view the presentation
TRANSCRIPT
The Next Generation of Global Tax Management
The Chicago Tax Club – 55th Annual Fall SeminarNovember 19, 2008
2
The Complexity of the Global Tax Environment
Globalization & velocity of business
Increasingly complex transactions and organizational structures
Heightened demand for accuracy
Increased enforcement by taxing jurisdictions and regulatory bodies
Drive toward currency
Current and forecasted shortages of qualified personnel
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
3
Total Tax Function Risk Defined
TTFR = (FR + OR + TTR) IR
TTFR = Total Tax Function Risk
FR = Finance Risk
OR = Operational Risk = Process Risk + Knowledge Risk + Technology Risk
TTR = Tax Technical Risk
IR = Integration RiskCopyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
4
Total Tax Function Risk Defined (cont’d)
Finance Risk: The quality and accuracy of data from accounting in accordance with existing financial reporting standards
Process Risk: The failure points in existing processes
Knowledge Risk: The risk of the loss of business intelligence and human error
Technology Risk: Improper or poor utilization of technology
Tax Technical Risk: The risk of misinterpreting or incorrectly applying tax statutes, regulations, case law, and financial reporting standards
Integration Risk: The failure to properly link and manage the flow of information
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
5
The Next Generation of Global Tax Management
One Company’
s Story
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
6
Company Profile
Publicly traded manufacturer based in the United States
Annual revenues in excess of $3 billion with sales in 50 states and Canada
Locations in 20 states and Canada
Legal entity structure comprises 50 entities
Oracle Financial based on management reporting
Tax Function Resources– Four full time professionals– One contractor– One intern
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
7
Tax Function Current State
Significant Reliance on Excel
– All tax processes: Income tax reporting and compliance, sales and use tax, and property tax are spreadsheet based
– Spreadsheets are stored on network drive
– Password protected files utilized
Document Retention
– Binders and hard copy files
Workflow tool
Status Reporting
– Email and meetings
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
8
Tax Function Current State (cont’d)
Tax Reporting– In excess of 200 spreadsheets to develop
provision– Not scalable for acquisitions– No linkage to financial reporting systems– Manual process prone to error
Tax Planning and Analytics– Spreadsheet based and relatively
inflexible for modeling– Inability to view the business in the same
manner as the rest of operations– Not much time for analysis
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
9
Tax Function Current State (cont’d)
Tax Compliance Functions– Income Tax Compliance
• In Source Express• Only trial balance imported, all other
data manually entered• Significant tax calculations performed
in hundreds of spreadsheets– Sales and Use Tax
• Manual processes - spreadsheets for completing sales tax returns
• Taxability of purchases made by AP clerk, no automated tax decisions
• Exemption certificates kept in a file cabinet by customer service, no review by tax
• Tax rates updated manually, no defined process
– Property Tax• Spreadsheet based and manual
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
10
Tax Function Change Agent
Significant consulting fees in prior year end close to prepare and review tax reporting as a result of errors in spreadsheets
Planned acquisition that would result in doubling in size of the organization
Existing process would not scale to handle additional complexity associated with recent acquisitions
Movement by external auditors toward eliminating reliance on spreadsheets for analytics and calculations
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
11
Tax Function Identified Risks
Data flow risks
– General ledger and trial balance not maintained at the legal entity level
– Legal entity data from accounting reports are poorly understood and lacked transparency back to the general ledger and trial balance
– Top-side entries that are not pushed down to the legal entities
– Poor controls related to reconciliations and Oracle queries
– Over 600 spreadsheets in use manipulating data
– Redundant data and processes with the same data cut and pasted from other spreadsheets
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
12
Tax Function Identified Risks (cont’d)
Data flow risks
− Each tax function process ran own reports from Oracle resulting in data inconsistencies
– Examples:• Apportionment for provision not the
same as for compliance or FIN 48• Sales by state from sales tax reporting
different than apportionment• Wages by state from employment tax
reporting different than apportionment– Data moved from spreadsheet to
spreadsheet via cut and paste resulting in multiple versions of the truth
– Updated data not necessarily carried through all spreadsheets
– Both data and calculations stored on spreadsheet resulting in the inability to lock down data during reviewCopyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
13
Tax Function Identified Risks (cont’d)
Workflow Risks– No Work flow management in place– Coordination dependent on meetings
and emails between the tax professionals
– Lack of transparency of work progress resulted in deadline driven work flow
– Management could not easily tell what capacity existed for special projects
– Tasks transferred via email resulting in multiple versions of the same document and version control issues
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
14
Tax Function Identified Risks (cont’d)
Process Risks – Process documentation nonexistent or
dated– Critical institutional knowledge known
only to key personnel, not documented– Controls established for only SOX
relevant sub-processes– No milestones or signoffs other than on
end product– No process for periodic review of
calculations and data sources (SALY)– No retention of accounting data at the
time of compliance– Paper binder based document retention
made location difficult, control impossible
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
15
TTFR = (FR + OR + TTR) IR
FR - Finance risk is high due to large amount of data manipulation in Excel. In addition, a high reliance on reports from source systems that were poorly understood by tax and rarely tested.
OR – Operational Risk extremely high.
– Reliance on a single tax professional and tax consultants presents an exposure to personnel shortage and turnover problems.
– Lack of visibility of entire process, coupled with difficulty coordinating activities
– Ineffective use of technology resulting highly manual processes prone with error
TTR – High tax technical risk to do lack of planning and analysis. So much spent getting it done, no time to get it right.
IR – High, tax processes ( Provision, State Compliance, Federal Compliance, Audit etc) treated as disconnected “waterfall” activitiesCopyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
16
The Next Generation Solution
Process and technology changes occur in tandem and iteratively
Processes and technology changes include all stakeholders; vendors, outside consultants and client
All vendors and stakeholders work in a coordinated and cooperative effort:– Single vision– Single set of requirements– Single project plan– Single success measure– Single methodology
Developed through multiple iterations rather than a single monolithic project
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
17
Tax Function Re-engineering (cont’d)
Implemented a tax portal (cont’d)
– Assignment of tasks to tax professionals• Visibility on progress on tasks• Visibility on capacity of tax department
– Integrated into a single view• Calendar• Tasks• Tools • Documentation
– Provide a single collaboration site for internal stakeholders and outside consultants
– Captured institutional knowledge on processes in work flow
– Reduced training time for new personnel
Single tax calendar– Milestone and tasks associated with all
deliverablesCopyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
18
Tax Function Re-engineering (cont’d)
Implemented OLAP Analytics and Reports
– Separated data from calculations– Calculations are secure and auditable– Reports are standard and provide drill down– Eliminated need to cut and paste data– Provided rapid analytics– Provided integration with compliance tools (In
Source)– Eliminate spreadsheet risk by limiting ability to
alter formulas– Reporting and analytics available across all tax
lifecycles– Complete transparency to source accounting and
tax data – Reduced ramp up time for new personnel by
eliminating the need to understand spreadsheets– Reduced training time by using an intuitive MS
Office interfaceCopyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
20
True Partners Consulting – Project Lead Tax Risk Management & Tax Advisory
Defined Next Generation Solution– Mapped existing state of the tax function
processes
– Identified areas of operational risk, financial risk, tax technical risk, and integration risk
– Determined and validated requirements with key stakeholders with a focus on risk management, increased efficiency, and value to the organization
– Developed the desired state based on best practices and latest technology in order to achieve a fully integrated tax function
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
21
Tax Risk – Process Definition
Mapped existing tax processes:
– Tax Reporting• FAS 109, FIN 48, FAS 5
– Income Tax Compliance• International, federal, and state &
local– Indirect Taxes
• Sales & use, VAT/GST• Exemption certificate management
– Property Taxes– Unclaimed Property– Significant Sub-Processes
• Fixed assets; section 199; apportionment; intercompany transactions; transfer pricing; credits and incentives; earnings & profits; stock basis calculations; purchase accounting
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
22
Tax Risk – Process Definition (cont’d)
Process mapping used to identify:– All source data– Outputs of each step of the process– Process weaknesses– Automation points– Financial and tax technical risk
Interviewed all key stakeholders to develop desired state:– Tax function – Accounting and finance– Internal audit– IT function– Management & operations– External consultants Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
23
Tax Risk – Process Design
Developed risk profile incorporating:– Identified risk– Management’s risk tolerance– Cost benefit analysis– Prioritization of objectives
Re-engineered tax function based on:– Process mapping– Requirements established in stakeholder interview processes– Best practices– Risk profile
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
24
Tax Risk – Tax Function Re-engineered
Execute re-engineering plan– Develop formal plan– Validate with key stakeholders– Identify technology enablers– Work with tax to communicate vision
Provide project management– Planning– Change & scope control– Project tracking and communication– Change management
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
25
Tax Risk – Tax Function Re-engineered (cont’d)
Validation of data & system
results – Data cleansing to ensure quality of data– Provide testing methodology – Expected results testing & reconciliation– Tax technical analysis– Signoff on tax technical results
Manage user acceptance of new process– Change management communication plan– Deployment– Training– Follow-up validation of user acceptanceCopyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
26
Intelysys Project Role – Technology Automation
Built Data Source– Designed & Built Accounting Data Store– Built Import Tool for loading Accounting
Metadata– Built Import Tool for loading Trial Balance, GL, Fixed Asset, Property Tax data from several
excel sheets into Accounting Data Warehouse– Built Tax Data Store– Provided exports for FAS 109 and Fin 48
Systems
Built Web Enabled Tax Portal– Built eFileRoom (embedded electronic data storage)– Built eWorkflow (embedded Project
Management)– Built Tax Issue Tracker– Built Tax Calendar and Integrated with Vertex
Tax Calendar– Integrated Power OLAP within eTaxPortalCopyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
27
Tools for Tax Risk Management and Process Automation
eTaxPortal - Single Point of Entry for all Tax Department related tools. Key Components of eTaxPortal:
– eTaxFileRoom: Tax Document System to Store eTaxWorkflow: Tax Task Management
– eTaxTER - Manage Budget vs. Actual, Time and Expense Reporting
– eTaskManager: Tax Project Tasks, Scheduling and Resource Management
– eLegalEntity: Legal Entity Manager– eTaxCalendar: Filing Dates Tracker by Entity– eTaxWorkPapers: Work Papers
Management Tool
Copyright 2008 – Intelysys ©
28
eTaxPortal - Tax Portal for Today's Tax Department
Embedded Tax Document Repository– Tax data categorization and taxonomy
implementation– Search across projects, documents, tasks,
attachments, messages– Application, Project, Document Access control and
Field Level Security– Access Logs for SOX Compliance
Embedded Tax Project Management– Assignment of tasks to tax professionals – Visibility on progress on tasks and capacity of tax
department
Personalized (Dashboards) for customization
Tax Calendar for tracking filing deadlines & milestones
Centralized communication & messaging
Publish Tax department specific content
Links to internal, external web pages and Tax Tools
Copyright 2008 – Intelysys ©
29
eTaxPortal - Open Architecture for Integration
Integration with Accounting and Tax Data Sources
Integration with Accounting Data Import utility
OLAP Integration for tax reporting and analysis
– Provision, compliance, various tax types – Reports accessible via the eTaxPortal
Outlook Integration
Work Paper Integration
Flexibility to integrate with existing tax technology utilized resulting in a fully integrated system
Copyright 2008 – Intelysys ©
33
Red Moon Solutions – Project Role Implementation & Reporting
OLAP and BI Tools– Eliminate integration risk– Reduce data flow risk by
creating a single source of data– Mitigate operation risk by
providing flexible planning and analysis
– Manage financial risk by providing the view of the data from tax to accounting
– Control tax technical risk by separating the calculations from data
SAP Expertise
Experience with tax, OLAP and BI toolCopyright 2008 – Red Moon Solutions ©
34
What is Business Intelligence & OLAP?Business Intelligence (BI)
Programs and technologies for gathering, storing, analyzing and providing access to data to help enterprise users make better business decisions
- Web definition
On-Line Analytical Processing (OLAP)
Provides ability to retrieve and analyze multi-dimensional, summarized views of business data to reveal business trends and statistics not directly visible in data directly retrieved from a relational database.
- Web definition
Copyright 2008 – Red Moon Solutions ©
35
Multi-dimensionality
entity
ass
et c
lass
location
entity
ass
et c
lass
actual/forecast
location
period
account
entity
Copyright 2008 – Red Moon Solutions ©
43
The Next Generation of Global Tax Management
TTFR = (FR + OR + TTR) IR
By looking at tax risk in a holistic manner incorporating all components driving risk for a tax function, the next level of tax risk management can be achieved
It is the proper alignment of people, process, technology within the tax function effectively integrated with all business processes that will allow an organization to achieve the next generation of global tax management
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
44
Today’s Presenters
Andrea Gronenthal
Managing Director – True Partners Consulting LLC
Chicago, IL
Telephone – 312-835-1184
Joseph Ochoa
Senior Manager – True Partners Consulting LLC
Chicago, IL
Telephone – 813-447-9421
Copyright 2008 – True Partners Consulting, LLC ©
Khaja Syed
President – Intelysys, Inc.
Ashburn, VA
Telephone – 703-939-0084
Kelley Lear
Managing Director – Red Moon Solutions, Inc.
Sarasota, FL
Telephone – 941-379-7108
45
Tax Advice Notice
We are required by regulation to inform you that any tax advice contained in this communication (or in any attachment) is not intended or written to be used, and cannot be used by any taxpayer, for the purpose of: (i) avoiding U.S. federal, state, or local tax penalties or (ii) promoting, marketing, or recommending to another party any transaction or matter addressed in this communication (or any attachment).