universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/fsas_2000_22_a.pdf · universiti...

25
UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN SENSITIVITY, MORPHOLOGICAL AND GENETIC MARKER STUDIES OF COLLETOTRICHUM GLOEOSPORIOIDES (PENZ) PENZ. AND SACC. FROM MANGO AND C CAPSICl (H. SYD.) E. BUTL AND BISBY FROM CHILLI QUAH JU LEE FSAS 2000 22

Upload: dangbao

Post on 03-Mar-2018

230 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

 

UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA

AZOXYSTROBIN SENSITIVITY, MORPHOLOGICAL AND GENETIC MARKER STUDIES OF

COLLETOTRICHUM GLOEOSPORIOIDES (PENZ) PENZ. AND SACC. FROM MANGO AND

C CAPSICl (H. SYD.) E. BUTL AND BISBY FROM CHILLI

QUAH JU LEE

FSAS 2000 22

Page 2: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

AZOXYSTROBIN SENSITIVITY, MORPHOLOGICAL AND GENETIC MARKER STUDIES OF

COLLETOTRICHUM GLOEOSPORIOIDES . (PENZ) PENZ. AND SACe. FROM MANGO AND

C CAPS1Cl (H. SYD.) E. BUlL AND BISBY FROM CHILLI

By

QUAHJU LEE

Th�is Submitted in Fulfilment of the Requirement.� (or the Oegree of Master or Science in the Faculty or Science Ind Environmenta. Studiest

Univeniti Putra Malaysia.

December 2000

Page 3: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

Abstract of thesis presented to the senate ofUniversiti Putra Malaysia in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Masters of Science

AZOXYSTROBIN SENSITIVITY, MORPHOLOGICAL AND GENETIC MI\RKER STUDIES OF COLLETOTRICHUM GWEOSPORIOlDES (PENZ)

PENZ. .... ND SACCo FROM MANGO AND C C4PSlCl (H. SYD.) E. BUTL AND BISBY FROM CHILLI

By

QUAHJU LEE

December 2000

Chairperson: Or. Faridah Abdullah

Faculty : Science and Environmental Studies

This project evaluated the sensitivities of Collelotric!lum g!nensporioide.� and (',

capsici towards the fungicide Azoxystrobin. This was complemented by

morphological and genetic marker studies of the two species in order to record the

natural variation of the two species.

Twenty five cultures of ( '. g!oeosporioides were isolated from mangoes (M(IIIj!.�fe"(J

mdica) and 22 of cultures of C. capsici isolated from chillies (C0l'.<;icum annum)

were used. They were collected from Malaysia. Indonesia, Thailand, Philippines and

Taiwan. Single spore cultures were made to establish the species idel"!tity.

Isolates of both species were tested separately for fungicide sensitivity. The spore

suspension was optimised to 10.5 sporeslml for bioassays.: :Tv� assay medium used

W!!S 3. glycerol based Alkyl Ester broth, amended with rates of technical azoxystrobin

at 0.000 1,0.00 I, 0.01 and 0.1 ppm with blanks of Alkyl Ester broth as controls.

ii

Page 4: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

The tests were divided into statistical validation and actual baseline studies. For

validation studies, 6 isolates in 6 replicate test!; were used in the calculation of

experimental errors. The baseline test consisted of 3 rephcate treatments per

Azoxystrobin mte per isolate with double controls for 14 isolates of ( ',

gloeo:vporioide.t and 1 5 isolates of C. cap.tid. The validation isolates were included

together with the baseline isolates during final analysis to give a total of20 isolate.

for C gloeosporioides and a total of21 isolates for C. cap..tici .

The Alkyl Ester broth was inoculated with spore ..,;uspensions of each isolate

separately to give a final concentration of lOS sporesiml in the mixture. 60 �I

droplets of the broth-spore mixtures were incubated. in 55 mm petri dishc5 and

covered with cover slips. The reference i50late PML I was included in all tests to

monitor the consistency. Assessment \\'8S done by scoring the number of spores out

of 50 that showed germ tube elongation to a minimum of twice the spore length.

Dose responses were plotted of log rate against the number of spores germinated to

derive 80% effective dose or EDIltI values for each isolate. This entire experiment

W<lS repeated twice and the data analysed to determine the intra and inter

experimental variation. Sensitivity values were also calculated by linear regression

analysis using arcsine transfonnatlon of the data (ACSAPWIN). Results showed that

the EDMlI range for ( .. g/of:osporUJide.'i was between 0.01 ppm to 0.1 ppm white this

was between 0.001 ppm to 0.01 ppm for C. caps;c;.

'"

Page 5: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

From cultural studies. C. capsici displayed similar characteristics whereas thi� range

was more variable for C. gloeosporioid£.f;. Morphological studies showed that the

growth rates of (.'. gIcJeo.f;porioides and C. cap/o;e; \¥ere similar with an average

growth rate of 7 em/day for. its diameter. The best growth medium was Alkyl Ii'ter

Agar followed by Oatmeal Agar, V8 Iuice Agar, Potato Dextrose Agar, Malt Agar

and lastly, Cooke's medium.

Genetic characterization was done usmg short primer Random Amplified

Polymorphic DNA (RAPD) studies, Long primer-Random Amplified Polymorphic

DNA studies (LP-RAPD) and Random Amplified Microsatellite studies (RAMS).

The final dendrograms showed general clustering according to countries of origin for

C. ?/oeosporinicles and C. capsici.

ov

Page 6: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

Abstract testis yang dikemukakan kepada Senat Universiti Putra Malaysia sebaga; memenuhi 'Yarat keperluan untuk ijazah Master Sains.

KAnAN SENSITJVm TERHADAP AZOXYSTROBIN DAN JUGA KA.IIAN MORFOLOGI DAN 'MARKER' GENETIK UNTUK COLLETOTRICHUM GLOEOSPORIOIDES (PENZ) PENZ. AND SACCo DAR! MANGA DAN C.

CAPSIC/(H. SYD.) E. BurL. AND BISBY DARI CIL!.

Oleh

QUAH.IU LEE

Di.ember 2000

Penyelia : Dr. Foridah Abdullah

Fakulti : Sains dan Pengajila Alam Sekitar

Projek in; meni'lai sensitiviti C'ollelolr;chum g!oeo.tpurioide,'t dan c.cap ... fci terhadap

fungisid Azo){ystrobin. Projek dilengkapi dengan kajian-kajian morfologl dan

petanda genetik bag; kedua-dua species dengan tujuan untuk merekodkan maklumat

variasi semulajadi bagi kedua-dua spesis.

. DUB puluh lima kultur ( ', gloeos{H,rioides yang dipencilkan dari bush mangga dan

dUB puluh dua kultur ( '. c:ap.�ici dan buah cili telah digunakan. Kuitur telah

dikumpulkan dan Malaysia, Indonesia, Thailand, Filipina dan Taiwan. Sampel

berpenyakit telah diisolatkan daripada perumahnya dan pemencilan dibuat untuk

membolehkan pengenalpastian spesis dibuat seterusnya.

Isolat daripada spesis telah diuji secara berasingan untuk mendapatkan mnklumat

sensitivity terhadap fungi sid. Suspensi isolat telah dioptimumkan pada kepekatan I O�

spora/ml untuk ujian. Medium ujian yang telah digunakan adalah broth Alkyl Ester

Page 7: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

yang berdasarkan gliserol dengan kepekatan Awxystrobin pada 0.0001 ppm. 0.001

ppm, 0.01 ppm dan 0.1 ppm sementara kawalan yang digunakan adalah broth Alkyl

Ester sahaja.

lJjian telah dibahagikan kepada Icajian bacaan ralat ujikaji atau . validation' dan

kajian sebenar sensitivity atau 'ba.seHne', Untuk kajian 'validation'� 6 isolal telah

digunakan dalam 6 ujian replilcat dan data telah digunakan untuk mengira bacaan

ralat eksperimen. Ujian 'baseline" terdiri daripada 3 rawatan replikat untuk setiap

kadar bagi setiap isolat dengan dua kali ganda replikat masing.masing untuk rawatan

kawalan bagi 14 iso1al C. gloeospor;oides dan 15 isolal C capsid. Isolat dari kajian

'validation' kemudiannya dimasukkan bersama dengan isolat 'baseline' uotuk

memberikan sejumlah 20 isolat untuk C. g{oeo.'fporinides dan 21 isolat untuk (',

capsici.

Broth Alkyl Ester tclah diinokulat secara bera-';ingan untuk ampaian spora setiap

isolat untuk menghasilkan kepekatan akhir sebanyak 105 spora/ml dalam campuran

tersebut. Titisan 60 �ll dari campuran broth dengan spora itu seterusnya dieramkan

dalam piring petri SS mm dengan ditutup dengan si::;ip kaca. Isolat rujukan , PMl.1.

telah dimasukkan ke dalam semua ujian untuk memantau keseragaman ujian.

Penilaian dilakukan dengan meng;ra bilangan spora yang menunjukkan percambahan

melalul tiub germa sekurang-kurangnya dua kali ganda panjang spora tersebut dari

50 spora setiap plat.

' Dose responses' kemudiannya telah diplot bag; kadar log mel.wan bilangan spora

tercambah untuk menghasilkan nilai-nilai EDR(! untuk setiap iwlal Keseluruhan

Page 8: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

UJlan tetah dijalankan dua kali untuk menentukan vanasi sesama isolat dalam

kumpulan atau 'intra' dan diantara isolat atau 'inter' dalam ujian-ujian. NHai-niiai

scnsitiviti juga dikira melalui regresi linear dengan menggunakan transformasi arc­

sin bagi data teOOut (ACSAPWIN). Keputussn menunjukkan nilsi ED., bagi C.

p;loeo.,porioides adafah diantara 0.0 I ppm hingga 0.1 ppm scmentara nilai ED.,

bagi ( .. capsici adalah diantara 0.001 ppm hingga 0.01 ppm.

Dad kajlan kultur C. capsici menunjukkan ciri-ciri yang hampir serupa sesama

sendiri manakala ciri-ciri C. glof!(),'iporioides menunjukkan lebih vanasi. Kajinn

morfologi pula menunjukkan bahawa kadar pe:rtumbuhan diameter hompir serupa

dengan purata 7 cmlhari. Medium pertumbuhan yang paling baik adalah Agar Alk,1

Ester diikuti oleh Agar Oatmeal. Aga, J ... \I8,Aga, P otato Dei<1TDS<\. Agar Malt H,tTak

dan akhimya Medium Cooke.

Pencirian genetik telah dilakukan dengan menggunakan kajian primer pendek

RAPD, kajian primer pao"angU'-1\ftPo dan kajian RAMS. Keputusan akhir dalam

benluk dendrogram menunjukkan perkelompokan umum mengikut negara asal

masing-masing untuk ('. fl.!oeo.'fipnrioide,<; dan C. capsid.

V"

Page 9: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

My sincere gratitude to:

Zeneca Agrochemicals for sponsoring this proje<:t and especially to Steve Dale, Steve Heaney, Sally Davies and Mari. Efstathiou of Zene<:a Agrochemicals for all the.technical advice given and kindness shown during my stay in J .. lotl's Hill, U.K.

All the staff of CCM Bioscience in Malaceo for all their support and understanding.

Dr. Faridah Abdullah for her supervision of this project and for access to her facilities in the laboratory as well as her moral support during tough times.

Professor Tan Soon Guan for his supervision of the genetic studies which is included in Chapter 5 of the thesis.

Kam Boon Seng, my fiancee, for his moral support and kindness shown during the project.

Everyone in the Mycology and Genetic laboratories for their cheerful enthusiasm and understanding and help in times of need.

Especially to my beloved father, Dr. Quah Soon Cheang, for all his care, love and guidarx::e.

Finally, to my beloved late mother who never failed to keep the faith and the belief that all things are possible with the help of God.

vw

Page 10: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

I certify that an Examination Committee met on 4" May 2001 to conduct the final examination of Quah Ju Lee on her Masters of Science thesis entitled "Azoxystrobin Sensitivity, Morphological and Genetic Marker Studies of Colletotrichum g/oeosporioides (penz) Penz. and Sacco from Mango and C. capsici (H. Syd.) E. Butl. and Bisby from Chilli" in accordance with Universiti Pertanian Malaysia (Higher Degree) Act 1980 and Universiti Pertanian Malaysia (Higher Degree) Regulations 1981. The Committee recommends that the candidate be awarded the relevant degree. Ahlis of the Examination Committee are as follows:

Radzali Muse, Ph.D. Associate Professor, Faculty of Science and Environmental Studies, Universiti Putra Malaysia. (Chairman)

Faridah Abdullah, Ph.D, Associate Professor, Faculty of Science and Environmental Studies, Universiti Putra Malaysia. (Member)

Tan Soon Guan, Ph.D. Professor, Faculty of Science and Envirorunental Studies, Universiti Putra Malaysia. (Member)

Mah Shook Yin, Research Officer. Stesen Jalan Kebun, MARDI, Klang, Selangor. (Member)

HAZAL-fMOHA YIDIN, Ph.D, Professor I Deputy Dean of Graduate School, Universiti Putra Malaysia

Date: 17 .MiN 2001

ix

Page 11: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

This thesis submitted to the Senate of Universiti Putra Malaysia has been accepted in fulfilment of the requirement for the degree of Masters of Science.

,

c2--� A�' IDEiSs:P/LD. Professor, Dean of Graduate School. Universiti Putrs Malaysia.

Date: 1 2 JUL 1001

Page 12: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

DECLARATION

I hereby declare that the thesis is based on my original work except for quotations and citations which have been duly acknowledged. I also cle<:lare that it has not been previously or concu�ntly submitted for any other degree at UPM or other institutions.

Quah Ju Lee

Page 13: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

TABLE OF CONTENTS

ABSTRACT ABSTRAK ACKNOWLEDGEMENT APPROVAL SHEETS DECLARA nON FORM LIST OFT ABLES LIST OF FIGURES LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS

CHAPTER

fNTRODUCnON

II LITERATURE REVIEW Historical Background Synthesis of Azoxystrobin

Mode of Action Biological Properties Physiological Properties

Selection of Colletolnchum for Testing The Genus ( :ollelOtrichum

Collelolrichum gloeosporioide ... (Penz.) Penz. and Sacco Col/etotrichum cap.'ic; (H. Syd.) E. Butl . And Bisby.

Sample Storage Chilli Mango Resistance Measuring Resistance to Fungicides Baseline data assessment 8ioassays for Detection

Poison Plate Tests Liquid Broth Tests In vivo Tests

Genetic Analysis Genetic Markers Various Genetic Methods Polymerase Chain Reaction

Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA Long-Primer Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA Random Amplified Microsatellites

xii

PAGE

ii V VIII ix x, xv, XVII xx

6 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 1 5 16 17 18 19 21 22 D 25 25 26 26 27 28 29 30 33 34

Page 14: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

[([ SAMPLE COLLECTION AND CHARACTERISATION Introduction Objectives Material and Methods

Collection of C. gloeo,'iporioide,t and (', cop:r;ic; isolates Isolation of Raw Samples Single Spore Isolation Species Identification Sample Storage

Results

Agar Slant Storage Cryopreservation

Colony Characteristics Morphological and Growth Studies Sporulation. Spore Germination and Appresoria studies Pathogenicity Test

36 37 38 38 40 40 41 41 41 42 42 43 44 45 46

Collection data for Colletotrichum g/oemporioide,'j and C. cap.vici 46 Culture Characteristics 49 Solid Media Growth Studies 49 Liquid Media Growth Studies 50 Pathogenicity Studies 50

Discussion 55

IV FUNGICIDE SENSITIVITY BASELINE BIOASSAY Introduction 59 Material and Methods 60

Media Used 60 Optimization 61 Spore Germination on Solid Media n I

agar and broth Washing of spores and increasing humidity on germination rates 64

Using microcycle conidiation versus "onnal c,onidiation on 64 germination rates

Concentrations of inoculum and broth on germination rates 6" Varying concentrations of Azoxystrohin on germination rates 65 Droplet test development 65 Validation bioassay 67 Baseline bioassay 6Q Experimental controls 70 Statistical Analysis 70

Results 71 The effect of different solid media on spore germination 71 Washing spores and increasing humidity on germination rates 71 Using microcycle conidiation versus nonnal on germination rate!' 72 Concentrations of inoculum and broth on germination rates 72 Droplet Test Development 73 Controls 73 Optimized Test 74

XIII

Page 15: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

Validation bioassay: Sensitivity ofCollelofrichllnl ghlef).'>porioit/e," to Aloxystrobin

Baseline bioassay: Sensitivity of (.'ollf'lolrichlllfl r./oen.'ii(H)rif)ide,'i to Azoxystrobin

Validation bioassay: Sensitivity of (.'olle,.IIrichum c.:ap. .. ;c; to Azoxystrobin

Baseline bioassay: Sensitivity of ('"lIelolr;clwlIl cap,(ic; to Azoxystrobin

Summary of Data Analysis Discussion

V MOLECULAR MARKER STUDIES

74

78

79

83

84 90

Introduction q7 Material and Methods 97

Sample Preparation q7 Genomic DNA Extraction qR

Phenol Chloroform Extraction QQ CT AB Extraction Method 100 DNA Purity and Quantity 100

Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA 1 01 (RAPD) Procedure

Ltmg-Primer Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA 102 (LP-RAPD) Procedure

Random Amplified MicTOsatel1ites 10) (RAMS) Procedure

Statistical Analysis of Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA. 105 Long-Primer Random Amplified Polymorphic nNA, Random Amplified Microsatellites markt:rs

Results 1 06 Optimization and the Effect ofDifTerent Reaction 106

Parameters Screening and Selection of Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA 1 ()6

Primers Random I\mplified Polymorphic DNA Bands 10101 Band Patterns 10Q Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA Population Analysis IOQ Screening ror Selection or Long Primer· Random Amplified 10Q

Polymorphic DNA Analysis Long Primer - Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA Bands IIQ Screening and Selection of Random Amplified Microsatellites 1 19

Primers Random Amplified Microsatelliles Bands II q Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA on ( '. J!.loeo ... "oriuide... 124 Random Amplified Polymorphic ON/\. on ( '. carsici 1 24 Long Primer - Random Amplifled Polymorphic DNA Trees 127 Long Primer· Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA on 127

( .. g/oeosrorioides

Page 16: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

Long Primer - Random Amplified Polymorphic DNA on 127 ( " , cap .... id

Random Amplified Microsatellites Trees 130 Random Amplified Microsateltites on ( ", g/oeo.">porioide... 130 Random Amplified Mierosatettites on C. cap,tici 131 Dendrogram for (�. �ft�m;{Jflrio;de,\' 131 Dendrogram for C. c<I{1_'ici 131

Discussion 136

VI GENERAL DISCUSSION

VII CONCLUSION

REFERENCES APPENDICES VITAE

146

156

15H

Page 17: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

LIST OF TABLES

Tables Page

3.1 Collection data for Co/lelolrichum g{oeosporioide.y 47

3.2 Collection data for Collelolrichum capsici 48

3.3 Cultural characteristics of Collelolrichum gloeosporioide., from 51 mango grown on Potato Dextrose Agar

3.4 Cultural characteristics of CQ{{etotrichum cap,fici from chilli 53 grown on Potato Dextrose Agar

4.1 Amount of Azoxystrobin incorporated into agar for various 63 final concentrations

4.2 Germination rates for (:olletOirichum gloeosporiQides and 71 Colletotrichum capsici

4.3 Table ofEDRO estimates and their 95% confidence limits for 77 validation (�t)lIeto(richum g/oeosporioides isolates

4.4 Table of confidence limits for EOzo values based on validation 81 study

4.5 Table of EDso estimates and their 95% confidence limits for 82 validation ('. cap.'iici isolates.

4.6 Validation test results for (:ollelolrichum ?,Ioeosporioides 86

4.7 Validation test results for Col/etolrichllm capsici 86

4.8 Calculation of confidence limits (95%) around maximum and 86 minimum sensitivity value for CollelOtrichtlm i!!oeo.vpor;oide ... and ('olle((}lrichum cap.,\ici

4.9 Azoxystrobin Baseline sensitivity values Col/elntrk/Jum 87 g/oeosporioides

4.10 Azoxystrobin Ba..c;eline sensitivity values Co/lelOlrichum capsici 88

5.1 List ofRAPD primers used in the population studies 107

5.2 Band frequencies of22 RAPD zones for 23 individuals 1\0 representing 5 populations of Col/etotricllUm g!oem.por;oides

5.3 Band frequencies of 17 RAPD zones for 23 individuals 112 representing 5 populations of Collelotrichum capsicj

"'"

Page 18: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

5.4 List of LP-RAPD primers used in the population studies 114

5.5 Band frequencies of 18 LP-RAPD zones for 23 individuals liS representing 5 populations of Collelolrichum g/aeospohoide:;

5.6 Band frequencies of 13 LP-RAPD zones for 23 individuals 117 representing 5 populations of Col!elolr;chum cap.rid

5.7 List of RAMS primers used in the population studies 118

5.8 Band frequencies of 19 RAMS zones for 23 individuals 120 representing 5 populations of Co/lelolrichum gloeo.rporioides

5.9 Band frequencies of 18 RAMS zones for 23 individuals 122 representing 5 popuLations of Co/lelotrichum capsie;

l(VII

Page 19: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

Figure

3.1

4.1

4.2

LIST O F FIGURES

Map of collection s;tes for ( "o/lelolric/wm gfoen."porioide." and ('ollelolrichllm capsic; from Malaysia

Alkyl Ester Broth (2x)

Layout of 6 well plates

Page

39

60

62

4.3 Dilution series for Azoxystrobin incorporated into agar for various 62 final concentrations

4.4 Dilution series for Azoxystrobin rates used . 66

4.5 Frequency distribution of Geometric Mean EDl\Ovalues for 76 ("(}llelolricitum gJoem'porioides

4.6 Histogram of log ED80 estimates for ('ol/efofriclmm 80

x/rleosptJrilJicies isolates

4.7 Graph of log ED�1 estimates for validation ('. ca" ... h:i 81 isolates

4.8 Histogram of log EDN) estimates for ('ollelOlrichwn capsid 84

isolates

4 Q Frequency distribution of geometric Mean E080 values for 8Q ('(JIlf!f(lfriclwm gh'eosporhmk ...

4.10 Frt!qucncy distrihution of geometric Mean RD80 va�ues for 89

( 'ollelolriclwm copsici

5,1 Table of isolates used and phenetic tree for (', Ki(leosporioi<les 125 isolates screened with RAPO primers,

5,2 Table of isolates used and phenetic tree for (', capsid isolates 126 screened with RAPD primers,

5.3 Table of isolates used and phenetic tree for ( " K/oeos{JorifJiJes 128 isolates screened with Lp·RAPD primers.

5.4 Table of isolates used and phenetic tree for ( ', cupsici isolates 129 screened with LP·RAPD primers

5.5 Table of isolates used and phenetic tree for ( '. g[oeosp(lrioides isolates screened with RAMS primers

132

Page 20: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

5.6

5.7

5.R

Table of i�olates used and phenetic tree tor (', cap.'tici isolates screened with RAMS primers

Dendrogram for (·ol/elotric.:hum g/oe'l.'tptlrioiae,<;

Dendrogram for ('ollelolnchwn capsici

132

134

135

Page 21: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

Chemicals

CTAB

EOTA

KCI

MgCI,

SOS

TBE

TE

Media

AEA

AEB

CB

C'OA

C'MA

DWA

LBA

MA

MEA

MEB

OMA

POA

POB

SOA

TWA

LIST OF ABBREVlA TIONS

cetyltrimethylammoniwn bromide

Ethylenediamine tetraacetate

Potassium chloride

Magnesiwn chloride

Sodium dodccyl sulphate

Tris·borate·EDT A buffer

Tris·EDTA buffer

Alkyl Ester Agar

Alkyl Ester Broth

Cooke's Broth

Czapek Dox Agar

('om Meal Agar

Oi,rilled Walcr Agar

Lima Be;to Agar

Malt Agar

Malt Extract Agar

Malt Extract Broth

Oatmeal Agar

Potato Dextrose Agar

Potato Dextrose Broth

Sabourand Dextrose Agar

Tap Water Agar

Page 22: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

Unib

"C'

EO

hr

kb

min

ml

mM

mg

nmole

ppm

p.s.1.

sec

sporeslml

�,g

�I

�M

V

w/v

Celsius

Effective Dose

hour

kilobase

minute

mililiter

milimolar

miligram

nanomole

part per million

pound per square inch

second

spores per mililiter of spore suspension

microgram

microliter

micrometTe

micromolar

volt

weight f volume

x)l.i

Page 23: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

CRAPTER 1

rNTRODUCTION

The disease anthracnose i!: a prevalent post-harvest disease in South East Asia. It is

caused hy several fungi, the most common of which is Col/elnlrichum. Certain

species of the genus are known to have a wide host range while others have specific

hosts. Among members of the genus, the most common form is CollefolricJrum

gloeosporioides. which has a wide host range. It causes symptoms of black sunken

lesions on surfaces of fruits such as mangoes, papayas and apples (Freeman el al..

1998) which reduces the market value of the otherwise perfect fruits. An equallv

important species is ( :. cap.�ici which has a nanow host range, infecting only chillies

(Misra and Mahmood. 1960). Mangoes and chillies are the major host; for ( ..

g/oew'pori(}ides and C. capsici respectively. if not controlled, anthracnose is capable

of cau!'ing huge post-harvest lo!'ses. The most .common means of control thwughoul

the world is by the use of fungicides.

The use of Fungicide depends on the expectation of achieving a yield greater than its

input and its application costs. Compared to other methods of increasing yield.

fungicides are comparatively more effective and economical in the long lerm

Fungicide-treated plants showed significantly greater yield in weight of marketahle

fruit, (Torgeson. 1967).

Page 24: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

2

A fungicide is a molecule that is able to destroy or halt the development of fungi

without killing the host (Torgeson, 1967). In the simplest term, a fungicide is a

substance destructive to fungi (Abercrombie et. al. 1971). There are Iwo general

type.' of fungicides. namely protectanl> and systemic. Protectants act by shielding the

plant surface whereas systemic fungicides are absorbed and I",nslocated to growing

points of the plants. Eradicants ace used to control disease spread on plants with

pronounced diseases symp�oms. Fumigants are volatile compounds that protects the

whole plant. Currently, classical protective organic fungicides are commonly used.

although the usage of highly active systemic compounds with curative action are

increasingly being tested (Torgeson, 1967).

Of the agrochemicals used worldwide, fungicides make up only 19% compared to

herbicides and insecticides, which makes up 48% and 28% of total pesticide sales in

1997 respeclively. Global sales of pesticides amounted 10 US $31.25 billion in 1997

(Anon, 19Q7). Adverse trading conditions during the economic downturn of IQ9R-

1999 have caused a decrease in pesticide sales volume of 5-10°/11. However. the

converse was true for A7.oxystrobin where sales grew o-ver 40% since its first

registration in the United Kingdom, Europe and United Stat� of America in 1997. In

1 9Q9, world wide sale of US $415 million was achieved making A7.0xystrobin a

leading proprieta!)' fungicide in the world (Anon. 1999).

Azoxystrobin, Zeneca Agrochemical's new broad spectrum systemic fungicide from

the strobilurin group, originated from natural fungicides. namely oudemansin A and

strobilurin A that are produced by a number of edible mushrooms that grow in

temperate forests on decaying wood. These natural anti-fungal products helped the

Page 25: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA AZOXYSTROBIN …psasir.upm.edu.my/9093/1/FSAS_2000_22_A.pdf · universiti putra malaysia azoxystrobin sensitivity, morphological and genetic marker studies

J

mushroom to compete w;th other fungi for nutrients. The compounds were tested

and found to give promising results of disease control. This lead to a programme of

chemical synthesis to design analogues with improved activity and optimized

physical properties, such as greater photostability and low volatility. Further

research, led to the selection of compounds which showed a high level of fungicidal

activity with excellent crop safety in addition to a low mammalian toxicity and

benign environmental profile. This compound was identified as Azoxystrobin and

was given the registrated trade name of Amistar� (Anon, 1996).

Presently. registrations have already been granted in over 40 countries. In the IJSA.

'Amistar' has been registered under the EPA's Reduced Risk Pesticide Program. In

the European Community, it is the first new active ingredient to be Annex I listed.

Registrations have been granted or are pending in several Asian countries with

widespread sales anticipated in the region from 1999 onwards (Dale el 01.,1 999).

In March 2000, Azoxvstrobin (Amistar�) was awarded the 'Millennium Product'

status by the Design Council of United Kingdom for being a product that challenge!'

existing conventions. is environmentally responsible, and demonstrates the

application of a new technology. The product has been approved for use in 61

countries on more than 65 crops (Anon, 2000).

In situations of intensive usage it is important to have appropriate monitoring 10

detect shifts in sensitivity before the product becomes commercially significant. The

basis of monitoring is to ensure product effectiveness with prolonged use. In order to

do this, Ihe sensitivity of Ihe pathogenic fungi 10 Azoxyslrobin before product