vogtle, npdes permit renewal application

Jeffrey T. Gasser Southern NuclearVice President Operating Company, Inc.

40 Inverness Center ParkwayPost Office Box 1295Birmingham, Alabama 35201

Tel 205.992.7721Fax 205.992.0403 O

SOUTHERNCOMPANY

December 15, 2003 Energy to Serve Your World"

Docket Nos.: 50424 NL-03-252350425

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionATTN: Document Control DeskWashington, D. C. 20555-0001

Vogtle Electric Generating PlantNPDES Permit Renewal Application

Ladies and Gentlemen:

In accordance with Section 3.2 of the Vogtle Electric Generating Plant EnvironmentalProtection Plan (Units I and 2), Appendix B to Facility Operating License Nos. NPF-68and NPF 8 1, enclosed is a copy of the permit renewal application package for NationalPollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit No. GA0026786 submitted tothe Georgia Environmental Protection Division.

This letter contains no NRC commitments. If you have any questions, please advise.

Sincerely,

Je e T.asser

JTG/KWK/daj

Enclosure

cc: Southern Nuclear Operating CompanyMr. J. D. Woodard, Executive Vice PresidentMr. W. F. Kitchens, General Manager - Plant VogtleMr. M. Sheibani, Engineering Supervisor - Plant VogtleMr. G. D. Elmore, Environmental ServicesMr. W. C. Carr, Environmental Services (wv/o attachments)Document Services RTYPE: CVC7000

Georgia Power CompanyMr. M. E. Wilder, Environmental Affairs (w/o attachments)

clD(

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionNL-03-2523

U. S. Nuclear Regulatory CommissionMr. L. A. Reyes, Regional AdministratorMr. S. D. Bloom, NRR Project Manager - VogtleMr. J. Zeiler, Senior Resident Inspector - Vogtle

State of GeorgiaMr. L. C. Barrett, Commissioner - Department of Natural Resources

Southern NuclearOperating Company, Inc.

*k Post Office Box 1295Birmingham, Alabama 35201 1295

Tel 205.992.5000

SOUTHERNAK

Energy to Serve Your WorldFile: E.03.07Log: EV-03-2479

December 4, 2003

FEDERAL EXPRESS

Voqtle Electric Generating Plant (NPDES Permit No. GA0026786)Permit Renewal Application Package

Mr. Michael S. CreasonUnit CoordinatorWater Protection BranchEnvironmental Protection Division4220 International Parkway, Suite 101Atlanta, Georgia 30354

Dear Mr. Creason:

Attached is the NPDES permit renewal application package for the Vogtle ElectricGenerating Plant (NPDES Permit No. GA0026786) located near Waynesboro,Georgia. The renewal package contains completed EPA Forms 3510-1 and 3510-2C. Also included are the results from whole effluent toxicity (WET) chronictesting, as required by the State of Georgia.

If you have any questions or need additional information, please contactGreg Elmore at (205) 992-5264.

Sincerely,

Wayne C. Carr, Manage AEnvironmental Services

WCC/GDE:ahl

Enclosure

EV-03-2479

Mr. Michael S. CreasonState of Georgia Environmental Protection DivisionPage Two

bcc: w/o EnclosureJ. T. GasserP. D. RushtonN. J. Stringfellow1. A. KocheryB. D. CarterM. E. WilderB. R. EvansA. Harris

w/ EnclosureW. F. KitchensC. M. BurkeSNC Document Management - Vogtle (Return Receipt)

V

I-, -j; *

Application for Permit Renewal

NPDES Permit No. GA0026786

Vogtle Electric Generating Plant

Submitted by Southern Nuclear Operating CompanyDecember 2003

SOUT#4LftN k.COMPrANY

I Ge

iI

EPA FORM 1 GENERAL

General InformationConsolidated Permits Program

Vogtle Electric Generating PlantNPDES No. GA0026786

Submitted by Southern Nuclear Operating CompanyDecember 2003 COFAPCuN'

ty/t ru It f'4JpIUV�U 'lIVID III) £UtIJUIJOU f9JjJIUVdI �J

:

IaGT ECTRIC GENERATING PL

, .v ..,

CAPP WNA' �RVICES 205 17

P.O. BOX 12955. CITY OR TOWN: :

|BIRMINGHAMV;I. FACIUTY LOCATION_

- 1::0 . -A. STREET, ROUTE Nt

£| 7821 R1VER ROADi 5s s 2

;I -LALJ - 35201

r ... .... . .. se450 .�. I-

. ' _ ; . . . .

12g: ::: : 7 :B. COUNTY NAME 77: :7:s;:1 :

BURKE -045e 70 X i ii .0 7 i

.r .

C. CITY OR-TOT

WAYNESBORO__.0.D STATE. E. ZIP CODE -:--F. COUNTY COI

t GA 30830 °- N/A|40 .l 41: 42 17t 47 :: -52 ? : ~ 54 | "'l- -, - -

EPA FOR 35 01 (.0 O iN E O E E S

.

'4911]Gnrto of Electricity ~ NIA

:E>: . | ~~~~NJA N/A

i-SOUTHERN NUCLEAR OPERATING CNIPANY - 0lg g,A l4 _Dw,'' 1 'o *-}_W .q-r- MIN. *~. ^t~4X5f

M~2STATLUS OF(PERATOR' ~trffigga l~te7fterinwtdenrbItr .0P-f avo5 £

*R~PRl A Z 5 i't'51 I 2~5

$ESTE1OR PO0.-BOX-tl5 ?SkVUmei TW,-I 41fZ "m

P..BOX 1295

~~~~~ OR ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~W- 7- G.- WATE Vt344~,:'ZliH 1PC CODE al

' BIR MI NG HAM AL 35201File ~41- -4 -1 f " -

X.rEXISTING-ENVIR~MiE-PAL'PERIM-n;'t, V.-

- - ~~~~~GA0026786 N/A ~

N:IA4 - SEE ATTACHED

A T4A C. RCR I aadu ats ~ ~ ~ nE

~~~~ ~~~N/A N/A

.Atbeh to thtiasppiircaton a opgraphic map 0f Ui amra extending to atleast onc miloebeyond proport ybhunderiThe mnap mustMt fic111ty,' l ocation of each o it-existing aend proposed intake and discharge s Mc utes~eachoiW

iha a dou t eatnt nstorge-or di~ facliits ,nd dachysii wheitnjets fluidsundorgrouvlndude j spingiaAeredaoter>i'tic'6ateil'nt - -i~ ~ i e rcoa 7

PM NATURE OFD1USINESS (-*f*de

Generation of electricity through the use of nuclear fuel.

Vogtle Electric Generating Plant is jointly owned by Georgia Power Company, Oglethorpe PowerCorporation, Municipal Electric Authority of Georgia, and the City of Dalton, Georgia.

u.PU.CERTIFICATION fsee /0Sh'z'-tbM~

~~6Afr~~~n~~'Ini~hftit&Jcg4JMV4&/7 7

A. NAME &OFFICIAL TITLE (b'0; opnd7Q JB. SIGN TUR C. DATE SIGNED

J. T. Gasser, Vice President b/ ' ~ ,o30COWNEFNTS FOR OFFICIAL USE 0"L7777;.

I. -1' ~~~_! -I ~~ - ~ --EPA Form 3510-1 (8-90)

Attachment to EPA Form 1, Section X.EExisting Environmental PermitsVogtle Electric Generating Plant

Permit Name Permit Number Held ByNPDES Permit GA0026786. _ Southern Nuclear Operating Co

NPDES General Stormwater Permit GAROOOOOO Southern Nuclear Operating C_.

NPDES General Construction Storrnwater GARI0000I Southern Nuclear Operating CoPermit

Public Non-Transient Non-Community PG0330017 Georgia Power CompanyWater System

Public Transient Non-Community Water NG0330036 Georgia Power CompanySystem

Public Non-Transient Non-Com-munity PG0330035 -- -Georgia Power CompanyWater System -

Haz. Materials Certificate of Registration 061603 001 014L Southern Nuclear Operating Co(Issued by U.S. Dept. of Transportation)

Dredging Permit 950004490 Southern Nuclear Operating Co(Issued by U.S. Army Corps of Engineers)

Surface Water Withdrawal 017-0191-05 Southern Nuclear Operating Co

Ground Water Use 017-0003 Southern Nuclear Operating Co

Solid Waste Handling-Permit.- _ 01-06Dj)I(X) No. 2 Georgia Power Company

Solid Waste Handling Permit 017-007D(L)(1) Georgia Power Company

Solid Waste Collection Permit By Rule PBR-0 I 7-07COL Southern Nuclear Operating Co

Part 70 Operating Permit 4911-033-0030-V-01-0 Georgia PowerCompany/Southern Company

GA0026786 Page I of I

4 A

EPA FORM 2C NPDES

Application for Permit to Discharge WastewaterConsolidated Permits Program

--- Vogtle-Eiectric Generating Plant-NPDES No. GA0026786

Siubmiued by Southern Nuclear Operating Company

December 2003 SCUl.MP&NA

t A

l - |

Please print or type in the unshaded areas only. IEPA LD.(coqyfom Atem /of~orm I)

GA0026786 IForm Approved.OMB No. 204D-0086Approval expires 7-31488

,FORMAi- .;. ir , '- *S. 'ENVIRONblAl PRl:Cll O NAGENCY!l;' 2C> , 'j'I ~P' . . z', ' .APPLICATON FOR PP ETTO DISCHARGE WASITWATER + H S %-_fi2c kjow E .rz hEXMMNG MANUFACURNG; COMMRIA MININGATPDj-ESiI -s' i

L .OUIrFALL LOACATI-,I.Pnr~ph n,, ~llI yetthe latitulfr and Innfortnifle J1;Imm I n~il~ff AIheflnIr~viI ISnernn lanh the name nI the? Yrrvn-mlr~T

A. OUr- B. LATITUDE C. LONGITUDEFALL NO. .D. RECEIVING WATER (n=6m

(7irO I.DEG. 2. MIN. 3. SEC. I.DEG. 2.MINT.J 3 SEC.-01-13 33 08 53 81----45 - - 09 SAVANNAH RIVER14-15 33 08 30 81 45 44 BEAVER DAM CREEK

A LOYWS, SOURCES OF POLL ION AN) TREAMNT TEaNOLOGIES _A:Attach a line drawing showingthe watr flow through th facility. Indiat souCees of intake waetr-operations conrnbuting ,wastewater to h efluaittivcfandt ntalert initslabel tocors Uimore defedd pnsiniteB. Costiaie aceonheiing,flo ws esofratbo rt t ' oitfa~l&KIf a',te balanca cannot bedet mirie. ,or, O ri5&' si ai ti),''vie

.-pictoria de pton~ofte natzrei t yicsofwr dtycolectioniorm nii nttsure>: '.;.B. For each ouifil. provide a desciption of (1) All oprations contibuting wastewater to the effluent including procss wastewatersanitay wastewater.70.I

.';r ooirng tcr~ and torm waterrunoff, (2)Tfhc ivcr c Dow utaed byach 6otion; and (3) ctr entreceiied Iythe wastewater;, Corn3;~~~~~~~~~~~-: _ _ _] .:__ Ew_., fr_::=__i .,;; S- *. .-.. -z f_ , .'1 C.. S -. t : ;: - _.-5 . _. ..... . . .' :r _- _ .i Sl2 . . S1 a .i ...-- W * rit

I - b ¢nm ttituonasneers n-T- *ecessary.-: .-.2 4 t -2:~.-4> ; -T ,'. _ '-7 ,-P ii

.PALLNT.-O',, ';';~ t O-.- R .C- NI FLOW. §R EAT - 4 .- ;h

r~t-;ffit ;i .sM':J a OPERATIO b.AVERAGE FLOW - DESCREMON b.;LST CODESFROM r

001 FINAL PLANT DISCHARGE 5,000 GPM 59,028 GPM 2E 4A(COMBINED PLANT WASTE (MAXIMUM)

_ STREAMS UNITS I & 2) ._ __ __._.

002 UNIT I COOLING TOWER 10,000 GPM 2F 4ABLOWDOWN (MAXIMUM)

002A UNIT I EMERGENCY 2F 4AOVERFLOW TO STORMDRAINS

003 UNIT 2 COOLING TOWER ,I Q00 GPM 2F 4ABLOWDOWN (MAXIMUM)

003A UNIT 2 EMERGENCY 2F 4AOVERFLOW TO STORMDRAINS

004 UNIT I WASTE WATER 1,300 GPM AARETENTION BASIN (MAXIMUM)

005 UNIT 2 WASTE WATER 1,300 GPM 4ARETENTION BASIN (MAXIMUM)

006 SEWAGE TREATMENT PLANT . 2F, 3A 4AEMERGENCY OVERFLOW

007 LIQUID RADWASTE SYSTEMS . 100 GPM 2J 4ADISCHARGE (UNIT I)- -- (MAXIMUM)

008 LIQUID RADWASTE SYSTEMS .00 GPM 2J 4ADISCHARGE (UNIT 2) (MAXIMUM)

009 NUCLEAR SERVICE COOLING . 500 GPM 2F 4ATOWER BLOWDOWN (UNITS I (MAXIMUM)&2)

010 RADWASTE DILUTION FLOW . . 4ATO OUTFALL 001

011 INTAKE SCREEN BACKWASH . .4A012 POWER BLOCK STORM . DISCHARGE FROM THIS 4A

WATER DISCHARGE TO OUTFALL IS GOVERNED BYSAVANNAH RIVER GENERAL PERMIT NO.

GAR000000

INTERMITTENTFLOW (SEE ATTACHEDTABLE)

DMCL USE ONLY (effluent guidelines sub-categories); . -' .' .

EPA Form 3S10-2C (Rev.2-85) PAGE 1 0F4 CONTINUE ON PAGE 2EPA Form 3510-2C (Rev.2-85) PAGE IOF 4 CONTINUE ON PAGE 2

Please print or type in the unshaded areas only. IEPA LD.(copyfrom item Jo/JForm

GA0026786"I

Form Approved.OMB No. 2040-0086Approval expires 7-31-88

'~~ 2C I ~~ '.~~ M'PPU1C-A9N FORlERMIT TO'DISCHAIRGE WASTEWA7TR.-42~,rl1;~,~.-~-.t:'~.P EXIS MA; ;A r. MERCIAA M G AND SILVCULMALOP ONS

NPE -. Pr.. a ~ i; t. .-t- <0i ~pt>[email protected] OUTMALLLOCA71ON>,: _For each outfall. listthe latitude and longitudeofits location to thenearest 15 seconds and the nane ofthe receivingR ater.-),r:X,.wi-f M.74 rjj.^, ;S , .'I

A. QUT- B. LATITUDE C. LONGITUDEFALL NO. _ D. RECEIVING WATER (name

(l7/ I.DEG. 2. MIN. 3. SEC. I.DEG. 1 2. MIN. 3. SEC. _

01-13 33 08 53 81 - .----45 -09 SAVANNAH RIVER14-15 33 08 30 81 45 44 BEAVER DAM CREEK

I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

IFLOWS, OURCES OF POLUM~ON. AND TREATMENT TECHNOLOGEES,: ~A;AtUach a ine draving showing thc wata flowtirugh thefacility.tIndicatesources of intakewvater, opeiatios contributing wastewaterlo the efiuenti-.m.-,,Ie.> detbit t tslh 1abcldi'c CCA~t~p~nd to the inm'r detailed dd ionin n r 'n toia wieo liat enr 'navoen e,

4o ee ios-'n'taljtio~itr benmet' units,'and ot.IfatsIs te~lri&aii ca' be deteunmine te.g for wain inm~ng ctivities~provid er-

B: For cach outfalD, providesa description of: (Ij) Alt operasuion contibuting'wsstewterto the effluentj, including process wastwater, sanitarywasewaewster;J4w 'ooi~ng vitar and slonn water runort; 2=)T !n veragfre lo ontnbuiea by o ean tir~ on;anod (3) Thet teatrrncnt received wj th Y u ,* -. oid dtiA sif ss''ti' tJl~l .h-' '+<Fi0s~t-s~r-* i t e~8:,;~4-0-;$ ' | ..... -ll '-' ~h¢x:*'i 4-.,>-

. . . . .. . , ! ! r s::

_UIOUT-;z~FALL NO ,'

1;,$.-f I

?, - - - 'L, t , 7 V ~ -.'.4,>.I.- 2.OPERAMlON(S)CONTRIF

I 4 � I- Zr -, �' -'i -.I -- � , , -� � .� "- 1 � �. �4 t�-- ; , .4 ; -.. " ;tj - �' � '.j : -�.j? � '� �t "..I -,, I --f -�, - -', " 1,- - �-,, 'j, , � -" ��,eZ�j St" �;fip, .- .. ., , 4f- , .. !.�' -4 �. , L �, 3 1,y ""4� � :� - '.., -;�.1 I , -� -, �, .-4 , i , I -. .

. _ _ _ : AA - ' t ' s a f _. A w_,,

I . R- - -1a.DESCRIFION '- - -T ~ *;i7:

-, j"'O It Lb.ULtfr2yKOjM%..!WrtrAL2.

... ...--- ---- _ …- I. .�

013 INTAKE STRUCTJ UR ST UK ORM --WATER DISCHARGE TOSAVANNAH RIVER

*0 _ DISCHARUG FRUM TH1S_ OUTFALL IS GOVERNED BY

. GENERAL PERMIT NO.GAROOOOOO

4A

014 EAST STORM WATER DISCHARGE FROM THIS 4ADISCHARGE TO BEAVER DAM OUTFALL IS GOVERNED BYCREEK (RETENTION POND I) GENERAL PERMIT NO.

GAR000000015 WEST STORM WATER . DISCHARGE FROM THIS 4A

DISCHARGE TO BEAVER DAM OUTFALL IS GOVERNED BYCREEK (RETENTION POND 2) GENERAL PERMIT NO.

GAROOOOOO_.

*' INTERMITTENTFLOW (SEE ATTACHEDTABLE)

OFFICIAL USE ONLY (cfflunt guidelines sub-categories) . . - . - ; :

-~~~~~~~~~~~~t u -r -: .A NJL f J .I .,.N .t .. N , .,,-:JBYA MITI J31u-ZL (KcV-Z-0-) rAujr, j ur 4f tk-UN I IlNUrl)) I-UN I I1N U UrY YAtir z

,es-w-r.<..-^.s.,L tt,!.3 wi,-z'- 4 FLOW t;; §',rli}-F'-i-

I

a-FLOW-RATF, i�.,n., A TO0TALIVOLUMEL,-,' ±+ L -..A .I

.5,.

OMAUM .ULY j

4,l:LONO,.): tU XI F2.

-

See attachment forIntermittent Discharges

N/A

-I .", -_,�- i I . .,:. ; " I : - -, - --,� 4 " - - -, , 'A '.., ;� !.-- ; . . - , - ;_-� P _', ! 'T.e" ., - � : :: t�'.4,!iz:71-.. '� ;:11:7i-, �4-.,� j, . .. . . . .. . . ... . .. . . . . . . .

.A.Are yT now rcqtred by, ay .Fcdend, sta or Iocal athority to meet any implementation schedule for the constrtction,-upading or operation ofuiwastewter treament equipnment or praices or any otherrmironm a rarns which''may affect the discharges descnbed in ts appiation? :tis

; irnclcdes, buiis not limited to nit co ditionsdmintstrative orenforcementorers, ennforcemat compliance scheduklen stipulationis,c6urt ordcrs,'j .n .,'d zrltiIB ;, *or< - f - - , I -:

-CONDMONAGREM~.r I _'s. I' "... .', *~: ;! i- it - -, j:_':..fd.

42.;AFFECTED OUTFAllS,a.NO:; B.SOURCEOFT...... .. DISCHARGE-S

43. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF PROIECI,., I, I..... .t,.;* ,.;1. ;

-- ,,4 ~FINAL'COMPI LCE wi7

_ . . . _^ __ . . __ ^ _ _ .

a _REQUIIED.L

: PROJECTED. I

B. OPTIONAI You may attach additional sheets describing any. additional water pollution control programs (or other envirrnmental projects ihichmayafect your discharges) you now have underway or wvhich you plati Indicate whether each program is now underway or pned;ano indicateyouractual

.or planred seIC5es for construction;: .. i -, A. -.* -;

' '-. -. ARKI"D FDESCRIMNONOFADDInONA LCONTROL PROGRAMISA1TACflE '.-i '" '

EPA Form 3510-2C (Rev. 2485) PAGE 2 OF 4 CONTINUE ON PAGE 3

EPA J.D.NUMBER (covpyvomIemIJ FormI) Form Approved.

. GA0026786 O 0MB No. 2040-0086CONTINUED FROM PAGE 2 Approval expires 7-31-88rV,-JNTAKEANDEFLUTCHARA S'lCS:-'4. .-3.:%~,'.!.-.".:-i I :%is' 4i',i*.s>:~z5 5, ::-- -` *j- J* P_¢;.USi eai,^4;iiAB. & C: :Se instructions before proccedingt Completeonesetoftables foreachoutfall -,Annoate theoutlIl nurmber in thespweprovided. -

.- .NOTE: '-Jabl s-.V-B; dV-Ca nchdlud ofis h ts, u -It u hV.9.Q.'D.Use thespace belowto list anyof thepollutants listed inTable2c3if the instructions;,.vhichyou knowor have reasonto believe is discharged ormay;.-,i bedisiSared rni'any bui afl.'.For every pollutant you list, briefy debithi rcasoisyou bdiev it to bc priscnt and rcnn any 31yric21 datn in .2ssion ) _i. ei resn you .v reor '~ .~~iia '= in}' r fs Sv. ~ !;

your ___________________ .- L/ffz~;;-^,izv;t il.^l;POLLUTANT r-. > -~eT rr2"2. !1¢ 2SOURCE 4 --:;-*:i- .~ I-,.l^J ",1;PQLLtJTANT~,, .+.t. -T- P U T 7i: 2.SOURCE r *None

VI. POTENIIAL DISCHARGES NC COVERED BY ANALYSIS * } _ _-s anypollutantlisted intemV-Casutaceor a component of a substance which you currently use ortnanuflcturc s an intermediate or final productao

N/A

EPA Form 3510-2C (Rev. 2-85) PAGE 3 OF 4 CONTINUE ON PAGE 4

CONTINUED FROM THE FRONTVII. BIOLOGICALTOXCITY TESTING DATA':;Do you have any knowledge or.reason to believe that any biological test foracute or dronic toxkity has bn made on any of yourdischarges orona receivmgwterin e aiont'y uri h'rg ithin t el ty :a -~-s. ji5.k.al ;r s ,. j.t;f -.''.'tJ-

: Y.. '.. -'t-.': ES (identify the test(s)and- describe theirpusrps 5 :,II .;1; 1NO (go to S

WHOLE EFFLUENT TOXICITY (WET) CHRONIC TESTING PERFORMED IN NOVEMBER 2003 AS REQUIRED BY

GEORGIA EPD TO SUPPORT NPDES PERMIT RENEWAL. TESTING RESULTS ARE INCLUDED WITH THIS RENEWNAL

APPLICATION.

Viii CONTRACT A}IALYS1S INFOR.MATION ~~~~~~~' .,.,~~ ~~:,{ri::. ;; ~~~~*-:. : .. :- *~~'- .. ... ;-. ;-..--. r' -r- 1. .r-!s.'~- '

Were any offteanalyses rportea In Item V Pertormed by a contact laboratoiyrcora'];nhrnv,- -` .

polltants anayi~d by;cach such laboruoi, or' firmn beo)r;~:~4~ -it11•,;:,.ADDRESSL?, _ -,1.,7C.TE1LEPH0N4E-;~' D.POLUFANTSANLZD

Alabama Power Company P.O. Box 2641 (205) 664-6182 All except pH, temperature, Total

General Test Laboratory Birmingham, AL 35291 Residual Chlorine, and Radiological

Florida Radiochemistry 5456 Hoffner Ave. (407) 382-7733 RadiologicalServices, Inc. Suite 201

Orlando, FL 32812

BioTox Laboratory 3200 Town Point Dr., NW (770) 421-7027 Whole Effluent Toxicity Testing

MACTEC Eng. & Consulting Suite 100Kennesaw, GA 30144

IX; CERTIFICATIONJcertrfy underpenalyoJ0/aw that this documentand allttachments wereprepared undermy direction orsupervision in accordance:with a system designatedto essure ihat ua4/ 7edpersonnd perlygather and evaluate the <died. ased on ry.:

inguiry of/theperson orpersons who manage ihe.ysfen ar thosepersons directl; retsponsibleforg atheri'ighe information, the

informadonosubmittedir / othebestof my nowldgedandlbelkf true; accurate, anddcompieie.. I am ewareih'atithere aresigniIC7cantt . r 3 -.. . _~ ___3 r_:_r. .,3___ . . _t _____ , ___ _:. _ _ ._t2 _

penaatiesor.rubrnmitinIOatse injormnatlon, incuding Ineposzoulp oiJrne onaimprisonmenriorAnow!n2 vioItaons. .

A. NAME & OFFICIAL TITLE (type or print) B. PHONE NO. (Area code & no.)

J. T. GASSER, VICE PRESIDENT (205) 992 -5000C. SIGNATURE D. DATE SIGNED

4 A wav-1 1 JJO __ _

EPA Form 3510-2C (Rev. 2-85) PAGE 4 OF 4

I .

9.

EPA FORM 2C SECTION V

Intake and Effluent CharacteristicsConsolidated Permits Program



SOUIMLnNACOPAPAWO

PLEASE PRiNT ORTYPE IN THE UNSIIADED AREAS ONLY. You may report someor all ofthis inrorfnation on separate sheets(Use the someformrla) instead of completing these pages.SEE INSTRUCTIONS.

V;. ITAKE:AND EFFLUlNT C-T. lRCH ERA STICS (cotinued from page.3oFForm 2

PART A - You must provide the results of at least one analysis for every pollutant in this table. Complete i

Form Approved.OMB No. 2040-0086

d.Fecal Colilfom . _

e.Fltoride(16984 48 8)

. Nitrate Nitrite ns. l9 i

EPA Form 35t0-2C (Rev. 2-85)

ITEM V-n

Cj..,.AtAN mlv _h

p I4O-L~ . _~-J

g. Nitrog c; x*Total Organic(a , Xh. Oil and Greasec

1. Phosphorus (as P) ;4Total (7723 i4-0) :.x1;.Raditactivit' " -,;

:(2) Beta, Total - - ___

(3) Radiuxn.Jbtal .-, x(4) Radium.226,

t ~~~xk. Sulrates 50; SO.*(i48a8-79.8) i*: e11. Sulfde (as SO.r,-'

l i4265 45-3)9-X.m..Sulfite (dasSOj)7\ :'(!4265-45 3). f:-- xi. Surahctantsa

xO. Aluminium, .--- ,.--,Total (i440 39 3)p. Banum, Totalu;1

q:Boron, Total - r,

(1440 42.8)x' : ., Xr; Cobalt, Total :(7440-48 4j

t ST ron,.Total ,(7439-89.6)s4.; . r< XtzMagnesiumTotai (7439-95 4) '

u. Molybdenum,: --Total (7439 9h-7).v. Manganese, -,

,.Totl 7439-96-5) Xw aTinj Total -

x. Titaniu'm, ..-..-Tofaii(t440-32-6) .EPA Form 3510-2C (Rev. 2-95)

EPA I.D. NUMBER (copyfrom Item I of Form l) OUTFALL NUMBER

I GA0026786 I 001

Form Approved.OMB No. 2040-0086Approval expires 7-31-88

CONTINUED FROM PAGE 3 OF FORM 2-C

PART C- If you are a primary industry sod this outrsll contains process wastewater, error to Table 2c-2 in the nstructions. lo t.tetnrmine whichttaf tho (ICIMS fractions You maul testfor. Mask 'X'in column 2- for all uch G luMS firactios that apply to yourindustr,' nd forALL toic itia,

cyanides. sdtotalphenols. If uarenotrequiredto na tcolumn2-a(secondaryiindustiesunonpcessws tewater ufaa no reqir ti C iS ftiont),mr t.' it 1ut 2-bfotr ahpolutt tyu owor hver o toeie e s prent Nurk a"in colum 2-oor each -

pollutant you believe is absent Ifyou mark column 2a for any pollutant, you must providetheresults of atleat one anal sis fort tatpoillutant, fyouma coun2 rith pou t you must {provide thercit ofat les n asi forthep ltutunt if you nwor tveas10t.to

believe it vilt be discharged in conettions of to ppb or greatet. If you murk column 2b for acrtin, astylonitrile, 2.4 dinitrophenol. or 2-methyl-4i, 6 dioitropbtieol, y m tal pirovIe the tesus of at least ou anlsis for e: ftee poluants . ihh y n o or hVe o tO bleve

thtlyoudischargein conentrationi oflt pphorgreater. therwise fo polatans forwhich you tro colur 2h, you moot etd e submit at trout on analsi obreNyd te ret or t polua nt se I he iscier Notth there -rs opg

dothi pajtple re iew

ainch c ar Cumplete one table (all I pages) or ecoutfa.See sutions r additional details and uirem ent. __ _ :: __ _ _ _ _

I. POLLUTANT 2. MARK X ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 3. EFFLUENT _______ ______ ______ ______4. UNIT 2 5. NTA KCE (o ti) , ,~

ANUCS i a Test- b. Be- b. Bet- 0. MAXIMUM DAILY b.MAXIMUM 30 DAY 6. LONG TERM AVRG d.NO. .

NUMOER iso loved ieved VALUE VALUE (lrvlol)VLE . -. O .',;. ~AVERAGE- VAU b.ANAL-

(Ifavaislble) Reuid Erent Absent (I) CONCEN. (2) MASS (T) CONCEN- (2) MASS (I) CONCEN- (2) MASS YSES TAI MASS (0 CONCE ( MASS .

METALS, CYANIDE, AND TOTAL PHENOLS - N T :T: I:.

I N4. Antimony, I

00 mg/I lb/day <0.0 121

Total (1440-36-0) X X <0.012

2M. Arsenic, Total(7440-38-2) X X <0.005

1 mg/l lb/day <0.005

3M. Beryllium, 00II mg l/a 00II

Total, 7440-41-7 X X <0.001 mg/I lb/day <oool I

4M. Cadmium,Total:(7440-43-9) X X <0.002

1 mg/I lb/day <0.002 1

SM. chromiumnTotal (7443-47-3):; t ; X _ X 0.001

I mg/I lb/day <0.001

6M. Coper Total X 0.006 mg/ b/day <0.005

7M. Lead, Tolal X X <0.004 1 mg/I lb/day <0.004

SM Mercury, Total

(7430-97-06) 0 X X <0.004 1 mg/I lb/day <0.0040

(M. Nickel, TotalI 40M. .elenI X I X <0,004 .

mg/I lb/day <0.004

I:IM. Silver, Total

(7440-22-4) ~~X X <0.0064 mg/I lb/day <0.006

12M.SeThalium, X<007_____

Total (7440-:28-0): X X . <0.005 mg/I lb/day <0.007

13M. Zinc8Total4 X

H(A7440 6-6) X0393mg/

lb/day .

14M. Cyanide, X X <0.005 . mg/l lb/day <0 005

15M.: Phenols, :- :;; X < 0.01 I mg/I lb/day <001

:oa .: :- -: -,

-. -_

:2,3 ,7, 8-Te tra-: i:SX DEC lEREUT

.chlorodibenzo-P-OSCIERSUT

EPA Fat (5712-2C(e. -5 rg -

EPA Form 3510-2C (Rev. 2-95) rage V-3

.

.POLLUTANT, O L M2 RIX-. :. -. IA DCAS--"':t

pAN -ta~e .'.'.. Rqird

.b .W; k Bit: I: kved -:

P .ei 'A6.mA

, CYd.IV.Amcrlin (107.02.8),:-

x%'-.Acry1dni trile'.: -

�--- x, ,

3WBenx

: ! . - - e

4V;,Bis(ChloromethYl) .:Itb/day

5V~,Brombfoin i nx

:6V. Catbon ---Th*reT;63cht6IiQe~6"-23-5)k:. x

1probentene- I. :L.-I7 *. ' _. x

8V,,Chf6-r6dibrom6.:f --1- -.4I .' -'-'ih' -YiN-49zh'!�". -� tne 6�6. x. , ,

lb/day <0.0030

lb/day <0.0020

lb/day I <0.0010

lb/day I <0.0010

lb/day i <0.0020

lb/day ! <0.0010

lb/day <0.0020

lb/day <0.0010

".,1 - 1-:_, It; I '. -�.t.,!-. , ._: .. i �- : ., ". x

-4-Clflom~~Ohylvinyl'

x

:1 IV. Chloroform. I v(676 63) tr rd, ;4:x

1l2V. Dclrboo;1methane (75;71.8) -74.,:' x

AM3V Dichltor6diqufluto.'-,I methan (~-7 - I

lb/day.. . \ .

I hanE - - x lb/day_

IlV 1,2Di' roclhtind'(1 07-06 ~ ;-2); ; x lb/day

.

[-I 6_VA1I- D-Di thlr.I -IfMf (7~~:354i 41:2 x lb/day

... ,~I.

_~p~ran (7R.87:)lb/dayx

_ _. _

1 8V,..13Dchoo -_-tI: ropylne(576 6.K

Ib/dayx

_ _., _

1 9V; 1!thylbenzenc t lb/dayx_ _- . _

20Y; Methyl Bromide.;::>~ (14iV ~-2.

lb/dayx-

- -

t IVMiMethyl Chldridqe:t;.'.' lb/dayx

EPA Form 3510-2C (Rev. 2-85)

CONTINUED FR~OM PAGE V.4

~~I.POLLUTANT'~>.r -~ .2.MARKXW -~.3rEFFLUET.~~ 1A~JDCAS .~~~>. ~i *..t.<. T 'b.8tj;., -. MAXMJMOA!LY,'; b 14bAXIMUM30 DAY I 1c LO

(If oval table) .,. - ~ ~ ~~ ~ ew'At (I (2)MA.SS, A()," :(2) WASSCocOC4* ,;" :.co~P 66. c

GC/NtS FRACTION-: VOLATILE COMPOUNDS (continudl-'' ~~: ; ~ v-22V.Mtbln Chlonide, 002

23 . 1M ,2 er)h~r eh n x <0.0020

(72-4V ex xroty~n <0.0020

luene (108-88 ~~~~xX <0.002026V; A,2-Trahs.-Dich~qoro-

27V 1256.61 I -Triobor0etIan

116 -60-5) ~~~T, x X <0.0020.29ViTtchdtowethylen th "&

X X <0.0020'30V; Trichiorofnuoro-rmethane,.--

:3 V., VinyI Chloride. (75 01.4) ~___GCiMS FRACTION-'ACID COMPOUNDS,:. - :~".-4 -.:','~.

I A." 2-Chloriopheriol (55 )X <.03____

2A.2.4.Dichlorophenol,x X <0.0027

.3A. 2,4-Dimethyiphenol ~~X X <0.0027

.4A4;6.Dinitr~~~..O-Cieso1 X X <0.024(5 4.52. -W--

~~ '*~~-~~~-~ X - X <0.042 --

.7A;4Nitropheiiof,(I 00.027)'YJ~~~~~:.. ~~~~~~~~ Xx <0.0024

,8AK;PChkrofdM-Ceo

X X <0.0030

!I A. Pbenholor(Iheflo (87.6-) <.06___ _____

.10A2 Phenol (108.952)&T: : x X <0.00 1 5 ________

I IA; 2,4,6-Tfichbloro-phtnoI'(88.:.06.2W- .. ••-':~~~~Ž:i-> ~~. X X <0.0027

- - t

EPA Fnrm

CONTINUED FROM FRONT---,IPOLLUTANT

AND CAS , -e

GCCMS FRACTION -BASE(NEUTR,

IB; Acenaphthene

.3B3.Ahthracene6 (120.1 2-7),

*4B.; Benizidine(2.87.5)

'5B:.Berzo(d), A~nthraceine.--

,6B, Benzo (a).Pyrehbe.4

,7B.3,4-Bdnzo-fluotanthefib

i8B.,Bento ONir) Peyrn~

* 9B3;.BEenzd (k)Fluoranthende~.

I121. flis 2h§ r

:12B.'4rm~ey ~Phn ther 1 21605: 1

151 ButylBenzyll

1613, 2-Chlotbnlphthakfene:

Phenyl Ether"(76005;7213) X1813; Chrysene (2,18 01-9)::.

.19B; Dibenzo (a I)Anthir-cen (53 70 3)

bezenc (95-50 I21B. 1,3 Dihloo-'bnien"e(541 73jA

. l.tt'f !i

..

EPA Fnrm 3510.2C (Rev. 245) Psge V-6

0EPA I.D. NUMBER (capyfrom Item I of OUTFALL NUMBER. Form Approved.Form I) OMB Mo. 2040-0086

CONTINUED FROM PAGE V-6 G001 0 pproval epres 7-31-88_________________________ ~~~~~GA0026786J_ ____Apoaepre7-18

z^,, Nsv Id'OLLITAN 1' '4 :' '! t.t.;': 2. MARK 'X ,!. .t i-;;. @). r¶.V- ._ ',:3 E UEN ' kt -, '? UNITS,- te ts INA~DCAS .,LV~t.', ,k~d-. ~fl~t~ ~LMAXIMJM DAILY,. _1,b. MAXIMUM30 DAY:,-.- ; LONGEN{VR.44dNOLONGTE,'M-t*~16 t"~~~~~~~~~~~~~Vt je k--&1t;, _M TERMVQ,,M;i ;d, NO., if g~ - - ffi

saz s E i~~cl on = MsDNE f [t iL COMN ! ont/~~~ed w -- 7, 34 Vss ERA SSXX

2U2BER. 1,Pi~otbnzn Jeved.; -~ .:''~VALUE2~.4~ _WALUE~fd 7lM ... ..~ ...VALAE . 4

_________ ~ ~ ~~ ~~~~O11111AA GENAL0,~O:tV~

(If available) [ j ,.,~~ -~Ai(f: ASS-."',TATN .M~~i ~'U- 4.2MSS, SEj'(l o-:i6,7 d c ONC E I- * z in ;4 ;>ts ;; ". X <0 0044 l mg/lMASS Id CONCc0 0044 1

GCfMS FRACTION:- BASE/NHUTRAL COMPOUN~DS(of~e~~~ ___ .

2213 1,4 Thchlc~~~~robeXn<z0044 mg/I lb/day <0.0044

238.B.3;3-Dichlorobenzidine~e- ;- _231-i.3 3\_ D~cblobetiznf , X s r tX ; '; .X X <0.0165 I mg/I lb/day <0.0165 1

,24B.;Dicthyl Phthalatl (84-66-2)i._.: .D-:m.; .hy ffi ":::,: l .htb.l-4t. X X <0.00169 1 mg/l lb/day <0.00 1 925BM Dimcfthl Phthal to ; "

2613I-Di-N)Buty :ht;; ;.e-* X X <0.00216 mg/Il lb/day <0.0016-26B.DI-N-2Butyl -. ;- _ _ .

X X <0.0057 1 mg/I lb/day <0.0057

288.t 84 Oj t- .- .-.4. f v . t; ; - X X <0.0025 1 mg/l lb/day <0.0025 I

29B..Di-N.Oetyl~~hlhalate X X <0.0025 1 mg/I lb/day <0.0025 1

.30B-; I j2Diphenyl hydraie,.30b;Z1,2-Dlphenyl-hI22a66ne X X <0.003 1 mg/l lb/day <0.003 I

(M~zobenze (I (22-66'7 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

311B. Fluoranthene (206-44 0) X X <0.0022 A _ _ 1 mg/ Ib/day <0.0022

*,32B.Fljorene (86.73 7) ; .= X _ X <0.0019 ________ __________ ________ I mg/l lb/day <0.00 19

.33B~exachlorobefntzen. ; - X X <0.0019 _ mg/I lb/day <0.0019 I~(l IR.7 ~ IV~t-: *.~ ____ ______ ______0__00___9

:

..r . ' TV. |

CONTINUED FROM FRONT _ -_ _

L' POLLUTANT -2. MARK.;X T', t.T "3 EFFLUNT0'. 4-' UN --,gA. ITVS _-_-_____ i__-_AE(op _ _-_

.,11w , I.- | __ _- *. ."F.' X ' E (

43 ;:Nillr4-.;t .+ . ,, X X <o nols 1 mg/l Ib/day <0.0019 1,il-4-7;,

'''(86~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~'*, ___________________________ .,'.:C''1.,, _"~.,'~ y' . .

- Pvt~~~e,4 42UR(fotAbtl oh(I ') i -*~ ~ s~ ih"',AS'~ EICNE. jASS I"YSES;

44B- Jt.,.f~.. g ~ ThA11ON,, -(2)ii,4-!(I hPrenCO, A.b1. , ;(j)C0N .: X X ooS4mIy0

___________________ TiO X - XN LAMM.0

(i2-82l 7. ,-ims I L r.

ac/Ms FRACTION- BASE/NEUTRAL COMPOUNS (;.flhsnued) ~ ~ U t' ;.g-";~ 44 w ' ~TO .',N -' .t. ,''..' d

2P; a BH(:;(3 1 9-84e;.<; _ X c0 003 I mg/l Ib/day <0 003 I owe&- i~lTRA -1'

70-w- - - -A

43B3 N-Nitro-',.--3dPhehylamnH.- (31X X <0.0031 9 mg/I lb/day <0.0019

4413h Phenanthrenc4(95,6 B-tC<(8)8,9-, ^ X X <0.0054 1 mg/ lb/day <0.0054

8P:45 4 -Dcne~;~. X <0.0019 I mg/l lb/day <0.0019 1

.46Th.1,2,4-TrizU, s . -X <0.00 19 . mg/l lb/day <0.0019

GNIMS FRACTION-PESTICIDES: ,;4o-- . Ax1:IP. Aldrin (309.00) - --

:___________________ <0.003 .I mg/l lb/day <0.003 . . I

_____________________ __X <0.003 . m g /l Ib/day <0.003 1-2P. #-BHC.(3l9-8546)T'!

* ~~~~~~~~ ~~X <0.003 __ __ _ _ _ __ __ _ __ _I lb/day <0.003 I

!3P.fi.BHC (31985-7) X 003__-________ _____ b/a <.0

4P. ~~~BHC(58-8?-9)~~~~~,. X <0.003 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ 1 lb/day <0.003 1

(57749) . - ~~ ~~~~~~~~X <0.003 1 mg/I lb/day <0.003 1

:7P~~~~ 4,4'-DDT ~~~~~~X <0.003 1 mg/I lb/day <0.003 I

x <0.003 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~mg/I lb/day <0.003I

(72-54-8) - - ~~ ~~~~~~~~ - <0__________ ______03___ ___ mg/I lb/day <0.003

t0P2Dieldrwn~~~~~~ - - ~X <0.003 1 mg/I lb/day <0.003

160-57-)- _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

II P~~~~~~~~~~a'-Endosulfan I ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~mg/I lb/day <0.003(1 iS~9.7) 4 X <0.003 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _

12Pf.EdtzfnX <.31 mg/i lb/day <0.003I

I.., I

. 11

I

I

I

Vogtle Electric Generating Plant Flow DiagramAttachment to EPA Form 2C, Section lI.A

NPDES Permit No. GA0026786

SOUTHERN NCOMPANY

;^e,ri*.Srl,lr"I~ r,,NNote: All flows are maximum.

a I" Xl a 6

Form 2C, Attachment 1Item Il.C. Intermittent and Miscellaneous Flows

- Outfall Description of Flow

002/003 - Units I and 2 Cooling TowerBlowdown

These points represent the blowdown from the Unit I andUnit 2 Turbine Plant Cooling Towers. Each towerrecirculates river water used to cool turbine condensatevia a heat exchanger. Periodic blowdown or dischargefrom the system is necessary to maintain the cycles ofconcentration in the circulating water system to preventthe build-up of solids. The estimated flow rate during ablowdown event is approximately 4,000 gpm for anapproximate duration of 3-4 hours. The discharge isrouted to the Blowdown Sump Mixing Box which is afinal mixing chamber.

002A/003A - Units I and 2 CoolingTower Overflow to StormDrains

These points are utilized for cooling tower basinoverflow to storm drains. Overflow events occurinfrequently and are generally the result of an operationalproblem with the system. The estimated flow rate in theevent of an overflow of the basins is 2,000 gpm for anapproximate duration of 1-2 hours.

004/005 - Units I and 2 Waste WaterRetention Basins

006 - Sewage Treatment PlantEmergency Overflow

007/008- Units I and 2 Liquid RadwasteSystems Discharge

These points represent the permanent collection basins(420,000 gallon capacity each) for plant low volumewaste streams. The basins provide aeration and retentiontime for the wastes. Each basin has two transfer pumpswhich discharge the effluent to the Blowdown SumpMixing Box. The pumping capacity will all four pumpsrunning is rated at 2,600 gpm.

This point represents the collection point for dischargefrom the plant sewage treatment plant in the event of anemergency. During normal operation, discharge from thesewage treatment plant is routed to the Waste WaterRetention Basins. The discharge during emergencyoverflow is approximately 125 gpm, and emergencyoverflow events occur infrequently.

These points represent wastewater generated in theReactor Building and Auxiliary Building which may beslightly radioactive. Radiologically contaminated fluidsare treated and monitored for radioactivity levels inaccordance with Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC)regulations prior to release. The maximum flow isapproximately 200 gpm (combined for both units).

Vogtle Electric Generating Plant, NPDES No. GA0026786 Page 1 of 2Vogtle Electric Generating Plant, NPDES No. GA0026786 Page I of 2

I . I

Form 2C, Attachment 1 (Continued)Item II.C. Intermittent and Miscellaneous Flows

009 - Nuclear Service Cooling Towers

Outfall Description of Flow

009 - Nuclear Service Cooling Towers(Units I and 2)

010- Radwaste Dilution Flow

011 - Intake Screen Backwash

This point represents the system which supplies coolingwater for safety related equipment. Each-unit has-its ownseparate NSCW system which consists of two coolingtowers. The discharge of each tower is routed to theBlowdown Sumnp Mixing Box. The maximum combinedflow for both units is approximately 500 gpm.

This point represents an internal stream consisting ofriver water with no additives. The discharge is routed tothe Blowdown Sump Mixing Box to provide dilutionwater for radwaste discharges. The maximum flow forthis discharge point is approximately 46,000 gpm.

This point represents a discharge consisting only of riverwater with no additives. The flow is used to backwashthe intake screens, and is returned directly to the IntakeCanal Maximum flow for this discharge point isapproximately 1,256 gpm.

Vogt_ Ecti Geeatn PnNDSN.G006 ae2oVogtle Electric Generating Plant, NPDES No. GA0026786 Page 2 of 2

IL 6. .

Requested Permit Revisions


, .- ^ . .

Submitted by Southern Nuclear Operating CompanyDecember 2003 S"TfHLRNAW.

CO MPAW~y

I's, '

Vogtle Electric Generating Pla NPDES Permit RenewalProposed Changes

The following is a list of the proposed changes to the Vogtle Electric Generating Plant NPDES permit:

--1.-Change-the sampling frequency for outfalls 007 and 008 (Liquid Radwaste System Unit I and Unit 2)from once per quarter to once per six months. Past data indicates that theseedischarges-are---- --

consistently meeting limitations and that more frequent sampling is not warranted.

2. Southern Nuclear requests the addition of the following item to the Special Requirements section ofthe permit.

"In accordance with 40 CFR 122.41 (m)(2), the permitlee may allow any bypass to occur which doesnot cause effluent limitations to be exceeded, but only if it also is for essential maintenance to assureefficient operation. These bypasses are not subject to the provisions ofparagraphs (m)(3) and (m)(4)of 40 CFR 122.41 or section II.A.5 of this permit. Sampling results from a bypass of this nature shallbe reported in a suitably concise format on the quarterly Operation Monitoring Report (OMR) for theperiod in which the bypass occurred."

3. For outfalls 002, 003, 002A, and 003A, change footnote 8 to apply to both Chromium and Zinc. Thischange would be consistent with other South-efWNuclear NPDES permits issued by EPD.

Vogile Electric Generting Plant, NPDES No GA0026786 Page 1 ofVogde Electric Generating Plant, NPDES No. GA0026786 Page I of I

1 4 1 v & �

Whole Effluent ToxicityxChronic TestingSummary Report



SOUTH tiN ACOMPANY

CHRONIC TOXICITY TESTING REPORT

SOUTHERN NUCLEARPLANT VOGTLE EFFLUENT

WAYNESBORO, GEORGIA

Test Period: November 18-25, 2003

Prepared for:

Southern Nuclear

Birmingham, Alabama

December 2003

11

MACTECDecember 3, 2003

Mr. Greg ElmoreSouthern Nuclear40 Inverness Center ParkwayBirmingham, AL 35242Fax: 205-992-6108

Subject: Chronic Toxicity Testing of Southern Nuclear Plant Vogtle Effluent,Waynesboro, Georgia, November 18-25, 2003MACTEC Project 6308-03-0045

Dear Mr. Elmore:

MACTEC Engineering and Consulting, Inc. (MACTEC) BioTox Laboratory has completed multi-concentration chronic toxicity testing using the water flea, Ceriodaphnia dubia, and fatheadminnow, Pimephales promelas, on Southern Nuclear's Plant Vogtle effluent samples collected bySouthern Nuclear personnel November 16-21. 2003.

Plant Vogtle's Instream Waste Concentration (IWC, or the estimated concentration of effluent in thereceiving stream during low flow conditions, 7Q10) designated for the permitted discharge ofeffluent into the receiving stream is 3.18% effluent. Chronic toxicity w as not exhibited to water fleasurvival or reproduction at -the IWC when statistically compared to the control treatment. The NoObservable Effect Concentration (NOEC), or the highest concentration tested that did not exhibitchronic toxicity, wvas 25.4% effluent for water flea survival and reproduction. When the NOEC isless than the hVC, chronic toxicity is indicated in the effluent samples submitted. In -this case, thewater flea NOECs are not less than the IWC; therefore, chronic toxicity was not indicated to thewvater flea in Plant Vogtle's effluent.

Chronic toxicity was not exhibited to fathead minnow survival or growth at the IWC when.statistically compared to the control treatment. The NOEC, therefore, was 100% effluent for fatheadminnow survival and growth. The NOECs for fathead minnow survival and growth are not less thanthe INVC; therefore, chronic toxicity wvas not indicated to the fathead minnow in Plant Vogtleeffluent.

Results are summarized in the accompanying report (55 total pages). All test results containedherein comply with the requirements of the National Environmental Laboratory AccreditationConference (NELAC). A summary of test conditions, as well as chemical and physical data, arelocated in Appendix A (10 total pages). Sample collection locations, dates, times, and temperatures.are located in the attached chain of custody documents in Appendix B (4 total pages). Test organismsource data are located in Appendix C (4 total pages). Raw laboratory data and statistical analysesresults are located in Appendix D (24 total pages).

1 of 8

MACTEC Engineering and Consulting3200 Town Point Drive NW, Suite 100 * Kennesaw, GA 30144

770.421-3400 * Fax: 770.421-3486

*oChronic Toxicity Testing ofSoutlher Nuclear's Plant Vogile Efflueht 8/5-12/03 December 3. 20033 *. ,. MACTEC Project No. 6308-03-0045.01

5 If there are any questions, please do not hesitate to contact Andrew S. Peiken at (770) 421-7027.

Sincerely,

MACTEC ENGINEERING AND CONSULTING, INC.

Andrew S. Peiken, C.E. Margaret . TannerBioTox Laboratory Manager Senior Environmental Engineer

Attachment: Data Report

2of8

Chronic Toxicity Testing of Southern Nuclear's Plant Vogile Effluent 8/5-12/0OI fACTEC Project No. 6308-03-0045.01

TEST SUMMARY

December 3, 2003

I. Client

Facility Tested:

NPDES Number:

Samples Tested:

Southern NuclearPlant VogdeRiver RoadWaynesboro, Georgia 30830

GA0026786

Plant Vogtle Effluent (MACTEC LAB ID # 03-0160-01, 03-0162-01,09-0164-01)

1I. Laboratory Accreditation

Laboratory: BioTox LaboratoryMactec Engineering and Consulting, Inc.3200 Town Point Drive N.W., Suite 100Kennesaw, Georgia 30144

Accreditor: State of Florida, Deptartment. of HealthBureau of Laboratories

Accreditation ID: Lab ID. E87477

Category: Non-Potable Water - Whole Effluent Toxicity

Effective: July 1, 2003 through June 30, 2004

III. Tests Conducted

Test:

Test Dates(Times):

Source/Age ofOrganisms:

Test Concentrations:

Water Flea, Ceriodaphnia dubiaChronic Definitive Survival and Reproduction TestEPA-82 1 -R-02-013, 2002

Fathead minnow, Pimephales promelasChronic Definitive Larval Survival and Growth TestEPA-82 1 -R-02-013, 2002

Water Flea: November 18 (1440) - 24 (1245), 2003Fathead Minnow: November 18 (1500) - 25 (1645), 2003

Water Flea: In-house cultures, ID# CERB01110703 /< 24 hoursFathead minnow: C-K, ID# CS906111803 / < 48 hours

Control, 1.59%, 3.18%, 6.36%, 12.72%, and 25.4% effluent

3of8

i iChronic Toxicity Testing ofSoutheni Nuclear s Plant Vogtle Effluent 8/5-12/03AfAC7EC Project No. 6308-03-0045.01

December 3. 2003

Control Water:

Deviation From Test

Statistical Analyses:

Water Flea: DMW, Diluted Mineral Water, 20-percent Perrier.Fathead minnow: LWC, moderately hard reconstituted fresh water.

None

Toxstat 3.5 (Gulley, 1996)

IV. Results

Survival and Reproduction DataEffluent. November 18-24. 2003.

for Water Fleas Exposed for Six Daysd to Plant Vogtle

% Total Effluent Survival Reproductions

Laboratory Control' 100 18.2

1.59 90 19.2

3.18 100 19.4

6.36 100 20.3

12.72 100 22.9

25.44 100 21.4

NOEC'(% Effluent) - -25.44 - 25.44Prepared by. ASP I 3.'03Checked bvy SEC 12/3/03

'Mean number of young (neonates) per original number of female water fleas, excluding those accidentally killed.b DMW = Diluted Mineral Water, Moderately Hard Synthetic Freshwater'NOEC = No Observable Effect Concentration See Section V. Summary for explanation.d Test ends when 60% of the surviving controls have had third brood.

Survival and Growth Data for Fathead MinnowsEfinient- Nnvember 1 R-25. 2003.

Exposed for Seven Days to Plant Vogtle

% Total Effluent | :Survival. - Growth'

Laboratory Control' 100 0.462

1.59 100 0.509

3.18 100 0.502

6.36 100 0.446

12.72 100 0.415

25.44 90 1 0.442

NOEC'(% Efuent) | 25.44 25.44Prepmared by ASP 12/3/03Checked by. SEC 12/3/03

' Mean dry weight per original number of fish used at test start, excluding those that were accidentally killed ormissing.b LWC = Laboratory Water Control, Moderately Hard Synthetic Freshwaterc NOEC = No Observable Effect Concentration. See Section V. Sununary for explanation.

4of8

Chronic Toxicity Testing of Southern Nuclear's Plant Vogile Effluent 865-12/03 December 3. 2003MACTEC Project No. 6308-03-0045.01

V. Summary

Plant Vogtle's Instream Waste Concentration (IWC, or the estimated concentration of effluent in thereceiving stream during low flow conditions, 7Q10) designated for the permitted discharge ofeffluent into the receiving stream is 3.18% effluent. Chronic toxicity was not exhibited to water fleasurvival or reproduction at the IWC when statistically compared to the control treatment (see Figure1). The No Observable Effect Concentration (NOEC), or the highest concentration tested that didnot exhibit chronic toxicity, was 25.4% effluent for water flea survival and reproduction. When theNOEC is less than the IWC, chronic toxicity is indicated in the effluent samples submitted. In thiscase, the water flea NOECs are not less than the IWC; therefore, chronic toxicity was not indicatedto the water flea in Plant Vogtle's effluent.

Chronic toxicity was not exhibited to fathead minnow survival or growth at the IWC whenstatistically compared to the control treatment (see Figure 2). The NOEC, therefore, was 100%effluent for fathead minnow survival and growth. The NOECs for fathead minnow survival andgrowth are not less than the IVC; therefore, chronic toxicity was not indicated to the fatheadminnow in Plant Vogtle effluent.

VU. Quality Assurance

Ceriodaphnia dubia, NaCI Reference Toxicant, RT#122CCD, 10/21/03Survival: IC 25 = 2,333 mg/L NaCl (ACCEPTABLE)

IC 25 Range of Acceptability = 900 to 3,460 mg/L NaCIReproduction: IC 25 = 823 mg/L NaCI (ACCEPTABLE)

IC 25 Range of Acceptability = 440 to 1,560 mg/L NaCI

Pimephales promelas, NaCI Reference Toxicant, RT# 147CPP, 10/21/03Survival: IC25 = 3,182 mg/L NaCl (ACCEPTABLE)

IC 25 Range of Acceptability = 1,400 to 5,800 mg/L NaCIGrowth: IC25 = 2,135 mg/L NaCI (ACCEPTABLE)

IC2 5 Range of Acceptability = 1,270 to 4,150 mg/L NaCI

5of8

Chronic Toxicity Testing ofSouthern Nuclear s Plant Vogile Effluent 8/5-12/03AMCTEC Project No. 6308-03-004S.01

December 3. 2003i

Acute

Chronic

Chronic

GLOSSARY AND ABBREVIATIONS

Involving a stimulus severe enough to rapidly induce a response; in toxicit-tests, a response observed in 96 hours or less typically is considered acute.

Involving a stimulus that lingers or continues for a relatively long period oftime, often one-tenth of the life span or more. A chronic effect can be lethality,growth, reduced reproduction, etc.

A numeric value representing the geometric mean of the NOEC (No ObservedEffect Concentration) and the LOEC (Lowest Observed Effect Concentration)by chronic toxicity testing. The chronic value is an estimate of the toxicantconcentration that wvill be the actual no effect concentration based on the chroniceffect tested.

Critical Value

DMW

EC

Ft-c

Graphical Method

Minimum numeric value for a toxicity test endpoint (i.e., survival, growth, orreproduction) below which a given test result wvill be statistically significantlydifferent from the control value.

Diluted Mineral Water

Effective Concentration, a point estimate of the toxicant concentration thatwould cause an adverse response such as death, immobilization, or seriousincapacitation.

Foot candles - a measure of light intensity

Log concentration versus percent mortality method. Toxicity test data areplotted on 2-cycle semi-log graph paper. The logarithmic axis Cv axis) is usedfor percent effluent concentration, and the linear axis (x axis) is used for percentmortality. The graph provides a reasonably accurate estimate of the LC50, butdoes not provide a confidence interval.

IC

LC

LC50

LCL

LOEC

LWC

Inhibition Concentration, a point estimate of the toxicant concentration thatwould cause a given percent reduction in a biological measurement such asfecundity or growth.

Lethal Concentration, identical to EC when the observed response is death.

The toxicant concentration that is lethal to 50 percent of exposed organisms at aspecific time of observation.

Lower 95-percent Confidence Limit

Lowest-Observed-Effect-Concentration, the lowest concentration of toxicant towhich organisms are exposed that causes adverse effects.

Lab Water Control, moderately hard synthetic freshwater prepared fromMILLIPORE MILLI-QR water and reagent grade chemicals.

6of8

Chronic Toxicity Testing of Southem ANuclears Plant Vogde Effluent 8,5-12/03M4CTEC Project No. 6308-03-0045.01

December 3. 2003

NOEC No-Observed-Effect-Concentration, the highest concentration of toxicant towhich organisms are exposed that causes no observable adverse effects.

Probit Analyses Probit Analysis consists of a group of statistical methods used to analyze datafrom concentration-response experiments, and provides an estimate of the LC5oand the precision of this estimate. In Probit Analysis, the percentages ofaffected organisms are converted to Probits (probability units), and the effluentconcentrations are converted to logarithms. The relationship between theProbits and the logarithmic values of the concentrations is approximately linear.A Probit regression line drawn through the data points is used to estimate theLC50 and its precision estimate. To use Probit Analysis, at least two partialmortalities must be obtained in the toxicity test.

RWC Receiving Water Control

UCL Upper 95-percent Confidence Limit

pE/m 2/s Micro-ergs per square meter per second - a measure of light intensity

7 of 8

Chronic Toxiciry Testing of Southern Auclear's Plant Vogile Effluent 815-12f03 December 3, 2003MACTEC Project No. 6308-03-0045-02

REFERENCES

Gulley, D.D., and WEST, Inc. 1996. TOXSTAT version 3.5. Fish Physiology and ToxicologyLaboratory. Department of Zoology and Physiology. University of Wyoming. Laramnie,Wyoniing.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 1979. Methods for Chemical Analysis of Water and Wastes.Environmental Monitoring Laboratory, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Cincinnati, OH.

EPA 600/4-79-020.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 1999. Errata for Effluent and Receiving Water Toxicity TestingManuals Acute Toxicity of Effluents and Receiving Waters to Freshwater and MarineOrgasnisms; Shon-Tcrm Methods for Estimatig the Chronic Toxicity of Effluent and ReceivingWaters to Frcshwater Orgarisms; and Short-Term Medtods for Esntiating the Chronic Toxicity ofEffluents and Receiving Waters to Marine and Estuarine Orgaaisms. U.S. EnvironmentalProtection Agency, Office of Research and Development, Duluth, MN. EPAI600/R-98/182.

U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. 2002. Short-term Methods for Estimating the Chronic

Toxicity of Effluents and Receiving Waters to Freshwater Organisms. Fourth Edition.Office of Water (4303T), U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Washington, DC. EPA-

821-R-02-0 13.

8 of 8

FIGURES

-1- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Figure 1. Southern Nuclear Plant Vogtle EffluentWater Flea Chronic Toxicity Test

11/18-24/03

-

C')

100 A 0 0 * 28

--24

80

70 t 20

60Level of Statistical Significance for Survival 16

50__, , __Level of Statistical Significance for Reproduction

1240 -

30 8

20

410

0 IIIIIIII0

0.00 1.59 3.18 4.77 6.36 7.95 9.54 11.13 12.72 14.31 15.90 17.49 19.08 20.67 22.26 23.85 25.44

Effluent Concentration (%)

-4-Survival -- Reproduction |

00

0

r-

I 0.o c

o 0

o) c, m

I I

- m m m m - - - m - -1 -11 -= - - -

Figure 2. Southern Nuclear Plant Vogtle EffluentFathead Minnow Chronic Toxicity Test

11/18-25/03-100 4

90 -

80

I- p

I

I

I

70 -

60 1I"I

I-

W

50

0.60

0.55

�7ev'e--iof Fi-atOt-icai7igrTic-a�7 fir-su-tviva7 0.50

0.45

0.40

7e7lof diaFis Fic-al !7gWicanje fo�Gro7h 0.35

0.30

0.25

0.20

0.15

0.10

0.05

i 0.009.54 11.13 12.72 14.31 15.90 17.49 19.08 20.67 22.26 23.85 25.44

Effluent Concentration

0

E

3:0I-0

40 4

30

20I

10 --

0 i i i i i

0.00 1.59 3.18 4.77 6.36 7.95

I . 0 Survival -*-Growth

APPENDICES

APPENDIX A

Chemical and Physical Data

- -M- - -- - - - - - - - - - - - -

Initial Chemical Characterization of Plant Vogtle Efuent, LWC, and DMW Used in Short-term Chronic Toxicity Tests,November 18-25, 2003.

Parameter 100% Effluent Lab Water Control' Diluted Mineral Waterb

Sampic date 11/16-17/03 11/18-19/03 11/20-21/03 11/18/03 11/18/03

Datc received 11/18/03 11/20/03 11/22/03 11/18/03 11/18/03

Temperature upon receipt (°C) 1.5 2.0 1.0 25.0 25.0

Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L) 8.94 8.92 8.48 7.40 7.74

pH 7.09 8.79 7.31 6.95 6.96

Total Alkalinity as CaCO3 (mg/L) 97.5 167.5 182.5 75.0 77.5

Total Hardness as CaCO3 (mg/L) 56.0 96.0 98.0 92.0 82.0

Conductivity @250C (ttmhos/cm) 358 646 577 327 163

Residual chlorine (mg/L)' 0.07 0.09 0.07 <0.01 <0.01

Ammonia-nitrogen NH3-N (mg/L)' 0.18 0.20 0.41 <0.01 <0.01Unless othcn ise noted, all chemical analsses determined according to EPA 600/4-79-020.

LWC. moderately hard reconstituted fresh watcrb DMW, diluted mineral %water, moderately hard fresh %water¢ Determined bv Hlach Spectrophotometric Test Kit

Prepared by ASP 12/3/03Checked by: SEC 12/13/03

Summary of Toxicity Test Conditions for the Water Flea, Ceriodaphnia dubia, Survival andReproduction Test.

1. Test type:

2. Temperature (0C):

3. Light quality:

4. Light intensity:

5. Photoperiod:

6. Test chamber size:

7. Test solution volume:

8. Renewal of test concentrations:

9. Age of test organisms:

10. No. neonates per test chamber:

11. No. replicate chambers per concentration:

12. No. neonates per concentration:

13. Feeding regime:

14. Aeration:

15. Dilution water:

16. Effluent concentrations:

17. Dilution factor:

18. Test duration:

19. End points:

20. Test acceptability:

Static renewal definitive

23.5-26.0 OC

Ambient laboratory illumination

10-20 iE/m2/s, or 50-100 ft-c

16-hr. light, 8-hr. darkness

30mL

15 mL/replicate

Daily

Newly hatched neonates < 24-hr. old

1

10

10

*Fed 0. I mL each of YCT and algaesuspension per test chamber daily

None

Moderately hard synthetic water isprepared using MILLIPORE MILLI-QRand Perrier.

Control, 1.59%, 3.18%, 6.36%, 12.72%,and 25.4% effluent

0.5

6 days, 60% of control females had 3broods

Survival and reproduction

80% or greater survival in controls;Average of 15 or more young/survivingfemale in the control solutions. At least60% of surviving females in controlsshould have produced their third brood.

Samples are collected daily, and usedwithin 36-hr. of the time they are removedfrom the sampling device

1.0 L per day

21. Sampling requirement:

22. Sample volume required:

Summary of Toxicity Test Conditions for the Fathead Minnow, Pimephales promelas, LarvalSurvival and Growth Test.

1. Test type:

2. Temperature (0C):

3. Light quality:

4. Light intensity:

5. Photoperiod:

6. Test chamber size:

7. Test solution volume:

8. Renewal of test concentrations:

9. Age of test organisms:

10. No. larvae per test chamber:

11. No. replicate chambers per concentration:

12. No. larvae per concentration:

13. Feeding regime:

14. Cleaning:

15. Aeration:

16. Dilution water:

17. Effluent concentrations:

18. Dilution factor:

19. Test duration:

20. End points:

21. Test acceptability:

Static renewal definitive

24.0-26.0OC

Ambient laboratory illumination

10-20 ptE/m 2Is, or 50-100 fl-c

16 hrs. light, 8 hrs. darkness

400mL

250 mL/replicate

Daily

Newly hatched larvae < 24-hr. old

10

4

40

Fed approximately 0.1 to 0.3 mL newlyhatched (less than 24-hr. old) brine shrimpnauplii three times daily. Larvae are notfed during the final 12-hr. of the test.

Siphoned daily, immediately before testsolution renewal

None

Moderately hard synthetic water preparedusing MILLIPORE MILL1-QR and reagentgrade chemicals

Control, 1.59%, 3.18%, 6.36%, 12.72%,and 25.4% effluent

0.5

7 days

Survival and growth (dry weight)

80% or greater survival in controls;Average dry weight of surviving controlsequals or exceeds 0.25 mg.

A minimum of three samples are collectedduring testing

4.0 L per day

a

22. Sampling requirement:

23. Sample volume required:

MACTEC ENGINEERING AND CONSULTING, INC.BIOTOX LABORATORY

DAILY WATER QUALITY DATA(STANDARD EPA CHRONIC TOXCITY TEST)

CLIENT: Southern Nuclear

SAMPLE: Plant Voutle Effluent

LOCATION: Wavnesboro. GA

NPDES NO.: G6t 2 ( 7 f4

TEST TYPE: Cerio Definitive

AERATION REQUIRED: N

TEST CHAMBER SIZE: 30 ml

TEST SOLUTION VOL.: IS en

DILUTION/CONTROL ID: DMWO111703

ORGANISM ID: CERBOI 110703

FOOD TYPE: YCS/Selenastnum

DATE/I1ME ORGANISMS FED: I X Daily

.;ON I a IfI . I

FINAL

AMAIAL~~~

FINIAAL j1 j ___ ___ J.V 1. -. 6

: JN111AL O I.' .. p. 7.I Cl ______ _O

F~. INI AL

FINAL C-S- *, 1 '1. '.0'-I3h M = 0. - 6 . 7/- 77 7/-7' /7

FINAL AK 77 I>r ~7- L <7/ 'f77/7

FINAL -7 L40 -7. 0. &-). -7 6Iii IMAALAL *7 i 7bw-. 7 -I-qo -J- f5

___ NAL_ -,?' 4 . .7 C% S7. I 17<3IR ~ ~ .777/777/</7777 9/777/m/ //

176 of/77/00/0/777777/07/77 /97/777 / 77

RC. //7/7/9////n/7/ //77777/7

D C). 717//77N1/7/ / 77T 1/7C> #///7 -//7777/ /

FIN_.~L'% A~iL. -'I , '.r .+.7'o .

j.u. N LALFINAL.

v. I -7. 2.J I 0- L 1- I 1) QI IA .W ~ "T -7 .3 - I I. I . .1 4 - . - I. - . I . -. - I- I

- , -- ~~I -GA 1 ' .C I I I- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 4 I. ._I I 1-TIA Ii - . I't41 *NLAIAL

FINAL.-T -$ I OA Ko I "I `19 I %~L

-I . I -. *'. I I

A.LKAUNI 1 iUil q7j

m jvtr1AhOlcrz I IAJle

NEONDuclivill lo.I M3t1-

II.A7%pn______

I 00% DO_____-?

Iu n9pn 1.3I00%DO____I UUVQ. 4 07

'.twmg'M uu-. C.,g-

1 00% Do_..iqj


DAILY WATER QUALITY DATA(STANDARD EPA OIRONIC TOXICITY TEST)

I CLIENT: Southern Nuclear

SAMPLE: Plant Voztle EffluentI LOCATION: Wavoesboro. GA

* NPDES NO.: CIA 17,i-'

TEST TYPE: FHM Definitive

AERATION REQUIRED: N

TEST CHAMBER SIZE: 400 ml

TEST SOLUTION VOL: 250 ml

DILUTION/CONTROL ID: LWCO4 111703

ORGANISM ID: CS906111803

FOOD TYPE: artemia

DATE/TIME ORGANISMS FED: 2 X Dailv

IpAiAAhALI . I I oiliffl ji I Al .liq -$I I ollo Aio I *.\t a. A,4 t I I% I A 16'C.3 lf hill-4 aM I LU.%L i'. I l i

I ,uN i ROL: .L TV - . . . . ..:li ~~. .. .. -I _ __ ___ __

FNk I LAL

FINAL.- tI A4b 1 -. Z,-; I < 1 -7 .9, 1 7.Z S I -7Q0 I '7.t I

b .7yr 1 1-2'- 1 -.72 1 7.ac I -t., I US.-l 4 W .2.' Ilik'

~~~.UJ~~~~~~~~iJ~~~~~~AJJ~~~~~~~~h~~~~... -. .~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~4iO - .- -* .m. - --, .. .. . . .

LJ.V. l~iNLALFINAL

-1 6'.4 -i . 6.1 1 -7.'7 J -7.33 I- 4 -�'-�-�--" 4 -,.--- I + - �. 4 4 -�---�--

-, *U57 ;.. K1) 7 C 1'In C I (s. irI r-w.�- 4 � - I -�-��----9 -. 4 - 4 4

pH- Ii iu LALFINAL

Ic" 'OS -1.11 I 7.97 1 -t I (i.1L.- - - I .- 9 I- 4-�"--�.'�- 4 -- -

1 .b1L A\iALiNhi i W/0 U% 7 5HAKUNESS -T1,-. 5 L

uONh)UClIvldl m'. SIhC mg/i Ioh. 0 e7.ss ms, a 1uu,. O .18-

q ' a C.7 1.S

17- 93 ..0 'i I 7. ZL

(-41, USI/c^ S'7 7 -,' I&-.

o C" ..' 7

100% DOH1I00/ pHL -00100%1DO 1-nDloo/- PH_:3�1001/0 DO -ir

* MACTEC ENGINEERING AND CONSULTINGBIOTOX LABORATORY

* TITRIMETRIC BENCH SHEETPARAMETER: HARDNESS METHOD REFERENCE: EPA 130.2I REAGENT REFERENCES: ANALYST: $ CC

1) BUFFER: 429 STANDARD REFERENCE: BKII p. 142

2) CALMAGITE: 228 CURVE REFERENCE: HRD061603

3) 0.020 N DISODIUM EDTA: 478 CLIENT: Southern Nuclear

SAMPLE - LAB DATE' :SAEPLE: V B1T V~iNAL VTOTAL STD BLK CONCSAMPLE VOLUME (n) L) (mL) CORR CORR (mgfL)ID NO., -+mg/l +1-F I

DMW 11/18/03 25/50 0 J * 0 _- L l.LWC 11/18/03 25/50 0 . 0DI Blank 11/18/03 25/50 0 d 0c.I 50 mng/L Std. 11/18/03 25/SO 0 a.55 0100% Vogte Eff. 03-cG to- el 11/18/03 25/50 0 ; I 0100% Vogtle Eff. O, ol - L * " 11/20/03 25/50 0 C) V jJW 0 _4100% Vogtle Eff. t,3- Cib,1- Ce 11/22/03 25/50 0 ; ______ 0

I _____( ._CO . __

I _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _

I _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 1__ _ _ _ _ _

I fVtotal + (BLANK CORR + STD CORR)J x 50,000 x Ntit rantMg/L HARDNESS =

SAMPLE VOLUME

REV'IEWED BY! O

DATE: igi/31

MACTEC ENGINEERING AND CONSULTING

BIOTOX LABORATORY

SPECTROPHOTOMETRIC BENCH SHEET

~~~ *~~~.*. . ..***. ..... ..

1'-FMTE~t CH 'OR ....E . . .............. ..iE.E GT : 30Ji ~*.. PARAMCTE~ ... - E 5.,.s S..:.f . ...

M;ETHOD: HACH PROCEDURE' . . ... .x'fS S INSTRUMENT ID: HACH DORI2SOD :.:..~:.:HA ' '

ANALYST: CURVE REFERENCE: CL2061603

STANDARD REFERENCE: 461 REAGENT REFERENCES:

CLIENT: Southem Nuclear 1 DPDAccuVac. #474

LWDATE: 11/18/03

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. . . ....... }

DIBlank 11118/03 9i7e-Y2 0

0.590 mg/L Std. _ 11/18/03 0ft ( 0 'S .

100% VogtleEff. 63 - i bi - al 11/18/03 T8. 0 b'7 0

100% VogtleEff. 0 3 -' k, Z -it 11/20103 gs-L o-o9 q 0 o I

l00% Vogtle Eff. 2-&oi- -ok 11/22/03 S845 o-c73 0

MgtL CHLORINE =[ (MgfL CURVE x CELL CORR) + (STANDARD + BLANK CORR) I

REVEIWED BY: QO;P

DATE: _________

MACTEC ENGINEERING AND CONSULTING

BIOTOX LABORATORYSPECTROPHOTOMETRIC BENCH SHEET

PARAMETER: AMMONIA WAVELENGTH: 425 NM

METHOD: HACH "PROCEDURES 8038 INSTRUMENT ID.HACH DR/2500

ANALYST: CURVE REFERENCE: NH3051503

STANDARD REFERENCE: Bk II, pg 148 REAGENT REFERENCES:

CLIENT: Southern Nuclear I) NESSLER RGT: #424

.________________________________ 2) MINERAL STABILIZER: 441 3) PVA: 440

SAMPLE: D SAM DAE / T I ,MG CELL: : STD/BLK FINAL-1D NO. :;::CURVE.:: .. CORR CO. . CONC

.FACTOR: . (MG/L)

DMW _ 11/18/03 7 1.( 0 c ___

LWC - 11/18/03 |&1o teai 01.5 mg/L Std. 11/18/03 7 ,33 I-( 0 I.DI Blank _ 11/18/03 7 &,-, 0 o T __ __

100%Vogtle o33-c6i-oi 11/18/03 (7 3.6 0- I_ _ 0 0

100%Vogtle 073-oz62-O' 11/20/03 | -. o o 0 _____3 _

100% Vogtle o3- o b6,-o 11/21/03 1 -i7 _ 0 42Ot0

Mg/L AMMONIA = [(Mg/L CURVE x CELL CORR) + (STANDARD + BLANK CORR)]

REVIEWED BY: aV9DATE: n/pg -J

MACTEC ENGINEERING AND CONSULTINGBIOTOX LABORATORY

. TITRIMETRIC BENCH SHEETPARAMETER: ALKALINITY :METHOD REFERENCE: EPA 310.1D REAGENT REFERENCES: ANALYST: 5 P (I

1) 0.02 N H2SO4: 454 STANDARD REFERENCE: BKII p. 141CURVE REFERENCE: ALK061603

CLIENT;: 5CJ4. o _____e

SAMPLE ID LAB ID DATE SAMPLE..: V VINAL VTOTAL STD BLK CONC.NO. . : VOLUME,: (mL: (mL) (niL) CORR CORR (mg/L)N o._ .::. : . . - (+1-) : (+1-)

DMW _ 11/18/03 20/40 0 1 . 6 0 -' T '77.rLWC 11/18/03 20/40 0 I Js I- SIX 0 ._._1So12D mg/L Std. 11/18/03 20/40 0 Z- tex 2*r- . 0 ___3o

DI Blank _ 11/18/03 20/40 0 O ' C. Sz 0 Z O * ,100%Vogtle v3-Oi6 c e 11/18/03 20/40 0 , 0 = = 9.I100% Vogtle o; * O6/- I 11/20/03 20/40 0 Y 0 I z_ *S100% Vogtle c;i- c/ C- 11/22/03 20/40 0 . 0

_ _ _ __= _ _

I .___ =______ ______ _ ____ ,___

IVtotal + (BLANK CORR + STD CORR)] x 50,000 x NtitrantMg/L ALKALINITY =

SAMPLE VOLUME

REVIEWED BY: q44

DATE: I- I U'3

APPENDIX B

Chain of Custody Records

w ,A N° 05129MACTEC ENGINEERING AND CONSULTINGBIOTOX LABORATORY3200 Town Point Drive NW, Suite 100Kennesaw, GA 30144(770) 421-3312 - FAX (770) 421-3314

CLIENTINFORMATION

NAME OF FACILITY: S N C( - tor

STREET ADDRESS ?O. 'tSi. \ (kZdC .~ ElCIlYISTATE: vi ft4&5 &1f2. C'4 A zPip, .

NPDES o (NATIONAL ORSTTE) G P _La79C|

PROJECT NAME MACTEC PROJECINb~t$ *

StIC_- Cloru A Z11.-7 Z t

SAMPLERS (SIGNATURE) SAMPLERS INITIAl

-. + . __ _ .. .. . . _ .SAMPLES SHIPPED VIA:

FEDEX V UPS HAND . . OTHER

II ___________________________________________________________________________________

.S (PRINT)

SAMPLE INFORMATION

GRAB SAMPLES: DATEfTIME VOL_

TIME COMPOSITE: STARTDATE1It' f'i 3 STARTTIMEoabOe

ENDDATE l- ENDTIME O1vCW

VOLUME OF SUBSAMPLES UeC Ct TIME INCREMENT _kourl_ _

TOTAL VOL________

FLOW-PROPORTIONED COMPOSITE: INITIATED

ENDED TOTAL VOL

SET VOL OF SU8SAMPLE I VOL FLOW

FIELD PARAMETERS

GRAB SAMPLES: pH

DO (mg/I) TEMP CC) _ _

CHLORINE (resdirual. mg/L)

COMPOSITES: pH (asl grab) V ¢

CHLORINE (residual lasil grab. mg)L) 0 OTEMP (last rab C)_ _ _

pH(composlled smrpe. C) F I

TEMP (composld sample, C) 3'

Ift o

COOLANT USED: ___ _ _ SHIP DATE ,e I- I- o3

DATE TIME GRAB COMPOSITE MATRIX SAMPLE STATION DESCRIPTION TOTALIOF CONTAINER TYPE I NUMBER ^' BIOTOX USE ONLY,"

(X) (X) CONTAINERS I OALLON 7 2UTER _1UTER T OTHER ; TEMP )Cj ':U

IELINOUISHEDo , DATE/TIME RECEIVED BY. DATE/TIME RELINQUISHED BY: RECE7?BY BORAT YI DATEITIME

(IN R -W 1S7IG5AURE 1 (SIGOTURE- (ARE 1________3(ItGNATURE). ( SIGNATURE) (SIGNATURE) |(SIGNATURE) O 1? r.-|

FOR VARIABLE VOLUME SUBSAMPLES BASED ON FLOW OR SET TIME INCREMENTS. ATTACH SAMPLE AND FLOW INFORMATION.

BIOTOXUSEONLY. ,,* <'-;'.-.', -' *'-'

ICE PRESENT? -_iE -pH -' SD ' D. CONDUCiTPA' VIS:AL' �1**MATRIX

WATER. W SLUDGE- SL

SOIL -SO OTHER . NA

Il SEDIMENT- SD IDistributon: OrtgInal Copy Accompany Sample ro Laboratory. Yellow Copy Retained By Sampler.

F1008-A 8/03.r

r - N2 05131MACTEC ENGINEERING AND CONSULTINGBIOTOX LABORATORY3200 Town Point Drive NW, Suite 100Kennesaw, GA 30144(770) 421-3312 * FAX (770) 421-3314

CLIENTINFORMATION

NAMEOFFACILRy: S'4L( -Vc6GfL.E

STREETADDRESS:O t '60 ; )O' U ( Rw- F )ICITYISTATE: %A 9I`4NQ& o , 4GN ztp g_3NPDES U (NATIONAL OR STATE): A &9 2 6 7846

PROJECT NAME

c - xi0TLE-SAMPLERS (SIGNATURE)

WJ t -8ch

MACTEC PROJECT #

SAMPLERS INITIALS (PRINT)

'-I-

SAMPLE INFORMATION

GRAB SAMPLES: DATEITIME VOL_ _

TIME COMPOSITE: STARTDATE Ikej-o3 STARTTIME_ ____

END DATE I1 C0 3 END TIME | uVOLUME OF SUBSAMPLES l TIME INCREMENT.Lt* "6TOTAL VOL....4oL.

FLOW-PROPORTIONED COMPOSITE: INmATED_ _

ENDED TOTAL VOL

SrT VnO OF SDIBFSAUMPLE I V t FOW

FIELD PARAMETERS

GRAB SAMPLES: pH

DO (mgl)_ _ TEMP CC)

CHLORINE (resdkual. mgtL)

COMPOSITES: pH (last grab)

CHLORINE (residul, last grab, mgIL)

TEMP (last grab. 'C)

pH (composied sample. C)

TEMP (womposlled sample. 'C)

___

SAMPLES SHIPPED VIA:FEDEX N/ UPS HAND___ OTHER

COOLANT USED: _ _ _ _ _ SHIP DATE I \ - let -o3

DATE TIME GRAB COMPOSITE MATRIX SAMPLE STATION DESCRIPTION TOTAL I OF CONTAINER TYPE I NUMBER11 . BIOTOX USE ONLY :.

(X) (X) CONTAINERS 1 OALLON 2 UTER I i UTER OTHER :TEMP ('C) LABS

iwoo V.4 FlMM. eFFLUG14iT 0 3

PELINCUISHED BY: DATE/TIME RECEIVED BY. OATE/TIME RELtNOrSHED BY. |R VDB OTDRYI DATEITIME1 nitl | rI f | III |illtt

(SIGNATURE) SCt | (SIGNATURE) (SIGNATURE) (SIGNATURE)-F O R _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ V A R I A B L E_ _ V O U M IUS M P E ( SIAA T R E O N_ _ _ ( SO WN A T U R E)IM E I N R M N S A T Cq x~ N L W N O M T OFOR VARIABLE VOLUME SUBSAMPt ES BASED ON FLOW OR SET TIME INCREMENTS. ATTACH SAMPLE AND FLOW INFORMATION

ICE PRESENT? YES I N . RE 6L DO CON . VISUAL

WATER -W

SOIL - SO

SLUDGE - SL

OTHER-NA

D1stribuffon: OrIgInal Copy Accompany Sample To Laboratory. Yellow Copy Retalned By Sampler.

F1008-A *8103Li SEDIMENT- SD

Cr 4TIE - & HtU-D - - - - - -N2 05130

MACTEC ENGINEERING AND CONSULTINGBIOTOX LABORATORY3200 Town Point Drive NW, Suite 100Kennesaw, GA 30144(770) 421-3312 * FAX (770) 421-3314

CLIENT

INFORMATION

NAME OF FACILITY: •N C, VL6 tGL1STREETADDRESS: V P° OX I 56sClTYtSTATE: &4j4/ i'Ld 4 6A ZIP: 3c'Y33NPDES C (NATIONAL OR STATE): G A oa I- ,72?G

.1PROJECT NAME MACTEC PROJECT #

Vo/L6 -L-s

SAMPLERS (SIGNATYRl SAMPLERS INITIAL

1; .m .g . _.._ .f14SAMPLES SHIPPED VIA:

FEDEX V/ UPS HANDO __ OTHER

.S (PRINT)

SAMPLE INFORMATION

GRAB SAMPLES: DATETIME _ VOL_ _

TIME COMPOSITE: STARTDATE II_2c -e STARTTIME____

ENDDATE Ift-2- ENDTIME Q'CO z,VOLUME OF SUBSAMPLES .3'g Z2I TIME INCREMENT/k

TOTALVOL f '1FLOW-PROPORTIONED COMPOSITE: INITIATED_ _

ENDED _ TOTAL'VOL_

FIELD PARAMETERS

GRAB SAMPLES: pH

DO (mgt)) TEMP CC)

CHLORINE (resdual, mg/t)

COMPOSITES: pH (last grab)

CHLORINE (residual. last grab, m/gL)

TEMP (laos grab, *C)

pH (composkled sample. *C) _

TEMP (conionasied seamle. *C)

COOLANT USED: _ _CC_ SHIP DATE II% -7_% -0 5_

- - - _______________ fl cc, vt~t.. ~,r ouoon,.rI , VhJL. r b~bLtjVUtLV ._ .. ____,_,_,_____

DATE TIME GRAB COMPOSITE MATRIX- SAMPLE STATION DESCRIPTION TOTAL I OF CONTANER TYPE I NUMBER <', BIOTOX USE ONLY.--:. '(x) (X) CONTAINERS IGALLON | 2UITER I 1LITER | OTHER ".TEMP'C) ,..,.LAB I

,z= 13 Li j(r o;:i;

tvUN~tWYQ |ODATEITIME |RECEIVED BY: DATEITIME REULNOUISHED BY: |RE RAEDqABORATY I ATE/TIME

ISIGNATURE) I _____ I S S I I II______ I| ~~~(SIGNATURE) ( O SIGNATURE) (SIGNATURE) |(SIGNATURE)

-FOR VARIABLE VOLUME SUBSAMPLES BASED ON FLOW OR SET TIME INCREMENTS, ATTACH SAMPLE AND FLOW INFORMATION

|sIOTox USE ONLY .. ,,'ts 3'>' ' ;,^ !; * Xsi.,* - s ,.*' ,; , ; .,,

.W I N .'RESIDUALCL __________ _____VSUALICE PRESENT? IN PHO COUCiI______VSA_____

- I*'MATRIX

WATER-W SLUDGE-SIL

SOIL-SO OTHER-NA

Il * SEDIMENT-SO IDistribution: Original Copy Accompany Sample To Laboratory. Yellow Copy Retained By Sampler.

F1008-A 8/03

APPENDIX C

Test Organism Documents

MACTEC Engineering and Consulting, Inc.BioTox Laboratory

Ceriodaphnia dubia In-house Culture Source Document

Brood Board ID Brood Board Date/Time Cups . Age of Test Water Food TypeNo. Date Marked Organisms Type/Temp.

.__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (OC )CERBO 1 10703 11/07/03 11/18/03 0900 <24-hr DMW /25.0 YCT &

Selenastrum


Pimephales promelas In-house Culture Source Document

Larvae Batch Source Hatch Date Age of Test Water Food Type

ID No. Organisms Type/Temp.

CS9 6111803 C-K 11/17/03 <48-hr LWC / 25.0 Arnemia

I.I1C-KI * A S S 0 C I Al7 E S -

ENVIRONMENTAL & ENGINEERING-CONSULTANTS

I

17170 PERKINS ROADBATON ROUGE, LA 70810

PH (225) 75S- 1000FAX (225) 755-2042

hUT p://wwwI C-LoR

AouAnc ToxIcoLoGy LAWEATOR

Test Organism Shipment Record-

Shipped to: Hai c Project*. b 55 -4aDate Shipped: II - 1i-03 P.O.#: ________ ___

Species: *. SenGdYL" Quantity: (4C /Price each: 25¢/, ?Z9' jI

Age/Lifestage: c24 ag Price Batch #: 33Y/ / /eQ3

Broodstock Source: C-K Associates, Inc.

Feeding: a4e4rM&-'

Water Chemistry Record

___Freshwater Species Marine Species

Alkalinity (mg/L):.. D . Alkalinity (mglL):_

Hardness (mg/L): 94 Salinity (ppt):

Comments: ,. J

I

Billing Information(This is not an invoice. You will be billed separately.)

I

Organism Price: I 8 City tax (5%) - State tax (4%) -

Shipping Charge: - (if not billed directly to recipient's Fed Ex account)

Shipment Total:______

Effective February 2001, C-K Associates, Inc. will mail you an invoice for the total amount of all|purchases made within the month. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact us. |

Thank You

oiJ / '

reV olrcS5

test organism shipment record.doc

I IIIIIIiIII APPENDIX D

I Laboratory Test Data Sheets and Statistical Analyses

'III

III

I

Fathead Minnow

Effluent Test


7-day Fathead Minnow Larval Survival and Growth Test(EPAI421 -R-02-013, 1000.0)

Client:Location:Sample:Minnow l.D. #:

Southern NuclearWaynesboro, GAPlant Vogtle Effluent

Test Location:INC # L03Shelf # CL...

CS906111803.

- . -. -. . ': ...-.Surviving Organisms (alive/dead)Day

0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

ConcentratiouiRep. #

date: ills 13lime: j5jc,

init: t

date:atl lo3

time: 155f

init: CvA*

date: q . j zIJ3time: I1U

.inH: 4

date:%lz.161

lime: i StinH: 1,V

date: t'|

time: ,, ;I

init: all

date: 1112)

time: II, -L,

ini: Q'1

date: itp.

time: I S rt 'int: ao/-

dale: (f(2i

time: lb-ir

init: o1 0% Survival1.� '- 13

1I /0O 10 1.J ' tJ

LWCto' to10 . I 1 .I

.a __I __ _ I -_.. I__ I _ I_ _ .I I a

.~~~~~I 25iiI0 '.

Temp CC) ZS 2 L. . Lt ru 2Js "S1 ) s rI 10 I I.. I-) (J t i

1.59%2 2 i ij la IO 10 (o (. I ;J I I3o O tj to I (J I (J I '(J I *#

4 . , , . -, I I4 I O I II _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ __ _ lo I II t. __ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

I tV

[Temp (C) Z7 L t k 17 r 2S1 jo o jL If j_ [o j -t j .0 j j

1 2 11 _ o I I (O II|3-18% | 3 la 1 I0 fitto1 | IC _I iJ t

(IWC) I 4 la _ ' to 34I |~~~~Temp(°CC| 1 4 S- 2 q 1 4 T fS T2 |2~

1 B 2 ,11 -ia.I....-I j I 1D I * I AI IJ I C I6.36% | 3 11 /J Lo _ _ |

I I ~~~~4 Jo to 11Temp CC) __ | ZC. | r -L L .| 2sr | __ __

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (o I 0 C C _| _r _ _

I 1 ~ ~2 j1 o ~ (#3 __ __ _ * **o 1 ie __ __ _ ' .., I 1

12.72% 3 11 '_ ;_ _ 1 1

4 13 I

Temp CC) 2V I _ _L _ _ | z __ __ I ___| _ z*L _ I _ s_11

[ ~~~~~I inl I ;VI _I I I :' 71 II

I I ~~~~2 in I" I{ 1ZFIs I25.4% 3 :3 I I I _I _I _ 13 _ 1' 13 10 j

I 4 1T __to LO I1_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

l |~~~~Temp (CC) Z@ U t; I | Z -if |Z Z. I _i |Z ( | 25 l

Sample ID:Comments:

c03-. 11, -ot


Laboratory weight data for larval survival and growth test

Client:

Discharge:

Location:

Southern Nuclear Test Dates: 11/18-25/03

VogticEffluent o3 *'I -01,03 °)4& 4)rganism: P.promelas. CS906111803

Wavnesboro. GA

Drying Temp.: .35 C

Drying Time: -2 .r A-

Analyst(s): 9 ..:f

.~ ~ ~ - .

Conc.: ReplicateNo.

Weight of.boat(gms)

Conc.: I Q.-~75 .s z-22 0. 97 Z-5

LWC 3 O.q74 44 OA1-; 5 c,0

Conc.: 1 .97(z2

1.59% 3

Cone.. r- 97t 7 22 e. * 7 ZU.

3.18% 3 e.q w,

Conc.: I C.q1910 t,2 0.•1/ 6Z..

6.36%,3 C k/4 r,.TF24 f

Conc.: I . 46 32 61q9J7"3 _

12.720% 3 opy374 6a1777 ci

Conc.: I ~ y 7

2 OD.975'7

25.44% 3 .i 94 w.

Dryweight Total dry Original Mean dryboat and ':weight of Number weight per rep.

larvae larvae of original number(gmns) (gms) larvac of larvae

Idav (in)

C.9o y0 7 / ( a/

0- f7S3 77 V .|

a fF37Y l 2

?75lcyS F |2

0-95s / // 7/ .7/

ODfo. ./ - UIINZO J/

Mean dryweight per

conc. originalnumber larvae

.... ,,*

Oven Times*in Out

Dot*: Dow.:

Is(


Laboratory weight data for larval survival and growth test

Client:

Discharge:

Location:

Southern Nuclear

Vogtle Effluent

Wavnesboro. Ga

Test Dates: 1/1 8-25/03

Organism: P. promelas. CS906111803

Sample ID: 03-0161-01. 03-0162-01.03.0164-01

Drying Temp.: 59 C

Drying Time: 24 hours

Analyst(s): ASPIMRF

Weight of:: Dry weight: Total dry Original Mean dry Mean dry Oven TimesConc.: Replicate boat . boat and weight of Number. weight per rep. weight per In Out

No. (gins) larvae larvae:, of original number conc., original(gmns) (gins) larvae of larvae number larvae Date: Date:

Jdav 01 (mg) (me) 12s2z03 I1J26-2DO3

Conc.: 1 0.97592 0.98046 0.00454 1 0 0.454 1645 1700

2 0.97254 0.97583 0.00329 10 0.329 1645 1700

LWC 3 0.97468 0.98008 0.00540 1 0 0.540 0.462 1645 1700

4 0.97850 0.98374 0.00524 10 0.524 1645 1700

Conc.: 1 0.97609 0.98104 0.00495 10 0.495 1645 1700

2 0.97705 0.98154 0.00449 10 0.449 1645 1700

1.59% 3 0.96851 0.97427 0.00576 10 0.576 0.509 1645 17004 0.97844 0.98358 0.00514 10 0.514 1645 1700

Cone.: 1 0.96737 0.97208 0.00471 1 0 OA71 1645 1700

2 0.97263 0.97791 0.00528 10 0.528 1645 1700

3.18% 3 0.96489 0.96963 0.00474 10 0.474 0.502 1645 1700

4 0.97193 0.97726 0.00533 10 0.533 1645 1700

Cone.: 1 0.97096 0.97559 0.00463 1 0 0.463 1645 1700

2 0.97162 0.97590 0.00428 1 0 0.428 1645 1700

6.36% 3 0.96710 0.97162 0.00452 1 0 0.452 0.446 1645 1700_ 4 0.98225 0.98667 0.00442 10 OA42 1645 1700

Cone.: 1 0.96633 0.97036 0.00403 10 0.403 1645 1700

2 0.96231 0.96676 0.00445 10 0.445 1645 1700

12.72% 3 0.97832 0.98239 0.00407 10 0.407 OA15 1645 17004 0.97729 0.98135 0.00406 10 OA06 1645 1700

Cone.: 1 0.98575 0.98967 0.00392 10 0.392 1645 1700

2 0.97570 0.97999 0.00429 10 0.429 1645 1700

25.44% 3 0.97043 0.97505 0.00462 1 0 0.462 0.442 1645 1700._________ 4 0.96766 0.97251 0.00485 10 0.485 1645 1700

Prepaired byReviewed by

(ID g1z1Z6< 4d i// 2

V A

Title: Southern Nuclear Plant Vogtle Eff. 11/18/03 FHM SurviveFile: 111803 .PPS Transform: ARC SINE(SQUARE ROOT(Y))

Number of Groups: 6

GRP IDENTIFICATION REP VALUE TRANS VALUE

1 0 LWC 1 1.0000 1.41201 0 LWC 2 1.0000 1.41201 0 LWC 3 1.0000 1.41201 0 LWC 4 1.0000 1.41202 1.59 t 1 1.0000 1.41202 1.59 % 2 1.0000 1.41202 1.59 t 3 1.0000 1.41202' 1.59 01 4 1.0000 1.41203 3.18 c 1 1.0000 1.41203 3.18 % 2 1.0000 1.41203 3.18 % 3 1.0000 1.41203 3.18 % 4 1.0000 1.41204 6.36 % 1 1.0000 1.41204 6.36 t 2 1.0000 1.41204 6.36 % 3 1.0000 1.41204 6.36 % 4 1.0000 1.41205 12.72 1 1.0000 1.41205 12.72 t 2 1.0000 1.41205 12.72 % 3 1.0000 1.41205 12.72 ! 4 1.0000 1.41206 25.4 1 0.7000 0.99126 25.4 i 2 0.9000 1.24906 25.4 ' 3 1.0000 1.41206 25.4 6 4 1.0000 1.4120

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

...

Title: Southern Nuclear Plant Vogtle Eff. 11/18/03 FHM SurviveI File: 111803 .PPS Transform: ARC SINE(SQUARE ROOT(Y))

Summary Statistics on Transformed Data TABLE 1 of 2

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -GRP IDENTIFICATION N MIN MAX MEAN

1 0 LWC 4 1.4120 1.4120 1.4120I. 2 1.59 % 4 1.4120 1.4120 1.41203 3.18 ' 4 1.4120 1.4120 1.41204 6.36 16 4 1.4120 1.4120 1.4120

* 5 12.72 % 4 1.4120 1.4120 1.41206 25.4 % 4 0.9912 1.4120 1.2661

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

B Title: Southern Nuclear Plant Vogtle Eff. 11/18/03 FHM SurviveFile: 111803 .PPS Transform: ARC SINE(SQUARE ROOT(Y))

j Summary Statistics on Transformed Data TABLE 2 of 2

GRP IDENTIFICATION VARIANCE SD SEM C.V. %

1 0 LWC 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00002 1.59 % 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000o 3 3.18 ' 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000I 4 6.36 t 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.00005 12.72 '0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000

* 6 25.4 % 0.0395 0.1987 0.0994 15.6960


Shapiro - Wilk's Test for Normality

D = 0.1185W = 0.4845

Critical W = 0.8840 (alpha = 0.01 , N = 24)W = 0.9160 (alpha = 0.05 , N = 24)

Data FAIL normality test (alpha = 0.01). Try another transformation.

Warning - The first three homogeneity tests are sensitive to non-normalityand should not be performed with this data as is.


Hartley's Test for Homogeneity of VarianceBartlett's Test for Homogeneity of Variance

These two tests can not be performed because at least one group haszero variance.

Data FAIL to meet homogeneity of variance assumption.Additional transformations are useless.

;


Steel's Many-One Rank Test - Ho: Control<Treatment

TRANSFORMED RANK CRIT. SIG'GROUP IDENTIFICATION MEAN SUM VALUE DF 0.05 \

1 0 LWC 1.41202 1.59 %-0 1.4120 18.00 10.00 4.03 3.18 q 1.4120 18.00 10.00 4.04 6.36 % 1.4120 18.00 10.00 4.05 12.72 % 1.4120 18.00 10.00 4.006 25.4 ' 1.2661 14.00 10.00 4.00

Critical values are 1 tailed ( k = 5 )

, N D/

Title: Southern Nuclear Plant Vogtle Eff. 11/18/03 FHM Growth

File: 111803 .PPG Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION

Number of Groups: 6

GRP IDENTIFICATION REP VALUE

111122223.-333444455556666

0 LWC0 LWC0 LWC0 LWC

1.59 %1.59 %1.59 9

1.59 '

3.18 %3.18 %3.18 %3.18 !6.36 6

6.36 '

6.36 a6.36 '

12.72 6

12.72 t12.72 %12.72 t25.4 6

25.4 %25.4 '

25.4 6

0.45400.32900.54000.52400.49500.44900.57600.51400.47100.52800.47400.53300.46300.42800.45200.44200.40300.44500.40700.40600.39200.42900.46200.4850

TRANS VALUE_____________

0.45400.32900.54000.52400.49500.44900.57600.51400.47100.52800.47400.53300.46300.42800.45200.44200.40300.44500.40700.40600.39200.42900.46200.4850

Ql P & L 41 . I-e P-

Title: Southern Nuclear Plant Vogtle Eff. 11/18/03 FHM GrowthFile: 111803 .PPG Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION

Summary Statistics on Data TABLE 1 of 2

I - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -GRP IDENTIFICATION N MIN MAX MEAN

I 1 0 LWC 4 0.3290 0.5400 0.46182 1.59 % 4 0.4490 0.5760 0.50853 3.18 % 4 0.4710 0.5330 0.50154 6.36 ' 4 0.4280 0.4630 0.44635 12.72 % 4 0.4030 0.4450 0.41536 25.4 ' 4 0.3920 0.4850 0.4420

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -_ _ _ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

| Title: Southern Nuclear Plant Vogtle Eff. 11/18/03 FHM GrowthFile: 111803 .PPG Transform: NO TRANSFORMATION

5 Summary Statistics on Data TABLE 2 of 2

I GRP IDENTIFICATION VARIANCE SD SEM C.V. ''

1 0 LWC 0.0092 0.0961 0.0480 20.80282 1.59 R 0.0028 0.0526 0.0263 10.3496I 3 3.18 t 0.0011 0.0336 0.0168 6.69414 6.36 Il 0.0002 0.0149 0.0074 3.33575 12.72 %t 0.0004 0.0199 0.0100 4.7937

1 6 25.4 % 0.0016 0.0405 0.0202 9.1603- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

------


ANOVA Table

SOURCE DF SS MS F_______________________________________________________________________-____

Between 5 0.0262 0.0052 2.0455

Within (Error) 18 0.0461 0.0026_________________________________________________--____________ ________-___

Total 23 0.0724

(p-value = 0.1204)

Critical F = 4.2479 (alpha = 0.01, df = 5,18)= 2.7729 (alpha = 0.05, df = 5,18)

Since F < Critical F FAIL TO REJECT Ho: All equal (alpha = 0.05)


Shapiro - Wilk's Test for Normality

D = 0.0461W = 0.9401

Critical W = 0.8840 (alpha = 0.01 , N = 24)W = 0.9160 (alpha = 0.05 , N = 24)

Data PASS normality test (alpha = 0.01). Continue analysis.


Bartlett's Test for Homogeneity of Variance

Calculated B1 statistic = 11.2234 (p-value = 0.0471)

Data PASS BI homogeneity test at 0.01 level. Continue analysis.

____________________________________________________________________________

Critical B = 15.0863 (alpha = 0.01, df = 5)= 11.0705 (alpha = 0.05, df = 5)


Dunnett's Test - TABLE 1 OF 2 Ho:Control<Treatment------------------------------------------------------------------- fD

TRANSFORMED MEAN CALCULATED IN SIGGROUP IDENTIFICATION MEAN ORIGINAL UNITS T STAT 0.0'

1 0 LWC 0.4618 0.46182 1.59 't 0.5085 0.5085 -1.30583 3.18 % 0.5015 0.5015 -1.11034 6.36 % 0.4463 0.4463 0.43295 12.72 t 0.4153 0.4153 1.29886 25.4 % 0.4420 0.4420 0.5517

Dunnett critical value = 2.4100 (1 Tailed, alpha = 0.05, df = 5,18)


Dunnett's Test - TABLE 2 OF 2 Ho:Control<Treatment

NUM OF MIN SIG DIFF % OF DIFFERENCEGROUP IDENTIFICATION REPS (IN ORIG. UNITS) CONTROL FROM CONTROL

_ _- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --_ - - - - - - - - - - - - - - --__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _-__ _ _ _-__ _

I

1 0 LWC 42 1.59 0i 4 0.0863 18.7 -0.04673 3.18 % 4 0.0863 18.7 -0.03974 6.36 i 4 0.0863 18.7 0.01555 12.72 % 4 0.0863 18.7 0.04656 25.4 % 4 0.0863 18.7 0.0198

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __- -_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __-- - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _

Ia 1

Water Flea

Effluent Test

I . _Client Southern NucfearIDischargePlant Voatle Effluent

ILocation Waynesboro, GA

Cup #1 DMW Cup;

MACTEC ENGINEERING AND CONSbLTING, INC.BIOTOX LABORATORY

Daily survival and reproduction data for ceriodaphnia dubia chronic test

Dilution Water 1D:C. dubia Source ID:

Template ID:

Cup #3 3.18%

DMW01111703

CERB01 110703

Cup 1#4 = 6.36%

Test Set-up Date (day 0): fll/ 81/0?Test Set-up Time: ___________

Test Set-up Analyst: gad_______

Cup#5 = 12.72% Cup N6 = 25.44%112= 1.59%

Day 1' Day2_________ Day 3: I Day 4: .jj2I-, . Day 5:...4,3ail.. Day6:j4W ..... Day 7:rime-jjill &I Tmne:_________ . Time:__________ Tim 6 Tie-.1. Tiwne: .u.±r.... Time:_____

/C~- t%%P W,,t~. rid.." . IntMO. -M ~ . - Infr ... e lnit.. b.Pi ... Initq-* a - . Inft,

Ur m fl n Pmhrvn A" iv Mul. At. . : r .- .MA=melwnut .fl rudduSA = mnmll Aiduft

ay~ Cup 6 Cupi -6-Cup2S Cup 36 : Cup .6 ::Cup 6S Day --CuplO .Cup 20 .Cup 30 Cup 40O Cup60 1 Cup go

0 e -__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 1. I _ _ _

_ _ 6 4 _

Day I Cup 4 1Cupi 14 .Cup 24 -Cup34.: .Cup44 -:Cup 6. 1-Day. Cup S CupiS Cup 29 Cup 39 CupS Icup B9

4 - . - - _ _ __ _ a 3 -4 _ __ _

I t/_ i It- uI ~ I I

Da Cup2 . Cup2 13 Cup 23 Cup 32 Cup 43 Cup62-. Day Cup?: 8 Cupi -8 Cup 27 Cup 38 -Cup 48 Cup 68__ _ __ _ __ _ __ _ _ Ii -. 0 . U. L, L " --

I _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ _ __ _ __ _ _ - - C(- ~

Day Cup 2 Cup 12 Cup 22 Cup 32 Cup 42 Cup 62 Day CupE 7 -cupl 17 -Cup27 Cup3S Cup dG Cup 67* 0 j ~ . .. . .- _ __ _ _ '4 ' _ __ _ _ '..- A., ___ __

* 2 _ _ _ _ L- ~ - T ~ _ _ _ _ _ _ 2

- 4 . 3.ZZ '1'-.7 Zz .. 7Z i 3 i 0 L*6 v .. A-V 17. VL.2 6 - v- -75 ~3 ZZ.Zj IZI

Da u u 1 Cp2 Cp3 u 1 Cp6 a Cup - - J Cup__ _ _:C__P2_ Cup _ 36 Cup 46 Cu _

f i ____ ___ __ _____Temperature (-C) ~DyCu#1 Cull1 Cup #21 -Cup# 31 Cup 41 Cup l l

up -I u 10-.5

_ _ _ _ _ _ - '0 . I . . 1 . . ~ %' . _ _ _

*S _ _ _- iV(~ L _ _ _

Vet Location .

SamplelID- Sun-Mon: 0-C r00Tue- Wed: a_____La__Thu- Fri: --wi 1I


Cerlodaphnina dubla 3-brood chronic test de-randomizatlon sheet

Client- Southern Nuclear Dilution Water ID: DMW01 I 11703 Test Set-up Date (Time): 11118103 (1440)I scharge: Plant Vogule EMuent C. dubia Source ID: CERB01 110703 Test End Date (Time): 11124103 (1245)1ocation: Waynesboro, GA Template ID: *Test Analyst(s): ASPIMRF

Cup ei DMW Cup #2 1.59% Cup #3 = 3.18% Cup #4 6.36% Cup #5 12.72% Cup #6 25.44%

MC mltn arpae dadadlt -Nno dadnenaes V mleadlt.E =epBehavauliNornenaesonboto

[ItE = molten embryo A a alive adult N=no. liv neonates MF = missing adult GA = gravid adult SA = small adult

C oU ncrpc edaut -N-n.da ents Yaml dl A-ehpilautN entso aoonc: . DMW .*. otl.

______ ~~~Da y'Neonates,

Cup# 0 1 J2 :3 4 5 61 :7 __

I A A A A 3 4 1 812 A A AA 4 7 12 2353 A A AA 3 8 13 2424 A AA A 2 7 1 2045 A A A A 3 4 6 1336 A A AA 3 7 6 1617 A A A A 4 9 10 2358 'Al A AA 6 1839 A A A 3 5 11 1910 A A A 4 r _ 1

M~a o of f~mw.: 1 0 U.9 nwm-gs pw f.me. 18.21- 182 _

onc: . 3.18% .. Total,______ - -~D yNeonates

Cu 1.] 2 [.3 4 :5 6- 721 AAAIA4 118 - 2332 A A A IA 3 8 12 233 A 22554 A A A A 4 9 2115 A A A A 2 7 51446 A '3 6 11 - 207 A A A A 6 9 62128 A A A A 3 5A 849 A JA AA 3 812_ 23

20A AA -A 486 4 16ng=.f no ofg~n,~..10 u.no o pn..:19.4 194

1onc: . 12.72. Total_____ - -. 2 ~Day Neonates

Cup 0 .1 .2 3-4 5. :6:. -7 _ _

41 A .. L.A. A A 2 7 12 212 A A A A 3 8 7 1823 {A A A A 2 5 13 2034 A A A A 4 10 15 2955 A A A A 4 5 15 24156 j A A A 5 5 13 2327 A A A A 3 7 9 19L 48 j A A A A~~ ~~ 51329

9 { A A A A ~~~4 1 11 ( 2760 IA A 4AI I 9 n1

no of ln~ols1 0 1 Li.. n.OnMo .s f. .nd: -22.9 229

Conc: . 1.59% .Total

- Day -Neonates

Cup# 0 1 2 33 4 5 6 7 I___.1 A A A A 3 9 1 1 123

42 A A A IA 4 10 141 2833 A A Al A 3 8111 22.4 A A A A 4 8 [I11 23:25 A A A A 1 8 61 15.56 A A A A 3 6 71 1 637 A A A A 4 7 178 A A A A 3 9 ___23

.29 A A A A 119112 23-50 AtLA -jA IA _ 2_ 2

2ioloof.nu. 10 juen~onwasp.rf.mai.: 19.21 192

Conc: 6.36% - - Total1____ ~~~~~~D y Neonates

31 A A A A 1311 8 22:52 A A A A 3 11 2213 A A A A 2 8 11 2144 Al A A A 3 5 8 16.5S A AlA A 4 8 5 1726 A A A A 3 6 7 1647 A A A A 4 10 13 27.18 A A A A Sf4 6 15.59 A A A A 219 14 2540 A A A A 5f8 9 22

no.0 l.of o 1 0 1 U.. -nef.*~ P., f.MWO: 20.3 203

-~~~ Oa~Dy NeonatesCupU 0 1 2_ 3 4 5 67

51 A A A_ A_ 3 9 8 2022 A A A_ A 3 9 1 2 2443 A A A_ A 3 1 112 2614 A A A A 4 8 12 2435 A A A A 3 4 10 - 176 A A A fA 3 7 12 22

57 AA AtA 2 8 7 17

19 A AAIA 3 9 I1 1 2330 A A Aj_ 4 1 1 W 25

Ong. m.of o-W: 10 IU~.nm. M .MPo tmwe: 21.41 214

Er...dby: Q

Chock.d br.!y 1 1:'

Fathead Minnow

Reference Toxicant Test

M M M M 'W. prorWhronP RefctoxicVPMa P M M M M ~ ~ ~

ITEST NO.[ . iTSAI nDATh .. |IC2 Surv JM MEAu CUM SD UPPER CONTRO OWER CONTR C25 GrowIUM MEN+ CUM SD PPER.CONTROOWE CONTROL.A:rS. ic~s~: :. sv:! Sr . . t SD) } iC2 +;.. 25c G |iC SD A:.2CMS

128 RFPIASP 112212002 2783 2780 2241 2240129 RFP/ASP 2126n2002 1908 2350 620 3590 1110 2241 2240 0 2240 2240130 RFP/ASP 312612002 3636 2780 860 4500 1060 2821 2430 330 3090 1770131 RFP/ASP 4n2312002 2800 2780 710 4200 1360 2673 2490 300 3090 1890132 RFP/ASP 7W/2002 4868 3200 1120 5440 960 3095 2610 370 3350 1870133 RFP/ASP 611812002 5400 3570 1340 6250 890 2669 2620 330 3280 1960134 RFP/ASP 7/30/2002 1900 3330 1380 6090 570 1690 2490 470 3430 1550135 ASPIRFP 812712002 4250 3440 1320 6080 800 2003 2430 460 3350 1510136 RPP/ASP 9/2412002 3117 3410 1240 5890 930 1950 2380 460 3300 1460137 RFP/ASP 10122n2002 5741 3640 1380 6400 880 3937 2530 660 3850 1210138 RFP/ASP 1112612002 4904 3760 1360 6480 1040 4396 2700 840 4380 1020139 ASP/RFP 12111/2002 3544 3740 1300 6340 1140 2525 2690 800 4290 1090140 RFP 112812003 3077 3690 1260 6210 1170 3167 2720 780 4280 1160141 MRF 212512003 4144 3720 1220 6160 1280 2932 2740 750 4240 1240142 ASPIMRF 3128103 3143 3680 1180 6040 1320 1928 2680 750 4180 1180143 MRF/ASP 4/292003 4802 3750 1180 6110 1390 3624 2740 770 4280 1200144 MRF/ASP sn120o1 3 2475 3680 1180 6040 1320 2882 2750 740 4230 1270145 ASP/MRF 7/2003 3112 3640 1150 5940 1340 2084 2710 740 4190 1230146 ASPIMRF 911612003 3143 3620 1130 5880 1360 3228 2740 730 4200 1280147 ASP/MRF 10/21/2003 3182 3600 1100 5800 1400 2135 2710 720 4150 1270

Chronic Fathead Minnow NaCI Reference ToxicantControl Chart - Survival

8000

7D0D0 ......................................................................

3000 ......... ....... ...........

012000C . .. . .............................................

1D00 A- ........* * ....................

0

Test Date

Chronic Fathead Minnow NaCI Reference ToxicantControl Chart - Growth

eooo

7000 ..................................................................................

gmC ..................................................................................

5" .................................................................................._4000 ........... . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...... ...... ...... ...... ......

3000 ....

2000 ....

T000 .-.. ...... .-..'............ .'.....

2000

Test Dat.

I --*- tC25 Surv. M UPPER CONTROL --a- LOWER CONTROL I I +5u IC25 Grown. .UPPER CONTROL -a-LOWER CONTROL

v I I .

Water Flea

Reference Toxicant Test

- m d C Na- - - - - - - - - -T- - -

C. dubia Chronic NaCI Reference Toticant Dala

Test No , itR Date 25 S u n Ivc Surnuitive Men cum Sp PPER CONTR OWER CONTROL

,_ __ 1 ___ __j ____~C ___ _ _ _ _103104105106107108109110t11112113114115116117118119120121122

RFPtASPRFP/ASPRFP/ASPRFPIASPRFP/ASPRFPIASPASP/RFPRFP/ASPRFP/ASPRFP/ASPRFP/ASP

RFPRFP/ASPMRF/ASPMRF/ASPMRFIASPASP/MRFASP/MRFASP/MRFASP/MRF

2n26n20023126/20024n2312002S/30Q20026/18120028/812002

8s2912009130/2002

10123120021116w2002121261200211280032/21120033/3112003412912003S/20/20036130120037/311200391162003

1012112003

27502071180016501650750

159118592750212528242333266727503000900

2571275024612333

27502410221020701980178017501770187019001980201020602110217020902120216021702180

480490490460650600560610580620600600610630690670670660640

3370319030502900308029502890309030603220321032603330343034703460350034903460

1450123010901060480550650650740740810860890910710780820850900

7451287543876102049010571043128611801247132765613581133571115110451199823

7501020860860890830860880930950980101098010101020990

10001000101010W

380380310280300290270290280280290290300290300290290280280

1780162014801450143014401420151015101540159015601610160015901580158015701560

260100240330230280340350390420430400410440390420420450440

Chronic C. dubia NaCI Reference ToxicantControl Chart - Survival

40003750 .......................................................................3500 ..............................................3250 .....

3000 '... ............*t.... .

2500 ... . ....,^2250 . ...... /..... .......... ...... ...

E2000 .. .. . . .. . . . .... .. *...****...****./.***....****.. **** 1 *** ****eit750 ... .. . . . . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . .. .. . . .. . .

z1500 . ... .. .......... ...... 1 ..... ....1250 .. .....................---.,--.--.---.--.-.-... ...............1000 .. . . . .\... . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .... . . .. . .

750 \................ 4--

500 ...250 .. ..................................................................

0

T st Date

1-4-Seriesi -- See3 -*-Seies4

Chronic C. dubla NaCI Reference ToxicantControl Chart - Reproduction

13

3750 ......................................................................3500 .....................................................................3250 .....................................................................3000 ...................................................................2750 ....................................................................2500 ..... .......... .. ......... ................. ............ ................2250 .................................................................2000 ..... .......... ....... ............. ......... .. ...... . ............1750 .. _.................................................................15001250_a\

1500.ft. ,250 .................. ...........

*500 ,, ,

Test Date

E-Se'1est-4 IiSefies3 SF 'i