wg22497 substance misuse treatment framework …...2 1. purpose this document provides some...
TRANSCRIPT
Substance Misuse Treatment Framework (SMTF) Improving Access to Substance Misuse Treatment for Older People
Digital ISBN 978 1 4734 1824 0© Crown copyright 2014 WG22497
1
Contents1. Purpose 2
2. Background 2 2.1 Context 2 2.2 SubstanceMisuseinOlderPeople 2 2.3 Drugs 3 2.4 Alcohol 3 2.5 Co-morbidityandComplexity 3 2.6 TheExtentofSubstanceMisuseinOlderPeople 4 2.7 ImplicationsforServices 4
3. ManagementofSubstanceMisuseinOlderPeople 5 3.1 Identification 5 3.2 EvidenceBaseforTreatment 6 3.3 BriefInterventions 7 3.4 SpecialistAssessment 7 3.5 Detoxification 8 3.6 PrescribingforOlderAdults 8 3.7 CarePathways 8
4. ImprovingAccesstoTreatment 9 4.1 PrudentHealthcare 9 4.2 Training 9 4.3 RangeofNeeds 10 4.4 Presentation 10 4.5 AwarenessandAttitudes 10 4.6 HomelessnessandHousingProblems 11 4.7 JointWorking 11 4.8 CommunityPharmacists 11 4.9 PrimaryCare 11 4.10AccidentandEmergencyDepartments 12 4.11 SubstanceMisuseServices 12 4.12 Dentists 12 4.13 OlderPeopleServices 12 4.14 ThirdSectorServices 12 4.15 LocalHealthBoards 13 4.16 AreaPlanningBoards 13
5. SummaryofRecommendations 14
References 15
Appendix–ServiceExamples 18
2
1.PurposeThisdocumentprovidessomebackgroundinformationonsubstancemisuseinthoseovertheageof50.Itsfocusisonaccesstotreatmentanditoutlinesactionthatcouldbetakentoimprovethisatlocallevel.ItisaimedatLocalHealthBoards,SubstanceMisuseAreaPlanningBoards,substancemisuseandmentalhealthserviceproviders,LocalMentalHealthPartnershipBoards,localauthorityadultservicesandthoseworkinginprimarycare.Itisintendedtoinformthedevelopmentoflocalcarepathwaysandwillbeofrelevancetopractitionersandthoseresponsibleforplanningandmanagingservicesaswellasserviceusersthemselves.Thisdocumentmayalsobeofrelevancetoothersworkingwiththeolderpopulationincludinggeneralpractitioners,socialworkers,thirdsectorserviceprovidersandothersprovidinghealthandsocialcareforthisagegroup.
Preventionofsubstancemisuseisnotspecificallyaddressedwithinthisdocumentbuttherearespecificissuesinrelationtothisagegroupthatwillneedtobeconsidered.ActionsthatarebeingtakentopreventsubstancemisuseinolderpeoplearesetoutinWorking Together to Reduce Harm,theWelshGovernment’stenyearsubstancemisusestrategyandassociateddeliveryplan2013-2015.Furtherconsiderationwillalsoneedtobegiventoraisingawareness,amongstthepublicandprofessionals,ontheissueofsubstancemisuseinolderpeople.
AreaPlanningBoardsshouldreviewtheirexistinglocalcarepathwayswithaviewtoensuringthataccesstosubstancemisusetreatmentforthoseagedover50yearsisimproved.Thisreviewwillneedtotakeintoaccountlocalfactorsandserviceavailability.LocalauthoritieswillneedtoconsidertheneedsofolderadultswithsubstancemisuseproblemswithinSingleIntegratedPlans.
2.Background
2.1ContextSubstancemisuseamongolderpeoplereceivesrelativelylittleattention.Theevidencesuggeststhatitisnotidentifiedandtreatedadequatelyinthisagegroupdespitetheirgreatersusceptiblytoharmatlowerlevelsofusethanyoungerpeople.Thisisparticularlyconcerning,giventhemorepronouncedtrendinWalesforanincreasedageingpopulation.The2008-2018SubstanceMisuseStrategyforWales,Working Together to Reduce Harm,recognisesthischallengeandtheparticularneedsofolderpeople1.Living longer, ageing well2013-2023,theWelshGovernmentstrategyforolderpeopleinWalesaimstoaddressthebarriersfacedbyolderpeople2.Thestrategyrecognisesthatgoodphysicalandmentalhealthcontributesgreatlytooverallwellbeing.Otherinitiatives,suchasthehealthchecksprogrammeforpeopleagedover50arepartoftheoverallpolicyresponseandareaimedatallowingpeopletohavegreatercontrolovertheirhealthandwellbeing.
2.2SubstanceMisuseinOlderPeopleSubstancemisuseproblemsinthoseover50arepredominantlyrelatedtoalcoholuse;howeverbothillicitandprescribeddrugswillalsobeanissue.Ingeneral,oldermenareconsideredtobeatgreatestriskofsubstancemisuse,includingalcoholandillicitdrugsbutolderwomenmaybemoreatriskofproblematicuseofsedative/hypnoticandanxiolyticmedication3.
3
2.3DrugsResearchsuggeststhatthoseolderpeoplewhouseillicitdrugslargelystartedforrecreationaluseasadolescentsoryoungpeople.Aproportion,however,dostartusinglaterinlife(intheirforties)asaconsequenceofadverselifeevents,tomanagepainorbecausetheyhadapartnerwhouseddrugs4.
Misuseinolderpeopleisnotrestrictedtoillicitdrugs.Theymayhaveproblemswithdependenceonprescriptiondrugsandoverthecountermedication.Problemswithprescriptiondrugscanbeexacerbatedbythecomplexityofregimes,hoardinganddrugsharingwithotherpeople.Misuseofsedativesandanalgesicsmaybeaparticularissue.Mixingofalcoholandprescriptiondrugsmayalsobeaproblem.
2.4AlcoholEarly-onsetdrinkersmayhavehadproblemsoverseveraldecadesbuthavesurvivedintoolderage.Later-onsetproblemdrinkersoftenbeginintheir50sor60sandtheirdrinkingmaybemoreassociatedwithlifeeventsandtransitionssuchaslossofapartner,retirement(lossofstatus,routine,boredom,theopportunitytospendmoretimedrinking).Lonelinessandisolationmaybefactorsandsomemaydrinkmoreinanefforttocopewithproblemssuchaspainorinsomnia.
Thereisdebateaboutwhatconstitutesharmful/hazardousdrinkinginolderpeople.TheRoyalCollegeofPsychiatristsarguethatcurrentsafelimitsarebasedonresearchonyoungerpeoplearguingthattheuppersafelimitforolderpeopleis1.5unitsadayor11unitsaweek3.Theyalsorecommendthatinolderpeoplebingedrinkingshouldbedefinedas>4.5unitsinasinglesessionformenand>3unitsforwomen.Giventhechangesinphysiologyaspeopleageitisprudenttoconsideralowerlevelinolderagegroups.ThereisageneralacceptanceinWales,thatthelowerlimitsrecommendedbytheRoyalCollegeofPsychiatristsshouldbeadoptedforthoseover65years.
2.5Co-morbidityandComplexitySomefactorsthatapplymoregenerallytoolderadultsmeanthatsubstancemisuseinthisgroupmaybemorecomplexandpresentmanagementproblemsthatdifferfromthoseinyoungerpeople.
Underlyingmedicalconditions,agerelatedchangesinliverandrenalfunctionandinteractionsbetweenmultiplemedicationsincreaserisksofolderpeopledevelopingsubstancerelatedproblemsatlowerlevelsofconsumption3.
Anxiety,depression,posttraumaticstressdisorder,druginducedpsychosis,schizophrenia,deliriumanddementiamayleadto,beaconsequenceoforcoincidewithdrugmisuse3.
Therelationshipbetweenalcoholandcognitiveimpairmentinolderpeopleiscomplex.Prolonged,excessiveusecanincreasetherisksofdementiaandalcoholrelatedcognitiveimpairment.Themanagementofthosewithalcoholmisuseanddementia/cognitiveimpairmentischallenging3.
4
Somearguethatacutealcoholwithdrawalsyndromeismoreprotractedandsevereinolderpeoplethaninyoungerpeoplewithdrinkingproblemsofequalseverity5.Thishasledtotherecommendationthatwithdrawalinolderpeopleshouldbemanagedonalargelyinpatientbasis.
Thereissomeevidencethatolderadultsmayusealcoholtomanagepain.Olderproblemdrinkerstendtoreportmorepainthannonproblemdrinkers6.
2.6TheExtentofSubstanceMisuseinOlderPeopleTheUKhasanageingpopulationbutthistrendismostpronouncedinWales7.TheproportionoftheWalespopulationaged50+isprojectedtobe41percent(1,301,000)by2020withactualnumbersincreasingto1,398,000by2035.
The2007ONSAdultPsychiatricMorbiditySurveyfoundthatthreepercentofmenandonepercentofwomenagedbetween65and74and0.5percentofmenagedover75reportedalcoholdependenceinthelast6months8.Thosewhobeginmisusingsubstancesaftertheageof65aremostlikelytomisusealcohol.Prevalenceofdrugdependenceinthepastyearforthoseagedover65waslessthanonepercentforbothmenandwomen8.
Inthe2012WelshHealthsurvey10percentofthoseaged45andoverreportedtheiraveragefrequencyofdrinkingasalmosteveryday9.48percentofthoseaged45to64and26percentofthose65andover,reportedthattheirmaximumdailyalcoholintakeinthepastweekwasaboverecommendedguidelines.
During2012-2013thetotalnumberofpeopleaged50andoverreferredforsubstancemisusetreatmentinWaleswas3783.Ofthese3266werereferredbecauseofproblemswithalcohol;24.4percentofallreferralsforalcoholmisuse10.Overthelastfiveyearstheproportionofallthosereferredwhosemainproblemwaswithalcoholandwhoareagedover50hasincreasedbyaboutfivepercent10.
2.7ImplicationsforServicesGiventheincreasingnumberofpeopleagedover50intheWelshpopulationandtheincreasingproportionofthosepresentingfortreatmentitislikelythatdemandforservicesinthisagegroupwillincrease.Manyspecialistdrugandalcoholservicesarefundedfor,ortargetedat,workingageadults.Considerationneedstobegiventodevelopingspecialistservicesspecificallyforolderpeoplewithsubstancemisuseproblems.Suchserviceswouldalsoneedtotakeintoaccountthedifferingneedsacrosstheover50sagerange.
Whilstserviceuserinvolvementmustplayasubstantialroleintheprovisionofallsubstancemisuseservices,theconceptofco-productionmustalsobeconsideredbyservicecommissioners,providersandusers.
Theneedforthepublicsectortoembed‘co-production’intoserviceprovisionisbecomingapparent.NESTA(NationalEndowmentforScience,TechnologyandtheArts)describeco-productionas‘deliveringpublicservicesinanequalandreciprocalrelationshipbetweenprofessionals,peopleusingservices,theirfamiliesandtheirneighbours’.
5
Co-productionalignstothehighestlevelofserviceuserinvolvement.Itallowsthoseserviceuserswhowishtobeinvolvedinco-commission,co-design,co-deliveryandco-evaluationofservices.OvertimeitisultimatelythislevelofserviceuserinvolvementwhichshouldbeaspiredtointheproductionofallsubstancemisuseservicesacrossWales.
InafewareasoftheUKspecialistsubstancemisuseservicesforolderpeoplearebeingdeveloped;thesetendtobeforthosewithco-morbidmentalhealthproblemsandnopublishedevidenceontheireffectivenesshasbeenidentifiedtodate10.SomeexamplesofservicesprovidedinWalesareincludedintheappendix.
3.ManagementofSubstanceMisuseinOlderPeople
3.1IdentificationItcanbedifficulttoidentifysubstancemisuseinolderpeople.Lackofawarenessandknowledgeregardingsubstancemisuseinthisgroupisasignificantbarrier.Clinicalandotherstaffworkingwitholderpeoplemaybereluctanttoraisetheissueofsubstanceusewiththisgroup.SubstancemisuseshouldbeconsideredinolderpeoplewhomakefrequentuseofhealthcareinprimarycareandparticularlyA&Edepartments(includingfractureclinics)andthoseusingmentalhealthservices5.Itshouldalsobeconsideredinthosepresentingwithselfneglect.Alcoholmisusemaybeanissueinsituationswheredomesticabuseisaproblem.Itshouldalsoberecognisedthatolderpeoplewithsubstancemisuseproblemsmaybeatgreaterriskofexploitation.Debtandlossofemploymentorarelationshipmayalsobesignsofanunderlyingsubstancemisuseproblem.
TheRoyalCollegeofPsychiatristsnotethattheInternationalClassificationofDiseases(ICD-10,WHO,1992)andDiagnosticandStatisticalManual(DSM-IV,AmericanPsychiatricAssociation,1994)criteriashouldbeadministeredthoughtfullyandwithclinicaljudgementwhenbeingusedtodiagnosesubstancemisuseinolderpeople3.TheyarguethattheDSM-IVcriteriainparticular,maynotbeadequatetodiagnoseolderpeoplewithsubstancemisuseproblems.
Assessmentshouldinvolveaninformant,forexampleafamilymemberorcarerandhomeassessmentmaybehelpfulastheenvironmentmayprovideevidenceofsubstancemisuse4.Involvementofaninformantmustbewiththeconsentoftheindividualbeingassessed.Assessinglevelsofconsumptioncanbedifficult,particularlywherethereiscognitiveimpairment.Signsandsymptomsofsubstancemisusemaybeattributedto,ormaskedby,otherproblems.Physicalsymptomsthatshouldtriggerscreeningforsubstancemisuseinclude11:
• Sleepcomplaints
• Cognitiveimpairment,memoryorconcentrationdisturbance
• Seizures,malnutrition,musclewasting
• Liverfunctionabnormalities
• Unexplainedmedicationinteractions
• Persistentirritabilitywithoutobviouscause
• Unexplainedchronicpainorothersomaticsymptoms
6
• Incontinence,urinaryretention
• Poorhygieneandselfneglect
• Unusualrestlessnessoragitation
• Complaintsofblurredvisionordrymouth
• Unexplainednauseaandvomiting
• Changesineatinghabits
• Slurredspeech
• Tremor,poormotorcoordination,shufflinggait
• Frequentfallsandunexplainedbruising.
3.1.1Screeningtools
NICEguidance(www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/live/13001/48984/48984.pdf)recommendsuseofAlcoholUseDisordersIdentificationTest(AUDIT)todecideonwhethertousebriefinterventionortorefertospecialistservices12.
TheRoyalCollegeofPsychiatrists(www.rcpsych.ac.uk/files/pdfversion/cr165.pdf)recommendthatGPsaskeverypersonover65yearsofageaboutsubstancemisuseaspartofaroutinehealthcheckusingspecifictoolssuchastheShortMichiganAlcoholismScreeningTest–Geriatricversion(SMAST-G)3.ThisisvalidatedforuseintheolderadultpopulationandtakesintoaccounttheRoyalCollegerecommendationswithregardtosafedrinkinglevelsinthisgroup.Theyfurtherrecommendthatthisscreeningincorporatescognitivetestingusingtools,forexample,theMini-MentalStateExamination(MMSE).Wherescreeningtoolsareusedthisshouldbeinconjunctionwiththoroughclinicalassessment3.
Theover50shealthcheckinWalesusesAUDITC.Opportunisticquestionsshouldbeconsideredasshouldwhenanindividualisundergoingmajorlifechangesortransitions.ScreeningshouldbeincludedasanelementoftheFrameworkonIntegratedAssessmentforOlderPeoplebeingdevelopedinWales.
Arangeofotherbriefandmoreindepthscreeningtoolsareavailable.Choiceoftoolwilldependonthesettingandspecificpurposeforwhichitisused.Thechosentoolshouldbevalidatedforuseinolderpopulations.
3.2EvidenceBaseforTreatment3.2.1Guidelines
Theevidencebaseforsubstancemisusetreatmentspecifictoolderpeopleissparse13buttheprinciplesoftreatmentintheworkingagepopulationapply14.NICEguidanceisavailableonDiagnosis,assessmentandmanagement15(www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/live/13337/53191/53191.pdf)ofharmfuldrinkingandalcoholdependenceandontreatingthephysicalcomplications16(www.guidance.nice.org.uk/cg100/niceguidance/pdf/english)ofalcoholusedisorders.
TheUKclinicalguidelines(www.nta.nhs.uk/uploads/clinical_guidelines_2007.pdf)ondrugmisuseanddependencedonotspecificallyaddresstheneedsofolderpeople17.
7
IntheUSAtheDepartmentofHealthandHumanServiceshaspublishedatreatmentimprovementprotocol(www.ncbi.nim.nih.gov/books/nbk64419/pdf/toc.pdf)onsubstanceabuseamongolderadults18.Thisisbasedonevidenceandprofessionalconsensusandwasrevisedin2012.
TheRoyalCollegeofPsychiatristsreport Our Invisible Addicts(www.rcpsych.ac.uk/files/pdfversion/cr165.pdf)makesrecommendationsontheassessmentandtreatmentofsubstancemisuseinolderpeopleanddiscussesappropriateservicemodels3.Thedocumentalsoprovidesguidanceonpharmacologicaltreatmentofsubstanceproblemsinolderpeople.
3.2.2Psychologicaltreatment
Evidenceshowsthatpsychologicaltreatmentsforolderpeoplewhomisusesubstances(overtheageof50)areeffectiveandinsomecasestheymayrespondbetterthantheiryoungercounterparts19.Thosewithlate-onsetsubstancemisusehaveabetterresponsetotreatmentthanthosewithearly-onset3.Cliniciansmaybereluctanttotreatsubstancemisuseinolderadults;howeverresponsetotreatmentislikelytobegoodandreducemortalityinthisagegroup.NICEhasissuedguidanceonpsychosocialinterventions(www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/live/11812/35973/35973.pdf)fordrugmisuse20.
3.2.3Dualdiagnosis
Thereissomeevidencethatolderpeoplewithco-existingmentalhealthandsubstancemisuseproblemsrequireanintensivesupportservicethatisprimarilyhomebased,supportedbylinkstootherservicesandusingmotivationalapproachesmaybebeneficial13.
WelshGovernmenthasalreadyissuedaserviceframework(www.wales.gov.uk/topics/housingandcommunity/safety/substancemisuse/publications/cooccuring/;jsessionid=d2374060981f7b85c6ab9aa953738687?lang=en)onmeetingtheneedsofpeoplewithaco-occurringsubstancemisuseandmentalhealthproblems21andwillbere-issuingupdatedguidanceforconsultationlaterin2014.
3.3BriefInterventionsBriefinterventionisacost-effectivefirststepforthosewhosedrinkingmeetsdiagnosticcriteriaforharmfuluse5.Thesecanbedeliveredinprimarycareandothersettings.Admissiontogeneralhospitalmedicalwardsandtraumacentresofferstheopportunityforbriefinterventionwithheavyalcoholusersandthereisgoodevidencethatthisiseffectiveinreducingbothconsumptionanddeathrates22.
3.4SpecialistAssessmentTheWelshIntegratedIndepthSubstanceMisuseAssessmentTool(www.wales.gov.uk/topics/housingandcommunity/safety/substancemisuse/publications/wiismat/;jsessionid=d2374060981f7b85c6ab9aa953738687?lang=en)(WIISMAT)providesassessmentinrelationtosubstancemisuse23.Thoroughphysicalassessmentisneededastreatmentneedstotakeaccountofco-morbidphysicalproblemsincludingneuropsychiatricdisorderandhepaticandrespiratorycomplications.Afullhistoryshouldbetakenincludingcollateralhistoryfromareliableinformant3.
8
3.5DetoxificationOut-patientdetoxificationmaynotbeappropriateforolderadultswhoarefrail,wholivealonewithlimitedsupport,orwhohavemultiplemedicalproblems5.ThetreatmentimprovementprotocolfromtheUSAalsorecommendsthatwithdrawalfromalcoholorprescriptiondrugsshouldbeonaninpatientbasisforsomepatients18.Thefollowingareindicatorsoftheneedforinpatientsupervision:-
• Highpotentialfordevelopingseizuresordeliriumbecausethedosageofbenzodiazepineorbarbituratehasbeenparticularlyhighorprolongedandhasbeenabruptlydiscontinuedorbecausethepatienthaspreviouslyexperiencedserioussymptoms.
• Anypatientwheretherehasbeenapasthistoryofcomplicatedalcoholwithdrawals(forexamplewithdrawalseizures,deliriumtremens,acuteconfusionalstates).
• Suicidalideationorthreatsorothermajorpsychopathology.
• Unstableoruncontrolledmedicalco-morbiditiesrequiring24hourcareorparenterallyadministeredmedications(forexamplerenaldisease,diabetes).
• Mixedaddictions,includingalcohol.
• Patientlivesaloneandhascontinuedaccesstoabusedsubstance(s).
TheWelshGovernmentcontinuestoringfence£1mofitssubstanceMisuseActionFundspecificallyforResidentialRehabilitationandInpatientDetoxification.AnAllWalesTier4brochureandapreferredresidentialrehabilitationproviderlistforWalesarecurrentlybeingdeveloped.
3.6PrescribingforOlderAdultsOlderadultspresentingwithaddictiontoopioids(prescribedorillicit)mayrequiresubstituteprescribing.Cautionmayberequiredbecauseofreducedhepaticfunctionassociatedwithageandtheissueofpolypharmacyinolderadults.However,patientsshouldnotbedeniedeffectivetreatmentsimplyonthebasisofage.Referraltospecialistswithexperienceofprescribingforthisgroupmaybenecessary.
Relapsepreventionprescribingmayalsobeappropriateinolderadults.Extremecareneedstobetakenwithdisulfiramandhepaticfunctionneedstobemonitoredwhentreatingwithnaltrexone.
3.7CarePathwaysThisdocumentfocusesonaccesstotreatment.Comprehensivecarepathwayswillneedtobedevelopedtakingaccountofspecificlocalcircumstances,needs,serviceavailabilityandaccess.Aswellastheissueshighlightedinthissection,followupandaftercareprovisionwillneedtobeconsidered.
9
4.ImprovingAccesstoTreatment
4.1PrudentHealthcarePublicservicesinWalesarerequiredtomovetowardsacultureof‘prudenthealthcare’–notprovidingtreatmentwhereitisunlikelytobenefitthepatient,orcoulddoharm.Prudenthealthcareinthiscontextrequirestherightserviceinterveningattherighttimeandintherightway.Wheremorethanoneserviceisrequiredtointervenethisshouldbedonecollaborativelymakingbestuseofresources,ensuringaproportionateresponseandavoidingduplicationofeffortandtreatment.
Thisculturalshiftisofrelevancewhencommissioningolderpeople’ssubstancemisuseservicesasweneedtoensurethatservicesareefficient,effectiveandempowering.Toassistthefollowingbroaderprincipleshavebeendeveloped:
• Donoharm.Theprinciplethatinterventionswhichdoharmorprovidenoclinicalbenefitareeliminated.
• Carryouttheminimumappropriateintervention.Theprinciplethattreatmentshouldbeginwiththebasicproventestsandinterventions.Theintensityoftestingandtreatmentisconsistentwiththeseriousnessoftheillnessandthepatient’sgoals.
• Organisetheworkforcearoundthe“onlydo,whatonlyyoucando”principle.TheprinciplethatallpeopleworkingfortheNHSinWalesshouldoperateatthetopoftheirclinicalcompetence.Nobodyshouldbeseenroutinelybyaconsultant,forexample,whentheirneedscouldbeappropriatelydealtwithbyanadvancednursepractitioner.
• Promoteequity.Theprinciplethatitistheindividual’sclinicalneedwhichmatterswhenitcomestodecidingNHStreatment.
• Remodeltherelationshipbetweenuserandprovideronthebasisofco-production.
4.2TrainingAppropriateeducationandtrainingisneededforabroadrangeofprofessionalhealthcarestafftoensurethatsubstancemisuseinolderpeopleisdetectedandmanaged.Thiswillincludeallservicesspecificallyforolderpeople(providingbothphysicalandmentalhealthcare)aswellasmoregenericservicesforexamplesexualhealthservices.Trainingshouldalsobegiventothoseworkinginotherrelevantagenciessuchassocialservices,socialcareandhousingproviders,relevantthirdsectoragencies,thoseworkingwiththehomeless,thepoliceandothercriminaljusticeservices.Educationandtrainingshouldaimtoincreaselevelsofawarenessandunderstanding,addressanyreluctancetoraisethetopicofsubstancemisusewitholderpeople,enableonwardreferral/signpostingand,forrelevantstaff,developskillsinscreening,assessment,basicmanagement,knowledgeofspecialistservicesandreferralpathways.BriefinterventiontrainingisavailableinWalesandshouldalsobeconsidered.
10
4.3RangeofNeedsThetermolderpeopleinthecontextofthisdocumentencompassesabroadagerangeandneedswithinthismaydiffer.A50yearoldwithasubstancemisuseproblemislikelytoneedadifferentservicetothatprovidedtoa75yearold.Ageofonset,co-morbidityandavailabilityofsupportnetworkswillneedtobeconsideredinthedevelopmentofindividualcareplans24.
‘Morethanjustwords…/Mwynageiriau…’isthestrategicframeworkdevelopedtoensurethatWelshspeakerscanaccessservicesinHealthandSocialServicesintheWelshLanguage.WeknowthatwhereWelshisafirstlanguage,beingabletouseandreceiveservicesinthislanguageoptimisessuccessfuloutcomesfortheserviceuserandthereforeshouldbeacorecomponentofcareandnotanoptionalextra.EffectivecommunicationisakeyrequirementofcareservicesandtheWelshLanguageinSocialCareframeworkrecognisesthisneedacrossallaspectsofphysicalhealthandmentalhealthcare.
4.4PresentationThepresentationofsubstancemisuseproblemsmaydifferinolderpeople.Forexampletheyarelesslikelytobeinvolvedinantisocialbehaviourandcriminalactivity.Substancemisusepresentationmaybenon-specificandmaypresentasotherdisorders,forexample,weightloss,neglect,falls,depressionorcognitiveimpairment.
Inthosepresentingfrequentlytohealthcare,forexampleinprimarycareorA&E,substancemisuseshouldbeconsidered.Substancemisuseshouldalsobeconsideredinthosepresentingtogeneralmedicine,gastroenterologyandoldagepsychiatry.Evidencesuggeststhatupto30percentofhospitalisedolderpatientsongeneralmedicalwardsmayhavehighlevelsofalcoholuse25.ResearchundertakenintheUKhasshownthatmedicalstaffmayfailtoidentifyuptotwothirdsofproblemdrinkersandmistakebothdementiaanddepressionforsubstancemisuse26.Presentationcouldalsobetootheragenciessuchassocialservicesorthepolice3.
4.5AwarenessandAttitudesHealthcareandotherstaffmaynotconsidersubstancemisuseinolderpeople.Theymaybereluctanttoraisethetopic.Somemaybelieveitisinappropriatetoaskolderpeopletogiveupestablishedhabits3.Thosewithsubstancemisuseproblems,theirrelativesorcarersmaybereluctanttoprovideinformation.Itisrecognisedthatevenwheremisuseisidentifiedinolderpeopletheyarelesslikelythantheiryoungercounterpartstobereferredtospecialistservicesorreceiveadequatetreatment.
RaisingawarenessandunderstandingofissuesassociatedwithsubstancemisuseinolderagehasbeenhighlightedasanissueintheStrategyforOlderPeopleinWales2013-2023.TheAdvisoryPanelonSubstanceMisuse(APoSM)willalsobetakingraisingawarenessintoconsiderationaspartoftheirreviewofthepolicyinterventionsnecessarytotacklesubstancemisuseinanageingpopulation.
11
4.6HomelessnessandHousingProblemsOlderpeoplewithsubstancemisuseproblemsmaybeatriskoflosingtheirtenancies.Lossofaccommodation,rentarrearsordeteriorationintheirlivingenvironmentmaybesignsofaproblem26.Housingrelatedsupportprovidersmanagingtenancyrelatedproblemsinolderpeople,particularlywherethesehavenotpreviouslybeenissues,shouldconsiderifsubstancemisuse,particularlyalcohol,maybeafactorandmakeappropriateonwardreferral.Akeyactionofthe‘Working Together to Reduce Harm Substance Misuse Delivery Plan 2013-2015’istoreducehomelessnessandhelppeoplewithsubstancemisuseproblemssustaintheirtenancies.
Older,homelessmen(whomaybeheavydrinkersorhavealcoholrelatedproblems)willneedtobeconsiderediftheyaretobesuccessfullyhoused3.Evidenceshowsthat‘housingfirst’approachesthatofferimmediateaccesstohousingandsupportforhomelesspeoplewithmentalillnessand/orsubstancemisuseproblemstoindependenthousingandsupportiveserviceswithoutanyrequirementforthemtofirstengagewithtreatment,canbeeffective27.
TheSupportingPeopleRegionalCollaborativeCommitteeinplaceacrossWalesprovideforawherehealthpractitionerscanworkwithlandlords,localauthoritySupportingPeopleteamsandtheThirdSectorhousingrelatedsupportproviderstoensurethatthereisanappropriatespectrumofservicestoaddresstheneedsofolderpeoplewithcooccurringhousingandsubstancemisuseneeds.
4.7JointWorkingEffectivemanagementofolderpeoplewithsubstancemisuseproblemswillrequirejointworkingbetweenspecialistalcoholanddrugservicesandotherserviceswitharoleincaringforthem.Thismayincludeolderpeople’steamsfrombothgeneralandmentalhealthservices.SharedcarewithGPsshouldalsobeencouraged.Wherethepatienthasdualdiagnosistherewillneedtobeclarificationofresponsibilitiesandaccountability(includingunambiguousclinicalresponsibility)betweenmentalhealthandsubstancemisusetreatmentservices.Considerationshouldalsobegiventowhereservicesareprovided;venuesneedtobeacceptabletoolderpeopleforexampleattendingahospitaloutpatientdepartmentoraGPsurgerymaybepreferabletoattendingservicesinvenuesspecificallylabelledasdrugandalcoholservices.
4.8CommunityPharmacistsCommunitypharmacistsmaybebestplacedforsurveillanceofrepeatprescriptionsandsupervisionofoverthecountersales.Acomparativelythoroughassessmentofanolderperson’sproblemsandprescribedmedicationmayhelptoreducemisuse3.
4.9PrimaryCareGPsshouldaskeverypersonincludingthoseover65yearsofageaboutsubstancemisuseaspartofanyroutinehealthcheck,suchasanewpatientquestionnaire.Briefinterventiontrainingshouldbeconsideredforprimarycarestaff.Allclinicalstaffworkinginprimarycareshouldhavetrainingtoincreasetheirunderstandingofsubstancemisuseinolderpeople,addressanyreluctancetoraisetheissueandensurethatappropriatereferralstospecialistservicesaremade.
12
4.10AccidentandEmergencyDepartmentsStaffinaccidentandemergencydepartmentsshouldhavetrainingtoensurethattheyunderstandtheextentandnatureofsubstancemisuseinolderpeople.Substancemisuseshouldalwaysbeconsideredinfrequentattendersandthosepresentingwithfallsorselfneglect.Briefinterventionstrainingforstaffshouldbeconsideredwherenotalreadyoffered.Whereavailableinaccidentandemergencydepartments,mentalhealthliaisonservicescanprovidealinkforolderpeoplewithsubstancemisuseproblems.
4.11SubstanceMisuseServicesSpecialistsubstancemisuseservicesshouldconsiderthespecificneedsofolderpeople,takingaccountofdifferingneedsacrosstheover50sagerange,includingculturaldifferencesandensuringthosewithadisabilityhaveequalaccesstoservices.Clinicalstaffneedappropriatetrainingtoequipthemtomanagecomorbidityandthecomplexityofsubstancemisuseinthisagegroup.Thereshouldbeeffectivejointworkingwitholderpeoplesphysicalandmentalhealthservicesandclearagreementsonclinicalresponsibility.WhereaddictiontoprescribedpainkillersisanissueGPsandspecialistpainservicesshouldbeinvolved.
4.12DentistsDentistsandtheirteamsmaybeinagoodpositiontodetectalcoholabuseandoralchangesduetosubstancemisuseasalcoholcancontributetothedevelopmentofmouthcancer.Substancemisusersareatriskofarangeoforaldiseaseasaresultofsubstancemisuseitselforpoororalhygieneandfrequentsugarintake.Dentalteamsfrequentlyseepatientsformanyyearsandmaybecomeawareofclinicalandbehaviouralchangeswhichindicateabuseofalcoholordrugs.Theywillneedtohandleissuesofsubstancemisusewithsensitivity–advisingtheirpatientofanyriskstooralhealthanddirectingpatientstoappropriatesupportservices.Dentalteamsworkinginprimarycareshouldhavetrainingtoincreasetheirunderstandingofsubstancemisuseinolderpeople,addressanyreluctancetoraisetheissueandensurethatappropriatereferralstospecialistservicesaremade.
4.13OlderPeoplesServicesLiving Longer, Ageing Well 2013-2023,theWelshGovernmentStrategyforOlderPeopleinWalesaimstoaddressthebarriersfacedbyolderpeopletoaccessinghealthandotherservices2.Staffworkinginolderpeoplesservices,inparticularoldagepsychiatry,generalmedicineandgastroenterology,shouldconsidersubstancemisuseinthosepresentingfrequentlytoservices.Stafftrainingshouldfocusonaddressinganyreluctancetoraisethistopicwitholderpeopleandtoreferthemtospecialistservices.
4.14ThirdSectorServicesThirdsectororganisationsshouldconsiderawarenesstrainingforstaffprovidingservicesforolderpeopletoincreasethelikelihoodthattheywillrecogniseolderpeoplewithsubstancemisuseproblems.Organisationsshouldalsoconsiderwhethertheremightbebenefitintrainingsomeoftheirstafftodeliverbriefinterventions.
13
4.15LocalHealthBoardsLocalHealthBoardswillneedtoensurethattheStrategyforOlderPeopleinWalesisimplemented2.Theywillneedtoensurethatsubstancemisuseservicesmeettherangeofneedspresentedbythoseagedover50years.
4.16AreaPlanningBoardsAreaPlanningBoardswillneedtoreviewtheirexistingcarepathwaystoensurethatolderpeoplewithsubstancemisuseproblemsareidentifiedandthattheirneedsareappropriatelymetbyexistingservices.AreaPlanningBoardsarerequiredtoproduceaSubstanceMisuseCommissioningStrategywhichhasbeeninformedbyarobustneedsanalysis.AspartoftheneedsanalysisAPBsshouldreviewtheirexistinglocalcarepathways(takingintoaccountlocalfactorsandserviceavailability)withaviewtoensuringthataccesstosubstancemisusetreatmentforthoseagedover50yearsisimproved.
14
5.SummaryofRecommendations• AreaPlanningBoards,LocalHealthBoardsandlocalauthorityadults
servicesshouldworktogethertoreviewexistinglocalcarepathwayswithaviewtoensuringthataccesstosubstancemisusetreatmentforthoseagedover50yearsisimproved.LocalMentalHealthPartnershipBoardsshouldalsobeinvolved.ThisreviewshouldbeundertakenaspartoftheneedsanalysisinformingAPBcommissioningstrategiesandwillneedtotakeintoaccountlocalfactorsandserviceavailability.
• Considerationshouldtobegiventodevelopingspecialistservicesspecificallyforolderpeoplewithsubstancemisuseproblems.Suchservicesshouldalsotakeintoaccountthedifferingneedsacrosstheover50’sagerange.
• Substancemisuseshouldbeconsidered,andwherenecessaryaddressed,inolderpeoplewhomakefrequentuseofhealthcareinprimarycarebutalsoA&Edepartments(includingfractureclinics)andthoseusingmentalhealthservices.Itshouldalsobeaddressedinthosepresentingwithselfneglect.
• PeopleinWalesshouldbeencouragedtoundertakeaselfassessmentthroughthe‘Addtoyourlife’assessmentforover50sincludingdetailedquestionsonalcoholwww.addtoyourlife.co.uk/
• Whereolderpatientspresentwithanysymptomsthatmightsuggestalcoholorothersubstancemisuse,GPsshoulduseappropriatetools,suchastheShortMichiganAlcoholismScreeningTest–Geriatricversion(SMAST-G)toassessolderpeopleinordernottomisswhatisanincreasinglycommonproblem.
• GPsshouldconsideropportunitiestoidentifysubstancemisuseissuesfornewlyregisteredpatientsincludingthoseover65yearsofage.
• Appropriateeducationandtrainingisneededforarangeofprofessionalhealthcarestafftoensurethatsubstancemisuseinolderpeopleisdetectedandmanaged.Trainingonsubstancemisuserelatedissuesshouldalsobegiventothoseworkinginotherrelevantagenciessuchassocialservices,socialcareandhousingproviders,relevantthirdsectoragencies,thoseworkingwiththehomeless,thepoliceandothercriminaljusticestaff.
15
References1. WelshAssemblyGovernment.(2008).Working together to reduce harm.
The substance misuse strategy for Wales 2008-2018.Cardiff:WAG.Availableat:www.wales.gov.uk/dsjlg/publications/commmunitysafety/strategy/strategye.pdf;jsessionid=2F329C62AD4CA3C5315EE02F2A4AB3CA?lang=en[Accessed6November2012]
2. WelshAssemblyGovernment.(2013).Living longer, ageing well. The strategy for older people in Wales 2013-2023.Cardiff:WG.Availableat:www.wales.gov.uk/docs/dhss/publications/130521olderpeoplestrategyen.pdf[Accessed4Aug2014]
3. RoyalCollegeofPsychiatrists.(2011).Our invisible addicts. First report of the older persons’ substance misuse working group of the Royal College of Psychiatrists. College Report CR165.London:RCPsych.Availableat:www.rcpsych.ac.uk/files/pdfversion/CR165.pdf[Accessed8Jan2013]
4. RoeBetal.(2010).Experiencesofdruguseandageing:health,qualityoflife,relationshipandserviceimplications. J Adv Nurs66(9):pp.1968-79
5. BadrakalimuthuVR,RumballDandWagleA.(2010).Drugmisuseinolderpeople:oldproblemsandnewchallenges.Adv Psychiatr Treat16(6):pp.421-9
6. BrennanPL,SchutteKKandMoosRH.(2005).Painanduseofalcoholtomanagepain:prevalenceand3yearoutcomesamongproblemandnonproblemdrinkers.Addiction100:pp.777-86
7. WelshAssemblyGovernment.(2008).Mid-year population estimates 2007.Cardiff:WAGStatisticalDirectorate
8. McManusSetal.(2007).Adult psychiatric morbidity in England, 2007. Results of a household survey.Leeds:HSCIC.Availableat:www.hscic.gov.uk/catalogue/PUB02931/adul-psyc-morb-res-hou-sur-eng-2007-rep.pdf[Accessed4Aug2014]
9. WelshGovernment.(2012).Welsh health survey 2011.Cardiff:WG.Availableat:www.wales.gov.uk/docs/statistics/2012/120919healthsurvey2011en.pdf[Accessed4Aug2014]
10. WelshGovernment.(2014).Substance misuse statistics.Cardiff:WG.Availableat:www.wales.gov.uk/statistics-and-research/substance-misuse/?lang=en#/statistics-and-research/substance-misuse/?lang=en[Accessed4Nov2013]
11. LangIetal.(2007).Whatlevelofalcoholconsumptionishazardousforolderpeople?FunctioningandmortalityinUSandEnglishnationalcohorts.J Am Geriatr Soc55:pp.49-57
12. NationalInstituteforHealthandClinicalExcellence.(2010).Alcohol-use disorders: preventing the development of hazardous and harmful drinking. Public Health Guidance 24.London:NICE.www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/live/13001/48984/48984.pdf[Accessed4Jan2013]
16
13. GalvaniSetal.(2011).Social work services and recovery from substance misuse: a review of the evidence.Edinburgh:ScottishGovernment.Availableat:www.scotland.gov.uk/Resource/Doc/346164/0115212.pdf[Accessed4Aug2014]
14. DarK.(2006).Alcoholusedisordersinelderlypeople:factorfiction?Adv Psychiatr Treat12(3):pp.173-81
15. NationalInstituteforHealthandClinicalExcellence.(2011).Alcohol-use disorders; Diagnosis, assessment and management of harmful drinking and alcohol dependence.CG115.London:NICE.Availableat:www.guidance.nice.org.uk/CG115/NICEGuidance/pdf/English[Accessed4Dec2013]
16. NationalInstituteforHealthandClinicalExcellence.(2010).Alcohol-use disorders. Diagnosis and clinical management of alcohol-related physical complications. CG100.London:NICE.Availableat:www.guidance.nice.org.uk/CG100/NICEGuidance/pdf/English[Accessed4Dec2013]
17. DepartmentofHealth(England)andthedevolvedadministrations.(2007).Drug misuse and dependence: UK guidelines on clinical management.London:DepartmentofHealth(England),theScottishGovernment,WelshAssemblyGovernmentandNorthernIrelandExecutive.Availableat:www.nta.nhs.uk/uploads/clinical_guidelines_2007.pdf[Accessed12Dec2012]
18. CenterforSubstanceAbuseTreatment.(2012).Substance abuse among older adults. Treatment improvement protocol 26.Rockville,USA.www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK64419/pdf/TOC.pdf[Accessed4Jan2013]
19. MoyIetal.(2011).Systematicandnarrativereviewoftreatmentforolderpeoplewithsubstanceproblems.Eur Geriatr Med2(4):pp.212-36
20.NationalInstituteforHealthandClinicalExcellence.(2007.)Drug misuse psychosocial interventions.CG51.London:NICE.Availableat:www.nice.org.uk/nicemedia/live/11812/35973/35973.pdf[Accessed29May2014]
21. WelshAssemblyGovernment.(2007).A service framework to meet the needs of people with a co-occurring substance misuse and mental health problem.Cardiff:WAG.Availableat:www.wales.gov.uk/topics/housingandcommunity/safety/substancemisuse/publications/cooccuring/;jsessionid=D2374060981F7B85C6AB9AA953738687?lang=en[Accessed19Dec2012]
22.McQueenJetal.Briefinterventionforheavyalcoholusersadmittedtogeneralhospital.Cochrane Database Syst Rev2011,Issue8.ArtNo.:CD005191.doi:10.1002/14651858.CD005191.pub3
23. WelshAssemblyGovernment.(2008).Wales Integrated In-Depth Substance Misuse Assessment Tool (WIISMAT) and guidance for use.Cardiff:WAG.Availableat:www.wales.gov.uk/topics/housingandcommunity/safety/publications/wiismat/;jsessionid=D2374060981F7B85C6AB9AA953738687?lang=en[Accessed19Dec2012]
17
24.BelfastStrategicPartnership/PublicHealthAgency(2011).Substance misuse among people over 55. Perspectives from the community and voluntary sector in Belfast.Belfast:GEMSNorthernIrelandLtd.Availableat:www.publichealth.hscni.net/sites/default/files/GEMSNI_SubMisInTheOlderPopInBelfast_May2011.pdf[Accessed4Aug2014]
25. AtkinsonJHandSchuckitMA(1983).Geriatricalcoholanddrugmisuseandabuse.Adv Subst Abuse3:pp.195-237
26.McInnesEandPowellJ(1994).Drugandalcoholreferrals;areelderlysubstanceabusediagnosesandreferralsbeingmade.BMJ308:pp.444-6
27. LarimerMEetal.(2009).Healthcareandpublicserviceuseandcostsbeforeandafterprovisionofhousingforchronicallyhomelesspersonswithseverealcoholproblems.JAMA30:pp.1349-57
18
Appendix–ServiceExample1
AlcoholServiceforOlderPeoplePilotProjectwithintheCardiffandValeofGlamorganAreaPlanningBoardTheWallichwerecommissionedbyCardiffandValeAreaPlanningBoard(APB)toundertakeafourmonthpilotstudyofthelevelandnatureofalcoholuseandmisuseamongtheover65sacrossCardiffandVale,inordertobuildtheevidencebaserelatingtotheneedforasupportservicespecificallyaimedatolderpeopleinSouthWales.
Thestudyranfrom1December2013until31March2014andprovidedanopportunitytocollectdataandinformationthatwillinformafundingbidforBigLotterymoneytofundthisprojectintothefuture,aswellasthenecessaryevidenceneededtoshapeandredesignlocalservicestomeettheneedsofolderpeople.Thepilotwasdesignedtodemonstratethelevelofneedinrelationtonumbersofolderpeoplewhoarecurrentlydependentonalcohol,ordrinkingatharmfullevels.Therewasaparticularfocusonthoseindividualsovertheageof60whowouldbemostabletoaddresstheiralcoholmisuseandeithersignificantlyreducetheiralcoholintaketowithinsafeguidelinesorstopdrinkingalcoholinfavourofabstinence.
WhattheprojectaimstoachieveThestudyaimedtoresearchthelevelandnatureofalcoholuseamongtheover65sacrossCardiffandVale,andtheextenttowhichtheseindividualsengagewithservices,inordertoenabletheAPBandotherhealthandsocialcareservicecommissionerstoeffectively:
• Buildawarenesswithprofessionalsinnonspecialistservicesaboutharmfuldrinkingamongstolderpeople.
• Increasecapacitywithingenericolderpeople’sservicestoidentifyalcoholmisuse,actupontheproblemand/orreferontospecialistserviceswhereappropriate.
• Increasethoseabletoidentifyandactuponalcoholmisusethroughengagementwithwiderworkforce.
• WorktowardsacommongoalasoutlinedintheAPBAlcoholActionPlan2013-2016.
• Addresskeyaim1oftheWelshGovernment’sSubstanceMisusedeliveryplanfor2013-2015.
• Provideeducation,trainingandconsultancyforprofessionalsworkingwitholderpeople.
• Providescreeningtoolstoidentifyolderpeoplewithharmfuldrinking.
• Gatherdataonneed.
• Gatherdataandinformationonengagementlevels.
• Makeconnectionswithservicesthatcurrentlysupportolderpeoplee.g.residentialcare,extracareschemes,shelteredhousing,AgeUK.
19
KeyFindings• Asignificantnumberofolderadults,livinginCardiffandtheVale,
demonstratepotentiallyunsafelevelsofalcoholuseandneedadvicebasedaroundsafelimits.
• Asignificantproportionofthosewhoshouldpotentiallybeengagingwithserviceswerenotdoingso.
• Barrierstoengagementwerebothwithintheindividual(shame,embarrassment,denialand/oralackofawareness)andexternaltotheindividual(servicesnotbeingageappropriate).
• Resultsfromserviceprovidersandpractitionersrevealedhighlevelsofalcoholrelatedphysicalinjuries,detrimentalhealthconsequences,mentalhealthcorrelationsandday-to-dayeffectsincludingselfneglectandpoorhygiene.
• Theageingofthe‘babyboomers’,coupledwithariseinlifeexpectancy,suggeststhatthisisnotjustaproblemthatolderadults,servicesandpractitionersarefacedwithnow,butwillbeanincreasingproblemforthefuture.
RecommendationsTheresearchreportprovidestheevidencethatthefollowingactionsareneededthroughtheAPBworkprogramme:
• Developage-appropriateservicesforolderproblemdrinkers(oratleastaclearlydefinedelementwithincurrentservices).
• Improvethecommunicationandpathwaysbetweencurrentservices.
• Increasethefrequencyofscreening,andthecapacityofage-appropriateinterventionsandspecialistaftercare.
• Ensuretheprovisionoftrainingandprofessionaldevelopmentforallstaffworkingwitholderadults.
20
Appendix–ServiceExample2
WelshCentreforActiononDependencyandAddiction(WCADA)
OlderPersonsServiceinNeathPortTalbotWithinNeathPortTalbotthereisadesignatedOlderPersonsServicethathasbeenoperationalsince2001.TheOlderPersonsWorkerprovidesarangeofinterventionstoolderpeople(aged50yearsplus)toreducetheharmcausedbytheirsubstancemisusetothemselves,theirfamiliesandthewidercommunity.Inordertoachievethis,theOlderPersonsworkerundertakeseffectivecasemanagement;assessingsupportneeds,careplanningandliaisonworkwithprimarycare,SocialServices,residential/nursinghomesandmentalhealthservices.Acomprehensivesupportpackageisavailabletoolderpeopleincludingadviceandawarenesssessions,healthpromotion,structuredindividualsupportandaccesstootheralcoholanddrugtreatmentservicesasappropriateandwraparoundservices,suchastheirdiversionaryactivitiesproject.
Asignificantamountoffocusisplacedonreducingisolationandsupportingolderpeopletoenhancetheirsupportnetwork.Thiscanincludeattendanceatself-helpgroupsandengagementwithlocalcommunityprojectsthatfacilitateactivitiesandshortcourses.