water supp _water storage

8/10/2019 Water Supp _water Storage

1/90

WATER STORAGEAND

WATER SUPPLY

STUDY

mARCH 2012


2/90

City of Raymore, Water Storage Supply Study

Table of Contents1 Executive Summary

11 Water Supply "ptio#$

12 Elevated Storage ver$u$ %rou#d Storage a#d Pump Statio#

2 'ac(grou#d

3 Exi$ti#g Water Dema#d$ a#d *acilitie$

+1 Dema#d$

+2 Exi$ti#g *acilitie$

4 Curre#t Water Co#tract -it. /a#$a$ City

5 Water Supply Source$

1 Re$ervoir$

2 Well Water

+ Co#tracti#g for Water

! /a#$a$ City

!1 1t.a#d /e#tuc(y Road eter

!2 3ucy We44 a#d 3i#col# Road eter

!+ Harri$o#ville Co##ectio#

!! 5vaila4le Capacity

! /a#$a$ City Co#tract

! Summary of Co#tracti#g -it. /a#$a$ City

Water"#e of 6o.#$o# Cou#ty, /a#$a$

1 5vaila4ility of Water

2 Co##ecti#g to Water"#e

+ Summary of Co#tracti#g -it. Water"#e

7ri8Cou#ty Water 5ut.ority

1 5vaila4le Capacity


3/90


7 Water Storage 5#aly$i$

&1 Exi$ti#g 9#fra$tructure

&11 Exi$ti#g Co##ectio# Poi#t$

&12 Exi$ti#g Storage a#d Co#veya#ce

&1+ Exi$ti#g Co#trol$

&2 *lo- Pro:ectio#$

&+ Po$$i4le 7a#( 3ocatio#$

&+1 Previou$ Studie$

&! Storage 7a#( Style$

&!1 Elevated Storage 7a#($

& %rou#d Storage 7a#( Style$ a#d 'oo$ter Pump Statio#$

&1 %rou#d Storage 7a#( Style$

&2 'oo$ter Pump Statio#

&+ Water ai# Co##ectio#

& Propo$ed 5lter#ative$

&1 5$$umptio#$

&2 5lter#ative Source$ a#d Site$

&+ Re;uired 9#fra$tructure

&& Co$t E$timate$

&&1 Elevated Storage 7a#($

&&2 %rou#d Storage 7a#($ a#d 'oo$ter Pump Statio#

&&+ 5lter#ative Co$t Compari$o#$

& Co#clu$io# Water Storage

&) Recomme#datio# Water Storage

APPENDIX A,OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCEPRESENT WORTH CALCULATIONS

APPENDIX B KCMO RATE INCREASE LETTER AND KANSAS CITY STAR ARTICLE ON WATER RATES


4/90


List of FiguresFIGURE 1-1,MONTHLY WATER DEMAND PROJECTIONS AND COST PER 1,000-GALLONS

FIGURE 1-2,WATER STORAGE REQUIREMENTS

FIGURE 3-1,WATER DEMAND PROJECTION

FIGURE 5-1,ANALYSIS OFANNUAL WATER COSTS

FIGURE 7-1,PROPOSED ELEVATED STORAGE TANK LOCATIONS

FIGURE 7-2,EXAMPLES OF A FLUTED COLUMN ELEATED TAN! "LEFT#AND COMPOSITE ELEATED TAN! "RIGH

FIGURE 7-3,CUTAWAY OF A COMPOSITE STYLE TAN!

FIGURE 7-$,ALTERNATIE GROUND STORAGE TAN! %ELEATED STORAGE TAN! LOCATIONS

List of TablesTABLE 1-1,POPULATION AND WATER DEMAND PROJECTIONS

TA&LE 3-1,200'WATER DEMAND PROJECTIONS

TA&LE 3-2,HISTORICAL WATER USE DATA

TA&LE 3-3,WATER USE PROJECTIONS &ASED UPON HISTORICALAERAGE DATA

TA&LE 3-$,PROPOSED WATER USE PROJECTIONS FOR NEW WATER PURCHASEAGREEMENTS

TA&LE 3-5,EXISTING FACILITIES AND CAPACITIES

TA&LE 5-1,COMPARISON OF WATER RATES

TA&LE 5-2,COST COMPARISON OFANNUAL WATER COSTS

TA&LE 7-1,COMPARISON OF TAN! STYLES

TA&LE 7-2,FLUTED COLUMN AND COMPOSITE TAN! DIMENSION

TA&LE 7-3,GROUND STORAGE MATERIAL COMPARISON

TA&LE 7-$,SUMMARY OF REQUIRED INFRASTRUCTURE FOR EACHALTERNATIE

TA&LE

7-5,E

LEATEDT

AN!C

APITAL,

O%M,

ANDP

RESENTW

ORTHC

OSTS

TA&LE 7-(,GROUND STORAGE TAN! AND &OOSTER PUMP STATION CAPITAL,O%M,AND PRESENT WORTH COST

TA&LE 7-7,ALTERNATIE COSTANALYSIS


5/90


1 Executive SummaryKana C!"#$ %a"&' ())*# +n"'a+" %!" Ra#.'& %!** &/)!'& !n "& #&a' 0012 T& +3' Ra#.'& an4 Kana C!"# " n&5"!a"& n&% *!.!" an4 " 4&6&*) a n&% +n"'a+" a.("(a**# a5'&&a*& *!.!"2 Ra#.'& '&8(&"&4 "a" HDR &6a*(a"& Ra#.'&$ %a"&' (an4 .a9& a '&+..&n4a"!n n )'+('!n5 an a44!"!na* %*&a*& %a"&' ())*# a**+&+n4 "a9, a 3**% () n "& 3!'", %a " &6a*(a"& "& +" 3 5'(n4 "'a5& an4 a )6&'( &*&6a"&4 "'a5& a %a"&' "'a5& )"!n " .&&" )&a9 (' 4&.an42

1.1

Water Supply Options

HDR '&-&6a*(a"&4 "& ))(*a"!n an4 %a"&' )':&+"!n )'6!4&4 !n Ra#.'&$ 0; 'Ma"&' P*an '&)'"2 W& &/a.!n&4 "& '&)'" )':&+"!n, !"'!+a* %a"&' (a5& an4 +Ba&4 n "! '&6!&% a '&6!&4 ))(*a"!n an4 +''&)n4!n5 %a"&' 4&.an4 )':&+"!4&6&*)&42 HDR$ )':&+"&4 %a"&' 4&.an4 !n4!+a"& "a" Ra#.'& %!** n&&4 &"%&&n.!**!n 5a**n )&' 4a# ?MGD@ 3' an a6&'a5& 4a# !n "& #&a' 021 an4 2;7-MGD2 T& +n"'a+" %!" Kana C!"# *!."


6/90


In4&)&n4&n+&, Ha''!n6!**&, an4 P(*!+ Wa"&' S())*# N2 7, +ann" )'6!4& (33!+!&n"

.&&" Ra#.'&$ %a"&' 4&.an4, an4 %&'& n" +n!4&'&4 3('"&'2

Ea+ 3 "& '&.a!n!n5 "'&& ("!*!"!& Kana C!"#, T'!-C(n"#, an4 Wa"&'On&, +(''&n"*#%a"&' " .(n!+!)a*!"!& ' %a"&' 4!"'!+" ("!4& 3 "&!' +')'a"& (n4a'!&, a a6a!*a*&, an4 a'& %!**!n5 " ())*# a44!"!na* %a"&' " Ra#.'&2 Nn& 3 "& )'6!4&)'6!4& "& a44!"!na* -MGD !..&4!a"&*#2 Kana C!"# ! "& n*# )'6!4&' a*& " (a44!"!na* 1-MG !..&4!a"&*#2 Cnn&+"!n " Wa"&'On& ' T'!-C(n"# %!** '&8(!'& +nn&% 3a+!*!"!&2 Ea+ 3 "&& )'6!4&' %a &6a*(a"&4 3('"&' a a )"&n"!a* %*&a*& %

)'6!4&'2 T& &6a*(a"!n an4 '&+..&n4&4 )*an 3 a+"!n +a.& 4%n " +" 3 %a"&

G!6&n "& C!"#$ !5 5'%" 'a"& 6&' "& *a" "&n #&a' a %&** a 3("('& ))(*a"!n )HDR '&+..&n4 "a" "& C!"# &5!n n&5"!a"!n n a n&% +n"'a+" 3' ""a* %a"&' (" ())*# a .a/!.(. 4a# 4&.an4 3 ;-MGD2 T! +an & !n "& 3'. 3 a !n5*& ('+' a 4(a* ('+&2 A 4(a* ('+& 3 ())*# ! '&+..&n4&4 &+a(& n& ())*!&' .a# (n3'&&&n !na!*!"# " 4&*!6&' %a"&'2

D&"&'.!n!n5 Ra#.'&$ '&+..&n4&4 +('& 3 a+"!n 5!n5 3'%a'4 a &&n 4!33!+(+an5& !n Kana C!"#$ %a"&' 'a"& an4 "& a+"!n 3 "&' %a"&' &n"!"!& n&!5'!nA" "! "!.& !" a))&a' T& C!"# 3 B&*"n %!** +n"'a+" %!" Wa"&'On& a an a44!"!na*%a"&' ())*#2 P(*!+ Wa"&' S())*# D!"'!+" N21 3 a+9n C(n"# ?G'an46!&%@ 4!+(+n"'a+" %!" T'!-C(n"# Wa"&' A("'!"#2

S!n+& )'6!4!n5 Ra#.'& %!" a 4'a3" 3 "! '&)'" !n (n& 011, a Kana C!"# S"a' n&a'"!+*& a))&a'!n5 n (*# 0"3 011, 8("&4 C!"# Mana5&' T'# S+(*"& a a#!n5 %a"Kana C!"# a'& &/)&+"&4 " '!& 1 ann(a**# " &*) Wa"&' S&'6!+& )a# 3' !n3'a"'(

!.)'6&.&n" n&&4&4 !n "&!' #"&.2 In an(a'# 010, Kana C!"# ann(n+&4 a 'a"&10 &5!nn!n5 !n Ma#2 T& Kana C!"# S"a' a'"!+*& an4 Kana C!"#$ *&""&' ann(n+!n!n+'&a& "! #&a' a'& !n+*(4&4 !n A))&n4!/ B2

Ra#.'&$ &/!"!n5 %a"&' 'a"& )&' 1,-5a**n 3'. Kana C!"# ! a))'/!.a"&*# 0.&"&' 3&& an4 '&-)(.)!n5 +" a'& !n+*(4&42 A 10 'a"& !n+'&a& %!** !n+'&a& "& ))('+a& %a"&' 3'. Kana C!"# "


7/90


)'5'a.2 A3"&' 0-#&a' "& TCWA 'a"& %(*4 4') " a +..4!"# +a'5& ' a))'/


8/90


3'. T'!-C(n"# ! &"!.a"&4 " 4') " -MG !n 5'(n4 "'a5& 3' a ""a* 3 -MG2 I" ! &/)&+"&Ra#.'& %!** n&&4 a44!"!na* %a"&' "'a5& !n "& #&a' 01>, " +.)*# %!" "& +(''&C!"# +n"'a+"2 T! &8(a"& " "& a6&'a5& 4a# %a"&' 4&.an4 3 020-MGD, a .a/!.(4&.an4 3 >20>-MGD an4 a ))(*a"!n 3 00,7;2

T& M!('! D&)a'".&n" 3 Na"('a* R&('+& ?MDNR@ D)*+ G.+/) C.+4 W4a"&4 A(5(" 0;, 0


9/90


Figure 1-%, Water &torage e'uirements

HDR &6a*(a"&4 "& +a)!"a* +" 3 &a+ "#)& 3 "'a5& a" "& !"& '&+..&n4&4 !n "&

0; Wa"&' Ma"&' P*an2 B" +a)!"a* +" an4 )&'a"!na* +" %&'& +.)a'&4 an4 &

+a)!"a* +" 3 a 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 an4 )(.) "a"!n ! *& "an an &*&6a"&4 "'a5&

)&'a"!n an4 .a!n"&nan+& ?OM@ +" %&'& !n+*(4&4 !n "& &6a*(a"!n, a "&' )(

an4 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 ! *& &/)&n!6& "an an &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 4('!n5 a 0-#

3'a.&2 I3 "& "!.& 3'a.& ! &/)an4&4 n4 0-#&a', "& &*&6a"&4 "'a5& 3a+!*!"# %!

&/)&n!6& 4(& " )(.) '&)*a+&.&n" an4 &n&'5# +"2 I3 "& ())*!&' +an .&&" Ra#.

#4'a(*!+ )'&('& 5'a4!&n", "&n an &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 %!** & "& '&+..&n4&4

Ra#.'&2

E*&6a"&4 "'a5& ! &"!.a"&4 " +" 2;-.!**!n an4 a 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 %!" )(.

&"!.a"&4 " +" >2=-.!**!n2 T& 4&+!!n " (!*4 5'(n4 "'a5& an4 a )(.) "a"!

&*&6a"&4 "'a5& %!** 4&)&n4 ()n "& #4'a(*!+ 5'a4!&n" "a" "& ())*!&' +an )'6!4

a" %!+ "& %a"&' +an & )'6!4&4, an4 "& )'!+& 3 "&&* an4 +n+'&"& a" "& "!.& 3 +

I" ! '&+..&n4&4 "a" Ra#.'& )*an 3' a n&% "'a5& 3a+!*!"# !n "& #&a' 01> !3 "&

Kana C!"# ' 001 !3 " +n"'a+" %!" T'!-C(n"#, 4&)&n4!n5 ()n ))(*a"!n 5'%

a6&'a5& 4a# %a"&' 4&.an42 T& +!+& 3 &*&6a"&4 ' 5'(n4 "'a5& 4&)&n4 ()n "

())*#2 O"a!n!n5 a44!"!na* %a"&' 3'. Kana C!"# %!** '&8(!'& Ra#.'& " +n"'(

000

100

200

+00

!00

00

00

&00

2010

2011

2012

201+

201!

201,

201

201&

201

201)

2020

2021

2022

202+

202!

202,

202

202&

202

202)

20+0

MillionGallonsPerDay

Year

Storage DBR De$ig# %uide /C" Re;uired Storage

5dd 2 %

of Storage


10/90


2 )ac*groun#T& C!"# 3 Ra#.'& %a n& 3 M!('!$ 3a"&" 5'%!n5 +!"!& !n "& *a" 4&+a4& %!"

!n+'&a& !n ))(*a"!n a++'4!n5 " US C&n( 4a"a2 Ra#.'& 5'&% 3'. 11,1= )&)

0 " 1;,0 !n "& #&a' 012 W!" "! 5'%" +a.& a44!"!na* !n3'a"'(+"('& n&&

&%&', 'a4 an4 C!"# &'6!+&2 P)(*a"!n 5'%" !n Ra#.'& *%&4 %!" +an5& !n

!n "& #&a' 07 " 0;, (" !" 4!4 n" "), "& C!"# +n"!n(&4 " a44 %a"&' .&"&' "

"!.& 3'a.& (n*!9& a *" 3 (''(n4!n5 +..(n!"!&2 I" ! &/)&+"&4 "a" ))(*a"!n 5'

+n"!n(&, (" a" a *!5"*# *%&' )a+& "an !" 4!4 !n "& *a" 4&+a4&2

Ra#.'& '&!4&n" +(''&n"*# '&+&!6& "&!' %a"&' 3'. "& C!"# 3 Kana C!"#, M!('+n"!n(&4 5'%" !n Ra#.'& ! 4&)&n4&n" ()n '&+&!6!n5 a44!"!na* %a"&' ())*# "

4&.an42 Ra#.'&$ &/!"!n5 +n"'a+" %!" Kana C!"#, *!.!" "& 6*(.& 3 %a"&' Ra#

'&+&!6& "


11/90


3 Existing Water "eman#s an# Facilities

+.1

"eman#sIn 0=, Ra#.'& a4 a Wa"&' S#"&. Ma"&' P*an 4&6&*)&42 T& Ma"&' P*an )':&

%a"&' 4&.an4 a&4 n &"!.a"&4 ))(*a"!n 5'%"2 A" "a" "!.& "& (!n5 !n4(

.!n5 a** a+' "& Un!"&4 S"a"&2 T& (!n5 (*& ('" %&n "& &+n.# *

an4 0, an4 "& 5'%" )':&+"!n (&4 !n "& 0= Ma"&' P*an &/+&&4&4 a+"(a* 5

C!"# a4 "& %a"&' )':&+"!n '&6!&4 a&4 n .'& +n&'6a"!6& ))(*a"!n 5'%"

Ta*&


12/90


"a(le )-%, Historical Water +se Data

Year opulation

Water

%eters

eople2

%eter gpc# gpm#

!verage

"ay

%aximu

"ay (000 11,0> =, 0277 27 00< 2;1 121

(001 11,>0< =, 7720= 0= 2; 021;

(00( 1< 027> 7121> 1; 2;< 12;7

(00+ 1,1;< 02 ;1201 0=0 120 1 020 2;= ,7= 027 >211 1 1217

(010 1;,0 , 020


13/90


U!n5 !"'!+a* a6&'a5&, "& %a"&' 4&.an4 )':&+"!n !n4!+a"& "& C!"# %!** n&&4 02-)!

Lucy Webb =oa# >

%issouri =oute ?

02-MGD %!"12-MGD 3' E.&'5&n+#

>2-MGD Sa.& a 3 Tan9

O"&' !.)'"an" )!n" !n "& A5'&&.&n" !n+*(4& "& 3**%!n5

A5'&&.&n" Da"& ! (n& 11, 01

T& "&'. 3 "& +n"'a+" ! 0-#&a'

A5'&&.&n" E/)!'& n (n& 1, 001

Ma/!.(. 'a"& 3 +n(.)"!n !


18/90


Kana C!"# .a# "&'.!na"& "& +n"'a+" 3' 6!*a"!n 3 )a'a5'a) 1-; 3 "& a4a# a3"&' 5!6!n5 %'!""&n n"!+& " "& C!"# 3 Ra#.'& !3 "& 6!*a"!n ! n" +

a"!3a+"!n 3 Kana C!"#2 U)n &/+&&4an+&J 3 "& +n"'a+" .a/!.(., Ra#.'& an4 Kana C!"# %!**

%!" "& !n"&n" 3 &n"&'!n5 !n" a n&% Wa"&' P('+a& A5'&&.&n"2J

Ra#.'& .(" )'6!4& Kana C!"# %!" a n& ?1@ #&a' )'!' %'!""&n n"!+& +nn&+"!n5 !" 4!"'!("!n #"&. " an# ('+& "&' "an Kana C!"#J2 T& %!** +an5& 3'. (* ('+&J " 4(a* ('+&J an4 "& %a"&' 'a"& ?!3 +nn&+"!('+&@ %(*4 +an5& " S(('an M&"&' Ra"&W*&a*& C(".&' Un'&"'!.!n!.(. )('+a& '&8(!'&.&n" &8(a* " an a6&'a5& 4a#$ +n(.)"!n, a&

)'&6!( 10-.n"2

A++'4!n5 " "& +n"'a+" Ra#.'& .(" .a!n"a!n a .!n!.(. a.(n" 3 "'a5& +a)a+.)*# %!" "& KCMO %a"&' )('+a& a5'&&.&n" "a" ! a&4 ()n 3*(+"(a"!n5 4&.C(''&n"*#, Ra#.'& a -.!**!n 5a**n !n "'a5& +a)a+!"#2 U!n5 !"'!+a* %a"&)':&+"!n !n F!5('&


19/90


5 Water Supply SourcesS&6&'a* %a"&' ())*# )"!n (*4 & +n!4&'&4 3' "& C!"# 3 Ra#.'&$ ('+& 3

%a"&'2 T& )"!n +n!4&'&4 !n+*(4&

Wa"&' 3'. R&&'6!'

W&** Wa"&'

Wa"&' 3'. Kana C!"#, M!('!

Wa"&' 3'. Wa"&' On& 3 nn C(n"#, Kana

Wa"&' 3'. T'!-C(n"# Wa"&' A("'!"#, In4&)&n4&n+&, M!('!

Wa"&' 3'. In4&)&n4&n+&, M!('!

.1 =eservoirs

T& a.(n" 3 %a"&' "'a5& n&&4&4 # Ra#.'& .&an "& !& 3 '&&'6!' %(*4 A an &/a.)*&, Ha''!n6!**& La9& ())*!& "& C!"# 3 Ha''!n6!**& %!" 4'!n9!n5 %a"M!('! D&)a'".&n" 3 Cn&'6a"!n *!" "& !& 3 "& *a9& a >0 a+'&2 T& *a9& )'" a 02-.!**!n 5a**n )&' 4a# "'&a".&n" )*an"2 Ra#.'& %(*4 n&&4 a !.!*a' !& '&.!n!.(.2

T +n"'(+" a '&&'6!' %(*4 '&8(!'& )&'.!" 3'. "& C') 3 En5!n&&' an4 "& MR&&'6!' Sa3&"# +(n+!*2 T& %n&' 3 "& 4a. %(*4 n&&4 " +n!4&' !n('an+& '&8an4 "& a3&"# 3 4%n"'&a. *an4 %n&' !n "& &6&n" "& 4a. %(*4 '()"('&2 O"a!n3'. a n&% .an.a4& *a9& %a '(*&4 (" 4(& " "& &/"'&.& +a)!"a* +" an4 "!.!n5 '+n"'(+" a .an .a4& '&&'6!'2

An"&' )"!n '!&3*# +n!4&'&4 %a "a!n!n5 %a"&' 3'. "& Ha''# S2 T'(.an R&

C*!n"n, M!('!2 T! )"!n %(*4 a* '&8(!'& +n"'(+"!n 3 a "'&a".&n" )*an" '%!" an &/!"!n5 &n"!"# an4 &/)an4!n5 an &/!"!n5 "'&a".&n" )*an"2 A))'/!.a"&*# .%(*4 & n&&4&4 a*n5 %!" &a&.&n" " 4&*!6&' "& %a"&' " Ra#.'&2 T& +a)!"a* ++n"'(+" "& )!)& n&&4&4 " )'6!4& Ra#.'& %!" 7-.!**!n 5a**n )&' 4a# %(*4 a))'/!.a"&*# >-.!**!n2

Cn"'(+"!n5 a '&&'6!' ' "a!n!n5 %a"&' 3'. T'(.an La9& %(*4 '&8(!'& )('+a+n"'(+"!n 3 a "'&a".&n" )*an", +n"'(+"!n 3 *n5 )!)&*!n&, "a!n!n5 &a&.&n""a!n!n5 a))'6a* 3'. '&5(*a"' (+ a C') 3 En5!n&&'2 Ra#.'& %(*4 n&&4+n"!n(a**# 3*%!n5 "'&a. an4 a *a'5& a.(n" 3 *an4 !n %!+ " +n"'(+" a '&&'6)'+& %(*4 "a9& &6&'a* #&a' an4 a *a'5& (. 3 .n .a9!n5 !" !.)'a+"!+a* 3' 3+n!4&'a"!n2


20/90

City of Raymore, Water Storage S

.( Well Water

T& 4'!**!n5 3 a %&** ' %&** !n

"& S"a"& 3 M!('! !'&5(*a"&4 # T& M!('!D&)a'".&n" 3 Na"('a*R&('+& ?MDNR@2 T& MDNRWa"&' R&('+& C&n"&'%&!"& a an !n"&'a+"!6& .a)"a" 4!+(& M!('!$5'(n4 %a"&' an4 a8(!3&'

+a'a+"&'!"!+2 A +)# 3 "!.a) ! *+a"&4 !n F!5('& >-12

T& C!"# 3 Ra#.'& ! !"(a"&4!n an a'&a !4&n"!3!&4 # "& !"&a "& W&" C&n"'a* M!('!G'(n4%a"&' P'6!n+&J2Wa"&' %!" *& "an 1,-.5L ""a* 4!*6&4 *!4 !5&n&'a**# +n!4&'&4 3'&%a"&' %!*& "a" +n"a!n!n5&"%&&n 1,-.5L an41,.5L ""a* 4!*6&4 *!4"&'.&4 'a+9!2J Wa"&' !n "&C&n"'a* M!('! G'(n4%a"&' P'(&2

In a44!"!n, a**% %&** a'(n4'&!4&n+& an4 %!** & 3 .a'5!na*

B&+a(& 4'!**!n5 %a"&' %&** !n '8(a*!"# 3 %a"&' " &'6& a !5n!3!%a n" &6a*(a"&42

.+ Contracting for Wate

T& .a:' %a"&' )'4(+&' "a"Ra#.'& %!" %a"&' a'&

Kana C!"#, M!

T'!-C(n"# Wa"&'

Wa"&'On& 3 n

upply Study

!&"

6!n+& ! +n!4&'&4 'a+9! an4 " .!n&'a*!&

Ra#.'& %!** a'&*# #!&*4 &n(5 %a"&' " ())8(a*!"#2

a'(n4 "& C!"# 3 Ra#.'& %!** n" )'6!4& (33an" )'"!n 3 "& C!"#$ ))(*a"!n 3' )"a*& (

a6& (33!+!&n" %a"&' '&('+& " +n"'a+"(a**#

('!, Wa"&' S&'6!+& D&)a'".&n"

A("'!"#, In4&)&n4&n+&, M!('!

n C(n"#, Kana

We$

%rou

*igure 81, DBR %rou#d-ater Provi#ce$

C.aracteri$tic$

4 3

# a

+!&&, "

))

Ce

#d-

#d


21/90


22/90


L&&$ S(..!", M!('!2 T& 0=-!n+ %a"&' .a!n a a +a)a+!"# 3 ;-MGD, %!+ ! (3())*# Ra#.'& %!" !" %a"&' 4&.an4 3' "& n&/" 0-#&a' Kana C!"# %&6&'

a** 3 !" a6a!*a*& %a"&' 3'. "& S(" T&'.!na* " !" "&' +(".&'2 Kana C!"# !+n"'(+"!n5 !.)'6&.&n" " n& &5.&n" 3 "& "'an.!!n .a!n "a" ())*!& %aS(" T&'.!na* P(.) S"a"!n2 Un3'"(na"&*#, !.)'6&.&n" " "&' )'"!n 3 "& ".a!n a'& n" (n4&' 4&!5n an4 !" .a#& &6&'a* #&a' &3'& !.)'6&.&n" a'& .a4&!n+'&a& Kana C!"#$ 4&*!6&'# +a)a+!"# " "& S(" T&'.!na*2

.3.+

-arrisonville Connection

In )'&6!( .&&"!n5 %!" Kana C!"# Wa"&' S&'6!+&, Ra#.'& %a !n3'.&4 " +a n&% )!)& " "& +nn&+"!n n BB-H!5%a# "a" %a )'&6!(*# 4&4!+a"&4 " "& C!"#

Ha''!n6!**&2 T! +nn&+"!n )!n" ! n "& a+9n-Ca C(n"# T'an.!!n .a!nH!5%a# a" a))'/!.a"&*# 170n4S"'&&"2 S&& A))&n4!/F, Kana C!"# Ha''!n6!**& CMa)3' "& *+a"!n 3 "& )')&4 +nn&+"!n2 T& a+9n-Ca T'an.!!n .a!# Kana C!"# !n "& .!4 1;;$ ())*!& %a"&' " P*&aan" H!** an4 "& MEP A'!& P%%&" 3 P*&aan" H!**2

T& Ha''!n6!**& +nn&+"!n )!n" %a '!5!na**# !n"a**&4 3' T'!-C(n"# Wa"&' A("*a"& 1;;$, %!+ a a )(.) "a"!n an4 &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 n& .!*& (" 3 "&

)!n"2 T'!-C(n"# %a (na*& " 3!na*!& a +n"'a+" %!" Kana C!"# an4 "& +nn&+%a )a&4 n " Ha''!n6!**&2

T& Ha''!n6!**& +nn&+"!n )!n" a* '&+&!6& %a"&' 3'. "& S(" T&'.!na* P(.)P*&aan" H!** a !n3'.&4 ( " +(*4 n" '&+&!6& "&!' +n"'a+"(a* *!.!" 3'. Kan)a" 4(& " )&'a"!n 3 "& A'!& P%&' P*an"2

A++'4!n5 " !n3'.a"!n "a!n&4 3'. M'2 T&4 Ma'"!n, Ha''!n6!**& C!"# En5!n&&', H

! )a#!n5 Kana C!"# a 3&& 3' "! +nn&+"!n )!n"2 T& 3&& ! '&&'6!n5 >-.!**!n 5a*3' "& C!"# 3 Ha''!n6!**&2 T& C!"# &5an 4&!5n 3 +n"'(+"!n )*an " (!*4 a %a"& Kana C!"# +nn&+"!n )!n" n BB-H!5%a#2 M!4%a# "'(5 4&!5n, a n&%*# &*&+(n+!* 6"&4 " ") "& 4&!5n %'9 4(& " (45&"a'# !(&2 M'2 Ma'"!n "a"&4 "& 4n *42 W&n a9&4 !3 Ha''!n6!**& .a# &** "&!' +nn&+"!n )!n" ' a a'& 3 "& 5a**n, M'2 Ma'"!n "a"&4 & +(*4 n" )&a9 3' "& +(n+!* (" "& "a33 '&+..&n4a" 9&&) "& +nn&+"!n2

T +nn&+" " "& a+9n-Ca T'an.!!n .a!n a" "& Ha''!n6!**& +nn&+"!n, Ran&&4 " 3'.a**# )&"!"!n "& C!"# 3 Ha''!n6!**& 3' a )'"!n 3 "&!' Kana C!"# %aan4 +n"'(+" a %a"&' *!n&, .&"&'!n5 3a+!*!"!&, an4 a )(.) "a"!n " '&+&!6& "& %a"&'

.3.3

!vailable Capacity

In .&&"!n5 &*4 &"%&&n "& S(('an Wa"&' Ca*!"!n an4 T&''# L&&4 "& A+"!n5 WD&)a'".&n" D!'&+"' 3' Kana C!"# M' L&&4 "a"&4 "& Wa"&' S&'6!+& D&)a'".&n"


23/90


a !n3'.&4 HDR, B&*"n an4 "&' &n"!"!& "a" " a6& a(" 1-.!**!n 5a**n 3 %a"&' a6a!*a*& a" "& (" "&'.!na*2 I" .a# "a9& > " 1 #&a' &3'& Kana C!"# +an

+a)a+!"# " )'6!4& Ra#.'& an a44!"!na* >-.!**!n 5a**n 3 %a"&' an4 "! ! 4&)&n"& +.)*&"!n 3 "& n&% %a"&' .a"&' )*an2

.3.

:ansas City Contract

T& C!"# 3 Ra#.'& &n"&'&4 !n" an a5'&&.&n" %!" Kana C!"# " "a!n %a"&' (n4&O'4!nan+& 01


24/90


.3.4 Summary of Contracting ,it :ansas City

Kana C!"# n&&4 " .a9& "'an.!!n .a!n !.)'6&.&n" &3'& " +an )'6!4&

%a"&' " "& ("&'n %*&a*& %a"&' +(".&'2 T& !.)'6&.&n" a'& n" +(''&n"an4 !" %!** "a9& a))'/!.a"&*# > " 1 #&a' &3'& Ra#.'& +(*4 '&+&!6& a44!"!na* +a)a+!"# 3'. Kana C!"#2 T& &/!"!n5 0=-!n+ %a"&' .a!n &'6!n5 "& L(+# W& .Ra#.'& &*&6a"&4 %a"&' "'a5& "an9 (" 3 H(a+ H!** Ra4 a +a)a+!"# 3' ;-.!)&' 4a#2 T! )'"!n 3 "& Kana C!"# %a"&' "'an.!!n #"&. 4& n" n&&4 "

Kana C!"# !n3'.&4 HDR a3"&' (' 4'a3" '&)'" %a 4&*!6&'&4 " Ra#.'&, "a" a44!"! a6a!*a*& a" "& S(" T&'.!na*2 Ra#.'& %(*4 n&&4 " &n4 a *&""&' " "& Wa"&' SA+"!n5 D!'&+"' '&8(&"!n5 an !n+'&a& !n "& +n"'a+"(a* *!.!"2 T& a+"(a* 8(an"!"# "a6a!*a*& 3'. Kana C!"# ! *& "an Ra#.'&$ )':&+"&4 0-#&a' 4&.an42

.

WaterOne of ?onson County@ :ansas

Wa"&'On& )&'a"& "% %a"&' "'&a".&n" )*an", a


25/90


V*(.& Ca'5& 02>-H!5%a# an4 K&nn&" Ra4, (" Ra#.'& %!** n&&4 " )a# 3' "& 4&*!6&' %a"&' 3'. "& "a"& *!n& " Ra#.'&2 T! +(*4 & )&'3'.&4 !n +n:(n+"!n%!"(" B&*"n, 4&)&n4!n5 ()n %&"&' B&*"n +& " +n"'a+" %!" Wa"&'On& 3

%a"&'2

I3 B&*"n an4 Ra#.'& ", %&'& " +n"'a+" 3' %a"&' 3'. Wa"&'On&, B&*"n an4 Ra&a+ )a# "&!' )')'"!na* a'& 3 "& n&% 3a+!*!"!&2 B&*"n .a# & a*& " (& !" &/4!"'!("!n #"&. +a)a+!"# " %&&*J %a"&' " Ra#.'& %!"(" Ra#.'& )a#!n5 3)!)&*!n&2 In "! !"(a"!n Ra#.'& %(*4 n&&4 " )a# 3' a n&% .&"&' +nn&+"!n " BRa#.'&$ )')'"!na* a'& 3 "& Wa"&'On& 3a+!*!"!&2

A .&n"!n&4 &3'& "& +a)a+!"# Wa"&'On& +(''&n"*# a a6a!*a*& a" "& Na** A6&n(&S"'&&" *+a"!n !


26/90


.4 Tri9County Water !utority

T'!-C(n"# Wa"&' A("'!"# ?T'!-C(n"#@ ! a n" 3' )'3!" +')'a"!n "a" )'4(+&

n a %*&a*& a!2 T'!-C(n"# )&'a"& a 1-.!**!n 5a**n )&' 4a# %a"&' "'&a".&n*+a"&4 n "& M!('! R!6&', :(" %&" 3 S!*, M!('!2 T& "'an.!!n .a!n &/.!*& (" 3'. "& M!('! R!6&' " Ha''!n6!**&, M!('!2 T'!-C(n"# ! 56&'n&43 D!'&+"' +n!"!n5 3 n& '&)'&&n"a"!6& 3'. &a+ 3 !" )a'"!+!)a"!n5 .&.&'2 T)a'"!+!)a"!n5 .&.&' +n!" 3 "& C!"# 3 G'a!n Va**, La9& W!nn&a5, P*&aan" Han4 n!n& %a"&' 4!"'!+" *+a"&4 !n a+9n, Ca an4 Ba"& C(n"!& 3 M!('!2 T'!-C)'6!4& %a"&' " "& C!"# 3 B*(& S)'!n52

.4.1 !vailable Capacity

T'!-C(n"# a &&n a))'a+&4 # '&)'&&n"a"!6& 3 a+9n 1, Ca 0, an4 B&*"n !n"& a6a!*a!*!"# 3 )'6!4!n5 a 3("('& %a"&' ())*#2 On A)'!* 1, " +6&' *&5a* +" " &+.&.&.&' 3 "& Ba'4 3 D!'&+"'2

A** +" &/+&)" "& !.)a+" 3&& a'& !n+*(4&4 !n "& )'!+& 3 %a"&'2

T& &"!.a"&4 +..4!"# +a'5& ?+" " )'4(+& an4 4&*!6&' %a"&'@ ! 127>5a**n2 T& '&.a!n4&' 3 "& %a"&' 'a"& ! " +6&' "& )':&+" 4&" &'6!+&2

T& ""a* &"!.a"&4 %a"&' 'a"& !n+*(4!n5 "& +..4!"# +a'5& 3' Ra#.'& !& >2==1,-5a**n !n!"!a**# an4 %!" )a&4 !.)'6&.&n" " "& TCWA !n+'&a& " >2;=1,-5a**n !n "& 3!na* #&a' 3 "& SRF *an2 T&& 'a"& .a/!.(. 4a# 4&.an4 3 -MGD !n +a)a+!"#2

B&+a(& T'!-C(n"# ! a n" 3' )'3!" +')'a"!n, Ra#.'& %(*4 n&&4 " *&*&+"!n " :!n T'!-C(n"# a++'4!n5 " "a"& *a%


27/90


.4.+ Summary of Contracting ,it Tri9County

C(''&n"*# T'!-+(n"# 4& n" a6& &/+& +a)a+!"# " ())*# Ra#.'& %!" %a"&' !3 !"

+n"'a+" %!" T'!-C(n"# a an a44!"!na* ('+& 3 ())*#2 T'!-C(n"# %(*4 *!9&*# n&!n+'&a& "'&a".&n" )*an" +a)a+!"# an4 ()!& "'an.!!n .a!n an4 "&' )(.) "4&)&n4!n5 ()n "& a.(n" +n"'a+"&42 T'!-C(n"# %!** !n+(' "& 4&" 3' "&& 3a+!*!"'an.!!n .a!n " Ra#.'&2 T'!-C(n"# %!** a* .&&" Ra#.'&$ #4'a(*!+ )'&("& )!n" 3 +nn&+"!n2 T& 4&" &'6!+& 3' Ra#.'&$ )')'"!na* a'& 3 "& 3a+!!.)'6&.&n" %!** & )a!4 a+9 " T'!-C(n"# !n "& %a"&' 'a"&2 On+& "& 4&" &'6!+&"& 'a"& %!** 4&+'&a& " "& )&'a"!na* an4 .a!n"&nan+& +" !n+(''&4 # T'!-C(n"A))&n4!/ D, T'!-C(n"# Wa"&' A("'!"#, Ma) an4 C" E"!.a"&, +n"a!n .a) an4+" 3 &'6!+& !n3'.a"!n 3' "& T'!-C(n"# +nn&+"!n2

.5 Cost Comparison of otential Sources

Ta*& >-1 +.)a'& )"&n"!a* +n"'a+" an4 )'!+!n5 !n a !4& # !4& 3'.a" 3' "& "'())*!&' )'6!4!n5 an a44!"!na* -MGD .a/!.(. 4a# 3*% 6&' a 0-#&a' )&'!42 I"3' Kana C!"# an4 Wa"&'On&, Ra#.'& %(*4 n&&4 " )a# 3' 4&!5n an4 +n"'(+"!.a!n " "& +nn&+"!n )!n"2 T'!-C(n"# 'a"& !n+*(4& 4&!5n an4 +n"'(+"!n +" "'an.!!n an4 )(.)!n5 !n "& %a"&' 'a"&2

"a(le -1,Comparison o$ Water ates

"escription

:ansas City

Water

Services 9

-arrisonville

WaterOne of

?onson

County

Wa"&' Ra"& )&' 1,-5a**n 027 02><

L&n5" 3 Wa"&' Ma!n N&&4&4 =1, 3"2 >1, 6&' 0-#&a'

121


28/90


.6 Cost Comparison of Tri9County an# :ansas City

A (*# 0, 011 , Kana C!"# S"a' n&%)a)&' a'"!+*& "a"&4 Kana C!"# %(*4 & !n+'&

%a"&' 'a"& # 1 ann(a**#, " )'6!4& 3(n4 3' !n3'a"'(+"('& !.)'6&.&n" n&&4"&.2 T& Kana C!"# S"a' n&%)a)&' a'"!+*& ! !n+*(4&4 !n A))&n4!/ B2 In )n& +&"%&&n HDR an4 M'2 S&an H&nn, Wa"&' S&'6!+& C!&3 F!nan+!a* O333!+&, M'2 H&nn& 'a"& !n+'&a& !n 010 an4 01< an4 "&n 'a"& %(*4 n*# !n+'&a& ann(a**# "&'aC!"#$ &/)&n& !n+'&a&42 In F&'(a'#, Ra#.'& %a !n3'.&4 'a"& %!** !n+'&a& 10a'& &/)&+"&4 " !n+'&a& 1 !n 01%D? @ 8 +@ Rate

@ to +@

Rate @ 8 +@ Rate

@ to +@

Rate +@ R2012 12

202) +2!


29/90


T& KCMO Ha''!n6!**& Cnn&+"!nJ +" !n Ta*& >-0, !n+*(4& Ra#.'&$ &"!.a"&

+n"'(+" a %a"&' *!n& " "& Ha''!n6!**& +nn&+"!n )!n" an4 "& '&*a"&4 4&" 3 1

5a**n2 T& KCMO E/!"!n5 Cnn&+"!nJ +" !n Ta*& >-0 a(.& a** "& %a"&' +an " Ra#.'& a" "& &/!"!n5 Kana C!"# +nn&+"!n )!n" an4 n&% 3a+!*!"!& a'& n" '&8

'a"& 3' KCMO a(.&4 a 10 !n+'&a& !n 010, a 1 !n+'&a& !n 012==-1,-5a**n &"%&&n 010 an4 000 an4 >2;= 00< an4 0-0, T'!-C(n"# ! "& *&a" &/)&n!6& %a"&' ('+& (n*& K

+an 9&&) "&!' ann(a* 'a"& !n+'&a& &*% = an4 Ra#.'& 4& n" a6& " +n"'(+

.a!n " "& Ha''!n6!**& +nn&+"!n )!n"2 F!5('& >-1 !**("'a"& Ta*& >-0 5'a)!+a**

Figure -1, #nalysis o$ #nnual Water Costs


30/90


"& )'&&n" (n9n%n2 T&'&3'& !" +an & a(.&4 Kana C!"#$ 'a"& %!** +n"!n(& "

"& 'a"& !n+'&a& .'& "an


31/90


6 Conclusion an# =ecommen#ation Water SupplyA6&'a5& %a"&' (& )&' +(".&' a 4&+'&a&4 a+' "& Un!"&4 S"a"& 6&' "& *a" 4

56&'n.&n" .an4a"&4 .4!3!+a"!n " 4!%a&', %a!n5 .a+!n& an4 )*(.!n4(& " )' &+n.!+ +n4!"!n an4 4(& " %a"&' +n&'6a"!n &4(+a"!n2 Ra#.'&$%a"&' (& )&' +(".&' a a* 4&+'&a&4 6&' "& *a" &6&n #&a' 3**%!n5 "& na"In 0= an4 -MGD n a6&'a5& !n "& #&a' 02 an4 2;7-MGD !n "& Ra#.'&$ +n"'a+" %!" Kana C!"# *!.!" Ra#.'&$ %a"&' (a5& "


32/90


7 Water Storage !nalysisT& C!"# 3 Ra#.'&, M!('! ! &6a*(a"!n5 ('+& 3 ())*# " a++..4a"& 3("('&

)a'" 3 "a" "(4#, "& C!"# ! *9!n5 " && % "&!' &/!"!n5 +a)!"a* !.)'6&.&n" )*aMG ?M!**!n Ga**n@ "'a5& "an9 a'& a33&+"&4 # "& ('+& 3 a44!"!na* ())*# an4 "%!+ "a" ())*# ! "a9&n2 T! )*ann!n5-*&6&* "(4# " &6a*(a"& "& '&8(!'&4 !n3'a"'n&% "'a5& a&4 n "& ('+& 3 ())*# an4 *+a"!n2 P'&*!.!na'# +" 3' a n&% &"'a5& "an9 a'& 4&6&*)&4 an4 +.)a'&4 " "a" 3 a 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 an4 "&"a"!n 3' 4!33&'&n" ('+& 3 ())*# a*"&'na"!6&2

5.1

Existing >"S" an4 K&n"(+9# R4@o ;0


33/90


&*&6a"&4 "an9 n -H!5%a#2 T& 3a+!*!"!& a" 1>>"S" an4 K&n"(+9# Ra4 an4 "& F/%Tan9 a'& n" .n!"'&4 # SCADA2 Kana C!"# %!** "('n n "&!' S(" T&'.!na* Fa+!%&n "& *&6&* !n "& Ra#.'& Tan9 4')2 T& )(.) a'& n a" 1,00> 3"2 an4 33 a" 1,

5.(

Flo, ro/ections

T! "(4# %!** (& "& HDR 011 R&+..&n4&4J 3*% %!+ a))&a' " '&3*&+" a 5'4&.an4 "a" ." +*&*# '&&.*& %a" "& C!"# ! &/)&'!&n+!n5 a" "! "!.&2 D&"a!*&!n3'.a"!n ! )'6!4&4 !n S&+"!n < 3 "! '&)'"2 I" %!** & a(.&4 "a" "& 0 MG E*&6a"&4 T

T& Ra#.'& 0= Wa"&' Ma"&' P*an '&+..&n4&4 "& n&% &*&6a"&4 "'a5*+a"&4 :(" n'" 3 "& !n"&'&+"!n 3 H%# > an4 K&n"(+9# R42, " a44'& *a*n5 H%# > 4('!n5 )&a9 3*%2

T& Wa"&' Ma"&' P*an *&""&' '&)'" ()4a"&, 4a"&4 (*# 0=, 0;, &/a.!n&4 3(*+a"!n 3' "& )')&4 &*&6a"&4 "an9 ?R&3&' " F!5('& 7-1 3' !"& *+a"!n@

o S+4) 1 - E6*4 !)4.; 5? "200$ M6*4) P86 L;64

S!"& .a# n" & a6a!*a*&, 4(& " )*ann&4 4&6&*).&n"2 S!"& ! a" &*&6a"!n 11 3"2, an4 "( "& "an9 %(*4 n&&4 " &

"& 6&'3*%2 A44!"!na* %a"&' *!n& ()5'a4& %(*4 & '&8(!'&42

o S+4) 2 - H68/ D+9) "L;64+ F@>/ E8)964)/ T6


34/90



35/90

y y , g pp y y

5.3 Storage Tan* Styles

5.3.1

Elevate# Storage Tan*sT& &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 %(*4 a6& "& 3**%!n5 4&!5n )a'a.&"&'

O6&'3*% E*&6a"!n 1,0


36/90

CBILan4.a'9P&n!/P!""('5

"& 3*("&4 +*(.n"an9 &/+&)" "&())'" +*(.n !.a4& 3 '&!n3'+&4+n+'&"&In"&'!' 3 ())'"+*(.n +an & (&43' .(*"!)*&)(')&In"&'!' a++&*a44&'

a))&a'an+& "#*& %(*4.a"+ "& KCMO Ra#.'&Tan9R!&' )!)& *+a"&4 !n!4&())'" +*(.n )'6!4&!n(*a"!n 3'. 3'&&!n5In"&'!' 3 ())'" +*(.n+an & (&4 3' .(*"!)*&)(')&In"&'!' *a44&' *!.!"(na("'!&4 a++&

P*&n"# 3 +.)&"!"!na.n5 .an(3a+"('&'Ma!n"&nan+&-3'&& +*(.n&/"&'!'S"&&* '&8(!'!n5 )a!n"!n5.a!n"&nan+& ! '&4(+&4 ""& %* 3 "& "an9 "'&4(+& OM +"

.&+n+n'&88(Ha(&"

Figure 4-%, 2amples o$ a Fluted Column leated "an5 6le$t7 and Composi

"an5 6ight7



37/90

Ta*& 7-0 % "& )!*& 4!.&n!n 3 3*("&4 +*(.n an4 +.)!"& &*&6a"&4 "

02>-MG2 D!.&n!n 6a'# *!5"*# # .an(3a+"('&', (" a'& '&*a"!6&*# +n!"&n"2 F!5(

a +("a%a# 3 a +.)!"& "#*& "an9 %!+ % "& &a4 'an5&2

"a(le 4-%, Fluted Column and Composite "an5 DimensionTan9 S"#*& Man(3a+"('&' B%* D!a2 ?3"@ Ba& D!a2 ?3"@ H&a4 Ran5&

F*("&4 C*(.nCBI 1 7 ==

Ca*4%&** 1= 7 ==2>

C.)!"&

P&n!/ 17 >0 =

CBI 1> =>

Lan4.a'9 10-110 >= =-=>Ca*4%&** 1= > =>

Figure 4-), Cuta!ay o$ a Composite &tyle "an5



38/90

Cn"'(+"!n Cn!4&'a"!n C.)!"& Tan9

T&'& a'& *!5" 4!33&'&n+& a.n5 "& .an(3a+"('&' 3 +.)!"& "an9 !n "&'. 3 "

+n"'(+"!n 3 "& +n+'&"& +*(.n2

Lan4.a'9 an4 CBI ("!*!& a 7-3" +n+'&"& 3'. &+"!n %!" &5.&n"&4 %a** +

Ca*4%&** Tan9 an4 P!""('5 Tan9 an4 T%&' ("!*!& a =-3" 3'. #"&.2 T& 4!

&"%&&n "& 7-3" 3'. an4 "& =-3" 3'. ! a&"&"!+2 T& 7-3" 3'. &+"!n

&5.&n"&4 %a** +n"'(+"!n a""&.)" " .!n!.!& "& a))&a'an+& 3 )(' *!n&

!n5*& *a4 3 +n+'&"& !n &a+ &+"!n2 In '4&' " +n"'* "&!' +", "& +n"'a+"

("!*!& "& =-3" 3'. #"&. *!9& " )*a+& "% " "'&& &+"!n a 4a#2 W&n .'&+"!n ! )*a+&4 !n n& 4a#, "& *%&' &+"!n an$" a4 0= (' " +('& %!+ .

(*5!n5 3 "& +n+'&"& n "& *%&' )(' a %&** a +'&a"& )(' *!n& !n "& +n+'&

4& n" +a(& a "'(+"('a* !(&, !n .& !n"an+& !" a n" &&n a&"&"!+a**# )*

In HDR$ &/)&'!&n+&, %& a6& a**%&4 "& =-3" 3'. #"&. a %&** a "& 7-3"

%&n !44!n5 +.)!"& &*&6a"&4 %a"&' "an9 %&6&', HDR "#)!+a**# 4& n" a*

+n"'a+"' " )*a+& .'& "an n& &+"!n a 4a# an4 a "'!+" +n+'&"& '&8(!'&." .!n!.!& a&"&"!+ !(&2 T! '&8(!'&.&n" .a# !n+'&a& "& )'!+& 3 "& +.)

&*&6a"&4 "an9 a.n5 "& .an(3a+"('&' "a" ("!*!& "& =-3" 3'. #"&. %&6

(33!+!&n" +.)&"!"!n !n "& +.)!"& &*&6a"&4 "an9 .a'9&" "! ! n" an !(&

R&5a'4*& 3 +n"'(+"!n "#)&, " "#)& 3 "an9 %(*4 & '&8(!'&4 " a4&'& " "

In"&'na"!na* B(!*4!n5 C4& ?IBC@, "& 0> ASCESEI 7->, "& 0> ACI ?3' "

)&4&"a*@, an4 "& 0> A.&'!+an Wa"&' W'9 A+!a"!n ?AWWA@ D1->2

5. &roun# Storage Tan* Styles an# )ooster ump Stations

5..1

&roun# Storage Tan* Styles

T&'& a'& "% "#)& 3 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 "a" HDR %(*4 '&+..&n4 )'&"'&&

an4 5*a-3(&4 "&&*2

Cn+'&"& "an9 a'& +n"'(+"&4 # )*a+!n5 )'&+a" +n+'&"& )an&*, %'a))!n5 "&.

.a!n"a!n +.)'&!n, an4 )'a#!n5 a +a" 3 5(n!"& " )'"&+" "& %!'&2 N )a!n"an9 ! '&8(!'&4 3' "& !n"&'!' ' &/"&'!', a*"(5 "& &/"&'!' .a# & )a!n"&4 3

'&an !3 4&!'&42

S"&&* "an9 a'& +n"'(+"&4 3 3a'!+a"&4 "&&* )an&* "a" a'& &!"&' %&*4&4 ' *



39/90

A +.)a'!n 3 "& "% 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 "#)& ! 5!6&n !n Ta*& 7- 3&&" TDH %(*4 a* & '&8(!'&4 " )(.) 3*% a

4&.an4 )&'!42

5..+

Water %ain Connection

A n&% %a"&' .a!n %!** & '&8(!'&4 " +nn&+" "& &*&6a"&4 "an9 ' 5'(n4 "'a5& "an

)(.) "a"!n " "& #"&.2 In "& +a& 3 an &*&6a"&4 "an9, n& *!n& +(*4 & (&4 a

an4 an ("*&" *!n& !n" "& #"&.2 I3 a 4!33&'&n" ('+& 3 ())*# ! (&4, an !n*&" *!n& 3

('+& +(*4 &n"&' "& "an9, %!" "& '&8(!'&4 !n*&" 6a*6&, .&"&', a+93*% )'&6&n"&

!n!4& 3 "& "an9 +*(.n T& ("*&" 3 "& "an9 %(*4 +nn&+" " "& C!"#$ #"&.



40/90

T& n&% *!n&?@ %!** & 0=-!n+ 4!a.&"&' 4(+"!*& !'n )!)&2 I*a"!n (""&'3*# 6a*6&

)'6!4&4 a" "& "an9 an4 a" "& +nn&+"!n " "& C!"#$ #"&. "& %a"&' "'a5& +a

3'. "& #"&., !3 n&+&a'#2 T& *&n5" 3 "& )!)&*!n&, :!n" '&"'a!n", 3!'& #4'an" 'a!' '&*!&3 6a*6& '&8(!'&.&n" a %&** a &a&.&n" '&8(!'&.&n" %!** & !"&-)&+!3!+ a

a*!5n.&n" an4 )'3!*&2

5.4 ropose# !lternatives

T& *+a"!n 3 "& )')&4 "'a5& "an9 .(" & &6a*(a"&4 '&*a"!6& " "& )"&n"!a*

())*#2 T& *+a"!n a* .(" & +n!4&'&4 !n +n:(n+"!n %!" "& &/!"!n5 Wa"&' M

an4 .4&*!n5 %'9 "a" a a*'&a4# &&n +.)*&"&4 3' "& C!"#2 Ra#.'& %!** n&&4 "

"& n&+&a'# "'an.!!n .a!n !n!4& "& C!"# " )')&'*# 4!"'!("& "& ())*# 3 %

a'& !5n!3!+an"*# !.)a+"&4 # %&'& Ra#.'& '&+&!6& %a"&' an4 +n"'(+" a "'a5&

*+a"!n a'& 4!+(&4 &*% 3' &a+ 3 "& "'&& ('+& 3 ())*# )"!n a&4 n

!n3'.a"!n a6a!*a*& a" "& "!.& 3 "! '&)'"2

5.4.1

!ssumptions

T& 3**%!n5 a(.)"!n %&'& .a4& !n &*&+"!n5 !"& 3' "& "'a5& "an9 an4 !!n5

3a+!*!"!& " .a9& a 3a!' +.)a'!n

Wa"&' "'a5& +a)a+!"# %!** & 02> MG 3' &!"&' 5'(n4 "'a5& ' &*&6a"&4 "'a5&2

In a** 3 "& a*"&'na"!6& "& &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 %!** & *+a"&4 a" S!"& 1, %!

*+a"!n %!" "& *%&" +"2 T& "an9 %!** & 1


41/90

T& 3!'" )'!'!"# ! " "a!n .'& %a"&' 3'. Kana C!"#2 T& a.& +nn&+"!n an4

)!n" %(*4 & ("!*!&4 an4 "& 02-MG 3 %a"&' !n "& Ra#.'& E*&6a"&4 Tan9 %(*4

" "& C!"#2 T& 0; Wa"&' Ma"&' P*an *&""&' '&)'", '&+..&n4&4 "& !"& a" K&n"(H!5%a# > a "& *%&" +" )"!n " )*a+& an &*&6a"&4 "an9 ?R&3&' " F!5('& 7-1 3'

3 "& 3(' !"& !n "& *&""&'@2 Ta" "(4# %a %'!""&n %!" "& a(.)"!n "a" Kana

)'6!4& %a"&', an4 "( "& *&""&'$ !5"!n5 '&+..&n4a"!n '&.a!n '&*&6an" !n "!

F' +.)a'!n, a 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 an4 "&' )(.) "a"!n %!** & &6a*(a"&4 a

a'& )*a+&4 a" "& n'"&a" +nn&+"!n )!n"2

A84)64+9) 1A Kana C!"# S())*# %!" E*&6a"&4 S"'a5& P*a+& an &*&6a"&4 "

S!"& 1 %!" a44!"!na* ())*# 3'. "& n'"&a" +nn&+"!n )!n" ?1>>"an4 KRa4@2

A84)64+9) 1& Kana C!"# S())*# %!" G'(n4 S"'a5& an4 a B"&' P(.) S

a 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 an4 "&' )(.) "a"!n a" "& n'"&a" +nn&+"!n )

0=-!n+ *!n& a n&+&a'# " )'6!4& "& &8(!6a*&n" 3*% an4 )'&('& a" S!"& 1

!n A*"&'na"!6& 1A2

!lternative (- O"a!n Wa"&' 3'. Kana C!"#, M!('! an4 a44!"!na* %a"&' 3'. W

B&*"n

T& &+n4 a*"&'na"!6& ! " "a!n >" S"2 an4 K&n"(+9# R42 %!" E*&6a"&4 S

P*a+& an &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 a" S!"& 1 %!" a +nn&+"!n )!n" a" 1>>" S" an4

R42 In"a** 0=-!n+ *!n& a n&+&a'# " )'6!4& 3*% 3'. "& +nn&+"!n )!n

A84)64+9) 2& Wa"&'On& S())*# a" 1>>" S"2 an4 K&n"(+9# R42 %!" G'(n4 S"

an4 B"&' P(.) S"a"!n P*a+& a 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 an4 "&' )(.) "a

S"2 an4 K&n"(+9# Ra42 In"a** a 0=-!n+ *!n& a n&+&a'# " )'6!4& "& &8(!6

an4 )'&('& a %(*4 & a""a!n&4 # "& &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 !n A*"&'na"!6&

A84)64+9) 2C Wa"&'On& S())*# a" H%# 71 an4 L(+# W& R42 %!" E*&6a"&4

P*a+& an &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 a" S!"& 1 %!" a +nn&+"!n )!n" a" H%# 71 an4

R4 In"a** 0= !n+ *!n& a n&+&a'# " )'6!4& 3*% 3'. "& +nn&+"!n )!n



42/90

T& "!'4 a*"&'na"!6& ! " "a!n an4 H!5%a# ,

1>>" S"'&&", )!*# () " K&n"(+9# Ra42 T% a*"&'na"!6& an &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an

an4 a 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 an4 "&' )(.) "a"!n a*"&'na"!6&, %&'& &6a*(a"&4 3' &

+nn&+"!n )!n" *+a"!n an4 a'& 4&+'!&4 &*%

A84)64+9) 3A T'!-C(n"# S())*# a" H%# > an4 H%# %!" E*&6a"&4 S"'a5&

&*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 a" S!"& 1 %!" a +nn&+"!n )!n" a" H%# > an4 H%# 2 I*!n& a n&+&a'# " )'6!4& 3*% 3'. "& +nn&+"!n )!n" " S!"& 12

A84)64+9) 3& T'!-C(n"# a" H%# > an4 H%# %!" G'(n4 S"'a5& Tan9 an4

P(.) S"a"!n P*a+& a 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 an4 "&' )(.) "a"!n a" "& H

H%# 2 In"a** 0=-!n+ *!n& a n&+&a'# " )'6!4& "& &8(!6a*&n" 3*% an4 )'&

%(*4 & a""a!n&4 # "& &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 !n A*"&'na"!6&


43/90



44/90

5.5 Cost Estimates

5.5.1

Elevate# Storage Tan*s

E*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 .an(3a+"('&' %&'& +n"a+"&4 " "a!n (45&"a'# &"!.a"& 3

+*(.n an4 +.)!"& &*&6a"&4 "an92 Ta*& 7-> *!" "& a6&'a5& )'!+& 3' &a+ "#*&

"an9 %!" an a(.&4 a**% 3(n4a"!n2

In a44!"!n " +a)!"a* +", "& )&'a"!n an4 .a!n"&nan+& ?OM@ 3 "& "an9 %a "a9

+n!4&'a"!n2 T& .a:' +" !"&. %&n &6a*(a"!n5 )&'a"!n an4 .a!n"&nan+& ! "&

'&)a!n"!n5 3 "& "an9 )&'!4!+a**# ?a))'/!.a"&*# &6&'# 1> #&a'@2 T& +.)!"& "a

OM +" &+a(& "& +n+'&"& )&4&"a* 4& n" n&&4 '&)a!n"!n52 OM +" a* a++!n)&+"!n, a '&+..&n4&4 # "& A.&'!+an Wa"&' W'9 A+!a"!n ?AWWA@, &6&

A))&n4!/ A +n"a!n "& OM )'&&n" %'" +a*+(*a"!n2

T& +a)!"a* an4 )&'a"!n an4 .a!n"&nan+& +" a'& +.)a'&4 a&4 n a )'&&n" %

6&' 0 #&a'2 T& ana*#! % "a" "& "an9 "#*& a'& +.)a'a*& !n )'!+& a" "& )

T& +.)!"& "an9 %!** & &*&+"&4 3' "& +" +.)a'!n !n "! '&)'"2 I3 an &*&6a"

"an9 ! &*&+"&4, !" %(*4 & '&+..&n4&4 "a" a +.)!"& "an9 & a& !4 %!" a 3*(

"#*& "an9 a an a*"&'na"& 3' )"!.(. +.)&"!"!n an4 +" a6!n52

"a(le 4-, leated "an5 Capital, ;9M, and Present Worth Costs, >,

M!/!n5 S#"&. >, >,

E*&6a"&4 Tan9 OM C"Pa!n"!n5 >,> 07=,>

In)&+"!n T"a* P'&&n" W'" =,=;=, =,=0,

N"&12 C" a(.& a !* &a'!n5 *a4 3 =, *8(a'& 3", %!+ a**% a )'&a4 3(n4a"!n "

5&"&+n!+a* !n6&"!5a"!n %(*4 n&&4 " & +n4(+"&4 !n "& )'&*!.!na'# 4&!5n )a& a" "& &*+a"!n " 4&"&'.!n& "& 6a*!4!"# 3 "& a(.)"!n2

02 C" 3 "& &*&6a"&4 "an9 ! 3' a**% 3(n4a"!n an4 "an9 a 8("&4 # "& .an(3a+"('&' n*#

!n+*(4& +" 3 *an4, !"& %'9 ' &n5!n&&'!n52

5.5.(

&roun# Storage Tan*s an# )ooster ump Station

G'(n4 "'a5& "an9 ?GST@ an4 "&' )(.) "a"!n .an(3a+"('&' %&'& +n"a+"&4 "

(45&"a'# &"!.a"& 3' +n+'&"& an4 5*a 3(&4 " "&&* "an9 an4 "&' )(.) "a"

* 4 3 * 3 4 9 ? 4



45/90

+a*+(*a"!n@2 T& OM 6a*(& a* !n+*(4& )'6!!n " '&)*a+& < 3 "& = *a'5& )(.)

.a** )(.) a" "& 0 #&a' ?0, 1,7>,

T&*&.&"'# >, >,B"&' P(.) S"a"!n OM C"

E*&+"'!+a* 0,11, 0,11,P(.) R&)*a+&.&n" a" 0 Y&a' 0>0, 0>0,

T"a* P'&&n" W'" >,07, >,7


46/90

"a(le 4-4, #lternatie Cost #nalysis

MG Cn+'&"& G'(n4 S"'a5& Tan9 an4 B"&' P(.) S"a"!n 0,;7>,

S!"& E*&+"'!+a* W'9 17>,

S!"&%'9 an4 G'a4!n5 =


47/90

4!a.&"&' )!)& !n!4& "& +!"# *!.!"2 T'an.!!n .a!n ("!4& "& +!"# *!.!" %&'& n

"& ana*#!2 On*# "& !.)'6&.&n" '&8(!'&4 !n!4& "& C!"# *!.!" a %n n F!5

!n+*(4&42 T& )'!+& 3 +nn&+"!n5 " Wa"&'On& an4 "& "'an.!!n .a!n n&&4&4 " "

%!** n&&4 " & a44&4 " "& +" 3 A*"&'na"!6& 0D2

F' "& T'!-C(n"# a*"&'na"!6& "& *%&" +" )"!n ! a 5'(n4 "'a5& an4 )(.)!n

*+a"&4 a" 1>>" K&n"(+9# Ra4 4(& " "& '"&' *&n5" 3 )!)& n&&4&4 " +nn&+" 3

&/!"!n5 &*&6a"&4 "'a5& a" F/%4 D'!6&2

F' Kana C!"# "& *%&" +" a*"&'na"!6& ! A*"&'na"!6& 1A, %!+ !n+*(4& a n&% +n

1>>"

K&n"(+9# Ra4 an4 an &*&6a"&4 "an9 a" S!"& 12

5.7

=ecommen#ation Water Storage

U*"!.a"&*# "& '&+..&n4a"!n 4&)&n4 ()n % +an ())*# Ra#.'& %!" "& a.

"a" ! n&&4&42 T& '&+..&n4a"!n &"%&&n a 5'(n4 "'a5& "an9 an4 )(.) "a"!

&*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an9 ! 4&)&n4&n" ()n "& *+a"!n %a"&' ! '&+&!6&4 an4 "& #4'a(

5'a4!&n" "a" +an & ())*!&42 Ba&4 ()n "& !n!"!a* +a)!"a* +" 3 "& )':&+" a 5'(n

"an9 an4 )(.) "a"!n ! +&a)&' "an an &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an92 O6&' &6&'a* #&a' an

"'a5& "an9 %!** a6& *& )&'a"!n an4 .a!n"&nan+& +" "an a 5'(n4 "'a5& "an

"a"!n2 I3 "& ())*!&' +an .&&" Ra#.'&$ #4'a(*!+ 5'a4& "& &" '&+..&n4a"!n

+n"'(+" an &*&6a"&4 "'a5& "an92 U!n5 4&.an4 )':&+"!n !n S&+"!n ' %&n "& a6&'a5& 4a

4&.an4 '&a+& 020-MGD2 T! &8(a"& " a ))(*a"!n 3 a))'/!.a"&*# 00,7;2 I3

+& an a*"&'na"!6& ('+& 3 ())*# (+ a T'!-C(n"# "&n a n&% 3a+!*!"# %!** & n

#&a' 001 %&n "& a6&'a5& 4a# %a"&' 4&.an4 '&a+& 02;-MGD an4 "& ))(*a"!na))'/!.a"&*# 0,;1=2



48/90

!ppen#ix !@ Operations an# %aintenance resent Wort Calculat



49/90

Operations an# %aintenance Calculations Elevate# Storage Tan*s

Table !ppen#ix !@ O>% Costs Composite Tan*C.)!"& Tan9

A+"!n Y&a' FP a" 0 P'&&n" W

In)&+"!nC*&an!n5 1 1201; 0,>;

R&)a!n"!n5 3 B%* 1> 12; 07>,>

In)&+"!nC*&an!n5 0 12=>; 1,0>

;

R&)a!n"!n5 3 B%* 1> 12; >,07

In)&+"!nC*&an!n5 0 12=>; 1,0>

>=; 1,0>


50/90

Operations an# %aintenance Calculations )ooster ump Station

ump =eplacement

Table !ppen#ix !@ O>% Costs@ ump =eplacements

B"&' P(.) S"a"!n

P(.) C" " R&)*a+& FP 00#' P'&&n" W'"

P(.) 1 >, 12=>; >7,0=

P(.) 0 >, 12=>; >7,0=

P(.) < >, 12=>; >7,0=P(.) = 12=>;

P(.) > , 12=>; =,; =,0,


51/90

Table !ppen#ix !@ ump =eplacement@ Electrical Costs

In

A(.)"!n In

A6&'a5& Da# F*% ; 3 10 .n"

Ma/!.(. Da# F*% < 3 10 .n"A6&'a5& Da# Wa"&' 3'. KCMO 0 MGD ?1 MGD 3'. a44!"!na* %a"&' ('+& 4(& " .!n!.(.a5'&&.&n"@Ma/!.(. Da# Wa"&' 3'. KCMO < MGD ?KCMO %!** a6& "& *&a" &/)&n!6& %a"&', (& a .)&a9 4a#@

C" )&' 9W' ! 2, !n3*a"&4


52/90

Electricity Costs )ase# on ea* "ay Flo,s

Year Total "eman# Water From :C%O Oter Source

ump

Stationo,er

=eA

"ai

Cos

?MGD@ ?GPM@ ?MGD@ ?GPM@ ?MGD@ ?GPM@ ?HP@

011 21> =,072<


53/90

Table Appendix A, Annual Electricity Costs

nnual )lectricity *osts

Year (otal *ost

,et Present

Worth

>5##ually?

water supp _water storage

Documents