university of california, berkeley fall energy and
TRANSCRIPT
University of California, Berkeley Fall 2017
Energy and Resources Group (ERG) & Goldman School of Public Policy
Energy and Society
ER 100 / 200 and Pub Pol C184 / C284
Professor Daniel M Kammen Email: [email protected] | Twitter: @dan_kammen
Office Hours: Wednesdays mornings in 326 Barrows Hall ‐ https://www.wejoinin.com/sheets/hoxnz.
Note: sections begin the week of August 28 Course websites: bCourses (course internal)
http://nature.berkeley.edu/er100 (open access site) Among the questions we will address in this course are: • In what ways has fossil‐fuel use defined the 20th Century? What about the 21st? • What role is there for renewable energy and energy efficiency today and in the future? • What is the role of nuclear power in our present and future energy mix? • Could fuel cells or the hydrogen economy cause a revolution in the automotive industry? • Is the U. S. ready to acknowledge and address global warming? • How are energy issues different in developing nations from those in the ‘North’? • What tools do you need to address these questions from an interdisciplinary perspective? Interested in these questions? Then Energy and Society is for you. Each of these questions about the use and impacts of energy systems requires an interdisciplinary understanding that explores the scientific, technical, economic, social, political, and environmental opportunities and impacts of our energy system.
Section Day/time Rm. No. ER100 CC# ER200 CC# PP184 CC# PP284 CC#
101 W 11 ‐ 12 107 Genetics & Plant Biology
23289 23312
40374 40320
102 F 12 ‐ 1 229 Dwinelle 23290 23313 40375 40321 103 W 1 ‐ 2 209 Dwinelle 23291 23314 40376 40313 104 Th 12 ‐ 1 200 Wheeler 23292 23315 40377 40314 105 M 12 – 1 108 Wheeler 23293 23316 40378 40315 106 M 1 – 2 209 Dwinelle 23294 23317 40379 40316 Th 2‐3 381 Barrows
Shasta Conf Rm
Energy and Society: ER100 & 200 / Pub Pol 184 & 284 Page 2
In this course, you will develop an understanding—and a technically and socially deep working knowledge—of our energy technologies, policies, and options. This will include analysis of the different opportunities and impacts of energy systems that exist within and between groups defined by national, regional, household, ethnic, and gender distinctions. Analysis of the range of current and future energy choices will be stressed, as well as the role of energy in determining local environmental conditions and the global climate. ER200/GSPP284 are graduate versions of ER100/GSPP184, and their lectures and sections are held in common. ER200/GSPP284 includes additional material, with added analytic tools and problems on both the problem sets and the examinations. Grading for the undergraduate and graduate courses are separate. Course Goals This course is designed to provide you with the methods, tools and perspectives to understand, critique, and ultimately influence the management of technical, economic, and policy choices regarding the options for energy generation and use. We will focus equally on the technical, socioeconomic, political, and environmental impacts of energy. We will examine the full ‘life cycle’, or ‘cradle to grave to cradle again’ of energy, from the stage of raw materials, or inputs, to generation, conversion, distribution, consumption, recycling, waste, impacts, and ethnic, racial, gender, and economic inequities. This work is inherently interdisciplinary, and will involve a fascinating but extensive effort to understand, critique, and integrate tools and perspectives from anthropology, cultural and ethnic studies, economics, engineering, physics, politics, sociology, and who knows what else. The challenge of this integration is not simply one of learning and applying methods from very diverse disciplines, but more importantly is one of understanding how and when different types of analysis, disciplinary and political perspectives, and “voices” are heard, unheard, ignored, or discredited. Energy is a fundamental societal resource, the control of which reflects and shapes interactions both within society and between humans and the natural environment. Coverage Over the semester we will take a roughly chronological tour of the major fuel types used in human civilization. From there we will begin a broad‐ranging analysis of the energy resource, combustion or conversion processes, application, waste, economic, social, political, cultural, and environmental impacts and options associated with these fuels and with the changing mix of fuels used within and across societies around the globe.
Energy and Society: ER100 & 200 / Pub Pol 184 & 284 Page 3
Assignments There will be seven problem sets and a policy memo (in total 40% of the grade), a mid‐term examination (25%), and a final exam (35%). Problem sets are distributed every other Tuesday, and due back, in class, the Thursday of the following week. You may also turn the assignment in at the box located in the hallway outside the ERG office (310 Barrows) BEFORE 6pm Thursday. Late assignments will be penalized 30% if turned in by 5pm on Monday, when the solution set will be posted. You will get the most out of the problem sets if you make an initial effort to work through all of the problems on your own. After attempting to solve the problems on your own, you may then work with other students to discuss different approaches. It is vital that you do your own work. It is a violation of the Code of Student Conduct to copy answers from anyone. As part of your participation in the course, you are encouraged to use the bCourses discussion board to make comments and/or ask questions related to the readings or lectures. We will also post the answers to questions about the problem sets on bCourses, so be sure to check bCourses regularly. Web‐based readings: A number of readings, both required and supplemental, are available on‐line. In order to download some of these, you will need to use an on‐campus computer or set up your home computer or laptop with the campus proxy service. For instructions, see: http://www.lib.berkeley.edu/using‐the‐libraries/connect‐off‐campus All readings are also available on the course bCourses site and on nature.berkeley.edu Required Reading assignments should be completed before the lecture for which they are assigned. While I recognize that this is not always possible, you need to try; the material in lecture does not simply review the readings; we use it as a basis for exploration of the course material and ideas.
Energy and Society: ER100 & 200 / Pub Pol 184 & 284 Page 4
Optional Field Trips
There will be several field trips during the semester. Each will be 3 ‐ 6 hours (including travel time), and all will be Friday mornings. The list will depend on availability, but will likely include:
The Pittsburgh Energy ‘Park’, a 2200 MW fossil‐fuel power plant (gas and oil);
California Windfarm
FlexLab, LBL
SunSet Solar (San Francisco)
Graduate Student Instructors and Office Hours
Grace Horvath Kelly Jiang Christian G Miller
Sara Mulhauser
Office: 399 Barrows 399 Barrows 399 Barrows 321 Barrows
Hours:
Fri 2‐10 AM
Tues 9–11 AM T 2‐3, W 12‐1 Wed 2–4 PM
Email:
gracehorvath [at] berkeley.edu
keljia [at] berkeley.edu
cgmiller [at] berkeley.edu
sara.mulhauser [at] berkeley.edu
Reach us by email or by coming to the office hours. Section meetings begin in Week 2 (i.e. starting 8/29). Lecture Slides Lecture slides (.pdf files) will be available for each lecture, and will be posted on the course website before the lecture. You should download the files and bring them to lecture so that you have all of the graphs and diagrams right in front of you.
Energy and Society: ER100 & 200 / Pub Pol 184 & 284 Page 5
Wk Date Lecturer Lecture #/Topic
1 8‐24 Kammen 1. How Energy Use Shapes Society & the Environment
2 8‐29 Kammen 2. Energy Toolkit I: Units, Forecasts, and the Back‐of‐the‐Envelope
8‐31 Kammen 3. Energy Toolkit II: Fuels, Energy Content & Basics of Combustion
3 9‐5 Kammen 4. Energy for ‘the South’ I: Energy Transitions and Development
9‐7 Kammen 5. Energy for ‘the South’ II: Biomass, Households, and Gender
4 9‐12 Guest 6. Energy Toolkit III: Energy Thermodynamics
9‐14 Kammen 7. Energy Toolkit IV: Thermodynamics of Modern Power Plants cancelled
5 9‐19 Kammen 8. Energy Toolkit IV: Thermodynamics of Modern Power Plants, and
‘Hydrocarbon Man’
9‐21 Kammen 9. ‘Hydrocarbon Man’ cont., and Evolution of the Modern Energy Economy
6 9‐26 Kammen 10. Energy Toolkit V: Economic Analysis of Energy Systems
9‐28 Horvath 11. Energy Toolkit VI: Life‐Cycle and Cost‐Benefit Analysis
7 10‐3 Kammen 12. Energy Efficiency I: Devices
10‐5 Kammen 13. Energy Efficiency II: Buildings and Larger Energy Systems
8 10‐10 Callaway 14. Electricity Grids: Managing the Network
10‐12 Kammen 15. Natural Gas, Fracking, and Carbon Capture and Storage
9 10‐17 GSIs Mid‐term review
10‐19 You! Midterm Exam, In class
10 10‐24 Guest 16. Nuclear Energy I: Physics and Engineering – Fission & Fusion
10‐26 Kammen 17. Nuclear Energy II: Waste, Risk & Economics
11 10‐31 Guest 18. Energy Toolkit VII ‐ Energy and Environmental Justice I (theory)
11‐2 Guest 19. Energy Toolkit VII ‐ Energy and Environmental Justice II (practice)
12 11‐7 Kammen 20. Renewable Energy I: Solar Energy
11‐9 Kammen 21. Renewable Energy II: Wind, Geothermal & Hydropower
13 11‐14 Kammen 22. Renewable Energy III: Electrochemistry ‐ H2, Fuel Cells & storage
11‐16 Kammen 23. Renewable Energy IV: Industrial Bioenergy & Land Use
14 11‐21 Kammen 24. Transportation systems and policies
11‐23 HOLIDAY THANKSGIVING
15 11‐28 Kammen 25. Climate Change I: Energy and Climate
11‐30 Kammen 26. Climate Change II: Energy Policy
Energy and Society: ER100 & 200 / Pub Pol 184 & 284 Page 6
Final Exam: Group 20: Friday, December 15, 7 – 10 pm
Problem Set # Assigned Due Coverage
1 8/29 9/7 Short warm‐up problems; analysis of utility bills; making unit analysis your friend, and getting comfortable with the myriad of energy units.
These problems may be unfamiliar in style for many of you; if necessary use the GSI’s and study groups to ‘get into the swing’ of these calculations/estimates. You must, however, do your own work.
2 9/12 9/21 Energy use at household and national scales; basic thermodynamics; combustion.
3 9/26 10/5 Thermodynamics of energy systems, combustion of various fuels; comparisons of energy conversion efficiencies, emissions, financial analysis of power plants. Energy economics.
4 10/5* 10/12 Life‐cycle analysis; learning curves; energy efficiency, evolution of the modern energy system. [Shorter problem set]
5 10/24 11/2 Environmental justice; energy efficiency and conservation; the grid; nuclear energy.
6 11/7 11/16 Nuclear energy and waste, renewable energy systems, fuel cells and hydrogen.
7 11/21 11/30 Biomass energy, transportation, energy and climate, and climate policy.
* Note: non‐standard assignment dates (mid‐term & thanksgiving). No late assignments accepted for PS #4 so that we can return to you graded problem sets on 10/17, prior to the exam. Problem sets are posted on the web, not physically distributed in class. Do not leave problem sets for the final few days. They are not hard if started early; they can be an unpleasant experience if left for the night before they are due. Problem sets are due in class or can be turned in to the problem set drop‐off box outside of the Energy and Resources Group, 310 Barrows Hall. Problem sets are late after 6:00 PM.
Problem sets cannot be turned in electronically or by fax.
Energy and
You shoulbe referenare requiryour unde
Lecture 1 Recommefor how uand editowriting a Yergin, D.
Pa Plus, read
go Read thes
Jeffrey Bahttps://w Ralph Cav
http://ww
Kendyl Crhttp://alt
Ban Ki‐Mo
http://ww
Paul Krughttps://w
There areRenewab
d Society: ER10
ld be familiar nced under thred for graduaerstanding of
(8/24) – Ener
endation: Geubiquitous andorial pages of‘policy memo
(1991) The P
ages 11 – 16.
d a selection –ood habit).
se ‘classic’ en
all and Dan Reww.nytimes.c
vanagh (2013
ww.nytimes.co
awford (2016daily.com/op
oon (2012) “P
ww.nytimes.co
gman (2017) “ww.nytimes.c
e many outletsle and Appro
00 & 200 / Pub
with the readhe assumptionate students. f the course m
Week 1 –
rgy and Socie
t in the habitd far‐reachinf your favorito’ that in mos
Prize: The Epic
[ Yergin_1
– you decide
ergy op eds:
eicher (2017) com/2017/03
) “How we le
om/2013/09/
6) “Addressinp‐ed‐addressin
Powering sust
om/2012/01/
“Trump’s enercom/2017/05
s to follow. Fpriate Energy
b Pol 184 & 284
dings listed fon that you haReadings list
material, but a
Introduction
ty: How Ener
t of looking fg energy issute newspapest cases can a
c Quest for O
1991.pdf]
how many ‐‐
“Making sola3/21/opinion/
arned not to
/13/opinion/h
g Environmenng‐environme
tainable ener
/12/opinion/p
rgy, low and 5/29/opinion/
or some locay Laboratory,
4
or each lecturave read themted as Suppleare not requir
to Energy Sy
gy Use Shape
or energy artes are in socirs. As yournd should be
Oil, Money, an
‐ of these ene
ar big enough/making‐sola
guzzle” (9/12
how‐we‐learn
ntal Justice inental‐justice‐i
rgy for all” (1/
powering‐sus
dirty” (5/29/2/trump‐g‐7‐su
l ones, see rael.berkeley
re date when m already. Reaemental will (red to success
ystems and So
es Society & th
ticles in newsiety. In additilast assignm
e submitted as
nd Power (Sim
ergy‐related o
h to matter” (ar‐big‐enough
2/13)
ned‐not‐to‐gu
n the Commoin‐the‐commo
/11/12)
stainable‐ene
2017) ummit‐energy
: @dan_kay.edu, and “En
the lecture oadings listed f(perhaps obvisfully complet
ociety
he Environme
spapers and ion, check the
ment of the cos an Op Ed yo
mon & Schust
op‐eds or oth
3/21/2017) h‐to‐matter.ht
uzzle.html?_r
nwealth“(3/2onwealth/
ergy‐for‐all.ht
y.html?mcub
mmen which nergy @ Haa
P
occurs—they wfor ER200/PPiously) supplete the course.
ent:
begin to get e opinion (“Oourse, you wourself
ter: New York
hers you look
tml?mcubz=1
r=0
23/2016)
ml
bz=1
is from the as”
Page 7
will P284 ement .
a feel OpEd”) will be
k).
up (a
1
Energy and
Lecture 2
Lovins, AmLo
CommentJohn Tiernhttp://ww ER200 & PRubin, Ed
[R SupplemeToolkit 1 before. Lecture 3 Masters, G
47 Suppleme
d Society: ER10
(8/29) – Ener
mory (1976) “ovins_1976.p
tary on the Loney (2008) “Aww.nytimes.co
PP284: ward S. (2001Rubin, EE], Ra
ental: (a review and
(8/31) – Ener
G. (1991) Intr
7. [ Maste
ental: Toolkit
00 & 200 / Pub
W
rgy Toolkit I: U
“Energy Stratepdf]
ovins paper frA gift from theom/2008/10/
1) Introductioates of Techno
d refresher) –
rgy Toolkit II:
roduction to E
ers_1991_Env
2 (resource m
b Pol 184 & 284
Week 2 – Meth
Units, Forecas
egy: The Road
rom The Newe ‘70s: Energy/07/science/0
on to Engineerology Adoptio
– optional/ref
Fuels, Energy
Environmenta
viro_Chemist
material)
4
hods in Energ
sts, and the B
d Not Taken”
w York Times:y lessons” (10/07tier.html?_
ring & the Enon, Pages 669
ference for th
y Content, an
al Engineering
ry.pdf]
gy Analysis
Back‐of‐the‐E
”, Foreign Affa
0/6/2008) r=1&8dpc&o
nvironment (M9 – 677.
hose who hav
d Basics of Co
g and Science
Envelope:
airs, 55(1): 65
oref=slogin
McGraw Hill: N
ve done these
ombustion:
e (Prentice Ha
P
5–96. [
New York, NY
e sorts of prob
all: NJ), pages
Page 8
Y)
blems
s 39–
Energy and
Lecture 4
GoldembeG
Jacobson,
B ER200 & PAlstone, P
e Lecture 5 Kammen,
38 Sovacool,
Kammen,Ka
ER200 & PCrewe, E.
R Bose, S. (1
WB
Suppleme
Pe
d Society: ER10
(9/5) – Energ
erg, J. (1996) oldemberg_1
, A. and D.M.
ridge, 35(4):
PP284: P., Gershensolectricity acce
(9/7) – Energ
D. M. and Do
8–41. [ Ka
B (2014) “En
D. M. (1995)ammen_1995
PP284: (1997) “The
. L. Stirrat, ed
1993) “Wome
Welfare (Oxforose_1993.pd
ental: Bailis, E
etroleum Ene
00 & 200 / Pub
W
gy for ‘the Sou
Energy, Envir1996.pdf]
Kammen. (20
pp. 11‐17. [
on, D. and Kamess,” Nature C
gy for ‘the Sou
ove, M. R. (19
ammen_1997
nergy studies
) “Cookstoves5.pdf]
silent traditio
ds. (Berg: Oxfo
en, Work, and
rd University f]. Note: this
Ezzati, Kamm
ergy Futures i
b Pol 184 & 284
Week 3 – Ene
uth’ I: Energy
ronment, and
005). “Scienc
Jacobson_
mmen, D. M. Climate Chan
uth’ II: Bioma
997) “The virt
7.pdf]
need social s
s for the deve
ons of develo
ord, UK), 59–
d Household
Press: Bombs is a challeng
en, (2005) “M
n Africa,” Scie
4
ergy and Deve
Transitions a
d Developmen
ce and Engine
_2005.pdf]
(2015) “Decege, 5, 305 – 3
ss, Household
tues of mund
cience,” Natu
eloping world
ping cooks”, D
–81. [ Crew
Electrification
ay, India), Chging reading.
Mortality and
ence, 308 (57
elopment
and Developm
nt (Earthscan
eering Resear
entralized ene314.
ds, and Gend
ane science”,
ure, 511, 529
,” Scientific A
Discourses of
we_1997.pdf]
n in Rural Ind
apter V, page
Greenhouse
718): p. 98‐10
ment:
: London, UK
rch that Value
ergy systems
der:
, Environmen
– 530.
American, 273
f Developmen
]
ia,” Money, E
es 143 – 181.
Gas Impacts
03. [ Bailis
P
), 11 – 37. [
es the Planet,
for clean
nt, 39(6): 10–1
3, 72 ‐ 75. [
nt, R. D. Grillo
Energy and
[
of Biomass a
s_2005.pdf]
Page 9
,” The
15,
o and
and
Energy and
Lecture 6 Masters, G
29 Lecture 7 Rubin, Ed
[R Masters, G
33 ER200 & PDavid Rob
(5/16/201
cleaner Suppleme
re
32 [This is an
o
d Society: ER10
(9/12) – Ener
G. (1991) Intr
9. [ Maste
(9/14) – Ener
dward S. (200Rubin, EE], Se
G. (1991) Intr
39. [ Mast
PP284: berts (2017) “
17) https://ww
ental: Beér, J.esponse to en
27. [ Beer
n advanced trpportunities]
00 & 200 / Pub
W
rgy Toolkit III:
roduction to E
ers_1991_Ene
rgy Toolkit IV
01) Introductiections 5.1 ‐ 5
roduction to E
ters_1991_Ai
“By 2020, eve
ww.vox.com
. M. (2000) “Cnvironmental
r_2000.pdf]
eatment of st.
b Pol 184 & 284
Week 4 – Ther
: Energy Ther
Environmenta
ergy.pdf]
V: Thermodyna
ion to Engine5.6.3 (except 5
Environmenta
ir_Pollution.p
ery Chinese co
m/energy-and
Combustion tchallenges,”
tate‐of‐the‐a
4
rmodynamics
rmodynamics:
al Engineering
amics of Mod
eering & the 5.2.2 & 5.2.3)
al Engineering
pdf]
oal plant will
d-environme
technology deProgress in E
rt fossil‐fuel p
s of Energy
:
g and Science
dern Power Pl
Environment); Pages 162 –
g and Science
be more effic
ent/2017/5/1
evelopments Energy and Co
power plant d
e (Prentice Ha
lants:
t (McGraw H– 175, 179 – 2
e (Prentice Ha
cient than eve
5/15634538
in power genombustion Sc
design issues
Pa
all: NJ), pages
Hill: New York215
all: NJ), pages
ery US coal p
8/china-coal-
neration in cience, 26, 30
and
age 10
s 15 –
k, NY)
s 327–
lant”
-
1 –
Energy and
Lecture 8
FriedmanFr
Farrell, Al
1, Hirsh, Ric Lecture 9 Hirsh, Ric
d Society: ER10
(9/19) – Hydr
, Thomas L. (2riedman_200
ex E., and Bra
, October 30.
hard (1999) P
(9/21) – Evol
hard (1999) P
00 & 200 / Pub
rocarbon Ma
2006) “The Fi06.pdf]
andt, Adam R
[ Farrell_
Power Loss (M
lution of the M
Power Loss (M
b Pol 184 & 284
Week 5 – ‘
n:
irst Law of Pe
R. (2006) “Risk
_2006_Risks.p
MIT University
Modern Energ
MIT University
4
‘Hydrocarbon
etropolitics,” F
ks of the oil tr
pdf]
y Press: Camb
gy Economy:
y Press: Camb
n man’
Foreign Policy
ransition,” En
bridge, MA) S
bridge, MA) S
y, 154: (28 –
nvironmental
Section I, Page
Section I, Page
Pa
36). [
Research Let
es 1 ‐ 54.
es 55 ‐ 88.
age 11
tters,
Energy and
Lecture 10 Rubin, EE Edenhofe
ht ER200 & PArrow, K.
35 Lecture 11 Rubin, EE ER200 & P Wynes, S.
re12
Hertwich,
E
Supplem Jones, C. M
su48
d Society: ER10
0 (9/26) – Ene
E, Chapter 13,
r, O. (2015) “ttp://science
PP284: et al., (2013)
50.[ Arrow
1 (9/28) – Ene
E, Section 13.4
PP284 [Suppl
. and Nicholasecommendat2, 074024. ht
, E. and PeterES&T, b, 6414
mental:
M. and Kammuburbanizatio8 (2), 895 – 9
00 & 200 / Pub
Week 6 –
ergy Toolkit V
Pages 545 –
“King coal and.sciencemag.
) “Determinin
w_2013.pdf]
ergy Toolkit V
4, Life‐cycle c
lemental for
s, KA (2017) “ions miss thettp://iopscien
rs, G. (2009) “4–6420. http:
men, D. M. (20on offsets ben02. https://n
b Pol 184 & 284
– Energy Econ
V: Economic A
577
d the queen oorg/content/
ng the benefit
VI: Life‐cycle a
ost, 556 – 56
ER100/PP184
“The climate e most effectivnce.iop.org/ar
“The carbon f//pubs.acs.or
014) “Spatial nefits of popuature.berkele
4
nomics and Li
Analysis of En
of subsidies,” /sci/349/6254
ts and costs fo
and Cost‐Bene
2.
4]:
mitigation gave individual rticle/10.1088
ootprint of narg/doi/pdfplu
distribution oulation densitey.edu/er100
ife‐Cycle Met
ergy Systems
Science, 12864/1286.full.pd
or future gen
efit Analysis:
ap: educationactions” Envi8/1748‐9326/
ations, a globus/10.1021/e
of U.S. carbonty”, Environm0/readings/Jo
thods
s:
6 – 1287. df
nerations,” Sc
and governmironmental R/aa7541/pdf
bal, trade links803496a
n footprints rmental Sciencenes‐Kammen
Pa
cience, 341, 34
ment esearch Lette
ked analysis”,
reveals e and Technoln‐2014.pdf
age 12
49 –
ers,
logy,
Energy and
Lecture 12 Rubin, EE Hirsh, Ric ER200 & PAttari, S. Z
co Lecture 13 David B. G
St ER200 & P Gillinghamhttp://ww Suppleme Nagournehttp://ww
gr
d Society: ER10
2 (10/3) – Ene
E, Chapter 7, a
hard (1999) P
PP284: Z. DeKay, M.
onsumption a
3 (10/5) – Ene
Goldstein (200
tudy Paper.[
PP284:
m, K, et al., (2ww.nature.com
ental:
ey, A., et al. (2ww.nytimes.crowth.html?s
00 & 200 / Pub
ergy Efficienc
and Section 1
Power Loss (M
L. Davidson, C
and savings”,
ergy Efficienc
08) Extreme E
Goldstein
2013) “The rem/nature/jou
2015) “Califorom/2015/04/smid=tw‐shar
b Pol 184 & 284
Week 7 – Ene
cy I: Devices:
3.8 of Chapte
MIT University
C. I. and Bruin
PNAS, 2010.
cy II: Buildings
Efficiency: Ho
_2008.pdf]
bound effect urnal/v493/n
rnia drought t/05/us/califore&_r=0
4
ergy Efficienc
er 13, Pages 2
y Press: Camb
ne de Bruin, W
[ Attari_2
s as Energy Sy
ow Far Can W
is overplayed7433/full/493
tests history ornia‐drought‐
cy (I & II)
281 – 314, 57
bridge, MA), p
W. (2010) “Pu
2010.pdf]
ystems
We Go If We Re
d”, Nature, 493475a.html?f
of endless gro‐tests‐history
7 – 583.
pages 90 – 11
ublic percepti
eally Need To
93, 475–476 foxtrotcallbac
owth,” The Ny‐of‐endless‐
Pa
17.
ions of energ
o? ACEEE Sum
ck=true
New York Time
age 13
y
mmer
es
Energy and
Lecture 14 Masters, G
In von Meie
in
ER200 & Fa
Reference Lecture 15 Brandt, A
(6 Deborah
N ht Aisch, Gre
gr ht ER200 & PMIT CCS rChapters
d Society: ER10
4 (10/10) – El
G. (2004) “Tra
nterScience: N
r, Alexandra (
ntroduction (J
PP284: Fairlairley_2004.p
e: Glossary of
5 (10/12) – N
A. et.al., (2016172), 733‐73
Sontag And ovember, ttp://www.ny
egor (2014) “round,” The Nttps://www.n
PP284: roadmap ‐ htt2 and 3 (page
00 & 200 / Pub
Week 8 – T
lectricity Grid
ansmission a
New York), pa
(2006), “Relia
ohn Wiley &
ey, P. (2004)pdf]
f electricity te
atural Gas, Fr
14) “Methan35.
Robert Gebe
ytimes.com/i
“What North New York Timnytimes.com/
tp://web.mit.es 5 – 42)
b Pol 184 & 284
he Power Gr
ds: Managing
nd Distributio
ages 145 – 15
ability” and “S
Sons: New Je
) “The unruly
erms. [ Ele
racking, and
e Leaks from
eloff (2014) “
nteractive/20
Dakota Woumes, Novembe/interactive/2
.edu/coal/
4
id & Unconve
the Network
on,” in Renew
1. [ Maste
Security,” in E
ersey), pp. 22
y power grid”
ectricity_Glos
Carbon Captu
m North Ame
“The downsid
014/11/23/us
ld Look Like er 25 2014/11/24/u
entional Foss
:
wable and Effi
ers_2004_TD
Electric Powe
9–234.[ v
”, IEEE Spect
ssary.pdf]
ure and Stora
erican Natura
de of the bo
s/north‐dako
if Its Oil Drill
upshot/nd‐oil
sil Fuels
icient Power S
D.pdf]
r Systems: a c
von_Meier_20
trum, 13 Aug
age
al Gas Syste
om,” The Ne
ota‐oil‐boom‐d
ing Lines We
l‐well‐illustrat
Pa
Systems (Wile
conceptual
006.pdf]
gust, 5 pages
ms,” Science
ew York Time
downside.htm
ere Above
tion.html
age 14
ey
. [
e, 343
es, 22
ml
Energy and Society: ER100 & 200 / Pub Pol 184 & 284 Page 15
Week 9 – Mid‐Term Review & Exam
Class (10/17) – Midterm examination review Your notes, lecture slides, section handouts, past problem sets and solutions, all previous readings. Class (10/19) – Midterm examination
Energy and
Lecture 16 Deutch an
U Nain, V. (2
El Suppleme
ht In
pn
Lecture 17 Rubin, EE Lester, Ric
n
The Nuclehttp://the ER200 & PMartin, Rhttps://w SupplemeHultman,
nH
d Society: ER10
6 (10/24) – N
nd Lester, (20
niv. Press, Ca
2017) “Progrelsevier, 3. htt
ental: Excellettp://www.nrn particular, rroduction anduclear reacto
7 (10/26) – N
E, pages 63‐68
chard K. "A Ro. 2 (Winter 2
ear Fuel Cycleebulletin.org/
PP284: . (2016) “Fail‐ww.technolo
ental: N., Koomey,
uclear powerultman_2007
00 & 200 / Pub
uclear Energy
004) Making T
ambridge, UK
ess in nuclearp://dx.doi.or
nt online matrc.gov/reactoeview ‘Aboutd managemeors) that provi
uclear Energy
8, 175‐178.
oadmap for U2016). http://
e Cost Calcula/nuclear‐fuel‐
‐safe nuclear gyreview.com
J. G, and Kam
r”, Environme7.pdf]
b Pol 184 & 284
Week 10
y I: Physics an
Technology W
, p. 109‐133.
r power techng/10.1016/B9
terial on reacors/power.htmt the NRC’, ‘Nnt) at one of ides power to
y II: Waste, Ri
U.S. Nuclear E/issues.org/32
tor: ‐cycle‐cost‐ca
power,” MITm/s/602051/f
mmen, D. M. (
ental Science &
4
0 –Nuclear Po
nd Engineerin
Work, Ch. 7: N
[ Deutch_
nology”, Ency978‐0‐12‐409
ctor types andml uclear securithe featured o northern Ca
isk & Econom
Energy Innova2‐2/a‐roadma
alculator
T Technology Rfail‐safe‐nucle
(2007) “What
& Technology
ower
ng – Fission/Fu
Nuclear Power
_2004.pdf]
yclopedia of S9548‐9.10103
d performanc
ty’, and read reactors, sucalifornia)
mics:
ation," Issuesap‐for‐u‐s‐nu
Review ear‐power/
t history can t
y, 41(7): 2088
usion:
r and Its Fuel
Sustainable Te3‐4
ce is available
about the evch as Diablo C
s in Science anuclear‐energy
tell us about
8 ‐ 2093. [
Pa
Cycle, Camb
echnologies,
e at
vents (power Canyon (unde
nd Technolog‐innovation/
the costs of f
age 16
ridge
er
y 32,
future
Energy and
Lecture 18 Pastor, M
Nature, p "Climate CGranholmhttp://ww Islamic CaWilson Di(8/18/201declaratio ER200 & PStephen Jagainst Clhttp://dx. Lecture 19 Sunter, D
st
d Society: ER10
We
8 (10/31) – En
anuel, (2007)
p. 351–376.[
Change, Consm ‐‐ In the Liviww.uctv.tv/sh
all on Climateizard (2015) “15) http://on.html
PP284: . Flusberg, Teimate Change.doi.org/10.10
9 (11/2) – Env
., Castellansotrategies”, in
00 & 200 / Pub
ek 11 – Energ
nergy and Env
) “Environme
Pastor_20
sumerism andng Room withhows/29853
e Change “Islamic scho/america.alja
eenie Matlocke”, Environm080/1752403
vironmental J
o, S., and Kamdraft.
b Pol 184 & 284
gy and Enviro
vironmental J
ental Justice: R
007.pdf]
d the Pope wih Henry E. Br
lars call on fazeera.com/a
k & Paul H. Thental Commu32.2017.1289
Justice: Practi
men, DM (20
4
onmental Jus
Justice:
Reflections fr
ith Prof. Daniady ‐‐ UC Pub
aithful to helrticles/2015/
hibodeau (20unication 9111
ice
017) “The env
stice: Theory
rom the Unite
iel Kammen ablic Policy Cha
p fight climat/8/18/islamic‐
17), “Metaph
vironmental i
and Practice
ed States”, Ch
and Governorannel"
te change,” A‐scholars‐issu
hors for the W
njustice of so
Pa
h. 14 in Reclai
r Jennifer
Al Jazeera Amue‐climate‐ch
War (or Race)
olar energy
age 17
iming
merica ange‐
Energy and
Lecture 20 Haegel, N
63 Masters, G
Po ER200 & PSunShot V
PeO
SupplemeZheng, Ch
Pht
Lecture 21 Masters, G
NM
“The Chinhttp://ww Latrubess
d
d Society: ER10
Week 12 –
0 (11/7): Sola
, et al. (2017)334, pp. 141‐
G. (2004) “Ph
ower Systems
PP284: Vision Study: R
erformance; Online Version
entary: heng and Kamhotovoltaic Inttp://www.sc
1 (11/9) – Ren
G. (2004) “W
ew York), pagMasters_2004
nese are obseww.bbc.com/f
se, et al. (2017oi:10.1038/n
00 & 200 / Pub
– Renewable
ar Energy
) “Terawatt‐s‐143. DOI: 10
hotovoltaic M
s (Wiley Inter
Read the Exe
and ; chaptern: http://ener
mmen, Daniel ndustry,” Eneciencedirect.c
newable Ener
ind Power Sy
ges 307 – 3544_Wind.pdf]
ssed with buifuture/story/
7) “Dammingature22333
b Pol 184 & 284
Energy I & II:
scale photovo0.1126/scienc
aterials and E
rScience: New
cutive Summ
r[ Solar_Vrgy.gov/eere/
(2014) “An Inergy Policy, 67com/science/
rgy II: Wind, H
ystems.” Rene
4 (pages 335‐
ilding large da/20151014‐th
g the rivers of
4
: Solar, Wind
oltaics: Trajectce.aal1288
Electrical Cha
w York), pages
ary; Chapter
Vision_Study_/sunshot/sun
nnovation‐Fo7, 159–169. /article/pii/S0
Hydropower a
ewable and Ef
347 are supp
ams” (2015) The‐chinese‐ar
f the Amazon
and Water P
tories and ch
aracteristics.”
s 445 – 463.[
4, Photovolta
_2010.pdf] shot‐vision‐st
cused Roadm
03014215130
and Geotherm
fficient Powe
plemental), 37
The British Bre‐obsessed‐w
basin”, Natu
Power, Geoth
hallenges”, Sc
Renewable a
Masters_
aics: Technolo
tudy
map for a Sust
012500
mal Energy
r Systems (W
71 – 378. [
roadcasting Cwith‐building‐
ure, 546, 363 –
Pa
hermal
ience, 356, Is
and Efficient
_2004_PV.pdf
ogy, Cost, and
tainable Glob
Wiley InterScie
Corporation ‐giant‐dams
– 369.
age 18
sue
f]
d
bal
ence:
Energy and
W Lecture 22 Masters, G
Yo Kittner, N
te10Ka
Lecture 23 Review th Rubin, EE Cornwall, http://ww ER200 & PWalsh, B,
10
Sanchez, EnNcoB
d Society: ER10
Week 13 – Ren
2 (11/14) – Re
G. (2004) “Fu
ork), pages 20
., Lill, F. and Kechnology mo0.1038/neneammen‐Natu
3 (11/16) – Re
he USDA ‐ Bill
E, Chapter 3, P
Warren (201ww.sciencema
PP284: et al., (2017)0.1038/ncom
Daniel L., Nelnables the TrNature Climateontent/uploaiomassEnable
00 & 200 / Pub
newable Ener
enewable Ene
uel Cells,” in R
06‐228. [
Kammen, D. Model for the crgy.2017.125ureEnergy‐Sto
enewable Ene
ion Ton Vision
Pages 83‐123
17) “Is wood aag.org/news/
) “Pathways fomms14856, PD
son, James Hansition to a e Change, 5, 2ds/2015/03/esCarbonNeg
b Pol 184 & 284
rgy III & IV: E
ergy III: Electr
Renewable an
Masters_200
M. (2017) “Enlean energy t. https://raelorage‐Innovat
ergy IV: Indus
n: https://nat
.
a green sourc/2017/01/wo
or balancing CDF: https://ww
H., Johnston, JCarbon‐nega230–234. doSanchez‐KamgativePowerSy
4
lectrochemis
rochemistry ‐
nd Efficient Po
04_Fuel_Cells
nergy storagetransition” Na.berkeley.edution‐2017.pdf
strial Bioenerg
ture.berkeley
ce of energy? od‐green‐sou
CO2 emissionww.nature.co
., Mileva, A., tive Power Syi:10.1038/nc
mmen‐etal‐ystems‐Natur
stry, Fuel Cell
‐ H2, Fuel Cell
ower Systems
s.pdf]
e deploymentature Energy,u/wp‐contenf
gy and Land U
y.edu/er100/r
Scientists areurce‐energy‐s
ns and sinks”, om/articles/n
and Daniel Mystem Acrosslimate2488. h
reClimateCha
ls & Storage,
s & storage
s (Wiley InterS
t and innovat 2, DOI: t/uploads/20
Use
readings/billio
e divided”, Scscientists‐are‐
Nature Commncomms1485
M. Kammen (2s Western Nohttps://rael.b
ange‐2015.pd
Pa
Bioenergy
Science: New
ion: a multi‐
017/07/Kittne
on_ton_vision
cience, ‐divided
munications, 6.pdf
2015) “Biomarth America”berkeley.edu/
df
age 19
w
er‐Lill‐
n.pdf
DOI:
ass , /wp‐
Energy and
Lecture 24
Internatiohttps://w Sager, J.,
toSa
ER200 & PJones, C. M
su48
Suppleme Kammen,
suhtC
No Lectur
d Society: ER10
4 (11/21) – Tr
onal Energy Aww.iea.org/p
Lemoine, D, A
o meet 2050 gager_etal_20
Pub Pol 284: M. and Kammuburbanizatio8 (2), 895 – 9
ental:
Daniel M., anustainability,”ttps://rael.beleanEnergyUr
re on (11/23)
00 & 200 / Pub
W
ransportation
Agency (2016)publications/f
Apte, J. and K
global climate11.pdf]
men, D. M. (20on offsets ben02. https://n
nd Sunter, De” Science, 352erkeley.edu/wrbanSustaina
– Thanksgivin
b Pol 184 & 284
Week 14 – Tr
n systems and
Global EV Oufreepublicatio
Kammen, D. M
e goals.” Envi
014) “Spatial nefits of popuature.berkele
eborah A. (202, 922 – 928. wp‐content/ubility‐Science
ng Holiday
4
ransportation
d policy:
utlook ons/publicatio
M. (2011) “Re
ironmental Re
distribution oulation densitey.edu/er100
016) “City‐inteDOI 10.1126
uploads/2016/e‐20May‐2016
n Systems
on/Global_EV
duce growth
esearch Lette
of U.S. carbonty,” Environm0/readings/Jo
egrated renew6/science.aad/05/Kammen6.pdf
V_Outlook_20
rate of light d
ers, 6(2), 0240
n footprints rmental Sciencenes‐Kammen
wable energy9302. n‐Sunter‐
Pa
016.pdf
duty vehicle t
018.[
reveals e and Technoln‐2014.pdf
y for urban
age 20
travel
logy,
Energy and
Lecture 25 Rubin, EE IntergoveWorking Ghttps://w Suppleme
ye Lecture 26 Figueres,
dTh
Hansen, JH
Steffen, W
Sr
SupplemeOnline reshttp://climsimulator
Baer, P., eB
d Society: ER10
5 (11/28) – Cl
E, Chapter 12,
ernmental PanGroup I (The Sww.ipcc.ch/p
ental: Emanu
ears.” Nature
6 (11/30) – Cl
C., et al. (201oi:10.1038/54hreeYearstoS
., Sato, M. anansen_etal_2
W. et al. (2015Science, 347, ramanathan.u
ental: source: C‐ROAmateinteracti/
et al. (2000). “aer_2000.pdf
00 & 200 / Pub
Week
limate Chang
Pages 470 –
nel on ClimatScience of Clipdf/assessme
el, Kerry (200
e, 436: 686–68
limate Chang
17) “Three ye46593a. httpSafeguardOur
nd Ruedy, R. (2012.pdf]
5) “Planetary DOI: 10.1126ucsd.edu/file
AD ive.wordpres
“Equity and Gf]
b Pol 184 & 284
15 – Energy a
ge I: Energy an
537.
e Change, Fifmate Changeent‐report/ar5
05), “Increasin
88, August 4.
ge II: Energy P
ars to safegus://rael.berkerPlanet‐Natur
2012) “Perce
boundaries: 6/science.125s/pr210.pdf
s.com/2008/0
Greenhouse G
4
and the Globa
nd Climate:
th Assessmene), Summary f5/wg1/WG1A
ng destructiv
[ Emanue
Policy:
ard our climaeley.edu/wp‐re‐2017_full.p
eption of clim
Guiding hum59855. http://
09/19/panga
Gas Responsib
al Environme
nt Report for PolicymakAR5_SPM_FIN
eness of trop
el_2005.pdf]
ate,” Nature, ‐content/uplopdf
ate change”,
an developm/www‐
ea‐our‐decisi
bility.” Scienc
ent
kers NAL.pdf
pical cyclones
546, 593 – 59oads/2017/06
PNAS, [
ment on a cha
ion‐maker‐or
ce 289 (5488)
Pa
over the pas
95. 6/Figueres‐
nging planet”
riented‐uclim
: 2287. [
age 21
st 30
”
ate‐