volusia county sheriff's office incident...

Juvenile Hate Crime

Elderly Abuse / Exploitation Agency Report Number

Agency ORI Number Telephone HandledCall? (T.H.C.)

1. Yes2. No

Time Completed (mil.)

2. Traffic Felony4. Traffic3. Misdemeanor

Misdemeanor

5. Ordinance9. Other

Incident: DayTO

Date Time (mil.)Date Time (mil.) Day Occurred During:U - Unknown

#1

#2

Incident Location (Street, Apt. Number) City Zip

Business Name / Area Identifier

01.Residence-Single 05.Convenience Store 09.Supermarket 13.Bank/Financial Inst. 17.Gov't/Public Bldg. 21.Airport 25.Parking Lot/Garage 29.Motor Vehicle10.Dept/Discount Store 14.Commercial/Office Bldg. 18.School/University 22.Bus/Rail Terminal

27.Park/Woodlands/Field02.Apartment/Condo03.Residence/Other04.Hotel/Motel

Location Type

06.Gas Station07.Liquor Sales08.Bar/Nightclub

11.Specialty Store12.Drug Store/Hospital

15.Industrial/Mfg.16.Storage

19.Jail/Prison20.Religious Bldg.

23.Construction Site24.Other Structure

26.Highway/Roadway

28.Lake/Waterway

30.Other Mobile

99.Other

W-WitnessR-Reporting Person

Extent of Injury

CO

DE

SE

VE

NT

DA

TA

INCIDENT REPORT

Zone #

Nature of Call (Report Type)Reported: Day Date Time Dispatched (mil.)Time (mil.) Time Arrived (mil.)

D - DayN - Night

From

Statute Violation Number A - Attempted

Description

Description

Drug Related0. N/A

# Prem. Entered1. Yes2. No

0. N/AAlcohol Related

2. No3. Attempted 1. Occupied

2. Unoccupied3. Abandoned

Arson-Inhabited1. Yes2. No

1. YesForced Entry Arson-Attempted

1. Yes2. No

88.Unknown

Location Type Codes

3. Adult

4. Business5. Government

9. Other

Victim/Subject Type

F-FemaleU-Unknown

M-MaleAddress/Phone Type

C. CellB. Business/Work

H. Home

M. MessageN. Next of KinO. Other V. Vacation

P. PagerS. School

Z-Other

H-Co-HabitantK-Knife/Cutting Inst.

Victim Relationship to OffenderS-SpouseP-ParentC-Child

O-Other DangerousH-Hands, Fists, Feet, Etc.

02.Stabbed

03.Laceration04.Unconscious05.Poss.Broken Bones

06.Poss. Internal Injury07.Loss of Teeth08.Burns

09.Abrasions/Bruises10.No Visible Injury99.Other Serious Injury

Domestic Violence

1. Yes2. No

V/W Code # V. Type

Other Contact Info (Time Available, Interpreter, etc.) Synopsis of Involvement

Race Sex Date of Birth Res. Type Res. Status Extent of Injury Relationship

1. #12. #2

VIC

TIM

/WIT

NE

SS 3. Both

Offense Indicator Name (Last/Business)Nature of Call (for Victim, if different from Incident)

Means of Attack Domestic Violence

Business/School/Other Address (Street, Apt. Number) City State Zip Phone TypeAddress Type Business/School/Other Phone

Address (Street, Apt. Number) City State Zip


Race Sex Date of Birth

1. #12. #2

VIC

TIM

/WIT

NE

SS 3. Both

Residence Phone


V/W Code # V. Type


Race Sex Date of Birth

2. #2

VIC

TIM

/WIT

NE

SS



V/W Code # V. Type



Race Sex Date of Birth Res. Type Res. Status Extent of Injury RelationshipVIC

TIM

/WIT

NE

SS 3. Both


Residence Phone

Means of Attack Domestic Violence


V/W Code # V. Type



1. #12. #2

VIC

TIM

/WIT

NE

SS 3. Both


Residence Phone


Page Pagesof

Domestic Violence

Gang

VOR

Endangered / Other

Sex0. N/A1. Juvenile2. L.E. Officer

(First)

(First)

(First)

(First)

(First)

(Middle)

(Middle)

(Middle)

(Middle)

(Middle)

Incident Type:1. Felony

Offense Type Statute Violation Number A - AttemptedC - Committed

C - Committed

V/W CodeV-Victim N-Next of Kin

O-Other

Race

I-American Indian

W-White O-Oriental/AsianB-Black U-Unknown6. Church

Means of AttackF-Firearm 00.N/A

01.GunshotB-SiblingO-Other Family

Residence PhoneZipStateCityAddress (Street, Apt. Number)

Age Ethnicity

Offense Indicator V/W Code # V. Type Nature of Call (for Victim, if different from Incident) Name (Last/Business)

RelationshipDomestic ViolenceExtent of InjuryMeans of AttackRes. StatusRes. TypeEthnicityAge

3. Both1. #1

RelationshipDomestic ViolenceExtent of InjuryMeans of AttackRes. StatusRes. TypeEthnicityAge

2. #21. #1

Age Ethnicity

RelationshipDomestic ViolenceExtent of InjuryMeans of AttackRes. StatusRes. TypeEthnicityAgeDate of BirthSexRaceIf Victim Type

If Victim Type

If Victim Type

If Victim Type

If Victim Type1, 2, or 3

1, 2, or 3

1, 2, or 3

1, 2, or 3

1, 2, or 3

Residence Type0. NA1. City2. County

3. Florida4. Out-of-State

Residence Status0. N/A1. Full Year2. Par. Year3. Non-Resident

Address (Street, Apt. Number) City State Zip Residence Phone

VOLUSIA COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE1 4

150029661

FL0640000 46 2

Friday 11-06-2015 1834 1836 1839 0408 DEAD Dead Person

Friday 11-06-2015 1800 Friday 11-06-2015 1835 N

9 77777777 Death C

DELTONA 32725

2 2 2

01

1 R 1 2 HARRELSON BOBBY C

O

NONE SON OF O1/NEPHEW OF V1

W M 51 N 1 1 F 10 2 O

1 V 1 3 DAVIS RAYMOND C

NONE UNCLE OF R1/BROTHER OF O1

W M 06-28-1947 68 N 1 1 F 01 2 O

1 O 1 3 HINDS HAZEL C

NONE MOTHER OF R1/SISTER OF V1

W F 11-09-1938 76 N 1 1 H 10 2 O

Offense Indicator3. Both1. #1

2. #2

Subject Code Code # Name (Last)Subj. Type Race Sex Ethnicity

Date of Birth Age Height Eye Color Hair Color Maiden Name To Age To Height

S-SuspectD-Defendant

V-Victim(Missing Person)

Weight To Weight

Nickname / Street Name Place of Birth - City County State Employer/Other/School Occupation

Last Known Address (Street, Apt. Number) City State Zip Phone TypeAddress Type Phone

City State Zip Phone TypeAddress Type PhoneOther Address (Street, Apt. Number)

SU

BJE

CT

/ MIS

SIN

G S

EC

TIO

N

Officer Reporting - Printed Officer Reporting - Signature

Officer Reviewing - Signature (If Applicable)Officer Reviewing - Printed (If Applicable)

ID. Number Unit Date


Clothing (Describe) Scars/Marks/Tattoos (Type/Describe) Scars/Marks/Tattoos (Type/Describe)

Hair Length /Style Skin Build Facial Features Speech/Voice Deformity Glasses

Mask Weapon Type

2. Other Agency1. Yes2. No

Warrant From:1. This Agency

Subject Was Alreadyin Custody?

Physical Condition: Mental Condition: Doctor Name: Dentist Name:

Driver's License State/Number Other ID NumberSocial Security Number ID Type

2. Parents

5. Endangered

6. DisasterVictim

7. Voluntary

Foul PlaySuspected?

1. Yes2. No

8. Unknown

1. Yes2. No

Missing Before? FingerprintsAvailable?

1. Yes2. No

1. Yes2. No

1. Yes2. No

Photo Available? Dental RecordAvailable?

8. Unknown

I, (Printed) (Signature) certify that I have reported the above person as a missingperson; and this agency has my permission to enter this person in a statewide alert.

Page PagesofINCIDENT REPORT (CONT.)

Offense Indicator3. Both1. #1

2. #2

Subject Code Code # Name (Last)Subj. Type Race Sex Ethnicity

Date of Birth Age Height Eye Color Hair Color Maiden Name To Age To Height

S-SuspectD-Defendant

V-Victim(Missing Person)

Weight To Weight

Nickname / Street Name Place of Birth - City County State Employer/Other/School Occupation

Last Known Address (Street, Apt. Number) City State Zip Phone TypeAddress Type Phone

City State Zip Phone TypeAddress Type PhoneOther Address (Street, Apt. Number)

SU

BJE

CT

/ MIS

SIN

G S

EC

TIO

N

2. Other Agency2. NoDate of Last Contact Date of Emancipation Caution Caution Reason Personal Habits (Drugs / Alcohol)

May Be With: Physical Condition: Mental Condition: Doctor Name: Dentist Name:

Driver's License State/Number Other ID NumberSocial Security Number ID Type

Incident Type1. Runaway2. Parents3. Involuntary4. Disabled5. Endangered

6. DisasterVictim

7. VoluntaryAdult

8. Unknown

Foul PlaySuspected?

1. Yes2. No

8. Unknown

1. Yes2. No

Missing Before? FingerprintsAvailable?

1. Yes2. No

1. Yes2. No

1. Yes2. No

Photo Available?

8. Unknown

I, (Printed) (Signature) certify that I have reported the above person as a missingperson; and this agency has my permission to enter this person in a statewide alert.

NA

RR

ATI

VE

AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE

Final CaseStatus:

Final CaseStatus Codes: 1.Arrest/Adult 2.Arrest/Juv. 3.Exceptional/Adult 4.Exceptional/Juv. 5.Closed 6.Unfounded Victim Advocate Triad SA Referral

Connecting Report Number

DCF HotlineCAC Spoke With:

Time: By:Date:FCIC / NCIC Entry

FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:

Other Describe:Veh./Tow SheetPropertyPersonsSA 707Narrative

/ / / / /

/ / /Demeanor

/ / / / /

/

Clothing (Describe) Scars/Marks/Tattoos (Type/Describe) Scars/Marks/Tattoos (Type/Describe)

Skin Build Facial Features Speech/Voice Deformity Glasses

Mask Weapon Type1. Yes

Warrant From:1. This Agency

Subject Was Alreadyin Custody?

/ / / / /

/ / /Demeanor

/ / / / /

/

(First)

(First)

(Middle)

(Middle)

/ / / /

/ / / /Date of Last Contact Date of Emancipation Caution Caution Reason Personal Habits (Drugs / Alcohol)

May Be With:

Incident Type1. Runaway

8. UnknownAdult

3. Involuntary4. Disabled

/StyleHair Length

Dental RecordAvailable?

If Arrested:

If Arrested:If Subject:

If Subject:

IF M

ISS

ING

IF M

ISS

ING

Additional FormsAttached:

2 4

1 On November 6th, 2015, at approximately 1836 hours, Deputies Cort and Mele responded to , Deltona, in reference to a 2 person shot. The reporting party, Bobby C. Harrelson (R1), indicated he had shot his uncle, later identified as Raymond C. Davis 3 (V1), in the head.45 Upon arrival on scene, Deputy Cort assisted other responding units by providing lethal cover during the apprehension of Harrelson.67 Once Harrelson was secured, Deputy Cort moved up the driveway, towards the house in order to provide security on the left side of the property, 8 while other units cleared the residence. 910 Upon hearing the residence had been secured, Deputy Cort moved from the driveway of the residence into the garage. Deputy Cort then moved

CRIME SCENE LOG

Cort, John 8413 1D47 11-06-2015

EV

NT Report Date Report Time Orig. Reported Date Nature of Call (for Incident) Agency Report Number 1.Original

2.Supplement

Page Pagesof





AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE


Connecting Report NumberCAC Spoke With:


FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N

NARRATIVE / SUPPLEMENT

Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


3 4

11-06-2015 1834 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 1

11 from the garage through an open door into the kitchen. Deputy Cort walked through the kitchen, then turned right to walk out of the residence 12 through the front door in order to consolidate with other responding deputies. 1314 Deputy Cort noticed the interior of the residence to be well-lit, with the ceiling fan in the living room turned on and the television also on.1516 Deputy Cort started and maintained the crime scene log which was turned in as a supplement to this report. 1718 The scene was turned over to Investigator Jayson Paul who arrived at 1917 hours. 1920 Case Status: Open / Continued to Criminal Investigations Division.

CRIME SCENE LOG

Cort, John 8413 1D47 11-06-2015

VOLUSIA COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE

DEATH INVESTIGATION REPORT

EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

Where Victim Found: Position of Body:

Condition of Body: General Appearance: Any Injury?

Autopsy Request? Medical Examiner Called? Name: M.E. / Investigator

Time Med.Examiner Called:

Physician at Scene?

Will Sign Death Certificate?

Date Last Attended Victim: Treatment:

Pronounced Dead By (Name): Time:

Time:

Unit ID:Location: Ambulance Used (Name):

Attendant's Name(s): Transported To:

Funeral Home (Name): Address:Rotation Requested

Notified Next of Kin? Will Located?

DE

ATH

INV

ES

TIG

ATI

ON

SE

CTI

ON

Person Code #

Vehicle Involved?

Next of Kin Name: Relationship:

Weather Conditions When Victim Found: Temp. Outside: Temp. Inside:

Time Med.Examiner Arrived: Attending Physician Name:

Nature of Illness

Meds. Collected? Property Retained? Photos Taken? Premise Sealed?

Other Agency: O.A. Officer: O.A. Case Number:





Physician at Scene?




Time:





DE

ATH

INV

ES

TIG

ATI

ON

SE

CTI

ON

Person Code #

Vehicle Involved?




Nature of Illness

Other Documents? Meds. Collected? Property Retained? Photos Taken? Premise Sealed?






Physician at Scene?




Time:





DE

ATH

INV

ES

TIG

ATI

ON

SE

CTI

ON

Person Code #

Vehicle Involved?




Nature of Illness

Other Documents? Meds. Collected? Property Retained? Photos Taken? Premise Sealed?





ID. Number Unit DateAD

MIN

.

Other Documents?

4 4

11-06-2015 1834 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 1

V 1 Living Room Floor Laying on back

Generally intact Head Trauma Gunshot wound to head N

Indoors 80 74

Y Y OROZCO

0030 0150

N

Sgt. Gowan 1850

DELTONA 32725

Y HAZEL HINDS B N N N Y 1 Y

Cort, John 8413 1D47 11-06-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-06-2015 1835 SHOOT 150029661 2

1 On 11-6-2015, Deputy Luoma responded to Deltona in reference to a shooting call.23 Prior to arrival, Deputy Luoma learned the reporting party, Bobby Harrelson (R1), had stated he had shot his uncle who was 4 "Attacking" his mother.56 Upon arrival, Harrelson was standing in the front yard of the residence with his hands in the air. Harrelson complied with Deputy Luoma's verbal 7 commands walking backwards with his hands visible to the middle of the road where he was secured in handcuffs by Deputy Escobar.89 Deputy Luoma asked Harrelson who else was in the residence and what rooms they were in. Harrelson replied his mother was on the floor in the 10 living room and that his uncle was in the same room. When Deputy Luoma attempted to call Harrelson's mother out of the residence utilizing the 11 P.A. system, Harrelson advised his mother was too distraught to get up and because of medical conditions, could not walk well.1213 Deputy Luoma, Sergeant Whitener, and a team of deputies approached the front and garage area of the residence. Deputy Campbell was 14 unsuccessful with establishing contact with Hazel Kinds (O1) from the front door. Deputy Luoma heard Kinds crying and moaning from the open 15 door of the garage leading to the residence. Deputy Luoma and Sergeant Whitener entered the residence through the garage as Deputy Campbell 16 and her team held the front door.1718 Deputy Luoma observed Kind on the floor, next to a table, lying in a fetal position crying and moaning. Deputy Luoma observed a deceased Ray 19 Davis (V1) lying on his back on the floor to the left of Kind with blood emanating from under the back of his head. A search of the residence was 20 made for any additional persons yielding negative results. 2122 As Deputy Campbell and her team were tending to Kind, Deputy Luoma observed a black Glock handgun on the couch. Deputy Luoma showed 23 Sergeant Whitener where the handgun was located. The handgun was left in place, the residence was vacated, and a crime scene log was 24 started.2526 No further investigative action was conducted by Deputy Luoma in this case.

Luoma, Bryan 2513 1K941 11-06-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-06-2015 1924 11-06-2015 PSHOT 150029661 2

1 On 11//06/2015, at approximately 1836 hours, Deputy Escobar responded to Deltona, in reference to a person shot.2 Deputies arrived on scene and observed a male, later identified as Bobby Harrelson, walking down the driveway from the residence into to road 3 towards the deputies. Deputy Escobar made contact with Harrelson, at which time he was placed inside his patrol car for scene safety.45 Harrelson uttered the following: He was sitting on the sofa in the living room and his mother, Hazel Hinds, was sitting in a recliner. Harrelson's 6 uncle, Raymond Davis, came out of his bedroom in an angry manner and began yelling at Hinds for making to much noise. Davis became 7 physical with Hinds, at which time Harrelson tried to separate them, but was knocked to the ground by Davis. Davis then straddled Hinds and 8 began strangling her. Harrelson grabbed his department issued duty weapon (Deland Police Department) and fired one shot at Davis in order to 9 stop him from strangling his mother. Harrelson stated he was in fear for his mothers life and needed to stop the threat.1011 Deputy Escobar had no further involvement in the investigation.

Escobar, Ruben 8193 1D92 11-06-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-06-2015 0805 11-06-2015 PSHOT 150029661 2

1 On 11-06-2015, at approximately 1837 hours, Deputy Hansard as well as several other deputies responded to , Deltona, in 2 reference to a person shot.34 Upon arrival, Deputy Hansard assisted other deputies in setting a perimeter on the aforementioned address. Deputy Hansard then, at the request 5 of Sergeant Whitener, cleared the residence. Deputy Hansard located a large white male lying face up in the living room area next to a chair. 6 Deputy Hansard observed a large pool of blood protruding from beneath the white male. While still clearing the residence Deputy Hansard also 7 located a white female who was lying face down approximately five feet away from the white male in the living room area. The white female was 8 extremely distraught. Deputy Hansard assisted the female into a wheelchair located within the residence and wheeled her outside to awaiting 9 deputies.1011 Deputy Hansard did not move or touch the male who was lying face down. 1213 Case Status: Active to Major Case

Hansard, Joshua 8189 1D49 11-06-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-06-2015 2000 11-06-2015 PSHOT 150029661 2

1 On 11/06/2015 at approximately 1834 hours, Deputy Campbell responded to Deltona, in reference to the report of a person 2 shot. Upon arrival, Deputies secured Bobby Harrelson and he advised his mother, Hazel Hinds, was still inside with his uncle, Raymond Davis.3 Deputy Campbell approached the front door of the residence and attempted to call Hinds from the residence. Deputy Campbell was the first 4 Deputy at the door and made several announcements for Hinds to exit the residence. Deputy Campbell could hear a female inside hysterically 5 crying but was not exiting the residence. Deputy Campbell, Deputy Hansard, Deputy Demarco and Deputy Luoma entered the residence and 6 observed Hinds face down on the kitchen/dining area floor. Deputy Campbell observed Davis lying on his back on the living room floor with blood 7 emanating from the back of his head and observed a black pistol on the couch closest to the kitchen. Deputies cleared the residence and did no 8 locate any other people inside.910 Deputy Campbell returned back to Hinds in an effort to get her out of the residence. Deputy Hansard and Deputy Campbell were able to get Hinds 11 off the kitchen floor, into her wheelchair and out of the residence safely.1213 Deputy Campbell had no further involvement in this case.1415 Case Status: Active

Campbell, Katie 7930 1D94 11-06-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-07-2015 1400 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 On Friday, 11/06/15, at approximately 1836 hours, Deputy DeMarco was one of several deputies dispatched to Deltona, 2 FL, in reference to a shooting. Upon arrival, Deputy DeMarco was one of the deputies who cleared the interior of the residence. Once the interior 3 of the residence was cleared, Deputy DeMarco was responsible for assisting Hazel Kinds (O1) out of the residence. Once outside of the 4 residence, EVAC personnel began to attend to Kinds, who did not require any medical attention. While Deputy DeMarco was with Kinds, she 5 spontaneously uttered the following statements throughout the time Deputy DeMarco was with her:67 "My brother was trying to choke me...I was on the floor, then I heard a shot."8 "I knew my brother was gonna kill me."9 "He was so drunk."10 "Ray was so drunk."11 "He's an alcoholic."1213 Deputy DeMarco notified Investigator Paul of the aforementioned statements, and documented such in a report. Deputy DeMarco took no further 14 action in the case.1516 This supplement does not change the status of this case.

Demarco, James 8327 1C92 11-07-2015


EV

NT Report Date Report Time Original Incident Date Nature of Call (for Incident) Agency Report Number 1.Original

2.Supplement

Page PagesofPROPERTY REPORT

02. Robbery 04. Pocket Picking05. Purse Snatching

06. Embezzlement07. From Coin Oper.Machine

11. By Computer12. Fraud

99.Other

THE

FT

13. Bicycle14. Motor Vehicle Parts

09. From Vehicle10. Extortion

Type Theft00. N/AType Theft

08. From PublicAccess Bldg.

Codes

CO

DE

S

L. Livestock

M. Musical InstrumentG-Games and Gambling ApparatusH-Household Appliance/Housewares

I-Items of IdentificationJ-Special Docs/Food Stamps/TicketsK-Keepsakes and Collectibles

R-Radio/TV/Sound DevicesS-Sports/Camping/Rec.Equip.T-Toxic Chemicals

V.Viewing Equip (Binoculars)W.Well-drilling EquipmentY-All Other Items and Equipment

(GUNS,DRUGS,JWLRY, Etc.)

Activity

B. Buy

P. PossessS. Sell

T. TrafficR. Smuggle

Z. OtherTypeA. AmphetamineB. BarbituratesC. CocaineE. HeroinH. Hallucinogen

M. MarijuanaO. Opium/DerivativeP. Paraphernalia/

EquipmentS. Synthetic

K. Dispense/Distribute

Cultivate

DR

UG

CO

DE

S

99.Other

Unit1. Gram2. Milligram3. Kilogram4. Ounce5. Pound

6. Ton7. Liter8. Mililiter9. Dose Unit/Term

F-Furniture and Furnishings

Person CodeV-VictimS-SuspectD-DefendantW-Witness

N-Next of Kin 8.Found9.Found/Contraband10.Prisoner's Pers.Prop.11.Stolen

16.Vehicle Inventory Prop.17.Baker Act18.Seized/Confiscated19.Abandoned

12.Stolen And Recovered13.Disposal14.Prop. Of Deceased15.Return to Owner

Person Involvement Code1. Finder

4. Other

Status Code:1. Evidence2. Damaged Prop.3. Arson/Burned4.Photo & Release

7.Recovered (OutsideAgency Recovered)

E-Equipment/Measuring Devices/Tools

Serial Number Owner Applied Number

PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$

Pers. Invl. Article Description

Qty. Model Jewelry Type Activity Type Quantity Unit Estimated Street Value

Make Model Type/Cat Action Finish Barrel Length Barrel TypeCaliber


PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$


F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value


Reason for Change:

Released by (Printed): Received by (Printed): Received by (Signature):Released by (Signature):

Reason for Change:

Item # Date: Time: Released by (Printed): Received by (Printed): Received by (Signature):Released by (Signature):

Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:CH

AIN

OF

CU

STO

DY


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:


Officer Reviewing - Signature (If Applicable)Officer Reviewing - Printed (If Applicable) ID. Number Unit Date

AD

MIN

. Officer Reporting - Printed Officer Reporting - Signature ID. Number Unit Date

Category


PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$

Article Description

F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value


Owner Applied Number

PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$ $




Person Code #

Person Code #

$

$

$

$

01. Burglary 03. Shoplifting

3. Suspect2. OwnerO-Other

R-Reporting Party6.Recovered5.Lost

C. Camera/Photo EquipmentP.Personal AccessoriesO. Office Equipment

D-Data Processing Equipment

Category Code

B. Bicycle

D. DeliverE. Use

M. Manufacture/Produce/

U. UnknownZ. Other

Person Code # Pers. Invl. Item # Status Category

Date Recovered:

CategoryStatusItem #

Serial Number Forfeiture Y / N: ValueF.W.T.C. (Y/N)Date Recovered:


Date Recovered: ValueF.W.T.C. (Y/N)

StatusItem ##Person Code

Date Recovered:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

Item # Date: Time:

20.Safekeeping21.Digital Evidence

1 2

11-10-2015 0800 11-06-2015 HOMICIDE 150029661 2

00

01 1 Y OTHER Projectile from victim's brain

02 1 Y OTHER Projectile fragments from victim's brain

03 1 Y OTHER Head and pubic hair standards from victim

04 1 Y OTHER Left and right fingernail clippings from victim

01-04 11-10-2015 0850 J. Mott 1681 L. Serido 7485

Evidence

Mott, Joshua 1681 11-10-2015


EV


2.Supplement





99.Other

THE

FT





Codes

CO

DE

S

L. Livestock






Activity

B. Buy

P. PossessS. Sell






Cultivate

DR

UG

CO

DE

S

99.Other









4. Other





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$


F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AIN

OF

CU

STO

DY


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AD

MIN


Category


PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$

Article Description

F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value



PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$ $




Person Code #

Person Code #

$

$

$

$






Category Code

B. Bicycle

D. DeliverE. Use


U. UnknownZ. Other


Date Recovered:






Date Recovered:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

Item # Date: Time:


2 2

11-10-2015 0800 11-06-2015 HOMICIDE 150029661 2

00

05 1 Y OTHER Boxer shorts from victim

06 1 Y OTHER FTA card from victim

07 21 Y OTHER 44 images contained in Call ID 15530

05-06 11-10-2015 0850 J. Mott 1681 L. Serido 7485

Evidence

Mott, Joshua 1681 11-10-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-10-2015 1000 11-06-2015 HOMICIDE 150029661 2

1 On 11/09/15 at 0900hrs Investigator Mott responded to the Volusia County Medical Examiner's Office to attend the autopsy of Raymond Davis.23 Investigator Mott was requested to attend the autopsy to assist Deputy Bethea in furtherance of this investigation.45 Investigator Mott took photos throughout the procedure.67 The autopsy was conducted by Dr. Marcela Chiste. 89 An entrance gunshot wound was located on the top of the head slightly to the left side. Its course was determined to be from back to front, 10 downward, and left to right. A projectile and fragments were recovered from within the head. A trajectory rod was used to visualize the wound in 11 photography.1213 Investigator Mott was provided the projectile and fragments, as well as head and pubic hair standards, left and right fingernail clippings, boxer 14 shorts, and an FTA card from the deceased.1516 The items were remanded to VCSO Evidence.1718 A total of 44 images taken by Investigator Mott were uploaded to the Digital Crime Scene photo management system under Call ID 15530.1920 Investigator Mott has not arranged any lab submissions concerning this case.2122 Case status is unchanged by Investigator Mott.

Mott, Joshua 1681 11-10-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-06-2015 2100 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 On 11/6/2015, Investigator Paul responded to Deltona, Florida in reference to a shooting that resulted in a death. Upon 2 arrival, Investigator Paul made contact with Deputy Escobar who provided the following information;34 Raymond Davis was shot in the head by his nephew, Bobby Harrelson. According to statements Bobby Harrelson said to Deputy Escobar, 5 Raymond Davis began fighting with his sister, Hazel Hinds because she was making too much noise. The altercation escalated to the point where 6 Raymond Davis was strangling Hazel Hinds. Bobby Harrelson retrieved a firearm and shot Raymond Davis.78 Investigator Paul transported Hazel Hinds to the District Four office where she was interviewed by Major Case investigators.910 Investigator Paul proceeded to 114 Elderberry Lane, Longwood, Florida and made contact with Raymond Davis' son, Steven Davis. Steven 11 Davis was notified of the passing of his father.

Paul, Jayson 8070 1F94 11-10-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-06-2015 1835 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 On 11-06-15 at approximately 1836 hours, Deputy Mele responded to Deltona, with Deputy Cort in reference to a person 2 shot. The reporting party advised Central Dispatch that he shot his uncle. 34 Upon arrival, Deputy Mele and Deputy Cort provided cover as other deputies secured the suspected shooter in handcuffs for investigative 5 purposes. Once the suspected shooter was in custody, Deputy Mele and Deputy Cort moved to the west side of the residence by the open 6 overhead garage door to keep exterior security of the residence. Deputy Mele noticed the interior garage door to the interior of the residence was 7 open, and could hear a female crying and yelling for help within. An entry team of Deputies entered the residence through the open interior 8 garage door. Deputy Mele heard a deputy request a wheelchair to assist with moving the female. Deputy Mele observed a wheelchair in the 9 garage and brought it into the residence. Deputy Mele returned back outside to keep exterior security with Deputy Cort, until deputies within the 10 residence finished clearing the residence of any threats. Deputy Mele then moved to the front door of the residence with Deputy Cort to assist in 11 maintaining security of the crime scene until no longer needed.1213 No further action taken by Deputy Mele.

Mele, Paul 7634 1D47 11-12-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-12-2015 1640 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 The purpose of this supplement is to clarify the information Deputy DeMarco provided in his first supplement to this case.23 Upon reaching the front door of the residence, Deputy DeMarco could hear a female screaming inside the residence. Deputy Campbell 4 attempted several times to get the attention of the female through verbal dialogue, but was unsuccessful. Deputy DeMarco entered the residence, 5 along with several other deputies, in an effort to check for any possible victim(s) and/or suspect(s). Deputy DeMarco did not observe any person(s) 6 within the front entry way of the residence, but upon entering the main living area, Deputy DeMarco observed a female (Hazel Kinds) laying on the 7 floor next to a table. Deputy DeMarco observed the female was laying in the fetal position, and was visibly upset and crying. Deputy DeMarco also 8 observed a male (Ray Davis) laying motionless approximately five to ten feet away from Kinds. Deputy DeMarco observed Davis to be laying on 9 his back, with a trail of blood emanating from the back of his head. Deputy DeMarco also observed a black handgun on the couch. Deputy 10 DeMarco continued checking the residence, and no further person(s) were observed in the residence. Deputy DeMarco then exited the residence, 11 and provided assistance to Kinds.

Demarco, James 8327 1C92 11-12-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-06-2015 1840 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 On 11-6-2015, at 1840 hours, Deputy Coker responded to Deltona, in reference to a person shot. 23 Prior to arrival Deputy Coker became aware that the reporting party, Bobby Harrelson (R1), had stated to Central Dispatch that he had shot his 4 uncle who was Attacking his mother. 56 Upon arrival Deputy Coker observed Harrelson standing in the front yard of the residence with his hands in the air. Deputy Luoma gave Harrelson 7 verbal commands to which he complied. Deputy Coker was then advised that Harrelson was secured and placed in a VCSO patrol car. 89 Deputy Coker, Deputy Cambell, along with several other deputies went to the front door of the residence. Deputy Campbell attempted to make 10 contact with Hazel Kinds (O1), with negative results. Deputy Coker could hear Kinds crying and moaning from the open front door. Deputy Coker 11 and the deputies with him, entered the residence and cleared the two bedrooms on the west side of the residence. Upon clearing the bedrooms on 12 the west side, Deputy Coker was advised that the remaining residence was clear and Ray Davis (V1) was deceased. Deputy Coker then vacated 13 the residence and secured the scene with crime scene tape.1415 No further investigative action was taken by Deputy Coker pertaining to this case.

Coker, Bryan 8325 1C98 11-12-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-12-2015 1026 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 On 11/06/15 at approximately 1838 hours Sergeant Gowan responded to Deltona , in reference to a report of a person 2 shot. Central Communications advised a male subject called and stated he just shot his uncle in the head. Sergeant Gowan arrived on scene at 3 approximately 1840 hours and observed Harrelson, Bobby standing in the street with his hands raised in the air. Deputies secured Harrelson for 4 officer safety and then began to assemble near the front of the residence to attempt to communicate with any person(s) inside. Deputy Campbell 5 was nearest the front door and was loudly announcing "Volusia County Sheriff's Office". There was no response to Deputy Campbell's 6 announcement, however; Sergeant Gowan could hear what sounded like a female voice crying and screaming.78 Deputy Campbell tried unsuccessfully to establish communications with the female (Hinds, Hazel). Deputy Louma lead a second group of deputies 9 into the open garage door and into the residence near the living room and kitchen area. Deputy Louma called out to Deputy Campbell and stated 10 he cleared the kitchen but needed additional deputies to enter the residence via the front door to check on Hinds. Deputy Campbell lead a small 11 group of deputies into the residence via the front door.1213 Sergeant Gowan remained outside and observed deputies checking the well being of Hinds and ultimately assisting her into a wheelchair so she 14 could exit the residence.1516 Sergeant Gowan remained outside the residence as additional resources arrived on scene. Investigator J. Paul was the first investigative 17 resource to arrive on scene. Investigator Paul stated he was going to enter the crime scene and requested Sergeant Gowan and Sergeant 18 Whitener accompany him. Sergeant Gowan entered the residence via the front door. Upon reaching the living room area, Sergeant Gowan 19 observed an adult, white male, lying on his back, face-up. Sergeant Gowan observed a pool of blood on the floor under and near the male's 20 (Davis) head. Sergeant Gowan noted a black semi-automatic pistol was on the couch cushion near Davis. Sergeant Gowan exited the residence 21 and updated District IV Command Staff via telephone.2223 Sergeant Gowan took no other action during this investigation.2425 Case Status remains unchanged by this supplement report.

Gowan, Sean 2435 1D40 11-12-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-13-2015 1929 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 On 11/06/2015, at 1836 hours, Sergeant Whitener responded to in reference to a person shot. On arrival, Sergeant 2 Whitener, Deputy Luoma, Deputy Campbell, Deputy Cort, Deputy Mele, and Deputy Hansard began clearing the house. Sergeant Whitener and 3 Deputy Luoma entered through the open garage, while the other deputies entered through the front door. Upon meeting the other deputies in the 4 dining room area, Sergeant Whitener observed Hinds(O1) on the floor, face down in front of the sliding glass door. Hazel was screaming and 5 would not listen to the deputies. Sergeant Whitener was able to see Davis(V1) on the living room floor, face up, with his head facing to the west or 6 the two side of the house. Sergeant Whitener blocked Hinds' view of Davis when Deputy Hansard and Deputy Campbell placed Hines into a wheel 7 chair and removed her from the residence. Sergeant Whitener notified central dispatch to have CID, Major Case, Crime Scene, and the Victim's 8 Advocate respond to the scene. The Watch Commander responded to the scene.910 Case Status: Active/Turned over to Major Case

Whitener, Charles 6844 1D90 11-13-2015


EV


2.Supplement





99.Other

THE

FT





Codes

CO

DE

S

L. Livestock






Activity

B. Buy

P. PossessS. Sell






Cultivate

DR

UG

CO

DE

S

99.Other









4. Other





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$


F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AIN

OF

CU

STO

DY


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AD

MIN


Category


PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$

Article Description

F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value



PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$ $




Person Code #

Person Code #

$

$

$

$






Category Code

B. Bicycle

D. DeliverE. Use


U. UnknownZ. Other


Date Recovered:






Date Recovered:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

Item # Date: Time:


1 1

11-17-2015 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

4 1 1 Y OTHER 1DVD Hazel Hinds interview 11/06/15

3 2 1 Y OTHER 1DVD Bobby Harrelson interview 11/09/2015

1,2 11-17-2015 1250

SK

Betz, Jerry 1371 11-17-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 1

11-30-2015 1025 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

12 On 11/06/15, at approximately 1945hrs, Inv. Burke was contacted by Inv. Betz per Sgt. Thoman, who requested assistance in reference to a 3 shooting that occurred at Deltona. Inv. Burke was informed by Inv. Betz that VCSO dispatch advised the shooter is an off-duty 4 Deland Police Officer, the deceased is the police officer's uncle. 56 Inv. Burke responded to District 4 and meet with Inv. Betz, Inv. Amhrine, Inv. Jayson Paul,and Sgt. Thoman. Inv. Paul advised he responded to 7 505 Tradwinds, he met with deputies on the scene. Inv. Paul briefed Inv. Burke, Inv. Betz and Inv. Amhrine of what he learned about the scene.8 See Inv. Betz report for synopsis of the briefing. 910 At District 4, Inv. Burke met with Victims Advocate, Pat Taylor. Pat had been sitting with Bobby Harrelson's mother, Hazel Hinds, at the district 11 until investigators arrived. Pat advised that Ms. Hinds told her that her brother, Raymond Davis, is an alcoholic and had been drinking all day, this 12 evening he told her that he was going to kill her. Pat advised Ms. Hinds told her that her brother would have killed her; she said she was hit in the 13 head and she heard a gun go off. Pat advised she didn't question Ms. Hinds about the events; these were just statements that she made to her.1415 Inv. Burke and Inv. Betz conducted a noncustodial interview with Hazel Hinds; Pat Taylor was also present during this interview. During the 16 interview Ms. Hinds explained that her brother, Raymond Davis, is an alcoholic and drank a lot of alcohol on this evening. Ms. Hinds explained 17 she and her son, Bobby, were in the living room when Raymond came out in a rage, lifted her up off the recliner, and started choking her. Ms. 18 Hinds advised Bobby tried to separate them but he couldn't, she said she heard a loud bang, she said during the interview that she knows what a 19 gun sounds like when it is fired. Ms. Hinds advised she would not look at Raymond after she heard the bang; she said the physical altercation 20 then stopped. Ms. Hinds explained during the interview that Raymond had been physically abusive toward her in the past but she never told 21 anyone of the abuse. Ms. Hinds had visible swelling and redness below her left eye, and a faint bruise on her left forehead at her hairline, no 22 visible injury could be seen around her neck at this time. Ms. Hinds was photographed by Crime Scene Investigators. This interview was 23 recorded; refer to DVD with recorded interview for complete details. 2425 After the interview with Ms. Hinds was conducted, Inv. Betz and Inv. Burke responded to Deltona. The house was entered after 26 CSI photographed the scene and the search warrant was read. The house appeared to be neat and orderly, Raymond Davis, was observed on 27 the floor in the family room with blood pooled around his head area. It appeared that Raymond had a gunshot wound to his head. A handgun was 28 observed lying on the couch where Ms. Hinds was sitting before Raymond picked her up. Inv. Burke observed the scene then returned to the 29 kitchen area while the scene was processed by CSU.3031 Case Status: Continued to Inv. Amrhine32

Burke, Tara 1465 11-30-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 5

11-06-2015 2104 11-06-2015 HOMICIDE 150029661 2

1 On 11-06-2015 at approximately 1926 hours, Deputy Bethea responded as a Crime Scene Investigator to Deltona in 2 reference to a person shot call. Deputy Bethea arrived on scene at approximately 2038 hours. While on scene, Deputy Bethea was informed by 3 Deputy Mele that the suspect, Bobby Harrelson(S1), and his mother, Hazel Hinds(W1), were transported to the Volusia County Sheriff's Office 4 District 4 Office. Deputy Bethea learned that Harrelson's uncle, Raymond Davis(V1), was deceased inside the residence. At that time, Deputy 5 Bethea did not enter the residence.67 On 11-06-2015 at approximately 2056 hours, Deputy Bethea responded to the Volusia County Sheriff's Office District 4 Office located at 1691 8 Providence Boulevard in Deltona. Deputy Bethea arrived at the Volusia County Sheriff's Office District 4 Office on 11-06-2015 at approximately 9 2102 hours. Deputy Bethea made contact with Major Case Investigators, Investigator Betz and Sergeant Thoman. Deputy Bethea was briefed 10 about the incident. Deputy Bethea along with Investigator Betz made contact with Harrelson who was sitting in the back seat of a patrol car (Not 11 Handcuffed). Investigator Betz identified himself before Harrelson was asked if he would submit to Gun Shot Residue (GSR) exam. Harrelson 12 advised he would not make any statements nor do anything until his attorney was present. Harrelson was visibly upset over the incident. 13 Harrelson's attorney arrived on scene and Harrelson's was provided some privacy to speak to his attorney. 1415 On 11-06-2015 at approximately 2230 hours, Harrelson submitted to a GSR exam. Deputy Bethea utilized a Tritech Forensics Gunshot 16 Residue Evidence Collection Kit on Harrelson's hands. Deputy Bethea donned and maintained examination gloves while processing / handling / 17 collecting evidence. 1819 On 11-07-2015 at approximately 0014 hours, Harrelson voluntarily provided his shirt and shorts. Deputy Bethea photographed Harrelson's 20 person while visually examining him for injuries while he was in an interview room. Deputy Bethea made the following observations regarding the 21 location of injuries on Harrelson; 2223 1) Abrasion on the exterior of right forearm.24 2) Bruising on right shin. 25 3) Abrasion / Bruising to right bi-cep, shoulder and pectoral.26 4) Bruising on left bi-cep and pectoral. 27 5) Redness across the top of the back between the shoulder blades. 28 6) Redness on right wrist. 29 7) Possible swelling on the right side of the head. 3031 Harrelson also allowed Deputy Bethea to use sterile cotton swabs to collect DNA from his mouth and hands. 3233 Deputy Bethea made contact with Hinds who was seated in a wheelchair in a separate interview room away from Harrelson. Hinds was visibly 34 upset and became even more upset after asking about her brother, Raymond Davis. Deputy Bethea photographed Hinds and documented the 35 following observations regarding Hinds';3637 1) Redness on the nose, forehead and left side of face.38 2) Substance consistent with blood in the hair on the back left side of the head. 39 3) Loose hair on the back of Hinds' t-shirt where the shirt meets her neck. 40 4) Red mark on the back left of her neck near a black non-metallic roped necklace she was wearing around her neck. 41 5) Abrasion / redness on the left portion of the upper lip. 4243 Hinds allowed Deputy Bethea to use sterile cotton swabs to collect DNA from her mouth and to swab the substance in her hair which was 44 consistent with blood. Hind's also willingly provided her t-shirt which had an unknown stain on the front of it. 4546 90 images of Bobby Harrelson and Hazel Hinds were remanded in Call ID 15519 to the Volusia County Sheriff's Office Digital Crime Scene 47 Server as evidence. 4849 A search warrant was obtained and executed at Harrelson's residence located in Deltona on 11-07-2015 at 50 approximately 0043 hours. Major Case Investigator Amrhine read the search warrant as Deputy Bethea digitally recorded the reading using a 51 Sony Handycam. Deputy Bethea conducted a walk-thru of the residence and property while recording with the Sony Handycam. The recordings 52 with the Sony Handycam were later submitted on compact disc as evidence. Investigator Graves and Deputy Turner assisted Deputy Bethea with 53 the documentation of the crime scene. 5455 Deputy Bethea made the following observations inside the residence where Davis' body was located;5657 1) The only signs of a struggle were observed in the living room / dining room area of the residence. 58 2) Davis' body was observed on the floor of the living room.

Bethea, Peter 7279 1CS16 11-09-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof





AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


2 5

11-06-2015 2104 11-06-2015 HOMICIDE 150029661 2

59 3) Davis' body was facing upwards with a large amount of blood and other bodily fluid beneath him. 60 4) Blood was observed coming from the nose, the corners of the eyes and ears. 61 5) Both eye appeared bruised and swollen. 62 6) Blood was observed on the inside of the left bi-cep.6364 A Crime Scene Sketch / Diagram was completed by Deputy Bethea with the assistance of Investigator Graves and Deputy Turner. 656667 The following items of evidence were photographed and collected from the following locations;6869 EVIDENCE DESCRIPTION LOCATION EVIDENCE WAS FOUND7071 1) Glock 35 (.40cal) / Serial Number: WLK828 / with magazine. On living room couch next to body.72 1 live cartridge in chamber / 14 cartridges in magazine.7374 2) Spent .40 caliber case On living room couch next to body.7576 3) Blue LG Cell Phone "H" On living room couch next to body.7778 4) 1.75L Jack Daniels - Gentleman Jack On living room floor next to body.7980 5) Open 2 liter bottle of Diet Coke On living room floor next to body.8182 6) Open 16oz Coors Light can In cup holder on couch next to body. 8384 7) Broken walking cane (Blue) On dining room floor. 8586 8) 1 Pair of bi-focal glasses On dining room floor.8788 9) Blood sample From living room floor next to body.8990 10) Duty gun belt and accessories From Harrelson's bedroom.9192 11) I-phone 5S From Harrelson's bedroom.9394 12) Berretta 9mm Semi-automatic handgun / (unloaded) From Davis' Bedroom dresser (right).95 Serial Number: BER302482Z9697 13) Taurus Judge .45 / .410 (5 -.410 cartridges) From Davis' Bedroom dresser (left). 98 Serial Number: CX94050999100 14) Glock 35 "DeLand Police Department" (Unloaded) From Harrelson's bedroom. (Closet / Top shelf)101 Serial Number: KHG645102103 15) Blue LG cellphone "R" From dining room table.104105 16) Safarliland holster (Black) From garage workbench (top).106107 17) GSR Kit from V1 (Raymond Davis) From Davis' hands.108109 306 Images of the scene were remanded in Call ID 15520 to the Volusia County Sheriff's Office Digital Crime Scene Server as evidence. 110111 On 11-10-2015 at approximately 1130 hours, Deputy Bethea examined, processed and photographed evidence items 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, 10 and 12 112 at the Volusia County Sheriff's Office Crime Scene Unit Processing Room located at the Volusia County Sheriff's Office Operations Center in 113 Daytona Beach, Fl. Deputy Bethea donned and maintained examination gloves while processing / handling evidence. The following items were 114 collected from items 1, 2, 3, 6, 7, 10 and 12; 115116 26) Sterile cotton swabs were used to collect from item #1's trigger, grips and rear slide.

Bethea, Peter 7279 1CS16 11-09-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof





AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


3 5

11-06-2015 2104 11-06-2015 HOMICIDE 150029661 2

117118 27) Sterile cotton swabs were used to collect from item #1's barrel.119120 28) Sterile cotton swabs were used to collect from item #1's front slide. 121 29) 15 cartridges were collected from item #1 magazine and chamber. 122123 30) Approximately 60ml of fluid was collected from item #6.124125 31) (5) .410 gauge SuperX HS cartridges were collected from item #13. 126127 10) Item #10 consisted of the following (counter clockwise);128 1) 1 black gun belt (basket weave design).129 2) 1 black double magazine pouch (basket weave design). containing 2 .40 caliber 15 round Glock magazines (total of 30 cartridges).130 3) 1 black Kydex Taser X-26 holster containing 1 Taser X-26 (Serial Number: X00-642211) with 69 5 second cycles left. 131 4) 1 black radio holster (basket weave design) containing 1 Harris P7300 portable radio. 132 5) 1 black flashlight holster (basket weave design).containing 1 Stinger flashlight.133 6) 1 black glove pouch (basket weave design). 134 7) 1 stainless finished key chain with ford vehicle key and handcuff key attached. 135 8) 1 black nylon belt keeper136 9) 1 black ASP baton holder (basket weave design) containing 1 black ASP expandable baton.137 10) 1 black Safariland holster (basket weave design) for Glock Model 35. (Empty)138 11) 1 black single handcuff pouch (basket weave design) containing 1 pair of Smith and Wesson hinged handcuffs. 139 12) 1 Gold finished belt buckle.140141 Black latent fingerprint powder was used to process item #7 for latent prints. 3 latent lifts were completed. The lifted latent prints were later 142 submitted to the Volusia County Sheriff's Office Technical Services Division for analysis. 143144 78 post scene images from 11-10-2015 were remanded in Call ID 15574 to the Volusia County Sheriff's Office Digital Crime Scene Server as 145 evidence.146147 On 11-11-2015 at approximately 1025 hours, Deputy Bethea examined, processed and photographed evidence items 13, 14, 15, 16, 18, 19 148 and 25 at the Volusia County Sheriff's Office Crime Scene Unit Processing Room located at the Volusia County Sheriff's Office Operations Center 149 in Daytona Beach, Fl. Deputy Bethea donned and maintained examination gloves while processing / handling evidence. The following items were 150 collected from items 13, 14, 15, 16, 18, 19 and 25; 151152 31) (5) .410 gauge SuperX HS cartridges were collected from item #13. 153154 32) Sterile cotton swabs were used to collect from item #14's trigger, grips and rear slide. 155156 33) Sterile cotton swabs were used to collect from item #14's barrel.157158 34) Sterile cotton swabs were used to collect from the front slide of item #14.159160 35) Gun case from item #13.161162 36) Gun box with 2 empty .40 caliber Glock magazines with reloading tool from item #14. 163164 55 post scene images from 11-11-2015 were remanded in Call ID 15575 to the Volusia County Sheriff's Office Digital Crime Scene Server as 165 evidence.166167 On 11-12-2015 at approximately 0830 hours, Deputy Bethea turned over the following items to Volusia County Sheriff's Office Evidence 168 Technician Lindsay Serido as evidence; 169170 Items 1-10171 Items 12-36172173 On 11-09-2015 at approximately 0900 hours, Investigator Betz took custody of item #1; I-Phone 5S from S1's bedroom. 174

Bethea, Peter 7279 1CS16 11-09-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof





AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


4 5

11-06-2015 2104 11-06-2015 HOMICIDE 150029661 2

175 The following items were sent to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement Orlando Regional Operations Center for analysis;176177 (Deputy Bethea's supplement report)178 #1) Glock 35 (BLK) SN: WLK828.179 #2) .40 cal shell case. 180 #14) Glock 35 "DeLand Police Department" SN: KHG845.181 #18) S1's Shorts.182 #19) S1's Shirt. 183 #21) SUTC from S1 (Buccal) Bobby Harrelson.184 #23) SUTC from Hazel Hinds (Buccal)185 #24) SUTC from Hazel's Hair. 186 #25) Hazel's shirt.187 #29) 15 .40 cal cartridges from item #1's magazine. 188189 (Investigator Mott's supplement report)190 #1) Projectile from victim's brain.191 #2) Projectile fragments from victim's brain.192 #04) Left and right fingernail clippings from victim. 193 #06) FTA card from victim. (Raymond Davis) 194195 Please see Investigator Mott's, Investigator Graves and Deputy Turner's supplements for additional information regarding the evidence 196 processed, documented and collected. 197198 A copy of this report and Deputy Bethea's findings were provided to Investigator Betz and Investigator Amrhine. 199200 This supplement does not change the status of this case.

Bethea, Peter 7279 1CS16 11-09-2015


EV


2.Supplement





99.Other

THE

FT





Codes

CO

DE

S

L. Livestock






Activity

B. Buy

P. PossessS. Sell






Cultivate

DR

UG

CO

DE

S

99.Other









4. Other





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$


F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AIN

OF

CU

STO

DY


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AD

MIN


Category


PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$

Article Description

F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value



PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$ $




Person Code #

Person Code #

$

$

$

$






Category Code

B. Bicycle

D. DeliverE. Use


U. UnknownZ. Other


Date Recovered:






Date Recovered:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

Item # Date: Time:


5 5

11-06-2015 2104 11-06-2015 HOMICIDE 150029661 2

00

37 21 Y OTHER 90 Images in Call ID 15519

90




Bethea, Peter 7279 1CS16 11-09-2015


EV


2.Supplement





99.Other

THE

FT





Codes

CO

DE

S

L. Livestock






Activity

B. Buy

P. PossessS. Sell






Cultivate

DR

UG

CO

DE

S

99.Other









4. Other





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$


F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AIN

OF

CU

STO

DY


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AD

MIN


Category


PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$

Article Description

F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value



PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$ $




Person Code #

Person Code #

$

$

$

$






Category Code

B. Bicycle

D. DeliverE. Use


U. UnknownZ. Other


Date Recovered:






Date Recovered:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

Item # Date: Time:


1 1

03-15-2016 1124 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 1 Y OTHER P/ 1.1: DNA Extracts,Cuttings, & Negative Controls

1 03-15-2016 1124 FDLE Orlando L Mandese / 7527

Evidence - FDLE Case 20150513198, Sub 001's DNA Extracts, Cuttings, & Negative Controls From: 4a,4b,5,1,2, & 3

Mandese, Lauren 7527 03-15-2016


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 2

11-08-2015 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 On 11/6/15, Deputy Turner responded to Deltona, to assist Deputy Bethea as a crime scene investigator in reference to a 2 domestic disturbance that resulted in a death. Deputy Turner arrived at VCSO district 4 at 2214 hours for briefing. Shortly after, Deputy Turner 3 relocated to , arriving on scene at 2328 hours.45 Deputy Turner assisted Investigator Graves with collecting personal items of clothing that were requested by the residents of the home. The 6 residents were being relocated to a different location for the evening, so the residence could be processed by VCSO Crime Scene units.78 Deputy Turner photographed bedrooms where the items were removed, prior to removing the items. The items removed were also photographed. 9 A total of 61 photographs were taken and later remanded to the digital crime scene database under call ID 15504.1011 After the execution of the search warrant, Deputy Turner assisted Deputy Bethea with the collection and preservation of evidence.1213 The case status was unchanged by Deputy Turner.

Turner, Jason 8194 1CS20 11-08-2015


EV


2.Supplement





99.Other

THE

FT





Codes

CO

DE

S

L. Livestock






Activity

B. Buy

P. PossessS. Sell






Cultivate

DR

UG

CO

DE

S

99.Other









4. Other





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$


F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AIN

OF

CU

STO

DY


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AD

MIN


Category


PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$

Article Description

F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value



PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$ $




Person Code #

Person Code #

$

$

$

$






Category Code

B. Bicycle

D. DeliverE. Use


U. UnknownZ. Other


Date Recovered:






Date Recovered:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

Item # Date: Time:


2 2

11-08-2015 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 21 Y OTHER 61 Photographs

Turner, Jason 8194 1CS20 11-08-2015


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 2

04-14-2016 1326 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 On 11-09-15 at approximately 1100 hours, Deputy Mefford met with Booby Harrelson (R1) at VCSO Operations. At that time Deputy Mefford took 2 several digital images of Harrelson's injuries he advised were sustained during the incident. 34 At approximately 1650 hours, Deputy Mefford and Inv. Amrhine responded to Deltona. At that time Deputy Mefford took digital 5 images of Hazel Hinds (O1) injuries with and without scales. 67 Deputy Mefford uploaded the following images into Digital Crime Scene:89 27 Images of Bobby Harrelson at VCSO Operation in call ID 1552810 14 Images of Hazel Hinds at her residence in call ID 169111112 At no point in time did Deputy Mefford question either person or take part in any interview. 1314 Case status is unchanged by Deputy Mefford.

Mefford, Eugene 7252 04-14-2016


EV


2.Supplement





99.Other

THE

FT





Codes

CO

DE

S

L. Livestock






Activity

B. Buy

P. PossessS. Sell






Cultivate

DR

UG

CO

DE

S

99.Other









4. Other





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$





PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$


F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AIN

OF

CU

STO

DY


Reason for Change:


Reason for Change:



AD

MIN


Category


PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$

Forfeiture Y / N:$

Article Description

F.W.T.C. (Y/N)


Value



PR

OP

ER

TY

Brand

Value Recovered:$ $




Person Code #

Person Code #

$

$

$

$






Category Code

B. Bicycle

D. DeliverE. Use


U. UnknownZ. Other


Date Recovered:






Date Recovered:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

Leave Blank:

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Drug

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

If Article

If Gun

Item # Date: Time:


2 2

04-14-2016 1326 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 21 Y OTHER IMAGES IN CALL ID 16911 AND 15528

Mefford, Eugene 7252 04-14-2016


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof

NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N






AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


1 7

05-12-2016 1026 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

1 On 11-06-2015, at approximately 1930 hours, Inv. Amrhine was contacted via telephone by Sgt. Thoman. Sgt. Thoman advised there was a 2 homicide, and requested Inv. Amrhine respond to the scene, advised to be Deltona. Sgt. Thoman stated that a male shot his 3 uncle in the head after the uncle attacked the male's mother. Sgt. Thoman advised Inv. Betz would be responding, as well as on call CID and 4 Crime Scene Unit.56 Inv. Amrhine later responded around 2130 hours to the VCSO District IV Office to meet with investigators there. Inv. Amrhine was briefed on the 7 current incident status, as well as that Inv. Betz was conducting an interview with Hazel Hinds, who was identified as the shooter's mother. The 8 shooter was advised to be Bobby Harrelson, an off duty Deland Police Department Sergeant. Harrelson was also currently at the District IV Office 9 with his attorney and union representative. Inv. Amrhine was advised Harrelson was not in custody, and was at the office on his own free will. Inv. 10 Amrhine was advised Harrelson would not be giving a statement, but would be responding to VCSO Operations Center on 11-09-2015 along with 11 his attorney for an interview.1213 Inv. Amrhine coordinated with Inv. Paul in the completion of a search warrant for the residence located at Deltona. The 14 completed search warrant was reviewed by HIU Attorney Davis. Inv. Amrhine and Inv. Paul then responded to meet with the on call judge. The 15 search warrant was signed by the Honorable Judge Miles on the same date (11-06-2015).1617 Inv. Amrhine was advised Inv. Paul would be making next of kin notification to Davis' son Steven Davis at his residence in Longwood, FL.18 Investigators Amrhine, Betz, Burke, Sgt. Thoman, along with CSIs Graves, Turner, and Bethea of the Crime Scene Unit then responded to 19 Deltona, to execute the search warrant. Upon arrival, Inv. Amrhine observed there was crime scene tape set up around the yard 20 of the residence, and there were marked patrol cars on scene with Deputies maintaining a crime scene log. Inv. Amrhine then read the search 21 warrant aloud in front of the residence on video recording by CSI Bethea.2223 After Crime Scene Unit completed their photographic documentation of the scene, Inv. Amrhine entered the residence via the front door. Inv. 24 Amrhine made the following observations at the scene:2526 The interior lights were on in the kitchen and living room. The residence appeared clean and tidy with not much clutter. There was a round dining 27 table in a dining area which sat next to the living room. There were prescription pill bottles on the table, and a medical device (oxygen or assisted 28 breathing apparatus) up against the bottom of the table. Nearby on the floor, there was a blue walking cane which was broken in half. The living 29 room did not appear in disarray. There was a red in color reclining loveseat sofa which faced away from the kitchen. There was a Glock 30 semi-auto handgun lying in plain view on the left hand side cushion nearest to the hallway. There was a spend shell casing lying in plain view on 31 the right hand side cushion nearest to the dining area. The right side recliner was in the reclined position.3233 The victim's body was observed lying on the floor face up with back on the floor and arms out to the side. The victim was observed to be an older 34 white male, identified as Raymond Davis. Davis was wearing only boxer shorts, and no other personal effects were observed. Davis' body was 35 lying in a large pool of blood, appearing to originate from the rear of the head. The blood appeared dark in color, and had already begun to 36 separate/coagulate. No other noticeable or apparent physical injuries were observed from Inv. Amrhine's vantage point.3738 An empty liquor bottle was observed sitting on the floor near the left hand side of the sofa next to an end table. There was an empty Coke 2-liter 39 bottle lying on the floor opposite to the end table on the other side of the victim's body.4041 Medical Examiner's Office Forensic Investigator Orozco responded to the scene. When FI Orozco and CSU turned the victim's body over, Inv. 42 Amrhine observed blanching and lividity in the victim's back. An obvious injury was also observed to the rear of the victim's head, consistent with 43 a gunshot wound.4445 The victim was then taken into Medical Examiner's custody via livery service and transported to the Medical Examiner's Office for later autopsy.46 See Crime Scene Unit supplements for details regarding scene processing and evidence collection.4748 Inv. Amrhine provided a copy of the search warrant to the Crime Scene Unit, who left the copy along with an inventory receipt in the residence 49 prior to the conclusion of the search.5051 The residence was secured and sealed by patrol.5253 On 11-07-2015, Inv. Amrhine was advised by Inv. Betz, that Steven Davis wished contact by the case agent regarding the investigation. Inv. 54 Amrhine then made telephone contact with Steven at his provided telephone number. Inv. Amrhine identified himself to Steven, and advised he 55 was the case agent in the investigation. Steven advised he had concerns regarding the circumstances surrounding the incident. Steven advised 56 he believed all (3) individuals involved in the altercation were consuming alcohol the night of the shooting. Steven was also concerned because 57 Harrelson shot his father Davis in the head, instead of some other part of the body. Steven also voiced concerns that Harrelson, because of his 58 employment in law enforcement, knew how to stage a crime scene.

5

Amrhine, Seth 7732 1E22 05-12-2016


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof





AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


2 7

05-12-2016 1026 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

5960 Inv. Amrhine advised Steven that he wished to speak with him further regarding his concerns as well as any knowledge regarding the relationships 61 and history of the parties involved in the incident. Inv. Amrhine requested that Steven meet with him at a later date and time to speak in person 62 regarding the incident. Steven agreed to meet with Inv. Amrhine at the VCSO Operations Center.6364 On 11-09-2015, around 0907 hours, Inv. Amrhine along with Inv. Betz met with Harrelson and his attorney Martin White at the VCSO Operations 65 Center for an interview. Harrelson was interviewed in an unlocked interview room with his attorney present. The following pertinent information 66 was obtained during the audio/video recorded interview:6768 Investigators re-introduced themselves to Harrelson, as well as reiterated that he was not in custody and was free to leave at any time during the 69 interview. Harrelson provided the following initial account of the incident:7071 Harrelson advised he resided at , Deltona, which was the location of incident. Harrelson (51 years of age) advised he lived at 72 the residence along with his mother Hazel Hinds (76 years of age), and his uncle Raymond "Ray" Davis (68 years of age). Harrelson stated he 73 was relaxing during the day on Friday 11-06-2015, as he had been at a school all week and did not have to return to work until Monday 74 11-09-2015. Harrelson stated he was not doing much of anything other than some chores, and intended on eating dinner at home.75 Harrelson advised he had been a law enforcement officer since 2003, and currently was employed as a Deland Police Department Sergeant.76 Harrelson advised he observed around 1200 hours on 11-06-2015, that Davis was already intoxicated. Harrelson advised around 1700 hours, he 77 observed Davis start the oven to get dinner ready, but then saw Davis go into his bedroom and passed out. Harrelson advised this was something 78 Davis did on occasion. Harrelson advised from about 1800 hours on, he was sitting on the couch with his mother (Hinds) watching television and 79 conversing with her. Harrelson advised he then observed Davis come raging out of his room unprovoked, which was something he witnessed on 80 (2) separate occasions prior. Harrelson stated Davis would always ask the same thing; why are you making so much fucking noise? Harrelson 81 described another instance he witnessed Davis yell at Hinds about making noise at 0700 hours, when in actuality it was 1900 hours at night.82 Harrelson stated Davis saw him standing in the kitchen, and turned around and went back into his room. Harrelson advised Davis did not go back 83 into his room during the latest incident. Harrelson then described the confrontation further.8485 Harrelson stated Davis stood near the recliner sofa, grabbed onto Hinds, and pulled her up from her seated position. Harrelson stated he believed 86 Davis grabbed Hinds by the neck. Harrelson advised he attempted to intervene and pull the two apart. Harrelson advised Davis then began to 87 strike him while Harrelson attempted to pull Hinds away from harm. Harrelson advised he believed Davis attacked him to keep him away.88 Harrelson advised Davis stated multiple times that he was going to kill both of them, meaning Harrelson and Hinds.8990 Harrelson stated at some point Davis must have pushed them, because Hinds fell to the floor and Harrelson fell back into the dining table.91 Harrelson stated by the time he stood up, he saw that Davis was straddling Hinds as she was on her back on the floor. Harrelson described 92 seeing Davis throttling Hinds' neck while saying he was going to kill her. Harrelson stated Hinds was screaming at the beginning of the attack.93 Harrelson then attempted to pull Davis off of Hinds, but stated it was ineffective and would only hurt Hinds more. Harrelson stated when he pulled 94 on Davis, Hinds would move as well. Harrelson stated Davis was a large man, and he could not get Davis off of Hinds. Harrelson stated he 95 believed Davis was killing Hinds based on Davis' statements and actions. Harrelson stated he felt that death was imminent.9697 Harrelson advised he believed Hinds only had seconds to live, so he retrieved his duty weapon and ordered Davis off of Hinds. Harrelson stated 98 he ordered Davis to get the fuck off of her (Hinds), but Davis did not stop. Harrelson stated he fired his weapon one time, which struck Davis and 99 ended the attack immediately. Harrelson advised his intention was to end the attack. Harrelson stated Davis then rolled onto his back which 100 caused him to lie next to Hinds. Harrelson stated he then grabbed Hinds and drug her away to the sliding glass door in the dining area. Harrelson 101 described Hinds as hysterical at that point. Harrelson stated he awaited law enforcement arrival.102103 Investigators then began to question Harrelson regarding the specifics of his advised statements, and to also obtain further details regarding the 104 incident.105106 Harrelson advised Davis had been living in the residence with Hinds for a few years, and Harrelson moved into the home in January of 2015.107 Harrelson stated there was one week where Davis moved out because Hinds was upset with him about his alcohol consumption. Harrelson 108 advised Davis moved in with his son Steven, who also did not like Davis' alcohol consumption, so Davis moved back home. Harrelson stated his 109 relationship with Davis was fine; however, he got frustrated with Davis' drinking habits. Harrelson described their relationship as an uncle nephew 110 relationship, and they were more of acquaintances. Harrelson described Davis and Hinds relationship, stating Hinds referred to Davis as her baby 111 all the time since she practically raised him. Harrelson stated Hinds probably loved Davis as much as she loved Harrelson. Harrelson stated he 112 knew Davis to be caring to Hinds, and helped out with her medical needs since he had a medical background.113114 Harrelson advised that prior to him moving into the residence, over a year ago, he noticed suspicious bruising on Hinds' face (cheekbone area).115 Harrelson stated Hinds told him that the bruising was caused by falling down. Harrelson stated he would not expect Hinds to take physical abuse 116 from any man, but stated she never told him she was being abused. Harrelson stated he would have expected Hinds to tell him if she was

5

Amrhine, Seth 7732 1E22 05-12-2016


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof





AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


3 7

05-12-2016 1026 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

117 suffering from physical abuse. Harrelson stated he asked Davis about the bruising when he first saw it, and David told him that Hinds would fall 118 often after taking Valium. Harrelson stated he believed both Davis and Hinds, because he knew that Hinds would fall from time to time as she did 119 utilize a walker. Harrelson described an instance when Hinds told him bruising she had on her eye socket (black eye) was from falling into a 120 dresser next to her bed.121122 Harrelson stated since he has lived at the residence, he has not observed Hinds to have any suspicious bruising.123124 Harrelson described Davis as a heavy alcohol user, and that he consumed alcohol (liquor) every day.125126 Harrelson stated Hinds told him after the incident, in their hotel room, that Davis had been physically abusing her (hitting). Harrelson stated Hinds 127 told him that Davis asked her if Harrelson (Bobby) saw Davis hit her. Harrelson stated Davis asked her that because Davis was too intoxicated to 128 remember if he had struck Hinds in front of Harrelson. Harrelson stated he did not have any knowledge of Davis physically abusing Hinds prior to 129 that night.130131 Harrelson then drew an overhead view layout of the living room of the residence, as well as where everyone involved was located in the room 132 during the altercation.133134 Harrelson stated the television's volume was on a low setting, and the television was turned off when deputies got to the residence.135 Harrelson advised he consumed alcohol the evening of the incident, which included a couple of beers and a shot of tequila around 1730-1800 136 hours. Harrelson stated he did not have any alcohol until then. Harrelson advised he did not have any knowledge of Hinds consuming any alcohol 137 that evening. Harrelson stated he knew Davis was intoxicated by the way he was talking and had observed Davis consuming alcohol earlier in the 138 day.139140 Harrelson stated the confrontation was completely unforeseen. Harrelson advised Davis threw his bedroom door open, and came out of the 141 bedroom. Harrelson further stated during the attack, Davis was striking him while Harrelson attempted to get Hinds away from Davis. Harrelson 142 advised he had some bruising which developed since the incident, and advised investigators could obtain photographs of the injuries.143 Harrelson repeated that he yelled for Davis to stop, but advised Davis would only respond that he was going to kill both you (meaning Hinds and 144 Harrelson). Harrelson stated he believed Davis was intent on carrying out the threat.145146 Harrelson advised when both he and Hinds fell to the ground, Hinds fell to her back with her head pointing towards Harrelson's bedroom.147 Harrelson stated he observed Davis was facing the same direction that Hinds' head was pointing, as Davis was straddling her chest while 148 strangling her. Harrelson stated he jumped up and ran over to Davis and attempted to pull Davis off of Hinds. Harrelson advised he only 149 attempted to pull Davis off of Hinds, and he did not attempt any strikes or other forms of pain compliance (knee strikes, hand strikes, choke holds, 150 etc.). Harrelson stated he repeatedly ordered for Davis to get off of Hinds, but that had no effect.151152 Harrelson reiterated that Davis was throttling Hinds' throat while saying he was going to kill her. Harrelson stated Hinds was screaming noises, but 153 not saying anything discernable. Harrelson stated he did not believe Hinds had much time to live. Harrelson stated he had no other choice but to 154 end the threat by retrieving his firearm. Harrelson stated the firearm he utilized (Glock model 35 .40 cal.) was located inside a holster affixed to his 155 Deland Police Department issued duty belt, along with a Taser model X26, an Asp expandable baton, a pair of hinged handcuffs, and a portable 156 radio. Harrelson advised the belt was lying out in the open on a table in his bedroom near the doorway.157158 Harrelson advised that he has had previous experiences where Taser was ineffective, and further stated that if he would have chosen to utilize his 159 Taser and a malfunction occurred he believed Hinds would have been killed.160161 Harrelson stated he believed the Asp expandable baton would have been ineffective, due to the large size of Davis. Harrelson advised he did not 162 believe that would have stopped Davis, moreover, he believed Davis would have further angered.163164 Harrelson was adamant that if he did not act quickly and utilize his firearm to stop the attack, he felt that Hinds would have been killed.165166 Harrelson stated after he retrieved his firearm, he went to the hallway opening to the living room and ordered Davis off of Hinds again. Harrelson 167 also stated at that point Hinds was no longer yelling. Harrelson advised he was about (8) feet away from Davis at the time he fired his weapon.168 Harrelson advised he was in clear view of Davis if Davis would have looked at him. Harrelson did not know if Davis looked up at him or not.169 Harrelson stated although he ordered Davis to get off of Hinds, he did not verbally threaten to shoot Davis nor did he say he had a gun. Harrelson 170 did not know how long he gave commands to stop, but advised he repeated them several times prior to shooting. Harrelson stated Davis was 171 looking at Hinds towards the ground when he fired at him. Harrelson stated he aimed specifically at Davis' head when he fired a single shot.172 Harrelson advised Davis stopped immediately, and rolled off onto the floor. Harrelson stated Davis fell to his back with his head pointing in the 173 same direction as Hinds' was (towards the bedrooms). Harrelson advised he then went to Hinds and dragged her away from Davis towards the 174 dining area. Harrelson did not remember what he did with the firearm, nor where he retrieved his Sergeant's phone, Deland PD issued cell phone,

5

Amrhine, Seth 7732 1E22 05-12-2016


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof





AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


4 7

05-12-2016 1026 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

175 from .176177 Harrelson described the incident as traumatic, and stated even though he was concerned about Davis' drinking, he was the last person he would 178 ever want to hurt. Harrelson stated he did not want to hurt his family, and advised if someone had attacked Davis the same way Davis was 179 attacking, that Harrelson would have responded in the same way.180181 Harrelson stated he did not touch or check on Davis' condition, as it was apparent that he was deceased.182183 Harrelson advised he checked Hinds briefly, and observed she was alive and breathing.184185 Harrelson advised he tried to away from Hinds, as he did not want her to hear what he was going to tell them. Harrelson stated 186 he remained on the phone until law enforcement arrived.187188 Harrelson advised he was not suffering from any physical ailments the night of the incident.189190 Harrelson signed and dated his drawing of the scene.191192 Harrelson granted verbal consent to conduct a forensic examination of both his personal phone and department issued phone. Harrelson also 193 completed a written consent form to do the same.194195 Harrelson swore and affirmed his statements were true and correct to the best of his knowledge. Refer to audio/video for full details.196 CSI Mefford took digital photos of several dark bruises observed on Harrelson's body (chest, side, back, leg).197198 Both of Harrelson's cell phones were turned over to VCSO Forensic Investigators to conduct a forensic examination of the digital contents.199200 Inv. Amrhine obtained audio files of the 911 calls from the Public Information Officer.201202 Inv. Amrhine later responded to along with Victim's Advocate Taylor and CSI Mefford. Inv. Amrhine made contact with both 203 Harrelson and Hinds at the residence. CSI Mefford took digital photos of Hinds, which included some redness on her face, swelling in her leg, and 204 bruising on her arm. Inv. Amrhine turned over the (2) cell phones back to Harrelson, who signed for them.205206 On 11-10-2015, Inv. Amrhine received a CD of the forensic extraction conducted on both of Harrelson's phones. During review of the information, 207 Inv. Amrhine observed phone call placed at approximately 1634 hours on 11-06-2015. Nothing suspicious was observed on either phone.208 Inv. Amrhine later met with Steven Davis at the VCSO Operations Center for an interview. The interview was conducted on audio recording, and 209 the following information was obtained:210211 Steven advised Raymond Davis was his father, Hazel Hinds was his father's sister, and Bobby Harrelson was his cousin (Hinds' son). Steven 212 advised he was last at the residence located at about a year ago. Steven stated he has only seen Harrelson and Hinds once 213 in the past year, but has seen Davis regularly. Steven advised he saw Davis about 2-4 times a month.214215 Steven advised Davis would tell him about the situation at their residence, and the issues that transpired. Steven advised he had no first-hand 216 information or knowledge regarding any violence or arguments, however, he felt that the living arrangement was volatile. Steven advised Davis 217 told him the following information of notation:218219 Davis advised Hinds spoke to Davis about leaving him the house, but Harrelson wanted the residence as a rental property. Davis advised Hinds 220 told him that he was her favorite in ear shot of Harrelson. Davis advised he and Harrelson often argued, therefore he would spend most of his 221 time in his bedroom. Davis stated he overheard Harrelson tell Hinds he could take care of him, and Davis believed Harrelson meant kill. Davis 222 advised this occurred within the past year. Davis advised he witnessed Harrelson act verbally abusive towards Hinds on different occasions.223 Davis advised Hinds begged him not to move out of the residence.224225 Steven advised he did not know of, or witness, any violent encounters between Harrelson, Davis, and Hinds, or any variation thereof. Steven 226 stated he knew of Davis' alcoholism, and advised he knew Harrelson used to consume alcohol heavily, but could not advise of his current habits.227 Steven advised he heard from Davis that Hinds consumed alcohol as well. Steven advised Davis did not drink alcohol around Steven's family 228 during visits.229230 Steven advised he did not believe Davis could become violent with an elderly person, especially Hinds. Steven advised he has never witnessed 231 Davis become violent with anyone in the past. Steven also did not believe that Hinds would talk about being abused, physically or otherwise, even 232 if she was.

5

Amrhine, Seth 7732 1E22 05-12-2016


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof





AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


5 7

05-12-2016 1026 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

233234 Steven was concerned that because of Harrelson's profession in law enforcement, that Harrelson had knowledge of how to stage a crime scene.235 Steven swore his statements were true and correct to the best of his knowledge. Refer to audio for full details.236237 On 11-20-2015, Inv. Amrhine contacted Gary Gang via telephone who had previously left a message stating he had information related to the 238 case. Gary advised he worked for a carpet cleaning business, and introduced his wife Judy to Hazel Hinds. Gary advised his wife Judy was the 239 current cleaning person for Hinds, and had done so once every few weeks. Gary advised Judy told him that Davis told her that he was tired of the 240 living situation, and was intending on moving out of the house. Gary stated he knew that Davis had a house that he was renting out, but was 241 intending on evicting the tenants to move back into it. Gary advised neither he nor Judy had any information regarding the incident, but were 242 aware of the problems in the living situation and that Davis was unhappy there. Gary advised Davis was a "hell of a nice guy". No information 243 was provided regarding any past violent encounters, or anything related to the shooting.244245 Inv. Amrhine later contacted Bob Nieland via telephone, who had previously left a message stating he had information related to the case. Bob 246 advised he was a Deltona C.O.P., and his wife Barbara used to be the cleaning person for Hinds a few years ago. Bob advised Barbara witnesses 247 Davis have angry outbursts during her time spent at the residence. Bob advised Barbara was not available to speak with Inv. Amrhine at that time, 248 however, agreed to meet at VCSO Operations Center on 11-23-2015 for an interview.249250 On 11-23-2015, Inv. Amrhine met with Bob and Barbara Nieland at VCSO Operations Center. Inv. Amrhine obtained the following information 251 during an audio recorded interview:252253 Barbara advised she was the cleaning person for Hinds from 02-2011 until about 12-2012. Barbara advised she cleaned the residence located at 254 Deltona once every (2) weeks during that time period. Barbara stated Davis resided with Hinds during the time, and 255 Harrelson did not. Barbara advised she observed that Davis was quick tempered, and did not help Hinds out around the house. Barbara stated 256 she witnesses Davis become angry and yell on (2) separate occasions, one directed towards someone on the telephone, and the other was 257 directed towards Hinds. Barbara advised she never observed any physical violence from Davis towards Hinds or anyone else. Barbara stated 258 she knew Hinds was of sound mind, however, she noticed a stark change in Hinds' behavior after Davis moved into her residence. Barbara 259 advised it appeared as if Davis was drugged. Barbara could not provide any information regarding the current living situation, or any information 260 regarding violence between Davis, Harrelson, and Hinds.261262 Barbara swore her statements were true and correct to the best of her knowledge. Refer to audio for full details.263264 On 11-30-2015, Inv. Amrhine received a digital drawing of the scene diagram from the shooting for his review.265266 Inv. Amrhine received a lab report from FDLE reference ballistics analysis results dated 11-20-2015. Inv. Amrhine observed the following 267 information:268269 The spent .40 caliber shell casing submitted, which was recovered from the crime scene, was determined to have been fired from the submitted 270 Glock model 35 (SN: WLK828).271272 The report was signed by Crime Laboratory Analyst - Firearms Section Elissa McLaughlin.273274 These analysis results were consistent with the statements obtained from Harrelson.275276 On 01-12-2016, Inv. Amrhine completed a release of evidence form for Hinds' cell phone which was e-mailed to VCSO Evidence to authorize 277 release to Harrelson.278279 On 01-27-2016, Inv. Amrhine submitted the case to the Flagler County State Attorney's Office for review.280281 On 01-27-2016, Inv. Amrhine requested Harrelson's documented training and disciplinary history from Deland Police Department Lt. Moon.282283 On 01-28-2016, Inv. Amrhine received Harrelson's training records and disciplinary history. Inv. Amrhine observed no documented discipline for 284 any excessive use of force, or other notable similar incidents.285286 On 02-16-2016, Inv. Amrhine received and reviewed an FDLE lab report reference to ballistics analysis regarding the submitted fired projectile.287 Inv. Amrhine observed the following information of notation:288289 Correspondence of individual characteristics strongly indicates that the bullet was fired from the Exhibit 11 pistol (40 S&W caliber Glock model 35 290 Gen. 4 SN: WLK828); however, the correspondence is insufficient for an identification.

5

Amrhine, Seth 7732 1E22 05-12-2016


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof





AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


6 7

05-12-2016 1026 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

291292 The report was signed by FDLE Crime Laboratory Firearms Section Analyst McGlaughlin on 02-11-2016.293294 On 02-24-2016, Inv. Amrhine reviewed the Medical Examiner's report in reference to Davis' death. After review, Inv. Amrhine observed the 295 following information of notation:296297 Davis' death was determined to be a Homicide, which was caused by a gunshot wound of the head from being shot by another person. The path 298 of the projectile was described (generally speaking) as being from back to front, left to right, and a downward angle. The entry wound was free of 299 soot, stippling, or muzzle imprint. The projectile impacted the inner portion of the right temporal bone, and therefore was no exit wound.300301 The toxicology report showed positive findings for the following substances:302303 Ethanol (BAC of .169), Diazepam, Nordiazepam, Alprazolam, and Benzodiazepines.304305 The report was signed by Associate Medical Examiner M. Chiste M.D. on 01-26-2016.306307 On 03-30-2016, Inv. Amrhine reviewed an FDLE lab report in reference to DNA analysis regarding submitted standards and samples. After 308 review, Inv. Amrhine observed the following information of notation:309310 The fingernail samples from Davis gave chemical indications for the presence of blood. Apparent hairs were observed on exhibit 4b (left 311 fingernails), however, were not suitable for STR DNA analysis. No DNA results foreign to Davis were found on exhibits 4a and 4b (right and left 312 fingernails).313314 The DNA swabs from Hinds' hair gave chemical indications for the presence of blood. A complete DNA profile was obtained, which determined 315 that Davis was the source of the DNA.316317 No stains of significance for serology testing were found on exhibits 6 and 7 (Harrelson's shorts and shirt).318319 Exhibit 8 (Hinds' shirt) failed to give chemical indications for the presence of blood.320321 The report was signed by FDLE Crime Laboratory Analyst - Biology Section J. Heina on 02-09-2016.322323 On 04-11-2016, Inv. Amrhine and Inv. Calkins responded to Deltona, in an attempt to contact Hazel Hinds regarding any 324 Living Will she may have per the State Attorney's Office request. Upon arrival, contact was made with Harrelson at the front door of the residence. 325 Inv. Amrhine identified himself, and advised of the reason for the response. After some dialogue with Harrelson, Harrelson advised he wished to 326 consult with his attorney prior to Hinds speaking with Investigators again given her diminished mental/physical state. Inv. Amrhine assured 327 Harrelson he would not be questioned without his attorney present, as that was not the purpose for the contact.328329 Inv. Amrhine captured the contact on audio recording. 330331 On 04-14-2016, Inv. Amrhine later contacted Harrelson via telephone, per his request, and asked about speaking with Hinds. Harrelson advised 332 he would ask Hinds if that was O.K., and she agreed to speak with Investigators as long as they did not question her about the night of the 333 incident.334335 Inv. Amrhine and Inv. Calkins responded back to Deltona, to speak with Hinds at her residence. Upon arrival, Investigators 336 contacted both Harrelson and Hinds, and entered the residence. Inv. Amrhine obtained the following information from Hinds during an audio 337 recorded conversation:338339 Hinds was asked if she had a Last Will, or anything similar to that type of legal document. Hinds advised she had a Living Trust, in which 340 Harrelson was the beneficiary. Hinds stated she did not have a Last Will, nor was Davis a beneficiary of any of her assets. Hinds advised she 341 made a change to her Living Trust after Davis' death, where she gave Harrelson authorization to write checks on her behalf. Hinds advised further 342 that Davis was not taken off of her Trust and was never on it as a beneficiary.343344 Harrelson was present during the conversation, who advised the Trust was able to be copied if that was necessary in the future.345 Hinds swore her statements were true and correct to the best of her knowledge.346347 Inv. Amrhine noted that Hinds appeared lucid, and understood what she was being asked and was able to answer without any apparent confusion.348

5

Amrhine, Seth 7732 1E22 05-12-2016


EV


2.Supplement

Page Pagesof





AD

MIN

ISTR

ATI

VE




FCIC / NCIC Cancel

T.T. BOLO

Agency

Date:


NA

RR

ATI

VE

/ C

ON

TIN

UA

TIO

N


Final CaseStatus:

DCF Hotline


7 7

05-12-2016 1026 11-06-2015 DEAD 150029661 2

349 On 05-12-2016, Inv. Amrhine received and reviewed a memorandum from the State Attorney's Office regarding their filing decision for the case.350 After review, Inv. Amrhine observed that the consensus was that Harrelson's actions were justifiable per statute 776.012(2) "Justifiable Use of 351 Deadly Force".352353 Based on the evidence and statements obtained during the course of the investigation, it was determined that no criminal charges would be filed 354 against Harrelson in reference to the incident.355356 Inv. Amrhine documented his investigation in a supplemental report.357358359 Case Status: Closed

5

Amrhine, Seth 7732 1E22 05-12-2016
