universiti putra malaysia limit criteria of post ...predicting maximum crack width deflection of...

25
UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST-TENSIONED THIN WEB BEAMS LEE TEANG SHUI FK 1989 1

Upload: others

Post on 14-Sep-2020

11 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

  

UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA

LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST-TENSIONED THIN WEB BEAMS

LEE TEANG SHUI

FK 1989 1

Page 2: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

It is hereby certified that we have read this thesis entitled 'Limit Criteria of Post-Tensioned Thin Web Beams' by Lee Teang Shui, and in our opinion it is satisfactory in terms of the scope, quality, and presentation as partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy

. . ....... . . .. . . . . . .

PETER MONTAGUE, Ph.D. Professor

Department of Engineering University of Manchester

(External Examiner)

��j. � • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • rt • • • •

SHUAIB H. AHMAD, Ph.D. Associate Professor

North Carolina State University (External Examiner)

ZOHADIE BA DAlE, Ph.D. Associate Professor/Dean

Faculty of Engineering Universiti Pertanian Malaysia

(Internal Examiner)

.. . . . . . .. . .. . .. . . .

S. A. SALAM, Ph.D. Associate Professor

Faculty of Engineering Universitl PeTtanian Malaysia

(Internal Examiner/Supervisor)

» #

Page 3: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

I certify that the Board of Examiners have met on October 14, 1989 to conduct the final examination of this candidate on his Doctoral thesis in accordance with Universiti Pertanian MalaYSia (Higher Degree) Act 1980 and Universiti Pertanian Malaysia (Higher Degree) Regulations 1981, and recommended that the candidate be awarded the relevant degree •

Date: 2 2 MAR 1990 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . �.

AHMAD MAHDZAN AYOB, Ph.D. Professor/Dean of Graduate Studies

(Chairman, Board of Examiners)

This thesis was submitted to the Senate of Universiti Pertanian Malaysia and was accepted as fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy.

, -

Date: AHMAD MAHDZAN AYOB, Ph.D. Professor/Dean of Graduate Studies

Page 4: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST-TENSIONED THIN WEB BEAMS

By

LEE TEANG SHUI

A Thesis Submitted in Partial Ful filment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy

in the Faculty of Engineering Universiti Pertanian Malaysia

october 1989

Page 5: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

The a ut hor wi s he s to record hi s apprec i at i o n a nd

grat itude to hi s s upervisor Dr . S . A . S a l a m, Depart me nt

o f civ i l a nd Env i ro nme nt a l Eng i ne e r i ng , Uni ve r s i t i

Pe r t a n i a n Ma l a ys i a (UPM ) fo r hi s s up e rv i s i o n,

e ncourageme nt a nd co mments . Appreciation is also due to

Ir . Aba ng Abdul l a h b i n Aba ng Al i , Profes sor a nd former

Dea n of Fa cul t y of Eng i neering , Univers i t i Perta ni a n

Ma l a ys i a , Dr . Mo hd . Zo hadie Barda i e , t he Dea n o f t he

Faculty of Engi neeri ng, Universiti Perta ni a n Mal a ys ia ,

a nd above a l l , Unive r s i t i Pert a ni a n Ma l a ys i a for t he

s upport prov ided . Recog ni t i o ns of apprec iat i o n are

a l s o d ue to t he Li b r a r y A ut ho r i t i e s i n Uni v e r s i t i

Ma l a ya , Univers i t i Tek no l og i Ma l a ys i a a nd Unive r s i t i

Pertanian Malaysia for provid i ng excel l e nt services and

s o ur c e s wher e mo s t o f t he l i t e r a t ur e rev i e wed a r e

obta i ned. The a ut hor wi s hes t o e xpre s s hi s profo und

grat i t ude t o En . B a harud i n b i n Abd ul Ka r i m fo r t he

val ua ble ass ista nce give n, without which the laboratory

e xp e r i me nt s und e r t a ke n wo ul d no t ha ve b e e n d ul y

compl eted in the scheduled time. Tha nks are also due to

Hj. Gha za l i b i n Said, En. Mesra n bi n Rasan, En. Sul e ima n

b i n Abdul Azi z, En. Jo hn Posko Amalara j, En. Ga nesan a /I

Pat hayappan and En. Sahat bin Daud, all o f who m have i n

o ne wa y o r a no t he r , he lped dur i ng t he c o ur s e o f t he

e xperime nts. The author is grateful to Dr . Douglas C.

ii

Page 6: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

G o o de f rom t h e D ep a r tmen t o f c i v i l E n g i n e er i ng ,

University o f Manchest er, Un i t ed Kingdom, f o r h i s

advice given during his short visit to the Faculty o f

Engineeri ng, Universiti Pertanian Mal aysia, in 1 9 88,

u n der t h e a c a dem i c l i n k f o st er ed b et w een t h e tw o

universities .

Lee, Teang Shui

Universiti Pertanian Malaysia S erdang , 4 3 4 00 Selangor Darul Ehsan Mal aysia

October 1989

iii

Page 7: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

TABLE OF CONTENTS

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

LIST OF TABLES

LIST OF FIGURES

LIST OF PLATES

LIST OF SYMBOLS

ABSTRACT

ABSTRAK

CHAPTERS

I INTRODUCTION

General

Advantages of Prestressed Concrete Over Reinforced Concrete

Pretens ioned and Posttensioned Prestressed Concrete

Bonded and Unbonded Posttensioned Prestressed Concrete

Partially Prestressed Concrete

Definition

Development of Partial Prestressing

Advantages and Disadvantages

I and T sections

Limit Criteria for Prestressed Concrete

Objectives and Scope of Work

iv

PAGE

i i

x

x i i

xvi

xix

xxi i

xxiv

1

1

5

7

8

1 0

1 0

13

16 18

19

2 4

Page 8: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

II FLEXURAL STRENGTHS OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED CONCRETE MEMBERS

PAGE

28

Introduction 28

Steel Stresses in Prestressed Concrete Beams 3 2

Determination of the Neutral Axis Depth 38

Code Provisions 41

Flexural Strengths of Partially Prestressed Beams by the strain Compability Method 43

III SHEAR STRENGTHS OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED CONCRETE MEMBERS 52

IV

V

Introduction to Shear in Prestressed Concrete

I and T sections

Shear Strength of Partially Prestressed Concrete Beams

Ultimate Shear Prescribed by Code of Practice BS 8 110:198 5

FLEXURAL CRACKS IN PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED CONCRETE

Introduction

Cracking Load

Predicting Maximum Crack width

DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS

Introduction

Predicting Deflection and Camber

v

5 2

6 1

64

66

72

72

75

77

87

87

89

Page 9: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

VI EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAM

General Description of Model Beams

constant and Varying Parameters of the Beams

Concrete : Mix Design for strength

Prestressing steel, Normal Reinforcement and Web Reinforcement

Ducts and Grouting for Prestressing Tendons

End Blocks

Prestressing of Tendons and Measuring of Camber

Beam Testing Procedure

Beam Testing Errors

PAGE

99

99

104

105

106

107

108

108

109

110

VII EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS 112

Presentation of Theoretical Calculations and Experimental Data 112

strain Measurements 113

VIII DISCUSSION 166

Flexure 166

Theoretical Predictions and Observed Ultimate Flexural Failure 166

Effect of Bond on Ultimate Flexural Load 169

Effect of Prestress on Ultimate Flexural Load 170

Effect of Additional Reinforcements on Ultimate Flexural Load 172

vi

Page 10: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

PAGE

Prediction of Ultimate Flexural Moment by Code BS 8110 173

Shear 175

Shear Cracking Resistance of Prestressed Concrete 175

Theoretical and Experimental Shear Cracking Strength 176

Effect of Deformed Bars on the First-shear-cracking Load on Concrete in Prestressed Concrete Beams 179

Effect of Shear Reinforcement on First-shear-cracking Load on Concrete in Prestressed Concrete Beams 180

Effect of Prestress on First-shear-cracking Load on Concrete 182

Combined Effect of Prestress, Additional Reinforcements and Shear Reinforcement on First-shear-cracking Load on Concrete 182

Predicted Ultimate Shear Strength and Experimental Ultimate Shear Strength of Concrete in Prestressed Concrete Beams 184

Effect of Shear Reinforcements on the Ultimate Shear Strength of Prestressed Concrete Beams 185

Combined Effect of Deformed Bars and Shear Reinforcements on the Ultimate Shear Strength of Prestressed Concrete Beams 187

Effect of Bond on Shear strengths of the Partially Prestressed Beams 187

Serviceability of Beams not Reinforced in Shear 188

Cracking Load, Number of Cracks, Crack Width and Crack Spacing 189

General 189

Cracking Load 191

vii

Page 11: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

IX

PAGE

Number of Cracks 194

Crack width 2 09

Crack Spacing 2 2 2

Effect of Bond on Cracking Load , Number of Cracks and Crack width 2 2 4

Factors controll ing Serviceabi l ity 2 2 7

Deflection 2 2 9

Effect of Shear Reinforcements on Deflection 2 2 9

Effect of Deformed Bars on Deflection 2 3 4

Predicting Defl ection of the Prestressed Beams 2 3 5

Effect of Bond on Deflection 2 36

CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Conclusions

Ultimate Load

Shear Strength

Flexural Cracking

Deflection

Recommendations

REFERENCES

APPENDICES

A End Block in Posttensioned Beams

B Design of Normal Concrete Mixes by DOE Method

v i i i

2 3 9

2 3 9

2 3 9

2 4 0

241

2 4 3

243

2 4 5

2 56

2 56

2 5 7

Page 12: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

C HP4 1C Program for Determining Neutral Axis and Calculat ing Ultimate Moment

D HP4 1C Program for Determining Serv ice Stresses and cracking Load

E HP4 1C Program for Determining centroi d of T Beams

F HP4 1 C Program for Calculating Deflection by Naaman's Method

G HP4 1 C Program for Calculating De flection (after Goode )

H HP4 1 C Program for Crack width

I HP4 1 C Program for Students' T stati stical Test for Pa ir Observations

J Analysis of Partially Prestressed Concrete Beams for Testing

K Ca lculation of Crack widths

VITA

L Theoretical Calculations, Experimental Data and Observations of Model Beams

ix

PAGE

2 58

2 63

2 65

2 67

2 70

2 72

2 7 6

2 7 8

2 85

2 88

3 06

Page 13: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

LIST OF TABLES

TABLE

1 criteria for Serviceability Limits

PAGE

in Prestressed concrete Beams 22

2 Limit States for Prestressed Concrete (BS 8 1 10 : 198 5) 23

3 Comparison of Experimental Ultimate Flexural Load to Theoretical Ultimate Flexural Load for Beams Designed to Fail in Flexure 167

4 Comparison of Experimental Ultimate Flexural Load to Theoretical Ultimate Flexural Load for Beams Designed to Fail in Shear 168

5 Increase in Ultimate Load (experimental) Capacity of Prestressed Beams Due to Prestress or Nonprestress Reinforcements 171

6 Experimental and Code-calculated Ultimate Moment of Prestressed Beams 174

7 Shear Strengths of Experimental Partially Prestressed Concrete Beams 178

8 Combined Effect of Prestress, Additional Reinforcements and Shear Reinforcements on Concrete Shear Cracking Resistance (Loads at Shear Cracking, KN) 183

9 Combined Effect of Additional Deformed Bars and Shear Reinforcements on Experimental Shear Strength of Prestressed Concrete 183

10 serviceability of Beams Not Reinforced in Shear 190

1 1 Comparisons of Cracking Loads 193

12 Cracking Load of Beams with 76 mm Web and Various Levels of Prestress and Deformed Bars . (Beam Number in Circle) 195

13 Cracking Load of Beams with 56 mm Web and Various Levels of Prestress and Deformed Bars. (Beam Number in Circle) 196

x

Page 14: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

TABLE

14

1 5

16

17

18

19

20

21

Summary of Calculations of Crack width by Various Methods

Observed and Calculated Average Crack Spacing

Loads at 12 mm and 20 mm Deflection of 76 mm Web Prestressed Beams With Shear Reinforcements

Loads at 12 mm and 20 rom Deflection of 76 mm Web Prestressed Beams without Shear Reinforcements

Loads at 12 mm and 20 mm Deflection of 56 mm web Prestressed Beams With Shear Reinforcements

Loads at 12 mm and 20 mm Deflection of 56 mm Web Prestressed Beams without Shear Reinforcements

Effect of Shear Reinforcement on Deflection of 76 mm Web and 56 mm Web Prestressed Beams. (Ratio of Loads of Prestressed Beams with and without Shear Reinforcements at Respective Deflections)

Calculated and Experimental Total Deflections of Prestressed Beams

xi

PAGE

2 11

2 23

231

231

232

232

233

237

Page 15: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

FIGURE

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

1 0

1 1

1 2

LIST OF FIGURES

Classification of Prestressed Concrete (Flexural Members)

stress s train Conditions At Ultimate Load Condition

Crack Patterns and Idealiz ed Zone structures (After Moayer and Reagan, 1 9 7 4)

Types of Cross sections of Experimental Beams

strain Distribution Along Depth At Mid Span of Beam 4 at Various Loadings

strain Distribution Along Depth At Midspan of Beam 9 at Various Loadings

strain Distribution Along Depth At Midspan of Beam 14 at Various Loadings

strain Distribution Along Depth At Midspan of Beam 2 5 at Various Loadings

strain Distribution Along Depth At Midspan of Beam 27 at Various Loadings

strain Distribution Along Depth At Midspan of Beam 3 2 at Various Loadings

strain Distribution Along Depth At Midspan of Beam 3 7 at Various Loadings

Load vs Deflection Graphs for Beams 1, 3, 5, 7 and 9 .

1 3 Load v s Deflection Graphs for Beams 2 , 4 , 6, 8 and 10.

14

15

16

Load vs Deflection Graphs for Beams 1 1 , 1 2 , 13, 14 and 15.

Load vs De flection Graphs for Beams 16, 1 8 , 2 0 , 2 2 and 2 4.

Load vs Deflection Graphs for Beams 17, 19, 2 1, 2 3 and 2 5 .

xii

PAGE

4

46

56

1 0 0

1 2 6

1 2 7

1 2 8

1 2 9

1 3 0

1 3 1

1 3 2

1 3 3

134

135

1 3 6

1 3 7

Page 16: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

FIGURE

17

18

19

2 0

2 1

2 2

2 3

2 4

2 5

26

2 7

28

2 9

3 0

3 1

Load vs Deflection Graphs for Beams 2 6 , 2 8 , 3 0 and 3 2.

Load vs Deflection Graphs for Beams 2 7 , 2 9 , 3 1 and 3 3.

Load vs Deflection Graphs for Beams 3 4 , 3 5 , 3 6 and 3 7 .

Load vs Deflection Graphs for Beams 38, 4 0 , 4 2 and 4 4.

Load vs Deflection Graphs for Beams 3 9 , 4 1 , 4 3 and 4 5.

Comparisons of Load Deflection Behavior for Beams with 76 mm Thick Web and 2 Prestressing Tendons

Comparisons of Load Deflection Behavior for Beams with 76 rom Thick Web and 4 Prestressing Tendons

Comparisons of Load Deflection Behavior for Beams With 76 mm Thick Web and 6 Prestressing Tendons

Comparisons of Load Deflection Behaviour for Beams With 76 mm Thick Web and 8 Prestress ing Tendons

Comparisons of Load Deflection Behaviour for Beams with 56 rom Thick Web and 2 Prestressing Tendons

Comparisons of Load Deflection Behaviour for Beams with 56 mm Thick Web and 4 Prestressing Tendons

comparisons of Load Deflection Behaviour for Beams with 56 mm Thick Web and 6 Prestress ing Tendons

Load vs Total Number of Cracks Graphs for Beams 1 , 3 , 5 , 7 & 9 .

Load vs Total Number of Cracks Graphs for Beams 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 & 15 .

Load vs Total Number of Cracks Graphs for Beams 16 , 18 , 2 0 , 2 2 & 2 4.

xiii

PAGE

1 3 8

1 3 9

1 4 0

1 4 1

1 4 2

1 4 3

1 4 4

145

146

147

148

149

150

151

152

Page 17: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

FIGURE

32

3 3

3 4

3 5

36

3 7

38

39

4 0

4 1

42

4 3

4 4

4 5

46

47

48

Load vs Total Number of Cracks Graphs for Beams 17 , 19, 21 , 23 & 25 .

Load vs Total Number of Cracks Graphs for Beams 26 , 28 , 3 0 and 3 2.

Load vs Total Number of Cracks Graphs for Beams 3 4 , 3 5 , 36 & 37 .

Load vs Total Number o f Cracks Graphs for Beams 3 8 , 4 0 , 42 & 4 4 .

Load vs Maximum Crack Width Graphs for Beams 1 , 3 , 5 , 7 & 9 .

Load vs Maximum Crack width Graphs for Beams 2 , 4 , 6 , 8 & 1 0 .

Load vs Maximum Crack width Graphs for Beams 11, 12 , 13 , 14 & 15 .

Load vs Maximum Crack width Graphs for Beams 16, 18 , 20 , 22 & 24 .

Load vs Maximum Crack Width Graphs for Beams 26 , 28 , 3 0 & 3 2.

Load vs Maximum Crack width Graphs for Beams 27 , 29 , 3 1 & 3 3 .

Load vs Maximum Crack width Graphs for Beams 3 8 , 4 0 , 42 & 4 4

Load vs Maximum Crack width Graphs for Beams 3 4 , 3 5 , 36 & 3 7 .

Load vs Maximum Crack Width Graphs for Beams 17 , 19 , 21, 23 & 25 .

Load vs Maximum Crack width Graphs for Beams 39 , 4 1 , 4 3 & 4 5 .

Flexural cracking Pattern of 76 mm Web Beams with Shear Reinforcements and 0 Deformed Bars.

Flexural Cracking Pattern of 76 rom Web Beams without Shear Reinforcements and with 0 Deformed Bars.

Flexural Cracking Pattern of 76 mm Web Beams with Shear Reinforcements and 2 Deformed Bars .

xiv

PAGE

1 5 3

1 5 4

155

1 56

1 57

158

159

160

161

162

163

164

165

165

198

199

200

Page 18: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

FIGURE PAGE

49 Flexural Cracking Pattern of 7 6 mm Web Beams with Shear Reinforcements and 4 Deformed Bars . 20 1

5 0 Flexural Cracking Pattern o f 7 6 mm Web Beams Without Shear Reinforcements and With 4 Deformed Bars . 2 0 2

5 1 Flexural Cracking Pattern of 56 mm Web Beams with Shear Reinforcements and 0 Deformed Bars. 2 0 3

5 2 Flexural Cracking Pattern o f 56 mm Web Beams Without Shear Reinforcements and 0 Deformed Bars . 2 04

5 3 Flexural Cracking Pattern of 56 mm Web Beams With Shear Reinforcements and 2 Deformed Bars. 2 05

54 Flexural Cracking Pattern of 56 mm Web Beams With Shear Reinforcements and 4 Deformed Bars . 2 0 6

5 5 Fl exural Cracking Pattern o f 5 6 mm Web Beams without Shear Reinforcements and with 4 Deformed Bars . 2 0 7

xv

Page 19: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

PLATE

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

1 1

12

LIST OF PLATES

Beam 1 ( 76 mm Web ) with Wide Flexural Cracks and No Shear Cracks . Good Recovery on Unloading .

Diagonal Tension Shear Failure of Lightly Prestressed Beam 2 .

Few and Widely Spaced Cracks With Wide Opening of Lightly Prestressed Beam 3 .

Beam 4 ( 76 rom Web ) Unreinforced in Shear , Failed in Flange compression in Flexural Span .

Beam 5 ( 76 mm Web ) Unbonded Failed in Flexure with Wide Cracks. Excel lent Recovery Upon Unloading As Shown .

Beam 6 ( 76 mm Web ) Unbonded with No Shear Reinforcements , Fai led in Flange compress ion .

Flexural-shear Failure of Highly Prestressed Beam 7 After Exceeding Theoretical Loads .

Shear-compression Failure of Very Highly Prestressed Beam 8 without Shear Reinforcement .

Beam 9 (76 mm web , On Release of Load ) Failed With Flange Compress ion

Shear compress ion Failure o f Beam 10 With Very High Prestress, without Shear Reinforcement and At Equal Theoretical Flexural Load .

Beam 1 1 ( 76 mm web , With Load Released) Failed in Shear Compression on Left Load Point .

Flange Comrpess ion Flexural Failure of Beam 12 At Equal To Theoretical Flexural Load .

xvi

PAGE

1 1 5

1 15

1 1 5

1 16

1 16

1 16

1 16

1 17

1 17

1 17

1 17

1 17

Page 20: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

PLATE

1 3

1 4

1 5

16

17

18

19

20

2 1

2 2

2 3

2 4

2 5

26

PAGE

Violent Flexural Failure of Unbonded Beam 1 3 ( 76 mm Web ) . 1 18

Flexural Shear Failure After Exceeding Theoretical Loads of Highly Prestressed Beam 14 . 1 18

Shear Compression State After Recovery of Very Highly Prestressed Beam 15 With 8 Tendons and 2 Deformed Bars . 1 18

Flexural Failure of Beam 16 With 2 Prestressing Tendons and 4 Deformed Bars . Flange Compression and Flexural Web Disturbance . 1 19

Recovered Diagonal Tension Shear Failure of a Lightly Prestressed Beam with the Aid of 4 Deformed Bars . 1 19

Medium Prestress Beam 18 Just After Exceeding Theoretical Ultimate Flexural Capacity . 1 19

Diagonal Tension and Bar Tension Failure of Beam 19 . 1 19

Flange crushing Flexural Failure of Unbonded Beam 2 0. 1 19

Wel l-recovered Shear Failure with the Aid of 4 Deformed Bars , of Beam 2 1.

Flange Compression Failure o f Beam

1 2 0

2 2 ( 76 mm Web , with Load Rel eased) . 1 2 0

Recovery o f Beam 2 3 with High Prestress and Deformed Bars, After Failing in Shear . 120

Violent Shear Compression Failure of Highly Prestressed Beam 2 4 (76 mm Web) . 12 1

Very Highly Prestressed Beam 2 5 , Failing in Shear in Tensioned bars , and At Ful l Recovery . 1 2 1

Typical Wide Crack of Low Prestressed Beam Failing in Flexure ( Beam 26 with 56 mm Web ) . 1 2 1

xvii

Page 21: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

PLATE

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

40

41

PAGE

Fewer Cracks of Beam 27 (56 mm Web) without Shear Reinforcements . 122

Very Thin Beam 28 After Shear Failure . 122

Large and Few Cracks of Bonded Beam 29 . 122

Explosive Web Cum Flange Crushing of High Prestress 56 rom Web Beam 32 . 122

Flexural Failure of Beam 33 . 123

Flange Heaving Failure of Beam 34 (56 mm Web) 123

Flexural Failure of Beam 35 With 4 Tendons and 2 Deformed Bars (133 kN) 123

Shear Compression Failure of Beam 37 (56 mm Web) . 123

Flexural Failure of Beam 38 with 2 Tendons and 4 Deformed Bars (121 kN) 123

Diagonal Shear and Tensioned Bar Failure of Lightly Prestressed Thin Beam 39 . 124

Flexural Flange Crushing of Bonded Beam 40 After Exceeding Theoretical Ultimate Flexural Load . 124

Laterally Explosive Web Crushing Failure With Secondary Failure in Separation of Deformed Bars in Beam 41 (56 mm Web) . 124

Violent Laterally Explosive Web Crushing of Thin Web (56 mm) Beam 43 with 4 Prestressing Tendons and 4 Deformed Bars. 124

Flange Compression Failure of Beam 44 with 56 rom Web, 6 Prestressing Tendons and 4 Deformed Bars . 125

Tensioned Bar Shear Failure of Beam 45 with 6 Tendons and 4 Deformed Bars and without Stirrups . 125

xviii

Page 22: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

f ci

f cu

G k

Q k

V TSR

v s

LIST OF SYMBOLS

concrete strength at transfer

concrete cube compressive strength, N/mm2

Dead load

Appl ied l oad

Material partial safety factor

Total shear resistance of a section

Shear resistance of a 4 5° strut inclination truss anal ogy

v Ultimate shear cracking resistance of a c sect ion of the concrete

V Web shear cracking capacity of a section-co uncracked in fl exure

V cr

b w

h

f t

f cp

Fl exural shear cracking capacity of a section cracked in flexure

Web width of T beam

Total depth of T beam

Maximum principal tensile stress

compressive stress at the centroidal axis due to prestress, taken as positive

f Effect ive prestress in the tendons after all pe losses have occurred .

f pu

v c

d e

Strength of a prestressing tendon

concrete shear stress

Effect ive depth of steel reinforcements

xix

Page 23: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

M 0

M u

V

A ps

A nps

A sv

S v

f y

f yv

d t

v u

b we

f ps

€ ps

x

m

E s

E c

h f

Moment necessary to produce zero stress in the concrete at the extreme tension fibre .

Bending moment value at the section due to the particular ultimate load condition

Shear force value at the section due to the particular ultimate load condition

Total area of prestress ing tendon section

Total area of nonprestressed steel section

Cross-sectional area of two l egs of a l ink/strirrup

Link/stirrup spacing

strength of a nonprestressed steel bar

Strength of the shear reinforcement

Depth to the bottom most longitudinal reinforcement

Maximum shear stress of concrete

Effective web width of T beam

Stress in prestressed tendon

Strain inprestressed tendon

Depth to neutral axis

Modular ratio

Elastic modulus of steel

Elastic moudlus of concrete

Flange depth

xx

Page 24: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

f 6 i nc h dia meter x 12 i nc h cyl i nder c' co mpress ive stre ngt h at 28 da ys

f Des ign tens ile stress in t he tendons p b

d n

Dept h to t he ce ntro id of t he compressio n zone or O . 45 x if fla nge t hickness e qual or more t ha n O . 9 x

€ Co ncrete strai n at e xtre me compressio n fi bre cu

a stress

xxi

Page 25: UNIVERSITI PUTRA MALAYSIA LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST ...Predicting Maximum Crack width DEFLECTION OF PARTIALLY PRESTRESSED FLEXURAL MEMBERS Introduction Predicting Deflection and Camber

ABSTRACT

Abstract of thesis sub mitted to t he S enate of Univers iti Pe rt a n i a n Ma l a ys i a , i n p a r t i a l ful fi l me n t o f t he re quirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy.

LIMIT CRITERIA OF POST-TENSIONED THIN WEB BEAMS

s upervisor Faculty

By

LEE TEANG SaUl

October, 1 9 8 9

Dr. S . A. Salam Engineering

A total of 45 partiall y prestressed post-tensioned

t hi n web T-b e a ms we re t e s t e d t o i n ve s t i ga t e t he i r

ul t i ma t e s he a r a n d fl e xur a l s t r e n g t hs a n d t he

s e rviceab i l it y l i mits o f defl ect i on and crack width.

The varying para meters inc l uded in t he s t udy are t he

a mo un t o f p r e s t r e s s , a mo un t o f s up p l e me n t a r y

nonprestressed reinforc e ment s , prestre s s ing tendons

being bonded or unbonded , absence or presence o f s hear

r e i n fo r c e me n t s a n d w i d t h o f t he we b . A s t r a i n

co mpatibil ity met hod with the associated bond factors i s

presented for the ult i mate fle xural strength analys i s of

t he b e a ms . Fo r p r e d i c t i o n o f t he o r e t i c a l l o a d s ,

mat e r i a l c haract e r i s t i c s are t a ken a t t he i r ul t i mate

wit h no materials safety factor associated. Equil ibrium

o f forces and a tril inear stress stra in relations hip for

xxi i