wh movement 3 oct. 19, 2012 – day 21 introduction to syntax anth 3590/7590 harry howard tulane...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
WH movement 3Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21Introduction to Syntax
ANTH 3590/7590
Harry Howard
Tulane University
![Page 2: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Course management
http://www.tulane.edu/~howard/ANTH3590/ We need to spend our $150 from the
Provost’s Undergraduate Activities Fund.
10
/19
/12
2
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
![Page 3: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
REVIEW
10
/19
/12
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne3
![Page 4: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
EMBEDDED WH QUESTION TREE (5.26)
10
/19
/12
4
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
TP
T’PRNshe
AuxPTAf3sPast
C[EF]
ø
VPAuxwas
Vdating
PRNwho
C’
VP
wonder CP
PRNwho
-----
----
was+
-----
From now on, I will collapse the creation of the specifier and the movement to it into a single step.
![Page 5: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
T’PRNshe
AuxPTAf3sPast
C[TNS, EF]
ø
VPAuxwas
Vdating
Qwhich
C’
QP
Nactor
REVIEW: MOVE Q WITHOUT N (5.39)
10
/19
/12
5
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
TP
was+
-----
was+Af3sPast+
-------------
-----
CP
Qwhich
-------
-----
•Chain Uniformity•Attract Smallest Condition•Left-branch Condition
![Page 6: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Pied-piping of superordinate prepositionsRadford §5.6
10
/19
/12
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne6
![Page 7: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Introduction Some data
49) They asked to whom he was referring. The problem
Whom is the smallest maximal projection containing an interrogative word, so it should move without the preposition, giving:
They asked who(m) he was referring to.Which is grammatical, but not the sentence we want.
Solution: impenetrability51) A constituent in the domain of a complementizer or preposition is impenetrable to (and so cannot be attracted by) a higher head c-commanding the complementizer or preposition.Thus the whole PP can be attracted up to C.
10
/19
/12
7
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
![Page 8: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
PREPOSITION STRANDING
But impenetrability prevents us from deriving the colloquial version of this sentence:52) They asked whom he was referring to.
There must be some way to get the interrogative word out of the c-command domain of the preposition.
10
/19
/12
8
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
![Page 9: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
T’PRNhe
AuxPTAf3sPast
C[EF]
ø
VPAuxwas
Vreferring
Pto
C’
PP
PRNwhom
INITIAL STRUCTURE FOR AN EMBEDDED CLAUSE (5.50)
10
/19
/12
9
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
TP
was+
-----
![Page 10: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
T’PRNhe
AuxPTAf3sPast
C[EF]
ø
VPAuxwas
Vreferring
P[EF]to
C’
PP
PRNwhom
ADD AN EDGE FEATURE FOR P (AND A SPECIFIER)
10
/19
/12
10
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
TP
was+
-----
P’
![Page 11: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
T’PRNhe
AuxPTAf3sPast
C[EF]
ø
VPAuxwas
Vreferring
P[EF]to
C’
PP
PRNwho
THE WH PRONOUN IS ATTRACTED TO SPEC OF PP (5.55) AND THEN ON UP TO SPEC OF CP 1
0/1
9/1
2
11
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
TP
was+
-----
P’PRNwho
------------
CP
Qwho
-------
-----
![Page 12: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
REMAINING DETAILS
Evidence for the edge feature of P in informal English (56) Speaker A: He has been talking to someone. Speaker B: Who to? Speaker B: *Whom to?
10
/19
/12
12
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
![Page 13: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Long-distance wh-movementRadford §5.7
10
/19
/12
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne13
![Page 14: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Introduction
10
/19
/12
14
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
What
What
![Page 15: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
CPVthink
C’
C[TNS, EF]
ø
TPC[EF]
PRNwho
Vdo
C’
T’
PRNthat
VP
VPT3sPast
CP
Tmight
T’
TP
PRhe
STRUCTURE FOR LONG-DISTANCE WH-MOVEMENT 1
0/1
9/1
2
15
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
------
-----
PRNwho
------might+
-----
----
-----
PRNwho
![Page 16: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
SOME CONSEQUENCES
Long-distance movement proceeds as a succession of short steps. If each intervening CP is called a cycle, then we
say that it proceeds in a successive-cyclic fashion.
It can also be called local, since the wh-expression is attracted to become the specifier of the closest C.
Each intervening C must have an edge feature.
10
/19
/12
16
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
![Page 17: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
EVIDENCE FOR THE LOCALITY/SUCCESSIVE CYCLICITY OF WH-MOVEMENT
Quantifier stranding or floating in West Ulster English64) What all did you get for Christmas?65a) What all did you think that he’ll say that we should buy?65b) What did you think all that he’ll say that we should buy?65c) What did you think that he’ll say all that we should buy?65d) What did you think that he’ll say that we should buy all?
10
/19
/12
17
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
![Page 18: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
EVIDENCE, CONT. Auxiliary inversion in Belfast English
What did Mary claim they stole? What did Mary claim did they steal? (68)
Reflexive anaphors69a) Jim was surprised that Peter wasn’t sure that
Mary liked this picture of himself best.69b) Jim was surprised that Peter wasn’t sure
which picture of himself Mary liked best.cf. (72) Peter wasn’t sure which picture of himself
Mary liked best. WH-copying in child English
73a) What do you think what Cookie Monster eats?73b) How do you think how Superman fixed the
car.
10
/19
/12
18
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
*
![Page 19: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
TOO MUCH MOVEMENT
A final datum74a) She might ask where he has been.74b) Where might she ask he has been.
Freezing constraint (75)An element moved to a position dedicated to some scope-discourse interpretive property … is frozen in place.
10
/19
/12
19
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne
*
![Page 20: WH movement 3 Oct. 19, 2012 – Day 21 Introduction to Syntax ANTH 3590/7590 Harry Howard Tulane University](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022062320/56649c6e5503460f94920686/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
NEXT TIMEQ6
Continue WH movement
10
/19
/12
20
AN
TH
35
90
/75
90
, Ha
rry Ho
wa
rd, T
ula
ne