what atomic physics can do for neutrino and direct dark matter detection? jiunn-wei chen national...

46
What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu (NTU) Chen- Pang Liu, Hsin-Chang Chih (NDHU) Keh- Ning Huang, Hao-Tse Shiao, Hao-Bin Li, Henry T. Wong, Lakhwinder Singh (AS)

Upload: moses-holland

Post on 20-Jan-2016

222 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark

          Matter Detection?

Jiunn-Wei Chen

National Taiwan U.

Collaborators:

Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu (NTU) Chen-Pang Liu, Hsin-Chang Chih (NDHU) Keh-Ning Huang, Hao-Tse Shiao, Hao-Bin Li, Henry T. Wong, Lakhwinder Singh (AS)

Page 2: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Neutrino and Dark Matter are Portals to New Physics

Page 3: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu
Page 4: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Neutrino: Challenges and Opportunities

• Mass: hierarchy and absolute values• Dirac or Majorana?• CP phase(s)• Sterile neutrinos? • Electromagnetic properties: magnetic moments? Charge

Radius?...

Those are probes of new physics!

Page 5: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

5

How neutrino magnetic moment arises in SM?

ii jj

ll

WW

ii jj

ll

WW

Page 6: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Neutrino Magnetic Moment (NMM)

Flavor changing MMFlavor changing MM Flavor unchanging MMFlavor unchanging MM

DiracDirac

MajoranaMajorana ×× (forbiden by CTP)(forbiden by CTP)

○ ○

eV 110 19 m

B

A probe of new physics!

Page 7: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Dark Matter (DM)

• Bigger density than the visible Universe• Its existence hints that there might be a dark

sector

Page 8: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Portals to the Dark Sector

• Other dark matter candidates include MACHOs: MAssive Compact Halo Objects WIMPs: Weakly Interacting Massive Particles

Page 9: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu
Page 10: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Why Atomic Physics?• Energy scales: Atomic (~ eV) Reactor neutrino (~ MeV) WIMP (~ GeV)• Neutrino: NNM atomic ionization signal larger at lower energy

scattering (current Ge detector threshold 0.1 keV) • DM: direct detection, velocity slow (~ 1/1000), max energy 1 keV for

mass 1 GeV DM. • Opportunity: Applying atomic physics at keV (low for nuclear physics

but high for atomic physics)

Page 11: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Neutrino Atomic Ionization

• The complete set of neutrino electromagnetic form factor is can be constrained:

Page 12: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

scattering

2/1sin2

2/1

wv

A

g

g

Weak InteractionWeak Interaction

Magnetic momentMagnetic moment

ETme

112

22

eνeν Xe

Should go for low T (energy transfered)!

Page 13: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Two Approximations ---IEquivalent Photon Approx.

• proposed by Henry Wong et al. ( PRL 105 061801)

• photon q2 ~ 0 : relativistic beam or soft photons qμ ~ 0

• several orders of magnitude enhancement

→ tighen the μν constraint with the same set of data

Page 14: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Two Approximations --- II

Free Electron Approx.

• revisited by Voloshin et al. ( PRL 105 201801)

• sum rule and Hydrogen-like calculation

• FEA works well at sub-keV regime

Page 15: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Toy: ν-H atomic ionization, exact result obtained (1307.2857)

Page 16: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Toy: ν-H atomic ionization, exact result obtained (1307.2857)

Page 17: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Two Approximations

Free Electron Approx.

(revisited by Voloshin et.al)Equivalent Photon Approx.

binding momentum of hydrogen: αme↓

Page 18: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

18

Ge atomic ionization: ab initio MCRRPA Theory

• MCRRPA: multiconfiguration relativistic random phase approx.

Reducing the N-body problem to a 1-body problem by solving the 1-body effective potential self consistently.

Hartree-Fock :

RPA:

RRPA:

MCRRPA:

↓Including 2 particle 2 hole excitations

↓Correcting the relativistic effect

↓More than one configurations in Hartree-Fock; Important for open shell system like Ge where the energy gap is smaller than the closed shell case

Page 19: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

MCRRPA Theory

( ) ( )t H V t HN-electron relativistic Hamiltonian

Dirac Hamiltonian +Coulomb interaction The rest of EM interaction

Solve initial wavefucntion of atom Solve final wavefunction by time evolution

↓ ↓

Page 20: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Benchmark: Ge Photoionization

Exp. data: Ge solid

Theory: Ge atom (gas)

Above 100 eV error under 5%.

JWC et. al. arXiv: 1311.5294

Page 21: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Ge atomic ionization withab initio MCRRPA Theory

JWC et. al. arXiv: 1311.5294

Page 22: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Ge atomic ionization withab initio MCRRPA Theory

JWC et. al. arXiv: 1311.5294

Page 23: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Ge atomic ionization withab initio MCRRPA Theory

JWC et. al. 1411.0574

Page 24: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

JWC et. al. arXiv: 1411.0574

Page 25: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Direct Dark Matter Detection

RPP 2014

Page 26: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

What Can Atomic Physics Contribute?

• Light dark matter detection:

• Electron recoil background from solar neutrinos for a LXe detector

• Large LXe detectors can be used as a neutrino/axion detectors as well (measuring NNM w/ a source nearby)

Page 27: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Electron Recoil Background for DARWIN (Lxe)

L. Baudis et al 1309.7024

Page 28: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Summary

• Neutrinos and dark matter particles are portals to new physics

• Ab initio calculations of Ge neutrino atomic ionization performed with 5-10% estimated error. Xe can be done as well.

• Ongoing: dark matter atomic ionization

Page 29: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Searching for the QCD Critical End Point

Jiunn-Wei Chen

National Taiwan U.

JWC, Jian Deng, Lance Labun

1410.5454

Page 30: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Universality• In the scaling region, physics is the same

within the same universality class---an effective field theory argument.

• QCD near CEP ~ Ising model

(Stephanov)

Page 31: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

4th momentCPOD 2014

Page 32: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

3rd momentCPOD 2014

Page 33: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

When the Imaginary is a Real Alternative

Jiunn-Wei Chen

National Taiwan U.

Phys.Rev.Lett. 110 (2013) 262301Collaborators: Jens Braun, Jian Deng, Joaquin E. Drut, Bengt Friman, Chen-Te Ma, Yu-Dai Tsai

Page 34: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

From the hottest to the coolest, and back?

Page 35: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

When Mr. Berry Meets Mr. Wigner

Jiunn-Wei Chen

National Taiwan U.

JWC, Shi Pu, Qun Wang, Xin-Nian Wang

Phys.Rev.Lett. 110 (2013) 262301

Page 36: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Flavor Structure of the Nucleon Sea from Lattice QCD

Jiunn-Wei Chen

National Taiwan U.

arXiv:1402.1462 [hep-ph]

Collaborators: Huey-Wen Lin, Saul D. Cohen, Xiangdong Ji

Page 37: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu
Page 38: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Backup slides

Page 39: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Solar Neutrino Flux

Page 40: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

40

Case study: NMM• Reactor antineutrino ( )

GEMMA : Ge detector with threshold 1.5keV

TEXONO: Ge detector with threshold 5keV

• Solar neutrino

Borexino

• Astrophysical limit (model dependent)

ee

Be

11109.2

Be

11104.7

B11104.5

B1311 10 to10 from

Page 41: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

41

scattering

ee

eνeν Xe

Weak InteractionWeak Interaction Magnetic momentMagnetic moment

Page 42: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

How low is low enough?Be

1010•

Now sub-keV Ge detector is available!

Page 43: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu
Page 44: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Parton Physics on a Euclidean LatticeX. Ji, PRL, 2013

Page 45: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Schematic QCD Phase Diagram

The location of the critical point (CEP)is still unknown.Th: Difficult to apply LQCD to the low T / high chemical potential region.

Page 46: What Atomic Physics Can Do for Neutrino and Direct Dark Matter Detection? Jiunn-Wei Chen National Taiwan U. Collaborators: Chih-Liang Wu, Chih-Pang Wu

Our Contribution JWC, Jian Deng, Lance Labun,1410.5454

• Work out the mapping in a simple model: 1+1dim Gross-Neveu model in the large N limit. Not in the same universality class---different critical exponents but behavior similar.

• More diagrams not included are also important in the power counting: