wents hybrid strategy packages final …f506b13c-605b-4878-8062... · 21 january 2013 page 2 1....

17
WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL RESULTS (2035) A total of 3 future scenarios (2035) have been evaluated and are presented in this project memo. All three future scenarios incorporate land use changes projected by the Metropolitan Transportation Plan (MTP) to 2035, and the travel demands associated with those land use changes. The first scenario is referred to as the Base Case, and assumes that Core Improvements are constructed or implemented within the study area. In addition, the Base Case incorporates the Phase 1 and Phase 2 implementation projects approved by the CIRC Alternatives Task Force. The second scenario is referred to as Hybrid Strategy Package 1 (HSP1). The key feature of HSP1 is a new bridge across the Winooski River at the current southern terminus of VT289, accessing a reconstructed Redmond Road. HSP1 incorporates all of the Core Improvements (inclusive of the Phase 1 and 2 Circ Task Force improvements), plus additional spot improvements designed to manage the changed traffic flow resulting from the new bridge. The third scenario is referred to as Hybrid Strategy Package 2 (HSP2). The key features of HSP2 are reconstruction of I-89 Exit 12 and new grid streets proximate to the Exit that are designed to better manage vehicular traffic in this section of the study area. As with HSP1, other spot improvements are incorporated within HSP2 to address the most significant areas of projected congestion. Also, as with HSP1, the Core Improvements and Circ Task Force Phase 1 and 2 improvements are included in the HSP2 scenario. 1.0 CORE IMPROVEMENTS 1.1 CIRC Alt Task Force Phase 1 and 2 Implementation Projects The Circ Alts Task Force Phase 1 implementation projects in the WENTS study area are: 1. Essex Junction Crescent Connector 2. Intersection improvements, VT117/Sand Hill Road (traffic signal, turn lanes) 3. Intersection and VT2A mainline improvements, James Brown Drive (traffic signal, turn lanes) The total estimated cost of the Phase 1 improvements is $11.5 million. The Circ Alts Task Force Phase 2 implementation projects in the WENTS study area are: 1. VT15 Post Office Square-to-Five Corners multimodal improvements. 2. Intersection improvements, VT15/Sand Hill Road (traffic signal, turn lanes) 3. VT15 multi-use path. The total estimated cost of the Phase 2 improvements is $13.9 million. 1.2 Additional Core Improvements The WENTS Core Improvements include bicycle and pedestrian improvements, transit service improvements, and the implementation of adaptive signal control within the WENTS study area. In addition, the Core Improvements include:

Upload: hakhanh

Post on 24-Apr-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES – FINAL RESULTS (2035) A total of 3 future scenarios (2035) have been evaluated and are presented in this project memo. All three future scenarios incorporate land use changes projected by the Metropolitan Transportation Plan (MTP) to 2035, and the travel demands associated with those land use changes.

The first scenario is referred to as the Base Case, and assumes that Core Improvements are constructed or implemented within the study area. In addition, the Base Case incorporates the Phase 1 and Phase 2 implementation projects approved by the CIRC Alternatives Task Force.

The second scenario is referred to as Hybrid Strategy Package 1 (HSP1). The key feature of HSP1 is a new bridge across the Winooski River at the current southern terminus of VT289, accessing a reconstructed Redmond Road. HSP1 incorporates all of the Core Improvements (inclusive of the Phase 1 and 2 Circ Task Force improvements), plus additional spot improvements designed to manage the changed traffic flow resulting from the new bridge.

The third scenario is referred to as Hybrid Strategy Package 2 (HSP2). The key features of HSP2 are reconstruction of I-89 Exit 12 and new grid streets proximate to the Exit that are designed to better manage vehicular traffic in this section of the study area. As with HSP1, other spot improvements are incorporated within HSP2 to address the most significant areas of projected congestion. Also, as with HSP1, the Core Improvements and Circ Task Force Phase 1 and 2 improvements are included in the HSP2 scenario.

1.0 CORE IMPROVEMENTS

1.1 CIRC Alt Task Force Phase 1 and 2 Implementation Projects The Circ Alts Task Force Phase 1 implementation projects in the WENTS study area are:

1. Essex Junction Crescent Connector

2. Intersection improvements, VT117/Sand Hill Road (traffic signal, turn lanes)

3. Intersection and VT2A mainline improvements, James Brown Drive (traffic signal, turn lanes)

The total estimated cost of the Phase 1 improvements is $11.5 million. The Circ Alts Task Force Phase 2 implementation projects in the WENTS study area are:

1. VT15 Post Office Square-to-Five Corners multimodal improvements.

2. Intersection improvements, VT15/Sand Hill Road (traffic signal, turn lanes)

3. VT15 multi-use path.

The total estimated cost of the Phase 2 improvements is $13.9 million.

1.2 Additional Core Improvements The WENTS Core Improvements include bicycle and pedestrian improvements, transit service improvements, and the implementation of adaptive signal control within the WENTS study area. In addition, the Core Improvements include:

Page 2: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

21 January 2013 Page 2

1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound approach to Exit 12.

2. Travel Demand Management initiatives designed to reduce work-based trips by 10% between targeted “TDM” zones. Initiatives include:

a. Increased public awareness/education programs b. Rewards and incentive programs c. Commuter intercept facilities, park and ride lots d. Support for existing “GoChittenden” programs.

1.2.1 Bicycle Facility Improvements

Bicycle facility improvements are designed to address discontinuities in the existing bicycle network within the study area. Three approaches are recommended depending on the location and the deficiency:

1. Restriping of existing roadways to create shoulders where none currently exist. 2. Widening shoulders to achieve bicycle facility design standards. 3. Addressing gaps and/or making connections to existing Shared Used Path facilities.

Specific improvements, and their estimated costs, are shown in Table 1.

Table 1: Recommended Bicycle Facility Improvements

1.2.2 Pedestrian Facility Improvements

Pedestrian facility improvements are designed to address discontinuities and/or missing links in the existing pedestrian network within the study area. In addition, pedestrian hardware and timing improvements at study area intersections are recommended (e.g. pedestrian countdown timers and advanced pedestrian interval (API) timing).

Specific improvements, and their estimated costs, are shown in Table 2.

Bicycle Facilities quantity unit unit cost* total costAddress lack of shoulders and discontinuity by:

1. restriping where achievable/beneficial (i.e. 3 ft local/collectors, 4 ft arterials, +1 ft at curb/GR)N Williston Rd btw Mt View and US2 5600 lf 2$ 11,200$

2. widening shoulder where necessary:N Williston Rd. N of Mt View 9400 lf 75$ 705,000$ Mountain View Road 13600 lf 75$ 1,020,000$ adjacent to Allen Brook crossing on VT2A (bridge replacement) 3400 sf 500$ 1,700,000$

approach work 2 ea 400,000$ 800,000$ temporary span 1 1,000,000$ 1,000,000$

along VT117 3400 lf 75$ 255,000$ VT15 between Village (@ Brickyard Rd) and VT289 5000 lf 75$ 375,000$

Address missing Shared Path facility connections, particularly on VT15 and VT2A:1. short section E of Old Stage on VT15, S side assume by developers2. VT15, N side, VT289 to Old Stage 1000 lf 400$ 400,000$ 3. VT15, N side, Old Stage to Essex Way 1300 lf 400$ 520,000$ 4. Meadow Run to Beaudry Lane (ea. Side VT2A/Allen Brook xing) (1) project in final design5. Mountain View Rd. (S Side) from Old Stage to VT2A at Industrial 11400 lf 400$ 4,560,000$ 6. VT2A - Industrial to Blair Park (complete West side) 3620 lf 400$ 1,448,000$

TOTAL (rounded) 12,800,000$

Page 3: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

Table 2: Recommended Pedestrian Facility Improvements

1.2.3 Transit Improvements

Recommended transit improvements include a number of spot investments such as new bus shelters and new sidewalks to connect to bus shelters. Specific service improvements include adding a new weekday mid-day trip on the CCTA Williston Route and adding a weekday peak hour commuter route on VT15 between Jeffersonville and Burlington.

1.2.4 Advanced Traffic Signal Control

VTrans has installed the first adaptive signal control project in the state on VT2A at the VT289 interchange. This first installation is designed to understand the capabilities and build technical capacity in the Agency. This technology is designed to improve traffic signal responsiveness to variations in traffic demand, and is particularly effective during non-saturated flow conditions.

For the WENTS study area there are 3 sections where adaptive signal control can be targeted. In order of priority, they are:

1. VT2A from Exit 12 to Zephyr Drive (7 signals) 2. VT15, inclusive of the VT289 interchange to Essex Way (5 signals) 3. VT2A from South Street/River Street to Five Corners (4 signals including the Crescent

Connector)

2.0 HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGE 1 The key component of Hybrid Strategy Package 1 is a new bridge across the Winooski River extending the current southern terminus of VT289 to Redmond Road in Williston. In Phase 1 of the WENTS study, both the Williston and Essex Selectboards voted to continue consideration of this Major Network Strategy through the remainder of the project.

Other improvements to the network are necessary to accommodate the changes in travel flow that will result from the new bridge. Specific improvements will be necessary at the Redmond Road/Mountain View Road intersection and at the VT2A/Mountain View/Industrial Ave. intersection.

HSP1 improvements are augmented by two spot improvements along VT2A near Exit 12. One of these is a capacity improvement at VT2A/Marshall Ave. The second is a reconstruction of the Exit 12 interchange to accommodate additional lanes and bicycle/pedestrian facilities under the bridge.

Pedestrian Facilitiescountdown timers 12 int. 10,000$ 120,000$ implement API timings 1 l.s. 10,000$ 10,000$ missing links (see specifics in bike ped deficiency list):

1. N Williston/US2 in Williston village at Korner Kwik Stop (W side NWRd, N/S of US2) 440 lf 175$ 77,000$ 2. US2 Williston Village on SW corner of Oak Hill 360 lf 175$ 63,000$ 3. VT2A Exit 12 sidewalk (no bridge work) 1800 lf 175$ 315,000$ 4. VT2A Marshall to US2 (W side) assume by developers5: VT2A Flag Works to Knight Lane (E side) funded identified separately6. VT2A Obrien Ct to Beaudry (E side) 800 lf 175$ 140,000$ 7. VT2A from River Cove to East View (East side) assume part of JB Drive project8. VT2A from Mt View to River Cove (E side) 2700 lf 175$ 472,500$ 9. short section @ 289 NB off ramp on VT15 50 lf 175$ 8,750$ 10. VT15, N side - Education to Athens Dr 2900 lf 175$ 507,500$ 11. VT15 Athens Dr to VT289 3300 lf 175$ 577,500$ 13. VT15 S side, Shaws plaza to VT128 1600 lf 175$ 280,000$

2,300,000$

Page 4: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

21 January 2013 Page 4

Table 3 shows the specific elements of HSP1 and their estimated costs. Figure 1 shows the study area with the general locations of recommended HSP1 improvements.

Table 3: Elements of Hybrid Strategy Package 1, with Estimated Costs

Figure 1: Map of Hybrid Strategy Package 1 Improvements

Page 5: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

3.0 HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGE 2 The key components of Hybrid Strategy Package 2 are reconstruction of I-89 Exit 12 and new grid streets proximate to the Exit designed to provide additional vehicle mobility in this section of the network. It is envisioned that any scoping of new grid streets would be combined with a review of design alternatives for the interchange as a whole to accommodate new ramps and bicycle/pedestrian mobility between the north and south sides of the Interstate. Table 4 shows specific grid street improvements, and their estimated costs, included in HSP2.

Table 4: Network Grid Connections Included in HSP2

Under direction of the Steering Committee HSP2 combined new grid street concepts with several spot intersection improvements that were evaluated for 2035 traffic conditions. A total of 7 intersection improvements are included in HSP2, which are shown in Table 5. Figure 2 shows the study area with the general locations of HSP2 recommended improvements.

Table 5: Intersection Improvements Included in HSP2

The total cost of HSP2 improvements is estimated to be $30.4 – 48.6 million.

Item Location/Descriptionlikely cost low high

1 Connect Harvest Lane near Home Depot to VT 2A near the state police barracks 2.0$ $1.0 $2.52 Connect Harvest (~UPS) to Trader Lane 0.7$ $0.5 $1.53 Connect VT2A at the state police barracks to the roundabout in MTP (right in right o 2.0$ $1.5 $2.5

4.7$ 3.0$ 6.5$

Item Location/Descriptionlikely cost low high

1 Towers Rd / VT 128/ VT 15 – WB left turn lane $0.1 $0.1 $0.32 N. Williston Road/US 2/Oak Hill Road - roundabout $1.0 $0.8 $1.53 N. Williston Road/VT117 - signal and lane additions $0.3 $0.3 $0.84 N. Williston Road/Mt View Road - roundabout $0.6 $0.4 $1.05 Industrial / VT2A: WB left, 2 EB lefts, 2nd NB thru $1.0 $0.8 $1.56 VT2A/Marshall Ave. (2nd WB thru, 2nd NB thru) $6.0 $5.0 $7.07 New interchange configuration at Exit 12 $25.0 $20.0 $30.0

$34.0 $27.4 $42.1

Page 6: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

21 January 2013 Page 6

Figure 2: Map of Hybrid Strategy Package 1 Improvements

4.0 SUMMARY OF PERFORMANCE Performance measures were established in consultation with the Steering Committee as part of the project’s Phase 2 work. Performance measures include network-wide performance measures, corridor travel times, and intersection operations performance measures.

Multimodal performance measures were also established. However, all future scenarios include the same bicycle, pedestrian, and transit improvements. As such, there is no differentiation among the scenarios. As a result, the performance measures shown below focus on vehicle mobility measures.

All performance measures are based on PM peak hour traffic conditions.

4.1 Network-Wide Performance Network-wide include:

1. Total Intersection Delay for the 13 Primary Study area intersections (Figure 3). 2. Total Vehicle Hours Traveled—total vehicle time for all vehicles in the traffic simulation

network (Figure 4). 3. Total CO2-equivalent emissions (Figure 5).

Performance of the 3 future 2035 scenarios is compared against the 2015 Base Case to provide a yardstick of changes to traffic and congestion over the 20 year period.

Page 7: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

Figure 3: Total Intersection Delay

Figure 4: Vehicle Hours Traveled

Figure 5: Total CO2-Equivalent Emissions

Page 8: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

21 January 2013 Page 8

4.2 Corridor Travel Times Bi-directional vehicle travel times were measured from model runs for the 2015 and 2035 Base Case, 2035 HSP1, and HSP2. The subject corridors are:

1. Allen Martin, VT15 - Sandhill 2. Mountain View Drive, VT2A – N. Williston Road 3. North Williston Road, US2 – VT117 4. Sandhill, VT117 – VT15 5. US2, VT2A – North Williston Road 6. VT15, Sand Hill – Five Corners 7. VT2A, Exit 12 – Five Corners

Bi-directional corridor travel times (minutes) are shown in Table 6.

Table 6: Corridor Travel Times

AllenMartin, VT15 - SandHill2015 Base Base HSP1 HSP2

SB 1.2 1.2 1.3 1.2NB 1.5 1.6 1.6 1.6

MountainView, VT2A - NWilliston2015 Base Base HSP1 HSP2

EB 4.8 6.1 8.2 4.5WB 6.3 11.5 11.9 9.6

NWilliston, US2 - VT1172015 Base Base HSP1 HSP2

NB 7.1 9.3 4.7 5.7SB 5.1 5.7 5.5 4.9

Sandhill, VT117 - VT152015 Base Base HSP1 HSP2

NB 3.1 3.3 4.9 3.2SB 3.3 9.0 4.4 3.6

US2, VT2A - NWilliston2015 Base Base HSP1 HSP2

EB 5.5 9.5 6.3 5.0WB 5.1 13.2 12.2 7.7

VT15, SandHill-FiveCorners2015 Base Base HSP1 HSP2

WB 6.0 6.1 5.9 6.4EB 6.3 6.8 6.8 6.8

VT2A, Exit12 - Five Corners2015 Base Base HSP1 HSP2

NB 12.7 15.7 11.0 13.6SB 9.4 17.7 12.7 13.9

Corridor2035 Travel Time

(mins.)

Page 9: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

4.3 Primary Intersection Performance The following tables provide the Level of Service/vehicle delay (in seconds) results for the study area’s primary intersections. The results for the 2035 scenarios (Base, HSP1, and HSP2) are shown along with the 2010 Base year results, which are closest to today’s operational conditions.

Many of the primary intersections are signalized. As such, some potential improvement in service is possible through additional signal optimization. Some optimization was performed prior to the HSP1 and HSP2 model runs. Additional improvements may be possible but would likely be only marginal.

Further, in many cases, intersection control changes from one scenario to the next. This is noted in the column heading under the scenario name. Some geometric changes assumed for HSP1 and/or HSP2 require additional traffic movements to be tracked in some specific cases.

VT2A/Exit 12 SBDirection Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overall 32 C 86 F 68 E 59 ENB TR 23 C 73 E 45 D 55 E

T 30 C 125 F 67 E 81 FSB L 34 C 58 E 44 D 47 D

T 18 B 32 C 24 C 23 CEB LT 47 D 93 F 91 F 65 E

L 46 D 140 F 114 F 78 ER 25 C 84 F 78 E 56 E

VT2A/Exit 12 NBDirection Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overall 15 B 85 F 30 C 34 CNB L 9 A 63 E 159 F 41 D

TR 8 A 26 C 8 A 11 BSB T 18 B 131 F 26 C 37 D

R 15 B 71 E 37 D 54 DWB L 53 D 179 F 59 E 64 E

R 34 C 156 F 33 C 58 E

VT2A/Marshall Ave./Maple Tree PlaceDirection Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overall 54 D 73 E 74 E 41 DNB L 76 E 72 E 136 F 75 E

T 31 C 41 D 66 E 37 DR 18 B 19 B 29 C 14 B

SB TR 56 E 89 F 66 E 41 DL 65 E 70 E 83 F 60 ET 42 D 84 F 60 E 36 D

EB L 152 F 55 D 80 E 77 ET 67 E 46 D 53 D 41 DR 19 B 41 D 26 C 15 B

WB TR 101 F 69 E 56 E 26 CT 61 E 28 CL 87 F 221 F 184 F 28 C

not applicable not applicable

Signal Signal

Signal Signal Signal Signal

Signal Signal Signal Signal

2035 HSP22035 HSP 1INTERSECTION 2035Base2010 BASE

Signal Signal

Page 10: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

21 January 2013 Page 10

VT2A/US2Direction Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overall 13 B 14 B 12 B 13 BNB L 15 B 23 C 16 B 19 B

T 11 B 10 B 9 A 11 BR 4 A 6 A 7 A 8 A

SB L 14 B 18 B 19 B 31 CT 9 A 9 A 7 A 12 BR 3 A 4 A 5 A 5 A

EB L 18 B 23 C 14 B 13 BT 12 B 13 B 11 B 9 AR 7 A 8 A 9 A 6 A

WB L 31 C 30 C 37 D 20 CT 15 B 18 B 20 B 13 BR 9 A 18 B 19 B 13 B

VT2A/Industrial Ave./Mountain View Dr.Direction Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overall 39 D 105 F 68 E 42 DNB L 91 F 102 F 75 E 62 E

T 15 B 13 B 14 B 18 BR 4 A 5 A 4 A 8 A

SB L 100 F 219 F 188 F 166 FT 45 D 167 F 161 F 52 DR 30 C 156 F 135 F 44 D

EB TR 42 D 104 F 85 F 50 DL 74 E 135 F 66 E 61 E

WB LTR / L 15 B 27 C 15 B 11 BTR 18 B 19 B

Mountain View Dr./Redmond RoadDirection Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overall 90 FSB L 14 B 25 C 50 D 35 D

R 11 B 14 B 41 D 19 BEB L 11 B 8 A 198 F 20 B

T 138 FWB T/TR 5 A 5 A 31 C 11 B

R 25 C

VT2A/South St./River St.Direction Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overall 70 E 76 E 97 F 70 ENB L 69 E 63 E 58 E 62 E

T 21 C 34 C 25 C 29 CSB TR 56 E 106 F 57 E 167 FEB LR 313 F 879 F 609 F 31 CWB TR 28 C 34 C 30 C 34 C

L 58 E 29 C 77 E 228 F

not applicable

not applicable not applicable

not applicable not applicable

not applicable

not applicable not applicable not applicable

not applicable

Signal Signal Signal Signal

Signal Signal Signal

Stop on Redmond Stop on Redmond Signal Stop on Redmond

not applicable

Signal Signal Signal Signal

Signal

Page 11: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

4.4 Environmental/Right-of-Way Constraints Standard Geographic Information System (GIS) techniques were used to evaluate the environmental and right-of-way impact of HSP1 and HSP2 relative to the Base Case.

5.0 SUMMARY OF RESULTS Relative impacts are visualized via the graphics shown in Figures 6 through 9. The same visualization techniques are used as were utilized during Phase 1 of the WENTS project evaluating the Major Network Strategies.

US2/Oak Hill Rd./N. Williston Rd.Direction Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overall 148 F 152 F 69 E 18 BNB LTR 13 B 17 B 16 B 10 BSB LTR 27 C 75 E 67 E 14 BEB LTR 309 F 348 F 122 F 26 CWB LTR 18 B 18 B 16 B 6 A

N. Williston Rd./Mountain View Rd.Direction Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overall 18 BNB LTR 6 A 12 B 10 B 10 BSB LTR 38 D 23 C 17 B 26 CEB LTR 66 E 129 F 89 F 17 BWB LTR 34 C 27 C 22 C 10 B

N. Williston Rd./VT117Direction Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overall 25 CNB L 200 F 349 F 51 D 38 D

R 160 F 266 F 25 C 34 CEB LTR 5 A 12 B 9 A 26 CWB L/TR 246 F 69 E 12 BWB L 19 B 30 C

Allen Martin Dr./VT15Direction Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overallNB L 12 B 18 B 20 C 18 B

R 2 A 4 A 3 A 3 AWB LT 2 A 3 A 4 A 3 A

VT117/Sand Hill Rd.Direction Movement Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS Delay (s) LOS

overall 100 F 81 F 49 DSB L 54 D 355 F 103 F 78 E

R 25 C 262 F 54 D 51 DEB L 51 D 44 D 117 F 58 E

T 21 C 92 F 21 CWB TR 6 A 29 C 25 C 357 F

not applicable

not applicable not applicable not applicable

not applicable not applicable not applicable

not applicable

not applicable not applicable not applicable

Stop on A. Martin Stop on A. Martin Stop on A. Martin Stop on A. Martin

Stop on Sand Hill Signal Signal Signal

not applicable

Stop on Mountainview Stop on Mountainview Stop on Mountainview Roundabout

Stop on N. Williston Stop on N. Williston Stop on N. Williston Signal

All Way Stop All Way Stop All Way Stop Roundabout

Page 12: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

21 January 2013 Page 12

Figure 6: Summary Results of HSP1 & HSP2: Environmental – Transportation – Costs

Page 13: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

Figure 7: Results for HSP1 Improvements: Environmental – Transportation – Costs

Page 14: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

21 January 2013 Page 14

Figure 8: Results for HSP2 Spot Improvements: Environmental – Transportation – Costs

Page 15: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

Figure 9: Results for HSP2 Grid Streets: Environmental – Transportation – Costs

Page 16: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

21 January 2013 Page 16

PROJECT TEAM RECOMMENDATIONS Based on the Performance Measures summarized in this report, and on the estimated costs and relative environmental impact, the project team recommends that the Steering Committee endorse Hybrid Strategy Package 2 (HSP2) to move forward as the recommended Implementation Plan for the WENTS area. Scoping studies based on HSP2 are recommended for the CIRC Alternatives Task Force’s consideration during their January 31st, 2013 meeting.

Specific elements of HSP2 should be advanced sooner into scoping given their relative impact on network performance and the need for quicker intervention. The following four Scoping Studies are recommended for approval by the CIRC Alternatives Task Force:

1. I-89 Exit 12 Reconfiguration and Grid Streets. This scoping study shall evaluate potential reconfigurations of Exit 12 to provide additional traffic mitigation in the immediate area. Safety improvements should be recommended for each intersection. Bicycle/pedestrian mobility north and south of I-89 is a paramount consideration. The scoping study should address the opportunity for new local roads connecting VT 2A to Harvest Lane (west of 2A) and to Maple Tree Place (east of 2A) as well as a new VT 2A intersection at the vicinity of the State Police Barracks.

2. VT2A/Mountain View/Industrial Avenue, inclusive of VT2A from this intersection to the James Brown Drive project improvement. In addition to addressing significant congestion issues at this intersection/corridor, this study should consider bicycle/pedestrian mobility in the area proximate to the intersection and connections to existing facilities along VT2A and along Mountain View Drive.

3. VT117/North Williston Road intersection, inclusive of the North Williston Road approach to the Winooski River Bridge to consider intermittent flooding of the road. Project should consider mitigation of peak period congestion, existing safety deficiencies, and bicycle/pedestrian safety and mobility.

4. Multimodal improvements: US2 from Taft Corner to Williston Village. This section of US 2 has several deficiencies that should be addressed in one inclusive multimodal study. Issues to be addressed include: a. Bicycle/pedestrian connections along and/or parallel to US2 connecting existing multiuse

paths. b. Removal and rehabilitation of the eastbound US2 climbing lane. c. Provision of transit access (i.e. bus shelters and pedestrian access to bus shelters) at

appropriate places along this segment. d. Other improvements to the US2 mainline to more safely accommodate bicycle/pedestrian

traffic.

Elements of the Core Improvements relating to bicycle/pedestrian connectivity should also be advanced to scoping, as funding permits, given their complexity relative to other elements. These are:

Mountain View Road (south side) from Old Stage Road to VT2A (to be linked to Scoping Study 2, above).

VT2A, Industrial Ave. to Blair Park - west side. Multimodal improvements and mode connectivity - VT2A across Allen Brook. VT15, north side, VT289 to Old Stage Road, and Old Stage Road to Essex Way.

Page 17: WENTS HYBRID STRATEGY PACKAGES FINAL …F506B13C-605B-4878-8062... · 21 January 2013 Page 2 1. Spot intersection safety improvements including a dynamic warning flasher at VT2A northbound

Despite the fact that relatively recent scoping projects have been completed for the US2/North Williston Road and North Williston Road/Mountain View Road intersections the project team recommends that additional capacity improvements be considered at these two locations. Traffic modeling conducted for HSP2 shows that single lane modern roundabouts, with appropriate bicycle/pedestrian safety features, will effectively and safely manage projected traffic flows at both intersections through 2035.

The project team acknowledges that roundabout recommendations, at these locations, in the past did not garner public support/acceptance. However, the WENTS study, with its careful consideration of land use changes in the WENTS study area, indicates significant increases in traffic volumes at both intersections by 2035 when compared to existing conditions.