uv nov2014 specialfeature

10
THE INDEPENDENT STUDENT NEWSPAPER OF THE UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO FACULTY OF LAW NOVEMBER 26 2014 | ULTRAVIRES.CA 35 % of students said their financial situation (i.e. debt load) influenced which employer they chose to apply to 62 % of students who applied to at least one job got an offer 66 % of students were satisfied with the outcome of the process Toronto Fall Recruitment Special 2014 RELIEVED I honestly found the process much less cutthroat than I was led to believe Like a weight has been taken off my shoulders Exhausted and dazed, but could not be happier Relieved that it's over and couldn't be more excited to have a job with the firm I'm going to summer at... I got what I wanted Excited to get started Exhausted Glad it is over and looking forward to never having to go through it again Not sure where it all went wrong Disappointed with TO approach. It felt very artificial, rushed, manipulative —like terrible speed-dating. New York just felt like... job interviews. It's not the end of the world, but it is rather dispiriting Drained and slightly bitter Unhappy

Upload: ultravires2

Post on 18-Jul-2016

783 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Toronto 2L OCI Recruitment Special

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: UV Nov2014 SpecialFeature

THE INDEPENDENT STUDENT NEWSPAPER OF THE UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO FACULTY OF LAW

NOVEMBER 26 2014 | ULTRAVIRES.CA

35%of students said their

financial situation (i.e. debt load) influenced

which employer they chose to apply to

62%of students

who applied to at least one job

got an offer

66%of students were

satisfied with the outcome

of the process

Toronto Fall Recruitment Special 2014

RELIEVEDI honestly found the process much less cutthroat than I was led to believe

Like a weight has been taken off my shoulders

Exhausted and dazed, but could not be happier

Relieved that it's over and couldn't be more excited to have a job with the firm I'm going to summer at... I got what I wanted

Excited to get started

Exhausted

Glad it is over and looking forward to never having to go through it again

Not sure where it all went wrong

Disappointed with TO approach. It felt very artificial, rushed, manipulative

—like terrible speed-dating. New York just felt like... job interviews.

It's not the end of the world, but it is rather dispiriting

Drained and slightly bitter

Unhappy

Page 2: UV Nov2014 SpecialFeature

ultravires.ca2 | NOVEMBER 26, 2014 SPECIAL FEATURE

Job Distribution by Firm and SchoolFIRM TOTAL

STUDENTSU OF T OSGOODE WESTERN QUEENS OTTAWA MCGILL WINDSOR DALHOUSIE OTHER

Aird & Berlis 8 2 2 1 2 1

Baker & McKenzie 4 1 1 1 1

Bennett Jones LLP 13 4 2 3 1 1 2

Bereskin & Parr 3 2 1

Blake, Cassels & Graydon, LLP 32 13 8 1 1 1 4 2 2

Blaney McMurtry LLP 7 2 2 1 1 1

Borden Ladner Gervais LLP 20 6 4 2 2 3 2 1

Brauti Thorning Zibarras LLP 2 1 1

Cassels Brock & Blackwell LLP 12 2 3 1 2 2 2

Dale & Lessmann LLP 1 1

Davies Ward Phillips & Vineberg LLP 17 3 5 4 1 1 1 1 1

Davis LLP 4 1 1 1 1

Dentons LLP 12 4 1 2 2 1 1 1

Dickinson Wright LLP 2 1 1

Dimock Stratton LLP 2 2

Edward H. Royle and Associates 2 2

Fasken Martineau DuMoulin LLP 12 2 1 2 1 1 2 3

Filion Wakely Thorup Angeletti LLP 4 1 1 1 1

Fogler, Rubinoff LLP 6 1 2 2 1

Gardiner Roberts LLP 3 1 1 1

Gilbert's LLP 1 1

Goodmans LLP 14 5 4 2 2 1

Gowling Lafleur Henderson LLP 15 2 4 3 1 2 2 1

Hicks Morley Hamilton Stewart Storie LLP

5 1 3 1

Koskie Minsky LLP 4 2 1 1

Legal Aid Ontario 21 3 1 2 1 2 3 2 7

Lenczner Slaght Royce Smith Griffin LLP

4 1 1 1 1

McCarthy Tetrault LLP 23 4 4 4 4 0 2 2 1 1

McMillan LLP 12 3 1 3 1 3 1

Miller Thomson LLP 9 5 1 1 1 1

Ministry of The Attorney General —Crown Law Office—Criminal (Toronto, ON)

7 4 1 1 1

Ministry of the Attorney General —Family Responsibility Office

3 1 1 1

Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP 19 5 2 4 2 1 1 1 1 2

Osler, Hoskin & Harcourt LLP 25 8 6 3 1 2 5

Paliare Roland Rosenberg Rothstein LLP

3 2 1

Reisler Franklin 5 1 1 3

Rueter Scargall Bennett LLP 1 1

Shearman & Sterling LLP 1 1

Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP

3 1 1 1

Smart & Biggar 2 1 1

Stikeman Elliott LLP 24 8 4 1 5 2 2 2

Thorsteinssons LLP—Tax Lawyers 0

Torkin Manes, LLP 3 1 1 1

Torys LLP 19 5 5 4 3 1 1

WeirFoulds LLP 6 1 2 1 1 1

Wildeboer Dellelce LLP 4 1 1 1 1

TOTAL 399 97 83 48 46 35 27 26 15 21

Approx class size (based on 2013 OLSAS/LSAC first year registrants)

1135 (Ontario)

194 306 176 173 390 174 228 170 7171

Approx % of Class with Toronto Fall Recruitment jobs

50.00% 27.12% 27.27% 26.59% 8.97% 15.52% 11.40% 8.82% 2.79%

2013 total 351 94 75 44 43 30 13 23 13 16

2012 total 379 89 89 43 43 39 18 28 14 16

2011 total 403 96 83 53 47 36 27 27 18 16

2010 total 444 104 99 55 43 44 25 44 15 15

Gruber
*
Gruber
Gruber
Gruber
* Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP hired one 2L student from U of T through its Toronto office. The other two students were hired through the firm's New York office, and will be splitting their summers between the two locations.
Gruber
Gruber
Gruber
Page 3: UV Nov2014 SpecialFeature

ultravires.ca NOVEMBER 26, 2014 | 3SPECIAL FEATURE

Seven Sisters Stats

Last year’s cover!

Firms with biggest changes in summer students numbers (keep in mind these firms will likely be participating in the 1L recruit this year):

Osler: 17 25 = 47% increase Stikes: 18 24 = 33% increase Davies: 13 17 = 30% increase Cassels: 17 12 = 29% decrease Blakes: 37 32 = 13.5% decrease

39% of total students hired are at Seven Sisters (131)

30% of students hired at Seven Sisters are from U of T (46)

13 STUDENTS

40% OF HIRES

BLAKES

STIKES

8 STUDENTS33% OF HIRES

OSLER

8 STUDENTS32% OF HIRES

Firm with highest number

of U of T students hired

Big change needed

!"#$%"&$'#(")**("%$"+,--*)"%$".,/*"%+01"-2$34*11".$2*" 0)4#'105*",)(",44*1106#*7" 82$."6$%+"*.-#$9*21",)("%+*"#,&"14+$$#:"!"60;"%,1/7"9*1<6'%"%+*"4$)5*21,%0$)")**(1"%$"+,--*):"

Look out for #1

%+$';+%"&$'#(")*5*2"6*"0)%*2*1%*("0)"9$'"4$'#("

)$%"4,##"$)"4,##"(,9:"=)"%+*"*)(7"-'%"9$'2"0)%*23*1%1",6$5*",##"*#1*",)("($"&+,%*5*2"9$'"%+0)/"01"

Feelings

=>."+,--9"="(0("0%:"=>."+,--9"&0%+"%+*"$'%4$.*:"=>." +,--9" 0%>1" $5*2:" ?'%" =" +,5*" )*5*2" +,(" 1$".,)9"-*$-#*".0)(8'4/".*"6*8$2*"0)".9"#08*:

=%" &,1" ,)" $5*2&+*#.0);" -2$4*11:" =" )*5*2" (0("4297"6'%",%"@ABC-."&+*)"="&,1"($)*"&0%+"0)%*23

8**#0);" &+*2*" =" &,1" 4$.-#*%*#9" $5*2&+*#.*(",)("1'((*)#9"8*#%" %+*")**("%$"4'2#"'-"0)%$"%+*"8*%,#"-$10%0$)",)("429:

=>." %02*(:" !)(" 2,%+*2" 82'1%2,%*(:" ?'%".$1%#9"%02*(:"="($)>%"/)$&"&+*%+*2"%$"#$$/"8$2&,2("%$"$2"(2*,(" %+*".$')%,0)"$8" 14+$$#&$2/" ="+,5*"%$"($"0)"%+*")*D%"E"&**/1:"F)"%+*"-#'1"10(*7"0%"01" 14+$$#&$2/7",)("="/)$&"+$&"%$"($"14+$$#3&$2/7"')#0/*"0)%*250*&1:"F)"%+*"$%+*2"+,)(7"0%"01"5*29".$')%,0)$'1:"

Overall advice

="2*.*.6*2"2*,(0);"%+*"!"#$%&'($)*&1-*40,#"*(03%0$)"$)"FG=1"#,1%"9*,2",)("8**#0);"4$)8'1*(7"$'%3$83%+*3#$$-7",)(","60%"(01.01105*",6$'%"%+*"&+$#*"

!)("&+9",2*"%+*"HI1"1$"1%2*11*(",6$'%","1'.3

9$'"6$';+%"0)%$"0%"0)"%+*"*)("(*1-0%*"9$'2"-$$+3-$$+1:"J+*"4$.-*%0%0$)"01"%$';+7",)("+,50);","

3

)$%" %+*" $)#9" &,9" $8" 1*4'20);" ," -$10%0$):" !)("%+*"-$10%0$)"9$'",4%',##9"&,)%".,9")$%"*5*)"6*"

0)%$"&+,%" 9$'"&,)%" %$" ;*%" $'%" $8" %+01" -2$4*117",)("6*"1'2*")$%"%$"%2*,%"0%",1","60;"1,8*%9")*%"6*3

K0;'2*"9$'21*#8"$'%:"L$"82$."%+*2*:"

WHAT ELSE WOULD YOU LIKE TO TELL US

Page 4: UV Nov2014 SpecialFeature

ultravires.ca4 | NOVEMBER 26, 2014 SPECIAL FEATURE

SIGNIFICANT HELPFUL FACTORS

3

('*" %$" 2,)($." 4+,)4*:"J+*9" ,2*" #01%*(" 0)" (*3

?*0);","MNOP?!"1%'(*)%

SIGNIFICANT HARMFUL FACTORS

DUBIOUS HARMFUL FACTORS

J+01"8,4%$2"01"+0;+#9"4$22*#,%*("&0%+"6$%+"+,50);"

3

$'%"0%1"')0Q'*"2$#*"0)"%+01"1%'(9:

INSIGNIFICANT FACTORS

33

?*0);",4%05*"$)"K,4*6$$/

What Helps You Get an Offer? We delved into the survey results to determine what factors had a significant effect on the probability of getting a job offer. Here we present to you factors that seem to be significantly helpful, factors that are significantly harmful, dubiously harmful, and then, those factors that just plainly don’t do anything.

100%of JD/MBA

respondents who applied

got a job (5/5)

76%of students with offers

had some kind of contact with the

employer before the recruitment process

even started

Firms v

Government

Of the students who applied to firm jobs, over

56%

received and accepted an offer

Of the students who applied to

government jobs, over

33%

received and accepted an offer

Page 5: UV Nov2014 SpecialFeature

ultravires.ca NOVEMBER 26, 2014 | 5

80%of those with

4+ Hs participating in the process got an offer

62%of U of T students

who applied to at least one OCI

job got an offer

75%of those with

4+ HHs participating in the process got an offer

49%of those with

4+ Ps participating in the process got an offer

43%of those with any LPs participating

in the process got an offer

49%of those with

0 HHs participating in the process got an offer

Do grades matter?*

*These are hard categories. I.e. Neither the 4+ HHs category nor 4+ Hs would include someone with 3 Hs and 3HHs.

SPECIAL FEATURE

“The evils the law society rules were intended to correct have simply morphed

into something more insidious. The process is dominated by nudges and code

words. The impossibility of clear expression and the tight time-frame of in-firms

make for a very harrowing and opaque process.”

“Indirect pressure to get a sense of my intentions (ex: consistently asking me at a

reception ‘is there anything else you need to know to make your decision’). As a

result I felt a lot of pressure to explicitly say they were my first choice, especially

after hearing horror stories about students not getting a job without saying those

magic words.”

“If someone tells you a firm really

cares about hearing "first choice", be-

lieve them. I heard this about one of

my top choices, but they seemed so

nice that I thought it wasn't necessary

if I expressed enough interest. Totally

not true. A friend was interviewing at

the same firm and she used a lot more

language very similar to first choice

and they called her mid-afternoon

Wednesday to confirm that they were

her first choice. She eventually caved

and told them they were her first choice, but I have no doubt that if she had not,

there would have been no offer. At the end of the day, they completely lead you

on and don't feel bad about it at all if you don't tell them they're your first choice.”

For goodness' sake, tell a firm they're your #1—they may still not give you an offer

but reading between the lines after speaking with the student directors, I know of

at least 2 firms who quite simply took me out of the running because I didn't tell

them I loved them.

Look out for number one. Tell every firm they are your top choice. I didn't and it

hurt me in the short term, but probably the right choice in the long term.

Page 6: UV Nov2014 SpecialFeature

ultravires.ca6 | NOVEMBER 26, 2014

F5*2"+,#8"%+*"4#,11"&0##";2,(',%*"&0%+","

*D-*4%" %$" ;2,(',%*" &0%+" (*6%" 6*%&**)"

SPECIAL FEATURE

Class Profile

R"$8"J"FG="-,2%040-,)%1",2*";*)*2,##9"Q'0%*"I06*2,#A

Page 7: UV Nov2014 SpecialFeature

ultravires.ca NOVEMBER 26, 2014 | 7

I didn’t want to end up on Bay Street

!"#$%#$&'()*&+),-).#')/0)(.1)&**)&.1)2()&**3)45&')67/).#')'5()'0%()#8)%($-#.)'5&')+&.'-)'#)+#$9),.-&.()5#:$-)&.1)+((9(.1-3)45&')6)5&;()&)-'$#.<)-#=,&*)>:-',=()#$,(.'&',#.?

!6)1#.7')%*&.)#.)-',=9,.<)&$#:.1)@&0)

!A#+)*,''*()6):.1($-'##1)=#$%#$&'()*&+3?

!67/)=#.=($.(1)&2#:')'5()*#.<)5#:$-)67**)

'##)&8$&,1)'#)&-9)&2#:')+#$9B*,8()2&*&.=()#$)2,**&2*()5#:$-)8#$)8(&$)'5&')'5(0)+#:*1)&--:/()6)+&-.7')%$(%&$(1)'#)+#$9)5&$13?

!6)5&'()&**)#8)'5(,$)=*,(.'-3?

Personality, i.e. I have one

!6)+&-)(--(.',&**0)2$&,.1(&1)'&*9,.<))'#)'5(/)&')'5(,$)=#=9'&,*)$(=(%',#.3?

"0)%$"*,4+",)("*5*29"$)*"$8".9"0)%*250*&1""

!A#.(-'*0)6)+&-)/#-'*0)>:-')/0-(*8C))+5,=5)%$#2&2*0)5&1)-#/('5,.<))

)/0)D)=#$%#$&'()E"67-3?

Realities

!F0)-#=,#(=#.#/,=)2&=9<$#:.1?

"

),.'($;,(+)G&.1),')+&-)+,'5)'5(/H3))6)5,1)'5&'C)&.1)5&1)'#)1#1<())I:(-',#.-)&2#:')5#+)2:-0))

My heart was in other places

!J**)/0).#.B"$#+.)#%',#.-)+($()2&=9:%-3?

!A#+)/:=5)6)+&.')9,1-3?

WHAT’S SOMETHING YOU DIDN'T WANT YOUR INTERVIEWERS TO KNOW ABOUT YOU

SPECIAL FEATURE

The CDO What you had to say about the CDO

!K&.'&-',=?)

!L(&**0)<$(&'?)

!M#)5(*%8:*)&.1)%&',(.'N?

!O#.1($8:*?

" "" ""!P($8(=')>#23)M#)+(**)%$(%&$(1)&.1)9.#+*(1<(&2*(3?

On the other hand

!45()"QE)1#(-)&)<$(&')>#23)R.8#$':.&'(*0)),'),-),/%#--,2*()8#$)'5(/)'#)9.#+)+5&')(/%*#0($-)&$()*##9,.<)8#$S

"

"

Love letters to Emily Orchard, Director, Career Development Office

!T/,*0)E$=5&$1),-)&)<#13)O#$-5,%)5($3?

""

!T/,*0)&.1)U#$1&.&)&$()-#)<(.($#:-)+,'5)'5(,$)',/()&.1)-:%%#$'3?

!T/,*0)&.1)U#$1&.&)&$()>:-')&/&V,.<3)45(0)&$(),.=$(1,2*0)-:%%#$',;()&.1))

&$(.7')8((*,.<)'5()/#-')*(;(*)5(&1(13?

3#,2#9"8$##$&*("'-"&0%+".*",6$'%"1.,##"%+0);1"

!T/,*0C)U#$1&.&)&.1)J..)+($();($0)&==(--,2*(3?

80%of U of T students found

the CDO to be helpful or very helpful in

preparing them for the recruitment process

76%of students who

participated in the process felt that

theCDO was knowledgeable

DO YOU HAVE ANY COMMENTS ON YOUR CDO’S SERVICES?

Page 8: UV Nov2014 SpecialFeature

ultravires.ca8 | NOVEMBER 26, 2014 SPECIAL FEATURE

The Process

ONE PIECE OF ADVICE FOR NEXT YEAR:

Plan ahead

!68)0#:)+&.')'#)+#$9)#.)@&0)M'$(('C)/&9()0#:$),.'($(-');($0)=*(&$)S)'&9()=#$%#$&'()=#:$-(-),.)W.1)0(&$C)<#))

)'5&')0#:)&$()<(.:,.(*0),.'($(-'(1))

""

Network

)0#:)&$(),.'($(-'(1),.3?

Do your homework

!M%(&9)'#):%%($)0(&$-N)45(0)+($()-#);&*:&2*(),.)<,;,.<)/()',%-)&.1)&1;,=(3?

1'2*"9$'"+,5*","1*#*4%";2$'-"$8"-*$-#*"&+$"+,5*"6**)"%+2$';+"%+01"%+,%"4,)"+*#-"9$'""

Be prepared

!M'&$')(&$*0N)P$(%)'&9(-)*#.<($)'5&.))0#:)'5,.9),')+,**N?

"08"9$'",2*")$%";$0);"8$2"%+*"+9-*24$.-*%0%05*"

Interviewing…

!P$&=',=()'5()&2,*,'0)'#)&.-+($)I:(-',#.-))'5&')&$()&+9+&$13)X(')-#/(#.()'#)&-9)0#:)$&.1#/)I:(-',#.-)'#)'(-')0#:$)&2,*,'0))'#)&.-+($)I:(-',#.-C)=#5($(.'*0)&.1)

""""

"&0##";$"&2$);",%"1$.*"-$0)%A"($)>%"-,)04""

%(#%*()+5#)&$()(Y=,'(1)'#)/((')+,'5)'5(/3?

Scheduling…

!L(=#<.,V()0#:$)*,/,'&',#.-3)68)0#:))8((*)*,9()0#:)&$()#.*0)=#/8#$'&2*())+,'5)1#,.<)Z),.'($;,(+-)1:$,.<))6.'($;,(+)O((9C)1#.7')-=5(1:*()[))>:-')2(=&:-()#'5($)%(#%*()&$()1#,.<))'5()-&/(3)J.1)1#.7')2()&8$&,1)'#))

),8)0#:)&$()8((*,.<)#;($+5(*/(1)\:-()'5&')#%%#$':.,'0)'#)$(B2&,'))

"

""

$8"%+$';+%"0)%$"&+$"9$'",--#9"%$"8$2""

Know what you want

!E.*0)&%%*0)'#)%*&=(-)'5&')0#:)&$())<(.:,.(*0),.'($(-'(1),.)+#$9,.<)&'C))&.1)=#.=(.'$&'()&**)'5(,$)(.($<0))#.)%$(%&$,.<)8#$)'5(-(),.'($;,(+-3?

"+,5*","1&/.)<##1)$(&-#."&+9"9$'"&,)%""

!45,.9)&2#:')+5&')0#:)&=':&**0)+&.')\0#:)1#).#')5&;()'#)<(')-:=9(1),.)&.1)'&9()%&$'),.)'5()%$#=(--),8),'7-).#')+5&')0#:7$()*##9,.<)8#$3?

%+,%"+,--*)1",%"%+*"14+$$#",2$')("8,##""2*42'0%.*)%7",)(",--2$,4+"%+*"-2$4*11""

Play the game

!4&9(),.,',&',;(N)6)1,1.7')<(')&)))

)-#)6)(/&,*(1)'5()-':1(.')1,$(='#$))(Y%$(--,.<)&.),.'($(-')&.1)6))

)

""

,2*"4$..')04,%0);"9$'2"0)%*)%0$)1""0.-#040%#9"69"9$'2"14+*('#0);"$)"%+*""

)(;(.)8#$)'5()2,<)#.(-3)Q#.7')%:')&**))0#:$)(<<-),.)#.()2&-9(')&.1)1#.7'))=#:.')0#:$)(<<-)2(8#$()'5(0)5&'=53?

""

$)*"*.-#$9*2>1"6$$/1",)(","G"4,)(0(,%*""

,2$')(7",)("9$'>##"6*"#,';+0);"4$.*""

!@()-'$&'(<,=3)Q#.7')<,;():%)#%%#$':.,',(-))

)(;($0#.(3)F&9()'5(/)'5,.9)0#:7$()),.'($(-'(13)Q#.7')8((*)2&1)&2#:')2(,.<)

.#')(.',$(*0)-:$()0#:)+&.')'#)+#$93)K,<:$()#:')+5#7-)'5()*#;()#8)0#:$)*,8(C)2:')

Take it in stride

!J==(%')'5&')(;(.),8)0#:)1#)(;($0'5,.<)0#:)=&.C)0#:)-',**)/,<5')=#/():%)-5#$'3)6')+,**)2()5&$1)'#)$(&*,V()&')'5()',/(C)2:')'5,-)-&0-).#'5,.<)&2#:')0#:)&-)&)%($-#.3)45,-),-).#')'5()(.1)#8)'5()+#$*13?) """"

"54%of U of T students

felt prepared for the process

The majority of students who were eligible for OCIs, but didn’t participate, had already obtained a job, either through the 1L recruitment process (14 people), or through the NY recruit (9).

1/4

of students who participated in the

process cried at onepoint in the process

Page 9: UV Nov2014 SpecialFeature

ultravires.ca NOVEMBER 26, 2014 | 9SPECIAL FEATURE

Firm Behaviour and LSUC Compliance

“One smaller boutique firm told me at the end of the interview that I would likely receive an offer, then

called me on Tuesday and basically said I would receive an offer. They didn't pressure me to accept

before the offer period, but did pressure me to respond quickly either way so they could find someone

else, which I thought was fair enough.”

BESIDES LSUC VIOLATIONS, DID YOU OBSERVEANY OTHER INAPPROPRIATE BEHAVIOUR?

!45(0)-9,$'(1)$(&**0)=*#-()'#)'5()(1<()#8);,#*&',.<)]MR")<:,1(*,.(-3)45(0)1,1.7')2$(&9)'5()2$,<5')*(''($)*&+C)2:')671)-&0)'5(0);,#*&'(1)'5()-%,$,')#8)'5#-()*&+-3?

!E.()(/%*#0($)&-9(1)/(),8)6)5&1)-/#9(1))/&$,>:&.&)+5,*()6)+&-),.)J/-'($1&/3?

!6)+&-)8$(I:(.'*0)&-9(1)'#)2()=$,',=&*))#8)/0)-=5##*)&.1)#8)'5()]MR")%$#=(--3?

"

!6)1,1)<(')&-9(1)/:*',%*()',/(-)+5#)(*-()6)+&-)),.'($;,(+,.<)+,'5)G&.1)'5,-),.8#$/&',#.)+&-)).#'(1)1#+.)#.)'5(,$),.'($;,(+).#'(-H3?

WHAT WERE THE MOST INAPPROPRIATE, AWKWARD, OR UNEXPECTED QUESTIONS YOU RECEIVED?

" "" ""!6)5&1)-#/()2:'),')+&-)&)2*:$)&.1)67/)1$:.9)).#+)-#)6)=&.7')$(/(/2($3?

Inappropriate

!A#+)#*1)&$()0#:^?

_TY%*&,.)5#+)`)+50)0#:)&$()&)8(/,.,-'^_)

"="2*-#0*(A">G,),(,>:"J+01"(0(")$%"1**."%$"6*",";$$("*)$';+""

Awkward

!Q#)0#:)5&;()&)*#')#8)8$,(.1-^?

"

_F#-')%(#%*()5,')a])#:')#8)'5()%&$9)&.1)'5&')1,1.7'))5&%%(.)8#$)0#:3)O50^?

""

!6)+&-)&-9(1),8)6)5&1)&.0)I:(-',#.-\&.1)6)=#:*1))'(**),')+&-)'#)&-9)&2#:')'5()1,;($-,'0)%#*,=03)6)/(&.)),')+&-).,=()'#)'&*9)&2#:'C)&.1)+&-),/%#$'&.')'#)/(C))2:'),')1,1)%:')/()#.)'5()-%#')'#)=#/()#:')&-)<&03?

Unexpected

!O5&')/#$()=&.)6)'(**)0#:)'#)5(*%)0#:)/&9()&)1(=,-,#.^?

!O5&')1#)0#:)/#-')1,-*,9(),.)&)%($-#.^?

!O5&')&$()'5$(()'5,.<-)&2#:')0#:)6)+,**)#.*0)*(&$.))&8'($)+#$9,.<)+,'5)0#:)8#$)&)0(&$^?

IF YOU WITNESSED ANY LSUC VIOLATIONS, PLEASE DESCRIBE:

9 students reported offers communicated prior to 5pm on Wednesday

8 students reported indirect or borderline rule-breaking

7 students reported that they were asked where the firm stands

6 felt aggressively pressured to indicate where else they were interviewing

5 felt pressure to commit prior to offer day

3 told that students who did not say “first choice” would not be considered for offers

23%of U of T students

witnessed employersbreaking LSUC rules

Page 10: UV Nov2014 SpecialFeature

ultravires.ca10 | NOVEMBER 26, 2014 SPECIAL FEATURE

Other: 10/262 = 4%

“Prestige”

“Debt”

“I really need money to help pay off school”

“I want to pay off my interest- accumulating student debts”

“Wanted to have a job lined up for articling”

“I wanted the prestige and income that comes with a Toronto firm job.”

“Make money”

What Would You Change About the Process?!T;($0'5,.<3?

,)(")$)*"$8"%+01".*110);",2$')("&0%+"2*;,2("%$"%290);"%$"(*%*2.0)*""

1'..*2",)(",2%04#0);7"1$"%+*9"+,5*"%$"6*"4,2*8'#:"J+*9",2*")$%"

"

!"5&.<()=&**B1&0),.'#)&.)&:'#/&'(1)#.*,.()-0-'(/3?

!T;($0'5,.<3)Q#),')*,9())b(+)c#$93)J.1)1#)),')#;($)'5()-://($3?

Rolling Offers

!T/%*#0($-)-5#:*1)))

2(8#$()O(1.(-1&0)&')d3?)

"="/*-%",1"6,4/"'-"6*4,'1*".9"%$-"4+$04*"4$'#("$)#9"+0)%",)("")$%"%*##".*"8$2"1'2*:"="&$'#("+,5*"-2*8*22*("%$"+,5*")$%"+,(""

)45()+&,'),-)'##)%&,.8:*3?

Less “signaling”" "

) ) ) !6'7-)$(&**0)5&$1)5&;,.<))) ) ) '#)-,<.&*),.'($(-'),.))

)) ) ) >:-')#.()#$)'+#),.'($;,(+-3))) ) ) 6)+,-5)'5($()+&-)(,'5($))

)) ) ) +($()-(.')#:'),.)-#/())

Maybe it’s the only way?

S*29"#0%%#*:"J+*2*",2*"#$%1"$8"%*2206#*"%+0);1",6$'%"0%7"6'%"-*$-#*"2,2*#9"4$)10(*2"&+,%"%+*",#%*2),%05*1"&$'#("#$$/"#0/*:"J+*"&$2#("&0%+$'%"%+01"-2$4*11"&$'#(",4%',##9"6*".$2*"*D-#$0%,%05*",)("')3-#*,1,)%"8$2"1%'(*)%1:"J+01"01"1+0%%97"6'%"0%"01"0)+*2*)%"0)"%+*"0)*Q',#3

,6$'%"0%7"%+01"191%*."01",6$'%",1"4#$1*",1"9$'"4,)"4$.*"%$"8,02:

Slow it down

!A&;()&)/&.1&'#$0)We)5#:$)%($,#1)2('+((.)+5(.)

-':1(.'7-)&).,<5')#8)$(-')'#)'5,.9)'5$#:<5)+5&')'5(0)+&.'),.-'(&1)#8)2:**0,.<)'5(/),.'#)/&9,.<)&)1(=,-,#.)+,'5,.)&)/&''($)#8)5#:$-3?

"

And of course

!f,**)&**)'5()*&+0($-3)B)@,**)M5&9(-%(&$(3?

44%of students were

surprised by the offersthey got/didn't get based on how theyfelt interviews went