watkins meegan lunch & learn series:
DESCRIPTION
On Thursday, December 2nd, Mr. Alan Stewart presented at Watkins Meegan's Monthly Lunch & Learn Series that takes place at the Tower Club in Tyson's Corner, VA. Mr. Stewart spoke about "CFO M&A Strategies & Experiences" to a packed room. As the former CFO of ICF, Mr. Stewart helped grow the company's annual revenue six-fold and completed 10 acquisitions successfully. To attend a Watkins Meegan Lunch & Learn email Andrea Contres at [email protected].TRANSCRIPT
Proprietary and Confidential
CFO M&A Strategies and ExperiencesDecember 2, 2010
Alan Stewart
Why do acquisitions? The lay of the land.
Proprietary and Confidential 2
•Why do acquisitions?•How did ICF source deal opportunities?•What type of reliance they had on internal & external experts?•How did ICF perform due diligence?•Negotiate to closing of the transaction•Post closing integration
ICF Transaction History
3
•June 1999 leveraged buyout with CM Equity from ICF Kaiser (a billion dollar public company heading into bankruptcy-12/99 debt to ebitda leverage at 7-1.•April 2002 first acquisition was completed, asset purchase of two units of the Arthur D. Little consulting practice in bankruptcy auction, with equity infusion by CM Equity.
•Subsequent Transactions:•January 2005 Synergy, Inc.•October 2005 Caliber Associates•January 2007 EE&A & APCG•June 2007 Ztech•December 2007SH&E•February 2008 Jones & Stokes•March 2009 Macro International•December 2010Jacob & Sunstrand
How did ICF source deal opportunities?
4
As a private company before we had capacity to acquire companies:• Hired buyside investment bankers in 2004 for a one year engagement• Reviewed potential targets and arranged CEO meetings• Participated in numerous auctions to understand process and
playersAs we deleveraged and had capacity for acquisitions:• Pursued and closed Synergy and Caliber acquisitions• Hired full time M&A staff person• Expanded contacts for CEO to pursue deals• Expanded reach to investment banking community for deals and participate in more limited auctions
What type of reliance they had on internal & external experts
5
•Necessary to have a mix of external and internal resources and used:•External accounting firms to audit quality of earnings, backlog and rate structure as well as revenue recognition practices and tax issues.•Outside counsel for legal corporate review and government contracts review•We often had an independent survey of major customers completed.•HR experts to review plans, 401k issues, conversion issues.•Internal staff to review government contracts, backlog, pipeline and proposals, rate structure, accounting systems and processes, internal IT systems, HR benefits, facilities, etc.
•Upon acceptance of a expression of interest (versus letter of intent), we obtained limited exclusivity with the target.•Provided our due diligence request list and plan for due diligence.•If sensitive of disclosure, we would send in an accounting firm to provide a business review of the target and expand work as needed.•We would request an electronic data room where possible.•Prepared documents which incorporated the due diligence reports from our external and internal experts, with our integration plan and financial model combining the companies. These reports were used for our Board of Directors and commercial bank approval. We used debt to acquire all but our first acquisition.•We started the integration planning process during the due diligence process.
How did ICF perform due diligence
6
Negotiate to closing of the transaction
•Get major terms on expression of interest or letter of intent•Obtain limited exclusivity for 30 to 60 days•Often negotiated two step agreement (signing with conditions to close)•Work directly through company executives and not investment bankers where possible.•Map out benefits strategy and prepare all employee presentation•We required a significant portion of billable employees to sign ICF standard agreements as a condition to close (intellectual property, code of ethics, nonsolicitation of clients or employees for one year after termination of employment). Also, we required all Key employees sign contracts as a condition to close.•Ensure that the senior and next one or two levels of management are sold on the deal, understand their new reporting, and their compensation arrangements prior to closing, and preferably signing if possible.•Work out refined financial model after signing if possible.
Proprietary and Confidential 7
Post closing integration
8
•Identify internal integration team•Involve integration team in due diligence as early as possible•Have weekly joint meetings on integration to identify all issues and develop plan and responsibility for actions•Cultural implications and communications are critical•Get into the details as quickly as possible•Be open, honest and upfront during the integration process•Consider retention bonuses for corporate staff, historical knowledge is important•Evaluate corporate staff for keepers as early as possible•Update post performance on financial, employee, customer results and review
Proprietary and Confidential
Acquisition Integration Overview Presentation
There are Four Basic Messages for Successful Acquisition Integration
Speed OverPerfection
Speed OverPerfectionFollow the MoneyFollow the Money
Run the CoreBusiness
Aggressively
Run the CoreBusiness
Aggressively
• Start before the close of the transaction
• Make decisions quickly• Make most of the
decisions in the first 100 days
• Minimize the productivity dip
• Maximize enthusiasm by minimizing uncertainty
• Keep it 80/20• Focus the work where
the bulk of the shareholder value is created
• Remember that 10 to 20 of the hundreds of possible initiatives drive the majority of the value
• Use small teams to manage the integration
• Preclude people running the core business from getting side tracked
Culture MattersCulture Matters
• Pay particular attention to the business systems and practices that comprise how the businesses are run
• Decide as early as possible
− The practices that are non-negotiable and will be imposed
− The areas of business practice that will be the combination of best practices from both companies
− The practices that will be needed to drive the value (in the VDA and price of the deal)
Value Driver Analysis Is an Iterative ProcessVDA Refines Due Diligence; Due Diligence Informs VDA
Eliminate
Due Diligence Data Analysis
Accept/Adjust
Preliminary Value Driver Assessment
Value Driver Operating
HypothesisDue Diligence Requests and Prioritization
Value Driver Analysis and Due Diligence Process Flow
Milestones
StageFormulation of StrategicObjectives
Formulation of StrategicObjectives
TransactionImplementationImplementation EvaluationEvaluation
Transition
Acquisition Candidate Confirmed
LOI Definitive Agreement &
Announcement
Close Close + 100 Days
Integration Process Incorporates Significant Integration Planning in Transition Stage
Also Communication, Culture and Employee Transition WorkstreamsAcquisition Integration Process
Transition and Implementation
Workstreams
Culture Assessment and Integration
Communication Plan Development and Execution
Employee Transition Planning & Implementation
Functional Area Planning & ImplementationFoundational
Integration Process
Workstreams
Overall Acquisition Integration Project Management
Team Formation
Knowledge Capture & Capability Building
Value Driver Analysis
Transaction Workstreams
Due Diligence
Regulatory Approval
Negotiation
Milestones
StageFormulation of StrategicObjectives
Formulation of StrategicObjectives
TransactionImplementationImplementation EvaluationEvaluation
Transition
Acquisition Candidate Confirmed
LOI Definitive Agreement &
Announcement
Close Close + 100 Days
Integration Process Incorporates Significant Integration Planning in Transition Stage
Also Communication, Culture and Employee Transition Workstreams
Acquisition Integration Process
Integration Leader to Oversee Value Creation and Continuity from VDA to Implementation
Traditional Approach Includes Only Deal Leader
Steering Committee
Value Driver Analysis
Deal(Leader)
Traditional Acquisition Approach
Integration (Leader)
Due Diligence(Teams)
Transition(Teams)
Implementation(Teams)
Functional Area Team Continuity
Conceptual Acquisition Integration Organizational Structure
A Balanced Scorecard Will Be Used to Monitor the Success of an IntegrationAppropriate Metrics Can Be Measured Real-Time
Sample Metrics for an AI Balanced Scorecard
FinancialInnovation and
Learning Customer InternalHR/Company
Culture
• Net Income %• ROE• Sales Growth
$/Units• EVA• Cash Flow
• Revenue from New Products
• Product Development Cycle Time
• Patents Issued• # New Products
in Pipeline• # R&D
Employees
• Customer Complaints
• On-time Delivery• % New Sales to
Existing Customers
• Customer Retention/ Attrition
• Market Share Growth
• Product Defects• Revenue/
Employee• Inventory
Turnover• Asset Turnover• Utilization Rate
(employee machine, etc.)
• Employee Satisfaction Rating
• Key Employee Retention %
• OSHA/Safety Record
• Absenteeism• Cross-Company
Teams
Source: Borghese, Robert J. and Borgese, Paul F.: “M&A from Planning to Integration”, pg. 122