vigiar e punir – história da (michel foucault) cristina tereza gaulia

R. EMERJ, Rio de Janeiro, v. 16, n. 62, p. 37 - 64, abr. - set. 2013 37

Vigiar e Punir Histria da !"#$%&!'(%')(*+!),-)(

(Michel Foucault)

CRISTINA TEREZA GAULIA !"#$%&!'!()(*+,%+&!-'!

./01234562(7(8*19:9/08562(38(2;18

!" #$%&'()* Surveiller et Punir: Naissance de la prison, Vigiar e Punir* +,-./'%01 1$/2/&%."3&43 3" 5678* 9 ," 3)4,01 '/3&:;'1 &1


V W%+I XXF MZ Y)43&4%@A1 01) U,+.G'/1)O

T /0(1!&%). S,&/@A1

V W%+I XF MS,&/@A1 [3&3$%./P%0%O

VW%+I XXF M\/B2%@A1 0%) S3&%)O

T 20(1!&%). Disciplina

V W%+I XF MW1$+1) R?'3/)O

V W%+I XXF MY) ]3',$)1) +%$% 1 ^1" Z03)4$%"3&41O

V W%+I XXXF MS%&1+B)"1O

T 30(1!&%). MS$/)A1O

V W%+I XF MX&)B4,/@H3) W1"+.34%) 3 Z,)43$%)O

V W%+I XXF MX.32%./0%03 3 R3./&1 FOUCAULT, Michel. Vigiar e Punir. dde 30I* S34$?+1./)F !0I a1P3)* fgg5* +I 55I


Z +$/"3/$% 2$%&03 ",0%&@% &1 '%"+1 +3&%. 9* )3" 0bC/0%* 1 03)%-+%$3'/"3&41 01) ),+.G'/1) h)/'1)* 01 '1$+1 "%$'%01* 01 3)+34D',.1 '(&/-'1 3" +$%@% +b-./'%* '1"1 ," 2$%&03 43%4$1I

I+(C6('+($E:,8+(JKLLL()(:+6)=+('+(JLJA(!(')$5)#%+(')(!8",-6!$("&!-')$(G+",)#&!$A(!(6)8!-:M8#:!(G)$%!(')(5,-#=>+(N!#O$)()7;-",#-'+?/

iD &3))% 4$%&)#1$"%@A1 01/) +$1'3))1) 03 /&43$3))3* 1 +$/"3/$1

)3&01 % ),+$3))A1 01 3)+34D',.1 +,&/BC1 +(%+:!&(6!#$(-+(:+&5+A(+,(+(69-#6+(5+$$9N)8A()(5!&!(!;-"#&(-)8)(!8"+(B,)(->+(E(+(:+&5+(5&+5!6)-%)(P???Q(!(5$>+A(!(&):8,$>+A(+$(%&!-D!8S+$( G+&=!'+$A( !( $)&N#'>+( ')( G+&=!'+$A( P???Q( !( ')5+&%!=>+(P???Q($>+(5)-!$(T$#:!$(P???Q( !$(!(&)8!=>+(:!$;"+O:+&5+(->+(E(#'U-;:!(!+(B,)()8!()&!(-!(E5+:!('+$($,589:#+$?2

Y )32,&01 +$1'3))1 03 4$%&)#1$"%@A1 9 1 0% /"+1)/@A1 0% +,&/@A1I

j%&41 01 +1&41 03 C/)4% 03 ),% &%4,$3P% +30%2?2/'%* '1"1 01 +1&-41 03 C/)4% 03 +('+(6!8A()(8#D)&%!(+$(6!-"#$%&!'+$('+(N#8(+T:#+(')(:!$;"!'+&)$?3

2 LD#')6, p. 12.

3 (LD#')6, p. 14.

4 (LD#')6, p. 13.


Z) +3&%) 03 "1$43* 1&03 1'1$$3"* %+3$#3/@1%" 3))3) '$/49$/1)F ),-+$3))A1 01 3)+34D',.1* %&,.%@A1 0% 01$I

4+($)(!5&+7#6!&(+(6+6)-%+('!()7):,=>+A(!58#:!6O$)(!+$(5!-:#)-%)$(#-W)=\)$(')(%&!-B,#8#i1,C3 % $30,@A1 0%) M"/. "1$43)O )1#$/0%) +3.1) ),+./'/%01) E 3)4$/-4% 3_3',@A1 '%+/4%. 3" 1B&%F Mk,%)3 )3" 41'%$ 1 '1$+1* % 2,/.>1B&% ),+$/"3 % C/0%*

tal como a priso suprime a liberdade, ou uma multa suprime os bens6.

S1$9"* 9 ," +$1'3))1 03 ",0%&@% .3&41 3 2$%0,%.* '1" 0/#3$3&43)

$3#3$3&'/%/)* 03 %'1$01 '1" % 9B'% +3&%. 03 '%0% +%G) 3 '1" %C%&@1) 3 $3-4$1'3))1)I U,-./&>3J)3


V(!G&+,7!6)-%+('!($)N)'!')(5)-!8(-+('):+&&)&('+$(^8;6+$($E:,8+$(E(,6(G)-h6)-+(D)6(:+-S):#'+(P???Q

@-%&)%!-%+A( G+#(N#$%+A(',&!-%)(6,#%+(%)65+A(')( G+&6!(")&!8A(:+6+( ( $)( G+$$)( G)-h6)-+( B,!-;%!;N+.(6)-+$( $+G)-%+A(6!#$($,!N#'!')A(6!#$(&)$5)#%+()(ZS,6!-#'!')[?

i)(->+(E(6!#$(!+(:+&5+(!(B,)($)('#")(!(5,-#=>+A()6($,!$(G+&6!$(6!#$(',&!$A($+D&)(+(B,)A()-%>+A($)()7)&:)j(4(&)$5+$%!('+$(%)M:+$(k('!B,)8)$(B,)(!D&!6A(5+&(N+8%!(')(_`cbA(+(5)&9+'+(B,)(!#-'!(->+($)()-:)&&+,(k(E($#658)$A(B,!$)()N#-')-%)?( *#&O$)O#!( #-$:%!( -!( 5&M5!( #-'!"!=>+?( 1+#$( ->+( E(6!#$(+(:+&5+A(E(!(!86!?(l()75#!=>+(B,)(%,'#!($+D&)(+(:+&5+(')N)($,:)')&(,6(:!$;"+(B,)(!%,)A(5&+G,-'!6)-%)A($+D&)(+(:+&!=>+A(+(#-%)8):%+A(!(N+-%!')A(!$('#$5+$#=\)$?8

=1,'%,.4 ),)43&4% /3$%$


flL Z \10/;'%@A1 01 MY-N341 W$/"3O n Z Z43&@A1 %1 W$/"/&1)1

4(&)8!;N!()$%!D#8#'!')('!( 8)#(+D"+,(,6( W+"+(')($,D$;%,#-=\)$($,;$()(&R5#'!$?(i+D(+(-+6)(')(:)$()(')8#%+$A($>+($)6-5&)(W,8"!'+$(:+&&)%!6)-%)(+$(+DW)%+$(W,&9'#:+$(')C-#'+$(5)8+(g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

10 LD#')6, p. 19.

55 UXcaZ* Z&% S%,.% ^%$'3.1) ]/-3/$1 0%I 3!)&


dlL Z \10/;'%@A1 0%) ]32$%) 03 !.%-1$%@A1 01 o,.2%"3&41 +3.1) o,GP3)

@A(:+6(#$$+A(:+6)=!&!6(!(G!+(5$#:M;:!A()5#$M'#+(')(')89-+A(5)&N)&$#'!')j[(I>+(6!#$($#658)$6)-%).(Zp,)6(E(+(!,-%+&j[( !$.( Zg+6+( :#%!&( +(5&+:)$$+( :!,$!8( B,)(+(5&+',


-!")-$()7%&!OW,&9'#:+$(P???Q(E(5!&!()$:,$!&(+(W,#+j( @,( &)$5+-')!?( ZH6(5+,:+( ')( %+-'!$( !$( 5!&%)$?[(r+,N)( #-N)-=>+( $)6('^N#'!A(6!$( #-N)-=>+(')( %+'!(,6!( %E:-#:!(')(N#"#8s-:#!A(')(:+-%&+8)(')( #-'#N9',-+$A()-B,!'&!6)-%+(')($),$(")$%+$A(')($,!(!;N#'!')A(')($,!()C:R:#!?(@( #$$+A(!(5!&;&('+$( $E:,8+$(JKL()(JKLLA(-+()7E&:#%+A(-+$(:+8E"#+$A()$:+8!$A(S+$5#%!#$(P???Q(H6!(%):-+8+"#!('+(5+')&(!5,&!'+()(:+;'#!-+A('+(5+')&($+D&)(+$(:+&5+$?(4(5$>+(E(!(C",&!(^8;6!(')$$!()&!('!$('#$:#58#-!$?

14(LD#')6, p. 22-23.


p,!-%+(!+(5!5)8($+:#!8('+()-:!&:)&!6)-%+A(E(5&):#$+(D,$:RO8+(!+(8!'+(')$%)(5)&$+-!")6(B,)(:+6)=!(!($)(')C-#&(-+($E:,8+(JLJ.(+(')8#-B,)-%)?(4(:+-$;%,#=>+('+(6)#+(')8#-B,)-%)(E(!D-$+8,%!6)-%)(:+&&)8!;N!(t()7#$%U-:#!('!(5$>+?(1&+:,&+,O$)(:+-$;%,#&(-+(5&M5+( #-%)+&('!$(6!$$!$(,6(5)B,)-+(-^-:8)+(')(5)$$+!$(B,)($)!6A($)(!$$#6(5+')6+$('#+(E(,6("#"!-%)$:+(8,:&+():+-h6#:+()(5+89;:+?(H6(8,:&+():+-h6#:+.(!$($+6!$(G!D,8+$!$(%&!+(!:)#%!&R(+$(:+-%&+8)$(5+8#:#!#$A($)6(:+-%!&(+(D)-)T:#+(')(,6!(6>+(')(+D&!("!&!-;'!(5!&!(!$(D!#7!$(%!&)G!$?(P???Q_a

Z +$/)A1* 1 )/)43"% +$/)/1&%.* +1$ '1&)32,/&43* &A1 &%)'3 $3+3&B&%-"3&43* "%) C%/* +1,'1 % +1,'1* )3&01 23)4%01 3" 1,4$1) .,2%$3) )1'/%/)I

O sistema vai sendo aprimorado com personas diversas, mas sempre a +%$B$ 0% /03/% &,'.3%$ 03 ./"/4%@A1 01) 3)+%@1) h)/'1)* 03 $32$%) 0/)'/+./-&%$3) +%$% '3$41) 3 0343$"/&%01) 2$,+1) )1'/%/)I

15 FOUCAULT, Michel. Segurana, Penalidade e PrisoI W1.3@A1 ]/41) 3 !)'$/41) aXXX* 1$2I \%&13. ^%$$1) 0% \1r%* Ed. Forense Universitria, p. 33.

16 L')6?


Aponta David Garland:

L%(#$(v#%S#-(%S#$(v#')&(::!8(5&+W):%(%S!%(*#$:#58#-)(!-'(1,--#$S($S+,8'(D)$%(D)(,-')&$%++'?(*)$5#%)(D)#-"($,D;%8)'(Z%S)(D#&%S(+G(%S)(5$+-[(!-'(5&)$)-%)'A(G+&(%S)(6+$%(5!&%A(#-(%S)(G+&6(+G(!(S#$%+:!8(-!&&!;N)A(%S)(D++w(v+&w$(8)$$(v)88(!$(!(S#$%+&x(+G(5,-#$S6)-%( %S!-(!$(!( $%&,:%,&!8(!-!8x$#$(+G(1+-v)&A(+&(%+(D)(6+&)()7!:%A(+G(%S)(5):,8#!&x(6+')&-(G+&6(+G()7)&:#$#-"(1+v)&(vS#:S(f+,:!,8%(:!88$(Z'#$:#58#-)[?(f+&(f+,-:!,8%A(!-(#-N)$;"!;+-(+G(%S)()6)&")-:)(+G(%S)(5$+-(#-(%S)()!&8x(-#-)%))-%S(:)-%,&x(#$(!:%,!88x(!(6)!-(+G()758+-"(%S)(6,:S(v#')&(y!-'(6+&)(:+-%)65+&!&xz(%S)6)(+G(S+v('+6#--!;+-( #$(!:S#)N)'(!-'( #-'#N#',!8$(!&)($+:#!88x(:+-$%&,:%)'(#-(%S)(6+')&-(v+&8'?

F(-+(s6D#%+(6!#+&(')(,6(5&+W)%+(:&9;:+(B,)($)(')N)(:+6-5&))-')&(ZK#"#!&()(1,-#&[?( ,#%+()6D+&!(+($,D{%,8+(ZI!$-:#6)-%+('!(5$>+[A()(+(5&M5+(8#N&+A($)W!(!5&)$)-%!'+A()6($,!(6!#+&( 5!&%)A( $+D(!( G+&6!(')(,6!(-!&&!;N!(S#$%M:!A(+( 8#N&+( E( 6,#%+(6!#$( ,6!( !-R8#$)( )$%&,%,&!8( '+( 1+')&( '+(B,)(!(S#$%M!('!$(5,-#=\)$?(1!&!( $)&6+$(!#-'!(6!#$()7!-%+$A(&)G)&)O$)(t(6+')&-!()(5):,8#!&(G+&6!(5)8!(B,!8(+(1+')&($)()7)&:)A(')-%&+('+(B,)(f+,:!,8%(:S!6!(Z'#$:#58#-![?(1!&!(f+,:!,8%A(,6!(#-N)$;"!=>+($+D&)(+(!5!&):#6)-%+('!(5$>+(-+( #-9:#+('+( $E:,8+(JLJ( :+-$;%,#(,6!( G+&6!(')()758+&!&(+(%)6!A(6,#%+(6!#$( !658+( y)( :+-%)65+&s-)+zA( ')( :+6+( $)(!8:!-=!(!( '+6#-!=>+( )( ')( :+6+(+$( #-'#N9',+$( $>+( $+:#!8-6)-%)(:+-$%&,9'+$(-+(6,-'+(6+')&-+?_`

Y, )3N%* =1,'%,.4 $341"%* 3" Vigiar e Punir, as anlises estrutu-$%./)4%) 01 +103$* 03"1&)4$%&01* '1"1 C/"1)* 3J)3


\%) 1 MU,+.G'/1O +$1))32,3 %.9" 01 '%+G4,.1 X* 3" 1 03 =1,'%,.4 3)4D &1 MW1$+1 01) W1&03&%01)O18, aprofundado, no '%+G4,.1 XX* MZ Y)43&4%@A1 01) U,+.G'/1)O19.

Refere Foucault que:

V($,589:#+(5)-!8(->+(:+&&)$5+-')(!(B,!8B,)&(5,-#=>+(:+&5+&!8.(E(,6!(5&+',=>+('#G)&)-:#!'!(')($+G)-%+$A(,6(%,!8(+&"!-#-+('+(5+')&(B,)(5,-).(->+(E(!D$+8,%!6)-%)(!()7!$5)&!=>+(')(,6!(W,$;=!(B,)A()$B,):)-'+($),$(5-:95#+$A(5)&')$$)(%+'+(+(:+-%&+8)?(I+$(Z)7:)$$+$[('+$($,589:#+$A($)(#-N)$%)(%+'!(!():+-+6#!('+(5+')&?/b

P???Q( :+658)6)-%!-'+( B,).( E( ,6( G)-h6)-+( #-)758#:RN)8( a )7%)-$>+('!( #6!"#-!=>+('+$( S+6)-$( 5!&!( !( D!&DR)( )( !(:&,)8'!')?/_

=1,'%,.4 4$%@% 3&4A1 '1&)/03$%@H3) )1-$3 % %.43$%@A1 0% &%4,$3P%

01 +$1'3))1 '$/"/&%.* ',N1 '1&43b01* 03 )3'$341* +%))% % )3$ +b-./'1* C1.-4%01 &A1 "%/) +%$% 1 '$/"3* "%) %21$% +%$% 1 %',)%01* )3&01* &1 3&4%&41*

)3, '1&>3'/"3&41 +$/C/.92/1 0% %',)%@A1I

Y "103.1 )32,/01 +3.1 +$1'3))1 +3&%. 03)03 % X0%03 \90/% 9 .%)4$3-%01 &1 X&


Z '1&;))A1* +1$ ),% C3P* 9 % $%/&>% 0%) +$1C%)* +1/)F

P???Q(5)8!(:+-C$$>+A(+(5&M5+(!:,$!'+(%+6!(8,"!&(-+(%,!8('!(5&+',=>+('!(N)&'!')(5)-!8?(P???Q/3

P???Q($)(%&!%!()6($,6!(')(5&+',)/"-?./'1)O* 3"


(%)*#+),-./ 0& 123*45#. 62% 78%11% 1#$. 5.9:%5#$.' &)1 52;. $%1%9(.*)( :.28%11% 1#$. 1%5(%


G%#'%-'".)>.'%4$23!"$8%)>1,23)4%%C'1%?$"#!#'1%&)2H!1IA

Refere Foucault:

R%(@# 9%N(. .2 5(#.1. (%5.95#*#)$.' $%B%91.( $. 8%($)$%#(. $#(%#


,4$%"'


7$25%#)8$/%,4$%!4$3)4%#)%#)1


1%9


b\X%[%02)-!1'%+,)%'%-'"#)"$#'%)">)23,)%$%0'1!:;'%#$%4'2$8!#$#)%0P?8!-$A

E, muito embora Foucault aponte que

L 3(#1-. %& 1%2


4'6-'4):$%$%1)2%0)"1$#$%)%!408$".$#$%1)3,"#'%#!


(#) #9b7* 62)*62%( )3(%9$#+)N%&/ J///K [. 3(#9543#. $.


,,,0'*!)1!,)&'(&)*!'2'%, 1,(3,$&

g'%-$0E.,8'%1)3,!".)/%(5%"$%.)2-)!2$%0$2.)%#)%Vigiar e Punir, chama-#'%Ce!1-!08!"$I/%K',-$,8.%"'1%$02)1)".$%,4$%02)8):;'%1'?2)%Ca1%-'20'1%#H-)!1I/%)%#)%-'4'%'1%4'#)8'1%#!1-!08!"$2)1%,68!O$#'1%)4%


o% *.5)*#+),]%1 B295#.9)#1/% 8,3$2)1% #)Z"!#'1% 0)8$% $#4!"!1.2$:;'%0$2$%Q5%.$4?*4%")-)11!#$#)%#)%-'".2'8)1%#$1%$6o%-,!#$#'1$%)"32)"$3)4%-'20'M'?().'_

o%,68!O$:;'%4$>!4!O$#$%#'%.)40'%$.*%$%)>$,1.;'A

Fixados os valores e pressupostos disciplinares, o novo modelo pe-"$8%2)+,)2%$!"#$/%0$2$%$6"3!2%1),1%'?()6E


$% 3(#8#*CN#. $% ;217,)' 5.& 12)1 *%#1 3(@3(#)1' 1%21 $%*#$4)%+,)% C-'4?!"$%$1% .*-"!-$1%#$%&!)2$2+,!$%+,)%s:% %?))7.9 #1' B.(


^H %?)&% #.1. C' 3)() %1


B-.1' )3(%9$#+%1' %1


Finalizando esta breve anlise de Vigiar e Punir/%-'"Z2$4M1)/%$!"#$%uma vez, os ensinamentos de Garland sobre a obra de Foucault:

!9


S)24!"$M1)%'%02)1)".)%.2$?$8&'%.2$O)"#'%$%4)8&'2%-'"-8,1;'%0'11E


GARLAND, David. Punishment and Modern Society: A Study

in Social Theory3& L.+&B>1C+)912M& (N& 4.1:-*(& G)+99%& OPN()0&B>1C+)912M&

press, 1990.

HOBSBAWN, Eric. Bandidos. Ed. Paz e Terra, 2012.

Q-&G-T5-&?-):+5(9&81U+1)(&0-3&/!'"0#'$)10#&*!"$),)2*,'340(-

5!6"(78$)9$#(5),)!*,$5:;!"()*()()0#=(?(. Rio de Janeiro: Luminria

S:-0VW1:-%&/012()-&=T5XN(:(%Y 3

vigiar e punir – história da (michel foucault) cristina tereza gaulia

Documents