university press scholarship online oxford scholarship online · response and recovery of water...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 1 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
UniversityPressScholarshipOnline
OxfordScholarshipOnline
Long-TermResponseofaForestWatershedEcosystem:ClearcuttingintheSouthernAppalachiansWayneT.SwankandJacksonR.Webster
Printpublicationdate:2014PrintISBN-13:9780195370157PublishedtoOxfordScholarshipOnline:May2015DOI:10.1093/acprof:osobl/9780195370157.001.0001
ResponseandRecoveryofWaterYieldandTiming,StreamSediment,AbioticParameters,andStreamChemistryFollowingLogging
WayneT.SwankJenniferD.KnoeppJamesM.VoseStephanieN.LaseterJacksonR.Webster
DOI:10.1093/acprof:osobl/9780195370157.003.0003
AbstractandKeywords
In1977,Watershed7(WS7)attheCoweetaHydrologicLaboratorywasclearcutandloggedusingamobilecablesystemthatcouldaccesslogsupto300mfromaroadandsuspendthelogscompletelyabovethegroundfortransporttotheloggingdeck.Watershed(WS)2,a12.6-hawatershedadjacenttoWS7,servedastheexperimentalcontrol.Thischapter(1)summarizesandevaluatesthelong-termhydrologicandwaterqualityresponsestoforestmanagement;and(2)linksstreamresponseswithprocess
![Page 2: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 2 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
levelresearchconductedwithinthewatershed.
Keywords:watershedecosystemanalysis,waterquality,forestmanagement,streamresponse,resourcesustainability
IntroductionWatershedecosystemanalysisprovidesascientificapproachtoquantifyingandintegratingresourceresponsestomanagement(HornbeckandSwank1992)andalsotoaddressissuesofresourcesustainability(Christensenetal.1996).ThephilosophicalcomponentsoftheresearchapproachatCoweetaare(1)thequantity,timing,andqualityofstreamflowprovidesanintegratedmeasureofecosystemresponsetolandmanagementpracticesand(2)responsetodisturbanceprovidesavaluabletoolforinterpretingecosystembehavior(SwankandCrossley1988).
Ourobjectivesinthischapterareto(1)summarizeandevaluatethelong-termhydrologicandwaterqualityresponsestoforestmanagementand(2)linkstreamresponseswithprocesslevelresearchconductedwithinthewatershed.
Thedetailsofgeneralandspecificforeststudysites,experimentaldesign,managementprescriptions,andnaturaldisturbancesspanningthe32-yearhistoryofthestudyatCoweetaaredescribedbySwankandWebsterinchapter1ofthisvolume.Briefly,a59-hasouth-facingmixedhardwoodcoveredwatershedwasclearcutandloggedin1977usingamobilecablesystemthatcouldaccesslogsupto300mfromaroadandsuspendthelogscompletelyabovethegroundfortransporttotheloggingdeck.Watershed(WS)2,a12.6-hawatershedadjacenttoWS7servedastheexperimentalcontrolforassessinghydrologicandwaterqualityresponsestothetreatmentonWS7.
(p.37) Hydrology
Methods
PrecipitationInputPrecipitationinputsweremeasuredusingstandardraingageslocatedwithintheCoweetabasin.Precipitationinputforeachwatershedwascalculatedusingestablishedrelationshipsbetweenspecificwatershedlocationswithinthebasinandindividualormultipleraingages.
StreamflowandAnnualWaterYieldWeusedthepairedorcontrolcatchmentmethodofanalysis(Hewlettetal.1969)toquantifytheeffectsofloggingtreatmentonthequantity,timing,andqualityofstreamflow.Inthismethod,therelationshipofstreamattributesbetweenreferenceandtreatedwatershedsforthecalibrationperiodisdeterminedbyregressionanalysiswhichincorporatesexperimentalcontrolforclimaticandbiologicalvariationswithinandbetweenyears.Thecalibrationperiodforhydrologicanalysisinthisstudyspanned11years,from1966to1976,withcontinuousmeasurementofdischargeusingsharp-crestedV-notchweirs(figure3.1).MeanannualdischargefromWS7duringthisperiodaveraged106cmandrangedfrom76to149cm.
![Page 3: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 3 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
Figure3.1 Upstreamviewof90ºV-notchweirinstallationonWS7,November2012.(USDAForestServicephoto)
(p.38) Thecoefficientofdetermination(r2)fortotalannualflowbetweenWS7andWS2duringthecalibrationperiodwas0.99.Theerrorterm(p<0.05)forpredictedindividualannualflowsfortreatmentyearsaveraged±5cm.Regressionanalysisusingmonthlyflowdatawasusedtoquantifythewithin-yearchanges;r2duringthecalibrationperiodrangedfrom0.96to0.99.
EarlyPostharvestSlashInterceptionLossAnimportantcomponentofevapotranspirationinforestsisinterceptionloss,whichhasseldombeenstudiedafterlogging.Forestcanopiesinterceptandaltertheamountandchemistryofprecipitationaswaterpassesthroughfoliage(throughfall)orflowsdownthestem(stemflow).ClearcuttingandharvestonWS7removedthecanopystructureforseveralyearsandaddedalargequantityofwoodyresiduetotheforestfloor.Several(1yrand8yraftercutting)studieswereconductedtoquantifytheeffectsoninterceptionloss(thischapter)andonnutrientleaching(seeKnoeppetal.,chapter4,thisvolume).
Thebasicexperimentaldesignofthefirststudywastheestablishmentofeighteen4x4mplotsat9locationsinWS7,whichwerestratifiedtoproportionallyrepresenttheforesttypesbeforeclearcutting.One2x2mplotwasnestedinonecornerofeach4x4mplot;thus,therewereatotalof36plots.Inthefirstyearaftercutting,coarsewood(CW;i.e.,logsandbrancheswithdiameters≥5cm)wasmeasuredforenddiametersandlengthofCWlyingwithineach4x4mplottocalculatevolumeandsurfacearea.Disksweretakenfromrepresentativelogstodeterminewooddensityandmass.CWsamplingwasrepeatedinyears6,7,and11inalong-termstudyofwooddecompositiononWS7(Mattsonetal.1987;seealsoMattsonandSwank,chapter7,thisvolume).
Finewood(branchesandstems<5cmindiameter)wassampledinthe2x2mplotsnestedinthecornerofeachCWplot.Theseplotswereselectedtorepresenttherangeofslashdominatedbystems,“brush,”ormixedslash,all<5cmindiameter.Woodwasalsosampledontheseplotstoestimatesurfaceareaandbiomassoffinewood.
![Page 4: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 4 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
Throughfallwascollectedbyinserting15x200cmV-shapedaluminumtroughsbeneaththeslash,attachedto19-Lpolypropylenecollectionjugs(seefigure4.1,inchapter4,thisvolume).Sampleswerecollectedonastormeventbasisandvolumesusedtoestimateinterceptionlossandleachingofnutrientsfromslash.
LaterPostharvestForestInterceptionLossAdetailedstudyofinterceptionloss,atmosphericdeposition,andfoliageleachingwasconductedonWS7whentheregeneratingforestwas8yearsold(Potteretal.1991;Potter1992)(figure3.2).InterceptionfindingsarereportedhereandcanopynutrientfluxesarereportedbyKnoeppetal.(seechapter4,thisvolume).Three20x20mplotswerelocatednearthemiddleofWS7inachestnutoak(Quercusprinus)community.A10-mtowerwaslocatedinthemiddleofthestudysiteandinstrumentedtocollectincidentrainfallanddryparticulateinputstothecanopy.(p.39)
Figure3.2 WS7eightyearsafterclearcutting.(USDAForestServicephoto)
Thirtytroughs(1.0x0.1m)wererandomlyplacedinthethreeplotstocollectthroughfall;stemflowwasmeasuredinnine1x2mplots(Potteretal.1991).Datawerecollectedonastorm-eventbasisandincluded20storms,14duringthegrowingseasonand6duringthedormantseason,throughouttheperiodJuly1984throughAugust1986.
ResultsandDiscussion
InitialWaterYieldandInterceptionResponsesIn1978,thefirstfullwateryear(MaytoApril)followinglogging,streamflowincreased26.5cm,orabout28%abovetheflowexpectediftheforesthadnotbeencut(figure3.3).Insubsequentyears,annualdischargeincreasesdeclinedatarateof5to7cmperyearuntilthefifthyearaftercutting,whenannualflowwasjust4cmabovepretreatmentlevels.Thereafter,changesinflowwerenotsignificant(p>0.05)anddischargefluctuatedaroundexpectedbaselinevalues.
ThepatternofinitialresponseandearlyrecoveryofannualstreamflowafterclearcuttingWS7areconsistentwithotherforestcuttingexperimentsatCoweeta(Swanketal.1988)
![Page 5: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 5 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
andinotherlocationsoftheAppalachianregionoftheUnitedStates(seeAdamsandKochendenfer,chapter12andHornbecketal.,chapter13,thisvolume).Wateryieldincreasesaretypicallygreatestinthefirstyearaftercuttingbecausetranspirationismostreducedduetominimalleafareaindex(LAI).Insubsequentyears,assproutsandseedlingsregrow,LAIandtranspirationincrease(seeBoringetal.,chapter2,thisvolume)resultinginalogarithmicdeclineinstreamflowoverthefirstsixyearsofsuccession.
(p.40)
Figure3.3 AnnualdeviationsinstreamflowonWS7priortoandfollowingclearcuttingandcommercialloggingatCoweetaHydrologicLaboratory,1967–2012.*Denotessignificantchange;p<0.05).
Loggingslashinterceptionwasmeasuredforatotalof36storms,rangingfrom5to12mmfromDecember1977throughApril1979.Interceptionloss(precipitationminusthroughfall)wasalinearfunctionofrainfallamountforalltypesofslash.Statisticalanalysesofregressionslopesshowednosignificantdifferencesamongtheslashtypes<5cm,soalldatafromthesmallmaterialwerecombinedintheregressions.However,theregressionslopeofthecoarsewood(logsandbranches≥5cm)wasdifferentfromalloftheothertypesofslashandresultedinadifferentregressionequation.
Linearregressionsforestimatinginterceptionlossfromslashare:
(Eq.1)
(Eq.2)
whereILisinterceptionlossandPisprecipitation,bothinmm.
EstimatesofannualinterceptionlossusingEqs.1and2werederivedfortheperiod
IL (CWD) = −0.44 + 0.2098 (P) ; = 0.70r2
IL (otherslash) = −0.82 + 0.1516 (P) ; = 0.47r2
![Page 6: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 6 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
September1977–August1978;stormprecipitationwasmeasuredmonthlyonagagelocatedonWS7andadjustedforeachmonthbasedonpreviouslydevelopedseasonalweightingfactors(Swiftetal.1988).Precipitationforthe12-monthperiodtotaled1,731mm,withamonthlyrangeof22to265mmdeliveredin76stormsovertheyear.InterceptionlossforCWwasestimatedtobe324mm,or18.7%ofprecipitation,comparedtoanestimatedinterceptionlossof197mm,or11.4%ofprecipitationforsmallerslash.Acombinedwoodinterceptionlosswasderivedbyweightingtheamountofthetwoslashtypesmeasuredonthe36plotsbasedonwoodsurfacearea.Themeanwoodsurfaceareaperplotareawas0.448m2/m2forCWand0.898m2/m2forsmallerslash,foratotalwoodsurfaceareaof(p.41) 1.346m2/m2.Usingtheappropriateweightingfactors,annualinterceptionlossforwoodwasestimatedtobe239mm,or13.8%ofprecipitation.
Similarstudiesofinterceptionbyloggingresiduearenotavailableforcomparisonwiththesefindings.However,HelveyandPatric(1988)reportedanannualinterceptionlossformaturehardwoodsatCoweetaof250mm,or13%totalprecipitation,including3%litterinterceptionloss.Thus,theearlypostharvestinginterceptioncomponentofthehydrologicbudgetonWS7wasnotsubstantiallyalteredandthefirstseveralyearsofannualwateryieldincreasesmeasuredaftercuttingandharvest(figure3.3)weremainlyduetoreductionsintranspiration.Thereareseveralfactorscontributingtotheinitialhighinterceptionloss.First,onlysawlogswereharvestedandtheremainingvegetationwascutaspartofthesitepreparationtreatment,whichcontributedtoahighloadingofwoodyresidue.Secondly,WS7isasouth-facingslope;previousresearch(Swift1972)foundradiationavailableforevapotranspirationisgreateronsouth-thannorth-facingslopes,animportantfactorthatwasincludedinamodelusedtopredictwateryieldresponseonWS7(table3.1).
LaterPostharvestForestInterceptionLossIntheregenerating8-year-oldforest(Potteretal.1991;Potter1992),datawerecombinedforallstorms.Throughfallandstemflowwereestimatedtobe83.3%and5.8%ofprecipitation,respectively,foranestimatedinterceptionlossof10.9%ofprecipitation.ThesewaterfluxesfortheregeneratingstandweresimilarinmagnitudetothosethatwereconcurrentlymeasuredintheadjacentreferencehardwoodforestonWS2(Swanketal.1992).
TherecoveryofcanopyinterceptionlossearlyinsuccessioncanbemainlyattributedtoarapidrecoveryofleafareaonWS7(seeBoringetal.,chapter2,thisvolume).Thecontributionsofinterceptionlosstowatershedevaporotranspiration(Et)andstreamflowrecoveryisadynamicprocess.Theimportanceofinterceptionlossfromwoodmeasuredthefirstyearaftercuttingdeclinedovertimewithdecomposition.However,11yearsaftercutting,thequantityofCWwasstillsignificant(seeMattsonandSwank,chapter7,thisvolume),whichcontributedto
Table3.1Comparisonofannualobservedvs.predictedincreaseinwateryieldfollowingclearcuttingonCoweetaWS7.
![Page 7: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 7 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
Yearfollowingclearcutting
Increasedpredictedbymodel(cm)
ObservedIncrease(cm)
1 25 262 17 203 12 174 8 125 6 46 3 4Total 71 83Source:Swanketal.(1988).
(p.42) waterstorageandinterceptionlossfromtheforestfloor.Overthesametimeperiod,canopyinterceptionlosswasreturningtoprecuttinglevels.Thus,duringthefirstdecadeofregrowth,thecombinedinterceptionlossfromwoodandtheregrowingcanopyprobablyexceededthatforamaturehardwoodforestandmayhavecontributedtosomeofthevariabilityinannualwateryield(figure3.3).
Longer-TermWaterYieldResponsesThesignificantincreaseinstreamflowin1992,whentheforestwas15yearsold(figure3.3)hasbeenattributedtoareductioninbothstemdensityandLAIassociatedwithcompetitionandself-thinning(stemexclusionstage)ofrapidgrowingcoppicevegetation(Swanketal2001;Elliottetal.1997),ahighmortalityrateofRobiniapseudoacaciacausedbystemborers(seeBoringetal,chapter2,thisvolume),declineofdogwood(Cornusflorida)duetoadisease,dogwoodanthracnose(Chellemietal.1992),andlossofabundantAmericanchestnut(Castaneadentata)sproutsduetothechestnutblight(seeBoringetal.,chapter2,thisvolume).Similarpatternsofchangesinstandstructure,wateruse,andstreamflowhavebeenfoundinotherclearcuttingexperimentsatCoweeta(SwiftandSwank1981).
Canopyopeningscreatedduringthestemexclusionstageofsuccessionwereshort-lived;andby1994to1995,17yearsaftercutting,thestandbasalareawas23m2/ha,whichissimilartothe25m2/habasalareaoftheoriginalforest(Elliottetal.1997)andLAIalsoincreasedtoprecuttinglevels(seeBoringetal.,chapter2,thisvolume).IntheensuingdecadeafterLAIstabilized,therehasbeenapatternofannualstreamflowreductionsthatfrequentlyexceed2.5cm(figure3.3).WehypothesizethathigherEtfortheregrowingversusmatureforestisrelatedtohighertranspirationlossassociatedwithmajorshiftsinspeciescomposition.Forexample,therewereverylargeincreasesinbasalareaofLiriodendrontulipifera,Acerrubrum,andRobiniapseudoacaciainthesuccessionalforestandanequallylargedeclineforcombinedCaryaandQuercusspp.(seeBoringetal.,chapter2,thisvolume).ThishypothesisissupportedbyrecentphysiologicalresearchatCoweetathathasshownlargedifferencesincanopytranspirationratesamonghardwoodspecies.Specifically,diffuseporousspecies,suchas
![Page 8: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 8 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
yellowpopularandredmaple,havemuchhighertranspirationratescomparedtooakandhickoryspecies(Fordetal.2010;Fordetal.2011).PersistentdecreasesinannualwateryieldwerealsoobservedatHubbardBrookfollowingaharvestandattributedtohighertranspirationratesforringporousearlysuccessionspeciescomparedtomaturenorthernhardwoodforests(Hornbecketal.1977;seealsoHornbecketal.,chapter13,thisvolume).
WaterYieldModelOneoftheoriginalobjectivesofthecuttingexperimentonWS7wastoobtainwateryieldresponsedataforasouth-facingwatershed.PrevioussynthesesofwatershedexperimentsintheAppalachianHighlandsPhysiographicregion(DouglassandSwank1972,1975)establishedempiricalequationsbetweenfirst-yearwateryield(p.43)increasesasafunctionofpercentbasalareacutandaninsolationindex(energyvariablerelatedtoslopeaspect)foracatchment.Inaddition,anotherempiricalequationwasdeveloped(DouglassandSwank1975)forpredictingwateryieldincreasesforanyyearfollowingharvestuntilstreamflowreturnstobaselinelevels.Themodelscontainlittledatafromsouth-facingclearcutwatershedswithnaturalforestsuccession.However,predictionsfromthesemodelsgenerallyshowedgoodagreementwithannualwateryieldresponsesmeasuredonsouth-facingWS7(table3.1).Thefirstyearaftercutting,streamflowincreasedabout26cmcomparedto25cmpredictedbythemodel.Subsequently,inthenext2years,predictedincreasesweresubstantiallybelowobservedincreases.TheseyearscoincidedwiththewettestyearonrecordandoneofthedriestyearsatCoweeta.Intheensuing3years,predictionswereincloseagreementwithobservedincreasesinwateryieldandthetotalchangepredictedforthe6-yearperiodwaswithin17%oftheobservedchange.
Intra-AnnualWaterYieldDuringthefirst3postcuttingyears,themonthlydistributionsofwateryieldincreases(figure3.4)weresimilartootherlow-elevationcuttingexperimentsatCoweeta(Swanketal.1988).Flowincreasesoccurredineverymonth,withthesmallestamountsinthespring(AprilandMay),atthesametimethatsoilmoistureinanundisturbedforestisusuallyfullyrecharged.Concurrentwiththegrowingseason,streamflowincreasesbecomelargerduetoreducedEtonWS7.SubstantialflowincreasescontinuedintothelatefallandwintermonthsandpartiallyreflectthelagbetweenwhenreducedEtoccursonthecutwatershedandwhenthewatersavingsreachtheweirduringtheperiodofhighprecipitation(figure3.4).
![Page 9: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 9 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
Figure3.4 Meanmonthlychangesinwateryieldduringthefirst4postcuttingyearsonCoweetaWS7.(ModifiedfromSwanketal.,1982)
(p.44) Ofnotableimportanceisthattwoofthelargestflowincreases(1.6cm,or28%increase)occurredinSeptemberandOctoberwhenflowsarenormallylowandwaterdemandsarehigh.
StormHydrographResponsesDetailedanalysisofeightstormhydrographparameterswasconductedforWS7usingpretreatmentstormdataonWS7regressedagainstthesameparametersasthereferencecatchment(WS2).Theanalysisuseddatafor75storms(≥2cm)fromthefirst4yearsaftertreatment,whichencompassedtheperiodofmaximumwateryieldincrease(Swanketal.2001).
Followingharvest,statisticallysignificantchangesinregressioninterceptsandslopeswerefoundforallstormparametersexcepttimetostormpeak(table3.2).Thelargestincreasesoccurredinpeakflowrates(15%)andinitialflowrates(14%);thelatterisduetoelevatedratesofbaseflowfromthewatershed.Quickflow(stormflow)volumeincreased10%,whichwasassociatedwitha10%increaseinrecessiontime.Takencollectively,thehydrographresponsesareconsideredtobeofminorimportancetodownstreamflooding.Forexample,inthefirst4yearsaftercuttingandharvest,theaverageprecipitationstorm,≥2cm,increasedthequickflowvolumebyonly0.03cm,or2.43m3/ha,andthepeakflowrateby1.7m3/ha.
Stormhydrographresponsestoharvestarepartlydependentupon(1)themagnitudeandmethodofloggingandassociatedroaddisturbanceand(2)theinherentresponsivenessofthewatershedtoprecipitationeventsintheabsenceof
Table3.2Stormhydrographparametersandchangesduringthefirst4yearsfollowingclearcuttingandloggingonWS7.Parameter Meanfor
treatmentwatershed
Significanceofregressioncoefficients
Percentchangeinparameteraftertreatmentformeanstorm
![Page 10: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 10 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
WS7 WS2 Intercept SlopeInitialflowrate(m3s−1km−2)
0.037 0.27 ** ** 14
Peakflowrate(m3s−1km−2)
0.136 0.127 ** ** 15
Timetopeak(h)
8.0 8.0 NSb NS 0
Totalquickflowvolume(cm)
0.32 0.40 ** ** 10
Quickflowafterpeak(cm)
0.08 0.09 ** ** 6
Quickflowafterpeak(cm)
0.24 0.31 * NS 11
Quickflowduration(h)
27.6 28.3 ** * 5
Recessiontime(h)
20.0 21.0 ** NS 10
aDerivedfromdifferencebetweenvaluepredictedfromcalibrationregressionandmeasuredvalue.
(b)Nonsignificant.
(*)p<0.05.
(**)p<0.01.
Source:ModifiedfromSwanketal.(1982).
(p.45) disturbance.Inherentresponsivenessisdrivenbyavarietyofphysicalfactorssuchaswatershedsize,soildepth,slopeandtopographiccomplexity,andinfiltrationrates.Theresponsefactor(meanannualquickflow/meanannualprecipitation)forWS7wasverylow(0.04),whichaccountsforsomeofthesmallchangesinstormhydrographparameters.Furthermore,thelowdensityofloggingroads,minimaldisturbanceofthesurfacesoilbycablelogging(seeSwankandWebster,chapter1,thisvolume),andcarefuldesignofroads(Swift1988)alsolimitedchangesinstormflowonWS7.
AbioticResponsestoClearcutting
SoilMoistureandTemperature
Regenerationcuttingcanproducesignificantchangesinthemicroenvironmentoftheforestfloorandsoilthatinturnregulateecosystemprocesses,suchasdecomposition;microbialactivity;nutrientcycles;andthegermination,sprouting,survival,andgrowthofvegetation.BeginninginAugust1977,studieswereinitiatedonWS7toevaluatetheeffectsofharvestingonsoilmoistureandtemperature.Soilmoisturewasmeasuredat
![Page 11: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 11 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
biweeklyintervalsintheO1andO2(organic)litterlayersoftheforestfloorand0to10-cmand10–30-cmdepthsinthesoilonWS7andalsoWS2,theadjacentcontrolwatershed(SwankandVose1988).Inthefirstautumn(Aug–Nov)afterharvest,littermoisturewas20%to30%belowthatfoundonWS2(table3.3).Inthesubsequentwinterquarter,littermoisturewassimilaronbothwatersheds.However,intheensuingyear(1978),littermoisturewasconsistently30%to50%lowerintheclearcutcomparedtoWS2.Incontrast,surfacesoilmoisture(0–10cm);increasedmorethan11%thefirstyearaftercutting(table3.3).Deeperinthesoilprofile,moistureincreasesweresmallorshowednochanges.
Soiltemperaturesweremeasuredatthelitter-soilinterfaceonWS7duringtheprecutyear(1976)priortoclearcuttingandinthefirstgrowingseasonaftercuttingandlogging(SwankandVose1988).Meanmonthlytemperatureswere7°Cto10°CaboveprecutlevelsintheperiodMaythroughOctoberinthefirstyearaftercutting.Meanmonthlymaximumsoiltemperaturesshowedlargeincreaseswithvaluesbeing10°Cto35°Caboveprecutlevelsanddailymaximumtemperaturesfrequentlyexceeded45°Cduringthisperiod.Insubsequentyears,increasesinsurfacesoiltemperaturesweremoderatedbyshadefromregeneration.
StreamChemistry
Methods
Streamchemistrymeasurementsbeganinlate1971onbothWS7andWS2.Weeklygrabsampleshavebeencollectedatafixedlocationjustabovetheweirfromeachwatershedsince1971,andflowproportionalsampleswerealsocollectedintheperiod1975–1981.SolutedeterminationsincludeNO3−,NH4+,SO4−2,PO4−3,Cl−,and(p.46)
Table3.3Quarterlyforestfloorandsoilmoistureaverages(percent)formixedhardwoodforestsduringthefirstyearafterclearcutting(WS7)andforthereferencewatershed(WS2).Treatmentanddepth
YearandQuater
Aug–Nov1977
Dec–Mar1977–78
Apr–Jul1978
Aug–Nov1978
Watercontent(percentbyweight)ClearcutO1 70 124 88 51O2 95 170 97 580to<10cm 46 70 55 3110to30cm 36 40 34 23ControlO1 92 121 120 105O2 126 211 120 109
![Page 12: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 12 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
0to<10cm 35 59 36 2810to30cm 32 40 29 24Note:O1=includesfreshorslightlydecomposedorganicmaterials.
O2=includesintermediateandhighlydecomposedorganicmaterials.
Source:ModifiedfromSwankandVose(1988).
basecations(Ca+2,Mg+2,K+,Na+)usingestablishedanalyticalmethodsatCoweeta(Brownetal.2009).Comparisonof3-yearaverageannualexportofsolutescalculatedfromweeklygrabsamplesversusflow-proportionalsamplesshowedgoodagreementformostsolutes(SwankandWaide1988).Annualchangeinexportofeachsoluteduetotreatmentthefirst6yearswasestimatedfrompretreatmentregressionsofmonthlyexportsbetweenWS7andWS2.Relationshipsofmonthlyexportsbetweenthetwocatchmentsweregood(r2values≥0.92)formostions.
ResponsetoTreatment
Streamchemistryresponsestotreatmentwererelativelysmall(table3.4)asdescribedinanearlieranalysis(Swanketal.2001).IncreasesinexportofPO4,K,Ca,andMginthefirstfullyearfollowingloggingarepartiallyrelatedtoreleasefromthefertilizerappliedtoroads.LackofsignificantNO3responsewasdueinparttosedimentdenitrificationthatdepletedNO3beforeitreachedtheweir(SwankandCaskey1982).DenitrificationinBigHurricaneBranch(WS7)wasremeasuredin2004aspartofalargeregionalstudyin49streamswithvaryingland-usecategories(Mulhollandetal.2009).Theyfoundmeasureablebutlowerratesofdenitrificationthanthosefoundin1977bySwankandCaskey(1982).However,differencesinbothmethodsandthesupplyofNO3ofthetwostudieslimitdirectquantitativecomparisons.
ThemagnitudeofnutrientexportisdeterminedbybothchangesinsoluteconcentrationsandincreasesindischargeresultingfromreducedEtfollowingcutting.Thefirsttwoyearsaftercutting,annualflowincreasedanaverageof23.5cm/y,but(p.47)
Table3.4Annualchangesinstreamflowandsolutesfollowingclearcuttingandlogging(posttreatment–pretreatment)onWS7.Timesincetreatment(May–Aprilwateryear)
Flow(cm)
Increaseordecreaseinstreamflowandsoluteexport(kgha−1)a
NO3-N
NH4-N
PO4-P
K Na Ca Mg SO4-S
Cl
First4months 0.5 0.01 <0.01
0.01 0.43 0.42 0.24 0.26 0.39 0.68
Firstfullyear 26.5 0.26 0.03 0.04 1.98 1.37 2.60 0.96 0.27 1.13Year2 20.5 1.12 <
0.010.01 1.95 2.22 2.51 1.15 −0.08 1.62
![Page 13: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 13 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
Year3 17.3 1.27 0.05 0.02 2.40 2.68 3.16 1.42 0.39 2.08Year4 11.9 0.25 0.15 0.02 0.80 1.07 1.63 0.46 0.31 0.59Year5 4.3 0.28 0.01 <
0.010.52 0.13 1.19 0.18 0.04 0.10
Year6 4.1 0.62 0.06 <0.01
0.73 0.69 0.89 0.42 −0.06 0.33
(a)Annualincreaseordecreasederivedfromsumofdeviationsusingmonthlycalibrationregressions.
Source:ModifiedfromSwanketal.(2001).
maximumconcentrationsofmostsolutesdidnotoccuruntilthethirdyearwhenwateryieldonWS7wasstillmorethan17cmabovepretreatmentlevels(table3.1).Bythesixthyearofpostdisturbance,streamflowwasnearpretreatmentlevelsandsoluteexportsalsoappearedtobeapproachingpretreatmentlevels.Thelonger-termresponsesofmostsolutesshowedasimilarpattern.Forexample,small(5µeq/L)increasesinCaconcentrationswereobservedafterloggingbutlaterreturnedtoexpectedpretreatmentlevels(figure3.5).Similarly,followingtheinitialincreaseinKconcentrations,interannualconcentrationsofKafter1983werehighlyvariable,andtherewerenoconsistentdifferencesinconcentrationsbetweenWS7andWS2(figure3.5).ThesamepatternwastrueforMg(figure3.6).TherewaslittlechangeinSO4concentrationsonWS7aftercutting,butbeginningin1989therehasbeenaconsistentdeclineinSO4concentrationsonbothWS7andreferenceWS2(figure3.6).ConcentrationsofNH4andPO4werelowandalmostidenticalforWS7andWS2duringtheentireperiodofrecord.Incontrast,thelong-termrecordforNO3showedinteresting,significantdynamicsfollowingcuttingandforestsuccession(figure3.7).
TheinitialincreaseinNO3concentrationsonWS7wasattributedtoincreasesinsoilNpoolsandconcentrationsthefirstthreeyearsafterlogging(Waideetal.1988;seealsoKnoeppetal.,chapter4,thisvolume).DeclineinstreamNO3concentrationsuntilabout1987areassociatedwiththerapidsequestrationandstorageofnutrientsinsuccessionalvegetation(Boringetal.1988;seealsoBoringetal.,chapter2,thisvolume).However,majorshiftsininternalecosystemNcyclingareevidentinalarge,sustainedpulseofNO3tothestreamfromabout1987through1997(figure3.7).MeanannualpeakNO3concentrations20yearsafterdisturbanceareaboutdoublethevaluesintheearlypostharvestyears.Thereafter,NO3concentrationsdeclinedabout8µeq/Lovera5-yearperiod,followedbyanotherincreaseduringtheensuing5yearsthatreachedamaximumof12µeq/Lin2008(figure3.7).
(p.48)
![Page 14: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 14 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
Figure3.5 MeanannualconcentrationsofCa(a)andK(b)instreamwaterofWS7andWS2duringcalibration(1971–1976),treatmentactivities(1976–1977),andpostharvestperiod(1978–2010).
AcomplexcombinationofecologicalprocessescontributetothemagnitudeandtemporaldynamicsinstreamNO3.AcceleratedNO3releasetothestreamcoincideswithstemexclusionin1992,andthus,someoftheNO3losswasprobablyduetothereduceduptake.However,thelargestcontributortoincreasedNavailabilitywasextensiveblacklocustmortalityduetolocustborerinfestation,whichisasimilarresponseobservedinanotherearlysuccessionwatershed(WS6)atCoweetawithlargelocustinfestationsandmortality(SwankandWaide1988).Blacklocustisasymbioticnitrogenfixer;inthe4-year-oldlocuststandsonWS7,fixationwasestimatedtobe30kgNha−1yr−1whilefixationcatchmentwidewasestimatedat10kgNha−1yr−1(BoringandSwank1984).Moreover,blacklocustisknowntoaccumulatelargequantitiesofNinfoliage,roots,branches,andstems(BoringandSwank1984).DecompositionoftheN-richorganicmatterfromthedeadtrees(330stems/ha)couldbeamajorsourceofstreamNO3laterinsuccession(figure3.7).(p.49)
![Page 15: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 15 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
Figure3.6 MeanannualconcentrationsofSO4(a)andMg(b)instreamwaterofWS7andWS2duringcalibration(1971–1976),treatmentactivities(1976–1977),andpostharvestperiod(1978–2010).
Figure3.7 MeanannualconcentrationsofNO3instreamwaterofWS7andWS2duringcalibration(1971–1978),treatmentactivities(1976–1977),andpostharvestperiod(1978–2010).
(p.50) Decomposingloggingresidue(seeMattsonandSwank,chapter7,thisvolume)isalsoapotentialsourceoflong-termstreamNO3enrichmentthatappearsinthestream.OtherpossiblereasonsforincreasedstreamNO3concentrationsareelevatedratesofsoilNmineralizationandnitrificationandreductioninthesoilC/Nratio.
![Page 16: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 16 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
MeasurementoftheC/Nratioshowednosignificantchangeoverthe18-yearperiodfollowingcutting(KnoeppandSwank1997).However,long-termassessmentofsoilNtransformationsshowcontinuedincreaseinNavailabilityinsurfacesoils20yearsfollowingharvest(seeKnoeppetal.,chapter4,thisvolume).
ThestreamNO3responsesobservedonWS7demonstratethevalueoflong-termstudiesinforestecosystemsandtheprocessesregulatingsystemresponses.Forexample,thefirst10-yeartrendinconcentrationssuggestedthatNO3concentrationshadreturnedtonearpretreatmentlevels.However,inthesubsequent30-yearperiod,concentrationsshowedverylargeincreasesanddecreasesthatgreatlyexceededtheinitialresponses.Thus,earlyterminationofthestudyandassociatedconclusionswouldhavebeenincompleteandpartlyinaccurate.
Theimportanceoftheinteractionbetweensuccessionalvegetation(e.g.,blacklocust)andinsectinfestationsonstreamNO3isclearlyevidentonWS7;however,thisdoesnotexplainallofthetemporalvariationinstreamNO3.Forexample,interannualmagnitudeandvariabilityofstreamNO3concentrationarealsorelatedtohydrologicvariables.AnnualstreamflowonWS7,rangedfrom45to130cm/yfrom1990to2009,andexplained36%oftheannualvariationinstreamNO3concentrationsfollowingcutting(figure3.8).
Takencollectively,nutrientlossesonWS7shouldnothaveanadverseimpactonthesustainabilityandgrowthofthesuccessionalforest.Atmosphericdepositionofnutrientsexceededtheelevatedlossesofnutrientsinmostyearsofthestudy(Swanketal.2001).Moreover,thehighN-fixationratesofblacklocustandavailabilityofNtoothertreespeciescanbeviewedasabenefittotreegrowthandforesthealth.Furtherdiscussionontherelevanceoffindingstomanagementandecologicalvaluesisfoundinchapter14ofthisvolume.
Figure3.8 TherelationshipbetweenmeanannualNO3-NconcentrationsandannualstreamflowonCoweetaWS7overa20-yearperiod.
(p.51) Sediment
Methods
![Page 17: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 17 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
TheeffectsofthemanagementpracticesonsoillosstostreamsonWS7weredeterminedatperiodicintervalsbymeasuringsedimentaccumulationsintheweirpondingbasinandalsoontheapproachapronofthepondingbasinofbothWS7andWS2.Thisapproachdoesnotaccountforsuspendedsedimentthatpassesacrosstheweirblade;therefore,totalsedimentexportwasunderestimated.Sedimentvolumeswereestimatedbymeasuringsedimentelevationsalongpermanenttransectswithatransitandlevelrodbeforeandaftercleaningthepondingbasinandapproachaprons.Bulksampleswerecollectedateachelevationmeasurementandprocessedtoestimatedryweight.Apretreatmentcalibrationregressionequationofperiodicsedimentlossovera2-yearperiodbetweenWS7andWS2wasderived(r2=0.91)toestimatechangesinsedimentlossduetomanagement.
SoillossesonsubdrainageswithinWS7werealsomeasuredtoseparateandquantifysedimentsourcesduetoroadsversuslogging.DischargeandsoilexportweresampledwithanHflumeandaCoshoctonwheelusingproceduresdescribedbyDouglassandVanLear(1983).Oneinstallationwaslocatedinaperennialstreambelowthemiddleloggingroad(figure3.9)andthreeinstallationswerelocatedabovetheinfluenceofloggingroadstoevaluateeffectsofcuttingandloggingonly.
Figure3.9 OnefootH-FlumeandCoshoctonsampler(no.701)onWS7—oneoffoursuchinstallationsusedtoassesswaterqualityaboveandbelowroads,1976.(USDAForestServicephoto)
(p.52) Results
Sedimentyieldinthe2yearsofpretreatmentcalibrationfromWS7andWS2averaged230and135kgha−1yr−1respectively.Thesebaselinesedimentyieldsaresimilartothemeanvaluesforsmall,forestedcatchmentsintheeasternUnitedStatessummarizedbyPatricetal.(1984).Inmid-May1976,roadsinWS7werefertilizedandseededbutroadfillsandtherunningsurfacewereunsettledandwithoutgrassorgravelcover.ThethirdweekofMay1976,a16-cmstormoccurredandwasfollowedMay28byalargerstormof22cmwithintensitiesof7cm/h.ThesecondstormproducedthegreatestdischargeratesmeasuredonmostcatchmentsatCoweetaduringtheprevious62yearsoftheLaboratorygaginghistory.Thesetwoeventsgreatlyacceleratedsedimentyieldonboth
![Page 18: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 18 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
WS7andWS2withanincreaseinsoillossinMayonWS7of1,470kgha−1yr−1(figure3.10).Roadsweretheprimarysourceofincreasedsedimentyieldasillustratedbysoillossmeasuredatoneofthegagingstationsinastreamimmediatelybelowaroadcrossingthemiddleofthecatchment(figure3.11).FollowingtheMaystorms,sedimentyieldatthestationwasnearly50tfrom0.086haofroadcontributingareacomprisedofroadbed,cut,andfill.FollowingroadstabilizationandminimumuseovertheperiodofJunethroughDecember1976,soillossfromtheroadwaslow,butitacceleratedagainduringthepeakofloggingactivities(figure3.10).Inensuingyears,soillossreturnedtobaselinelevels.Inthesametimeperiod,samplerslocatedaboveroads,whichwereonlyinfluencedbycuttingandyarding,onlycollectedsmallamountsofmaterialcomprisedmainlyoforganicmatter.
FollowingtheinitialpulseofsedimentfromtheMay1976storms,sedimentyieldshowedmuchdifferenttemporalpatternsattheweir(figure3.10)comparedtosedimentlossfromtheroads.Sedimentyieldremainedsubstantiallyelevated
Figure3.10 SedimentyieldmeasuredinthepondingbasinonWS7followingloggingcomparedtothesedimentyieldpredictedfromWS2,theadjacentreferencewatershed,overa35-yearperiod.
(p.53)
Figure3.11 Cumulativesedimentyieldmeasuredinafirst-orderstreambelowaloggingroadduringthefirst32monthsafterlogging.
![Page 19: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 19 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
duringandafterloggingdisturbancesandcontinuedtohavesedimentlossesthatwerefrequentlyinexcessof500kgha−1yr−1aboveexpectedlossesovertheperiod1978—1985(figure3.10).AlargepulseofsedimentwasdeliveredtoweirsonbothWS2andWS7in1989inresponsetothewettestyearonrecordatCoweeta.SedimentyieldonWS7wasabout800kgha−1yr−1abovetheexpectedyield.In1991sedimentyieldonWS7returnedtopretreatmentlevels(234kgha−1yr−1)andremainedataboutthesamelevel(179kgha−1yr−1)basedonthreesampleperiodsinsubsequentyears(figure3.10).
Thelong-termsedimentyieldresponsesillustratethedelayorlagbetweenpulsedsedimentinputstoastreamandroutingofsedimentsthroughthewatershed.Soillossderivedfromroadswasverylowfollowingstabilizationwithgrassandgravelcover.Moreover,followinglogging,roadtravelwasminimal—roadswereonlyusedforaccesstoresearchsites.Also,basedonlong-termcross-sectionmeasurementsonthemainstreamonWS7,therehaveonlybeeninfrequentandminorinstancesofstreambankerosion(Websteretal.unpublisheddata).Thus,intheabsenceofsignificantadditionalsourcesofsedimenttoWS7streams,thelong-termsedimentincreasesobservedattheweironWS7wereduetoacontinuedreleaseofsedimentfromupstreamstorage,whichwasdepositedfromthreeroadcrossingsonperennialstreamsandfourcrossingsofintermittentstreamsonWS7intheMay1976storms.
Theuniqueconditionsthatproducedthesesedimentresponsesshouldberecognized,thatis,recordstormsoccurredattheprecisetimewhenroadswerefreshlyconstructedandwithoutvegetationcover,andthusmostvulnerabletoerosion.Itisalsoimportanttopointoutthatbestmanagementpracticeswereusedinharvesting(p.54)andinloggingroadlocationanddesign.Thelong-termeffectofthismanagementprescriptiononwater,soil,vegetationsustainabilityandhealth,andthestructureandfunctionofbenthicinvertebratesisfurtherdiscussedinaconcludingsynthesis(seeWebsteretal.,chapter14,thisvolume).
LiteratureCited
Bibliographyreferences:
Boring,L.R.,andW.T.Swank.1984.Theroleofblacklocust(Robinapseudo-acacia)inforestsuccession.JournalofEcology72:749–766.
Boring,L.R.,W.T.Swank,andC.D.Monk.1988.DynamicsofearlysuccessionalforeststructureandprocessesintheCoweetabasin.Pages161–179inForestHydrologyandEcologyatCoweeta.W.T.SwankandD.A.Crossley,Jr.,editors.Springer-Verlag,NewYork,NewYork.
Brown,C.L.,C.Harper,N.Muldoon,andS.Cladis.2009.ProceduresforchemicalanalysisattheCoweetaHydrologicLaboratory.CoweetaFiles.CoweetaHydrologicLaboratory,Otto,NorthCarolina.
![Page 20: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 20 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
Chellemi,D.O.,K.O.Britton,andW.T.Swank.1992.InfluenceofsitefactorsondogwoodanthracnoseintheNantahalaMountainRangeofWesternNorthCarolina.PlantDisease76:915–918.
Christensen,N.L.,A.M.Bartuska,J.H.Brown,S.Carpenter,C.D’Antonio,R.Francis,J.F.Franklin,J.A.MacMahon,R.F.Noss,D.J.Parsons,C.H.Peterson,M.G.Turner,andR.G.Woodmansee.1996.ThereportoftheEcologicalSocietyofAmericaCommitteeontheScientificBasisforEcosystemManagement.EcologicalApplications6:665–691.
Douglass,J.E.,andW.T.Swank.1972.Streamflowmodificationthroughmanagementofeasternforests.ResearchPaperSE-94.USDAForestService,SoutheasternForestExperimentStation.Asheville,NorthCarolina.
Douglass,J.E.,andW.T.Swank.1975.Effectsofmanagementpracticesonwaterqualityandquantity:CoweetaHydrologicLaboratory,NorthCarolina.Pages1–13inProceedingsofthemunicipalwatershedmanagementsymposium.GeneralTechnicalReportNE-13.U.S.DepartmentofAgriculture,ForestService,NortheasternForestExperimentStation,Broomall,Pennsylvania.
Douglass,J.E.,andD.H.VanLear.1983.PrescribedburningandwaterqualityatephemeralstreamsinthePiedmontofSouthCarolina.ForestScience29:181–189.
Elliott,K.J.,L.R.Boring,W.T.Swank,andB.R.Haines.1997.Successionalchangesinplantspeciesdiversityandcompositionafterclear-cuttingasouthernAppalachianwatershed.ForestEcologyandManagement92:67–85.
Ford,C.R.,R.M.Hubbard,andJ.M.Vose.2010.QuantifyingstructuralandphysiologicalcontrolsonvariationincanopytranspirationamongplantedpineandhardwoodspeciesinthesouthernAppalachians.Ecohydrology3.doi:10.1002/eco.136
Ford,C.R.,S.H.Laseter,W.T.Swank,andJ.M.Vose.2011.Canforestmanagementbeusedtosustainwater-basedecosystemserviceinthefaceofclimatechange?EcologicalApplications21:2049–2067.
Helvey,J.D.,andJ.H.Patric.1988.Researchoninterceptionlossesandsoilmoisturerelationships.Pages129–137inForestHydrologyandEcologyatCoweeta.W.T.SwankandD.A.Crossley,Jr.,editors.Springer-Verlag,NewYork,NewYork.
Hewlett,J.D.,H.W.Lull,andK.G.Reinhart.1969.Indefenseofexperimentalwatersheds.WaterResourcesResearch5:306–316.
Hornbeck,J.W.,andW.T.Swank.1992.Watershedecosystemanalysisasabasisformultiple-usemanagementofeasternforests.EcologicalApplications2:238–247.
Hornbeck,J.W.,C.W.Martin,andC.Eagar.1997.SummaryofwateryieldexperimentsatHubbardBrookExperimentalForest,NH.CanadianJournalofForestResearch27:2043–2052.
![Page 21: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 21 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
Knoepp,J.D.,andW.T.Swank.1997.Long-termeffectsofcommercialsawlogharvestonsoilcationconcentrations.ForestEcologyandManagement93:1–7.
Mattson,K.G.,W.T.Swank,andJ.B.Waide.1987.Decompositionofwoodydebrisinaregenerating,clearcutforestintheSouthernAppalachians.CanadianJournalofForestResearch17:712–721.
Mulholland,P.J.,R.O.Hall,D.J.Sobota,W.K.Dodds,S.E.G.Findlay,N.B.Grimm,S.K.Hamilton,W.H.McDowell,J.M.O’Brien,J.L.Tank,L.R.Ashkenas,L.W.Cooper,C.N.Dahm,S.V.Gregory,S.L.Johnson,J.L.Meyer,B.J.Peterson,G.C.Poole,H.M.Valett,J.R.Webster,C.P.Arango,J.J.Beaulieu,M.J.Bernot,A.J.Burgin,C.L.Crenshaw,A.M.Helton,L.T.Johnson,B.R.Niederlehner,J.D.Potter,R.W.Sheibley,andS.M.Thomas.2009.Nitrateremovalinstreamecosystemsmeasuredby15Nadditionexperiments:denitrification.LimnologyandOceanography54:666–680.
Patric,J.H.,J.O.Evans,andJ.I.Helvey.1984.SummaryofsedimentyielddatafromforestedlandintheUnitedStates.JournalofForestry82:101–104.
Potter,C.S.1992.Stemflownutrientinputstosoilinasuccessionalhardwoodforest.PlantandSoil140:249–254.
Potter,C.S.,H.L.Ragsdale,andW.T.Swank.1991.AtmosphericdecompositionandfoliarleachinginaregeneratingSouthernAppalachianforestcanopy.JournalofEcology79:97–115.
Swank,W.T.,andW.H.Caskey.1982.Nitratedepletioninasecond-ordermountainstream.JournalofEnvironmentalQuality11:581–584.
Swank,W.T.,andD.A.Crossley,Jr.1988.Introductionandsitedescription.Pages3–16inForestHydrologyandEcologyatCoweeta.W.T.SwankandD.A.Crossley,Jr.,editors.Springer-Verlag,NewYork,NewYork.
Swank,W.T.,J.E.Douglass,andG.B.Cunningham.1982.ChangesinwateryieldandstormhydrographsfollowingcommercialclearcuttingonasouthernAppalachiancatchment.Pages583–594inHydrologicalResearchBasinsandtheiruseinWaterResourcePlanning.SwissNationalHydrologicalServiceSpecialPublication,Berne,Switzerland.
Swank,W.T.,L.J.Reynolds,andJ.M.Vose.1992.Annualmeanatmosphericdeposition,throughstemflow,andsoilsolutionfluxesformajorionsatCoweetahardwoodsite.Page634inAtmosphericDepositionandForestNutrientCycling,D.W.JohnsonandS.E.Lindberg,editors.Springer-Verlag,NewYork,NewYork.
Swank,W.T.,L.W.Swift,Jr.,andJ.E.Douglass.1988.Streamflowchangesassociatedwithforestcutting,speciesconversions,andnaturaldisturbances.Pages297–312inForestHydrologyandEcologyatCoweeta.W.T.SwankandD.A.Crossley,Jr.,editors.Springer-Verlag,NewYork,NewYork.
![Page 22: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 22 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015
Swank,W.T.,andJ.M.Vose.1988.Effectsofcuttingpracticesonmicroenvironmentinrelationtohardwoodregeneration.Pages71–88inGuidelinesforRegeneratingAppalachianHardwoodStands.H.C.Smith,A.W.Perkey,andW.E.Kidd,Jr.,editors.SAFPubl.88-03.WestVirginiaUniversityBooks,Morgantown.
Swank,W.T.,J.M.Vose,andK.J.Elliott.2001.Long-termhydrologicandwaterqualityresponsesfollowingcommercialclearcuttingofmixedhardwoodsonasouthernAppalachiancatchment.ForestEcologyandManagement143:163–178.
Swank,W.T.,andJ.B.Waide.1988.Streamchemistryresponsestodisturbance.Pages339–357inForestHydrologyandEcologyatCoweeta.W.T.SwankandD.A.Crossley,Jr.,editors.Springer-Verlag,NewYork,NewYork.
Swift,L.W.,Jr.1972.Effectofforestcoverandmountainphysiographyontheradiantenergybalance.Dissertation.DukeUniversity,Durham,NorthCarolina.
Swift,L.W.,Jr.1988.Forestaccessroads:design,maintenance,andsoilloss.Pages313–324inForestHydrologyandEcologyatCoweeta.W.T.SwankandD.A.Crossley,Jr.,editors.Springer-Verlag,NewYork,NewYork.
Swift,L.W.,Jr.,G.B.Cunningham,andJ.E.Douglass.1988.Climatologyandhydrology.Pages35–55inForestHydrologyandEcologyatCoweeta.W.T.SwankandD.A.Crossley,Jr.,editors.Springer-Verlag,NewYork,NewYork.
Swift,L.W.,Jr.,andW.T.Swank.1981.Longtermresponsesofstreamflowfollowingclearcuttingandregrowth.HydrologicalSciencesBulletin26:245–256.
Waide,J.B.,W.H.Caskey,R.L.Todd,andL.R.Boring.1988.Changesinsoilnitrogenpoolsandtransformationsfollowingforestclearcutting.Pages221–232inForestHydrologyandEcologyatCoweeta.W.T.SwankandD.A.Crossley,Jr.,editors.Springer-Verlag,NewYork,NewYork.
Notes:
(*)Correspondingauthor:CoweetaHydrologicLaboratory,USDAForestService,3160CoweetaLabRoad,Otto,NC28763USA
Accessbroughttoyouby: JacksonWebster
![Page 23: University Press Scholarship Online Oxford Scholarship Online · Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, Abiotic Parameters, and Stream Chemistry Following](https://reader033.vdocuments.net/reader033/viewer/2022050512/5f9cc57d516a7014d020e0be/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Response and Recovery of Water Yield and Timing, Stream Sediment, AbioticParameters, and Stream Chemistry Following Logging
Page 23 of 23
PRINTED FROM OXFORD SCHOLARSHIP ONLINE (www.oxfordscholarship.com). (c) Copyright Oxford University Press, 2015.All Rights Reserved. Under the terms of the l icence agreement, an individual user may print out a PDF of a single chapter of amonograph in OSO for personal use (for details see http://www.oxfordscholarship.com/page/privacy-policy). Subscriber: JacksonWebster; date: 28 June 2015