united states district court uiwj:.. or plain'l'ij'j' ojii'fid … ·...

15
r UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTatCT or JUIODE ISLAND UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Plaintitt C. A. No, 19-0565P AMERICAN CYANAMID COMPANY and. Jt.OHM I HAAS COMPANY , Defendant• UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD ITATII TO DIJ'IIfDAJrl'l' lftlllllOOATOUII The United Stat.. of Allerica (the "United Statea") hereby anavera the interroqatorha of ,._.rican cyana•id Co•pany and Roh• 6 Haae Co•pany (the "Oetendanta") •ailed on Noveaber :n, 1919 . rnliaiaan tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae ane wara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of Defendant•• interrogator! .. that b not answered below , IDIWirl Of tbt Qpi\td ltttll Iaterroaatoa Mo. 2 (regarding Paragraph 11 of the co•phint) : Iteaiza by aaount, date(e), contractor , consultant or ot her payee, aervicaa rendered and phaae of reaoval, all eu•• ot aoney which (a) the United Stat.. haa expended in reaponae coeta at the Picillo aite, apecitying in particular the component• ot the $3.5 •illion alleged; (b) the United State• eathates it will have to apend •• additional reaponae coata at the Picillo aite. In responding to thh interrogatory, identity costa which have been i ncurred, or may be incurred, with respect to both actual and

Upload: others

Post on 14-Mar-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

r

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTatCT or JUIODE ISLAND

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

Plaintitt

C A No 19-0565P

AMERICAN CYANAMID COMPANY and JtOHM I HAAS COMPANY

Defendantbull

UIWJ or PLAINlIJJ OJIIfiD ITATII TO DIJIIfDAJrll lftlllllOOATOUII

The United Stat of Allerica (the United Statea) hereby

anavera the interroqatorha of _rican cyanabullid Cobullpany and Rohbull

6 Haae Cobullpany (the Oetendanta) bullailed on Noveaber n 1919

rnliaiaan ttbulltbullbullpt

In conjunction with theae anewara the United Statea b

filinq aeparately objectiona to each of Defendantbullbull

interrogator that b not answered below

IDIWirl Of tbt Qpitd ltttll

Iaterroaatoa Mo 2 (regarding Paragraph 11 of the cobullphint)

Iteaiza by aaount date(e) contractor consultant or other

payee aervicaa rendered and phaae of reaoval all eubullbull ot aoney

which (a) the United Stat haa expended in reaponae coeta at the

Picillo aite apecitying in particular the componentbull ot the $35

bullillion alleged (b) the United Statebull eathates it will have to

apend bullbull additional reaponae coata at the Picillo aite In

responding to thh interrogatory identity costa which have been

i ncurred or may be incurred with respect to both actual and

__

ANjur bulla a

(a) ~middot Total expendituraa by tha United Stata

Environbullantal Protection Agency (EPA) for the Plcillo ran Site

accounted for aa of January 17 1990 ara at leaat $5190016061

thh nuaber bullbullY be adjuatad bullbull the State of Rhoda Idand b atill

providing EPA with intonation on tha Statabulla coata that ware

axpnded under a cooperative aqraa-nt vith EPA EPA haa

recdved a total of $1611100 in aattlant payanta for tha

Picillo Fan Site Tha ainbua tiqura of $35 aillion of

llnracovared coata notad in tha United Stataabull c oaplaint waa

calculated by applying tha $1611800 in aattlaaanta to the

aarliaat of tha at lent $5 190086 06 of totd coata incurred

($5190016 ainua $1681800 bull $3508286) Tha tiqurea do not

include recoverable i ntaraat

In addition to these EPA coata the United Statea Departaent

ot Justice haa incurred recoverable coata the United States

vil l aupplebullent thia answer to include the amount ot theae

Departnt ot Justice expenditures

In ita objec tions tiled separately the United Stat has

objected to InterrOCJatory No 2 bulla requests to itemize costa with

respect to actual releasee and threatened releas es and to 1tebullize

coats by phase ot removal Without waiving this objection the

United Statea anawera that there ia no way to separate theae past

response costa i nto costa incurred with respect to actual

r e l eases and those incurred with respect to threatened releases

__

rbulllbullbullbullbullbull frobull the druaa of vaate and the liquid waata found at

the Picillo tan Sita

(b) settltbullnta The United ltatee entered into four

Conaent Deerbullbullbull with twelve partiea lhe United ltatee

a e ttleMnte provided for a total recovery of $1611100 in paat

r eapon11 coatbull plua an aqreent by four of the defendantbull

(Monaento Co r poration CAP Corpor ation General lect ric Co1pany

and Aahland Cheaical C011pany) t o perf ora rebulloval o f contaainated

eoil pilea and aitbull cloture work at t he lit e

In the larqea t caah aet tl111nt the Un i ted Statbullbull received

$1500000 on Hay 2amp 1988 frobull Daniel Capuano Jack Capuano

Lotlbl C Cepuano aa ad1inbtratrix of the 11tat1 of Anthony

Capuano United Sanitation Inc Sanitary Landfill Inc and A

Capuano Brothera Inc and their heirbull exec utorbull bullucceeeorbull

bullbulld9nbull

In the bullecond s ettlement the United Statebull received $75000

(in addition to an agreement to perfona bullource control actions )

in May of 1918 from Aahland Chebullical Cobullpany (a diviaion of

Abullhland Oil Inc ) ($39750 on May 19 1988) GAP Corporation

($18000 on May 18 1988) General Electric Cobullpany ($12375 on

Hay 10 1988) and Monsanto Corpora t i on ( $48 75 on May 10 988)

In the t hird aet tlement t he United St a t ebull r eceived $J7 soo

on June J O 1989 f r oa Rut ge r e the State Univereity o f New

Jeraey

In t he four t h eettlement t he United States received $69 300

a-n = = =

r

~ -middotshyon March J 1119 fr011 Hydron Laboratoriea Inc

the following cat~oriea ax~ndituna under aqnabullanta with

private eontrac tora with other fadanl aganciaa and with the

l tata of Rhoda Ialand1 PA regional payroll axpenaaa travel

axpenaaa anltl other EPA reqional coata1 EPA indirect coata1 and

EPA haadquartara payroll axpe naaa and travel axpenaaa Thaaa

cateqoriaa ara broken down balov

1 Aqraanta v ith Privata Contractora

Alliance TachnoloqiaaGCA Corporation perforad tchnical

anforcaaant aupport aarvicaa undar contract no 61-W9-000J froa Januuy to April of 1989 for a total coat of $36905 -nAlliance TachnoloqiaaGCA Corporation perfonaad an

anclanqanaent aaaaaamant and perfonaad technical anforcaaant = aupport aarvicaa under contract no 61-01-6769 frobull Auguat ot =ca 1913 to Decbullbullbbullr ot 1986 tor a total coat ot $17789703

Ebaaco Inc performed reaedial aupport servicebull under

contract no 68-01-7250 rom July ot 1987 to July ot 1989

(overeight of the aoil pile rebulloval ork and developaent of a

ork plan to conduct a groundwater RI FS) tor a total coat of

$149002 09

Ecology and Environment Inc aaaiated in sampling and

aonitoring activitbullbull and provided overaight activitiea under

contract no 68-01-5158 from May of 1980 to Noveaber of 1982 tor

a total coat of $120884 73

Ecology and Environment Inc obtained data in connection

r

-5shy

with the developbullent of rabulledhl action alternativee perfoned

oveniqht of teophyaical work and aaabted groundwater

evaluationbull under contract no 61-01-6056 frobull February of Ull

to Januuy of 1112 for a total coat of $UfiOl612

CCA Technology Corporation perfo~ad an andanqanent

aeuaaHnt faaaibllity atudy and PRP arch activitiaa under

contract no 61-0J-3243 frobull July of 1915 to April of 1917 for a

total coat of $10329539

NUS Corporation parfontad co-unity relatione plan

activitha under contract no fil-01-6699 frobull February of 1915 to

Noveaber of 1915 tor a total coa t of $13 51600

Peabody Clean Industry Inc provided labor (including the

on acene coordinator) and equipbullent for diapoaal operationbull at

the lite uncSar contract no 61- Jl-0011 frobull Septellber of 1981 to

NoveUr of 1912 for a total cos t of $539 588 48

Planning Research Corporation performed PRP search and

haaibility study activitiea under contract no 68-01-7037 from

October of 1914 to Sept embe r of 1987 for a total cost of

$131012 09

Techlaw Inc organized developed an index for and

su-arized certain PRP-related documentbull from October of 1984 to

Septetgter of 1986 Theae activities were couenced under

contract no 61-01-6138 at a cost ot $670583 and completed

under contract no 68-01-7104 a t a coat of $921509

Techlaw Inc pe r formed enforcement support octivities under

contract no 68-01-7369 from Novellber of 1987 to July of 1989 tor

-a-n = =ca

-middotshya total coat of U1107JL

vua pe rfonad laboratory eaapla analyah bullbullrvicaa for the

l ite unde r an IPA national laboratory contract in October of ltlt

tor a t otal coat of tu 514 Ol

aoy P Waaton provided ahtanca vlth bullbullbullpling under

contnct U-01-7443 in Auguat a nd Saptaaber of Ull for a total

of Uamp5 7l

2 Agranta with other Federal Aganciea

The United lltataa Coaa t Guard perfonad haurdoua aubatanca

cleanup activi ties unde r i nteragency agraaaant no AD69Pl5900

froa February of 1981 to OCtober of 1911 tor a total coat of

U69415oo

Tile United Statea Opartaant of the Interior perfoned a

praliainary natunl raaoureaa survey undar interagency aqraaaant

no DWU03120l in Saptaaber of 1914 for a total coat of

$134169

The United States Aray Corps of Enqlneera perfonad

technical aadatanc a and overaiqht or Rl FS activitiea under

intera9anoy agoreabullent no DW96114201 frobull April of 1985 to

January of 1986 for a total coat of $6292 45

l J9rant vith the State of Rhode Ialand

(a) ~middot The State of Rhoda I a land perfonaed re111oval

activitba and u rs activ i tha frobull April of 1982 to octobe r of

1989 under a cooperative aqreemant noa OV0017 0801 and

OV00172101 ) wi th EPA f or a total coat o f a t least $2 4 55 764 27

thh nullbar bull ay ba ad j uatad aa the St a t e of Rhode I a land ia atill

-7shy

providing PA with inforation on the Statabulla coata The State

of Jthoda I a land bulla coata an furtMr broken down a a followa

Contractbull

Payroll

Trave l

$2351033 44

131575 74

2919 53

2094066

7123

fS 51 146 lll

$ 2455764 17

-a-n Ct Ct ca

Cb) CoatraotJ lnaiOoyp Tha State of Rhoda Ialand antand

into nueroua contracta (at laaat 45 for perforaanc a of aarvicaa

and proviaion of aquipnt related to tha Picillo Pan Site

Eighteen of tha contractbull ara for aaounta ovar $1 000 Thaaa

aightaan contracta account for $2348 377 out of the total

$235tOllU contract coata and ara broken down aa followa

C bull K Electric provided aarvic or equipment frobull January

of 1915 to Ocallbar of 1988 for a total coat of $1848 60

Colonial Security provide aarvicaa frobull June of 1982 to

January of 1984 for a total coat of $70735 88

Ecoloqy and Environaent provided aervicea froa July of 1982

to February of 1984 for a total coat of $35758 89

GCA Corporation provided aervicea from June of 1982 to July

of 1983 for a total coat of $84 959 00

H Nu syateaa provided servicebull or equipment from Hay of 1982

to Novembe r of 1984 for a total coat of $7733 oo

r

-middot-Xavin Hubbard provided aervicaa fr~ Mbully of ltU to October

of un for a total coat of $1470150

John Lov~ran provid~ aarvicaa froa April of 1112 to Aucruat

of 1913 for a total coat of $7051 70

M 6 I InvaatiQationa providc aarvicaa frobull March of UU to

June of 1911 for a total coat of UOl 116 77

Nav 9land Talaphona provided aarvicaa and aquipbullant frobull

June of UU to February of 1919 for a totd coat of $J 164 11

Navport Ibullporta provided aarvicaa or aquipbullant in Auguat of

1912 for a total coat of $9 192 oo

O K Matariala provided aarvicaa frobull May of 1912 to July of

1913 for a total coat of $1 426 10657

Peabody Clean Induatriaa provided aarvicaa frobull January of

1911 to May of UU fo r a total coat of $25658106

Perkina Jordan providad aarvicaa frobull March of 1912 to Juna

of 1912 for a total coat ot $2460000

Port A John Inc provided equipaent and aervicea frobull

Auquat of 1982 to February of 1988 tor a total coat of $1522 50

Rhode Ialand Analytical provided aervicea or equipaent in

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $1958 00

Roger Williaaa Hoapital provided ae rvicea from september of

1982 to July of 1984 tor a total coat of $262900

San i Kan provided aquipaant and aervicea troll OCtober ot

1983 to June of 1988 for a t otal coat of $313750

Tighe and Bond provided aervicea troa February of 1983 to

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $19428061

-n = = ca

The reaaining contractbull the State of Rhode Ialand entered

into under the EPA cooperative agreent are aa folloolal

Adlerbull provided aervicea or equipaent froa January of UU

to April of 1913 for a total coat ol $30123

Allied Court Reporterbull provided aervicea in Auquat of 1914

lor a tott coat of $23000

Anderaon Contracting and Supplies provided aervicea or

equipnt in OCtober of 1912 for a total coat of $21500

AT T provided aervicea froa May ot 1915 to March of 1919

for a total coat of $25074

Atvell Coapany provided aervicea or equipaent in March ot

1912 for a total coat of $265 00

Contractorbull Supply provided equipaent in January of 1914 for

a total coat of $2200

Dictaphone Corporation provided equipaant or aervicea froa

Malrch to Kay of 1912 for a total coat of $12195

Dunqarian Brotherbull provided aervicea or equip11ent frobull

Decellber of 1983 to June of 1985 for a total coat of $11530

oupaine Gaa provided aervicea froa December of 1984 to March

of 19115 for a total coat of $37161

Federal Expreaa provided aervicea from December of 1914 to

March of 1915 for a total cost of $17800

General Pence provided equipment in June of 1985 for a total

coat of $650 00

MacDonald and Watson waate Oil Company provided aervicea or

equipaent in September of 1987 for a total coat of $15000

r

-10shy

Mine Safety provided aervlcaa or aquipbullant in october of

ltl5 for a total coat of $36170

Preaco H Pierce Cobullpany provided aqutpnt in Novaabar of

1114 tor a total coat of $97 50

Providence Blueprint provided aarvicaa in SapteaMr of 1914

for a total coat of $3000

Providence Journal provided aarvicaa in October of un and

in June of 1917 for a total coat of $410 61

Radio Shack provided aquipbullant in September of un for a

total coat of $12385

Raportinq Aoclataa provided aarvicaa in January of 1915

for a total coat of $28800

save-Rita provided aquipbullant in Auguat of 1984 for a total

coat of $1997

Scituate Portable Toilata provided equipbullant or aarvicaa

froa saptaabar of 1988 to January of 1989 for a total coat of

$34000

Saara provided equipment in June of 1984 for a total cost ot

$2599

Shoe Horn provided services or equip111ent in June of 1982 for

a total cost of $50 oo

Stbullr Gas provided services or equipment from March of 1983

to February of 1985 or a total cost o $63544

John Stockholm provided services in May o 1982 for a total

cost o $59 50

Suburban Propane provided equipment o r services rom August

-a-n = = CD

- -11shy

of UU to June of ltl7 for a total coat of $569 91

Unico provided aarvicaa or aquipaent in June of 1915 for a

total coat of uo n

Wear Guard provided aquipaant froa Decallber of Ull to

January of 1919 for a total coat of $17 4 91

4 PA Regional Payroll Travel a nd Otbar Expenaaa

EPA payroll travel and other axpenaaa of at laaat

$24619161 va r a incurred for 1)41 r aonnd activitiaa including

technical and anforcaaant activitiaa frobull Pabruary of 1982 to tha

praaant Thbullbullbull include activitiaa in the araaa of PRP aaarch alta invaatigation ovaraight raaady aalaction co-unity

ralationa and other aattara Coata accounted for a a of January shyn 17 1990 ware aa followa =

Payroll $241017 8) ca= Travel 5 229 79

Niac axpenaaa 651 06

$346898 68

5 PA Indirect coata

EPAbull indirect costa aaount to at least $363966 00

accounted tor as of January 17 1990 EPA bull indirect coata are

accounted tor by aite and are calculated by multiplying- two

tacton (1) total direct houre charqed to the Sitbull by EPAbull

Reqion I bullbullploybullbullbull ot the Waste Emerqency Services Water and

Air Divbiona for each fiacal year tro1a tiacal year 1983 to

fiscal year 1990 times (2) the EPA indirect cost rate for each

J

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 2: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

__

ANjur bulla a

(a) ~middot Total expendituraa by tha United Stata

Environbullantal Protection Agency (EPA) for the Plcillo ran Site

accounted for aa of January 17 1990 ara at leaat $5190016061

thh nuaber bullbullY be adjuatad bullbull the State of Rhoda Idand b atill

providing EPA with intonation on tha Statabulla coata that ware

axpnded under a cooperative aqraa-nt vith EPA EPA haa

recdved a total of $1611100 in aattlant payanta for tha

Picillo Fan Site Tha ainbua tiqura of $35 aillion of

llnracovared coata notad in tha United Stataabull c oaplaint waa

calculated by applying tha $1611800 in aattlaaanta to the

aarliaat of tha at lent $5 190086 06 of totd coata incurred

($5190016 ainua $1681800 bull $3508286) Tha tiqurea do not

include recoverable i ntaraat

In addition to these EPA coata the United Statea Departaent

ot Justice haa incurred recoverable coata the United States

vil l aupplebullent thia answer to include the amount ot theae

Departnt ot Justice expenditures

In ita objec tions tiled separately the United Stat has

objected to InterrOCJatory No 2 bulla requests to itemize costa with

respect to actual releasee and threatened releas es and to 1tebullize

coats by phase ot removal Without waiving this objection the

United Statea anawera that there ia no way to separate theae past

response costa i nto costa incurred with respect to actual

r e l eases and those incurred with respect to threatened releases

__

rbulllbullbullbullbullbull frobull the druaa of vaate and the liquid waata found at

the Picillo tan Sita

(b) settltbullnta The United ltatee entered into four

Conaent Deerbullbullbull with twelve partiea lhe United ltatee

a e ttleMnte provided for a total recovery of $1611100 in paat

r eapon11 coatbull plua an aqreent by four of the defendantbull

(Monaento Co r poration CAP Corpor ation General lect ric Co1pany

and Aahland Cheaical C011pany) t o perf ora rebulloval o f contaainated

eoil pilea and aitbull cloture work at t he lit e

In the larqea t caah aet tl111nt the Un i ted Statbullbull received

$1500000 on Hay 2amp 1988 frobull Daniel Capuano Jack Capuano

Lotlbl C Cepuano aa ad1inbtratrix of the 11tat1 of Anthony

Capuano United Sanitation Inc Sanitary Landfill Inc and A

Capuano Brothera Inc and their heirbull exec utorbull bullucceeeorbull

bullbulld9nbull

In the bullecond s ettlement the United Statebull received $75000

(in addition to an agreement to perfona bullource control actions )

in May of 1918 from Aahland Chebullical Cobullpany (a diviaion of

Abullhland Oil Inc ) ($39750 on May 19 1988) GAP Corporation

($18000 on May 18 1988) General Electric Cobullpany ($12375 on

Hay 10 1988) and Monsanto Corpora t i on ( $48 75 on May 10 988)

In the t hird aet tlement t he United St a t ebull r eceived $J7 soo

on June J O 1989 f r oa Rut ge r e the State Univereity o f New

Jeraey

In t he four t h eettlement t he United States received $69 300

a-n = = =

r

~ -middotshyon March J 1119 fr011 Hydron Laboratoriea Inc

the following cat~oriea ax~ndituna under aqnabullanta with

private eontrac tora with other fadanl aganciaa and with the

l tata of Rhoda Ialand1 PA regional payroll axpenaaa travel

axpenaaa anltl other EPA reqional coata1 EPA indirect coata1 and

EPA haadquartara payroll axpe naaa and travel axpenaaa Thaaa

cateqoriaa ara broken down balov

1 Aqraanta v ith Privata Contractora

Alliance TachnoloqiaaGCA Corporation perforad tchnical

anforcaaant aupport aarvicaa undar contract no 61-W9-000J froa Januuy to April of 1989 for a total coat of $36905 -nAlliance TachnoloqiaaGCA Corporation perfonaad an

anclanqanaent aaaaaamant and perfonaad technical anforcaaant = aupport aarvicaa under contract no 61-01-6769 frobull Auguat ot =ca 1913 to Decbullbullbbullr ot 1986 tor a total coat ot $17789703

Ebaaco Inc performed reaedial aupport servicebull under

contract no 68-01-7250 rom July ot 1987 to July ot 1989

(overeight of the aoil pile rebulloval ork and developaent of a

ork plan to conduct a groundwater RI FS) tor a total coat of

$149002 09

Ecology and Environment Inc aaaiated in sampling and

aonitoring activitbullbull and provided overaight activitiea under

contract no 68-01-5158 from May of 1980 to Noveaber of 1982 tor

a total coat of $120884 73

Ecology and Environment Inc obtained data in connection

r

-5shy

with the developbullent of rabulledhl action alternativee perfoned

oveniqht of teophyaical work and aaabted groundwater

evaluationbull under contract no 61-01-6056 frobull February of Ull

to Januuy of 1112 for a total coat of $UfiOl612

CCA Technology Corporation perfo~ad an andanqanent

aeuaaHnt faaaibllity atudy and PRP arch activitiaa under

contract no 61-0J-3243 frobull July of 1915 to April of 1917 for a

total coat of $10329539

NUS Corporation parfontad co-unity relatione plan

activitha under contract no fil-01-6699 frobull February of 1915 to

Noveaber of 1915 tor a total coa t of $13 51600

Peabody Clean Industry Inc provided labor (including the

on acene coordinator) and equipbullent for diapoaal operationbull at

the lite uncSar contract no 61- Jl-0011 frobull Septellber of 1981 to

NoveUr of 1912 for a total cos t of $539 588 48

Planning Research Corporation performed PRP search and

haaibility study activitiea under contract no 68-01-7037 from

October of 1914 to Sept embe r of 1987 for a total cost of

$131012 09

Techlaw Inc organized developed an index for and

su-arized certain PRP-related documentbull from October of 1984 to

Septetgter of 1986 Theae activities were couenced under

contract no 61-01-6138 at a cost ot $670583 and completed

under contract no 68-01-7104 a t a coat of $921509

Techlaw Inc pe r formed enforcement support octivities under

contract no 68-01-7369 from Novellber of 1987 to July of 1989 tor

-a-n = =ca

-middotshya total coat of U1107JL

vua pe rfonad laboratory eaapla analyah bullbullrvicaa for the

l ite unde r an IPA national laboratory contract in October of ltlt

tor a t otal coat of tu 514 Ol

aoy P Waaton provided ahtanca vlth bullbullbullpling under

contnct U-01-7443 in Auguat a nd Saptaaber of Ull for a total

of Uamp5 7l

2 Agranta with other Federal Aganciea

The United lltataa Coaa t Guard perfonad haurdoua aubatanca

cleanup activi ties unde r i nteragency agraaaant no AD69Pl5900

froa February of 1981 to OCtober of 1911 tor a total coat of

U69415oo

Tile United Statea Opartaant of the Interior perfoned a

praliainary natunl raaoureaa survey undar interagency aqraaaant

no DWU03120l in Saptaaber of 1914 for a total coat of

$134169

The United States Aray Corps of Enqlneera perfonad

technical aadatanc a and overaiqht or Rl FS activitiea under

intera9anoy agoreabullent no DW96114201 frobull April of 1985 to

January of 1986 for a total coat of $6292 45

l J9rant vith the State of Rhode Ialand

(a) ~middot The State of Rhoda I a land perfonaed re111oval

activitba and u rs activ i tha frobull April of 1982 to octobe r of

1989 under a cooperative aqreemant noa OV0017 0801 and

OV00172101 ) wi th EPA f or a total coat o f a t least $2 4 55 764 27

thh nullbar bull ay ba ad j uatad aa the St a t e of Rhode I a land ia atill

-7shy

providing PA with inforation on the Statabulla coata The State

of Jthoda I a land bulla coata an furtMr broken down a a followa

Contractbull

Payroll

Trave l

$2351033 44

131575 74

2919 53

2094066

7123

fS 51 146 lll

$ 2455764 17

-a-n Ct Ct ca

Cb) CoatraotJ lnaiOoyp Tha State of Rhoda Ialand antand

into nueroua contracta (at laaat 45 for perforaanc a of aarvicaa

and proviaion of aquipnt related to tha Picillo Pan Site

Eighteen of tha contractbull ara for aaounta ovar $1 000 Thaaa

aightaan contracta account for $2348 377 out of the total

$235tOllU contract coata and ara broken down aa followa

C bull K Electric provided aarvic or equipment frobull January

of 1915 to Ocallbar of 1988 for a total coat of $1848 60

Colonial Security provide aarvicaa frobull June of 1982 to

January of 1984 for a total coat of $70735 88

Ecoloqy and Environaent provided aervicea froa July of 1982

to February of 1984 for a total coat of $35758 89

GCA Corporation provided aervicea from June of 1982 to July

of 1983 for a total coat of $84 959 00

H Nu syateaa provided servicebull or equipment from Hay of 1982

to Novembe r of 1984 for a total coat of $7733 oo

r

-middot-Xavin Hubbard provided aervicaa fr~ Mbully of ltU to October

of un for a total coat of $1470150

John Lov~ran provid~ aarvicaa froa April of 1112 to Aucruat

of 1913 for a total coat of $7051 70

M 6 I InvaatiQationa providc aarvicaa frobull March of UU to

June of 1911 for a total coat of UOl 116 77

Nav 9land Talaphona provided aarvicaa and aquipbullant frobull

June of UU to February of 1919 for a totd coat of $J 164 11

Navport Ibullporta provided aarvicaa or aquipbullant in Auguat of

1912 for a total coat of $9 192 oo

O K Matariala provided aarvicaa frobull May of 1912 to July of

1913 for a total coat of $1 426 10657

Peabody Clean Induatriaa provided aarvicaa frobull January of

1911 to May of UU fo r a total coat of $25658106

Perkina Jordan providad aarvicaa frobull March of 1912 to Juna

of 1912 for a total coat ot $2460000

Port A John Inc provided equipaent and aervicea frobull

Auquat of 1982 to February of 1988 tor a total coat of $1522 50

Rhode Ialand Analytical provided aervicea or equipaent in

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $1958 00

Roger Williaaa Hoapital provided ae rvicea from september of

1982 to July of 1984 tor a total coat of $262900

San i Kan provided aquipaant and aervicea troll OCtober ot

1983 to June of 1988 for a t otal coat of $313750

Tighe and Bond provided aervicea troa February of 1983 to

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $19428061

-n = = ca

The reaaining contractbull the State of Rhode Ialand entered

into under the EPA cooperative agreent are aa folloolal

Adlerbull provided aervicea or equipaent froa January of UU

to April of 1913 for a total coat ol $30123

Allied Court Reporterbull provided aervicea in Auquat of 1914

lor a tott coat of $23000

Anderaon Contracting and Supplies provided aervicea or

equipnt in OCtober of 1912 for a total coat of $21500

AT T provided aervicea froa May ot 1915 to March of 1919

for a total coat of $25074

Atvell Coapany provided aervicea or equipaent in March ot

1912 for a total coat of $265 00

Contractorbull Supply provided equipaent in January of 1914 for

a total coat of $2200

Dictaphone Corporation provided equipaant or aervicea froa

Malrch to Kay of 1912 for a total coat of $12195

Dunqarian Brotherbull provided aervicea or equip11ent frobull

Decellber of 1983 to June of 1985 for a total coat of $11530

oupaine Gaa provided aervicea froa December of 1984 to March

of 19115 for a total coat of $37161

Federal Expreaa provided aervicea from December of 1914 to

March of 1915 for a total cost of $17800

General Pence provided equipment in June of 1985 for a total

coat of $650 00

MacDonald and Watson waate Oil Company provided aervicea or

equipaent in September of 1987 for a total coat of $15000

r

-10shy

Mine Safety provided aervlcaa or aquipbullant in october of

ltl5 for a total coat of $36170

Preaco H Pierce Cobullpany provided aqutpnt in Novaabar of

1114 tor a total coat of $97 50

Providence Blueprint provided aarvicaa in SapteaMr of 1914

for a total coat of $3000

Providence Journal provided aarvicaa in October of un and

in June of 1917 for a total coat of $410 61

Radio Shack provided aquipbullant in September of un for a

total coat of $12385

Raportinq Aoclataa provided aarvicaa in January of 1915

for a total coat of $28800

save-Rita provided aquipbullant in Auguat of 1984 for a total

coat of $1997

Scituate Portable Toilata provided equipbullant or aarvicaa

froa saptaabar of 1988 to January of 1989 for a total coat of

$34000

Saara provided equipment in June of 1984 for a total cost ot

$2599

Shoe Horn provided services or equip111ent in June of 1982 for

a total cost of $50 oo

Stbullr Gas provided services or equipment from March of 1983

to February of 1985 or a total cost o $63544

John Stockholm provided services in May o 1982 for a total

cost o $59 50

Suburban Propane provided equipment o r services rom August

-a-n = = CD

- -11shy

of UU to June of ltl7 for a total coat of $569 91

Unico provided aarvicaa or aquipaent in June of 1915 for a

total coat of uo n

Wear Guard provided aquipaant froa Decallber of Ull to

January of 1919 for a total coat of $17 4 91

4 PA Regional Payroll Travel a nd Otbar Expenaaa

EPA payroll travel and other axpenaaa of at laaat

$24619161 va r a incurred for 1)41 r aonnd activitiaa including

technical and anforcaaant activitiaa frobull Pabruary of 1982 to tha

praaant Thbullbullbull include activitiaa in the araaa of PRP aaarch alta invaatigation ovaraight raaady aalaction co-unity

ralationa and other aattara Coata accounted for a a of January shyn 17 1990 ware aa followa =

Payroll $241017 8) ca= Travel 5 229 79

Niac axpenaaa 651 06

$346898 68

5 PA Indirect coata

EPAbull indirect costa aaount to at least $363966 00

accounted tor as of January 17 1990 EPA bull indirect coata are

accounted tor by aite and are calculated by multiplying- two

tacton (1) total direct houre charqed to the Sitbull by EPAbull

Reqion I bullbullploybullbullbull ot the Waste Emerqency Services Water and

Air Divbiona for each fiacal year tro1a tiacal year 1983 to

fiscal year 1990 times (2) the EPA indirect cost rate for each

J

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 3: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

__

rbulllbullbullbullbullbull frobull the druaa of vaate and the liquid waata found at

the Picillo tan Sita

(b) settltbullnta The United ltatee entered into four

Conaent Deerbullbullbull with twelve partiea lhe United ltatee

a e ttleMnte provided for a total recovery of $1611100 in paat

r eapon11 coatbull plua an aqreent by four of the defendantbull

(Monaento Co r poration CAP Corpor ation General lect ric Co1pany

and Aahland Cheaical C011pany) t o perf ora rebulloval o f contaainated

eoil pilea and aitbull cloture work at t he lit e

In the larqea t caah aet tl111nt the Un i ted Statbullbull received

$1500000 on Hay 2amp 1988 frobull Daniel Capuano Jack Capuano

Lotlbl C Cepuano aa ad1inbtratrix of the 11tat1 of Anthony

Capuano United Sanitation Inc Sanitary Landfill Inc and A

Capuano Brothera Inc and their heirbull exec utorbull bullucceeeorbull

bullbulld9nbull

In the bullecond s ettlement the United Statebull received $75000

(in addition to an agreement to perfona bullource control actions )

in May of 1918 from Aahland Chebullical Cobullpany (a diviaion of

Abullhland Oil Inc ) ($39750 on May 19 1988) GAP Corporation

($18000 on May 18 1988) General Electric Cobullpany ($12375 on

Hay 10 1988) and Monsanto Corpora t i on ( $48 75 on May 10 988)

In the t hird aet tlement t he United St a t ebull r eceived $J7 soo

on June J O 1989 f r oa Rut ge r e the State Univereity o f New

Jeraey

In t he four t h eettlement t he United States received $69 300

a-n = = =

r

~ -middotshyon March J 1119 fr011 Hydron Laboratoriea Inc

the following cat~oriea ax~ndituna under aqnabullanta with

private eontrac tora with other fadanl aganciaa and with the

l tata of Rhoda Ialand1 PA regional payroll axpenaaa travel

axpenaaa anltl other EPA reqional coata1 EPA indirect coata1 and

EPA haadquartara payroll axpe naaa and travel axpenaaa Thaaa

cateqoriaa ara broken down balov

1 Aqraanta v ith Privata Contractora

Alliance TachnoloqiaaGCA Corporation perforad tchnical

anforcaaant aupport aarvicaa undar contract no 61-W9-000J froa Januuy to April of 1989 for a total coat of $36905 -nAlliance TachnoloqiaaGCA Corporation perfonaad an

anclanqanaent aaaaaamant and perfonaad technical anforcaaant = aupport aarvicaa under contract no 61-01-6769 frobull Auguat ot =ca 1913 to Decbullbullbbullr ot 1986 tor a total coat ot $17789703

Ebaaco Inc performed reaedial aupport servicebull under

contract no 68-01-7250 rom July ot 1987 to July ot 1989

(overeight of the aoil pile rebulloval ork and developaent of a

ork plan to conduct a groundwater RI FS) tor a total coat of

$149002 09

Ecology and Environment Inc aaaiated in sampling and

aonitoring activitbullbull and provided overaight activitiea under

contract no 68-01-5158 from May of 1980 to Noveaber of 1982 tor

a total coat of $120884 73

Ecology and Environment Inc obtained data in connection

r

-5shy

with the developbullent of rabulledhl action alternativee perfoned

oveniqht of teophyaical work and aaabted groundwater

evaluationbull under contract no 61-01-6056 frobull February of Ull

to Januuy of 1112 for a total coat of $UfiOl612

CCA Technology Corporation perfo~ad an andanqanent

aeuaaHnt faaaibllity atudy and PRP arch activitiaa under

contract no 61-0J-3243 frobull July of 1915 to April of 1917 for a

total coat of $10329539

NUS Corporation parfontad co-unity relatione plan

activitha under contract no fil-01-6699 frobull February of 1915 to

Noveaber of 1915 tor a total coa t of $13 51600

Peabody Clean Industry Inc provided labor (including the

on acene coordinator) and equipbullent for diapoaal operationbull at

the lite uncSar contract no 61- Jl-0011 frobull Septellber of 1981 to

NoveUr of 1912 for a total cos t of $539 588 48

Planning Research Corporation performed PRP search and

haaibility study activitiea under contract no 68-01-7037 from

October of 1914 to Sept embe r of 1987 for a total cost of

$131012 09

Techlaw Inc organized developed an index for and

su-arized certain PRP-related documentbull from October of 1984 to

Septetgter of 1986 Theae activities were couenced under

contract no 61-01-6138 at a cost ot $670583 and completed

under contract no 68-01-7104 a t a coat of $921509

Techlaw Inc pe r formed enforcement support octivities under

contract no 68-01-7369 from Novellber of 1987 to July of 1989 tor

-a-n = =ca

-middotshya total coat of U1107JL

vua pe rfonad laboratory eaapla analyah bullbullrvicaa for the

l ite unde r an IPA national laboratory contract in October of ltlt

tor a t otal coat of tu 514 Ol

aoy P Waaton provided ahtanca vlth bullbullbullpling under

contnct U-01-7443 in Auguat a nd Saptaaber of Ull for a total

of Uamp5 7l

2 Agranta with other Federal Aganciea

The United lltataa Coaa t Guard perfonad haurdoua aubatanca

cleanup activi ties unde r i nteragency agraaaant no AD69Pl5900

froa February of 1981 to OCtober of 1911 tor a total coat of

U69415oo

Tile United Statea Opartaant of the Interior perfoned a

praliainary natunl raaoureaa survey undar interagency aqraaaant

no DWU03120l in Saptaaber of 1914 for a total coat of

$134169

The United States Aray Corps of Enqlneera perfonad

technical aadatanc a and overaiqht or Rl FS activitiea under

intera9anoy agoreabullent no DW96114201 frobull April of 1985 to

January of 1986 for a total coat of $6292 45

l J9rant vith the State of Rhode Ialand

(a) ~middot The State of Rhoda I a land perfonaed re111oval

activitba and u rs activ i tha frobull April of 1982 to octobe r of

1989 under a cooperative aqreemant noa OV0017 0801 and

OV00172101 ) wi th EPA f or a total coat o f a t least $2 4 55 764 27

thh nullbar bull ay ba ad j uatad aa the St a t e of Rhode I a land ia atill

-7shy

providing PA with inforation on the Statabulla coata The State

of Jthoda I a land bulla coata an furtMr broken down a a followa

Contractbull

Payroll

Trave l

$2351033 44

131575 74

2919 53

2094066

7123

fS 51 146 lll

$ 2455764 17

-a-n Ct Ct ca

Cb) CoatraotJ lnaiOoyp Tha State of Rhoda Ialand antand

into nueroua contracta (at laaat 45 for perforaanc a of aarvicaa

and proviaion of aquipnt related to tha Picillo Pan Site

Eighteen of tha contractbull ara for aaounta ovar $1 000 Thaaa

aightaan contracta account for $2348 377 out of the total

$235tOllU contract coata and ara broken down aa followa

C bull K Electric provided aarvic or equipment frobull January

of 1915 to Ocallbar of 1988 for a total coat of $1848 60

Colonial Security provide aarvicaa frobull June of 1982 to

January of 1984 for a total coat of $70735 88

Ecoloqy and Environaent provided aervicea froa July of 1982

to February of 1984 for a total coat of $35758 89

GCA Corporation provided aervicea from June of 1982 to July

of 1983 for a total coat of $84 959 00

H Nu syateaa provided servicebull or equipment from Hay of 1982

to Novembe r of 1984 for a total coat of $7733 oo

r

-middot-Xavin Hubbard provided aervicaa fr~ Mbully of ltU to October

of un for a total coat of $1470150

John Lov~ran provid~ aarvicaa froa April of 1112 to Aucruat

of 1913 for a total coat of $7051 70

M 6 I InvaatiQationa providc aarvicaa frobull March of UU to

June of 1911 for a total coat of UOl 116 77

Nav 9land Talaphona provided aarvicaa and aquipbullant frobull

June of UU to February of 1919 for a totd coat of $J 164 11

Navport Ibullporta provided aarvicaa or aquipbullant in Auguat of

1912 for a total coat of $9 192 oo

O K Matariala provided aarvicaa frobull May of 1912 to July of

1913 for a total coat of $1 426 10657

Peabody Clean Induatriaa provided aarvicaa frobull January of

1911 to May of UU fo r a total coat of $25658106

Perkina Jordan providad aarvicaa frobull March of 1912 to Juna

of 1912 for a total coat ot $2460000

Port A John Inc provided equipaent and aervicea frobull

Auquat of 1982 to February of 1988 tor a total coat of $1522 50

Rhode Ialand Analytical provided aervicea or equipaent in

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $1958 00

Roger Williaaa Hoapital provided ae rvicea from september of

1982 to July of 1984 tor a total coat of $262900

San i Kan provided aquipaant and aervicea troll OCtober ot

1983 to June of 1988 for a t otal coat of $313750

Tighe and Bond provided aervicea troa February of 1983 to

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $19428061

-n = = ca

The reaaining contractbull the State of Rhode Ialand entered

into under the EPA cooperative agreent are aa folloolal

Adlerbull provided aervicea or equipaent froa January of UU

to April of 1913 for a total coat ol $30123

Allied Court Reporterbull provided aervicea in Auquat of 1914

lor a tott coat of $23000

Anderaon Contracting and Supplies provided aervicea or

equipnt in OCtober of 1912 for a total coat of $21500

AT T provided aervicea froa May ot 1915 to March of 1919

for a total coat of $25074

Atvell Coapany provided aervicea or equipaent in March ot

1912 for a total coat of $265 00

Contractorbull Supply provided equipaent in January of 1914 for

a total coat of $2200

Dictaphone Corporation provided equipaant or aervicea froa

Malrch to Kay of 1912 for a total coat of $12195

Dunqarian Brotherbull provided aervicea or equip11ent frobull

Decellber of 1983 to June of 1985 for a total coat of $11530

oupaine Gaa provided aervicea froa December of 1984 to March

of 19115 for a total coat of $37161

Federal Expreaa provided aervicea from December of 1914 to

March of 1915 for a total cost of $17800

General Pence provided equipment in June of 1985 for a total

coat of $650 00

MacDonald and Watson waate Oil Company provided aervicea or

equipaent in September of 1987 for a total coat of $15000

r

-10shy

Mine Safety provided aervlcaa or aquipbullant in october of

ltl5 for a total coat of $36170

Preaco H Pierce Cobullpany provided aqutpnt in Novaabar of

1114 tor a total coat of $97 50

Providence Blueprint provided aarvicaa in SapteaMr of 1914

for a total coat of $3000

Providence Journal provided aarvicaa in October of un and

in June of 1917 for a total coat of $410 61

Radio Shack provided aquipbullant in September of un for a

total coat of $12385

Raportinq Aoclataa provided aarvicaa in January of 1915

for a total coat of $28800

save-Rita provided aquipbullant in Auguat of 1984 for a total

coat of $1997

Scituate Portable Toilata provided equipbullant or aarvicaa

froa saptaabar of 1988 to January of 1989 for a total coat of

$34000

Saara provided equipment in June of 1984 for a total cost ot

$2599

Shoe Horn provided services or equip111ent in June of 1982 for

a total cost of $50 oo

Stbullr Gas provided services or equipment from March of 1983

to February of 1985 or a total cost o $63544

John Stockholm provided services in May o 1982 for a total

cost o $59 50

Suburban Propane provided equipment o r services rom August

-a-n = = CD

- -11shy

of UU to June of ltl7 for a total coat of $569 91

Unico provided aarvicaa or aquipaent in June of 1915 for a

total coat of uo n

Wear Guard provided aquipaant froa Decallber of Ull to

January of 1919 for a total coat of $17 4 91

4 PA Regional Payroll Travel a nd Otbar Expenaaa

EPA payroll travel and other axpenaaa of at laaat

$24619161 va r a incurred for 1)41 r aonnd activitiaa including

technical and anforcaaant activitiaa frobull Pabruary of 1982 to tha

praaant Thbullbullbull include activitiaa in the araaa of PRP aaarch alta invaatigation ovaraight raaady aalaction co-unity

ralationa and other aattara Coata accounted for a a of January shyn 17 1990 ware aa followa =

Payroll $241017 8) ca= Travel 5 229 79

Niac axpenaaa 651 06

$346898 68

5 PA Indirect coata

EPAbull indirect costa aaount to at least $363966 00

accounted tor as of January 17 1990 EPA bull indirect coata are

accounted tor by aite and are calculated by multiplying- two

tacton (1) total direct houre charqed to the Sitbull by EPAbull

Reqion I bullbullploybullbullbull ot the Waste Emerqency Services Water and

Air Divbiona for each fiacal year tro1a tiacal year 1983 to

fiscal year 1990 times (2) the EPA indirect cost rate for each

J

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 4: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

r

~ -middotshyon March J 1119 fr011 Hydron Laboratoriea Inc

the following cat~oriea ax~ndituna under aqnabullanta with

private eontrac tora with other fadanl aganciaa and with the

l tata of Rhoda Ialand1 PA regional payroll axpenaaa travel

axpenaaa anltl other EPA reqional coata1 EPA indirect coata1 and

EPA haadquartara payroll axpe naaa and travel axpenaaa Thaaa

cateqoriaa ara broken down balov

1 Aqraanta v ith Privata Contractora

Alliance TachnoloqiaaGCA Corporation perforad tchnical

anforcaaant aupport aarvicaa undar contract no 61-W9-000J froa Januuy to April of 1989 for a total coat of $36905 -nAlliance TachnoloqiaaGCA Corporation perfonaad an

anclanqanaent aaaaaamant and perfonaad technical anforcaaant = aupport aarvicaa under contract no 61-01-6769 frobull Auguat ot =ca 1913 to Decbullbullbbullr ot 1986 tor a total coat ot $17789703

Ebaaco Inc performed reaedial aupport servicebull under

contract no 68-01-7250 rom July ot 1987 to July ot 1989

(overeight of the aoil pile rebulloval ork and developaent of a

ork plan to conduct a groundwater RI FS) tor a total coat of

$149002 09

Ecology and Environment Inc aaaiated in sampling and

aonitoring activitbullbull and provided overaight activitiea under

contract no 68-01-5158 from May of 1980 to Noveaber of 1982 tor

a total coat of $120884 73

Ecology and Environment Inc obtained data in connection

r

-5shy

with the developbullent of rabulledhl action alternativee perfoned

oveniqht of teophyaical work and aaabted groundwater

evaluationbull under contract no 61-01-6056 frobull February of Ull

to Januuy of 1112 for a total coat of $UfiOl612

CCA Technology Corporation perfo~ad an andanqanent

aeuaaHnt faaaibllity atudy and PRP arch activitiaa under

contract no 61-0J-3243 frobull July of 1915 to April of 1917 for a

total coat of $10329539

NUS Corporation parfontad co-unity relatione plan

activitha under contract no fil-01-6699 frobull February of 1915 to

Noveaber of 1915 tor a total coa t of $13 51600

Peabody Clean Industry Inc provided labor (including the

on acene coordinator) and equipbullent for diapoaal operationbull at

the lite uncSar contract no 61- Jl-0011 frobull Septellber of 1981 to

NoveUr of 1912 for a total cos t of $539 588 48

Planning Research Corporation performed PRP search and

haaibility study activitiea under contract no 68-01-7037 from

October of 1914 to Sept embe r of 1987 for a total cost of

$131012 09

Techlaw Inc organized developed an index for and

su-arized certain PRP-related documentbull from October of 1984 to

Septetgter of 1986 Theae activities were couenced under

contract no 61-01-6138 at a cost ot $670583 and completed

under contract no 68-01-7104 a t a coat of $921509

Techlaw Inc pe r formed enforcement support octivities under

contract no 68-01-7369 from Novellber of 1987 to July of 1989 tor

-a-n = =ca

-middotshya total coat of U1107JL

vua pe rfonad laboratory eaapla analyah bullbullrvicaa for the

l ite unde r an IPA national laboratory contract in October of ltlt

tor a t otal coat of tu 514 Ol

aoy P Waaton provided ahtanca vlth bullbullbullpling under

contnct U-01-7443 in Auguat a nd Saptaaber of Ull for a total

of Uamp5 7l

2 Agranta with other Federal Aganciea

The United lltataa Coaa t Guard perfonad haurdoua aubatanca

cleanup activi ties unde r i nteragency agraaaant no AD69Pl5900

froa February of 1981 to OCtober of 1911 tor a total coat of

U69415oo

Tile United Statea Opartaant of the Interior perfoned a

praliainary natunl raaoureaa survey undar interagency aqraaaant

no DWU03120l in Saptaaber of 1914 for a total coat of

$134169

The United States Aray Corps of Enqlneera perfonad

technical aadatanc a and overaiqht or Rl FS activitiea under

intera9anoy agoreabullent no DW96114201 frobull April of 1985 to

January of 1986 for a total coat of $6292 45

l J9rant vith the State of Rhode Ialand

(a) ~middot The State of Rhoda I a land perfonaed re111oval

activitba and u rs activ i tha frobull April of 1982 to octobe r of

1989 under a cooperative aqreemant noa OV0017 0801 and

OV00172101 ) wi th EPA f or a total coat o f a t least $2 4 55 764 27

thh nullbar bull ay ba ad j uatad aa the St a t e of Rhode I a land ia atill

-7shy

providing PA with inforation on the Statabulla coata The State

of Jthoda I a land bulla coata an furtMr broken down a a followa

Contractbull

Payroll

Trave l

$2351033 44

131575 74

2919 53

2094066

7123

fS 51 146 lll

$ 2455764 17

-a-n Ct Ct ca

Cb) CoatraotJ lnaiOoyp Tha State of Rhoda Ialand antand

into nueroua contracta (at laaat 45 for perforaanc a of aarvicaa

and proviaion of aquipnt related to tha Picillo Pan Site

Eighteen of tha contractbull ara for aaounta ovar $1 000 Thaaa

aightaan contracta account for $2348 377 out of the total

$235tOllU contract coata and ara broken down aa followa

C bull K Electric provided aarvic or equipment frobull January

of 1915 to Ocallbar of 1988 for a total coat of $1848 60

Colonial Security provide aarvicaa frobull June of 1982 to

January of 1984 for a total coat of $70735 88

Ecoloqy and Environaent provided aervicea froa July of 1982

to February of 1984 for a total coat of $35758 89

GCA Corporation provided aervicea from June of 1982 to July

of 1983 for a total coat of $84 959 00

H Nu syateaa provided servicebull or equipment from Hay of 1982

to Novembe r of 1984 for a total coat of $7733 oo

r

-middot-Xavin Hubbard provided aervicaa fr~ Mbully of ltU to October

of un for a total coat of $1470150

John Lov~ran provid~ aarvicaa froa April of 1112 to Aucruat

of 1913 for a total coat of $7051 70

M 6 I InvaatiQationa providc aarvicaa frobull March of UU to

June of 1911 for a total coat of UOl 116 77

Nav 9land Talaphona provided aarvicaa and aquipbullant frobull

June of UU to February of 1919 for a totd coat of $J 164 11

Navport Ibullporta provided aarvicaa or aquipbullant in Auguat of

1912 for a total coat of $9 192 oo

O K Matariala provided aarvicaa frobull May of 1912 to July of

1913 for a total coat of $1 426 10657

Peabody Clean Induatriaa provided aarvicaa frobull January of

1911 to May of UU fo r a total coat of $25658106

Perkina Jordan providad aarvicaa frobull March of 1912 to Juna

of 1912 for a total coat ot $2460000

Port A John Inc provided equipaent and aervicea frobull

Auquat of 1982 to February of 1988 tor a total coat of $1522 50

Rhode Ialand Analytical provided aervicea or equipaent in

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $1958 00

Roger Williaaa Hoapital provided ae rvicea from september of

1982 to July of 1984 tor a total coat of $262900

San i Kan provided aquipaant and aervicea troll OCtober ot

1983 to June of 1988 for a t otal coat of $313750

Tighe and Bond provided aervicea troa February of 1983 to

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $19428061

-n = = ca

The reaaining contractbull the State of Rhode Ialand entered

into under the EPA cooperative agreent are aa folloolal

Adlerbull provided aervicea or equipaent froa January of UU

to April of 1913 for a total coat ol $30123

Allied Court Reporterbull provided aervicea in Auquat of 1914

lor a tott coat of $23000

Anderaon Contracting and Supplies provided aervicea or

equipnt in OCtober of 1912 for a total coat of $21500

AT T provided aervicea froa May ot 1915 to March of 1919

for a total coat of $25074

Atvell Coapany provided aervicea or equipaent in March ot

1912 for a total coat of $265 00

Contractorbull Supply provided equipaent in January of 1914 for

a total coat of $2200

Dictaphone Corporation provided equipaant or aervicea froa

Malrch to Kay of 1912 for a total coat of $12195

Dunqarian Brotherbull provided aervicea or equip11ent frobull

Decellber of 1983 to June of 1985 for a total coat of $11530

oupaine Gaa provided aervicea froa December of 1984 to March

of 19115 for a total coat of $37161

Federal Expreaa provided aervicea from December of 1914 to

March of 1915 for a total cost of $17800

General Pence provided equipment in June of 1985 for a total

coat of $650 00

MacDonald and Watson waate Oil Company provided aervicea or

equipaent in September of 1987 for a total coat of $15000

r

-10shy

Mine Safety provided aervlcaa or aquipbullant in october of

ltl5 for a total coat of $36170

Preaco H Pierce Cobullpany provided aqutpnt in Novaabar of

1114 tor a total coat of $97 50

Providence Blueprint provided aarvicaa in SapteaMr of 1914

for a total coat of $3000

Providence Journal provided aarvicaa in October of un and

in June of 1917 for a total coat of $410 61

Radio Shack provided aquipbullant in September of un for a

total coat of $12385

Raportinq Aoclataa provided aarvicaa in January of 1915

for a total coat of $28800

save-Rita provided aquipbullant in Auguat of 1984 for a total

coat of $1997

Scituate Portable Toilata provided equipbullant or aarvicaa

froa saptaabar of 1988 to January of 1989 for a total coat of

$34000

Saara provided equipment in June of 1984 for a total cost ot

$2599

Shoe Horn provided services or equip111ent in June of 1982 for

a total cost of $50 oo

Stbullr Gas provided services or equipment from March of 1983

to February of 1985 or a total cost o $63544

John Stockholm provided services in May o 1982 for a total

cost o $59 50

Suburban Propane provided equipment o r services rom August

-a-n = = CD

- -11shy

of UU to June of ltl7 for a total coat of $569 91

Unico provided aarvicaa or aquipaent in June of 1915 for a

total coat of uo n

Wear Guard provided aquipaant froa Decallber of Ull to

January of 1919 for a total coat of $17 4 91

4 PA Regional Payroll Travel a nd Otbar Expenaaa

EPA payroll travel and other axpenaaa of at laaat

$24619161 va r a incurred for 1)41 r aonnd activitiaa including

technical and anforcaaant activitiaa frobull Pabruary of 1982 to tha

praaant Thbullbullbull include activitiaa in the araaa of PRP aaarch alta invaatigation ovaraight raaady aalaction co-unity

ralationa and other aattara Coata accounted for a a of January shyn 17 1990 ware aa followa =

Payroll $241017 8) ca= Travel 5 229 79

Niac axpenaaa 651 06

$346898 68

5 PA Indirect coata

EPAbull indirect costa aaount to at least $363966 00

accounted tor as of January 17 1990 EPA bull indirect coata are

accounted tor by aite and are calculated by multiplying- two

tacton (1) total direct houre charqed to the Sitbull by EPAbull

Reqion I bullbullploybullbullbull ot the Waste Emerqency Services Water and

Air Divbiona for each fiacal year tro1a tiacal year 1983 to

fiscal year 1990 times (2) the EPA indirect cost rate for each

J

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 5: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

r

-5shy

with the developbullent of rabulledhl action alternativee perfoned

oveniqht of teophyaical work and aaabted groundwater

evaluationbull under contract no 61-01-6056 frobull February of Ull

to Januuy of 1112 for a total coat of $UfiOl612

CCA Technology Corporation perfo~ad an andanqanent

aeuaaHnt faaaibllity atudy and PRP arch activitiaa under

contract no 61-0J-3243 frobull July of 1915 to April of 1917 for a

total coat of $10329539

NUS Corporation parfontad co-unity relatione plan

activitha under contract no fil-01-6699 frobull February of 1915 to

Noveaber of 1915 tor a total coa t of $13 51600

Peabody Clean Industry Inc provided labor (including the

on acene coordinator) and equipbullent for diapoaal operationbull at

the lite uncSar contract no 61- Jl-0011 frobull Septellber of 1981 to

NoveUr of 1912 for a total cos t of $539 588 48

Planning Research Corporation performed PRP search and

haaibility study activitiea under contract no 68-01-7037 from

October of 1914 to Sept embe r of 1987 for a total cost of

$131012 09

Techlaw Inc organized developed an index for and

su-arized certain PRP-related documentbull from October of 1984 to

Septetgter of 1986 Theae activities were couenced under

contract no 61-01-6138 at a cost ot $670583 and completed

under contract no 68-01-7104 a t a coat of $921509

Techlaw Inc pe r formed enforcement support octivities under

contract no 68-01-7369 from Novellber of 1987 to July of 1989 tor

-a-n = =ca

-middotshya total coat of U1107JL

vua pe rfonad laboratory eaapla analyah bullbullrvicaa for the

l ite unde r an IPA national laboratory contract in October of ltlt

tor a t otal coat of tu 514 Ol

aoy P Waaton provided ahtanca vlth bullbullbullpling under

contnct U-01-7443 in Auguat a nd Saptaaber of Ull for a total

of Uamp5 7l

2 Agranta with other Federal Aganciea

The United lltataa Coaa t Guard perfonad haurdoua aubatanca

cleanup activi ties unde r i nteragency agraaaant no AD69Pl5900

froa February of 1981 to OCtober of 1911 tor a total coat of

U69415oo

Tile United Statea Opartaant of the Interior perfoned a

praliainary natunl raaoureaa survey undar interagency aqraaaant

no DWU03120l in Saptaaber of 1914 for a total coat of

$134169

The United States Aray Corps of Enqlneera perfonad

technical aadatanc a and overaiqht or Rl FS activitiea under

intera9anoy agoreabullent no DW96114201 frobull April of 1985 to

January of 1986 for a total coat of $6292 45

l J9rant vith the State of Rhode Ialand

(a) ~middot The State of Rhoda I a land perfonaed re111oval

activitba and u rs activ i tha frobull April of 1982 to octobe r of

1989 under a cooperative aqreemant noa OV0017 0801 and

OV00172101 ) wi th EPA f or a total coat o f a t least $2 4 55 764 27

thh nullbar bull ay ba ad j uatad aa the St a t e of Rhode I a land ia atill

-7shy

providing PA with inforation on the Statabulla coata The State

of Jthoda I a land bulla coata an furtMr broken down a a followa

Contractbull

Payroll

Trave l

$2351033 44

131575 74

2919 53

2094066

7123

fS 51 146 lll

$ 2455764 17

-a-n Ct Ct ca

Cb) CoatraotJ lnaiOoyp Tha State of Rhoda Ialand antand

into nueroua contracta (at laaat 45 for perforaanc a of aarvicaa

and proviaion of aquipnt related to tha Picillo Pan Site

Eighteen of tha contractbull ara for aaounta ovar $1 000 Thaaa

aightaan contracta account for $2348 377 out of the total

$235tOllU contract coata and ara broken down aa followa

C bull K Electric provided aarvic or equipment frobull January

of 1915 to Ocallbar of 1988 for a total coat of $1848 60

Colonial Security provide aarvicaa frobull June of 1982 to

January of 1984 for a total coat of $70735 88

Ecoloqy and Environaent provided aervicea froa July of 1982

to February of 1984 for a total coat of $35758 89

GCA Corporation provided aervicea from June of 1982 to July

of 1983 for a total coat of $84 959 00

H Nu syateaa provided servicebull or equipment from Hay of 1982

to Novembe r of 1984 for a total coat of $7733 oo

r

-middot-Xavin Hubbard provided aervicaa fr~ Mbully of ltU to October

of un for a total coat of $1470150

John Lov~ran provid~ aarvicaa froa April of 1112 to Aucruat

of 1913 for a total coat of $7051 70

M 6 I InvaatiQationa providc aarvicaa frobull March of UU to

June of 1911 for a total coat of UOl 116 77

Nav 9land Talaphona provided aarvicaa and aquipbullant frobull

June of UU to February of 1919 for a totd coat of $J 164 11

Navport Ibullporta provided aarvicaa or aquipbullant in Auguat of

1912 for a total coat of $9 192 oo

O K Matariala provided aarvicaa frobull May of 1912 to July of

1913 for a total coat of $1 426 10657

Peabody Clean Induatriaa provided aarvicaa frobull January of

1911 to May of UU fo r a total coat of $25658106

Perkina Jordan providad aarvicaa frobull March of 1912 to Juna

of 1912 for a total coat ot $2460000

Port A John Inc provided equipaent and aervicea frobull

Auquat of 1982 to February of 1988 tor a total coat of $1522 50

Rhode Ialand Analytical provided aervicea or equipaent in

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $1958 00

Roger Williaaa Hoapital provided ae rvicea from september of

1982 to July of 1984 tor a total coat of $262900

San i Kan provided aquipaant and aervicea troll OCtober ot

1983 to June of 1988 for a t otal coat of $313750

Tighe and Bond provided aervicea troa February of 1983 to

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $19428061

-n = = ca

The reaaining contractbull the State of Rhode Ialand entered

into under the EPA cooperative agreent are aa folloolal

Adlerbull provided aervicea or equipaent froa January of UU

to April of 1913 for a total coat ol $30123

Allied Court Reporterbull provided aervicea in Auquat of 1914

lor a tott coat of $23000

Anderaon Contracting and Supplies provided aervicea or

equipnt in OCtober of 1912 for a total coat of $21500

AT T provided aervicea froa May ot 1915 to March of 1919

for a total coat of $25074

Atvell Coapany provided aervicea or equipaent in March ot

1912 for a total coat of $265 00

Contractorbull Supply provided equipaent in January of 1914 for

a total coat of $2200

Dictaphone Corporation provided equipaant or aervicea froa

Malrch to Kay of 1912 for a total coat of $12195

Dunqarian Brotherbull provided aervicea or equip11ent frobull

Decellber of 1983 to June of 1985 for a total coat of $11530

oupaine Gaa provided aervicea froa December of 1984 to March

of 19115 for a total coat of $37161

Federal Expreaa provided aervicea from December of 1914 to

March of 1915 for a total cost of $17800

General Pence provided equipment in June of 1985 for a total

coat of $650 00

MacDonald and Watson waate Oil Company provided aervicea or

equipaent in September of 1987 for a total coat of $15000

r

-10shy

Mine Safety provided aervlcaa or aquipbullant in october of

ltl5 for a total coat of $36170

Preaco H Pierce Cobullpany provided aqutpnt in Novaabar of

1114 tor a total coat of $97 50

Providence Blueprint provided aarvicaa in SapteaMr of 1914

for a total coat of $3000

Providence Journal provided aarvicaa in October of un and

in June of 1917 for a total coat of $410 61

Radio Shack provided aquipbullant in September of un for a

total coat of $12385

Raportinq Aoclataa provided aarvicaa in January of 1915

for a total coat of $28800

save-Rita provided aquipbullant in Auguat of 1984 for a total

coat of $1997

Scituate Portable Toilata provided equipbullant or aarvicaa

froa saptaabar of 1988 to January of 1989 for a total coat of

$34000

Saara provided equipment in June of 1984 for a total cost ot

$2599

Shoe Horn provided services or equip111ent in June of 1982 for

a total cost of $50 oo

Stbullr Gas provided services or equipment from March of 1983

to February of 1985 or a total cost o $63544

John Stockholm provided services in May o 1982 for a total

cost o $59 50

Suburban Propane provided equipment o r services rom August

-a-n = = CD

- -11shy

of UU to June of ltl7 for a total coat of $569 91

Unico provided aarvicaa or aquipaent in June of 1915 for a

total coat of uo n

Wear Guard provided aquipaant froa Decallber of Ull to

January of 1919 for a total coat of $17 4 91

4 PA Regional Payroll Travel a nd Otbar Expenaaa

EPA payroll travel and other axpenaaa of at laaat

$24619161 va r a incurred for 1)41 r aonnd activitiaa including

technical and anforcaaant activitiaa frobull Pabruary of 1982 to tha

praaant Thbullbullbull include activitiaa in the araaa of PRP aaarch alta invaatigation ovaraight raaady aalaction co-unity

ralationa and other aattara Coata accounted for a a of January shyn 17 1990 ware aa followa =

Payroll $241017 8) ca= Travel 5 229 79

Niac axpenaaa 651 06

$346898 68

5 PA Indirect coata

EPAbull indirect costa aaount to at least $363966 00

accounted tor as of January 17 1990 EPA bull indirect coata are

accounted tor by aite and are calculated by multiplying- two

tacton (1) total direct houre charqed to the Sitbull by EPAbull

Reqion I bullbullploybullbullbull ot the Waste Emerqency Services Water and

Air Divbiona for each fiacal year tro1a tiacal year 1983 to

fiscal year 1990 times (2) the EPA indirect cost rate for each

J

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 6: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

-middotshya total coat of U1107JL

vua pe rfonad laboratory eaapla analyah bullbullrvicaa for the

l ite unde r an IPA national laboratory contract in October of ltlt

tor a t otal coat of tu 514 Ol

aoy P Waaton provided ahtanca vlth bullbullbullpling under

contnct U-01-7443 in Auguat a nd Saptaaber of Ull for a total

of Uamp5 7l

2 Agranta with other Federal Aganciea

The United lltataa Coaa t Guard perfonad haurdoua aubatanca

cleanup activi ties unde r i nteragency agraaaant no AD69Pl5900

froa February of 1981 to OCtober of 1911 tor a total coat of

U69415oo

Tile United Statea Opartaant of the Interior perfoned a

praliainary natunl raaoureaa survey undar interagency aqraaaant

no DWU03120l in Saptaaber of 1914 for a total coat of

$134169

The United States Aray Corps of Enqlneera perfonad

technical aadatanc a and overaiqht or Rl FS activitiea under

intera9anoy agoreabullent no DW96114201 frobull April of 1985 to

January of 1986 for a total coat of $6292 45

l J9rant vith the State of Rhode Ialand

(a) ~middot The State of Rhoda I a land perfonaed re111oval

activitba and u rs activ i tha frobull April of 1982 to octobe r of

1989 under a cooperative aqreemant noa OV0017 0801 and

OV00172101 ) wi th EPA f or a total coat o f a t least $2 4 55 764 27

thh nullbar bull ay ba ad j uatad aa the St a t e of Rhode I a land ia atill

-7shy

providing PA with inforation on the Statabulla coata The State

of Jthoda I a land bulla coata an furtMr broken down a a followa

Contractbull

Payroll

Trave l

$2351033 44

131575 74

2919 53

2094066

7123

fS 51 146 lll

$ 2455764 17

-a-n Ct Ct ca

Cb) CoatraotJ lnaiOoyp Tha State of Rhoda Ialand antand

into nueroua contracta (at laaat 45 for perforaanc a of aarvicaa

and proviaion of aquipnt related to tha Picillo Pan Site

Eighteen of tha contractbull ara for aaounta ovar $1 000 Thaaa

aightaan contracta account for $2348 377 out of the total

$235tOllU contract coata and ara broken down aa followa

C bull K Electric provided aarvic or equipment frobull January

of 1915 to Ocallbar of 1988 for a total coat of $1848 60

Colonial Security provide aarvicaa frobull June of 1982 to

January of 1984 for a total coat of $70735 88

Ecoloqy and Environaent provided aervicea froa July of 1982

to February of 1984 for a total coat of $35758 89

GCA Corporation provided aervicea from June of 1982 to July

of 1983 for a total coat of $84 959 00

H Nu syateaa provided servicebull or equipment from Hay of 1982

to Novembe r of 1984 for a total coat of $7733 oo

r

-middot-Xavin Hubbard provided aervicaa fr~ Mbully of ltU to October

of un for a total coat of $1470150

John Lov~ran provid~ aarvicaa froa April of 1112 to Aucruat

of 1913 for a total coat of $7051 70

M 6 I InvaatiQationa providc aarvicaa frobull March of UU to

June of 1911 for a total coat of UOl 116 77

Nav 9land Talaphona provided aarvicaa and aquipbullant frobull

June of UU to February of 1919 for a totd coat of $J 164 11

Navport Ibullporta provided aarvicaa or aquipbullant in Auguat of

1912 for a total coat of $9 192 oo

O K Matariala provided aarvicaa frobull May of 1912 to July of

1913 for a total coat of $1 426 10657

Peabody Clean Induatriaa provided aarvicaa frobull January of

1911 to May of UU fo r a total coat of $25658106

Perkina Jordan providad aarvicaa frobull March of 1912 to Juna

of 1912 for a total coat ot $2460000

Port A John Inc provided equipaent and aervicea frobull

Auquat of 1982 to February of 1988 tor a total coat of $1522 50

Rhode Ialand Analytical provided aervicea or equipaent in

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $1958 00

Roger Williaaa Hoapital provided ae rvicea from september of

1982 to July of 1984 tor a total coat of $262900

San i Kan provided aquipaant and aervicea troll OCtober ot

1983 to June of 1988 for a t otal coat of $313750

Tighe and Bond provided aervicea troa February of 1983 to

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $19428061

-n = = ca

The reaaining contractbull the State of Rhode Ialand entered

into under the EPA cooperative agreent are aa folloolal

Adlerbull provided aervicea or equipaent froa January of UU

to April of 1913 for a total coat ol $30123

Allied Court Reporterbull provided aervicea in Auquat of 1914

lor a tott coat of $23000

Anderaon Contracting and Supplies provided aervicea or

equipnt in OCtober of 1912 for a total coat of $21500

AT T provided aervicea froa May ot 1915 to March of 1919

for a total coat of $25074

Atvell Coapany provided aervicea or equipaent in March ot

1912 for a total coat of $265 00

Contractorbull Supply provided equipaent in January of 1914 for

a total coat of $2200

Dictaphone Corporation provided equipaant or aervicea froa

Malrch to Kay of 1912 for a total coat of $12195

Dunqarian Brotherbull provided aervicea or equip11ent frobull

Decellber of 1983 to June of 1985 for a total coat of $11530

oupaine Gaa provided aervicea froa December of 1984 to March

of 19115 for a total coat of $37161

Federal Expreaa provided aervicea from December of 1914 to

March of 1915 for a total cost of $17800

General Pence provided equipment in June of 1985 for a total

coat of $650 00

MacDonald and Watson waate Oil Company provided aervicea or

equipaent in September of 1987 for a total coat of $15000

r

-10shy

Mine Safety provided aervlcaa or aquipbullant in october of

ltl5 for a total coat of $36170

Preaco H Pierce Cobullpany provided aqutpnt in Novaabar of

1114 tor a total coat of $97 50

Providence Blueprint provided aarvicaa in SapteaMr of 1914

for a total coat of $3000

Providence Journal provided aarvicaa in October of un and

in June of 1917 for a total coat of $410 61

Radio Shack provided aquipbullant in September of un for a

total coat of $12385

Raportinq Aoclataa provided aarvicaa in January of 1915

for a total coat of $28800

save-Rita provided aquipbullant in Auguat of 1984 for a total

coat of $1997

Scituate Portable Toilata provided equipbullant or aarvicaa

froa saptaabar of 1988 to January of 1989 for a total coat of

$34000

Saara provided equipment in June of 1984 for a total cost ot

$2599

Shoe Horn provided services or equip111ent in June of 1982 for

a total cost of $50 oo

Stbullr Gas provided services or equipment from March of 1983

to February of 1985 or a total cost o $63544

John Stockholm provided services in May o 1982 for a total

cost o $59 50

Suburban Propane provided equipment o r services rom August

-a-n = = CD

- -11shy

of UU to June of ltl7 for a total coat of $569 91

Unico provided aarvicaa or aquipaent in June of 1915 for a

total coat of uo n

Wear Guard provided aquipaant froa Decallber of Ull to

January of 1919 for a total coat of $17 4 91

4 PA Regional Payroll Travel a nd Otbar Expenaaa

EPA payroll travel and other axpenaaa of at laaat

$24619161 va r a incurred for 1)41 r aonnd activitiaa including

technical and anforcaaant activitiaa frobull Pabruary of 1982 to tha

praaant Thbullbullbull include activitiaa in the araaa of PRP aaarch alta invaatigation ovaraight raaady aalaction co-unity

ralationa and other aattara Coata accounted for a a of January shyn 17 1990 ware aa followa =

Payroll $241017 8) ca= Travel 5 229 79

Niac axpenaaa 651 06

$346898 68

5 PA Indirect coata

EPAbull indirect costa aaount to at least $363966 00

accounted tor as of January 17 1990 EPA bull indirect coata are

accounted tor by aite and are calculated by multiplying- two

tacton (1) total direct houre charqed to the Sitbull by EPAbull

Reqion I bullbullploybullbullbull ot the Waste Emerqency Services Water and

Air Divbiona for each fiacal year tro1a tiacal year 1983 to

fiscal year 1990 times (2) the EPA indirect cost rate for each

J

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 7: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

-7shy

providing PA with inforation on the Statabulla coata The State

of Jthoda I a land bulla coata an furtMr broken down a a followa

Contractbull

Payroll

Trave l

$2351033 44

131575 74

2919 53

2094066

7123

fS 51 146 lll

$ 2455764 17

-a-n Ct Ct ca

Cb) CoatraotJ lnaiOoyp Tha State of Rhoda Ialand antand

into nueroua contracta (at laaat 45 for perforaanc a of aarvicaa

and proviaion of aquipnt related to tha Picillo Pan Site

Eighteen of tha contractbull ara for aaounta ovar $1 000 Thaaa

aightaan contracta account for $2348 377 out of the total

$235tOllU contract coata and ara broken down aa followa

C bull K Electric provided aarvic or equipment frobull January

of 1915 to Ocallbar of 1988 for a total coat of $1848 60

Colonial Security provide aarvicaa frobull June of 1982 to

January of 1984 for a total coat of $70735 88

Ecoloqy and Environaent provided aervicea froa July of 1982

to February of 1984 for a total coat of $35758 89

GCA Corporation provided aervicea from June of 1982 to July

of 1983 for a total coat of $84 959 00

H Nu syateaa provided servicebull or equipment from Hay of 1982

to Novembe r of 1984 for a total coat of $7733 oo

r

-middot-Xavin Hubbard provided aervicaa fr~ Mbully of ltU to October

of un for a total coat of $1470150

John Lov~ran provid~ aarvicaa froa April of 1112 to Aucruat

of 1913 for a total coat of $7051 70

M 6 I InvaatiQationa providc aarvicaa frobull March of UU to

June of 1911 for a total coat of UOl 116 77

Nav 9land Talaphona provided aarvicaa and aquipbullant frobull

June of UU to February of 1919 for a totd coat of $J 164 11

Navport Ibullporta provided aarvicaa or aquipbullant in Auguat of

1912 for a total coat of $9 192 oo

O K Matariala provided aarvicaa frobull May of 1912 to July of

1913 for a total coat of $1 426 10657

Peabody Clean Induatriaa provided aarvicaa frobull January of

1911 to May of UU fo r a total coat of $25658106

Perkina Jordan providad aarvicaa frobull March of 1912 to Juna

of 1912 for a total coat ot $2460000

Port A John Inc provided equipaent and aervicea frobull

Auquat of 1982 to February of 1988 tor a total coat of $1522 50

Rhode Ialand Analytical provided aervicea or equipaent in

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $1958 00

Roger Williaaa Hoapital provided ae rvicea from september of

1982 to July of 1984 tor a total coat of $262900

San i Kan provided aquipaant and aervicea troll OCtober ot

1983 to June of 1988 for a t otal coat of $313750

Tighe and Bond provided aervicea troa February of 1983 to

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $19428061

-n = = ca

The reaaining contractbull the State of Rhode Ialand entered

into under the EPA cooperative agreent are aa folloolal

Adlerbull provided aervicea or equipaent froa January of UU

to April of 1913 for a total coat ol $30123

Allied Court Reporterbull provided aervicea in Auquat of 1914

lor a tott coat of $23000

Anderaon Contracting and Supplies provided aervicea or

equipnt in OCtober of 1912 for a total coat of $21500

AT T provided aervicea froa May ot 1915 to March of 1919

for a total coat of $25074

Atvell Coapany provided aervicea or equipaent in March ot

1912 for a total coat of $265 00

Contractorbull Supply provided equipaent in January of 1914 for

a total coat of $2200

Dictaphone Corporation provided equipaant or aervicea froa

Malrch to Kay of 1912 for a total coat of $12195

Dunqarian Brotherbull provided aervicea or equip11ent frobull

Decellber of 1983 to June of 1985 for a total coat of $11530

oupaine Gaa provided aervicea froa December of 1984 to March

of 19115 for a total coat of $37161

Federal Expreaa provided aervicea from December of 1914 to

March of 1915 for a total cost of $17800

General Pence provided equipment in June of 1985 for a total

coat of $650 00

MacDonald and Watson waate Oil Company provided aervicea or

equipaent in September of 1987 for a total coat of $15000

r

-10shy

Mine Safety provided aervlcaa or aquipbullant in october of

ltl5 for a total coat of $36170

Preaco H Pierce Cobullpany provided aqutpnt in Novaabar of

1114 tor a total coat of $97 50

Providence Blueprint provided aarvicaa in SapteaMr of 1914

for a total coat of $3000

Providence Journal provided aarvicaa in October of un and

in June of 1917 for a total coat of $410 61

Radio Shack provided aquipbullant in September of un for a

total coat of $12385

Raportinq Aoclataa provided aarvicaa in January of 1915

for a total coat of $28800

save-Rita provided aquipbullant in Auguat of 1984 for a total

coat of $1997

Scituate Portable Toilata provided equipbullant or aarvicaa

froa saptaabar of 1988 to January of 1989 for a total coat of

$34000

Saara provided equipment in June of 1984 for a total cost ot

$2599

Shoe Horn provided services or equip111ent in June of 1982 for

a total cost of $50 oo

Stbullr Gas provided services or equipment from March of 1983

to February of 1985 or a total cost o $63544

John Stockholm provided services in May o 1982 for a total

cost o $59 50

Suburban Propane provided equipment o r services rom August

-a-n = = CD

- -11shy

of UU to June of ltl7 for a total coat of $569 91

Unico provided aarvicaa or aquipaent in June of 1915 for a

total coat of uo n

Wear Guard provided aquipaant froa Decallber of Ull to

January of 1919 for a total coat of $17 4 91

4 PA Regional Payroll Travel a nd Otbar Expenaaa

EPA payroll travel and other axpenaaa of at laaat

$24619161 va r a incurred for 1)41 r aonnd activitiaa including

technical and anforcaaant activitiaa frobull Pabruary of 1982 to tha

praaant Thbullbullbull include activitiaa in the araaa of PRP aaarch alta invaatigation ovaraight raaady aalaction co-unity

ralationa and other aattara Coata accounted for a a of January shyn 17 1990 ware aa followa =

Payroll $241017 8) ca= Travel 5 229 79

Niac axpenaaa 651 06

$346898 68

5 PA Indirect coata

EPAbull indirect costa aaount to at least $363966 00

accounted tor as of January 17 1990 EPA bull indirect coata are

accounted tor by aite and are calculated by multiplying- two

tacton (1) total direct houre charqed to the Sitbull by EPAbull

Reqion I bullbullploybullbullbull ot the Waste Emerqency Services Water and

Air Divbiona for each fiacal year tro1a tiacal year 1983 to

fiscal year 1990 times (2) the EPA indirect cost rate for each

J

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 8: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

r

-middot-Xavin Hubbard provided aervicaa fr~ Mbully of ltU to October

of un for a total coat of $1470150

John Lov~ran provid~ aarvicaa froa April of 1112 to Aucruat

of 1913 for a total coat of $7051 70

M 6 I InvaatiQationa providc aarvicaa frobull March of UU to

June of 1911 for a total coat of UOl 116 77

Nav 9land Talaphona provided aarvicaa and aquipbullant frobull

June of UU to February of 1919 for a totd coat of $J 164 11

Navport Ibullporta provided aarvicaa or aquipbullant in Auguat of

1912 for a total coat of $9 192 oo

O K Matariala provided aarvicaa frobull May of 1912 to July of

1913 for a total coat of $1 426 10657

Peabody Clean Induatriaa provided aarvicaa frobull January of

1911 to May of UU fo r a total coat of $25658106

Perkina Jordan providad aarvicaa frobull March of 1912 to Juna

of 1912 for a total coat ot $2460000

Port A John Inc provided equipaent and aervicea frobull

Auquat of 1982 to February of 1988 tor a total coat of $1522 50

Rhode Ialand Analytical provided aervicea or equipaent in

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $1958 00

Roger Williaaa Hoapital provided ae rvicea from september of

1982 to July of 1984 tor a total coat of $262900

San i Kan provided aquipaant and aervicea troll OCtober ot

1983 to June of 1988 for a t otal coat of $313750

Tighe and Bond provided aervicea troa February of 1983 to

January of 1986 tor a total coat of $19428061

-n = = ca

The reaaining contractbull the State of Rhode Ialand entered

into under the EPA cooperative agreent are aa folloolal

Adlerbull provided aervicea or equipaent froa January of UU

to April of 1913 for a total coat ol $30123

Allied Court Reporterbull provided aervicea in Auquat of 1914

lor a tott coat of $23000

Anderaon Contracting and Supplies provided aervicea or

equipnt in OCtober of 1912 for a total coat of $21500

AT T provided aervicea froa May ot 1915 to March of 1919

for a total coat of $25074

Atvell Coapany provided aervicea or equipaent in March ot

1912 for a total coat of $265 00

Contractorbull Supply provided equipaent in January of 1914 for

a total coat of $2200

Dictaphone Corporation provided equipaant or aervicea froa

Malrch to Kay of 1912 for a total coat of $12195

Dunqarian Brotherbull provided aervicea or equip11ent frobull

Decellber of 1983 to June of 1985 for a total coat of $11530

oupaine Gaa provided aervicea froa December of 1984 to March

of 19115 for a total coat of $37161

Federal Expreaa provided aervicea from December of 1914 to

March of 1915 for a total cost of $17800

General Pence provided equipment in June of 1985 for a total

coat of $650 00

MacDonald and Watson waate Oil Company provided aervicea or

equipaent in September of 1987 for a total coat of $15000

r

-10shy

Mine Safety provided aervlcaa or aquipbullant in october of

ltl5 for a total coat of $36170

Preaco H Pierce Cobullpany provided aqutpnt in Novaabar of

1114 tor a total coat of $97 50

Providence Blueprint provided aarvicaa in SapteaMr of 1914

for a total coat of $3000

Providence Journal provided aarvicaa in October of un and

in June of 1917 for a total coat of $410 61

Radio Shack provided aquipbullant in September of un for a

total coat of $12385

Raportinq Aoclataa provided aarvicaa in January of 1915

for a total coat of $28800

save-Rita provided aquipbullant in Auguat of 1984 for a total

coat of $1997

Scituate Portable Toilata provided equipbullant or aarvicaa

froa saptaabar of 1988 to January of 1989 for a total coat of

$34000

Saara provided equipment in June of 1984 for a total cost ot

$2599

Shoe Horn provided services or equip111ent in June of 1982 for

a total cost of $50 oo

Stbullr Gas provided services or equipment from March of 1983

to February of 1985 or a total cost o $63544

John Stockholm provided services in May o 1982 for a total

cost o $59 50

Suburban Propane provided equipment o r services rom August

-a-n = = CD

- -11shy

of UU to June of ltl7 for a total coat of $569 91

Unico provided aarvicaa or aquipaent in June of 1915 for a

total coat of uo n

Wear Guard provided aquipaant froa Decallber of Ull to

January of 1919 for a total coat of $17 4 91

4 PA Regional Payroll Travel a nd Otbar Expenaaa

EPA payroll travel and other axpenaaa of at laaat

$24619161 va r a incurred for 1)41 r aonnd activitiaa including

technical and anforcaaant activitiaa frobull Pabruary of 1982 to tha

praaant Thbullbullbull include activitiaa in the araaa of PRP aaarch alta invaatigation ovaraight raaady aalaction co-unity

ralationa and other aattara Coata accounted for a a of January shyn 17 1990 ware aa followa =

Payroll $241017 8) ca= Travel 5 229 79

Niac axpenaaa 651 06

$346898 68

5 PA Indirect coata

EPAbull indirect costa aaount to at least $363966 00

accounted tor as of January 17 1990 EPA bull indirect coata are

accounted tor by aite and are calculated by multiplying- two

tacton (1) total direct houre charqed to the Sitbull by EPAbull

Reqion I bullbullploybullbullbull ot the Waste Emerqency Services Water and

Air Divbiona for each fiacal year tro1a tiacal year 1983 to

fiscal year 1990 times (2) the EPA indirect cost rate for each

J

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 9: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

The reaaining contractbull the State of Rhode Ialand entered

into under the EPA cooperative agreent are aa folloolal

Adlerbull provided aervicea or equipaent froa January of UU

to April of 1913 for a total coat ol $30123

Allied Court Reporterbull provided aervicea in Auquat of 1914

lor a tott coat of $23000

Anderaon Contracting and Supplies provided aervicea or

equipnt in OCtober of 1912 for a total coat of $21500

AT T provided aervicea froa May ot 1915 to March of 1919

for a total coat of $25074

Atvell Coapany provided aervicea or equipaent in March ot

1912 for a total coat of $265 00

Contractorbull Supply provided equipaent in January of 1914 for

a total coat of $2200

Dictaphone Corporation provided equipaant or aervicea froa

Malrch to Kay of 1912 for a total coat of $12195

Dunqarian Brotherbull provided aervicea or equip11ent frobull

Decellber of 1983 to June of 1985 for a total coat of $11530

oupaine Gaa provided aervicea froa December of 1984 to March

of 19115 for a total coat of $37161

Federal Expreaa provided aervicea from December of 1914 to

March of 1915 for a total cost of $17800

General Pence provided equipment in June of 1985 for a total

coat of $650 00

MacDonald and Watson waate Oil Company provided aervicea or

equipaent in September of 1987 for a total coat of $15000

r

-10shy

Mine Safety provided aervlcaa or aquipbullant in october of

ltl5 for a total coat of $36170

Preaco H Pierce Cobullpany provided aqutpnt in Novaabar of

1114 tor a total coat of $97 50

Providence Blueprint provided aarvicaa in SapteaMr of 1914

for a total coat of $3000

Providence Journal provided aarvicaa in October of un and

in June of 1917 for a total coat of $410 61

Radio Shack provided aquipbullant in September of un for a

total coat of $12385

Raportinq Aoclataa provided aarvicaa in January of 1915

for a total coat of $28800

save-Rita provided aquipbullant in Auguat of 1984 for a total

coat of $1997

Scituate Portable Toilata provided equipbullant or aarvicaa

froa saptaabar of 1988 to January of 1989 for a total coat of

$34000

Saara provided equipment in June of 1984 for a total cost ot

$2599

Shoe Horn provided services or equip111ent in June of 1982 for

a total cost of $50 oo

Stbullr Gas provided services or equipment from March of 1983

to February of 1985 or a total cost o $63544

John Stockholm provided services in May o 1982 for a total

cost o $59 50

Suburban Propane provided equipment o r services rom August

-a-n = = CD

- -11shy

of UU to June of ltl7 for a total coat of $569 91

Unico provided aarvicaa or aquipaent in June of 1915 for a

total coat of uo n

Wear Guard provided aquipaant froa Decallber of Ull to

January of 1919 for a total coat of $17 4 91

4 PA Regional Payroll Travel a nd Otbar Expenaaa

EPA payroll travel and other axpenaaa of at laaat

$24619161 va r a incurred for 1)41 r aonnd activitiaa including

technical and anforcaaant activitiaa frobull Pabruary of 1982 to tha

praaant Thbullbullbull include activitiaa in the araaa of PRP aaarch alta invaatigation ovaraight raaady aalaction co-unity

ralationa and other aattara Coata accounted for a a of January shyn 17 1990 ware aa followa =

Payroll $241017 8) ca= Travel 5 229 79

Niac axpenaaa 651 06

$346898 68

5 PA Indirect coata

EPAbull indirect costa aaount to at least $363966 00

accounted tor as of January 17 1990 EPA bull indirect coata are

accounted tor by aite and are calculated by multiplying- two

tacton (1) total direct houre charqed to the Sitbull by EPAbull

Reqion I bullbullploybullbullbull ot the Waste Emerqency Services Water and

Air Divbiona for each fiacal year tro1a tiacal year 1983 to

fiscal year 1990 times (2) the EPA indirect cost rate for each

J

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 10: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

r

-10shy

Mine Safety provided aervlcaa or aquipbullant in october of

ltl5 for a total coat of $36170

Preaco H Pierce Cobullpany provided aqutpnt in Novaabar of

1114 tor a total coat of $97 50

Providence Blueprint provided aarvicaa in SapteaMr of 1914

for a total coat of $3000

Providence Journal provided aarvicaa in October of un and

in June of 1917 for a total coat of $410 61

Radio Shack provided aquipbullant in September of un for a

total coat of $12385

Raportinq Aoclataa provided aarvicaa in January of 1915

for a total coat of $28800

save-Rita provided aquipbullant in Auguat of 1984 for a total

coat of $1997

Scituate Portable Toilata provided equipbullant or aarvicaa

froa saptaabar of 1988 to January of 1989 for a total coat of

$34000

Saara provided equipment in June of 1984 for a total cost ot

$2599

Shoe Horn provided services or equip111ent in June of 1982 for

a total cost of $50 oo

Stbullr Gas provided services or equipment from March of 1983

to February of 1985 or a total cost o $63544

John Stockholm provided services in May o 1982 for a total

cost o $59 50

Suburban Propane provided equipment o r services rom August

-a-n = = CD

- -11shy

of UU to June of ltl7 for a total coat of $569 91

Unico provided aarvicaa or aquipaent in June of 1915 for a

total coat of uo n

Wear Guard provided aquipaant froa Decallber of Ull to

January of 1919 for a total coat of $17 4 91

4 PA Regional Payroll Travel a nd Otbar Expenaaa

EPA payroll travel and other axpenaaa of at laaat

$24619161 va r a incurred for 1)41 r aonnd activitiaa including

technical and anforcaaant activitiaa frobull Pabruary of 1982 to tha

praaant Thbullbullbull include activitiaa in the araaa of PRP aaarch alta invaatigation ovaraight raaady aalaction co-unity

ralationa and other aattara Coata accounted for a a of January shyn 17 1990 ware aa followa =

Payroll $241017 8) ca= Travel 5 229 79

Niac axpenaaa 651 06

$346898 68

5 PA Indirect coata

EPAbull indirect costa aaount to at least $363966 00

accounted tor as of January 17 1990 EPA bull indirect coata are

accounted tor by aite and are calculated by multiplying- two

tacton (1) total direct houre charqed to the Sitbull by EPAbull

Reqion I bullbullploybullbullbull ot the Waste Emerqency Services Water and

Air Divbiona for each fiacal year tro1a tiacal year 1983 to

fiscal year 1990 times (2) the EPA indirect cost rate for each

J

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 11: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

- -11shy

of UU to June of ltl7 for a total coat of $569 91

Unico provided aarvicaa or aquipaent in June of 1915 for a

total coat of uo n

Wear Guard provided aquipaant froa Decallber of Ull to

January of 1919 for a total coat of $17 4 91

4 PA Regional Payroll Travel a nd Otbar Expenaaa

EPA payroll travel and other axpenaaa of at laaat

$24619161 va r a incurred for 1)41 r aonnd activitiaa including

technical and anforcaaant activitiaa frobull Pabruary of 1982 to tha

praaant Thbullbullbull include activitiaa in the araaa of PRP aaarch alta invaatigation ovaraight raaady aalaction co-unity

ralationa and other aattara Coata accounted for a a of January shyn 17 1990 ware aa followa =

Payroll $241017 8) ca= Travel 5 229 79

Niac axpenaaa 651 06

$346898 68

5 PA Indirect coata

EPAbull indirect costa aaount to at least $363966 00

accounted tor as of January 17 1990 EPA bull indirect coata are

accounted tor by aite and are calculated by multiplying- two

tacton (1) total direct houre charqed to the Sitbull by EPAbull

Reqion I bullbullploybullbullbull ot the Waste Emerqency Services Water and

Air Divbiona for each fiacal year tro1a tiacal year 1983 to

fiscal year 1990 times (2) the EPA indirect cost rate for each

J

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 12: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

-ushyof thoaa aa fiacal yaara

6 EPA Headquartara Payroll and fraval Expena

IPA Head artara payroll travel and other axpanaea of at

lHat $20 1 56101 vera incurrad for Haadquartera paraonnal

anforcaMnt activitiaa Coate accountact for aa of January 17

ltiO vara aa followa

Payroll 1603356

Travel bull $27

Total $ 2056101

(d) rutuu cgata It h ibullpoaaibla at thh tiaa to

aatiaata tha future coata that the United Stataa will hava to apend aa additional raaponaa coata at tha Sita Tha Rabulladial c Invaatiqationjraaaibility atudy that will addraaa qroundwatar = rctiation haa not yet bequn ao that the extant or = cccontuination tha lavala of riaka and the altarnativaa tor

raaedial action cannot be datarinad at thh tiae

Ioterrgqatgry No u (reqardinq preparation of anawara)

Identify tha peraon(a) anawarinq or aaaiatinq in the

preparation of anawara to thaaa intarrOCjlatorias and tor each and

avery parson idantitlad qiva hh or har buainass address hobullbull

addra job affiliation title or poaition employaent dutiea

and specific anavar with which each parson participated

Anayar Np 16 1

The Answer to Intarroqatory 2 h basad larqely on

intor111ation contained in documents in EPA a posseaaion and in

EPA a tlnancial 111anaqeaant systems For the coat information

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 13: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

r

-ushy

regarding the expencUtuna of the State of Rhoda Uland the

United Stataa relied largely on tha docuaanta and atataaanta

provided by Jaaaa a tarorqa an accountant vith tha Rhoda Ialand

DepartHnt of Environaantal Managaaant EPA relied on tha

currant and folller IPA Raaedial Project Manaqara for tha

inforaation about tha bpoadbility of aatiaatinq futun coata

Tha penona vho aadatad in tha preparation of tha Anawar to

Intarroqatory Kuaber 2 are the following

1 Chrhtophar OConnor Coat Recovery Coord i nator Superfund Enforcant support Section u s nvironaental Protction Agency JrX Federal Bu1ldinq HS-CANl aoton MA 02103 (617) 573-9611

Kr OConnorbull dutiaa include producing collactinq reviavinq and aaintaininq coat docunta for EPA Superfund eitaa in Region 1

1 Lynne Pratua Porer Rebulledial Project Manager Rhode Uland Superfund Section us Environbullental Protection Agency JPJ Federal Building HSV-CANl Boaton MA Ol20J (617) 573-9634

Ma rratuabull duti included beinq hbulliliar with rebulledial iasuea and oversight of contractor perfonanca at the Picillo Fan~ Site

J Anna Kraako CUrrent Rebulledial Project Manager U S Environbullenta1 Protection Agency JPK Federal Building HSV-CAN2 Boston MA 02203 (617) 573-5769

Ma Kraakoa duties include being familiar with remedial issues and overaight of contractor performance

-n = = ca

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 14: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

r

at the Picillo ran Site

4 JaHa R LaForge Accountant Rhoda Iahnd Departaant of nvironaantal Manaqaaant 391 Providence Street Providence RI 03101 (401) 217-6125

Mr LaPorqaa dutha include ravhwinq and uintaininq the accounting recorda of tha Rhode Iahnd Oeprt-nt of nvironaantal Manaqaaant for the Plcillo ran lite

VERIPICATION

I Chriatophar OConnor atata

1 I bullbull tha Coat Recovery Coordinator in the Superfund nforcaaant Section Waata Manaqaaant Diviaion US nvirormantal Protection Agency Raqion I In ay role bullbull Coat Recovery Coordinator I am taailiar with tha docuaanta produced or uintained by EPA Region I relating to coata incurred by PA in connection with ita activitiaa at the Picillo ran Site

2 Neither I nor any other paraon haa cobullplete peraonal knovled9e ot all the facta aat forth in tha foregoing anawan to the intarrOCJatoriea or Defendantbull Tha facta set forth in the anawara were cobullpilad largely through raviaw of docubullanta and coaputar tilaa bullaintained by EPA with ona exception Tha exception is those documents EPA Region I received frobull the State ot Rhode Island that relate to Rhode I a land a costa under the cooperative aqreeaent it entered into with EPA regarding tha Picillo ran Site for these documents I relied on the recorda knowledge and statements or James R LaForge a n accountant who hu aaintainad tha Picillo Fan Site accounting recorda for tha State of Rhode I s land

J Baaed on ay knowledge of the information contained in tha docuanta r e lating to EPAbull costa at the Picillo Farm Site I believe that the facts relating to the costs incurred by EPA in connection with the Picillo Farm site set forth in Answer to Detendantabull Interrogatory Number 2 above are true

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing ia true and correct Executed at Boston Haaaachusetta on January 26 1990

a-n = = ca

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374
Page 15: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT UIWJ:.. or PLAIN'l'IJ'J' OJII'fiD … · tt•t••pt, In conjunction with theae anewara, the United Statea b filinq aeparately objectiona to each of

-15shy

CRTIFICATC or SZRVICI

I hereby certify that tha original ot tha toregoincJ Anavan

ot Plaintiff United Stataa to Dehndanta Intarrocratori v

aailed thia 21th day ot January 1 1990 to Dehndantabull attorney

Deainq E Sheraan Eaq Edwardbull l Anqell 1100 Hoapital Truat

Tower Providence Rhoda Ialand 02903 and that a true copy ot

auch Anawera waa aailed thla day to Michael Bardae aq

lnvironental lnforcebullent Section Land and Natural Raaourcea

Diviaion United Btataa Departaant of Juatica P O Box 7611 Ben Pranklin Station Washington D C 1 0044 1 and to Everett -nsrtino Eaq Aaaia tant United stataa Attorney Waatainatar

aqlara 8lildinq Tan Dorrance Street Providence Rhoda Ialand = = Olt03 ca

riJU TaylorA middot latant Region Counaal 0 ica of Region 1 Counaal U s Environbullantal Protction Agency Jrx Federal Building RC0-1903 Boaton MA 02203 (617) 565-3430

  1. barcode 575374
  2. barcodetext SDMS Doc ID 575374