelsea 17-cv-03350

Helmholtz, Michael 17-cv-02932

Keyes, Ellis 14-cv-02211

Luckes, Bernard 17-cv-02933

McBride, Richard 16-cv-06635

McBride, Rico / The Queen Esther

Commercial Fishing

16-cv-15255

Merchant, Raymond Joe 15-cv-04290

Miller, John Earl Jr. No case. See note below.

Thompson, Ashley 17-cv-02854

Thompson, Joe L. 17-cv-02854

Wesley, Charles William, Jr. 17-cv-03326

Note to BP and Plaintiff’s Liaison Counsel: Provide the Court with a mailing

address for John Earl Miller, Jr.


MDL 2179 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs Not Matched to Valid MSA Opt Out

Highly Confidential

2018.05.09 -- Updated with full SSN data 2018.05.23

Plaintiff data taken from PTO 63 submissions (except for green-shaded data that was missing from PTO 63 submissions and taken from SFJs or other sources).

Plaintiff Name

EDLA

Case

Number

SSN/TID SPC ID (if found)Class Membership

(if established)

Overall Case

Status/FindingsCurrent Mailing Address City State ZIP DOB Counsel

Alvarado, Sergio 13-01778 SPC0028056

Did not file claim

(POCF); confirmed

CUW

DDF Only Douglas M. Schmidt, APLC

McBride, Richard 16-06635 SPC0026911 CUWSPC Determined A1,

PaidPro Se

McBride, Rico O. 16-15255 SPC0001995 CUWSPC Determined A3,

Paid

Thompson, Alvin Lee 17-03156 SPC0001383 CUWPMCP Determined,

SPC DeniedJacobs, Sarrat, Lovelace & Harris

Kizzee, Anthony 17-03158 SPC0005289 CUWPMCP Determined,


Bradley, Charles 17-03164 SPC0004435 CUWPMCP Determined,


Cage, Patrick D. 17-03174 435-25-5678 SPC0004273 CUWPMCP Determined,

SPC Denied22131 S. 39th Place Kent WA 98032 Not Provided Jacobs, Sarrat, Lovelace & Harris

Hicks, Ronald 17-03176 465-37-8126 SPC0004227 CUWPMCP Determined,

SPC Denied1602 East Bowie Marshall TX 75670 9/4/1976 Jacobs, Sarrat, Lovelace & Harris

Taylor, Mary S. 17-03201 SPC0022648 CUWSPC Determined A1,

Paid

Smith Stag, L.L.C;Krupnick, Campbell,

Malone, Buser, Slama, Hancock,

Liberman, P.A.

Case 2:10-md-02179-CJB-JCW Document 25356-1 Filed 01/31/19 Page 1 of 3

BenjaminAllums

Text Box

EXHIBIT 1

Collier, James L. 17-03415 SPC0025547 CUWSPC Determined A1,

Partial Payment

Nexsen Pruet, LLC;Douglas M. Schmidt,

APLC

Liddell, Quient 17-04411 SPC0005902

Did not file claim

(POCF); confirmed

CUW

Opt Out, Revocation

and DDF


APLC

Locke, Joe Lewis 17-04413 SPC0005906

Did not file claim

(POCF); confirmed

CUW

Opt Out, Revocation

and DDF


APLC


Morris, Demetria L. 17-04459 SPC0005815 CUWSPC Determined A1,

Paid


APLC

Taylor, Eric Marice 17-04600 SPC0005982

Did not file claim

(POCF); confirmed

CUW

Opt Out, Revocation

and DDF


APLC



BenjaminAllums

Text Box

EXHIBIT 2


BenjaminAllums

Text Box

EXHIBIT 3

REVOCATION OF OPT OUT REQUEST

N A M E OF POTENTIAL CLASS MEMBER: ^j^L)i<jT^

ADDRESS:

CITY: fV^&S^j^/QTt STATE: Al's ZIP CODE:

PHONE:

DATE OF BIRTH:

SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER (Optional):

GCCF ID (Optional):

MEDICAL BENEFITS CLAIM NUMBER (Optional):

ATTORNEY (Optional):

I wish to revoke my request to opt out of the Medical Benefits Settlement Class. By revoking my opt out request, I hereby withdraw and waive any and all current and future objections that I may have to the Medical Benefits Class Action Settlement.

Printed Name of Potential Class Member Signature of Potential Class Member (or Authorized Representative) (or Authorized Representative)

Date

*This form is for revocations submitted after a final ruling on settlement approval and before December 15, 2012 only. Revocations submitted before a final ruling on settlement approval do not need to include a waiver of objections and should follow the procedures described in the Medical Benefits Class Action Settlement.

Deepwater Horizon Medical Benefits Claims Administrator | 935 Gravier Street, Suite 1400 | New Orleans, LA 701 12 Phone: I-877-545-5 I I I | Website: www.deepwaterhorizonmedicalsettlement.com


http://www.deepwaterhorizonmedicalsettlement.com


BenjaminAllums

Text Box

EXHIBIT 4


NAME OF POTENTIAL CLASS MEMBER: Jpg huh kcti ADDRESS:

CITY: STATE:

PHONE:

DATE OF BIRTH:


ZIP CODE: 2MA.-1

GCCF ID (Optional):




Printed Name of Potential Class Member (or Authorized Representative)

/fi - 5--I Date

mature of Potential £farss Member r (or Authorized Representative)

*This form is for revocations submitted after a final ruling on settlement approval and before December 15, 2012 only. Revocations submitted before a final ruling on settlement approval do not need to include a waiver of objections and should follow the procedures described in the Medical Benefits Class Action Settlement.

Deepwater Horizon Medical Benefits Claims Administrator | 935 Gravier Street, Suite 1400 New Orleans, LA 701 12 Phone: 1-877-545-51 I I | Website: www.deepwaterhorizonmedicalsettlement.com


http://www.deepwaterhorizonmedicalsettlement.com


BenjaminAllums

Text Box

EXHIBIT 5


NAM E OF POTENTIAL CLASS MEMBER: trie Ta\\

ADDRESS:

CITY: /i ObJt STATE .Ac PHONE:

DATE OF BIRTH:


GCCF ID (Optional):

ZIP CODE




Printed Name of Potential Class Member (or Authorized Representative)

Signature of Potential Class Member (or Authorized Representative)

Date /

This form is for revocations submitted after a final ruling on settlement approval and before December 15, 2012 only. Revocations submitted before a final ruling on settlement approval do not need to include a waiver of objections and should follow the procedures described in the Medical Benefits Class Action Settlement.


p A C K E T 0 1 0 4 6 9


BenjaminAllums

Text Box

EXHIBIT 6

v. J

5c&Prt&Mie/u± Ao€

% fvUAjJbiii

^ECE/^,

DEC 24 2Q% l^(bjykf Woriuii /vitdi&l S^flwif

(Ifcr^S f-kLMiAi'SlnzJor

Q 26 (br&tfief&hrtbltSuiK li/oO Pieu} Or leo.fi, 701IQ

11)»> I! I I - t I I I 1111 I 111 I I I I 11 I I 11 J -t i F! 11 I I J ;l M ] 11»11 I ] I ] T I I M I J I



NAME OF POTENTIAL CLASS MEMBER: rnprr'iS

ADDRESS:JSq^ ftue.

CITY: n\\i\feUe STATE: All ZIP CODE: J&ficQ

PHONE:

DATE OF BIRTH:

SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER (Optional)

GCCF ID (Optional):


ATTORNEY (Optional): . 1


Mini hnrifiAM Printed Name of Potential Class Member Signature of Potential Class Member (or Authorized Representative) (or Authorized Representative)

This form is for revocations submitted after a f inal ruling on settlement approval and before December 15, 2012 only. Revocations submitted before a final ruling on settlement approval do not need to include a waiver of objections and should follow the procedures described in the Medical Benefits Class Action Settlement.


Deepwater Horizon Medical Benefits Claims Administrator 935 Gravier Street, Suite 1400 New Orleans, LA 70112 James Collier c/o Downs Law Group, PA 3250 Mary St, Ste 307 Coconut Grove, FL 33133

MEDICAL BENEFITS CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT

Date: 07/14/2017 Re: Explanation of Payment for Claim Number SPC0025547 Dear James Collier:

Enclosed is an Explanation of Payment for your Specified Physical Condition compensation in the Deepwater Horizon Medical Benefits Class Action Settlement. Please note that this Explanation of Payment does not reflect any amounts that your attorney may deduct for fees and expenses, in accordance with your agreement with your attorney. If you have any questions regarding the calculation of your payment or any of the information in the Explanation of Payment, please contact your attorney. You may also contact the Claims Administrator at (877) 545-5111. Sincerely,

DEEPWATER HORIZON MEDICAL BENEFITS CLAIMS ADMINISTRATOR


BenjaminAllums

Text Box

EXHIBIT 7

Explanation of Payment KEEP THIS COPY FOR YOUR RECORDS

James Collier c/o Downs Law Group, PA 07/14/2017 3250 Mary St, Ste 307 Coconut Grove, FL 33133

RE: MEDICAL BENEFITS CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT Claimant: James Collier – SPC0025547

Payment Determination: A1 Clean-Up Worker Lump Sum Award Amount ......................................................................................................... $1,300.00 Enhancer for Overnight Hospitalization – 0 day(s) ......................................................................... $0.00 Gross Settlement Award ....................................................................................................................................... $1,300.00

Plus Reimbursements: Actual Hospital Expenses .................................................................................................................. $0.00 Audit Copying and Scan .................................................................................................................... $0.00 Less: Medical Record Retrieval Fees ......................................................................................................... $0.00 Total Payable Award Amount ................................................................................................................................ $1,300.00

Less: Deductions for Liens and Other Interests Governmental Payers*

Medicare Part A and/or B .......................................................................................................... $0.00 Medicaid (Missouri)* ................................................................................................................. $0.00 Veterans Administration, TRICARE or Indian Health Services ...................................................$0.00

Medicare Part C or Part D Program Sponsors*……………….…………………...…...………….....……..……………$0.00

Other Payors/Providers*…………………………………………...…………….....……..………...…….....……..……………$0.00

Other Liens and Interests**

Rueb & Motta Law Firm c/o Nations Law Firm (Lien Holder from UCC Filing) .................... ($163.57)

Net Settlement Award ........................................................................................................................................... $1,136.43

Less: Total Amounts Previously Paid ......................................................................................................... $0.00 Net Settlement Award Currently Payable ............................................................................................................. $1,136.43

Payees of Net Settlement Award Currently Payable:

Downs Law Group, PA 3250 Mary St, Ste 307, Coconut Grove, FL 33133 $1,136.43


* As set forth in Section XXIX of the Medical Benefits Class Action Settlement Agreement, the Claims Administrator is responsible for identifying and resolving liens, claims, or rights of subrogation, indemnity, reimbursement, conditional or other payments, or interests of any type claimed or asserted by certain governmental and non-governmental healthcare payers and providers against the compensation or benefits you are eligible to receive pursuant to the Medical Settlement Agreement. If the Explanation of Payment shows a deduction from your compensation for one of the listed payers or providers, that payer or provider has asserted a lien, claim, right, or interest in or against your compensation, and the Claims Administrator is withholding the listed amount from your compensation while it works to resolve that lien, claim, right, or interest. Any amount not needed to satisfy the lien, claim, right, or interest will be disbursed to you at a later date. ** As set forth in Section XXIX.N of the Medical Benefits Class Action Settlement Agreement, if any employer, attorney, insurer and/or any other entity claims any rights such as liens, assignments, rights of subrogation, encumbrances, garnishments, security interests, or any other legally perfected right, other than the healthcare-related claims described above, with respect to a Medical Benefits Settlement Class Member’s compensation, the Claims Administrator is required to hold such compensation in an escrow account until the Claims Administrator determines that individual’s or entity’s rights to such compensation. If the Explanation of Payment shows that the Claims Administrator is withholding such an amount from your compensation, please provide the Claims Administrator with any information and/or documentation you have about the claim that you have not already provided to us. You may send the information and/or documentation to the address listed in the footer on this page.


EXHIBIT 8 - 911 Remaining B3 Plaintiffs with Materially Compliant PTO 66 Submissions - Alphabetical by Name

Row Plaintiff Name Case No.

1 Abdelfattah, Khaled 17-cv-03443

2 Adams, Rosia 17-cv-03000

3 Aguinaga, Steven Ray 17-cv-03173

4 Alexander, James 17-cv-03017

5 Alford, Olivia 17-cv-03018

6 Allen, Basil 17-cv-03447

7 Allen, Brenda Lee 17-cv-03479

8 Amaya-Rodriguez, Denis 17-cv-04127

9 Anderson, Bernice 17-cv-03020

10 Anderson, Christopher 17-cv-03023

11 Anderson, Latonya 17-cv-03022

12 Anderson, Shuanise 17-cv-03024

13 Antoine, Jintrin 17-cv-03885

14 Armstrong, Cynthia 17-cv-03021

15 Arrington, Rico 17-cv-03025

16 Ash, Marcus 17-cv-03026

17 Askew, Bruce 17-cv-03626

18 Assi, Mohammed 17-cv-03027

19 Aubert, Teandra 17-cv-03628

20 Bachi, Christian 17-cv-04129

21 Bachi, Colton 17-cv-04129

22 Bachi, Sabrina 17-cv-04129

23 Backstrom, David 17-cv-03029

24 Baggett, Vernon 17-cv-03030

25 Bailey, George 17-cv-03031

26 Baldo, Lisa Marie 17-cv-03368

27 Baltimore, Marilyn 17-cv-03032

28 Bank, Ryan Clayton 17-cv-03372

29 Banks, Christopher 17-cv-03033

30 Barkley, Joni Marie 13-cv-00995

31 Barkley, Ulysses Napoleon 13-cv-00998

32 Barksdale, Donald 17-cv-03034

33 Barlow, Torrey 12-cv-02248

34 Barnes, Kate 17-cv-03035

35 Barnes, Krystal 17-cv-03629

36 Barnes, Orlander 17-cv-03036

37 Barnes, Susan 17-cv-03630

38 Barrington, Chadwick 17-cv-03632

39 Bass, Samuel 17-cv-03037

40 Beacham, Lathaddeus Omar 17-cv-03038

41 Beachem, Cedric Taiwan 13-cv-01003

42 Bean, John 17-cv-03634

43 Becnel, Lisa 17-cv-03635

44 Beeler, Austin 17-cv-03039

45 Bell, Fabian 17-cv-03040

46 Belton, Roderick 17-cv-03480

47 Belvin-Fleming, Terrie 17-cv-03990

48 Bendolph, Donell 17-cv-03041

49 Bengson, Joshua 17-cv-03210

50 Bennett, Gwendolyn 17-cv-03042

51 Benoit, Bernice Ann 17-cv-03323

52 Benoit, Roy Paul 17-cv-03328

53 Benyard, Natalie 17-cv-03043

54 Berry, Justin Paul 17-cv-03044

1


BenjaminAllums

Text Box

EXHIBIT 8



55 Bertrand, Russell James 13-cv-00248

56 Beverly, Cleophus 17-cv-03482

57 Beverly, Joy 17-cv-03045

58 Bice Jr., Arthur R 14-cv-01155

59 Bice, Elizabeth Dae 14-cv-01155

60 Bice, Elizabeth Nicole 14-cv-01155

61 Binder, Sammie 17-cv-03636

62 Bivins, Clarance 17-cv-04130

63 Black, Jamarcus 17-cv-03483

64 Black, Lesia 17-cv-03047

65 Blackston, Kaden 17-cv-04131

66 Blackston, Kermit 17-cv-03637

67 Blackston, Savannah 17-cv-04131

68 Blackston, Victor 17-cv-03048

69 Blackwell, Cherrae 17-cv-03490

70 Blakley, Ashley 17-cv-03492

71 Bland, Daray 17-cv-03049

72 Blanks, Romond 17-cv-03050

73 Boatright, Michael E 17-cv-03111

74 Bodiford, Thomas 17-cv-03341

75 Boggs, Charles Archibald 16-cv-13476

76 Boler, Sterling 17-cv-03499

77 Bolton, Jonathan Joe 17-cv-04132

78 Bonilla, Sara 17-cv-04133

79 Bonvillain, Wayde 17-cv-04134

80 Booker, Dondy 17-cv-03051

81 Booker, Willie 17-cv-03052

82 Booth, Chianti 17-cv-03053

83 Bosarge, Dennis 17-cv-03639

84 Bosarge, Lorinda 17-cv-03639

85 Bowden Jr, William 17-cv-03506

86 Bowden, Teresa 17-cv-03505

87 Bowens, Charles 17-cv-03054

88 Boyles, Patricia Diane 17-cv-03243

89 Bradley, Eric 17-cv-04136

90 Bradley, Ervin 17-cv-03055

91 Braggs, Michael 17-cv-03887

92 Branch, McKinley 17-cv-03056

93 Brandon, Ta'Tanisha 17-cv-04137

94 Brandon, William 17-cv-03057

95 Brazzle, Velma 17-cv-03078

96 Brehm, William H 17-cv-03412

97 Brewer, Crystal 17-cv-04138

98 Brewer, John 17-cv-03079

99 Brewer, Thimus 17-cv-03508

100 Bridges, Clarence 17-cv-03080

101 Briggs, Jimmy 17-cv-03083

102 Brimage, Iesha 17-cv-03640

103 Brister, Courtney 17-cv-04652

104 Brister, Darrell 17-cv-04652

105 Britney, Micheln 17-cv-04437

106 Broadway Jr, Floyd 17-cv-03087

107 Brock, Krista Meja nka Fountain, Krista 17-cv-04139

108 Brooks, JT 17-cv-04655

2




109 Brooks, Karen 17-cv-03088

110 Broughton, Dewayne Nero 17-cv-03090

111 Brown, Arthur 17-cv-03093

112 Brown, Cher 17-cv-03516

113 Brown, Donna 17-cv-04141

114 Brown, Estate of Bryan 17-cv-04140

115 Brown, Jamie 12-cv-02333

116 Brown, Joseph 12-cv-02333

117 Brown, Lena 17-cv-03097

118 Brown, Michael Todd 17-cv-03366

119 Brown, Ray S 17-cv-03099

120 Brown, Regina 17-cv-04142

121 Brown, Rennell 17-cv-03101

122 Brown, Reynard 17-cv-03104

123 Brown, Rochelle 17-cv-04143

124 Brown, Shah 17-cv-03641

125 Brown, Shonte 17-cv-03519

126 Bruce, Shane Maddox 18-cv-02626

127 Brumfield, Curtis 17-cv-04499

128 Brumfield, Deja'Jana 17-cv-04562

129 Brumfield, Herbert 17-cv-03107

130 Brunet Jr., Levy J 17-cv-02672

131 Bruton, Joseph 17-cv-03110

132 Bryant, Eric 17-cv-03114

133 Buckingham, Kathy Elaine 17-cv-04649

134 Buckley, Barbara 17-cv-03115

135 Bueno-Alba, Jose 17-cv-03523

136 Bunch, John 17-cv-04144

137 Burkett, Craig Michael 17-cv-03681

138 Burns, Albert 17-cv-03117

139 Bush, Douglas 17-cv-03118

140 Butler III, Milton 17-cv-03075

141 Butler, Debra 17-cv-03077

142 Butler, Lakesha 17-cv-04145

143 Butler, Michael 17-cv-04153

144 Byrd, Brandon 17-cv-03073

145 Byrd, George 17-cv-03070

146 Byrd, Jennifer 17-cv-03642

147 Caldwell, Stephon 13-cv-01007

148 Cambre, Andoche 17-cv-03643

149 Campbell, Sharon 17-cv-03119

150 Campbell, Trevor 17-cv-03524

151 Cantillo, Dwaine 17-cv-03226

152 Caraway, Michael 17-cv-03120

153 Card, Lora Ann 17-cv-03121

154 Cargill, Markeelin 17-cv-03644

155 Carpenter, Otis 17-cv-03645

156 Carter, Charles 17-cv-03123

157 Caser Jr, Willie 17-cv-03525

158 Castleberry, Jackie 17-cv-04154

159 Castleberry, Jeffrey 17-cv-04154

160 Castleberry-Ford, Jancey 17-cv-04154

161 Catchings, Dawn 17-cv-03124

162 Causey, Roy 17-cv-03888

3




163 Chambers, Brianne 17-cv-04067

164 Chapman, Shata 17-cv-04155

165 Chapman, Tatyana 17-cv-04155

166 Charles, Corey 17-cv-03125

167 Chatman, vonshea 17-cv-03646

168 Cheramie, Estate of Rodney Joseph 17-cv-04507

169 Cheramie, Gabrielle 17-cv-04502

170 Cintra, Elvis 17-cv-03889

171 Clay, Christopher 17-cv-03526

172 Coastal Water Cleaners and Environmental Services, LLC 11-cv-02621

173 Coco, III, Malcolm Alphonse 17-cv-03393

174 Colbert, Edward 17-cv-03647

175 Colburn, Rita 17-cv-03648

176 Cole, Willie 17-cv-03649

177 Coleman, Barbara 17-cv-03127

178 Coleman, Charles 17-cv-04157

179 Coleman, Herbert 17-cv-03128

180 Coleman, Lillie 17-cv-03130

181 Coleman, Steve 17-cv-04158

182 Collier, Nicholas W 17-cv-03356

183 Collier, Patrick 17-cv-03131

184 Conley, Fred 17-cv-03650

185 Coon, George 17-cv-03686

186 Cotton, Cillo 17-cv-03132

187 Cotton, Gary 17-cv-03133

188 Couture, Jr., Raymond 17-cv-03373

189 Craig, Anthony 17-cv-03134

190 Cranmer, Danielle 17-cv-03688

191 Crawford, Olivia 17-cv-03135

192 Crawford, Patrick 17-cv-03136

193 Crosby, Melton III 17-cv-03689

194 Crumpton, Carolyn 17-cv-03527

195 Cuevas, Dean 17-cv-03137

196 Culberson, Renell 17-cv-04159

197 Curbelo, Ivan 17-cv-03690

198 Dailey, Lucy 17-cv-03528

199 Dang, Anh Ngoc 17-cv-02387

200 Daniel, Dana 17-cv-04160

201 Daniel, Eileen 17-cv-04309

202 Daniels, Estee 17-cv-04392

203 Daniels, Robert Jr. 17-cv-04394

204 Danos, Janice Marie 17-cv-03240

205 Danos, Jorey Tristan 17-cv-03113

206 Danos, Richard Thomas 17-cv-03240

207 Dardar Sr, Benny 17-cv-03138

208 Darrington, Lequaita 17-cv-03139

209 Dasco, Leif 17-cv-03531

210 Davenport, Kevin 17-cv-03725

211 Davenport, Larry 17-cv-03726

212 Davis, Frederick 17-cv-03140

213 Davis, Luke III 17-cv-04310

214 Davis, Mary 17-cv-03141

215 Davis, Michael 17-cv-04664

216 Davis, Sedija 17-cv-04312

4




217 Davis, Travis 17-cv-04313

218 Davison, Sandra 17-cv-03142

219 Davis-Sherrod, Myesha 17-cv-04314

220 Dawkins, Frederick 17-cv-03533

221 Dean, Michael (Conditionally Compliant) 17-cv-06800

222 DeBose, Chrishawn Derrick 17-cv-03680

223 DeBose, Jimmy Raymond 17-cv-03675

224 DeBose, Karen Ann 17-cv-03670

225 Dedeaux, Yolanda 17-cv-03143

226 Deese, Eric 17-cv-03144

227 Delmar, Karis 17-cv-04648

228 DeLoach, Robert 17-cv-03149

229 DePaz, Susana 17-cv-03892

230 Dial, Jack 17-cv-03150

231 Dill, Johnny 17-cv-04315

232 Dinkins, Michael 17-cv-04319

233 Dixey, Heather 17-cv-04320

234 Dixey, Jordan 17-cv-04321

235 Dixon, Michael 17-cv-03900

236 Do, Yen 17-cv-03903

237 Dobbs, Terresa 17-cv-03152

238 Doom, Christian Michael 17-cv-04395

239 Doom, Danielle 17-cv-04395

240 Doom, Gavin 17-cv-04395

241 Doom, Kathryn 17-cv-04395

242 Doom, Paul Matthew 17-cv-04395

243 Doom, Paul Raymond 17-cv-04395

244 Dorsey, Wilbert 17-cv-03154

245 Doud, Elizabeth 17-cv-03534

246 Ducksworth, Vantavious L. 17-cv-03157

247 Duke, Tiffany Savage 16-cv-13873

248 Dukes, Marshall 17-cv-03159

249 Dumas, David P. 17-cv-03160

250 Dumas, Hakim 17-cv-04322

251 Durden, Angela Laverne 17-cv-03536

252 Durham, Keith E. 17-cv-03537

253 Durr, Mario 17-cv-03538

254 Dwyer, Derek Thomas 13-cv-01010

255 Dykes, Wendell 17-cv-04323

256 Easterling, Tonnie 17-cv-03913

257 Edwards, Al 17-cv-04324

258 Edwards, Junior 17-cv-03928

259 Edwards, Natasha 17-cv-03957

260 Elliott, Cynthia Anne 13-cv-01011

261 Ellzey, Eric D. 17-cv-03163

262 Elrod, Aiden Connor 17-cv-03334

263 Elrod, Jarod Shane 17-cv-03331

264 Elzey, Estate of Johnny 17-cv-03985

265 England, Thomas M. 17-cv-03180

266 English, Elizabeth Sibley 17-cv-03182

267 English, Jr., Eugene 17-cv-03182

268 English, Mervin 17-cv-04325

269 Estate of Alan Henderson 17-cv-03273

270 Estate of Alvin Holifield 17-cv-03284

5




271 Estate of Chavis Allen 17-cv-03019

272 Estate of Joe May, Jr. 17-cv-04550

273 Estate of Kimlyn Preatto 17-cv-04556

274 Estate of Leona Austin 17-cv-04128

275 Estate of Raymond Lirette 17-cv-03333

276 Estate of Sherrie McKinley 17-cv-04562

277 Evans, Keywaski 17-cv-04326

278 Evans, Robert 16-cv-03966

279 Expose, Bernard 17-cv-03986

280 Fairley, Alford 17-cv-03184

281 Fairley, Freddie 17-cv-03988

282 Fairley, Royce 17-cv-03188

283 Fast, William 17-cv-03989

284 Favorite, Carl 17-cv-03192

285 Ferguson, Minnie 17-cv-04327

286 Fetterhoff, Carol Lynn 17-cv-03350

287 Fetterhoff, Chayton Lee 17-cv-03350

288 Fetterhoff, Chelsea Lynn 17-cv-03350

289 Fielder, Cheryl 17-cv-03193

290 Fitzgerald, Nathan Joseph 13-cv-00650

291 Flair, Kimberly 17-cv-03161

292 Fleming, James 17-cv-03195

293 Flournoy, David Allen Sr. 17-cv-04396

294 Flournoy, Jr., David 17-cv-04396

295 Flournoy, Nancy 17-cv-04396

296 Ford, Leslie 17-cv-03198

297 Fountain, John 17-cv-03200

298 Fountain, Mary 17-cv-03202

299 Fountain, Reginald 17-cv-03204

300 Fowler, Julian 17-cv-03208

301 Foxworth, Jackulin 17-cv-03991

302 Foxworth, Tiffany 17-cv-04328

303 Francisco, Mark 17-cv-03212

304 Franichevich, Andrew 17-cv-03992

305 Franklin, Jr., Charles M. 17-cv-03215

306 Franks, Robert 17-cv-03216

307 Frazier, Debra 17-cv-03219

308 Fugatt, Curtis Carl 13-cv-01014

309 Fuller III., Robert Dewery 13-cv-05372

310 Gaines, Shawndaius 17-cv-04329

311 Gainey, Carolyn 17-cv-03993

312 Gainey, Estate of Russell 17-cv-03993

313 Gamble, James 17-cv-03994

314 Gara, Dennis 17-cv-03223

315 Garcia, John 17-cv-03541

316 Gardner, Sandra 17-cv-03224

317 Garlow, Clarence 17-cv-04330

318 Gaspard, Jamie Lee 13-cv-04437

319 Gathers, Renee 17-cv-03229

320 Gentry, Brandon 17-cv-03995

321 Gilliam, Earl 17-cv-03234

322 Gilmore, Arthur 17-cv-03236

323 Giusti, Jr., Ernest 17-cv-03996

324 Godfrey, Scott 17-cv-04331

6




325 Goldsmith, Marcine 17-cv-03256

326 Gomes, Tevon 17-cv-04332

327 Gonzales, James 17-cv-04333

328 Gonzalez, Hector 17-cv-03257

329 Gooding, John 17-cv-03238

330 Granier, Stephen 17-cv-02674

331 Grant, Marcus 17-cv-04334

332 Graves, Carl 17-cv-04335

333 Gray, Michael 17-cv-04336

334 Gray, Princess 17-cv-04660

335 Green, Birmella 17-cv-04337

336 Green, Christopher Alan 17-cv-03191

337 Green, Timothy 17-cv-03997

338 Griffin, Alice Mae 17-cv-03244

339 Griffin, Kacey W. 17-cv-03258

340 Griffin, Marshall D. 17-cv-03259

341 Guess, Serena 17-cv-03260

342 Hakenjos, Jamerson 17-cv-04338

343 Hall, Lanycha 17-cv-03998

344 Hall, Lorinzo 17-cv-03261

345 Halsell, Edwin 17-cv-03262

346 Hamilton, Terrence 17-cv-03263

347 Hampton, Jerry Paul 13-cv-03929

348 Hardy, Ronnie 17-cv-04339

349 Harewood, Kirk 17-cv-04340

350 Harmon, James 17-cv-04341

351 Harris Jr, Ezzard 17-cv-04344

352 Harris, Al'Terryal 17-cv-04342

353 Harris, Cedric 17-cv-03264

354 Harris, Charles 17-cv-03265

355 Harris, Derry 17-cv-04343

356 Harris, Elvis 17-cv-03266

357 Harris, Rushion 17-cv-03267

358 Harris, Terrance 17-cv-04345

359 Harris, Tyron 17-cv-03268

360 Harrison, Kennard 17-cv-04346

361 Harry, Jerome 17-cv-04347

362 Harvey, Khristi 17-cv-03269

363 Hasdorff, Beverly Ann Painton 17-cv-03235

364 Hasdorff, Terri 17-cv-03233

365 Hatcher, Dana 17-cv-04348

366 Hatcher, Daniel Veryle 17-cv-03179

367 Hawthorne, Ayana 17-cv-03270

368 Hayes, Isaac 17-cv-04397

369 Hayes, Isaiah 17-cv-04397

370 Hayes, Mary 17-cv-04397

371 Hayes, Rodney 17-cv-04349

372 Haynes, Alexander 17-cv-03271

373 Haynes, Almetis 17-cv-04350

374 Haynes, Willie 17-cv-03272

375 Heathington, Thomas 17-cv-04353

376 Hebert, Paul Anthony 11-cv-01200

377 Henderson, Wayne 17-cv-03275

378 Hendrix, Mitchell 17-cv-04354

7




379 Henson, Jr James 17-cv-03276

380 Henson, Sr James 17-cv-03277

381 Hicks, Keundra 17-cv-04356

382 Higginbotham, Dorothy Clayton 17-cv-03315

383 Hill, Robyn Lyn 17-cv-03252

384 Hill, Sherry 17-cv-03278

385 Hillard, Julius 17-cv-03279

386 Hines, Thomas Jr. 17-cv-03280

387 Hinton, Arlene 17-cv-04357

388 Hockaday, Edison 17-cv-03281

389 Hodge, Charlie 17-cv-03282

390 Hohnadell, Alec 17-cv-03999

391 Hohnadell, Gale 17-cv-03999

392 Hohnadell, Kimberly 17-cv-03999

393 Holder, Dane II 17-cv-03283

394 Holifield, Eric 17-cv-04358

395 Holifield, Gollie 17-cv-04359

396 Hooker, Jarvis 17-cv-04065

397 Horne, Haley 17-cv-04568

398 Horne, Karem 17-cv-03285

399 Houser, Bruce 17-cv-04360

400 Howard, John L 17-cv-03347

401 Howard, Larry 17-cv-03543

402 Howell, Frank Morris 17-cv-03232

403 Howell, Patricia 17-cv-03287

404 Howze, Alfonso Cardell 17-cv-03288

405 Huddleston, Carson Cortez 17-cv-03289

406 Hudley, Daniel Robert 10-cv-04200

407 Hudson, Mark 17-cv-04361

408 Hudson, Travis 17-cv-04362

409 Hughes, William Robert 17-cv-04363

410 Hundley, Clamus 17-cv-03290

411 Hunt, Bruce Donald 13-cv-01017

412 Hunter, Dale Anthony 13-cv-03147

413 Hurd, Shikiah 17-cv-04364

414 Hurd, Steven 17-cv-04000

415 Hurd, Theresa 17-cv-03545

416 Huynh, Trong 17-cv-03291

417 Hye, Ella 17-cv-03292

418 Hye, Terry 17-cv-03293

419 Isom, Cedric 17-cv-04365

420 Jackson, Anthony 17-cv-03294

421 Jackson, Brenda 17-cv-03295

422 Jackson, Christola 17-cv-03296

423 Jackson, Greogry 17-cv-03297

424 Jackson, Marcus 17-cv-03298

425 Jackson, Sharon 17-cv-03299

426 Jackson, Tarus 17-cv-04366

427 Jacobs, Euweeka 17-cv-03300

428 Jacquez, Jose 17-cv-03301

429 Jaouhari, Hilal 17-cv-03302

430 Jenkins, Chris 17-cv-03303

431 Jenkins, Terri 17-cv-04367

432 Jesco Construction Corporation of Delaware 11-cv-00911

8




433 Johns, Joan 17-cv-03304

434 Johnson Jr, Travis 17-cv-04399

435 Johnson, Beaux 17-cv-03305

436 Johnson, Carl 17-cv-04369

437 Johnson, Carmine 17-cv-03306

438 Johnson, Chestere 17-cv-03307

439 Johnson, Deborah 17-cv-04370

440 Johnson, Gena 17-cv-04371

441 Johnson, Grady 17-cv-03308

442 Johnson, Lisa;Williams, Lisa Allean 17-cv-04372

443 Johnson, Reginald 17-cv-04647

444 Johnson, Roderick 17-cv-04373

445 Johnson, Stephen 17-cv-04374

446 Johnson, Victoria 17-cv-04399

447 Johson, Aaron 17-cv-04368

448 Joiner, Richard 17-cv-03310

449 Jones, Al'Lisha 17-cv-04375

450 Jones, Andre 17-cv-04376

451 Jones, Brandon 17-cv-04378

452 Jones, Charlene 17-cv-03312

453 Jones, Cynthia 17-cv-04377

454 Jones, Edward 17-cv-04379

455 Jones, Howard 17-cv-04380

456 Jones, Larry 17-cv-04381

457 Jones, Marvin Earl 17-cv-04382

458 Jones, Sammie 17-cv-04383

459 Jones, Tekira 17-cv-04384

460 Jones, Travis 17-cv-04385

461 Joseph, Eldridge 17-cv-04386

462 Jourden, Forest 17-cv-04569

463 Kalinowski, Kevin 17-cv-04387

464 Kaoui, Peter M. 17-cv-03313

465 Keller, Brian Edward 17-cv-01018

466 Kendrick, Jared Lee 13-cv-03928

467 Kenner, Taijahrell 17-cv-03314

468 Keyes, Christine Cook 14-cv-02211

469 Keys, Ernestine 17-cv-04389

470 Kidd, Larry 17-cv-04390

471 Kiff, Hank J. 12-cv-03179

472 King, Clifton 17-cv-04393

473 King, Dewayne 17-cv-04398

474 King, Tai-Keysha 17-cv-04398

475 Kirkland, Christopher 17-cv-04391

476 Kolian, Stephan R 17-cv-03108

477 LaBrosse, Jeremiah 17-cv-04401

478 LaForce, Allen Bradley 17-cv-04402

479 Landers, Jason Eugene 13-cv-01019

480 Landrieu, David Joseph 17-cv-03161

481 Landry, Cy 17-cv-03317

482 Laneaux, Eureaka 17-cv-04403

483 Lartigue, Roger 17-cv-03353

484 Laster, Patrick Jr 17-cv-03319

485 Lawrence, Jamie 17-cv-04654

486 Lawson Environmental Services, LLC 12-cv-00740

9




487 Lawson, Telly 17-cv-04404

488 Lawton, Diana 17-cv-03320

489 Le, Trinh 17-cv-04001

490 Le, Trinity 17-cv-04001

491 Learn, Cherry 17-cv-03321

492 Learn, Michael 17-cv-03322

493 Leathwood, Charles 17-cv-04405

494 Lee Jr, Elbert 17-cv-04406

495 Lee, Ava 17-cv-04558

496 Lee, Kathy 17-cv-04407

497 Lee, Terrance 17-cv-04558

498 Lee, Tiffany Monique 16-cv-13874

499 Lenard, Dalan 17-cv-03546

500 Lepoma, Mary 17-cv-04408

501 Lett, Hibbard 17-cv-04409

502 Leverette, Clyde 17-cv-03324

503 Lewis Jr, Ulyses 17-cv-03330

504 Lewis, Glenda 17-cv-03325

505 Lewis, Lashona 17-cv-04410

506 Lewis, Sherrie 17-cv-03329

507 Loftus, Wesley 17-cv-03339

508 Lopez, Irene 17-cv-04415

509 Louisiana Workers' Compensation Corporation 10-cv-02771

510 Lucky, Ethel 17-cv-03340

511 Lundy, Luke 17-cv-04417

512 Lutin, Frederick 17-cv-04419

513 Mackles, Duke 17-cv-04002

514 Mackles, Shane 17-cv-04003

515 Macon, Willie 17-cv-03548

516 Maddox, Jeffery 17-cv-04560

517 Maddox, Josephine 17-cv-04560

518 Magee, Andrea 17-cv-04399

519 Magee, Richard 17-cv-03549

520 Magee, Virdee 17-cv-04561

521 Magee, Whitney 17-cv-04561

522 Magee, Xavier 17-cv-04561

523 Maneen, Rachel Renee 17-cv-03183

524 Mann, Maxie 17-cv-04421

525 Manning, Anthony 17-cv-04422

526 Manquel Liddell, Kendrick Sharonta 17-cv-03332

527 Marler, Gregory Lee 17-cv-03206

528 Marshall-Reech, Angie 17-cv-04564

529 Martin, Chris Albert 17-cv-03228

530 Martin, Clifton 17-cv-04004

531 Martin, Flint 17-cv-03358

532 Martin, Jennifer Ann 17-cv-03228

533 Martin, Lizzie 17-cv-04424

534 Martin, Sterling 17-cv-03249

535 Martin, Tatasha 17-cv-04429

536 Martin, Trudy 17-cv-03360

537 Matthews, Cleveland 17-cv-04005

538 Matthis, Shawna 17-cv-03550

539 Matulonis, Anthony Jason 13-cv-01512

540 Maurras, Douglas John 17-cv-03185

10




541 May, Derrick 17-cv-04068

542 Mayfield, Anthony 17-cv-03364

543 McArthur, Corey 17-cv-03371

544 McCall, Verda 17-cv-03551

545 McCammon, Larry 17-cv-03375

546 McCann, Missouri 17-cv-04006

547 McClendon, Dorothy 17-cv-03379

548 McConaghy, Kade 17-cv-03116

549 McConaghy, Kara 17-cv-03116

550 McConaghy, Kent 17-cv-03116

551 MCConaghy, Kohl 17-cv-03116

552 McCray, Anthony 17-cv-03552

553 McDaniel, Ronald 17-cv-04069

554 McDonald, Bobby 17-cv-04432

555 McDonald, David 17-cv-04434

556 McDougle, Derrick 17-cv-03386

557 McElroy, Alexis 17-cv-04070

558 McGill, Erik 17-cv-03392

559 McGill, Jeremy 17-cv-03395

560 McGill, Ray 17-cv-04071

561 McInnis, Jr., Jacques 17-cv-03555

562 McInnis, Sr., Jacques 17-cv-03556

563 McInnis, Traci 17-cv-04436

564 McIntosh, William Dante 13-cv-01020

565 McKay, Melina 17-cv-04072

566 McMeans, Charles 17-cv-03558

567 McMillan, Jeffari 17-cv-03396

568 McQueen, Henry 17-cv-03563

569 Meadows, Alton Rockford 13-cv-01746

570 Medel, Jesse 17-cv-03564

571 Merchant, Raymond Joe 15-cv-04290

572 Michael, III, Frank 17-cv-04563

573 Michael, Trai 17-cv-03565

574 Mickles, Shantae 17-cv-03566

575 Millender, Raymond 17-cv-04439

576 Miller, Carolyn 17-cv-04441

577 Miller, James 17-cv-02678

578 Miller, Jerry 17-cv-04444

579 Miller, Taschet 17-cv-03569

580 Miller, Timothy Bennett 17-cv-03398

581 Mills, Kenneth 17-cv-04448

582 Milsap, Angela 17-cv-04449

583 Milsap, Dennis 17-cv-04451

584 Minor, Michael 17-cv-04073

585 Minton, Lee 17-cv-03400

586 Moore, Albert B III 17-cv-03571

587 Moore, Albert R IV 17-cv-03572

588 Moore, Anthony 17-cv-04453

589 Moore, Anthony W 17-cv-04454

590 Moore, April 17-cv-04456

591 Moore, Charles 17-cv-03573

592 Moore, Cheryl 17-cv-04657

593 Moore, Cynthia 17-cv-04074

594 Moore, Dennis 17-cv-03574

11




595 Moore, Felicia 17-cv-03576

596 Moore, Kendall 17-cv-03402

597 Moore, Sandra 17-cv-04457

598 Moorere, Holly 17-cv-04461

599 Morgan, James 17-cv-03187

600 Morgan, Taccari 17-cv-03579

601 Murphy, Lorinzo 13-cv-01031

602 Murray, Kelvin 17-cv-03582

603 Nance, Jimmy 17-cv-04462

604 Naples, John 12-cv-02564

605 Naquin, Bryant 17-cv-03584

606 Naquin, Velma 17-cv-03586

607 Nehlig, Chris Emile 17-cv-03376

608 Nelson, Robert Jr 17-cv-04075

609 Nestle, Stephen 17-cv-04463

610 Netherland, Gabriella 17-cv-04559

611 Netherland, Jonathan 17-cv-04559

612 Newton, Brandon 17-cv-03588

613 Ngo, Phieu 17-cv-04464

614 Nguyen, Hillary 17-cv-04465

615 Nguyen, Hung Van 17-cv-04467

616 Nguyen, Kha 17-cv-04468

617 Norris, Daphne 17-cv-04565

618 Norswearthy, Chester Jr 17-cv-03590

619 Norwood, Austin 17-cv-03203

620 Norwood, Margaret 17-cv-03203

621 Novelozo, Ulric Adriel 13-cv-01033

622 Odoms Jr., Alonzo 16-cv-13201

623 Olds, Joe Annie 17-cv-03591

624 O'Neal, Estate of Richard 17-cv-04076

625 Orange, Tony 17-cv-03592

626 Osbey, Christopher 17-cv-04470

627 Pace, Linda 17-cv-04471

628 Packer, Patrick 17-cv-04077

629 Paige, Cynthia 17-cv-03594

630 Parker, Edward 17-cv-04078

631 Patterson, Dana 17-cv-04079

632 Patton, Carlos 17-cv-04473

633 Payton, Alexzander 17-cv-04474

634 Paz, Cesar 17-cv-04557

635 Paz, Cesar Andrew Jr. 17-cv-04557

636 Paz, Isreal 17-cv-04557

637 Paz, Keren 17-cv-04557

638 Peairs, Marcus 17-cv-03596

639 Pearson, Barbara 17-cv-03597

640 Pejic, Nenad 17-cv-04475

641 Penn, Tavarish 17-cv-04080

642 Pennington, Kathy 17-cv-04280

643 Perdomo, Henry Giovanni 17-cv-03346

644 Perkins, Isaac 17-cv-04476

645 Peschlow, Mark 17-cv-03598

646 Peters, Rhett 17-cv-04479

647 Pettaway, Denise 17-cv-03404

648 Pettaway, John 17-cv-03599

12




649 Pettway, Delrick 17-cv-04481

650 Pettway, Sandra 17-cv-04146

651 Phillips, Angela 17-cv-04163

652 Phillips, Bryant 17-cv-04281

653 Pickett, George 17-cv-04482

654 Picou, Donna 17-cv-03207

655 Pinell, Richard J DBA Billy Sue, Inc 17-cv-03349

656 Plummer, Edna 17-cv-04483

657 Poirson, Patrick

17-cv-03177

17-cv-03378

658 Polk, Felton 17-cv-04282

659 Polk, Tonta 17-cv-03600

660 Porter, Scott Alan 17-cv-03344

661 Pough, Ervin 17-cv-04164

662 Powe, Andre 17-cv-04484

663 Powell, Donald 17-cv-04489

664 Powell, Whirlee 17-cv-04283

665 Prest Sr, Kirk Edgar 17-cv-03409

666 Prestenbach, Anthony 17-cv-04570

667 Price, Calvin Sr 17-cv-04571

668 Price, James 17-cv-04572

669 Pritchett Jr., Wilbert Devon 17-cv-03231

670 Quiroz, Robert 17-cv-04166

671 Ramey, Robert 17-cv-03405

672 Ranson, Ron 17-cv-04168

673 Rawls, Derrick 17-cv-04509

674 Reeb, Michael 17-cv-03602

675 Reech, Riley 17-cv-04564

676 Reed, Antonio 17-cv-04174

677 Reed, Chester 17-cv-03603

678 Regan, Laura 13-cv-02378

679 Regan, Robert 13-cv-02378

680 Revels, Carl 17-cv-04175

681 Richard, Tyrone 17-cv-04284

682 Richardson, A'Donna 17-cv-03407

683 Richoux, Denise Malcombe 17-cv-03186

684 Riddell-Hare, Teresa 17-cv-04177

685 Riley, Darren 17-cv-04304

686 Roan, Kenneth 17-cv-04178

687 Roberson, Raynard 17-cv-04286

688 Roberts, Cynthia 17-cv-03605

689 Roberts, Frances 17-cv-04513

690 Robertson, Carrie 17-cv-04573

691 Robin, III, Charles Raymond 17-cv-03381

692 Robin, Jr., Ricky R 17-cv-03383

693 Robin, Ricky Raymond 17-cv-03389

694 Robinson, Brian 17-cv-03606

695 Robinson, Crystal 15-cv-06131

696 Robinson, Patrick 17-cv-04574

697 Robinson, Ricco Jr. 17-cv-04536

698 Rogers, Betty 17-cv-04575

699 Rooks, Darla 17-cv-04400

700 Rooks, Todd 17-cv-04400

701 Ross, Erica 17-cv-04287

13




702 Ross, Vanessa 17-cv-04288

703 Rounds, Gregory 17-cv-04576

704 Rye, Patricia Marie 17-cv-03155

705 Sanchez, Victoria Angelina Avila 12-cv-00164

706 Saxton, Latonya 17-cv-04577

707 Scaief, Veronica 17-cv-04242

708 Scarborough, Michael 17-cv-04243

709 Schexnayder, Farrell D 17-cv-03207

710 Schexnayder, Gary Lane 17-cv-03207

711 Schexnayder, Larry 17-cv-03207

712 Schmidt, Michelle 17-cv-04279

713 Schmidt, Rachel 17-cv-04179

714 Scott, Barbara 17-cv-03608

715 Scott, Codie 17-cv-04578

716 Scott, Corey 17-cv-04554

717 Scott, Joliegh 17-cv-04554

718 Scott, Katrina 17-cv-04579

719 Scott, Matthew 17-cv-04554

720 Scott, Nakia 17-cv-03609

721 Scott, Nicole 17-cv-04554

722 Seay, Sharitye 17-cv-04244

723 Sebastian, Herbert 17-cv-04355

724 Sellers, Terrance 17-cv-03610

725 Sewell, Carolyn 17-cv-04245

726 Sewer, Misha 17-cv-04581

727 Shade, Twinella 17-cv-04246

728 Shannon, Tory 17-cv-03611

729 Shearon, Jr. Ronald Franklin 17-cv-03155

730 Shearon, Karla June 17-cv-03155

731 Shearon, Kenzie Joy 17-cv-03155

732 Shepard, Lori 17-cv-04582

733 Sherrod, Christopher 17-cv-03410

734 Siegel, Barton J 13-cv-00768

735 Simmons, Blake 17-cv-04553

736 Simmons, Gayla 17-cv-04248

737 Simmons, Kevin 17-cv-04553

738 Simmons, Kevin II 17-cv-04553

739 Simmons, Tony 17-cv-04583

740 Simon, Jamie Marie 11-cv-01432

741 Sketteno, Samuel Jr 17-cv-04181

742 Slaughter, Bobby 17-cv-04584

743 Sledge, Raymond 17-cv-04249

744 Smith, Cindy 17-cv-04180

745 Smith, LaJoy 17-cv-04250

746 Smith, Lee A. 17-cv-04586

747 Smith, Linda Trotter 17-cv-04251

748 Smith, Tyrone 17-cv-04551

749 Sonnier, Jason 17-cv-04252

750 Spencer, Rita 17-cv-04253

751 Spencer, Trellis 17-cv-04254

752 Sproat, Nancy Lee 17-cv-04255

753 Spurlock, Deedra 17-cv-04256

754 St. Ann, John 17-cv-04257

755 Stallworth, Beste 17-cv-04566

14




756 Stallworth, Gloria 17-cv-03411

757 Stallworth, III, Ben 17-cv-03612

758 Stallworth, Josiah 17-cv-04514

759 Stallworth, Marlon 17-cv-04183

760 Stanton, Patrick 17-cv-04258

761 Steiner, Machelle F 17-cv-03387

762 Stennis, Ernest 17-cv-04590

763 Stephens Jr, Thomas 17-cv-04520

764 Stephens, Randi 17-cv-04294

765 Stephens, Sr., Thomas 17-cv-04592

766 Stepleton, Charles 17-cv-04588

767 Stewart, Alpenaton 17-cv-04184

768 Stewart, Elizabeth 17-cv-04299

769 Stewart, Jr., Lloyd 17-cv-03613

770 Stockstill, Damien 17-cv-04400

771 Stockstill, Daniel 17-cv-04400

772 Storey, Daniel 17-cv-04593

773 Stovall, Lambert 17-cv-04640

774 Strauss, Robert 17-cv-03615

775 Street, Carrington 17-cv-04259

776 Street, Corey 17-cv-03619

777 Street, Don 17-cv-04300

778 Street, Shadronica 17-cv-04260

779 Stricklin, Samhouston 17-cv-04552

780 Stubbs, Estate of Jesse 17-cv-04261

781 Summerall, Tara 17-cv-04643

782 Summers, Andrea 17-cv-04262

783 Sunseri, Anthony 17-cv-04263

784 Swaney, Julie 17-cv-04186

785 Swanier, Marqueda 17-cv-04644

786 Tabokka Chapman, Jr 17-cv-04155

787 Tate, Curtis 17-cv-04264

788 Taylor, Charles William 17-cv-03222

789 Taylor, Jeremy 17-cv-04190

790 Taylor, Kimberly 17-cv-04603

791 Taylor, Robert Vaughan 17-cv-03201

792 Taylor, Shana 17-cv-04191

793 Tebbs, Michael 17-cv-04605

794 Tebbs, Sheila 17-cv-04606

795 Terrebonne, Betty Ann 17-cv-04549

796 Terrebonne, Jr., Gary 17-cv-04192

797 Terrebonne, Sr., Gary 17-cv-04549

798 Thomas, Carlos 17-cv-04608

799 Thomas, David Jr. 17-cv-04556

800 Thomas, Kendrick 17-cv-04195

801 Thomas, Kennedy 17-cv-04301

802 Thomas, Lakesha on Behalf of the Estate of Jimmie Thomas 17-cv-04547

803 Thomas, Raymond 17-cv-04595

804 Thompson, Adonis 17-cv-04198

805 Thompson, Brian 17-cv-04265

806 Thompson, Christopher 17-cv-04609

807 Thompson, DeForrest 17-cv-04611

808 Thompson, Randy 17-cv-04202

809 Tickell, Rebecca Harrell 17-cv-03169

15




810 Timmons, Frances 17-cv-04266

811 Tobias, Warren 17-cv-04613

812 Toler, Juanita 17-cv-04267

813 Tolliver, Michael 17-cv-04268

814 Torres, Esmerelda 17-cv-04204

815 Townser, Frank N. III 17-cv-04519

816 Townser, Jr., Frank 17-cv-04205

817 Traylor Evans, Gabrielle 17-cv-04302

818 Treme, Josh 17-cv-04269

819 Triplett, Danny 17-cv-04270

820 Trotter, Marvin Kenneth 17-cv-03621

821 Troxler, Jr., Clifford 17-cv-04207

822 Turner, Gregory Scott 17-cv-03225

823 Turner, Judy A. 17-cv-04614

824 Turner, Michael 17-cv-04210

825 Turner, Michael Anthony 17-cv-01035

826 Turner, Tonie 17-cv-04214

827 Turner, Vickey 17-cv-04616

828 United States Environmental Services, LLC 17-cv-03370

829

United States Maritime Services, Inc. d/b/a United States

Maritime Services, LLC

17-cv-03382

17-cv-03388

830 Upchurch, Amanda Johnson 17-cv-03413

831 Vaughan, Jeff R 17-cv-03250

832 Vaughan, Rochelle Avila 17-cv-03250

833 Vazquez, Jr., Eric 17-cv-04617

834 Veal, Ernest 17-cv-04215

835 Vickers, Michael Brandon 13-cv-00456

836 Vicknair, Rachel Rost 17-cv-04517

837 Villere, Jane 17-cv-04217

838 Waddell, Tyrell 17-cv-04271

839 Wade, James 17-cv-04624

840 Walker, Allen 17-cv-03012

841 Walker, Cynthia 17-cv-04645

842 Walker, Glynn 17-cv-04645

843 Walker, II, Rodney 17-cv-04219

844 Walker, Lisa 17-cv-03622

845 Walker, Roxanne 17-cv-03012

846 Wallce, Guy Hillyer 13-cv-01039

847 Walter, Shanavia 17-cv-04273

848 Ward, Jennifer 17-cv-04220

849 Ware, Mia 17-cv-04221

850 Warren, Larry D 17-cv-04626

851 Washington, Janel 17-cv-04296

852 Washington, Victoria 17-cv-04297

853 Watkins, Archie 17-cv-04274

854 Watson, Esther Marie 16-cv-15259

855 Watts, Derek 17-cv-04627

856 Watts, Jeremy 17-cv-04298

857 Waxman, David 17-cv-04222

858 Weathersby, Sherlyon 17-cv-04295

859 Weathersby, Terry 17-cv-04275

860 Webb, Dalisha 17-cv-04223

861 Webb, John 17-cv-04276

862 Wellington, Jada 17-cv-04542

16




863 Wellington, Janya 17-cv-04542

864 Wellington, Melissa 17-cv-04542

865 Wells, Rabell 17-cv-04224

866 Wensel, April 17-cv-04225

867 Wensel, Betsy 17-cv-04629

868 Wheaton, Don 17-cv-04226

869 White, Alexis 17-cv-04227

870 White, Rashawn 17-cv-03623

871 White, Ricardo 17-cv-04229

872 Whitfield, Chelsea 17-cv-04230

873 Whittiker, Timothy 17-cv-04231

874 Whittinghill, Clay 10-cv-01984

875 Wilcox, Dennis 17-cv-04232

876 Williams Jr., Herman 17-cv-02675

877 Williams, Angelinia 17-cv-04632

878 Williams, Armis 17-cv-03414

879 Williams, Ashley N 13-cv-01041

880 Williams, Auron 17-cv-04633

881 Williams, Charetta 17-cv-04233

882 Williams, Charles 17-cv-04277

883 Williams, Clarence 17-cv-04234

884 Williams, Darlene 17-cv-03207

885 Williams, Dawarren 17-cv-04291

886 Williams, Gregory 17-cv-04306

887 Williams, Holly 17-cv-04307

888 Williams, Jahnia 17-cv-04634

889 Williams, Jr., James 17-cv-04235

890 Williams, Kaneika Naylor 17-cv-04636

891 Williams, Pricilla 17-cv-04660

892 Williams, Rachel 17-cv-03207

893 Williams, Randy 17-cv-04236

894 Williams, Roy 17-cv-04516

895 Williams, Viola 17-cv-04237

896 Willis, Aaron 17-cv-04597

897 Wilson, Bernice 17-cv-04239

898 Wilson, Cossie 17-cv-04659

899 Wilson, Mark 17-cv-04278

900 Woodland, Antonio 17-cv-04240

901 Wright, Andre 17-cv-04241

902 Wunstell, John 10-cv-02543

903 Wynne, Gisele Reese 17-cv-03230

904 Wynne, Gregg Lawrence 17-cv-03230

905 Wynne, Marlee Addison 17-cv-03230

906 Wynne, Monette Renee 17-cv-03230

907 Wynne, Ranger Cade 17-cv-03230

908 Yarbrough, Daniel 17-cv-04293

909 Yarbrough, Rebecca 17-cv-04292

910 Yerkes III., Joseph E 17-cv-03194

911 Zayzay, Freddie 17-cv-04637

17


united states district court eastern district of … · 12-cv-00740 learn, michael 17-cv-03322 lee,...

Documents