using social media to activate local communities

39
CONFIDENTIAL Using social media to activate local communities Brad Flora Founder, http://windycitizen.com

Upload: socialdevcamp-chicago

Post on 12-May-2015

521 views

Category:

Business


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Lessons learned from experiments with the WindyCitizen during the past few years, specifically focused on the difficulty of attracting the core contributors necessary to make a news site flourish.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Using social media to activate local communitiesBrad Flora

Founder, http://windycitizen.com

Page 2: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

About Me

Founder, WindyCitizen.com Lives in Chicago’s Old Town neighborhood @bradflora on Twitter College Admissions Officer -> Summer Camp

Counselor -> Journalist -> Start-up guy

Page 3: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

What makes something “local”?

Anything that appeals to people specifically because they share a connection to a geographic region.

Page 4: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

How are these communities being reached now?

Two approaches

Page 5: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

How are these communities being reached now?

Two approaches Editorial approach

Create content that attracts an audience, Vertical Newspaper/Magazine sites, blogs, TV, radio, newsletters

Page 6: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

How are these communities being reached now?

Two approaches Editorial approach

Create content that attracts an audience, Vertical Newspaper/Magazine sites, blogs, TV, radio, newsletters

Social approach Create a place where people can interact with each other, create their own content, Horizontal/bottom-up Yelp, LikeThis

Page 7: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

How are these communities being reached now?

Two approaches Editorial approach

Create content that attracts an audience, Vertical Newspaper/Magazine sites, blogs, TV, radio, newsletters

Social approach Create a place where people can interact with each other, create their own content, Horizontal/bottom-up Yelp, LikeThis

Trend Editorial businesses looking to go social

Huffington Post’s new Facebook page NYTimes letting you track who’s reading what, connect with other NYTimes readers

Page 8: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

My approach

Problem Local media fragmenting

Page 9: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

My approach

Problem Local media fragmenting

Chicago has 150+ sources creating local content each day

Page 10: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

My approach

Problem Local media fragmenting

Chicago has 150+ sources creating local content each day City blogs, TV networks, newspapers, magazines, local guides, flickr, yelp Reverting to situation 100 years ago

Page 11: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

My approach

Problem Local media fragmenting

Chicago has 150+ sources creating local content each day City blogs, TV networks, newspapers, magazines, local guides, flickr, yelp Reverting to situation 100 years ago

How do you find what’s hot right now and meet people who also like it?

Page 12: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

My approach

Problem Local media fragmenting

Chicago has 150+ sources creating local content each day City blogs, TV networks, newspapers, magazines, local guides, flickr, yelp Reverting to situation 100 years ago

How do you find what’s hot right now and meet people who also like it?

Windy Citizen Surface the best of Chicago, offer a central place to talk about it

Page 13: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

My approach

Problem Local media fragmenting

Chicago has 150+ sources creating local content each day City blogs, TV networks, newspapers, magazines, local guides, flickr, yelp Reverting to situation 100 years ago

How do you find what’s hot right now and meet people who also like it?

Windy Citizen Surface the best of Chicago, offer a central place to talk about it Crowd-powered city guide

Page 14: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

My approach

Problem Local media fragmenting

Chicago has 150+ sources creating local content each day City blogs, TV networks, newspapers, magazines, local guides, flickr, yelp Reverting to situation 100 years ago

How do you find what’s hot right now and meet people who also like it?

Windy Citizen Surface the best of Chicago, offer a central place to talk about it Crowd-powered city guide Launched proof-of-concept site Jan. 2009

Page 15: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

My approach

Problem Local media fragmenting

Chicago has 150+ sources creating local content each day City blogs, TV networks, newspapers, magazines, local guides, flickr, yelp Reverting to situation 100 years ago

How do you find what’s hot right now and meet people who also like it?

Windy Citizen Surface the best of Chicago, offer a central place to talk about it Crowd-powered city guide Launched proof-of-concept site Jan. 2009

3-5k uniques/day 100-150 comments/day 550-600 votes/day cast on stories and comments Sending ~2k/day visitors away to local sites Ad-supported Just received grant from Chicago Community Trust to develop real deal

Page 16: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Why go after local communities?

Pros: Passionate users: People

who care, care A LOT Can leverage the power

of beer to connect with early adopters

Creating social capital, making the world better

No one’s figured it out yet

It just feels awesome

Cons: Market deceptively small Getting press coverage

works differently, if at all Won’t get you laid

(unless it’s a dating site)

Page 17: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Deceptive Market Size

3 million people in a region != 3 million audience

Page 18: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Deceptive Market Size

3 million people in a region != 3 million audience Local isn’t a niche, it’s a niche inside of a niche

Page 19: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Deceptive Market Size

3 million people in a region != 3 million audience Local isn’t a niche, it’s a niche inside of a niche

e.g. (sports(Chicago)) or (bars(Chicago)) or (politics(Chicago)) RedEye devotes < 4 pages/day to local coverage for a reason

Page 20: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Deceptive Market Size

3 million people in a region != 3 million audience Local isn’t a niche, it’s a niche inside of a niche

e.g. (sports(Chicago)) or (bars(Chicago)) or (politics(Chicago)) RedEye devotes < 4 pages/day to local coverage for a reason

Kevin Rose: “There’s not enough content in any one city to require a solution as drastic as crowdsourcing. The local sites do a good enough job already.”

Page 21: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Deceptive Market Size

3 million people in a region != 3 million audience Local isn’t a niche, it’s a niche inside of a niche

e.g. (sports(Chicago)) or (bars(Chicago)) or (politics(Chicago)) RedEye devotes < 4 pages/day to local coverage for a reason

Kevin Rose: “There’s not enough content in any one city to require a solution as drastic as crowdsourcing. The local sites do a good enough job already.” Metafilter guy: Critical mass for a community= 100 active users

When your potential audience is 100,000, getting those 100 people is a lot harder than when it’s 5 million

Page 22: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Media can only help so much

When you go local… Bye-bye tech blogs, reddit, Digg, other apps that announce new things

Page 23: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Media can’t help you so much

When you go local… Bye-bye tech blogs, reddit, Digg, other apps that announce new things Leaves you with local media

Page 24: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Media can’t help you so much

When you go local… Bye-bye tech blogs, reddit, Digg, other apps that announce new things Leaves you with local media

The “pipes” are owned by 1-2 players

Page 25: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Media can’t help you so much

When you go local… Bye-bye tech blogs, reddit, Digg, other apps that announce new things Leaves you with local media

The “pipes” are owned by 1-2 players They’re finally realizing that every web site on the web is competition

Page 26: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Media can’t help you so much

When you go local… Bye-bye tech blogs, reddit, Digg, other apps that announce new things Leaves you with local media

The “pipes” are owned by 1-2 players They’re finally realizing that every web site on the web is competition They’re backwards about linking out

Chicago Tribune wrote story about launch, no backlink in online article Reporters have told me they won’t cover WC since it hits too close to home

Page 27: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Media can’t help you so much

When you go local… Bye-bye tech blogs, reddit, Digg, other apps that announce new things Leaves you with local media

The “pipes” are owned by 1-2 players They’re finally realizing that every web site on the web is competition They’re backwards about linking out

Chicago Tribune wrote story about launch, no backlink in online article Reporters have told me they won’t cover WC since it hits too close to home

Limited news budget for techie stuff

Page 28: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Media can’t help you so much

When you go local… Bye-bye tech blogs, reddit, Digg, other apps that announce new things Leaves you with local media

The “pipes” are owned by 1-2 players They’re finally realizing that every web site on the web is competition They’re backwards about linking out

Chicago Tribune wrote story about launch, no backlink in online article Reporters have told me they won’t cover WC since it hits too close to home

Limited news budget for techie stuff Local blogs

Still too small for any 1-2 to be able to help you much

Page 29: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

What’s worked

Giving users ways to connect with each other

Page 30: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

What’s worked

Giving users ways to connect with each other Monthly meetups Focusing on making social activity easy

More important to improve commenting system than our posting process

Page 31: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

What’s worked

Giving users ways to connect with each other Monthly meetups Focusing on making social activity easy

More important to improve commenting system than our posting process Partnerships with fish too small for big fishermen

CBS2 Widget Buttons on prominent local blogs, news org sites

Page 32: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

What’s worked

Giving users ways to connect with each other Monthly meetups Focusing on making social activity easy

More important to improve commenting system than our posting process Partnerships with fish too small for big fishermen

CBS2 Widget Buttons on prominent local blogs, news org sites

Face to face meetings with users Easier to sell a vision over beer and burgers

Page 33: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

What’s worked

Giving users ways to connect with each other Monthly meetups Focusing on making social activity easy

More important to improve commenting system than our posting process Partnerships with fish too small for big fishermen

CBS2 Widget Buttons on prominent local blogs, news org sites

Face to face meetings with users Easier to sell a vision over beer and burgers

Syncing into social media Mainstream media “owns” Digg, trying to do same with Twitter, not there yet Successes:

Twitter/Facebook alerts for stories that get voted up/down Publish once on WC, push to Facebook/Twitter

Page 34: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

What’s worked

Giving users ways to connect with each other Monthly meetups Focusing on making social activity easy

More important to improve commenting system than our posting process Partnerships with fish too small for big fishermen

CBS2 Widget Buttons on prominent local blogs, news org sites

Face to face meetings with users Easier to sell a vision over beer and burgers

Syncing into social media Mainstream media “owns” Digg, trying to do same with Twitter, not there yet Successes:

Twitter/Facebook alerts for stories that get voted up/down Publish once on WC, push to Facebook/Twitter

E-mail strategy Newspapers don’t own inboxes, product can get a fair shake Thrillist, Daily Candy, Groupon have build large business just on e-mail products

Page 35: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Fin.

The local web is virgin territory still waiting to be claimed

Page 36: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Fin.

The local web is virgin territory still waiting to be claimed Though substantial, the territory is smaller than it looks

Page 37: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Fin.

The local web is virgin territory still waiting to be claimed Though substantial, the territory is smaller than it looks Current media conditions make it harder to get known

Page 38: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Fin.

The local web is virgin territory still waiting to be claimed Though substantial, the territory is smaller than it looks Existing media conditions make it difficult to get a foothold If your product has a local focus or angle, events, social media, and e-mail will do more for you than mainstream local media coverage

Page 39: Using Social Media to Activate Local Communities

CONFIDENTIAL

Fin.

The local web is virgin territory still waiting to be claimed Though substantial, the territory is smaller than it looks Existing media conditions make it difficult to get a foothold If your product has a local focus or angle, events, social media, and e-mail will do more for you than mainstream local media coverage

Questions?