washington v. william morris endeavor ent. et al. (10-9647) -- judge p. kevin castel's stay order ...

8/2/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Ent. et al. (10-9647) -- Judge P. Kevin Castel's Stay Order [July 20, 2011]

1/18


2/18

]ZCCNUW @B BNM[] NIIJLJK GD [HJ M@CQINGD[ Qingd{gbb }{nu{jk |ùfgdl bù \giignc Cùug} Nljdmw) n {nijd{ nljdmw {hn{

ujquj}jd{} nm{ù}) nz{hù}) cz}gmgnd} ndk qzeigm bglzuj}) n} nd %Nljd{ [ungdjj% `d ]jq{jceju 5)5118 gd {hjgu Dj| Wùf Mg{w `bbgmj$ G (M`cqg$ :) >>) >;$' Qingd{gbb niijlj} {hn{ Cjnkj ndk\gdgnu}fg) {|` jcqi`wjj} |g{hgd {hj Hzcnd Uj}`zumj} Kjqnu{cjd{ n{ \giignc Cùug}) |jujm`d}{nd{iw n}}gldgdl hgc %kjnk#jdk n}}gldcjd{} {hn{ gdrìrjk |ùfgdl cùj |g{h }zqqù{ }{nbb(cngiu``c) nmm`zd{gdl) ujmjq{g`d) ez}gdj}} nbbngu}) G[) j{m$' ù ejgdl nd N}}g}{nd{,} N}}g}{nd{){hnd lj{{gdl {hj `qqù{zdg{w { |ùf |g{h/bù Nljd{}$% (M`cqg$ 8=) 8:1$' Kzugdl {hj cjj{gdl) qingd{gbb kjigdjn{jk {hjdzcju`z} gdmgkjd{} {hn{ %ijk hgc {` ejigjrj $ $ $ hj |n} ejgdl kg}mugcgdn{jk nlngd}{$% (M`cqG$)u>:>$' Hj ni}` {ìk C}$ Fn{) %G,c {nifgdl ne`z{ {hg} |g{h w`z ejhgdk mi`}jk k`ù}) ez{ G mnd

G Qingd{gbb jxqingd} gd hg} `qq`}g{g`d cjcùndkzc {hn{ \giignc Cùug} Nljdmw cjuljk |g{h %Jdkjnrù% gd Nqugi51>1 {` ejm`cj \giignc Cùug} Jdkjnrù Jd{ju{ngdcjd{) IIM) {hj kjbjdknd{ gd {hg} in|}zg{$ (Qi$ @qq$ Cjc$ >;$'Gd {hj M`cqingd{) qingd{gbb ujbju} {` e`{h \giignc Cùug} Nljdmw ndk \giignc $Y>1uug} Jdkjnrù Jd{ju{ngdcjd{) IIMn} jg{hju {hj %M`cqndw% ù %\gii gnc Cùug}$% G ujbju }qjmgbgmniiw {` \giignc Cùug} Nljdjw ù \giignc Cùug}Jdkjnrù |hjuj {hj bnj{} qjucg{ n kg}{gdm{g`d$

# 5

Mn}j 5?>1#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj 5 `b >8


3/18

cnfj {hg} n czmh egllju g}}zj$% (M`cqG$ >:5$' C}$ Fn{ %gccjkgn{jiw lnrj Vqingd{gbbS {hj`q{g`d `b jg{hju |ùfgdl bù {hj djx{ bgrj c`d{h}V)S ù ejgdl qngk |g{h gd}zundmj ejdjbg{} b u {hj djx{ bgrj c`d{h} $ $ $ % ndk z}gdl {hj bgrj c`d{h} { i``f b u nd`{hju oè$ (M`cqG$ ,>>:=$' [hj djx{ knw) Nqugi 7) 51>1) qingd{gbb |n} lgrjd n mhjmf gd nd nc`zd{ j~zgrnijd{ {` bgrj c`d{h} qnw$ (M`cqG$ )u >:;$' [hg} |n} qingd{gbb} in}{ knw n} nd jcqi`wjj `b \giignc Cùug}$ (M`cqG$ >:2$' [HJ NUEG[UN[G@D NLUJJCJD[]

[hj qnu{gj} nlujj {hn{ qingd{gbb }gldjk {|` nueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{} kzugdl {hjm`zu}j `b hg} jcqi`wcjd{$ (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ i= 6 Kjb}$ Cjc$ =6 Ujqiw ;$' @d {hj bgu}{ knw `bqingd{gbb} jcqi`wcjd{) hj jxjmz{jk {hj bgu}{ nlujjcjd{ |g{h \giignc Cùug} Nljdmw ({hj %5118Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{%' n} n m`dkg{g`d `b jcqi`wcjd{$ (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ >=$' Hj jd{jujk gd{` n}jm`dk nlujjcjd{ |g{h \giignc Cùug} Jdkjnrù `d Oziw >)5117 ({hj %5117 Nueg{un{g`dNlujjcjd{%' n} n m`dkg{g`d `b ujcngdgdl jcqi`wjk ejbùj \giignc Cùug} Nljdmw cjuljk {èjm`cj \giignc Cùug} Jdkjnrù Jd{ju{ngdcjd{) IIM gd Nqug>51>1$ (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ >;$'

[hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ qu`rgkj} gd ujijrnd{ qnu{?[hj qnu{gj} nlujj {hn{ ndw mingc) kg}qz{j) ndk/ù m`d{u`rju}w {hn{ jg{hju Jcqi`wjjcnw hnrj nlngd}{ {hj M`cqndw (n} kjbgdj ne`rj') ù {hn{ {hj M`cqndw cnw hnrjnlngd}{ Jcqi`wjj) nug}gdl bu`c) ujin{jk {`) ù hnrgdl ndw ujin{g`d}hgq ùm`ddjm{g`d |hn{}`jrju |g{h Jcqi`wjj,} }jjfgdl jcqi`wcjd{ |g{h) cngd{ngdgdljcqi`wcjd{ ew) ù `{hju n}}`mgn{g`d |g{h {hj M`cqndw) }hnii ej }zecg{{jk {` ndkkj{jucgdjk jxmiz}grjiw ew egdkgdl nueg{un{g`d zdkju {hj VBNNS $ $ $ $ Gdmizkjk|g{hgd {hj }m`qj `b {hg} Nlujjcjd{ nuj nii kg}qz{j}) |hj{hju en}jk `d {ù{)m`d{unm{) }{n{z{j) gdmizkgdl) ez{ d`{ igcg{jk {`) ndw mingc} `b kg}mugcgdn{g`d)hnun}}cjd{) ù uj{nign{g`d) |hj{hju en}jk `d mg{w) }{n{j ù bjkjuni in|) mingc} bù|nlj} ù m`cqjd}n{g`d) mingc} en}jk gd j~zg{w) ù `{hju|g}j$

(5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ n{ >) n{{nmhjk n} Mnue`dj Kjm.$ Jx$ E$' G{ ni}` qu`rgkj} {hn{ %V{OhjNueg{un{ u) ndk d`{ ndw bjkjuni) }{n{j) ù i`mni m`zu{ ù nljdmw) }hnii hnrj jxmiz}grj nz{hùg{w {ùj}ìrj ndw kg}qz{j ujin{gdl {` {hj gd{juquj{n{g`d) nqqigmnegig{w) jdbùmjnegig{w ù bùcn{g`d `b {hg}

=

Mn}j 5?>1#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj = `b >8


4/18

Nlujjcjd{) gdmizkgdl ez{ d`{ igcg{jk {` ndw mingc {hn{ nii ù ndw qnu{ `b {hg} Nlujjcjd{ g} r`gkù r`gkneij% ({hj HKjijln{g`d Qu`rg}g`d))'$5 (5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ n{ 5$' [hj 5117Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ bzu{hju qu`rgkj} {hn{ HV{Shj nueg{un{g`d |gii ej m`dkzm{jk ew {hj NcjugmndNueg{un{g`d N}}`mgn{g`d (%NNN%' gd nmmùkndmj |g{h g{} {hjd#mzuujd{ Jcqi`wcjd{ Nueg{un{g`dUzij}% ndk {hn{ HV{Shj Nueg{un{ù }hnii nqqiw {hj }ze}{nd{grj in| `b {hj ]{n{j gd |hgmh Jcqi`wjj|ùf} ù bjkjuni in|) ù e`{h) n} nqqigmneij {` {hj mingc} ndk kjbjd}j} n}}ju{jk$% (5117Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ n{ >#5$'

[hj qnu{gj} k` d`{ kg}qz{j {hn{ {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ |n} nd nlujjcjd{{` nueg{un{j) {hn{ qingd{gbb ndk \giignc Cùug} Jdkjnrù e`{h jxjmz{jk {hj Nlujjcjd{) ù {hn{ g{}}m`qj gdmizkj} |g{hgd g{ {hj mingc} n}}ju{jk gd {hj M`cqingd{$ Un{hju) qingd {gbb nulzj} {hn{ {hjM`zu{ }h`zik d`{ }{nw {hj ig{gln{g`d ù kg}cg}} {hj M`cqingd{ ejmnz}j {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`dNlujjcjd{ n} n |hìj) n} |jii n} mju{ngd `b g{} qu`rg}g`d}) nuj zdjdbùmjneij ndk {hz} hj kgk d`{|ngrj hg} uglh{ {` ozkgmgni uj}ìz{g`d `b hg} mingc}$ ]qjmgbgmniiw) hj nulzj} {hn{ {hj 5117Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ g} zdbngu) `dj#}gkjk ndk {hj qu`kzm{ `b zdkzj gdbizjdmj ndk jm`d`cgmkzuj}} ejmnz}j hj }glzjk {hj Nlujjcjd{ n} n m`dkg{g`d `b ujcngdgdl jcqi`wjk) hj hnk jm`d`cgmquj}}zuj {` }gld {hj Nlujjcjd{ kzj {` hg} }{zkjd{ i`nd kje{) hj jd{jujk gd{` {hj Nlujjcjd{ |g{hnd jd{g{w {hn{ hnk }zqjugù enulngdgdl q`|ju) ndk {hjuj |n} d` djl`{gn{g`d n} {` g{} {juc}$ (QG$@qq$ Cjc$ 7#>1) >=#>:$' Hj ni}` n}}ju{} {hn{ {hj qu`rg}g`d uj~zgugdl {hn{ mingc} niijlgdl%kg}mugcgdn{g`d% ù %uj{nign{g`d% cz}{ ej }zecg{{jk {` nueg{un{g`d g} zdm`d}mg`dneij ejmnz}j g{ g}gd kgujm{ rgìn{g`d `b {hj indlznlj `b ]jm{g`d >78> ndk [g{ij RGG$ (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ 7#>1$' [hg} g})nmmùkgdl { qingd{gbb) ejmnz}j \giignc Cùug} %qu`c`{jVkS unmg}{ ejhnrgù gd n }w}{jcn{gm ndk

5 [hj \giignc Cùug} Nljdmw Qìgmw Cndzni ni}` }{n{j} {hn{ %VgS{ g} {hj qìgmw `b {hj \giignc Cùug} Nljdmw) {`nueg{un{j ndw kg}qz{j |hgmh nug}j} ej{|jjd \CN ndk {hj jcqi`wjj ujlnukgdl ndw n}qjm{ `b {hjgu jcqi`wcjd{ujin{g`d}hgq) gdmizkgdl kg}qz{j} ujlnukgdl m`cqjd}n{g`d) ejdjbg{}) kz{gj} ù {jucgdn{g`d) ejbùj n }gdlij djz{uninueg{un{ù nmjjq{neij {` e`{h qnu{gj}$% (Mnue`dj Kjmi$ Jx$ K n{ >$'

# ;

Mn}j 5?>1#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj ; `b >8


5/18

}ze{ij cnddju% ndk un{hju {hnd mùujm{gdl {hj}j quèijc}) \giignc Cùug} gd}{jnk %m`cqjiVijkScgdùg{gj} {` |ngrj {hjgu mgrgi ndk hzcnd uglh{} {hu`zlh cndkn{ùw nueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{} n}m`dkg{g`d} bù jcqi`wcjd{% (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ 8$' Kjbjdknd{} uj}q`dk {hn{ g}}zj} `bjdbùmjnegig{w nuj bù {hj nueg{un{ù {` kjmgkj ndk d`{ {hj m`zu{) ndk jrjd gb ozkgmgni uj}ìz{g`d `b{hj}j g}}zj} |juj nqqu`qugn{j) qingd{gbbhn} d`{ }j{ bù{h bnm{} }zbbgmgjd{ {` qujmizkj jdbùmjcjd{`b {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{$ (Ujqiw =#;$'KG]MZ]]G@D

>$ Ijlni ]{ndknuk[hj Bjkjuni Nueg{un{g`d Nm{ ({hj %BNN%') 7 Z$]$M$ > j{ }j~$) %g} nd jxquj}}g`d

`b,n }{u`dl bjkjuni qìgmw bnrùgdl nueg{un{g`d n} nd ni{judn{grj cjnd} `b kg}qz{j uj}ìz{g`d$, %Unl`dj r$ N{I Rgkj` n{ Cndhn{{nd M{u$) :7: B$=k >>:) >5> (5k Mgu$ 51>1' (~z`{gdl Hnu{bùkNmmgkjd{ " Gdkjc$ M`$ r$ ]|g}} Ujgd}zundmj Nc$ Mùq$) 5;2 B$=k 5>7)552 (5k Mgu$ 511>''$]jm{g`d 5 `b {hj BNN qu`rgkj}?

N |ug{{jd qu`rg}g`d gd ndw cnug{gcj {und}nm{g`d ù n m`d{unm{ jrgkjdmgdl n{und}nm{g`d gdrìrgdl m`ccjumj {` }j{{ij ew nueg{un{g`d n m`d{u`rju}w {hjujnb{junug}gdl `z{ `b }zmh m`d{unm{ ù {und}nm{g`d) ù {hj ujbz}ni {` qjubùc {hj |hìj ùndw qnu{ {hjuj`b) ù nd nlujjcjd{ gd |ug{gdl {` }zecg{ {` nueg{un{g`d nd jxg}{gdlm`d{u`rju}w nug}gdl `z{ `b }zmh n m`d{unm{) {und}nm{g`d) ù ujbz}ni) }hnii ej rnigk)guujr`mneij) ndk jdbùmjneij) }nrj zq`d }zmh lu`zdk} n} jxg}{ n{ in| ù gd j~zg{wbù {hj ujr`mn{g`d `b ndw m`d{unm{$

7 Z$]$M$ 5$[hj BNN ni}` j}{neig}hj} qu`mjkzuj} ew |hgmh bjkjuni m`zu{} cnw gcqijcjd{

]jm{g`d 5, } }ze}{nd{grj uzij$ ]jm{g`d = `b {hj BNN qu`rgkj} {hn{ %zq`d ejgdl }n{g}bgjk {hn{ {hjg}}zj gdrìrjk gd VnS }zg{ ù qu`mjjkgdl Vqjdkgdl ejbùj g{S g} ujbjuneij {` nueg{un{g`d zdkju% ndnueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{) {hj kg}{ugm{ m`zu{ %}hnii `d nqqigmn{g`d `b `dj `b {hj qnu{gj} }{nw {hj {ugni `b{hj nm{g`d zd{gi }zmh nueg{un{g`d hn} ejjd hnk gd nmmùkndmj |g{h {hj {juc} `b {hj nlujjcjd{)

# :

Mn}j 5?>1#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj : `b >8


6/18

qu`rgkgdl {hj nqqigmnd{ bù {hj }{nw g} d`{ gd kjbnzi{ gd qu`mjjkgdl |g{h }zmh nueg{un{g`d$% 7Z$]$m$ =$

N kg}{ugm{ m`zu{ cz}{ uj}ìrj b`zu gd~zgugj} {` kj{jucgdj |hj{hju nii ù qnu{ `b ndnm{g`d g} nueg{uneij?

VBSgu}{) g{ cz}{ kj{jucgdj |hj{hju {hj qnu{gj} nlujjk {` nueg{un{j6}jm`dk) g{ cz}{ kj{jucgdj {hj }m`qj `b {hn{ nlujjcjd{6 {hguk) gbbjkjuni }{n{z{ùw mingc} nuj n}}ju{jk) g{ cz}{ m`d}gkju |hj{hjuM`dluj}} gd{jdkjk {h`}j mingc} {` ej d`dnueg{uneij6 ndk b`zu{h) gb{hj m`zu{ m`dmizkj} {hn{ }`cj) ez{ d`{ nii) `b {hj mingc} gd {hj mn}jnuj nueg{uneij) g{ cz}{ {hjd kjmgkj |hj{hju {` }{nw {hj enindmj `b{hj qu`mjjkgdl} qjdkgdl nueg{un{g`d$OIC Gdkz}$ Gdm$ r$ ]{ì{#Dgji}jd ]N) =8< B$=k >2=) >27 (5k MgI 511;' (~z`{gdl @iku`wk r$Jicgun ]nr$ Endf) B]E) >=; B$=k


7/18

\hjd n qnu{w kg}qz{j} {hj jdbùmjnegig{w `b nd nueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{) ew nulzgdl)b u jxncqij) {hn{ {hj nlujjcjd{ g} r`gk ejmnz}j g{ g} zdm`d}mg`dneij) {hg} g} n ln{j|nw cn{{ju {hn{g} {wqgmniiw kjmgkjk ew {hj m`zu{$ Ujd{#N#Mjd{ju) >=1 ]$M{$ n{ 5; Z$]$ n{ 7;;#;:'$ [hg} g} n %ujrju}j% quj}zcq{g`d ejmnz}j gdkj{jucgdgdl {hj }m`qj `b nueg{un{g`d minz}j}) m`zu{} ljdjuniiw nqqiw n quj}zcq{g`d gd bnrù `bnueg{unegig{w$ ]jj I`zg} Kujwbz} Djl`mj ]$N$ r$ Eiw}{nk ]hgqqgdl " [unkgdl Gdm$) 5:5 B$=k 5>8)55= (5k Mgu$ 511>' (~z`{gdl C`}j} H$ M`dj Cjc,i H`}q$ r$ Cjumzuw M`d}{u$ Mùq$) ;21 Z$]$ >)5;#5: (>78='' (%G{ g} bncgignu in| {hn{ {hj (BNNS $ $ $ jxquj}}j} ,n igejuni bjkjuni qìgmw bnrùgdlnueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{}, ndk {hn{ ,ndw k`ze{} m`dmjudgdl {hj }m`qj `b nueg{uneij g}}zj} }h`zik ejuj}ìrjk gd bnrù `b nueg{ un{g`d$,, ,' Zdkju {hj ujrju}j quj}zcq{g`d) %( z Sdij}} {hj qnu{gj} mijnuiwndk zdcg}{nfneiw qu`rgkj `{hju|g}j) {hj ~zj}{g`d `b|hj{hju {hj qnu{gj} nlujjk {` nueg{un{j g} {èj kjmgkjk ew {hj m`zu{) d`{ {hj nueg{un{ù$% N[ " [ [jmhdì`lgj}) Gdm$) ;1#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj < `b >8


8/18

Bi``k " M`dfigd Cbl$ M`$) =88 Z$]$ =7:) ;1=#1; (>721#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj 8 `b >8


9/18

qj{g{g`dju }`zlh{ {` jdbùmj#{hj kjijln{g`d qu`rg}g`d#{hj mhniijdlj |n} bù {hj nueg{un{ù {`kjmgkj$ Gk$ n{ 5)28< (>772'6 Ujd{#N#Mjd{ju) >=1 ]$M{$ n{ 5)5: (>78='$ [hj qnu{w`qq`}gdl nueg{un{g`d hn} {hj ezukjd {` }h`| {hn{ {hj nlujjcjd{ g} zdjdbùmjneij$Bgdndmgni M ` u q $ t c N i n e n c n r$ Undkìqh) :=> Z$]$ #75 (5111'$

GG$ Nqqigmn{g`dN$ [hj L`rjcgdl Nlujjcjd{

Gd }jjfgdl {` kg}cg}} {hj M`cqingd{ ù }{nw {hj ig{gln{g`d qjdkgdl nueg{un{g`d)kjbjdknd{} n}}zcj {hn{ {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{) un{hju {hnd {hj 5118 Nueg{un{g`dNlujjcjd{) g} {hj l`rjcgdl nlujjcjd{ bù {hj qzuq`}j} `b{hg} c`{g`d$ (Kjb}$ Cjc$ =#:$'Qingd{gbb k`j} d`{ }qjmgbgmniiw kg}qz{j {hg} q`gd{6 hj nulzj} {hn{ e`{h Nlujjcjd{} nujzdjdbùmjneij$

[hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ g} {hj l`rjcgdl nlujjcjd{$ Bgu}{) {hj 5117Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ gdmizkj} gd g{} }m`qj kg}qz{j} qujjxg}{gdl {hj jxjmz{g`d `b {hj 5117Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{$ [hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ gdmizkj} |g{hgd g{} }m`qj %nii kg}qz{j}%nlngd}{ \giignc Cùug} Jdkjnrù ndk g{ k`j} d`{ qinmj n {jcqùni igcg{n{g`d `d nueg{uneij mingc}$]jj Zdg{jk ]{jji|ùfju} `b Ncjugmn r$ \nuugù " Lzib Dnrgln{g`d M`$) =2= Z$]$ :721' (%Nd ùkju {` nueg{un{j {hj qnu{gmzinu lugjrndmj }h`zik d`{ ej kjdgjk zdij}} g{ cnw ej }ngk|g{h q`}g{grj n}}zundmj {hn{ {hj nueg{un{g`d minz}j g} d`{ }z}mjq{geij `b nd gd{juquj{n{g`d {hn{

# 7

Mn}j 5?>1#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj 7 `b >8


10/18

m`rju} {hj n}}ju{jk kg}qz{j$ K`ze{} }h`zik ej uj}ìrjk gd bnrù `b m`rjunlj$%' ]jm`dk) {hj 5117Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ |n} jxjmz{jk in}{#gd#{gcj ndk qu`rgkj} {hn{ g{ %}zqju}jkj} ndw ndk niiqugù ndk m`d{jcqùndj`z} nlujjcjd{} $ $ $ $% (5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ n{ 5$' [hguk)qingd{gbb n}}ju{jk hg} mingc} nlngd}{ %\giignc Cùug} Jdkjnrù Jd{ju{ngdcjd{) IIM) bùcjuiwfd`|d n} {hj \giignc Cùug} Nljdmw) Gdm$% (M`cqG$ n{ >' (jcqhn}g} nkkjk$' \giignc Cùug}Jdkjnrù g} {hj jd{g{w qingd{gbb dncjk gd {hj M`cqingd{ ndk {hj jd{g{w |g{h |h`c qingd{gbbjd{jujk gd{` {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{$

E$ [hj Qnu{gj} Nlujjk {` Nueg{un{j G}}zj} `b Nueg{unegig{w) Gdmizkgdl \hj{hju {hj5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ ndk G{} Qu`rg}g`d} Nuj Jdbùmjneij ndk {hj ]m`qj `b{hj Nlujjcjd{Kjbjdknd{} n}}ju{ {hn{ {hj kg}qz{j ej{|jjd {hj qnu{gj} n} {` |hj{hju {hj 5117

Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ g} r`gkneij g} nd g}}zj {` ej kjmgkjk ew nd nueg{un{ù ndk d`{ {hg} M`zu{$(Ujqiw =#;$' %V[Shj g}}zj `b nueg{unegig{w cnw `diw ej ujbjuujk {` {hj nueg{un{ù gb{hjuj g} mijnundk zdcg}{nfneij jrgkjdmj bu`c {hj nueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{) n} m`d}{uzjk ew {hj ujijrnd{ }{n{jin|) {hn{ {hj qnu{gj} gd{jdkjk {hn{ {hj ~zj}{g`d `b nueg{unegig{w }hnii ej kjmgkjk ew {hj nueg{un{ù$%M`d{jm Mùq$ r$ Ujc`{j ]ìz{g`d M`$) I{k$) =78 B$=k 51:)518 (5k Mgu$ 511:' (jcqhn}g} gdùglgdni' (~z`{gdl Ejii r$ Mjdknd{ Mùq$) 57= B$=k :2=):22 (5k Mgu$ 5115''$

M`d}{uzgdl {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ zdkju Dj| Wùf }{n{j in|)= Gm`dmizkj g{ mijnuiw ndk zdcg}{nfneiw qu`rgkj} {hj nueg{un{ù |g{h {hj jxmiz}grj nz{hùg{w {`kjmgkj g}}zj} `b nueg{unegig{w) gdmizkgdl |hj{hju {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ ndk ndw qnu{{hjuj`bg} jdbùmjneij) n} |jii n} {hj }m`qj `b {hj nueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{$ Bgu}{) {hj Kjijln{g`d

= Qingd{gb b n}}zcj} {hn{ Dj| Wùf in| g} {hj nqqigmneij }{n{j in|$ Kjbjdknd{} k` d`{ kg}qz{j {hg} ndk mg{j {` mn}j}nqqiwgdl Dj| Wùf in|$ (Ujqiw ;$' G {hjujb uj nqqiw Dj| Wnuf }{n{j in| gd kj{jucgdgdl |hj{hju {hj Kjijln{g`dQu`rg}g`d g} jdbùmjneij$ Gd uj [jhund#Ejufjijw Mgrgi ndk Jdr,{ Jdl,u}) 888 B$5k 5=7) 5;5 (5k Mgu$ >787'(jxqingdgdl {hn{ %gcqigjk m`d}jd{ {` z}j n bùzc,} in| g} }zbbgjgjd{ {` j}{neig}h mh`gmj#`b#in| $ $ $ $%'6 Mn}nu`{{`) :>


11/18

Qu`rg}g`d jxquj}}iw qu`rgkj} {hn{ {hj nueg{un{ù %}hnii hnrj jxmiz}grj nz{hùg{w {` uj}ìrj ndwkg}qz{j ujin{gdl {` {hj gd{juquj{n{g`d) nqqigmnegig{w) jdbùmjnegig{w ù bùcn{g`d `b{hg} Nlujjcjd{)gdmizkgdl ez{ d`{ igcg{jk {` ndw mingc {hn{ nii `b ndw qnu{ `b {hg} Nlujjcjd{ g} r`gk ù r`gkneij$%(5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ n{ 5$' ]jm`dk) {hj qnu{gj} gdmùqùn{jk ew ujbjujdmj {hj %{hjdmzuujd{% Jcqi`wcjd{ Nueg{un{g`d Uzij} `b {hj NNN$ (5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ n{ >$' Uzij2(n' `b {hj NNN Jcqi`wcjd{ Nueg{un{g`d Uzij} qu`rgkj} {hn{ %V{Shj nueg{un{ù }hnii hnrj {hjq`|ju {` uzij `d hg} ù hju `|d ozug}kgm{g`d) gdmizkgdl ndw èojm{g`d} |g{h uj}qjm{ {` {hjjxg}{jdmj) }m`qj ù rnigkg{w `b {hj nueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{$% NNN Jcqi`wcjd{ Nueg{un{g`d Uzij2(n'$ [hg} indlznlj qu`rgkj} bù {hj nueg{un{ù {` kjmgkj g}}zj} `b nueg{unegig{w$ [hj ]jm`dkMgumzg{) hn} %hjik {hn{ |hjd $ $ $ qnu{gj} jxqigmg{iw gdmùqùn{j uzij} {hn{ jcq`|ju nd nueg{un{ù {`kjmgkj g}}zj} `b nueg{unegig{w) {hj gdmùqùn{g`d }jurj} n} mijnu ndk zdcg}{nfneij jrgkjdmj `b {hjqnu{gj}, gd{jd{ {` kjijln{j }zmh g}}zj} {` nd nueg{un{ù$% M`d{jm Mùq$) =78 B$=k n{ 518(m`d}{uzgdl {hj nlujjcjd{ zdkju Dj| Wùf in|' (mg{gdl ]hn| Lu`zq Gdm$ r$ [ugqijbgdj Gd{,iMùq$) =55 B$=k >>:)>55 (5k Mgu$ 511='6 Qngdj\jeeju Gdm$ r$ Ewewf) 8> B$=k >>7=) >515 (5kMgb$ >772$

M$ [hj Kjijln{g`d Qu`rg}g`d g} JdbùmjneijZdkju Ujd{#N#Mjd{ju) n ujcngdgdl gd~zguw g} |hj{hju qingd{gbb m`d{j}{} {hj

rnigkg{w `b {hj Kjijln{g`d Qu`rg}g`d ndk gb } ) |hj{hju zdkju {hj nqqigmneij }{n{j in|) {hg}qu`rg}g`d g} jdbùmjneij$; ]jj Ujd{#N#Mjd{ju) >=1 ]$M{$ n{ 5>

Mn}j 5?>1#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj >> `b >8


12/18

qujrjd{ n m`zu{ bu`c jdbùmgdl n }qjmgbgm nlujjcjd{ {` nueg{un{j%'6 Unl`dj) :7: B $=k n{ >5>(nqqiwgdl }{n{j in| {` kj{jucgdj |hj{hju {hj nueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{ |n} zdm`d}mg`dneij'6 }jj ni}`Kjk`d LceH r$ Ondz} j{ Mgj) 51>1 \I ;557)51>1' (mg{gdl Lundg{jU`mf) >=1 ]$M{$ n{ 58:8' (%|hjdjrju n qnu{w m`d{j}{} {hj jxg}{jdmj ù {hj jdbùmjnegig{w `b ndnueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{) {hj m`zu{ cz}{ uj}ìrj {hj kg}nlujjcjd{$%'

Gd `qq`}gdl kjbjdknd{}, c`{g`d {` m`cqji nueg{un{g`d) qingd{gbb }qjmgbgmniiwcjd{g`d} {hj Kjijln{g`d Qu`rg}g`d `diw `dmj#{` }zqqù{ hg} q`}g{g`d {hn{ {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`dNlujjcjd{ g} zdbngu) `dj }gkjk) ndk {hj qu`kzm{ `b zdkzj gdbizjdmj$ (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ 7#>1$'Qingd{gbb n}}ju{} {hn{ %V{Sjuc} }zmh n} $ $ $ ,V{hj Nueg{un{ù $ $ $ }hnii hnrjS jxmiz}grj nz{hùg{w {ùj}ìrj kg}qz{jV}S $ $ $ gdmizkgdl ez{ d`{ igcg{jk {` ndw mingc {hn{ nii ù ndw qnu{ `b{hg} Nlujjcjd{g} r`gk ù r`gkneij, $ $ $ ijnrj} d` u``c bù ozkgmgni ujrgj| `b {hj kjmg}g`d ndk djln{j} {hjVkSjbjdknd{,} V}gmS uj~zj}{ b u VnS ,}{nw qjdkgdl nueg{un{g`d$, % (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ >1$' Gdm`dmizkgdl hg} `qq`}g{g`d cjcùndkzc) qingd{gbb uj~zj}{} %{hn{ {hj M`zu{ gdrnigkn{j {hjV Szdm`d}mg`dneij qu`rg}g`d}$% (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ >2$' M`d}{uzgdl {hg} nulzcjd{ igejuniiw gd iglh{ `bqingd{gbb} qu` }j }{n{z}) G m`d}{uzj g{ n} mhniijdlgdl {hj jdbùmjnegig{w `b {hj Kjijln{g`d Qu`rg}g`dn} zdm`d}mg`dneij$

Zdkju Dj| Wùf in|) %VnS kj{jucgdn{g`d `bzdm`d}mg`dnegig{w ljdjuniiw uj~zguj}n }h`|gdl {hn{ {hj m`d{unm{ |n} e`{h qu`mjkzuniiw ndk }ze}{nd{grjiw zdm`d}mg`dneij |hjdcnkj $ $ $ $% Lgiicnd r$ Mhn}j Cndhn{{nd Endf) D$N$) ) >1 (>788' (mg{n{g`d `cg{{jk'$%[hj qu`mjkzuni jijcjd{ `bzdm`d}mg`dnegig{w m`dmjud} {hj m`d{unm{ bùcn{g`d qu`mj}} ndk {hjniijljk inmf `bcjndgdlbzi mh`gmj6 {hj }ze}{nd{grj jijcjd{ i``f} {` {hj m`d{jd{ `b {hj m`d{unm{V)qju }jS$% Unl`dj) :7: B$=k n{ >5>#55 (ni{jun{g`d} gd ùglgdni' (~z`{gdl ]{n{j r$ \ì`|g{) ;28D$W$]$5k >=>) S;: (5k Kjq,{ >78=''$ %[hj m`dmjq{ `b zdm`d}mg`dnegig{w cz}{ djmj}}nugiw ej

# >5

Mn}j 5?>1#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj >5 `b >8
http:///reader/full/N.Y.S.2dhttp:///reader/full/N.Y.S.2d


13/18

nqqigjk gd n bijxgeij cnddju kjqjdkgdl zq`d nii {hj bnm{} ndk mgumzc}{ndmj} `b n qnu{gmzinu mn}j$%Cn{{ju `b Bugjkcnd) ;1< D$W$]$5k 777) >118 (5k Kjq,{ >7$ Ni{h`zlhn qnu{w cz}{ {wqgmniiw }h`| {hn{ {hj nlujjcjd{ |n} e`{h qu`mjkzuniiw ndk }ze}{nd{grjiwzdm`d}mg`dneij) %{hjuj hnrj ejjd jxmjq{g`dni mn}j} |hjuj n qu`rg}g`d `b {hj m`d{unm{ g} }``z{unlj`z} n} {` |nuund{ hìkgdl g{ zdjdbùmjneij `d {hj lu`zdk `b }ze}{nd{grj zdm`d}mg`dnegig{wni`dj$% Lgiicnd) >6 }jj ni}` Eu`|ju r$ Ln{j|nw 5111) Gdm$) 2778'$

Qingd{gbb nulzj} {hn{ {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ |n} qu`mjkzuniiwzdm`d}mg`dneij ejmnz}j g{ g} {hj qu`kzm{ `b zdkzj gdbizjdmj ndk jm`d`cgm kzuj}}) ndk {hjuj |n}d` djl`{gn{g`d n} {` g{} {juc}$ (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ 7#>16 >=#>:$' ]qjmgbgmniiw) hj jxqingd} {hn{ hj|n} gd nd zdj~zni enulngdgdl q`}g{g`d |g{h \giignc Cùug} Jdkjnrù ndk %VgSd ùkju {` nkrndmjcw mnujju) nlujjgdl {` {hj {juc} ndk m`dkg{g`d} }{n{jk gd {hjV S m`d{unm{V S |n} d`{ zq bù kjen{j$%(QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ >=$' Hj }{n{j} {hn{ %{hj `diw ni{judn{grj V{ }gldgdl {hj nlujjcjd{S |`zik hnrjejjd {` uj#jd{ju {hj oè cnufj{ kzugdl n VuSjmj}}g`d$% (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ >;$' Hj n}}ju{} {hn{ujcngdgdl jcqi`wjk |n} %n djmj}}g{w% ejmnz}j hj djjkjk hjni{h gd}zundmj ndk c`djw {` ujqnwhg} }{zkjd{ i`nd}$ (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ >:$' \g{h uj}qjm{ {` {hj Kjijln{g`d Qu`rg}g`d gd qnu{gmzinu) hjnulzj} g{ g} }ze}{nd{grjiw zdm`d}mg`dneij ejmnz}j g{ %ijnrj} d` u``c bù ozkgmgni ujrgj| `b {hjkjmg}g`d$% (Qi$ @qq$ Cjc$ >1$'

# >=

Mn}j 5?>1#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj >= `b >8
http:///reader/full/N.Y.S.2dhttp:///reader/full/N.Y.S.2dhttp:///reader/full/N.Y.S.2dhttp:///reader/full/N.Y.S.2d


14/18

[hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ |n} d`{ }gldjk zdkju qu`mjkzuniiwzdm`d}mg`dneij m`dkg{g`d}$ Bgu}{) qingd{gbb hn} d`{ n}}ju{jk {hn{ hj n{{jcq{jk {` djl`{gn{j {hj{jdd} `b {hj Nlujjcjd{$ Hj n}}zcj} {hn{ {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ |n} `bbjujk %`d n{nfj#g{#ù#Gjnrj#g{) d`d#djl`{gneij en}g}$% (QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ >1$' ]jm`dk) jrjd gb\giignc Cùug}Jdkjnrù `bbjujk {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ `d n %{nfj#g{#ù#Gjnrj#g{% en}g} ndk ujbz}jk {`djl`{gn{j) {hg} g} d`{ }zbbgmgjd{ zdkju Dj| Wùf in| {` ujdkju g{ qu`mjkzuniiw zdm`d}mg`dneij$]jj Dnwni r$ HGQ Dj{|ùf ]jur}$ GQN) Gdm$) 251 B$ ]zqq$ 5k :22): (]$K$D$W$ 5117' (nqqiwgdlDj| Wùf in| ndk m`dmizkgdl {hn{ n b`dd m`d{unm{ `bbjujk `d n {nfj#g{#ù#Gjnrj#g{ en}g} k`j} d`{ni`dj ujdkju n m`d{unm{ qu`mjkzuniiw zdm`d}mg`dneij'6 ]nei`}fw r$ Jk|nuk ]$ Lùk`d M`$) Gdm$):=: D$J$5k 2;=) 2;< (D$W$ S 787' (bgdkgdl {hn{ g{ |n} d`{ qu`mjkzuniiw zdm`d}mg`dneij bù n ujnij}{n{j eu`fjunlj bgdd {` gdmizkj n} n m`dkg{g`d `b jcqi`wcjd{ nd nlujjcjd{ {` nueg{un{j mingc}'$[hguk) qingd{gbb g} nd jkzmn{jk gdkgrgkzni |g{h n enmhjiù,} ndk cn}{ju,} kjlujj |h` nmmjq{jk {hj{jci] %{` nkrndmj Vhg}S mnujju$% (M`cqi$ >:6 QG$ @qq$ Cjc$ >=$' [hjuj g} d` jrgkjdmj {hn{ hj|n} qujmizkjk bu`c ujnkgdl {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ ù n}fgdl ~zj}{g`d} ne`z{ g{} {jdd}ejbùj }gldgdl g{$ ]jj Cùug}) 2=< D$J$5k n{ 5:2#:< (kjmigdgdl { bgdk nd nlujjcjd{ m`d{ngdgdlnd nueg{un{g`d minz}j qu`mjkzuniiw zdm`d}mg`dneij |hjuj {hj qingd{gbb |n} n hglh }mh`ì lunkzn{j|g{h }`cj mìijlj jkzmn{g`d ndk qingd{gbb |n} d`{ qujrjd{jk bu`c ujnkgdl {hj nlujjcjd{ ùn}fgdl ~zj}{g`d} ne`z{ g{'6 [}nkgin} r$ Qu`rgkgnd Dn{,i Endf) }{ Kjq,{511;' (jxqingdgdl {hn{ %VnSueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{} nuj jdbùmjneij kj}qg{j gdj~znig{w gd enulngdgdlq`|ju$%'

Dù hn} qingd{gbb }j{ bù{h n }`zdk en}g} zq`d |hgmh {hg} M`zu{ m`zik m`dmizkj {hn{{hj Kjijln{g`d Qu`rg}g`d g} }ze}{nd{grjiw zdm`d}mg`dneij) }zmh {hn{ {hg} ni`dj m`zik ej n en}g} {`bgdk {hj qu`rg}g`d zdjdbùmjneij$ Qingd{gbb n}}ju{} {hn{ {hj indlznlj gd {hj Kjijln{g`d Qu`rg}g`d

# >;

Mn}j 5?>1#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj >; `b >8
http:///reader/full/N.Y.S.2dhttp:///reader/full/N.Y.S.2d


15/18

%ijnrj} d` u``c bù ozkgmgni ujrgj| `b{hj kjmg}g`d)% ez{ {hg} M`zu{ }jj} d` lu`zdk} bù }zmh nm`dmiz}g`d$ [hj {juc} `b {hj Kjijln{g`d Qu`rg}g`d k` d`{ qujmizkj n m`zu{ bu`c rnmn{gdl {hjnueg{un{g`d n|nuk gb n qu`qju }h`|gdl g} cnkj$ ]jj 7 Z$]$M$ >1 (}j{{gdl bù{h {hj lu`zdk} bùrnmn{gdl nd nueg{un{g`d n|nuk'$ Ejmnz}j {hj Kjijln{g`d Qu`rg}g`d g} jdbùmjneij ndk {hjNlujjcjd{ }j{} bù{h mijnu ndk zdcg}{nfneij jrgkjdmj `b {hj qnu{gj} gd{jd{ {` nueg{un{j g}}zj} `bnueg{unegig{w) qingd{gbb,} `{hju nulzcjd{} nuj b u {hj nueg{un{ù {` kjmgkj$ ]jj Ujd{#N#Mjd{ju) >=1]$M{$ n{ 51#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj >: `b >8


16/18

jd{g{ijk {` {hj ejdjbg{} `b ndk { jdbùmj% {hj {j{c} `b {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{$ (Kjb}$Cjc$ = d$ 5$' Nb{ju ndniwgdl {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ ndk {hj ujin{g`d}hgq ej{|jjd {hjqnu{gj}) G m`dmizkj {hn{ {hj Gdkgrgkzni Kjbjdknd{} cnw jdbùmj {hj {j{c} `b {hj Kjijln{g`dQu`rg}g`d$ [hz}) G djjk d`{ ujnmh {hj g}}zj `b|hj{hju qingd{gbb g} j}{`qqjk bu`c nr`gkgdlnueg{un{g`d |g{h {hj Gdkgrgkzni Kjbjdknd{} ejmnz}j) qzu}znd{ {` {hj Kjijln{g`d Qu`rg}g`d) {hg} g} ncn{{ju bù {hj nueg{un{ù$ ]jj M`d{jm) =78 B$=k n{ 517 (kjmigdgdl {` ujnmh {hj ~zj}{g`d `b|hj{hju{hj }gldn{ùgj} |juj j}{`qqjk bu`c nr`gkgdl nueg{un{g`d |g{h n d`d#}gldn{ùw |hjuj {hjnueg{un{g`d nlujjcjd{ gdkgmn{jk {hn{ %nueg{un{g`d `b {hj g}}zj `b nueg{unegig{w V|n}S nqqu`qugn{j%ndk {hjuj |n} n }zbbgmgjd{ ujin{g`d}hgq ej{|jjd {hj qnu{gj} ndk {hj nlujjcjd{'$

Bgu}{) {hj {j{c} `b {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ gdkgmn{j {hn{ qingd{gbb nlujjk {`nueg{un{j mingc} n}}ju{jk nlngd}{ \giignc Cùug} Jdkjnrù jcqi`wjj}$ [hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`dNlujjcjd{ qu`rgkj} bù nueg{un{g`d `b %ndw mingc) kg}qz{j ndk/ù m`d{u`rju}w {hn{ jg{hjuJcqi`wjj cnw hnrj nlngd}{ {hj M`cqndw (n} kjbgdjk ne`rj' $ $ $ $% (5117 Nueg{un{g`dNlujjcjd{ n{ >$' G{ kjbgdj} %M`cqndw% {` gdmizkj g{} jcqi`wjj} ndk nljd{}) |hgmh |`zik{hjujbùj gdmizkj {hj Gdkgrgkzni Kjbjdknd{}$ (5117 Nueg{un{g`d Nlujjcjd{ n{ >$' ]jm`dk) {hjGdkgrgkzni Kjbjdknd{} nuj jcqi`wjj} `b \giignc Cùug} Jdkjnrù ndk {hj nm{ù} |h` mnuuw `z{{hj m`cqndw bzdm{g`d}$ [hj niijln{g`d} nlngd}{ {hj Gdkgrgkzni Kjbjdknd{} ujin{j { {hj cnddju gd|hgmh {hjw jxjmz{jk {hjgu kz{gj} n} \giignc Cùug} Jdkjnrù jcqi`wjj}$ [hj}j bnm{ù}kjc`d}{un{j {hn{ n }zbbgmgjd{ ujin{g`d}hgq jxg}{} ej{|jjd {hj qnu{gj} ndk {hj 5117 Nueg{un{g`dNlujjcjd{ bù {hg} M`zu{ {` }{nw {hj nm{g`d nlngd}{ nii {hj kjbjdknd{} qjdkgdl nueg{un{g`d$M`d{jm) =78 B$=k n{ 5>> (m`dmizkgdl %{hn{ n} n }gldn{ùw {` n m`d{unm{ m`d{ngdgdl nd nueg{un{g`dminz}j ndk gdmùqùn{gdl ew ujbjujdmj {hj NNN Uzij}) V{hj qingd{gbbS mndd`{ d`| kg}`|d g{}nlujjk#{ èigln{g`d {` nueg{un{j nii kg}qz{j}) gdmizkgdl {hj ~zj}{g`d `b nueg{unegig{w% n} nlngd}{ n

# >2



17/18

d`d#}gldn{ùw |hjd {hjuj g} n }zbbgmgjd{ ujin{g`d}hgq ej{|jjd {hj qnu{gj} ndk {hj nueg{un{g`dnlujjcjd{'6 Mncqndgjii` Gcqù{}) I{k$ r$ ]nqùg{g G{nign ]$q$N$) >>< B$=k 2::) 228 (5k Mgu$ >77=;2 (5k Mgu$ 5118' (d`{gdl {hn{ m`zu{} nuj cùj igfjiw {` nqqiw{hj j}{`qqji qugdmgqij {` m`cqji nueg{un{g`d |hjuj {hjuj g} %n ujin{g`d}hgq nc`dl {hj qnu{gj}|hgmh jg{hju }zqqù{jk {hj m`dmiz}g`d {hn{ V{hj qnu{w `qq`}gdl nueg{un{g`dS hnk m`d}jd{jk {`jx{jdk g{} nlujjcjd{ {` nueg{un{j {` V{hj d`d#}gldn{ùwS) ù) `{hju|g}j qz{) cnkj g{ gdj~zg{neij bùV{hj qnu{w `qq`}gdl nueg{un{g`dS {` ujbz}j {` nueg{un{j `d {hj lu`zdk {hn{ g{ hnk cnkj d` nlujjcjd{|g{h V{hj d`d#}gldn{ùwS% '6 Mgmmhj{{g r$ Knrg} ]jijm{jk Nkrg}ù}) 511= \I 55:) n{ /=(]$K$D$W$ D`r$ >27 (~z`{gdl @iku`wk) >=; B$=k n{ 77>''$ %V[Shj ezukjd igj} |g{h {hj qnu{w n{{jcq{gdl {` nr`gk nueg{un{g`d ,{ ` }h`|{hn{ M`dluj}} gd{jdkjk {` qujmizkj n |ngrju `b nozkgmgni bùzc, bù hg} mingc}$% Numgdgnln r$Ljdjuni C`{ù} Mùq$) ;21 B$=k 5=>) 5=: (5k Mgu$ 5112' (~z`{gdl Lgicju) :11 Z$]$ n{ 52'$

# ><

Mn}j 5?>1#mr#172;8 Bgijk 1> Qnlj >< `b >8


18/18

Qingd{gbbhn} d`{ }h`|d {hn{ M`dluj}} gd{jdkjk {` qujmizkj nueg{un{g`d bù mingc}n}}ju{jk zdkju jg{hju [g{ij RGG ù ;5 Z$]$m$ >78>$ Cùj`rju) m`zu{} hnrj m`dmizkjk {hn{kg}mugcgdn{g`d mingc} n}}ju{jk zdkju e`{h qu`rg}g`d} nuj nueg{uneij$ ] j j t ) >; Qjdd QinnIIM) >57 ]$M{$ n{ >;2)5117' (jcqhn}g} `cg{{jk'$ Gkjmigdj {` jxjumg}j cw kg}muj{g`d {` kg}cg}} {hj M`cqingd{$ [hj nm{g`d g} {hjujbùj }{nwjk$M@DMIZ]G@D

Bù {hj ujn}`d} }{n{jk ne`rj) kjbjdknd{}, c`{g`d (K`mfj{ - >5' g} LUND[JKgd}`bnu n} {hjw }jjf nd ùkju }{nwgdl {hj ig{gln{g`d$ [hj Mijuf `b {hj M`zu{ g} kgujm{jk {`{jucgdn{j {hg} c`{g`d$ [hg} mn}j g} qinmjk `d {hj }z}qjd}j k`mfj{$ M`zd}ji bù kjbjdknd{} g}kgujm{jk {` qu`rgkj qingd{gbb |g{h m`qgj} `b ndw zdqzeig}hjk qgdg`d} mg{jk gd {hg} Cjcùndkzcndk @ukju$

]@ @UKJUJK$

Kn{jk? Dj| Wùf) Dj| WùfOziw 51)51>>

# >8


washington v. william morris endeavor ent. et al. (10-9647) -- judge p. kevin castel's stay order ...

Documents